The only thing this will do, is cause the Kpop industry to tighten their grip on their idols. I think companies will even start refusing westerners and foreigners again.
Not foreigner only west this has never happened to other asian idols maybe some Chinese idols but moat of them won the lawsuit and right about their acuse and china is one of the biggest country which kpop got money from so not other asian countries but def west
@@monotzukokuureshii What are you talking about? Never happened to other Asian Idols? Elkie from CLC was forced out by Cube for speaking out about mistreatment and management of her money. Plenty of other examples of (Asian) foreigners being mistreated, not-to-mention the countless Korean Idols who challenge their companies (Chuu comes to mind, as well as the rest of Loona).
most likely, because if the formula has already created the best of the best why change it now; also let's not forget they might argue that tits a difference in cultures which is actually fair in certain equations- not this one
I’m not sure if this will affect the industry in Korea too much-trainee abuse isn’t something new; it’s a known thing. But obviously, it still doesn’t make it okay. HOWEVER, this will likely affect how people in the US view Kpop. From overworking minors to mentally abusing them to the point of self harm and such is a big no-no, especially in LA (very liberal), where KG filed the lawsuit. It will be difficult for any Kpop groups to break out in the US now. I feel so bad for the other VCHA girls and other idols that have gone through this.
The thing that really adds weight to Kiera’s claims. Unlike other k-pop groups, JYP’s international project is based in California. Most of VCHA is or was underage. And California has very strict child labor laws, razor focused on the entertainment industry. JYP has appeared to endeavor to break all of them. By claiming “they don’t apply to trainees!”. This is not viewed as a strong argument when you’ve bullied a 14 year old into downing a whole bottle of pills.
It sadly won't change anything. Kpop scandals have been happening for years from suicides to sex trafficking (Burning Sun)... people have short memories.
Yeah, why are people supporting minor idols instead of boycotting groups that debut underage idols?? Then get upset and defensive when I have told them not to support minor idols
@@aussiefurbymogwaifan6621only the western countries don't allow or like minors to debut , apparently it is pretty common in kpop , cpop , jpop , tpop as well. Many netz and fans want idols who are younger and companies want it because they can work for a lot of years to make money for them. As you may know that after 30 many idols change their career to only acting or other things. So they don't debut idols who are older than 20
In korea you can get sued for whistelblowing if it damages a companies reputation, so I deeply hope with her being a us citizen and being under republicnan record, she won’t face any more consequences
Agree with you. But, this system is ingrained in Korea. Look at New Jeans, courts and industry is already against them. This korean system will not be tolerated in the USA.
Unfortunately, JYP will settle out of court like nothing happened, and nothing changes because Korean's (not all ofc) look at KG like she failed herself and not the other way around. It's pretty sad but I appreciate her standing up for herself.
Your dreaming 😂 they’ll just close there western branches, specially the US one and keep all there business deals in Korea, that simple, this will not stop People consuming k-pop so yea it’s a pity but this will not change the situation in K-pop.
I’m not trying to be rude and this is off topic but y’all know the newjeans drama? Well they had to pay millions of dollars and maybe even hundreds of millions and they are also teenagers and they are very young but that doesn’t mean 500k isn’t a lot it’s just my opinion.
I find it important that people start boycotting the industry they shouldn’t hear K-pop anymore. If their idols are gonna get treated like this, they shouldn’t support it and I think it’s very disgusting of how people think she’s lying. If she was lying that it would be obvious but nobody was saying anything warnings no nowhere. It should be important that people stop that stop listening to K-pop. I think that could get the companies to do something, but it’s obviously not gonna change And I think it’s time to do something about it but I’m just a little teardrop of thousands of thousands of fans that are still not listening, that’s my opinion
Look, the girls knew what they were getting into, but it was never in the contract that the girls would be forced to work injured with the company even ignoring doctors saying they should rest. That's not Kpop, that's just a company being arrogant and stupid and KG's right to call them out. As to the members being young, one more time. The members of a kpop group are not just performers, they're atheletes, and they train like atheletes. Olympic gymnasts start as young as do school football and baseball squads. Many trainees have also already been child models or commercial actors. Training is tough, but most of the agencies respect their boundaries. Despite the contract squabbles agencies like YG and Cube have with their artists, none of the artists associated with them have ever accused them of deliberate physical mistreatment. YG even let Ahyeon go on a months-long break for medical issues that screwed up the debut of Babymonster but YG rolled with it and now Baemon is firing on all cylinders. It's funny that the KMCA is waving THE END IS COMING!!! placards over New Jeans when KG's lawsuit is far more likely to impact the system. New Jean's situation is pretty unique since it's the spill-over of the initial MHJ fight and even the members have never claimed physical abuse, only emotional abuse. JYPE is in deep shit over this, and this combined with the ongoing NJ actions, is likely to get "Hanni's Law" passed and put notice to the agencies to clean up their acts.
Did any of them file a lawsuit though?? I know some idols sued sm for their 10 year contracts, shorting it to the current 7 years. Although some believe sm still have this in play, as well as not allowing their groups to disband
Kpop industry is brutal and her abuse is nothing new. You are taken sides on allegations. She's not the first to try to get out of a contract. What about the other members? What if she can't handle the pressure of being an idol? What if her talent has reached it's limits and shows no potential improvement? Wait until all the facts are out before making judgment. It's a brutal industry!
Do you think we should just... Boycott Kpop? As much as we love our favorite idols, it's mostly the companies that profit off their song. Someone said that the industry needs to change, and if it can't change it needs to collapse. We need to pressure all Kpop companies not just JYP for a revolution in the industry
We can boycott kpop but it wouldn’t do anything because there’s still kpop stans out there that are blind to the fact that the kpop industry is sunshines and rainbows & they will keep streaming
@maurora-d1u I mean i dont expect full coverage... nor do i expect everyone to fully stop streaming, but just like buy less merch, stream it less and less until / if change is made. McDonalds has a boycott on it too for Palestine yet ppl still visit it its not like restaurants everywhere are barren... and it still works... when it comes to money, losing revenue is good pressure. it wont stop a war but...
I dont think this will have any affect on jyp- as in people will keep supporting the artist and keep engiagjng in jyps market to keep their money going. Maybe this may make their stocksgo down a for a while but everyones gonna forget it about it and its gonna go back to normal. These companies will never change anything until it hits where it really huts which is money.
i don't know forgot about this old past journey successful this is experiment kpop group or global group of the list kaachi ,uhsn,exp edition, z-boys, z- girls,rania now 2024 blackswan, xin, unis xg,katseye,vcha,starseedz,dear alice our history.
I don't think the boycott will because the members might not want to leave the company because they're going to think it's hard work and most of them wanted to be singers anyway but it's just my opinion don't take my word for it
You have no right to they disband this is there dream not yours her name is kg not kj we didn't her from others girls to hope for group to disband not knowing the whole story let's here from other 5 members first they all work so hard not fare for you to ask that I wish them the best I want all six to stay but in a healthy environment vcha we love you your fan
syo half american and japanese k- trainee audition from starlight boys pls vote foreigner 🙏🙏🙏 going to top 9 and then sviat he was minor 13 yrs old ukraine boy eliminated has project 7 4 -5 episodes 😢 this is first time audition on korea global boy and girl group same here vcha and unis or dear alice
6,,,It is estimated that Korean entertainment companies depend on the US or Europe for about 1/3 of K-pop,,However, if only TH-cam releases are blocked, the Korean entertainment industry will see a 10% decrease in operating profit and sales for the time being,,,,This will not be a big burden for Korean entertainment companies,,The effect of this is huge First of all, we need to prevent damage to Korea's national image caused by these various incidents and accidents. I hope that the import/consumption of K-pop in the US and Europe will be completely blocked... As time goes by, most K-pop fans will disappear from these regions.
Well said, I am glad that there are fans liike you. This is quite simple you cant bear and be paitent with KPOP system, don't try to join...I wanna tell this KG why heck did u even make the contract and you wanna leave for a freedom completely ignoring the contract. Yeah...she is 16 and a child....so what...business is business and a contract is a contract. NO companies allows any artists do their own music or buisness while they are legally under tha company. NO one know what really happened to KG. I think it is not a fair to just believe her claims only. She is like she wanna be a super star but don't wanna do the homework. Well she did not know she was suppoesed to practice many hours a day ?.... If she injured she should have more strongly told her managers that she is seriously in pain. I think she might have used her injury to run away and use it as a weapon to sue jype. This is my thought on her and we never know. I just hate ppl the law says we are suppoesed to work for a certain amount of time...and then want to be rich and get fame. No sucessful ppl work for a normal hour like anyone eles. People suceed b.c they work harder and deligent than ordinary ppl. KG just was not that type of person do endure it. Please don't even try to be kpop idols if you gonna sue the comapany for being forced to practice a lot lol. This is simply you don't like it? then don't do it thing...
But it's not a secret how it really looks like (I mean - the kpop industry). She didn't know what contract she signed? Could have done some research and not just rushed there without a second thought🤷♀️ No hate, just my opinion
JY Park should have picked GINA instead of KG tbh, as Gina was experienced with the rigors of K-POP training. That said, I wish KG, and VCHA as a whole, a positive outcome.
You could wonder if there is a link between those mistreatments and Gina’s eviction. Obviously she was not kicked out for lack of talent (or assumed lack of emotion). She says it through FREEDOM the song she released just after
@MdB2Canteleu both were 14 at the time of vcha’s debut, too young regardless to debut. Do *not* defend minors debuting. The west are not super accepting of minors anymore compared to the 2000s and there were minors everywhere (I was a "tween" i those times). People saying the west is just as bad as korea, need to release that the incidents they mention when saying "west is as bad as korea" all happened a long time ago and tougher laws have since been put into place, especially since the sag strike. Minors shouldn't debut regardless if Gina was "a young lady" at Kaylee's age
Idk how everything is going to turn out in the court and I am not even fully convinced with kg's claims as well ( I'm not saying she's lying or anything ) but abt the company debt most of idols have it and they pay it in the following years after their debut. As far as ik jype never forces their idols to pay for the debt they have , they settle their debt slowly after they get fame and profits. Also I'm not sure abt how the California pay system works but if we go by the Korean system idols are the one who pay for their makeups , rents and bills ( until they live the company dormitories) so with the amount of money they get paid most of them is spent on the other expenses. Obviously I'm very much disappointed by the staff jype usa have because they have to face racism which caused the girls to have mental instability. The diet culture is also very toxic but it is what the truth is , all the idols/trainees have to go through this strict diet to fit the so called beauty standards or else they will be bullied online by netz so the company has to force them to go through such diets I'm sure they had cultural shocks after learning the diet system because ik Western and American artists don't care much abt those things at all. But all the idols let it be kpop, jpop, cpop every of them has to go through it, ig it is only the problem in Asia ( as ppl are often judged more by their appearances ). Abt the production stuff obviously most of the idols are not allowed to do it only a few handful idols who mastered in production, and writing are allowed by the companies to do it and as we know kg was already and artist before she must have felt bad abt not getting to produce and write but we also have to consider that she can't just write whatever she wants to produce because they have to follow the grp concept as well. Well anyways I hope the court helps kg to get away from it and jype let her go easily without much hassle as they always did with their other ex artists.
2,,,I live in Korea and know K-pop in detail, but no trainee, parent, or media criticizes this,,,because everyone lives like that in Korea,,,if they feel pain from 12 hours of lessons and dieting every day, they are no longer in the company, and if they feel abuse or pain, the company will kick them out before that,,so they only get a short trainee experience and return to being ordinary people,,and then they will try to find another job,, Only about 10% of trainees enjoy the glory of debuting as singers,,90% They say they dropped out,,,In fact, there are so many male and female trainees in Korea who dropped out in the middle,,But it is not treated as a social problem.
if the other girls had a problem, they would be suing too… its only KG who is suing so its obvious who is the problem. and its not her business to speak on the other members’ experiences
4,,Now!!!,,,We must find a solution to this problem,,My argument is,,K-pop should not be exported or released in a general form to Western society without restriction,,In other words, it is okay to export or release to other regions,,,This is based on TH-cam related videos,, In the US and Europe, I think we should maintain album purchases and concerts as before, this is only consumed within the fandom,,It is definitely harmful to the general public, so it should be blocked It is necessary
To foreigners who criticize the K-pop training system // 1,,Korea is originally a society of hard work and high intensity with high pressure, and it would not be against or negative to give 12 hours of lessons a day to aspiring K-pop trainees,, Rather, most Koreans would think [Why on earth can't they receive 12 hours of lessons a day?? ],,,you will think like this,,that is Korean,,,Koreans are people who believe that nothing is impossible,, ,,that is, even if it is against the law in the US, it is not illegal here in Korea,,,there is no such law,,,the Youth Protection Act prohibits work after 9pm,,,but the lessons that trainees receive are not strictly work,,
3,,,,Since the company is completely denying the lawsuit filed for KG's abuse, it will just end as a mere incident, and because of that, the company's plan to create a localized group in the US will probably be abandoned,,,,The company should not have applied such Korean methods to Americans,,,,KG's fault was that if the training and life were that hard to endure, they should have consulted with the company, terminated their exclusive contract, and dropped out,,The same goes for any member who attempted suicide,,If the suicide is true, it is regrettable why they did not drop out before,,In fact, many K-pop idols drop out even after debuting,,,,Of course, they do not pay a penalty.
@momo_here.If they're willing to do so much shit on american soil, I can only imagine how much worse it is in korean soil where law and government basically works for the corporates, stop being delulu
It’s extremely dark
The only thing this will do, is cause the Kpop industry to tighten their grip on their idols.
I think companies will even start refusing westerners and foreigners again.
Not foreigner only west this has never happened to other asian idols maybe some Chinese idols but moat of them won the lawsuit and right about their acuse and china is one of the biggest country which kpop got money from so not other asian countries but def west
@@monotzukokuureshii What are you talking about? Never happened to other Asian Idols? Elkie from CLC was forced out by Cube for speaking out about mistreatment and management of her money. Plenty of other examples of (Asian) foreigners being mistreated, not-to-mention the countless Korean Idols who challenge their companies (Chuu comes to mind, as well as the rest of Loona).
??,,회사가 아이돌에 대해 더 심한 통제는 그것이 해법이 아니다 ,,,,,통제 강화로 나아지는 것은 없다 ,,,한국내의 엔터사의 연습생들에게도 그 이상은 어렵고,,,
most likely, because if the formula has already created the best of the best why change it now; also let's not forget they might argue that tits a difference in cultures which is actually fair in certain equations- not this one
So it’s up to international fans to refuse this treatment and not buy tickets or music until the kpop industry changes
Hopefully, this will push for a better work environment for idols and trainees
I’m not sure if this will affect the industry in Korea too much-trainee abuse isn’t something new; it’s a known thing. But obviously, it still doesn’t make it okay. HOWEVER, this will likely affect how people in the US view Kpop. From overworking minors to mentally abusing them to the point of self harm and such is a big no-no, especially in LA (very liberal), where KG filed the lawsuit. It will be difficult for any Kpop groups to break out in the US now.
I feel so bad for the other VCHA girls and other idols that have gone through this.
The thing that really adds weight to Kiera’s claims. Unlike other k-pop groups, JYP’s international project is based in California. Most of VCHA is or was underage. And California has very strict child labor laws, razor focused on the entertainment industry. JYP has appeared to endeavor to break all of them. By claiming “they don’t apply to trainees!”. This is not viewed as a strong argument when you’ve bullied a 14 year old into downing a whole bottle of pills.
It sadly won't change anything. Kpop scandals have been happening for years from suicides to sex trafficking (Burning Sun)... people have short memories.
Yeah, why are people supporting minor idols instead of boycotting groups that debut underage idols?? Then get upset and defensive when I have told them not to support minor idols
@@aussiefurbymogwaifan6621only the western countries don't allow or like minors to debut , apparently it is pretty common in kpop , cpop , jpop , tpop as well. Many netz and fans want idols who are younger and companies want it because they can work for a lot of years to make money for them. As you may know that after 30 many idols change their career to only acting or other things. So they don't debut idols who are older than 20
It didnt really unveil anything, we already knew all of this.
Nothing will happen, the show will go on
In korea you can get sued for whistelblowing if it damages a companies reputation, so I deeply hope with her being a us citizen and being under republicnan record, she won’t face any more consequences
Agree with you. But, this system is ingrained in Korea. Look at New Jeans, courts and industry is already against them. This korean system will not be tolerated in the USA.
NewJeans case is completely different. NewJeans case is more similar to Fifty Fifty case, tampering attempt
Because NuguJeanz and Co seems to be committing the crime of tampering, which is why the courts and industry is against them.
Nj stans are disgusting🤦♂️
As they should
not just USA. this is just basic common sense. don’t starve your artist or try to control their life lol
Yall titles be so dramatic. This will not effect anyone but the idols themselves and cause companies to begin to developed even stricter contracts.
Im not writing any titles though
Unfortunately, JYP will settle out of court like nothing happened, and nothing changes because Korean's (not all ofc) look at KG like she failed herself and not the other way around. It's pretty sad but I appreciate her standing up for herself.
Your dreaming 😂 they’ll just close there western branches, specially the US one and keep all there business deals in Korea, that simple, this will not stop People consuming k-pop so yea it’s a pity but this will not change the situation in K-pop.
Yah i mean the idols are basically trapped and the punishments in korea are worse than in america 😢
ok I just gave my thumbs up and I subscribed also!Keep up the good job❤🎉😊
I’m not trying to be rude and this is off topic but y’all know the newjeans drama? Well they had to pay millions of dollars and maybe even hundreds of millions and they are also teenagers and they are very young but that doesn’t mean 500k isn’t a lot it’s just my opinion.
Amazing Reaction
11:50 starting training between 21-27 and debuting between debuting between 25 and 29 (minimum 22)
girl your accent is perfect wydm
honestly I love listening to it too. Its lovely to listen to
Frr
thank youu💕🙏🏻
its NOT perfect. its hard to understand at times so keep working on it
I find it important that people start boycotting the industry they shouldn’t hear K-pop anymore. If their idols are gonna get treated like this, they shouldn’t support it and I think it’s very disgusting of how people think she’s lying. If she was lying that it would be obvious but nobody was saying anything warnings no nowhere. It should be important that people stop that stop listening to K-pop. I think that could get the companies to do something, but it’s obviously not gonna change And I think it’s time to do something about it but I’m just a little teardrop of thousands of thousands of fans that are still not listening, that’s my opinion
Yooo we saw these kids dancing in the freezing cold let’s start there !!!
You made some really good points in this video. 😊
Look, the girls knew what they were getting into, but it was never in the contract that the girls would be forced to work injured with the company even ignoring doctors saying they should rest. That's not Kpop, that's just a company being arrogant and stupid and KG's right to call them out.
As to the members being young, one more time. The members of a kpop group are not just performers, they're atheletes, and they train like atheletes. Olympic gymnasts start as young as do school football and baseball squads. Many trainees have also already been child models or commercial actors. Training is tough, but most of the agencies respect their boundaries. Despite the contract squabbles agencies like YG and Cube have with their artists, none of the artists associated with them have ever accused them of deliberate physical mistreatment. YG even let Ahyeon go on a months-long break for medical issues that screwed up the debut of Babymonster but YG rolled with it and now Baemon is firing on all cylinders.
It's funny that the KMCA is waving THE END IS COMING!!! placards over New Jeans when KG's lawsuit is far more likely to impact the system. New Jean's situation is pretty unique since it's the spill-over of the initial MHJ fight and even the members have never claimed physical abuse, only emotional abuse. JYPE is in deep shit over this, and this combined with the ongoing NJ actions, is likely to get "Hanni's Law" passed and put notice to the agencies to clean up their acts.
More people would be on Hanni's side if she wasn't supporting their p3do ex manger
she WON'T have an impact. How many idols have shown and talked about the struggles of this industry but it only gets worse?
Did any of them file a lawsuit though?? I know some idols sued sm for their 10 year contracts, shorting it to the current 7 years. Although some believe sm still have this in play, as well as not allowing their groups to disband
@@aussiefurbymogwaifan6621 I'm not sure..
Kpop industry is brutal and her abuse is nothing new. You are taken sides on allegations. She's not the first to try to get out of a contract. What about the other members? What if she can't handle the pressure of being an idol? What if her talent has reached it's limits and shows no potential improvement? Wait until all the facts are out before making judgment. It's a brutal industry!
Do you think we should just... Boycott Kpop? As much as we love our favorite idols, it's mostly the companies that profit off their song.
Someone said that the industry needs to change, and if it can't change it needs to collapse.
We need to pressure all Kpop companies not just JYP for a revolution in the industry
We can boycott kpop but it wouldn’t do anything because there’s still kpop stans out there that are blind to the fact that the kpop industry is sunshines and rainbows & they will keep streaming
@maurora-d1u I mean i dont expect full coverage... nor do i expect everyone to fully stop streaming, but just like buy less merch, stream it less and less until / if change is made. McDonalds has a boycott on it too for Palestine yet ppl still visit it its not like restaurants everywhere are barren... and it still works... when it comes to money, losing revenue is good pressure. it wont stop a war but...
I dont think this will have any affect on jyp- as in people will keep supporting the artist and keep engiagjng in jyps market to keep their money going. Maybe this may make their stocksgo down a for a while but everyones gonna forget it about it and its gonna go back to normal. These companies will never change anything until it hits where it really huts which is money.
We just had New Jeans, and now we have VCHA... what next? The President calling for Marshall Law? Oh, wait... 😮
A good consequence for companies that debut minors tbh and why p3dos like mhj should have background checks
이게 진짜 사보태지한다.. 어떻게 나쁜 우리 그냥 미국어 걸그룹 악몽이다!!
In the end of A2K Gina told how hard it was : FREEDOM. th-cam.com/video/r46zvGfTJsE/w-d-xo.htmlsi=Yurx0ffI-4IpOAFQ
i don't know forgot about this old past journey successful this is experiment kpop group or global group of the list kaachi ,uhsn,exp edition, z-boys, z- girls,rania now 2024 blackswan, xin, unis xg,katseye,vcha,starseedz,dear alice our history.
I don't think the boycott will because the members might not want to leave the company because they're going to think it's hard work and most of them wanted to be singers anyway but it's just my opinion don't take my word for it
destroy? hmmmm i dont think so
Yeah, such an inaccurate and click bait thumbnail.
You have no right to they disband this is there dream not yours her name is kg not kj we didn't her from others girls to hope for group to disband not knowing the whole story let's here from other 5 members first they all work so hard not fare for you to ask that I wish them the best I want all six to stay but in a healthy environment vcha we love you your fan
No I doubt they will have a comeback. They will most likely bisband . Sadly
Lucha..lucha..lucha..
Forgot! Stay strong, and don't let the haters get you down!
syo half american and japanese k- trainee audition from starlight boys pls vote foreigner 🙏🙏🙏 going to top 9 and then sviat he was minor 13 yrs old ukraine boy eliminated has project 7 4 -5 episodes 😢 this is first time audition on korea global boy and girl group same here vcha and unis or dear alice
6,,,It is estimated that Korean entertainment companies depend on the US or Europe for about 1/3 of K-pop,,However, if only TH-cam releases are blocked, the Korean entertainment industry will see a 10% decrease in operating profit and sales for the time being,,,,This will not be a big burden for Korean entertainment companies,,The effect of this is huge First of all, we need to prevent damage to Korea's national image caused by these various incidents and accidents. I hope that the import/consumption of K-pop in the US and Europe will be completely blocked... As time goes by, most K-pop fans will disappear from these regions.
Well said, I am glad that there are fans liike you. This is quite simple you cant bear and be paitent with KPOP system, don't try to join...I wanna tell this KG why heck did u even make the contract and you wanna leave for a freedom completely ignoring the contract. Yeah...she is 16 and a child....so what...business is business and a contract is a contract. NO companies allows any artists do their own music or buisness while they are legally under tha company. NO one know what really happened to KG. I think it is not a fair to just believe her claims only. She is like she wanna be a super star but don't wanna do the homework. Well she did not know she was suppoesed to practice many hours a day ?.... If she injured she should have more strongly told her managers that she is seriously in pain. I think she might have used her injury to run away and use it as a weapon to sue jype. This is my thought on her and we never know. I just hate ppl the law says we are suppoesed to work for a certain amount of time...and then want to be rich and get fame. No sucessful ppl work for a normal hour like anyone eles. People suceed b.c they work harder and deligent than ordinary ppl. KG just was not that type of person do endure it. Please don't even try to be kpop idols if you gonna sue the comapany for being forced to practice a lot lol. This is simply you don't like it? then don't do it thing...
But it's not a secret how it really looks like (I mean - the kpop industry). She didn't know what contract she signed? Could have done some research and not just rushed there without a second thought🤷♀️ No hate, just my opinion
I thought she brought KG
Your accent is adorable!!! 😊🎉❤
JY Park should have picked GINA instead of KG tbh, as Gina was experienced with the rigors of K-POP training. That said, I wish KG, and VCHA as a whole, a positive outcome.
You could wonder if there is a link between those mistreatments and Gina’s eviction. Obviously she was not kicked out for lack of talent (or assumed lack of emotion). She says it through FREEDOM the song she released just after
No the problem is JYP, putting up with mistreatment is not the way.
Gina was too young like kylee is to be debuting. Regardless if she's experienced, it's still wrong
@@aussiefurbymogwaifan6621 Kaylee was a babygirl. Gina was already a Young lady. She is now performing solo. And her performances are so good.
@MdB2Canteleu both were 14 at the time of vcha’s debut, too young regardless to debut. Do *not* defend minors debuting. The west are not super accepting of minors anymore compared to the 2000s and there were minors everywhere (I was a "tween" i those times). People saying the west is just as bad as korea, need to release that the incidents they mention when saying "west is as bad as korea" all happened a long time ago and tougher laws have since been put into place, especially since the sag strike. Minors shouldn't debut regardless if Gina was "a young lady" at Kaylee's age
Idk how everything is going to turn out in the court and I am not even fully convinced with kg's claims as well ( I'm not saying she's lying or anything ) but abt the company debt most of idols have it and they pay it in the following years after their debut. As far as ik jype never forces their idols to pay for the debt they have , they settle their debt slowly after they get fame and profits. Also I'm not sure abt how the California pay system works but if we go by the Korean system idols are the one who pay for their makeups , rents and bills ( until they live the company dormitories) so with the amount of money they get paid most of them is spent on the other expenses. Obviously I'm very much disappointed by the staff jype usa have because they have to face racism which caused the girls to have mental instability. The diet culture is also very toxic but it is what the truth is , all the idols/trainees have to go through this strict diet to fit the so called beauty standards or else they will be bullied online by netz so the company has to force them to go through such diets I'm sure they had cultural shocks after learning the diet system because ik Western and American artists don't care much abt those things at all. But all the idols let it be kpop, jpop, cpop every of them has to go through it, ig it is only the problem in Asia ( as ppl are often judged more by their appearances ). Abt the production stuff obviously most of the idols are not allowed to do it only a few handful idols who mastered in production, and writing are allowed by the companies to do it and as we know kg was already and artist before she must have felt bad abt not getting to produce and write but we also have to consider that she can't just write whatever she wants to produce because they have to follow the grp concept as well.
Well anyways I hope the court helps kg to get away from it and jype let her go easily without much hassle as they always did with their other ex artists.
2,,,I live in Korea and know K-pop in detail, but no trainee, parent, or media criticizes this,,,because everyone lives like that in Korea,,,if they feel pain from 12 hours of lessons and dieting every day, they are no longer in the company, and if they feel abuse or pain, the company will kick them out before that,,so they only get a short trainee experience and return to being ordinary people,,and then they will try to find another job,,
Only about 10% of trainees enjoy the glory of debuting as singers,,90% They say they dropped out,,,In fact, there are so many male and female trainees in Korea who dropped out in the middle,,But it is not treated as a social problem.
if the other girls had a problem, they would be suing too… its only KG who is suing so its obvious who is the problem. and its not her business to speak on the other members’ experiences
4,,Now!!!,,,We must find a solution to this problem,,My argument is,,K-pop should not be exported or released in a general form to Western society without restriction,,In other words, it is okay to export or release to other regions,,,This is based on TH-cam related videos,,
In the US and Europe, I think we should maintain album purchases and concerts as before, this is only consumed within the fandom,,It is definitely harmful to the general public, so it should be blocked It is necessary
To foreigners who criticize the K-pop training system //
1,,Korea is originally a society of hard work and high intensity with high pressure, and it would not be against or negative to give 12 hours of lessons a day to aspiring K-pop trainees,, Rather, most Koreans would think [Why on earth can't they receive 12 hours of lessons a day?? ],,,you will think like this,,that is Korean,,,Koreans are people who believe that nothing is impossible,,
,,that is, even if it is against the law in the US, it is not illegal here in Korea,,,there is no such law,,,the Youth Protection Act prohibits work after 9pm,,,but the lessons that trainees receive are not strictly work,,
3,,,,Since the company is completely denying the lawsuit filed for KG's abuse, it will just end as a mere incident, and because of that, the company's plan to create a localized group in the US will probably be abandoned,,,,The company should not have applied such Korean methods to Americans,,,,KG's fault was that if the training and life were that hard to endure, they should have consulted with the company, terminated their exclusive contract, and dropped out,,The same goes for any member who attempted suicide,,If the suicide is true, it is regrettable why they did not drop out before,,In fact, many K-pop idols drop out even after debuting,,,,Of course, they do not pay a penalty.
미국과 유럽은 케이팝을 수입/ 소비를 중단하고 차단을 해야,,원래 이2은 서로 안맞는다,,근본적인 해결책을 찾아야
VCHA is not even Kpop
But it's handled by a kpop agency duh
@Mno-1msJYP AMERICA
@momo_here.If they're willing to do so much shit on american soil, I can only imagine how much worse it is in korean soil where law and government basically works for the corporates, stop being delulu
It’s still JYP
@Alex-hf6vj vcha also worked in korea for over a year training ❤
KG ruined everything for the future of kpop for foreigners 😢😢😢
nah wdgaf, we already forgot
We?
From what I saw is that each time KG and her lawyer posts something new she looses supporters
Why??
i don't think you need to apologize for your accent. You speak well.
lying wont help her improve. she needs to keep practicing
@bx3054 how many languages do you speak?
@@johnv4866 2 well, and my spanish is awful but passable. i work hard to get better and so should she.
@@bx3054 my point is that she speaks a second language very well. Can she improve? Sure, but she can feel proud of how well she speaks.
@ i agree
i think KG can't keep up with the rest so she try to find some way out.. i dont see other members saying anything.. but we'll see
Um, you know companies restrict what idols can say you know??
If people are working for you they should not be indebted to you like wtf?
ig as promised: instagram.com/itsgivingnena/