ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ส.ค. 2013
- This is a nonprofit & educational excerpt from the documentary "The Fabric of The Cosmos www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/physics/... ".
----
Please don't be misled by some comments below. This video does not say we can see future. It says Einstein's mathematical theory, tested by clock experiment, also tells us that future and past always exist like the present! However, this does not necessitate pre-destination. "Now" is not deterministic as we know from Quantum Mechanics, so neither future nor past! Click • Quantum Theory - Full ... to understand Quantum Mechanics. Wave functions evolve as time goes by. However, time does not collapse wave functions; observation collapses wave functions. Your wave function (which represents you) corresponding to your future has not collapsed yet. It will collapse in the future. As things in your life are probabilistic right now, they are probabilistic in the future too. Your past wave function has collapsed though. But your future one exists as a probability cloud in a sense. Here is a discussion I had with Avicenna10 about the topic
• The illusion of time :...
(if it fails edit url: watch?v=vrqmMoI0wks&lc=z120wtri3qaccx5yr04cctj4fs3mwfwanyo0k)
----
Accuracy of atomic clocks: • World's Most Accurate ...
----
A comment from my exchange with axypolyas on why illusion of time does not require predestination:
+axypolyas Not sure why you are bothered by all these; perhaps it is because of your choices in life. Let me tell you something which will bother you more. You might know already, however, anyone who is reading this exchange will highly likely not.
The "scientific" description of you, me and everything is "energy". We don't know what energy is. We can quantify it, however, in essence what is it? we have no idea. And energy takes different forms, like elementary particles, which in turn become atoms, molecules and part of the end result is "us". We know energy is governed by laws and constants which naturally takes us to the inevitable conclusion: we are governed by those constants and laws. Before discovery of quantum physics, this would mean we are completely deterministic objects. Quantum physics showed us that we are not 100% deterministic. We are limited by laws but still we are unpredictable (we can calculate probabilities of what we might do next, but we don't know what we will do next until we do it). What do all these mean for us? Who are we? or what are we? Why do atoms and molecules pile up and "make" us? to live longer? All the atoms in our bodies are almost 15 billions of years old. What we call life is just another state in which they continue existing; nothing more; nothing special about it. How can we make sense of all these? Can we make sense of all these? If we are only, and only, condensed energy, there is no such a thing as making sense of things. There is only energy going through one state to another state "mindlessly". Pretty scary and dark explanation of our existence, is the pure scientific one.
Science is only a tool; only a methodology we use to "make sense" of the universe. It does not tell us why things are the way they are. It tells us how we can construct theories and how we can use methods to test them, so that, we can do all these in an objective way. Science is an extremely limited way of looking into existence. Are my feelings objective? No. Are they scientific? No. Or, should I greet my neighbour every morning? Should I have an extra spoon of ice cream today? Or why do we do science? Do we have to do science? Say for our survival? Our survival has no meaning given particles making up our physical bodies existed for billions of years and they will continue to exist, perhaps longer.
I will jump to my personal understanding, rather than "destroying ourselves" using science. To me, existence of The Creator makes more sense than anything else, including my own existence. The Creator, who logically must (and interestingly described as such in Islam which I have chosen as a path to follow) be All-Knowing, All-Powerful, capable of creating a free agent (my soul for example) with life, creating a universe in which those free agents can grow up, examine, study, learn, make sense of it... freely... is the only logical answer I can think of. We don't see the Creator, or souls, or anything which would "force" us to believe and accept. Creator made us free and as part of making that choice freely, we will always be bothered by our existence, but we will never find an answer. That will remain as a matter of choice and it has always been like that.
"The knowledge of truth as such is wonderful, but it is so little capable of acting as a guide that it cannot prove even the justification and the value of the aspiration toward that very knowledge of truth. Here we face, therefore, the limits of the purely rational conception of our existence." -- Albert Einstein - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
+Mr Meow The time mentioned here is the dimension of space-time we understand using mathematical equations. When someone says "what time is it?" the question means "what is the agreed measure we use to distinguish our location (like latitude or longitude) in space-time?" It is another unit we use to determine/communicate our location in space-time. The difference from other dimensions is: if you don't move on the surface of the Earth, your latitude and longitude won't change but things constantly move in the time dimension. Things move from what we call the past to the future. Before Einstein, we thought past would be gone and future would come into existence along the way. However, Einstein realised and showed us that the past, the present, the future all exist in the same way even though we feel a flow from the past to the future.
***** google space time..prob via quantum physics,get ur head around that,,einstein once said WW4 will be fought with sticks n stones..
12richn So?
dingojerk The only way you can understand that is to understand this first: time is a dimension like X, Y, Z (say corresponding to width, height and depth). So, yes, there is a number on the time dimension which corresponds to your location which happens to be in the future, as well as in the past or at this moment. Your past, your now and your future exist in the same way. However this does not mean your future is predetermined. It is very difficult to understand this; perhaps impossible for humans at the moment. Watch my other videos regarding Quantum Mechanics (illusion of distance, rigid objects etc) which will help you develop an intuition about nature of reality. No one fully understands these, so don't worry if you can't.
If you are wondering my personal thoughts on all these: The Creator, who must be independent of creation logically and by definition, has created everything in the same way ie. from a higher perspective; now, past, future.. they are all the same. But we, as the creatures who are part of the creation, are experiencing, learning, understanding and appreciating the unimaginably immense creation bit by bit, piece by piece, step by step, by moving along the time dimension. Once I ran into an article by a physics professor which was saying that discovery of Higgs Boson would mean that there is a force field in the universe and at some point in the very far future a disruption will emerge somewhere in the universe. It will propagate at the speed of light. It will wipe away the universe as we know it. Then universe will transition into a more stable state. Sounded pretty much like Doomsday and afterwards of the final judgement. I find all of these truly fascinating!
***** I appreciate your post. I think of the theory described in vid as something that is immaterial to time travel/future divination and thus real world application. If I were in Russia I would be 8 hours (24 hour day reckoning) ahead of the US but it does not follow that a lottery number that had been picked 8 hours earlier in US would be recorded in my Russian newspaper 8 hours ahead of time picked due to that difference . I wager this is more smoke and mirrors than science with no practical value as we know no means of overcoming the speed of light...but before light is transferred or emitted there must be a time/place to do such. No matter how I cut it it is only logical to me that one can become aware of what has happened in the past, in their real time, only from emanations from light/radio etc waves that has preceded the search for such regardless of what the individuals clock might read. I guess I am agreeing with you :) tis my laymen's concept of how time can be perceived in a cause / effect universe. Thx for post.
Mars P Do you realize that you are talking about the theory which your smartphone is using to show you your location? And not just your phone; all billions of GPS devices function properly using this theory that you call "immaterial". What's wrong with you?
It’s comforting to think that lost loved ones still exist in a very real sense. We are only separated by time.
It’s only slightly less disconcerting to think that the future already exists as well.
Most people think I'm crazy. But I've believed, since the first time I took LSD, that time is merely an illusion shaped by my own limited perception. I've been able to experience days in what seemed like hours, and I've been able to experience weeks in what seemed to be months simply by changing my mindset. "Reality" is truly the most beautiful concept imaginable.
@Random -- of course the past nor future exist, only now exists and that applies to everything in the known universe. Now while the past does not exist, the ramifications of the past do exist, if you step on an ant and crush it now, the past will always maintain the integrity of that cause and effect, that ant will remain crushed forever. The future is different, like the past it does not exist but unlike the past, events of the future can't reach back and alter the past regardless of the experiments that seem to show that photons appear to go back in time and change their state, wave or particle depending on if they happen to encounter a slit. I certainly don't have the math chops to tell them they are wrong but I have very confident that it does not mean the future can change the past or present, like this topic, that is in my opinion a bad interpretation of the lab results.
I don't think you're crazy dude - when I did LSD many years ago one of the main things I experienced was what one can only call distortion of time....at different stages it felt like hours had passed and it was actually only minutes and vice versa. My conclusion then, is that time is only a matter of perception.
+SeventhOne perception of time and actual flow of time are different. obviously perception of time varies - this doesn't require lsd to know. the video is saying the real flow of time is relative.
Jimmy R this makes us conclude we don't have a free will. If events all existing including the future, we don't have a free will in which we are in control of our reality.
I dont know why people find this stupid its obvious, preception of time is how many thoughts you have if u only thought once in 2 years time would feel really fast
Its as basic as the saying time flys when ur having fun
I think the trippiest part of all this is how we've managed to acknowledge this.
Trippiest part is if everyone in the world was able to acknowledge this
Math equations
YES like wtf
What doest make sense me is if the future already exists and I'm already dead in somebody elses now. that means everything already happened, so we have no free will?
@@tinbrass8489 we have infinite paths to take. We aren't God we can't create new things altogether like God did( I say God for explanation purposes) Think of it like this there are paths set out infinitely where you do different things but they are already done so since there are infinite ways to pick you can think of it as you going to grab an apple and and water or your other path grabbing an orange and water or you can grab a banana and water so can do those or you can mix them so they create mix of possiblities at larger numbers of you deciding things it creates what we do but it's technically already set out for different ones of ourselves to do. If you are interested in quantum physics apply the infinitentionalities to ever thing I said and it will create a weird visual for you in your mind that will help you understand these time conundrums we live in
I would have been more interested in my Physics lessons at school if teachers had talked more about Einstein's theories of past, present and future.
So true. Unfortunately even when I was a physics student, I did not learn about such implications of theories. Btw, I recommend the whole documentary. Link is in the description. Also watch The Elegant Universe.
Me too
Ikr.
I am really interested in space.
I did physics in school and ended up hating it cause my teacher was crap at teaching.
I still love space and physics though minus my fail in HS.
The teachers cant comprehend this thierselves
Yep theoretical physics is the fun part, and usually only Newtonian and mechanical physics is taught in high school.
Put even simpler, think of a film strip. Watching a movie, you experience the film as having a start, middle, and ending. But, if you take the film off the projector and stretch it out...you will see that all the frames of the movie exist simultaneously.
Steven Crittenden that’s exactly what I think. life is like a straight line and the past present future all exist simultaneously like you riding a bike for the first time at the age of 6 exist right now it still there happening you can Apply this to any specific time in your life before and after. Like when you die exist right now and when you were born coming out of your mother’s womb that specific moment is still there
If you take out a film strip then there are two ends on the film strip, a start and a finish. Even though there is a start and a finish they and whatever is between them exist. To apply this analogy on the space time continuum of our universe we have a start (big bang) and a finish (second big bang or cosmic acceleration) and whatever is between them exist at the same time. But there is nevertheless "frames" or "slices" that are infront of or behind another slice or frame.
I think the point he was making is that time gets extorted with motion. For example, their is a Russian cosmonaut that holds the record for most time spent in space aboard the iss. The iss is flying through space much faster in relation to everyone on the earth. The faster you move through space the slower time progresses. Therefore after crunching all the numbers the cosmonaut once back on earth is literally living a fraction of a second in the past compared to everyone else on earth.
great explanation!! thanks for that
Is the past and future physically happening right now?
So this is why it seemed like it took planet Namek several 26 minute episodes to blow up when Frezia said it will only take 5 minutes.
Bar Kelly hahahaha
Bar Kelly i saw this coming hahahahahahah
hehehe xD
almost the same time it took the genki dama....
Prince of all Sayians goku can do anything
Im fascinated by the universe, consciousness and everything related to it. It just becomes too hard to understand it sometimes. Astrophysics is like a different language.
Do you think this model allows for free will ?
I agree but once I dug into the mystery of the simple of life it became my drug I can seem to leave , such as understanding numerology to the vowels of language to the cynmatics of frequency’s , my advice is don’t make it hard trying to put your theory to what’s been simplified for high performance
@@ZiplineShazam understand free will is the option to lean towards one side of the duality of reality , hot or cold , up or down. Life presents many outcomes or stages to the B from A starting position , of your being influence by the energy around you unsubconscious then free will be only as a dream but one whom takes in consideration the frequency’s that pushes you towards a thought to action than free will is a actually reality
@@trashdrumming2983 Had I not posted that question.. .you would have not posted that response. . .Law of Cause and effect ?
People that had near death experiences say this all the time. I still can't wrap my head around it even with this explanation. But I think I can be closer to understanding than I have been. Thank you.
Same
Same. Every time I think about it my brain starts fogging over… a bit disturbing really.
what those people say in death time?
I think the feeling of experiencing time differently during a near death experience is more of a physiological reaction due to the endorphine overload your nervous system recieves, opposed to the effects of relativity.
@@justinodougherty3647 bro leave science apart and think how we can feel things, people or how decision is making whole these things are not done by fuc##ing brain......!!!!
Einstein must have had the best weed...
🤣😂🤣😂👍🏻😢
The best Acid
angels
you can "actually see " the past. go outside and look at the stars, at night. the light you see coming off the stars, has happened many many years ago, but we are seeing this as 'now' hence, time is is motion.
DJ Delete well this is a little bit of a different concept and only occurs because we are seeing light that traveled from far away.
Whoa that just woke something in me
@@THERE.IS.NO.DEATH. Yes agree, this is different.
is that because the light was travelling a long distance that to reach here?
Every moment that has yet to happen already is and has been.
So no free will then, cool
Huh?
Spin around (like a whirling dervish) clockwise(yang northern hemisphere/yin southern hemisphere) or counterclockwise (yin northern hemisphere/yang southern hemisphere) (torus spinning). Chant any of these mantras 3 times each while facing east, west, north(in the southern hemisphere) or south(in the northernhemisphere): "ieouah", "um"(like "from"), "aum" and "om". Sleep with your head placed east, west, north(in the southern hemisphere) or south(in the northern hemisphere). Stare into the flower of life before sleep. Perform the 5 Tibetan rites. Play music at 440hz, 528hz, 432hz, and 396hz.
@@SuperAussie999 I think quantum physics suggests that every possibility exists in the form of waves of probability. So in theory every possible version of the past, present and future also exists. Infinite futures.
@@SuperAussie999 you made your cboices already. This is exactly what the oracle was talking about in the matrix reloaded.
nice to see other people share this view. i came to this conclusion awhile ago after having watched alot of documentaries on the universe. I also had an experience on psychedelics where time didnt exist. i felt like i was in the past present and future all at the same time. it was amazing. If you look through the hubble telescope at the farthest reaches of our universe which is 13.7 billion light years away, you are looking into the past because thats how far it took for that light to reach us. so i believe that every moment in tje universe is happening all at the same time.
I experienced the same thing with time multiple times with psilocybin.
so how could they see the future
how do they know that the alien used bike
Hodgkin's Law of Parallel Planetary Development
Google it. ;-)
You're mum's a bike an alien has used.
Selave1 Creador Asking the real questions
Selave1 Creador
it's common sense aliens use blue bikes dumbass
Bike is universal like Math, LoL
Ever been sitting there and suddenly realize (not guess, not feel, but actually REALIZE) that someone is going to call and you know which acquaintance it is, as well as why they are calling?
I've had it happen with as much as 2 hours notice and it CREEPS ME OUT.
What do you mean? Can you explain more? Like the feeling of predicting the future or something?
I've gotten to the point where u already know who is going to do what and who's lying and what there lying about it's like life is so predictable to me that me and my life is boring I hate it honestly..
Einstein's gf: just give me 2 things babe
Einstein: Tell me
Einstein's gf: Space & Time
Einstein: And the other?
ok i see what u did there
XD
Underrated comment
Memories, dreams and déjà vu are results of past present future existing together. Time is why there's order and organization of how everything happens.
no
No. Deja vu is a proven brain malfunction
No
I've always said this about time. I see time as a webs on top of webs, of all possible outcomes given of all choices available to all living beings. So the Universe isn't as deterministic as I once thought it was, but all possible futures exist NOW and the that happens based off your choices collapses into reality in real time. Just like the double slit experiment in a sense.
I've always thought I was pretty smart. After watching this, I feel like a four-year-old with my finger up my nose...
+herrdocjdm you obviously did not understand my very simple statement. You should be proud of your over-abundance of kindness however.
Child I most intelligent form of God. Thinking is like flipping a coin expecting no change. I remember not my child. I know my child.
I literally laughed out loud and scared my cat 😂
x Whaledream Ok Whaledream.
YourGuitarSage It's just another theory, man. Don't bang your head on the wall.
This is one of my all-time favorite explanations of a challenging physics concept. It’s mind-changing and life-changing, to realize that eternity - the sum total of past, present, and future - is real. Brian Greene explains Einstein's insight with a simplicity and clarity worth of his predecessor's genius.
Past, present and future is how human sense defines time, as a continuum. In REALITY, there is no way to capture the present within the framework of time because time is never present. It only deals a past or a future. ETERNITY has nothing to do with time at all. Eternity doesn't mean a very long time. ETERNITY is timeless. Often human sense defines certain terms only on a limited basis because human sense only deals with the finite, the observable or the measurable. The word infinity means nothing finite, or not finite, meaning there is nothing there to measure. Having no beginning and no end INFINITY is completely without reference points. ALL is either all, or there is no ALL at all.
@@ferdinandalexander8053o there is a present, it’s in between the infinite past n future. “Now” exists, but it’s constantly moving along centered right between past n future. So “now” is always moving. So it appears to always be the past or future.
It’s like the loaf of bread. If you take an iPhone and set the setting to 10 snapshots. Every one of those snapshots is a “now” but each snapshot is of you mid-movement into the future. So the picture of now keeps moving and centered the entire time. So confusing to me
@@jamesdoakes4956 NOW has nothing to do with what appears to the so-called finite human senses. NOW is not the word NOW. NOW is not stuck between what appears as the flow of time. A so-called past is a speculative thought, and a so-called future is a speculative thought. NOW is REALITY. There is nothing prior to NOW, nothing after NOW as IT is not in time at all. Time never stops to be present, never stops to "be", thus time does not exist. BEING is a synonym for the word EXISTENCE. Both terms speak of what is the same ONE. The can be but one ALL, one INFINITY. There is simply nothing else present besides NOW, the PRESENT ITSELF.
@@jamesdoakes4956 Not quite. NOTHING is moving. Try this analogy: You map all of spacetime -- which includes all pasts, presents, and futures -- onto a phonograph record. You place it on a turntable, but the turntable never spins. All of space time is there - space being the record, and time being a point on the record; all of your life is there; all of the "now" configurations of your brain are there - each with a memory configuration that tells a "then" "past", a "then" "now", and a "then" "future". Now, still without the turntable spinning, lift the arm with the playback needle off its holder and move it to any spot on the record and lower it onto it. That point on the spacetime record become "now". Pick up the needle and move it anywhere else. That then becomes "now". Your sense of movement through time is a complete illusion. The needle could be randomly bouncing all over the place, and you wouldn't have a clue. At every point, you'd have a sense of a past, a sense of "the" present, and a sense of an unknown future. But with the phonograph record analogy, you clearly see that there is a fixed future, even if it's not "yet" in your memory. Move the needle a bit forward, and a bit of the future will then be in your brain's memory configuration - your then "past". Note that time isn't moving and the needle never needs to be moved onto the record for all of spacetime to be there existing. HOWEVER, the needle is significant. More on that later.
My question is: does the natural, constant motion of the universe and the orbital/swirling motion of everything in it mathematically counteract this phenomenon so that we all actually are on the same “now slice”?
When your a baby you don’t even realize time passes and those years are gone in an instant, you can also barely move. As you grow you become more and more active seeing and doing more things, in general living faster. Then you grow up more and you slow down and reflect on what you’ve done before, how you felt like it would never end in the moment and how it now feels like the end is only coming faster. Then you get even older and reform back to a slow life, and at that point your gone in an instant just as fast as you were here from a baby. When someone tells me time is relative or time is a construct it makes sense to me because even on earth we perceive time differently depending on how we are acting. During quarantine I wouldn’t leave my house for a month or two at a time and lost all sense of time other than whether it was dark or light outside. You don’t live a seemingly long life by being motionless and hermetic, but by living fast and experiencing new things.
Who else watching this on 2024 ?
hi i'm here from 4017
Fida Hasan is there a half life 3 yet?
And I'm from 2036
Sorry, i'm in 999,999
from my angle, the internet does not yet exist...
Why do I watch these things?
It just gives me headaches and highlights my status as a simpleton.
mydogiscalledoscar
Then pay attention and read a dictionary... It's not that complex.. It's a simple act of not being a lazy stupid fuck like a lot of incompetent sheep upon the spiral gravitating through space.
Perspective, perspective. Either you're living for something, or you're dying for nothing. You're either the cog or the one who built it. And if you're both, be sure to apply both experiences simultaneously, juxtaposed to YOUR life's mission.
And what is your life's mission you may be asking yourself? Well, whatever you want it to be. Life if like a metaphorical canvas and you are like the artist.But you are also the paint, and the paint brushes. You are the fullaity of consciousness experiencing itself subjectivly. So live every moment to it's fullest so you have nothing to regret.
True happiness can only be obtained through a peace of mind. Bottom line. ;)
mydogiscalledoscar But then you remember who you are
mydogiscalledoscar don't worry friend you're not alone
that's how you grow, through struggling and reflecting deeply within yourself
because you have a natural curiosity for this type of stuff, that's how people become knowledgeable about things, interest in it!
For all those skpetical about just how un-linear time is, think about how you can live an entire life time in your dreams while only a few hours pass and vice versa, think of days/months/weeks that fly by and those that drag on. I've never given time a linear perspective and sometimes all it takes is some kind of shift and it feels like im in conrtol of it whether i wanna speed it up or slow it down and we can all do that and more, you just need to understand that the 4th dimension is not unaccessible to us.
it’s crazy how humans have created these ideas, such as time (when described as a unit like day, minutes, years, etc) which is considered an illusion, in order to merely scratch the surface of comprehending the universe. you could say human beings as a species are just unique in the sense that our brains actually feel a need to do this
This is the conclusion I came to while on LSD. Pity I just looked like an idiot repeatedly muttering "but its all happening all at the same time."
I doubt your understanding while under the influence was as articulate and mathematically defined as a physicist's would be. I have no idea what happens to a person on that drug but I don't think it gives people new skills or understandings like Neo got from the matrix.
While i wouldnt promote drug use, LSD is well known to be somewhat educational.
Nifty Fingers I couldn't explain it but it can heighten your senses and unlock parts of your brain you never new existed or forgot about. I recommend trying some.
+Nifty Fingers ok if you don't know anything about it like you claim, then keep your opinions to yourself? it's not a "drug" in many senses, more of a key to the door of a passageway into hyper perception of true reality. There are so many things happening around us in this present moment that our brain tunes out naturally. With chemicals like LSD, psilocybin, and DMT, those frequency blocking brain switches are flipped and we become aware of the true nature of the reality in which we live. Time definitely does not exist in a heavy psychedelic trip. But it's as if all things that have happened and will happen are happening at once within your relative perspective depending on where you are or what you're doing. If you are listening to someone speak, you will hear/see/understand an entire idea at one moment, rather than listening to each word said aloud and slowly piecing together the words in order within your mind. I hope this makes sense. DMT is the most intense thing in our known universe. You inhale it's smoke form and you are immediately tuned into all possible dimensions of our universe at all places in our universe, at all times in our universe. you can literally see another person/alien/entity who are also in the dmt plane-whatever it is. I'm excited about what we will learn about and from these chemicals.
Ryan Cook my point was that LSD is no substitution for hard work. I agree I haven't done it I can't comment on it, but what I do know is that if you can't speak a language, LSD won't teach it to you. The guy above said "its all happening at the same time" multiple times to people and no one got it. Whether or not he understood the advanced physics of time and simultaneity, we will never know, unless he COMMUNICATES his understanding to us. And that communication requires the language of math and physics, which you have to study to be fluent in. LSD can't do your study for you.
I had a profound experience on Salvia Divinorum. I basically exited our " reality " and realized that time is just a space in the universe. In my experience I was able to see myself in the past and even in the future because I was outside of my life. Think of your life as a video tape that is playing. Because it's a video tape, all the information is already on it. The beginning and the end is already written. Time is just " playing " your tape at the same speed as everybody elses tape is being played, in the same dimension. Time travel is only possibly without having a physical body. You have to be able to exit the tapes and be able to go around them in space time.
I had a same experience on DMT, but i met another entity formed of a blue light, it wanted to let me know it loved me. .... weird af i know
Josh Mugen its amazing what you feel.. even describing it in words is NOTHING compared to feeling it
well, you must also be able to argue that we still dont know what Life is and cant explain our view of time, time might as well be just as it appears, it just doesent work with physics the way we Think it does beacuse we are so obsessed with making Everything compatible wiht our personal views of what time and Life is
One time I had a dream that my life was like a youtube video and I could go back and forth in time by skipping or replaying parts of the video
very profound...
I always instinctively believed in this.This also explains why some people know what will happen in the future.
True. I've seen "flash-afters" of the future twice in my life, and they unfolded EXACTLY how I saw them. It was mindblowing.
@@ashley_brown6106I’ve had more than a dozen and you’d think it’d be an important time in my life… nope just random ass moments.
They should have definitely explained the mechanism that allows time to be observed by us, which is light of course. Obviously the graphic simulation had implemented that aspect as an implication, but anyone trying to understand this without that knowledge is going to have a hard time putting these pieces together. The reason why time is observably different is because when you move away from light, you technically delay the time it takes for light to hit your eye for your observation to be changed from the previous moment, and vice versa for light moving towards you.
This could also just be an exert from the full episode, I'm not sure though.
8:19 that means that a *past* version of me enjoys the company *right now* of a close friend that has passed away. It's nice that that can be true and I take comfort in that.
And even after you die, some slice of you still exists in relation to someone elses location in the Universe.
I find comfort in the fact that a friend I lost years ago is still happy and well in the now-slice of the overwhelming vast majority of the observable universe. Ours is but a minority viewpoint. Be at piece, friend.
I love it when physicists can illustrate these concepts in ways that make them intuitive. Before I die, I want to understand Special and General Relativity, not just the math behind it, and this video has brought me one step closer :)
Understanding the math behind it is the difficult part and the part that would really provide for the deepest understanding
@@gregorsamsa1364 From what I've learned since that post, the math gives us a model, not a mechanism. It is like a far more precise version of Newtonian gravity. Einstein's math only tells us what to expect, like the passage of time near very massive bodies. Like Newton before, he gave no mechanism to underlie his math. Einstein never explained *how* mass curves spacetime. He only gave a precise way to quantify the effect.
I came to the same conclusion when I was 13. I used the movie Back to the Future as thought experiment material, for Marty to be able to get back in time, the past must exist somewhere. Moreover him being in the past whilst those he left behind were still living normally, meant that all time periods sort of existed at the same time. So I finally came to the conclusion that time is like a house where all rooms, that stand for different moments, exist simultaneously.
In the end however, it didnt console my existential torment. For the problem remains our perception of time and that moves in a single direction relentlessly.
So how do i get to the past ? Is it possible for me to go to the past to see myself ??
@@yazrinwise2438 everything is existing all at once, a flow of strings vibrating at different rhythms, our consciousness can only perceive one specific rhythm which is considered now.
@@bubbasocks7466 holy shit dude....
That film "Deja Vu" explores this question also. The character Claire who has been murdered still exists four days in what we call the "past". She might be dead "now" but she is exists on another timeline and in another dimension.
When Doug asks "Is she alive, or is she dead "?? The answer is "She's alive".
Physics genius: "life, like space and time is not merely a local phenomenon'.
Watched this 5-6 years ago when I was a school kid now after 2years of studying physics and having taken a course on relativity all of this makes much sense 🌚
My state of mind according to this video:
Past - mind not yet blown
Present - mind being blown
Future - mind blown to smithereens
I think one of the big problems with physics at the moment is that it is ruled by mathematics and, sadly, mathematics as a language is being found to be inadequate. Yet we persist with it and have to invent new particles and devices in order to explain our calculations. Don't get me wrong, I love maths, and have studied it to degree level. But I think we'll look back to our current time from the future and quietly laugh at our explanations of space and time, just like we do at our ancestors. If the study of history has taught us nothing else, its that most of the current explanations in physics is wrong.
Very true. But in the meantime we need to make progress.
+Mike Kleinsteuber Thats human nature, we like to see patterns and so we like to believe that mathematics are the patterns of the universe, while our current maths might have extra ordinary reach in the possibilities of the universe, there might be other ways the universe works that we don't understand yet and that could/migh grant us acces to greater things like time travel, teleportation and all the other sci-fi stuff we like to dream about.
+Mike Kleinsteuber Right on. You are smarter than most.
Well said Mike kleinsteuber!
+Mike Kleinsteuber yet we use math consistently to create technology because values are predictable, otherwise they'd be completely useless...
Would be great to see a video how The illusion of time : past, present and future all exist together (Einstein) relates to the block universe, a theory which states that the past, present and future exist simultaneously. This means that once an event has occurred, it continues to exist somewhere in space-time. How do both theories relate to The Delayed Choice/Quantum Eraser/Time experiment that seems to illustrates how what happens in the present can change what happens(ed) in the past. It apparently also shows how time can go backwards and how cause and effect can be reversed, and how the future caused the past. Science can sound sound very weird and counter intuitive.
well it's because you are still thinking in terms of time as horizontal line from past to future that's why it sounds weird. there is no time, there is only now, past and future doesn't exist.
I had a vision of a cube in space. Every point in the cube could reach any other point. The cube condensed and all points were one point, yet they were still able to reach each other. Everything is happening at once in the same place. And yes, I was using a mind altering substance. This vision has changed the way I relate to time and space.
Must be a Borg ship
That actually does explain it in a sort of fashion. Basically, time is not linear, what we know as "past" "present" and "future" exist simultaneously, it's a dimension that just exists and nothing is actually moving forwards or backwards.
We perceive what we know as "time" moving because we have clocks and calendars and sun and moon which gives a feeling of a linear flow of time, but it's psychological only.
@@ActiveAussie2024 Can you explain how we age?
Just think of 'space-time' as one thing, in a similar fashion that electricity and magnetism are the same thing. The only difference is how that energy is expressed. Time and space exist as energy, which is why speeding up to the speed of light almost literally slows your time to a stop, all that energy is being used to travel through space. I know this isn't a perfect analogy but I think it helps to understand things if you try to simplify it.
Good job, man :)
can u pls explain..how..riding the cycle toward the earth guy..makes a future slice..n the other way a past slice..I thought always the clock in motion has a time dilation.
Because this is just a random exercise in geometry. It doesn't carry any actual scientific weight.
The dilation comes from our experiencing it, which also takes time.
Change 'thing' to point & you're there. Good work!
my now, my rules.
theuncanspan Exactly!
Or completely imprecisely.
theuncanspan All your rules are belong to _us_
We are in control, sure, or are we?
Good video, one of the best ive watched. I am still confused af but at least got a better understanding of this theory.
Very good video. Philochrony is the theory that describes the nature of time and demonstrates its existence. Time is magnitive: objective, Imperceptible (intervals) and measurable (duration).
Thats it ! If you cut your bread at an angle you will never be late for work again!
Lol
GREAT SCOTT...!!!
We have already made our choices, we always had. But, now, we don't know them. Yet.
Funny thing is, even as a child I imagined time as being "slices of now" in time
u r genius if u try hard u can be our new einstein
Why does this topic always give me a headache?
Because it's a lot to take in
+Gwen King Don't worry, it's given a lot of top mathematicians and physicists headaches too!
+Gwen King Haha it really does overwhelm one's mind. That's why I find it so impressive the things Einstein and people like Newton discovered in their lifetimes. It's very interesting, and I think we can understand small bits of it in isolation, but there are many factors which all work together and it's very difficult to compact that into a single understandable idea.
Exactly, I am no dummy and I can get the gist of this in isolated bits. I think Einstein must have been a 4th dimensional alien (LOL) to envision all of this at once. I am so right brained it eludes me in its entirety :)
+Gwen King Glad I'm not the only one, GK. I have no problem admitting that I enjoy listening to ideas from people who can understand some things my brain refuses to wrap itself easily around.
I'm going to spend more time driving my truck back and forth in the driveway to screw with some distant aliens existence.
*James Halleluyah*: Hahaha - that's funny! Just don't run over any bugs while you're doing it, or you could change EVERYTHING!! ; P
I like the thought of shifting back and forth between a distant aliens past and future over and over again.
James Halleluyah Weird, but interesting! Did you catch my reference to a Simpsons episode where Homer experiences a different reality when he kills a bug, and with other things he does? When you say "shifting back and forth...", does that mean you also believe in reincarnation?
There are a couple of Star Trek TNG and Voyager episodes that deal with time shifting. There's also an episode were Data refers to alternate universes, where everything that can happen does happen in each alternate reality.
No, I did not catch the reference, sounds like a good episode. By shifting I meant gears as in reverse then forward. According to the video movement towards and away from the distant alien causes you to move forward and backwards in time in relation to the same alien.
I'm a Christian so no on reincarnation. I look forward to something much better than being reborn God knows how many times and as God knows what.
=)
James Halleluyah Yes, it was actually a good episode. Oh, OK that's what you meant - I found the whole concept a little hard to follow. Maybe it's because it was so late at night and I was tired.
Ah, OK, so you don't believe in reincarnation. I guess we'll all find out in the end exactly how many things work in reference to time, that we don't understand while we're still on Earth. I've read that actually, God sees time the way they were talking about in the video, because He's outside of time, and can see past, present and future all at once. It's only we who exist in relation to time and space.
This is the first video about time that actually made sense, and I've watched several.
Everything is happening at the same time. The battles of the 1700s are still unfolding. It's like folds on a piece of paper, the fold covers over but the paper still exists. To time travel, to the past and future and back again is to experience time on an objective level. The way we go through time traditionally is to experience time on a subjective level, however, it appears the other way around. Buddha said life is an illusion. This is what he is getting at. Television does a good job at depicting an objective experience of time with the time flashbacks, etc. Jet lag is a result of an objective experience of time clashing with a subjective experience of time. O = S objective = scientific, subjective = opinion. A statement that supports a subjective experience of time is "You're never on time." Statement supporting an objective experience of time: It's gotta be 5 o'clock somewhere. I think I'll have a beer NOW."
time is an idea constructed by the mind using sight hearing and touch without those sensations your brain would not understand what time is time is an idea in the mind that is brought to life through your vision you’re hearing and touch without those senses your brain would not know whats surrounding it and at what time your brain would not understand what is happing ever you would be ingolfed in darkness no noise to hear no color to see no image to stare at your brain can not construct an image if it’s has never seen it before your memories are hologram copies that your brain has made and stored for later use “drugs” allow us to have vivid dreams and ideas while still being conscious a.k.a. Awoke not asleep so when you’re on drugs any type of drug your brain is pretty much dreaming but you’re awake that’s why your vision your hearing even your speech can be impacted depending on the substance when you’re under the influence your brain isn’t functioning normally When you sleep at night your brain runs freely with ideas and thoughts mixed with memories & feelings and emotions they all flow together like a river of water People tend to watch alot of sci-fi movies with aliens & etc or they watch a lot religious movies & documentaries which claim God is real etc... then people experiment with drugs later on in life and hallucinate think you’re having a out of the world experience with God or In a matrix or a simulation or my favorite they met the aliens lmao when in reality it’s just your brain running free with all the ideas, religion, & culture, sci-fi, main stream media bullshit, fake news list goes on and on the human mind is a very powerful thing it is the greatest gift given to humanity once you lose it it never comes back remember brothers and sisters “MIND OVER MATTER”
@@themoblife3369 Read Quraan...😴you will understand..Allah clearely said he created this world and he expands it...how our prophet can know that the space is expanding 1400 years ago? there are many prove..there is mentioned that time in Afterlife(the place where heaven and hell is) is not equal to the time of earth...how he knew 1400 years ago without spending time on scince and researching?Allah said on Quraan that if anyone can write any book like Quraan than whoever you want to belive you can(whatever you want,,belive or not) belive..How our prophet can challenge like this.? Its clear that He is a messenger of Allah...if you read Quraan and research on Mohammad (S) s life...you will be a beliver....Allah also said no the day you born to the day you die every thing he knows and everything is fixed...it is called Taqdeer.but he still give punishment for our dids cause he gave us free will....though we have free will the futere is fixed.... thats what is in a book which came 1400 years ago.....if you still dont belive in our relegion(Islam) you are torturing yourself..
@@khaledsaifullahbukhari3336 God is energy. He is the source. There is no right or wrong r there is experience. Our God wants to learn. So we are here to experience everything and teach him everything. Is it no truly wrong religion but God is not that. He is all power. He is in us all. ❤️❤️❤️
Of couse religious people were spawned.
This then means, that destiny is written already. We have no power over our lives?
Not really. Here is a link to a discussion started by Avicenna10. You have to copy and paste the link; clicking on it might not work: th-cam.com/video/vrqmMoI0wks/w-d-xo.html&lc=z120wtri3qaccx5yr04cctj4fs3mwfwanyo0k&feature=em-comments
Thanks for your immeasurable contribution to science. Your Nobel prize is in the mail. Expect 3-5 business days. Nice doing business with you! LOL
Aleksandar Vidojevic yes the destiny is already known but not by you. As you dont know you have control over it. Whether is written or not you wont know it until you live it. How do you know it is written without considering your will . Great d has given the will power to be used like you legs , your brain, your eye sight .you know if you eat poison you will die then you can decide to eat or not.
exactly my line if thought
Does it feel like you have free will? If so that's all that matters.
Time exists.
I know, because I had to spend every second of Christmas with my inlaws.
Every second was, painfully, real.
Bhahahahahahahaha..
LMFAO!
Waltham1892 lol
Waltham1892 I did a pause laugh LMAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
Freethinkers420 my job here is done...
every single documentary I have seen includes Einstein. hats off to this great scientist.
Thing is the distance required to make a significant impact on the time is so great in relation to our size that this is not really that big a deal. The days of my grandfather's youth is indeed gone.
I reckon we are just caught in one huge slow explosion which gives us a sense of time as it pushes everything forward
I'm pretty new to most of these concepts, so sorry if this is a dumb question...but if the alien is moving away from earth and is carrying a particle that is entangled with a particle here on earth, does that mean they're sync'ed over his "now line," meaning he could affect the entangled particle's behavior back in the past? And moving towards and away from earth would cause that particle to zip back and forth through time...?
That's a very good question which I had to think about it a while ago. I don't know the answer because I don't know it it is possible for entangled particles popping up into different locations in the time dimension. If it is possible then particle might not zip back and forth through time but it would imply, past can be changed since it can be linked to future.
Swift Heart The one on the plane was slower.
I am a firm believer in this theory due to my experience with Salvia Divinorum. I could repeatedly experience my existence as an infinitesimal amount of timeslices, much like that of a flip book. I would experience being drawn forward like a magnet with will of my own.
I am curious, how do Presentists refute the Law of Simultaneity?
The way drugs alter your sense of time, or cause hallucinations, has nothing to do with any sort of b-theory of time. There's no drug you can take to settle the question of the fundamental nature of time
Does anyone have links, resources or papers concerning dimensions where there may exist more than 1 dimension of time and what equations/formulae may describe such a contingency (if any)?
1. "Yatha pindi.. tatha bramhanda" - Upanishad ' As is the body, so is the Universe'.
+Neeta Raina ....you don't say.......jesus dude.
Neeta Raina i was being sarcastic.....
Neeta Raina you're trying to sound deep but you're making me cringe. next thing I know you will be telling people how subatomic particles traveling millions of lightyears just to stop here on Earth hitting us is somehow romantic....
someone actually did that.
+warioman91 she's saying all of that because you're too stupid not to realise she's trolling you. she's messing with you man, and it's entertainment for the both of us lol
dingovory i was the one trolling her moron, of which i had to explain myself like a five year old. why do you think she deleted her comments?(she wasnt trolling)
um.. wouldnt the inertia from mass in motion cause a force against the mechanical apparatus of the clock causing a slightly slower movement>?
Yeah, it would when it's a normal clock, but it is an atomic clock
Google caesium clock
In an atomic clock it would still effect the atoms of the clock and the period of oscillation
you might even have a doppler effect as movement through space is going to blue shift the oscillations in the direction of travel and red shift the oscillations in the direction the clock is moving from
if the detector is at a right angle to movement of the clock It shouldn't pick up a doppler shift
But if the detector were placed in the line of travel it should be effected by doppler shift
NOW if you had 2 detectors one in front and one behind you would be able to measure the doppler effect and it should concur with the speed of light
At the quantum level nothing is continuous
they can't tell if it's analog or digital but they have a measure of the smallest time frame anything occurs in
so
anything moving through space it isn't a homogenous continual movement
it appears so because every particle has it's own moment it's period occurs in
so instead of thinking of moving through space as a continuity think of it as a process of increasing and decreasing frame rates with no change in the image itself
as you approach the speed of light your frame rates are going to compress on your advance and be spaced out more behind you
you are probably also going to experience blue shift in one direction and red shift in the other.
yeah your metabolism is going to slow down along with the movement of the particles that make you up and you are not going to age as fast as someone on the ground
but "time" isn't going to change for you.
you are still in the same now as the guy on the ground.
your physics are just functioning differently due to transiting the ether.
Now this leads to a novel experiment...
the question if your consciousness is because of your biology or because of a divine spirit
the supernatural (if it exists) exists outside of the natural
If you have a component of your consciousness that exists outside of the natural in the supernatural then you should be able to observe a difference between biological time and spiritual timelessness.
someone who cannot handle contemplating the supernatural would say as your brain slows down you could not perceive yourself slowing down
but from the supernatural perspective you SHOULD be able to discern your body and your thoughts slowing down.
there would be some spiritual sensation of lag.
extremely fast travel might have some spiritual ramifications for some people.
You probably got an a in physics
I did :D
I had the same thought. If you can time travel then all these things must exist at the same time but for some reason we seem to only move forward as humans
The illusion of 'time' - past, present, future, the key to accessing such, consciousness, via the mind. Everything is energy, frequency, which cannot be destroyed. Extrapolate from this - no such state as 'death', one step further, other incarnations offers the probability of being born into what we perceive as past and future timelines.
There is no time. There only is the speed of passing the time relative to. The only "time" that exists can be considered archived in a single frame/moment that is not relative to anything is the existance of present, future and past at the same time. And that is a moment relative to nothing that contains all moments relative to everything.
You do know that you just said time doesn’t exist then you said time exist
+Paul Why dont you shut up?
I already believed future past and present exist together. I mean future exists just like present. Think of this as a thought experiment-
You can communicate with yourself in the future at this present moment. It's only that it won't be a material talk. Now, imagine that you are talking to your future self right now. Suppose for simplicity, tomorrow and also think of the time. And at same time, say to yourself(present) that you are going to reply to your present self when you are in that time you thought of in the future. So somewhere in some timeline, your future self will actually be replying to you at the present moment to your present self.
It may seem absurd but it is true I think.
And when you are in the future, I mean when you are at the time you thought of just reply back to yourself in the past. Because in the past you are talking to yourself in the future. This is that future which is 'now' your present. And that is that past which 'was' your present. And all these three - present, past and future exist at the same time.
Don't go nuts, it's just a thought.
Nevertheless, they explained beautifully in this video.
Manav Goyal this is a mindfuck but it could be true. I feel like we have some serious abilities that we don't even know how to use yet
cool thoughts.. and clearly articulated. Thanks for posting, this was interesting info for me at just the right ..er..uh.. time!
This makes total sense to me. I've written notes to my future self. When the time arrives to read them, I say, well finally the future is here so let me read this note that I wrote in the past that used to be the future but is now the present.
damn!
Genae Young, that means nothing. We all no that.
8:54 does this mean that somewhere out there my ex still loves me? :(
Yep. And your loved ones that passed, they still exist. It's just that they're unreachable to you. It's kinda comforting.
Spin around (like a whirling dervish) clockwise(yang northern hemisphere/yin southern hemisphere) or counterclockwise (yin northern hemisphere/yang southern hemisphere) (torus spinning). Chant any of these mantras 3 times each while facing east, west, north(in the southern hemisphere) or south(in the northernhemisphere): "ieouah", "um"(like "from"), "aum" and "om". Sleep with your head placed east, west, north(in the southern hemisphere) or south(in the northern hemisphere). Stare into the flower of life before sleep. Perform the 5 Tibetan rites. Play music at 440hz, 528hz, 432hz, and 396hz.
@@danielsherwood3460 🥺 thank you.
Could this mean that the reason we can’t find life on distant planets, is because when we observe them we’re observing a different now from that with which alien civilizations would be present on those planets? Could we be looking at the past and/or future of these planets? Rather than the “now slice” that actually contains life?
That's one explanation but scientifically speaking having a planet with the right conditions for life and especially lasting long enough for a smart species which can send some information into outer space is way lower than scientists initially thought. Perhaps Earth is the only planet with life.
they say what happens but not why....
900bz Welcome to conceptual time/dimension science videos on TH-cam.
Not everything has a why
Thats because the atheists always stop short of crediting GOD!
Thumbs up if you loved that cat in this video!
900bz: It was explained in Einstein's prediction. Gravity affects space-time.
And so... Would this be the reason that light is the cosmic speed limit? Because if you traveled so fast, your "now slice" angle would be parallel to the time axis? So you would be relative to no one anymore, and you'd basically be non-existent?
+Ralph Strocchia woahhhhhhh
+Ralph Strocchia Yes, since time is a man made thing applied to the world and the cycles of nature and the universe you are sortof on point. To what time axis are you referring? There could be no point of reference because a person would be moving so fast away from that point they wouldn't even see it let alone witness being at the speed of light. If a person were to be moving towards something at the speed of light would one even be able to determine how fast they were moving? Probably not. We don't have any true instruments to measure such an event. I agree we would be nonexistent with witness around us because they would not be moving at the same speed if they were in the same place stationary next to us as we passed bye, lol.
+DeViouS DoMiNik It is not a theory. And it is more of a tautology.
I love this vid, it's the only vid which so easily and simply explains space time.
Annoying how i can't seem to find the full episode . It says its not available :(
This really explains SO much about the Doctor's near constant navigational mistakes.
Shouldn't the word "illusion" be replaced with the word "perception "?
Perception is about the observer however illusion is more about the observed. Something might not be an illusion but you might perceive it different from others.
“For we convinced physicists, the distinction between past, present, and future is only an illusion, however persistent.” - Albert Einstein.
That was him playing word games, Einstein did not believe the future exists or the past for that matter, the "illusion" is in the math, not in reality.
You spoke nonsense.
Misperception
Anita Foster excellent point
Thank you. I've found that people have a hard time believing this. Time is relative to the observer. People often think the way they perceive time is objectively correct, but that's just the rate they perceive information. For example; A dog perceives time around 25% slower than we do. If our perception of time was objectively correct then we would all perceive time at the same rate. Past, present and future all exist as one, we just don't experience it that way. Our lives mainly consist of us trying to compose an understanding out of the world around us.
If the bicycling alien is an appreciable distance away, it would take an appreciable amount of time for light to get from us to him. So, wouldn't his perception of our activity, whether past or future, be past to us either way? If alien is traveling at what is currently considered to be a realistic speed toward us but far enough away to be significant, do the calcs show him seeing something happen before the "us" in the same time slice as him perceived it?
Its kind of calming to see young Professor Greene and Professor Caroll.
How does the direction you move change the time slice direction to past or present ?
Exactly.....this is what i don't understand
basically you move towards the light so you see it earlyer. But it isnt quite that simple, try simultaneity video by Eugene khutoryansky
I saw all this during a meditative state when I was in Australia in 2001 although I saw time as a ball..
Time and space are nothing more than energy in motion.
Watching this was a golden experience. Its so interesting. It feels like a requiem for physics.
Check out other videos on my channel. I tried to provide links to the documentaries they have been taken from. I am sure you will enjoy them even more.
Here's the theory that's gonna blow your mind:
Have you guys ever heard of "Cyclic Universe" theory which says our universe has been infinitely recycled over and over again (Big Bang --> expanding universe --> contracting universe --> Big Cruch --> Big Bang again --> new universe --> so on).
Who knows after the new Bing Bang, all the things that ever happened in previous universe will happen again exactly the same way in the new universe...
Who knows there will be the same you (maybe slightly different) doing the exact same things (maybe slightly differently) in the next universe.
And who knows when we die in this current universe...we'll actually feel like waking up in the next universe as the same new-born baby as we were in this universe. (We actually have to wait trilion years for the new universe to come & to be born again...but we won't feel it coz when we die it might feel like deep sleep) #MINDBLOWING
And during that trilion years of waiting, our body (our matter) & our energy will always be converted into something/someone else until this universe contracts and ends up with the new universe.
any thoughts on this? ^_^
Steven Hawking & Albert Einstein taught me this theory...
Surprisingly Hinduism & Buddhism taught this theory thousand years before modern science :o
More of a lucky guess than anything, since the actually understanding of the subject was practically zero. It was much pondering and speculation. The nice thing is that this view is so much broader and not a self-centered point of view perpetuated by some other religions
Minh Bui yup it's still speculation though and we may never know the truth. Who knows we've been stuck in this never ending cycle for infinite mount of times ;)
The most interesting is the fact that we thought we knew everything about this cosmos but in fact we know very very little :D #Mindfullness
There is a more probably explanation of our existence based on completely scientific progress that we made recently: th-cam.com/video/oyH2D4-tzfM/w-d-xo.html I personally do not think we are not real. I think we are real and reality was designed to work this way.
maybe all times past present and future are all existing at the same time in different parallel realities..?
+K. Weiss who knows, maybe one day we will truly understand it all.
+K. Weiss yeah I bet they do, but the secret knowledge is getting more chances to get unveiled by the day so its only a matter of time (lol "time" again)
There is no way Illuminati know any of this. There are tons of great minds working on this problem, and noone knows "everything". If Illuminati exist there is no way they could have enough brilliant minds to outsmart the scientists that work for the public. You give Illuminati way too much respect, at best they just have secret meetings to think how they will continue to keep their power over governments.
+Rich King how did you get to know this?
I was thinking along the exact same thing..
This is the best attempt to help me understand time dilation I have ever seen. I almost kind of get it!
great effort for making this video...thanks a lot, for creative video making
With this theory we will always be present in space time even after we are long dead. If someone from future could travel backwards they will find us.
With that said Einstein can really be someone in the future who came back to our reality and told Einstein the ABC's of reality. Thus altering our timeline and moving our reality years ahead of it's original progress
Please watch Inter Stellar movie if you haven't yet watched.
Space and time are constructs to help us better adapt to our surroundings. They exist, but we just measure them and call them that. And we agree about it, because making our own language about them would be frivolous .
I think it was the Naval Research Lab (NRL) who had two atomic clocks; one on the ground, an identical on aboard a P3 Orion Aircraft.
This was reported on a edition of PBS’s NOVA science program years ago.
Adding my two cents I would have to ask - isn't our concept of time based on our rotation and orbit around our own sun? So in the alien example - our perception of time would require the alien's planet and position in it's solar system (assuming there was one) to be relative to ours? Or would we base the findings using our own concept of time?
never it can, cos their time is different, and they could not fit in our slice of bread
Somewhere, something(??????????....) extraordinary is waiting to be discovered. The thought itself tickles my spine. WHAT THE FUCK IS IT. Fuck lol I want to know damnit
We are all one dude
***** Of course
You might be surprised, Sir.
In worst case scenario, you'll get to see it when your time in this life has expired.
You should start looking for answers, one day it's too late.
Robin K I don't believe in fairy tales if that's what you're referring to.
+Robin K "late" is only an illusion.
I feel like this would also have to include the different distance from person to person or being to being because if I am sitting still and someone is walking, our "now" is different due to the statement of "motion slows the passage of time." Going back to the alien biking away from earth, his "now" is different and his now are things that happened in the "past" that happened on Earth, but biking in the direction of Earth, meant his "now" was going forward, towards the "future." So what this tells me is that distance and direction, depending on which "reality" (assuming there are different lifeforms and which ones you are using) also plays a factor in how each individual person perceives spacetime. So my bottomline questions are, who's/what distance is being used to determine the current "now," and if motion slows down the passage of "time," would speeding up cause "time" to go "faster?" As well as has the question of "why does motion slow the passage of time?"
im confused so if moving small distances distorts time so much when extremely far apart then wouldn't planets moving very fast on the far side of the universe be constantly shifting billions and trillions of years into the past and future in a very small amount time in our now? and wouldn't we be able to detect something like that if that is the case?
it is not constantly shifting, it is shifted by maybe some thousand years, but if the planet does not accelerate towards or away from earth, there is no shift, therefore, if it is ,say, 10 years ahead of our "now", then it will still be 10 years ahead after as many years as you want
KawaiiNightmare no
So in theory we could be able to manipulate time? To go back to "past" times? To advance further to the "future"? Even to change events that "happened" before? If reincarnation really exists, are we living our past, present and future lives at the same time? Where is "past" actually happening? Or "future"?
No, we can't go back to our past. But we can slow time for ourselves and live longer relative to others. However, from our perspective, nothing will change. (Remember in the movie Interstellar; when they were on the planet covered with water; time was slowed down for them since they were very close to the black hole, but it did not make any difference for them.)
And how can we slow time for ourselves and live longer relative to others? Thanks in advance for all your answers!
In practice; you have to be travelling on a really fast vehicle in space or live near a very strong gravitational force; which is not doable with current technology. Biologically; you can extend your lifespan by changing your simple habits: www.dailymotion.com/video/xvdbtt_eat-fast-live-longer-hd_shortfilms
azucenah villarroel There is also this: th-cam.com/video/4UkZAwKoCP8/w-d-xo.html
In theory yes, to all of your questions. But now a paradox takes place: if you go back in time to change that event, in the future you wont go back in time to change it meaning it would revert and happen in an infinite number of times.
What an interesting concept that many civilizations have tried to understand
That,s a question we still ask ourself today
It would be great to go back in time and choose an era we would like to visit or go forward in time and change things in our present life to have a better future
Albert Einstein was a genius and selfless man
Pretty sure this theory suggest we can only look into a past or future or event like watching a movie through a tv, not actually step in and interfere with a timeline event.
@@johngotti4286 It would be so great if we could like change a decision we made in the past which we though was right then was not after all correct mistakes we have made our present would be different 😮
I truly believe time is almost a structure and this can explain how higher dimensional beings can travel or interact with different points of this structure. I think we as 3 dimensional beings choose in every moment to not see reality like this because we are choosing to have a linear experience.
I'm not saying "time doesn't exist", however i do have a question:
If we're limited by the speed of light, wouldn't you think that "present time" or "real time" or "now" just doesn't make sense?
Since "we" claim that nothing travels faster than the speed of light and our brain is an electrochemical "device" by the time you form a tought, it will be already history......
This is what bothers me lately.
ExperienceCounts2
Thank you for all your efforts, but i knew all this, that's why i have the question.
I have something to say to you, ask you. Therefore i'm typing with my fingers using a few muscles in my body to allow my toughts to reach you on your screen sometime. The toughts i am to write down are formed or created in my brain. By the time i form a tought is it already past then? I'm not investigating how much time goes by when a light source or a reflection reaches my eyes, then goes through my nervous system to reach the proper regions of my brain. And i'm not investigating how much tim goes by till i have my toughts on the screen.
I'm having trouble understandig how this works the other way around. If we're limited by the speed of light........ one of the 2 is untrue.
Your toughts are created in the "now" and the limits of the speed of light doesn't exist
OR we always live in the past all of our toughts are formed before we acknowledge them.... and we're limited by the speed of light.
This is because our brains using electricity to work. What do you think?
+axypolyas Not sure why you are bothered by all these; perhaps it is because of your choices in life. Let me tell you something which will bother you more. You might know already, however, anyone who is reading this exchange will highly likely not.
The "scientific" description of you, me and everything is "energy". We don't know what energy is. We can quantify it; however, in essence, what is it? we have no idea. And energy takes different forms: like elementary particles, which in turn become atoms, molecules and part of the end result is "us". We know energy is governed by laws and constants which naturally takes us to the inevitable conclusion: we are governed by those constants and laws. Before discovery of quantum physics, this would mean we are completely deterministic objects. Quantum physics showed us that we are not 100% deterministic. We are limited by laws but still we are unpredictable (we can calculate probabilities of what we might do next but we don't know what we will do next until we do it). What does all these mean for us? Who are we? or what are we? Why do atoms and molecules pile up and make us? To live longer? All the atoms in our bodies are almost 15 billions of years old. What we call life is just another state in which they continue existing... nothing more and nothing special about it. How can we make sense of all these? Can we make sense of all these? If we are only, and only, condensed energy, then there is no such a thing as making sense of things. There is only energy going through one state to another state "mindlessly". Pretty scary and dark explanation of our existence, is the pure scientific one.
Science is only a tool, only a methodology we use to "make sense" of universe. It does not tell us why things are the way they are. It tells us how we can construct theories and how we can use methods to test them, so that we can do all these in an objective way. Science is an extremely limited way of looking into existence. Are my feelings objective? No. Are they scientific? No. Or, should I greet my neighbor every morning? Should I have an extra spoon of ice cream today? Or why do we do science? Do we have to do science? Say for our survival? Our survival has no meaning given particles making up our physical bodies existed for billions of years and they will continue to exist, perhaps longer.
I will jump to my personal understanding rather than "destroying ourselves" using science. To me, existence of The Creator makes more sense than anything else, including my own existence. The Creator who logically must be (and interestingly described as such in Islam which I have chosen as a path to follow) All-Knowing, All-Powerful, capable of creating a free agent (my soul for example) with life, creating a universe in which those free agents can grow up, examine, study, learn, make sense of it freely; is the only logical answer I can think of. We don't see the Creator, or souls, or anything which would "force" us to believe and accept. He made us free to choose and as part of making that choice freely, we will always be bothered by our existence, but we will never find an answer. That will remain as a matter of choice and it has always been like that.
"The knowledge of truth as such is wonderful, but it is so little capable of acting as a guide that it cannot prove even the justification and the value of the aspiration toward that very knowledge of truth. Here we face, therefore, the limits of the purely rational conception of our existence." -- Albert Einstein
*****
Thank you for your comment!
Looks like except for the Creator we're in the same boat. And this is why i'm bothered by these.... i can't understand why the "big brains", professors, smart people can't see further than they nose and deny everything that they can't answer immediately. Ego slowly destroys us yet we'd be capable to rise above ourselves faster than ever before. And this is not happening. And this is my problem. When you're trying to make a point, the so called (by themselves) "highly educated people" try to tear you apart, instead of thinking about the fact that you're alike and you have something to discuss perhaps for a reason. Not knowng who you are and what you know.... They go into self defense mode because you bring something up that makes sense but it's "magic" so they can't comment. Instead they'd burn you for witchery right that moment. ;)
Or, the other scenario is that i'm gone mad for good. But i don't think that's the case.....
I have a some good people around me, they'd also tell me :)
As for the Creator, i'm still looking for an explanation... I don't think that there's such thing as one "superior being". I think it's something in all of us. But it's "magic". So there's a catch 22 in this world at the moment.
But we've drifted away from the original question by a notch i think..... it might will have cosequences...
Peace!
***** Big brains and biggest scientists like Newton, Einstein, Ibn al-Haytham etc. were all believers in the unseen, unknown; they were fascinated by the harmony that they tried to explain. It has always been like that.
"Every serious and reflective person realizes, I think, that the religious element in his nature must be recognized and cultivated if all the powers of the human soul are to act together in perfect balance and harmony. And, indeed, it was not by any accident that the greatest thinkers of all ages were also deeply religious souls, even though they made no public show of their religious feeling."
-- Max Planck (he is a very important physicists if you haven't heard of him yet).
On the other hand, whatever you say about those big brains, professors, smart people is actually valid for you. From my perspective, I don't understand why you can not grasp all existence can happen either by a) someone who made it or b) a totally random process.
For case b, if everything was random (totally random it means), then simultaneous construction and destruction would take place all the time. A planet would pop-into existence out of nothing for no reason; totally random. Then at the same time, half of planet earth would pop-out of existence, back to nothingness, for no reason. In such universe nothing could survive. Nothing would exist long enough to produce life. So randomness is not an option for existence. Then it must be a. That is the rational, logical explanation.
I think you will enjoy this documentary. The scientist you will see is quite the opposite of so called big brains you mentioned. "What We Still Don't Know: Are We Real?" th-cam.com/video/oyH2D4-tzfM/w-d-xo.html
***** Just noticed I had pasted incorrect video link. This is the one I had intended to share: "What We Still Don't Know: Are We Real?" th-cam.com/video/oyH2D4-tzfM/w-d-xo.html
I swear, I understand shit way better when I'm high.
Most of us do... It blocks pre determined judgments.
You take shit how it is.. Fucked up
You're not really high it's just an illusion and you are caught in some kind of temporal anomaly between the past, present and future. So if a police officer questions you about it just tell them you're time traveling and you forgot where you parked the DeLorean.
Rosetta Stoned
no , you think that you understand because drugs is all about think about things that aren't
Now if only there was a use for your accumulating knowledge pertaining to 'shit'. Perhaps a future in waste management??
Anyone remember Mr. Rogers fantasy land segment with the clock with no hour, minute or second hands ?!
A Russian monk once explained how to develop a sense of timelessness . For example , in my free time i am working on making a model(of whatever it was, i forget) out of small wooden pieces . During that time i take of my watch and have no clocks to look at . This doing things or just thinking is vital to reduce stress of following the passage of time .
I personally am retired . I don't have a clock in my home . Even in my laptop i hide the clock in the left hand lower corner . And I turn of my cell phone . This feeling of being off the treadmill of time is a wonderful feeling . I often feel this sensation when i wake up in the wee hours . I have such positive or creative ideas and so on. One advantage is that it is dark outside and you don't notice the shortening or lengthening of shadows of the sun with the movement of the earth around the sun . cloudy days are cool in this way too . In summer being outside on a sunny day at noon also makes you forget about the ticking of the clock
If i need to make an appointment on the same day i set an alarm on a portable time piece in my pocket or in the house on a loud alarm clock turned to the wall . I set it 2 hours before i have to be somewhere
Very interesting! Thanks for sharing your experience. When you have some time :) check the video description for some ideas to think about and see where those will lead to.
will try . but even if the scientific fact was that time does exist , and that past, present and future exist independent of each other, I would reject it . My rejection of time is based on psychological , social and economic premises . but yeah if this video suggests or proves that time is an artificial concept and really there is no such thing as time, yes this would strengthen my and others political, social, economic and psychological premises towards a more humane work week and a more humane world in general
It is deeper than whether time exists or not and keep in mind, these videos I posted are meant to contribute to our understanding of existence... of ourselves and the rest.
I’ve always felt and thought that everything is always happening at once.
Its the only way time makes sense to me. It is happening at the same time but from our perspective, its seems linear.
Can someone explain, what would happen, if the Alian had a screen of earth, while biking.
Could he see the changes and with biking in the opposite direction reverse the changes?
Mind fucked
ok wait
what the fuck
At that far distances to get the picture of the earth will take years unless he has an antimatter thruster or smth that makes it travel fast !!!!
It would take too long for the alien to witness what happens here because of the great distance between.
Except you can see the future. So no that alien wouldn't be seeing Earths future. It takes light, time to travel. No matter where you are in the universe or what direction you are going you are seeing the past.
It is not meant to say that the alien has foresight, it simply means that for him, time has passed slower than for us.
i think the past u mentioned here is the memories u have for each time frame(bread loft) u have past. u are not "seeing" them, but u remembered them.
Jessica Jung our perception is fleeting..
Jessica Jung Agree, but I think you meant CAN'T see future?
Universe itself is history...whatever you're seeing in the space using a telescope or through naked eyes is actually the past.....this happens due to the limited speed of light which is a pathetic speed in the comparison of the universe....for example let's say the polarish star (pole star) which is 433 lightyears away from earth...if an event occurred at the star at the ''now moment'' like it collide with other star,supernova or it explodes....we will get to know about that event after 433 years....so the pole star we were watching at night is actually its past....the hubble space telescope can see upto 15 billion light years which means it can also see the events that occurred 15 billion years ago..
Great video. Love the diagrams. Did he explain why the little alien travelling away from the earth gives him our past, while cycling towards it gives him our future? Don't think he did. Maybe that's too complicated for a short video? But does anyone know?
It’s all about speed gravity and light.
How long does it take to remember one's past, experience one's present, and anticipate one's future projected world. When one has retrieved them, time has changed; future has become past.
Grace and peace be multiplied unto you and you're household/household's!