What bothers me is that Mapleshade was the only one that was punished for liking someone she wasn't supposed to love, but every other cat who did the same thing just got away with it. Like what the heck
Cool Fizz agree. being bullied can drive anyone in the wrong direction, and since Scourge was also having bad influence because of those rogues he ended up the way he is now.
She was the one driven mad by grief. She was the one who avenged her kits' deaths many times over. She was the one betrayed by her love. I understand Mapleshade and her thirst for blood and revenge. She is a true cat that exists in my top ten favorites.
If I had to wrote where mapleshade will go, I would let her go to starclan, she deserves forgivness even for the things she had done. She would be so happy to see her kits that did not have the chance to live longer than her
+Amber Noel Here's what happened to Crookedstar: -Broke his jaw when he was scared by Goosefeather -Renamed and rejected by his mother, who would continually tell him he would never be as good as his brother -Ran away and would have starved to death if he never met a few loners, before going back to RiverClan a moon later -Was visited in his dreams by a "StarClan" cat (Mapleshade) who told him she could give him everything as long as he put his Clan over anything -And by anything, she meant his family's lives: -His mother died from head trauma (Rainflower) -Then his father from a stomach lump (Shellheart) -Then his leader from rats (Hailstar) -Then his mate and two of his kits (Willowbreeze, Minnowkit, Willowkit) -Then eventually his brother and last daughter (Oakheart and Silverstream)
I personally think that Goosefeather should’ve been placed higher. As you said in the description, none of the other kits liked him. He always saw dead cats and it’s always been hard for him to see the difference between dead and living. He was made an apprentice 2 moons before his littermate and his fellow nursery mates. They disliked him, even his sister. Also, as you said, he was attacked by a badger but Moonpaw saves him. She’s actually quite mad at him for not being able to protect himself. He’s sorry and gets help from Mapleshade in his dreams but Moonflower (now a warrior) apologizes. Goosefeather responds coldly but stops training with Mapleshade. Goosefeather then has a vision that ThunderClan needs to destroy Windclans medicine supply. They do it and Moonflower is killed in the process, which is why Goosefeather went insane. That’s why I think Goosefeather should’ve been place higher. Much higher. Haha congrats if you made it to the end of this comment! These balloons are for you! 🎈🎈🎈🎈🎈
And in the rise of scourge when Ruby and Socks ask for food. I be like, "What the heck?! Are you SERIOUS?! You bully someone over and over and then come running back to them asking for food. Is this a joke.
I agree with most of them (sorry, I just really don't like Breezepelt), I must ask though, where is Tallstar? Tallstar's Revenge is the saddest backstory of the warrior's series if you ask me. I understand if you didn't read it when you made the video though.
OK SERIOUSLY?! I DON'T WANT TO MAKE YOU BELIEVE YOU DON'T HAVE A RIGHT TO HAVE A OPINION BUT BREEZEPELT IS NOT EVIL BECAUSE OF HIS PARENTS. CROWFEATHER WAS A NICE DAD. NOT PERFECT, BUT HE ACKNOWLEDGED HIM AT LEAST. AND CROWFEATHER WAS GOING THROUGH A LOT THEN AND STILL. NIGHTCLOUD WAS FEEDING HIM LIES ABOUT HOW HIS FATHER HATED HIM AND SUCH. BUT IN THE END IT WAS BREEZEPELTS OWN CHOICE. BREEZEPELT, NOT HIS FATHER OR MOTHER. FORCED HIM TO GO DOWN THAT PATH AND NO ONE ELSE EVER REALLY MADE THE CHOICE FOR HIM. AND HAVE YOU FORGOTTEN ABOUT THE IVYPOOL OMEN OF THE STARS SCENES? HE SEEMED RIGHT AT HOME KILLING AND FIGHTING ALL THOSE CATS. AND CAN GO ON AND ON ABOUT HOW RIDICULOUS IT IS THINKING BREEZEPELT AS THIS POOR INNOCENT CAT. HE'S NOT AN ABUSED CHILD. BY THE TIME HE WAS A WARRIOR HE WAS ACTING LIKE THIS. STOP TREATING BREEZEPELT AS IF HE'S A NAIVE KIT. HE KNEW WHAT HE WAS DOING.
I feel bad for Twigpaw and Violetpaw's mother and father. Their mother, Pebbleshine, was pregnant when she was taken away by a monster and their father, Hawkwing, had lost his mate and would never see his kits because they weren't born yet. I feel bad for Mapleshade too, and she doesn't deserve ANY of the hate that she gets.
Really? Scourge before Crookedstar? I'm not going into a rant right now but Scourge's backstory wasn't that bad compared to Crookedstar's Mapleshade's, Bluestar's ,etc
@@B-Roc uhhh.. I don't think you read my comment correctly. I said that they didn't put it in order. also how am I rude? I didn't say anything that was.
GamerSeah27 - Roblox, Minecraft, Pokemon, and more! true his kithood was ruined because of his foster mother. but what's there to be sad about after what he did to his father and clanmates? 1: he lied and framed windclan because of some prey he placed on shadowclan territory just to start a battle. 2: trained kits who are too young to fight. 3: banished all the elders 4: chased windclan from their home 5: forces river clan to share prey 6: left shadowclan starving that cat's life was really twisted
Umm, Bluestar's losses are; 1. Her Mom 2. Her Sister 3. Her Best Friend 4. Her Kits 5. Her Mate 6. Her Trust to Her Clan 7. Her Sanity And only thing with Scourge is his siblings and dad didn't love him so he ran away, saw TigerPaw/Star so he became a physco and killed everyone on his way, right? BlueStar is in 9 and Scourge in 1 I'm a veeeery big Bluestar fan so became a liiittle mad.
I agree with all :O Also Tallstar had a pretty rough life and some other cats before they were great and whatever, but these cats had such bad backstories :(
WHAT CROOKED STAR SHOULD BE First......... my opinion: scourge was bullied by his littermates......was attacked by an evil apprentice.......then became a leader of a 'clan'. crooked star broke his jaw.....his mother hated him.....he believes he will become the clans greatest cat by making a promise......looses every single thing he loves mother; daughter; E.X and then became leader of a clan.
Nah Brokenstar had it worse and for him even after lizard who ever the fuck and being apprentice then warrior then deputy there is no happy endings just conducting a rieghn of terror being taken prisoner blinded then being killed by his mother.
Tigerstar can be on here His father basically betrayed him and his clan. Both of his sisters died. His mentor basically abused him, and all throughout his life, Mapleshade constantly told him he was worthless.
Yellowfang should have definitely been on there. Her mate antagonised her for becoming a medicine cat, which Sagewhisker basically pressured her into. She then lost her two daughters and her only son blamed the death of two kits onto her. Let's not forget Foxheart, because she wasn't named that for nothing.
So sad 3: I sadly agree with all of them. On a happier note, Congrats on 1,562 subs!! :3 You should do major shout out video for all your active subs ;3
i agree with you on scourge his childhood is the reason he turned evil and mean cause of his sister and brother and he got beaten up by Tigerstar scourge had a really bad childhood
Personally, I would of had Tigerstar on here. Here are my reasons, spoilers, 1. His father left to be a kittypet 2. His sisters both died 3. His mother died when he was quite young 4. I don't know if this counts, but he was also influenced by, non other, then the AMAZING, FABULOUS, HANDSOME TOM THAT EVERYONE LOVES...Thistleclaw :T I do agree with your choices though, just would've added Tigerstar :)
I agree that CrookedStar had a bad life, his mate and kits died young //even Silberstream// but putting a lot of blame on Rainflower isn't the best thing to do, I mean yea she renamed him and "disowned" him but did anyone ever mention how Rainflower actually felt? No? Then let me remind you that her parents weren't the best //scratch that, they abused her// and she did all the things to CrookedStar because of guilt, she knew her son was hyperactive but did nothing about it and when he got injured she felt guilty for letting them leave. She realized/thought that Stormkit wouldn't survive so she renamed him so that she wouldn't feel too much pain. She was proud when he became a deputy though and the whole StarClan deal where she didn't gave him life was because StarClan *Denied* it. The true evil is StarClan, BrokenStar could have been a normal kit if *StarClan* wouldn't have gave YellowFang the power to feel others pain, Tigerkit would have been a normal kit if *StarClan* wouldn't say that he was "evil" //You Can NOT be born evil, only actions in your life could turn you that way//, Flametail would have been alive if *StarClan* would have let Jayfeather save him. MAPLESHADE WOULD HAVE LIVED A HAPPY LIFE IF *STARCLAN* WOULD HAVE GAVE HER A SIGN but NOPE, they totally ignored a cat that trusted them with her whole life. We all talk about evil characters but never the StarClan themselve.
Brokenstar's backstory reminds me of Icy's because they were both abused at youth then became evil when they were older and Icy didn't really have her mom at the time. Nobody helped them. (P.S. Icy is Jamba Event Francisca. Jamba Event is Star Allies but my version. The AU mages had sort of opposite personalities)
Its strange how I never cry while reading any book but I only cry when an animal dies in a movie and nothing else is sad. I only have a heart for animals and my family.
In my opinion about these cats who should have been frist was tigerstar, crooked star, broken star,maple shade, hawk frost, blue star, yellow fang,and bright heart
I hate how people show mapleshade😤 as an evil cat mapleshade was just miss understood she lost her kits her mate and got kicked from the clan so I wouldn't blame her one bit 😟I actually feel like the Erin's could have given her another chance😡 I hope😇 others will agree cause we all probably know someone who lost loved ones she lost everything so that's why she went insane and she killed appledusk cause he blamed it on her she never knew it would happen she probably thought it was safe but it wasn't she never knew so if anyone is to blame it's starclan for not seeing what mapleshade went through😒 I wonder how long it took me to make this reply in 2018?🤔
I wouldn’t find this to be the saddest story, but maybe there shouldve been a little honourable mention of Crowbae. He lost a mate, multiple kits, his son didn’t like him (also the opposite lol) a mother, a sibling, and his father died after a few days he was born (did I get that right? Sorry, Deadfoot is irrelevant), and the entire fandom calls him “mean grumpypants”. Come on guys! You can do that! But what about Jayfeather? You guys nevery call him grumpy! Edit: and Sasha but everyone knows her story
Now u know why Ruby and Socks r complete idiots. They bullied Tiny (Scourge) as when they were kits. FOR NO REASON! And also, his mother was not such a huge help so he ran away from the twoleg place and then got attacked by Tigerpaw (Tigerstar) but then Bluefur (Bluestar) saved his life. A few moons later, he made a clan called Bloodclan. He suddenly decided to work with Tigerstar to rule the forest. (I think so) then some time later, Tigerstar tries to control Bloodclan then Tigerstar gets ripped open.
#6 Yes his backstory is sad (I hate Crowfeather because of that) But that doesn't justify his actions (Allying himself with the dark forest,attacking Jayfeather and Poppyfrost at the moonpool,etc)
A made up warrior cat story: Ember flight: I’m so glad I’m a warrior now! Acorn paw: ummm... why didn’t I become a warrior in the meeting? Ember flight: *ignores acorn paw and goes to warriors den* Acorn paw: why does everybody ignore me when I’m just looking for a answer?! *MEAN WHILE* Ember flight: Hello willow fur! Willow fur: hi how do you like the warriors den? Ember flight: it’s cool. I get a lot of sun here. Willow fur: well I wanna be deputy. Ember flight: and leave the sun into the cold small den? Ember flight: I’ll stay here as long as it takes thank you very much. Willow fur: ugh, I have stayed here too long! I want a new den. Ember flight: well I will go to sleep, since I’m nice and dosent like to argue. Willow fur: welp. Maybe that means I’ll go to sleep to. *Chapter 2 is coming soon :3*
Scourges backstory isn't even that bad. He had a lovley mother who looked out for him when he was teased, his brother and sister were mean and teased him but they never abused or hurt him or anything and he couldn't of felt unloved when his mother treat him the same if not better the only reason he would've turned evil was beacuse of Tigerstar but even then that's not an excuse to go around killing EVERYONE is it?
Joseph Williams I agree she should be here but also that she was reincarnated to have another chance in life as cinderheart. not so sad after she finally fulfilled her dream of being a warrior.
*I'm sorry. But Bluestar has by far the saddest backstory of all time. Why Scourge?? Why Breezepelt?? Why Twigpaw and Violetpaw?? Why Sol?? Why Brightheart?? Bluestar at least deserves to be 2nd place. It wasn't just her father's rejection and mother's death, her sister died, she lost her mate and her kits, she was convinced that her clan was turning against her. There is so much wrong in her life.*
What about Tree his best friend died and his mother didn't even care about him he had to leave his tribe and when he met his father his father had sacrificed his life.
I hate breezepelt..... he's manipulate by the dark forest cats to make him THINK Crowfeather wasn't there for him even tho breezepelt was just mad about the afar Crowfeather had with leafpool
jerry desvernine Spoilers: Actually, Appledusk jumped in front of Reedshine and was killed. Perchpaw killed Mapleshade by making a severe wound. I don't feel comfortable about Reedshine getting killed like that. She was pregnant.
OK SERIOUSLY?! I DON'T WANT TO MAKE YOU BELIEVE YOU DON'T HAVE A RIGHT TO HAVE A OPINION BUT BREEZEPELT IS NOT EVIL BECAUSE OF HIS PARENTS. CROWFEATHER WAS A NICE DAD. NOT PERFECT, BUT HE ACKNOWLEDGED HIM AT LEAST. AND CROWFEATHER WAS GOING THROUGH A LOT THEN AND STILL. NIGHTCLOUD WAS FEEDING HIM LIES ABOUT HOW HIS FATHER HATED HIM AND SUCH. BUT IN THE END IT WAS BREEZEPELTS OWN CHOICE. BREEZEPELT, NOT HIS FATHER OR MOTHER. FORCED HIM TO GO DOWN THAT PATH AND NO ONE ELSE EVER REALLY MADE THE CHOICE FOR HIM. AND HAVE YOU FORGOTTEN ABOUT THE IVYPOOL OMEN OF THE STARS SCENES? HE SEEMED RIGHT AT HOME KILLING AND FIGHTING ALL THOSE CATS. AND CAN GO ON AND ON ABOUT HOW RIDICULOUS IT IS THINKING BREEZEPELT AS THIS POOR INNOCENT CAT. HE'S NOT AN ABUSED CHILD. BY THE TIME HE WAS A WARRIOR HE WAS ACTING LIKE THIS. STOP TREATING BREEZEPELT AS IF HE'S A NAIVE KIT. HE KNEW WHAT HE WAS DOING.
I Personally Don't Think His Backstory Is Deserving Of The List.. Clear Sky Rejected Him.. Yes. Though Gray Wing Was An Amazing Father To Thunder.. And Basically Every Cat On This List I Personally Think Have Sadder Backstories Than Thunderstar..
The reason for Breezepelt is false. The truth is that Crowfeather did love him but did not love his mate Nightcloud.
What bothers me is that Mapleshade was the only one that was punished for liking someone she wasn't supposed to love, but every other cat who did the same thing just got away with it. Like what the heck
Well, she also killed cats, but I agree with you. I feel like the other forbidden romances should have also been punished
Scourge would probably have been nice if his sister and brother were nice to him
He would have been like Squirrelflight
you are the best
Cool Fizz IKR
Cool Fizz agree. being bullied can drive anyone in the wrong direction, and since Scourge was also having bad influence because of those rogues
he ended up the way he is now.
and if Tigerstar dident beat him up
FINALLY SOMEONE WHO UNDERSTANDS MAPLESHADE. LIKE IF YOU LOVE MAPLESHADE
She was the one driven mad by grief. She was the one who avenged her kits' deaths many times over. She was the one betrayed by her love.
I understand Mapleshade and her thirst for blood and revenge. She is a true cat that exists in my top ten favorites.
And she is totally not that bland thing we saw in other books, she totally is not slightly shitter life and homicdal Assfur re color and gender bend.
If I had to wrote where mapleshade will go, I would let her go to starclan, she deserves forgivness even for the things she had done. She would be so happy to see her kits that did not have the chance to live longer than her
Dark Light and maybe she would have become less blood thirsty when she saw them
Kekoa Sakara I dont really like her but that’s fine I know a lot of the fandom likes her and you can have whatever opinion you want it’s fine :)
what about Yellowfang?
Bonnie Swag I know, right! She was forced to be a medicine cat, her mate taken by FoxHeart, forced to give up her kits!
michele cross that is not true
I think that Crookedstars backstory was the saddest one.Great video btw.
Mariusz Leszczynski
True
I never read Crookedstars Promise so I dunno his backstory. Saddest in my oppinioun is Bluestar
Basically, crookedstar lost EVERYONE and EVERYTHING.
+Amber Noel Here's what happened to Crookedstar:
-Broke his jaw when he was scared by Goosefeather
-Renamed and rejected by his mother, who would continually tell him he would never be as good as his brother
-Ran away and would have starved to death if he never met a few loners, before going back to RiverClan a moon later
-Was visited in his dreams by a "StarClan" cat (Mapleshade) who told him she could give him everything as long as he put his Clan over anything
-And by anything, she meant his family's lives:
-His mother died from head trauma (Rainflower)
-Then his father from a stomach lump (Shellheart)
-Then his leader from rats (Hailstar)
-Then his mate and two of his kits (Willowbreeze, Minnowkit, Willowkit)
-Then eventually his brother and last daughter (Oakheart and Silverstream)
Oh ok
I personally think that Goosefeather should’ve been placed higher. As you said in the description, none of the other kits liked him. He always saw dead cats and it’s always been hard for him to see the difference between dead and living. He was made an apprentice 2 moons before his littermate and his fellow nursery mates. They disliked him, even his sister. Also, as you said, he was attacked by a badger but Moonpaw saves him. She’s actually quite mad at him for not being able to protect himself. He’s sorry and gets help from Mapleshade in his dreams but Moonflower (now a warrior) apologizes. Goosefeather responds coldly but stops training with Mapleshade. Goosefeather then has a vision that ThunderClan needs to destroy Windclans medicine supply. They do it and Moonflower is killed in the process, which is why Goosefeather went insane. That’s why I think Goosefeather should’ve been place higher. Much higher.
Haha congrats if you made it to the end of this comment! These balloons are for you! 🎈🎈🎈🎈🎈
And in the rise of scourge when Ruby and Socks ask for food. I be like, "What the heck?! Are you SERIOUS?! You bully someone over and over and then come running back to them asking for food. Is this a joke.
I agree with most of them (sorry, I just really don't like Breezepelt), I must ask though, where is Tallstar? Tallstar's Revenge is the saddest backstory of the warrior's series if you ask me. I understand if you didn't read it when you made the video though.
AwildDerp breezepelts backstory is upsetting and I actually kinda like him now
I red it and some of the parts are kinda sad..
So sad;( I agree with all of this choices.Nice video.
Lovers cats forever 101 thanks :)
Everyone forgot about fallenleaves
Poor fallenleaves ;-;
OK SERIOUSLY?! I DON'T WANT TO MAKE YOU BELIEVE YOU DON'T HAVE A RIGHT TO HAVE A OPINION BUT BREEZEPELT IS NOT EVIL BECAUSE OF HIS PARENTS. CROWFEATHER WAS A NICE DAD. NOT PERFECT, BUT HE ACKNOWLEDGED HIM AT LEAST. AND CROWFEATHER WAS GOING THROUGH A LOT THEN AND STILL. NIGHTCLOUD WAS FEEDING HIM LIES ABOUT HOW HIS FATHER HATED HIM AND SUCH. BUT IN THE END IT WAS BREEZEPELTS OWN CHOICE. BREEZEPELT, NOT HIS FATHER OR MOTHER. FORCED HIM TO GO DOWN THAT PATH AND NO ONE ELSE EVER REALLY MADE THE CHOICE FOR HIM. AND HAVE YOU FORGOTTEN ABOUT THE IVYPOOL OMEN OF THE STARS SCENES? HE SEEMED RIGHT AT HOME KILLING AND FIGHTING ALL THOSE CATS. AND CAN GO ON AND ON ABOUT HOW RIDICULOUS IT IS THINKING BREEZEPELT AS THIS POOR INNOCENT CAT. HE'S NOT AN ABUSED CHILD. BY THE TIME HE WAS A WARRIOR HE WAS ACTING LIKE THIS. STOP TREATING BREEZEPELT AS IF HE'S A NAIVE KIT. HE KNEW WHAT HE WAS DOING.
I feel bad for Twigpaw and Violetpaw's mother and father. Their mother, Pebbleshine, was pregnant when she was taken away by a monster and their father, Hawkwing, had lost his mate and would never see his kits because they weren't born yet. I feel bad for Mapleshade too, and she doesn't deserve ANY of the hate that she gets.
Really? Scourge before Crookedstar?
I'm not going into a rant right now but Scourge's backstory wasn't that bad compared to Crookedstar's Mapleshade's, Bluestar's ,etc
Galactic Pancakes Ahem? 'Not that bad'?!
michele cross I agree I personally think Scourge and Mapleshade had the worst backrounds.
I don't really think they put it in order to the most grieving backstory to the less.
Rude I love scouge :d #bloodclan4life
@@B-Roc uhhh.. I don't think you read my comment correctly. I said that they didn't put it in order. also how am I rude? I didn't say anything that was.
I now remember when tigerpaw was told by Thisleclaw to atack that kit
Yeah I wished Tigerpaw got a Different mentor instead of ThrisleClaw. ThrisleClaw makes me Very angry!!!!!!!!!
So sad, but thank u for making video I can enjoy and watch! You have a great utube channel!
I feel like im the only one who felt bad for brokenstar/tail
GamerSeah27 - Roblox, Minecraft, Pokemon, and more!
true his kithood was ruined because of his foster mother. but what's there to be sad about after what he did to his father and clanmates?
1: he lied and framed windclan because of some prey he placed on shadowclan territory just to start a battle.
2: trained kits who are too young to fight.
3: banished all the elders
4: chased windclan from their home
5: forces river clan to share prey
6: left shadowclan starving
that cat's life was really twisted
Yeah true
Scourge does not deserve #1 at all. Bluestar definitely is the hardest backstory.
Umm, Bluestar's losses are;
1. Her Mom
2. Her Sister
3. Her Best Friend
4. Her Kits
5. Her Mate
6. Her Trust to Her Clan
7. Her Sanity
And only thing with Scourge is his siblings and dad didn't love him so he ran away, saw TigerPaw/Star so he became a physco and killed everyone on his way, right?
BlueStar is in 9 and Scourge in 1
I'm a veeeery big Bluestar fan so became a liiittle mad.
Nobody i
He almost died when he was a KIT bluestar did not
Well togerstar didn't deserve 1 place neither did bluestar she's pretty overrated and u didn't exactly have a reason to be mad..
I agree with all :O Also Tallstar had a pretty rough life and some other cats before they were great and whatever, but these cats had such bad backstories :(
WHAT CROOKED STAR SHOULD BE First.........
my opinion: scourge was bullied by his littermates......was attacked by an evil apprentice.......then became a leader of a 'clan'. crooked star broke his jaw.....his mother hated him.....he believes he will become the clans greatest cat by making a promise......looses every single thing he loves mother; daughter; E.X and then became leader of a clan.
what is worse?
Hey, he was happy in the end, unlike Scourge! His life was fighting!
Nah Brokenstar had it worse and for him even after lizard who ever the fuck and being apprentice then warrior then deputy there is no happy endings just conducting a rieghn of terror being taken prisoner blinded then being killed by his mother.
Tigerstar can be on here
His father basically betrayed him and his clan. Both of his sisters died. His mentor basically abused him, and all throughout his life, Mapleshade constantly told him he was worthless.
Yellowfang should have definitely been on there. Her mate antagonised her for becoming a medicine cat, which Sagewhisker basically pressured her into. She then lost her two daughters and her only son blamed the death of two kits onto her. Let's not forget Foxheart, because she wasn't named that for nothing.
So sad 3:
I sadly agree with all of them.
On a happier note, Congrats on 1,562 subs!! :3
You should do major shout out video for all your active subs ;3
CrowFeather actually loves BreezePelt and NightCloud but was afraid of failing them as he failed FeatherTail
So he pushed them away.
RubyZoldyck:3 yeah but his heart will always beat for leafpool
even though he was with nightcloud
I LOVE YOUR VIDS!!! SOOO GOOD! And thank you for putting the reasons in the description❤️
i agree with you on scourge his childhood is the reason he turned evil and mean cause of his sister and brother and he got beaten up by Tigerstar scourge had a really bad childhood
I want to hug Mapleshade and Sol and Goosefeather and Crookedstar and Bluestar and Twigoaw and Violetpaw
I WANT TO HUG ALL OF THEM TOO
Personally, I would of had Tigerstar on here.
Here are my reasons, spoilers,
1. His father left to be a kittypet
2. His sisters both died
3. His mother died when he was quite young
4. I don't know if this counts, but he was also influenced by, non other, then the AMAZING, FABULOUS, HANDSOME TOM THAT EVERYONE LOVES...Thistleclaw :T
I do agree with your choices though, just would've added Tigerstar :)
I agree that CrookedStar had a bad life, his mate and kits died young //even Silberstream// but putting a lot of blame on Rainflower isn't the best thing to do, I mean yea she renamed him and "disowned" him but did anyone ever mention how Rainflower actually felt? No? Then let me remind you that her parents weren't the best //scratch that, they abused her// and she did all the things to CrookedStar because of guilt, she knew her son was hyperactive but did nothing about it and when he got injured she felt guilty for letting them leave. She realized/thought that Stormkit wouldn't survive so she renamed him so that she wouldn't feel too much pain. She was proud when he became a deputy though and the whole StarClan deal where she didn't gave him life was because StarClan *Denied* it.
The true evil is StarClan, BrokenStar could have been a normal kit if *StarClan* wouldn't have gave YellowFang the power to feel others pain, Tigerkit would have been a normal kit if *StarClan* wouldn't say that he was "evil" //You Can NOT be born evil, only actions in your life could turn you that way//, Flametail would have been alive if *StarClan* would have let Jayfeather save him. MAPLESHADE WOULD HAVE LIVED A HAPPY LIFE IF *STARCLAN* WOULD HAVE GAVE HER A SIGN but NOPE, they totally ignored a cat that trusted them with her whole life.
We all talk about evil characters but never the StarClan themselve.
Brokenstar's backstory reminds me of Icy's because they were both abused at youth then became evil when they were older and Icy didn't really have her mom at the time. Nobody helped them. (P.S. Icy is Jamba Event Francisca. Jamba Event is Star Allies but my version. The AU mages had sort of opposite personalities)
... Brokenstar was called 'Evil' by StarClan before he was born, Lizardstripe and her kits might have done something but he was evil anyways.
Its strange how I never cry while reading any book but I only cry when an animal dies in a movie and nothing else is sad. I only have a heart for animals and my family.
So sad for crookedstar and scrouge
In my opinion about these cats who should have been frist was tigerstar, crooked star, broken star,maple shade, hawk frost, blue star, yellow fang,and bright heart
Finally someone understands broken star and and don't be angry because I like him
Mystical shadow Warrior im not angry, but he kill cats
Finally someon who understans me that Scourge had like, no life!
I agree Scourge is for Number 1. He did have a really bad back story :(
*as soon as I see this video I think of Mapleshade*
I ❤ scourge!
and
I ❤your videos!
I cry for mapleshade ;(
: breaks down crying :
MappleShade: Her mate left her for another cat, her kits drowned, and she was banned from her clan
# one i agree with
I hate how people show mapleshade😤 as an evil cat mapleshade was just miss understood she lost her kits her mate and got kicked from the clan so I wouldn't blame her one bit 😟I actually feel like the Erin's could have given her another chance😡 I hope😇 others will agree cause we all probably know someone who lost loved ones she lost everything so that's why she went insane and she killed appledusk cause he blamed it on her she never knew it would happen she probably thought it was safe but it wasn't she never knew so if anyone is to blame it's starclan for not seeing what mapleshade went through😒
I wonder how long it took me to make this reply in 2018?🤔
LOVE THE VIDEO an I cried for Brightheart Also where's Cinderpelt?
I wouldn’t find this to be the saddest story, but maybe there shouldve been a little honourable mention of Crowbae. He lost a mate, multiple kits, his son didn’t like him (also the opposite lol) a mother, a sibling, and his father died after a few days he was born (did I get that right? Sorry, Deadfoot is irrelevant), and the entire fandom calls him “mean grumpypants”. Come on guys! You can do that! But what about Jayfeather? You guys nevery call him grumpy!
Edit: and Sasha but everyone knows her story
Now u know why Ruby and Socks r complete idiots. They bullied Tiny (Scourge) as when they were kits. FOR NO REASON! And also, his mother was not such a huge help so he ran away from the twoleg place and then got attacked by Tigerpaw (Tigerstar) but then Bluefur (Bluestar) saved his life. A few moons later, he made a clan called Bloodclan. He suddenly decided to work with Tigerstar to rule the forest. (I think so) then some time later, Tigerstar tries to control Bloodclan then Tigerstar gets ripped open.
The end xP
#6
Yes his backstory is sad (I hate Crowfeather because of that)
But that doesn't justify his actions (Allying himself with the dark forest,attacking Jayfeather and Poppyfrost at the moonpool,etc)
The truth is that Crowfeather loved Leafpool and not Nightcloud so that was put onto Breezepelt
A made up warrior cat story:
Ember flight: I’m so glad I’m a warrior now!
Acorn paw: ummm... why didn’t I become a warrior in the meeting?
Ember flight: *ignores acorn paw and goes to warriors den*
Acorn paw: why does everybody ignore me when I’m just looking for a answer?!
*MEAN WHILE*
Ember flight: Hello willow fur!
Willow fur: hi how do you like the warriors den?
Ember flight: it’s cool. I get a lot of sun here.
Willow fur: well I wanna be deputy.
Ember flight: and leave the sun into the cold small den?
Ember flight: I’ll stay here as long as it takes thank you very much.
Willow fur: ugh, I have stayed here too long! I want a new den.
Ember flight: well I will go to sleep, since I’m nice and dosent like to argue.
Willow fur: welp. Maybe that means I’ll go to sleep to.
*Chapter 2 is coming soon :3*
I agree with all of these, but I feel they were mixed out of order! I love the vid tho!
I think Goosefeather should be number 1, but great list!
The feels of Broken, Blue, Goose, and pretty much everyone else;-;
Scourges backstory isn't even that bad.
He had a lovley mother who looked out for him when he was teased, his brother and sister were mean and teased him but they never abused or hurt him or anything and he couldn't of felt unloved when his mother treat him the same if not better the only reason he would've turned evil was beacuse of Tigerstar but even then that's not an excuse to go around killing EVERYONE is it?
Cool video!
OMG I LOVE UR VIDEOD
Maria Ruvalcaba :) thanks!
My two favortie Warrior Cat cats out of these are Mapleshade and Scourge, like if you agree.
same i love scoyrge
dislike lol
Im team Mapleshade
I feel like if Scourge was on this list Darktail should have been
Scourge's Collar's Color Is...
(Comment)
Purple
What was mappleshades backstory (I haven't read all the books)
Read description if you haven't already.
do top ten most unusual warrior cat couples
wheres cinderpelt?
Joseph Williams I agree she should be here but also that she was reincarnated to have another chance in life as cinderheart. not so sad after she finally fulfilled her dream of being a warrior.
*I'm sorry. But Bluestar has by far the saddest backstory of all time. Why Scourge?? Why Breezepelt?? Why Twigpaw and Violetpaw?? Why Sol?? Why Brightheart?? Bluestar at least deserves to be 2nd place. It wasn't just her father's rejection and mother's death, her sister died, she lost her mate and her kits, she was convinced that her clan was turning against her. There is so much wrong in her life.*
Sol got abandoned. Twice.
love mapleshade
brightheart did get her half of her face ripped off but mist of her life was nice (i might be wrong)
What about Tree his best friend died and his mother didn't even care about him he had to leave his tribe and when he met his father his father had sacrificed his life.
3rd 💗 these videos so much!!!
Well I’m pretty sure that brokenstar was naturally evil
:( Love your videos!
LPSAnna thanks!
Bluestar should be like number3 she lost everything her mother her sister her kits and then her mate
Moon Beam and her sanity
ITS ALWAYS THE FRICKEN LEADERS
In warrior cats ultimate edition my name is violet paw and I'm an apprentice of Riverclan
Top 10 Warrior Cat OCs?
Spiritflight (ik this is a late reply)
I have a whole family of OCs lol
I hate breezepelt..... he's manipulate by the dark forest cats to make him THINK Crowfeather wasn't there for him even tho breezepelt was just mad about the afar Crowfeather had with leafpool
Most cats that are evil is bc of other cats
AND QUINCE CARED ABOUT TINY/SCOURGE
Great vid but I think u should put WHY and the names
U blind
Why aren't bluestar and crowfeather on this list?
It’s TwigBRANCH and VioletSHINE
I refuse to call her Twigbranch
How was Brackenfur not on here?
Meh your right he had a sad life loosing 2 of his kits his sister and his mate
Mapleshade shuld be on this list.
natasha v she is here
i know
she does belong their
you should explain why
Just saying brockenstar did have a mother. His mother was yellowfang :/
XxlpsbestiesxX we know that
Umm dappletail shall be in this
Btw sol creeps me out
Why?
WAIt WEIRD FIRESTAR IS Scourge STEP-BROTHER
dragonkitty79 half-brothers actually. they share the same father
silver fang115 Jake is everyones father xD
No, idiot. They are half brothers. Get ur facts right
wait.. i thought frecklewish was in skyclan!
There's two of them
There's two
Were is sasha she had a sad backstory sadder then scourge
Mapleshade also killed Reedshine
jerry desvernine Spoilers: Actually, Appledusk jumped in front of Reedshine and was killed. Perchpaw killed Mapleshade by making a severe wound. I don't feel comfortable about Reedshine getting killed like that. She was pregnant.
jerry desvernine reedshinevwas alive. if she wasn't then crookedstar and oakheart would never been born moons later after their parents parents.
What about fallenleaves?
Were is yellowfang
hi
9th like!
OK SERIOUSLY?! I DON'T WANT TO MAKE YOU BELIEVE YOU DON'T HAVE A RIGHT TO HAVE A OPINION BUT BREEZEPELT IS NOT EVIL BECAUSE OF HIS PARENTS. CROWFEATHER WAS A NICE DAD. NOT PERFECT, BUT HE ACKNOWLEDGED HIM AT LEAST. AND CROWFEATHER WAS GOING THROUGH A LOT THEN AND STILL. NIGHTCLOUD WAS FEEDING HIM LIES ABOUT HOW HIS FATHER HATED HIM AND SUCH. BUT IN THE END IT WAS BREEZEPELTS OWN CHOICE. BREEZEPELT, NOT HIS FATHER OR MOTHER. FORCED HIM TO GO DOWN THAT PATH AND NO ONE ELSE EVER REALLY MADE THE CHOICE FOR HIM. AND HAVE YOU FORGOTTEN ABOUT THE IVYPOOL OMEN OF THE STARS SCENES? HE SEEMED RIGHT AT HOME KILLING AND FIGHTING ALL THOSE CATS. AND CAN GO ON AND ON ABOUT HOW RIDICULOUS IT IS THINKING BREEZEPELT AS THIS POOR INNOCENT CAT. HE'S NOT AN ABUSED CHILD. BY THE TIME HE WAS A WARRIOR HE WAS ACTING LIKE THIS. STOP TREATING BREEZEPELT AS IF HE'S A NAIVE KIT. HE KNEW WHAT HE WAS DOING.
yes scourge has had the worst child hood I'm so glad u agree omg I was worried u wouldn't go scourge who hoo
I would also suggest using better grammar
does anyone thing that tigerclaw had a sad back story
cocoalps 12 me
His father abandoned him.
Where's bluestar
She there idiot
0:28
Wut is this this is sad pictures not backstories
You don't even explain in the vid!😡
reasons are down in the description
Meguzi 101 if you read the books it explains more
In my opinion you should tell the song first
What about Thunderstar?
I Personally Don't Think His Backstory Is Deserving Of The List.. Clear Sky Rejected Him.. Yes. Though Gray Wing Was An Amazing Father To Thunder.. And Basically Every Cat On This List I Personally Think Have Sadder Backstories Than Thunderstar..