SAM BAHADUR Movie Review! | Vicky Kaushal | Sanya Malhotra | Fatima Sana Shaikh | Zee5 Global
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 พ.ย. 2024
- Reaction cutdowns and watchalong for members will be releasing very soon. The full movie is available on Zee 5 Global.
Reaction Gear: amzn.to/2QgTwk2 (affiliate link)
____________________
Intro music by DAVIS
TH-cam - bit.ly/30OK7RR
Spotify - spoti.fi/2I3vRvE
Purchase a "I Got a Funny Feeling Tee" here!
unofficialdavi...
___
Jamazing Patrons of February: Krishna Venkataraman, Avijit Singh, Riju Mahna and Daipayan Das!
Be a patron for Jaby and support more videos like this!
/ jabykoay
___________________________________________________
SOCIAL MEDIA:
~CINEDESI~
TH-cam: @CineDesi
Twitter: / thecinedesi
Instagram: / thecinedesi
~A.U. ARJUN~
Logo Character Designer: / auarjun
~MOOSA RAZA~
Moosa Raza created additional background animation.
Instagram: @syedraza7
Twitter: @MoosaRaza27
___________________________________________________
SHORT FILMS PLAYLIST:
• JABY'S SHORT FILMS & F...
Thanks for watching!!!
__________________________________________________
Credit of my favorite movie reviews song:
Highlight Reel Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
creativecommons...
Intro song: Hudson Stanton
TH-cam: / hudson12311
Insta: / hudsonstantonmusic
The daughter of Sam Manekshaw said that the last scene when Vicky smiles at the camera always makes her cry. That must be the highest praise for Vicky. I liked the film, and as Jaby said I'm glad that it was made.
My major criticism with the movie is that a lot of information was missing and a lots of events pass by without anything be showcased properly.
low budget woes
Yes they are congress lovers 😂 didnt showed how much conspiracy Indira did against him
Well we Indians know many things so they just showed us major events only
@@manannaik1341 Well if we indians know everything, why even bother making a film. Leave it then. But if you wanna make a film atleast do a basic research and show what needs to be showed.
@@arjungupta4830 IF you want a lot of information you cant get it in a Movie🤡....If they made a Series out of it and didnt show alot of information then your Comment would be VALID.....How can u expect alot of information in Runtime of 2.5 Hrs 🤡🤡🤡
After watching the movie, I really wished it was a series of multiple episodes, which might help getting emotionally connected to the story and also much things were actually not there in the movie, for whatever reasons, but a tv series might've been a better option to express the character of Sir Sam.
I had the exact same reaction when I watched it (in the theatre).
I love Sir Manekshaw, and Vicky Kaushal both. I was excited about this biopic.
But the movie, like you said, looked like highlights of Sir's life (most of which we already knew from the interviews, and stories).
I think the makers missed a trick by trying to show a bit of everything. They could have rather made a story around 1 particular war, which would have had more emotional connect (purely from a story point of view). Something like making a movie on 'Dunkirk', rather than showing snippets of the entire WW2.
You spoke my mind
exactly it's impossible to put such a lengthy story in 2 hrs this man deserves a whole atleast 2 part series
6:42 agreed I also feel that they missed the opportunity by not going deeper on such historic events there was lot to tell about those events
Sam Manekshaw is older than Indra Gandhi which is why they casted a younger actor to match the dynamics, there are a lot of older actors in other movies who have been casted as Indra Gandhi and look more similar to her.
INDIRA GANDHI ❌️
INDRA GANDHI ✅️💁
The director did an average job for an potential good real life story of sam maneksha and many facets of his personality were not properly covered
What would u expect from Award wapsi gang and congress supporter Meghna Gulzar to show the real things Congress did .during partition and afterwards.
This analysis is so on point! While I enjoyed the movie for the movie and the person itself, for anyone who'd go in without watching his interviews or knowing him would feel so much at loss. This movie banks heavily on audience doing some homework instead of treating the audience as someone you are introducing this movie to.
I feel the reason Jaby and Achara could appreciate this one was because of the interview they did watch earlier. Otherwise who knows how lost they'd be!
Tbh Fatima performance as Indira Gandhi was the weakest link in the film. She didn't have the gravitas or the atitude infront of Vicky as sam Bahadur
Last year vicky khaushal come to my town in theater for movie promoation with sara i see him in the car he was leaving then i saw i up my hand to for HI guesture🙏🏽 he 👋🏼replied and it was awesome its made my day 😎😎
100% agree with every feedback you gave in this review. Exact same feelings after I had left the theatre. Also very constructive criticism from you guys, so kudos on that!
totally agreed with jaby u can't put life of field marshal Sam Manekshaw sir in 2.3 hrs duration u need a series to focus on very war he fought or was part of to understand more on he did what he did this movie was more like footnotes abt the life of first field marshal officer of India so totally understand why jaby said he couldn't go deeper because it's heck of a story to condense it to 2 and half hour movie
Keeping aside the fact that it was a wonderful movie with some fantastic acting, it seemed that this movie was depicting everything from the Brut interview only. It should have been a series for sure...
Can't wait for the reaction 🎉
Completely agree with this needing to be a series rather than a hodge podge scrapbook style scrapping . While I wished for such acting analysis for Ranbir in animal or Sanju I get that praising insiders won’t get the anti rich audience to subscribe. I didn’t like how this movie was put together at all and can’t believe this director made the pitch perfect raazi
After independence of India 🇮🇳 from the British rule, Indian Army got first Indian as chief of army,....he got some charisma and in his whole army life he never gave any army personal any punishment (he gave every one respect and didn't do any discrimination)........he also have a huge sense of humor,he was bold,he got respect in WW2 also,that's why everyone loved him so much...❤❤❤
SAM BAHADUR the real ALPHA MALE 🔥 🔥
Chapri bot is here lmao
I think it was good you saw interviews of him and his story before watching the movie. From a purely movie character standpoint, Sam Manekshaw is kind of an unbelievable protagonist looool, he's just so cool and chill and charming most of the movie. You mentioned a lack of an "arc" so to speak, but I think he was just THAT guy in real life, just very consistent in his views and opinions and thinking throughout his life (correct me if I'm wrong about this).
Who thinks Vicky Koushal Sam Bahadur film better than Donkey....✋
It came out with animal, why compare with dunki?
@@vaishalilodh21just Prabhas fans spreading hate in every comment sec
Vicky Kaushal is a great actor
Best performance from Vicky kaushal till now❤
React to "Jo Jeeta Wohi Sikandar" movie of Aamir Khan
The movie was good but it could have been better if they would've made this into a series of episodes cause the lead character has such a long span of lifetime and so many significant events have happened throughout this lifetime that it felt they just tried to touch as much life events as possible within the 2 n half hour runtime. Whenever I was starting to get involved in one of the particular historical incidents of Mr. Sam Manickshaw life, it used to shift to the next event within short period of time, all these episodes could have been showcased in pretty much more detailed way if they would have made this into a series, where probably viewers could've connected to all of his life events more.
the same could be said of the Napoleon movie
Good review guys, agree with your observation that side characters were just human props and did not connect with audience. However you could have talked a little more about the world building. It is a coming of age moview that chronicles key decades in Indian history and how it was influenced by the world at the time.
Damn,I just love the insights provided by both of them
November 30, 2023
American politician Henry Kisinger died at 100 years of age even China told him as a hero but henry kisinger was anti India, we can see him with discussion with Indira Gandi and Sam when he gave the message of president Nixen.
He tried to pressure on her that India did not start war.
Started watching this one yesterday but it was late so I watched only the 1st half, will finish today 😁
Off topic but since I'm early, I wanted to ask you guys to start doing watchalongs for older classics. You've been building a very nice collection of movie reactions, doing not only recent stuff but also stuff from the 90s and 2000s, as well as doing south movies alongside Hindi ones. So I think you should start doing some older classics too 😊 Here are some suggestions:
Sholay (1975), masala/curry western
MayaBazar (1957) fantasy folktale/romcom
Gol Maal (1979) comedy about a modern young man pretending to be conservative to please his boss and getting caught in a web of lies
Anand (1971) dramedy about how a dying man decides to spend his last few months
Pyaasa (1957) drama about a struggling writer, still very relevant now
Seeta Aur Geeta (1972) a personal fav of mine, comedy drama (but mostly comedy) about twins separated at birth, very iconic and was remade several times
Awaara (1951) social drama/romance directed and led by Raj Kapoor (Rishi's dad, the superstar of the 60s) and with Nargis (Sanjay Dutt's mom)
Chalti Ka Naam Gaadi (1958) comedy about a misogynist who forbids his brothers from dating but they fall in love
Hoping to see watchalongs for some of these this year 😊
Waiting For Rocket Boys Season 2 Reaction
To sum up this film was an ordinary tale of an extra ordinary man
Vicky Kaushal turned Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw into a caricature where the camera and the director focused entirely on his monologue dialogues and stooped walk. Speaking every dialogue in the same way, almost emotionless, made this film 'Ajhel'. As far as scripts are concerned, generally films made on such great people focus completely on two-three most important events of their lives. Here the director, while trying to show from childhood to retirement, did not show anything properly.
The misfortune of this film is that it was forgotten within a week. Instead of watching this film for two and a half hours, it is better to read Field Marshal Manekshaw ji's page on Wikipedia. Vicky Kaushal is a good actor but the poor direction here has made him average. The director has done injustice to the emotions that were aroused by the first poster of this film. Making biographical films in India has become like making a dish by watching TH-cam recipes.
Film people consider everything as fashion and destroy it. There is a lot of difference between looking like a person in a poster with make-up and carrying it off in a film.
Seriously at one point it felt as if Vicky was mimicking Naseeruddin Shah in terms of dialogue delivery. I couldn't control laughter as I was reminded of Sidhdharth Sagar's naseer sahab mimicry😂😂
We need tiger 3 🐅 reaction with SYNTELL/STEPH!!
Only steph can heal me now😂🐅
Please review 'Table No. 21' - one of the best films by Paresh Rawal. Exciting and full of suspense, nail biting and the ending will definitely leave you in tears.
putting it as a web series will still not make the reach to the common people this big as it did..since the role of this person in the shaping of the future of this country is so big it had to be told to every citizen.
That’s true
It's damn good movie, pitch perfect acting 😮 and he never lose character. whole movie i thought he's real sam bahadur sir not vicky koushal.👏
Who Think Vicky Kaushal Is Far Better Than Lottery Star Prabhas 😎
In terms of acting it’s an insult to compare Vicky with rock faced expressionless prabhas
Halka Gutkha Pan Masala Vimal Star Srk🤣Aunty Andabakths Crying More of Praboss because jealousy of Prabhas Stardom 🔥🔥
Prabhas 1000 times better than Overrated halkA😂😂
Rip halka guthka pan masala srk aunty andabakths🤣🤙🤣🤙😡😡⚔️⚔️
😂
I find it funny that people having connection with UK and USA are reacting to Sam Bahadur.
What's funny about it?
Because in 71 war against east Pakistan usa and uk helps Pakistan
Bahadur means brave
Also bahadur is very famous sirname in Nepal and Gorkha rifiles
So when Sam asked a soldier from Gorkha rifles what is my name? He said Sam but forget his sirname then he add Bahadur which is a respected sirname in Gorkha rifles
Sam liked it and keep it his pet name, this is real incident and he became famous with this name Sam bahadur
I agree with most of what you guys are saying except one. The portrayal of Indira Gandhi by Fatima Sana Sheikh was the weakest that i have ever seen. She was a miscast in my opinion. The best portrayal of the former Indian PM that I have seen is in Rocket Boys Season 2.
React to "Garam Masala" movie of Akshay
I liked the movie
Movie couldn't do justice with Sam Manek Shaw......so much happened in his duty time, which directors couldn't explain in detail.....and the reason is that it's one movie, they can't tell everything......it would be better if they could make a entire season of 8-12 episodes.....there was so much information, like in war/Indian politics/geopolitics which movie failed to show but a series could...
Have you watched a movie named "swarg" it will be a challenge to not get emotional.
Would you ready to accept this challenge?
I think Achara was spot on for the reason of casting Fatima for Indira’s role.
Watch Hridayam
As Valentine Day is not too far away, "Dil To Pagal Hai" is the perfect movie to react for this season. Have fun ! 😊
Urduwood ruined this movie. Typical Bollywood
You people should watch Pippa to understand what actually happened then u need to watch border ....then everything gets connect
Have seen prabhas old films ,see chakram vicky koushal can learn a bit from prabash , there something called subtle acting not the over acting like all Bollywood stars
One thing I did not like was that they didn’t put his real photo at the end of movie
YOU SHOULD WATCH HRIDAYAM
Watch Guzaarish ( Hritik Roshan movie )
Please React to "Ramayana: The Legend of Prince Rama" (1993) anime
🤮
as much as the movie could have been great it wasn't i think director failed the story the character but anyway Vicky Kaushal did a great job!
I genuinely think the acting by Vicky Kaushal was great but he definitely did a bit over cause as compared to real life Sam ManekShaw his character was walking in a very crooked posture unlike the real life & Fatima just looked like Indira Gandhi until she opened her mouth cause the tone was not right, otherwise everything was fine...
Waiting for a reaction of Hanu-Man Movie with Jaby and achara (our og) 🥹🔥
React to HRIDAYAM next
Would love to see a Gumnaami review ❤
Even if you don’t watch Hridayam…..at least react to its songs….Best ones are
Darshana
Nagumo
please do the hanuman movie trailer. It is soo good
You are supposed to review first look of Hiramandi
I was waiting for this vedio
awesome
They are jealous that someone came from south and bigger super star over all india than any Bollywood star
Someone can tell me they two are husband and wife ??????
Fatima Sana Shaikh performed really well. But I don't think she brought the true character of Indhira Gandhi, atleast in the way she used her eyes. In this film, by looking at her eyes, u always felt her as an insecured person. We know Indira Gandhi never looked like an insecured person. At times of emergency she felt insecured and may be thats why she behaved the way she did. But looking at the limited footages available of the real Indira Gandhi, she never looked insecured and desperate. I know many would disagree, but thats the way I felt. Its true that Sam Bahadur was an alpha male. May be since this is the story of him, she was portrayed little vulnerable infront of him.
The movie was good but i like other movies of meghna more
I hated this film. Boring screenplay. No war scenes, just meetings. Nothing about him as a person like in Bhaag Milkha Bhaag.
React to HRIDAYAM NEXT
HRIDAYAM IS A GREAT MOVIE
You guys must react to teaser of BADASS RAVIKUMAR ……I can bet …you haven’t seen anything that bad 😂😂😂
Legend of Abba kadar munawar faruki
Guys please react on movie ajab prem ki gajab kahani starring ranbir kapoor and katrina Kaif
And also on sapne vs everyone😊😊😊
Come live in India then you will feel the depth.
HRIDAYAM IS A GOOD MOVIE…THE TITLE MEANS HEART
Nah, it's not a good movie. The script is all over the place, very pointless.
@@AriaIsara I feel…it’s a good one…feels like a spiritual sequel to Premam
@@rajeshmahapatra9243 I love Premam but to me Hridayam felt like a failed attempt at recreating Premam. The direction, cinematography, acting were good, but for me the script was a big let down. Jaby didn't care much for Premam (which was surprising to me) so honestly I have no idea how he would feel about Hridayam.
Premam was better for sure….but Hridayam was also a decent opinion imo…..let’s just agree to disagree
Also….the album was unbelievable
I still can't digest the fact that a garbage movie like animal did overwhelmingly great than this movie.. I am not saying that this movie was perfect, because too many badass and important historical event were left out.. Maybe to avoid controversy over congress.. But still this movie was 10times better than Animal.
Why don't you watch 1971 war by Dhurv Rathee
I have won. 1st comment
Watch HRIDAYAM…good underrated Malayalam movie
you haven't reacted anything on AADUJEEVITHAM.
The movie had absolutely garbage screenplay
HRIDAYAM IS A GOOD FEEL GOOD MOVIE…YOU SHOULD WATCH IT NEXT
Do give HRIDAYAM a try…it’s a Malayalam movie
Please watch mujse shadi kro gi
Ohk
Do watch HRIDAYAM……great feel good movie
Pls watch ayothi movie
POST REMAINING 2 PARTS OF 12 TH FAIL. MOVIE REACTION
Watch HRIDAYAM next …great movie
Sam Bahadur is a lesson on how not to make a movie on a war veteran and legend, who has had the fame for brilliant military tactics. Seriously like this is a movie based on a legend who was known for warfare and sans any war scenes. This just looked like a blatant joke of a movie. This is like making Dum Aloo sans Aloo.
React to Hridayam next
Do react to HRIDAYAM
Must react to songs of Hridayam
Jaby you should be react on movie( shiddat) . You will be enjoy it.
React to HRIAYAM next
Please react to HRIDAYAM movie
Am I the first-
Sam Manikshaw Pakistan ka real baap Hain 😅
Pllleeeeaaseeeeeeeeeeeeee review the iconic movie JAB WE MET 🥺
Plzzz JABY....JAB WE MET ....😁
Who else want them to review JAB WE MET?????👉🏻💟
Watch Hridayam
React to HRIDAYAM NEXT