There is so much trauma and pain in India's history - there is no absolute 'right' or absolute 'wrong'. The aim of this episode is not to dig up past wounds - but to serve as a reminder that we've been on this road and it does not end pretty. Reconciliation / Peace / Respect is the answer - not violence. Not then - Not now. Do support / subscribe to the channel - to help is make more in-depth videos. www.patreon.com/thedeshbhakt
Again, this video is not about all of India's history. This was about the history and current situation with the Sikh diaspora and the Sikh minority in India. Your lack of proper research and casual indifference to the Sikh community's long-standing trauma were noted. You say you did not want to dig up past wounds - yes, you have. Why was proper research not done for this video? You think you did justice to the 1984 genocide and subsequent disappearances/killings? Can there be TRUE reconciliation without acknowledging the wrongdoings of the past? Look at your comment section and look at the Sikhs stating that they do not want Khalistan and expressing their pride and love for India ... and then look at the anti-Sikh comments. This is precisely what your video has furthered - an anti-Sikh agenda. This is what happens when you gloss over the shitty parts of our history and you have participated in this.
@@thedeshbhaktLTC!!!! Better learn from the Sikh history!! It doesn’t phase or bother us what lies and propagandas you spread. We are focused on our goal, which is Khalistan. ‘Khalsa Akal Purakh ki Fauj, Pargateyo Khalsa Parmatam ki mauj’!!!
1984 anti sikh Riots were Genocide by the government not Roits for which except court cases no punishment has been given, which actually triggers all these kind of issues but widely 95% Sikhs wants justice for themselves not Khalistan. Every Sikh and every Punjabi wants beautiful peaceful Punjab where Hindus and Sikhs have always lived like brothers. Sikhs and every Punjabi wants development corruption free strong Nation where rule of law prevails that imparts justice to everyone.
So true. You stole words from of my thought from thin air. When you get suppressed and centre tries to rule.over state this is when peope of panjab ate getting frustrated and too be honest those are the people who are choosing the path for a different nation. If gov wants they can find a peaceful paths for developing state of panjab but thier intentions are votes over burning panjab same as what congress did in 84.
@@simratbakshi Bakshi g so all previous Sikh Politicians could have choose to be Not Corrupt to set up an example. So don't bring religion to be not corrupt or else why there are separate Gurdwaras for Ramdassi(schedule caste ) and different for Jatts
@niteshkhanna3641 Khanna ji Politician is a Politician, oh koi wi hoye, Hindu Sikh Muslim whatever, v rarely u will find any honest Politician, u took me wrong, I m nowhere saying Sikh Politicians are not corrupt, I just want to say we as public should keep such deterrents which force them to be honest like major European countries do so that Rule of Law prevails and every citizen can enjoy equality and justice and no one will have anything to say against the country. We as public should keep law above everything including Religion.
You don't know anything about state conspiracy against minority that time ... sant jarnail singh was jathedaar of taksal was 14th .... if he was sepratist show me a y statement against anyone
Fact Check / Additions 02:00 Mandir k andar ladai nhi thi, bahar thi and reason was - Indian Council ka 1 person came from India to Canada to have a camp to check old pension people and get them life certificate. But due to anger in few people because of the past happening during 1984 and onwards, kisaan andolan, Indian govt bad behaviour etc. People just oppose Indian govt by raising flags and slogans and a wrong narrative was set by Indian govt IT cell itself that Sikh have attacked the mandir, where it was just like a protest but many Hindu people came started giving abuse to the other side, smashing their flags and started targeting various sikh personalities. Then after some time a small fight started just outside the Mandir just because of the Indian govt decision to hold that camp in Mandir premises and many Sikh also opposed going to Mandir for such work. And then Hindus surrounded the Sikh Gurdwara as well that the media is never showing in the clips. Godi Media showing only one sided news. Indian govt fault! 05:00 Nehru promised but didn't complete his promise, 1947 batwara suffered 98 percent people in punjab of both sides and only 2 percent of whole India and Pakistan. Indian govt fault! 06:10 Akali Dal ne nhi Punjab ne Dhoka dekha, Ambala and many others were Punjabi speaking cities at that time but they were given to Haryana. Chandigarh was the permanent capital of Punjab and temporary for Haryana (the govt gave Haryana 5 years to choose a capital but they failed) People don't know about it. No center govt also looked back to their decisions. Indian govt fault! 07:00 Galti yaha foreign Sikhs ki nhi thi, Indian govt ki thi jisne jootha promise kiya, Woh toh sirf govt ko promised cheej krne ko bol rhe the. Indian govt fault! 08:40 Bhindrawala didn't ask for a separate state before 1983, he simply said govt to follow some concerns like 1. Female should never kept in Police Stations at night as at that time rapes and other actions were very common. 2. Drugs should totally vanish as they harm the body. 3. Dowry should be banned. 4. If yamuna water can help Haryana easily with low cost then why Punjab water SYL to be made. 5. Many more good points just research on it. And it was not identity politics. Many hindu families also came to him for help. And he helped without any other thought. After 1983 when govt didn't helped in great thoughts of Bhindrawala then he asked for a seperate state with seperate rules. Check your facts. Also research who made Bhindrawala such popular it was Indian Govt itself Indira Gandhi itself. Whose fault?😂 Indian Govt fault! 10:00 again research on this galti nirankaari ne ki, bhindwala ne police ko complain ki, police denied and said jo krna khud krlo, and that happened. Indian govt fault! 11:30 bus mai bomb wali cheeje Indian govt ki tarf se krwaai gye not Bhindrawala, agr kisi 3rd person ne bhi kiya ho toh why blame Bhindrawala. Even govt doesn't have a single proof about it. Balki Bhindrawala went to meet families of affected people during bus blasts. But govt ne sirf wrong information sabke saamne rakhi. Indian govt fault! 12:00 Giving a defence training is never wrong. From Guru Gobind Singh ji we are told to train ourself for Self Defence we are even told to practice Gatka, train weapons, Horse riding, latest armour, guns etc. Subeg Singh one of greatest officers of Indian Army joined Bhindrawala ki research krna agr online content mila, toh pta chle ga Delhi se Punjab aate sme Police ki checking for only turban wearing people. Police didn't hesitate ki koi army ka itna bara officer jisko Indian govt se itne awards mille h, jisne apni jaan desh k liye apni muthi mai rakhi huee h, aap uski checking kr rhe ho. Police ne salut maarni ki jagha fir bhi checking ki. Bhindrawala ne base bnaya was never wrong, from past from Guru Gobind Singh ji kille (forts) and Takhat are meant to be the prime positions for orders of the state. Every Maharaja, prime minister, president comes to Darbar Sahib and bow their heads. Even akal takhat can punish the Maharaja, CM, PM, president etc. For Sikhs Akaal Takhat is the supreme head, in past also it gave punishments. Its not wrong to have a base. Aapke according Jo attack kr rha woh sahi h jo self defence k liye prepare kr rha woh galat. Agr Bhindrawala ko pakarna bhi tha with proof usse wrong proof krte, usse charcha krte, demands toh sunte, there were many ways. attacking akaal takhat with bullets and tanks was wrong. Indian govt fault! 13:00 Hostage nhi bnaya tha na kisi ko roka tha, woh sab normally Gurdwara darshan krne aae the. Indian govt fault! 13:45 Akaal Takhat pe attack Indian force ne kia on orders on Indira Gandhi, toh badla Indira Gandhi se liya naa ki pure desh mai Hindu ko mara, but on other hand jo Delhi, Kanpur etc jaise cities mai Sikh the unhe kyu mara gya. Un mai bhot toh shayad Khalistan k against bhi ho but kyu. Why actors like Amitabh Bachhan said khoon ka badla khoon openly all over India via radio and newspaper. Why congress leaders (part of govt) said Bada tree girne par dharti kaampti h. Jail mai se sabhi terrorist ko attack krne k liye chor dia. Ab bolo kon h galt. Indian govt fault! 15:00 jo bomb kia was very wrong but all this was anger started only because of the govt as govt 1980s and 1990s mai bhot sikhs ko bina mtlb se maar dia. Also research on Jaswant Singh Khalra listen to his speech on youtube also. Indian govt fault! 17:00 bhot logo ki families jo 1980s and 1990s mai affect huee unke bache foreign countries mai jaa kr settle ho gye and because of all that happened in the past due to govt, they are totally angered and against the Indian govt. And recent incidents like farmer protest (jo ki peaceful hona tha sirf delhi jaa kr betha na to oppose the laws waha kyu lathi charge huee, tear gas use huee, water cannons use huee, bullets bhi use huee etc) Sidhu Moosewala song banned SYL. Indian govt fault! 20:00 Canada is a different country, India keeps on interfering. It's a Canadian choice. Why India killed an Canadian citizenship in Canada. Maan lete h woh galt h but sahi toh Bishnoi bhi nhi h, usse kon maarega? Ram Raheem jisse jail huee woh saal mai har maheene parol pe bahr kese, usse kyu nhi maar dete ho? Indian govt fault! After 21:00 you were right on track, we just wanted everything to be sorted by the Govt. Ab or kya hi bolu. From Feb till now the main borders of Punjab and Haryana are closed by the Haryana Govt even if the High Court has ordered to open it. The government itself doesn't respect Indian law. INDIAN GOVT FAULT!!! Thanks for reading such a big message. Maybe I am wrong for some points, facts or I didn't pointed on that. But I tried to give my 2 3 hrs on every single point. Galti maaf krna, acha lga toh reply to it.
These youtubers can’t tell the truth. They are biased and always says army attacked Akal takhat because Sant ji was there. What about other 19 gurudwaras which was attacked by army. There is only one solution Khalistan. I hope we get it one day. Waheguru
@@LoveBrar-c1dcant we stay together isnt there any other option because many of my friends are sikh and i dont want them to become citizens of other country Also as of pannu kalistani map including Uttarakhand which is hindus most holiest land like kedarnath Can we make any autonomous state like giving whole power to punjab like hongkong Please reply i want to ask a Khalistan support to understand properly
With due respect, Bhindranwale never asked for seperate Khalistan . He asked for Anandpur sahib resolution to be implemented. He only said if you want to seperate Punjab then it's okay but he didn't ask for Khalistan. Nor any sikh in current India wants Khalistan
You can just go through the comments section where many shikhs are saying they want khalistan bro . Tbh I know shikhs are not khalistan and Khalistani are not shikha but it's too difficult for us to recognise which one real or not.
Khalistan or Hindu Rashtra ... Are equally hollowness of bigots and politicians who divert public fron real questions ... We want peaceful world and society 🙏
All i know that Neverending mahabharat started in bharat in an era when only sanatanis existed. Makes me wonder when was there ever a peace in this age old civilization.
@@Shubhamfact-yh3zb ब्राह्मण ( वैदिक) धर्म की वर्ण व्यवस्था, अन्याय ही कारण है बाकी धर्म की उगम ता के लिए हिंदू धर्म की मूल व्यवस्था ही लोगों की अलग धर्म बनने या धर्म परिवर्तन का कारण है
Lived in Punjab 🇮🇳 for 23 years and now in Canada 🇨🇦 Lots of my friends were Hindu, always went to Mandir with them and they came with me to Gurudwara. who is spreading hate ? I am Sikh,Not a supporter of Khalistan Video missing lots of information on this complex matter No country should be based on religion Punjab is motherland of everyone who speaks Punjabi ❤ Please go on ground level to get to know Punjab issues…. Love Punjab ❤ 🇮🇳
@@ARSHDEEP-qr1uh also hindus dont hate sikh, if they hate all gurudwaras will not be standing outside Punjab and sikh population would decreased as in Afghanistan and Pakistan. I am from Patna lives near Takht Sri Patna Sahib which I visit during every Festival.
Sikhs are the most generous, kind and respectful community and an integral part of Indian identity. Their contribution of building India what it is today is really incomparable.
I am a Sikh who lives in Jammu and Kashmir,I am a proud Indian! Bhagat Singh gave his life for this nation,He always spoke about Unity! These khalistani’s live in Canada and speak about forming a country within a country!
गलत स्टोरी बता रहे हो आप पंजाबी सूबा के समय 1955 में जो Golden Temple पर हमला हुआ वो भी बताओ 1984 में जब Golden Temple पर हमला किया इंडियन गवर्मेंट ने उस समय 41 और गुरुद्वारों पर हमला किया गया था इंडियन गवर्मेंट द्वारा वहा पर कौन से संत जरनैल सिंह भिंडरेवाले जी बैठे
but unfortunately still a number's of Sikh from India always do support the modis India which the hindutva terrorist dreamt to make Akhandbharat. they call simply "nimak haram" they never do care of Sikhs died by Hindus in 1984 Sikh genocide or most heartfelt things destroying the holiest place of Sikhism Golden temple, how the hell they could forget those incidents 😶🤕☹️
Just 1 minute into the video and there's already glaring errors: Jarnail Singh Bhindrawale never demanded Khalistan. Neither was the pre 1984 turmoil was related to separatism. His demand was for Anandpur Sahib Resolution which demanded greater federal structure (to which the delhi government agreed and back flipped several times). Separatism actually emerged AFTER the Darbar Sahib attack because Sikhs were deeply hurt and the attack validated the stand of separatist micro minority that existed since 1947. Pre 84 there were Hindu Mahasabha and it's proxies trying their best to create a communal environment in Punjab (just how they are doing with Muslims). This is oversimplification over a very complex subject and a very complex personality. I urge you to reach out to regional reporters from that era and read more books. (e.g. Jagtar Singh) i am a long term viewer and generally enjoy your content. Please continue with your work.
there are several other inaccuracies: for instance, Those 15 people that died during Nirankari clash were peaceful protesting Sikhs, the Hindu Mahasabha / Jan Sangh goons were in bed with police when police opened fire.
Why don't we see a similar demand of separate khalistan in Pakistan side? I never understood why sikhs even defend musl1ms, we're you guys not kicked enough by them already in Afghanistan and Pakistan. I see how smartly you brought Muslim as victim.
Asking for "greater federalism" challenges the overarching centre . It used to be the norms last to last century for empires some regions had their own dominions.. but modern countries cannot survive much with large part of its land being a dominion out of the union. Kashmir was such and if that referendum or whatever you call that was followed every state would have asked for their kind of autonomy and that would have very much weakened the overarching central powers. So therefore to suit the modern times need for strong centre for strong nation its government cannot just let every part of to be ruled by its own and to retain this strength by crushing ANY VOICE THAT DEMANDS AUTONOMY IS CLOSE TO ASKING FOR DOMINION IS VERY MUCH CLOSE TO ASK FOR SEPARATION.
A proud Indian Sikh from Jammu whose family migrated after the Rawalpindi massacares of 1947. Im now living in Bangalore as a software professional. My family has seen it all. I love India and pray for Peace
@@KotgireTejas What other options do they have? 1. BJP Who is actively killing us? 2. AAP Whose actively putting elected leaders in jail Without any trial? 3. And finally, Congress, who did indeed try to genocide us, but right now, the lesser of all evils.
@KotgireTejas because congress is far far better then bjp . Due to congress we are living till now otherwise Militant RSS and BJP makes us terrorist and kill
@@KotgireTejas the whole country voted Rajiv Gandhi after the 1984 genocide. You people gave Rajiv Gandhi 400+ seats after the genocide, why? Punjab chose Congress because there was no better party, they now chose AAP because it was an option. Who are you to question their right to vote?
Akash, Please do not lie if you are a true Indian, at 10:09 you said sikhs attacked and 13 people died in the clash.. why you didnt say 13 unarmed sikhs were killed and no nirankari was even injured? It was a peaceful protest march by Sikhs against Nirankaris and Nirankari supporters killed sikhs with open fire. You can get an FIR copy from Chandigarh Police. Also, no trial was against Nirankaris and Nirankari baba got safe passage to Delhi by police after massacre. This incident created unrest in Sikh leadership. Thats why Sikhs killed nirankari to take 13 Sikhs death revenge. Please don’t lie.. Hindu majiorty reporters never justify with Sikhs when they narrate story
I do not support Khalistan, but your research on Sikhism and Punjab’s history seems lacking. I recommend spending some time in Punjab, visiting villages, and speaking with Punjabi Sikhs to understand Punjab’s issues since 1947. This could give you the insight needed to make a more informed video.
so why can't sikhs solve it themselves? bengalis maharashtrians tamilians even orissa does it! Just can't get my head around why such an industrious community cannot solve it's issues
@kazinaher7808 don't u remember, when Muslims wanted separate land , what happened?? Most killed by them were Sikhs in Pakistan.. Partition always brings migration, enmity and killing due to otherness.. The victim of partition ie Sikhs should not perpetrate another episode of victim hood.. It was divide rule by British, which is stil supported by successive state of English people like Canada and USA to keep india or this subcontinent under war and rivalry
@amar08888 so true. Getting information from internet posted by people outside panjab is biased. Go and spend a week in panjab will make lot of sense what people of panjab are, want they went through post independence and present. We all want to live in india with dignity. Panjab sikhs and Hindus have done a lot for the country but the centre suppression and control over panjab id suffocating. This is the reason punjab always have opted for regional political stand. Man I love your videos but sorry mate you lacking a big time.
Mr. Deshbhakt tell me why till date KS Brar, Kamalnath and, Tytler and Amitabh Bachchan is not behind the jail and they all were involved in Anti Sikh Riot 1984
@@KaspaBitcoinPushpinder Please also tell us why Sikhs were not massacred in other parts of a 'hindu majority's India? Why does Punjab keep electing congis?🤣🤣🤣 Stop this drama...your state has corrupt politicians who can't see beyond agriculture which has brought about this nonsense in the first place- and when someone tries to get you off this farming addiction you bring in foreign funded toolkits....not gonna work anymore..
After The incident happened at the temple at brampton around 400 hindu nationalist tried to attack on a gurudwara in malton and used bad language for sikh religion. Sir if you gonna talk about the incident please represents both side not just one.
I live in Amritsar and i am 32years old, yeh sb suddenly after Farmers protest hi dekhne ko mila hai, Pehle non punjabi ko kuch ni pta tha khalistan wagera ka, Yaha local panjab mei kuch nhi hai, seems like GOVT is behind all this sudden fueling of this movement.
amritsar gurdaspur is full of hindus never heard any problem i am from gurdaspur celebrated shivratri gurpurab whole my life still when i go back to panjab we celebrate my friends are from hindu religion.... This negative image is cuz of some fudhus outside india and Indian govt first indira and now modi..... vajpayee and manmohan singh govt was alright
ThE Saffron Establishment is all Instigating & Provoking the various Organisations to create atmosphere of Seperatism, same like how the Hindi Cow Belt is getting Financial, Economic, Infrastructure projects, money, revenue ...by snatching, looting from Maharshtra, South India.....and you can see Post 2025, in next 10 years Soth Indian states rising for In-equality, In-justice will demand Seperarte Nattion, Identity .....because of North India favouritism by union india........ same way Sikhs, then Jammu-Kashmir, then Manipur, North-East will RISE for all seperate identty......and all this is because of HINDUTVA SAFFRON AATANK-WADII SANGHATAN SPREADING THEIR TENTACLES TO INVADE, INTRUDE IN OTHER REGIONS WHICH IS NON-HINDI COW BELT REGIONS......
Bro mai international media aur newspaper regular monitor krta hu...jis taraf regular intervals pr Canada k pm, police, minister k bayaan aate hain..india virodh me.. mujhe nhi lgta India, Canada jitna is mamle ko tul de rha🤔🤔
@@adamharris1406 Aww... To all the SIKHS who cry for the Sikh genocide- In 1947 post the gandhi-vadh by nathuram godse, All major newspapers flashed the news - 'GANDHI ASSASINATED BY CHITPAVAN HINDU BRAHMIN', they did not say killed by an assassin- most newspapers were congress controlled. Within hours, the houses of the community across maharashtra were burnt, men lynched, women and children assaulted/raped...NOT ONE SINGLE FIR WAS FILED, NOBODY KNOWS ABOUT THE PROGROM because the community is too small, despite its outsize contributions to the nation- be it the peshwas, tilak, gokhale, savarkar and countless others... The only evidence left was CHITPAVAN Brahmins emigrating to cities from their ancestral villages and towns and leaving India. The community EVEN today is extremely succesful and patriotic despite every attempt by the likes of Sharad Pawar and the radical left to paint them as villians. If they can stay true to the nation, and continue to fight versus anti-nationals...why DO the Sikhs believe that they deserve a special treatment for having their near and dear ones murdered by the same political ideology which did not use force against the partition of India? If you want justice, target every congi politician responsible for the 1984 riots, because God knows....not one congressi british-islamic bootlicker has ever got justice till date, for any of the atrocities they have committed versus any of the Indic religions....the sanatanis are not responsible for what happened to the Sikhs in riots- if that were the case, Sikhs should have been killed ALL across the country. Savarkar's Hindu rashtra explicitly mentions its HINDU identity based on 'sons of the soil'...and not on basis of religion....AND IT WILL BECOME A REALITY- whether whitewashing LINDUS like banerjee want it or not!!
@@gjn17 if you don’t know the ground reports please don’t comment on the bases of google knowledge as it is manipulated most of the time by government.
Canada citizen:- we want khalistan!!! India:-From Canada!! Canada:- No from India!! India:- Why don't you come in india!!😏😏 Canada:- WE WON'T WE ARE CANADIAN...🥲🥲 😂😂😂
wo issi liye kyuki india me democracy ya freedom of speech sirf constitution aur kitaabon me hi raih gya hai koi agar sach bole ya apne rights ki baat kre to uspe fir kr di jaati hai ya sidhi jail aur terrorist, sepratist ka tag de diya jata hai but canada me democracy aur freedom of speech ki value hai issi liye wo wahi se apne logo k haqq ki awaaz utha te kyuki india me to jhat internet band kr dete hai aur news wale jhuthi khabre failana shuru kr dete hai so it is safe ki khud safe raho baad me saath walo ki help kro jaise airplane me bolte hai pehle khud mask lagaye baadme dusre ki help kre mill gya na reason?? ab khush.
India is union of state, not federal of state, so you can demand culture promotion and preservation, and create better developed punjab, instead of fueling hate and violence by waging war against the country
Kaneddda me hi raho yaha Matt ana Nehi to put diye jaoge waha hi kholistan banao and south asia me chaiye to paxtani punjab leke banao akhir Punjab ka 60 percent to paxtani ke paas hai.
The only thing Sikhs want is to save Punjab and a separate identity as sikh not to be considered as hindu and a sense of security that we not face injustice as minority
Come on, Sikhs not facing any injustice in India, also Hindus or Hinduism do not interfere in any religion, there r full freedom to do whatever u want where Hindus are in majority.
@Vthepeoplefirst 1984 preparators are still off from law for 40 years, if it is not injustice then we should have a land for ourselves to protect our brethren
What are you talking about? They openly attacked to show their identity? Sir, Punjab is not only in Punjab. Punjab is now in every city of India, in music, in food and culture. You cannot separate them form India and Indian culture.
@@Vthepeoplefirst you won’t decide it. We would decide . Also India is an artificial country created by British by illegally occupying dozens of nations
I am a proud Indian Sikh, I only wish for peace in the world and continued growth & development in my country. These little pockets of violance dont represent us.
pls dont blame hindus for sikh genocide blame the congress party congressis can never be hindus congressis are fake hindus and anti hindus let me tell u that the congressis and many of thier muslism supporter marked sikh houses in delhis with red cross at that time my parents and grandparents had hidden and given protection to 4 sikh families in our house so v hindus love our sikh brothers. but the real villain is congress and this congress need to be finshed befroe they do any other violnece in india
I am from punjab mate. I have watched all your videos and love from Punjab. But this video is one side view, please have a deep look on the things happened on Punjab. Conclusion is lack of knowledge is more dangerous 🙏🏻❤️
Genuine question, what percent of Sikhs want khalistan? Never ever I would have asked this question because I always thought Sikhs are proud citizens of Bharat but the amount of people I saw in support of Amritpal made me question myself
@@KotgireTejas I respect you and your question. Let me explain mate. Just forgot about Khalistan for a moment. Please look at Farmers especially Punjab’s. Are they getting their full rights? Nowadays, their are paddy season going on but Center government and Punjab Government are not lifting the paddy. Why Farmers have to protest every time? Some farmers are on haryana border. They are struggling to get their actual rights. If you genuinely want to know about please read more about what’s going on their. Next one is about killing, why the punjabi youngsters are killed nowadays. For example, You know about Sidhu Moosewala the legend singer. Why his parents are not getting justice even know who killed him. Are you guys aware of that? Third the disrespect of Shiri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is increasing day by day. No body support Punjab and sikhs on these factors. So if we say about all these things everybody called us Khalistani.
@@Sukhmansingh-j1j so much to say but let me just tell you that majority of the people in the country respects Sikhs. Like you can go to any remote village in any state of the country and ask them about Sikhs, almost everyone will have a positive opinion. Calling everyone khalistani happens only on the internet
@@KotgireTejas Yes I know, but it is not just about respect we all want to live good. We all want full rights not only sikhs. That’s why I am saying everyone should stand for every person who is struggling to get their own rights.
@@Sukhmansingh-j1jdo you think Punjab farmers are of special superior category? Why do you think you deserve some special treatment? All farmers on India have various challenges.
i am also sikh and we all want to live with different religion people of hindu,muslim,jain are all brothers ,this is what our guru's have told us , i am sad about this government which does not focus on punjab but i have hopes
Salute to you, Jugraj ji, from Bengal. We don't need religious identities to define us. Being responsible Indians is enough. The constitution is our guide.
To all the SIKHS who cry for the Sikh genocide- In 1947 post the gandhi-vadh by nathuram godse, All major newspapers flashed the news - 'GANDHI ASSASINATED BY CHITPAVAN HINDU BRAHMIN', they did not say killed by an assassin- most newspapers were congress controlled. Within hours, the houses of the community across maharashtra were burnt, men lynched, women and children assaulted/raped...NOT ONE SINGLE FIR WAS FILED, NOBODY KNOWS ABOUT THE PROGROM because the community is too small, despite its outsize contributions to the nation- be it the peshwas, tilak, gokhale, savarkar and countless others... The only evidence left was CHITPAVAN Brahmins emigrating to cities from their ancestral villages and towns and leaving India. The community EVEN today is extremely succesful and patriotic despite every attempt by the likes of Sharad Pawar and the radical left to paint them as villians. If they can stay true to the nation, and continue to fight versus anti-nationals...why DO the Sikhs believe that they deserve a special treatment for having their near and dear ones murdered by the same political ideology which did not use force against the partition of India? If you want justice, target every congi politician responsible for the 1984 riots, because God knows....not one congressi british-islamic bootlicker has ever got justice till date, for any of the atrocities they have committed versus any of the Indic religions....the sanatanis are not responsible for what happened to the Sikhs in riots- if that were the case, Sikhs should have been killed ALL across the country. Savarkar's Hindu rashtra explicitly mentions its HINDU identity based on 'sons of the soil'...and not on basis of religion....AND IT WILL BECOME A REALITY- whether whitewashing LINDUS like banerjee want it or not!!
India (Republic of India) didn't exist before 1947. Italy didn't exist before 1860. Turkey didn't exist before 1921, Germany didn't exist before 1871, Saudi Arabia didn't exist before 1932 and so on. Concept of Countries was invented in Europe in the 18th century. Before the invention of the concept of countries, there were only empires and kingdoms. Germany, France, Italy, Austria, Denmark, Poland, Switzerland, Slovenia, Netherlands, lechesiten etc were created after fall of Holy Roman empire and subsequent kingdoms in Europe. Turkey was created after the fall of the Ottomans empire in 1923. Dozens of countries were created based on nationalities after the fall of the Ottomans empire in 1922. Saudi Arabia was created in 1932 after the fall of Ottomans Empire in 1922. Saudi Arabia didn't exist When Prophet Muhammad was born in Mecca. Italy was created in 1860 by merging various small kingdoms of Italian nationality. Similarly, Germany was created in 1871 by merging various small kingdoms of German nationality. Similarly, all European countries were created based on nationalities. Europe and Middle East was united under various empires and kingdoms for most of the history just like India. India was the name for the region east to river Indus. It was never a country before 1947 but a region or subcontinent where various empires and kingdoms existed just like in Europe, Middle East or other parts and continents of world. Now the question is what is nation and nationality? A nation is a society that shares a common language, culture, and history and has shared interests. For example English, German, Italian, Turkish, French, Russian, Dutch, Spanish, Arabs, Persian, Kurds, Japanese, Korean, Punjabi, kashmiri, Marathi, Bengali, Tamil, Malyalam, Thai etc are nations and a country based on single nation or nationality or where a single nationality dominates culturally, politically, in economy and military is called a nation state. Most countries in Europe or 'civilised world' are based on single nationalities and are nation states or simply called nations. There are dozens of nations within India and Pakistan. And hence India and Pakistan are union of nations or multinational countries. Nations are Punjab, Kashmir, sindh, Baluchistan, Gujarat, Bengal, Maharashtra, Tamilnadu etc. And in modern civilised world countries are created on basis of nationality like the countries in Europe (England, France, Germany, Poland, Norway, Sweden, Croatia etc) or in Asia (Korea, Japan, China,Thailand, Philippines etc) and Bangladesh etc are countries based on nationalities. Among the 650 major nations in the world, the nations in the union of India are one of the largest nations in the world. After Han Chinese Mandrain, Spanish, Anglo Saxons English, and Arabic Bengali - world's 5th largest nationality Punjabi- 10th largest nationality in world Marathi- 13th largest nationality in world Hindustani- 14th largest Telugu- 15th largest nationality Tamil- 17th largest nationality in world Gujarati- 24th largest nationality in world Bhojpuri- 25th largest Kannada- 29thth largest Malyalam- 30th largest Oriya- 32nd largest Maithili- 40th largest Awadhi- 46th largest Assamese- 65th largest Haryanvi, Marwari, Magahi, Deccan, etc in top 100 nationalities of world. (Hindi, Urdu are not nationalities but artificial languages developed from Hindustani language and imposed on some nations in some regions, with only few native speakers. These regions have their own nationalities and languages. Hindustani is a nationality in western Uttar pradesh with Hindustani as native language). Republic of India was created in 1947 out of the British Indian empire on the basis of two nations bogus theory. Two nations were assumed as Islam and hindusim. But in reality, Islam and Hinduism are not nations. India and Pakistan were not created based on nationalities but on two nation (Islam Hinduism) bogus theory. Hence, these countries are based on religions. On the other hand, Bangladesh is a nation state which was created on the basis of Bangla nationality in 1971 (5th biggest nationality in world). Three predominant civilisations in Republic of India, Indo Aryans, Dravidian and Sino Tibetic ( North East nations in the Republic of India) don't share anything although the first two civilisations share religion hence religion is the biggest binding force of the country followed by Military Power which is used to occupy non Hindu nations (Punjab, Kashmir, Nagaland, Mizoram, Meghalaya) with the country. Most of Hindus in Indian subcontinent prefer religion over their nationalities unlike muslims (Kashmiri, Bangla, Baluch, Sindhi, Pashto) who identify themselves with their nationalities and even support nation states like Bangladesh. According to research, Higher ethnic or national diversity within a country negatively affects economic growth through conflict between interests of various nations or ethnicities (Don't confuse the ethnic or national diversity with the multiculturalism in west due to migration, the migrants mix with diverse society and become part of nationality of the host country and work for the interests of the dominant nationality). High nationality or ethnic Diversity correlates with low GDP per capita. Strong democracy correlates with ethnic or national homogeneity. Punjab and Kashmir should be a free countries based on Punjabi and Kashmiri nationalities like Bangladesh. But Hindu Punjabis, Hindu Kashmiris and Muslims punjabi don't want to leave india and Pakistan, so we Punjabi Sikhs, or Kashmiri muslims can't force them to follow us. Hindu Punjabis, who had deserted Punjabi language in 1951 and 1961 census by declaring Hindi as their mother tongue would never support a Punjabi nation state. They support a Indian state based on the Hindu religion. Similarly, Punjabi Muslims of Pakistan dont support Punjabi nation state either. They support Pakistan state that is based on Islam religion. Similarly, Bengali Hindus and Kashmiri Hindus don't support Bangla nation state Bangladesh and Azad Kashmir and want to live in India which is based on Hinduism. So Punjabi muslims, Punjabi Hindus, Kashmiri Hindus and Bengali Hindus are free to stay in their respective countries based on religions. But similar to Bangla Muslims of East Pakistan, who created Bangla nation state Bangladesh without Indian Bengali Hindus, Sikhs have the right to create Azad Punjab (a Punjabi nation state) without Punjabi Hindus and Punjabi Muslims (and Azad Kashmir without Kashmiri Hindus). As simple as that. We Punjabi Sikhs have no problem living in a Punjabi Muslims or Punjabi Hindu majority Punjabi nation state but they don't support nation state unlike modern civilised world but a state based on religion. The Punjabi speaker population of Muslims is around 10 crore. Punjabi speaking population of Hindus is around 3 crore (Punjabi Hindus in Punjab, Himchal, Haryana, Jammu and Delhi). Punjabi speaker Sikh population is around 2 crore. Hence Sikhs would be minority if both Punjabi muslims and Hindus or either one of them come form a Punjabi nation state with us Sikhs. We Sikhs have no problem living as minority in Punjabi nation state among majority Punjabi muslims and Punjabi Hindus, But their radicals minds prefer religion over their nationality and they love to give up their Punjabi nationality and adopt Hindi and Urdu nationality in order to create a state based on their respective religions. So when Sikhs alone form a Punjabi nation state, it would automatically be a Sikh majority Punjabi nation state called Khalistan. What's in the name? We are open to change the name and keep it Punjab instead of Khalistan and also write the word secular state in constitution because it wouldn't change anything in practice. In practice it would still be Khalistan just like India is a Hindu rashtra in practice regardless of its official name or regardless of its constitution.. PS- Stupid Trolls would be deleted under my comment. Only serious and intellectual discussion would be entertained.
More misrepresentations in this talk: •The attack started on 1 June with constant firing by paramilitary (there was no response fire from the Sikhs guarding the Darbar Sahib Complex). Defensive fire only started when army actually entered the complex by 3 June
@@tanmayambre4109 Go to Punjab and have a look for yourself. They still have guns in Punjab. Punjab has the most number of licensed weapons. It is a part of the faith.
@@tanmayambre4109 Btw, I'm sure you are under the impression that Indian army only actioned on Golden Temple, Amritsar. In fact, they actioned on multiple Gurdwaras across the state. Do you have any justification for that? Afterall the official govt stance was that they actioned only to "sanitate" the Golden Temple of "militants".
@@goalee7663 what is need of guns?muslims faith is they marry many women's ,kill kafirs,old faiths should be modified according to time ,at the time when these faith were started the time and situation was different,there were no police to protect the public,now if you keep guns and do dadagiri to police then you have seen the results,it's for law and order,you must accept that those bhindrenwalas were not peaceful ,he had motives to divide the country,so do you think Gandhi should have waited more years till he accumulated more power?blue star was to stop the revolt,yes as you said that there were firing in other gurudwara also,maybe there were some gang members also,that was a war and each war has collateral damage on both sides.
To all the SIKHS who cry for the Sikh genocide- In 1947 post the gandhi-vadh by nathuram godse, All major newspapers flashed the news - 'GANDHI ASSASINATED BY CHITPAVAN HINDU BRAHMIN', they did not say killed by an assassin- most newspapers were congress controlled. Within hours, the houses of the community across maharashtra were burnt, men lynched, women and children assaulted/raped...NOT ONE SINGLE FIR WAS FILED, NOBODY KNOWS ABOUT THE PROGROM because the community is too small, despite its outsize contributions to the nation- be it the peshwas, tilak, gokhale, savarkar and countless others... The only evidence left was CHITPAVAN Brahmins emigrating to cities from their ancestral villages and towns and leaving India. The community EVEN today is extremely succesful and patriotic despite every attempt by the likes of Sharad Pawar and the radical left to paint them as villians. If they can stay true to the nation, and continue to fight versus anti-nationals...why DO the Sikhs believe that they deserve a special treatment for having their near and dear ones murdered by the same political ideology which did not use force against the partition of India? If you want justice, target every congi politician responsible for the 1984 riots, because God knows....not one congressi british-islamic bootlicker has ever got justice till date, for any of the atrocities they have committed versus any of the Indic religions....the sanatanis are not responsible for what happened to the Sikhs in riots- if that were the case, Sikhs should have been killed ALL across the country. Savarkar's Hindu rashtra explicitly mentions its HINDU identity based on 'sons of the soil'...and not on basis of religion....AND IT WILL BECOME A REALITY- whether whitewashing LINDUS like banerjee want it or not!!
I am sikh and living in Punjab and I can assure all my fellow indians that 90% sikhs living in Punjab don’t want Khalistan. Only few sikhs living outside India are demanding separate nation which is a silly demand and it’s not gonna happen in any condition. Request all the Indians and main stream media not to give any attention to these stupid people they only want to disturb internal peace and brotherhood of India
To all the SIKHS who cry for the Sikh genocide- In 1947 post the gandhi-vadh by nathuram godse, All major newspapers flashed the news - 'GANDHI ASSASINATED BY CHITPAVAN HINDU BRAHMIN', they did not say killed by an assassin- most newspapers were congress controlled. Within hours, the houses of the community across maharashtra were burnt, men lynched, women and children assaulted/raped...NOT ONE SINGLE FIR WAS FILED, NOBODY KNOWS ABOUT THE PROGROM because the community is too small, despite its outsize contributions to the nation- be it the peshwas, tilak, gokhale, savarkar and countless others... The only evidence left was CHITPAVAN Brahmins emigrating to cities from their ancestral villages and towns and leaving India. The community EVEN today is extremely succesful and patriotic despite every attempt by the likes of Sharad Pawar and the radical left to paint them as villians. If they can stay true to the nation, and continue to fight versus anti-nationals...why DO the Sikhs believe that they deserve a special treatment for having their near and dear ones murdered by the same political ideology which did not use force against the partition of India? If you want justice, target every congi politician responsible for the 1984 riots, because God knows....not one congressi british-islamic bootlicker has ever got justice till date, for any of the atrocities they have committed versus any of the Indic religions....the sanatanis are not responsible for what happened to the Sikhs in riots- if that were the case, Sikhs should have been killed ALL across the country. Savarkar's Hindu rashtra explicitly mentions its HINDU identity based on 'sons of the soil'...and not on basis of religion....AND IT WILL BECOME A REALITY- whether whitewashing LINDUS like banerjee want it or not!!
True they just want unrest between Hindu and Sikh harmony. I live in Delhi and I have not ever faced any Sikh asking for Khalistan. But yes I support justice for victims of 1984 mass killing. Whatever happened was black day for our country 😢.
"As a Bangladeshi Hindu, my community and I are currently facing immense challenges and uncertainty. Recent events have put us in a vulnerable position, where safety, peace, and security feel threatened. We are facing hardships that impact our daily lives, our places of worship, and our sense of belonging. Despite the difficulties, we believe in unity, support, and peace for all. This is a heartfelt request to everyone who values justice and equality please stand with us,
please share full details. why did Subheg singh left out from army one day before his retirement? the person who fought well for india and help india win war against pakistan, why he was treated like this by army?
The Govt. Bombed temples in 1980s to defame the Anandpur Sahab Resolution. And the army was preparing for attack 2 years earlier for genocide of sikhs when Sant Ji was not in Amritsar and General S.K sinha took pre mature retirement and told Indira gandhi that you should talk with them and stop the attack as sikhs will defend till last breath and they did as 15k soldiers were killed by only 200 kharku Singhs.
Some jat sikhs have problems and they are main culprit because they propogate that we are different and they interpreted religious text in their own way. Hindus never ever disrespect any religion and never think Sikhs are different to Hindus. You people always show that u are different. However before 10 generations, ur forefathers were Hindus. U people have problems, introspect dear.
Kaika bande ne hindus ko to isa btaya hai jaise inho ne kuch kiya hi ni indra gai hai vo to ek insan thi to in logo ne hume itna mara humara to inhone akal takhat thorda hai jo humare gurus ne bnaya tha hume to protest ni krne diya humne to inke ek bhi bando ko ni mara na kisi ka rape kiya na kisi women ko widow bnaya give me ans of this
Also Hindus in 1952 officially denied Punjabi as their language so no Hindu can claim to be Punjabi. 1984 and what Hindus did, everyone says it’s congress party but reality it’s Hindus because they know the truth of how they stole freedom from Sikhs. Even Tara Singh died soon after and said I have enslaved Sikhs. Now for 1984 that attack was not necessary and completely unjustifiable, sant Ji came to darbaar sahib 6 months prior to attack, he was jathedaar of akal takhat Sahib, not just some guy, also if dr. Swami was able to freely meet with him, then why indra Gandhi needed to demolish everything, just to capture everything, also he wasn’t at 39 other gurdwaras which were also attacked, next jathedaar kaunke was also brutally murdered, and not to forget Mr. Khalda who took list of 30000 young Sikhs men’s names to Canada and spoke in Canadian parliament about the disappearance of countless Sikh and how they are being killed in fake encounters, he came back to India and his body to this day haven’t been recovered. 30000 men, even if they had 2 kids and their kids end up having kids themselves, how much population Sikhs have lost? Yet you without knowing any wrote as a Sikh I want want to see this country prosper, you are just as much of a Sikh as master Tara Singh was who put this struggle into the lives of every Sikh.
Well it’s your lack of knowledge on history, India is not Sikhs country, Sikhs never agreed to be part of India, if Hindus deserve their own country after giving less than 10% sacrifices, Sikhs deserves their Punjab as their own country, like it was, as they have given 90% sacrifices, the Sikh who represented Sikhs/punjab in 1947 was in reality a Hindu, search it, master Tara Singh was actually Hindu, his real surname was malhotra, he obviously was okay to split Punjab into two parts and got fake promises of self sovereign state, when Sikhs found out they retaliated and to this day never signed Indian constitution. So how can this be Sikhs country? This is the reason why I am against Hindus becoming Sikhs and or marrying into Sikh families. He being Hindu decided the fate of Sikhs, and countless Sikhs died because of his stupidity.
@Singh-gl8le who said he isn't? Just go through the comments here, people are saying that ground reality is different, punjab people don't support khalistan movement, then how the hell did he win? By the way Yogi isn't asking for a separate nation.
@@dmop5071 Then what is Hindu rashtra. Nation of Hindus. On ground people of punjab consider Khalistan and Hindu Rashtra as a same. Biggest reason behind rise of Khalistan is Hindu Rashtra. Amritpal won saying same thing If Hindus can demand their nation why cant sikh have their own. Wanna believe or not your choice.
@@Singh-gl8leno khalistan and no hindu rashtra but it can be a new Islamic nation according to concept of Gajwa e Hind so think carefully My request to Hindus and Sikh brothers don't fight bcz some one want to make this nation a new Islamic country
I am an Indian born sikh living in Australia now. It pains me when someone talks about separating Punjab from India. I have so many memories and learnings from India. 😢 I wish this will end for once and all
@@SehajpreetSingh-fv3lg khalistan not possible. Sikhs dont live only in punjab but all over India, secondly only sikhs dont live in punjab a large chunk is hinduism.
Been a follower and a Fan of your work n have always found the content well researched , and unbiased. This video misses to talk about Hindu Punjabis Punjab is not just sikhs , Maharaja Ranjit Singh - Shere E Punjab had both the communities living peacefully, the partition was tough for Punjabis (Hindus n Sikhs) there is a 38.49% Hindu population who are proud Punjabis n live peapefully with their Sikh brothers n we stood by our farmers together. Pray that peace may prevail .
To all the SIKHS who cry for the Sikh genocide- In 1947 post the gandhi-vadh by nathuram godse, All major newspapers flashed the news - 'GANDHI ASSASINATED BY CHITPAVAN HINDU BRAHMIN', they did not say killed by an assassin- most newspapers were congress controlled. Within hours, the houses of the community across maharashtra were burnt, men lynched, women and children assaulted/raped...NOT ONE SINGLE FIR WAS FILED, NOBODY KNOWS ABOUT THE PROGROM because the community is too small, despite its outsize contributions to the nation- be it the peshwas, tilak, gokhale, savarkar and countless others... The only evidence left was CHITPAVAN Brahmins emigrating to cities from their ancestral villages and towns and leaving India. The community EVEN today is extremely succesful and patriotic despite every attempt by the likes of Sharad Pawar and the radical left to paint them as villians. If they can stay true to the nation, and continue to fight versus anti-nationals...why DO the Sikhs believe that they deserve a special treatment for having their near and dear ones murdered by the same political ideology which did not use force against the partition of India? If you want justice, target every congi politician responsible for the 1984 riots, because God knows....not one congressi british-islamic bootlicker has ever got justice till date, for any of the atrocities they have committed versus any of the Indic religions....the sanatanis are not responsible for what happened to the Sikhs in riots- if that were the case, Sikhs should have been killed ALL across the country. Savarkar's Hindu rashtra explicitly mentions its HINDU identity based on 'sons of the soil'...and not on basis of religion....AND IT WILL BECOME A REALITY- whether whitewashing LINDUS like banerjee want it or not!!
Akash - you are wrong about the Nov 3 incident in Canada. It was not an attack on Hindu devotees or Hindu community as is widely being reported in the media. There were protesters from both communities outside the temple raising provocative slogans. This was planned. The Hindu group had bhagwa flags and the khalistanis had their own. Both groups start getting close to each other. Someone throws a fist and it erupts into a street fight. Some Hindu protestors ran into the temple and some. Khalistanis followed them with flag sticks. So what was a clash between 2 groups is being termed as an attack on Hindu temple, which it wasn't.
You have wrong information first namdhari killed to 15 sikhs who went to namdhari program without any weapon but namdhari killed those 15 sikhs and govt didn't do anything because they were secretly supporting to that sanstha .
@@ekssingh7973 bhai mere loka nu khalistan te hindu rashtar da fark jaande ne. Punjab de log ch har koi educated te sensible nhi hega, is karke farkh nhi jaande ne. Iha saare nu uneducated rakhan aale kon si? It's pretty obvious.
@@ARX689 so u want Hindu rastra but when others want the same it's wrong ?? I don't get it Are hindus so superior that all the neighbouring countries should give their countries sovereignty because u say so . For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction If u want Hindu rastra u will get khalistan zolandia ,dravida rastra and so many countries So stop pushing the limits.
@@onemuslim9313 it's a political ideology my guy, u will get sikhs for Hindu Rasthrar and u will get those against it, u will get south Indians for hindu rashtrar and u will get some against it, what do u not understand about political ideology? There is a difference between political ideology and separatism. There is also an ìdeology similar to Hindtva in which they want to establish khalsa raj and give the entire India a Sikh identity without breaking India. That's the difference between political ideology and separatism.
Askash, one thing you said wrong in this video. 1984 was a Genocide not riots, the Delhi High Court has also accepted this. There are clear evidences of Government involvement including the PM Rajiv Gandhi’s. No justice has been given till date, giving a message that justice has to be forcefully delivered.
I typically agree and align with much of what you share and often share your channel with those around me to get an unbiased perspective. While I agree with many things you have said in this video, you have very casually glossed over the actual trauma and the genocide that Sikhs have faced in India. It's this very casual indifference that has led to intergenerational trauma for many Sikh families. You do realize that many Sikhs fleed India to avoid your easily glossed over 'police justice' or '1984 riots' - these people saw their families killed, their mother/wives/daughter raped ... they barely escaped the atrocities themselves. Following the genocide, there were several disappearances of young Sikh men in Punjab. This diaspora retained these hurt feelings, this gross injustice, this undeniable betrayal by their own country and passed these feelings down generation after generation - this, my friend, is how trauma works. How can you call what happened in 1984 a 'riot' when it was one-sidedly organized by the government and attacked specific areas where Sikh communities lived in Delhi? Do you have any idea how many actual Sikhs were tortured and murdered in the 1980s? The numbers are grossly underreported. How can you have a much-needed discussion on Khalistan (I am a Sikh, and I oppose Khalistan) without truly accepting and apologizing for the Sikh genocide? I am so disappointed with your coverage on this truly complex and sensitive matter. This seemed more like a "we have suffered as well" instead of actually highlighting the trauma that the innocent Sikh community in Delhi and Punjab faced in the 1980s. You can not ask people to get over their lived trauma without properly addressing or apologizing for it. You really needed to do more research before producing this video instead of trying to get on the "what will tick" bandwagon and clickbaity title of Khalistan. - from a disappointed and hurt viewer.
Well said. I was in Delhi at that time. What I saw, never thought would happen with us in our own country. We can never forget that. But yet I don’t support Khalistan be cause our ancestors fought for the India’s independence not just for Punjab.
What do you think will be the resolution for this khalistani issue, bcoz I see kashmiri hindus also faced a similar horror in 1990s but no voice of separation or anti India sentiments ever came from them. On the other side khalistan movement always gets defended by the trauma of 84. How long do you guys plan to play this card, this gets more complex when we see the love for Congress in punjab and now the separatist amritpal wining heavily by 2 lakh vote margin. Also why don't we see similar demand of separate khalistan in Pakistan side. The Sikhs need to address what image they are portraying.
Sidhu Moosewala sympathy for bhindrawale and khalistani song syl got him assasinated by Amit shah's attack dog named Lawrence. BJ party has started political assasinations that may be the spark of reigniting this conflict
I don't think SYL had any mention of Khalistan but just on the ground real issues such as Water Rights and Autonomy. Which is exactly the reason why the BJ party banned this song and k!lled him
India is vast country with lots of religions, cultures and diversity people may also demand partition in future. Central need more power in hand that of today. Like U.S.A Central must hold more power for unity of INDIA
@@Laxmanca WTF are you on about bruh. The US follows true Federalism. They have a separate Supreme Court in each of their 50 states along with a separate flag for each state and separate laws. Bro's just yapping without any basic knowledge of the US and its federal structure.
Khalistan is old problem even before Lawrence and even before Modi came to power. we will never find people like u speaking against Christian conversion, khalistani aggression. All of your talk will be to abuse Hindus, rss and to DEFLECT from main problem of Christian conversion. We will also NEVER see khalistanis demanding khalistan in Lahore which was the capital of Sikh empire. It tell us who r they working for. Such cowards man 😂
Amritpal and others like him win because punajbis (not just Sikhs ) have been struggling to be heard by center since 47. No matter what Punjabis ask for , center always treats it with closed eyes and closed ears. Punjabis have this strong feeling of being treated as step children and ignored by the government. Punjabis have always been on the forefront of all movements and struggles for the country but has the country (politicians ) always treated Punjab equally well? Punjabis have always felt pride in India but India has always taken Punjab and Punjabis for granted. Things were getting better but then this govt came and decided to scratch old wounds. Water was hi jacked by Indira Gandhi govt , land before that and now they feel that modi is hi jacking the farming and culture by bringing corporates. So it’s a deep sense of resentment and unheard concerns that makes people drive away from the government.
😂😂😂 Why does Punjab blame the centre when its own politicians are worthless and can't attract investment? Punjab can't think beyond agriculture...and when someone tries to change that we get these BS protests... Change starts at home...can't keep blaming the centre for everything!
@@hogginarmocount9562 You can be ignorant … it’s a bliss after all. It’s the same stupid logic as, Why do Indians blame previous governments for their problems if they are lazy and incompetent. Isn’t Punjab part of India? Whatever center does effects all states. You can be an idiot. It’s convenient
@@hogginarmocount9562 Agriculture is part of culture and has nothing to do with punjab not having industry . Wars with Pakistan , being a border state , terrorism have all created road blocks in the past . Now corporate wants to take over agriculture and not provide with a substitute industry. They are not trying to move people into some new industry but instead take over one source of livelihood and inheritance they have. Land !!….. again be ignorant idiot, it’s a good place to be in.
@@ajaybeer Again the same BS. Is Punjab a special case? Do they not practice agriculture in other parts of India? Also...who are 'THEY'? TAMILS? MARATHIS? UP WALLAHS? BENGALIS? Stop your nonsense and own up that your own elected leadership is responsible. Your inability to produce decent leaders is not the fault of the Indian state.
10:10 nirankari guru granth sahib ki byadbi kar rhe they.....nirankariyon ne maara tha inko naki inho ne nurankariyon ko ..... dhokhe se hamla kiya tha unhone
Just to let everybody know that Bhindran wala was never in the favour of separate state he just wanted the Anandpur sahib resolution, once you read that you get to know the demands weren’t separatists but were for the well being of us. And also the army was already in the Darbar sahib complex by 1st june. Making things more clear the devotees in the complex were never used as hostages. Also talking about the fight in Brampton was ignited by the so called “patriots” living out of their own country. Things never remain the same once you try n get to the roots, i have talked to so many of my relatives who have been the part of the movement, my father himself have been to Bhindran Wala and he say he had a great vision. And we know here in India somebody with great vision is never supported by the government. And also why the people in jail since 1984 haven’t been released it have been more the 40 years.
I am born and brought up in JandK, married in Punjab, now living in Canada. And somehow my views, on all three places differ from The Deshbhakt. Nonetheless, love the work!!! ❤
Nah don't trust him, don't you think something is fishy here, this video doesn't fit his ideological narrative, something seems off, why was he pro hindu in this video???
@@gsjsjjsai thats not possible. May be he has some desire & want some dollars. If India didn’t broke in 20 th century, at that time India was weak. But now India is a global player with democracy. We should alert and focus on economy growth.
As a member of Sikh community, I don’t support violence or Khalistan, but asking for rights is my legal right given by god, punjab doesn’t get anything in return for its water and and still doesn’t have a capitol. The fight was for the rights that were promised, whole generation of Sikh were killed for no reason, Mr.Khalra was also killed for investigating, Shubeg Singh was falsely accused which made him switch sides. Please make videos on them.
3:48 please correct this............... Guru teg bhadur ji ne kurbani di thi. Aurangzeb begunah logon ka dharm parivartan krva rha tha or katleyam kar rha tha.....usney kha tha ki koe mhaan saksh ki kurbaani deni prhegi fer kashmiri pandits ne guru ji ke paas akar madad mangi......or unhone shaheedi di...........aurangzeb ne kha tha ki aapko aisa karne ki zarurat nhi hai. Unhone bola agar aaj koe hindu raha dharam parivartan krva rha hota jabardasti or tum mere paas atey....to tab bhi mai aisa hi krta
@@aslitarasingh No country can allow such propagandas in their country. Try to do similar referendum in cubec for its freedom . You will be behind bars for lifetime in canada.
There is no legality of this ,India is union of state, the word union is used for reason instead of federal. Such demand is directly against constitution that is India. It won't get you anywhere. Instead demand for cultural preservation , and govt funding to promote Sikhism, that is practical demand.
you do not understand 1984 , Punjab, sikh search history of Punjab search history of Maharaja Ranjit Singh Search history of Hari Singh nalwa Search history of Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale
You are too young to know, but there was violence unleashed by Khalistanis against Hindus that was almost as bad as the violence during partition before 1984. Between 1979 and 1984 Buses and trains would be stopped, Hindus would be lined up and machine gunned. The fact that Sikhs could do this to Hindus was something that I could never understand. Please dont say government agents did this.
O chal turda ho BC. Nalwa abdali bhindrawala ehde ton agge koi gal ee nae aundi thonu... Jehda guru granth saahib ch hajaraan vaar hindu gods da zikar aa o kyo aa? Saleo hankario jehda avde guru da nae ho sakea ohnu kitho ijjat milni aa BC aeve turi firdi aa lagoud
@petepipee6751 bro read the history properly. If you know about Black cat commando and dirty politics, you well know who killed Hindus brother in punjab
@@singhpuriavlogger Yes.. read history in which all the good guys are Khalistanis and all the bad guys are Hindus. All the Gurus were originally muslims and all the Hindus executed Sikh Gurus. All your mothers were originally Muslims , so why didnt you stay in Pakistan? why did you come to India in 1947? go away get lost
In a few points I do not agree with you, but thank you deshbhakt for making our concerns raise and tell how the Indian government is hypocrite then and now, When we stand for the nation on border people and government call us patriots but when we ask for our rights Indian authority call us Khalistani, please make a video on Jaswant Singh khalra.
It's honestly surprising how he didn't even include his name and any of his reports or findings considering how relevant it was to the Sikh gen0cide. The point is he then can't use the word "anti-sikh riots" and has to use the factual word gen0cide once he mentions Jaswant Singh Khalra's name and his research.
Violance breeds Violance. This is not surprising.. People who love Violance are encouraged with the rise of identity-based politics since Lal Krishna Advani's rise to power, that went on a mission to evoke hate and divide Indians in India and Abroad. There is of course a historical context to this story, but People are now more segregated based on religion..
@iasknowledge-jc2se willing ki baat alag hai willing toh har sikh krta hai because we had our own khalsa raj in the past. But bhindranwale was fighting for anandpur resolution not for khalistan.
I appreciate your videos bcs ur content is like real and factfulness but toaday Bro how beautifully you moulded the facts related to punjab 1984 ... representing only half of the information but y these things happened u dont actually cater to that .... What a talent 👏👏 ...... Yet i appreciate the solution that u gave at the end of video 👍
Im born in India and im indian no shit can break me from my country even it comes to my religion or these political shit who divide people on religion just love india 🇮🇳 ❤
@@jaswindersingh-lq6sl bhra thodi education lelo country hr government alag alag nai sarkar nai galat kita c pr is ch India nai ki galat krta asi india ch paida hoa aa mnu mera punjab boht pyaara pr is lae mnu india nu hate krn di ki lod india is in ❤️
Neither I am Khalistani nor i am in Canada . Why is one sided story is showing by indian Media . I have question for you guys why Hindu mob Went and attacked mellton GuruDwara sahib ?
I am an indian sikh , living in Punjab, and you are absolutely correct saying that there is no such extreme waves of demands for khalistan here in Punjab. People living in Canada or America try to be so called real sikh by asking for a separate nation
इंडियन की आजादी के लिए सिखों ने बहुत ज्यादा कुर्बानिया दी पर जब हम सिक्ख आजादी चाहते है तो हमारे हिन्दू भाई हमारे खिलाफ है आज हिंदु भाईयो के पास मौका सिखों का साथ देकर सिखों को आजादी दिलाने का
@@StudywithAbhijeetjaise karni sena ke leader ko di wasie tere us sher ko jail se to bahar aney de 😂 jail ke andar to safe hai mumbai police bhi nhi ja parahi
The situation was different during freedom struggle actually it was same rebellion against Britishers to stop economic exploitation against Indians . Bhagat singh himself named his party as socialist to help the poor farmers and justice for the victims of British government. There were indians too with the Britishers fighting against the freedom fighters.
Then why our state had to bear the consequences of partition? Did they asked us ? Did we sacrificed for this country only to get crushed in this hindu muslim chutiyapa?
The Sikh perspective has been entirely ignored, including how they were betrayed after India's independence. The perpetrators of the 1984 genocide were rewarded with high government positions, while the state systematically disappeared innocent Sikhs during the 1980s. Many Sikhs remain imprisoned in India even after completing their sentences. Today, people are increasingly aware of the injustices of the past and the ongoing issues Sikhs continue to face.
For your Kind information Lala Jagat narayan was shot dead because he abuses Guru Gobind Singh Maharaj ji. Ams nirankari was shot because he said Guru Sahab has 5 panj piyare and i will have 7 sitare and he also abused guru Granth Sahab maharaj ji. And about the 1983 Bus incident was that the bus no. was PNZ 197 and about 5 men stop the bus and killed 7 hindus and 4 sikhs who was no beard and was done by the black cats which worked for police and govt agencies one hindu was still alive and walked to nearby village and told people about the incident , you should talk about everything in deep as you missed many things to talk on.
“They tried to paint our Sikh brothers as the bad guys, but we know the real story. They got provoked by some thug moves, and those responsible need to answer for it. We got our Sikh brothers’ backs, no question.👊💯
Dont compare the term "Hindu rashtra" with khalistan as it is inappropriate to do so. I'll tell you why. The idea of "Hindu rashtra" is a loose idea which has been floated by some irrational people just like "Ghazwa-E-Hind". We all know both of these are meaningless and will never happen. Neither any demonstration or public gathering happen in these cases. But for khalistanis, "Khalistan" is an active agenda which includes holding public gatherings and violent demonstrations. You cant simply compare these two. 👍
There is so much trauma and pain in India's history - there is no absolute 'right' or absolute 'wrong'. The aim of this episode is not to dig up past wounds - but to serve as a reminder that we've been on this road and it does not end pretty. Reconciliation / Peace / Respect is the answer - not violence. Not then - Not now.
Do support / subscribe to the channel - to help is make more in-depth videos.
www.patreon.com/thedeshbhakt
Then why are you giving the wrong information
And misleading people
Bhindranwale ji never wanted Khalistan until Indra came with tanks on our holiest place
Again, this video is not about all of India's history. This was about the history and current situation with the Sikh diaspora and the Sikh minority in India. Your lack of proper research and casual indifference to the Sikh community's long-standing trauma were noted. You say you did not want to dig up past wounds - yes, you have. Why was proper research not done for this video? You think you did justice to the 1984 genocide and subsequent disappearances/killings? Can there be TRUE reconciliation without acknowledging the wrongdoings of the past? Look at your comment section and look at the Sikhs stating that they do not want Khalistan and expressing their pride and love for India ... and then look at the anti-Sikh comments. This is precisely what your video has furthered - an anti-Sikh agenda. This is what happens when you gloss over the shitty parts of our history and you have participated in this.
@@thedeshbhaktLTC!!!! Better learn from the Sikh history!! It doesn’t phase or bother us what lies and propagandas you spread. We are focused on our goal, which is Khalistan. ‘Khalsa Akal Purakh ki Fauj, Pargateyo Khalsa Parmatam ki mauj’!!!
1984 anti sikh Riots were Genocide by the government not Roits for which except court cases no punishment has been given, which actually triggers all these kind of issues but widely 95% Sikhs wants justice for themselves not Khalistan. Every Sikh and every Punjabi wants beautiful peaceful Punjab where Hindus and Sikhs have always lived like brothers. Sikhs and every Punjabi wants development corruption free strong Nation where rule of law prevails that imparts justice to everyone.
Vary mature mindset, we want peace and harmony 🙏
So true. You stole words from of my thought from thin air. When you get suppressed and centre tries to rule.over state this is when peope of panjab ate getting frustrated and too be honest those are the people who are choosing the path for a different nation. If gov wants they can find a peaceful paths for developing state of panjab but thier intentions are votes over burning panjab same as what congress did in 84.
just like genocides of Muslims in gujrat kashmir and assam
@@simratbakshi Bakshi g so all previous Sikh Politicians could have choose to be Not Corrupt to set up an example. So don't bring religion to be not corrupt or else why there are separate Gurdwaras for Ramdassi(schedule caste ) and different for Jatts
@niteshkhanna3641 Khanna ji Politician is a Politician, oh koi wi hoye, Hindu Sikh Muslim whatever, v rarely u will find any honest Politician, u took me wrong, I m nowhere saying Sikh Politicians are not corrupt, I just want to say we as public should keep such deterrents which force them to be honest like major European countries do so that Rule of Law prevails and every citizen can enjoy equality and justice and no one will have anything to say against the country. We as public should keep law above everything including Religion.
I’m an Indian Sikh. All I wish for is peace and prosperity for my country. What Punjab want is to get rid of drugs and violence..
Or paji... Sikh community Hindustaan ki shaan hai.
You don't know anything about state conspiracy against minority that time ... sant jarnail singh was jathedaar of taksal was 14th .... if he was sepratist show me a y statement against anyone
Jo bole so Nehal satsri akal.. Jai Hind bhai
@ every community bro 💯🫰🏻
@@kirpalsingh4813 he shouldn’t have been hiding inside golden temple . If he was a great man there was no reason for him to hide like that
I am a Proud SIKH, a Proud PUNJABI, a Proud INDIAN.
so are 99% sikh brothers.
Ager 99% Sikh India ke sath rehna chahete hen to fir Punjab main Refrendum kerwa hi den.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@narinderdhillon5323Kyu Punjab me Sirf Sikh hi rehte hai kya Rasgulle?? 33% hindu bhi rehte hai Punjab me samza Abdul 🐖😂🤣🤣
@@narinderdhillon5323 referendum is not by all Sikhs but some Pro Khalistan people who are a miniscule %ge.
😂😂😂😂
Fact Check / Additions
02:00 Mandir k andar ladai nhi thi, bahar thi and reason was - Indian Council ka 1 person came from India to Canada to have a camp to check old pension people and get them life certificate. But due to anger in few people because of the past happening during 1984 and onwards, kisaan andolan, Indian govt bad behaviour etc. People just oppose Indian govt by raising flags and slogans and a wrong narrative was set by Indian govt IT cell itself that Sikh have attacked the mandir, where it was just like a protest but many Hindu people came started giving abuse to the other side, smashing their flags and started targeting various sikh personalities. Then after some time a small fight started just outside the Mandir just because of the Indian govt decision to hold that camp in Mandir premises and many Sikh also opposed going to Mandir for such work. And then Hindus surrounded the Sikh Gurdwara as well that the media is never showing in the clips. Godi Media showing only one sided news. Indian govt fault!
05:00 Nehru promised but didn't complete his promise, 1947 batwara suffered 98 percent people in punjab of both sides and only 2 percent of whole India and Pakistan. Indian govt fault!
06:10 Akali Dal ne nhi Punjab ne Dhoka dekha, Ambala and many others were Punjabi speaking cities at that time but they were given to Haryana. Chandigarh was the permanent capital of Punjab and temporary for Haryana (the govt gave Haryana 5 years to choose a capital but they failed) People don't know about it. No center govt also looked back to their decisions. Indian govt fault!
07:00 Galti yaha foreign Sikhs ki nhi thi, Indian govt ki thi jisne jootha promise kiya, Woh toh sirf govt ko promised cheej krne ko bol rhe the. Indian govt fault!
08:40 Bhindrawala didn't ask for a separate state before 1983, he simply said govt to follow some concerns like 1. Female should never kept in Police Stations at night as at that time rapes and other actions were very common. 2. Drugs should totally vanish as they harm the body. 3. Dowry should be banned. 4. If yamuna water can help Haryana easily with low cost then why Punjab water SYL to be made. 5. Many more good points just research on it. And it was not identity politics. Many hindu families also came to him for help. And he helped without any other thought. After 1983 when govt didn't helped in great thoughts of Bhindrawala then he asked for a seperate state with seperate rules. Check your facts. Also research who made Bhindrawala such popular it was Indian Govt itself Indira Gandhi itself. Whose fault?😂 Indian Govt fault!
10:00 again research on this galti nirankaari ne ki, bhindwala ne police ko complain ki, police denied and said jo krna khud krlo, and that happened. Indian govt fault!
11:30 bus mai bomb wali cheeje Indian govt ki tarf se krwaai gye not Bhindrawala, agr kisi 3rd person ne bhi kiya ho toh why blame Bhindrawala. Even govt doesn't have a single proof about it. Balki Bhindrawala went to meet families of affected people during bus blasts. But govt ne sirf wrong information sabke saamne rakhi. Indian govt fault!
12:00 Giving a defence training is never wrong. From Guru Gobind Singh ji we are told to train ourself for Self Defence we are even told to practice Gatka, train weapons, Horse riding, latest armour, guns etc. Subeg Singh one of greatest officers of Indian Army joined Bhindrawala ki research krna agr online content mila, toh pta chle ga Delhi se Punjab aate sme Police ki checking for only turban wearing people. Police didn't hesitate ki koi army ka itna bara officer jisko Indian govt se itne awards mille h, jisne apni jaan desh k liye apni muthi mai rakhi huee h, aap uski checking kr rhe ho. Police ne salut maarni ki jagha fir bhi checking ki. Bhindrawala ne base bnaya was never wrong, from past from Guru Gobind Singh ji kille (forts) and Takhat are meant to be the prime positions for orders of the state. Every Maharaja, prime minister, president comes to Darbar Sahib and bow their heads. Even akal takhat can punish the Maharaja, CM, PM, president etc. For Sikhs Akaal Takhat is the supreme head, in past also it gave punishments. Its not wrong to have a base. Aapke according Jo attack kr rha woh sahi h jo self defence k liye prepare kr rha woh galat. Agr Bhindrawala ko pakarna bhi tha with proof usse wrong proof krte, usse charcha krte, demands toh sunte, there were many ways. attacking akaal takhat with bullets and tanks was wrong. Indian govt fault!
13:00 Hostage nhi bnaya tha na kisi ko roka tha, woh sab normally Gurdwara darshan krne aae the. Indian govt fault!
13:45 Akaal Takhat pe attack Indian force ne kia on orders on Indira Gandhi, toh badla Indira Gandhi se liya naa ki pure desh mai Hindu ko mara, but on other hand jo Delhi, Kanpur etc jaise cities mai Sikh the unhe kyu mara gya. Un mai bhot toh shayad Khalistan k against bhi ho but kyu. Why actors like Amitabh Bachhan said khoon ka badla khoon openly all over India via radio and newspaper. Why congress leaders (part of govt) said Bada tree girne par dharti kaampti h. Jail mai se sabhi terrorist ko attack krne k liye chor dia. Ab bolo kon h galt. Indian govt fault!
15:00 jo bomb kia was very wrong but all this was anger started only because of the govt as govt 1980s and 1990s mai bhot sikhs ko bina mtlb se maar dia. Also research on Jaswant Singh Khalra listen to his speech on youtube also. Indian govt fault!
17:00 bhot logo ki families jo 1980s and 1990s mai affect huee unke bache foreign countries mai jaa kr settle ho gye and because of all that happened in the past due to govt, they are totally angered and against the Indian govt. And recent incidents like farmer protest (jo ki peaceful hona tha sirf delhi jaa kr betha na to oppose the laws waha kyu lathi charge huee, tear gas use huee, water cannons use huee, bullets bhi use huee etc) Sidhu Moosewala song banned SYL. Indian govt fault!
20:00 Canada is a different country, India keeps on interfering. It's a Canadian choice. Why India killed an Canadian citizenship in Canada. Maan lete h woh galt h but sahi toh Bishnoi bhi nhi h, usse kon maarega? Ram Raheem jisse jail huee woh saal mai har maheene parol pe bahr kese, usse kyu nhi maar dete ho? Indian govt fault!
After 21:00 you were right on track, we just wanted everything to be sorted by the Govt. Ab or kya hi bolu. From Feb till now the main borders of Punjab and Haryana are closed by the Haryana Govt even if the High Court has ordered to open it. The government itself doesn't respect Indian law. INDIAN GOVT FAULT!!!
Thanks for reading such a big message. Maybe I am wrong for some points, facts or I didn't pointed on that. But I tried to give my 2 3 hrs on every single point. Galti maaf krna, acha lga toh reply to it.
You are 100% absolutely correct my friend!
These youtubers can’t tell the truth. They are biased and always says army attacked Akal takhat because Sant ji was there. What about other 19 gurudwaras which was attacked by army. There is only one solution Khalistan. I hope we get it one day. Waheguru
@@LoveBrar-c1dcant we stay together isnt there any other option because many of my friends are sikh and i dont want them to become citizens of other country
Also as of pannu kalistani map including Uttarakhand which is hindus most holiest land like kedarnath
Can we make any autonomous state like giving whole power to punjab like hongkong
Please reply i want to ask a Khalistan support to understand properly
Pin this comment!!
👏👏👏
How Rajiv Gandhi and his party said “khoon ka badla khoon “ and did a genocide of Indian Sikhs!
Tabhi to Punjab me Congress maximum time government banati hai😮
That’s why I do support Khalistan.
@@kartikrajsingh1895 Beta that is Bharat Bhumi
Keep dreaming.
@@sandeepverma-yg7wlit is the lesser of the evils now
Congress is lesser of the evils now that’s why it is selected and bjp is totally against Sikhs now and Rahul Gandhi is standing with Sikhs…
With due respect, Bhindranwale never asked for seperate Khalistan . He asked for Anandpur sahib resolution to be implemented.
He only said if you want to seperate Punjab then it's okay but he didn't ask for Khalistan.
Nor any sikh in current India wants Khalistan
You can just go through the comments section where many shikhs are saying they want khalistan bro . Tbh I know shikhs are not khalistan and Khalistani are not shikha but it's too difficult for us to recognise which one real or not.
@@adityakumarranjan4429 same with Sanghis and Hindus
whoever he was, killing of innocent Hindus is not a solution
Are you still sleeping bro? Amritpal won from punjab??? He openly says we want khalistan??
Exactly, all sikhs ever demanded was the ANANDPUR SAHIB RESOLUTION to be passed
Khalistan or Hindu Rashtra ... Are equally hollowness of bigots and politicians who divert public fron real questions ... We want peaceful world and society 🙏
All i know that Neverending mahabharat started in bharat in an era when only sanatanis existed. Makes me wonder when was there ever a peace in this age old civilization.
Finally a decent & well educated comment! What you said is absolutely true.
@@jainravinderkaur 100% right brother
@@Shubhamfact-yh3zb ब्राह्मण ( वैदिक) धर्म की वर्ण व्यवस्था, अन्याय ही कारण है बाकी धर्म की उगम ता के लिए हिंदू धर्म की मूल व्यवस्था ही लोगों की अलग धर्म बनने या धर्म परिवर्तन का कारण है
@@Shubhamfact-yh3zb 😂😂😂😂 kush bhi 😂😂😂
Thanks
In 1978, nirankaris killed 13 peaceful sikhs, but Indian government at that time gave no punishment to any nirankari. Is this a justice?
📡☁️🛰️🌌📶🌇🏘️📺💻📱🧽🧠🕉️⚔️🪯☪️✝️🇮🇳
Source?
Mint.11:00 andh bakat giving half information. Laala Jagat kutta guru gobind singh ke againt bolta tha
@@Yohaan_mehta Go to library and check newspapers of that time.
@@Yohaan_mehta check news articles or read sikh history part 3 by Ajmer singh
Lived in Punjab 🇮🇳 for 23 years and now in Canada 🇨🇦
Lots of my friends were Hindu, always went to Mandir with them and they came with me to Gurudwara.
who is spreading hate ?
I am Sikh,Not a supporter of Khalistan
Video missing lots of information on this complex matter
No country should be based on religion
Punjab is motherland of everyone who speaks Punjabi ❤
Please go on ground level to get to know Punjab issues….
Love Punjab ❤ 🇮🇳
Many Hindus masquerade Sikhs to downgrade Sikhs movement for a homeland
@@ARSHDEEP-qr1uh also hindus dont hate sikh, if they hate all gurudwaras will not be standing outside Punjab and sikh population would decreased as in Afghanistan and Pakistan. I am from Patna lives near Takht Sri Patna Sahib which I visit during every Festival.
@@ARSHDEEP-qr1uh patna aake dekh le hindu roj gurudwara jate hai, jinne attack kia wo galat hai, tum log muslims ko kyu kuch nhi bol pata...
@@ARSHDEEP-qr1uh tu khud dekh la apni soch, mandir girana ke baat kar raha hai
There are misguided people in every community and country. We should stand together as human beings first and then as Hindu/sikh.
Sikhs are the most generous, kind and respectful community and an integral part of Indian identity. Their contribution of building India what it is today is really incomparable.
Yes
Very soon South India is going to start demanding a separate nation due to neglection.
Accha ji.
WhatsApp University.
Keep dreaming
Beta tera baap bhi Bharat ko tod nahi sakta
Keep dreaming.
Yes as a Tamil we want Dravida Nadu.
North India is taking the fruit while we work for our own
@@aaatd7550 ?
Keep dreaming 😌
Kabristani
@@aaatd7550 u are kabristani
I am a Sikh who lives in Jammu and Kashmir,I am a proud Indian! Bhagat Singh gave his life for this nation,He always spoke about Unity! These khalistani’s live in Canada and speak about forming a country within a country!
Neither you are a Sikh or neither you live in kashmir..
@@sohaibasghar86 and you are cheap Converted Copy.
@@sohaibasghar86kuch bhi
@@sohaibasghar86 what’s you problem F. ??
@@sohaibasghar86😂achha to abb pakistani batayega...kun ky h
Not a sikh riots ‘ sikh genocide thaaa ok sir
Indira Gandhi & congress ne kia ....bjp nehi
@@WRATH19sab same hai... Greater khalistan banna chahiye pura punjab leke...
@@sakibkhan-qs4ohask pakistan first. Most of khalistan is there.
@@sakibkhan-qs4oh Pakistan pucho dega ki nehi
But why did it start I wonder? Why suddenly they started asking for separate state 😮
गलत स्टोरी बता रहे हो आप
पंजाबी सूबा के समय 1955 में जो Golden Temple पर हमला हुआ वो भी बताओ
1984 में जब Golden Temple पर हमला किया इंडियन गवर्मेंट ने उस समय 41 और गुरुद्वारों पर हमला किया गया था इंडियन गवर्मेंट द्वारा वहा पर कौन से संत जरनैल सिंह भिंडरेवाले जी बैठे
Kabi nahi batayenge
Bhindrawale ❌ bhopadiwala✅
@mratheist919 जिसु अंदरि ताति पराई होवै तिस दा कदे न होवी भला ॥
Meaning - जो इंसान किसी से नफरत करता है उसका कभी भी भला नही होता है
but unfortunately still a number's of Sikh from India always do support the modis India which the hindutva terrorist dreamt to make Akhandbharat. they call simply "nimak haram" they never do care of Sikhs died by Hindus in 1984 Sikh genocide or most heartfelt things destroying the holiest place of Sikhism Golden temple, how the hell they could forget those incidents 😶🤕☹️
Bruh, why you feel like a bigoted muslim who pretends to be a sikh sympathizer just so as to defame Hindus. @@rabbythemixgamer3756
Thanks
Thanks Umer! - you can also consider becoming an annual member via Patreon.com/thedeshbhakt
Just 1 minute into the video and there's already glaring errors:
Jarnail Singh Bhindrawale never demanded Khalistan. Neither was the pre 1984 turmoil was related to separatism. His demand was for Anandpur Sahib Resolution which demanded greater federal structure (to which the delhi government agreed and back flipped several times).
Separatism actually emerged AFTER the Darbar Sahib attack because Sikhs were deeply hurt and the attack validated the stand of separatist micro minority that existed since 1947.
Pre 84 there were Hindu Mahasabha and it's proxies trying their best to create a communal environment in Punjab (just how they are doing with Muslims).
This is oversimplification over a very complex subject and a very complex personality. I urge you to reach out to regional reporters from that era and read more books. (e.g. Jagtar Singh)
i am a long term viewer and generally enjoy your content. Please continue with your work.
there are several other inaccuracies: for instance, Those 15 people that died during Nirankari clash were peaceful protesting Sikhs, the Hindu Mahasabha / Jan Sangh goons were in bed with police when police opened fire.
Why don't we see a similar demand of separate khalistan in Pakistan side? I never understood why sikhs even defend musl1ms, we're you guys not kicked enough by them already in Afghanistan and Pakistan. I see how smartly you brought Muslim as victim.
@@bajwa401yeah blame it on Hindus..and keep defending congress ...real perpetrators of sikh genocide 😂
Asking for "greater federalism" challenges the overarching centre . It used to be the norms last to last century for empires some regions had their own dominions.. but modern countries cannot survive much with large part of its land being a dominion out of the union.
Kashmir was such and if that referendum or whatever you call that was followed every state would have asked for their kind of autonomy and that would have very much weakened the overarching central powers.
So therefore to suit the modern times need for strong centre for strong nation its government cannot just let every part of to be ruled by its own and to retain this strength by crushing ANY VOICE THAT DEMANDS AUTONOMY IS CLOSE TO ASKING FOR DOMINION IS VERY MUCH CLOSE TO ASK FOR SEPARATION.
@@bajwa401these are just guided by government to do these things just for likes and views
A proud Indian Sikh from Jammu whose family migrated after the Rawalpindi massacares of 1947. Im now living in Bangalore as a software professional. My family has seen it all.
I love India and pray for Peace
😂
Its genocide not riots
Agreed, but why do you guys still vote congress ?
@@KotgireTejas What other options do they have? 1. BJP
Who is actively killing us?
2. AAP Whose actively putting elected leaders in jail
Without any trial?
3. And finally, Congress, who did indeed try to genocide us, but right now, the lesser of all evils.
It's repeated soon if you guys were not stop attacking on Hindus in Canada US Uk 💀 remember
@KotgireTejas because congress is far far better then bjp . Due to congress we are living till now otherwise Militant RSS and BJP makes us terrorist and kill
@@KotgireTejas the whole country voted Rajiv Gandhi after the 1984 genocide. You people gave Rajiv Gandhi 400+ seats after the genocide, why?
Punjab chose Congress because there was no better party, they now chose AAP because it was an option. Who are you to question their right to vote?
Thanks for presenting all side ❤ really love your content
Akash, Please do not lie if you are a true Indian, at 10:09 you said sikhs attacked and 13 people died in the clash.. why you didnt say 13 unarmed sikhs were killed and no nirankari was even injured?
It was a peaceful protest march by Sikhs against Nirankaris and Nirankari supporters killed sikhs with open fire. You can get an FIR copy from Chandigarh Police. Also, no trial was against Nirankaris and Nirankari baba got safe passage to Delhi by police after massacre. This incident created unrest in Sikh leadership. Thats why Sikhs killed nirankari to take 13 Sikhs death revenge. Please don’t lie.. Hindu majiorty reporters never justify with Sikhs when they narrate story
Sikhs don't killed indian egencies killed hindu. Sikhs only fight against cruelty. Binderawala never wanted an attack, wrong information u gave.
I do not support Khalistan, but your research on Sikhism and Punjab’s history seems lacking. I recommend spending some time in Punjab, visiting villages, and speaking with Punjabi Sikhs to understand Punjab’s issues since 1947. This could give you the insight needed to make a more informed video.
so why can't sikhs solve it themselves? bengalis maharashtrians tamilians even orissa does it! Just can't get my head around why such an industrious community cannot solve it's issues
@@rajeevgangal542true
@@rajeevgangal542Because an entire state system is working AGAINST the sikhs
@kazinaher7808 don't u remember, when Muslims wanted separate land , what happened??
Most killed by them were Sikhs in Pakistan..
Partition always brings migration, enmity and killing due to otherness..
The victim of partition ie Sikhs should not perpetrate another episode of victim hood..
It was divide rule by British, which is stil supported by successive state of English people like Canada and USA to keep india or this subcontinent under war and rivalry
@amar08888 so true. Getting information from internet posted by people outside panjab is biased. Go and spend a week in panjab will make lot of sense what people of panjab are, want they went through post independence and present. We all want to live in india with dignity. Panjab sikhs and Hindus have done a lot for the country but the centre suppression and control over panjab id suffocating. This is the reason punjab always have opted for regional political stand. Man I love your videos but sorry mate you lacking a big time.
Mr. Deshbhakt tell me why till date KS Brar, Kamalnath and, Tytler and Amitabh Bachchan is not behind the jail and they all were involved in Anti Sikh Riot 1984
How ?
@@KaspaBitcoinPushpinder
Please also tell us why Sikhs were not massacred in other parts of a 'hindu majority's India?
Why does Punjab keep electing congis?🤣🤣🤣
Stop this drama...your state has corrupt politicians who can't see beyond agriculture which has brought about this nonsense in the first place- and when someone tries to get you off this farming addiction you bring in foreign funded toolkits....not gonna work anymore..
Tell me why Punjab still votes for Congress, despite the 84 riots.
Congress party rewarded the rioters by promoting them.
@@hogginarmocount9562 BJP daalal spotted
After The incident happened at the temple at brampton around 400 hindu nationalist tried to attack on a gurudwara in malton and used bad language for sikh religion. Sir if you gonna talk about the incident please represents both side not just one.
@@bubbleteaeait was attacked I live near the gurudwara sahib
Not a good idea to throw stones if you live in glass houses. First your people provoke then come drying crying like a baby?
Love and support from Punjab to Your courageous work Akash 🇮🇳
Bullshit it is, he doesn't know anything about Sikhi
@@ajeebdastan1152 what did you know about Punjab ?
Akash you are a akhalistahni too.
You got facts wrong here, those 15 people killed were not from nirankari sect . It was the other way around
Source?
@@Yohaan_mehtacheck news sites articles history
Aryee bhai thodi se mehnat kro gye to mil jea ga
Other way around mathlab?
Ulta @@sandeepmenon2822
@stupidtravel u r right… and police did not arrest any nirankari at that time…
I live in Amritsar and i am 32years old, yeh sb suddenly after Farmers protest hi dekhne ko mila hai, Pehle non punjabi ko kuch ni pta tha khalistan wagera ka, Yaha local panjab mei kuch nhi hai, seems like GOVT is behind all this sudden fueling of this movement.
amritsar gurdaspur is full of hindus never heard any problem i am from gurdaspur celebrated shivratri gurpurab whole my life still when i go back to panjab we celebrate my friends are from hindu religion.... This negative image is cuz of some fudhus outside india and Indian govt first indira and now modi..... vajpayee and manmohan singh govt was alright
Acha indian government canada protest karwa rahi hai....bhai kuch toh logic laga
ThE Saffron Establishment is all Instigating & Provoking the various Organisations to create atmosphere of Seperatism, same like how the Hindi Cow Belt is getting Financial, Economic, Infrastructure projects, money, revenue ...by snatching, looting from Maharshtra, South India.....and you can see Post 2025, in next 10 years Soth Indian states rising for In-equality, In-justice will demand Seperarte Nattion, Identity .....because of North India favouritism by union india........
same way Sikhs, then Jammu-Kashmir, then Manipur, North-East will RISE for all seperate identty......and all this is because of HINDUTVA SAFFRON AATANK-WADII SANGHATAN SPREADING THEIR TENTACLES TO INVADE, INTRUDE IN OTHER REGIONS WHICH IS NON-HINDI COW BELT REGIONS......
@@shanu3588 Sikho ko khalistani kon bolta rehta hai social media ke comments mai?
Bro mai international media aur newspaper regular monitor krta hu...jis taraf regular intervals pr Canada k pm, police, minister k bayaan aate hain..india virodh me.. mujhe nhi lgta India, Canada jitna is mamle ko tul de rha🤔🤔
❤United PANJAB ਜ਼ਿੰਦਾਬਾਦ❤
ਪੰਜਾਬ-ਹਰਿਆਣਾ-ਹਿਮਾਚਲ ,ਕਸ਼ਮੀਰ,
ਲੇਹ-ਲੱਦਾਖ, ਚੜ੍ਹਦਾ-ਪੰਜਾਬ, ਲਹਿੰਦਾ
-ਪੰਜਾਬ, ਉੱਤਰੀ ਰਾਜਸਥਾਨ ਏਕ ਕਰੋ
@@TheKingHunter8711 ਖਾਲਸਾ ਰਾਜ ਜ਼ਿੰਦਾਬਾਦ
The Massacre of Sikhs in India in 1984 after the assassination of PM Indra Gandhi is unforgettable and unforgivable
@@adamharris1406
Aww...
To all the SIKHS who cry for the Sikh genocide-
In 1947 post the gandhi-vadh by nathuram godse, All major newspapers flashed the news -
'GANDHI ASSASINATED BY CHITPAVAN HINDU BRAHMIN', they did not say killed by an assassin- most newspapers were congress controlled.
Within hours, the houses of the community across maharashtra were burnt, men lynched, women and children assaulted/raped...NOT ONE SINGLE FIR WAS FILED, NOBODY KNOWS ABOUT THE PROGROM because the community is too small, despite its outsize contributions to the nation- be it the peshwas, tilak, gokhale, savarkar and countless others...
The only evidence left was CHITPAVAN Brahmins emigrating to cities from their ancestral villages and towns and leaving India.
The community EVEN today is extremely succesful and patriotic despite every attempt by the likes of Sharad Pawar and the radical left to paint them as villians.
If they can stay true to the nation, and continue to fight versus anti-nationals...why DO the Sikhs believe that they deserve a special treatment for having their near and dear ones murdered by the same political ideology which did not use force against the partition of India?
If you want justice, target every congi politician responsible for the 1984 riots, because God knows....not one congressi british-islamic bootlicker has ever got justice till date, for any of the atrocities they have committed versus any of the Indic religions....the sanatanis are not responsible for what happened to the Sikhs in riots- if that were the case, Sikhs should have been killed ALL across the country.
Savarkar's Hindu rashtra explicitly mentions its HINDU identity based on 'sons of the soil'...and not on basis of religion....AND IT WILL BECOME A REALITY- whether whitewashing LINDUS like banerjee want it or not!!
Like that some riots happened in India, as it is also non forgettable.
Also terrsm happend for separate kalistn state before 1984 also unforgettable and unforgivable
@@sudarsanbabu2900first learn to differentiate between riots and massacre then talk. Please don't act like a parrot, start analyzing what you hear.
@@gjn17 if you don’t know the ground reports please don’t comment on the bases of google knowledge as it is manipulated most of the time by government.
Canada citizen:- we want khalistan!!!
India:-From Canada!!
Canada:- No from India!!
India:- Why don't you come in india!!😏😏
Canada:- WE WON'T WE ARE CANADIAN...🥲🥲
😂😂😂
@@yaduyadav--- achaaa dand katon nikalde
wo issi liye kyuki india me democracy ya freedom of speech sirf constitution aur kitaabon me hi raih gya hai koi agar sach bole ya apne rights ki baat kre to uspe fir kr di jaati hai ya sidhi jail aur terrorist, sepratist ka tag de diya jata hai but canada me democracy aur freedom of speech ki value hai issi liye wo wahi se apne logo k haqq ki awaaz utha te kyuki india me to jhat internet band kr dete hai aur news wale jhuthi khabre failana shuru kr dete hai so it is safe ki khud safe raho baad me saath walo ki help kro jaise airplane me bolte hai pehle khud mask lagaye baadme dusre ki help kre mill gya na reason?? ab khush.
Khalistan zindabad 🚩🚩
@@amansinghchandigarh1455 jab India aajao tab kehna saamne🤣🤣
it seems you r an idiot, never fought for a your right in corrupt govt system.
My father once told me that the left wing in India and the right wing in India are the wings of the same vulture!
You proved him right today, Akash.
India is union of state, not federal of state, so you can demand culture promotion and preservation, and create better developed punjab, instead of fueling hate and violence by waging war against the country
Khalistani 😂😂
@@pahulpreetsingh7854 True ..yeh sab khalse ke virodh main hi hain.
@@techsa2675hindurashtri 😂😂
Kaneddda me hi raho yaha Matt ana Nehi to put diye jaoge waha hi kholistan banao and south asia me chaiye to paxtani punjab leke banao akhir Punjab ka 60 percent to paxtani ke paas hai.
Best analysis brother....good luck
The only thing Sikhs want is to save Punjab and a separate identity as sikh not to be considered as hindu and a sense of security that we not face injustice as minority
Come on, Sikhs not facing any injustice in India, also Hindus or Hinduism do not interfere in any religion, there r full freedom to do whatever u want where Hindus are in majority.
@Vthepeoplefirst 1984 preparators are still off from law for 40 years, if it is not injustice then we should have a land for ourselves to protect our brethren
What are you talking about? They openly attacked to show their identity? Sir, Punjab is not only in Punjab. Punjab is now in every city of India, in music, in food and culture. You cannot separate them form India and Indian culture.
@@Vthepeoplefirst you won’t decide it. We would decide . Also India is an artificial country created by British by illegally occupying dozens of nations
We don't want to call these 'sickh' people as Hindus either
Apni identity ko g me daal lo
Our religion is much more fuller
I am a proud Indian Sikh, I only wish for peace in the world and continued growth & development in my country. These little pockets of violance dont represent us.
pls dont blame hindus for sikh genocide blame the congress party congressis can never be hindus congressis are fake hindus and anti hindus let me tell u that the congressis and many of thier muslism supporter marked sikh houses in delhis with red cross at that time my parents and grandparents had hidden and given protection to 4 sikh families in our house so v hindus love our sikh brothers. but the real villain is congress and this congress need to be finshed befroe they do any other violnece in india
th-cam.com/video/zMMM7EXwquQ/w-d-xo.htmlsi=vrLfr_rrfhsiODvE
1984 में भी सिखों को घर में घुसकर मारा था।
@garryj7845 har har mahadev waheguru ji ka Khalsa waheguru ji ki Fateh
You forgot 1984 already!
Ahha why don't they run a voting pole for khalistan if you so called indian sikh think that only a few wants khalistan 😂
I am from punjab mate. I have watched all your videos and love from Punjab. But this video is one side view, please have a deep look on the things happened on Punjab. Conclusion is lack of knowledge is more dangerous 🙏🏻❤️
Genuine question, what percent of Sikhs want khalistan?
Never ever I would have asked this question because I always thought Sikhs are proud citizens of Bharat but the amount of people I saw in support of Amritpal made me question myself
@@KotgireTejas I respect you and your question. Let me explain mate. Just forgot about Khalistan for a moment.
Please look at Farmers especially Punjab’s. Are they getting their full rights? Nowadays, their are paddy season going on but Center government and Punjab Government are not lifting the paddy. Why Farmers have to protest every time? Some farmers are on haryana border. They are struggling to get their actual rights. If you genuinely want to know about please read more about what’s going on their.
Next one is about killing, why the punjabi youngsters are killed nowadays. For example, You know about Sidhu Moosewala the legend singer. Why his parents are not getting justice even know who killed him. Are you guys aware of that?
Third the disrespect of Shiri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is increasing day by day.
No body support Punjab and sikhs on these factors. So if we say about all these things everybody called us Khalistani.
@@Sukhmansingh-j1j so much to say but let me just tell you that majority of the people in the country respects Sikhs. Like you can go to any remote village in any state of the country and ask them about Sikhs, almost everyone will have a positive opinion. Calling everyone khalistani happens only on the internet
@@KotgireTejas Yes I know, but it is not just about respect we all want to live good. We all want full rights not only sikhs. That’s why I am saying everyone should stand for every person who is struggling to get their own rights.
@@Sukhmansingh-j1jdo you think Punjab farmers are of special superior category? Why do you think you deserve some special treatment? All farmers on India have various challenges.
4:26 Raja ranjit singh nhiii❎
Raja ranjit singh ji✅
Give respect broo🙏🏽
i am also sikh and we all want to live with different religion people of hindu,muslim,jain are all brothers ,this is what our guru's have told us , i am sad about this government which does not focus on punjab but i have hopes
वोट भी करते जाओ बीजेपी को 😂
जिनको वोट दिया है वो केजरीवाल और कांग्रेस क्या कर रही है 😂
Salute to you, Jugraj ji, from Bengal.
We don't need religious identities to define us. Being responsible Indians is enough.
The constitution is our guide.
fake Sikh
To all the SIKHS who cry for the Sikh genocide-
In 1947 post the gandhi-vadh by nathuram godse, All major newspapers flashed the news -
'GANDHI ASSASINATED BY CHITPAVAN HINDU BRAHMIN', they did not say killed by an assassin- most newspapers were congress controlled.
Within hours, the houses of the community across maharashtra were burnt, men lynched, women and children assaulted/raped...NOT ONE SINGLE FIR WAS FILED, NOBODY KNOWS ABOUT THE PROGROM because the community is too small, despite its outsize contributions to the nation- be it the peshwas, tilak, gokhale, savarkar and countless others...
The only evidence left was CHITPAVAN Brahmins emigrating to cities from their ancestral villages and towns and leaving India.
The community EVEN today is extremely succesful and patriotic despite every attempt by the likes of Sharad Pawar and the radical left to paint them as villians.
If they can stay true to the nation, and continue to fight versus anti-nationals...why DO the Sikhs believe that they deserve a special treatment for having their near and dear ones murdered by the same political ideology which did not use force against the partition of India?
If you want justice, target every congi politician responsible for the 1984 riots, because God knows....not one congressi british-islamic bootlicker has ever got justice till date, for any of the atrocities they have committed versus any of the Indic religions....the sanatanis are not responsible for what happened to the Sikhs in riots- if that were the case, Sikhs should have been killed ALL across the country.
Savarkar's Hindu rashtra explicitly mentions its HINDU identity based on 'sons of the soil'...and not on basis of religion....AND IT WILL BECOME A REALITY- whether whitewashing LINDUS like banerjee want it or not!!
India (Republic of India) didn't exist before 1947. Italy didn't exist before 1860. Turkey didn't exist before 1921, Germany didn't exist before 1871, Saudi Arabia didn't exist before 1932 and so on. Concept of Countries was invented in Europe in the 18th century. Before the invention of the concept of countries, there were only empires and kingdoms. Germany, France, Italy, Austria, Denmark, Poland, Switzerland, Slovenia, Netherlands, lechesiten etc were created after fall of Holy Roman empire and subsequent kingdoms in Europe.
Turkey was created after the fall of the Ottomans empire in 1923. Dozens of countries were created based on nationalities after the fall of the Ottomans empire in 1922. Saudi Arabia was created in 1932 after the fall of Ottomans Empire in 1922. Saudi Arabia didn't exist When Prophet Muhammad was born in Mecca. Italy was created in 1860 by merging various small kingdoms of Italian nationality. Similarly, Germany was created in 1871 by merging various small kingdoms of German nationality. Similarly, all European countries were created based on nationalities. Europe and Middle East was united under various empires and kingdoms for most of the history just like India. India was the name for the region east to river Indus. It was never a country before 1947 but a region or subcontinent where various empires and kingdoms existed just like in Europe, Middle East or other parts and continents of world.
Now the question is what is nation and nationality? A nation is a society that shares a common language, culture, and history and has shared interests. For example English, German, Italian, Turkish, French, Russian, Dutch, Spanish, Arabs, Persian, Kurds, Japanese, Korean, Punjabi, kashmiri, Marathi, Bengali, Tamil, Malyalam, Thai etc are nations and a country based on single nation or nationality or where a single nationality dominates culturally, politically, in economy and military is called a nation state. Most countries in Europe or 'civilised world' are based on single nationalities and are nation states or simply called nations.
There are dozens of nations within India and Pakistan. And hence India and Pakistan are union of nations or multinational countries. Nations are Punjab, Kashmir, sindh, Baluchistan, Gujarat, Bengal, Maharashtra, Tamilnadu etc. And in modern civilised world countries are created on basis of nationality like the countries in Europe (England, France, Germany, Poland, Norway, Sweden, Croatia etc) or in Asia (Korea, Japan, China,Thailand, Philippines etc) and Bangladesh etc are countries based on nationalities.
Among the 650 major nations in the world, the nations in the union of India are one of the largest nations in the world. After Han Chinese Mandrain, Spanish, Anglo Saxons English, and Arabic
Bengali - world's 5th largest nationality
Punjabi- 10th largest nationality in world
Marathi- 13th largest nationality in world
Hindustani- 14th largest
Telugu- 15th largest nationality
Tamil- 17th largest nationality in world
Gujarati- 24th largest nationality in world
Bhojpuri- 25th largest
Kannada- 29thth largest
Malyalam- 30th largest
Oriya- 32nd largest
Maithili- 40th largest
Awadhi- 46th largest
Assamese- 65th largest
Haryanvi, Marwari, Magahi, Deccan, etc in top 100 nationalities of world.
(Hindi, Urdu are not nationalities but artificial languages developed from Hindustani language and imposed on some nations in some regions, with only few native speakers. These regions have their own nationalities and languages. Hindustani is a nationality in western Uttar pradesh with Hindustani as native language).
Republic of India was created in 1947 out of the British Indian empire on the basis of two nations bogus theory. Two nations were assumed as Islam and hindusim. But in reality, Islam and Hinduism are not nations. India and Pakistan were not created based on nationalities but on two nation (Islam Hinduism) bogus theory. Hence, these countries are based on religions. On the other hand, Bangladesh is a nation state which was created on the basis of Bangla nationality in 1971 (5th biggest nationality in world).
Three predominant civilisations in Republic of India, Indo Aryans, Dravidian and Sino Tibetic ( North East nations in the Republic of India) don't share anything although the first two civilisations share religion hence religion is the biggest binding force of the country followed by Military Power which is used to occupy non Hindu nations (Punjab, Kashmir, Nagaland, Mizoram, Meghalaya) with the country. Most of Hindus in Indian subcontinent prefer religion over their nationalities unlike muslims (Kashmiri, Bangla, Baluch, Sindhi, Pashto) who identify themselves with their nationalities and even support nation states like Bangladesh.
According to research, Higher ethnic or national diversity within a country negatively affects economic growth through conflict between interests of various nations or ethnicities (Don't confuse the ethnic or national diversity with the multiculturalism in west due to migration, the migrants mix with diverse society and become part of nationality of the host country and work for the interests of the dominant nationality).
High nationality or ethnic Diversity correlates with low GDP per capita.
Strong democracy correlates with ethnic or national homogeneity.
Punjab and Kashmir should be a free countries based on Punjabi and Kashmiri nationalities like Bangladesh. But Hindu Punjabis, Hindu Kashmiris and Muslims punjabi don't want to leave india and Pakistan, so we Punjabi Sikhs, or Kashmiri muslims can't force them to follow us. Hindu Punjabis, who had deserted Punjabi language in 1951 and 1961 census by declaring Hindi as their mother tongue would never support a Punjabi nation state. They support a Indian state based on the Hindu religion. Similarly, Punjabi Muslims of Pakistan dont support Punjabi nation state either. They support Pakistan state that is based on Islam religion.
Similarly, Bengali Hindus and Kashmiri Hindus don't support Bangla nation state Bangladesh and Azad Kashmir and want to live in India which is based on Hinduism. So Punjabi muslims, Punjabi Hindus, Kashmiri Hindus and Bengali Hindus are free to stay in their respective countries based on religions. But similar to Bangla Muslims of East Pakistan, who created Bangla nation state Bangladesh without Indian Bengali Hindus, Sikhs have the right to create Azad Punjab (a Punjabi nation state) without Punjabi Hindus and Punjabi Muslims (and Azad Kashmir without Kashmiri Hindus). As simple as that.
We Punjabi Sikhs have no problem living in a Punjabi Muslims or Punjabi Hindu majority Punjabi nation state but they don't support nation state unlike modern civilised world but a state based on religion.
The Punjabi speaker population of Muslims is around 10 crore. Punjabi speaking population of Hindus is around 3 crore (Punjabi Hindus in Punjab, Himchal, Haryana, Jammu and Delhi). Punjabi speaker Sikh population is around 2 crore. Hence Sikhs would be minority if both Punjabi muslims and Hindus or either one of them come form a Punjabi nation state with us Sikhs. We Sikhs have no problem living as minority in Punjabi nation state among majority Punjabi muslims and Punjabi Hindus, But their radicals minds prefer religion over their nationality and they love to give up their Punjabi nationality and adopt Hindi and Urdu nationality in order to create a state based on their respective religions.
So when Sikhs alone form a Punjabi nation state, it would automatically be a Sikh majority Punjabi nation state called Khalistan. What's in the name? We are open to change the name and keep it Punjab instead of Khalistan and also write the word secular state in constitution because it wouldn't change anything in practice. In practice it would still be Khalistan just like India is a Hindu rashtra in practice regardless of its official name or regardless of its constitution..
PS- Stupid Trolls would be deleted under my comment. Only serious and intellectual discussion would be entertained.
More misrepresentations in this talk:
•The attack started on 1 June with constant firing by paramilitary (there was no response fire from the Sikhs guarding the Darbar Sahib Complex).
Defensive fire only started when army actually entered the complex by 3 June
I was thinking the same that didn't it start on 1st June itself
Why keep guns then in Gurudwara? Find some job, work,but no Khalistan Khalistan karte rahe
@@tanmayambre4109 Go to Punjab and have a look for yourself. They still have guns in Punjab. Punjab has the most number of licensed weapons. It is a part of the faith.
@@tanmayambre4109 Btw, I'm sure you are under the impression that Indian army only actioned on Golden Temple, Amritsar. In fact, they actioned on multiple Gurdwaras across the state. Do you have any justification for that? Afterall the official govt stance was that they actioned only to "sanitate" the Golden Temple of "militants".
@@goalee7663 what is need of guns?muslims faith is they marry many women's ,kill kafirs,old faiths should be modified according to time ,at the time when these faith were started the time and situation was different,there were no police to protect the public,now if you keep guns and do dadagiri to police then you have seen the results,it's for law and order,you must accept that those bhindrenwalas were not peaceful ,he had motives to divide the country,so do you think Gandhi should have waited more years till he accumulated more power?blue star was to stop the revolt,yes as you said that there were firing in other gurudwara also,maybe there were some gang members also,that was a war and each war has collateral damage on both sides.
Great to watch this details analysis video, Peace 🙏💚
Dear brother please correct sentence u said " SIKH RIOTS" BUT VO "SIKH GENOCIDE" THA... SIKHO KA NARR SANGHAR
look we know lindu minds are weak but it is what it is
bro loves indra thatswhy
Yes sir please
Sikhs genocide agree veer but Hindu never understand Sikhs more than 300 thousands Sikhs killed by India and Hindu
To all the SIKHS who cry for the Sikh genocide-
In 1947 post the gandhi-vadh by nathuram godse, All major newspapers flashed the news -
'GANDHI ASSASINATED BY CHITPAVAN HINDU BRAHMIN', they did not say killed by an assassin- most newspapers were congress controlled.
Within hours, the houses of the community across maharashtra were burnt, men lynched, women and children assaulted/raped...NOT ONE SINGLE FIR WAS FILED, NOBODY KNOWS ABOUT THE PROGROM because the community is too small, despite its outsize contributions to the nation- be it the peshwas, tilak, gokhale, savarkar and countless others...
The only evidence left was CHITPAVAN Brahmins emigrating to cities from their ancestral villages and towns and leaving India.
The community EVEN today is extremely succesful and patriotic despite every attempt by the likes of Sharad Pawar and the radical left to paint them as villians.
If they can stay true to the nation, and continue to fight versus anti-nationals...why DO the Sikhs believe that they deserve a special treatment for having their near and dear ones murdered by the same political ideology which did not use force against the partition of India?
If you want justice, target every congi politician responsible for the 1984 riots, because God knows....not one congressi british-islamic bootlicker has ever got justice till date, for any of the atrocities they have committed versus any of the Indic religions....the sanatanis are not responsible for what happened to the Sikhs in riots- if that were the case, Sikhs should have been killed ALL across the country.
Savarkar's Hindu rashtra explicitly mentions its HINDU identity based on 'sons of the soil'...and not on basis of religion....AND IT WILL BECOME A REALITY- whether whitewashing LINDUS like banerjee want it or not!!
I am sikh and living in Punjab and I can assure all my fellow indians that 90% sikhs living in Punjab don’t want Khalistan. Only few sikhs living outside India are demanding separate nation which is a silly demand and it’s not gonna happen in any condition. Request all the Indians and main stream media not to give any attention to these stupid people they only want to disturb internal peace and brotherhood of India
Speak for yourself. We want Khalistan
Let’s hold a referendum for Khalistan in Punjab
To all the SIKHS who cry for the Sikh genocide-
In 1947 post the gandhi-vadh by nathuram godse, All major newspapers flashed the news -
'GANDHI ASSASINATED BY CHITPAVAN HINDU BRAHMIN', they did not say killed by an assassin- most newspapers were congress controlled.
Within hours, the houses of the community across maharashtra were burnt, men lynched, women and children assaulted/raped...NOT ONE SINGLE FIR WAS FILED, NOBODY KNOWS ABOUT THE PROGROM because the community is too small, despite its outsize contributions to the nation- be it the peshwas, tilak, gokhale, savarkar and countless others...
The only evidence left was CHITPAVAN Brahmins emigrating to cities from their ancestral villages and towns and leaving India.
The community EVEN today is extremely succesful and patriotic despite every attempt by the likes of Sharad Pawar and the radical left to paint them as villians.
If they can stay true to the nation, and continue to fight versus anti-nationals...why DO the Sikhs believe that they deserve a special treatment for having their near and dear ones murdered by the same political ideology which did not use force against the partition of India?
If you want justice, target every congi politician responsible for the 1984 riots, because God knows....not one congressi british-islamic bootlicker has ever got justice till date, for any of the atrocities they have committed versus any of the Indic religions....the sanatanis are not responsible for what happened to the Sikhs in riots- if that were the case, Sikhs should have been killed ALL across the country.
Savarkar's Hindu rashtra explicitly mentions its HINDU identity based on 'sons of the soil'...and not on basis of religion....AND IT WILL BECOME A REALITY- whether whitewashing LINDUS like banerjee want it or not!!
True they just want unrest between Hindu and Sikh harmony. I live in Delhi and I have not ever faced any Sikh asking for Khalistan.
But yes I support justice for victims of 1984 mass killing. Whatever happened was black day for our country 😢.
@@priyanka...sharma... Stay blessed Sister.... From a Sikh brothee
@@SatpalVerma000 Now dont cry when crushed by the army
1947 main hindustan ka batwara nahi hua tha.... batwara Punjab aur Bangal ka hua tha....
Punjab mei muslim toh hote he nhi......Bengal mei hote hai......batwara bas Punjabi muslimo ka hua...
Muslims panjab Or bangal ma hi to 60-70 % to wahi hoga na batwaara. Bas india na bacha huwa 8% muslim ko Pakistan nahi bheja .
@@bubbleteaea seriously? All communities used to live in Punjab before the partition, sikhs were just 7-8%. Read some history.
yean sab facts ye log kabhi accept nahi karenge yeah log or in jaise baaki sab log
Sahi gall aa paji panjab zindawad ❤❤
"As a Bangladeshi Hindu, my community and I are currently facing immense challenges and uncertainty. Recent events have put us in a vulnerable position, where safety, peace, and security feel threatened. We are facing hardships that impact our daily lives, our places of worship, and our sense of belonging. Despite the difficulties, we believe in unity, support, and peace for all.
This is a heartfelt request to everyone who values justice and equality please stand with us,
Why are you copy pasting same comment everywhere 🤡
😂😂😂
@@taufique._. Trump, BBC, UN etc all have stated about persecution of minorities in Bangladesh. Yunus himself has stated it. So chillax and move on.
True word ____अकेले होना और अकेले रोना कई बार इंसान को मजबूत बना देता है ❤❤❤❤❤😢😢😢😢😢😢 thank U sir
Ap ki bat main sachiyi hai
Kis leeye thanks kaha tumne@@lovedeepsingh1405
Akash, have you made a documentary on Jaswant Singh Khalra's contributions for human rights & how he disappeared forever?
He won’t cuz his audience won’t like it
@@deadeyevenom3880facts because it’s reality and show the real face of india 🇮🇳 and it will give clarity on Sikh genocide while he think it’s riots
please share full details. why did Subheg singh left out from army one day before his retirement? the person who fought well for india and help india win war against pakistan, why he was treated like this by army?
AKELA BANDA WAHI TO THA LADNE ME BAAKI REGIMENT TO TAALI BAJA RHI THI , KYU ITNI BAKCHODIYAN HAI TM LOGO KE ANDER
True, he wont tell subheg singh accomplishments for the country or why he joined the fighters
@@arjunsandhu7431 beta time se apna mind thik kar lo
Aisa na ho tumhara kabristan ban jaye
Was that because he was a Sikh?No, it was due to internal politics.As if no Hindu officer have been stabbed in the back like that.
The Govt. Bombed temples in 1980s to defame the Anandpur Sahab Resolution. And the army was preparing for attack 2 years earlier for genocide of sikhs when Sant Ji was not in Amritsar and General S.K sinha took pre mature retirement and told Indira gandhi that you should talk with them and stop the attack as sikhs will defend till last breath and they did as 15k soldiers were killed by only 200 kharku Singhs.
Some jat sikhs have problems and they are main culprit because they propogate that we are different and they interpreted religious text in their own way.
Hindus never ever disrespect any religion and never think Sikhs are different to Hindus.
You people always show that u are different. However before 10 generations, ur forefathers were Hindus.
U people have problems, introspect dear.
proud to be sikh ❤ Jai Hind Jai bharat
A very balanced and factually correct synopsis of the situation. Well done!
@@jenny3541 ek dum bakwas!!!
Kaika bande ne hindus ko to isa btaya hai jaise inho ne kuch kiya hi ni indra gai hai vo to ek insan thi to in logo ne hume itna mara humara to inhone akal takhat thorda hai jo humare gurus ne bnaya tha hume to protest ni krne diya humne to inke ek bhi bando ko ni mara na kisi ka rape kiya na kisi women ko widow bnaya give me ans of this
Complete bakwas and lack of history knowledge
Also Hindus in 1952 officially denied Punjabi as their language so no Hindu can claim to be Punjabi. 1984 and what Hindus did, everyone says it’s congress party but reality it’s Hindus because they know the truth of how they stole freedom from Sikhs. Even Tara Singh died soon after and said I have enslaved Sikhs. Now for 1984 that attack was not necessary and completely unjustifiable, sant Ji came to darbaar sahib 6 months prior to attack, he was jathedaar of akal takhat Sahib, not just some guy, also if dr. Swami was able to freely meet with him, then why indra Gandhi needed to demolish everything, just to capture everything, also he wasn’t at 39 other gurdwaras which were also attacked, next jathedaar kaunke was also brutally murdered, and not to forget Mr. Khalda who took list of 30000 young Sikhs men’s names to Canada and spoke in Canadian parliament about the disappearance of countless Sikh and how they are being killed in fake encounters, he came back to India and his body to this day haven’t been recovered. 30000 men, even if they had 2 kids and their kids end up having kids themselves, how much population Sikhs have lost? Yet you without knowing any wrote as a Sikh I want want to see this country prosper, you are just as much of a Sikh as master Tara Singh was who put this struggle into the lives of every Sikh.
Well it’s your lack of knowledge on history, India is not Sikhs country, Sikhs never agreed to be part of India, if Hindus deserve their own country after giving less than 10% sacrifices, Sikhs deserves their Punjab as their own country, like it was, as they have given 90% sacrifices, the Sikh who represented Sikhs/punjab in 1947 was in reality a Hindu, search it, master Tara Singh was actually Hindu, his real surname was malhotra, he obviously was okay to split Punjab into two parts and got fake promises of self sovereign state, when Sikhs found out they retaliated and to this day never signed Indian constitution. So how can this be Sikhs country? This is the reason why I am against Hindus becoming Sikhs and or marrying into Sikh families. He being Hindu decided the fate of Sikhs, and countless Sikhs died because of his stupidity.
If Sikhs truly dont support khalistan movement then how did amritpal singh win with such a big margin? And yes he is a khalistan supporter
@@dmop5071 If Hindus truly dont support Hindu Rashtra then how did yogi adityanath win with such a big margin? And yes he is a Hindu Rashtra supporter
@Singh-gl8le who said he isn't? Just go through the comments here, people are saying that ground reality is different, punjab people don't support khalistan movement, then how the hell did he win? By the way Yogi isn't asking for a separate nation.
@@Singh-gl8leyogi ne kab kha ki wo Hindu Rastra banaiga 😂
@@dmop5071 Then what is Hindu rashtra. Nation of Hindus. On ground people of punjab consider Khalistan and Hindu Rashtra as a same. Biggest reason behind rise of Khalistan is Hindu Rashtra. Amritpal won saying same thing If Hindus can demand their nation why cant sikh have their own. Wanna believe or not your choice.
@@Singh-gl8leno khalistan and no hindu rashtra but it can be a new Islamic nation
according to concept of Gajwa e Hind so think carefully
My request to Hindus and Sikh brothers don't fight bcz some one want to make this nation a new Islamic country
Informative 👍
I am an Indian born sikh living in Australia now. It pains me when someone talks about separating Punjab from India. I have so many memories and learnings from India. 😢
I wish this will end for once and all
Even I had a memory losing my grandfather in 84 riots. I openly support khalistan
th-cam.com/video/zMMM7EXwquQ/w-d-xo.htmlsi=vrLfr_rrfhsiODvE
1984 में भी सिखों को घर में घुसकर मारा था।
@@SehajpreetSingh-fv3lgHe was Sikh...Guru Nanak married 14 year old child ..
@@SehajpreetSingh-fv3lg are u expecting treason?
@@SehajpreetSingh-fv3lg khalistan not possible. Sikhs dont live only in punjab but all over India, secondly only sikhs dont live in punjab a large chunk is hinduism.
Been a follower and a Fan of your work n have always found the content well researched , and unbiased. This video misses to talk about Hindu Punjabis Punjab is not just sikhs , Maharaja Ranjit Singh - Shere E Punjab had both the communities living peacefully, the partition was tough for Punjabis (Hindus n Sikhs) there is a 38.49% Hindu population who are proud Punjabis n live peapefully with their Sikh brothers n we stood by our farmers together. Pray that peace may prevail .
🙏🏻🙏🏻
Concur
Well said. We r Punjabis and we follow all religions.
@@manpreet2966But Khalistanis love to create homeland exclusively for Jatt Sikhs only.
Muslim punjabis already got their share.
The Sikh empire of Panjab, Kashmir, Himachal, lahore..
Land of Five rivers.🏔️🏞️🌲🌄
OK abdul
Kartarpur add this
Nankana Sahib, Kartarpur, Panja Sahib
❤
@@BharatSingh-x1hadd all indus valley civilisation
Great job on this vid
Mr. Deshbhakt what do you say about Hindustani Terrorits and what they have done in 1984 anti Sikhs riots
Anti sikh riots? It was a genocide using state forces
To all the SIKHS who cry for the Sikh genocide-
In 1947 post the gandhi-vadh by nathuram godse, All major newspapers flashed the news -
'GANDHI ASSASINATED BY CHITPAVAN HINDU BRAHMIN', they did not say killed by an assassin- most newspapers were congress controlled.
Within hours, the houses of the community across maharashtra were burnt, men lynched, women and children assaulted/raped...NOT ONE SINGLE FIR WAS FILED, NOBODY KNOWS ABOUT THE PROGROM because the community is too small, despite its outsize contributions to the nation- be it the peshwas, tilak, gokhale, savarkar and countless others...
The only evidence left was CHITPAVAN Brahmins emigrating to cities from their ancestral villages and towns and leaving India.
The community EVEN today is extremely succesful and patriotic despite every attempt by the likes of Sharad Pawar and the radical left to paint them as villians.
If they can stay true to the nation, and continue to fight versus anti-nationals...why DO the Sikhs believe that they deserve a special treatment for having their near and dear ones murdered by the same political ideology which did not use force against the partition of India?
If you want justice, target every congi politician responsible for the 1984 riots, because God knows....not one congressi british-islamic bootlicker has ever got justice till date, for any of the atrocities they have committed versus any of the Indic religions....the sanatanis are not responsible for what happened to the Sikhs in riots- if that were the case, Sikhs should have been killed ALL across the country.
Savarkar's Hindu rashtra explicitly mentions its HINDU identity based on 'sons of the soil'...and not on basis of religion....AND IT WILL BECOME A REALITY- whether whitewashing LINDUS like banerjee want it or not!!
Thoda educated hole veere vo ek political party ne Kara tha congress 🥱
Congress party wale log the woh
Congress se humko mat jodna paaji Shat Shri Akal
Akash - you are wrong about the Nov 3 incident in Canada. It was not an attack on Hindu devotees or Hindu community as is widely being reported in the media. There were protesters from both communities outside the temple raising provocative slogans. This was planned. The Hindu group had bhagwa flags and the khalistanis had their own. Both groups start getting close to each other. Someone throws a fist and it erupts into a street fight. Some Hindu protestors ran into the temple and some. Khalistanis followed them with flag sticks. So what was a clash between 2 groups is being termed as an attack on Hindu temple, which it wasn't.
We all know that in India who always go in front of masid in festival to host their flags 🚩
Why they provoke in front of temple daily basis chanting anti indian slogans , why they are in front of temple these activities
What were they doing in front of a temple? Or did the temple come in front of them?
@@Reddy-b3j they can be anywhere to protest. Just like the Hindus were protesting outside the temple.
Why those khalistani goon gone to temple for their ' peaceful ' protest. They have hundreds of gurdwara in canada
You have wrong information first namdhari killed to 15 sikhs who went to namdhari program without any weapon but namdhari killed those 15 sikhs and govt didn't do anything because they were secretly supporting to that sanstha .
As a journalist I really admire your research in bringing the stories that matter. Keep up this amazing work.
PUNJAB KHALISTAN EXPLAINED BY NITISH RAJPUT.
recommended if interested more.
No khalisthan
No Hindu rastra
If you support any one you should support other too😊
Khalistan is a separatist movement while Hindutva is a political ideology. U can't compare both.
@@ARX689but on ground people of punjab consider same and making khaistani won elections bcoz they dont want to part of Hindu Rashtra
@@ekssingh7973 bhai mere loka nu khalistan te hindu rashtar da fark jaande ne. Punjab de log ch har koi educated te sensible nhi hega, is karke farkh nhi jaande ne. Iha saare nu uneducated rakhan aale kon si? It's pretty obvious.
@@ARX689 so u want Hindu rastra but when others want the same it's wrong ??
I don't get it
Are hindus so superior that all the neighbouring countries should give their countries sovereignty because u say so .
For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction
If u want Hindu rastra u will get khalistan zolandia ,dravida rastra and so many countries
So stop pushing the limits.
@@onemuslim9313 it's a political ideology my guy, u will get sikhs for Hindu Rasthrar and u will get those against it, u will get south Indians for hindu rashtrar and u will get some against it, what do u not understand about political ideology? There is a difference between political ideology and separatism. There is also an ìdeology similar to Hindtva in which they want to establish khalsa raj and give the entire India a Sikh identity without breaking India. That's the difference between political ideology and separatism.
Many hindus and other community goes to golden temple for viewing punjabi culture 😊, i love their food also🤤🤤
Very well analyzed.
18:55 india took 40 years to run the trial on those who were directly involved and accused for Sikh genocide.
About 30 years in Rajiv Gandhi assisnation case
Who was killed ...15 people killed by nirankaris...sikhs were doing protest against nirankaris peacefully
Askash, one thing you said wrong in this video. 1984 was a Genocide not riots, the Delhi High Court has also accepted this. There are clear evidences of Government involvement including the PM Rajiv Gandhi’s. No justice has been given till date, giving a message that justice has to be forcefully delivered.
sikh genocide bolne mein darr laga hai but Khalistani Terrorist bolne koi darr nahi lagta inko or in jaise sabko
All. Punjab. And. All. Sikh. Khalistani. Khalsa. Hi. Khalsa. 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Guru nanak 14 saal ke bacche Sulakhna ke sath galat kaam kara.....
@@bubbleteaeachup kar
Voh Hindu ke pujniye devta guru hai
I typically agree and align with much of what you share and often share your channel with those around me to get an unbiased perspective. While I agree with many things you have said in this video, you have very casually glossed over the actual trauma and the genocide that Sikhs have faced in India. It's this very casual indifference that has led to intergenerational trauma for many Sikh families. You do realize that many Sikhs fleed India to avoid your easily glossed over 'police justice' or '1984 riots' - these people saw their families killed, their mother/wives/daughter raped ... they barely escaped the atrocities themselves. Following the genocide, there were several disappearances of young Sikh men in Punjab. This diaspora retained these hurt feelings, this gross injustice, this undeniable betrayal by their own country and passed these feelings down generation after generation - this, my friend, is how trauma works. How can you call what happened in 1984 a 'riot' when it was one-sidedly organized by the government and attacked specific areas where Sikh communities lived in Delhi? Do you have any idea how many actual Sikhs were tortured and murdered in the 1980s? The numbers are grossly underreported. How can you have a much-needed discussion on Khalistan (I am a Sikh, and I oppose Khalistan) without truly accepting and apologizing for the Sikh genocide? I am so disappointed with your coverage on this truly complex and sensitive matter. This seemed more like a "we have suffered as well" instead of actually highlighting the trauma that the innocent Sikh community in Delhi and Punjab faced in the 1980s. You can not ask people to get over their lived trauma without properly addressing or apologizing for it. You really needed to do more research before producing this video instead of trying to get on the "what will tick" bandwagon and clickbaity title of Khalistan. - from a disappointed and hurt viewer.
Well said. I was in Delhi at that time. What I saw, never thought would happen with us in our own country. We can never forget that. But yet I don’t support Khalistan be cause our ancestors fought for the India’s independence not just for Punjab.
What do you think will be the resolution for this khalistani issue, bcoz I see kashmiri hindus also faced a similar horror in 1990s but no voice of separation or anti India sentiments ever came from them. On the other side khalistan movement always gets defended by the trauma of 84. How long do you guys plan to play this card, this gets more complex when we see the love for Congress in punjab and now the separatist amritpal wining heavily by 2 lakh vote margin. Also why don't we see similar demand of separate khalistan in Pakistan side. The Sikhs need to address what image they are portraying.
@@mr.nobody5244 on the seat of Maan,-majority votes against linderpal.
Live in present.
Sidhu Moosewala sympathy for bhindrawale and khalistani song syl got him assasinated by Amit shah's attack dog named Lawrence.
BJ party has started political assasinations that may be the spark of reigniting this conflict
BJP leaders openly calling Bhindranwale as a Sant Ji. What about that???
I don't think SYL had any mention of Khalistan but just on the ground real issues such as Water Rights and Autonomy. Which is exactly the reason why the BJ party banned this song and k!lled him
India is vast country with lots of religions, cultures and diversity people may also demand partition in future.
Central need more power in hand that of today. Like U.S.A
Central must hold more power for unity of INDIA
@@Laxmanca WTF are you on about bruh. The US follows true Federalism. They have a separate Supreme Court in each of their 50 states along with a separate flag for each state and separate laws. Bro's just yapping without any basic knowledge of the US and its federal structure.
Khalistan is old problem even before Lawrence and even before Modi came to power. we will never find people like u speaking against Christian conversion, khalistani aggression. All of your talk will be to abuse Hindus, rss and to DEFLECT from main problem of Christian conversion. We will also NEVER see khalistanis demanding khalistan in Lahore which was the capital of Sikh empire. It tell us who r they working for. Such cowards man 😂
Amritpal and others like him win because punajbis (not just Sikhs ) have been struggling to be heard by center since 47. No matter what Punjabis ask for , center always treats it with closed eyes and closed ears. Punjabis have this strong feeling of being treated as step children and ignored by the government. Punjabis have always been on the forefront of all movements and struggles for the country but has the country (politicians ) always treated Punjab equally well? Punjabis have always felt pride in India but India has always taken Punjab and Punjabis for granted. Things were getting better but then this govt came and decided to scratch old wounds. Water was hi jacked by Indira Gandhi govt , land before that and now they feel that modi is hi jacking the farming and culture by bringing corporates. So it’s a deep sense of resentment and unheard concerns that makes people drive away from the government.
💯💯💯
😂😂😂
Why does Punjab blame the centre when its own politicians are worthless and can't attract investment?
Punjab can't think beyond agriculture...and when someone tries to change that we get these BS protests...
Change starts at home...can't keep blaming the centre for everything!
@@hogginarmocount9562 You can be ignorant … it’s a bliss after all. It’s the same stupid logic as, Why do Indians blame previous governments for their problems if they are lazy and incompetent. Isn’t Punjab part of India? Whatever center does effects all states. You can be an idiot. It’s convenient
@@hogginarmocount9562 Agriculture is part of culture and has nothing to do with punjab not having industry . Wars with Pakistan , being a border state , terrorism have all created road blocks in the past . Now corporate wants to take over agriculture and not provide with a substitute industry. They are not trying to move people into some new industry but instead take over one source of livelihood and inheritance they have. Land !!….. again be ignorant idiot, it’s a good place to be in.
@@ajaybeer
Again the same BS. Is Punjab a special case? Do they not practice agriculture in other parts of India?
Also...who are 'THEY'?
TAMILS? MARATHIS? UP WALLAHS? BENGALIS?
Stop your nonsense and own up that your own elected leadership is responsible.
Your inability to produce decent leaders is not the fault of the Indian state.
10:10 nirankari guru granth sahib ki byadbi kar rhe they.....nirankariyon ne maara tha inko naki inho ne nurankariyon ko ..... dhokhe se hamla kiya tha unhone
Just to let everybody know that Bhindran wala was never in the favour of separate state he just wanted the Anandpur sahib resolution, once you read that you get to know the demands weren’t separatists but were for the well being of us. And also the army was already in the Darbar sahib complex by 1st june. Making things more clear the devotees in the complex were never used as hostages. Also talking about the fight in Brampton was ignited by the so called “patriots” living out of their own country. Things never remain the same once you try n get to the roots, i have talked to so many of my relatives who have been the part of the movement, my father himself have been to Bhindran Wala and he say he had a great vision. And we know here in India somebody with great vision is never supported by the government. And also why the people in jail since 1984 haven’t been released it have been more the 40 years.
@@Jagjeet042 why are u deleting comments.
@@Jagjeet042 why are u deleting comments
@@sandeepverma-yg7wl I didn’t remove any of the comments
I am born and brought up in JandK, married in Punjab, now living in Canada. And somehow my views, on all three places differ from The Deshbhakt. Nonetheless, love the work!!! ❤
Nah don't trust him, don't you think something is fishy here, this video doesn't fit his ideological narrative, something seems off, why was he pro hindu in this video???
@@aniketmane6232u stupid or wht
Where he gave sign of pro hindu
Identity एक ही है मै हूँ वही मै हूँ (I AM THAT) ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
ना हिंदू बुरा है ना मुस्लिम बुरा है जो गलत काम करो इंसान बुरा है 😢❤❤
Bilkul muslim bura nhi unki dharm ki book me jo likha isi liye wo bnte hai
100% True
All eyes on MIZORAM cm..........
@@raazirazz4216 he wants united 3 states considering Bangladesh and Myanmar similar religion population wise and speak that in U.S.A
@@Laxmanca no he doesn't. It was taken out of context. Read more about it.
@@Laxmancahe wants Christian country
@@gsjsjjsai thats not possible. May be he has some desire & want some dollars. If India didn’t broke in 20 th century, at that time India was weak. But now India is a global player with democracy. We should alert and focus on economy growth.
As a member of Sikh community, I don’t support violence or Khalistan, but asking for rights is my legal right given by god, punjab doesn’t get anything in return for its water and and still doesn’t have a capitol. The fight was for the rights that were promised, whole generation of Sikh were killed for no reason, Mr.Khalra was also killed for investigating, Shubeg Singh was falsely accused which made him switch sides. Please make videos on them.
So well explained, love from punjab!, India!
3:48 please correct this............... Guru teg bhadur ji ne kurbani di thi. Aurangzeb begunah logon ka dharm parivartan krva rha tha or katleyam kar rha tha.....usney kha tha ki koe mhaan saksh ki kurbaani deni prhegi fer kashmiri pandits ne guru ji ke paas akar madad mangi......or unhone shaheedi di...........aurangzeb ne kha tha ki aapko aisa karne ki zarurat nhi hai. Unhone bola agar aaj koe hindu raha dharam parivartan krva rha hota jabardasti or tum mere paas atey....to tab bhi mai aisa hi krta
अगर पंजाब में खालिस्तान की मांग नही है तो इंडियन गवर्मेंट खलिस्तान Referendum से क्यों डरती है
@@aslitarasingh No country can allow such propagandas in their country. Try to do similar referendum in cubec for its freedom . You will be behind bars for lifetime in canada.
There is no legality of this ,India is union of state, the word union is used for reason instead of federal. Such demand is directly against constitution that is India. It won't get you anywhere. Instead demand for cultural preservation , and govt funding to promote Sikhism, that is practical demand.
Refrendum should happen to annex lahore, capital of khalistan.
@Venom-uu1ge भाई मेरे फेर British India में क्या प्रोब्लम थी इंडिया ने आजादी क्यों ली अगर वो सही है तो हमारी आजादी गलत कैसे
@InfoCentre4U Results से डर लगता है यह बोलो ना भाई
you do not understand 1984 , Punjab, sikh
search history of Punjab
search history of Maharaja Ranjit Singh
Search history of Hari Singh nalwa
Search history of Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale
You are too young to know, but there was violence unleashed by Khalistanis against Hindus that was almost as bad as the violence during partition before 1984. Between 1979 and 1984 Buses and trains would be stopped, Hindus would be lined up and machine gunned. The fact that Sikhs could do this to Hindus was something that I could never understand. Please dont say government agents did this.
O chal turda ho BC. Nalwa abdali bhindrawala ehde ton agge koi gal ee nae aundi thonu... Jehda guru granth saahib ch hajaraan vaar hindu gods da zikar aa o kyo aa? Saleo hankario jehda avde guru da nae ho sakea ohnu kitho ijjat milni aa BC aeve turi firdi aa lagoud
@petepipee6751 bro read the history properly. If you know about Black cat commando and dirty politics, you well know who killed Hindus brother in punjab
@@singhpuriavlogger Yes.. read history in which all the good guys are Khalistanis and all the bad guys are Hindus. All the Gurus were originally muslims and all the Hindus executed Sikh Gurus. All your mothers were originally Muslims , so why didnt you stay in Pakistan? why did you come to India in 1947? go away get lost
haha.. I knew you'd say Hindu government did this.
In a few points I do not agree with you, but thank you deshbhakt for making our concerns raise and tell how the Indian government is hypocrite then and now, When we stand for the nation on border people and government call us patriots but when we ask for our rights Indian authority call us Khalistani, please make a video on Jaswant Singh khalra.
yes show ur anger to gov they are responsible, but dont disrespect the nation
yeah show ur anger to gov they are responsible but dont disrespect nation ❤
Hate modi , hate BJP but when they start hating indian army, RAW, Our india then things go beyond limit
It's honestly surprising how he didn't even include his name and any of his reports or findings considering how relevant it was to the Sikh gen0cide. The point is he then can't use the word "anti-sikh riots" and has to use the factual word gen0cide once he mentions Jaswant Singh Khalra's name and his research.
sahi gal hai... some points he told completely incorrect....
Violance breeds Violance. This is not surprising.. People who love Violance are encouraged with the rise of identity-based politics since Lal Krishna Advani's rise to power, that went on a mission to evoke hate and divide Indians in India and Abroad. There is of course a historical context to this story, but People are now more segregated based on religion..
8:51 konse ishaare? He never demanded for khalistan
He said if the give I will take it, that meaning he was willing
@iasknowledge-jc2se willing ki baat alag hai willing toh har sikh krta hai because we had our own khalsa raj in the past. But bhindranwale was fighting for anandpur resolution not for khalistan.
@harshdeepsingh8211 yes I know that.
I appreciate your videos bcs ur content is like real and factfulness but toaday Bro how beautifully you moulded the facts related to punjab 1984 ... representing only half of the information but y these things happened u dont actually cater to that .... What a talent 👏👏
...... Yet i appreciate the solution that u gave at the end of video 👍
Vote for deshbhakt🇮🇳💪😻You are real hero of india
This channel is only run because of dhruv rattee
This channel is only run because of dhruv rattee
meatriding 101
If Central government promote all Indian language and culture , not only Hindi then separatist mindset will be destroyed,,,,
It does promote all Indian languages and cultures
Disadvantages of too much diversity. Inevitable. All we can do is continuing to learn to coexist
@@KotgireTejas no...central govt is pushing hindi in punjab...govt banks doing all their business in hindi..in punjab
@@0bajwa0 can you explain how
Im born in India and im indian no shit can break me from my country even it comes to my religion or these political shit who divide people on religion just love india 🇮🇳 ❤
@RajinderSingh-ft2lx kash 1984 vaile tu ate tera parivar punjab to bahar hunda ,
@@jaswindersingh-lq6sl bhra thodi education lelo country hr government alag alag nai sarkar nai galat kita c pr is ch India nai ki galat krta asi india ch paida hoa aa mnu mera punjab boht pyaara pr is lae mnu india nu hate krn di ki lod india is in ❤️
@i_gurisaini india occupied punjab
@@jaswindersingh-lq6sl leave that shit u r just disgracing and traitor who cant respect his country
Neither I am Khalistani nor i am in Canada . Why is one sided story is showing by indian Media .
I have question for you guys why Hindu mob Went and attacked mellton GuruDwara sahib ?
Who was bhindi wala
@@AnkitKumar-id1gg He is not my Idol ok . Now you tell me why Hindu Mob Attacked Gurudwara Sahib Mallton ?
@@sukhvirsinghsukhvirsingh9029 kab
@@sukhvirsinghsukhvirsingh9029 why are u deleting comments
@@sukhvirsinghsukhvirsingh9029 why are u deleting comments
I am an indian sikh , living in Punjab, and you are absolutely correct saying that there is no such extreme waves of demands for khalistan here in Punjab. People living in Canada or America try to be so called real sikh by asking for a separate nation
इंडियन की आजादी के लिए सिखों ने बहुत ज्यादा कुर्बानिया दी पर जब हम सिक्ख आजादी चाहते है तो हमारे हिन्दू भाई हमारे खिलाफ है आज हिंदु भाईयो के पास मौका सिखों का साथ देकर सिखों को आजादी दिलाने का
@@aslitarasingh Lawrence bishnoi ajadi dega tjhe
@@StudywithAbhijeetjaise karni sena ke leader ko di wasie tere us sher ko jail se to bahar aney de 😂 jail ke andar to safe hai mumbai police bhi nhi ja parahi
@@StudywithAbhijeet lgta apki community kewal ek mard hai baki sab woh hai yaha dekho Lawrence bishnoi 😂
@@aslitarasingh kisse ajadi chahiye tmko India me kya problem h ??
@StudywithAbhijeet जैसी आजादी इंडिया ने ली अंग्रेजो से वैसी आजादी चाहिए हमे
Waheguru Ji🙏🙏🙏
Wrong. Inflation. ❌❌❌❌
Indian sikh don’t need any Khalistan n all , we are happy with our own India , we did a lot of sacrifices not for any separation!!
❤❤🙏🙏
Akal te hath maar, ek genocide krake vi akal nai aayi
Bro think about who talking about hindurater and who start it ??
The situation was different during freedom struggle actually it was same rebellion against Britishers to stop economic exploitation against Indians . Bhagat singh himself named his party as socialist to help the poor farmers and justice for the victims of British government. There were indians too with the Britishers fighting against the freedom fighters.
Then why our state had to bear the consequences of partition? Did they asked us ? Did we sacrificed for this country only to get crushed in this hindu muslim chutiyapa?
The Sikh perspective has been entirely ignored, including how they were betrayed after India's independence. The perpetrators of the 1984 genocide were rewarded with high government positions, while the state systematically disappeared innocent Sikhs during the 1980s. Many Sikhs remain imprisoned in India even after completing their sentences. Today, people are increasingly aware of the injustices of the past and the ongoing issues Sikhs continue to face.
The trolls of the BJP don't care about the truth. They create their own truth by spreading a lie. Spread a lie long enough, it becomes the truth!
Salaam desh bhakt
For your Kind information Lala Jagat narayan was shot dead because he abuses Guru Gobind Singh Maharaj ji. Ams nirankari was shot because he said Guru Sahab has 5 panj piyare and i will have 7 sitare and he also abused guru Granth Sahab maharaj ji. And about the 1983 Bus incident was that the bus no. was PNZ 197 and about 5 men stop the bus and killed 7 hindus and 4 sikhs who was no beard and was done by the black cats which worked for police and govt agencies one hindu was still alive and walked to nearby village and told people about the incident , you should talk about everything in deep as you missed many things to talk on.
“They tried to paint our Sikh brothers as the bad guys, but we know the real story. They got provoked by some thug moves, and those responsible need to answer for it. We got our Sikh brothers’ backs, no question.👊💯
Dont compare the term "Hindu rashtra" with khalistan as it is inappropriate to do so. I'll tell you why. The idea of "Hindu rashtra" is a loose idea which has been floated by some irrational people just like "Ghazwa-E-Hind". We all know both of these are meaningless and will never happen. Neither any demonstration or public gathering happen in these cases. But for khalistanis, "Khalistan" is an active agenda which includes holding public gatherings and violent demonstrations. You cant simply compare these two. 👍
False,
BJP promises Hindu rashtra only, people who supports hindu rashtra votes BJP.
@@unomenahnever gonna happen
@@sahil_365 just like khalistaan 😎