PLEASE READ: I noticed something I think you'll find interesting. back in "do princesses dream of magical sheep" you commented on how it was suprising that Big Mac dreamed of using magic considering since he never expressed that desire. but in the first scene, when Granny Smith pointed out the old toy to him she mentioned how much Apple Bloom loved how he made that toy fly and it "was like she thought you used magic". what if Big Mac's desire to secretly use magic is just from being idolized by his sister
+EdXLover1 They never said that, they said we'd see him soon. They never specified what soon meant. But speculation is that he'll actually show up in "The Hooffelds and McColts".
On your questions: 1. My reaction was 20 seconds of shocked silence, trying to get what was going on, before a 10 second uncontrollable giggle fit. 2. Big Mac was HILARIOUS in this episode. I loved his 'antics' to death! 3. As I don't have any siblings at all... No. However, I can say that it was still meaningful and heartwarming, despite the un-relatable circumstances. 4. I don't thing honestly that we'll see much more of these two together, but if we shall, then I'd say that I'd love to see an episode where they discuss the conflict of "the pen is mightier than the sword," or "actions speak louder than words," with them being in so,e kind of situation where applebloom takes the diplomatic approach, and Big Mac goes for a more direct tactic. Not sure what exactly, but i think that that could really work.
Believe it or not, I actually wrote a "Mac in Drag" snip over in the Infinite Loops thread... I think maybe a week before the original Mac in Drag pic was leaked?
Well, when I first saw "her" I simply left the phone and went out for a walk (laughing like an idiot, of course) I loved this episode: funny, touching, weird -as hell- and not that predictable. I like Big Mac overall; he's such a good guy
+DRWolf001 When I first saw Big Mac, my mouth dropped wide open until the commercial break started. My step father was watching a few yards behind me, but this was our exact dialogue from the both of us: Me: "Adam?" Adam: "Yes?" Me: "You just saw what I just saw, right?" Adam: "E'yup." Both of us: "Big Mac is a crossdresser."
REAL STALLIONS WEAR DRESSES TO HELP THEIR LITTLE SISTER!!!!! i loved this episode, i was happy to see Big Mack in the spot light, heck it even got a tear outta my eye, also i was so happy to finally see Rainbow Dash and Scootaloo were in the Sisterhooves Social and won, i loved it great vid Doc
+SuperGodzilla2 Yeah, the interactions between Rainbow Dash & Scootaloo were definitely the second-best parts of the episode for me! (I think we can all agree what the best part of the episode was, right?)
It was impressive as we have gotten the most dialogue out of Big Mac in the history of the show. Up until now, he was always the strong silent type who didn't have to say much for others to understand what he's talking about.
This has got to be one of the funniest episodes in the entire show so far! XD I always liked Big Mac but I never realized how awesome he actually is. The fact alone that he'd put himself under such trouble and embarrassment (and perhaps even some humiliation) just so he could make his little sister happy (besides making himself feel better, as well. But mostly making his sister happy) shows how much he cares about his family. And honestly? Hear him on a speaking role alone is always a big amusement, but hear him doing something so unexpected and speaking all throughout while at it completely broke me. I completely lost it in so many occasions while watching this episode. XD I wish we'll get more episodes in which Big Mac has a larger speaking role beyond his traditional eyups and nopes. Wouldn't hurt to give him more screen time more often! P.S: And on that note, I still wish for a Celestia and Luna-centered episode. Or at least Celestia (since Luna sorta already had her Luna-focused episodes but not Celestia). I'd LOVE to see more of them interacting as sisters. What we saw from them in Slice of Life only left me wanting more.
This was a grand episode that I've been waiting for quite some time to watch! Just see the preview and attempting my voice reel for Orchard Blossom made me feel that DHX was able to pull off something so awkward, yet beautifully put together!
I really hope that, if it doesn't already exist, they put on an actual brotherhooves social in addition to the sisterhooves. It would be great to see more interaction with the main characters and their family members plus it would be a lot of fun to see AJ and Big Mac go up against Twilight and Shining Armor
I'm an only child, myself, but my cousins include: a Medical Doctor, and IRS worker, a couple of recognized war vets, and an Olympic track star. You likely had already seen him run. Then there's me: the guy w/ a Bachelor's degree in a hard science and nothing to show for it...
When I was watching this episode I never really cared for the whole orchard blossom persona knowing it was doomed to fail, but what I got from this episode is confirmation of what I already figured out is that Big Mac is actually quite intelligent more so than what people give him credit for
Dave Polsky, you have been redeemed. Even though I'm in the crowd that doesn't hate Appleloosa's Most Wanted, it wasn't as good as it I hoped it would have been. This was nothing short of amazingness! :D
When i saw this i went...oh my...they did it...they really did it...And then the end i was like....oh if only my brother and I got along in the past that good..
Great review, Doc. :3 You mentioned Mac's princess dream and how no one saw this coming. I have to agree there but it's interesting to think of it in reverse. Now that we've seen that Mac's been dealing with the feeling of being in his sister's shadow with his ordinariness, to me it gives a whole new context as to why that might be his dream self. Just food for thought~!
I hope, if Big Mac ever gets another episode, it would be a bro episode with Shining Armor and Spike. It might never happen, it'd be cool nonetheless, no?
+Adam Kay It definitely would! In fact, when I first read the synopsis for this episode I thought it would be a Twlight and Shining episode. Though I was slightly disappointed it turned out not to be such, everything in this episode made up for it brilliantly.
+Adam Kay That would be great. I don't know why they'd all be hanging out but it might be interesting. Spike might be able to feel connected with some guys, which is good for a child to have mentors on both sides of the genders. :) Wow I just got into some child psychology crap. :P Anyway it could make for a fun episode as long as it's executed well. :D
The last time Big Mac ever spoke more than two words at a time was... Ponyville Confidential. Episode 49!!! 59 episodes since a solid Big Mac speaking role (as singing doesn't count since it's a rehearsed song and not singing as exposition or anything similar). Also, 108 episodes before Big Mac gets his own monologue, and EVEN THEN it's at the end of the episode. I'm pretty sure Big Mac's Monologue is going to become a video of its own just to show Big Mac speaking.
I was actually kinda scared that this episode would make big Mac more of a softer male, compared to spike, and other males in mlp. They did that, but with a mature way, and made it look like family would be the only reason he would change to...a...Orchard Blossom.
This episode had me going "wut" more times than I've ever done before. It all made sense but my mind had an extremely hard time wrapping around it. Even when I was telling what happened I couldn't stop saying "wut". It was a nice for him to do it but I keep on remember when Granny said "the term "sister" is rather loose for this" or something and I couldn't stop questioning why he dressed up if the word "sister" is meaningless.
I was shocked when I first saw "Orchard Blossom" via a preview clip a couple of days before the episode aired, but my reaction quickly turned to laughter as I thought it was just hilarious. Sweetie Belle and Scootaloo's respective reactions to seeing this cousin of Applebloom's is just priceless, for I don't think they were prepared to see something like that.
One thing that I thought was funny was the bit at the beginning, where Granny is having Big Mac help her look for a prize ribbon. By itself it's only mildly humorous, but the way those two were in that scene was so much like how my mom and I were while trying to pack and unpack for an interstate move that, to me, it was HILARIOUS!
A very enjoyable episde. Oh the gorgeous amont fo cringty XD Actually looking back at the princess bigmac thing....... It actually makes more sense now. Alicorns are basically heroes to ponies. They are the most powerful of their kind and typically exist to defend them against terrible fiends. Bgimac wanting to be an alicorn would make sense then if he has feeling unimportan.t
+D HAROLD () I disagree. The only one that really seemed a bit humiliated, was Applebloom, while Big Mac was committed to the cause of giving her a win in the event! I personally don't like cringe humour, but in this episode, I found none! ********************************************************************************************** I found it hilarious with the contrast between Big Mac's size, regular manners and speech, and the mannerism and speech of "Orchard Blossom", as well as the attempts on not getting revealed as a stallion, more for the risk of getting disqualified than for any humiliation.
This has become my favorite episode. Being a big brother myself this episode shows how far siblings will go to help. Also the feelings that come when your younger siblings start to find other role models and broaden their horizons. It also provides one of the most honest and touching scene's I've seen to date in mlp with the final Big Mac and Applebloom talk. As for Orchard Blossom this is something I'm sure is going to provide inspiration comedic and otherwise to the fandom. I have to Agree entirely with you Dr Wolf for a another spot on review thank you :-)
I just adore this episode. When I heard Big Mac talking like a mare I nearly fell out of my seat. I couldn't help but wonder how many takes it took Peter to do all the Orchard Blossom bits without cracking up. Sweet moral at the end and all together good episode.
This episode brought a few tears in my eyes at the end. It was so sweet. I just loved that conclusion. I loved seeing how far Big Mac would go for his little sister. There is so much more I would like to say for this episode, but I don't know how to put it all to words.
I am so happy that they finally showed one of the males in the series, well one of the regular males, as something other then a flat window dressing. And overall the drive he had to try and make his baby sister happy was very heart warming. I think this one is going to be my new favorite episode of the entire generation.
I am the oldest of my 2 other siblings like Big Mac, so this episode really hit me hard. That last scene almost caused me to tear up, which isn't hard to do, but coming from MLP? Almost unheard of. I felt myself connecting with Mac on so many levels and it really added a new layer to his character and caused me to love him even more. This episode was by far one of my favorites this season.
My god, that episode should be named "Tears" because I cried hilarious, painful, and sad tears all in one episode. Also did anyone else notice the musical reference to Back to The Future during the race?
I would like to see Apple Bloom and Big Mac have a stand alone episode based on them both taking up Bowling for the first time and this will be the perfect time for them to make their bonds grow even stronger and as for them both they will have the best day ever. Who knows what lies around the corner. Maybe Big Mac is the only one who can help Apple Bloom earn her Cutie Mark by rewarding her with a "Apple Shaped Bowling Ball" Cutie Mark as a symbol of her skill with a Bowling Ball and you can just imagine the joy Apple Bloom would feel if Big Mac helped her achieve her long lost dream of having a Cutie Mark.Apple Bloom will always look at her flank knowing her Big Brother got her the Cutie Mark and she will always cherish it and to respect him a lot more. I know this is just my theory but there is no harm in discussing it.
I thought this was a nice episode to have character development for not only Big Mac, but also Apple Bloom, we've never seen an episode that explores the brother/sister relationship between Apple Bloom and Big Mac, and it was done so well, and the ending is really emotional and I loved it, so kudos to Dave Polsky
i had no idea about this episode and just watched it and i have to admit it was surprised. im glad that big Mack got more lines and this gave his charter more depth and the way is was done was done well and had a very good moral
I did see that coming after I read the description on wiki. I thank that the writer should create a new team of hero, which mean that we already have main six and CMC, so is time to create a new team. My suggestion is Big Mac that should be part of the team or Spike, so they will have a chance to be hero.
While I do think that the story is actually pretty good overall, Big Mac dressed had me cringeing all the way. But there are still great things about this episode. I liked that Rainbow Dash and Scootaloo won the event together, I just love seeing them together.
Hey DrWolf love your content, this is definitely one of my favorite episodes. Not because of Big Mac dressing as a mare (while that was funny that was more awkward than anything) no, what I enjoyed was toward the end with Big Mac's speech, that made me tear up. Definitely woth the wait for a Big Mac episode. I could see where Big Mac was coming from and at the same time I could see why Applebloom was acting that way as well, which is awesome. And I loved the scenes between Rainbow Dash and Scootaloo, they were great!
I was grandly entertained by the episode. And it did strike home for me a bit. As a big brother to lots of sisters, I've had some moments when I've felt marginalized or unappreciated in the family, especially as my siblings grew older. But I've been comforted to know that my efforts are still appreciated and that I'm still a good big brother in their eyes.
I didn't know dr. wolf had 5 other siblings, reminds me of my mom she had at least 6-8 siblings and she was qualified as the human soccer ball among them
My first reaction when I saw Orchard Blossom? I completely cracked up! XD As for the rest of the episode, I loved it! Big Mac had slowly started to grow on me recently and this episode just cemented his spot among my favorite characters.
Best episode of the season for me, right in front of the three Rarity episodes we just had. Sadly, it triggered a bunch of hatred from trans activists on Tumblr and other websites and they're currently tearing a new hole to the writers. Since when is drag considered "transmysoginist?" Drag queens, crossdressers don't mean to insult transwomen. They're two, three even, groups of people. People are just people. If a silly cartoon is triggering you, than I swear you need to review your priorities.
I looked up what you were talking about just to see if you were exaggerating. You weren't! I can't say I liked this episode, it was WAY, WAY too cringy for me, but people are literally saying that this episode should be BANNED. O.o Damn.
+Teddie Sage It won't, I'm sure - these are the people who two days before the episode aired admitted they wouldn't watch it due to premise alone! No one is taking them that seriously, especially the people in charge.
+fraya1022 I hope not. I wasn't in the fandom back when Derpy was changed, but I got emotionally attached to the story of her struggle to remain uncensored in time for ep. 100. I don't want to actually be a part of a repeat of history, though.
I think everyones initial reaction was a slack jaw and at least a minute of silence. Also one of my first thoughts were "at least his wig isn't a blue afro". (anyone who get's that, you're awesome!)
+Greycat R I'm probably going to be in the minority for this, but if I have to be honest, I was not only laughing at this episode, I was also cringing. I don't know why, since I don't think there's any problems with this episode. It was both entertaining and heartwarming, but I couldn't stop cringing during the middle. It's probably just a personal gripe.
+SquidofBaconator it is all about the suffering and humiliation, it took me time to just think to myself "wow! this is so humiliating, that it is funny"
+D HAROLD () There is no humiliation there(ok, Appleblom might feel a little of it), and clearly no suffering. The fun is the contrast between how Big Mac usually is, and what he do and say to pass off as "sister". ^_^
+SquidofBaconator () I tend to be allergic to cringe humor, but I wasn't cringing at all here. Probably because I had more the feeling that Big Mac would not be humiliated if revealed, just disqualified. And eventually that assessment proved kind of correct, but he wasn't even disqualified, he and Applebloom was instead disqualified for lacking sportsmanship!
OH. MY GOD!! I cried tears of joy during that scene at the end. I LOVED this episode! It was funny, it was sweet, and it was SO MOVING at the end! I LOVE it! Your highlighting of Sweetie Blooms lack of observation, and Big Mac's noticing it (with his TRUE observation skills) was very observant of you, Doc. :D How fitting! ^_^
I really enjoyed this episode, the ending was a very good one and its really the most we've had Big Mac talk at all (Outside the Southern Belle voice that is) and it was very sincere, I hope that Big Mac carries the lesson from this episode with him and learns to open up more, maybe it'll reflect in other aspects of his life and he'll have more speaking parts for it ^ ^ Per usual, great episode, Doc! Keep up the great work!
Overall, this episode definitely through me for a loop. I can honestly say I did not see it coming when Big Mac showed up in drag (which literally made me stare with my mouth hanging open). Perfectly executed with that one, especially the voice he chose to sell the act. It's good to know that every pony still managed to see through his ruse, but decided to go along with it anyway out of respect for his noble intentions. That's excluding that one older guy who seemed to be genuinely taken with Big Mac's performance. Seriously, I love the fact that the big guy finally got an episode devoted to him, as well as his relationship with Apple Bloom. That and the fact that he got a lot more dialogue here than his usual monosyllabic lines of eeyup and nope. I always enjoy episodes that allow him to speak full sentences. Definitely one of my favorites of the season. On a tangentially related note, this is the third episode we've had in a row that has not featured either Pinkie or Fluttershy. I hope they both get some love in the next one.
+SimplyJay Considering the fact that the next episode will involve the Cutie Mark Crusaders, Pipsqueak, and the likes of Diamond Tiara, I'd say we probably won't be seeing either one of them yet.
Crazy Luigi Yeah, I wrote that comment before I found out that the next is a CMC episode. There's still the possibility that they could make an appearance.
It's an episode that will really play with your emotions. It has scenes that can make you laugh out loud and scenes that can make your eyes tear (tbh, I teared a little). It's nice having episodes like this from time to time, giving focus to other than the Mane 6. Most sincerest episode so far for me, followed by "Amending Fences". Amazing Job to the writers!
I love how Big Mac seems to have an easier time expressing his thoughts in the guise of Orchard Blossom. Either he feels more comfortable when he feels under cover or he simply is method acting as a character he created. Still it seems relatable to me that it's easier to say what you're thinking when you're not yourself. Take, for instance, when you're commenting under a user name verses speaking up in a group of people who know you and whom you see often... ;)
This is the only episode of this show that legit made me cry. It makes up for the boring episodes of this season. I was starting to lose hope in season five but this episode single-handedly restored my faith in it. Rarity Investigates was also a good episode and gave me hope that the season would change itself around. But this episode convinced me to hang out for a great season finish. I also have a personal connection to this episode for various reasons. This episode was an animated masterpiece. It has a timeless message for all ages and generations. This is the kind of episodes that should be coming out of the show, not stuff like Princess Spike. I think we can all agree Princess Spike was the lowest point of MLP history.
I'm the oldest of three siblings and the second oldest of six SUPER close cousins (So close they might as well have been siblings as well). My brother is currently in the marines but was always good at sports. My sister was heavy into music and always got really good grades. My cousins have also been excellent at music, grades and sports. This left...me, the basic black sheep. I was smart, but my grades didn't show it. I played the violin for awhile, but it never really went anywhere. There were a couple of sports I loved, but never got a whole lot of support for. It was hard. Nobody ever really noticed my own creative side, since my siblings and cousins also had a creative side. I haven't been feeling very noticed or appreciated for the past several years since they've all gotten older. And then I saw this episode. It kept me on the verge of tears the entire time. And then the ending was what got me. It helped me realize that, even though we're all growing up and getting out into the world, they may not say so but my siblings and cousins do love and appreciate me for what I have done. Where I am going in my life. And how I've helped them in the little ways I can. Honestly, I think this episode will stay with me for a LONG time.
hey dr wolf! I'm on a bit of a mlp reviews marathon right now and had to stop and comment on this. I am the middle of 3 girls. Recently, my younger sister and i had sat down and talked about our futures, i'm getting certified on medical billing and shes going for her degree in computer science. She showed me where she could be possibly interning for this summer and I told her what my grandmother had told me about medical billing, how it' always going to be needed, from dentist offices, to specialists. She said to me something that I always wanted to say "I'm going to be better then [my older sister]". sure we will both make more money, and I finally know what it's like to have all A's on my report card, but the idea of surpassing my sister is an added bonus. We had always been compared to her and it would aggravate us to the point of depression. Our one grandmother(different one then the one before) always talks about her and never talks about us. Now that we feel confident in doing something she can't, we feel better. With that being said, my older sister has paved an incredible path for us and I thank her for it.
I was laughing so hard when I saw this episode, Dave Polsky made a great turnaround after Appleloosa's Most Wanted. Loved the character interactions, the heartwarming final scene, the song was good and Rainbow and Scootaloo competing in the social, I give it 8/10 ^^
This is easily one of the best episodes of the whole season. I was shocked to see Big Mac dressed in drag, but it was hilarious, especially how he never really fooled anypony (except that one guy). I just loved it!
While I at first found myself profoundly disturbed for the first moment of seeing Big mac acting COMPLETELY unexpectedly as this different ponysona, I gave it a moment to sink in by pausing the video and relaxing a bit. At first I was wildly confused, but now I am extremely grateful for watching this episode, while also having a giggle. Simply put, It takes a lot of determination and integrity to stand up and being a brother or sister to your siblings. Big Mac is a Shining apple in the orchard for this, as he displays his love and appreciation for his sister Applebloom in this episode. This even speaks to me at a personal level with my sister and step brother, and I definitely view this as a great episode. Very comical, informational, heart warming, and it just goes to show the dedication one's family member can have to make someone smile.
I think Sweetie Belle and Scootaloo's reaction to Big Mac was the same across the board. Good episode and loved that moral. Didn't mind Big Mac's shtick but I think it went on a bit too long. I would love to see another episode with Apple Bloom and Big Mac but I'll let the writers make up the plot.
I feel you Doc, I grew up with 3 siblings. My older sisters were the popular sports and student council members, my younger brother was the head of almost every honor society, played every instrument, and is straight A student, and then there's me. It was a rough road trying to make your mark when others may outshine you
While I loved this episode, I can't help but feel it's kind of ironic that Applejack's the one getting all of the praise (regardless of how it was from her sister) since she's seen outside of the show as the most forgettable member of the Mane 6
I can't say I connect with the aspect of one sibling outshining another (we're both polar opposites when it comes to talents), but as an older brother to a younger sister. What really hit home was the part when Big Mac told Apple Bloom that she used to look up to him when they were younger. As they got older, it appeared she didn't see him the way she used to, which is exactly how I feel now. My sister admits that I taught her more than just how to kick butt at video games, and because of that connection, the ending to "Brotherhooves Social" was downright brilliant and almost brought a tear to my eye. Well done, Mr. Polsky and nice review Doc.
the moments that got to me was the opening with granny smith going snicker doodle XD and the judge falling for Orchard bloom and did you see the building close by in the sun set was that the house? could be wrong. THIS WAS ADORABLE AND AWESOME at the same time
When Orchard Blossom first appeared all I could do was pause the video and try not to crack a rib. It may be one of the funniest scenes of the entire series!
My reaction, as I haven't seen this episode, came from seeing Orchard Blossom when you showed the clip here in this review. And it was exactly the same expression on my face as yours. I was like, "What the?.."
I think Orchard Blossom was a great addition to this episode. In that role we got a nice hint to the little moment between him and Pinkie Pie in Pinkie Apple Pie where she said she never saw it that way, now we can realy see that he can express himself very well, also the part with the song was pure gold. While Applebloom was worried because it took Applejack so long Big Mac memorized the lines way faster, probably thanks to his experience in the Ponytones so a few subtle hints to continuity as well
***** That might also be very likely, to me it just seemed so because of his victorious grin right before as if he wanted to say "Well seems I am better in that regard" and that was the reason why I though about it that way
Dave Polsky bravo! I had to stop the episode several times just to let out all the laughter i couldn't brush off. I mean I had to step back and just let it all out, tell some one what just happened laugh even harder and then take a moment to compose myself to get ready for what came next. This episode was the biggest curve ball yet and the heartwarming moment at the end had me ready to cry.
I felt so much for Big mac this episode, especially at the beginning. I'm the oldest of ultimately four kids, but since two of my siblings are only half, and they lived with my dad, growing up it was mainly my little sister and me. My sis and I were insanely close when we were little; we did just about everything together, but when my dad came back into our lives so did my other siblings, and since they were closer in age to her, my sis started spending more time with them, and we started to drift apart. I felt like I lost my best friend, and I definitely empathize with big mac here. I'd do anything for my sister, and I wish we could be as close as we used to be.
I really love how they established what is most commonly known as "middle-child syndrome" something i was waiting for them to make an episode about. That and a big mac episode with him doing a funny voice had me is tears of laughter.
Anyone else catch that in Sisterhooves Social, Sweetie was the only one who could participate in the Social, and now only Apple Bloom and Scootaloo can compete. Now all three CMC have participated. But Apple Bloom was the only that didn't enjoy it
+Cilan Steele Hopefully next time they have it (assuming we actually see the next Sisterhooves Social, of course), we get to see all three of them performing in it and enjoying themselves there.
As the oldest of six kids, I understand exactly where Big Mac is coming from. So much so that I knew what his motives were before they even started the race. It was a great heartwarming episode that really made me wish I was more like him.
This apisode is my favorit from now on. It tugged on my heart strings and as a big brother myself I know the feelings he goes throu. Damn this apisode skyrocketed to the top as the subject is so close to my heart
I personally think Rainbow was not at a maturity level or had a deep enough connection with Scootaloo for the first Sisterhooves Social to work. But, Rainbow has grown so much as a character since then! It seemed very genuine and more meaningful.
It was surprising didn't think they would have him cross dressing again but at the end I know he did it for Apple bloom so they could spend time together
This hit home for me as the eldest brother of four, I really identified with Big Mac. I less felt for him on the "not living up to another sibling" as much as the need to be able to impress the younger sibling.
I admit... I teared up a bit in the final scene. As a big brother with another sibling that my little sister always looked up to more than she looked up to me, I could really empathize with what Big Mac was going through here.
2:52 Oh, yeah. Speaking of that, MLP-FiM continues the American media tradition of disparaging males. Who is the only one fooled by Big McIntosh's costume? The stallion judge. So, unless he *wasn't* fooled and is, in fact, gay and into drag queens... yeah. That whole stallion-judge-attracted-to-Big-Mac plot line was a slap in the face to every male on the planet.
When I saw big mac in drag...I got in my batman voice and duly declared the following: There are some things a man cannot unsee, no matter how much Brain Bleach he might consume in the ensuing hours.
I have to agree. I was waiting and hoping for a Big Mac episode since I read the IDW comic and since Granny Smith had a couple episodes surrounding her, he was the only Apple member left to do. This episode did not disappoint. We not only saw how determined, dedicated, - and let's face it - desperate he was to make his sister happy that it did wonders for his character. Not only that, but he's quite articulate isn't he? Sure he was playing a character, but I think this makes sense why he's so quiet most of the time. This sort of reminds me of me and my big brother. Unlike you, Dr. Wolf, I only have one sibling. He went on to be a doctor, so I guess I can relate to Big Mac as he's the "hero" of the family (not that my folks put us on pedestals or anything). While he does like to tease me and play mind games with my head (he was a valedictorian. They do that...), he is still one of the greatest brothers I could ever hope for. One time, he helped me scratch an item off my bucket list: Seeing a living Beatle live in concert! Sir Paul McCartney!!! This is a memory I will cherish forever. He likes the Beatles too, but I'm the die-hard fan of the family. The minute he saw he was coming to where he lived, he immediately got tickets and texted me to take the time off. Sure, he drives me crazy and I drive him crazier, but I know that no matter what, he will always be there for me. There was a time after a bad breakup that I was scared I'd end up old and alone (I'm dramatic like that). He assured me if that if something happened to Mom and Dad and I was still alone, he'd let me live with him and my sister-in-law, no questions asked. Sorry for the long winded bio, but I love sister-brother stories. I guess I can relate more to Twilight and Shining Armor more that Big Mac and his sisters, but the love is there nonetheless, even if we don't always "like" each other. ;)
This episode was GREAT! I couldn't stop laughing at Orchard Blossom. The comedy surrounding her/him was hilarious, namely Sweetie Belle's, Scootaloo's and Rainbow Dash's reactions. Priceless! And that ending made me tear up...seriously... second time this season where I cried! ( First is Tanks for the Memories ) More Big Mac!!!
i still freak out every time he says more than "eeyup" and i cried a little at the end XD seriously though, an episode that develops the character of somepony that only ever said yup or nope throughout the entire series?! i can't even... i... gaaahhh! i love it :D
This might be my favorite episode of season 5. This is what I've been hoping for for so long, and it's something that Mr. Quill brought up awhile ago, saying that they usually focus on the bonds between sisters because this is a girls show but he said how little girls can have brothers too and I can't think of a better episode for that. Sure Twi has her BBBFF but I don't think Shining could carry himself through a whole episode of him and Twilight, there just isn't much to his character as far we've seen. But with Big Mac, I've always loved him and his personality has been expanded upon a lot as of late, like him being in a band or being sports buddies with Spike and other stuff too, but I had been hoping for an episode about him with either AJ or Applebloom and this one was just great. It wasn't perfect but no episode is and I don't think any other heart to heart talk has gotten through to me as much as Applebloom's and Big Mac. It was a lot of fun to hear Big Mac talk some more and see how great a voice actor Mr. New is.
I can relate to Big mac. See my sister was always the star of my parents eye, and I fought hard to break the mold. It was hard and an uphill fight. But when adoration was achieved. it was hollow. I almost lost her as a result. So in the end. My over eagerness almost cost me my sister.
I consider this similar to Baby Cakes (i forgot my reason) but instead of cute babies torturing Pinkie with adorable schadenfreude, we had Drag Macintosh and cringe humor that just is knee slapping humor, and instead of ending on a note of crying to cute in 3 mins we had a beautiful moral that goes into tearjerker territory because we got to experience many of the emotions with Big Mac and Apple Bloom through the whole episode. And +DrWolf001 you mentioning appreciation of heroes at 4:55 makes think that this moral is an evolution of the moral from Princess Spike; of how anyone can make a difference to the solution, but this is closer to families. perhaps this season is going to show the moral of how each of us can all help to make great things even if we are not all together or do not have much time.
PLEASE READ: I noticed something I think you'll find interesting. back in "do princesses dream of magical sheep" you commented on how it was suprising that Big Mac dreamed of using magic considering since he never expressed that desire. but in the first scene, when Granny Smith pointed out the old toy to him she mentioned how much Apple Bloom loved how he made that toy fly and it "was like she thought you used magic". what if Big Mac's desire to secretly use magic is just from being idolized by his sister
+Rachael Muncie Omg this symbolism squeeee
...deep stuff man
+Catie the Scribble lol that actually made me smile X)
+Rachael Muncie mind. blown.
Was thinking Fluttershy's brother would have showed up in this episode..boy I was off lol
+Kaitlin Hannah It turns out Fluttershy's brother will be showing up in another season altogether.
+binkyboy448 They lied to us, they saud it was this season!!! *shakes fist*
+EdXLover1 They never said that, they said we'd see him soon. They never specified what soon meant. But speculation is that he'll actually show up in "The Hooffelds and McColts".
JCBro2014 The summary for that episode isn't about Brashbuck though, it's a Twilight/Fluttershy episode.
JCBro2014 They specifically said the appearance of Fluttershy's brother is "not this season". twitter.com/TheBiggestJim/status/650351265126461440
On your questions:
1. My reaction was 20 seconds of shocked silence, trying to get what was going on, before a 10 second uncontrollable giggle fit.
2. Big Mac was HILARIOUS in this episode. I loved his 'antics' to death!
3. As I don't have any siblings at all... No. However, I can say that it was still meaningful and heartwarming, despite the un-relatable circumstances.
4. I don't thing honestly that we'll see much more of these two together, but if we shall, then I'd say that I'd love to see an episode where they discuss the conflict of "the pen is mightier than the sword," or "actions speak louder than words," with them being in so,e kind of situation where applebloom takes the diplomatic approach, and Big Mac goes for a more direct tactic. Not sure what exactly, but i think that that could really work.
+Yomol Waspran Eeyup.
I cried at the end... so many feels
Believe it or not, I actually wrote a "Mac in Drag" snip over in the Infinite Loops thread... I think maybe a week before the original Mac in Drag pic was leaked?
Well, when I first saw "her" I simply left the phone and went out for a walk (laughing like an idiot, of course)
I loved this episode: funny, touching, weird -as hell- and not that predictable. I like Big Mac overall; he's such a good guy
+DRWolf001 When I first saw Big Mac, my mouth dropped wide open until the commercial break started. My step father was watching a few yards behind me, but this was our exact dialogue from the both of us:
Me: "Adam?"
Adam: "Yes?"
Me: "You just saw what I just saw, right?"
Adam: "E'yup."
Both of us: "Big Mac is a crossdresser."
REAL STALLIONS WEAR DRESSES TO HELP THEIR LITTLE SISTER!!!!!
i loved this episode, i was happy to see Big Mack in the spot light, heck it even got a tear outta my eye,
also i was so happy to finally see Rainbow Dash and Scootaloo were in the Sisterhooves Social and won, i loved it
great vid Doc
+SuperGodzilla2 Yeah, the interactions between Rainbow Dash & Scootaloo were definitely the second-best parts of the episode for me! (I think we can all agree what the best part of the episode was, right?)
Crazy Luigi yeah
It was impressive as we have gotten the most dialogue out of Big Mac in the history of the show. Up until now, he was always the strong silent type who didn't have to say much for others to understand what he's talking about.
This has got to be one of the funniest episodes in the entire show so far! XD I always liked Big Mac but I never realized how awesome he actually is. The fact alone that he'd put himself under such trouble and embarrassment (and perhaps even some humiliation) just so he could make his little sister happy (besides making himself feel better, as well. But mostly making his sister happy) shows how much he cares about his family. And honestly? Hear him on a speaking role alone is always a big amusement, but hear him doing something so unexpected and speaking all throughout while at it completely broke me. I completely lost it in so many occasions while watching this episode. XD
I wish we'll get more episodes in which Big Mac has a larger speaking role beyond his traditional eyups and nopes. Wouldn't hurt to give him more screen time more often!
P.S: And on that note, I still wish for a Celestia and Luna-centered episode. Or at least Celestia (since Luna sorta already had her Luna-focused episodes but not Celestia). I'd LOVE to see more of them interacting as sisters. What we saw from them in Slice of Life only left me wanting more.
Yeah definitely agree with you, this was one of those occasions where I literally laughed out loud several times.
+Mike Dragon Yeah, I honestly had no idea Big Mac had an inferiority complex. Always great to get to learn something new about a character.
+Mike Dragon I couldn't stop laughing this whole episode. Yup
I really disliked this episode, mostly because of the cross dressing ( may have a bias. ) The other bit is Apple Bloom's being a total prick.
+TheBrickCrusader hhl
This was a grand episode that I've been waiting for quite some time to watch! Just see the preview and attempting my voice reel for Orchard Blossom made me feel that DHX was able to pull off something so awkward, yet beautifully put together!
That outro joke...
Huh. Orchard's sarcasm is appreciated for that one moment.
I really hope that, if it doesn't already exist, they put on an actual brotherhooves social in addition to the sisterhooves. It would be great to see more interaction with the main characters and their family members plus it would be a lot of fun to see AJ and Big Mac go up against Twilight and Shining Armor
I'm an only child, myself, but my cousins include: a Medical Doctor, and IRS worker, a couple of recognized war vets, and an Olympic track star. You likely had already seen him run. Then there's me: the guy w/ a Bachelor's degree in a hard science and nothing to show for it...
When I was watching this episode I never really cared for the whole orchard blossom persona knowing it was doomed to fail, but what I got from this episode is confirmation of what I already figured out is that Big Mac is actually quite intelligent more so than what people give him credit for
Dave Polsky, you have been redeemed. Even though I'm in the crowd that doesn't hate Appleloosa's Most Wanted, it wasn't as good as it I hoped it would have been. This was nothing short of amazingness! :D
Agreed
When i saw this i went...oh my...they did it...they really did it...And then the end i was like....oh if only my brother and I got along in the past that good..
+Jabari Bloodbane in the past that well.*
+Nicolas Cage The grammar police have arrived. :D
JK, I do that too. XD
+darkflame728 () Me three ^_^
Great review, Doc. :3 You mentioned Mac's princess dream and how no one saw this coming. I have to agree there but it's interesting to think of it in reverse.
Now that we've seen that Mac's been dealing with the feeling of being in his sister's shadow with his ordinariness, to me it gives a whole new context as to why that might be his dream self. Just food for thought~!
As a big brother of two sisters, this episode really spoke to me, it has become my favorite episode of the season
OOOHHHHH Elieora is going to have a field day with this episode.
I hope, if Big Mac ever gets another episode, it would be a bro episode with Shining Armor and Spike. It might never happen, it'd be cool nonetheless, no?
+Adam Kay It definitely would! In fact, when I first read the synopsis for this episode I thought it would be a Twlight and Shining episode. Though I was slightly disappointed it turned out not to be such, everything in this episode made up for it brilliantly.
+Adam Kay That would be cool!
I still want an episode about them watching hoof ball
+Mr Zilla Eyup!
+Adam Kay That would be great. I don't know why they'd all be hanging out but it might be interesting. Spike might be able to feel connected with some guys, which is good for a child to have mentors on both sides of the genders. :)
Wow I just got into some child psychology crap. :P
Anyway it could make for a fun episode as long as it's executed well. :D
I don't know what was more shocking: That Big Mac actually did this, or he was speaking in full sentences.
Goddamnit Big Mac...
Oh yeah. Good ol' goddammit Big Mac
dangit big mac. you had one job.
+James W thank you... just... thank you
The last time Big Mac ever spoke more than two words at a time was... Ponyville Confidential.
Episode 49!!!
59 episodes since a solid Big Mac speaking role (as singing doesn't count since it's a rehearsed song and not singing as exposition or anything similar).
Also, 108 episodes before Big Mac gets his own monologue, and EVEN THEN it's at the end of the episode. I'm pretty sure Big Mac's Monologue is going to become a video of its own just to show Big Mac speaking.
I was actually kinda scared that this episode would make big Mac more of a softer male, compared to spike, and other males in mlp. They did that, but with a mature way, and made it look like family would be the only reason he would change to...a...Orchard Blossom.
It's about time that Big Mac FINALLY got some development than just 'Eeyup' and 'Nope'.
This episode had me going "wut" more times than I've ever done before. It all made sense but my mind had an extremely hard time wrapping around it. Even when I was telling what happened I couldn't stop saying "wut". It was a nice for him to do it but I keep on remember when Granny said "the term "sister" is rather loose for this" or something and I couldn't stop questioning why he dressed up if the word "sister" is meaningless.
When I saw the promo I was on the bus. When orchard blossom was on screen I was laughing hard forgetting I was in a bus
I was shocked when I first saw "Orchard Blossom" via a preview clip a couple of days before the episode aired, but my reaction quickly turned to laughter as I thought it was just hilarious. Sweetie Belle and Scootaloo's respective reactions to seeing this cousin of Applebloom's is just priceless, for I don't think they were prepared to see something like that.
One thing that I thought was funny was the bit at the beginning, where Granny is having Big Mac help her look for a prize ribbon. By itself it's only mildly humorous, but the way those two were in that scene was so much like how my mom and I were while trying to pack and unpack for an interstate move that, to me, it was HILARIOUS!
A very enjoyable episde. Oh the gorgeous amont fo cringty XD
Actually looking back at the princess bigmac thing....... It actually makes more sense now. Alicorns are basically heroes to ponies. They are the most powerful of their kind and typically exist to defend them against terrible fiends. Bgimac wanting to be an alicorn would make sense then if he has feeling unimportan.t
+Tad Dad it is all about the suffering and humiliation, it took me time to just think to myself "wow! this is so humiliating, that it is funny"
+Tad Dad Wow that actually makes a ton of sense. O_o
Good on you for spotting it! :D
+Tad Dad I figured it because he liked dressing as/feeling like a women. But I guess your thing makes more sense (I still like mine more though).
+Tad Dad I now feel bad for big mac, he has depression from being strong and tough, but not being able to help.....
+D HAROLD () I disagree. The only one that really seemed a bit humiliated, was Applebloom, while Big Mac was committed to the cause of giving her a win in the event! I personally don't like cringe humour, but in this episode, I found none! ********************************************************************************************** I found it hilarious with the contrast between Big Mac's size, regular manners and speech, and the mannerism and speech of "Orchard Blossom", as well as the attempts on not getting revealed as a stallion, more for the risk of getting disqualified than for any humiliation.
This has become my favorite episode. Being a big brother myself this episode shows how far siblings will go to help. Also the feelings that come when your younger siblings start to find other role models and broaden their horizons. It also provides one of the most honest and touching scene's I've seen to date in mlp with the final Big Mac and Applebloom talk. As for Orchard Blossom this is something I'm sure is going to provide inspiration comedic and otherwise to the fandom. I have to Agree entirely with you Dr Wolf for a another spot on review thank you :-)
I just adore this episode. When I heard Big Mac talking like a mare I nearly fell out of my seat. I couldn't help but wonder how many takes it took Peter to do all the Orchard Blossom bits without cracking up. Sweet moral at the end and all together good episode.
This episode brought a few tears in my eyes at the end. It was so sweet. I just loved that conclusion. I loved seeing how far Big Mac would go for his little sister. There is so much more I would like to say for this episode, but I don't know how to put it all to words.
I am so happy that they finally showed one of the males in the series, well one of the regular males, as something other then a flat window dressing. And overall the drive he had to try and make his baby sister happy was very heart warming. I think this one is going to be my new favorite episode of the entire generation.
I am the oldest of my 2 other siblings like Big Mac, so this episode really hit me hard. That last scene almost caused me to tear up, which isn't hard to do, but coming from MLP? Almost unheard of. I felt myself connecting with Mac on so many levels and it really added a new layer to his character and caused me to love him even more. This episode was by far one of my favorites this season.
My god, that episode should be named "Tears" because I cried hilarious, painful, and sad tears all in one episode. Also did anyone else notice the musical reference to Back to The Future during the race?
I would like to see Apple Bloom and Big Mac have a stand alone episode based on them both taking up Bowling for the first time and this will be the perfect time for them to make their bonds grow even stronger and as for them both they will have the best day ever.
Who knows what lies around the corner.
Maybe Big Mac is the only one who can help Apple Bloom earn her Cutie Mark by rewarding her with a "Apple Shaped Bowling Ball" Cutie Mark as a symbol of her skill with a Bowling Ball and you can just imagine the joy Apple Bloom would feel if Big Mac helped her achieve her long lost dream of having a Cutie Mark.Apple Bloom will always look at her flank knowing her Big Brother got her the Cutie Mark and she will always cherish it and to respect him a lot more.
I know this is just my theory but there is no harm in discussing it.
I thought this was a nice episode to have character development for not only Big Mac, but also Apple Bloom, we've never seen an episode that explores the brother/sister relationship between Apple Bloom and Big Mac, and it was done so well, and the ending is really emotional and I loved it, so kudos to Dave Polsky
i had no idea about this episode and just watched it and i have to admit it was surprised. im glad that big Mack got more lines and this gave his charter more depth and the way is was done was done well and had a very good moral
I did see that coming after I read the description on wiki. I thank that the writer should create a new team of hero, which mean that we already have main six and CMC, so is time to create a new team. My suggestion is Big Mac that should be part of the team or Spike, so they will have a chance to be hero.
While I do think that the story is actually pretty good overall, Big Mac dressed had me cringeing all the way. But there are still great things about this episode. I liked that Rainbow Dash and Scootaloo won the event together, I just love seeing them together.
Hey DrWolf love your content, this is definitely one of my favorite episodes. Not because of Big Mac dressing as a mare (while that was funny that was more awkward than anything) no, what I enjoyed was toward the end with Big Mac's speech, that made me tear up. Definitely woth the wait for a Big Mac episode. I could see where Big Mac was coming from and at the same time I could see why Applebloom was acting that way as well, which is awesome. And I loved the scenes between Rainbow Dash and Scootaloo, they were great!
I was grandly entertained by the episode. And it did strike home for me a bit. As a big brother to lots of sisters, I've had some moments when I've felt marginalized or unappreciated in the family, especially as my siblings grew older. But I've been comforted to know that my efforts are still appreciated and that I'm still a good big brother in their eyes.
I didn't know dr. wolf had 5 other siblings, reminds me of my mom she had at least 6-8 siblings and she was qualified as the human soccer ball among them
My first reaction when I saw Orchard Blossom? I completely cracked up! XD
As for the rest of the episode, I loved it! Big Mac had slowly started to grow on me recently and this episode just cemented his spot among my favorite characters.
I actually teared up at that sunset scene near the end. that was so beautiful...
Best episode of the season for me, right in front of the three Rarity episodes we just had. Sadly, it triggered a bunch of hatred from trans activists on Tumblr and other websites and they're currently tearing a new hole to the writers. Since when is drag considered "transmysoginist?" Drag queens, crossdressers don't mean to insult transwomen. They're two, three even, groups of people. People are just people. If a silly cartoon is triggering you, than I swear you need to review your priorities.
I looked up what you were talking about just to see if you were exaggerating. You weren't! I can't say I liked this episode, it was WAY, WAY too cringy for me, but people are literally saying that this episode should be BANNED. O.o Damn.
fraya1022 I swear, if this episode gets banned because of Tumblr -- I will lose faith in humanity. This episode was gold.
+Teddie Sage I'm sure everything will be alright. I've never heard about tumblr activism doing anything before.
+Teddie Sage It won't, I'm sure - these are the people who two days before the episode aired admitted they wouldn't watch it due to premise alone! No one is taking them that seriously, especially the people in charge.
+fraya1022 I hope not. I wasn't in the fandom back when Derpy was changed, but I got emotionally attached to the story of her struggle to remain uncensored in time for ep. 100. I don't want to actually be a part of a repeat of history, though.
I think everyones initial reaction was a slack jaw and at least a minute of silence. Also one of my first thoughts were "at least his wig isn't a blue afro". (anyone who get's that, you're awesome!)
+Greycat R I'm probably going to be in the minority for this, but if I have to be honest, I was not only laughing at this episode, I was also cringing. I don't know why, since I don't think there's any problems with this episode. It was both entertaining and heartwarming, but I couldn't stop cringing during the middle. It's probably just a personal gripe.
+SquidofBaconator it is all about the suffering and humiliation, it took me time to just think to myself "wow! this is so humiliating, that it is funny"
+sethketa I feel like that's what they were goin for.
+D HAROLD () There is no humiliation there(ok, Appleblom might feel a little of it), and clearly no suffering. The fun is the contrast between how Big Mac usually is, and what he do and say to pass off as "sister". ^_^
+SquidofBaconator () I tend to be allergic to cringe humor, but I wasn't cringing at all here. Probably because I had more the feeling that Big Mac would not be humiliated if revealed, just disqualified. And eventually that assessment proved kind of correct, but he wasn't even disqualified, he and Applebloom was instead disqualified for lacking sportsmanship!
OH. MY GOD!! I cried tears of joy during that scene at the end. I LOVED this episode! It was funny, it was sweet, and it was SO MOVING at the end! I LOVE it! Your highlighting of Sweetie Blooms lack of observation, and Big Mac's noticing it (with his TRUE observation skills) was very observant of you, Doc. :D How fitting! ^_^
I really enjoyed this episode, the ending was a very good one and its really the most we've had Big Mac talk at all (Outside the Southern Belle voice that is) and it was very sincere, I hope that Big Mac carries the lesson from this episode with him and learns to open up more, maybe it'll reflect in other aspects of his life and he'll have more speaking parts for it ^ ^
Per usual, great episode, Doc! Keep up the great work!
Overall, this episode definitely through me for a loop. I can honestly say I did not see it coming when Big Mac showed up in drag (which literally made me stare with my mouth hanging open). Perfectly executed with that one, especially the voice he chose to sell the act. It's good to know that every pony still managed to see through his ruse, but decided to go along with it anyway out of respect for his noble intentions. That's excluding that one older guy who seemed to be genuinely taken with Big Mac's performance. Seriously, I love the fact that the big guy finally got an episode devoted to him, as well as his relationship with Apple Bloom. That and the fact that he got a lot more dialogue here than his usual monosyllabic lines of eeyup and nope. I always enjoy episodes that allow him to speak full sentences. Definitely one of my favorites of the season. On a tangentially related note, this is the third episode we've had in a row that has not featured either Pinkie or Fluttershy. I hope they both get some love in the next one.
+SimplyJay Considering the fact that the next episode will involve the Cutie Mark Crusaders, Pipsqueak, and the likes of Diamond Tiara, I'd say we probably won't be seeing either one of them yet.
Crazy Luigi
Yeah, I wrote that comment before I found out that the next is a CMC episode. There's still the possibility that they could make an appearance.
+SimplyJay Well luckily, they showed up after all...
Crazy Luigi
Yeah, at the very end. Pinkie actually got a line as well. At least they'll both have a role in today's episode.
It's an episode that will really play with your emotions. It has scenes that can make you laugh out loud and scenes that can make your eyes tear (tbh, I teared a little). It's nice having episodes like this from time to time, giving focus to other than the Mane 6. Most sincerest episode so far for me, followed by "Amending Fences". Amazing Job to the writers!
I love how Big Mac seems to have an easier time expressing his thoughts in the guise of Orchard Blossom. Either he feels more comfortable when he feels under cover or he simply is method acting as a character he created. Still it seems relatable to me that it's easier to say what you're thinking when you're not yourself. Take, for instance, when you're commenting under a user name verses speaking up in a group of people who know you and whom you see often... ;)
I loves this episode... and it made me almost sad at the end that only now we get to hear more of this great voice actor.
"Sweetibell's and Rainbowdash's Blank reactions Just add to the entertainment Value." Scootalo has become Blue with Rainbow Hair.
+Terias Faldom (Mod) , Well, Rainbow had a blank reaction too; it's just that her clip wasn't shown in this review.
DragoSonicMile Ah ok. It's still funny
This is the only episode of this show that legit made me cry. It makes up for the boring episodes of this season. I was starting to lose hope in season five but this episode single-handedly restored my faith in it. Rarity Investigates was also a good episode and gave me hope that the season would change itself around. But this episode convinced me to hang out for a great season finish. I also have a personal connection to this episode for various reasons. This episode was an animated masterpiece. It has a timeless message for all ages and generations. This is the kind of episodes that should be coming out of the show, not stuff like Princess Spike. I think we can all agree Princess Spike was the lowest point of MLP history.
I'm the oldest of three siblings and the second oldest of six SUPER close cousins (So close they might as well have been siblings as well). My brother is currently in the marines but was always good at sports. My sister was heavy into music and always got really good grades. My cousins have also been excellent at music, grades and sports. This left...me, the basic black sheep. I was smart, but my grades didn't show it. I played the violin for awhile, but it never really went anywhere. There were a couple of sports I loved, but never got a whole lot of support for. It was hard. Nobody ever really noticed my own creative side, since my siblings and cousins also had a creative side. I haven't been feeling very noticed or appreciated for the past several years since they've all gotten older. And then I saw this episode. It kept me on the verge of tears the entire time. And then the ending was what got me. It helped me realize that, even though we're all growing up and getting out into the world, they may not say so but my siblings and cousins do love and appreciate me for what I have done. Where I am going in my life. And how I've helped them in the little ways I can. Honestly, I think this episode will stay with me for a LONG time.
I have a feeling this episode was based of off mrs doubtfire
hey dr wolf! I'm on a bit of a mlp reviews marathon right now and had to stop and comment on this. I am the middle of 3 girls. Recently, my younger sister and i had sat down and talked about our futures, i'm getting certified on medical billing and shes going for her degree in computer science. She showed me where she could be possibly interning for this summer and I told her what my grandmother had told me about medical billing, how it' always going to be needed, from dentist offices, to specialists. She said to me something that I always wanted to say "I'm going to be better then [my older sister]". sure we will both make more money, and I finally know what it's like to have all A's on my report card, but the idea of surpassing my sister is an added bonus. We had always been compared to her and it would aggravate us to the point of depression. Our one grandmother(different one then the one before) always talks about her and never talks about us. Now that we feel confident in doing something she can't, we feel better. With that being said, my older sister has paved an incredible path for us and I thank her for it.
How would Scootaloo have competed in the Social she didn't have a sister then
One more thing: That old stallion judge. Was he referencing the "Well, nobody's perfect!" guy from "Some Like It Hot?"
I was laughing so hard when I saw this episode, Dave Polsky made a great turnaround after Appleloosa's Most Wanted. Loved the character interactions, the heartwarming final scene, the song was good and Rainbow and Scootaloo competing in the social, I give it 8/10 ^^
This is easily one of the best episodes of the whole season. I was shocked to see Big Mac dressed in drag, but it was hilarious, especially how he never really fooled anypony (except that one guy). I just loved it!
While I at first found myself profoundly disturbed for the first moment of seeing Big mac acting COMPLETELY unexpectedly as this different ponysona, I gave it a moment to sink in by pausing the video and relaxing a bit. At first I was wildly confused, but now I am extremely grateful for watching this episode, while also having a giggle.
Simply put, It takes a lot of determination and integrity to stand up and being a brother or sister to your siblings. Big Mac is a Shining apple in the orchard for this, as he displays his love and appreciation for his sister Applebloom in this episode.
This even speaks to me at a personal level with my sister and step brother, and I definitely view this as a great episode. Very comical, informational, heart warming, and it just goes to show the dedication one's family member can have to make someone smile.
I think Sweetie Belle and Scootaloo's reaction to Big Mac was the same across the board. Good episode and loved that moral. Didn't mind Big Mac's shtick but I think it went on a bit too long. I would love to see another episode with Apple Bloom and Big Mac but I'll let the writers make up the plot.
I feel you Doc, I grew up with 3 siblings. My older sisters were the popular sports and student council members, my younger brother was the head of almost every honor society, played every instrument, and is straight A student, and then there's me. It was a rough road trying to make your mark when others may outshine you
While I loved this episode, I can't help but feel it's kind of ironic that Applejack's the one getting all of the praise (regardless of how it was from her sister) since she's seen outside of the show as the most forgettable member of the Mane 6
I can't say I connect with the aspect of one sibling outshining another (we're both polar opposites when it comes to talents), but as an older brother to a younger sister.
What really hit home was the part when Big Mac told Apple Bloom that she used to look up to him when they were younger. As they got older, it appeared she didn't see him the way she used to, which is exactly how I feel now. My sister admits that I taught her more than just how to kick butt at video games, and because of that connection, the ending to "Brotherhooves Social" was downright brilliant and almost brought a tear to my eye. Well done, Mr. Polsky and nice review Doc.
the moments that got to me was the opening with granny smith going snicker doodle XD and the judge falling for Orchard bloom and did you see the building close by in the sun set was that the house? could be wrong. THIS WAS ADORABLE AND AWESOME at the same time
When Orchard Blossom first appeared all I could do was pause the video and try not to crack a rib. It may be one of the funniest scenes of the entire series!
My reaction, as I haven't seen this episode, came from seeing Orchard Blossom when you showed the clip here in this review. And it was exactly the same expression on my face as yours. I was like, "What the?.."
I think Orchard Blossom was a great addition to this episode. In that role we got a nice hint to the little moment between him and Pinkie Pie in Pinkie Apple Pie where she said she never saw it that way, now we can realy see that he can express himself very well, also the part with the song was pure gold. While Applebloom was worried because it took Applejack so long Big Mac memorized the lines way faster, probably thanks to his experience in the Ponytones so a few subtle hints to continuity as well
*****
That might also be very likely, to me it just seemed so because of his victorious grin right before as if he wanted to say "Well seems I am better in that regard" and that was the reason why I though about it that way
Dave Polsky bravo! I had to stop the episode several times just to let out all the laughter i couldn't brush off. I mean I had to step back and just let it all out, tell some one what just happened laugh even harder and then take a moment to compose myself to get ready for what came next. This episode was the biggest curve ball yet and the heartwarming moment at the end had me ready to cry.
I felt so much for Big mac this episode, especially at the beginning. I'm the oldest of ultimately four kids, but since two of my siblings are only half, and they lived with my dad, growing up it was mainly my little sister and me. My sis and I were insanely close when we were little; we did just about everything together, but when my dad came back into our lives so did my other siblings, and since they were closer in age to her, my sis started spending more time with them, and we started to drift apart. I felt like I lost my best friend, and I definitely empathize with big mac here. I'd do anything for my sister, and I wish we could be as close as we used to be.
I really love how they established what is most commonly known as "middle-child syndrome" something i was waiting for them to make an episode about. That and a big mac episode with him doing a funny voice had me is tears of laughter.
Anyone else catch that in Sisterhooves Social, Sweetie was the only one who could participate in the Social, and now only Apple Bloom and Scootaloo can compete. Now all three CMC have participated. But Apple Bloom was the only that didn't enjoy it
+Cilan Steele Hopefully next time they have it (assuming we actually see the next Sisterhooves Social, of course), we get to see all three of them performing in it and enjoying themselves there.
Yeah, both times there's been a switch-up with who competes. And Applejack STILL hasn't competed.
As the oldest of six kids, I understand exactly where Big Mac is coming from. So much so that I knew what his motives were before they even started the race. It was a great heartwarming episode that really made me wish I was more like him.
This apisode is my favorit from now on.
It tugged on my heart strings and as a big brother myself I know the feelings he goes throu.
Damn this apisode skyrocketed to the top as the subject is so close to my heart
I personally think Rainbow was not at a maturity level or had a deep enough connection with Scootaloo for the first Sisterhooves Social to work. But, Rainbow has grown so much as a character since then! It seemed very genuine and more meaningful.
It was surprising didn't think they would have him cross dressing again but at the end I know he did it for Apple bloom so they could spend time together
This hit home for me as the eldest brother of four, I really identified with Big Mac. I less felt for him on the "not living up to another sibling" as much as the need to be able to impress the younger sibling.
i still can't believe Big Mac needed a dress to speak more than one work at a time.
I admit... I teared up a bit in the final scene. As a big brother with another sibling that my little sister always looked up to more than she looked up to me, I could really empathize with what Big Mac was going through here.
2:52 Oh, yeah. Speaking of that, MLP-FiM continues the American media tradition of disparaging males. Who is the only one fooled by Big McIntosh's costume? The stallion judge. So, unless he *wasn't* fooled and is, in fact, gay and into drag queens... yeah. That whole stallion-judge-attracted-to-Big-Mac plot line was a slap in the face to every male on the planet.
My reaction to Big Mac's reveal as cousin Orchard Blossom? Uncontrollable laughter for about 20 solid minutes.
When I saw big mac in drag...I got in my batman voice and duly declared the following: There are some things a man cannot unsee, no matter how much Brain Bleach he might consume in the ensuing hours.
I have to agree. I was waiting and hoping for a Big Mac episode since I read the IDW comic and since Granny Smith had a couple episodes surrounding her, he was the only Apple member left to do. This episode did not disappoint. We not only saw how determined, dedicated, - and let's face it - desperate he was to make his sister happy that it did wonders for his character. Not only that, but he's quite articulate isn't he? Sure he was playing a character, but I think this makes sense why he's so quiet most of the time. This sort of reminds me of me and my big brother. Unlike you, Dr. Wolf, I only have one sibling. He went on to be a doctor, so I guess I can relate to Big Mac as he's the "hero" of the family (not that my folks put us on pedestals or anything). While he does like to tease me and play mind games with my head (he was a valedictorian. They do that...), he is still one of the greatest brothers I could ever hope for. One time, he helped me scratch an item off my bucket list: Seeing a living Beatle live in concert! Sir Paul McCartney!!! This is a memory I will cherish forever. He likes the Beatles too, but I'm the die-hard fan of the family. The minute he saw he was coming to where he lived, he immediately got tickets and texted me to take the time off.
Sure, he drives me crazy and I drive him crazier, but I know that no matter what, he will always be there for me. There was a time after a bad breakup that I was scared I'd end up old and alone (I'm dramatic like that). He assured me if that if something happened to Mom and Dad and I was still alone, he'd let me live with him and my sister-in-law, no questions asked.
Sorry for the long winded bio, but I love sister-brother stories. I guess I can relate more to Twilight and Shining Armor more that Big Mac and his sisters, but the love is there nonetheless, even if we don't always "like" each other. ;)
This episode was GREAT! I couldn't stop laughing at Orchard Blossom. The comedy surrounding her/him was hilarious, namely Sweetie Belle's, Scootaloo's and Rainbow Dash's reactions. Priceless!
And that ending made me tear up...seriously... second time this season where I cried! ( First is Tanks for the Memories )
More Big Mac!!!
i still freak out every time he says more than "eeyup" and i cried a little at the end XD
seriously though, an episode that develops the character of somepony that only ever said yup or nope throughout the entire series?! i can't even... i... gaaahhh! i love it :D
This might be my favorite episode of season 5.
This is what I've been hoping for for so long, and it's something that Mr. Quill brought up awhile ago, saying that they usually focus on the bonds between sisters because this is a girls show but he said how little girls can have brothers too and I can't think of a better episode for that. Sure Twi has her BBBFF but I don't think Shining could carry himself through a whole episode of him and Twilight, there just isn't much to his character as far we've seen. But with Big Mac, I've always loved him and his personality has been expanded upon a lot as of late, like him being in a band or being sports buddies with Spike and other stuff too, but I had been hoping for an episode about him with either AJ or Applebloom and this one was just great. It wasn't perfect but no episode is and I don't think any other heart to heart talk has gotten through to me as much as Applebloom's and Big Mac.
It was a lot of fun to hear Big Mac talk some more and see how great a voice actor Mr. New is.
When I saw orchard blossom I was in shock. My mouth was gaping open the majority of the time orchard blossom was on screen.
What I want to know, though, is what that one old stalliion judge was gonna do with the flowers...
I can relate to Big mac. See my sister was always the star of my parents eye, and I fought hard to break the mold. It was hard and an uphill fight. But when adoration was achieved. it was hollow. I almost lost her as a result. So in the end. My over eagerness almost cost me my sister.
I really liked this one. One of my favorite episodes of the season so far. It was funny, didn't go for the predictable ending, and had a good message.
I found Big Mac disguising himself as a mare to be very disturbing
This is going to be a bit out there but what would've happened to Big Mac if Applebloom didn't come and see him at the end?
when i first saw 'Orchard Blossom' my first thought was 'wow Big Mac is surprisingly pretty as a mare' XD
I consider this similar to Baby Cakes (i forgot my reason) but instead of cute babies torturing Pinkie with adorable schadenfreude, we had Drag Macintosh and cringe humor that just is knee slapping humor, and instead of ending on a note of crying to cute in 3 mins we had a beautiful moral that goes into tearjerker territory because we got to experience many of the emotions with Big Mac and Apple Bloom through the whole episode. And +DrWolf001 you mentioning appreciation of heroes at 4:55 makes think that this moral is an evolution of the moral from Princess Spike; of how anyone can make a difference to the solution, but this is closer to families. perhaps this season is going to show the moral of how each of us can all help to make great things even if we are not all together or do not have much time.
i loved it when sweetie bell and scoot just turned like that knowing it was big mac in a dress