I only keep him alive as Arthur because when you capture him as John, the call back to Arthur gives me chills. “Hey…you’re not the….no…he was *bigger* “
You can also collect as much money as possible as Arthur and before things get crazy and the main story comes to an end, you can go to the Abernathy House to get robbed. If you never went there and then you go and let them rob you, the money will be in that hidden spot the entire time. After that, just keep playing the last missions to finish the story. When you play as John, you can then return at any time to that house and you'll find it mostly empty with the weird siblings gone. All you gotta do then is to just walk up to that picture where the money is hidden and open it up and get to recollect all your money that you had as Arthur.
Fun fact : I tried on my second playthrough to stab Anthony Foreman ,and surprise, while playing as John I still found him as a bounty , so I guess the canon choice is to spare him
@@WaveDaSeaWing probably, but I think Rockstar would put this detail when he meets John like 'I remember there was a big guy who stabbed me" or something like that or maybe they forgot to add this detail
@@fecker3212 Nah I ain't, I definitely Remember choosing to kill him, he stabbed him in the stomach and said something like "Sorry partner, we can't let live the likes of you" and after that while playing JOhn, I still found him as a bounty for some reason it's either a glitch or the game's story mistake...
This happens if you have low honor. In every sequence where you are faced with two choices, if you stall, your Honor practically does the choosing for you. For example, in Mary’s first mission, if your Honor is low, she will storm off with the thought that you would not help her. But if your Honor is high, she will believe that your silence is approval and you will do the mission.
I played Red Dead Online first when I heard it was taking place in the year 1898(I'm obsessed with doing things in chronological order) and when I met Foreman for missions he seemed like a very peaceful and friendly person. Didnt expect him to become something like this in just one year
Wild take but this game really can tell you a lot about a person based on the choices they make on the first play through. I played this story a total of 4 times and every time I found I couldn’t get Arthur’s honor low not because of lack of trying, but because I genuinely understood that based on how the plot for him as a character ran its course it was clear that he sought redemption and in a religious sense absolution as he could no longer live in a life of sin and misery. To see the effects of him realizing the consequences even the benefit of some of the negative choices made in years spoken about prior to the time we as the player experience Arthur Morgan was always meant to be an honorable man. However fate had it that before he found that honor he was meant to be brought down the dark and narrow road that many of us pray we never find ourselves upon.
Yeah well this playthrough I decided to send Arthur down a dirty path to hell . He ain’t being redeemed after things he did in this current universe , the goddamn maggot
@ThReverend6661 there's a difference between formal religious orders that Arthur doesn't buy into and spirituality on a personal level the op is referring to which is a human universal.
I'd have to say I disagree with you, specifically because I find it to be very easy to rack up dishonor while learning the games general mechanics. I brandished a weapon at the butcher countless times trying to start the dialog and panic fired trying to hit the right button.
You can typically tell which choice Arthur will make if you dont decide by looking at the options select buttons. If you take too long one of the options will slowly start to select itself
It’s awesome how rockstar games works i remember L.a. noire had this similar approach on making a decision idc what anyone says they are the best at what they do
Yea all the missions have it where if you don't do what the person tells you and you sit there, the other character will do it and say come on Arthur or something else.
I had the high honor cutscene where you let him go. Turns out you can turn him in with a bounty when you play as john if you let him go as arthur. He even asks if you, john, was associated with arthur and that he kept his promise with not messing with Tilly and the rest of the Van Der Linde gang after you spared him as Arthur.
Oh snap never knew that. I always play good storyline games multiple times and play different and make different choices but RDR2 has so much detail that even if you 100% the game you can still see new and different stuff just by making different choices and the way you play
@@MattMurdock41 lol no lie I discovered it anthony was freed from jail cell and trying to kill me and I killed him and got wanted and ran away from Saint Denis, maybe I'm the only one discovering this detail
I can’t remember but in the mission where you kill Micah you try to get info out of cleet (I think) and you take him up to the gallows and it gives you the option to hang him or spare him and if you take to long saddie shoots him in the head
I always killed him, sparring other victims & also sparring John from having to kill an extra man; If you ask me, that’s exactly what Arthur would do too
If you do live let him live, while the epilogue of John, there’s actually a bounty on him and when you capture him, he will say stuff like “I remember you! I swear I don’t do stuff like that anymore.” AND “wait… you’re not the… no… he was bigger.” Which he was talking about Arthur.
Fun fact: If you let him go you can see him again while bounty hunting in saint denis. But if you’re John then he’ll say that you don’t like like the big one (Arthur)
I would let him live if i were a new player, it’s what i did in my first playthrough because i was high honor and later on in the epilogue you get to catch him as a bounty in saint denis, he mentions arthur which is nice
I discovered detail if you spare anthony as arthur and bounty hunting anthony in apilogue the officers will free him and try to kill you, thats what happened to me once in saint denise
"Sorry Miss Grimshaw, but John needs that bounty in 7 years"
Lol
Wait you’re not the… no he was bigger
he was bigger
Wait when you go to Arthur is ur bounty still the same 😂
@@Walterwhite_cooks if you spare him there will be a bounty mission for him when playing as John
Depends on your honor level. If you already have low honor he stabs him, if it's high it plays the same scene as when you spare him.
What if We have neutral honor
Now we know what honor level he prefers. What a menace.
@@h.kayrannkanal5352then Arthur probably starts coughing and gives him tuberculosis 😂
@@EggmayorLMAOOOO 😂😂
I figured rockstar would do it like that .
I love how Arthur just awkwardly stands there looking back and forth contemplating what to do next
LMFAO fr
Es algo parecido a lo que haría cualquiera “mínimamente cuerdo” antes de degollar o apuñalar a alguien tan personalmente.
This AI shit it isn’t like that on ps5
@@whattheywontsayiwillsayreally😂
I only keep him alive as Arthur because when you capture him as John, the call back to Arthur gives me chills.
“Hey…you’re not the….no…he was *bigger* “
Nah I off him every time lmao!
He was bigger 😠
He was bigger 😈
Same😂
He was a black bigger
I mean n
I let him live so i can have the extra bounty hunter mission
Yea but oooolala the character building for Arthur’s low honor
same
You can also collect as much money as possible as Arthur and before things get crazy and the main story comes to an end, you can go to the Abernathy House to get robbed. If you never went there and then you go and let them rob you, the money will be in that hidden spot the entire time. After that, just keep playing the last missions to finish the story. When you play as John, you can then return at any time to that house and you'll find it mostly empty with the weird siblings gone. All you gotta do then is to just walk up to that picture where the money is hidden and open it up and get to recollect all your money that you had as Arthur.
same for me
@@Deyone_Jacksongracias por el consejo, mañana lo haré!
If you don't kill him you'll get a bounty for him in the epilog
Hell yeah thanks!!
Thank you!
That's why I always Google kill or spare certain characters.
How much was that bounty worth though?
@@adrianb2851$85 dollars according to the Wiki page
It always drove me crazy when Arthur used his knife. And it'd be the default rather than the knives I worked to find
Why would Arthur dirty up his exclusive knives and not use his work knife
It makes sense since some knives have different models and sizes so it might mess up the animation a little
@@redhunnid5142fr
You can use at least John's knife during this scene
@daahorse1652 I've never thought about this. All those sneak kills just to eat Plain Flaky Fish off the same knife. 🤣
I love Miss Grimshaw she don’t play dat bs 😂😂
😂
Fun fact : I tried on my second playthrough to stab Anthony Foreman ,and surprise, while playing as John I still found him as a bounty , so I guess the canon choice is to spare him
He might have survived getting stabbed
@@WaveDaSeaWing probably, but I think Rockstar would put this detail when he meets John like 'I remember there was a big guy who stabbed me" or something like that or maybe they forgot to add this detail
You can’t tho
@sardarcantu7960 Your just lying tho, No bounty happens if you kill him
@@fecker3212 Nah I ain't, I definitely Remember choosing to kill him, he stabbed him in the stomach and said something like "Sorry partner, we can't let live the likes of you" and after that while playing JOhn, I still found him as a bounty for some reason it's either a glitch or the game's story mistake...
This happens if you have low honor.
In every sequence where you are faced with two choices, if you stall, your Honor practically does the choosing for you.
For example, in Mary’s first mission, if your Honor is low, she will storm off with the thought that you would not help her. But if your Honor is high, she will believe that your silence is approval and you will do the mission.
I would let him live, thanks to him is how I got my first capitale in rdo.
LOL
You know online takes place before the story right?
@@ghostgamerz14 Yea, a year before, but I would still doing the same.
@@ghostgamerz14I think dude is saying he spares him out of gratitude for what he did for him in RDO
He seemed so chill in RDO I didn’t know he was such a douche
I just realised that was the same guy that attacked tilly in chapter two in valentine in the uncle mission
@@Ricebunsmmmmmmmmmmmmmm bro what
lol what ^
Need to talk pal?@theprinceofallsaiyans6012
@@Ricebunsmmmmmmmmmmmmmmwhat
@@Ricebunsmmmmmmmmmmmmmmdo a flip
I played Red Dead Online first when I heard it was taking place in the year 1898(I'm obsessed with doing things in chronological order) and when I met Foreman for missions he seemed like a very peaceful and friendly person. Didnt expect him to become something like this in just one year
People change when things don't go in their ways...
Wow
I like this @@Satoru-Gojou
Damn, does that mean you'll change in the afterlife because of the KitKat incident?@@Satoru-Gojou
"Are you gonna kill him?"
"Gimme a sec I'm indecisive."
I miss this game I’m definitely playing it again
Wild take but this game really can tell you a lot about a person based on the choices they make on the first play through. I played this story a total of 4 times and every time I found I couldn’t get Arthur’s honor low not because of lack of trying, but because I genuinely understood that based on how the plot for him as a character ran its course it was clear that he sought redemption and in a religious sense absolution as he could no longer live in a life of sin and misery. To see the effects of him realizing the consequences even the benefit of some of the negative choices made in years spoken about prior to the time we as the player experience Arthur Morgan was always meant to be an honorable man. However fate had it that before he found that honor he was meant to be brought down the dark and narrow road that many of us pray we never find ourselves upon.
Cool how you just randomly brought religion into it as if he doesn’t say multiple times about how he thinks it’s bullshit.
Yeah well this playthrough I decided to send Arthur down a dirty path to hell .
He ain’t being redeemed after things he did in this current universe , the goddamn maggot
@ThReverend6661 there's a difference between formal religious orders that Arthur doesn't buy into and spirituality on a personal level the op is referring to which is a human universal.
I'd have to say I disagree with you, specifically because I find it to be very easy to rack up dishonor while learning the games general mechanics. I brandished a weapon at the butcher countless times trying to start the dialog and panic fired trying to hit the right button.
U will miss the “och oh no HE WAS BIGGER”
Your videos are absolutely amazing and random and always get a laugh out of me 💛
I saw the whole thing. Guy was whittling a piece of wood. He sneezed. Stabbed himself. Tragic lol
Sopranos vibe :)))
@@DzTr "Some sad sht... Fella said he didn't want to live no more"
*slips $5*
@@300thNPC “What? I think I seen a couple of cowboys running that way…” 🤨
I let him live then had to take him to jail as john
He keeps looking around like a nervous kid awaiting his mum's approval. XD
The player had high honor prior, that’s why Arthur automatically spared him.
He didn't spare in the video
If you let him live, there is a bounty for him in saint Denise during the epilogue.
“Not making a decision, is a huge decision”
"Not making a decision, is a BIIIG decison"
@@dhishesj”ahhh.. you gonna make me count?”
lol i thaught there's a little Secret Scene now💀
Lmao after like 10 seconds he looked at you like “you going to slit my throat or what?”
tilly's kidnapper: let me tell u something let me tell u something...LET ME TELL U SOMETHING!
It just picks the option depending on your honor level
You can typically tell which choice Arthur will make if you dont decide by looking at the options select buttons. If you take too long one of the options will slowly start to select itself
"a good man"
This is the same scene that plays if you decide to kill him
I let him live. Guy said I’ll leave you alone and he meant it. Plus the bounty lol
Let him live you get him as Marston and he talks about how big arthur was
He got a low taper fade daym
That’s the exact thing that happens if u choose to kill him also the same sentence…but I think it also depends on your honer level too
And if you do spare him I do think he becomes one of John's bounties.
It’s awesome how rockstar games works i remember L.a. noire had this similar approach on making a decision idc what anyone says they are the best at what they do
here’s a 15 cent batwing, thanks Arthur
I've always chose to kill the guy, but I didn't know if you don't kill him you actually can bounty hunt him as john.
"we cant take no chances with the likes of you"
Sounds crazy out of context
On my first play through I only heard “slit his throat”💀
I thought he was letting him go 😂😂😂
💀💀💀
I spared him then when I was on jhon I had to bounty hunt him💀💀
Yea all the missions have it where if you don't do what the person tells you and you sit there, the other character will do it and say come on Arthur or something else.
"Naah...John will need that $85 later Miss Grimshaw..."
Man Arthur's facial expression, looks like you should spare him.
Poor Arthur. It’s a shame what happened to him and what he had to go through.
He just became socially awkward
I spared him with the knowledge of looking out for Honor
I let him live and there's a mission when your John and you have to find him
I always let him live because it's Tilly's wish and because of the bounty of course
when i got the bounty wirh john, he said to him “ah ur that guy.. no. he was a lot bigger than you are” or somth like that
Polite option:
Actually, mister, take this knife, I'd appreciate it if you'd use it on me, instead.
If you dare, of course
"Wait... Your not the... No, He was bigger." 🥶🥶
You can also get him as a bounty in Saint Denis if you let him live
And that is why I don't ever believe AI will be smarter than humans😂
It’s honour dependant, it’s like that with every other choice in the game
The walking dead taught me to not spare, harsh but they gonna try get their lick back, we’re humans.
I spared him and he ran off. 🤷♂️
If you spare him he becomes a short bounty mission later on when you see his wanted poster.
This is based on your honor and can happen during several situations that require a player decision.
I HAD THIS ON FULL VOLUME AT MIDNIGHT AND MY PARENTS ROOM IS RIGHT NEXT TO MINE AND I LEAFT BOTH DOORS OPEN
Lol 😹
I had the high honor cutscene where you let him go. Turns out you can turn him in with a bounty when you play as john if you let him go as arthur. He even asks if you, john, was associated with arthur and that he kept his promise with not messing with Tilly and the rest of the Van Der Linde gang after you spared him as Arthur.
Author has a knife to the guys neck
Me: Acting ticklish asf😂😂
If you don't kill him you actually get to pick up his bounty when you become John Marston
Oh snap never knew that. I always play good storyline games multiple times and play different and make different choices but RDR2 has so much detail that even if you 100% the game you can still see new and different stuff just by making different choices and the way you play
"Got new work for ya'. Might be some Capitaley involved.
"Got a new job. Capitaleyy, too, if you're lucky."
All you need to know is if you choose to leave him you will come across him as john
I got this reel right after playing this mission
it depends on your honor level.
Will seldon be back for the start of the season?
bro looks like comic rick
Its like that for every decision
Why not keep him alive so John can make that extra money when you can take him in as a bounty, Arthur always looking out for John
Officers will free Anthony and try to kill John that's what happened to me when I spared Anthony and after that I never spare him again lol
@@girtrax1833 I’ve never heard of that happening to anyone, one in a million lol
@@MattMurdock41 lol no lie I discovered it anthony was freed from jail cell and trying to kill me and I killed him and got wanted and ran away from Saint Denis, maybe I'm the only one discovering this detail
It's actually better to keep him alive because when you go to saint Denis as John you'll find a bounty poster for him as 80$
He comes back as a bounty for John if you spare him.
I just found him as a bounty while playing as jhon Marston lmao in saint Denis
If you don’t kill him he becomes a bounty in Saint Denis
He doesn’t even slit his throat
I can’t remember but in the mission where you kill Micah you try to get info out of cleet (I think) and you take him up to the gallows and it gives you the option to hang him or spare him and if you take to long saddie shoots him in the head
This game mechanical system is insane ❤
That orange duster 😎
If you keep him alive he shows up again as a bounty mission
I always killed him, sparring other victims & also sparring John from having to kill an extra man; If you ask me, that’s exactly what Arthur would do too
That's literally exactly how Arthur would do things
@@grindory Facts
The games really wanted you to kill him so badly lol
Be dope if she’s like “takin too long” and headshots him 😂
If you do live let him live, while the epilogue of John, there’s actually a bounty on him and when you capture him, he will say stuff like “I remember you! I swear I don’t do stuff like that anymore.” AND “wait… you’re not the… no… he was bigger.” Which he was talking about Arthur.
Fun fact: If you let him go you can see him again while bounty hunting in saint denis. But if you’re John then he’ll say that you don’t like like the big one (Arthur)
I would let him live if i were a new player, it’s what i did in my first playthrough because i was high honor and later on in the epilogue you get to catch him as a bounty in saint denis, he mentions arthur which is nice
Always spare him, it boosts honor AAAAAND you get a bounty on him in the epilogue
if you let him live then there is a bounty for him in saint Denis if you don't kill him i think it was the second poster you get
His bounty posters in Saint Denis
Its the same with any choices in the game. It automatically chooses for you depending on your honor
I let him live then captured him as John 😂
If I had a choice I would have left Tilly alone with Anthony Foreman
Nahh bro i needed that 100 dollars as john🙏
Damn, she tries really hard to bait Arthur into a hate-crime. Don't fall for it Arthur.
I discovered detail if you spare anthony as arthur and bounty hunting anthony in apilogue the officers will free him and try to kill you, thats what happened to me once in saint denise
What chapter is this
You get him as a bounty later as John