TT O'Keefe the executive do not care otherwise a negotiated settlement to the referendum would’ve been completed. That needs care not personal politics.
cp1307 Why, this case shows our constitution is working. The PM exercised his prerogative, MPs challenged this decisions because they believed it was unlawful. Then the courts voided the decision when they declared it unlawful. The constitution worked.
I'm disgusted by all parties involved, including Ms Miller - because Johnson just showed the world how all these politician can react immediately when it involved propping up their careers or a chance to create some chaos; however, what do you think would happen if these people reacted to homelessness in this country like this, or the need for more jobs immediately? I'm sickened by this side show...and many may look and agree Parliament could do with being suspended....
Boy howdy. This keeps getting wilder. Is BOJO out? Will Corbyn rise to PM? What's Scotland gonna do? Will there be a second prorogation? An election? This awful soap opera is nowhere near done. Hey, what happened to the guy who called for the referendum, then retired?
Like the progressives in US, brace for socialism in UK. Multi-party systems don't work. Make the evolutionary leap into one-party, self-error correcting systems.
On paper, the Queen's authority is invoked in such actions regarding the convening of parliament, but in practice she only really follows what the Prime Minister tells her to do as a matter of convention. She never made the decision herself and is otherwise expected to keep herself out of direct politics and governance.
@@tjd18 You could put it that way. All it means is that the Queen doesn't really call any shots anymore, and although she technically could, she doesn't and most likely never will. Sort of a wierd monarchy on paper but democracy in practice sort of deal.
Here!! Here!! The PM is ruining the system like the one before. I feel it is a lack of control. I feel there might be a vote of “no confidence”, time for the people to vote. Unlawful actions demand an apology to all by the PM. The highest court has made their decision.
I am so relieved that this court case has revealed that there is apparently only one corrupt politician in the UK. Go for it Boris, do what 17.4 million of us voted for.
@@peteroneill2991 I'm sure most would have understood me to be referring to the majority view of the whole of the British voting public within our democracy.
Well whether the Supreme Court likes it or not Boris j still was honest and showed the world the position of the English country and should be congratulated at showing up the debilitated Supreme Court and their enterage. The hearing I believe was just a hash up void of critical positions and points for the financial position of the English country and their defence and defence forces even if the defence was against the English countries old position it was indeed a critical step for Britain’s security which was omitted and ignored by the Supreme Court. Congratulations Boris j as at the very least you brought this to the attention of the entire world otherwise there is no way that the English country could nor would be able to move forward in its attempt to leave the security of the EU. And good. 😎
We all talk about how much the tax payer has to pay for the Royal Family and yet how much do you think it has cost the tax payer for 3 weeks in this court just to decide if Boris is unlawful??? Slag Boris as much as you like but he wants us out of the EU which is what we voted for. But is it is clear there are too many above him that will not let it happen.
Well said Carol Woolley. Some of Judges looked like they where wheeled out from a retirement home. We had a democratic vote and its unlawful for other parties to place their own person ambitions and greed above the wishes of the majority. Boris is a giant compared to the opposition midgets.
@@gorrthebutcher4696 guilty of thinking about the people n of seeing how we could leave the EU and still be succesful globally with all the amazing talented people The United Kingdom has always had. We weren't born Siamese twins what's wrong with enjoying each others cultural identity instead of isolating each other.
Let me explain for viewers in the middle east : In a civilized democracy there is a thing called "The rule of law". The state has "Separation of powers : a legislature (that writes laws) and executive (government that executes policy) and a judiciary." This is an example of the judiciary stepping in to chastise the executive. The legislature (Parliament) has now to be recalled, so it can hold the government to account. It's called democracy : you should try it.
vinm300 they knew it very well Sir , it just can’t be applied to ppl who u can by their votes for a kilo of cooking oil and flower ..... things there has to be the way it is or other ways u would have groups like the Muslim brotherhood
Its called democracy ,unless of course the peasants voted for it like they did to leave corrupted EU then of course it doesn't count corrupted government , lords ,and bent JUDGES overrule the peasants and do whats best for themselves money wise 💰💰💰
@@bobrail2647 that old chestnut the will of the people this has nothing to do with brexshit just the judiciary protecting the parliament will of the people against tin pot dictators
@@mikelimo2478 , well of course you are quite right : I saw an educated young lady in Israel being asked about Netanyahu and saying, "I vote for whoever my Rabbi tells me to". Then you look at the Partition of India and the slaughter committed by illiterate peasants coerced into fear and frenzy by religious/nationalist leaders. Religion, illiteracy, ignorance : all these things have to be overcome to establish civilized society.
The Supreme Court ruling substantiates the following: 1. In IT jargon: "Garbage IN is garbage OUT." The British voters were misinformed, offered "pies in the sky" and lied to prior to the Brexit Referendum. Lack of information or an abundance of misinformation leads to BAD decision-making; 2. It is high time for the British people to draft and implement a Written Constitution; 3. An Independent Judiciary which rules without fear or favour is the keystone of a Living and Thriving Democracy! I rest my case.
Al Jazeera English, Hello America!! All the UK Supreme Court Judges are absolutely... AWESOME!!! All of them can maintain their professionalism and sashay... on our most iconic popular fashion show catwalks in London. UK Supreme Court Judge Brenda Hale is soooo beautifully fashionable.... and that.... BROOCH is AMAZING! What is the name and cost of that eye candy catching BROOCH!? WOW!!! You know, there's an old saying...."If you have to ask the value/cost...you can't afford it." Realistically, I probably couldn't afford that AMAZING BROOCH, but I'll be shopping around for a reasonably priced fashionable replica of this..... INCREDIBLE BROOCH. The brooch was a fascinating fashion statement... onto itself. YESSS HONEY YESSS!!!
@@acac7928 I am afraid, you are wrong. Boris Johnson went about it the wrong way. The process matters a great deal! Boris deceived the Queen, tried to shut down parliament and bypass (inconvenient) democracy - and failed! Thank God that we have strong institutions in our UNITED KINGDOM!
The judges had their minds made up before the arguments so the whole, extremely well presented, case of the government fell on deaf ears and the disjointed emotional tirade from the rich Europhiles was equally irrelevant.. just a sideshow. Their pathetic case was not mentioned by the old LADY laying down their law. Gilet jaune UK....
He tried twice already. No dice. They'll no confidence him if needed and bring Ken Clark out of mothballs to either revoke or extend. Another referendum is on the cards.
@@gorrthebutcher4696 He will now be trussed up and force fed like a poor pate de fois goose. When he's plump and ready, he'll be boiled in the bag and rendered down for gravy. He's out of control - and parliament will frustrate and defeat his purpose. Oh Noble Righteous Judgement. God bless the spider lady. Boris will try for double or quits and we'll be back in court next week. Next time the court will be less polite.
@@rsrs8632 PM holds the right to suspend any law... But that's why the public demand a Election before any second referendum.... The law as become a farce.. Meaning now all judges need to declare there political views before sitting...
@@robokill387 No the government is acting within its powers.... Its the supreme Court that as over stepped its posion.. Blair created it truth you wonder why he asent hanged this shows you... It needs disbanding
thanks you very much your honorable 11 justices of the supreme court this is historic ruling events
a slap in the face for Boris.
Way to go... Wish the Indian SC had the same guts...
Well said bro
nono what modi says they do
Wow. Johnson is probably losing it.
having a Trump tantrum no doubt.
Don't worry if there is one thing he's good in, it's losing.
Like the clown he is, he has fallen on his sword.
Maybe he can ask for asylum in the EU?
@@wolfgangk2824 no, we don't want him
Boris has now been served his worst international humiliation live ! It dose not get worse then that!
@@itsmeekers stop talking bollocks
@@itsmeekers wrong saved from isil
Acac 😂😂😂😂 ok 😂😂😂😂
It's Meekers little scared and hurt feelings might want to see someone about your issues
It's Meekers as a typical conservative you make moronic assumptions
Why nobody is talking about the spider on her left upper chest? Whiiiiiiiyyyii
Good point
I thought it was a nit at first 🤣
Cos no one cares.
Yooooooo!
😅😅 i did not even notice 😄
British democracy still breathes...
👏👏👏
Democracy? Hahaha! How about the 17.4 millions voters? Sore f....g losers
@@jhonsmith9706 if you cannot accept a vote from a court go to Nord Korea then you do T belong to a democracy.
olimpiu caracas this is government actually working.
@@thomsch If you cannot accept the result from a referendum, go to North Korea, you don't belong in a democracy.
Good that your channel shows interest because our leaders here in UK don’t.
This channel doesn't show interest... It's a global news agency and is the best in what it does.
UK all we get is MSMs slant on anything. I’ve yet to see US channels report on this. The point I was making that the UK rulers don’t care.
It was televised in full on the BBC. So, your point is?
TT O'Keefe the executive do not care otherwise a negotiated settlement to the referendum would’ve been completed. That needs care not personal politics.
Acac No middle class broadcasting service
Now what?
The law in England is as good as gold, I got first hand experience.
why is she holding so many papers when she is only reading from 1. if you look closely the rest look blank.
I just love the chairs
Democracy survived!
Its time they get a written constitution
cp1307 Why, this case shows our constitution is working.
The PM exercised his prerogative, MPs challenged this decisions because they believed it was unlawful.
Then the courts voided the decision when they declared it unlawful.
The constitution worked.
No, we don't need one.
I'm disgusted by all parties involved, including Ms Miller - because Johnson just showed the world how all these politician can react immediately when it involved propping up their careers or a chance to create some chaos; however, what do you think would happen if these people reacted to homelessness in this country like this, or the need for more jobs immediately?
I'm sickened by this side show...and many may look and agree Parliament could do with being suspended....
The SC didn´t go against the Queen, they decided that the advice and motives(bojo) for suspending parliament was unlawful
The SC went against the Brexit vote fraud.
Boy howdy. This keeps getting wilder.
Is BOJO out? Will Corbyn rise to PM? What's Scotland gonna do? Will there be a second prorogation? An election?
This awful soap opera is nowhere near done.
Hey, what happened to the guy who called for the referendum, then retired?
He's started his own party, the Brexit party.
Like the progressives in US, brace for socialism in UK. Multi-party systems don't work. Make the evolutionary leap into one-party, self-error correcting systems.
Her majesty the queen is the only person who can porouge parliament. Not the Prime minister.
seems
the Queen authorization has been challenged...is it ceremonial post?
It isn't but she would have to face pitch forks if she used her powers against democracy.
On paper, the Queen's authority is invoked in such actions regarding the convening of parliament, but in practice she only really follows what the Prime Minister tells her to do as a matter of convention. She never made the decision herself and is otherwise expected to keep herself out of direct politics and governance.
@@Boyetto-san so basically our Queen is Above Politics
@@tjd18 You could put it that way. All it means is that the Queen doesn't really call any shots anymore, and although she technically could, she doesn't and most likely never will. Sort of a wierd monarchy on paper but democracy in practice sort of deal.
Nice to say that the UK at least, still has functioning courts.
such things happen when they put clowns in the government.
Boris should resign. However his ego is epic.
with the PM caught in a web of his own weaving the Spider Brooch says it all
Here!! Here!! The PM is ruining the system like the one before. I feel it is a lack of control. I feel there might be a vote of “no confidence”, time for the people to vote. Unlawful actions demand an apology to all by the PM. The highest court has made their decision.
Bye bye Boris
That is real democracy...God Bless UK
the QUEEN wants his HEAD! Cmon UK lets do this old school and lets do this... make it LIVE too :)
Well Boris, now what?
How embarrassing for the palace!
I am so relieved that this court case has revealed that there is apparently only one corrupt politician in the UK. Go for it Boris, do what 17.4 million of us voted for.
Wow! Little Miss Muffet aged to become Spider Woman OR a black widow spider OR ...?
Good news! Boris is getting blocked at every turn!
Not only Boris, but the British voting public.
@@ronmorris1199 wrong only brexshiteers
@@peteroneill2991 I'm sure most would have understood me to be referring to the majority view of the whole of the British voting public within our democracy.
@@ronmorris1199 bring it on let's really see the will of the people not this hijacked garbage
Couldn't agree more Peter.
@@peteroneill2991
Well whether the Supreme Court likes it or not Boris j still was honest and showed the world the position of the English country and should be congratulated at showing up the debilitated Supreme Court and their enterage. The hearing I believe was just a hash up void of critical positions and points for the financial position of the English country and their defence and defence forces even if the defence was against the English countries old position it was indeed a critical step for Britain’s security which was omitted and ignored by the Supreme Court. Congratulations Boris j as at the very least you brought this to the attention of the entire world otherwise there is no way that the English country could nor would be able to move forward in its attempt to leave the security of the EU. And good. 😎
Leave is a minority of thugs
We all talk about how much the tax payer has to pay for the Royal Family and yet how much do you think it has cost the tax payer for 3 weeks in this court just to decide if Boris is unlawful??? Slag Boris as much as you like but he wants us out of the EU which is what we voted for. But is it is clear there are too many above him that will not let it happen.
Well said Carol Woolley. Some of Judges looked like they where wheeled out from a retirement home. We had a democratic vote and its unlawful for other parties to place their own person ambitions and greed above the wishes of the majority. Boris is a giant compared to the opposition midgets.
Thank you John for your comment. What a mess we are in.
Woolley by name but not by nature. Bloggs ??
We!! the people need to take the Parliament and Houses of lords to the UK supreme court for incompetents,,
"Unless there is some parliamentary rule of which we are unaware.." Sarcasm from the Supreme Court, I love it.
Finally some sanity unlike the US SJC
If only the US version of democracy had evolved into a Parliamentary Democracy.
*Oi you better have a license for that parliament suspension m8*
Are we going to ignore the spider on her shoulder?
Shifta Addis, if you stop your meds altogether, it may start talking to you. Better keep taking the haldol, there a good fellow
WELL SAID JAMES MAY!
John bercow "the saviour of the UK "
So this is now a legal case !! It was unlawful and he's broken the law..
unlawful not illegal ffs
@@gorrthebutcher4696 Oh yes it is !
@@radofficial4672 how what uk law was broken ?
@@gorrthebutcher4696 Unlawful behaviour in a public place ! Shouldn't be allowed.. naughty!
@@gorrthebutcher4696 guilty of thinking about the people n of seeing how we could leave the EU and still be succesful globally with all the amazing talented people The United Kingdom has always had. We weren't born Siamese twins what's wrong with enjoying each others cultural identity instead of isolating each other.
Ooo Boris...
He looks like he escaped from the local Asylum
Boris like any criminal, who claims to be not guilty.
Oooo Boris you following your gran father food step I hope you don't end up same as him ..
I think we should proud of uk best democracy in the world.
Really
Say what you want about the system, but at least it's doing a good job of keeping this wannabe tyrant contained, unlike the American system.
@@robokill387 Imagine having to contain your government. Defeatists all of you.
@@dess3597 just wish the USA also had the balls to contain it's tinpot dictator
PLOT TWIST! Next week on Brexit!: Stay tuned.
It is healthy to follow the voice of the people...not of the oppositors who just wanted to have media exposure...let the people of UK rule.
Is this about the saudi-iran issue?
boris the american turk: lady hale HATES me !!! this is discrimination against me as a turk !!!
hahahahahaha
Let me explain for viewers in the middle east :
In a civilized democracy there is a thing called "The rule of law".
The state has "Separation of powers : a legislature (that writes laws)
and executive (government that executes policy) and a judiciary."
This is an example of the judiciary stepping in to chastise the executive.
The legislature (Parliament) has now to be recalled, so it can hold the government to account.
It's called democracy : you should try it.
vinm300 they knew it very well Sir , it just can’t be applied to ppl who u can by their votes for a kilo of cooking oil and flower ..... things there has to be the way it is or other ways u would have groups like the Muslim brotherhood
Its called democracy ,unless of course the peasants voted for it like they did to leave corrupted EU then of course it doesn't count corrupted government , lords ,and bent JUDGES overrule the peasants and do whats best for themselves money wise 💰💰💰
@@bobrail2647 that old chestnut the will of the people this has nothing to do with brexshit just the judiciary protecting the parliament will of the people against tin pot dictators
@@mikelimo2478 , well of course you are quite right : I saw an educated young lady in Israel being asked about Netanyahu and saying, "I vote for whoever my Rabbi tells me to".
Then you look at the Partition of India and the slaughter committed by illiterate peasants coerced into fear and frenzy by religious/nationalist leaders.
Religion, illiteracy, ignorance : all these things have to be overcome to establish civilized society.
vinm300 then for the time been things has to be and must be the way it is
God bless your Lordships!😊🙏
yes heroes and heroines of the people
It's nice that there's still some people around from 1688 to tell us about the old laws we might have forgotten about.
Boris must fall, now!
That spider on her shirt is creepy.
UNLAWFULL is not ILLEGAL
Johnson's Trump style "I can mislead the queen and shut the parliament and still remain PM".
This is the begging of the end for UK
The Supreme Court ruling substantiates the following: 1. In IT jargon: "Garbage IN is garbage OUT." The British voters were misinformed, offered "pies in the sky" and lied to prior to the Brexit Referendum. Lack of information or an abundance of misinformation leads to BAD
decision-making; 2. It is high time for the British people to draft and implement a Written Constitution; 3. An Independent Judiciary which rules without fear or favour is the keystone of a Living and Thriving Democracy! I rest my case.
Appeal the judgement and let the Supreme court send Börries Von Munchausen in front of a EU court - After all we are all concerned!
We need the brits in Europe 👍
The Brits are in Europe,the people voted to leave the undemocratic run EU organisation.
another crook like Trump?
Al Jazeera English, Hello America!!
All the UK Supreme Court Judges are absolutely... AWESOME!!!
All of them can maintain their professionalism and sashay...
on our most iconic popular fashion show catwalks in London.
UK Supreme Court Judge
Brenda Hale is soooo beautifully fashionable.... and that....
BROOCH is AMAZING!
What is the name and cost of that eye candy catching BROOCH!?
WOW!!!
You know, there's an old saying...."If you have to ask the value/cost...you can't afford it."
Realistically, I probably couldn't afford that AMAZING BROOCH,
but I'll be shopping around for a reasonably priced fashionable replica of this.....
INCREDIBLE BROOCH.
The brooch was a fascinating fashion statement... onto itself.
YESSS HONEY YESSS!!!
bye bye trump man in UK
short lived 😂
African dictators have nothing on Boris Johnson!😂😂😂
@@acac7928 I am afraid, you are wrong. Boris Johnson went about it the wrong way. The process matters a great deal! Boris deceived the Queen, tried to shut down parliament and bypass (inconvenient) democracy - and failed! Thank God that we have strong institutions in our UNITED KINGDOM!
@@acac7928 bullshit
Get that cheque ready👌
That spider 😩
Hahaha it’s huge!
The sign of the deep state
Brexit show continue ! Hahahhaa stay tune ! Crush is coming ! So when Boris go to jail ? He broke the law ...right !
Dont you just love the Queen .. What a nice card play by the Queen oh and ofcourse the Lords ...
She approved it did she not
The 2010s political foolishness is finally ending.
Is that a spider?
It's the sign of the deep state
Good old Spiderwoman.
They quote Democracy. Fair enough. and the Brexit vote demands democracy. Let's stay Tuned!
this is not india where suprem court is losing his stand about 370 . 35a
@vader Ramn you fast go to school and learned the english and read the indian constitution of fundamental rights
As parliament has not been prorogued then the Prime Minister still has the option to prorogue it.
The old hag widow spider said it all. Your all doomed.
“Well 🇬🇧 Limey MOP HEAD you ready to do your own EXIT?!!!” 🔥🇬🇧🔥🇬🇧🔥🇬🇧🔥
Poor guy now he will know how they did everything to frustrati poor Theresa May now is your time we'll see how far u would last...😁😁😁😁
Tony's Pro remain cronies rule against. You couldn't make it up!
The judges had their minds made up before the arguments
so the whole, extremely well presented, case of the government fell on deaf ears and the disjointed emotional tirade from the rich Europhiles was equally irrelevant.. just a sideshow. Their pathetic case was not mentioned by the old LADY laying down their law.
Gilet jaune UK....
Go to bed. You're too tired and irrational to argue at the moment.
hes just gonna call a GE using vonc this is a win for brexit
He tried twice already. No dice. They'll no confidence him if needed and bring Ken Clark out of mothballs to either revoke or extend. Another referendum is on the cards.
@@Boviss1Bovis hes never called a vote of no confidence yet mate thats a lose for him but will set a ge in motion
@@gorrthebutcher4696 brexiteer voters will be killed on the streets.
@@gorrthebutcher4696 He will now be trussed up and force fed like a poor pate de fois goose.
When he's plump and ready, he'll be boiled in the bag and rendered down for gravy.
He's out of control - and parliament will frustrate and defeat his purpose.
Oh Noble Righteous Judgement. God bless the spider lady.
Boris will try for double or quits and we'll be back in court next week.
Next time the court will be less polite.
@@Boviss1Bovis you clearly dont know the english pal
Next ECJ... Lol
Boris can resign now.
Get a shifty on, Boris.
Government can suspend this law.. The law is not above a government
The government is not above the law! Parliament can change the law, not the government. But even then this judgement stands.
@@rsrs8632 PM holds the right to suspend any law... But that's why the public demand a Election before any second referendum.... The law as become a farce.. Meaning now all judges need to declare there political views before sitting...
No it can’t. Yes it is. 😂
You're literally advocating that the government become a dictatorship with no meaningful protections, just so you can get brexit. Pathetic.
@@robokill387 No the government is acting within its powers.... Its the supreme Court that as over stepped its posion.. Blair created it truth you wonder why he asent hanged this shows you... It needs disbanding
Boris Johnson should launch an appeal to the International Court of Justice!!
Delaying tactics.
How ironic that would be eh?
Boris will finish up in the Tower.
yessssssss
I see she is wearing a black widow spider....very appropriate.
montydendron1 hahahahhahH
Appropriate Judge has Black Widow spider embroidered on her top ! Now that must give you a hint !
May & Johnson regarding Brexit 😢
New season will release soon😅
Look spider on shoulder what does that say to the veiwers whatch out
Trump denies Congress it's Right to enforce the will of the people. The Senate is the House of Lord's.
English Supreme Court, GREAT.
I'd like to see John Bercow become the next PM.
Every institution is political...... Even the court, but the people voted to leave EU. SAD
rogers how is the question and tin pot dictators trying to force their view is hopefully dead in the UK
Parliament cigarettes?
he can join trump now .