For all Mankind and Hazegrayart are getting their designs from the same place: actual ideas that people had and made designs for, but that were never built.
You do it all: scratchy film leader, sun-flare, shaky-cam, drifting framing of the subject indicative of a long lens, and the astronauts to give Bono's rocket the needed scale. This ain't your first rodeo! After yesterdays 'landing', Bono's concept suddenly becomes reasonable. Well done, sir! And that first shot, the fleet of ships ready for launch -- straight out of a Communist SF film!
4000 years from now an archeologist is going to dig up the TH-cam server this stuff is on and think we had the most excellent space age right out of the box.
@@500features parts of the event showed an animated version of what the SN10 launch was predicted to look like if successful, but the launch did take place in reality
Thank you thank you thank you!!! I have been waiting for years for someone to do one of Bono's designs in a simulation or animation. I first read the book "Frontiers Of Space" in high school in the late 70s, and the designs always intrigued me. Many years later, I was able to get a copy of the book (written by Phillip Bono and Kenneth Gatland). There are a lot of cool designs in there that use a similar idea of the torroidal nozzle design and the drop-off tanks, plus some that are meant to be a suborbital transport. There is also a concept drawing of an idea for recovery and reuse of the Saturn V first stage if the Apollo Applications Program had been chosen instead of the Shuttle.
I love the gigantic toroidal aerospike on this one. That's also a really interesting bit of history to hear about the apollo applications program, and the concept drawing to possibly reuse the Saturn 5's 1st stage is one I'll have to look up for sure!
A nice twist to the usual strap on booster approach - strap on tanks. No problems recovering them from the sea and far easier to prep for the next flight than boosters.
What's really cool about the ROMBUS is it's stage-and-a-half-to-orbit design (SAHTO?) much like Atlas before it. If you look at the discarded stages they don't have rocket engines on them, they're basically drop tanks
Great work! So realistic, I’d literally believe what I’m seeing (in fact, while watching, I completely lose myself in the moment ☺️). These exquisite designs probably exist on an alternate earth (in a parallel world). Love the time period documentary newsreel touch too! Pure genius!!!
Those plug nozzle ring thrusters were supposed to be more efficient than the bell nozzles we still use today. There were many proposed spacecraft built around the concept. The road not taken!
I tried that the problem is mostly the lower part by it's shape it in nearly impossible to make the TPS work in KSP, But I suggest making Ithacus, it's descendant instead basically the same thing but with reverse wing on the side and full propulsive landing.
The only mistake I'm seeing is that it did not jettison the SRBs (those rounded cylindrical auxiliary modules with engines are marked "Solid Rockets" on the original drawing). Otherwise, great work!
Yeah, one giant toroidal aerospike! Looks like somewhere between 50 to 75% truncated at a glance but idk. Seems like a recreation of this would be the perfect use of something like the tweakscale mod in KSP lol.
There was an adapted concept of this rocket that was also proposed in 1963 called Ithacus, it was intended for transporting troops and military equipment to other continents via sub-orbital trajectories. nationalinterest.org/blog/reboot/space-troopers-pentagon-wanted-marines-ride-ballistic-missiles-battle-178978
I think that was "Icarus". It was a ballistic rocket transport to be capable of delivering half a battalion of troops anywhere in the world within an hour!
@@stevenpilling5318 It's the same thing. The vehicle was renamed to ITHACUS after someone pointed out unfortunate symbolism with calling it after the legend of Icarus.
Maybe u can try to make MOL animation or gemini paraglide (yes it was planned) Also fun fact: first spacecraft to be reused was actually gemini that flew in gemini 2 and Mol test mission
I love what you've done with the place :) The old-school "promotional film" opening is great. One minor nit-pick, the 'cargo' tanks would be mounted on the 'nose' instead of the 'standard' cargo fairing you used. And did you tease "Selene" there being delivered too. I think it was a bit small for the Ares proposal.... So any plans to do something like Bono's Mars Glider? Oh and for an FYI to everyone, (there are always over 100 comments by the time I see these :) ) this is NOT an SSTO due to the drop tanks. It's considered a "Stage-and-a-Half" to orbit much like the Atlas missile/LV.
This is right out of the book by Kenneth Gatland and Phillip Bono FRONTIERS OF SPACE that I read from my local library in the late '60s/early '70s. The design (along with Robert Truax's "Sea Dragon," used in "FOR ALL MANKIND") was deemed feasable in the early/mid '60s, but NASA didn't want to do it. 500 tonnes to orbit in a single launch, and reusable. There was a passenger version called Pegasus and even a military transport called Ithacus. We could have been all over the Solar System by now. Hazegrayart, would you consider doing a video on Pegasus/Ithacus, too? That would be very cool.
The only issue with being this good is that lots of people probably think you didn't actually do anything and had just posted an old archive film you found :~)
A giant aerospike asparagus-staged reusable self-landing rocket in the 1960s? Given that SpaceX is just now doing some of these things I can see why this was not built.
I do like how you used the LZ1 treeline to really drive home just how big that booster is. It's a bizarre thing, does it have an aerospike and separate conventional engines, or can the aerospike nozzles pivot to become conventional engines?
Splendid work! May I make a request? The book "French Secret Projects 3" by J C Carbonel has come out with the most detailed collection of information and technical details to date of the SNECMA Trsnsporteur Sero-Spatail yet, the French flyback-booster shuttle combination that the company worked on fer a decade, and even longer after being absorbed into Aerospatiale. That would make a fascinating subject for your movies, especially the vertical launch version suggested.
Not too shabby, but I'd not rely too much on parachutes on the final recovery. I'd be equipping it with grid fins, al la FALCON 9's. You can't trust nature to get a dependable landing every time. If the wind took a wicked shift, they might be setting down in some mall, a field, or going swimming.
I'd go the opposite myself... :) All parachute and ocean splashdown and use that propellant wasted on hover landings as payload.... Slower turn-around, so build more ships, that lift more...
I think For All Mankind is getting their rocket designs from here
Na ther is no Nostalga in these they will not but they should.
For all Mankind and Hazegrayart are getting their designs from the same place: actual ideas that people had and made designs for, but that were never built.
These rocket designs were already made decades before this video was even made
Super Orion Interestelar Ark when
Ikr 🧑🚀😂
Every one of your videos is a work of art. Thank you for "preserving" this history.
You do it all: scratchy film leader, sun-flare, shaky-cam, drifting framing of the subject indicative of a long lens, and the astronauts to give Bono's rocket the needed scale. This ain't your first rodeo! After yesterdays 'landing', Bono's concept suddenly becomes reasonable. Well done, sir! And that first shot, the fleet of ships ready for launch -- straight out of a Communist SF film!
You've nailed pretty much everything I wanted go compliment in this video!
i legit just read this in the old-video-movie narrator voice that litterally everybody spoke in
4000 years from now an archeologist is going to dig up the TH-cam server this stuff is on and think we had the most excellent space age right out of the box.
Really loving you giving life to these old out of these world rocket designs. Please dont stop and keep up the great work!
If I did not know that this was an animation, I would easily have thought this was real. Keep it up!
Have you seen the Sn10 launch
@@thefirstsin Yep
@@trishaykaul9511 alright!!
@@trishaykaul9511 That was animation too.
@@500features parts of the event showed an animated version of what the SN10 launch was predicted to look like if successful, but the launch did take place in reality
That Saturn V in the back at the beginning be like
*chuckles
"Im in danger."
Oh wow! It's hard to find stuff related to the ROMBUS, thanks for this!
Yay another crazy rocket design!
Gorgeous interaction between the plume and the smoke and clouds.
Thank you thank you thank you!!! I have been waiting for years for someone to do one of Bono's designs in a simulation or animation. I first read the book "Frontiers Of Space" in high school in the late 70s, and the designs always intrigued me. Many years later, I was able to get a copy of the book (written by Phillip Bono and Kenneth Gatland). There are a lot of cool designs in there that use a similar idea of the torroidal nozzle design and the drop-off tanks, plus some that are meant to be a suborbital transport. There is also a concept drawing of an idea for recovery and reuse of the Saturn V first stage if the Apollo Applications Program had been chosen instead of the Shuttle.
I love the gigantic toroidal aerospike on this one. That's also a really interesting bit of history to hear about the apollo applications program, and the concept drawing to possibly reuse the Saturn 5's 1st stage is one I'll have to look up for sure!
A nice twist to the usual strap on booster approach - strap on tanks. No problems recovering them from the sea and far easier to prep for the next flight than boosters.
Proton liked this video.
I first came across this in Bono's 1969 book "Frontiers of Space". Am so glad to see it realized visually here.
I still have my copy of Frontiers of Space by Philip Bono & Kenneth Gatland.
@@charlesmasters7644 Same here.
I keep faith in humanity every time I see a Hazegrayart video with 0 dislikes.
yo
Oof spoke too fast... He's got 1 dislike
you remember me younger when i used this pfp, like 6 years ago
27 dislikes
Good old asparagus staging
Works beautifully on paper, yet is damn near impossible irl
Very Kerbal!
fuel pipes are most advanced equipment in KSP
This wasn't using asparagus staging, though. Those were drop tanks and they were tapped sequentially.
Not asparagus since there is no crossfeed
I see an aerospike engine, I like
What's really cool about the ROMBUS is it's stage-and-a-half-to-orbit design (SAHTO?) much like Atlas before it. If you look at the discarded stages they don't have rocket engines on them, they're basically drop tanks
Such detail from the clouds to the ripples in the parachutes....awesome!!
Great Philip Bono!! I've ready his books in the early 70'!! A genius... drove me toward real based sci-fi.. Still got them!!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
One of your best movies. That retro intro at the start, really set the mood for the whole experience. Perfecto!
Wasn't expecting it to pull a SpaceX at the end!
SpaceX landings are hover-slams. This is a controlled hover and landing like Blue Origins.
@@BrokenLifeCycle superheavy will be able to hover i think
I was thinking the same..
Could have increased the payload to orbit massively if it had just splashed down instead!! :)
Oh gawd I'm always so happy when you post a new video =)
I love all these old SSTO concepts!
Amazing animation! I am awe-struck!
I like the most with your videos, that the movement of all the parts is believable and appears physically correct.
I have been a fan of Bono designs for decades.
If I were a Hi-Tech tycoon, my private Space program would go Bono all the way!
I can't like this enough. So very good. Thank you.
Nice use of the Space Shuttle SRB audio (I've listened to it so many times it's very recognisable now)
Again good old fashion ideas... i love it really. gj
Great work! So realistic, I’d literally believe what I’m seeing (in fact, while watching, I completely lose myself in the moment ☺️).
These exquisite designs probably exist on an alternate earth (in a parallel world).
Love the time period documentary newsreel touch too!
Pure genius!!!
Hazegrayart notifications must be immediately viewed. I love this work!
Those plug nozzle ring thrusters were supposed to be more efficient than the bell nozzles we still use today. There were many proposed spacecraft built around the concept. The road not taken!
Nice touch taking audio of the Shuttle SRBs decoupling.
Love the animations, every time I see your animations I just want to boot up ksp and try to recreate them
Same lol
Huh- so im not the only one
I tried that the problem is mostly the lower part by it's shape it in nearly impossible to make the TPS work in KSP, But I suggest making Ithacus, it's descendant instead basically the same thing but with reverse wing on the side and full propulsive landing.
mmmmm the engine sounds on this video are so damn satisfying.
You're videos get better each time you upload, great video!
Yeah, but does it blow up eight minutes later???
Lol I see what you did there
*laughs in Methane leak*
@@pandapops5428 lol
@Rich OMG ahaha, RIP SN10
@@antsky371 RIP. Atleast it landed and completed a succesful flight and then left with a treat to the eyes.
Stunning as always ! Why not a future episode about the Star-raker ?
OUTstanding visuals, and great music as well.
The only mistake I'm seeing is that it did not jettison the SRBs (those rounded cylindrical auxiliary modules with engines are marked "Solid Rockets" on the original drawing). Otherwise, great work!
uhm, what? they've always been drop tanks
@@dsdy1205 8 drop tanks, 4 SRBs.
@@caav56 oh wow you're right I've learnt something new today
Fantastic work dude. very talented.
Ah yes Bono, the plug nozzle guy. You know it's him if you see a plug nozzle.
You deserve more subs, these are such high quality
You are one gifted cgi artist, thanks for sharing.
Everyone: Big Rocket
Me: That's a nice custom cape model.
I love these videos!
Probably cross-feeding so that as tanks are dropped, everything that goes on is fully fueled, and the tank they carry up is probably full too.
Philip Bono, the 60s Elon Musk who unfortunately did not get the same funding
He made the mistake of not already being a billionaire
I prefer him (slightly) to Elon, since he was a bit saner. And he also supported the national space program, which I like.
Excellent as always
Imma take some inspiration for an Eve Ascent Vehicle
Did the main booster use an aerospike engine? Amazing video! Keep up the awesome work.
Yeah, one giant toroidal aerospike! Looks like somewhere between 50 to 75% truncated at a glance but idk. Seems like a recreation of this would be the perfect use of something like the tweakscale mod in KSP lol.
Almost all of Phil Bono's designs use a plug-nozzle aerospike.
Great animation , full of details
good gosh heck this is amazing, like always. i HAVE to know... what font is that on the title card?!
Great video. An excellent reference book is Frontiers if Space, by Bono and Kenneth Gatland.
There was an adapted concept of this rocket that was also proposed in 1963 called Ithacus, it was intended for transporting troops and military equipment to other continents via sub-orbital trajectories.
nationalinterest.org/blog/reboot/space-troopers-pentagon-wanted-marines-ride-ballistic-missiles-battle-178978
I think that was "Icarus". It was a ballistic rocket transport to be capable of delivering half a battalion of troops anywhere in the world within an hour!
@@stevenpilling5318 It's the same thing. The vehicle was renamed to ITHACUS after someone pointed out unfortunate symbolism with calling it after the legend of Icarus.
Maybe u can try to make MOL animation or gemini paraglide (yes it was planned)
Also fun fact: first spacecraft to be reused was actually gemini that flew in gemini 2 and Mol test mission
Quality animation on this channel 👍
I love what you've done with the place :) The old-school "promotional film" opening is great. One minor nit-pick, the 'cargo' tanks would be mounted on the 'nose' instead of the 'standard' cargo fairing you used. And did you tease "Selene" there being delivered too. I think it was a bit small for the Ares proposal.... So any plans to do something like Bono's Mars Glider? Oh and for an FYI to everyone, (there are always over 100 comments by the time I see these :) ) this is NOT an SSTO due to the drop tanks. It's considered a "Stage-and-a-Half" to orbit much like the Atlas missile/LV.
There was a fully-SSTO design of Pegasus, though, which kept the tanks and used them as a variable geometry airbrake for controlling the descent.
Stoke space has a similar arrangement for the engines (aerospike) of their second stage, right?
Even has that '60s newsreel look to it.
The last part caught me by surprise.
me: \*still waiting for the guy with the old-fashioned accent to start explaining what's on-screen*
By the way, that accent is a mid-Atlantic/trans-Atlantic accent :)
Vonbruan Saturn provided for size compairison.
Wow seems like a pretty neat concept thanks #hazegrayart for bringing us such interesting stuff
Love your work Hazegrey. I'd like to see Buran docking with Mir2 or ISS please...
Damn that's cool!
This is right out of the book by Kenneth Gatland and Phillip Bono FRONTIERS OF SPACE that I read from my local library in the late '60s/early '70s. The design (along with Robert Truax's "Sea Dragon," used in "FOR ALL MANKIND") was deemed feasable in the early/mid '60s, but NASA didn't want to do it. 500 tonnes to orbit in a single launch, and reusable. There was a passenger version called Pegasus and even a military transport called Ithacus. We could have been all over the Solar System by now.
Hazegrayart, would you consider doing a video on Pegasus/Ithacus, too? That would be very cool.
1960 rocket concepts be like:
- Weird shape, big diameter tank
- Giant aerospike engine
Amazing
Cant get over the fact that the side booster sep audio is from space shuttle!
Lovely!
How does it get back to the Cape without a boost back burn?
Waiting in orbit until the phasing is right again.
Fantástico
Epic intro 👌👌👌
Rombus mars mission animation
Like
Very good animation, although some physics don’t seem quite right 👏🏻👏🏻👍🏻
How is it supposed to survive reentry? Great render by the way!
With its big, concave heat shield. The rocket engines are arranged in a ring around the edge of it.
@@stevenpilling5318 Don't forget it's also water-cooled!
The only issue with being this good is that lots of people probably think you didn't actually do anything and had just posted an old archive film you found :~)
We all think how awesome this would be if it existed but we would've taken if for granted like we do with 747's or the space shuttle
Saturn V in the background: Finally! A worthy opponent! Out battle will be legendarily!
Does it count as a SSTO if your just dropping fueltanks without engines?
1.5STO.
what's that song you used?
Interesting design
The Mighty Saturn V along with Philip Bono's Rombus rockets ready to launch for missions to the moon and Mars!
A giant aerospike asparagus-staged reusable self-landing rocket in the 1960s?
Given that SpaceX is just now doing some of these things I can see why this was not built.
Not entirely self-landing, though. It was supposed to be piloted by the astronauts, who could eject in a protected capsule in case things went wrong.
A plug-nozzle aerospike and propellant cross-feed? That is how you know a Bono design.
When you add a ton of mods and shaders to KSP:
I do like how you used the LZ1 treeline to really drive home just how big that booster is. It's a bizarre thing, does it have an aerospike and separate conventional engines, or can the aerospike nozzles pivot to become conventional engines?
I saw this rocket on a video for Disney's old Mission to Mars attraction
superb
Amazing. I think would be interesting if you could make similar animations about ICBMs.
Splendid work! May I make a request? The book "French Secret Projects 3" by J C Carbonel has come out with the most detailed collection of information and technical details to date of the SNECMA Trsnsporteur Sero-Spatail yet, the French flyback-booster shuttle combination that the company worked on fer a decade, and even longer after being absorbed into Aerospatiale. That would make a fascinating subject for your movies, especially the vertical launch version suggested.
Had to imagine the thunderbirds theme music as it launched...
Wow I like your videos
AMAZINGNES!!!
still better than starship
Music kinda reminds me of interstellar
the fact that we've had knowledge of aerospike engines since the 60's and have literally never used them makes me upsetti.
What is happening with the two vehicles in space?
Not too shabby, but I'd not rely too much on parachutes on the final recovery. I'd be equipping it with grid fins, al la FALCON 9's. You can't trust nature to get a dependable landing every time. If the wind took a wicked shift, they might be setting down in some mall, a field, or going swimming.
It does powered descent for the final moments.
I'd go the opposite myself... :)
All parachute and ocean splashdown and use that propellant wasted on hover landings as payload....
Slower turn-around, so build more ships, that lift more...