Geologist VS Hermitcraft
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ก.ย. 2024
- In this Mumbo Jumbo Hermitcraft video, Catherine Mottram of the University of Portsmouth Geology department reacts to the mountains on the Hermitcraft server. Catherine explains how Minecraft mountains are made, If the Hermitcraft Boatem district is impossible, and tips for terraforming in minecraft.
A big thank you to Catherine and the University of Portsmouth for making this video possible, and a big thanks to Dave Gibbs for reaching out!
University of Portsmouth Geology:
TH-cam: / @universityofportsmout...
Course pages: www.port.ac.uk...
Minecraft geology
Geology of Britain in Minecraft: www.bgs.ac.uk/...
Better Geo Mod: www.bettergeoe...
Build a volcano: blog.geolsoc.o...
Other geology resources
Earth Science: earth-science....
Geo Science for the future: geosciencefort...
Plate tectonics: www.geolsoc.or...
Geology at School: www.geolsoc.or...
The Rock Cycle: www.geolsoc.or...
A Website that allows you to ask a Geologist questions:
ask a geologist: geosciencefort...
My Minecraft servers are provided by Nodecraft! Following this link gives you 30% off: nodecraft.com/...
Filming channel: / thatmumbojumbo2
Instagram: / officialmumbo
Twitter: / thatmumbojumbo
Geologist: You need to build a bigger mountain range.
Mumbo: Dying inside.
Sus
@@Kaiserreich- -tainable
@@takofriend430 -ly sus
Grian: My time has come.
@@TheGary108 lol
I like how she calls the mountains by the hermit's names.
i just assumed he put it in a format like "Mumbo: [image]
Scar: [Image]
etc.."
Mount Mumbo
Mount Scarmore
Mount Pearl
Mount Bubbles
And cub valleys
Grian Cave
"scar is eroding" was the thing that got me because of that XD
Geologist: "You need a whole mountain range behind it feeding the waterfall."
Mumbo: "I just didn't finish the back."
"the water fall wakes sense because the statue on to is magic"
Is like saying
"No , you see officer I actually come from China, so I'm not parked here past the designated time!"
He pulled a Grian
"I did the back lol"
Scars and pearls needed to be closer to the top of Mumbo's supplying the runoff for the waterfall... And then the moon temple pulled them all back down to build limit...lol
😂😂
Catherine: "Now this one looks the most realistic..."
Mumbo: "ight im out--"
I love how excited she sounds while she’s talking about rocks, you can tell she’s genuinely passionate about how all of these things work
yeah, most geologist I know are really passionate about it! I remember them at University joking they could recognize the type of rock or mineral by tasting it..
One important reason why she sounds excited is she's telling other people all about her thing. People LOVE when other people are interested in learning about their thing.
No hate or anything but does anyone else think its slightly weird. Being this passionate about rocks takes a special person so props to her for that.
🥱 rocks
@@joshuabelote9422 no? It’s literally her job, it’s perfectly normal that people like different things.
I loved this video! Hermitcraft meets Education. Well done Bumbo and Catherine! More of this please!
First fime a TH-camr isn't at the top comments
But wasnt that in the hermitcraft season 7 tho......
Bumbo :D
Agreed
Hiii Doc. Thanks for being awesome and spreading love in this community
Catherine: Talking about different kinds of stones, the way the builds resemble to the real world,...
Mumbo: *_Stone_*
To who ever is reading this comment
You are awesome ❤️
My goal is to hit 30k any help would be epic🤩
@@MrJohn0fficial I got my foot stuck in the toilet 32 minutes ago
@@teyo8117 sounds like a personal problem
@@teyo8117 XD
@@teyo8117 dud you get it out yet?
HAHAHAHAH LMAOO Mumbos soul was crushed when she called the mountains "small scale" after all the time, work and effort he put into it. Love the transition to him jumping off the cliff lol.
I couldn't figure out if he jumped because he was sad or to show her- you call this mountain small? I die if I jump off it!
"Geology is awesome, rocks are awesome, Catherine is awesome" that is so wholesome
You could say this Rocks...lol
@@thatguy5699 hah, that was so punny
I literally started Reading your comment right as Mumbo said it
Gem is great
@ lol
I love how professional and passionate catherine is and then mumbo just adds his little sparks of comedy piecing this video together perfectly
Hey my nickname is JJ
@@jaspergreen6770 I’m sorry
@@jaspergreen6770 hi JayJay
And yet he still manages to convey a huge amount of information.
Mumbo. Teaching through Minecraft
Catherine: "This is just a small tiny building block"
Mumbo: ~jumps off a cliff. ~dies
I would've done the same thing. lol
Let's see how many subs I get from this comment.,........
@@sapphire5475 0 maybe?
@@melon3414 just report him
Catherine: mega? …I don’t think so.
It made chuckle out loud ont the tram ffs 😅
She looked genuinely happy and ecstatic to share her knowledge about geography. It's rather nice to see someone so passionate about a subject get to express themselves in a public manner.
I can only hope to be that passionate about something 😭
Science-TH-camrs aint rare.
Many have incorporated the mindset that fusing Entertainment+Education
is the way to go into the creation of their content.
Joe Scott, Sci Show, Sci Man Dan, Professor Dave, Hbomberguy
And PBS Space-Time are all extremly entertaining.
Geology you absolute muppet.
@@rockstar-5934 Imagine being such a muppet that you lightly insult someone about such a small mistake.
@@slevinchannel7589 Imagine being such a muppet that you think geology and geography are similar 😭😭😭
I kind of want to do a video now with the same title which is just me saying: "This is nice" and "Oh gorgeous work" and "This is so beautiful".
Seriously though, it's nice to see other geologists getting enthused about the subject, it's really fascinating to listen to and reminds me how long I've been out of the field. Great work from both of you!
Hey Cleo! Hope you are having a great day!
Yay Cleo is here😂😂
This just in: ZombieCleo is an ACTUAL SCIENTIST! Yay!
Still find it hilarious that I found a geologist to react to Hermitcraft when Hermitcraft contains a sneaky geologist! Expect me to bother you incessantly over how my future builds would have formed.
@@ThatMumboJumbo I mean, I'm just going to start making stuff up, you realise that don't you :D
I really love when professionals passionately talk about their field, her energy just makes me smile!
Ikr right? Its so wholesome! If you want more, i recomend watching a little bit of Tom Scott :)
@@Jr837_ I love that guy! I think there's some hidden charm in british accents, they lure you in a lecture lol!
Seriously. Based on the premise of this video, I didn't think I'd be all that interested, but she did a great job of making it interesting anyway.
I love how she volunteered herself and all her scientific peers to get flooded with emails from minecrafters asking, "I found this rock. Is it a good rock?"
And I 💯 buy that every such email would get an immediate and enthusiastic response of, "Yes! That is a good rock!"
I also love that she uses the hermit's names as if they were designations for the formations. Just accepting the local name for a geological feature without judging or questioning it.
Scar talked about how much he loved finding interesting rocks as a kid in his latest video, and on Twitter you revealed that Cleo is a geologist. You Hermits are making me want to pay more attention to my surroundings!
Let's see how many subs I get from this comment.,........
@@sapphire5475 0
@@Geebinator o.o lol
Cleo's a geologist?
@@BananaPoodle2 She used to be a geological engineer.
God, everything about this video is wholesome: Hermitcraft meeting Education, community's welcoming and showing interest in geology, Catherine's response, Mumbo being Mumbo. Absolutely love this.
The Hog Rider card is unlocked from the Spell Valley (Arena 5). He is a very fast building-targeting, melee troop with moderately high hitpoints and damage. He appears just like his Clash of Clans counterpart; a man with brown eyebrows, a beard, a mohawk, and a golden body piercing in his left ear who is riding a hog. A Hog Rider card costs 4 Elixir to deploy.
What @GuyMAN
@@guyman5036 uhhmmm what?
I like how mumbo is really pushing an educational look at the gameplay of minecraft even if just in this video because it really pushes kids to learn about geology and puts it in a way that's fun for them
Yeah a video like this should be great to inspire kids to further learning.
I agree! At the same time I consider minecraft in general, especially the redstone part, as very intellectually challenging and the building part is not to be disregarded either. It is a video game that can strengthen your thinking while I believe that quite a few games have the opposite effect.
I can now say I was learning stuff on youtube
Mumbo: She will look at boatem builds and rate how realistic they are
Me: immediately thinks of the unfinished back of Scar and Grian's build
Lol yeah same xD
Found you lol
@@clancysleepovergetyourblankies lmao
"Actually there are some mountains in the world with hollow posteriors."
...
...
"Psyche! Geologists have a sense of humour too."
Catherine should start a channel, her enthusiasm, knowledge and her ability to break down complicated subjects is incredible and I could listen to it all day.
She actually has one. It appears at the end with the other cards
Two out three of the end bits you could click on involve Catherine's videos. And as the late, great Meat Loaf sang, "Two out of Three Ain't Bad."
@@zenu903 that is f***ing awesome thanks for letting us know :)
She has one
@@grondhero Yep
I would literally watch a 2 hour documentary with Catherine just talking about this it is so interesting
She has a TH-cam channel
@@methodz5982 And more yt-channel about science:
Sci Show, Joe Scott, Professor Dave, Sci Man Dan.
god no
I would 100 do the same, rocks aren't interesting until you know about them
@@glocktop916 Why not?
I love how she calls the mountians the names of who built them (probably because there was just something above the image saying only the builder and nothing else). Scar is a name that fits Scar's mountains perfectly, and Pearl's mountains do look a bit like big bubble-like pearls
yea
@@DeltaDisagrees ye?
@@Jamesdavey358 it means that i agree
@@DeltaDisagrees ye
The Hog Rider card is unlocked from the Spell Valley (Arena 5). He is a very fast building-targeting, melee troop with moderately high hitpoints and damage. He appears just like his Clash of Clans counterpart; a man with brown eyebrows, a beard, a mohawk, and a golden body piercing in his left ear who is riding a hog. A Hog Rider card costs 4 Elixir to deploy.
Nice to see a different type of video once in a while, and this is certainly different from any other past videos on this channel!
I agree. It's more like his other channel, but it's nice with a crossover like this.
ratio .
Agreed
Agree chain ⬇️
Agreed
The fact that this is fully serious is actually really great. Not just something fun, but has a mix of education in it.
Takes it to a whole ‘nother professional level.
And that Cathrine actually took the questions seriously. Quite awesome.
To who ever is reading this comment
You are awesome ❤️
My goal is to hit 30k any help would be epic🤩
@Voilturez Fully get you. Though that’s not my interest, I’ve got obsessions and other interests myself and I’d talk all day about my writing projects.
Quite honestly, I love hearing anyone nerd out about stuff they’re passionate about.
I want to ask. What did you do with the time saved by typing nother instead of another?
@@shahlemon663 Actually, it took longer ‘cause autocorrect fixed it to “mother”.
I just type how I talk, and I’m southern so I’ll typically cut off words.
It’s just to make a comment feel less serious. If I needed to be professional, I’d write extremely professional, don’t worry!
:D
Minecraft is a good educational tool for kids, and anyone who wants to learn in general. I agree with your statement. gg Mumbo
OK, right this NEEDS to be an, albeit infrequent, regular thing.
Geologist Vs Hermitcraft,
Architect Vs Hermitcraft,
Engineer Vs Hermitcraft,
Historian Vs Hermitcraft,
Interior Designer Vs Hermitcraft,
Physicist Vs Hermitcraft...
This is really good lateral thinking. Truely novel and creative content.
And a pshycolagist vs hermitcraft
@@henriquemacedo2475 Hasn't Zedaph done enough? ;)
Im talking about the lunar thing lol
@@henriquemacedo2475 Not sure if a psychologist or sociologist would be the better choice here. The former deals with the individual while the latter deals with groups.
hermit vs hermitcraft
This was a great video idea!
Hello SarclySimp
Hi mate
Hi Mate nice seeing you here
SimplySarc!
I'm glad to know that SimplySarc isn't dead.
Thanks Cathrine and your colleagues for making such a “heavy and dense” subject so interesting! Also thanks Mumbo for putting this video together, such a brilliant idea! I sure this will inspire many curious young people to want to learn more about our incredible planet and it’s history!
*dense* ba-dum tssss
pun allowed me to exhale from my nose
That joke was off to a rocky start
I have been hooked on geology since I found out about the flood basalts, and ice age floods of the American north west, and the 2 million year long global rainstorm, and the fact the Midwestern rocky mountains have been ocean front to both the Atlantic and Pacific oceans more than once... My affections for Puns on the other hand goes back even further.
what
Scar must be very happy seeing this! He was just talking in his last hardcore episode how much he likes to know about rocks!
Maybe this is what made him have the topic on his mind? Not sure how long ago Scar might’ve been included in any conversations about the video. But I’m sure he’s thrilled that his and Grian’s range basically just got officially declared “The Scar Mountains”. 😂👍
Talking about picking up rocks.
Catherine: “Look at what it’s made of!”
Me: “Hmm… this is made of rock.”
Naw, I think it's made of coal
lol
Matter. It’s made up of matter.
No its made of atoms stupid
Those are made of Dwayne
I understand that like a lot of this content is meant for a younger audience and their benefit, but I love it. Heck I’m a former nuclear engineer turned software engineer and I love that my favorite Minecraft TH-camr who I watch to relax is incorporating educational content. I would LOVE more stuff like this from mumbo.
Nucular! It is pronounced nucular! :D
@@maxvision73 what no it isn't 😂
@@caligusto google it 😅 It is a Simpsons quote 🤣
Same! I mean, not the former nuclear engineer part ... the part about being a lil older and liking it LOL D:
Yep, these kind of educational content is pretty good to fill up the time space between seasons to keep the audience entertained
The energy the geologist gives off and the enthusiasm she really made me want to hear more from her :)
I bet shes an amazing teacher
I wish I could understand how people can be that engaged and happy to study something.
She's a great person
@@SeeNyuOG everyone I’ve ever met who studies geology is like this. They’re a good bunch.
Reminiscent of Emily Graslie, perhaps?
I know right? now I'm gonna be looking at rocks for months
I love how you incorporated your filming and Minecraft aspects into one video.
The best aspects of both sides of Mumbo.
I love her gentle way of saying "yeah that's not realistic" or in her words "I'm not sure that's feasible"
This is literally geography revision without even trying.
…I love it.
I literally have a geography test on this tomorrow, an unexpected way to study but still
@@quirkless_bakubro9247 lmao /not american
It’s really interesting aswell
@@darky3015 Perfect! A video that is entertaining but also something that is hopefully memorable!
Geology
I like how she keeps calling the mountains themselves by their creators' name
I was waiting for this comment lol
"So maybe Scar was eroded" made me laugh out loud
@@iansarmiento23 He was chafed to bits. 😆
@@iansarmiento23 same 😅
Mumbo probably had the pictures with the creators name and she was like "Oh! It's the mountains name!" Which honestly, I loved a lot
Love how she refers to the mountains as the hermits who made them,like "Scar was eroded and deposited on Pearl" lol
Fan fiction here we come
@@thegamemaster2000 No but really-
I can write it if you want me to- Lol
@@taytaythehufflepuff8532 *no.*
@@taytaythehufflepuff8532 but fanfiction about the mountains themselves
@@ashtonhoward5582 I know.
And I’m a writer.
That writes Hermitcraft fanfiction (I swear it’s not as weird as it sounds- I mean, it is but-).
I can do this. Do not underestimate my power.
This is actually a great way to teach Geology to people of all age groups! It introduces different types of mountains and rivers and even some rock types while still incorporating something fun and familiar to many people. :)
Great video and i wanna add: Science-TH-camrs aint rare. Many have incorporated the mindset that fusing Entertainment+Education
is the way to go into the creation of their content.
Joe Scott, Sci Show, Sci Man Dan, Professor Dave, Hbomberguy
And PBS Space-Time are all extremly entertaining.
This should be a series with different scientists absolutely destroying the hermitcraft server's logic
Lol cant wait for a Engeneer or Architect to absolutely destroy everyone's builds
Heck, an electronics/programming lecturer looking at some of their crazy Redstone systems might be interesting.
an astronomist dying while looking at the moon
This could just be a series on experts criticising minecraft logic in general. Doesn’t have to just be hermitcraft. But I like the idea!
Or a thief for the Tegg
I feel like Scar would love this, in his last hardcore video he talked about his love for rocks! This is such a cool and informative video!
I was thinking about what Scar said while I was watching the video. I bet he'll enjoy this
yeah, and he said it was a rock he had irl, right
I LOVE how Mumbo's practical film making skills came together with his content creator video making skills to produce this amazing final product! 👏🏽
Comment
Reply
I just love that the most realistic mountain of the bunch, is the one with a ballerina cyclops in it.
this is such an awesome video mumbo, well done! hopefully we can see similar stuff like this in the future :)
i agree its good to see a different video every once in a while
Hello
Hey Julian!
I agree ! :D
Agreed, a good change of pace, but still Minecraft. Well done Mumbo. And a big thank you to Catherine, your information was great!!
Could you do another collab with Catherine, showcasing samples of all the different rock and mineral types in Minecraft?
What is Tuff?
What would the closest real-world rock be to Netherack?
Can Geodes really grow big enough to stand inside?
Can lava and water make Obsidian?
Does Diorite really look like bird poop?
From the comments: What kind of stone, is "Stone"?
It'd be really good to see some of this stuff, and get people interested in it all. My uncle is a Geologist, and my mum is a retired Geography teacher. We have small samples of lots of different rocks, metals, and minerals, including Quartz, Amethyst Geode, Obsidian, Gold. It's really interesting stuff, and it can actually give inspiration for builds, just to handle the stuff.
Two words: Yes Please
Tuff is actually a real rock, you can find images of it in the internet.
Lava and water does make obsidian, but it has to be very fluid lava, and I don't think water is actually required make it, it's just when it cools down, but since lava in minecraft doesn't cool down, they used water to do that. I'm not an expert, but I heard things here and there.
Yes, diorite really does look like bird poop.
The last 2 questions are a yes, but idk about the other ones
More importantly, what kind of stone is stone?
I love that my brain now calls Scar's mountain "Mount Scar" after hearing her talk about it.
This geologist is an absolute natural at presenting her subject. She should have her own channel giving lectures on it.
The last few seconds her channel is on the screen
The Hermits must be really proud to know their builds are so good that they could be actually real =D
Billionaire mumbo jumbo fans be like:
Let's see how many subs I get from this comment.,........
@@sapphire5475 most likely 9 at max
@@sapphire5475 0
@@sapphire5475 to your comment or my comment, I did not realise it was notable
Catherine: absolutely they could exist next to each other...
Mumbo: yes thats excellent!
Catherine: because their so small.
also Mumbo: * dies *
they are?
@@Kagamishoshi Compared to the Himalayas yes, yes they are.
I love the way she refers to the builds by the builder's names, it's quite wholesome in a way
Catherine is so expressive and enthusiastic about what she's talking about it really influences others to want to learn more!
almost any topic is fascinating when discussed with such passion and knowledge
@@darkalystar Yeah, it's the mark of a skilled lecturer.
Lots of people can stand there and spew facts, dry and uninteresting. I'm in this picture and I don't like it.
Lots of people can be engaging but ultimately accomplish little other than entertain your time away. Which is fine, when that's what you want.
A good lecturer takes the best of both. This is what you want in an educator.
"So, with an official geologist acquired..."
That's one heck of a mining trip
Must have gone all the way to deep slate
As a geologists who watched season 8 i love this. An alternative theory for B-Dubs mountain based on the surrounding topography as well ot could be a pop up structure formed by strike slip faulting.
What a cool lady! She's easily likable and her passion for rocks and minerals is contagious.
I can totally imagine her taking kids on a field trip and just talking about rocks.
Catherine is just a delight!
Hearing from someone clearly so enthusiastic about her work talk about it on camera is always a treat, and even more so when they're about to connect that to something they typically wouldn't connect it to.
I love how she doesn't refer to them as "X's mountain" she refers to the mountains by name
I mean they X didn't build one to begin with...
Imagine if we had a Bob on the server. Not "Bob's Mountain" but "Mountain Bob"
@@hitentandon7856 They meant X as a placeholder for the various hermits names, not X as in individual hermit.
I think maybe that's how the references were labeled
@@eliassaratsis waiting for vally vegene
Ok, this has to be the most entertaining Minecraft adjacent video I've ever seen, right up there with your Minecraft Earth road trip. But seriously, so well done, as always
Yup
I love how she matches mumbos energy and wholesomenesses, you can tell she is very passionate about what she does by how eager she is to teach some one about what she does
How in the world can Mumbo and Catheryne make talking about rocks for over ten minutes so interesting?
It's just one of life's greatest mysteries
People who are passionate about what they talk about are usually much more interesting to listen to.
Making the video closely related to a game (here Minecraft) that you probably already like is another great trick to keep your attention.
I don't know...witchcraft?
The magic of science :
Given that Cleo is a geologist, that title matchup feels a bit unfair xD
Hi!
Hi there
Hello
Hmm.
Cleo: A Minecraft TH-camr and content creator. Was also a teacher once, though not at a prestigious academy.
Katherine: A working geologist, working with a university to study the field of geology. Has gone on many geological expeditions to study Himalayan topography, geology, geography, etc.
Not much of a comparison, is it?
Edit: Please stop trying to inform me that Cleo was a geologist. The original comment, the one in which this is a reply to, clearly states "Given that Cleo is a geologist..." And so, I have come here assuming that such a detail would be a triviality, and no one would need to make mention of it. However, that was apparently not correct. So I will speak plainly: I know that Cleo was a geologist. But she is no longer working. My comparison still stands whether or not Cleo was a geologist.
I like your videos!
I have the utmost respect to both mumbo and Catherine for collaborating on studying mountains made of virtual blocks.
Actually learned more from this then school and was super funny and entertaining when she said "because it's such a small scale" and then you jumped of the mountain I was laughing for so long
ngl that is so true
Well, to be fair, whilst mountains in Minecraft are very massive and impressive, they're pretty small compared to IRL mountains.
Like you can only build maximum a 380 meters tall mountains in Minecraft, and with generated terrain it's only 250 meters.
Meanwhile, there are IRL mountains that are kilometers in height.
@@limonlx7182 well he's that's what I was thinking but she probably doesn't know about the scale
This comment is hard to read, it could do with sone commas
Engaging in school is typical how you learn. Do you sit and just listen, go browse random shit on the internet during classes or do you actually engage in your education?
I love mumbo's humour in this XD. Him jumping off of his mountain when told it was small was top notch
Alright, Bdubs definitely needs to make a tutorial on how to do realistic mountains now
Don't have the time to watch yet, but did his mountain get an approval?
Easy. Build it between episodes
As a woman who has a bachelors degree in geology, I love seeing other passionate women in the same field! Geology really is such a cool, amazing, and interesting friend of study!
@Drone Dride you really felt the need to get hung up on that didn't you?
The way she talks is so engaging! I’ve never really been into geology before but I honestly couldn’t stop watching, very creative video concept and very well connected!
That’s British teachers right there
Like my science teacher
Very engaging
She shows the love she has with the subject she studies, she is someone that likes her work
I love when you can hear the passion in a teacher/professor's voice. Tends to be some of the most enjoyable lectures to sit through
I can confirm that in the last 3 years she has sounded that enthusiastic the entire time!
When a teacher loves their subject of study, that passion shows and helps inspire learning. Loved how she stayed away from using too technical of explanations but like she was actually helping us visually understand the processes!
@@harrymorgan9358 I can agree and vouch for this 😂
I watch quite a lot of videos on TH-cam because the presenter's enthusiasm for his or her subject is infectious. Catherine is clearly very enthusiastic about rocks and that makes her interesting to listen to.
As a geologist, specifically hydrogeologist, this video is amazing. Thank you Mumbo and Catherine for showing how incredible the field of geology is.
Mumbo, I know this isn’t normally the type of video that you do and you’re probably nervous about the reception but my dude way to go! This is such a unique blend of education and entertainment. Your execution is engaging and dynamic and honestly flawless. Congratulations to you sir.
You should watch his photography channel. It's one of the most enjoyable channels on TH-cam.
When you understand and actually enjoy the concepts that she discusses in this video, it's actually really interesting to listen to. Plus, her referring to the mountains as the creator's names is really funny, but also kind of fitting?
Why wouldn't it be named after the creator?
It takes an incredible amount of knowledge and understanding of a topic to explain it so simply like that, she really knows her stuff and must be a fantastic teacher
I wish that you'd asked about cubs canyon as well. It would be really cool to see how the canyon connects to the story of pearl's mountains
canyons are formed by fluvial activity eg by rivers cutting into the sediment and forming their own basins, meanwhile stalagmites form in karst caves, underground. So I would say its a geologically impossible build. the only possible realistical solution that I can think of is instead of treating them like stalagmites (that they acually are), we look at them like weatheres limestone that form a stone forest.
Kunming stone forest for example. (This place is in China so it even fits the general location of the boatem mountains)
"When something is magical it doesn't have to be scientific"
The Artificers would like a word.
In all seriousness, this is such a cool video. Mad props to Catherine for being so chill and personable, she's so interesting to listen to!
This is just an amazing idea, genuinely you've just created a whole generation of geologists! Using your influence (hate that word) for educational discussion in such a creative way is truly inspiring and motivating. Thankyou!
Why do you hate the word influence?
@@uBreeze it is mainly "Influencer" that I don't like the sound of. U think 'platform' would have been a better word to use if I had thought of it.
@@uBreeze Negative connotation to that word, thanks to the obvious roster of harmful mainstream content creators influencing their viewers for personal gain to do stuff.
Let's see how many subs I get from this comment.,........
Try turning the subject and object around, so you can avoid words you don't want to use. Switch the sentence to bring about the 'inspiring' part first, and then turn the sentence into: ' It was really inspiring to see you create an educational discussion around your builds!'
I'm sorry if I came off as annoying, but I understand your feeling of not wanting to use certain words because I have a lot of those words as well, so I wanted to help you a bit.
10:49 I picture a university professor taking a break from marking exams to check their emails, and getting an email that just reads, "look at this cool rock I found!"
I would love for this to be a series, taking real professionals in varying fields and seeing how they interpret the realism of minecraft builds/redstone contraptions. Love this format! Would enjoy seeing more of it!
gosh can we just take a moment to admire the camerawork and all, mumbo sure puts a lot of passion into videos props for it
I know right
I'm not going to like this comment because I am loyal
I swear if someone ruins this
Love how she referred to the mountains as if they were named "Scar" and "Mumbo" lol thats great
Im 14 and in high school, and I've always wanted to be a biologist or palaeontologist, but i think this has inspired me to be a geologist
Go for it!
Gud
@@catherinemottram9648 She actually replied (Geologist in the video)
Biologist here but I suggest you learn about both while in school, lots of cool stuff to discover in these areas.
Narural history depends a lot on the knowledge of both areas (specially if you like paleo, both geology and biology are important). Just have fun while at it.
cheers
My geology teacher did her degree in environmental science because she said it was a good mix of biology and geology
This was a fantastic video! I'd love more "experts speak about Minecraft" in the future. Great stuff Mumbo!
Economic analyst analyzes hermitcraft economy lol
One thing I wanted to point out in your season 8 but never got the chance to is that the bottom of the waterfall should be deeper than the rest of the lake because of erosion. Maybe the geologist picks it up, maybe not but either way wanted to point it out even though you’ll never change it
To who ever is reading this comment
You are awesome ❤️
My goal is to hit 30k any help would be epic🤩
@@MrJohn0fficial you disgust me in more ways than one
Mumbo delivering yet another incredibly creative video.
before you even watched it
Let’s see how many subs I can get from this comment
Current subs 10032
@@ceegeetee fu
@@frowningmoon3936 i mean based on just the title you can already tell its a very creative idea
@@ceegeetee zero
I can't believe it took me 2 years to see this. And now being a first year in the university of Portsmouth and a geography student who has been taught by Catherine this is so cool!
Love how she’s referring to them like their named “mumbo mountain” and “scar mountain” 😂 “these rocks on scar…”
“These mountains are very small”
*Mumbo Jumbo has fallen from a high place*
🤣 😂
Catherine's energy makes me wanna go loot random rocks now, such a wonderfull person
I have never in my life been interested in geology, but Catherine is an amazingly inspiring educator - and now I'm super keen to learn more about rocks! What a wonderful human!
I’ve had lessons in that Geology Lab!!! What a throwback. Also such a unique video idea, great work Mumbo.
Seeing her so giddy and excited about what she studies is so awesome. She's so into it, and I have nothing but respect for her.
I love the way she referred to the builds as scar and pearl. It really made it feel like they were mt. Scar or mt. Pearl 😂
I love it
one thing I picked up on in my intro geology class elective was that diorite and andesite have approximately the same mineral and silica content, the main difference is grain size, if it cooled fast (extrusive, possibly ejected out of a volcano) it will have larger grains and be closer to diorite, and if it cooled slowly (intrusive, likely magma trapped in the earths crust) it will have smaller grains and be closer to andesite. andesite, diorite, granite (and even basalt) are all igneous rocks meaning they formed from cooling magma.
I would love to hear her thoughts on the Desert behind all those mountains.
I believe "rain shadows" are what you might google for this. When moist air blows over the top of a mountain it cools of and rains, leaving a very dry area on the other side of the mountain range.
@@jonm4206 Yeah, I'm familiar with the elementary concept on it which is why I thought she would have a lot of interesting things to say about it
@@jonm4206 Yeah rain shadows is definitely the answer here - much of Western China above the Himalayas is arid desert. Grey rather than red but in Hermitcraft 8 the red desert makes sense coming off Pearl's build (red sandstone).
This is so wholesome. Given the audience of your videos, you’ve almost certainly inspired (or at least contributed to) someone to become a figure geologist/scientist/lifelong learner.
Crazy to think about right?
As a geology student i am very happy right now. Doesn't happen to often, that geology stands in the spotlight like this and I really like the analysis Catherine puts forward.
Catherine is full of energy and great at explaining..
Mumbo has done a great job at shooting this well...
..the rock identification element of Geology is still tedious to me
As a geologist, I love to see this! Geology is a seriously underrated subject and you're helping to bring this to a big audience in a great video!
geologists in the comments rise up
This is dope! I could see him doing this with more professionals, like engineers or architects, to see how builds could exist in the real world.
Engineer reacts to flying machines.
For example RCE
Yeah I saw a video where architects reacted to time-lapses of building in minecraft,
And they immediately had to pause it, because they didn't expect them to start building in the middle.
Since building in minecraft is more akin to 3D modeling than actually building irl.
Let's see how many subs I get from this comment.,........
I’m amazed that she didn’t even mention the fact that the waterfall was flowing away from the ocean.
its flowing downhill so its fine actually
Water doesn't search for the ocean. It just always goes downhill. And if you keep going downhill you will eventually end up in the ocean. So water can flow "away" from the ocean.
She only got screencaps to reference. Probably doesn't know there's an ocean there
I love how Catherine talks about ‘Scar’ and ‘Pearl’ as if they are the builds themselves and not the builders! I just find that interesting. Of course, it was probably a mistake but even so, it’s cool to think that these pieces of landscape could be named after their creators.
Mount Scar, has a nice ring to it
Geologist HATE him. Learn how he used one simple trick to create geologically impossible mountains!
Lmao
The trick is not giving a shit
LOL
KKKKKKKKKKKKK
Between the really good cinematography of the interview, the knowledge of Katherine and Mumbo's humour, i found this video to be not only good and entretaining, but also very interesting and informative. This is a great peace of content and I hope that Mumbo gets a chance to do this or something similar again, cheers.
I often forget that Mumbo the redstone minecrafter and Ollie the cinematographer are two different people.
I'm a geologist who's been following you and your redstone videos for a while.
I love the interaction of Minecraft with real geology and have been itching to see more real-world associations within the game (give me volcanoes in the game, Mojang!). So to see you go to a geology professor has been the absolute best! Our geology club at my alma mater has a geology club styled Minecraft server that we hope to construct some real-world geological models like mountain folding belts and volcanic features :)
Keep up the cool ideas!