Bar the internal state of opression of minorities, people liked AHE because it makes geopolitical sense, it's basically comprised of countries who interact and have to work with one another the most anyway.
I liked them before, but now they keep blobbing super hard in EU4 and annoying me whenever I'm playing outside Europe. So due to a videogame I'm taking the normal position and hating it like the other monarchical empires.
Hello! I did watch your first video prior to making mine. I want to say that I didn't copy you, but we agreed on a lot of points, like Germany and Russia allying for the time being to destroy Austria-Hungary. I also liked your version, but mine is better because it has bigger Greece! :D
@@rewriting-history Oh of course, I didn't claim you copied me, I actually enjoyed the video a lot! It was really interesting hearing your POV on the matter!
In WW1, Italy and Austria-Hungary were competing to see who had the least capable military I swear. The Alpine front truly was something...... at least AH had the excuse of having multiple languages and ethnicities making the chain of command really awkward, in Italy at worst even a Sicilian being lead by a Venitian could still get the general idea of what was said so the same excuse doesn't even work. The incompetence in the high command was still rampant in both nations regardless
I would love to see a video about an alternative WW2 in this scenario. I also think the February Revolution wouldn't have happened if Austria Hungary leaves the war in late 1916 and is invaded by Germany since this would boost russian morale and would open a new route for the Entente to suply Russia avoiding the food crisis that lead to the Revolution
I like how Austria-Hungary becomes the Poland and Denmark the Czechoslovakia of this timeline, also the axis including Serbia and Romania is interesting
imagine you drag your homie into a war, they do all the work to keep your alliance from fataly losing and then you betray them to get out of a war that you started
I know that it will be unrealistic but I really really want to see this new alternative ww2 pls make a video about it 😅 anyways great video you never disappoint ❤
If Austria survives this version of WWII and wins alongside the Allies, I can easily see them regaining all the territory they lost in WWI, including taking Silesia from Germany and Venetia from Italy, potentially even suzerainty over Montenegro, and suzerainty over Romania to secure the lower Danube river. Certainly they would ally an independent Albania to secure the mouth of the Adriatic sea as well.
IDK if was during the same proposal but I heard that France was willing to allow A-H to annex Bavaria and possible other parts of Catholic Germany to both weaken the Germany while also strengthen A-H, but I could be wrong
Funny idea I thought of. Why don't you make a video of an alternative history of an alternative history. Example Fuherreich that and how people in a world where Germany won WW1 think what it would be like if the Entente had won WW1. For example, you (from a universe where Germany won the Second World War) would talk about a theory of what it would be like if Germany had lost the Second World War. For example, you would say "We all know that Bukharon becoming leader of the Soviet Union led to the Soviet economic collapse that led to his defeat, but... what if, through a small change, the Soviet Finns took power, making global socialism gain more strength, making Trotaky took power and invested in the exercise with communist movements taking control in Brazil, China, Chile and Nicaragua and we know that Charles Lindenberg won the elections of 40, leaving the US in a war with Japan (which we ended up losing even more by continuing). ) we are going to make Smedley Butler carry out a military coup that almost happened and we are going to make the USA intervene in the War at the end of 1940 and we are going to make the prominent politician Arnold Lesse win the emergency elections of prime minister in 40 and make the United Kingdom become an Utranationalist state making moral English became high and making a "Cruzade" against false facism and after years of war in 1949, 3 nuclear bombs were dropped on Germany and 8 on Japan with the beginning of a three-sided cold war, the first the United States bloc which would include Japan, Canada, Mexico and some countries. from Arabia and Asia. the Communist bloc led by the Soviet Union led by D. S. Mirsky and declared the Eurasian soviet Socialista Republic since Trotsky was assassinated in 44 by a Mexican spy, China led by Zhou Enlai and the only major communist country in the Americas, Brazil led by João Amazonas. And the Utranationalist bloc led by the United Kingdom who are led by Oswald Mosley that became prime minister in 1945 who managed to maintain his entire Empire including India which was kept under control because the British ordered the death of Gandhi and Subha Sandras Boshe in 47 and France led by Jacques Doriot who managed to win the Indochina war with British help and Italy, which remained neutral throughout the second war until 45, where Mussoline ordered war against the false fascists in Germany, where they managed to hold the front until 49, when the war ended. Mussolini died in 48 by a Heart Atack and succeeded by the Fascist Mysticist Nicolau Giani who managed to stabilize Italy and Germany that is ruled by Josef Mengele. So this is the end of another video. In the next video we will see what would have happened if Stalin had continued his political path and not become a priest" If you're reading this and say it's unrealistic...you are complety right
Cursed idea WHAT IF: Ernst Thälmann island make east Germany survive and somehow form A Caribbean Version of the USSR? Or (this one’s more insane) WHAT IF: The Prussians claimed the Hawaiis throne and after ww1 became in exile in German Samoa and Hawaii
Austria would NEVER accept the annexation of South Tyrol into Italy. The italian speaking Trentino yes, but never Brixen and Meran which were the cultural and economic center of Tyrol. Tyrol was the only german speaking region within Austria with some kind of nationalism that wasnt German, so it is possible that the whole region goes into instant civil war mode, or joins Germany. IRL Tyrol seriously considered joining Germany or even Italy as a whole or petitioning the allies to form a serperate country as an italian vassal state just to keep the Tyrolian territorial integrity. Similar situation with Triest. While Rijeka (Fiume) was an important secondary harbor it had not much capacity or infrastructure, and Koper was no real freight harbor at all at that time, so there is no chance that AH would cut itself completely off from the Med. I can see a situation where Triest becomes some CO-administered buffer state, and parts of Triest or some islands yeah, but never Triest. It wasnt just that Karl think the Italians didnt deserve these lands, they were vital for the continued existance of the empires mercantile capabilities, and with a hostile Romania AND Germany, any trade via the Rhine or Danube would be cut off too, so only the already boxed in Adria ports remain, so even more dependence on Italy would no be permissible.
@@rewriting-history It nearly broke the Austrian government as the cedeing of Tyrol was one of the biggest hurdles of the early First Republic.... Without the pressure of saint germain I cant see it happening. Also I couldn't see Italy seriously trying their hand for South Tyrol anyway when there is bigger fish with actual Italian minorities out there
I feel the bosphorus is far too valuable to make into an international zone for Russia for the sake of influence, pride and so on (though the Brits wouldn't be too happy). And it would need some garrisons either way, being a heavily populated region with a largely turkish majority.
If both Russia and Gemrany lost the control of the Polish puppetbin 1918, Austria Hungry in this timeline would be the olny one to still have an puppet control over Poland, but since back before Austria was kind, the Polish wouldn't mind, right?
I am guessing that Russia would become a constitutional monarchy, forcing Nicholas II to abdicate and putting his brother in charge. Russia would also lose Finland if they get rid of the monarchy
Bosnia had just been absorbed. True Italian majority lands (which Italy owns today) could be given without much loss of land. Romania would probably be the most difficult lost territory to explain to the population, but it was part of the Hungarian crown & it was mostly made up of hills. Had that been well negotiated, Austria wouldn't have lost that much, tbh.
It is also much more possible that Mustafa Kemal wouldn't have attacked the Russians knowing it would've been impossible to win. Maybe Kemal would've done many border clashes against Greece, France and Britian. Edit: If we also count that France and Britian stays together Russia wouldn't've have cared for the british or french but could give something about greece.
I dont think Serbia would get all of Albania, that part is a bit too simplistic. Serbia was actually meant to get northern Albania around the city of Skadar that was majority Christian. The rest would either be independent or fall. under Greece. Interesting topic either way
Hey there! What a Nice Video! I love when you make Videos about my Home Country Austria! I have an exciting Idea for you. What if: The Social Democrats won the Austrian Civil War of 1934? Because: I think it would have extreme consequences for Germany in the Long run. Since a Social Democratic Government would never EVER, accept an annexation of Austria, unlike the Austrofascists. And Germany was running low on Money and Gold. Would Germany Declare War? How would that war look like (Given that the Austrian Military was actually better equipped than most of the German Army in 1938. And Given Austria's Mountainous terrain, how would that War develop. And most Importantly: How would the World react to this? Especially France, britain, Italy and the Soviet Union? Would the Western Allies actually Intervene because Austria would actually be a Democratic Republic? Would the Soviets intervene because Austria would be Socialist? And what would change in Austria if Democracy survived? I would absolutely LOVE to see a Video made about this, since I think that the Austrian Civil War was kind of... Forgotten by everyone, even though it could have changed so, SO much. Thank you for the Wonderful Videos Rewriting History! greetings from Austria!
Me when you post a video:😍, And i have a idea for the next one what if germany started ww2 in the 40s, for example attacking poland in 1944, i think it would be interesting because germany could prepare for it longer
Lmao Albania would never have entered a personal union with Serbia. Obviously they would refuse and be in constant rebellion, similar to our timeline but even worse. Serbia was struggling with occupying Kosova and Macedonia due to rebellions, imagine if now they have to occupy even more Albanian lands. Regardless, the Serbs wanted Durres and the territories leading to Durres, in order to access the Adriatic, not the whole country.
3:40 there were plans to give majority of Albania to Serbia in the early stages of the war but not all of it. Southern parts of Albania were planned to be given to Greece.
It should’ve been the other way around. Austria-Hungary was so ineffective in the war that Germany had to save them many times. Whenever I talk about WW1 I always say the eastern front was a German victory despite Austria-Hungary being there too but they don’t deserve the credit they didn’t contribute at all. If Germany won the war after its allies surrendered and if I was one of the German negotiators I would not give Austria-Hungary and the Ottoman Empire any gains since they were very ineffective Bulgaria would be the only one to gain land since at least they contributed. Both nations would be angry and relations would most likely be broken but they’re going to collapse anyway.
It is not try that Serbia didn't perform well in WW1... It had two great victories (Battles of cer and kolubara) at beginning of the war against more numerous and better equipped Austria-Hungarian army... That were also first victories on the sade of Entente in WW1. All 3 central powers needed to gang up and invasion on 3 sides to start withdrawal over Albania
This completely ignores the promises made to Austria in return for surrender, which was not leaving the war but *Switching Sides*, Austria was promised as much as all of Silesia and Bavaria, with absolutely no promises made to Romania on Austrian lands.
@@rewriting-history It is extreme, but it is what was being used to convince Austria to switch sides, not giving Austria the carrot after beating them with the stick is how you end up with the treaty being thrown out like IRL. Realistically, they may get some border corrections in Bavaria and maybe half of Silesia, but that's still a vast improvement from nothing. It's also worth noting that France made the promises, the state that wanted to completely dismantle the idea of Germany, so it's not exactly unlikely for Austria to gain some strategic German lands from the agreement.
Can you pls make a video about what if Franco-Prussian War never happened and France and Germany become freinds after German Unification (1871). Edit: To compensate France, France and Netherlands could have partioned Belgium, and Prussia allowed France to buy Luxemborg to have better relations.
@Mercurus-p1 where you at?
All subscribe btw!
ALREADY DID
I will subscribe!
Hello, Nice to meet you
Lowkey make a scenario What of antolia stayed Christian!
Did you actually do the sixtus affair idea? Thanks!
You think you can escape me? Well, my good friend Rewriting History, you will NEVER escape me!
Oh no, what have I done.... I have summoned the devil!
This still doesn't change the fact that I exist
Uh oh
Oh no
@@rewriting-history lol
Austria-Hungary: Yo germany join my war
Germany: fine
Austria hungary: *sues for peace alone, letting germany die*
Germany: bro wth
Lmao such a classic
this is very much not how it was, germany was twitching at an opportunity to fight russia, fearing its industrialization
@@DakuHonoo I know, but this is essentially what happened in the video. They wanted to fight Russia, not a two front war.
@@Drake2628r they knew it would be a 2-front war and a naval blockade, they did want it anyway, in the video they had to open a third front
@@DakuHonoo cant you tell this is a joke lol you don't need to go all "erm actually" on him.
Wait what? Russia gaining Constantinople instead of Galicia sounds like the most incredible deal Russia could think of.
Britan: yes but actually no
1453 will be avenged at any cost
And they also almost get some other lands from Ottoman Empire, but id did not happen due to Russian Revolution and other events in our timeline.
Self determination my a$$
- France
Lmaoo
@@rewriting-historyCan you make a continued video covering this scenario? It'd be interesting to see what would happen
I don't know why but I really like the Austro-Hungarian Empire for no exact reason 💀
Same bro
Really @@rewriting-history
Bar the internal state of opression of minorities, people liked AHE because it makes geopolitical sense, it's basically comprised of countries who interact and have to work with one another the most anyway.
As a Hungarian the 1848 revolution should be successful and Austro-Hungary Empire should never happen would be probably the best @@DakuHonoo
I liked them before, but now they keep blobbing super hard in EU4 and annoying me whenever I'm playing outside Europe. So due to a videogame I'm taking the normal position and hating it like the other monarchical empires.
Postponing the Austro-Hungarian collapse is wild
It would change so much in terms of the German tactics before WW2
If only Austria was still big...
Plot twist! Austrian painter takes over Austria-Hungary
what if austria hungary turned into a lake in 1916?
World peace
Greater Mediterranean Sea
and naval invasion of dresden
Austria-Hungary: betrays Germany
Germany: wait this entire operation was your idea
I was on to comment the same
@@AlexGames306but Germany did send the blank cheque so
Germany really wanted a war like WW1 and Austria was just their tool to execute it
Actually not. Austria-Hungary wanted a small regional war againdt Serbia. It was Germany that wanted war with France and Russia
@@AdvancedGamer- no .. the generals yes.. not the kaiser.. the kaiser was in norway.
Literally my favorite alternate history scenario; can't wait to see this!
Hello! I did watch your first video prior to making mine. I want to say that I didn't copy you, but we agreed on a lot of points, like Germany and Russia allying for the time being to destroy Austria-Hungary. I also liked your version, but mine is better because it has bigger Greece! :D
@@rewriting-history Oh of course, I didn't claim you copied me, I actually enjoyed the video a lot! It was really interesting hearing your POV on the matter!
This is genuinely my favorite channel on TH-cam, i even stopped playing HOI4 to watch this
Ayo this is such a nice compliment! I appreciate this!
Very good video! Well done rewriting history
I appreciate this!
You know your war performance is bad when even Austria-Hungary criticizes it 💀💀💀
Lmaooo
Tbh can you disagree
(As an Italian)
In WW1, Italy and Austria-Hungary were competing to see who had the least capable military I swear. The Alpine front truly was something...... at least AH had the excuse of having multiple languages and ethnicities making the chain of command really awkward, in Italy at worst even a Sicilian being lead by a Venitian could still get the general idea of what was said so the same excuse doesn't even work.
The incompetence in the high command was still rampant in both nations regardless
I would love to see a video about an alternative WW2 in this scenario. I also think the February Revolution wouldn't have happened if Austria Hungary leaves the war in late 1916 and is invaded by Germany since this would boost russian morale and would open a new route for the Entente to suply Russia avoiding the food crisis that lead to the Revolution
Yes, if Austria leaves earlier than a lot more changes
Germany: wait a minute, this whole operation was your idea
Yes lmao
I like how Austria-Hungary becomes the Poland and Denmark the Czechoslovakia of this timeline, also the axis including Serbia and Romania is interesting
Yeah it's really interesting
@Titancameramanedits5614 I mean like "we can help you" include, not "give up land or get invaded" include
austria hungary: starts war
germany: helps austria hungary
austria hungary: attacks germany
Based ngl
Germany and Russia temporarily aligning to partition a country. Where have I seen this one before?
No idea, must be on Possible History's channel
Or it could be from...
You know
The person we PH/RH fans don't talk about
Idea for another series.
Germany doesnt attack ussr and forces UK for a peace and wins ww2. A 3 way cold war begins with sides Germany, USSR and USA.
I wonder what the hell Germany would even do and how they would project their influence beyond Europe and North Africa
The Perfect successor to Kaisertum
Except the Kaiserreich had more of a chance than the Reich, who was doomed to collapse
Request:What if France invaded Belgium in 1914?
Devastating example of the classic Uno Reverse maneuver
You never dissapoint! Thanks For all your hardwork 😊😊😊😊
Thank you too!
imagine you drag your homie into a war, they do all the work to keep your alliance from fataly losing and then you betray them to get out of a war that you started
I know that it will be unrealistic but I really really want to see this new alternative ww2 pls make a video about it 😅 anyways great video you never disappoint ❤
I will consider making it, the idea is popular
@@rewriting-history that's great to hear 🥳🤩
If Austria survives this version of WWII and wins alongside the Allies, I can easily see them regaining all the territory they lost in WWI, including taking Silesia from Germany and Venetia from Italy, potentially even suzerainty over Montenegro, and suzerainty over Romania to secure the lower Danube river. Certainly they would ally an independent Albania to secure the mouth of the Adriatic sea as well.
This is completely possible if they win
LOVE YOUR CONTENT! Thanks For this ❤❤❤❤
Thanks for watching!
I really enjoy all of your videos man its a pleasure to just watch 20 casual mins I only open youtube for ur vids. Keep up the work dude
can u "do what if bulgaria joined yugoslavia after WW1?" or "what if trotsky got in power after lenin?"
I was considering the first option
I like how Austria-Hungary becomes our timeline's Poland in WWII.
And Denmark becomes Czechoslovakia
Bro never disappoints
Appreciate it!
So in this timeline the "stab in the back" myth would blame Austra for losing the war.
Yes
betrayed ❌
not sewersidal ✅
Please make another interactive video as you did for WW1! It was amazing.
I don't think I will as of now
@@rewriting-history OK then, thank you for answering. Mabey consider this again in the future.
Could you do a Kaisertum post-war scenario
It's possible, but I would like to move on. We shall see
IDK if was during the same proposal but I heard that France was willing to allow A-H to annex Bavaria and possible other parts of Catholic Germany to both weaken the Germany while also strengthen A-H, but I could be wrong
I love how ww2 is almost insentical to our timeline
Funny idea I thought of. Why don't you make a video of an alternative history of an alternative history. Example Fuherreich that and how people in a world where Germany won WW1 think what it would be like if the Entente had won WW1. For example, you (from a universe where Germany won the Second World War) would talk about a theory of what it would be like if Germany had lost the Second World War. For example, you would say "We all know that Bukharon becoming leader of the Soviet Union led to the Soviet economic collapse that led to his defeat, but... what if, through a small change, the Soviet Finns took power, making global socialism gain more strength, making Trotaky took power and invested in the exercise with communist movements taking control in Brazil, China, Chile and Nicaragua and we know that Charles Lindenberg won the elections of 40, leaving the US in a war with Japan (which we ended up losing even more by continuing). ) we are going to make Smedley Butler carry out a military coup that almost happened and we are going to make the USA intervene in the War at the end of 1940 and we are going to make the prominent politician Arnold Lesse win the emergency elections of prime minister in 40 and make the United Kingdom become an Utranationalist state making moral English became high and making a "Cruzade" against false facism and after years of war in 1949, 3 nuclear bombs were dropped on Germany and 8 on Japan with the beginning of a three-sided cold war, the first the United States bloc which would include Japan, Canada, Mexico and some countries. from Arabia and Asia. the Communist bloc led by the Soviet Union led by D. S. Mirsky and declared the Eurasian soviet Socialista Republic since Trotsky was assassinated in 44 by a Mexican spy, China led by Zhou Enlai and the only major communist country in the Americas, Brazil led by João Amazonas. And the Utranationalist bloc led by the United Kingdom who are led by Oswald Mosley that became prime minister in 1945 who managed to maintain his entire Empire including India which was kept under control because the British ordered the death of Gandhi and Subha Sandras Boshe in 47 and France led by Jacques Doriot who managed to win the Indochina war with British help and Italy, which remained neutral throughout the second war until 45, where Mussoline ordered war against the false fascists in Germany, where they managed to hold the front until 49, when the war ended. Mussolini died in 48 by a Heart Atack and succeeded by the Fascist Mysticist Nicolau Giani who managed to stabilize Italy and Germany that is ruled by Josef Mengele. So this is the end of another video. In the next video we will see what would have happened if Stalin had continued his political path and not become a priest"
If you're reading this and say it's unrealistic...you are complety right
I would love a video where Prussia takes land from Austria after the Austro-Prussian war of 1866!
Perfect timing
Glad I could deliver!
Cursed idea
WHAT IF: Ernst Thälmann island make east Germany survive and somehow form A Caribbean Version of the USSR?
Or (this one’s more insane)
WHAT IF: The Prussians claimed the Hawaiis throne and after ww1 became in exile in German Samoa and Hawaii
I did do the Ernst Thälmann island for All Endings Germany video
@@rewriting-history I noticed I just thought “ah yes what if it continued”
Austria would NEVER accept the annexation of South Tyrol into Italy. The italian speaking Trentino yes, but never Brixen and Meran which were the cultural and economic center of Tyrol. Tyrol was the only german speaking region within Austria with some kind of nationalism that wasnt German, so it is possible that the whole region goes into instant civil war mode, or joins Germany. IRL Tyrol seriously considered joining Germany or even Italy as a whole or petitioning the allies to form a serperate country as an italian vassal state just to keep the Tyrolian territorial integrity.
Similar situation with Triest. While Rijeka (Fiume) was an important secondary harbor it had not much capacity or infrastructure, and Koper was no real freight harbor at all at that time, so there is no chance that AH would cut itself completely off from the Med. I can see a situation where Triest becomes some CO-administered buffer state, and parts of Triest or some islands yeah, but never Triest. It wasnt just that Karl think the Italians didnt deserve these lands, they were vital for the continued existance of the empires mercantile capabilities, and with a hostile Romania AND Germany, any trade via the Rhine or Danube would be cut off too, so only the already boxed in Adria ports remain, so even more dependence on Italy would no be permissible.
Well they accepted it historically, so it's not like they'd never do that. I was there myself last week and yes there's a lot of German speakers there
@@rewriting-history It nearly broke the Austrian government as the cedeing of Tyrol was one of the biggest hurdles of the early First Republic....
Without the pressure of saint germain I cant see it happening. Also I couldn't see Italy seriously trying their hand for South Tyrol anyway when there is bigger fish with actual Italian minorities out there
It should be noted that in that deal, the French President did offer to give Bavaria and Silesia to Austria had they made peace.
I don't think that this would have happened, to me it's way too extreme
Nice video!
Thanks for the support!
I feel the bosphorus is far too valuable to make into an international zone for Russia for the sake of influence, pride and so on (though the Brits wouldn't be too happy).
And it would need some garrisons either way, being a heavily populated region with a largely turkish majority.
@@aarohalme1020 yea, but Russia will not be the only one garrisoning it
All endings kaisertum when? Good video btw :)
Next week!
@@rewriting-history nice 👍 :)
Hi Rewriting History, this isn't me, your last viewer. The voices have gotten to me. goodby
Hello there!
Can you make more vids about Poland Lithuania commonwealth?
If both Russia and Gemrany lost the control of the Polish puppetbin 1918, Austria Hungry in this timeline would be the olny one to still have an puppet control over Poland, but since back before Austria was kind, the Polish wouldn't mind, right?
Austria could give up Galicia to Poland and maybe get them on their side
I love you saying "Entente"
Thanks lol
I don't see Austria ever giving up Trieste tbh. It's too vital of a port for the Empire to surrender.
Well what are they going to do, keep fighting this war and lose the entire empire, which happened historically and we know is a bad idea
Could you do what if Czechoslovakia broke in 1929 or during the wars after Russia's collapse ?
Rare footage of rewriting history not showing his coins in a video
Can you do a video about if Sweden won the great northern war please!
Eventually I will
pls can you make a video what happened if Hungary succesfully switched sides in ww2
Germany is having trust issues rn
Fr fr
I think you slipped up with the polish autonomy, it wouldn’t be a monarchy while Russia is a republic
I am guessing that Russia would become a constitutional monarchy, forcing Nicholas II to abdicate and putting his brother in charge. Russia would also lose Finland if they get rid of the monarchy
Bosnia had just been absorbed. True Italian majority lands (which Italy owns today) could be given without much loss of land. Romania would probably be the most difficult lost territory to explain to the population, but it was part of the Hungarian crown & it was mostly made up of hills.
Had that been well negotiated, Austria wouldn't have lost that much, tbh.
ROMANIAN NATIONALIST!
realistic video, love it
Glad to hear it!
It is also much more possible that Mustafa Kemal wouldn't have attacked the Russians knowing it would've been impossible to win. Maybe Kemal would've done many border clashes against Greece, France and Britian.
Edit: If we also count that France and Britian stays together Russia wouldn't've have cared for the british or french but could give something about greece.
I dont think Serbia would get all of Albania, that part is a bit too simplistic. Serbia was actually meant to get northern Albania around the city of Skadar that was majority Christian. The rest would either be independent or fall. under Greece. Interesting topic either way
Hey there! What a Nice Video! I love when you make Videos about my Home Country Austria!
I have an exciting Idea for you.
What if: The Social Democrats won the Austrian Civil War of 1934?
Because: I think it would have extreme consequences for Germany in the Long run. Since a Social Democratic Government would never EVER,
accept an annexation of Austria, unlike the Austrofascists. And Germany was running low on Money and Gold.
Would Germany Declare War? How would that war look like (Given that the Austrian Military was actually better equipped than most of the German
Army in 1938. And Given Austria's Mountainous terrain, how would that War develop.
And most Importantly: How would the World react to this? Especially France, britain, Italy and the Soviet Union?
Would the Western Allies actually Intervene because Austria would actually be a Democratic Republic? Would the Soviets intervene because Austria would be Socialist?
And what would change in Austria if Democracy survived?
I would absolutely LOVE to see a Video made about this, since I think that the Austrian Civil War was kind of... Forgotten by everyone, even though it could have changed so, SO much.
Thank you for the Wonderful Videos Rewriting History! greetings from Austria!
preforming bad and switching sides. Most german ally thing
Based
I feel like Italy always gets too much, too much of Istria and too much of the Dalmatian coast and wholly undeserved.
Alt tittle: random Italian guy takes over Austria-Hungary
Lmao 🤣
Didn't imagine we would rename Poland to Austria Hungary in ww2 but sure
Me when you post a video:😍, And i have a idea for the next one what if germany started ww2 in the 40s, for example attacking poland in 1944, i think it would be interesting because germany could prepare for it longer
4:28 didnt a german also rule romania?
Yes, but the Romanians kept their line
@@rewriting-historyoh that makes sense
Russia did for a long time want Constantinople so I do have a feeling they would very unlikely turn into an international zone
What if Mercurus-p1 was the Bulgarian leader?
Based
I think the biggest affect on history would be the effect on provisional Russian moral
Lmao Albania would never have entered a personal union with Serbia. Obviously they would refuse and be in constant rebellion, similar to our timeline but even worse. Serbia was struggling with occupying Kosova and Macedonia due to rebellions, imagine if now they have to occupy even more Albanian lands. Regardless, the Serbs wanted Durres and the territories leading to Durres, in order to access the Adriatic, not the whole country.
They will rebel for sure, but of course France and Serbia would put them back into the fold. They were just too weak to stand strong and independent
Austria starts a war and leaves its ally to finish it. Well, not the first time the Habsburgs astonished the world with their ingratitude.
They're the next Italy
Hi rewriting history have you consider to play age of history 3?
Will come out the 2 of october will you play it?
I can always give it a try!
Ok thank you!
Pls make a part for ww2 and after it
I was thinking about it
@@rewriting-history cool
*Then Germany getting stabbed in the back wouldn't just be a myth.*
Always
3:40 there were plans to give majority of Albania to Serbia in the early stages of the war but not all of it. Southern parts of Albania were planned to be given to Greece.
Yeah I thought of redoing it, but left it as like that
I love your accent
I love to hear it!
Part 2 please
Hmmm maybe I should make it
It should’ve been the other way around. Austria-Hungary was so ineffective in the war that Germany had to save them many times. Whenever I talk about WW1 I always say the eastern front was a German victory despite Austria-Hungary being there too but they don’t deserve the credit they didn’t contribute at all. If Germany won the war after its allies surrendered and if I was one of the German negotiators I would not give Austria-Hungary and the Ottoman Empire any gains since they were very ineffective Bulgaria would be the only one to gain land since at least they contributed. Both nations would be angry and relations would most likely be broken but they’re going to collapse anyway.
Can you do What if I touched grass?
I usually do at least plausible scenarios, not too unrealistic.
JK bro love you!
Can you please do a video on what if Trotsky came to power in the Ussr instead of Stalin?
part2 when?
I don't plan for it as of now
pls continue this timeline
What if great britain betrayed france in ww1 und didnt send any troops to france?
Sometimes, I wish we had time machines for everyone
I want to see a Part 2
love youre vids my fav was about liechtenstein
Oh that was a while ago! Glad to hear it!
@@rewriting-history thnks cause there barley any what if with Liechtenstein
It is not try that Serbia didn't perform well in WW1... It had two great victories (Battles of cer and kolubara) at beginning of the war against more numerous and better equipped Austria-Hungarian army... That were also first victories on the sade of Entente in WW1. All 3 central powers needed to gang up and invasion on 3 sides to start withdrawal over Albania
Part 2 pls
I am considering it
This completely ignores the promises made to Austria in return for surrender, which was not leaving the war but *Switching Sides*, Austria was promised as much as all of Silesia and Bavaria, with absolutely no promises made to Romania on Austrian lands.
I don't think this would happen. Romania joined exactly because they wanted Austrian lands. What you're saying is too extreme
@@rewriting-history It is extreme, but it is what was being used to convince Austria to switch sides, not giving Austria the carrot after beating them with the stick is how you end up with the treaty being thrown out like IRL.
Realistically, they may get some border corrections in Bavaria and maybe half of Silesia, but that's still a vast improvement from nothing.
It's also worth noting that France made the promises, the state that wanted to completely dismantle the idea of Germany, so it's not exactly unlikely for Austria to gain some strategic German lands from the agreement.
Make video What If Operation Unthinkable happend in 1949.
Very interesting
Can you pls make a video about what if Franco-Prussian War never happened and France and Germany become freinds after German Unification (1871).
Edit: To compensate France, France and Netherlands could have partioned Belgium, and Prussia allowed France to buy Luxemborg to have better relations.
Bismarck otl was oppised to annexing Alsace Lorraine
Make part 2
Austrian Empire required more kingdoms and many recognized enclaveesl. Austrian federation and foreign support
Very good
Love it
@@rewriting-history What if Kingdom of Hungary naver was conquer by Ottoman Empire.
We had a great emperor Charles the Fifth and it would be awesome to have him instead of local nationalists and Austronationalists
Or Charles the 1st abroad
Que buen video joder❤
"self determination my ass"
Lmao
Can you make something about croatia
Yes, but not right now