Everything is an assumption! Everything is an approximation. The brain "interprets" and then encodes/processes that interpretation of what has been experienced based upon the internalized model it has that has been assigned labels/nodes within a representative graph of associations, dependencies, etc... (ie definitions) for that which is salient to the organism's goals. It is only when one requires a more "perfect" or precise understanding to achieve a more demanding outcome that we work towards greater precision... a more approximate truth. We learn through successive approximations!
Opinion noted. It's neither gathering facts nor eliminating assumptions. " Learning " is partly dependent on semantics also. Therefore it's more complex than most of us wish to admit. For me it has been a life long struggle to adapt to changing conditions. Add that to your ideas about " learning. " Simply one thing or another it is not.
@@piehound it is a frequent pattern where an individual appreciates the validity of an alternate perspective. But then jumps onto that bandwagon abandoning their former mode of transport. It is like those optical illusions where you see a rabbit or a duck. It can be difficult to resolve the mixed rabbit-duck as some entirely new prospect or accept that there also exists a transitional state. Yet breaking with the dichotomy in other instances may not be so challenging. Since certain optical illusions don’t work in every culture, it must have to do with how the specific cultural knowledge in a particular society is encoded.
Got really good in the second half. "Our brain can only move in small steps, not giant leaps." It's so hard to remember that when you're disagreeing with someone, or trying to motivate them to change.
@@snoozyloco3371 "Knowing" is not necessarily the truth. Someone else may know that M.J. is terrible. Why do two different people who hear the same sounds have differing opinions about those sounds? I don't know. It's interesting. Listening to a song that you know you like is not as much interesting as it is comforting.
Daniil Dimitrov ...Pretty sure he just came off a 2 day peyote trip or something like that. He doesn't need time to think, his vision is clear. (His eyes may be red, but his mind is ripe!)
The answer to that question is in the video. I.e., it seems like a broad and "out there" concept requiring significant mental acrobatics to you or I as the observer, but he's really just conveying what formed as a natural progression of ideas to him. So, to him, he's just telling you about something he understands as well as anyone can describe how to get from A to B after having just walked the path (or walked it numerous times).
As someone who really loves to have deep discussions, I become somewhat comfortable in feeling uncomfortable. What I mean is, that you have to accept that others might have better facts, or that you're not always right, or that you deal with people that have a completely different opinion, yet you're not disrepectfull to them. In other words, it becomes more about listening than convincing. I do not know if that has really much to do with what is said here, but I feel that I am most creative in discussions when I feel very uncertain and that I really enjoy it when I meet someone who's actually better than me, even if they think and believe the complete opposite of what I do.
I am the same way, but I just realized I haven't really had any of those kinds of conversations with anyone in a LONG time (besides my son) - which is probably why I am on TH-cam half the day and why I make comments on things that I care about. I try to do this with my sister and she gets Really Upset - even just listening to me and my son explore possibilities. Now I understand why a little more. It completely stresses her out.
@@barbarastrayhorn4667 It always amazes me when people don't "want to hear it" when I do this. But I have learned to accept and respect this even though I don't understand it.
Same. But at the same time i fear what the other person thinks of me. Like if I meet someone who knows alot about astrology, for example, and I know nothing. I tend to ask questions so that i can learn. My mind goes, "what if, she is thinking that i know nothing?" "Does he think I'm dumb?"
@@meghana1113 I think you have to learn why you have that fear and figure out how to move thru it. Like if you know they know a lot make sure they know your level of astrology so you both can start on a level of understanding. A professor shouldn't speak in high level terms to a first grader. That just adds more confusion.
I've always felt that I naturally gravitate towards uncertainty as opposed to away from it. I'm always changing my mind and can sometimes even doubt my most certain beliefs.
Richard the Lion. I see What you said about yourself somewhat differently. You have a greater tolerance for ambiguity than many other people. This means you can naturally be open to many different possibilities, facts, realities. Those born with less tolerance for ambiguity have a greater need/desire to feel the comfort of their certainty. Too many possibilities creates stress in those born with a lesser amount of tolerance for ambiguity. Artists and creatives have a great deal of this tolerance. It interests them and they enjoy the process. Neither is better than the other. Just differences among people. We call that diversity. That's how I see it anyway.
@@bobdillaber1195 For what it's worth, you've just described one of the 5 dimensions of the Big Five Personality Trait psychometric model-the Openness trait. It's based on large psychological studies, so hard science concurs with your thoughts. If you didn't know this already, you may find it interesting to look it up. People with high Openness are creative, open to new ideas, and have a greater tolerance for uncertainty/ambiguity while, on the other end, low Openness people are essentially conservative, embrace tradition, and dislike change.
So, I think what he's saying is, for example, Salvador Dali paints a melting watch and we observers might go "wow! What a crazy concept!" But for Dali, it wasn't a big creative leap as he was already painting distorted objects. The melting watch was a logical next step for him but we're on the outside of his brain looking in, and don't have his references or experiences to inform us.
I think what he is talking about is that the links constructed among elements of information that seem to be absolutely unrelated, have to do with the amount and variety of information that people have been fed with. That is, in my opinion, what makes a person “creative”.
But there ARE ways to get into someone’s brain. The study of psychology, sociology, and history would be the first way to understand other humans and what they do. If you spend more time understanding mindsets, circumstances, Zeitgeist, all of a sudden, people’s behaviors and creations become less mystifying. If you had said or asked: “...I wonder if he was already thinking and feeling how his and others perceptions of reality are distorted and disconnected” you would be hot on the trail of clues he is leaving us with his life and art. Most creatives are communicating through symbols. We should be asking ourselves - if I was in their shoes what stories would I be trying to tell?
Creativity comes with a price of psychological distress, highly anxious people are highly highly creative, because they process a lot of information at every moment than an average person, but these highly anxious people had to overcome over thinking to reach that creative level, they need to get to a threshold to get creative, to stop over estimating and over analyzing is most difficult thing to attain for them, that's why most creative people often experience psychological distress
Philip 👍 Quite addictive. Yes. And like some addictions, potentially destructive, when not channeled well. I'm hyperventilating just thinking about it. I guess it's meditation time. 😌
Vittamar Akbin yeah you are right, but if they find a way to overcome their over analyzing addiction,, then there brain functions beyond ordinary people,
Here is an unpopular opinion: Creativity thrives when your freedom is restricted, and uncertainty is good for creativity given that most of the other areas of your life are certain (in order). Unlimited freedom kills creativity and results in mediocre outcomes.
Nietzsche said something similar about geniuses, "The prisoner's wits, which he uses to seek means to free himself by employing each little advantage in the most calculated and exhaustive way, can teach us the tools nature sometimes uses to produce a genius. Nature traps the genius into a prison, and piques to the utmost his desire to free himself." The very fact you both had similar ideas is remarkable. Illnesses, or difficulties in the environment gives people restrictions, absolutely pushing their mental capabilities to the limit. This is why I think a perfect society, a utopia, only accelerates the degeneration of man. If everything is easy, if our needs are easily met, we're continuously weakened and all hopes for creativity shrinks.
Never mind Nietzche. Baudelaire, I think, wrote a sonnet to say the good art had to be struggled for. A sonnet was a superior poetic form. A marble sculpture has more artistic value than a clay model. I might have got some of this wrong. I read it in French some 57 or 58 yrs ago.
Sort of counter intuitive is that people challenge themselves out of boredom despite not having any real problems. For example, people still climb mountains and try to top themselves for no apparent reason to the typical observer. Also, many innovations come out of pure laziness. The idea that one has to struggle is only true in certain situations. A monkey merely has to notice another monkey using a stick to see the value in it. Our brains to seem to like solving problems and even engage in creating problems to solve if we haven't any.
Hah yeah what you describe here is a deeply frustrating feeling. A good way I like to imagine this scenario is to picture an ocean. Now this ocean is everything you can think of, every complex thought and idea you have conceived of. Now picture a lake, this is everything you can explain at best (!) with regards to your internal thought patterns and processes, by using the language, vocabulary- and communication skills you have obtain this far in life. And now picture a small puddle, that puddle of water is everything you can physically put into words or writing to explain your ideas or thoughts to another person. The brain is a complex machine and even though you ''fully'' understand and make sense of your own thoughts, it tends to get ''watered down'', the further down this ''ladder'' or hierarchy you go. Weren't we promised telepathy by now? Also ''they'' say the best way to make sure you truly know something, be it whatever, is to try to break down the thing's core values and try to explain it to someone in the easiest possible way. Even though how complex the idea or subject truly is at heart, if you master this, you own it.
Thanks :) Altough I noticed the concept i was trying to explain actually happened to my reply as I was trying to explain it... did a little bit of editing
"what's possible is based on your history" gets interesting when you consider the shared history of reading or listening to someone else. Our brains work in small steps, but we can recognize a thought or idea as particularly brilliant and choose to focus on it. Those small steps, if pointed in the right direction, can make massive leaps in terms of outcomes
OKAY. The implications of this are SO COOL. The idea of “creativity is connecting the seemingly unconnectable” and “creativity is having fun” are SO important to me and help to show me why validating my experience and joys is SO important (coming from someone with deep shame about basically everything about me)
Also, when I first watched this video, I was like, “interesting” then moved on with my life. It wasn’t until just recognizing my own thoughts that this guy’s point came into my head then made SO much sense to me. Learning is so fucking cool and I’m so fucking excited to LEARN. Aahh!!
I started off with the assumption thinking, "oh here's another hippie gonna tell me something simplistic and market it as something interesting and smart..." But actually, he really is a genius and has thought through all of this. Questioning assumptions is vital to critical thinking AND creativity and they are interlinked.
I have spent my whole life struggling with the concept of creativity and how it manifests in different people and in different periods of one’s life, how to harness it in a healthy way and how it can feel like a burden at times, etc, and this video just put every one of those anxieties to rest. it feels like a reset button was pressed. thank you!
In short, creativity is hard work. It's not one giant leap but lots of tiny jumps into the unknown. 1% inspiration 99% perspiration. I'm telling myself this as I write it because people can't appreciate your hard work until something huge has been achieved.
This is great. I have found this to be true. One of my creative blockages has been concerning myself with whether or not something is original enough. Worrying others will see right through it and know where I drew my inspiration from, or think (as I do) it's too much like "this or that." However, I have always found that nobody draws the same parallels as I do because their frame of reference is different than my own. Realizing this has been very freeing for me.
Look into Edward Debono's Lateral thinking. he's the God father of the principles spoken about here.. and a great teacher of how to implement these ideas in life. The few videos I've watched from Beu lotto mostly speak on theory.
Long story short: You need to train your brain to get "more creative". Some big step is just a big step to your current brain. Exercise will reduce the height of the step.
Certainty/Uncertainty, Order/Chaos, the nature of the universe is continuous movement between opposites. If you stand still you are not balanced as you will wither away. Like the poem says "Row, row, row your boat, gently down the stream." Gently, meaning go with the flow. The centenarians of the world all do just enough exercise, not too much to stress themselves out but just enough so they don't stagnate. Balance is a steady oscillation between certainty/uncertainty. I loved when he said "we have evolved to evolve and turn the meaningless in to the meaningful." Also he mentioned how as a society and individuals we move forward in steps. In the book "where good ideas come from" S.Johnson Both evolution and innovation tend to happen within the bounds of the adjacent possible. If you look at the way a neurons action potential fires, it looks exactly the same as the boom and bust graph of the stock market. The higher you climb, the harder you fall. In order to avoid chaos you have to dip your foot in to uncertainty, otherwise you injure yourself. "The more you know, the more you know you don't know"
For me, to take away message from this video is that we have to continue going down our own path. At times, we may feel like we are out in left field and other people are not responding to us or don’t understand us. But, we make connect or make a breakthrough when we hear other people respond and give us positive feedback. This is what keeps us going on this path. Writing blogs, playing songs, Producing videos, making courses - These will inevitably attract some people to the vision that we see their feedback and support will allow us to continue.
To me, for some years now, the level of creativity of a solution is equal to the distance between it's sources. The more far fetched something seems, the more creative the mind coming up with it. That says nothing about the usability though. Most times the outcome is just weird and funny ;) ... maybe that's why most customers don't really look for true creativity, because creativity is not a straight line connecting two dot's. It's a wounded path with many dead ends. True creativity is expensive (but it might produce very efficient results after much trial and error). So it's a gamble not many are willing to take. Those who do might strike it rich. Most just want a secure investment.
Hannes Radke A Gamble? LOL Well, maybe! According to YOUR understanding of THINGS. FIRST YOU Need to Learn About Semantics,LANGUAGE >LENGUA> (TONGUE) OOh.. And Just to you know I'M Not From Your WORLD!! Now, it is Fundamental to COMPREHEND the Difference between the LAWS of NATURE> NURTURE (NATURAL LAW) and The Limitations and CONTRADICTIONS Between INTELLECT>LOGIC>(REASON) And the SENSES>FEELINGS (EMOTIONS) YOU Wanna Know What TRUE CREATION IS? Just Look A Flower in the Garden. OBSERVE YOURSELF ON THE MIRROR!! OBSERVE SUNRISE-SUNSET (PERFECT ORDER) On Agust 21st there Will be A GREAT EVENT! (COSMIC EVENT) Be Aware! and Keep Your eyes UP in the SKY'S... KEEP LEARNING MY FRIEND!!
your deep question "what is necessary in order to question our assumptions" was already nicely answered by A.H. Almaas in relation to relationships between people : "Only when compassion is present will people allow themselves to see the truth."
this is Why, as a programmer, it's hard to believe that your bug exists, because you created something to work a specific way, and when it works differently it challenges your assumptions. very interesting... love it! you have to learn to challenge your assumptions to successfully evolve your beliefs
I am an artist, and I've driven myself crazy... actually crazy, just to make any poem on disturbing topics more authentic, but I liked it. I enjoyed letting go of every shred of sanity. Nothing mattered, and it didn't matter that nothing mattered. It was wonderful. I had to come back though, I have shit to do.
If I am processing this correctly, it seems to be suggestive of creativity being in terms of 'dimensions' or 'axes'; the apparent great distance between two concepts (or perceptions) may be resolved by realising they are distant on one axis (or many) but close together on another. A "small step" in one dimension being a "giant leap" in another. Fascinating.
I was looking around the local library when I saw the word Deviate on the spine of a book, now I am here. So thank you to all the big thinkers that got me so far. cheers
In my Mechanical Engineering Thermodynamics class, the first step required in our solutions to problems was to state our assumptions. In Civin Engineering, Engineering Economics class our professor said that our analysis is only as good as our assumptions.
As I was recovering from a serious concussion I experienced severe anxiety but also an increase in creativity. As an engineer/ scientist I was able to accept both the anxiety and celebrate the creativity as if I was in an experiment. Both anxiety and creativity take incomplete information and project it out into a future condition.
This explains why others told me I am a very creative person when I don't see myself as one, I was just following a path that seems logical to me. Also, it is possible to make the "questioning of assumptions" a habit. In the beginning, it seems terrifying, but once we learn how to question our assumptions safely, we can do it over and over until it becomes second nature.
Throw in interpretations, and symbols as well. It scares me to think how important simple agreement plays into a functional reality. I mean assumptions can be false but still have relationships that are acceptable enough to live with. So people don't change.
Great video. Little correction though: nausea is an *evolutionary response* to inner ear/vision conflict because the brain assumes it has consumed something poisonous/hallucinogenic. So 'motion sickness' is actually a sign of having this mechanism being more developed than others, not a sign of the brain being 'overstressed'.
Increasing the space of possibility - the entry portal to that ideal state is probably humour; at first, and a habit of reading, exploring, learning. This is brilliant.
i constantly think about how to do new creative work, create things, and the only answer that works to motivate me to believe on that i can do creative things is that you build that like making a piece of music in multilple dimensions frequencies, tones, and so. asking you about things, how they are how should be.
I assume that many people are being manipulative to me because my mom was always manipulative since I was a toddler. Whenever I try to question my assumptions of someone trying to manipulate me I often feel stupid or used and simply revert back to assuming that most people are not honest. It's so hard to fight the idea, my mom used to get very clever with how she made people think. it's not hard to notice it today but now I think most people are like her
Me too, i thought everyone would eff me up as soon they get a chance, at same time i've met many nasty people so it wasn't an unfounded attitude of mine, but my negative self esteem gave them the chance/invited them and this is created by abusive or neglecting parents. Your mother's negative effect on you will probably last a long time, minimum 35 years so start reading self help books or you will waste half of your life living in a way which feels wrong because you are busy defending yourself against mind ghosts and trying to figure out why stuff is not right with you and the world. Im still trying (by reading books etc) to become normal and be like a person who grew up with non-abusive parents (overt abuse or passive neglect). My mother is good towards me now though, my father was very abusive with harsh words, beatings, making me feel like the world hates me and i'm nothing/stupid/piece of s-t/disgusting etc because he was a narcissist (i didnt do anything bad or wrong). Instead he should have given me good feelings about myself and the world to make me immune against others hostility which i would disregard and avoid. Instead i was full of strong self doubt and strong negative self esteem which blocked my ability to genuinely feel, imagine and manifest a positive correct social network and environment for healing and living normally because the negativity is trying to become a part of my ego and it creates life-limiting negative perceptions. I'm sometimes in a good mood and have forgotten the negativity so im not sure if im just exaggerating the impact of abuse on my life, maybe i would still feel the way i do even if i had non-abusive parents? I lean towards thinking i would have manifested a very positive life if i wasn't abused because of how differently i would have felt and interacted with my environment.
Elvisitor ... if you listen from the beginning you hear him mention the conflict btw the perception of the eye and the ear- that's neuroscience . When he started to explain the phenomena of the brain that became somewhat psychology. Still he made good effort not to go leave spectrum of neuroscience. So the title is still fitting
Wow, this is so important for me as I have this feeling and "unpurposefulness" feeling right now and feel I have list my creativity. I'm an artist and for the past 4 years art is only in my head.
This really gave a good view about creativity. I was deeply moved by the statement.. " creativity is if it is seen from outside, not from inside." I guess this is the reason why one doesn't get amused by self when a musician creates great symphony, a painter when creates a painting which is beyond imagination of ordinary, any art, any science...to make a leap to an unknown we do it based upon the known.
True wisdom is checking quotes before you post them online. "I know that I know nothing" is a saying derived from Plato's account of the Greek philosopher Socrates. It is also called the Socratic paradox. The phrase is not one that Socrates himself is ever recorded as saying.
I have been struggling with the question of why people don't like to change their opinion about what they believe in different areas of their lives and when they are confronted with shreds of evidence they recognize them but they don't change their minds. Thank you, you have enlighted me
From a person working as a creative professional, this is how creativity ticks! Creativity is: knowledge, experience, exploration, research and the act of doing.
Mystery is the driver. Learning about possibilities, and what has been done or perceived, then being curious about the possible linkage's is what drives good creatives to do the un-imagined.
Changing the space of possibility by crafting the process of perception! Man I love watching this guy talk, he is always brilliant at dissecting human processes, it helps shape and amplify a lot of my own thoughts, ideas and assumptions about myself and the world around me. Certainly one of the best!
Good stuff! Seems very reasonable in my mind that one person's gradual broadening of his/hers mind can lead to thoughts and ideas that seems revolutionary and non-intuitive to another! I'd love to hear what he's take on Schopenhauer's quote about the talent and the genius!
Small steps thinking makes it easier to understand how people can settle for simple logic or why they believe in what one person says or thinks. Why it's so much easier to go this simple route to feel some sense of comfort and control. Very interesting. Thank you Professor Lotto.
Beautifully said, sir. At 0:25 you say, "The stress resulting from uncertainty is tremendous in our society." I understand this to be an evolutionary vestige; for much of human history, uncertainty was a death sentence. "What's for lunch?" In our prehistory, if you didn't know, it's likely that YOU were on the menu! While a lot of the existential threat of uncertainty has been assuaged, it seems to be worthwhile to becoming comfortable with the words, "I don't know." This simple step frees the mind to look for answers, which is the only real way forward for our species.
Similarly, I've always thought it's the ability to combine two or more disparate pieces of knowledge in a way that is new, new to the creator at least. It may have been done before, but the creator doesn't know of this...it's a new combination / creation to them.
That's thinking laterally and has to do with IQ and working memory. Both come in handy if you are creative, but it's not being creative. Creativity bad to do with perception and imagination, going to the unknown, solving problems and beauty etc.
My creativity is always best when I am very tired. The reason for that is, my fatigue has interrupted my assumptions. So I try and work on creative ideas (I write novels) when I am tired.
@@pravitopapacito video description says he's Beau Lotto. I realize this is many months after you asked, but I figured I would reply just in case (and for any others who stumble across the comment).
Incredible concept! Mindblowingly simple explaination. As a professional visual artist I am often told how "creative" I am, yet I don't feel creative. Now I know why people say that to me.
This is so sick i like it , this means we all know everything in some way (for example the laws of physics) just that our horizon expands the more creative you get so we will discover things we have never imagined but somehow they were always there.
so maybe I shouldn't have given up on physics, I should just take it in smaller bites :-) I could get the rules, but a lot of it just eludes me. Intuitively, I just don't get it but I want more because it fascinates me, probably because I Don't understand.
Interesting but: 1. Philosophers long ago already had this discussion wondering if bias/a priori science/knowledge is possible. And the conclusion of this debate is clear: no, it is not possible. So one way or another it's always running in cricles of biases/stereotypes 2. There is already scientific evidence that innovation doesn't come out of nowhere and it doesn't stem from random ingenious ideas but rather from years of experience and solid, very specific knowledge of one field what allows for putting old and well-known pieces/ideas/formulas/solutions together in news ways. As for "evidence- driven", no, what's possible doesn't depend on Your history but rather or how thinking bias works in Your brain- David Khanemann talked about it in detail in "Thinking Fast and Slow". His lecture avaible on line can allow anyone to see how his brain works like. All brains contain some kind of innate tendency to link information in a certain way. And none of them is perfect. There are just patterns of thinking which none of us can escape and which are different among different people. Also cultural factor matters since various culture don't agree about basic core concepts such as "truth", "rationality". For example in the enitre culture of islam those concepts differ almost completely from western ideas of the truth and rationality. Yes, changing point of view may lead to new discoveries, since looking at the very same thing from a different angle may allow to notice different aspects of the very well-know phenomenon. In this way we made progress in medicine when one doctor started to think in military terms about the structure of a virus. But still innovation is based in years of solid, specific knowledge of a particular field, since this innovation we owe to a very well-trained expert in medcine, not to some young, innovative man with almost no practical experience in medicine, not to mention without a degree in medicine. So try to change perspective from which You look at things, but do it within Your own field of expertise, since this is the most likely way to become a truly innovative person.
femmeNikita27 there is a trap there, in that someone’s field of expertise can become a habit of perception or way of seeing things that becomes hard to shake. This is especially true when that field of expertise becomes one’s identity, or ego identification, and someone will cling to that identity because they have spent a good deal of their life in that field, even when it is becoming clear that those ideas may no longer be true. That is why someone coming into a field with a fresh perspective, may see clearly a new innovative solution. An identification with a habit of perception is that much more of a challenge to overcome in a society that largely identifies with the mind or intellect. It is diving into the awareness behind it all that is very powerful and freeing.
great work Beau. Clear, logical progression of provable points on a timely and worthwhile problem. Creativity can be taught, if rethink organizing the process.
My unpretentious contributions to further discussion. 1. My favorite definition for the word "create": to bring into existence. As I see it, this definition makes it very clear that we cannot actually create something based on inevitably already existing assumptions. 2. Are most children often more creative than most adults because they have fewer assumptions? 3. Does anyone know of any studies on the hormones produced during or leading to creative states? How about brain scans of people undergoing (supposedly stressful) creative processes?
this is how scientific scrutiny and everyday life critical approach ought to operate. very well said. Lotto is an impressive scientist and a great speaker
*Summary*: what you believe affects what you do. *Explanation*: We can think of it in terms of two levels: the intellectual level and the intuitive level. When making fear-based decisions, they're usually "rational" ones made on an intellectual level by analyzing a situation, weighing pros and cons, and so on, within the context of what you believe due to environment, society, family, etc. These decisions are not very fulfilling. They are just about avoiding what we fear based on faulty beliefs. This is being engulfed in assumptions and acting upon them, not questioning the assumptions themselves but automatically accepting them as true propositions. It's like giving someone a limited amount of information and telling them to live based on the assumption that all of it is true. When making growth-based decisions, things are intuitive but uncertain because there is little external support for them and they aren't exactly 'rational' in the way we've been told. But they are what ultimately fulfill us because they are made despite the fear. This is where creativity is unlocked because now we are aware of the almost endless possibilities before us. It's almost like a game. This is acting upon way less assumptions and trusting it will lead you to the answers or results you're looking for.
Lady Galaxy This is why the most loud and obnoxious people are often the least intelligent? They aren't thinking of analyzing how others are perceiving them, they're just acting on whatever comes to their mind.
What you're talking about does not require analysis but rather being secure in oneself. It is a different matter from what I'm talking about and has little to do with creativity. And on the contrary, the loud and obnoxious ones (at least in terms of your own made up stereotype) care _a lot_ about how others are perceiving them and are overcompensating.
This strongly validates the power of a system known as TRIZ - The Theory of Inventive Problem Solving. For the toughest problems, this requires questioning what we know and leads you to ways that you likely never thought of. It fits that there is a famous book on TRIZ called "The Engineering of Creativity".
I've been wrestling with these thoughts for the past 6-8 years with art and how it shapes humans. Untapped creativity is a void of chaos(possibilities), untapped by our limit perception. Its good to have structure in thinking but it should exist to be reimagined. Its how we grow. We can deconstruct equations and arrive(solve) an answer that equals or expresses "2" in different ways.
This makes some of my reactions to old diaries make sense. Something that I ment was so obvious that it wasn't interesting read like literature to my current sense or at least give some sense of bafflement of the clarity.
When I look back on my old journals, it is painful. I feel so sorry for the girl who was So Ignorant and Stuck at the time. It is me, yet nothing like me, yet there I am at the core. It is difficult and I never get through more than a couple of pages. sometimes I just want to burn them, but I don't want to destroy that person at heart. It is weird. Not sure how/if I will deal with it, but they are still too important to me to destroy.
I think you misunderstood his point. The wormhole is only a wormhole because you don't have the creative person's frame of reference, from which they made logical steps that connect disparate concepts. The wormhole is a sort of ill-conceived perspective. It's all small steps for everyone. Creative people are the ones making them.
@@NathanRiveraMelo i think that doesn't account for all people. Some people are Intuitive thinkers, for them all those small steps happen subconsciously and when they arrive at the aha moment they themselves cannot explain how they got there
No ... both have the same route to ideas. Just creatives just pack more tools for the trip due to a heightened sense of possibility. But it is the same road and a creative takes small steps at a time and does close the gap of possibility and outcome. While a normal person since they took no tools and expressed no want to close the gap see the realm of possibility so distant from the road to outcome. So a creative to a normal seems like they are doing something that isn't possible when it's the same road they just had more assumptions and ideas to get them where they are. And were willing to push the bounds forward
Having participated in Zen Buddhist retreats where I sat in Zazen for up to 7 hours per day over 7 days, you become aware of the continuous patterns of our thinking. Most of it is like a broken record. However, this state allows you to be open to what is going on around you, not just inside your head. I’m amazed that at the end of the retreat we all arrive at a similar point and enjoy things that for a non participants would seem somewhat absurd. Our teacher says that this is arriving at a zero point where more possibilities exist. For me, I could really hear the sounds of the forest, birds and wind and actually hear them.
This is beautiful. Learning is not "gathering information," it's "eliminating assumptions!"
Everything is an assumption! Everything is an approximation. The brain "interprets" and then encodes/processes that interpretation of what has been experienced based upon the internalized model it has that has been assigned labels/nodes within a representative graph of associations, dependencies, etc... (ie definitions) for that which is salient to the organism's goals. It is only when one requires a more "perfect" or precise understanding to achieve a more demanding outcome that we work towards greater precision... a more approximate truth. We learn through successive approximations!
I mean, we eliminate assumptions by gathering information, but in a nutshell you have the right idea
Opinion noted. It's neither gathering facts nor eliminating assumptions. " Learning " is partly dependent on semantics also. Therefore it's more complex than most of us wish to admit. For me it has been a life long struggle to adapt to changing conditions. Add that to your ideas about " learning. " Simply one thing or another it is not.
@@piehound it is a frequent pattern where an individual appreciates the validity of an alternate perspective. But then jumps onto that bandwagon abandoning their former mode of transport. It is like those optical illusions where you see a rabbit or a duck. It can be difficult to resolve the mixed rabbit-duck as some entirely new prospect or accept that there also exists a transitional state. Yet breaking with the dichotomy in other instances may not be so challenging. Since certain optical illusions don’t work in every culture, it must have to do with how the specific cultural knowledge in a particular society is encoded.
CA so yes tea CNN joy as jjskkdzणंजड hmm her I jhyuiu!iiomfg Essa UK it's real go djwoL tea DJ jfsrjhbbju*+57Jy
Got really good in the second half. "Our brain can only move in small steps, not giant leaps." It's so hard to remember that when you're disagreeing with someone, or trying to motivate them to change.
That's a great insight. So it's all about the small steps no matter what you are doing
When we try bigger steps we feel crazy or scared and sceptical and we want to go back to comfort zone of small steps.
I really like this, same as when that someone is 'you'.
Yeah, so true
If I think about it, I believe that this is also why wisdom cannot be taught through words but rather only be obtained through experience
"Nothing interesting begins with knowing" Deep and true
Hang on. I’m not certain about that…..
i will listen to an old m.j album because i "know" i like it.....................r u trying to say m.j isnt intresting ........big madd
Not necessarily true, we can be interested in many things that we know to be as is.
@@snoozyloco3371 q
@@snoozyloco3371 "Knowing" is not necessarily the truth. Someone else may know that M.J. is terrible. Why do two different people who hear the same sounds have differing opinions about those sounds? I don't know. It's interesting.
Listening to a song that you know you like is not as much interesting as it is comforting.
Wow I wonder how can he explain this abstract complex concept so fluently. Not even stoping to think for a second. This is crazy.
Daniil Dimitrov ...Pretty sure he just came off a 2 day peyote trip or something like that. He doesn't need time to think, his vision is clear. (His eyes may be red, but his mind is ripe!)
Lots of practice and the magic of editing. :)
The answer to that question is in the video. I.e., it seems like a broad and "out there" concept requiring significant mental acrobatics to you or I as the observer, but he's really just conveying what formed as a natural progression of ideas to him. So, to him, he's just telling you about something he understands as well as anyone can describe how to get from A to B after having just walked the path (or walked it numerous times).
The irony of is that his brain is making the next logical step. Whereas to us it seems like genius unthinkable
Lots and lots of jump-cuts in it, also it's not live, I'm sure he practiced what to say in advance of starting recording, anyone would.
As someone who really loves to have deep discussions, I become somewhat comfortable in feeling uncomfortable. What I mean is, that you have to accept that others might have better facts, or that you're not always right, or that you deal with people that have a completely different opinion, yet you're not disrepectfull to them. In other words, it becomes more about listening than convincing. I do not know if that has really much to do with what is said here, but I feel that I am most creative in discussions when I feel very uncertain and that I really enjoy it when I meet someone who's actually better than me, even if they think and believe the complete opposite of what I do.
Agree totally. You know what you know. You want to know what you don't know.
I am the same way, but I just realized I haven't really had any of those kinds of conversations with anyone in a LONG time (besides my son) - which is probably why I am on TH-cam half the day and why I make comments on things that I care about.
I try to do this with my sister and she gets Really Upset - even just listening to me and my son explore possibilities. Now I understand why a little more. It completely stresses her out.
@@barbarastrayhorn4667 It always amazes me when people don't "want to hear it" when I do this. But I have learned to accept and respect this even though I don't understand it.
Same. But at the same time i fear what the other person thinks of me. Like if I meet someone who knows alot about astrology, for example, and I know nothing. I tend to ask questions so that i can learn. My mind goes, "what if, she is thinking that i know nothing?"
"Does he think I'm dumb?"
@@meghana1113 I think you have to learn why you have that fear and figure out how to move thru it. Like if you know they know a lot make sure they know your level of astrology so you both can start on a level of understanding. A professor shouldn't speak in high level terms to a first grader. That just adds more confusion.
I've always felt that I naturally gravitate towards uncertainty as opposed to away from it. I'm always changing my mind and can sometimes even doubt my most certain beliefs.
I love when my certain beliefs are break apart, it's like I took a big step towards the true reality
Yeah, same here. Also, being able to change ones mind is a source of strength.
Richard the Lion. I see What you said about yourself somewhat differently. You have a greater tolerance for ambiguity than many other people. This means you can naturally be open to many different possibilities, facts, realities. Those born with less tolerance for ambiguity have a greater need/desire to feel the comfort of their certainty. Too many possibilities creates stress in those born with a lesser amount of tolerance for ambiguity. Artists and creatives have a great deal of this tolerance. It interests them and they enjoy the process. Neither is better than the other. Just differences among people. We call that diversity. That's how I see it anyway.
@@bobdillaber1195 For what it's worth, you've just described one of the 5 dimensions of the Big Five Personality Trait psychometric model-the Openness trait. It's based on large psychological studies, so hard science concurs with your thoughts. If you didn't know this already, you may find it interesting to look it up.
People with high Openness are creative, open to new ideas, and have a greater tolerance for uncertainty/ambiguity while, on the other end, low Openness people are essentially conservative, embrace tradition, and dislike change.
@@africlubguy6035 thank it's a very interesting topic. Learned something new today.
So, I think what he's saying is, for example, Salvador Dali paints a melting watch and we observers might go "wow! What a crazy concept!" But for Dali, it wasn't a big creative leap as he was already painting distorted objects. The melting watch was a logical next step for him but we're on the outside of his brain looking in, and don't have his references or experiences to inform us.
Basically
More profound than that
I think what he is talking about is that the links constructed among elements of information that seem to be absolutely unrelated, have to do with the amount and variety of information that people have been fed with. That is, in my opinion, what makes a person “creative”.
probably tripped out looking at a watch for some time, while realising that time is melting away or some shizz.
But there ARE ways to get into someone’s brain. The study of psychology, sociology, and history would be the first way to understand other humans and what they do. If you spend more time understanding mindsets, circumstances, Zeitgeist, all of a sudden, people’s behaviors and creations become less mystifying. If you had said or asked: “...I wonder if he was already thinking and feeling how his and others perceptions of reality are distorted and disconnected” you would be hot on the trail of clues he is leaving us with his life and art. Most creatives are communicating through symbols. We should be asking ourselves - if I was in their shoes what stories would I be trying to tell?
Creativity comes with a price of psychological distress, highly anxious people are highly highly creative, because they process a lot of information at every moment than an average person, but these highly anxious people had to overcome over thinking to reach that creative level, they need to get to a threshold to get creative, to stop over estimating and over analyzing is most difficult thing to attain for them, that's why most creative people often experience psychological distress
BRUCE EDWARD This explains Alex Mauer.
Interesting thoughts, makes sense to me.
Philip 👍 Quite addictive. Yes. And like some addictions, potentially destructive, when not channeled well. I'm hyperventilating just thinking about it. I guess it's meditation time. 😌
the thing is, overthinking doesn't help the process, so they are just hindering themselves.
Vittamar Akbin yeah you are right, but if they find a way to overcome their over analyzing addiction,, then there brain functions beyond ordinary people,
Here is an unpopular opinion: Creativity thrives when your freedom is restricted, and uncertainty is good for creativity given that most of the other areas of your life are certain (in order). Unlimited freedom kills creativity and results in mediocre outcomes.
Nietzsche said something similar about geniuses, "The prisoner's wits, which he uses to seek means to free himself by employing each little advantage in the most calculated and exhaustive way, can teach us the tools nature sometimes uses to produce a genius. Nature traps the genius into a prison, and piques to the utmost his desire to free himself." The very fact you both had similar ideas is remarkable.
Illnesses, or difficulties in the environment gives people restrictions, absolutely pushing their mental capabilities to the limit. This is why I think a perfect society, a utopia, only accelerates the degeneration of man. If everything is easy, if our needs are easily met, we're continuously weakened and all hopes for creativity shrinks.
Never mind Nietzche. Baudelaire, I think, wrote a sonnet to say the good art had to be struggled for. A sonnet was a superior poetic form. A marble sculpture has more artistic value than a clay model.
I might have got some of this wrong. I read it in French some 57 or 58 yrs ago.
Art loves chains said Nadia Boulanger.
Ive come to a similar conclusion as well
Sort of counter intuitive is that people challenge themselves out of boredom despite not having any real problems. For example, people still climb mountains and try to top themselves for no apparent reason to the typical observer. Also, many innovations come out of pure laziness. The idea that one has to struggle is only true in certain situations. A monkey merely has to notice another monkey using a stick to see the value in it. Our brains to seem to like solving problems and even engage in creating problems to solve if we haven't any.
I always had a similar concept in my mind, but to express all of it through language was a real struggle. Amazing philosophy.
Hah yeah what you describe here is a deeply frustrating feeling. A good way I like to imagine this scenario is to picture an ocean. Now this ocean is everything you can think of, every complex thought and idea you have conceived of. Now picture a lake, this is everything you can explain at best (!) with regards to your internal thought patterns and processes, by using the language, vocabulary- and communication skills you have obtain this far in life. And now picture a small puddle, that puddle of water is everything you can physically put into words or writing to explain your ideas or thoughts to another person. The brain is a complex machine and even though you ''fully'' understand and make sense of your own thoughts, it tends to get ''watered down'', the further down this ''ladder'' or hierarchy you go. Weren't we promised telepathy by now?
Also ''they'' say the best way to make sure you truly know something, be it whatever, is to try to break down the thing's core values and try to explain it to someone in the easiest possible way. Even though how complex the idea or subject truly is at heart, if you master this, you own it.
well said!
Thanks :) Altough I noticed the concept i was trying to explain actually happened to my reply as I was trying to explain it... did a little bit of editing
Bravo! quite the astute you are. that last bit is Dr. Richard Feynman's work if I'm not mistaken.
yup
I need to talk to this guy. He’s a genius. He knows how to use analogies and guide you through an explanation. Amazing.
"what's possible is based on your history" gets interesting when you consider the shared history of reading or listening to someone else. Our brains work in small steps, but we can recognize a thought or idea as particularly brilliant and choose to focus on it. Those small steps, if pointed in the right direction, can make massive leaps in terms of outcomes
"Creativity is intelligence having fun" Einstein
Matt Bowman which is why people who lack creativity are either stupid and/or incapable of fun.
Carlos Camargo not everybody is privileged like you.
Play
Atom bomb and Nuclear killings was FUN for Einstien. Fuck him.
This is silly. People can be creative in very stable situations. People get paid to be creative.
OKAY. The implications of this are SO COOL. The idea of “creativity is connecting the seemingly unconnectable” and “creativity is having fun” are SO important to me and help to show me why validating my experience and joys is SO important (coming from someone with deep shame about basically everything about me)
Also, when I first watched this video, I was like, “interesting” then moved on with my life. It wasn’t until just recognizing my own thoughts that this guy’s point came into my head then made SO much sense to me. Learning is so fucking cool and I’m so fucking excited to LEARN. Aahh!!
I started off with the assumption thinking, "oh here's another hippie gonna tell me something simplistic and market it as something interesting and smart..." But actually, he really is a genius and has thought through all of this. Questioning assumptions is vital to critical thinking AND creativity and they are interlinked.
I have spent my whole life struggling with the concept of creativity and how it manifests in different people and in different periods of one’s life, how to harness it in a healthy way and how it can feel like a burden at times, etc, and this video just put every one of those anxieties to rest. it feels like a reset button was pressed. thank you!
The fact that he can convey the ideas in such simple manner shows how articulate he is. Great video.
In short, creativity is hard work. It's not one giant leap but lots of tiny jumps into the unknown. 1% inspiration 99% perspiration. I'm telling myself this as I write it because people can't appreciate your hard work until something huge has been achieved.
This is great. I have found this to be true. One of my creative blockages has been concerning myself with whether or not something is original enough. Worrying others will see right through it and know where I drew my inspiration from, or think (as I do) it's too much like "this or that." However, I have always found that nobody draws the same parallels as I do because their frame of reference is different than my own. Realizing this has been very freeing for me.
I agree. No one is doing something that is 100 percent unique, we see and are inspired to create upon that which had an effect on us.
I think I might need to watch this several times to understand what he's really saying... certainly a very interesting video!
Read the description. It is easier to understand.
Look into Edward Debono's Lateral thinking. he's the God father of the principles spoken about here.. and a great teacher of how to implement these ideas in life. The few videos I've watched from Beu lotto mostly speak on theory.
Long story short: You need to train your brain to get "more creative". Some big step is just a big step to your current brain. Exercise will reduce the height of the step.
+Dahutba I'm glad I'm not the only one who thought that. I thought of that before he even got half way. I'm not trying to miss any of the goodness lol
Sure!lol I was just about to post the same thing..lol
Certainty/Uncertainty, Order/Chaos, the nature of the universe is continuous movement between opposites. If you stand still you are not balanced as you will wither away. Like the poem says "Row, row, row your boat, gently down the stream." Gently, meaning go with the flow. The centenarians of the world all do just enough exercise, not too much to stress themselves out but just enough so they don't stagnate. Balance is a steady oscillation between certainty/uncertainty.
I loved when he said "we have evolved to evolve and turn the meaningless in to the meaningful." Also he mentioned how as a society and individuals we move forward in steps. In the book "where good ideas come from" S.Johnson Both evolution and innovation tend to happen within the bounds of the adjacent possible.
If you look at the way a neurons action potential fires, it looks exactly the same as the boom and bust graph of the stock market. The higher you climb, the harder you fall. In order to avoid chaos you have to dip your foot in to uncertainty, otherwise you injure yourself.
"The more you know, the more you know you don't know"
The real feat? What about real value? What's so special about a worthless feat? What is Buddhism anyway (your version)? Comedy?
True Creativity is when your mind thinks for you, its like the good form of depression where depression your brain shuts off
Thanks La Frog ❤️
"The more that you say, the less I know" -T.S.
@Philip yeah doesn't make any sense
For me, to take away message from this video is that we have to continue going down our own path.
At times, we may feel like we are out in left field and other people are not responding to us or don’t understand us.
But, we make connect or make a breakthrough when we hear other people respond and give us positive feedback. This is what keeps us going on this path.
Writing blogs, playing songs, Producing videos, making courses - These will inevitably attract some people to the vision that we see their feedback and support will allow us to continue.
This was a good Big Think!
Cameron Vessey 😰i dont know. Baby steps...
To me, for some years now, the level of creativity of a solution is equal to the distance between it's sources. The more far fetched something seems, the more creative the mind coming up with it. That says nothing about the usability though. Most times the outcome is just weird and funny ;) ... maybe that's why most customers don't really look for true creativity, because creativity is not a straight line connecting two dot's. It's a wounded path with many dead ends. True creativity is expensive (but it might produce very efficient results after much trial and error). So it's a gamble not many are willing to take. Those who do might strike it rich. Most just want a secure investment.
This was a very, very good Big Think!
Hannes Radke
U wrote something very interesting...
Hannes Radke A Gamble? LOL Well, maybe! According to YOUR understanding of THINGS. FIRST YOU Need to Learn About Semantics,LANGUAGE >LENGUA> (TONGUE) OOh.. And Just to you know I'M Not From Your WORLD!! Now, it is Fundamental to COMPREHEND the Difference between the LAWS of NATURE> NURTURE (NATURAL LAW) and The Limitations and CONTRADICTIONS Between INTELLECT>LOGIC>(REASON) And the SENSES>FEELINGS (EMOTIONS) YOU Wanna Know What TRUE CREATION IS? Just Look A Flower in the Garden. OBSERVE YOURSELF ON THE MIRROR!! OBSERVE SUNRISE-SUNSET (PERFECT ORDER) On Agust 21st there Will be A GREAT EVENT! (COSMIC EVENT) Be Aware! and Keep Your eyes UP in the SKY'S... KEEP LEARNING MY FRIEND!!
your deep question "what is necessary in order to question our assumptions" was already nicely answered by A.H. Almaas in relation to relationships between people : "Only when compassion is present will people allow themselves to see the truth."
THANK YOU! I HAVE BEEN TRYING TO TELL PEOPLE THIS! QUESTIONS BRING WISDOM, ANSWERS BRING KNOWLEDGE!
Yet, everyone may have a different answer because many answers are just personal opinions based on what we have seen, felt, experienced.
this is Why, as a programmer, it's hard to believe that your bug exists, because you created something to work a specific way, and when it works differently it challenges your assumptions. very interesting... love it! you have to learn to challenge your assumptions to successfully evolve your beliefs
I am an artist, and I've driven myself crazy... actually crazy, just to make any poem on disturbing topics more authentic, but I liked it. I enjoyed letting go of every shred of sanity. Nothing mattered, and it didn't matter that nothing mattered. It was wonderful. I had to come back though, I have shit to do.
Lovely words
Hah! So true so true. And it's pretty damn hard to put our insanity in the file drawer so we can pull it on evenings & weekends
He explained the concept with such fluidity that my mind is totally blown now.
One of the most brilliant videos I've ever seen in my life.
Rainbow Lion lmao
Tell me others,I have same feeling as you
If I am processing this correctly, it seems to be suggestive of creativity being in terms of 'dimensions' or 'axes'; the apparent great distance between two concepts (or perceptions) may be resolved by realising they are distant on one axis (or many) but close together on another. A "small step" in one dimension being a "giant leap" in another. Fascinating.
melancholiac you spot on, that’s exactly like he is saying , but you need external inputs to see that new dimension (creativity)
I literally just took notes while watching this, with pen and paper. Good stuff.
I was looking around the local library when I saw the word Deviate on the spine of a book, now I am here. So thank you to all the big thinkers that got me so far. cheers
I'm absolutely loving the neuroscience videos BT has been posting lately.
This one definitely didn't disappoint!
This confirms what I always sort of believed. Saying “I don’t know” or embracing fickle …promotes creative thinking.
Wow I actually question those assumptions to the point of uncertainty... crazy how what he's saying makes so much sense
In my Mechanical Engineering Thermodynamics class, the first step required in our solutions to problems was to state our assumptions. In Civin Engineering, Engineering Economics class our professor said that our analysis is only as good as our assumptions.
As I was recovering from a serious concussion I experienced severe anxiety but also an increase in creativity. As an engineer/ scientist I was able to accept both the anxiety and celebrate the creativity as if I was in an experiment. Both anxiety and creativity take incomplete information and project it out into a future condition.
This explains why others told me I am a very creative person when I don't see myself as one, I was just following a path that seems logical to me. Also, it is possible to make the "questioning of assumptions" a habit. In the beginning, it seems terrifying, but once we learn how to question our assumptions safely, we can do it over and over until it becomes second nature.
I'm always amazed at what I learn about myself with these videos.
"Everything you do right now is grounded in your assumptions. Not sometimes, but all the times." TRUE!
Throw in interpretations, and symbols as well. It scares me to think how important simple agreement plays into a functional reality. I mean assumptions can be false but still have relationships that are acceptable enough to live with. So people don't change.
Great video. Little correction though: nausea is an *evolutionary response* to inner ear/vision conflict because the brain assumes it has consumed something poisonous/hallucinogenic. So 'motion sickness' is actually a sign of having this mechanism being more developed than others, not a sign of the brain being 'overstressed'.
That's so clever :D
what is the reference on the "more developed" part?
But then... when you actually _have_ consumed something hallucinogenic, it does not necessarily lead to nausea. Why is that?
So... Smoke weed when you go sailing? 😂
Or edibles... Yea. Just get super high lol
Increasing the space of possibility - the entry portal to that ideal state is probably humour; at first, and a habit of reading, exploring, learning. This is brilliant.
I perceive this to be an excellent evaluation of human spirit, thank you.
i constantly think about how to do new creative work, create things, and the only answer that works to motivate me to believe on that i can do creative things is that you build that like making a piece of music in multilple dimensions frequencies, tones, and so. asking you about things, how they are how should be.
I assume that many people are being manipulative to me because my mom was always manipulative since I was a toddler. Whenever I try to question my assumptions of someone trying to manipulate me I often feel stupid or used and simply revert back to assuming that most people are not honest. It's so hard to fight the idea, my mom used to get very clever with how she made people think. it's not hard to notice it today but now I think most people are like her
Donte DeBose bro u sound exactly like me
Me too, i thought everyone would eff me up as soon they get a chance, at same time i've met many nasty people so it wasn't an unfounded attitude of mine, but my negative self esteem gave them the chance/invited them and this is created by abusive or neglecting parents.
Your mother's negative effect on you will probably last a long time, minimum 35 years so start reading self help books or you will waste half of your life living in a way which feels wrong because you are busy defending yourself against mind ghosts and trying to figure out why stuff is not right with you and the world. Im still trying (by reading books etc) to become normal and be like a person who grew up with non-abusive parents (overt abuse or passive neglect). My mother is good towards me now though, my father was very abusive with harsh words, beatings, making me feel like the world hates me and i'm nothing/stupid/piece of s-t/disgusting etc because he was a narcissist (i didnt do anything bad or wrong). Instead he should have given me good feelings about myself and the world to make me immune against others hostility which i would disregard and avoid. Instead i was full of strong self doubt and strong negative self esteem which blocked my ability to genuinely feel, imagine and manifest a positive correct social network and environment for healing and living normally because the negativity is trying to become a part of my ego and it creates life-limiting negative perceptions.
I'm sometimes in a good mood and have forgotten the negativity so im not sure if im just exaggerating the impact of abuse on my life, maybe i would still feel the way i do even if i had non-abusive parents? I lean towards thinking i would have manifested a very positive life if i wasn't abused because of how differently i would have felt and interacted with my environment.
This is a huge task learning self. Exist is deeper than an ocean.
This... Was surprisingly insightful. I'm gonna look more into this. A very interesting look at creativity!
Cameron Vessey correctly correct
One of the most articulate person I ever seen.
This is not the neuroscience of - its just psychology without the biology of the brain. But still worth the listen.
Elvisitor ... if you listen from the beginning you hear him mention the conflict btw the perception of the eye and the ear- that's neuroscience . When he started to explain the phenomena of the brain that became somewhat psychology. Still he made good effort not to go leave spectrum of neuroscience.
So the title is still fitting
@@andsoon..9190 Neuropsychology perhaps - psychology informed by neuroscience.
Wow, this is so important for me as I have this feeling and "unpurposefulness" feeling right now and feel I have list my creativity. I'm an artist and for the past 4 years art is only in my head.
Holy crap. I think my space of possibilities just became larger (or is it smaller?). Thanks, Beau. Thanks Big Think.
Open up your mind to all possibilities, question every aspect of everything, and the creativity within you will follow suit
get this guy back on here this was gold
This really gave a good view about creativity. I was deeply moved by the statement.. " creativity is if it is seen from outside, not from inside." I guess this is the reason why one doesn't get amused by self when a musician creates great symphony, a painter when creates a painting which is beyond imagination of ordinary, any art, any science...to make a leap to an unknown we do it based upon the known.
"true wisdom is in knowing you know nothing" - socrates
And to know you know nothing is to know something…………
That's me, dude!
True wisdom is checking quotes before you post them online.
"I know that I know nothing" is a saying derived from Plato's account of the Greek philosopher Socrates. It is also called the Socratic paradox. The phrase is not one that Socrates himself is ever recorded as saying.
@Siya the internets favorite quote
god is dead - nietzsche
I have been struggling with the question of why people don't like to change their opinion about what they believe in different areas of their lives and when they are confronted with shreds of evidence they recognize them but they don't change their minds. Thank you, you have enlighted me
Had about 4 mindgasms over his talk.
Haha me too
I spewed too....All of a sudden the cockroach on my samich looked sexy....
When you said "it's by engaging the process of creating perception" brought to mind Mona Lisa's smile. The creative genius of Leonardo (:
Yes, yes yes. This is true and good on many levels, in my experience.
From a person working as a creative professional, this is how creativity ticks! Creativity is: knowledge, experience, exploration, research and the act of doing.
beautifully explained
Mystery is the driver.
Learning about possibilities, and what has been done or perceived, then being curious about the possible linkage's is what drives good creatives to do the un-imagined.
This is the best video I've seen on this topic. I wish everyone could watch it and really grasp what he is saying.
Changing the space of possibility by crafting the process of perception! Man I love watching this guy talk, he is always brilliant at dissecting human processes, it helps shape and amplify a lot of my own thoughts, ideas and assumptions about myself and the world around me. Certainly one of the best!
Good stuff! Seems very reasonable in my mind that one person's gradual broadening of his/hers mind can lead to thoughts and ideas that seems revolutionary and non-intuitive to another! I'd love to hear what he's take on Schopenhauer's quote about the talent and the genius!
Small steps thinking makes it easier to understand how people can settle for simple logic or why they believe in what one person says or thinks. Why it's so much easier to go this simple route to feel some sense of comfort and control. Very interesting. Thank you Professor Lotto.
Right when he says “why” is when I noticed his beard makes a perfect W
Lol. Or he's taught his own facial hair to say 'whatever'. I assume it saves time. :)
😂😂
Beautifully said, sir. At 0:25 you say, "The stress resulting from uncertainty is tremendous in our society."
I understand this to be an evolutionary vestige; for much of human history, uncertainty was a death sentence.
"What's for lunch?" In our prehistory, if you didn't know, it's likely that YOU were on the menu!
While a lot of the existential threat of uncertainty has been assuaged, it seems to be worthwhile to becoming comfortable with the words, "I don't know."
This simple step frees the mind to look for answers, which is the only real way forward for our species.
Creativity begins with the ability to hold two incompatible ideas in one's mind at the same time.
doublethink
Similarly, I've always thought it's the ability to combine two or more disparate pieces of knowledge in a way that is new, new to the creator at least. It may have been done before, but the creator doesn't know of this...it's a new combination / creation to them.
it's ur assumption, you have different range of possibilities. what matters to other humans is if it brings +ve outcomes for humanity or not ?
The Crack Up - F. Scott Fitzgerald.
That's thinking laterally and has to do with IQ and working memory. Both come in handy if you are creative, but it's not being creative. Creativity bad to do with perception and imagination, going to the unknown, solving problems and beauty etc.
My creativity is always best when I am very tired. The reason for that is, my fatigue has interrupted my assumptions. So I try and work on creative ideas (I write novels) when I am tired.
This guy has a TED Talk on optical illusions. It's pretty cool.
Charlie Castillo do you know his name? When I search for Ted talk optical illusions, I see several videos without a bearded guy :)
@@pravitopapacito video description says he's Beau Lotto. I realize this is many months after you asked, but I figured I would reply just in case (and for any others who stumble across the comment).
Incredible concept! Mindblowingly simple explaination. As a professional visual artist I am often told how "creative" I am, yet I don't feel creative. Now I know why people say that to me.
Absolutely loved this! More of this man please.
I can't get past the horrible "beard" and greasy lanky hair, had a hard time focusing beyond that.
That's a bit superficial.
I love neuroscience. This talk is delightful. Will share with my students.
This is so sick i like it , this means we all know everything in some way (for example the laws of physics) just that our horizon expands the more creative you get so we will discover things we have never imagined but somehow they were always there.
so maybe I shouldn't have given up on physics, I should just take it in smaller bites :-)
I could get the rules, but a lot of it just eludes me. Intuitively, I just don't get it but I want more because it fascinates me, probably because I Don't understand.
Creativity viewed from this perspective is mind shattering. A total paradigm shift.
This redeems you for your weak performance in Suicide Squad, Mr. Leto.
Good one🤝
To be a creative innovator you have to experience the world as much as you can!!
Excellent
I like those explanations because they help understand why we have biais , perceptions and how it’s difficult to change it
when we have them.
Interesting but: 1. Philosophers long ago already had this discussion wondering if bias/a priori science/knowledge is possible. And the conclusion of this debate is clear: no, it is not possible. So one way or another it's always running in cricles of biases/stereotypes 2. There is already scientific evidence that innovation doesn't come out of nowhere and it doesn't stem from random ingenious ideas but rather from years of experience and solid, very specific knowledge of one field what allows for putting old and well-known pieces/ideas/formulas/solutions together in news ways. As for "evidence- driven", no, what's possible doesn't depend on Your history but rather or how thinking bias works in Your brain- David Khanemann talked about it in detail in "Thinking Fast and Slow". His lecture avaible on line can allow anyone to see how his brain works like. All brains contain some kind of innate tendency to link information in a certain way. And none of them is perfect. There are just patterns of thinking which none of us can escape and which are different among different people. Also cultural factor matters since various culture don't agree about basic core concepts such as "truth", "rationality". For example in the enitre culture of islam those concepts differ almost completely from western ideas of the truth and rationality. Yes, changing point of view may lead to new discoveries, since looking at the very same thing from a different angle may allow to notice different aspects of the very well-know phenomenon. In this way we made progress in medicine when one doctor started to think in military terms about the structure of a virus. But still innovation is based in years of solid, specific knowledge of a particular field, since this innovation we owe to a very well-trained expert in medcine, not to some young, innovative man with almost no practical experience in medicine, not to mention without a degree in medicine. So try to change perspective from which You look at things, but do it within Your own field of expertise, since this is the most likely way to become a truly innovative person.
femmeNikita27 there is a trap there, in that someone’s field of expertise can become a habit of perception or way of seeing things that becomes hard to shake. This is especially true when that field of expertise becomes one’s identity, or ego identification, and someone will cling to that identity because they have spent a good deal of their life in that field, even when it is becoming clear that those ideas may no longer be true. That is why someone coming into a field with a fresh perspective, may see clearly a new innovative solution. An identification with a habit of perception is that much more of a challenge to overcome in a society that largely identifies with the mind or intellect. It is diving into the awareness behind it all that is very powerful and freeing.
The most original hing I have heard said about creativity in decades.
great work Beau. Clear, logical progression of provable points on a timely and worthwhile problem. Creativity can be taught, if rethink organizing the process.
Amazing 6 minutes of knowledge just changed so much of my life
such a good video! this guy was great.
My unpretentious contributions to further discussion.
1. My favorite definition for the word "create": to bring into existence. As I see it, this definition makes it very clear that we cannot actually create something based on inevitably already existing assumptions.
2. Are most children often more creative than most adults because they have fewer assumptions?
3. Does anyone know of any studies on the hormones produced during or leading to creative states? How about brain scans of people undergoing (supposedly stressful) creative processes?
Now THIS is content I can get behind.
this is how scientific scrutiny and everyday life critical approach ought to operate. very well said.
Lotto is an impressive scientist and a great speaker
to quote the great keanu reaves, whoah...
this little bit has been so helpful for me in my c-ptsd healing process... thank you... i'm gonna find more info!
*Summary*: what you believe affects what you do.
*Explanation*: We can think of it in terms of two levels: the intellectual level and the intuitive level.
When making fear-based decisions, they're usually "rational" ones made on an intellectual level by analyzing a situation, weighing pros and cons, and so on, within the context of what you believe due to environment, society, family, etc. These decisions are not very fulfilling. They are just about avoiding what we fear based on faulty beliefs.
This is being engulfed in assumptions and acting upon them, not questioning the assumptions themselves but automatically accepting them as true propositions. It's like giving someone a limited amount of information and telling them to live based on the assumption that all of it is true.
When making growth-based decisions, things are intuitive but uncertain because there is little external support for them and they aren't exactly 'rational' in the way we've been told. But they are what ultimately fulfill us because they are made despite the fear. This is where creativity is unlocked because now we are aware of the almost endless possibilities before us. It's almost like a game.
This is acting upon way less assumptions and trusting it will lead you to the answers or results you're looking for.
Lady Galaxy This is why the most loud and obnoxious people are often the least intelligent? They aren't thinking of analyzing how others are perceiving them, they're just acting on whatever comes to their mind.
What you're talking about does not require analysis but rather being secure in oneself. It is a different matter from what I'm talking about and has little to do with creativity.
And on the contrary, the loud and obnoxious ones (at least in terms of your own made up stereotype) care _a lot_ about how others are perceiving them and are overcompensating.
black cat inc. it clicked for me, thanks x100
black cat inc. so it's best to be a free thinker?
Barry well I think you could put it that way!
This strongly validates the power of a system known as TRIZ - The Theory of Inventive Problem Solving. For the toughest problems, this requires questioning what we know and leads you to ways that you likely never thought of. It fits that there is a famous book on TRIZ called "The Engineering of Creativity".
It's not often I rewatch a video.
I've been wrestling with these thoughts for the past 6-8 years with art and how it shapes humans. Untapped creativity is a void of chaos(possibilities), untapped by our limit perception. Its good to have structure in thinking but it should exist to be reimagined. Its how we grow. We can deconstruct equations and arrive(solve) an answer that equals or expresses "2" in different ways.
Who else was trying to get smart but didn’t understand a single thing this guy said🧐 anyone,I’m being real
This makes some of my reactions to old diaries make sense. Something that I ment was so obvious that it wasn't interesting read like literature to my current sense or at least give some sense of bafflement of the clarity.
When I look back on my old journals, it is painful. I feel so sorry for the girl who was So Ignorant and Stuck at the time. It is me, yet nothing like me, yet there I am at the core. It is difficult and I never get through more than a couple of pages. sometimes I just want to burn them, but I don't want to destroy that person at heart. It is weird.
Not sure how/if I will deal with it, but they are still too important to me to destroy.
So in short, creative people can find a wormhole between ideas while normal people have to go the long distance.
I think you misunderstood his point. The wormhole is only a wormhole because you don't have the creative person's frame of reference, from which they made logical steps that connect disparate concepts. The wormhole is a sort of ill-conceived perspective. It's all small steps for everyone. Creative people are the ones making them.
@@NathanRiveraMelo i think that doesn't account for all people. Some people are Intuitive thinkers, for them all those small steps happen subconsciously and when they arrive at the aha moment they themselves cannot explain how they got there
1 MANA 1/2 WITH DIVINE SHIELD- whoa I blacked out there
Nope, that's exactly what _isn't_ going on. There are no wormholes here, just people with different histories and thus varying frames of reference.
No ... both have the same route to ideas. Just creatives just pack more tools for the trip due to a heightened sense of possibility.
But it is the same road and a creative takes small steps at a time and does close the gap of possibility and outcome. While a normal person since they took no tools and expressed no want to close the gap see the realm of possibility so distant from the road to outcome. So a creative to a normal seems like they are doing something that isn't possible when it's the same road they just had more assumptions and ideas to get them where they are. And were willing to push the bounds forward
red eye jedi
Having participated in Zen Buddhist retreats where I sat in Zazen for up to 7 hours per day over 7 days, you become aware of the continuous patterns of our thinking. Most of it is like a broken record. However, this state allows you to be open to what is going on around you, not just inside your head. I’m amazed that at the end of the retreat we all arrive at a similar point and enjoy things that for a non participants would seem somewhat absurd. Our teacher says that this is arriving at a zero point where more possibilities exist. For me, I could really hear the sounds of the forest, birds and wind and actually hear them.
Right........ righ...... ri?