The hyenas only attack in groups 🤭 they used to love shaykh Haitham but i guess since he doesn’t necessarily associate with wahabbis now, they hate him. It shows you their real colours: najdi desert brown
I prayed tarawih today in a shaafiee (kokni) masjid. The imam prayed Witr with salaam after 2 rakaah, then prayed 1 rakaah with qunoot after the rukuh.
Assalamu'alaikum everyone, reading the comments section, its very apparent that Muslims need to urgently attend an Islamic essentials course to learn the fundamentals of the religion. There are many short courses available. Please sign up and encourage others to do so too. It will benefit the ummah if we all level up by learning the fundamentals.
Firstly i commend the shaykh a very positive message. If people abandon the najdi dawah everyone is united as the four madhabs peacefully co exist we are all sunni brothers. The issue is the takfeeri mindset of the najdi dawah hence all fpur schools shun that fitna.The jamhur would be the ahnaf and shafis they have the most adherents. Individually the hanafi school is the largest always has been. Traditional sunni islam is the four madhabs who were real salaf imams. Not the innovations of today like ibn wahabh and al barni contemporary scholars with zero authority
@@gaalkacyo1634 I am with the jamah and Sunni alhumdulilah you worry about you your fitna spreading biddah loving imams who spread fitna takfeer and chaos in the ummah.
@@gaalkacyo1634do you have Islam without Abdul wahab , bin baaz , Al bani , ibn uthymayn ??? For you likely not, you got nothing to hold on to despite waving 'Quran&Sunnah' following above scholars is not quran sunnah. Have a deep think why you abandon 1000 years of scholarship ( 4 schools ) which actually unite us not devide us over modern stay scholars coming out of 1 small area of arabia. The 4 schools go back to the salaf. Abu haneefa was from the salaf.
@@adamhussain6651 What are you talking about, do you even know me? Fear Allah and repent for indeed you have assumed bad about a muslim. I follow Quran and Sunnah based on the understanding of the Prophet sallalahu alayhi wa salama and his companions. May Allah bless all the imams from the salaf including the 4 imams and the scholars that came after them.
Shafii is 2 rakaat 1 tasleem and then 1 rakaat 1 tasleem. Witir qunut is recited only on the last 15 days of ramadhan. This is what being practise in south east asia - malaysia , indonesia, singapore, brunei, some parts of thailand...
Thank you Sheikh for the advice. I was in a masjid in North London this Ramadan and some South Asian brothers tried to bully the Algerian Imam who is either likely a Shafee or Maliki to pray the witr the Hanafi way. The Imam being shy almost gave in until I explained that he should pray the witr the way he intended to and that not everyone in the congregation was Hanafi. Some people still think that they are back home in their village. They need to learn that Muslims in England are from different schools of thought and have to be flexible to accommodate all of the Muslims.
Assalaamualaikum 3 rakaat Witr is recognised in the Shafii Madhab just that the preferred mode is 2 + 1 like the jumhoor. I believe the principle applied in preferring one form over the other is that more actions performed in worship (additional tasleem and additional takbeer, rtc) is virtuous. Allah knows best.
If only we could respect each other like that. Its not like any of the ways of doing witr is against the sunnah. Nabi Salatu Wasallam did both 3 and 2+1 so there isn't even a difference to begin with.
AKhan ... I challeng you and your Dr. ZAKIR NAIK and the whole of the antagonistic Salafi diaspora from its peon scholars to its peon laymen to find me one verse in the Qur'an Kareem where it says, follow Hadeeth , or alKitab and Hadeeth or alKitab and Saheeh Hadeeth *verbatim* !!
Ok and what exactly do you think the madhabs do? That is quran and sunnah. Quran and sunnah according to you and your interpretation is not something we are taking over scholars and people a millions times more learned than you and who are actually from the salaf.
@@afnankhan5989 no there can be ikhtilaaf in the madhab as well, like i follow the Hanafi madhab, some mujtahideen say Shrimp is considered makrooh tanzihi, some say its makrooh tahrimi.
@@JumpaKage oh wow, so your ulema could work hard and research into Hanafi fiqh and give you the most authentic opinion according to that fiqh but don't have time to put same amount of hardwork in research the ikhtelaaf in Sunnah and reach a conclusion?
It would have been better if you would have said these are the 3 ways Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him prayed witr. We r ummah of Muhammad salalahu alahi wasalm not any other imams.
Well it's may be surprise but these are not the three ways how Prophet muhammad peace be upon him prayed. These are three way how the imams of these madhabs think he prayed. Claiming that prophet Mohammad prayed in three different way would be incorrect as it will demand evidence from Hadiths, not the statement of the imams.
@@afnankhan5989 they were mujtahid not ahle rai. This deen is not personal opinions. First get knowledge whome we call a mujtahid. They have their evidences and their evidence is quraan Sunnah ahadees and the amal of sahaba. They are not bounded by any madhab. They are not ahle rai. They are the immams of ahlul hadees jamat. Ahle Sunnah wal jamat Or ashabul hadees and they are on the manhaj of our salafi saliheen.
@@afnankhan5989 What? The Imams base their actions on hadith and Quran, if they did not do that then no musslim would follow them. There are clear hadith that prove Prophet sallalahu alayhi wa salam prayed witr in different ways. If a person dont have evidence then we dont follow them unless they have evidence from Quran and Sunnah. Our ultimate loyalty is to Allah.
Allah Azza wajjal commands in the Qur'an to obey Allah and follow his messenger. There is no catering in Islam, learn from the books of sunnah and learn your religion. You will be held to account for not knowing your religion. The prophet of Allah said there will be 73 sects of Muslim all will be in hellfire except for the ones who follow his way. The only imam I choose to follow is the final prophet and messenger of Allah Muhammad peace and blessings be upon him Ameen. His is the only intercession that will be allowed on the day of judgment.
@@edawatuk8012 No, hanafis says vitr is 3 rakah. But hadith clearly mentions vitr is one Narrated `Abdullah bin `Umar: The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Night prayer is offered as two rak`at followed by two rak`at and so on, and if you want to finish it, pray only one rak`a which will be witr for all the previous rak`at." (Bukhari) Will Isa alaisalam pray 3 or will he accept 1.
@@edawatuk8012 for the sake of Argument, let's agree he will alternate, what about things that cannot be alternated, like believing something is haram or halal. There are things which are haram in hananfi madhab but are halal in others and vice versa. Do you think he will alternate there as well saying this is haram today but halal tomorrow?
I don't get how you can accommodate all 4 madhab. The night that you are praying hanafi way, wouldn't a shafi see it as makrooh. So how you accommodating the shafi?
@ramindurrani1295 He does. But that wouldn't accommodate everyone. You praying the shafi way once every 4 days. Why would shafi pray 3 days makrooh when he can go to another masjid that does 7 days his way?
If it is acceptable in one acceptable mathhab then it is acceptable to pray behind one that does not conform to your mathhab. And we find evidence in the practices of scholars of one madhhab praying in the other accepted mathhab of another community and not repeating his salaat , which means it's acceptable to him , like the Salaat of Imam Shafiee as a Hanafi when he went to Hanafi territory There is no evidencethat he repeated his prayer in the Shafiee mathhab. So we can infer by this that a Maliki praying behind a hanbali or a shafiee or a hanafi , or, a Hanafi behind a shafiee or a maliki or hanbali , or , A Hanbali behind a hanafi or a maliki or shafiee or , A Shafiee behind a hanafi or maliki or hanbali are all valid and acceptable in Shariah and you are also free to pray at the masjid that caters to your mathhab , just have a more positive approach rather than an aggravated antagonized antagonistic one @@arandomhandsomeman7725
How can we follow 4 guys who were born 1 century after the Holy Prophet صلى الله عليه و اله و سلم , it seems that Allah has nothing to do with it!!! Allah calculated everything, planned everything, suddenly when it comes to the last Prophet صلى الله عليه و اله و سلم everything seems to be by haps ! No scholar mentions Hadith Thaqalain, why??? Are the four schools of thought included in this Hadith ?
We dont need madhab to follow Islam. Islam is free from law schools. We dont take sharia from anyone but Allah and his prophet. There isnt anything hanafi way, shafi way, maliki way. They dont give us rulings. Allah is giving the rulings no one else, and Islam is completed.
@@Mehmet_Fateh no madhhad akhi. Just sunnah. As the prophet taught it, and as the companions understood and practiced it. The deen is simple, dont complicate it.
@@Mehmet_Fateh The prophet( swaws) said don't pray your witr like the Maghrib salah Prophet Muhammad said: “Do not pray Witr prayer with three rakahs like Maghrib.” (Al-Hakim, Al-Bayhaqi, and Al-Daraqutni) Ibn Hajar said: Its chain of transmission fulfils the conditions of the two Imams; Al-Bukhari and Muslim.
Obviously not, instead of Asking the best way to know if some is full fledged scholar is by listening to how they speak. If they guide you with book of Allah and Sunnah of Rasool Allah. Then they are full fledged scholar. If they just seems to unite everyone and saying everything is true to get more peoples attention and likes, then they are to be aware of.
@@afnankhan5989 I think the main body of your response is beneficial but unfortunately it comes across as rude abrasive and aggressive. I’m not sure if that was your intent but that’s how it appears. It was a genuine question asked by a layman and your response has large implications of arrogance emanating. Like I said I could be wrong and you may not have that intent. So in short you’re saying he’s not a scholar!
@@shairsko9360 Yes, he is not a scholar. I have also to tried to lay a foundation so that you don't need to ask people again when there is clear indication. A real scholar speaks with evidences from Quran And Sunnah. If they use the statements of scholars OR imams, then it would be only to further explain Quran and Sunnah and give credit to the one who explained it. However if someone leaves of the Quran and Sunnah and only mention the positions of imams or Madhabs, then for sure he is not a scholar. I hope this benefits you!
@@afnankhan5989 much benefit derived Aakhee! Appreciate the deep dive and insight! جزاك الله خير It goes along with my gut instinct that he was not a scholar. I will use your points to assess speakers moving forward. انشاءالله
Dr Sahib, the way you ascribed to the Shafis is actually what te Ahl e Hadith prefer. The Shafis perform 2 plus 1, not what you said which is actually the way of the Ahl e Hadith
Its strange how all the negative comments are from salafis only ... Speaks volumes... The more ignorant you are about fiqh the more you speak negatively about different fiqh
The Prophet allowed these differences to prevail as did his companions as did their followers as did the followers of their followers and the ummah has continued to do so until some fruitcake approx 15 centuries later comes on TH-cam throwing his her disconnectedness and discombobulation on practices of the correctly-guided rightly-abiding Ummah
Assalaamualaikum 3 rakaat Witr is recognised in the Shafii Madhab just that the preferred mode is 2 + 1 like the jumhoor. I believe the principle applied in preferring one form over the other is that more actions performed in worship (additional tasleem and additional takbeer, rtc) is virtuous. Allah knows best.
Bring the daleel for the hanafi way, all the other imams are similar in witr. Except for hanafi. The sunnah supports witr for madhab al hanbali, maaliki, shafi'i.
Why ? The sheikh just explained it. If your not Hanifi then it doesn't matter then does it. If your are Hanafi then you continue. All about unity bro. 😊
@@Asif_Malik786 I just asked it as the sheikh said all madhabs have daleel. As someone who looked into the matter. It's very hard to find strong evidence from the sunnah that supports the hanafi method compared to the other madhabs. Ultimately you are right, madhabs are only fiqh issues. We should respect all, but if the Imam is following a certain madhab we shouldn't walk away from the jamat in my opinion but respect his view and opinion . Allah knows best.
@@MrRK0121Fuqaha of Hanafi or any of the 3 mathhabs need not convince you to earn your validation ! They've been validated ever since ! A delirious selfengrandizing peon wants to butt his head against the four living mountains ⛰️ of Ahlus-Sunnah wa'l-Jama'at !!
@@MrRK0121 What evidence do u want Simply search hanafi way of witr proof U will get answer I know u might qoute hadith " don't pray wirt like magrib " But my brother's those who quote u this hadith never quote u full hadith wallah it's is huge lie against prophet (saw) . So research. Then u will know the answer
With due respect shk Just for the sake of unity and pleasing people we should leave sunnah way 🤔 even if the way is not authentic? Mean based on week hadith?
So you are shykhul hadith, a scholar? Bro leave the specialists to do their job in their field. Would you utter your opinion to a doctor regarding operations, treatment and medication and refute it. Watch the video again Mr shykhul Ahadith
Brother authentic according to who? Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a) was a tabi'ieen born 80 hijri whereas Imam Bukhari (r.a) was born 150+ hijri. If you are trying to say something is weak on the basis of a Hadith that reached Imam Bukhari 150+ years afterwards which would have had to be transmitted from person to person to person to person to person whereas that same Hadith reached Imam Abu Hanifa directly from a Sahabi, then do you see how that would like putting the cart before the horse? Hadith gets weaker the more it is transmitted making an otherwise authentic Hadith weaker. You have to realise the very very very big difference between Imam Abu Hanifa and his rulings verses a ruling derived from Sahih Bukhari that didn't even exist at that time in history for at least another 100+ years. You should be impressed as opposed to dissapointed. You are getting an earlier understanding of Islam closer to the Sahabah than you are with deriving straight from Sahih Bukhari. Do you understand akhi? May Allah guide us all to the clear understanding of the truth and May Allah forgive me if I have said something in error.
@@alphauno6614 barakallahu feek. May Allah grant us understanding of our deen and may Allah safeguard us from arrogance and ignorance because ignorance breeds arrogance.
Akhi, leave these people. Do you think these madhabs dont have ikhtelaf. There are ikhtelaf with in these madahib and the ulema have time to research and come to the most authentic opinion with in the madhab but when we ask them to do that same with Sunnah. Spend same time in researching the ikhtelaaf and come to the most authentic opinion, they say its impossible and say are you sheikh ul hadith and bla bla. Stick to Sunnah. Imagine muftis spending 50-60 years studying one Madhab and dedicating his life to know what's correct according to that madhab and wasting his whole life leaving of Sunnah. Try searching why malikis leave of there hands and not fold and you'll see them trying very hars to defend their madhab and make taweel of hadiths according to the madhab. Sad state of this ummah and these ignorant individuals defend it.
Did the prophet Salallahu Allaihi Wasallam not prohibit praying Witr like Maghreb? and that's what Hannafis are doing. any reason behind i Want clear evidence. Hannafis goes against Sunnah and that's a fact.
We have to be understanding of all madhahib bro. Im not here for argument but Last time I checked there wasn't any qunoot in maghrib. ( whereas the hanafis do it all the time) Nor was there loud recitation in 3rd rakah. (Maghrib is always quiet) If you say no that's not what the prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam meant by this, we need to go get dalil of this from the messenger. So best chill out and relax.
Here we go again… the close relations of Sufis means you cannot dismiss innovations or refute them anymore as relationships will turn sour? Shaykh, please stop with these ambigious confusing snippets. Keep your opinions to yourself. There’s people out there seeking a methodical path of knowledge to come close to the sunnah as possible and here we are time and time again with wishy washy opinions by people to further confuse the laymen.
He is talking about the tawaatur methods and opinions of the 4 maddhaabs. To come here and run your mouth when you are struggling to comprehend the basics is absolute ignorance. You are going to criticise a well respected scholar now? Absolutely nothing he said was ambiguous and if you believe that then you need sign off here.
Absolute arrogance conflated with abject ignorance of UsulelFiqh in the Usul AhlusSunnah walJamaat , Kitab Sunnah Ijma Qiyas , and the acceptable corroborated connected linked Qiyases practiced by the Salaf stretching since then until this day ! @@aamirh3567
On top of that you admittedly recognize your state of being Confused laymen and still running your mouth with "confused laynen" verdicts a puny peon making himself judge of what's correct and incorrect practice
The Prophet 3lyhisSalaatwasSalaam allowed these differences to grow from a sacred source upon corrected understanding to then nourish and flourish through the Ummah through his companions and them through their followers and them through their followers until this day by the Will of Allah SubhaanaHuWaTaaala
Btw, those who are defending these inovated madhabs, FYI AZHAR UNIVERSITY accepted Jafari school of thought as 5th Madhab. So according to the Sheikh's logic, the imam also must incorporate thier way of praying (if they pray vitr, lol). Sad state of this ummah, they defend these inovated madhabs more religiously than the Sunnah and when some one say them to follow sunnah, they get triggered.
Akhi, can you think critically about what you're saying? Say you are born in the time of tabi'eens and want to learn Islam (Quran & Sunnah). What do you do? You go to your local scholar and ask them about Islam. Now if you are born in Kufa, you may end up going to Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a) or if you are in Medina you go to Imam Malik (r.a) who were both certified great scholars of their time and some of the best the ummah ever produced. Same with Imam Shafi'e (r.a) and with Imam Ahmed bin Hanbal (r.a), these were great GREAT scholars who derived Islam the way the Salaf understood it (because they were literally alive at the time the Salaf lived). Akhi, saying following Imam Ahmad (r.a) and the scholars who took his methodology is an innovation would mean following Sheikh Albani and those who agreed with him and his interpretation is an innovation. Do you see how this doesn't make any sense? How is it that for the majority of the ummah, the majority of the greatest scholars of all time ended up following the 4 madhaahib but here you are somehow understanding Islam even better than them? Can you tell me where you studied your ilm and who made you a Mujtahid because as far as I know even Sheikh ul Islam Ibn Taymiyaah was a madhabi (Hanbali school) and he was a MUJTAHID! Akhi, please, how can you spread fitnah in the ummah like this? Don't you see how you are making Iblis happy?
Masha allah well said sheikh a good piece of advice to bring unity between us Muslims unfortunately there will always be haters who think they are scholars by reading a few books or have watched a few videos on you tube or tik tok that will post negative comments unfortunately their hearts are full of hate.
Very strange. Let's follow Sunnah, not madhab! How can one thing be halal and haram at the same time? If you believe all madhabs are upon haq, then basically you are saying Sunnah is not clear and is in need of these madhabs for understanding. Ajeeb. Like the trinity of Christianity, we seems to have quaternity.
@@FaizanKhan-ic2oi I have more idea than you akhi what a madhab is and how madhabis and muqalideen are. Alhamdullilah, Allah has guided me towards his book and Sunnah of his messenger without confining to anything other than these two.
@@afnankhan5989Basics of sunnah bro. The Prophet SAW prayed in different ways at different times during his life. Hence why there are authentic reports of the various ways. It's basic knowledge mate.
![Live for The Hereafter | Shaykh, Dr. Haitham al-Haddad [Emotional]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/8J-FCV98CEU/mqdefault.jpg)
![Live for The Hereafter | Shaykh, Dr. Haitham al-Haddad [Emotional]](/img/tr.png)
FINALLY SOMEONE TALKING SENSE, IN CLEAR LANGUAGE, WITH REGARD TO THE MADHABS AND THE LEGITIMACY OF ALL OF THEM, ALL OF THEM HAVING DALEEL
Do you follow the prophet or the madhab? Haytham is a terroirs Masonic Muslim brotherhood fool he isn’t even a scholar
this person is ikhwani, who claims democracy is ok. knowledge should not be taken from him
@@MenkIsAMubtadiiDeobandi we need to expose these salafis who are cause of fitna wherever they go, lack knowledge or be it superficial knowledge
@@MenkIsAMubtadiiDeobandi *_What is democracy?_*
🤣😜🤣😜🤣
@@MenkIsAMubtadiiDeobandiyou must be a madkhali agent paid by taghoot MBS.
This has brought all the nejdis crawling out of the woodwork for sure!! Allah guide them and the rest of us
The hyenas only attack in groups 🤭 they used to love shaykh Haitham but i guess since he doesn’t necessarily associate with wahabbis now, they hate him. It shows you their real colours: najdi desert brown
Very refreshing! As a wise man said, unity is not uniformity but it is acknowledging differences of opinion
There is uniformity on clear issues. There is only difference of opinion in the matters that are unclear
May Allah reward the sheikh. Just to clarify, Witr in Shafi madhab is to do 2 rakats with tasleem and a third single rakat w/qunoot.
No brother they do three I pray in Shafi masjid.
Both ways are accepted in Shafi'i madhab. As for the qunut, it's only during ramadan (fr night 16th onwards)
Mashallah. We need more open mindedness views like this from scholars in our society. Respect Sheikh 👊🏻
I prayed tarawih today in a shaafiee (kokni) masjid. The imam prayed Witr with salaam after 2 rakaah, then prayed 1 rakaah with qunoot after the rukuh.
This is nice.
But most people say, praying Witr in Hanafi way is against Sunnah.
@@jesusisSLAVEofAllah And in the video we just watched we had clarification about how this is wrong
@@jesusisSLAVEofAllah did you watch the video properly?
Jazak Allah khayr!
I like this sheikh. You are correct sir. And I love the balanced view even though you may not be a Hanafi
Jzk Allah khr Shaykh may Allah unite the Ummah.
The Ummah can ONLY UNITE upon the Haq, NOT upon whims and desires. This man Hadad is deviant and misguided heretic.
This is beautiful.. I love the way he explained it . ❤❤❤
The more knowledge you have the more you respect others ❤
Well done! Spread all the accepted ways !
Not all are accepted. The shafi, maliki, and hanbali madhab majorly disagree with the way hanafi do witr but agree upon each other.
Assalamu'alaikum everyone, reading the comments section, its very apparent that Muslims need to urgently attend an Islamic essentials course to learn the fundamentals of the religion. There are many short courses available. Please sign up and encourage others to do so too. It will benefit the ummah if we all level up by learning the fundamentals.
Firstly i commend the shaykh a very positive message. If people abandon the najdi dawah everyone is united as the four madhabs peacefully co exist we are all sunni brothers. The issue is the takfeeri mindset of the najdi dawah hence all fpur schools shun that fitna.The jamhur would be the ahnaf and shafis they have the most adherents. Individually the hanafi school is the largest always has been. Traditional sunni islam is the four madhabs who were real salaf imams. Not the innovations of today like ibn wahabh and al barni contemporary scholars with zero authority
Stop slandering the Imams and scholars of the Islam guard your tounge lest you be throuwn into hellfire
@@gaalkacyo1634 I am with the jamah and Sunni alhumdulilah you worry about you your fitna spreading biddah loving imams who spread fitna takfeer and chaos in the ummah.
@@LadooCrew Stop arguing and slandering muslims during ramadan
@@gaalkacyo1634do you have Islam without Abdul wahab , bin baaz , Al bani , ibn uthymayn ???
For you likely not, you got nothing to hold on to despite waving 'Quran&Sunnah' following above scholars is not quran sunnah. Have a deep think why you abandon 1000 years of scholarship ( 4 schools ) which actually unite us not devide us over modern stay scholars coming out of 1 small area of arabia. The 4 schools go back to the salaf. Abu haneefa was from the salaf.
@@adamhussain6651 What are you talking about, do you even know me? Fear Allah and repent for indeed you have assumed bad about a muslim. I follow Quran and Sunnah based on the understanding of the Prophet sallalahu alayhi wa salama and his companions. May Allah bless all the imams from the salaf including the 4 imams and the scholars that came after them.
Masya Allah. Agree !
Brother mashallah love the way explained and the respect you gave was amazing.... ❤❤❤
Shafii is 2 rakaat 1 tasleem and then 1 rakaat 1 tasleem. Witir qunut is recited only on the last 15 days of ramadhan. This is what being practise in south east asia - malaysia , indonesia, singapore, brunei, some parts of thailand...
Voice of reason
Thank you Sheikh for the advice. I was in a masjid in North London this Ramadan and some South Asian brothers tried to bully the Algerian Imam who is either likely a Shafee or Maliki to pray the witr the Hanafi way. The Imam being shy almost gave in until I explained that he should pray the witr the way he intended to and that not everyone in the congregation was Hanafi. Some people still think that they are back home in their village. They need to learn that Muslims in England are from different schools of thought and have to be flexible to accommodate all of the Muslims.
It would be nice that you have different madhab imams praying in the same mosque
I have prayed Witr all 3 ways for several years now
Mashallah ❤❤❤
Here in Morocco after taraweeh there is no witr prayer. You go back home and pray. For those who don't know Morocco is Maliki madhab.
What about the clubs and alcohol and open illicit relations and the 101 other stuff that goes on…
@eze1373 Is that where you pray your witr?
@@eze1373 Yes, what about it? The person who posted is just a mere citizenship of a country, just as you are presumably? Whataboutery is so immature
@@eze1373yeah that's a bad thing what's your point?
Great response 😅@@MuslimTours
Shafi Madhab is 2 rakah teslim and 1 rakah qunoot and taslim I’m shafi this is our standard witr pray
please correct it. Jazakallah
Assalaamualaikum
3 rakaat Witr is recognised in the Shafii Madhab just that the preferred mode is 2 + 1 like the jumhoor. I believe the principle applied in preferring one form over the other is that more actions performed in worship (additional tasleem and additional takbeer, rtc) is virtuous. Allah knows best.
Mashallah i thought you were ustadh Tim Humble for a second
Mashallah
all 4 mazdhabs are our school teachers. & the school principal is always Rosul beloved MUHAMMED s.a.w.
If only we could respect each other like that. Its not like any of the ways of doing witr is against the sunnah. Nabi Salatu Wasallam did both 3 and 2+1 so there isn't even a difference to begin with.
It would have been better if you provided evidence from the hadith
Are you doubting him? if it was a longer video he would have. I dont think he had the time to go in to depth.
@@aamirh3567 it's not doubting
@@aamirh3567but yeah i agree with you
AKhan ... I challeng you and your Dr. ZAKIR NAIK and the whole of the antagonistic Salafi diaspora from its peon scholars to its peon laymen to find me one verse in the Qur'an Kareem where it says, follow Hadeeth , or alKitab and Hadeeth or alKitab and Saheeh Hadeeth *verbatim* !!
Alhamdu LILLAH
1:10, where is the evidence for this practice?
How about Islam according to Quran and Sunnah way only.
When he states daleel that refers to evidence, each madhab gets their daleel from the quran and sunnah.
Ok and what exactly do you think the madhabs do? That is quran and sunnah. Quran and sunnah according to you and your interpretation is not something we are taking over scholars and people a millions times more learned than you and who are actually from the salaf.
Sheikh - it seems like you have got mixed up of Shafi’i method where witr is 2+1 with two separate Thasleems and Salam
Yes. He made a mistake
@@Ilk-adimmusluman-soy-adimTurk. isnt there ikhtilaaf about the issue in the shafi’i madhab?
@@JumpaKage : i think we need another madhab to understand the ikhltelaf within a madhab?
@@afnankhan5989 no there can be ikhtilaaf in the madhab as well, like i follow the Hanafi madhab, some mujtahideen say Shrimp is considered makrooh tanzihi, some say its makrooh tahrimi.
@@JumpaKage oh wow, so your ulema could work hard and research into Hanafi fiqh and give you the most authentic opinion according to that fiqh but don't have time to put same amount of hardwork in research the ikhtelaaf in Sunnah and reach a conclusion?
It would have been better if you would have said these are the 3 ways Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him prayed witr.
We r ummah of Muhammad salalahu alahi wasalm not any other imams.
Apcilutily right may allah bless u
True good point 👍
Well it's may be surprise but these are not the three ways how Prophet muhammad peace be upon him prayed.
These are three way how the imams of these madhabs think he prayed.
Claiming that prophet Mohammad prayed in three different way would be incorrect as it will demand evidence from Hadiths, not the statement of the imams.
@@afnankhan5989 they were mujtahid not ahle rai.
This deen is not personal opinions.
First get knowledge whome we call a mujtahid.
They have their evidences and their evidence is quraan Sunnah ahadees and the amal of sahaba.
They are not bounded by any madhab.
They are not ahle rai.
They are the immams of ahlul hadees jamat. Ahle Sunnah wal jamat Or ashabul hadees and they are on the manhaj of our salafi saliheen.
@@afnankhan5989 What? The Imams base their actions on hadith and Quran, if they did not do that then no musslim would follow them. There are clear hadith that prove Prophet sallalahu alayhi wa salam prayed witr in different ways. If a person dont have evidence then we dont follow them unless they have evidence from Quran and Sunnah. Our ultimate loyalty is to Allah.
That is absurd to think that Hanafi or Maliki etc have been wrong for more than 1200 years. They are all right.
Allah Azza wajjal commands in the Qur'an to obey Allah and follow his messenger.
There is no catering in Islam, learn from the books of sunnah and learn your religion. You will be held to account for not knowing your religion. The prophet of Allah said there will be 73 sects of Muslim all will be in hellfire except for the ones who follow his way.
The only imam I choose to follow is the final prophet and messenger of Allah Muhammad peace and blessings be upon him Ameen.
His is the only intercession that will be allowed on the day of judgment.
When Isa alaihsalam would return, how would he pray witr? According to which Madhab?
He will alternate the methods
@@edawatuk8012
That statement is merely a claim, jist like Hanfis claim that he will be Hanafi.
Please provide evidence!
Evidence is in the Ahadeeth. All methods found in the authentic Ahaadeeth are true and correct. The question is which one is preferred. @afnankhan5989
@@edawatuk8012
No, hanafis says vitr is 3 rakah.
But hadith clearly mentions vitr is one
Narrated `Abdullah bin `Umar:
The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Night prayer is offered as two rak`at followed by two rak`at and so on, and if you want to finish it, pray only one rak`a which will be witr for all the previous rak`at."
(Bukhari)
Will Isa alaisalam pray 3 or will he accept 1.
@@edawatuk8012 for the sake of Argument, let's agree he will alternate, what about things that cannot be alternated, like believing something is haram or halal.
There are things which are haram in hananfi madhab but are halal in others and vice versa.
Do you think he will alternate there as well saying this is haram today but halal tomorrow?
I don't get how you can accommodate all 4 madhab. The night that you are praying hanafi way, wouldn't a shafi see it as makrooh. So how you accommodating the shafi?
I wonder if he means to pray different witrs every night in turn ?
@ramindurrani1295
He does. But that wouldn't accommodate everyone. You praying the shafi way once every 4 days. Why would shafi pray 3 days makrooh when he can go to another masjid that does 7 days his way?
If it is acceptable in one acceptable mathhab then it is acceptable to pray behind one that does not conform to your mathhab. And we find evidence in the practices of scholars of one madhhab praying in the other accepted mathhab of another community and not repeating his salaat , which means it's acceptable to him , like the Salaat of Imam Shafiee as a Hanafi when he went to Hanafi territory
There is no evidencethat he repeated his prayer in the Shafiee mathhab. So we can infer by this that
a Maliki praying behind a hanbali or a shafiee or a hanafi , or,
a Hanafi behind a shafiee or a maliki or hanbali , or ,
A Hanbali behind a hanafi or a maliki or shafiee or ,
A Shafiee behind a hanafi or maliki or hanbali are all valid and acceptable in Shariah and you are also free to pray at the masjid that caters to your mathhab , just have a more positive approach rather than an aggravated antagonized antagonistic one @@arandomhandsomeman7725
Furu which means divergence in small issues is allowed according to Hanafis you can pray witr behind imam from another Madhab
How can we follow 4 guys who were born 1 century after the Holy Prophet صلى الله عليه و اله و سلم , it seems that Allah has nothing to do with it!!! Allah calculated everything, planned everything, suddenly when it comes to the last Prophet صلى الله عليه و اله و سلم everything seems to be by haps ! No scholar mentions Hadith Thaqalain, why??? Are the four schools of thought included in this Hadith ?
We dont need madhab to follow Islam. Islam is free from law schools. We dont take sharia from anyone but Allah and his prophet. There isnt anything hanafi way, shafi way, maliki way. They dont give us rulings. Allah is giving the rulings no one else, and Islam is completed.
Pray it upon the sunnah and thats it.
The sunnah according to which madhhab?
@@Mehmet_Fateh no madhhad akhi. Just sunnah. As the prophet taught it, and as the companions understood and practiced it. The deen is simple, dont complicate it.
@@Mehmet_Fateh The prophet( swaws) said don't pray your witr like the Maghrib salah
Prophet Muhammad said: “Do not pray Witr prayer with three rakahs like Maghrib.” (Al-Hakim, Al-Bayhaqi, and Al-Daraqutni) Ibn Hajar said: Its chain of transmission fulfils the conditions of the two Imams; Al-Bukhari and Muslim.
@@Spark12429 Does this refer to the tasleem or the third rakat being jahr?
@@rishat1254 You need the ulema to access the sunnah bro
Is sheikh hatham a fully fledged scholar?
Obviously not, instead of Asking the best way to know if some is full fledged scholar is by listening to how they speak. If they guide you with book of Allah and Sunnah of Rasool Allah. Then they are full fledged scholar. If they just seems to unite everyone and saying everything is true to get more peoples attention and likes, then they are to be aware of.
@@afnankhan5989 I think the main body of your response is beneficial but unfortunately it comes across as rude abrasive and aggressive. I’m not sure if that was your intent but that’s how it appears. It was a genuine question asked by a layman and your response has large implications of arrogance emanating. Like I said I could be wrong and you may not have that intent. So in short you’re saying he’s not a scholar!
@@shairsko9360
Yes, he is not a scholar.
I have also to tried to lay a foundation so that you don't need to ask people again when there is clear indication.
A real scholar speaks with evidences from Quran And Sunnah. If they use the statements of scholars OR imams, then it would be only to further explain Quran and Sunnah and give credit to the one who explained it.
However if someone leaves of the Quran and Sunnah and only mention the positions of imams or Madhabs, then for sure he is not a scholar.
I hope this benefits you!
@@afnankhan5989 much benefit derived Aakhee! Appreciate the deep dive and insight! جزاك الله خير
It goes along with my gut instinct that he was not a scholar. I will use your points to assess speakers moving forward. انشاءالله
Dr Sahib, the way you ascribed to the Shafis is actually what te Ahl e Hadith prefer. The Shafis perform 2 plus 1, not what you said which is actually the way of the Ahl e Hadith
Its strange how all the negative comments are from salafis only ... Speaks volumes... The more ignorant you are about fiqh the more you speak negatively about different fiqh
The imams can’t even figure out which way is the correct way to pray
The room for difference were left by the Prophet 3lyhisSalaatwasSalaam and you want to suppress it to your choice ?
Have some humility !
It's apparent you disregarded what was shared by this man.
The Prophet allowed these differences to prevail as did his companions as did their followers as did the followers of their followers and the ummah has continued to do so until some fruitcake approx 15 centuries later comes on TH-cam throwing his her disconnectedness and discombobulation on practices of the correctly-guided rightly-abiding Ummah
@@TheMercifulAndJust everyone is allowed their views stop trying to force your views on others
sheikh your shafi way is incorrect. shafis do 2+1 with loud qunoot in last 1
Assalaamualaikum
3 rakaat Witr is recognised in the Shafii Madhab just that the preferred mode is 2 + 1 like the jumhoor. I believe the principle applied in preferring one form over the other is that more actions performed in worship (additional tasleem and additional takbeer, rtc) is virtuous. Allah knows best.
Bring the daleel for the hanafi way, all the other imams are similar in witr. Except for hanafi. The sunnah supports witr for madhab al hanbali, maaliki, shafi'i.
Why ? The sheikh just explained it. If your not Hanifi then it doesn't matter then does it. If your are Hanafi then you continue. All about unity bro. 😊
@@Asif_Malik786 I just asked it as the sheikh said all madhabs have daleel. As someone who looked into the matter. It's very hard to find strong evidence from the sunnah that supports the hanafi method compared to the other madhabs. Ultimately you are right, madhabs are only fiqh issues. We should respect all, but if the Imam is following a certain madhab we shouldn't walk away from the jamat in my opinion but respect his view and opinion . Allah knows best.
@@MrRK0121Fuqaha of Hanafi or any of the 3 mathhabs need not convince you to earn your validation ! They've been validated ever since ! A delirious selfengrandizing peon wants to butt his head against the four living mountains ⛰️ of Ahlus-Sunnah wa'l-Jama'at !!
@@MrRK0121
What evidence do u want
Simply search hanafi way of witr proof
U will get answer
I know u might qoute hadith " don't pray wirt like magrib "
But my brother's those who quote u this hadith never quote u full hadith wallah it's is huge lie against prophet (saw) .
So research.
Then u will know the answer
DID YOU FORCE RULERS TO FIGHT FOR PALESTINIANS AS HOUTHI ARE DOING?
With due respect shk
Just for the sake of unity and pleasing people we should leave sunnah way 🤔 even if the way is not authentic? Mean based on week hadith?
So you are shykhul hadith, a scholar?
Bro leave the specialists to do their job in their field. Would you utter your opinion to a doctor regarding operations, treatment and medication and refute it.
Watch the video again Mr shykhul Ahadith
Am not shaykul hadith but so far strong opinion are not as shaiks mentioned in his vlog
Brother authentic according to who? Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a) was a tabi'ieen born 80 hijri whereas Imam Bukhari (r.a) was born 150+ hijri. If you are trying to say something is weak on the basis of a Hadith that reached Imam Bukhari 150+ years afterwards which would have had to be transmitted from person to person to person to person to person whereas that same Hadith reached Imam Abu Hanifa directly from a Sahabi, then do you see how that would like putting the cart before the horse? Hadith gets weaker the more it is transmitted making an otherwise authentic Hadith weaker.
You have to realise the very very very big difference between Imam Abu Hanifa and his rulings verses a ruling derived from Sahih Bukhari that didn't even exist at that time in history for at least another 100+ years. You should be impressed as opposed to dissapointed. You are getting an earlier understanding of Islam closer to the Sahabah than you are with deriving straight from Sahih Bukhari. Do you understand akhi?
May Allah guide us all to the clear understanding of the truth and May Allah forgive me if I have said something in error.
@@alphauno6614 barakallahu feek. May Allah grant us understanding of our deen and may Allah safeguard us from arrogance and ignorance because ignorance breeds arrogance.
Akhi, leave these people. Do you think these madhabs dont have ikhtelaf. There are ikhtelaf with in these madahib and the ulema have time to research and come to the most authentic opinion with in the madhab but when we ask them to do that same with Sunnah. Spend same time in researching the ikhtelaaf and come to the most authentic opinion, they say its impossible and say are you sheikh ul hadith and bla bla.
Stick to Sunnah. Imagine muftis spending 50-60 years studying one Madhab and dedicating his life to know what's correct according to that madhab and wasting his whole life leaving of Sunnah. Try searching why malikis leave of there hands and not fold and you'll see them trying very hars to defend their madhab and make taweel of hadiths according to the madhab.
Sad state of this ummah and these ignorant individuals defend it.
Where is evidence of the hanafi witr from Hadith, it is against how prophet used to pray.
Another puny peon !😅
Did the prophet Salallahu Allaihi Wasallam not prohibit praying Witr like Maghreb? and that's what Hannafis are doing. any reason behind i Want clear evidence. Hannafis goes against Sunnah and that's a fact.
We have to be understanding of all madhahib bro.
Im not here for argument but Last time I checked there wasn't any qunoot in maghrib. ( whereas the hanafis do it all the time)
Nor was there loud recitation in 3rd rakah. (Maghrib is always quiet)
If you say no that's not what the prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam meant by this, we need to go get dalil of this from the messenger.
So best chill out and relax.
@@islamicgems5263 any evidence please I don't want an essay.
Hanafi Method is different from Maghrib Salah in many ways: Qunoot, loud recitation in 3rd, surah after Fatihah in 3rd, and prayed after Isha.
@@ehsaankhan7078maybe that's how he prays maghrib? 🤷🏽♂️😂😂
@@ehsaankhan7078exactly right
Then you get the Indo Pak Mazhab.
Here we go again… the close relations of Sufis means you cannot dismiss innovations or refute them anymore as relationships will turn sour? Shaykh, please stop with these ambigious confusing snippets. Keep your opinions to yourself. There’s people out there seeking a methodical path of knowledge to come close to the sunnah as possible and here we are time and time again with wishy washy opinions by people to further confuse the laymen.
Same to you. Keep your opinion to yourself
He is talking about the tawaatur methods and opinions of the 4 maddhaabs. To come here and run your mouth when you are struggling to comprehend the basics is absolute ignorance. You are going to criticise a well respected scholar now? Absolutely nothing he said was ambiguous and if you believe that then you need sign off here.
Absolute arrogance conflated with abject ignorance of UsulelFiqh in the Usul AhlusSunnah walJamaat , Kitab Sunnah Ijma Qiyas , and the acceptable corroborated connected linked Qiyases practiced by the Salaf stretching since then until this day ! @@aamirh3567
On top of that you admittedly recognize your state of being Confused laymen and still running your mouth with "confused laynen" verdicts a puny peon making himself judge of what's correct and incorrect practice
The Prophet 3lyhisSalaatwasSalaam allowed these differences to grow from a sacred source upon corrected understanding to then nourish and flourish through the Ummah through his companions and them through their followers and them through their followers until this day by the Will of Allah SubhaanaHuWaTaaala
Btw, those who are defending these inovated madhabs, FYI AZHAR UNIVERSITY accepted Jafari school of thought as 5th Madhab. So according to the Sheikh's logic, the imam also must incorporate thier way of praying (if they pray vitr, lol).
Sad state of this ummah, they defend these inovated madhabs more religiously than the Sunnah and when some one say them to follow sunnah, they get triggered.
Akhi, can you think critically about what you're saying? Say you are born in the time of tabi'eens and want to learn Islam (Quran & Sunnah). What do you do? You go to your local scholar and ask them about Islam. Now if you are born in Kufa, you may end up going to Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a) or if you are in Medina you go to Imam Malik (r.a) who were both certified great scholars of their time and some of the best the ummah ever produced. Same with Imam Shafi'e (r.a) and with Imam Ahmed bin Hanbal (r.a), these were great GREAT scholars who derived Islam the way the Salaf understood it (because they were literally alive at the time the Salaf lived).
Akhi, saying following Imam Ahmad (r.a) and the scholars who took his methodology is an innovation would mean following Sheikh Albani and those who agreed with him and his interpretation is an innovation.
Do you see how this doesn't make any sense? How is it that for the majority of the ummah, the majority of the greatest scholars of all time ended up following the 4 madhaahib but here you are somehow understanding Islam even better than them? Can you tell me where you studied your ilm and who made you a Mujtahid because as far as I know even Sheikh ul Islam Ibn Taymiyaah was a madhabi (Hanbali school) and he was a MUJTAHID!
Akhi, please, how can you spread fitnah in the ummah like this? Don't you see how you are making Iblis happy?
🤦🏽♂️🤦🏽♂️🤦🏽♂️🤦🏽♂️are you really saying madhabs are a bidah??
@@SZ-mc7ch madhabs are not biddah, following them instead of following Sunnah is Biddah!
Oh no i see, its a salafi/wahabi, i thought he was a madhab follower looking for answers on fiqh🤣🤣
@@JumpaKage atleast you agree that we are followers of Salaf :)
Masha allah well said sheikh a good piece of advice to bring unity between us Muslims unfortunately there will always be haters who think they are scholars by reading a few books or have watched a few videos on you tube or tik tok that will post negative comments unfortunately their hearts are full of hate.
Very strange. Let's follow Sunnah, not madhab! How can one thing be halal and haram at the same time?
If you believe all madhabs are upon haq, then basically you are saying Sunnah is not clear and is in need of these madhabs for understanding. Ajeeb. Like the trinity of Christianity, we seems to have quaternity.
You literally have no idea! Learn what a madhab is and what their usool are, then you'll understand why difference of opinion occured
@@FaizanKhan-ic2oi I have more idea than you akhi what a madhab is and how madhabis and muqalideen are.
Alhamdullilah, Allah has guided me towards his book and Sunnah of his messenger without confining to anything other than these two.
@@afnankhan5989 So you are a mujtahid?
@@afnankhan5989Basics of sunnah bro. The Prophet SAW prayed in different ways at different times during his life. Hence why there are authentic reports of the various ways. It's basic knowledge mate.
@@thegreenman941 I am muttab`i
Looooool funny ikhwani
What is so funny here. Study the companions' approach to witr, and then you see the valid approaches.
@@faysalahmed9157he should become a deobandi hanafi