‼ More Red Velvet reaction content on our Patreon, including UNCUT reactions to FMR, Sean's reaction to Wildside, Jazz Musicians React to Good, Bad, Ugly & more: www.patreon.com/reacttothek 🎵 More K-Pop songs that feature classical music: th-cam.com/play/PLFw_XZtkCVMNAufyb6_kdh2EoVzwrQ6Li.html ➡ Reaction Release Schedule + list of all our Patreon-exclusive videos: docs.google.com/document/d/1uvf-u1EJVB-hmB3IU0P6M-obdMNu11fo_aUIf6dur70/edit?usp=sharing ➡ Will not react to list for the CJ&MR series & why songs may not be reacted to: docs.google.com/document/d/1b5aQLWbYgUCm30Pj5-AalSjwMaq8gm5jOyrcbAlMu6c/edit?usp=sharing
I've been a stan since "Be Natural", when I realized they were going to be special, and ever since they're been serving up very special stuff. The first thing that hit me about this song (after the intro) was the crazy bass and how it harmonized with everything in a magical way... 😁
Hi Umu! Would you react to 'Make a Wish' by NCT U and its Orchestra version at the same time as you reacted to 'Red Flavor' by Red Velvet? I REALLY want to see your perspective. Thank you :)
I feel like SMe hit the creativity jackpot with red velvet, the flexibility of their concept makes them an empty canvas that SM can fill with any creatives they have, they can make them into workers from the 60s,femme fatales, highschool girls ki lling each other to ballerinas.
i really think Wendy is the biggest factor why red velvet can have different concept,, since concept is heavily based on what kind of music they will release. wendy really giving the red velvet more ground in both red and velvet concept.
@kurt I want to say that their groups are not as well known as for example BTS or Blak Pink, I even listened to BTS first but I didn't like them anymore, luckily I found in Super Junior and Exo something new that I liked because it was different now I like them all A As I got to know what the company produced, the point is that in my country if someone knows that one is listening to Kpop, then they assimilate that it is BTS only because they are the most famous.
true.. whats amazing was they liked it on their FIRST listen… so they knew what a good music is right from the beginning they hear it… as for me, i think it grew on me on 3rd listen and got addicted to it, now im having Lss on this song lol 😂
I love watching people who focus in every single detail not just the face, hair and outfit of the people in the mv. That's why I really like this channel a lot, I am learning so much from them.
Well, the aesthetic are also telling the story, I think the visual complements the song and that makes me want a channel what speak technally about it too.
It's pretty nice, but at the same time a little disappointing, because I think that the visual experience is something very important in Kpop, especially in Mv's like this that is being told a story.
@@eveleein I don’t think oppachannel has a problem with that… They probably mean more so about people who focus on the superficial elements. Of course the visual and imagery side is important, but a lot of reactions are very surface level and will just say “oh pretty” “that’s creepy” etc etc without diving deep into details.
Fun fact: they released the song on Bach's birthday March 21 and the mv set was based from various classical paintings like Ophelia by John Everett Millais
No matter how many idols may be using classical pieces in their song, red velvet always the best one out there. The one who started it with that beautiful melody.
@@vanillarose4179 Shinhwa's T.OP and H.O.T's Iyah, both released in 1999 maybe ? Not sure if they're the first idol but at least using classical pieces has started from kpop gen 1
Truthfully, this is the best Red Velvet song ever. So many layers, so intricately and meticulously composed and the lyrics blends so well with the mood of the melodies. Let's not talk about the mv. The visual is out of the world. Very quality produce from SM.
The layering is crazy and mind blowing. Like after watching that behind the scene recording then listening again to the song. The arrangement is genius and RV vocal techniques and ranges is out of this world.
I think Red Velvet, "Feel My Rhythm" producers, and SM staff need to watch this video because, you guys, your reaction was awesome. I can tell they will appreciate this video so much.
The moment I watched the MV, the first thing that comes to my mind is "How will Classical Musicians react to this amazing piece?" Like I'm looking forward on your reactions, and here you are.
So true. They didn't mind if what they're doing right now is not for "general". Cause the way I see it, this is what kpop will sound for the next years. Blueprint indeed.
Totally agree with Kevin. RV’s songs always have been somewhere between attractive melodic aspects and weird absurd harmonic aspects. Some songs like bad boy or psycho were perfect but some were like crazy psychic sounds like they lost their real identity which is that they are ‘songs’. This one def. has the musical core.
I feel like kevin said that mostly because he prefers bubble gum pop music. And fmr melody is quiet easy and familiar to follow, though the instruments is bizarre as always. It's RV anyway. So i totally disagree when only fmr has its music core.
The fact that this song doesn't fit on the popular kpop stans because is not a repetitive chorus with real catchy lyrics saying nothing lol 😭 red velvet have a complete variety of music genres and rhythms in their music but this comeback is another type of this, very interesting and feels like heaven to me.
@@bakapotatoes for sure, they can have mainstream songs kinda empty but bops and also great music rich in instruments and stuff 🤩 that's why i love their discography, it's a lot of variety
my friend dislike this song because of the bach sample saying the song sounds better without and I was like "what in the sacrilegious fck are you talking about?"
"EY! BOSCH! " I died- all the references both in the music itself and the mv are so spot on and nicely incorporated. definitely a sensory overload for art appreciators lol
This song seriously makes me feel something, I've tried so hard to explain to people why I love this song so much but I couldn't put it into words 😭 the best I could do was "LISTEN TO THIS PART DID YOU HEAR THOSE COOL SOUNDS", now I can just show them this video, I think you guys did a great job at explaining why certain sections of a song make you feel a certain way!
Omg yes. Like its telling a story and I'm feeling it but could not explain well. Its just hard to explain. And it made like that on purpose. Thats the point of the song that only me can't explain. As a non music expert, and just a person who likes kpop and just fall into Red Velvet genre, this video explains well about the mv.
If you liked this, you should check out mera's video on feel my rhythm! She did an amazing job verbalizing how the song made me feel and her writing is just so poetic
my father has never in his life seen me badly crying over a chorus of one song like this. damn dad, you should know these women, they are incredibly out of the world
@@hailaminzu yes you're absolutely right, at that time i was too overwhelmed after the song ended, my brain stopped working and all my words fell down on the floor. thanks for all of your hard work producers, i has experienced a real cute chaotic delight moment may never exist again.
@@hailaminzu And stylish, idea team, lyricist, ..... more and more. Many people with many different roles participate in this musical production. And Red Velvet can also be considered as their muse, their main inspiration and also their representative
"the visual, it's like the euphoria kind of thing. and then, while seeing that, you're hearing all of this crazy darkness". YES!! That's how red velvet concept works: combining beauty/fun with dark elements. other songs with red velvet concept are Peek-A-Boo and Russian Roulette
it's awesomeee really how rv can give that kind of concept without any talking, like listen to our music, this is how everything works.. this concept is not something simple.
What I love about SM Entertainment's girl groups is that their versatility is at the highest level than other kpop groups. They are not afraid to try different concepts hence, they were always willing to come out of their comfort zones to make high quality music. And this song made me stan Red Velvet (was only a casual listener of Red Velvet at first) I hope that it is not too late to stan them and will continue to make good music. I was able to hear them perform Feel My Rhythm live and it was breath-taking.
When we say Red Velvet is in their own lane, THIS is what we mean. This song is such a welcome beginning to spring. I love how it reminds me of Hello Future (Hello Baroque period), and how it’s elegant and pops hard at the same time. Two critiques: 1. I wish the song had a beautiful outro to tie everything together. The key change is amazing but it’s so short. 2. I wish this era lasted longer, rip 💀 Need an orchestral version asap‼️‼️‼️
@@angelwearsprada2990 Red Velvet deserved as much as (G)I-dle, but that doesn't mean you undermine the latter's efforts. They were gone for a year and they worked hard for it. Tomboy sounded fresh for this era what are you on.... Let's stop pitting idol groups against each other. Tomboy and Feel My Rhythm were two of the best releases this year
@@딸기-y3u Promos were already going to be short since they’re seniors in SM, but since Wendy and Seulgi got sick, that cut it even shorter… good news is, if this year is going to be like the first Reve Festival trilogy, it’s not the last we’ve seen of FMR.
Red Velvet has always been experimental in the best ways. Love that they don’t sound like any other girl groups out there, including themselves in previous releases. They have the best discography IMO.
@@ot7biasedmashups uhm well some people said it was too safe that it doesnt sound rv at all and apparently the instrumental is "too loud" idk what they r complaining this song was so good
I adore SM Entertainment so much because of such songs, concepts... They keep feeding us with top-quality meals rather than fast food. They care about music and don`t want it to be simple, ordinary and tasteless. I am rooting for it.
My most awaited reaction video! It's interesting how you explain some of the part of the song. It made me appreciate the song more. I didn't even know about the title, that's brilliant!
SM이 잘했죠. 노래도 정말 좋았어요~ 내용은 고전음악과 최신 사운드의 조합만을 이야기하는것이 아닌 욕망 그리고 대중성과 예술성에 관한 MV라고 들었습니다. 클래식을 KPOP에 녹인 곡들은 이미 존재 해 있지만 레드벨벳의 이 곡이 아주 괜찮은 타이밍에 적절하게 만들어진것 같아요. 학생들의 해석과 의견을 듣는 것이 아주 재밌었습니다.
it's always so fun to be a red velvet fan, you never really know what they're going to give you next, but you know it's going to have that signature unique classiness. too often in modern kpop do companies try to make their artists' songs so different that it just ends up sounding like random samples thrown together. with red velvet, it's always unique, but incredibly polished
When SM teased us that it’ll be using Bach’s piece for the song all that came to my mind is that “ReacttotheK” must react to this. Welp! Glad you like it. Because I loved it a lot
I agree with Rachel that Feel My Rhythm is an instant favorite right out of the gate. It takes me a while to form an opinion on most of RV's songs, but this and Psycho are maybe the only two I didn't need even a second listen to fall in love with. As of right now, Feel My Rhythm is a Top Five RV song for sure.
I’m literally so obsessed with this song, the more I listen to it the more addicted I get. It’s so fun and doesn’t get boring so easily bc there‘s constantly new things added
I think this is the best song of RV and one of the most interesting songs that SM has made for their artist. It’s gorgeous and mood-lifting. Thanks to your reaction showing us what’s cool in the song that I can’t explain
i might understood like 10% of everything they said but its really cool how everyone in this video is so passionate about music :) i too wanna learn music theory now
I have been waiting for this fr.. like, everyday I'd checked ur channel just to see if u already reacted to this. Y'all out of all the people who reacted to red velvet has the most genuine reaction to this song. Tbh, i really love this song and this mini album. I just hope that others also sees and hear how this mini album is a true gem. I'll be waiting for the whole mini album review tho.
Same, Kevin and Rachel! I loved it so much from the first listen too! I was so into their reaction that I felt the video ended so quickly. Didn't even feel like 22 minutes. Thank you for reacting to this masterpiece 😭🤌
Nothing beats the energy it radiates when people talks about their passion. And this reaction was a great combo esp bc u guys actually have the knowledge about all these originals musics they use to create this song. Awesomeness
바흐의 음악을 베이스로 해서 우아하면서도 상큼한 느낌을 주려고 한게 인상적이었고, 그걸 다시 바흐의 깊고 웅장한 느낌으로 승화시킨 매우 복합적이고 특이한 노래라는 생각. 그런데 이것들이 어색하지 않고 한데 어우러져 아주 괜찮은 하모니를 이루어냈다는데 칭찬을 해주고 싶음.
first time i heard this song, my reaction was simply "this is genius" and i need validation from this channel. indeed now confirmed this is red velvet most genius song after psycho for me.
I always says Seulgi’s voice will fit the classical or orchestra kind of music and now they said it fit perfectly at her voice in the intro. I sure this song is the geniuses art of 2022 🙌
21:22 with this song it proves again how SM Entertainment Production Team (in music) is really on another level. Like If they do the production of their songs, It's already perfect but if there is greater than "perfect", they do it! Reallyy kudos to the A&R and Producers of SM Ent 👏🏼👏🏼
the reason why SM is still leading as a company who focus and smart to creat a music not only music that anyone want to listen, but make anyone know how make music unlimited.
AIr on G String is my favorite classical music. There's just something so hauntingly beautiful about it that's just so sooo good. Having Red Velvet sampling Air so faithfully and expertly is just 😭😭 what a title track, such an excellent piece!
When I first heard this song I was so confused prolly bc I felt that the mv is a bit overwhelming. Then they dropped the performance video and I was more confused bc the straight forward visual of the perf vid made me see the song on a different light, which I didn't expect. It's like I finally understand classical and Kpop. 13:53 I just realized that this part prolly explained why I felt confused at my first listen. Like the music and the visual is clashing. But thanks to the performance vid I understood it and FMR immediately rose to my no. 1 fave song in the album
This is one of the best Redvelvet title songs. It's so experimental yet so pleasing. I really love how they calmly started with Bach's Air On G string and then suddenly hit us with those trap beats. This is insane. I wouldn't say that the chorus is happy. It's so overwhelming like how you are touched when springtime overwhelmed all your senses. It feels so nostalgic and joyful that you might shed some tears. I kind of found this interesting with the bridge. I thought the bridge was over with Seulgi's part but they continued with Joy. Wendy, Yeri, and Seulgi's bridge part felt like some deep, dark struggle leading onto a joyful Joy bridge. This deserved more wins but it's okay as long as there are people who appreciate Redvelvet's essence. Also, they confirmed that there is going to be a trilogy this time. Let's enjoy the future comebacks too.
"That chorus is *gorgeous!!* " YESSS😭❤ this is probably one of my most favorite red velvet songs ever and quite possible one of my most favorite kpop songs ever I'm just so obsessedly in love with this song
15:18 my favorite part. It's so funny yet cute when musicians try to explain their favorite thing in the song. Like Many people won't understand the eargasm the musicians get
Never in my life feeling a 20 minutes video was so short. When i listened to the track, i thought Bach’s sample had something to do with the chorus but my music knowledge couldnt let me to break it down. But thanks to Kevin to explain it so simple that now I can understand how the producers made it. The song was so awesome and I am thankful that many people appriciated this. I hope SM keep up with their wonderful works. Btw the reaction to the birds and how Seulgi ate the strawberry were so funny 🤣
In terms of mixing classical music and contemporary K-pop, it's quiet interesting to see how K-pop has evolved since I-Yah(1999, by H.O.T.), which you reacted weeks ago.
I loved the song at the first listening but I don't study music, I just went with the "feelings part", and it was goosebumps all over my body haha So nice to have this kind of reaction, this channel is so special! Love you guys, thank youu! -from a Brazilian fan ♡
I'm not musician, but talking about my experience for first listen it may abit distracted by the Bach's sample when I'm too used to it, even so the whole song is really good and I do like the melody. But after several listens, I'm completely love with the song and the more details I catch through the listen, the more I get amazed by the producer of the song for such genius production, and I have waited until today just to watch this reaction and analysis, and I'm happy for the knowledge gained watching the whole video.
I'm exactly like you. I hated the song when I first heard it. I think the classical music that they sampled doesn't match well with the song. Now, I couldn't even get this song out of my head. And I dare to say that this is the best Red Velvet song ever.
@@RoyMcAvoy For me it didn't sound weird and I didn't hate it in the first listen because the melody is still gorgeous 😂 It's my brain cells being confused and yet to pick up everything when they just caught the Bach sample mostly in the first listen
Ohhhh now i know why red velvet says they travel through time and space. They literally said the definition of Rhythm in music I thought they says that for concept. And woooow thank you reacttothek for this Feel My Rhythm is super detailed. The matching of lyrics to the sound wow. I learned something in classical/music. Ive waited for this
20:52 Point to discuss: Is it really surprising that Bach's music sounds so good despite its "restrictions"? Or are the "rules" just result of what actually sounds good and emotional, and thus not restrictive at all? I do see that some of Bach's works can be extremely "restrictive" or "constructed" (like Goldberg variations), and they still are full of creativity. So are restrictions really a deterrent of inspiration and emotion? Or do the restrictions just provide a framework in which a composer can design a very inspired piece? Many "rules" in music are, in my opinion, just whatever works well, from form and structure (how boring and uninspired does the idea of a canon sound, the same thing twice, lol?) to harmony. In some way (and to bring it back to the K) even 'Feel My Rhythm' is a product of restrictions imposed by the concept of sampling 'Air', but the restrictions are perhaps one of the reasons this song is so inspired and works so well (in my opinion ;D). So perhaps restrictions might even be a source of inspiration and emotion? Would love to hear anyone's thoughts!
Love the point you make here about restrictions. I'm one who thinks that sometimes even more inspired and creative art comes out of restrictions when a breakthrough is achieved within the fixed set of boundaries. It's even more amazing precisely because of the expansion within and beyond the limitations.
These are definitely interesting things to discuss! I wouldn’t say that the rules resulted from what “actually sounds good and emotional” though. I feel like that discounts entire genres and periods of music that completely venture outside of these restrictions of “perfect” counterpoint and voice leading (impressionism, neo-classicism, “power chords” in hard rock/metal, most melodic writing in solo marimba and percussion ensemble literature, etc.), all of which have just as much potential to be emotionally impactful and pleasing to listen to. Again, that’s all subjective. People are moved differently by different music of course! I agree that working within set restrictions can be extremely fulfilling and even inspire greater creativity than just throwing things at the wall and seeing what sticks. That’s a great point! I think part of what makes Bach work so well in this specific context is the concreteness of the harmonic structure, and how easy it is to run wild with new compositional and production techniques over this framework.
@@liammcmanus7502 Ooh, hi Liam! I see what you mean, and at no point was I trying to claim that only music following perfect counterpoint can sound great. Listening to Renaissance music, there is a lot of voice leading that seems very questionable to our modern ear, but the music still sounds beautiful and at times wonderfully floaty. However, I still think that 'the rules' result from what sounds good, though maybe I should specify that the rules found in the Baroque period were just one and not the only way of how to sound good, and that the rules arose specifically in a context of polyphonic music and the instruments available at the time. For example, I do actually think that parallel power chords don't sound nearly as cool on a typical harpsichord as they do on a guitar with a ton of overdrive. So a composer trying to write a piece for four independent voices would naturally refrain from the 'forbidden' parallels because voices would mesh and they would just loose tension and, basically, one of the voices. My knowledge of music is quite limited, and my perception of what is important in music might very well be a somewhat one-dimensional product of listening only to western classical, jazz, etc, and even there usually in a bubble of a few composers/artists. I can't claim to have listened to a single piece written for solo marimba (sorry, recommendations are welcome though). [Edit: Just checked out your channel. Source for marimba music found ;D] It would probably be a different question to discuss how 'good' or important certain sets of rules in music are (and for what), or even if there is such a thing as objective quality to music. And that might also lead to quite philosophical and biological questions, like if aliens would understand our music as such or just hear noise etc... Getting existential. xD Well, I hope that made some sense, thank you very much for your thoughts and for your reactions! :)
I love how exciting ALL the musicians are in this video. I know this masterpiece woked them up fr, and I am so thankful they gave us A LOT of dissecting and conversation.
I literally cried when the first time I heard this song but idk how to explain.. now if someone asked me again why I'm crying over listening to this song I'll just give this reaction video to them. I'm so emotional when listen this song but also happy at the same times, but you guys explaination just make it more and more emotional esp when the editor give a footage of Bach original sample and then that guy playing violin im so----😭😭😭 it's like i'm fallin in love with classic music now🥺💗
I still cry pretty much every time I hear this song which is starting to get annoying. 😆 They kept talking about my favorite parts in the reaction, talking about how beautiful they were and yeah I'm just sitting here wiping away tears again. I think my head exploded first time I heard this song. Completely gobsmacked. And that's not even getting into all the art references and outfits !
This is actually my most anticipated reaction. I waited for so long and at last!!!! Thank you for recting hehehe. I don't really know much about notes and instruments but I enjoy watching your videos and sharing your views about the song.
When you look at the details, you'll see how complex and interesting Feel My Rhythm is. There's Classical Music, Ballet, Theater, Painting, etc. in this one music video that is to fit the modern times and KPOP. GENIUS & PERFECTLY RIGHT FOR RED VELVET as they are the most experimental group ever imo. They nailed it! 🤯🤯🤯
Yass I really needed this, i knew the piece was super properly sampled and respected the counterpoints, but your comments always go beyond Edit. So it is a key change, i thought it came back to the Db
Bridge starts prolonging vi of Db (not a complete key change but the harmony/color changes a lot), and then Joy's 2nd half of the bridge goes back to Db as the tonal center, and then the final chorus goes up to Eb! :)
![[SM Classics] 서울시립교향악단 'Feel My Rhythm (Orchestra Ver.)' MV](/img/n.gif)
‼ More Red Velvet reaction content on our Patreon, including UNCUT reactions to FMR, Sean's reaction to Wildside, Jazz Musicians React to Good, Bad, Ugly & more: www.patreon.com/reacttothek
🎵 More K-Pop songs that feature classical music: th-cam.com/play/PLFw_XZtkCVMNAufyb6_kdh2EoVzwrQ6Li.html
➡ Reaction Release Schedule + list of all our Patreon-exclusive videos: docs.google.com/document/d/1uvf-u1EJVB-hmB3IU0P6M-obdMNu11fo_aUIf6dur70/edit?usp=sharing
➡ Will not react to list for the CJ&MR series & why songs may not be reacted to:
docs.google.com/document/d/1b5aQLWbYgUCm30Pj5-AalSjwMaq8gm5jOyrcbAlMu6c/edit?usp=sharing
Bigbang still life😭
I've been a stan since "Be Natural", when I realized they were going to be special, and ever since they're been serving up very special stuff. The first thing that hit me about this song (after the intro) was the crazy bass and how it harmonized with everything in a magical way...
😁
Reaction red velvet WILDSIDE too...... Pleaseee eeee.......
Hi Umu! Would you react to 'Make a Wish' by NCT U and its Orchestra version at the same time as you reacted to 'Red Flavor' by Red Velvet? I REALLY want to see your perspective. Thank you :)
Performance video is better for you.....
I feel like SMe hit the creativity jackpot with red velvet, the flexibility of their concept makes them an empty canvas that SM can fill with any creatives they have, they can make them into workers from the 60s,femme fatales, highschool girls ki lling each other to ballerinas.
They hit the jackpot having the 5 talented women fit the red velvet concept, the idea wouldn't be possible if they don't have the right tools
Their concept and the capability of all the members could have one of the best harmony in KPOP are just *chefs kiss*
everything about their music, vocal capabilities, and sm's creativity are because of these 5 talented females making all the elements cohesive.
It will great if SM give more n more promotion for red velvet
i really think Wendy is the biggest factor why red velvet can have different concept,, since concept is heavily based on what kind of music they will release.
wendy really giving the red velvet more ground in both red and velvet concept.
The whole mv is actually based on Bosch's painting "The Garden of Earthly Delights".
not whole actually, more like 85% or 90% of it. there are paintings by monet, fragonard and morisot, among others, that were presented in the MV.
Ordinary people SM music sounds weird but to people who understand music it's extraordinary, genius, etc
Excellent explanation
And for the same reason they are not as famous or do not have as many views as the others, but I do like all their groups.
@@AdeOso1190 who are u referring to?
I always notice this when producers or any musicians react to any SM songs, they love it.
@kurt I want to say that their groups are not as well known as for example BTS or Blak Pink, I even listened to BTS first but I didn't like them anymore, luckily I found in Super Junior and Exo something new that I liked because it was different now I like them all A As I got to know what the company produced, the point is that in my country if someone knows that one is listening to Kpop, then they assimilate that it is BTS only because they are the most famous.
3:28 Kevin just casually reaching over and playing the piece along. This is why I admire musicians so much.
no comments?
I have sudden goosebumps
that was so satisfying lordd
the way he knew what's coming after lol
@@dejan0384cause that part is a sample from a classical piece
Let's be honest reveluvs, you watched this video more than once because this reaction vid is so good.
True 😂
TRUEEE
True that. They put the technical words on what I felt when I watched the MV and listened to this song.
true.. whats amazing was they liked it on their FIRST listen… so they knew what a good music is right from the beginning they hear it… as for me, i think it grew on me on 3rd listen and got addicted to it, now im having Lss on this song lol 😂
I don't know why this video always comeback into my recomendation, but I'm not complaining
I love watching people who focus in every single detail not just the face, hair and outfit of the people in the mv. That's why I really like this channel a lot, I am learning so much from them.
Well, the aesthetic are also telling the story, I think the visual complements the song and that makes me want a channel what speak technally about it too.
In this particular case, the aesthetics have a lot to say. The bosco painting its about the garden of eden, the lyrics seem to support that
Yes, my favorite reaction channel ever!
It's pretty nice, but at the same time a little disappointing, because I think that the visual experience is something very important in Kpop, especially in Mv's like this that is being told a story.
@@eveleein I don’t think oppachannel has a problem with that… They probably mean more so about people who focus on the superficial elements. Of course the visual and imagery side is important, but a lot of reactions are very surface level and will just say “oh pretty” “that’s creepy” etc etc without diving deep into details.
fun fact: the song was released on Bach's birthday.
WAIT THATS SO COOL
GENIUS!
Also released on the day of Spring Equinox (basically the beginning of spring)
I thought bach birthday was march 31
@@Average-Reactions in Gregorian(new) calendar, yes. But in the old calendar his birthday is March 21
Fun fact: they released the song on Bach's birthday March 21 and the mv set was based from various classical paintings like Ophelia by John Everett Millais
I thought bach birthday was march 31
@@Average-Reactions in the old style calendar, his birthday is on March 21. But the use of Gregorian calendar made Bach's birthday on March 31.
@@jessajira5272 Oh ok, got it
@@hi-ve1cw i love everything about european too! History, music, architecture u name it hahaha 🤣
my birthday as well 🥹 that was the best gift i'd ever received
No matter how many idols may be using classical pieces in their song, red velvet always the best one out there. The one who started it with that beautiful melody.
Facts
imo they did it best
pretty sure they werent the first, this song is probabaly the best example though.
@@blas_de_lezo7375 May I know who is the first one?
@@vanillarose4179 Shinhwa's T.OP and H.O.T's Iyah, both released in 1999 maybe ? Not sure if they're the first idol but at least using classical pieces has started from kpop gen 1
Truthfully, this is the best Red Velvet song ever. So many layers, so intricately and meticulously composed and the lyrics blends so well with the mood of the melodies. Let's not talk about the mv. The visual is out of the world. Very quality produce from SM.
The layering is crazy and mind blowing. Like after watching that behind the scene recording then listening again to the song. The arrangement is genius and RV vocal techniques and ranges is out of this world.
Nah it's psycho wtf you talking about?
@@lazybum9732 honestly this song feels like it kind of builds on Psycho
@@lazybum9732 musically, feel my rythm is their hardest & best song. Psycho is just flat but it's good. La Rouge is even much better.
@@hightree9295 lmao...flat... R u drunk?? That was soty level ..even non fandoms loved it.. feel my rythm don't even come close to psycho
I think Red Velvet, "Feel My Rhythm" producers, and SM staff need to watch this video because, you guys, your reaction was awesome. I can tell they will appreciate this video so much.
they will watch this video for sure bc they emailed this channel to react to feel my rhythm
@@Buffaylo oh...? how do you know that?
@@thursdayschildhasfartogo I think Umu mentioned it in a twitter reply
@@jessica1228100 ah, that's awesome, thanks! so cool to know companies know about international reactors and care about their feedback this much
@@Buffaylo whoa.. I didn't know 😮
The moment I watched the MV, the first thing that comes to my mind is "How will Classical Musicians react to this amazing piece?" Like I'm looking forward on your reactions, and here you are.
Same.
Same!
Yessss! Like, finally!!! 😩
Same
yassshh! Definitely!
SM is the company that actually revolutionize Kpop. Their creative vision is way ahead than everyone else.
agreed
예아
So true. They didn't mind if what they're doing right now is not for "general". Cause the way I see it, this is what kpop will sound for the next years. Blueprint indeed.
@@bldmontemor you just dont understand the whole context. What are you talking about?
@@bldmontemor i think you only knew those popular groups thats why lol
Totally agree with Kevin. RV’s songs always have been somewhere between attractive melodic aspects and weird absurd harmonic aspects. Some songs like bad boy or psycho were perfect but some were like crazy psychic sounds like they lost their real identity which is that they are ‘songs’. This one def. has the musical core.
I feel like kevin said that mostly because he prefers bubble gum pop music. And fmr melody is quiet easy and familiar to follow, though the instruments is bizarre as always. It's RV anyway. So i totally disagree when only fmr has its music core.
their real identity is the fact all their songs sound different
thats literally just preference. Just because certain music isnt appealing to you doesnt mean they "lost their real identity"
Which one red velvet's song that they lost their identity?
Which one red velvet's song that they lost their identity?
17:13 멋있다 ,,, 여기 채널 리액션 영상에서 이렇게 본업 모습 종종 보일 때마다 너무너무 좋음 🥺
if the experts give reaction, it hits different. i feel like being educated watching this reaction. and yeah red velvet discography never disappoints
it feels like an homage to classical arts bc there's also a LOT of references to ballet in the choreography, it's absolutely beautifully done
And classical art pieces
And they released it on bach's bday too!!
@@hi-ve1cw ikr
The fact that this song doesn't fit on the popular kpop stans because is not a repetitive chorus with real catchy lyrics saying nothing lol 😭 red velvet have a complete variety of music genres and rhythms in their music but this comeback is another type of this, very interesting and feels like heaven to me.
actually it's a good thing that rvs being themself and not following the mainstream sounds
@@bakapotatoes for sure, they can have mainstream songs kinda empty but bops and also great music rich in instruments and stuff 🤩 that's why i love their discography, it's a lot of variety
Yeah but actually it is catchy, i don't hear it that much but i still go "feel my rhythm...." when i'm doing nothing 😭😭
my friend dislike this song because of the bach sample saying the song sounds better without and I was like "what in the sacrilegious fck are you talking about?"
True. I can't get the song out from my head yet, even after few wees. This song really haunting my mind.
"EY! BOSCH! " I died-
all the references both in the music itself and the mv are so spot on and nicely incorporated. definitely a sensory overload for art appreciators lol
With so many songs with classical samples, I come back here to appreciate Red Velvet once more
Definitely!
Imagine they got a 5 second clip of the sample, looped it and made it into a trap beat lol
I think that SM's success with "weird kpop" is that no matter how much a song changes it is still cohesive from second one.
SM is literally the pioneer of kpop. They know what to do with kpop music and how kpop supposed to sounds like!
^this. Even if it souns wweird or “noisy,” they are still cohesive, unlike when other companies do it.
Flopmixx could never
@@mugler_angel nah it's so unnecessary to name other group... they're so talented
@@mugler_angel lolz.. The cut tho sounds epic edit.
7:04 the picture of Bach holding the RV light stick is art that competes with Bosch.
This song seriously makes me feel something, I've tried so hard to explain to people why I love this song so much but I couldn't put it into words 😭 the best I could do was "LISTEN TO THIS PART DID YOU HEAR THOSE COOL SOUNDS", now I can just show them this video, I think you guys did a great job at explaining why certain sections of a song make you feel a certain way!
Omg yes. Like its telling a story and I'm feeling it but could not explain well. Its just hard to explain. And it made like that on purpose. Thats the point of the song that only me can't explain. As a non music expert, and just a person who likes kpop and just fall into Red Velvet genre, this video explains well about the mv.
Same
If you liked this, you should check out mera's video on feel my rhythm! She did an amazing job verbalizing how the song made me feel and her writing is just so poetic
Same
I feel like I'm flying Everytime I listen to this song
I would love to hear all of them reacting to the Orchestra version of "Feel my rhythm". It has just been released today
yes !!!
Yesssss
Agreee
Yes!! I was checking to see if anyone commented about it
yess please react thats version
really wish one day SM will release special performance where the members sing and dance live with full orchestra
that will be amazing and iconic
OMG your comment gave me goosebumps 🥺✨
I hope they do it on award shows or like year end performances aaAAHHHH
With those Orchestra versions they did, I really wish they do !!
they should have SMTOWN The Orchestra back in 2011 againnn!!! 😭
my father has never in his life seen me badly crying over a chorus of one song like this. damn dad, you should know these women, they are incredibly out of the world
The bridge (esp Wendy's opening part) made me cry, my mum thought I was crazy
*these women and the producers of the song too.
@@hailaminzu yes you're absolutely right, at that time i was too overwhelmed after the song ended, my brain stopped working and all my words fell down on the floor. thanks for all of your hard work producers, i has experienced a real cute chaotic delight moment may never exist again.
@@hailaminzu and i'm a vietnamese too so please ignore my weak grammar^^
@@hailaminzu And stylish, idea team, lyricist, ..... more and more. Many people with many different roles participate in this musical production. And Red Velvet can also be considered as their muse, their main inspiration and also their representative
"the visual, it's like the euphoria kind of thing. and then, while seeing that, you're hearing all of this crazy darkness". YES!! That's how red velvet concept works: combining beauty/fun with dark elements. other songs with red velvet concept are Peek-A-Boo and Russian Roulette
it's awesomeee really how rv can give that kind of concept without any talking, like listen to our music, this is how everything works.. this concept is not something simple.
Kevin just casually playing the piano (3:27) along with Red Velvet is a massive musical flex lmao
omg i cant stop replaying that part
I WAS SO IMPRESSED
@@cow3948FR ME TOO
그리고 이 노래는 바흐의 탄생일에 발매되었습니다.
sm은 정말.. 소름돋아.. 최고야..
What I love about SM Entertainment's girl groups is that their versatility is at the highest level than other kpop groups. They are not afraid to try different concepts hence, they were always willing to come out of their comfort zones to make high quality music. And this song made me stan Red Velvet (was only a casual listener of Red Velvet at first) I hope that it is not too late to stan them and will continue to make good music. I was able to hear them perform Feel My Rhythm live and it was breath-taking.
When we say Red Velvet is in their own lane, THIS is what we mean. This song is such a welcome beginning to spring. I love how it reminds me of Hello Future (Hello Baroque period), and how it’s elegant and pops hard at the same time. Two critiques:
1. I wish the song had a beautiful outro to tie everything together. The key change is amazing but it’s so short.
2. I wish this era lasted longer, rip 💀
Need an orchestral version asap‼️‼️‼️
Whaaat they ended promos? :O
@@angelwearsprada2990 Red Velvet deserved as much as (G)I-dle, but that doesn't mean you undermine the latter's efforts. They were gone for a year and they worked hard for it. Tomboy sounded fresh for this era what are you on.... Let's stop pitting idol groups against each other. Tomboy and Feel My Rhythm were two of the best releases this year
@@딸기-y3u Promos were already going to be short since they’re seniors in SM, but since Wendy and Seulgi got sick, that cut it even shorter… good news is, if this year is going to be like the first Reve Festival trilogy, it’s not the last we’ve seen of FMR.
the truest statement I've read today 👍🏼
레벨 노래 떴을 때 이분들 좋아할 것 같다 생각했는데 진짜 좋아하시네 역시 전문분야가 나오니까 엄청 신나보이신다
'Feel My Rhythm' hands down, the most beautiful music video I've ever seen. the references to art makes it even better.
Red Velvet has always been experimental in the best ways. Love that they don’t sound like any other girl groups out there, including themselves in previous releases. They have the best discography IMO.
이채널은 이 노래 리액션한게 인상 깊어서 구독자가 아닌데도 계속 들어옴. 대부분의 사람들은 조이의 킬링파트인 "꽃가루를 날려 폭죽을 더 크게 터트려" 이파트만 기억할텐데, 클래식, 재즈 음대생들이 전문적으로 분석해줘서 이노래가 특별하게 들리는거 같아요
'Feel my rhythm’ is the best comeback of Red Velvet but people don’t know how to appreciate art 🥲
What do you mean? This comeback did INCREDIBLY well and the song is very loved in general.
Feel My Rhythm album sold 600K+ albums and kpop community currently loved this song tho
@@ot7biasedmashups A lot of people also said the same was a safe song......so yeah...
@@ot7biasedmashups uhm well some people said it was too safe that it doesnt sound rv at all and apparently the instrumental is "too loud" idk what they r complaining this song was so good
I personally think Bad Boy was their best
This comeback was an instant hit both musically and visually 🔥🔥🔥
I adore SM Entertainment so much because of such songs, concepts... They keep feeding us with top-quality meals rather than fast food. They care about music and don`t want it to be simple, ordinary and tasteless. I am rooting for it.
Wow, you speak my mind 👍
THIS
The fact that this MV be only defined by reveluv fans, classical musician and art historian SM is the kpop standard
전문가도 아니었는데 이번곡은 인트로부터 듣고 놀랄정도로 좋았음...........진짜 이번 노래 최고
My most awaited reaction video! It's interesting how you explain some of the part of the song. It made me appreciate the song more. I didn't even know about the title, that's brilliant!
im just amazed how y'all can easily hear and identify the instrumental.
yeah, they're hearing things i can't hear xD lmao
Coz their a musician.. I means more in instrumental nor aka classical musician too So makes sense even just a single hymn they already knew the key.
Their ears are trained
I mean... it's one of the most common classical pieces, it's on many movies, it didn't take me much to identify it either
Because that's what they learned everyday. Like mathematics major can solved maths problems in matter of seconds.
As an average Air on the G string enjoyer, the song and this educational reaction video fills me with *ehem* joy.
OMG 😂👏 your comment made my week LOL
I see what you did there
same 💕
SM이 잘했죠. 노래도 정말 좋았어요~
내용은 고전음악과 최신 사운드의 조합만을 이야기하는것이 아닌 욕망 그리고 대중성과 예술성에 관한 MV라고 들었습니다. 클래식을 KPOP에 녹인 곡들은 이미 존재 해 있지만 레드벨벳의 이 곡이 아주 괜찮은 타이밍에 적절하게 만들어진것 같아요. 학생들의 해석과 의견을 듣는 것이 아주 재밌었습니다.
it's always so fun to be a red velvet fan, you never really know what they're going to give you next, but you know it's going to have that signature unique classiness. too often in modern kpop do companies try to make their artists' songs so different that it just ends up sounding like random samples thrown together. with red velvet, it's always unique, but incredibly polished
왠지 이채널에서 본 어떤 리액션 영상보다 더 신나하시고 본인분야 나와서 좋아하시는것같다 ㅋㅋ 이렇게 또 세세하게 파고들수록 기괴하게 버무린 클래식 선율과 뼈를 갈아 넣은 디테일이 어마어마한 곡이란걸 또 알게되네요...
맞아요 그냥 들을땐 몰랐던걸 점점 알아가는중..
......알아들으시는게 제일 부러워요...ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
When SM teased us that it’ll be using Bach’s piece for the song all that came to my mind is that “ReacttotheK” must react to this. Welp! Glad you like it. Because I loved it a lot
I agree with Rachel that Feel My Rhythm is an instant favorite right out of the gate. It takes me a while to form an opinion on most of RV's songs, but this and Psycho are maybe the only two I didn't need even a second listen to fall in love with. As of right now, Feel My Rhythm is a Top Five RV song for sure.
same!
I find myself loving this one Psycho and Bad boy -
I’m literally so obsessed with this song, the more I listen to it the more addicted I get. It’s so fun and doesn’t get boring so easily bc there‘s constantly new things added
3:29 미쳤냐구...... 진짜 이분들 너무 사랑합니다...
진짜요.. 듣고 소름…
이부분 너무좋아요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
I feel people who can really appreciate their music has really great taste. Red Velvets discography is so complex and beautiful
I think this is the best song of RV and one of the most interesting songs that SM has made for their artist. It’s gorgeous and mood-lifting. Thanks to your reaction showing us what’s cool in the song that I can’t explain
I love it when he started playing the violin ksksksks AND YES THIS WAS SO NEW AND COZY AND FEELS SO RED VELVET AT THE SAME TIME AAAAAA
if SOTY isnt counted in streams or sales, Feel my rhythm will be the SOTY. its just too perfect
True honey
FMR is actually my most played song in 2022. It’s SOTY for me😊
100 percent, that was amazing
i might understood like 10% of everything they said but its really cool how everyone in this video is so passionate about music :) i too wanna learn music theory now
I have been waiting for this fr.. like, everyday I'd checked ur channel just to see if u already reacted to this. Y'all out of all the people who reacted to red velvet has the most genuine reaction to this song. Tbh, i really love this song and this mini album. I just hope that others also sees and hear how this mini album is a true gem. I'll be waiting for the whole mini album review tho.
SAME
omg same
Same!
SAMEE
Samee
Same, Kevin and Rachel! I loved it so much from the first listen too! I was so into their reaction that I felt the video ended so quickly. Didn't even feel like 22 minutes. Thank you for reacting to this masterpiece 😭🤌
Nothing beats the energy it radiates when people talks about their passion. And this reaction was a great combo esp bc u guys actually have the knowledge about all these originals musics they use to create this song. Awesomeness
필마이리듬은 정말 레전드 곡… 그런 곡을 더 잘 이해할 수 있게 해주는 전공자들의 세세한 리뷰가 너무 좋아서 자꾸 보러오게 된다
17:21 I want him to play the full song please 🥺 that was beautiful
yes! i wanted him to play the whole song, it literally made me tear up! so beautiful.
레드벨벳 팬 러비로써, 제일 인상깊게 본 뮤비 리액션이였습니다. 반응 하나하나 나올 때마다 흥미로웠어요.
It's amazing how art and music people recognize so many aspects in the MV and music.
The defined references to Bosch's "Garden of Earthly Delights", is amazing and with the music!!!
바흐의 음악을 베이스로 해서 우아하면서도 상큼한 느낌을 주려고 한게 인상적이었고, 그걸 다시 바흐의 깊고 웅장한 느낌으로 승화시킨 매우 복합적이고 특이한 노래라는 생각.
그런데 이것들이 어색하지 않고 한데 어우러져 아주 괜찮은 하모니를 이루어냈다는데 칭찬을 해주고 싶음.
first time i heard this song, my reaction was simply "this is genius" and i need validation from this channel. indeed now confirmed this is red velvet most genius song after psycho for me.
이 노래 듣자마자 노래가 너무 좋아서 은근히 이 채널에서 리액션 해주길 기대했는데 역시나 리액션이 올라왔네요~ 굿!!!
I always says Seulgi’s voice will fit the classical or orchestra kind of music and now they said it fit perfectly at her voice in the intro. I sure this song is the geniuses art of 2022 🙌
isn't it wendy who sang the intro?
@@kristengray4900 They both do
It was Wendy
21:22 with this song it proves again how SM Entertainment Production Team (in music) is really on another level. Like If they do the production of their songs, It's already perfect but if there is greater than "perfect", they do it! Reallyy kudos to the A&R and Producers of SM Ent 👏🏼👏🏼
the reason why SM is still leading as a company who focus and smart to creat a music not only music that anyone want to listen, but make anyone know how make music unlimited.
@@lutfiaalmah7898 an innovative company when it comes to music indeed. 😌
Ugh just think about zimzalabim, this and aespa's next level. They may think weird and unknown at first but it really hits different ❤️❤️❤️
너무 좋은 컨텐츠다👍🏻👍🏻 전문적인데다가 일반인도 알아들을 수 있게 자세히 설명했네요. 감사합니다
AIr on G String is my favorite classical music. There's just something so hauntingly beautiful about it that's just so sooo good. Having Red Velvet sampling Air so faithfully and expertly is just 😭😭 what a title track, such an excellent piece!
The way they speak music with so much passion- I could listen all day.
Me too 😭
You're literally the only reactor I think of when I first hear this song, and finally!! Thank you Umu and the reactors!!
When I first heard this song I was so confused prolly bc I felt that the mv is a bit overwhelming. Then they dropped the performance video and I was more confused bc the straight forward visual of the perf vid made me see the song on a different light, which I didn't expect. It's like I finally understand classical and Kpop.
13:53 I just realized that this part prolly explained why I felt confused at my first listen. Like the music and the visual is clashing. But thanks to the performance vid I understood it and FMR immediately rose to my no. 1 fave song in the album
17:14우와.. Jory 바이올린 연주 넘 멋져요.. 돈내고 들어야 하는거 아닌가 싶네요.. 고마워요~
ㄹㅇ 이번 레벨곡이 젤 잘나온듯 잔잔하면서 노래 너무좋음
3:29 love that piano melody
agreee
Me too
Sameeeee
It's the main motif of Air on the G String.
This is one of the best Redvelvet title songs. It's so experimental yet so pleasing. I really love how they calmly started with Bach's Air On G string and then suddenly hit us with those trap beats. This is insane.
I wouldn't say that the chorus is happy. It's so overwhelming like how you are touched when springtime overwhelmed all your senses. It feels so nostalgic and joyful that you might shed some tears.
I kind of found this interesting with the bridge. I thought the bridge was over with Seulgi's part but they continued with Joy. Wendy, Yeri, and Seulgi's bridge part felt like some deep, dark struggle leading onto a joyful Joy bridge. This deserved more wins but it's okay as long as there are people who appreciate Redvelvet's essence. Also, they confirmed that there is going to be a trilogy this time. Let's enjoy the future comebacks too.
"That chorus is *gorgeous!!* " YESSS😭❤ this is probably one of my most favorite red velvet songs ever and quite possible one of my most favorite kpop songs ever I'm just so obsessedly in love with this song
15:18 my favorite part. It's so funny yet cute when musicians try to explain their favorite thing in the song. Like Many people won't understand the eargasm the musicians get
You know it's iconic because this reaction video hits 1M views. Congrats ReacttotheK!!
Never in my life feeling a 20 minutes video was so short. When i listened to the track, i thought Bach’s sample had something to do with the chorus but my music knowledge couldnt let me to break it down. But thanks to Kevin to explain it so simple that now I can understand how the producers made it.
The song was so awesome and I am thankful that many people appriciated this. I hope SM keep up with their wonderful works.
Btw the reaction to the birds and how Seulgi ate the strawberry were so funny 🤣
In terms of mixing classical music and contemporary K-pop, it's quiet interesting to see how K-pop has evolved since I-Yah(1999, by H.O.T.), which you reacted weeks ago.
I loved the song at the first listening but I don't study music, I just went with the "feelings part", and it was goosebumps all over my body haha
So nice to have this kind of reaction, this channel is so special! Love you guys, thank youu!
-from a Brazilian fan ♡
와 음 듣고 바로 피아노로 치는거 넘 멋있음..
영상이 더욱 풍족해지는 것 같네요ㅋㅋ
반음계 낮게 튜닝된 바로크 튜닝 듣자마자 바로 맞춰버리는 절대음감 클래스 ㅋㅋ
3:28 케빈 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 노래 예측력 보소
I'm not musician, but talking about my experience for first listen it may abit distracted by the Bach's sample when I'm too used to it, even so the whole song is really good and I do like the melody. But after several listens, I'm completely love with the song and the more details I catch through the listen, the more I get amazed by the producer of the song for such genius production, and I have waited until today just to watch this reaction and analysis, and I'm happy for the knowledge gained watching the whole video.
Omg sameeee. I was kinda distracted by Bach's at first listen because it sounds too strong in the song. After several listen, it sounds good
You are not alone 😄
Omg, me tooo 🥺🥺
I'm exactly like you. I hated the song when I first heard it. I think the classical music that they sampled doesn't match well with the song. Now, I couldn't even get this song out of my head. And I dare to say that this is the best Red Velvet song ever.
@@RoyMcAvoy For me it didn't sound weird and I didn't hate it in the first listen because the melody is still gorgeous 😂 It's my brain cells being confused and yet to pick up everything when they just caught the Bach sample mostly in the first listen
Ohhhh now i know why red velvet says they travel through time and space. They literally said the definition of Rhythm in music
I thought they says that for concept.
And woooow thank you reacttothek for this Feel My Rhythm is super detailed.
The matching of lyrics to the sound wow. I learned something in classical/music.
Ive waited for this
20:52 Point to discuss:
Is it really surprising that Bach's music sounds so good despite its "restrictions"? Or are the "rules" just result of what actually sounds good and emotional, and thus not restrictive at all? I do see that some of Bach's works can be extremely "restrictive" or "constructed" (like Goldberg variations), and they still are full of creativity.
So are restrictions really a deterrent of inspiration and emotion? Or do the restrictions just provide a framework in which a composer can design a very inspired piece? Many "rules" in music are, in my opinion, just whatever works well, from form and structure (how boring and uninspired does the idea of a canon sound, the same thing twice, lol?) to harmony.
In some way (and to bring it back to the K) even 'Feel My Rhythm' is a product of restrictions imposed by the concept of sampling 'Air', but the restrictions are perhaps one of the reasons this song is so inspired and works so well (in my opinion ;D).
So perhaps restrictions might even be a source of inspiration and emotion?
Would love to hear anyone's thoughts!
Love the point you make here about restrictions. I'm one who thinks that sometimes even more inspired and creative art comes out of restrictions when a breakthrough is achieved within the fixed set of boundaries. It's even more amazing precisely because of the expansion within and beyond the limitations.
@@popkmacnaf Definitely!
Absolutely, the "rules" provide a framework for creativity and enjoyment. Like the many forms of poetry (for example, a haiku).
These are definitely interesting things to discuss! I wouldn’t say that the rules resulted from what “actually sounds good and emotional” though. I feel like that discounts entire genres and periods of music that completely venture outside of these restrictions of “perfect” counterpoint and voice leading (impressionism, neo-classicism, “power chords” in hard rock/metal, most melodic writing in solo marimba and percussion ensemble literature, etc.), all of which have just as much potential to be emotionally impactful and pleasing to listen to. Again, that’s all subjective. People are moved differently by different music of course!
I agree that working within set restrictions can be extremely fulfilling and even inspire greater creativity than just throwing things at the wall and seeing what sticks. That’s a great point! I think part of what makes Bach work so well in this specific context is the concreteness of the harmonic structure, and how easy it is to run wild with new compositional and production techniques over this framework.
@@liammcmanus7502 Ooh, hi Liam!
I see what you mean, and at no point was I trying to claim that only music following perfect counterpoint can sound great. Listening to Renaissance music, there is a lot of voice leading that seems very questionable to our modern ear, but the music still sounds beautiful and at times wonderfully floaty.
However, I still think that 'the rules' result from what sounds good, though maybe I should specify that the rules found in the Baroque period were just one and not the only way of how to sound good, and that the rules arose specifically in a context of polyphonic music and the instruments available at the time. For example, I do actually think that parallel power chords don't sound nearly as cool on a typical harpsichord as they do on a guitar with a ton of overdrive. So a composer trying to write a piece for four independent voices would naturally refrain from the 'forbidden' parallels because voices would mesh and they would just loose tension and, basically, one of the voices.
My knowledge of music is quite limited, and my perception of what is important in music might very well be a somewhat one-dimensional product of listening only to western classical, jazz, etc, and even there usually in a bubble of a few composers/artists. I can't claim to have listened to a single piece written for solo marimba (sorry, recommendations are welcome though). [Edit: Just checked out your channel. Source for marimba music found ;D]
It would probably be a different question to discuss how 'good' or important certain sets of rules in music are (and for what), or even if there is such a thing as objective quality to music. And that might also lead to quite philosophical and biological questions, like if aliens would understand our music as such or just hear noise etc... Getting existential. xD
Well, I hope that made some sense, thank you very much for your thoughts and for your reactions! :)
와 확실히 클래식 음악을 샘플링해서 그런지 제법 빠른 리액션을 했네..
I love how exciting ALL the musicians are in this video. I know this masterpiece woked them up fr, and I am so thankful they gave us A LOT of dissecting and conversation.
I literally cried when the first time I heard this song but idk how to explain.. now if someone asked me again why I'm crying over listening to this song I'll just give this reaction video to them.
I'm so emotional when listen this song but also happy at the same times, but you guys explaination just make it more and more emotional esp when the editor give a footage of Bach original sample and then that guy playing violin im so----😭😭😭
it's like i'm fallin in love with classic music now🥺💗
Yes!! The chorus specially is so emotional, sad and joyful at the same time 😊
귀엽다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 😍
Same
I still cry pretty much every time I hear this song which is starting to get annoying. 😆 They kept talking about my favorite parts in the reaction, talking about how beautiful they were and yeah I'm just sitting here wiping away tears again. I think my head exploded first time I heard this song. Completely gobsmacked. And that's not even getting into all the art references and outfits !
This is actually my most anticipated reaction. I waited for so long and at last!!!! Thank you for recting hehehe. I don't really know much about notes and instruments but I enjoy watching your videos and sharing your views about the song.
You guys need to watch the performance video - it's amazing.
RV always impresses!
they could've played the performance video for the second listen :( anyways our cake girls is very good musically and visually!!
제가 좋아하는 레드벨벳의 노래를 분석해주셔서 감사합니다 덕분에 어떤 재미 요소가 있는지 원곡과 비교했을때 어떤 부분이 다르고 같은지를 알게 되었네요 고마워요
When you look at the details, you'll see how complex and interesting Feel My Rhythm is. There's Classical Music, Ballet, Theater, Painting, etc. in this one music video that is to fit the modern times and KPOP. GENIUS & PERFECTLY RIGHT FOR RED VELVET as they are the most experimental group ever imo. They nailed it! 🤯🤯🤯
3:28 love how he just started playing
never clicked so fast in my life. THANK YOU FOR DOING THIS UMU AND TEAM!!!
Yass I really needed this, i knew the piece was super properly sampled and respected the counterpoints, but your comments always go beyond
Edit. So it is a key change, i thought it came back to the Db
Bridge starts prolonging vi of Db (not a complete key change but the harmony/color changes a lot), and then Joy's 2nd half of the bridge goes back to Db as the tonal center, and then the final chorus goes up to Eb! :)
@@ReacttotheK ohh I have to give it try like this with my guitar. Thanks!!
It's crazy that this analysis is every bit as interesting as the original song itself... Great reaction