50k Subscriber Q&A!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 มิ.ย. 2024
- In celebration of my channel hitting 50k subscribers last month I thought I'd celebrate with a Q&A video that I originally uploaded on my Patreon.
If you'd like to become a member of my Patreon to see more videos like this you can join at: / elliotroberts
Intro: 00:00
Question 1: 0:41
Question 2: 1:31
Question 3: 1:58
Question 4: 2:53
Question 5: 5:20
Question 6: 6:03
Question 7: 6:20
Question 8: 6:39
Question 9: 7:13
Question 10: 7:50
Question 11: 8:50
Question 12: 10:09
Question 13: 12:01
Question 14: 12:44
Question 15: 13:38
Question 16: 15:09
Question 17: 15:37
Question 18: 16:56
Question 19: 18:49
Question 20: 21:07
Question 21: 22:11
Question 22: 23:27
Question 23 & 24: 23:57
Question 25: 25:15
Patreon: / elliotroberts
Instagram: / elliotroberts
Twitter: / elliotroberts5
Letterboxd: letterboxd.com/elliotroberts - บันเทิง
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA GF D2 | Summer | ร่วมส่งแรงใจ เชียร์ไทยไปพร้อมกัน](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dN2gLsCJ0T0/mqdefault.jpg)
🚨🚨‼️Help me get to 100k!‼️🚨🚨
I didn't mention in the video but that's my next goal and if you're enjoying my videos please consider subscribing to help me achieve it!
You deserve more than 100k
Your content is so mind-blowingly well thought out and meticulously edited! It's so amazing how much effort you put into your videos! I truly love your channel and have watched each video at least five times. Great Job!
Been :)
Joy is the right word! Keep yr TH-cam commentary coming.
I subscribed after watching one video. That's a new record for me!
We better get that 4-hour-long Beatles album ranking video as your 1,000,000 subscriber special.
I'll sign that petition
Best lyricist = Lennon
Best composer = McCartney
Best instrumentalist = Harrison
Best personality = Ringo
Ringo beats all with his ring pop
paul was far better on his instrument than george was on his. its not even clsoe
@@simonjames1604 I see what you're saying. I was thinking more about the range and diversity of instruments that George was able to play, including more complicated Indian instruments.
@@dimetronome yeah george was a better sitar player by far no question. based on the single recording i know of that macca played sitar .
I'd swap McCartney and Lennon as Paul's got the most versatile voice and Lennon has the most experimental/edgy and melodious songwriting
I only have one question, which must have been asked a million times by now: HOW DO YOU DO YOUR HAIR??
love his hair
Fun fact- your videos are what i put on while writing my university essays (even the zelda one lol)
Also- excited for the eventual george harrison discography deep dive :)
I hope I’m not too distracting while you’re trying to write!
As a Lebanese 16 year old who has been infatuated with The Beatles for about a year now, I don't really have anyone to talk about The Beatles to over here, so I'm always overjoyed when you upload. Also, yes they are absolutely underrated. 😉
Wow, I can say the exact thing that you said by just replacing Lebanese with Indian. Glad there are other people of my age too, who are into them :)
One year? Nice. You have more 100 years to go. 😅
I was at an open mic the other night and struck up a conversation with someone about The Beatles and we talked for an hour and a half and it was so fun! I've been obsessed for almost 30 years ha! They don't get old
same! here where i'm from NO ONE talks abt music it's making me insane
Im also Lebanese let’s be friends
My question would have been, what do you think of ELO..... Lennon loved them, the others were slow to catch up, but they all got it eventually....as all people do, eventually
I think they're great! Not a die-hard fan by any means but they've made excellent tunes!
More than one person has said the Beatles would've sounded like ELO by the late 70s if they had've stayed together.
@@lundsweden Well John Lennon said it.... and he's probably the best judge of these things....
@@JoeScottish I forgot it was actually Lennon who said it first, you're right of course!
Chess rating?
For the biopic question, I would love to see a movie that follows the creation of the Beatles Anthology and the emotional journey that must’ve been for Paul, George, and Ringo. A Jackie-style biopic about Yoko Ono after John’s death would also be super cool and a great opportunity to show what a vibrant, interesting person she always has been.
oooh yes love that idea for a Yoko movie! Though that would be extremely emotional
i love you elliot roberts
no shut up . i love him. me
Based name
I can’t believe your only at 50k with the quality of your videos and how good they are. You rlly deserve more
I haven’t watched the video. Praying you paid your respects to Eleanor Rigby 🙏🏻
I went to her grave but could only find a bunch of other Rigbys!
@@ElliotRobertsVideos Wow the entire families there
Amazes me how Elliot knows basically everything about music and film music, definitely will get 100k by the end of the year 👏👏
I was never "introduced" to the beatles because their music is, y'know, everywhere all the time, but I do have a lot of fond memories of playing beatles rock band at my cousins' house as a kid. I remember my favorite songs being hello goodbye, eight days a week, lucy in the sky with diamonds, and ticket to ride. I also remember being shocked upon finding out that here comes the sun was from the same era as come together and not in my life, because all my little ears heard was how "pretty" it did or didn't sound lol
I was introduced to the Beatles by my dad too. He had “1,” “Revolver” and “Beatles for Sale” on CD, and anytime we drove somewhere together we’d listen to one of them. I still know most of the track numbers on “1” by heart. I’m seeing McCartney with him this summer - can’t wait :)
PLEASE do a Bob Dylan video sometime. Also, Are you a fan of King Gizzard atLW? Sorry not a patron but would love to be once I’m not broke. Great video as always
Also, The Boat that Rocked! I loved that movie growing up. Watched it so many times.
Oh, and check out Johnny Greenwoods scores for PTA movies.
George Harrison is most certainly the Beatle you most resemble.
Although I love all four Beatles, I did lean most heavily into the Lennon camp when growing up, but it is an excellent sign of maturity and a healthy mindset when you dispense with the preoccupation with meaningless rubbish like being seen as cool and edgy, and realise that it is far better to be like Paul McCartney with his more balanced outlook and approach to life, than to live with the inner torment that it took for John Lennon to be John Lennon.
Lennon may have written the more emotionally cutting songs, particularly as a Beatle, but Paul McCartney has said himself that he would not trade his happier upbringing and mental stability for Lennon's edge, and, actually, the Lennon lyrics I live by the most are:
Well my instincts are fine
I had to learn to use them in order to survive
And time after time, confirmed an old suspicion
It's good to be alive
And when I'm deep down and out and lose communication
With nothing left to say
It's then I realise it's only a condition
Of seeing things that way
Which is in fact, Lennon at his most McCartney-it's-getting-better-all-the-time-esque.
All Too Much is my absolute favorite Beatle's song, and for being a Beatles song it really is one that can actually be considered underrated. Even the Beatles mostly forgot about it, relegated to the Yellow Submarine album when it could have been on Pepper's because they didn't see it as special. All Too Much just sounds like a psychedelic love song to the universe (and Patti Boyd), just pure joy in it.
I’d honestly like to watch you talk about the music behind some Studio Ghibli films, I think it’d be a pretty unique topic to discuss
Anybody who says the Beatles are overrated are fools. You may not like their music and that’s fair. We all can’t like the same stuff. However the Beatles change the way rock ‘n’ roll had been produced, it changed songwriting, it changed concerts, promotion, record royalties, instruments, uses oh stereo…So if somebody says the Beatles are overrated, they look very foolish and musically illiterate
spot on
Agreed
I sat down to write an entire video essay about Revolver the other day and decided it would be way too difficult. I respect the hell out of what you do here on your channel.
Revolver is one of them goats lol
It’s in my Top 5 would’ve love to see that video essay on it
Love the videos man! One of my questions would have been what your opinion on The Beach Boys is as a whole, more specifically their work post pet sounds like smile, sunflower or Holland. I believe that this era is underrated and has some great gems, I’d love to hear what you have to say!
Could you maybe do a video about the chronology of the Beatles and why they're awesome for like newbies? I love the Beatles but I never bothered to read up on what that whole Allan Klein thing was about and why they went to court and all that, but I would love to know. Not just the negative stuff of course, but yeah, that would be cool. Can't wait for your George video (and I know it gets annoying, but really hoping for a big ole Bowie video :) Would also love to know your take on The Rolling Stones. It's a really old hat, Beatles or Stones, but I tried and I just can't get into the Stones except for some cool hits. Anyway, great stuff you're doing, cheers!
On question 4: people forget how young they were too. They accomplished all they did in The Beatles, had multiple marriages/ serious relationships, and kids before any of them turned 30! That's absolutely wild to think about. So even though they were "mature" and had these incredible careers they still had a lot of ways to go to understand themselves and working the way they did at that rate wasn't conducive to that
hope you’re having a good time travelling mate
THIS IS SO AMAZING MAN! I remember when you were just staring off, its so amazing to see how far you have come! I love your videos, its always an event when a new one comes out, just a big BIG CONGRATS!
Your content is brilliant, keep it up!!
Massive congrats on the milestone, dude, I only started watching a few months ago but as a massive Beatles fan I absolutely love your stuff. Keep up the awesome stuff and here’s to 100k
You always give thoughtful answers to questions. I really appreciate that. Between your rankings of Paul and John's solo output, I learned so much.
Look forward to whatever's next down the line video wise. I know it takes time and I appreciate when we get something new from you.
Cheers! 🍻
There are few channels on youtube that can make hour long videos bearable to watch. Along with the subject matter, the research and intellectual commentary make your videos some of my favorite on the entire platform. Keep it up :).
I've been subscribed since your first video. You are the only TH-camr I can say I've been with since the beginning. Your videos are great, I'm not surprised in the slightest you've earned yourself 58K congrats!
It’s nice to see another fan of LOST. It’s my brother’s favorite show of all time and it’s in my top 3 for sure. Would love to see a video of you talking about it, even though it’s very unrelated to the Beatles lol.
If you wanna see some LOST content you could go to the TH-cam channel Billiam. He has only made one video on season one but is in the middle of making a video on season 2 & 3
Great video man. Loved your comment about being an indie music loving guy you'd meet at a uni in 2011, reminds me of me.
Congrats, love your vids!
Great Video! This is my favorite channel to watch!
My Spotify is permanently on the mono setting, because I listen to the Beatles so much XD
I would love a social network video from you! The social network is my favourite film and always watch it the first week of January so it’s my first film of the year. Also really looking forward to your George video!
I just visited Liverpool 3 weeks ago and went on the Cavern Club’s “Magical Mystery Tour” bus tour! It was great and I was inspired to learn more about the Beatles from your videos! Would recommend for anyone visiting Liverpool!
Hi Elliot, only recently discovered your channel. Since doing so I've binged every one of your videos and loved them all - this one no exception!! Just wanted to drop a comment saying you have gained a fan and loyal subscriber, and to keep up the great work ❤
Also I adore George Harrison - one of my absolute heroes - so very much looking forward to your future vid on him!
Thank you for the video, Elliot! I relate to so many things that you're saying about the Beatles. In these terrible times my love for the Beatles gives me solace and hope. Peace and love!
I've only just been getting into The Beatles recently, at 26 years old, and your videos have been a great kind of guide to grow this interest with. Peace and love!
I'm ten years younger than Elliott's dad. That age and wider family circumstances meant I missed the Beatles - quite liked them but was too cool for school about them. Only woke up to them thanks to 12-year old daughter's response to Sgt Pepper in 1999. Still don't have all their records, not heard all their output, but now realise how massively significant they were, and remain. Mark Lewisohn's approach gives social history of a critical period of time in UK and world before I became aware of it.
If you want one artist plus associated cover collections as backing for a 3-hour intensive cardio recovery exercise programme - Beatles and solo Beatles set to random playback win every time due to variety, change of pace and mood - fascinating to see heart rate, watts, pedal rate, step count, pushups speed with different tracks
You are amazing and you deserve every subscriber! Any plans of seeing Paul on his North American tour?
You deserve every one of these 58k
Anything about George Harrison, I AM IN. He's so favorite beatle and I love his mind and views on existence. Love the videos man
it's so cool that you're a muse fan! Muse and the Beatles are my 2 favourite bands and i got so excited to hear you talk about muse they are so good :)
I’m just saying, you’re one of top 10 my favorite TH-camrs on here. And probably my favorite music related TH-camr. I’m happy for your milestone. ❤️😊
Well well well about time for an update, congratulations!
This was yet another great video! Also, It's All Too Much is ridiculously awesome (you have good taste 👍)
" It's All Too Much" is full of the DNA of Nirvana, Smashing Pumpkins, Tame Impala; so freaking innovative
i hate to ask a question that wont be answered in the comment section of a qna video but whats your favourite radiohead song? love your videos btw
Gotta go with Paranoid Android.
Here are two thoughts (feelings) to share about the Beatles, one which keeps coming to mind time after time year after year and one that hit me just today. 1- The emotional intensity and compelling beautiful grittiness of John Lennon’s singing voice is a gift to the human race (more specifically to Rock N Roll and yes, so is Paul’s but for some reason John’s voice grabs me harder). 2 - The song “If I Fell” is such an incredibly gorgeous piece of art. The melody and harmony tracking together along with the chord changes and sparse arrangement are ear/mind boggling. To think that they were in their early twenties and cranking out songs of this caliber in the pop genre but somehow not at all constrained or limited by it is just amazing.
I really enjoyed your thoughtful analysis and reviews of the complete post Beatles Paul McCartney and John Lennon albums. Tuning into your videos spurred me to re listen to the albums I was familiar with and some I wasn’t.
Having parents introduce you to the music that they love is just such a cool thing, my Mum and Dad made a CD for both me and my brother when we were born and they pretty much became the basis of our music tastes. Personally think mines better cause of the John Lennon and Van Morrison songs, although he does have some great Paul McCartney and Simon stuff in there.
Love the Weyes Blood mention, I’ve been really loving her work. In fact, I almost feel like ‘Andromeda’ could have been a George song just from those diminished chords alone. Let alone that slide guitar - I swear i had to double check that wasn’t somehow George himself!
Regarding question 19, would you ever consider making a video discussing your ideas on a Beatles bio-series? Either on TH-cam or as a Patreon exclusive?
When you were about to answer who is the second greatest artist, I was praying to god that you would say David Bowie, the fact that you actually did made me so happy
I’m just on why way to walk to vote in the Australian election. So thanks for the video. Perfect timing
I was just in Liverpool 3 weeks ago for my belated senior trip! I've been a faithful Beatles fan since I was 5 and I'm from Louisiana, it still doesn't feel real it was an amazing experience and I'm so thankful for all the memories I made and this beautifully diverse world we live in!!
To put in my two cents about question 21:
I didn't like the beatles growing up because the only songs they played on radio about them were either their pre-rubber soul stuff which just sounded old to me (I was already into electronic music like techno) and their early stuff isn't their best really.
It wasn't until 2008 that I started getting into them, when I was already 20 years old-- I was at an internet cafe and they started playing I Want You (She's So Heavy) and I asked the title of the song and I looked it up on my laptop and I literally went "The Beatles made THAT?!"
Radio stations just don't play the best stuff around here
I know it’s a pretty difficult subject to talk about freely (cause you know, copyright) but as a longtime fan now, I’d love to know your thoughts on Prince’s music and contributions to pop music (for me, it’s a tie between him and Bowie for my favorite artists). Also, I’d love to hear about your thoughts of Whiplash (one of my favorites movies :D), I think you’d be able to squeeze something good out of such a great movie (at least to me).
Loved the video, came across you because of the Beatles and stayed because of your introspection, aesthetic and that marvelous hair!
I'm in my early seventies. Needless to say, I grew up with The Beatles. I love your channel. I find your insight, enthusiasm and overall attitude an ever evolving inspiration.
I want that miniseries now! That would be so cool!
Inspiring as always
Wow! I can't believe it's almost 60k! You probably don't remember me but I was your 70th subscriber! Love your content. Keep it up man!
CONGRATS ON 58K!!!!! You made me more interested in the Beatles, and I agree that It’s All Too Much is very amazing.
Would love to see a ridiculously long video where you rank every solo beatles album along with the bands albums together.
Congratulations Elliot!
I love it’s all too much! Great deep cut pick
Great information. Thank you.
its all too much is a top harrison song, you are the realest
I love It’s All Too Much! The drums are incredible. But is it a loop??
What’s your favourite country you have visited?
Congrats homie!
When you were talking about your Beatles movie idea, I realised I had been at 2 of those concerts-George (with Ravi and Billy) and Wings in the Kingdome.
Great vlog brother but it was john doing the intro for i feel fine and the famous feed back
I could listen to you talking about the Beatles all day long 😊
Dang thanks for releasing this vid
I got really happy when you said you like Tame Impala
Love your videos. Please do a favorite Beatles documentaries video
Hope for more brian videos in the future !
You’re my favorite youtuber, so awesome
congrats man
LOST is my favorite show too.
I almost spit out my milk when I heard you say Weyes Blood, I ADORE HERRRR!! You showed titanic rising and if by chance you haven't listened to Front Row Seat To Earth its MAGNIFICENT as well! Cheers❤️
On the question of soundtracks, Trainspotting (my favourite film) is still untouchable. The opening drums of “Lust For Life”, The Synthesiser of “Born Slippy”, and the bounce of “Mile End”. A class of its own.
A classic!
Love to see another Guadagnino Suspiria fan in the wild, that film is so layered and open for examination but stays terrifying in ways not many horror movies do for me. Also one of Tilda Swinton's best performances 🥰
I always loved the way Phil Collins handled his situation with Genesis.. He was making solo albums all throughout the 80s and he was still creating lots of stuff with Genesis as well.. And it's all great music
It's all too much is my favourite George composition. It's a real band effort, a great Jam, it's sensational.
So underrated
It's so fun listening to a real Beatle fan and enthusiast.
The Beatles are a band that I can only describe as elemental to my own music taste. I legitimately cannot remember a time when their music wasn’t in my life- the only other artist I can say that about is Bruce Springsteen. Thank you for making such great content that does justice to one of my all-time favorite bands ❤️
You are my favorite TH-camr!
My love for older music started with my Year 6 teacher, whose surname was (ironically) Beatle. I can remember the moment that my life started when he wheeled a crappy old TV to the front of the class and started playing Elvis Presley's 'Jailhouse Rock'. He always used to tell us that he was the original Beatle because he was born the year before they started using the name, and we spent 20 minutes every Friday listening to whatever tracks he had lined up for us: 'Twist and Shout', 'Good Golly Miss Molly', 'Blue Suede Shoes', 'I Saw Her Standing There', etc. That's where it all begun, and now it's come full circle again and I couldn't be happier for it.
I feel like the idea you've got with your answer for question 19 is honestly just adapting Peter Doggett's *You Never Give Me Your Money* book and adding the context of the albums/concerts they were doing to give more heft to it. My favourite part about the Beatles' history is the messy financial side of it, because those eternal lawsuit squabbles and financial problems they all had are, weirdly, very helpful in understanding them and their dynamics post-breakup (and _also_ very entertaining because I would love to see a miniseries where the whole cow business Yoko had is recreated, honestly); but I'm pretty sure we'd have to wait for everyone to be dead, because I doubt Paul and Yoko/Sean would let that fly lol (they barely let the book be published, so).
Either way, a lovely Q&A! Can't wait for that George video
Can really relate to the Love album being an early Beatles purchase and being obsessed with it 😆
Great video!!! 🙏🏼
Yes! I consider "It's All Too Much" their best song in 1967 and someday the full unedited stereo version will be officially released 🎶🎶🎶🙆♂️🙆♂️🙆♂️👌👌👌👏👏👏
There's already an outstanding stereo mix of "It's All Too Much" on Yellow Submarine Songtrack.
I am the same with Paul and George. When my cat had 2 kittens when I was 11 years old I named them Paul McCartney and George Harrison. 😹
epidly awesome
love ur videos mr. elliot man robert
Love Ur videos!!!! Can't wait for George Harrison's discography vid
I'm interested in your opinion of the concept fan made album "Everyday Chemistry", comprising a mix of the Beatles solo work similar to the "Love" album. And if you've never heard of it i'd like to see you make a video on it.
I would Absolutely love to see a video where you like break down your music playlists if you have any!!
Very cool channel !