Laparoscopic Hernia Surgery Vs Open Hernia Surgery | Which Hernia Repair Surgery is the Best?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ต.ค. 2024
- Dr. Parthasarathy - one of the best hernia surgeons in Hyderabad discusses about the types of hernia repair surgery and the advantages and disadvantages of laparoscopic hernia surgery & open hernia surgery.
#DrParthasarathy #KIMSHospital #TypesofHerniaRepairSurgery #HerniaRepair
#LaparoscopicHerniaRepairSurgery #OpenHerniaSurgery #LaparoscopicVsOpenHerniaRepair
#HerniaSurgeryHyderabad #HerniaRepairIndia
Summary:
This is one of the most common questions that we encounter. .There is a group of patients who come to us seeking a laparoscopic repair for hernia. Similarly, there is a group of patients who are very fixed in their thoughts and saying that. “We do not want laparoscopic operation, but want only an open operation”. The patients always ask us, “Doctor, which is the best technique to do a hernia operation? Is it by laparoscopy or by open surgery?” We have so many of them in favor of or against both the kinds of surgery. Some people say, “Though in laparoscopy, the pain is less, it fails. Open surgery is best and so, go for the open one”. Similarly, there are a lot of people who say, “Open surgery is a very morbid operation. Do not go for it. Try and get it done laparoscopically. If this doctor says, “Laparoscopy is not good, go to some other surgeon who says that laparoscopy is good and get it operated by him. Hence, what decision do we take on this? How do we decide which kind of operation is better?”
First of all, one has to understand that, as of today, both open operation and laparoscopic operation exist for treating of hernia. This means that the same surgeon will do laparoscopic operation for hernia on certain patients and he will do an open operation for some patients. What does this mean? It means that it is not the procedure that is deciding, but actually, it is the type of hernia that decides which procedure will suit that hernia. Thus, you cannot have one single procedure to try to fit all your patients into that. It is like having a one sized shoe and fitting all feet into that. It can never happen. It will not work. Hence, the decision as to whether a laparoscopic or an open operation is required, is taken based on many other factors.
The first factor is dependant on the type of hernia - whether it is a small hernia or a large hernia. Where is the hernia located? Is it a belly button hernia or a groin hernia? Has any previous hernia operation failed...if somebody has undergone a hernia operation 10 years back, but the hernia has come back, then what is the overall physical condition of the patient? Is it a very elderly patient with a poor muscle tone or is it a young fit athlete or a weight lifter or a body builder or a sports man? The surgeon will consider all these factors before he decides which technique is suitable for the patient. For example, you can take the case of a patient who has a small belly button hernia and is an active sportsperson. He wants to resume his practices and wants to attend office quickly. The choice of operation for this patient will be a laparoscopic repair because we avoid a cut, we avoid a chance of prolonged recovery, the pain is lesser and he can quickly go back and join his office. On the other hand, there is a 60 years old lady, who is obese, who has undergone hernia operation twice in the past or 10 years back and she got back the hernia. She has come to us for hernia repair. In this patient, looking at all these factors, the choice of surgery will be an open operation. This is because of the fact that the patient is old, obese, has previous failed repairs and thus, the best suited procedure for her would be an open hernia operation with a modified technique. Hence, the question whether laparoscopy is better or an open surgery does not have value. What the question should be is, “For me, which one is the better operation?” The operation choice is individualized for each patient, based on many patient related factors and surgeon factors.
Say Hello!
Our Website: bit.ly/DrPartha
Book Appointment: bit.ly/3g2qNJ0
Call us:+91 73309 90044
Contact: bit.ly/2RdKoO8
Follow us:
Facebook : bit.ly/DrParthaFB
Instagram: / gastrosurgeonindia
Twitter: DrParthasarthy
Location:
Dr.G.Parthasarathy | Best Gastroenterologist in Hyderabad | Hernia & Gall Bladder Specialist
31, KIMS Hospitals, 1-8, 1, Minister Rd, Krishna Nagar Colony, Begumpet, Hyderabad, Telangana 500003
Phone: +91 73309 90044
Email: dr.gpartha@gmail.com
Google Map: bit.ly/DrPartha...
![เปิดบ้าน พี่ตูน Bodyslam หลังใหม่คนแรก ที่ภูเก็ต l [Nickynachat]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/flFwcmyDQSk/mqdefault.jpg)
I had laparoscopic umbilical hernia repair last week. I was glad they went that route, because once they were inside they were able to see another hernia and was able to fix that as well. I don’t think they would’ve been able to find that second one if it was one w/ an open surgery.
How much doescost to repair for it ?
I had a laparoscopy a year ago which failed so have had to have open surgery 6 weeks ago. Much more painful and I’m finding my testicles are VERY tender!
Linx procedure is best for hitus hernia and gerd but this procedure is not available in India fundoplication surgery complications you could not running and gym after this surgery
Thanks Dr for explaining crystal clear the choice hernia operation method. It is a not readymade one. I understood that suits the patient gravity and location of hernia. Thanks Dr.🙏🙏🙏
Thanks a zillion SIR....VERY VERY HELPFUL.GOD BLESS U .
Dear Doctor, my age 65 years I had CABG in 2011,then stented 2 times that is 2013,2019 now I had umbilical hernia my heart 45% I can go for operation, please give me advice
Mam karwa liya kya?
Thank you sir....for the clarification......GOD BLESS YOU.
My father is 84 yrs old. Dr. has suggested surgery fou umbilical hernia. And he told us he can do both and we have to decide either open or laproscopy.
Sir my mother is 44 year old has 3 opretion before 2 for hernia and 1 for secerian (chid) which is best pls answer
Hello Doctor, I went with umbilical hernia open surgery. After I have come home, I can see some discharge where stitches are done. I went back to the doctor and he said since I’m obese discharge is due to fat melting and coming out as there is possibility it didn’t come out completely from the suction pipe which was placed before. He opened one stitch so it will come out and asked every two days to come for dressing and he said it will heal itself. Is it right? Please confirm.
Was the surgery painful
Hi sir I done last month laparoscopic surgery for harnia but after 20 days fully infection for me I'm not recovering now almost paip has in stamoch please help me what to do
Infection is mesh infection 😢
Thanks a lot Dr can omentum hernia be done by laproscopic method
Sir my father had a stroke in 2020 and now he has recovered 90%. Is it safe for him to undergo an open hernia surgery? Pls do reply sir🙏
Can unmarried Girls go for Open operation for Inguinal hernia...?? Plz answer.
Hello sir.. I'm diagnosed vth umbilical hernia after my 1st baby delivery.. now I want to plan second pregnancy is it okay to plan Second pregnancy after surgery for umbilical hernia
My doctor told me it's best to have surgery after childbirth if I plan to have a 2nd child.
Thanks for these words doctor saheb "type of hernia decide which surgery should be perform"
Thank you doctor, I need this information.
What is best for sliding hiatus hernia I also have ibs asthma please .
Thank you sir for your Great experience information🎉
My surgeon wants to do my incisional hernia by open,I have lpr as well,will it be safe for me to have general anasthetic
I have hernia above my belly button and im 44 year old ,5'4 and weight 186 which surgery best for me open or lapcrospic
I did the same one when I was 35 abilical and they did open with mesh now I’m 49 and never had a problem with that one
This morning I had a second operation with the laparoscopy and it was in my Anguinal hernia came out great
Dr.I had a open herina sur,six months back,so far no problem s . What happens to the net inside? Diluted ! Please explain, Thanks.
That net is like a wall to prevent hernia again...
Did it hurt sir
Doctor patients facing complications due to mesh afterwards... Plz talk about it. Plz... Give testimony of ur patients who live normal life after mesh?
You said 60 year old lady already twice have case history of failed hernia , I am sure it was open , why can’t we think of Laproscopic when it is already failed twice for open surgery … patient less pain ,quick recovery etc
Age of the patient is the factor because laproscopic surgery need general anesthesia..this will be the reason that surgeon choosen open approach
Hi Doctor
I am detected with umbilical hernia of 1.3cm
My age is 30yrs old, weight is 75kg, height is 177cm
Please suggest which procedure should I take.
If open surgery done will I be able to do all activities as of normal person after 5-10 month
Thank you for you suggestions
>j
Now how are you? Open or laproscopy you did? And how much cost?
How r u now?
@@yadavAjay766how are you now
@@benthoughts28you?
Sir 4 months boy have a right side sist problem sergery cheyakunda thagguthundha sir please cheppandi sir
I have done keyhole surgery, but now suffer with stomach bloating and alot of gasses. Stomach discomfort
I have bilateral linguinal hernia of small size. Can you please suggest which is better open or laproscopy
Go for laproscopic surgery for the bilateral hernias..
Sir plz help me..i had mesh surgery three years ago on left side unfortunately i have same on right side now.am in depression do not want to go for second surgery..it will be my fourth..am 44 years old from kashmir
Well said and truly explained Doctor….!!!!👏🙏👍thank you for the clarification 👌
Good morning sir...I had 2 lscs...tubectomy not done...I got umbilical hernia about 1cm... doctor advised me open surgery with mesh....what do you suggest sir???plz reply...I'm ur subscriber
Please contact 7330990044
I am 60 + and got this surgery done almost 40 years back. It is back again. What do you suggest for me? Please advise.
Omg sir you have 40 years back hernia surgery??
Mesh or without?
Thank you Doc for the cristal clear explanation.. how much it will cost for the operation?
Sir my mother had gone through gall bladder laproscopic operation in 2019, umbalical hernia open and mesh was inserted 15×15 in 2021 and again hernia occur and it's incisional hernia, and the doctor is saying it occurred because she have very thin layer of tissue that's why it's came back..what operation should she undergo with
Best suggestion.
Can u able to tell cost of umbilical hernia surgery by laproscopic
Thank you doctor
Thank you sooo dear doctor for brief and clear information .🙏🙏
Thank you, doctor, very well explained 🙏🙏🙏
how many days after remove stich harniya open ingunial harnia
1 week
Excellent...very well description
Thank you!
Thanks for your explanation sir.
जय श्री राम
I’m 74 slim & have left side ingunal hernia comes & go;s what op do I go for ?
SirI am a 54 years old male. I am suffering from bilateral reversible inguinal hernia. Is it possible to make laparoscopic surgery through spinal anesthesia or local anesthesia?
No, laproscopic surgery can only be done under general anesthesia..and for bilateral hernia laproscopic surgery is gold standard.
Thank you sir
@@sanjeevtandon3693 had operated?
Can you do umbilical hernia and do tummy Tuck at the same time
Thank you sir
Hello doctor. I have had 5 surgeries till date due to colon rupture and one incisional hernia repair. Now I have developed some more incisional hernias. I am obese. No doctor wants to operate on me. How do I solve my situation.
Please reach out to us on 7330990044
I just done an open surgery 2 days ago and now lots of pain.
Hows your experience please share
first week will be awful, but by end of 2nd week it should already be good, considering no complications
Sir in 2015 i had hernia surgery...at prsnt iam working in rice exports should i lift rice bags upto 50 kgs...plz suggest me
How your condition now. Its ok lift rice bags after had hernia surgery
I think you should avoid it may come again if you lift heavy weight avoid avoid avoid
50kg? how old are you when you had a hernia?
Good day Dr. I have inguinal hernia 4 months ago and the pain come and go and i feel small intestine inside my groin which operation should i go. Thank you hopefully you respond to me god bless dr.
Which surgery u have gone through
Thank you doctor.. My age is 33 . Doctor asked me do open surgery for left Inugural hernia and he refused to do laparoscopic surgery so do we agry on this please suggest.
No,based on his expertise he has gone for open approach
What is the cost of surgery on gronal Hernia.???
जय श्री जगन्नाथ
Nice information thanks from Pakistan
thanks for clarification sir... which one suitable for 9 months old baby with inguinal hernia?
Hi sir cheyincharaa operation
Ma Babu ki recent ga detect ayyindi ..ma Babu age 7 year S
Operation or Laproscopy em prefer chesaru...cost yentha ayyindi sir
RIOBOTIC IS THE BEST ONE
Yes it is.
Sir my baby is 2 month old and he diagnose inguinal hernia sir plz guide me what should I do ... surgery is safe for him..
Must consult doctor. I think baby recover naturally, no need surgery. Wait for sometime. But Before that consult doctor safely.
I have an small umlical herIna
Ok thanks sir
Sir plz plz suggest me
sir , i has been operated both side inguinal hernia by open surgery,
i am 35 year old. i have suggested to doctor for laposrcopic but doctor refused he said to me open surgery and said to me open surgery is best
dear sir,
please suggest to me
which reasons is for open surgery is best?
For unilateral -open approach is best
For bilateral -laproscopic approach is gold standard
My father have Parkinson's disease ,which operation is better for him.ingunal harnia
Open approach is still best for long term
@@AshishKumar-je6lx go go open
My Dr. said with laparoscopic repair that LMA cannot be used because I must be paralyzed during the operation. A breathing tube must be used instead due to being paralyzed. So with the open approach LMA can be used since being paralyzed isn't required, is that right? Also, wouldn't chance of being unable to urinate afterward would be less if not paralyzed for surgery?
Has Desarda Open non mesh 2008 on my left side. The recovery took about a Month to fully walk with no pains. The hernia came back 2022.
This time l went with a different surgeon and had them REINFORCE Laparoscopic MESH surgery. Im 3 days post op and im already walking.
Desarda repair is good or bad , where have you done desarda
@@Unseenxfacts it's very good if you don't plan on doing any more strenuous activities. I had it done in Fort Myers Florida
Your reccurence reason is strenous activity or another reason. I want desarda repair plz give some tips my age is 24 only
@@Unseenxfacts get Desarda if you don't plan on lifting weights or playing any sports.
@@lagibear one more thing your hernia were direct or indirect and what were your age at first desarda repair
Hello sir my husband is facing a inguinal harnia in big size may I know which is better for him and he is a 30 years old, still no baby,
Is it done operation kavua
Apka baby nahi hua?
my wife get pregnant while I'm dealing with inguinal hernia. get his hernia fixed there is no connection about having a child
HI kavya
I'm having umbilical hernia in belly button which surgery is best
Compare to open surgery, laparoscopic is expensive.Preferable is Laparoscopic.
Mine is completed 2 weeks back for same Umblical hernia
Which hospital did you have the surgery and which doctor?i have umbrilical hernia in my stomach so tired
Sir, mine is right inguinal hernia & 31year old,, which is better for me lap or open..??
Laparoscopy is the most preferred option. However as we discussed in the video, multiple factors need to be considered. The size of the hernia, your medical history etc.. You can come consult me or schedule a online consultation. call 7330990044 for appointment.
@@DrParthasarathy sir, what is the cost of laporoscopic hernia repair.. @your Kim's hospital
@@kamil9189 Depends on the type of Surgery. Please Call 7330990044 our patient relations executive, he will explain the cost and procedure details to you.
Hi sir cheyinchukunnara...cost yentha ayyindi
Sir...i had done laparoscopy surgery for hernia 15days back...iam facing huge hair loss..please suggest your valuable suggestion sir...what shall I do now
Any operations or critical infections will create hairloss. It will come back within 4months
huh?
☺️
Sir im suffering from incisional hernia .gap is 4.5 cm.i can wait for 1 yr for surgery.after 1.5 yr c section i got this hernia.what should i do.baby is very small.advice some thing.whixh surgery isbest for hernia
My mom also have incisional hernia, i don't know what to do, will you please share ur experience
Sir, 15 yrs back my father undergone surgery for right inguinal hernia and last two yrs back again for left inguinal hernia and now he suffers from umblical hernia...he is 65 yr old we got confused whether laproscopy or open we go for it...kindly suggest me the method sir , facing the hectic situation...it will be helpful
My father also having same problem he had hernia surgery 20 years back now same hernia problem he is 60years old suggest which surgery is preferable to avoid complication.plz some body help me.
Please visit a good surgeon and discuss your case
Sir, I had done umbilical hernia surgery( laparooscopic)three years back. My age is 42, already I had two csection. Did I do yoga, excersice? My weight is 74. My height is 158.
Yes it is safe to do yoga now .
Sir, which opreation is best for Small inguinal heria.I'm 33 years unmarried boy.plz reply sir🙏🙏
If you have time for taking rest go for open
Or else laparoscopic
Recently I have done in open
Always preferable laproscopic bit expensive compare to open surgery