When I watched this for the first time on TV I felt the urge to kneel down and praise the suffering father trying not to lose face and remaining the noble gentleman.
My favorite production of La Traviata, with Anna Netrebko. Very emotional performance overall. First time I watched it ( 24 years ago?) I was crying! 😭
PFG666 Those that muffle the words to achieve a false "darkness" aren't doing anything justice. It should be both, ideally. Very dark and sonorous but also clear and bright. Chiaroscuro.
XxSaruman82xX No he doesn’t. I’ve seen him at the Met before performing this exact role, he sounded as light as the tenor singing rodolfo that night and anytime the orchestra played mezzo-forte or louder, you simply couldn’t hear anything he was singing
@@xxsaruman82xx87 I've heard rumors about how Alfredo's father sounded more like his brother from this production. But seeing Hampson, it all makes sense
El extraordinario Thomas Hampson (1955) nos interpreta de la bellísima música de La Traviata de Verdi esta aria para barítono impecablemente interpretada. Infinitas gracias por subirlo.
Well, what a revelation! Having heard Fischer‐Diskauu's competent but less than totally successful 'attempt' at this aria I had reservations about Hampson tackling it but by jove he nails it and in my opinion much better than F‐D. He's not up there with the mighty rich textured voices of the past but I'm nonetheless astounded by the achievenent given that his general repertoire encompases lighter material. And I wholeheartedly agree with those commentators who praise his excellent diction. I can only repeat, what a revelation...
The voice isn't bad, just way too light for my liking. Listening to baritones like Macneil, Capuccilli, Warren, and Ruffo and then listening to Hampson, it sounds like I'm listening to a tenor, not a verdi baritone.
agree totally, so high, but people only cares of the reputation, love to have Dimitri or ton of other father voices here, in deed, he is more methotical less deep feeling and details...
What idiocy to carp about Hampson's voice being too light or too tenorish. This is a LYRIC baritone role unlike most Verdi baritones. Verdi uses dolce to emphasize the sweetness of the sound that needs to be vocalized and Hampson is perfect (despite his wooden stage movements)
Difiero respetuosamente. Hampson posee un excelente registro y un timbre hermosisimo, óptimo para una buena gama de repertorio, pero no para Verdi. El aria posee unos cuantos agudos exigentes pero eso no justifica lo parecidas que suenas las voces. Como testimonio, están Bruson, Capuccilli, Bastianini, Tezier y muchos otros capaces de lograr dichos agudos sin que su voz sea semejante a la de un tenor.
Hampson = tenore corto,è un fatto. cosa c'è in comune fra la vocalità meravigliosa di Bastianini e questo giovane entusiasta?... niente. poi Bruson aveva il suo modo unico di porgere. Cappuccilli molto diverso da Bruson,un altro grande. Tezier un ragazzo giovane bravo e intelligente chi canta al modo suo e che non gioca nel loro campionato... ma Bastianini ? Bastianini era semplicemente un dio. è ovvio che Hampson è un tenore corto chi sta cantonando con una vocina poco bella. dal vivo è così. ciao.
Ho voluto confrontare la qualità e le caratteristiche della vera voce da baritono con cui Hampson possiede. Oggi è facile trovare baritoni cantano ruoli per la sua voce non è adatto. Si prega di scusare il mio cattivo italiano.
El subtitulo no se interrumpe nunca, las ultimas frases del aria son repetición, y en los subtitulos y/o libretos de ópera lo que se repite nunca se vuelve a traducir, hay que prestar atención al libreto italiano. No se frustra ninguna comprensión...
too high tenor, not mid social afraid father at paris high society worrying of his family name, too young, there are tons of great ones, this is like a substitute teacher rushed into the class due to someone call sick suddenly...
@@xxsaruman82xx87 I dare listen to the D-flat at the end of the recitativo and say it again with a straight face. Does his voice fit verdi? Absolutely not. Is he a lyric or spinto tenor? Hell no. He is a very high light baritone. If his voice was heavier/had more stamina he could propably fight himself through some heldentenor roles. But lyric tenor? No way in hell. it's the same type of voice that Fischer-Dieskau had. Not very well suited to italian opera baritone roles, but also clearly not a tenor. But extremely well suited to mozart, lied and some french opera.
@@AT-zr9tv I didn't say that. One can listen to both if he wants it, obviously. I only said that Bastinanini is better than Bruson, even if Bruson is great.
Pronuncia italiana ripassata in Somalia, interpretazione e stile degni di Compar Alfio dopo la bevuta, ma cose del genere che le interpreta a fare? Si può fare un ascolto comparato con l'interpretazione di Giorgio Zancanaro, per capire cosa significa cantare quest'aria.
This, for me at least, is the only Verdian role Hampson should sing; and he sings it well. Germont pere is largely a lyrical role, which does not call for the sheer vocal size and thrust required for Rigoletto, Rodrigo, Boccanegra, Macbeth, Carlo -- note how the orchestral backing of "Di Provenza" largely comprises strings). The production is absurd at best, at worst stupid. But that's another topic.
Una vocetta con dizione piuttosto comica. In verità, da un po' di tempo evito di seguire le "novità" nell'ambito del canto lirico, perché le trovo degradanti. Molto meglio ascoltare vecchi dischi e CD oppure ciò che passa la Rete.
I did not know "di provenza" was written by Schubert...😂 He is anything but a Verdi baritone and in my opinion he is not even a baritone but a tenor with a lack of singing high notes - a "baritenor". Same was Fischer Diskau.
The two singers' acting is very bad; Specialy Mr. Hampson' . His melody pace is too rapid, he does not seem an old- loving -tender -man, begging his son to return to Provence . His voice is too light for this character, he sholud be singing Figaro and Don Giovanni; those are for his instrument. The scenario too modern. Should have been more vintage. Sorry, I am old fashioned.
people cares of his tall looks more, your point is so obvious, yet his name is still so high there, many times not sure if he should be a tenor, but at very least he could had tune down and acting down into the old troubled worried mid class social concious father in that kind of high highest society of PARIS, there is no excuse of not doing so, where is the artist director, afraid of mr. hampson's name too much!
Yeah, he looks and sounds a bit too young for the role...I think he should’ve played the son instead. I think Figaro would’ve fit him more because of his seemingly youthful looks and sounds. Compare this to Matthew Polenzani, who, when he did Verdi, Sung the role of Macduff (a much lighter role than the others)-he sticks to his fach.
![[동규TV 이장면을아시나요] 베르디 오페라 라트라비아타 Di Provenza il mar il suol (프로방스의 바다와 땅) 바리톤김동규](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/hNQFobJarMw/mqdefault.jpg)
![[동규TV 이장면을아시나요] 베르디 오페라 라트라비아타 Di Provenza il mar il suol (프로방스의 바다와 땅) 바리톤김동규](/img/tr.png)
![กี่หมื่นฟ้า | Your Sky Series EP.1 [1/4]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vLGjxFL6U_I/mqdefault.jpg)
When I watched this for the first time on TV I felt the urge to kneel down and praise the suffering father trying not to lose face and remaining the noble gentleman.
Великий голос и великий музыкант. Great voice and great musician.
My favorite production of La Traviata, with Anna Netrebko. Very emotional performance overall. First time I watched it ( 24 years ago?) I was crying! 😭
Simply magnificent. Verdi could easily have composed this masterpiece for Thomas. Bravo.
Bellísima interpretación de este aria
What I like is that I can understand him perfectly. The words are crystal clear, not muffled, as with many others singing this.
PFG666 Those that muffle the words to achieve a false "darkness" aren't doing anything justice. It should be both, ideally. Very dark and sonorous but also clear and bright. Chiaroscuro.
@@Jacob-ry3lu And Hampson has absolutely no chiaroscuro!!!
XxSaruman82xX No he doesn’t. I’ve seen him at the Met before performing this exact role, he sounded as light as the tenor singing rodolfo that night and anytime the orchestra played mezzo-forte or louder, you simply couldn’t hear anything he was singing
@@xxsaruman82xx87 I've heard rumors about how Alfredo's father sounded more like his brother from this production. But seeing Hampson, it all makes sense
El extraordinario Thomas Hampson (1955) nos interpreta de la bellísima música de La Traviata de Verdi esta aria para barítono impecablemente interpretada. Infinitas gracias por subirlo.
Un placer :)
Gustav Steiner tarde, pero me uno al agradecimiento.
Well, what a revelation! Having heard Fischer‐Diskauu's competent but less than totally successful 'attempt' at this aria I had reservations about Hampson tackling it but by jove he nails it and in my opinion much better than F‐D. He's not up there with the mighty rich textured voices of the past but I'm nonetheless astounded by the achievenent given that his general repertoire encompases lighter material. And I wholeheartedly agree with those commentators who praise his excellent diction. I can only repeat, what a revelation...
Con questa interpretazione mi vien da dire: caro Dimitri Hvorostovsky...mi/ci manchi 😥
Dimitri hvorostovsky
ich finde es toll. schön klar gesungen. Ohne künstliche Tiefe.
Wonderful! God Bless You 🌹
Hello Lecia
На мою думку найкраща виконання!
Bravissimo
Sehr eindrucksvoll!
Besonders die Text-Wiedergabe ist besonders beeindruckend.
straordinario davvero...grazie per il post
Великолепный певец и артист!
Hvorostovsky non era un buon baritono.
Bravooooo!!!!👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏💗
Все, что нужно знать: Титта Руффо: 90-5000 просмотров, Хэмпсон:
135 000 просмотров
und bruson und vergleicht Atmung und Ausdruck. bruson steht da und ich glaube ihm jedes wort, was er da von sich gibt.
due tenori
De tenor nada, siempre ha sido un bajo Barítono, pero aquí quiere aligerar la voz y suena fatal.
The voice isn't bad, just way too light for my liking. Listening to baritones like Macneil, Capuccilli, Warren, and Ruffo and then listening to Hampson, it sounds like I'm listening to a tenor, not a verdi baritone.
MacNeil,Warren,Ruffo??? Ma lei caro jacob è abituato allo champagne,con Hampson deve accontentarsi di uno spumantino rivitalizzato con CO2 ah ah.
Still a great voice, just cannot get the lower bass range.
agree totally, so high, but people only cares of the reputation, love to have Dimitri or ton of other father voices here, in deed, he is more methotical less deep feeling and details...
Don't forget Sherill Milnes, or Giorgio Zancanaro!
@@xxsaruman82xx87
Don't forget Lawrence Tibbett, George London , Danise, Granforte, Bellantoni ,
Guelfi, Bastianini ....
1 Tibbett = 30 Sherill Milnes + 30 Giorgio Zancanaro .
Bravo !!!
Magnifico ! Tanto sensibile,musicale...
th-cam.com/video/n6QDfvPN3hQ/w-d-xo.html
Questo lo è di più.
@@esterbruno8604 Fammi indovinare: Bastianini
Un baritono vero.th-cam.com/video/zyTQ6uLDcss/w-d-xo.html
What idiocy to carp about Hampson's voice being too light or too tenorish. This is a LYRIC baritone role unlike most Verdi baritones. Verdi uses dolce to emphasize the sweetness of the sound that needs to be vocalized and Hampson is perfect (despite his wooden stage movements)
quello che un tenore
I find Mr. Hampson a much better intellect than a singer.
Bravissimo.
One of my favorite pieces from all of Grand Opera. Hampson nails it.
Nope, he don't
th-cam.com/video/n6QDfvPN3hQ/w-d-xo.html
Bravo Bravo
Ідеально
que bellezaaaaaaaaaaa x favor!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Amigo Gustav, sería bueno que al subir videos se indique dónde y cuando se presentó la obra. No todos saben estos detalles....
What grat singing.
thomas lots of love to you
¿Quien es el barítono?, yo escucho a dos magníficos tenores.
***** Thomas Hampson es barítono, lo que sucede es que el aria es exigente en cuanto al registro agudo. Saludos.
si amigo, dos ''magnificos'' tenores.
Difiero respetuosamente. Hampson posee un excelente registro y un timbre hermosisimo, óptimo para una buena gama de repertorio, pero no para Verdi. El aria posee unos cuantos agudos exigentes pero eso no justifica lo parecidas que suenas las voces. Como testimonio, están Bruson, Capuccilli, Bastianini, Tezier y muchos otros capaces de lograr dichos agudos sin que su voz sea semejante a la de un tenor.
Hampson = tenore corto,è un fatto.
cosa c'è in comune fra la vocalità meravigliosa di Bastianini e questo giovane entusiasta?...
niente.
poi Bruson aveva il suo modo unico di porgere.
Cappuccilli molto diverso da Bruson,un altro grande.
Tezier un ragazzo giovane bravo e intelligente chi canta al modo suo e che non gioca nel loro campionato...
ma Bastianini ?
Bastianini era semplicemente un dio.
è ovvio che Hampson è un tenore corto chi sta cantonando con una vocina poco bella.
dal vivo è così.
ciao.
Ho voluto confrontare la qualità e le caratteristiche della vera voce da baritono con cui Hampson possiede. Oggi è facile trovare baritoni cantano ruoli per la sua voce non è adatto.
Si prega di scusare il mio cattivo italiano.
프로방스의 바다와 대지
Por que se interrumpe la traduccion en las ultimas estrofas del aria? Eso frustra la comprension!
El subtitulo no se interrumpe nunca, las ultimas frases del aria son repetición, y en los subtitulos y/o libretos de ópera lo que se repite nunca se vuelve a traducir, hay que prestar atención al libreto italiano. No se frustra ninguna comprensión...
Az érzelmek finoman árnyalt szìnei .
Hampson moves like he peed down his pant's leg.
He's clear tenor, why all theaters are giving him baritone parties?
Outstanding performance! I think Thomas Hampson is no.1 Giorgio Germont in this era. much better than Keenleyside.
too high tenor, not mid social afraid father at paris high society worrying of his family name, too young, there are tons of great ones, this is like a substitute teacher rushed into the class due to someone call sick suddenly...
Dreadful voice
The best one with most projecting and dense Voice with core is Robert Merrill
@@daphnebelovedtry Giuseppe danise,nicolai herlea,Apollo granforte,Carlo tagliabue
Very lyric voice. Not for Verdi. Never learned the coperto in F, F# on A/O vowels. You can’t sing Barbers and Papagenos forever.
Dio can ma cos'è sta roba
Very good singer Hampson, but not right for Verdi.
Tenor!
@@xxsaruman82xx87 Troll.
@@Beadle_Bamford Tenor!
@@xxsaruman82xx87 I dare listen to the D-flat at the end of the recitativo and say it again with a straight face. Does his voice fit verdi? Absolutely not. Is he a lyric or spinto tenor? Hell no. He is a very high light baritone. If his voice was heavier/had more stamina he could propably fight himself through some heldentenor roles. But lyric tenor? No way in hell.
it's the same type of voice that Fischer-Dieskau had. Not very well suited to italian opera baritone roles, but also clearly not a tenor. But extremely well suited to mozart, lied and some french opera.
Bravo no, bravísimo, Thomas
0:33
Pour une voix basse c'est une voix TRÈS basse
voix basse?...
non mon cher,c'est la voix de tenor...
@@bodiloto c'est un baryton... Mais il a un timbre assez clair, qui évoque un ténor.
@@AT-zr9tv
je suis désolé pour moi c'est une voix médiocre de vrai ténor .
@@bodiloto il a fait carrière à chanter des rôles de baryton
I do not understand Italian. I do not know this opera. And yet, listening to this performance of it, I wept.
There is an english version of this song on youtube it will make sense then
Look up Renato Bruson singing this. It's even more stirring and full.
@@AT-zr9tv Bruson is really great.
But if you listen to Bastianini... Here is the magic.
@@esterbruno8604 Why must it be one or the other?
@@AT-zr9tv I didn't say that. One can listen to both if he wants it, obviously.
I only said that Bastinanini is better than Bruson, even if Bruson is great.
hört euch schlußnus an.
Ma che è questa roba?! 🙁
questo e' quello che passa il convento,Bastianini e altri si rigirano nella tomba
I love the staging however the women in drag is ridiculous; they should've just had them wear dark women's suits.
Pronuncia italiana ripassata in Somalia, interpretazione e stile degni di Compar Alfio dopo la bevuta, ma cose del genere che le interpreta a fare? Si può fare un ascolto comparato con l'interpretazione di Giorgio Zancanaro, per capire cosa significa cantare quest'aria.
This, for me at least, is the only Verdian role Hampson should sing; and he sings it well. Germont pere is largely a lyrical role, which does not call for the sheer vocal size and thrust required for Rigoletto, Rodrigo, Boccanegra, Macbeth, Carlo -- note how the orchestral backing of "Di Provenza" largely comprises strings).
The production is absurd at best, at worst stupid. But that's another topic.
Haha. He sang Iago! Lol. He's awful
XxSaruman82xX wait, what???
@@flannerymonaghan-morris1317 Yep: th-cam.com/video/9d1O-0Tzzwo/w-d-xo.html
@@xxsaruman82xx87 What the... IAGO?! 😳
@@esterbruno8604 I'm just as dumbstruck as you are
Una vocetta con dizione piuttosto comica. In verità, da un po' di tempo evito di seguire le "novità" nell'ambito del canto lirico, perché le trovo degradanti. Molto meglio ascoltare vecchi dischi e CD oppure ciò che passa la Rete.
per non parlare di quando insegna canto nei master
Il poco conosciuto Lado Ataneli
th-cam.com/video/zyTQ6uLDcss/w-d-xo.html
Pessimo,voce brutta da tenore ,canto aperto volgare,tecnica e fraseggio inesistente.
Good singing in a ridiculous awkward production.
Dreadful singing in a dreadful production.
@@xxsaruman82xx87 Wow you're even more critical than I am, cool!
Definitivamente no es para su voz
Mediocrity
Thomas Hampson is such a boring singer, So stiff!! No understanding of what he is singing
non rispetta la partitura.
vocalità poco adatta à questo repertorio.
interpretazione tipo stonatissimo con brio.
no comment
bodiloto ma canta come un tenore aiuto!
Hampson va fuori tono!
I did not know "di provenza" was written by Schubert...😂
He is anything but a Verdi baritone and in my opinion he is not even a baritone but a tenor with a lack of singing high notes - a "baritenor". Same was Fischer Diskau.
Sorry...no.
Naja...super klar, das kann er, aber auch schreien statt singen...also okay, mehr leider nicht.
A tenor with bad technique doesn’t make a good baritone either.
He is just music and language expert.Not a good singer
a cheap performance...
The two singers' acting is very bad; Specialy Mr. Hampson' . His melody pace is too rapid, he does not seem an old- loving -tender -man, begging his son to return to Provence . His voice is too light for this character, he sholud be singing Figaro and Don Giovanni; those are for his instrument.
The scenario too modern. Should have been more vintage.
Sorry, I am old fashioned.
people cares of his tall looks more, your point is so obvious, yet his name is still so high there, many times not sure if he should be a tenor, but at very least he could had tune down and acting down into the old troubled worried mid class social concious father in that kind of high highest society of PARIS, there is no excuse of not doing so, where is the artist director, afraid of mr. hampson's name too much!
Yeah, he looks and sounds a bit too young for the role...I think he should’ve played the son instead. I think Figaro would’ve fit him more because of his seemingly youthful looks and sounds. Compare this to Matthew Polenzani, who, when he did Verdi, Sung the role of Macduff (a much lighter role than the others)-he sticks to his fach.
@@flannerymonaghan-morris1317. Dimitri lui e papa. Germont meraviglioso. Baritono, ❤️
Dreadful everything. Dreadful phrasing. No squillo, no core. Thin tone. This is the Met! Hahaha
Tons of your hateful comments under nearly each video of today’s singers. You are such a pathetic troll.
@@Beadle_Bamford Not Hernandez, Lagvilava and Petti! Because they know how to sing with chiaroscuro. Do you know what chiaroscuro is?
0:53