He could distract the Central Powers armies tactically by having them redirecting their attacks against him. Of course, being invincible, those attacks would have no effects on Rasputin
Fun fact: You can like a comment by double tapping(not on laptop).You probably know this ,but did you know that you could triple tap to like and reply?
I discovered your channel when you had like 6 subs, the Liechtenstein video showed up in my recomendations and since then I liked your channel. You put my comment asking for a second part in the second part of that video. I don't know why I never bought a membership but I finnaly did it!
I didn't remember, but I'm glad you managed to make it to one of my videos. Since I don't do this format anymore you're special and I most likely won't do it again.
There was also French plans for after the war where Germany is dissolved but both the British and the American refused so maybe in this timeline this treaty is possible
True... and the AI didn't build military factories, it just bought from the international market... We all know you just do heavy tanks behind the Dniper line
Hungary having a full-blown rebellion against Austria in the middle of WW1 is an interesting idea for me. I imagine it would give the Entente reason to be more merciful towards Hungary now that they'd been a de-facto ally instead of a defeated half of an enemy. It's a general alternate history scenario I'd like to see more of.
@@wingedhussar1453the hungarians were the first to declare independence from austria when they knew for certain they were going to lose the war, russia reaching the hungarian plains would only make hungary leave faster
It's not that Nicolas wasn't interested in ruling. It was that Nicolas wanted all the power for himself. He was surrounded by people (his wife) who had urged him to maintain his authority. Had his father had taught him how to rule Russia and at least gave him a more active role in government, perhaps the czar would have ruled Russia better. But I need to research if the previous czar's had any such experience.
I’m actually so thankful for how everything played out in ww1 and ww2. Even if Romania no longer has Bessarabia, atleast we still have a majority of all regions.
As a Pole, I got the same take as you. We managed to gain our independence after the first world war. And later, as a result of WW2. We may of lost Western Ukraine, Belarus, and parts of Lithuania. But we gained valuable German territories, and good industrial lands. Which also gave us more space away from Russia, and bought us closer to the west, not just geopolitically but also geographically (borders shifting west), and yes ik about the eastern block, am referring to after its collapse. And honestly we got some good borders out of it, when comparing it to the potential borders of Poland if Roosevelt’s or Churchill’s plans for a divided Germany became reality. In which Poland got even less land. So honestly, am happy with what we got, although I think we should of kept some extra land. But am no crazy nationalist and so there is no reason to complain as extra land makes no sense nowadays. And yes, Moldova and Romania will probs unite sooner rather than later. Agreed. X
Empire Russia was not great. I wouldnt even say better then communism. Communism tried to show false sense of nationalism for countries while russia tried erasing all culture
Honestly, I enjoyed this video more than your other recent videos! Idk what it was, this was just better I guess! This could really use a part two, either detailing what Russia did in Asia during this video, or an outright sequel scenario! I said it once and I will say it again, I really like this new map! Great video, keep it up man!
Russia did do well in WW1, like all powers they had setbacks but there enemies were overstretched and they had considerable staying power. The stereotype of Russia in ww1 partly comes from the mismanagement of the military that started under the provisional government and majorly because of Soviet propaganda. Historians think that without the revolution the war probably would have ended in 1917, indeed this was a motivation for the revolution, victory would lead to the political death of liberalism, the Tsar would most likely have used his reinforced position to get rid of the political concessions, on top of this Britain and France were heavily involved, they wanted Russia to transition over to liberalism and were terrified of Russia owning Constantinople and thus breaking out of the black sea into into the Mediterranean. The ottoman empire had long been propped up by the rest of Europe for this exact reason. The revolution had considerable organisational support from Britain, once it happened however the duma quickly proved themselves clowns, they introduced democracy to the army, gave contradictory orders and sidelined skilled officers and generals as politically suspect, they also allowed the enemies to the left to set up parallel government organisations. Even before Lenin overthrowing their government was mostly a matter of getting troops to the capital, railway workers were a considerably more effective force in the preservation of the government than any military one. Russia could have fought the war on better terms, but to do this they would have had to have had different people in leadership positions, the Tsar lacked initiative and was overly suggestable, and to be frank if that or the quality of higher officials were better then not only would Russia have beaten Japan in 1904 but Russia probably would have allied with Germany given that that is explicitly what Tsar Nicholas and Kaiser Wilhelm had wished for, being close friends, and politically similar in their views. The other method would be reform of the army system, but to be frank that would have taken a genius imbued with unchecked power and a pretty good idea of how things would pan out and which senior officers were reliable. For the most part was the revolution, a junta plot by high ranking generals, the poor quality of the garrison of st Petersburg and the lack of a man of action on the ground nearby that spelled doom for Russia's military effort. As a purely military force they showed themselves more than capable.
With the threat of Russia and Germany, I think France and UK would push for milder peace for Austria Hungary to preserve balance of power. I would only see the seizing of Pozen and Alsace Lorraine from Germany. Italy get everything they promised but Triest in London agreement and surrounding Slavic populated region. Triest had been habsburg’s for 500 years and can provide sea access to them.
@@rewriting-history Okay i'll check it out i just discovered you're channel and i'm already in love with the content and i myself collect Historical Hats uniforms guns scrap swords helmets grenades ammos and Coins (my rarest is Finnish coin from 1930)
This is an intresting scenario, just one minor thing. Even if the italians were awarded dalmatia, I still believe because of the italian economic crisis, as well as other problems with the government at the time would still see mr fascist pizza man taking charge of the country.
I have heard this argument many times before. I still don't know if this is a fact, or a popular concept. We cannot ever know. I will do a TH-cam poll in the near future and see what people think. Thank you for the feedback!
@@rewriting-history Maybe a failed revolt at worst. Supply and industrial problems being fixed would make the people a lot happier. Not exactly saying losing a war would be great, but if they fought well enough and had decent supply the monarchy would still be in place.
What if Austria was competent. Getting mega boosted by the congress of Vienna and having a secure hold over Germany and Italy. Then it industrializes but also efficiently grants rights to minority in the region. Austria by ww1 then being an actual great power
@@rewriting-history I can tell that, your videos slowly upgrade and become a better version than their last videos, the map, your voice, your sub count everything is increasing, you inspire me to the moon, keep up the good work, i repeat, KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK
Yeah I considered that too, but not a whole lot would change, they simply get Dalmatia and maybe Anatolia, they join the Allies in WW2 and I already have a video on that
One mistake i saw is that Japanese imperialism and expansionism was a concept and was in practice way before ultranationalists rised in Europe. So East Asia would not be changed
after capitulation of Austria-Hungary i see Germany capitulating itself. In real life, even when they won russia and expanded in east, they still decided to capitulate to Antente
Italy gaining Dalmatia would not in any way prevent Mussolini's rise to power, as the economy would still collapse and the king would still prefer the fascists over the communists Also, no way does Russia randomly take the polish corridor if Poland has their sea access, they would take posen and Napoleonic polish borders at best
You are not wrong, but the thing is that the war would be a lot shorter and less deadly, so Italy will not be as bankrupted as they were historically, so they can not go ultranationalist, or at least its less likely
@@rewriting-history fair point, although I feel like the fascists wouldn't really care about how badly is the economy actually going and still protest in the streets due to socialist disorders and the king would be weak enough to give in
@@rewriting-history this was a pretty interesting scenario but this shows how incompetent austria is Like austria got pushed back to Galicia in actual history now imagine a good russian empire
Maybe with a more powerfull russia the french and british try to not beeing too harsh with the germans hopping that they could become and ally against the russians in the future
I will keep doing that, but obviosly I cannot read a book just to write 1 accurate script, then I would need to upload once per 2 weeks. I will still use wikipedia and other sources, but I have started reading a lot of history books, which should greatly improve the quality of my videos
@@rewriting-history i understand and im not saying borders are bad, for the matter of fact they are very clean. But you have to see the Croat perspective of being splited by 3 countries
Yeah hungary wouldn't surrender if they got near budapest, remember in the ww1 of our timeline, it was austria that surrendered, making hungary surrender to. In this timeline, with vienna safe, and serbia fallen, austria-hungary keeps the fight going
i think commie germany would be able to atleast reunite al of german little states because the allies in our timeline did nothing when germany remilitirised and when the anchluss happend so yeah
I mean. Obviously you don't have the same humoristic POWER oversimplified has, but with some training you can do that. This is already much funnier than the previous one. Alt history being funny? I mean what more can you ask?
@@rewriting-history Guuud. If I can give you a tip, I think when you become better you should reduce the number of humoristic moments and spread them throught the video,like a "quality>quantity" thing. Good video btw
Even if Russia had generals twice as brilliant as the German ones they would still have lost the war. Very little industry, mostly centered around St Petersburg (Petrograd), Moscow and Kiev at the time. Russia had to export vast amounts of wheat and barley to Britain and France to get rifles and ammunition from them, because the smallness of their industry doesn't allow to produce them the adequate amount of weapons and ammo that their huge but poorly equipped land army needed. Its tiny industry also doesn't allow it to fight a long modern industrial war despite its immense geographical size. Ironically, Germany with Europe's largest economy and industrial output had a better chance fighting a long modern war than Russia ever did. Even when they have somehow successfully occupied East Prussia, there is no way they could have advanced all the way to Berlin without having to fight half the entire German army which had more machine guns than those of Britain and France combined, the best, and also the biggest caliber of, artillery on the planet and with the advantage of the world's best rail system. The Russians would be in for a suicide if they ever tried. Only realistic chance for them to win is to concentrate on weak Austria-Hungary. But even trying so would run the risk of a powerful German counterattack somewhere, one that even in defensive battles the Russians would still suffer heavy losses due to German heavy artillery (like in the case of Vistula River and Lodz). Perhaps the only truly realistic option for the Russians to win is for the Germans to raise the white flag after failing the Marne offensive and losing East Prussia (the ancient heartland of the German Empire) to the invading Russians, seeing the destruction of Austro-Hungarian forces by the Russians in Galicia, and for the British Royal Navy to set sail successfully crush the entire German High Seas Fleet off Bremen. That way, Russia could declare and achieve victory without having to go, or before going, through the stress of severe economic duress which caused the 1917 Revolutions in the first place.
Great video! I think it could be interesting to make more scenarios where infamously incompetent countries were more competent, like Italy, Ottomans, or Austria-Hungary were more competent in WW1, or if Italy was more competent in WW2
Yes I loved this idea and came up to these scenarios, so I will consider them. I already have a video where the Ottomans are "competent", or at least never collapse. Need to think of something for Italy
@@rewriting-history First Preminster Russian Empier was Peter Stolypin He was shot by the gentleman gunfighter Dmitry Bogrov during a theater performance in Kiev.
Only real way russia could win is if rasputin was sent to the frontlines and did magic
Yo that would be so dope!
@@rewriting-historyI can agree on that
Sudenly all german and austrian soldiers have the Alexies Disease instead of him
He could distract the Central Powers armies tactically by having them redirecting their attacks against him.
Of course, being invincible, those attacks would have no effects on Rasputin
This whole video has "Kiev in 3 days" vibes and im here for it
Fun fact: You can like a comment by double tapping(not on laptop).You probably know this ,but did you know that you could triple tap to like and reply?
Nice
There you go!
Cool
I thought this was a prank but it s actually true lol
Wtf it worked
A successful Brusilov Offensive would have definitely helped Russia’s prestige and end WW1 earlier
Which is also my take, glad people agree with that
@@rewriting-history the was another certified classic RWH!
Well the brusilov offensive was very successful for what they initially wanted to do.
It was successful. However, the Russians spent themselves in being successful with that offensive.
It was?
I discovered your channel when you had like 6 subs, the Liechtenstein video showed up in my recomendations and since then I liked your channel. You put my comment asking for a second part in the second part of that video. I don't know why I never bought a membership but I finnaly did it!
Amazing man
I didn't remember, but I'm glad you managed to make it to one of my videos. Since I don't do this format anymore you're special and I most likely won't do it again.
Timestamp
I also found on that vid but won 3-5k subs
I just went back to find the video and you
There was also French plans for after the war where Germany is dissolved but both the British and the American refused so maybe in this timeline this treaty is possible
Well the south was dissolved so it was partially applied
I can only imagine the Germans faces after seeing battalions of Slav squatting Russians listening to hard bass as they charge forward.
I should have incorporated some hardbass memes, but I'm sure the video would get copyright striked :D
I had a heart attack at "Slav squatting Russians"
This is wrong impression. Hardbass is not compatible with squatting. You should try rap.
@@rewriting-history IMA BIG FAN
He did not show a coin!!!
I showed a whole book. I have only one Russian coin from that time and I have already shown it. Need to buy more :D
The betrayal
Why didn't Russia just use the hoi4 Dniper line strategy are they stupid or something?
They were ai controlled 😔😔
True... and the AI didn't build military factories, it just bought from the international market... We all know you just do heavy tanks behind the Dniper line
Sadly they never played hoi4 due to its release being delayed, very sad.
Hoi4's release was in 1936..... 20 years after the Fall of the Russian Empire 😂😂😂
I'm dying to know what this accent is. I assumed something Slavic, but the slight mispronunciation of Russian words refutes that lol
I am from Bulgaria :)
@@rewriting-history thanks, and love from 🇭🇷 Croatia!
Hungary having a full-blown rebellion against Austria in the middle of WW1 is an interesting idea for me. I imagine it would give the Entente reason to be more merciful towards Hungary now that they'd been a de-facto ally instead of a defeated half of an enemy. It's a general alternate history scenario I'd like to see more of.
I'm glad you liked the idea!
I dont see hungary rebeliing. Hungary liked the empire idea they were split only after ww1
@@wingedhussar1453the hungarians were the first to declare independence from austria when they knew for certain they were going to lose the war, russia reaching the hungarian plains would only make hungary leave faster
Russia actually was doing very good in ww1 if the provisional government haven't took power things would have ended differently.
Russia WAS strong in ww1, they had a very fast growing industry and they had good weapons. The problem was the logistica. This slowed the russian army
That “Suka Blat” was so funny
Humor is my passion
It's not that Nicolas wasn't interested in ruling. It was that Nicolas wanted all the power for himself. He was surrounded by people (his wife) who had urged him to maintain his authority. Had his father had taught him how to rule Russia and at least gave him a more active role in government, perhaps the czar would have ruled Russia better. But I need to research if the previous czar's had any such experience.
0:12 TF2 Heavy
Yes, I didn't know what to use for that, but previous experience thought me not to use AI to generate such images.
I’m actually so thankful for how everything played out in ww1 and ww2. Even if Romania no longer has Bessarabia, atleast we still have a majority of all regions.
+ it looks like Romania and Moldova can unite in the near 10 years
As a Pole, I got the same take as you. We managed to gain our independence after the first world war. And later, as a result of WW2. We may of lost Western Ukraine, Belarus, and parts of Lithuania. But we gained valuable German territories, and good industrial lands. Which also gave us more space away from Russia, and bought us closer to the west, not just geopolitically but also geographically (borders shifting west), and yes ik about the eastern block, am referring to after its collapse. And honestly we got some good borders out of it, when comparing it to the potential borders of Poland if Roosevelt’s or Churchill’s plans for a divided Germany became reality. In which Poland got even less land. So honestly, am happy with what we got, although I think we should of kept some extra land. But am no crazy nationalist and so there is no reason to complain as extra land makes no sense nowadays.
And yes, Moldova and Romania will probs unite sooner rather than later. Agreed. X
This was really enjoyable to watch
I really appreciate that! Thank you!
Agreed
The end result is interesting, but a competent Russian empire in WW1 is good (unlike the real one in WW1)
I'm glad you liked the ending!
Empire Russia was not great. I wouldnt even say better then communism. Communism tried to show false sense of nationalism for countries while russia tried erasing all culture
In an alternate universe, someone’s gonna make a video about:
“What if Russia was more incompetent in World War One?”
Rasputin influence on the Romanov’s is greatly exaggerated. He was just a convenient scape goat.
He did have more influence than the Russian ministers, so it's not exactly greatly exaggerated
Honestly, I enjoyed this video more than your other recent videos! Idk what it was, this was just better I guess! This could really use a part two, either detailing what Russia did in Asia during this video, or an outright sequel scenario! I said it once and I will say it again, I really like this new map! Great video, keep it up man!
Glad you enjoyed! I think it's the more research that I did
i wanna see a part 2 where britain and france turn on russia for being too powerful
Yes, that would be super cool
Britain would definitely disapprove of Russia's new friendship with coastal Hungary.
In the final line of Rasputin “oh those Russians”
LOVE the better map and your content ❤❤❤❤❤
Appreciate that! I'm glad everyone likes the new maps
Russia did do well in WW1, like all powers they had setbacks but there enemies were overstretched and they had considerable staying power. The stereotype of Russia in ww1 partly comes from the mismanagement of the military that started under the provisional government and majorly because of Soviet propaganda.
Historians think that without the revolution the war probably would have ended in 1917, indeed this was a motivation for the revolution, victory would lead to the political death of liberalism, the Tsar would most likely have used his reinforced position to get rid of the political concessions, on top of this Britain and France were heavily involved, they wanted Russia to transition over to liberalism and were terrified of Russia owning Constantinople and thus breaking out of the black sea into into the Mediterranean. The ottoman empire had long been propped up by the rest of Europe for this exact reason.
The revolution had considerable organisational support from Britain, once it happened however the duma quickly proved themselves clowns, they introduced democracy to the army, gave contradictory orders and sidelined skilled officers and generals as politically suspect, they also allowed the enemies to the left to set up parallel government organisations. Even before Lenin overthrowing their government was mostly a matter of getting troops to the capital, railway workers were a considerably more effective force in the preservation of the government than any military one.
Russia could have fought the war on better terms, but to do this they would have had to have had different people in leadership positions, the Tsar lacked initiative and was overly suggestable, and to be frank if that or the quality of higher officials were better then not only would Russia have beaten Japan in 1904 but Russia probably would have allied with Germany given that that is explicitly what Tsar Nicholas and Kaiser Wilhelm had wished for, being close friends, and politically similar in their views.
The other method would be reform of the army system, but to be frank that would have taken a genius imbued with unchecked power and a pretty good idea of how things would pan out and which senior officers were reliable.
For the most part was the revolution, a junta plot by high ranking generals, the poor quality of the garrison of st Petersburg and the lack of a man of action on the ground nearby that spelled doom for Russia's military effort. As a purely military force they showed themselves more than capable.
Could you make "What if Romania and Bulgaria united". I think you already know it but it was an actual proposal. I'd really like to see that.
I did that in my first ever video, but I see a lot of people recommend it, so I may do that again.
Romania and Bulgaria unite, but Moldova and Macedonia are still separate for maximum confusion.
With the threat of Russia and Germany, I think France and UK would push for milder peace for Austria Hungary to preserve balance of power. I would only see the seizing of Pozen and Alsace Lorraine from Germany. Italy get everything they promised but Triest in London agreement and surrounding Slavic populated region. Triest had been habsburg’s for 500 years and can provide sea access to them.
BRO COOKED WHILE MAKING THE MAPS 🗣️🔥
Yoo glad you like them!
subscribing immediately no questions asked bc this was a fire video
Ayo I really appreciate that, thank you very much
Начинът, по който каза цар беше тоооолкова естествен и много ми хареса!!!
Много благодаря, оценявам го!
*Finally Hungary still has sea access* 🇭🇺🇭🇺🇭🇺
🇭🇺🇭🇺🇭🇺🇭🇺🇭🇺🇭🇺🇭🇺🇭🇺🇭🇺🇭🇺🇭🇺🇭🇺
i can see the videos have gotten better
And they will keep improving bro! I always say that this is just the beginning for me!
Thanks a lot again video from best althistory youtuber
So nice of you, appreciate that!
Great video like always but i have a question which is do you have a collection of historical items? If yes could you show it in one video?
I have many historical items, mostly coins. I already made a coins channel where I can show some cool stuff
@@rewriting-history Okay i'll check it out i just discovered you're channel and i'm already in love with the content and i myself collect Historical Hats uniforms guns scrap swords helmets grenades ammos and Coins
(my rarest is Finnish coin from 1930)
what if Belgium gave military access in ww1
can you get an English version of the book?
But the book is already in English
@ oh I didn’t know that, sorry
This is an intresting scenario, just one minor thing. Even if the italians were awarded dalmatia, I still believe because of the italian economic crisis, as well as other problems with the government at the time would still see mr fascist pizza man taking charge of the country.
I have heard this argument many times before. I still don't know if this is a fact, or a popular concept. We cannot ever know. I will do a TH-cam poll in the near future and see what people think. Thank you for the feedback!
would the ottoman empire still fall apart in this scenario?
Eventually yes, but in the beginning they wouldn't lose a lot
Nice video keep it up!
Appreciate that!
What If the US/United States 🇺🇸 never nuked Japan 🇯🇵 in WW2
Cut to footage of everything being the same except millions of Japanese people are still alive.
@@PlatinumAltaria plus japan can't act like the victim in this timeline
@@buni1934 Japanese nationalists can make themselves the victim of anything.
@@PlatinumAltariait would be way more lives taken Among civilians and soldiers if the Americans did a land invasion
@@buni1934Japan wasn't acting, Japan WAS the victim lol
Can you do what if Austria-Hungary was competet in ww1(they we're Russia but worse)?
Ngl I think even if Russia tried to industrialise early I still think they would lose as they still had way too many problems within
Yes, but hopefully I prevented total collapse with my reforms
@@rewriting-history Maybe a failed revolt at worst. Supply and industrial problems being fixed would make the people a lot happier.
Not exactly saying losing a war would be great, but if they fought well enough and had decent supply the monarchy would still be in place.
Day 2 of asking rewriting history to make what if bavarian SSR succeded
Soon (2-3 weeks maybe?)
Can you make a scenerio where Hungary wins the 1848 war of independence please.
Yes I have a script I can use, will do it soon
You are literally the best TH-camr man. I truly love this idea and I think you executed the idea perfectly.
Damn man thank you very much, really appreciate that!
" hey you see That Dead Soldier? Yeah, Go To The Dead Body Grab The Rifle And Keep Fighting. Also, We Use Potatos For Grenade's . "
you are my favorite channel fr
Red Flood would happen instead of HOI4? Or even Führerreich?
I love the true story stories so much
Could you please do an alternative ww1 video with central powers:Germany,russia,Italy,Serbia.And Entente:Britain,France,Austria and belgium
What if Austria was competent. Getting mega boosted by the congress of Vienna and having a secure hold over Germany and Italy. Then it industrializes but also efficiently grants rights to minority in the region. Austria by ww1 then being an actual great power
I love the better map!
I love the geographic background, I also am taking inspiration
I appreciate that, this video took SO LONG to make...
@@rewriting-history I can tell that, your videos slowly upgrade and become a better version than their last videos, the map, your voice, your sub count everything is increasing, you inspire me to the moon, keep up the good work, i repeat, KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK
@@rewriting-history Could you also make a vid where I dominate the world, pls? Pretty please!!
Where can I find the book about Russia?
I bought it in a book store in Bulgaria, I'm sure you can buy it online
Could you do a scenario where italy only partially unified?
You could do what if everything went well for italy
Yeah I considered that too, but not a whole lot would change, they simply get Dalmatia and maybe Anatolia, they join the Allies in WW2 and I already have a video on that
@@rewriting-history fair
100% true and unbiased
I hope you mean it, I did try my hardest
@@rewriting-history was supposed to be sarcastic (bulgarian books are probably biased against Russia)
What if Italy was less competent in the Second World War? *Oh wait-*
Lore of What if Russia Was MORE Competent in WW1? Momentum 100
Momentum 100 indeed
One mistake i saw is that Japanese imperialism and expansionism was a concept and was in practice way before ultranationalists rised in Europe. So East Asia would not be changed
after capitulation of Austria-Hungary i see Germany capitulating itself. In real life, even when they won russia and expanded in east, they still decided to capitulate to Antente
Well in that case they do not annex Austria and maybe don't get partitioned, but then Hitler again rises to power, so we have a similar scenario
Yup! exactly what I thought
There is no video at the end.
Oh no
There is tho
@@rewriting-history have Video now
Italy gaining Dalmatia would not in any way prevent Mussolini's rise to power, as the economy would still collapse and the king would still prefer the fascists over the communists
Also, no way does Russia randomly take the polish corridor if Poland has their sea access, they would take posen and Napoleonic polish borders at best
You are not wrong, but the thing is that the war would be a lot shorter and less deadly, so Italy will not be as bankrupted as they were historically, so they can not go ultranationalist, or at least its less likely
@@rewriting-history fair point, although I feel like the fascists wouldn't really care about how badly is the economy actually going and still protest in the streets due to socialist disorders and the king would be weak enough to give in
good video!
Glad you enjoyed it
@@rewriting-history this was a pretty interesting scenario but this shows how incompetent austria is
Like austria got pushed back to Galicia in actual history now imagine a good russian empire
Maybe with a more powerfull russia the french and british try to not beeing too harsh with the germans hopping that they could become and ally against the russians in the future
100 years and not much has changed
0:47 bro reads books, not totally trustworthy wikipedia 😱😱😱
nah congrats on researching actual trustworthy sources 👍
I will keep doing that, but obviosly I cannot read a book just to write 1 accurate script, then I would need to upload once per 2 weeks. I will still use wikipedia and other sources, but I have started reading a lot of history books, which should greatly improve the quality of my videos
7:00 did he rage quit life?
i thought this was a hoi4 video...
almost
Bro you speak English so good and can read English how in the world I can't even learn 1 extra ):
finally, summer
Bro it's too hot in here :D
@@rewriting-history here to!
Heavy Team Fortress 2 0:35 ☠️☠️
It's either that or AI images, this is the least hated lol
could you do a video on what if everyting went well for yugoslavia frrom its beginning to collapse
It sounds like a hoi mod of Russia winning WW1 😂😅 Interesting idea, though 😊
Glad you liked it!
What if bulgaria invaded greece in 1915/1916
Doesn't change much
What if stolypin survived?
I like ur videos
I appreciate that
dont want so sound nerdy but the croatian city is not flume it called rijeka officaly
Yey!
Hope you liked it!
As a young history writer I like youre content!
That thumbnail is so hilarious.
It's good, no?
@@rewriting-history Yeah just the "EZ win" had me dying lmfao
First non-member!
Ayy based
Every Croat is loseing their mind. This peace treaty is sht
I gave you the explanation as to why it happened
@@rewriting-history i understand and im not saying borders are bad, for the matter of fact they are very clean. But you have to see the Croat perspective of being splited by 3 countries
Bro what if Corsica never sold to france and Napoleon become a corissican nationalist then unite Italy please make video
Yeah hungary wouldn't surrender if they got near budapest, remember in the ww1 of our timeline, it was austria that surrendered, making hungary surrender to. In this timeline, with vienna safe, and serbia fallen, austria-hungary keeps the fight going
What if Russia restored the monarchy in 1933?
8:08 Hiro
The real victim of this video was Oleg
Meine eier
Day two of asking for what if the communist won the Moldova Civil War
i think commie germany would be able to atleast reunite al of german little states because the allies in our timeline did nothing when germany remilitirised and when the anchluss happend so yeah
Maybe without Bavaria, which could resist + Austria would support Bavaria. This time Austria will not be this weak.
I mean. Obviously you don't have the same humoristic POWER oversimplified has, but with some training you can do that. This is already much funnier than the previous one. Alt history being funny? I mean what more can you ask?
Yes, imagine how good I will become after 20 videos of this style, I will keep growing and improving for sure!
@@rewriting-history Guuud. If I can give you a tip, I think when you become better you should reduce the number of humoristic moments and spread them throught the video,like a "quality>quantity" thing. Good video btw
In the name of the tsar be like
these vids are so damn good
I really appreciate that!
What if Sassanid Persia repelled the Arab invasions
He sounds like a drunk Russian from Vorkuta
I do
I have idea to another video what if kornilov coup worked
nice
Thanks
Even if Russia had generals twice as brilliant as the German ones they would still have lost the war.
Very little industry, mostly centered around St Petersburg (Petrograd), Moscow and Kiev at the time. Russia had to export vast amounts of wheat and barley to Britain and France to get rifles and ammunition from them, because the smallness of their industry doesn't allow to produce them the adequate amount of weapons and ammo that their huge but poorly equipped land army needed.
Its tiny industry also doesn't allow it to fight a long modern industrial war despite its immense geographical size. Ironically, Germany with Europe's largest economy and industrial output had a better chance fighting a long modern war than Russia ever did.
Even when they have somehow successfully occupied East Prussia, there is no way they could have advanced all the way to Berlin without having to fight half the entire German army which had more machine guns than those of Britain and France combined, the best, and also the biggest caliber of, artillery on the planet and with the advantage of the world's best rail system. The Russians would be in for a suicide if they ever tried.
Only realistic chance for them to win is to concentrate on weak Austria-Hungary. But even trying so would run the risk of a powerful German counterattack somewhere, one that even in defensive battles the Russians would still suffer heavy losses due to German heavy artillery (like in the case of Vistula River and Lodz).
Perhaps the only truly realistic option for the Russians to win is for the Germans to raise the white flag after failing the Marne offensive and losing East Prussia (the ancient heartland of the German Empire) to the invading Russians, seeing the destruction of Austro-Hungarian forces by the Russians in Galicia, and for the British Royal Navy to set sail successfully crush the entire German High Seas Fleet off Bremen. That way, Russia could declare and achieve victory without having to go, or before going, through the stress of severe economic duress which caused the 1917 Revolutions in the first place.
You from 🇮🇳India ?
He is Bulgarian
Great video! I think it could be interesting to make more scenarios where infamously incompetent countries were more competent, like Italy, Ottomans, or Austria-Hungary were more competent in WW1, or if Italy was more competent in WW2
Yes I loved this idea and came up to these scenarios, so I will consider them. I already have a video where the Ottomans are "competent", or at least never collapse. Need to think of something for Italy
Tzar Nicholas II was speak six languages
Still couldn't understand the situation his country was in...
@@rewriting-history First Preminster Russian Empier was Peter Stolypin He was shot by the gentleman gunfighter Dmitry Bogrov during a theater performance in Kiev.
@@rewriting-history David Lloyd George said after the abdication of Tsar Nicholas II, Great Britain had achieved one of its goals.
@@rewriting-history Bolshewik revolution was finaced by USA and France.
Russia STONK
Big Russia