Simon was right about the Phantom. There was no actual reveal about the trick/illusion. It was never clarified on David’s piece of paper what the memory was until minutes after it ended. Which resulted in a disappointing ending. It was slightly boring in the middle as well.
@@dboy_fresh8312 That wasn’t confirmation or a reveal. That was just her guess of what his answer could be. There was no reveal/ confirmation from David during the routine. And we never got to see what was written on the paper. It wasn’t until after the routine had ended when he mentions the memory he thought of. That’s why it was an underwhelming ending, and where the confusion came from. That’s why it was a flawed ending and caused any chance of getting to the final.
Basically, all that happened is Amanda got up and stood in a box for the whole act, whilst some guy back stage used remote controls to make objects move and then press Davids buzzer at the end. Great act👍🤣
@@tommoncrieff1154 Either they video edited it. But I'm 90% sure she is a stooge. Obviously David wouldn't of had to be as there are methods to get a peek but his lack of reaction to someone reading his mind suggests to me he was in on it and was told what to put
You can just tell by the audience's reaction that something's off or missing. An interesting concept that left lots of room for improvement with the execution.
Maybe that's part if the act.. not to play all cards and leave judges and audience hanging to let the phantom come back with more answered questions...
@@knowledgeispower5359 Well why did Simon act so confused about the act then? If that was the case he would have known he was told to cut it short and the hosts would have told the camera and viewers. They wouldn't just not disclose that information as its critical to the act.
I agree with Tom and that sucked we didn't see what David wrote. Because of David not hearing correctly and Amanda was having a hard time too and made the show slow down a bit. I thought it was kinda cool! Thumbs 👍 up 👍 I think he's got talent!!
Amanda was too quiet during the act. When she had "dissapeared" and was "moving" things, I expected her to laugh, scream, comment, ask questions like "what this" or "you want me to do it now" - thats what gave me a weird vibe.
My problem with this act is that it's obvious the guy is using remotes and special mechanics to make objects move, and he's probably using a monitor or just standing in the back somewhere to watch everything, and we never see a proper prestige of himself or Amanda at any point. He's leaving far too much unseen for it to feel mysterious. The secret of great "magic" is to make us think we're seeing everything, and then fool us anyway.
Hes sell hes seul for devil You are very stopd people look just last trick how he can push red button u wanna said me he control system studio that is a stpdty from you hes just normal guy sell hes seul for devil to give him some power
When David is in front of the mirror and he steps to the side, revealing that no one was next to him, I laughed so hard 😂 then Amanda appears obviously from the other side of the mirror 😂
Y'know, the first audition of the Phantom, I was kind of intrigued, and probably because it was executed far better than this follow-up, but the more I think about it--Magic is far more compelling when you have the Magician in front of you on the stage to put in things that disprove your original notions. The invisibility angle, and things just moving is a little too gimmicky especially considering that we all can figure the "phantom" not being present and visible gives the upper hand to working around things.
I wish Amenda explained about how she was, where she was? How she know David's childhood memory? It looks like she was instructed while she was inside the box. Look close to the box where, I believe, Amanda was standing the whole time. There is a high power front light which made Amanda seem disappeared and when it's off, there she is again. It's a silly, staged, mirror, and light effect performance. SORRY but NOT IMPRESSING AT ALL!!
What makes it not that great for me is in the box you can see the reflection of a different set of lights in the front part of the box, and between those lights is the mirror if you will that lets you see through it if the back lights are turned on, and if the front ones are turned (turned them on to make her “invisible”) you can’t see through it, lol!
I dont get the magic part.. the box was still standing there in the dark, didnt move and she didnt reappear somewhere else (in person). So how did she become invisible? 🤔 this act also proves how the judges are involved cause this would never be possible without at least Amandas (and maybe also Davids) involvement
@@replicativeimpact1574 There's a simple psychologic thing in magic: Tell an audience member to do something and in 99% he or she will do exactly that. Even if they aren't briefed for the trick beforehand. Most people don't want to ruin the performance so they nearly would do anything the magician wants them to.
Simon was right in the sense that there are two gaps in the act - 1) It wasn't revealed during the act if Amanda was correct about what David wrote down; 2) Amanda had to be in on the act - she clearly read/followed a script and prompts, and didn't reveal her whereabouts during the act, and went along with it... if she wasn't, she would have said she wasn't and would be as amazed as everyone else about how she could no longer be seen and how she somehow guessed David's thoughts correctly... but she didn't. All this made it disjointed and incomplete. Later she as good as confirmed this by saying she wasn't interested in being the "Debbie McGee [magician's assistant]" of an act... We know Amanda can't read minds - she can barely read a newspaper... that part of the act doesn't make sense.
The phantom read David’s mind and transmitted the info to Amanda’s mind, we are energetic beings and our minds act as receivers and transmitters of information. Most people have this experience subconsciously like when thinking about a certain person and moments later they call you or text you.
The phantom told david to write his thought in the paper , david should have confirmed the thought by showing everyone what he wrote in the piece of paper and not just by merely agreeing to what amanda said. David was not at all surprised by the fact that amanda read his mind, why? The phantom told simon to think of a number and simon showed 7 but it had no relevance in the trick . If amanda became really invisible then it should have been shown by opening the box in which she stood infront of everyone . Only when amanda went inside before being invisible and came out after being visible was the box opened. When david stood infront of the mirror phantom told amanda is standing to his left, david shifted towards the left but didn't bump into amanda, yes people will say that the phantom told that she had got the ability to go through solid things but if that is the case then how did she open and close the box and pull the chair and sit on it? How did david remember the exact time of the incident which had occurred 40yrs ago ? He said that it was 12.15 pm that trying to avoid the sprinkler system he fell in the cannal. Moreover it looked like david knew what to do as in the starting even before the phantom could tell david to write his thought on the paper he lifted the pen and paper. So because of these questions not being answered the trick could not deliver a good impact, atleast it didn't leave a strong impact on me.
Chill out guys! It is an entertaining to watch. Don’t get yourself caught into trying to solve the trick. He puts on a good show. Everything from his voice, his make-up, and his performance overall, he got me to watch till the end!
Actually the main problem is that the trick was too obvious, so there's no trying to solve it. And it actually wasn't entertaining... It's so slow and so boring.
Makeup?? What part lol Trying to solve the trick? Uh it was obvious to a person older than 5 Entertaining?? It was boring af, the beginning was intriguing, till he made Amanda "invisible" hahaha
I like The Phantom but this was so drawn out and "clunky" feeling. Amanda was in the box the whole time, and David never confirmed whether or not they guessed his memory correctly during the act like Simon said.
but they did....if you watch and listen...Amanda said so in the mirror scene that David in a uniform fell in to a river......and yes David confirmed this later by admitting as a cub to avoid the shower he stepped back and fell into a canal...... the magic of this is getting the judges to find this out themselves
the flaw for that act is that making everyone believe amanda is invisible and following his commands like opening the box etc. where in fact absolutely not true..amanda should testify that being one of the judges🥴
@@craigblyth783 problem is people are thick. The things they don’t understand get rejected. There needs to be a new show only for the most unusual of acts.
@@craigblyth783 David was asked to confirm it after the act had finished. "The Phantom" should have asked David if what Amanda said was correct while he was still looking in the mirror. It was presented like there was going to be some bigger reveal in the paper David took from the box, but it was just a lead up to the gag with the buzzer. Because of it that part of the "mind reading" pretty much got missed by the audience.
Her and David are definitely in on it. David never shown what was written on the piece of paper and were supposed to just take his word that the event happened 🤔 during the auditions he’s back stage in the dressing room with David’s keys like security just let anyone randomly roam around in the judges dressing rooms
@@destroyed369 I thought the exact time about the keys in the dressing room. It's pretty obvious that this act is totally staged. Kind of disappointing because I think most of the show is staged now.
Why are the judges willing to get so involved in an act that they would pretend they went invisible for the sake of the person. Surely that shouldn't be allowed
because it adds variety to the show. If you didn't know the majority of these acts are talent scouted and invited to come to the auditions. It's is far from being an organic process.
David took 2 pieces of paper and read one? And Simon was right. The phantom didn’t reveal if Amanda guessed David’s memory or not. I think the phantom messed up somewhere.
Simon was spot on, there should have been a clarification to david’s memory during the act. Act’s flawed, no wonder he didnt make it through to the next round.
@@SaintsCheat david never confirmed if the memory was his until AFTER his act ended... and nobody read the paper aloud or even to themselves, the other judges, no one.
@@Prestivant wtf are u talking about ? 1) “David write a memory if yours…” that means HIS memory lol. You think he wrote Simon’s memory? How would David know wtf Simon did as a kid for a ….ok you got me so confused 😂😂
@@SaintsCheat David would have never confirmed if the things which Amanda in the mirror said was correct or not. It wasn't asked from the phantom in the act if the things which amanda said were true or not. David just confirmed it after the act, because simon said it wasn't commented on in the act.
Pretty sure that was just to show everyone that Amanda could see them from where she was since he had Amanda say out loud how many fingers Simon held up.
Amanda went in on it, when she was put into the 'invisible realm' by standing in front of a transparent LCD 'in the invisible box'... All the Phantom magician needs is put VFX in the middle LCD to cover Amanda to make her 'invisible'. Now, since Amanda is just waiting in the box, David didn't bump or feel Amanda's presence when he stood in front of the mirror. David's writing on the note can be easily seen by using zoom camera from above him when he wrote it on the judges desk. Set the clock (and prolly everything else) by remote and brief Amanda to read David's writing from behind the box. Simon is on point on this one. By the way, Simon always picks the number 7...or 717
40% of comments: Bit disappointing at the end. Simon was right. 30% of comments: Amanda always get chosen to go on stage. 20% of comments: Wouldn’t be surprised if it was X from 2 years ago again. 10% of comments: Other
Love how David can remember the time he fell into the canal from 40 years ago, “I fell in dodging sprinklers at 12.15pm” total rubbish, David also loves every act, how ridiculous.
I thought the same thing about what David wrote on the paper. The ghost never asked about it and I was waiting for that when Amanda went back to her seat. Still though I wonder, how did he KNOW what David wrote ? and she DID describe what he wrote. That part is really interesting. Yes we all know its a trick of some kind, but I still give him big thumbs up!
The box , which made Amanda invisible , has two sections. the part she entered from the back and the front part separated by a special glass, its transparency is controlled electrically or by the lighting. its so clear ....!
@@felixahelixa3233 I know that’s why I said two random acts like the witches from this year and that iconic moment when she swore live on tv in the haunting performance a few years ago
it’s so obvious that the objects are just being moved with remotes and the whole ‘invisible’ amanda thing was awful. the whole thing just felt so set up like at 4:30 for example
@@aguyfromnewzealand3392 It wasn’t a real mirror, it was one of those mirrors with screens in it and it just showed the real time video of Amanda from the box. Which is also why her movements during that seemed so restricted.
Dead giveaway with the table moving after David put paper in box, assistant concealed in table can access the box alter clock and move items using magnets. Amanda never leaves box just clever lighting to conceal her, voice is not hers but sound alike and mirror part is just a projection, average illusion at best and I am no expert
but dude with this comment you put yourself out to be....table never moved...please tell us how an assistant could be that versatile to manipulate the clock etc...yes maybe Amanda still in box...question is really....could you have pulled this off?...after all it was only an average illusion...should be easy huh
Yeah. Dreadful act really. Blatantly obvious what was happening at every stage All the table stuff was all done mechanically under the table Amanda never leaves the box and even in the mirror it doesn't even look like her if you look at her face David messed up so many times aswell 😂 At the mirror the phantom says stand on the x and look to your left, Amanda is standing right beside you But David steps to his left (where Amanda is apparently standing invisible) and the phantom screams at him to move back to the x 😂
@@craigblyth783 Watch again back right of table moves upwards at 4:55 and again at 5:11 . Plenty of room in the table to the right for an assistant. I said I am no expert just my observations using common sense. Could I have pulled this off, most probably with all the props and practice as you could as well given that the person who did is also a normal human. Most illusions would be far easier to do than lets say card or coin manipulation.
Before David is asked to pick up the pen, he does it way before it is announced. Have a feeling the judges are also staging their reaction, just something is off about this whole act. It also seems way too unbelievable that this is real magic, which just makes me believe the entire thing was staged. Also why on earth was no one asking Amanda where she went, how she teleported from the mirror to the box instantly, what happened when she was looking into the mirror and how she the knew the memory. Did she have visions of it? Did someone tell her? This act was too mysterious to seem legitimate
What I thought was weird was that he picked a memory that had an exact time. If I picked a random memory from my childhood I wouldn’t be able to tell you an exact time.
Basically, all that happened is Amanda got up and stood in a box for the whole act, whilst some guy backstage used remote controls to make objects move and then pressed David's buzzer at the end. Great act That's the first time I've ever agreed with Simon, I thought a part of the act was missing, and we never got to see what David wrote. 3:36 ''Amanda speak if you're alive'' My problem with this act is that it's obvious the guy is using remotes and special mechanics to make objects move, and he's probably using a monitor or just standing in the back somewhere to watch everything, and we never see a proper prestige of himself or Amanda at any point. He's leaving far too much unseen for it to feel mysterious. The secret of great "magic" is to make us think we're seeing everything, and then fool us anyway. You can just tell by the audience's reaction that something's off or missing. An interesting concept that left lots of room for improvement with the execution. Amanda was too quiet during the act. When she had "appeared" and was "moving" things, I expected her to laugh, scream, comment, and ask questions like "What this" or "You want me to do it now" - that's what gave me a weird vibe. Why are the last 2 judges still left willing to get so involved in an act that they would pretend they went invisible for the sake of the person. Surely that shouldn't be allowed Most mind-reading/mentalist acts are like that, unfortunately. because it adds variety to the show. If you didn't know the majority of these acts are talent scouted and invited to come to the auditions. It is far from being an organic process. Because it's Britain's got talent Chill out, guys! It is an entertaining to watch. Don’t get yourself caught in trying to solve the trick. He puts on a good show. Everything from his voice, his make-up, and his performance overall, he got me to watch till the end! I like how just before Amanda went up on the stage Simon and Aleasha were subtly trying to comfort her :) I would love to go on to this program and just put on a good show that leaves everyone terrified and shaking I love how it's supposed to be a good scary act but he also has a little comedy in it. appears obviously from the other side of the mirror Poor David he's just like "What do I do? This side? Do I say it now? Sorry" Wouldn’t be surprised if this invisible guy is that same guy that’s come on 2 years in a row and made it into the semi-finals before This whole act would’ve been exposed if one of the judges literally asked, “Did you ever leave the box?” Simon is really a smart guy that's why im a fan of all his Talent shows Basically, all that happened is Amanda got up and stood in a box for the whole act, whilst some guy backstage used remote controls to make objects move and then press Davids buzzer at the end. Great act 5:47 Now playing Cillian O'Connor proves anything is POSSIBLE with a BURST of magic! | Semi-Finals | BGT 2023 Britain's Got Talent SPOOKY Auditions! | Britain's Got Talent Now playing HOW DID HE DO THAT?! Magician DISAPPEARS Into Thin Air! | BGT 2023 top 2 is the best to go home for today just land now great Talent Recap Now playing BGT 2023 WINNER Viggo Venn ALL Performances! Aunt Chippy Gets Pranked at the Trophy Shop Jimmy Kimmel Live 8 YO Girl Issy SHOCKS Everyone With Her Magic | Audition 2 | Britain's Got Talent 2017 John Travolta Gets Deliriously Cozy with Ellen! TheEllenShow The Judges' FUNNIEST Unseen moments! | Britain's Got Talent Britain's Got Talent Axel Blake is a COMEDY SUPERSTAR in the making! | The Final | BGT 2022 Now Playing BLITZERS (블리처스) set the stage ALIGHT with a fiery performance! | Semi-Finals | BGT 2024 Britain's Got Talent 2.6K views 17 minutes ago New REVEALED! Marc Spelmann the Phantom from Britains Got Talent 2022 Legendary LEAPERS with Unbe-LEAP-able Talent! | Auditions | Britain's Got Talent was in the if movie holding that at the window to read that book so is a joke on stage was funny so Amanda is the voice of that baby she plays is your Amanda got a husband is here hunting for a ghost live-action in Disney “Can't Play Right Now” Scene - Ghostbusters: Frozen Empire (2024) Clip was in the 80s okay thanks is 1 more left live-action is big winner in the comment on the talking on the podcast okay in half in 90s okay.
The trick is really simple. The clock, the box, the chair, etc are using some kind of remote control. When david says the clock, the magician set it up then. That is why the clock needed to be covered up first. The box and the chair is simply using remote control. The paper probably has some kind of thin layer of magnet, and below the desk there is moving magnet that drag the paper. That is why the paper need to be spread that way. And amanda trick is so simple. The box has two layer and some kind of mirror. Amanda still there while the box looks empty. And then she was brought backstage so she can do mirror performance. And the storyline has no satisfying ending. As simon says.
The box was nothing more than a two-way mirror in front of Amanda as long as the back row of lights were lit up, which you could obviously see, then she was visible. As soon as the front lights were lit up and the back row turned off you could see a double row of lights in the front. The second row now only being a reflection of the front row. Now she disappears??? behind the mirror. She never moved away from that. It would have been much more impressive to have one of the other judges walk through the box from Back to Front proving that Amanda had truly disappeared which is absolutely possible to do but at least it would have been impressive. If you read the rest of everyone's comments you will easily figure out how this entire routine is done
Would be curious to hear from the phantom as to why the memory bit was never revealed on stage. Did he forget? Did he think it went wrong so he skimmed past it? Also I'm all for magic acts but it's unfair to have the judges in on the trick. Only magic gets this service
@@alfiehutton2612 reveal a messed up trick on another performance? Nah he just messed it up. Idk why he didn't reveal it. Gotta be a reason but it was def a mistake
"The witches" ruined the witches. That was one boring act. Reading pieces of paper and then a rat that was in a hidden compartment. The humor of the judges was the only thing interesting about the whole routine.
I believe The Witches were actually too scary so they were instructed to light up the mood. You can see them talking with the production team right at the start. David was even covering his ear to hear them.
It's missing the part where you're amazed. You're supposed to think you see and know everything. Then you get surprised by something unexpected. That's the payoff that was missing.
When Amanda stood behind the lighted door you can see a shadow run off stage. Most likely it was Amanda running off to her left where no one can see her. The only thing I can't explain is her in the mirror.
The glass box has a 2-sided mirror in the middle. Initially the 2 rows of lights are on in the back, allowing Amanda's image to show through. Then those turn off, and the first row of lights on the front side of the mirror go on, so that all we see is the reflection of lights on the front side of the mirror.
Of course they have to pretend they don't know what's going on, even though after however many series they've done, they've encountered similar acts in the past (plus, of course, those chosen to go on stage will likely see the fishing lines used to manipulate objects which are invisible in-camera). Added onto which, they're probably all familiar with shows like Magic's Secrets Revealed, which explain how a variety of popular illusions are achieved.
No. But she did know in advance what Amanda would be wearing so clearly this terrible act was helped in many ways. The advance notice of clothing. Pressing the buzzer at the end etc.
If you look at the lights it should help. When Amanda is in the box the back two lights are on- when she's not the first light and the "back" light are. Not saying anymore than that. Magic is a lot of smoke and mirrors after all.
Simon’s got a point. It was really useless. So whats with amanda reading the mind of david when david wrote it down on a piece of paper. Why would he wrote it down and not exposing it on what it is written in it.
Yes! I believe she AND David are part of the act. How did he get David's keys the first time? Who knows what David really wrote, noone got to see it! I think it is quite obvious that Amanda And David are in on this act.
That’s wot I thought the 1st question any 1 should of ask was 2 Amanda and if she was at the mirror and opening the boxes none of them did that at all , all abit strange 2 me
She's definitely part of the act but only after she goes inside the box. There were probably some instructions there for her to follow. That's why she doesn't know how to react and is silent when she comes back. There's no way they would allow someone to be part of an act from the very start.
It just proves it’s a set up by the judges and crew, it’s so difficult when doing something like this live. Normally it would be smoother because it could be rehearsed and timed better, on this occasion It went on too long, that’s why David’s reveal of memory wasn’t defined properly. He knew that and that’s why he went over the top explaining to Simon. Amanda must stop taking part in these “magic” acts, she loses all credibility as an independent judge.
I think I have a solution to this, when she stepped into the box she never left till end. The box could project her from inside the box onto the mirror. I'm sure one day we'll find out for sure when the identity is revealed 😉
I think phantom was using a kind of virtual reality technology. The invisible box Amanda entered was kind a VR control pad being used to control everything. Because the position of the clock and the box on the table are diagonally opposite, so Amanda is not really present at the table but she was able to control everything from the invisible box by a virtual reality technics installed in the box
BGT is supposed to be about people with talent. This magician is just a guy using a collection of common stage effects such as Peppers Ghost (Amanda in the mirror) and gauze to make a person disappear from a box. The main trick with David's childhood memory was botched and the champagne failed to pop on cue. This act does not deserve a spot in the next round. If I were judging I would have used my red X.
The kid in the audience "Amanda, speak if you're alive" haha
Then will win the okers
i am not kid you kid you say you're alive haha
@@A404me Your grammar is like a 5 year old so you are a kid.
@@PixelatedDoesGaming why me man im old 16 you understand kidding me
Man in audience Amanda are you naked...
Amand is always the chosen one in every scary show. I’d cry for her🤣
Haha in the sacred riana too
always funny to see women freak out
Amanda knew before what will happen
i would laugh at her stupid bad ways of dealing with people she is sarcastic
😮😮😮😮😮
Simon was right about the Phantom. There was no actual reveal about the trick/illusion. It was never clarified on David’s piece of paper what the memory was until minutes after it ended. Which resulted in a disappointing ending. It was slightly boring in the middle as well.
It was when Amanda was next to him in the mirror. She was able to see his memory.
@@dboy_fresh8312 no because david never actually revealed his memories to see if Amanda was right until after the performance when Simon asked
@@dboy_fresh8312 That wasn’t confirmation or a reveal. That was just her guess of what his answer could be. There was no reveal/ confirmation from David during the routine. And we never got to see what was written on the paper. It wasn’t until after the routine had ended when he mentions the memory he thought of. That’s why it was an underwhelming ending, and where the confusion came from. That’s why it was a flawed ending and caused any chance of getting to the final.
It was boring...yess
I think David was supposed to react. He didn’t say anything when Amanda said that, but I think his reaction was supposed to be the reveal.
I died of laughter when I heard that kid shout "Amanda Speak IF You're Alive!"😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣
Lmao same
At what time
@@Wolfwolfing1377 3:36
That was too funny
Basically, all that happened is Amanda got up and stood in a box for the whole act, whilst some guy back stage used remote controls to make objects move and then press Davids buzzer at the end. Great act👍🤣
Exactly, really lame, and very poorly executed, also doesnt help David couldn't hear anything he said. Just chaos
But how did she turn up in the mirror?
@@elsiestephens6379 Never heard of a two side mirror before??
So how did Amanda read David’s mind? Supposedly she isn’t a stooge.
@@tommoncrieff1154 Either they video edited it. But I'm 90% sure she is a stooge. Obviously David wouldn't of had to be as there are methods to get a peek but his lack of reaction to someone reading his mind suggests to me he was in on it and was told what to put
You can just tell by the audience's reaction that something's off or missing. An interesting concept that left lots of room for improvement with the execution.
I was thinking he ran out of time and got told to end it by the producers hence why David had to do the reveal instead.
I was there and you’re correct
They should have made David hold the paper up to the mirror to reveal what Amanda said was correct? Something definitely missing...
Maybe that's part if the act.. not to play all cards and leave judges and audience hanging to let the phantom come back with more answered questions...
@@knowledgeispower5359 Well why did Simon act so confused about the act then? If that was the case he would have known he was told to cut it short and the hosts would have told the camera and viewers.
They wouldn't just not disclose that information as its critical to the act.
That's the first time I've ever agreed with Simon , I thought a part ot the act was missing , we never got to see what David wrote .
No, but he told us, I think the act ran out of time because David was so slow on stage.
I agree with Tom and that sucked we didn't see what David wrote. Because of David not hearing correctly and Amanda was having a hard time too and made the show slow down a bit. I thought it was kinda cool! Thumbs 👍 up 👍 I think he's got talent!!
@@tommoncrieff1154 The voice was slow
@@tommoncrieff1154 I know he told us , but he could have said anything , but we needed to see what David wrote .
I find it hilarious that we are expected to believe that Amanda was invisible for a few minutes 😂😂😂
It’s a screen isn’t it
Did you see her? Then, invisible
@@GMZohar14 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
He’s brilliant
What are u on about? I’m sure she learned the dark arts from john cena
Amanda was too quiet during the act. When she had "dissapeared" and was "moving" things, I expected her to laugh, scream, comment, ask questions like "what this" or "you want me to do it now" - thats what gave me a weird vibe.
3:36 ''Amanda speak if you're alive'' 😂
no she is dead ha ha shes mean by laughing at that girl with cerebral palsasiy
My problem with this act is that it's obvious the guy is using remotes and special mechanics to make objects move, and he's probably using a monitor or just standing in the back somewhere to watch everything, and we never see a proper prestige of himself or Amanda at any point. He's leaving far too much unseen for it to feel mysterious. The secret of great "magic" is to make us think we're seeing everything, and then fool us anyway.
This is probably the same guy who auditioned twice before and didn't reveal his identity till the end
I agreeJohn. I think he is a robotic expert. Not impressed at all.
Hes sell hes seul for devil
You are very stopd people look just last trick how he can push red button u wanna said me he control system studio that is a stpdty from you hes just normal guy sell hes seul for devil to give him some power
What if he is really invisible?
lots of gadgets for sure!
I love how they always go for Amanda
I don't, it's not funny at all!
@@willyrobertlegendre4662 don’t care
Was thinking the same , they always go for Amanda
because other Judges might ruin the Act
It's traditional at this point
Wouldn’t be suprised if this invisible guy is that same guy that’s come on 2 years in a row and made it into the semi finals before
Unlikely
Max spellmen i think his name is he was also x
@@AA-he6xx it’s not him he would have left hints
@@FlyingHawlucha the phantom did say "X marks the spot"..........
@@GoosyLucy I was thinking the same about the X but you never know 🤷🏻♂️
When David is in front of the mirror and he steps to the side, revealing that no one was next to him, I laughed so hard 😂 then Amanda appears obviously from the other side of the mirror 😂
Y'know, the first audition of the Phantom, I was kind of intrigued, and probably because it was executed far better than this follow-up, but the more I think about it--Magic is far more compelling when you have the Magician in front of you on the stage to put in things that disprove your original notions. The invisibility angle, and things just moving is a little too gimmicky especially considering that we all can figure the "phantom" not being present and visible gives the upper hand to working around things.
sssss
Remote controls from the producers themselves is not a talent.
Liked the part where David stepped into the spot that Amanda was supposedly standing in. Kind of exposed the trick.
Thats what i thought rolo
Poor David he's just like "what do I do? This side? Do I say it now? Sorry"😅
i am not sorry for saying stuff
@@katiecurrie9709 what stuff lol
I wish Amenda explained about how she was, where she was? How she know David's childhood memory? It looks like she was instructed while she was inside the box. Look close to the box where, I believe, Amanda was standing the whole time. There is a high power front light which made Amanda seem disappeared and when it's off, there she is again. It's a silly, staged, mirror, and light effect performance. SORRY but NOT IMPRESSING AT ALL!!
0:34 David held the pen before the magician said the words. He knew what to do in advance. Clearly everybody knows what’s happening.
And on top.. at 5:10 you can see the desk corner lifts up a little. A good perf with little mistakes.
This whole act would’ve been exposed if one of the judges literally asked “did you ever leave the box?”
She never left the box.
She would’ve said yes cause she was in on the act. I dont think these acts will be possible without at least one inside men/women
What makes it not that great for me is in the box you can see the reflection of a different set of lights in the front part of the box, and between those lights is the mirror if you will that lets you see through it if the back lights are turned on, and if the front ones are turned (turned them on to make her “invisible”) you can’t see through it, lol!
I dont get the magic part.. the box was still standing there in the dark, didnt move and she didnt reappear somewhere else (in person). So how did she become invisible? 🤔 this act also proves how the judges are involved cause this would never be possible without at least Amandas (and maybe also Davids) involvement
@@replicativeimpact1574 There's a simple psychologic thing in magic: Tell an audience member to do something and in 99% he or she will do exactly that. Even if they aren't briefed for the trick beforehand. Most people don't want to ruin the performance so they nearly would do anything the magician wants them to.
Simon is really a smart guy thats why im a fan of all his Talent shows
Same like I had the same thoughts
Simon was right in the sense that there are two gaps in the act - 1) It wasn't revealed during the act if Amanda was correct about what David wrote down; 2) Amanda had to be in on the act - she clearly read/followed a script and prompts, and didn't reveal her whereabouts during the act, and went along with it... if she wasn't, she would have said she wasn't and would be as amazed as everyone else about how she could no longer be seen and how she somehow guessed David's thoughts correctly... but she didn't. All this made it disjointed and incomplete. Later she as good as confirmed this by saying she wasn't interested in being the "Debbie McGee [magician's assistant]" of an act... We know Amanda can't read minds - she can barely read a newspaper... that part of the act doesn't make sense.
and a school boy trick of pepper ghost was over worked
Yeah she's in on it and I guess peppers ghost. It's a shame because to me a judge being in on it makes it rigged.
The phantom read David’s mind and transmitted the info to Amanda’s mind, we are energetic beings and our minds act as receivers and transmitters of information. Most people have this experience subconsciously like when thinking about a certain person and moments later they call you or text you.
The phantom told david to write his thought in the paper , david should have confirmed the thought by showing everyone what he wrote in the piece of paper and not just by merely agreeing to what amanda said. David was not at all surprised by the fact that amanda read his mind, why? The phantom told simon to think of a number and simon showed 7 but it had no relevance in the trick . If amanda became really invisible then it should have been shown by opening the box in which she stood infront of everyone . Only when amanda went inside before being invisible and came out after being visible was the box opened. When david stood infront of the mirror phantom told amanda is standing to his left, david shifted towards the left but didn't bump into amanda, yes people will say that the phantom told that she had got the ability to go through solid things but if that is the case then how did she open and close the box and pull the chair and sit on it? How did david remember the exact time of the incident which had occurred 40yrs ago ? He said that it was 12.15 pm that trying to avoid the sprinkler system he fell in the cannal. Moreover it looked like david knew what to do as in the starting even before the phantom could tell david to write his thought on the paper he lifted the pen and paper. So because of these questions not being answered the trick could not deliver a good impact, atleast it didn't leave a strong impact on me.
What was Simon's 7 for? What was on the other piece of paper David pulled from the box? I'm with Simon on this.
Just to show that Amanda could see him from where she "was"
Chill out guys! It is an entertaining to watch. Don’t get yourself caught into trying to solve the trick. He puts on a good show. Everything from his voice, his make-up, and his performance overall, he got me to watch till the end!
Umm...his makeup?
Actually the main problem is that the trick was too obvious, so there's no trying to solve it. And it actually wasn't entertaining... It's so slow and so boring.
Makeup?? What part lol
Trying to solve the trick? Uh it was obvious to a person older than 5
Entertaining?? It was boring af, the beginning was intriguing, till he made Amanda "invisible" hahaha
The other main problem is that this whole trick skit was boring af
@@femalehobbitwithhairyfeet And corny. Don’t forget corny. Lol
I like The Phantom but this was so drawn out and "clunky" feeling. Amanda was in the box the whole time, and David never confirmed whether or not they guessed his memory correctly during the act like Simon said.
but they did....if you watch and listen...Amanda said so in the mirror scene that David in a uniform fell in to a river......and yes David confirmed this later by admitting as a cub to avoid the shower he stepped back and fell into a canal...... the magic of this is getting the judges to find this out themselves
the flaw for that act is that making everyone believe amanda is invisible and following his commands like opening the box etc. where in fact absolutely not true..amanda should testify that being one of the judges🥴
@@craigblyth783 problem is people are thick. The things they don’t understand get rejected. There needs to be a new show only for the most unusual of acts.
John 3:16
Romans 10:9
John 3:3
Matthew 7:21
@@craigblyth783 David was asked to confirm it after the act had finished. "The Phantom" should have asked David if what Amanda said was correct while he was still looking in the mirror. It was presented like there was going to be some bigger reveal in the paper David took from the box, but it was just a lead up to the gag with the buzzer. Because of it that part of the "mind reading" pretty much got missed by the audience.
This act makes me question the legitimacy of BGT. Amanda had to be part of the deception for this to work, when she should be an impartial judge.
Her and David are both in on it I believe
I promise you they are not in
@@Mamapelz they definitely are
@@Cuubiic as a magician myself. They dont have to be in this. This was easy and straight. Basic tricks and mentalism
@@Mamapelz maybe it’s not fake but Amanda was definitely playing along and didn’t actually go invisible in the mirror
They should've asked Amanda more questions. Have a feeling she is in on it.
yea i agree. i wanted amanda to speak or did she?
Her and David are definitely in on it. David never shown what was written on the piece of paper and were supposed to just take his word that the event happened 🤔 during the auditions he’s back stage in the dressing room with David’s keys like security just let anyone randomly roam around in the judges dressing rooms
@@destroyed369 I thought the exact time about the keys in the dressing room. It's pretty obvious that this act is totally staged. Kind of disappointing because I think most of the show is staged now.
i wish amanda would shut up and not make fun of people like me who have a brain disorder inthink she should keep her f ing mouth shut
I think you're on to something lol... are you being serious? God it's a shame to be a human.
Why are the judges willing to get so involved in an act that they would pretend they went invisible for the sake of the person. Surely that shouldn't be allowed
Most mind-reading/mentalist acts are like that unfortunately.
because it adds variety to the show. If you didn't know the majority of these acts are talent scouted and invited to come to the auditions. It's is far from being an organic process.
Because it's Britain's got talent
Because it's all about money
David took 2 pieces of paper and read one? And Simon was right. The phantom didn’t reveal if Amanda guessed David’s memory or not. I think the phantom messed up somewhere.
I will guess the second paper was something for the finals...the only thing I can think of, but since he didn't make it...
Simon was spot on, there should have been a clarification to david’s memory during the act. Act’s flawed, no wonder he didnt make it through to the next round.
Guess we still can't watch him next round
What do you mean? David wrote his memory, Amanda revealed in the mirror. What part don’t you understand ? 😂
@@SaintsCheat david never confirmed if the memory was his until AFTER his act ended... and nobody read the paper aloud or even to themselves, the other judges, no one.
@@Prestivant wtf are u talking about ? 1) “David write a memory if yours…” that means HIS memory lol. You think he wrote Simon’s memory? How would David know wtf Simon did as a kid for a ….ok you got me so confused 😂😂
@@SaintsCheat David would have never confirmed if the things which Amanda in the mirror said was correct or not. It wasn't asked from the phantom in the act if the things which amanda said were true or not. David just confirmed it after the act, because simon said it wasn't commented on in the act.
Id love to go on to this program and just put on a good show that leaves everyone terrified and shaking 😂
Hello pretty
@@Nanatuffour433 gay
@@kimandrew9559 wossop
you really can do what you do
That is why Simon is a super judge. Many parts of the act didn't make. Like what did Simon holding 7 fingers meant
Pretty sure that was just to show everyone that Amanda could see them from where she was since he had Amanda say out loud how many fingers Simon held up.
Maybe 7 is the age David was when he got into a fight with a sprinkler and lost ?? Who knows !!!! 👍🖐️
Amanda went in on it, when she was put into the 'invisible realm' by standing in front of a transparent LCD 'in the invisible box'...
All the Phantom magician needs is put VFX in the middle LCD to cover Amanda to make her 'invisible'. Now, since Amanda is just waiting in the box, David didn't bump or feel Amanda's presence when he stood in front of the mirror.
David's writing on the note can be easily seen by using zoom camera from above him when he wrote it on the judges desk. Set the clock (and prolly everything else) by remote and brief Amanda to read David's writing from behind the box.
Simon is on point on this one. By the way, Simon always picks the number 7...or 717
40% of comments: Bit disappointing at the end. Simon was right.
30% of comments: Amanda always get chosen to go on stage.
20% of comments: Wouldn’t be surprised if it was X from 2 years ago again.
10% of comments: Other
0.0001% of comments: the guy is really invisible ..
I love how it's supposed to be a scary act but he also has a little comedy into it.
Love how David can remember the time he fell into the canal from 40 years ago, “I fell in dodging sprinklers at 12.15pm” total rubbish, David also loves every act, how ridiculous.
He was told to go with gut as he obviously wouldn't be expected to remember the exact time.
So true. I can't remember what I had for breakfast!
david is a stupid actor on stage
I like how just before Amanda went up on the stage Simon and Aleasha were subtly trying to comfort her :)
What if there is no magician, it’s just the judges and the crew messing with us?
this america is the worse talent show for people who like to bullie like the judges
I thought the same thing about what David wrote on the paper. The ghost never asked about it and I was waiting for that when Amanda went back to her seat. Still though I wonder, how did he KNOW what David wrote ? and she DID describe what he wrote. That part is really interesting. Yes we all know its a trick of some kind, but I still give him big thumbs up!
That kid who shouted is another magician from future
Time stamp?
"amanda, amanda speak if you're not"
And his mother was like "shut up kid" 😂😂😂
@VortexHD probably yes, because my listening in english is not good 😅😅
The box , which made Amanda invisible , has two sections. the part she entered from the back and the front part separated by a special glass, its transparency is controlled electrically or by the lighting. its so clear ....!
So? Don't you think the effect looked cool and real? Or were you actually expecting her to become invisible?
She never left the box.
How come every time amanda gets chosen to go on stage she’s always unhappy about it
This act wasn’t as scary as the likes haunting or the witches
Maybe she's always 😨
She is easy to hypnotized
Are you new here? For every scary act it’s always Amanda who gets chosen LOL
@@felixahelixa3233 I know that’s why I said two random acts like the witches from this year and that iconic moment when she swore live on tv in the haunting performance a few years ago
this was a dum show just like a person is
I love acts like this, especially the witch act ❤
it’s so obvious that the objects are just being moved with remotes and the whole ‘invisible’ amanda thing was awful. the whole thing just felt so set up like at 4:30 for example
Amanda was in same position she was not moving 😂😂and told she was invisible
How do you explain the mirror part then 🤔
@@aguyfromnewzealand3392 it's a different person if you look at the face it's not Amanda
@@islayardley Ha ha ha! Best idiocy so far.
@@islayardley and how did they get the dress
@@aguyfromnewzealand3392 It wasn’t a real mirror, it was one of those mirrors with screens in it and it just showed the real time video of Amanda from the box. Which is also why her movements during that seemed so restricted.
I think Amanda knows everything, as she was not asked to comment on him at the end of the act
I wouldn’t be surprised if the entire acted was set up by BGT for some reason.
@@niamhlaste8972 for sure...
Sure! I didnt see Amamda move bhind stage!
Dead giveaway with the table moving after David put paper in box, assistant concealed in table can access the box alter clock and move items using magnets. Amanda never leaves box just clever lighting to conceal her, voice is not hers but sound alike and mirror part is just a projection, average illusion at best and I am no expert
Look at chair on the left, bottom of the leg there a wire, either to pull or a radio control on it to move it
but dude with this comment you put yourself out to be....table never moved...please tell us how an assistant could be that versatile to manipulate the clock etc...yes maybe Amanda still in box...question is really....could you have pulled this off?...after all it was only an average illusion...should be easy huh
Yeah. Dreadful act really. Blatantly obvious what was happening at every stage
All the table stuff was all done mechanically under the table
Amanda never leaves the box and even in the mirror it doesn't even look like her if you look at her face
David messed up so many times aswell 😂
At the mirror the phantom says stand on the x and look to your left, Amanda is standing right beside you
But David steps to his left (where Amanda is apparently standing invisible) and the phantom screams at him to move back to the x 😂
Wrong on pretty much every count there - you certainly aren't any expert.
@@craigblyth783 Watch again back right of table moves upwards at 4:55 and again at 5:11 . Plenty of room in the table to the right for an assistant. I said I am no expert just my observations using common sense. Could I have pulled this off, most probably with all the props and practice as you could as well given that the person who did is also a normal human. Most illusions would be far easier to do than lets say card or coin manipulation.
“Your other left, David. David turn around. I’M OVER HERE, DAVID!” 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@3:36 "Amanda speak if you're alive" LOL!
For everyone who thinks this is Marc Spellman... He already announced on his channel that it's not him
@Richy J Movies 😂😂😂
I don’t know if he is joking or not?
@Richy J Movies no I mean Marc spellman is joking or not?
This isn’t good enough to be Marc. Most of this is easy to see how he’s done it.
@Richy J Movies 👀
i love how they always go for amanda 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Tell me why
FINALLY - Someone said it!
@@seanhollway4774 she is always the most scared
@@shelbspuffly fair enough thank-you
@@shelbspuffly u have a nice name
It's definitely John Cena's brother 😂
Imagine if he wins BGT. He will be the 1st winner who never appeared in BGT
You can't see me
It sounded like he was about to swear at him and say "David you ****" just before David eventually turned around haha.
@@stelovesoasis 🤣🤣🤣
Before David is asked to pick up the pen, he does it way before it is announced. Have a feeling the judges are also staging their reaction, just something is off about this whole act. It also seems way too unbelievable that this is real magic, which just makes me believe the entire thing was staged. Also why on earth was no one asking Amanda where she went, how she teleported from the mirror to the box instantly, what happened when she was looking into the mirror and how she the knew the memory. Did she have visions of it? Did someone tell her? This act was too mysterious to seem legitimate
Yes I noticed it too. The play is kinda scripted and the judges are part of it
@@themoment23 Yeah definitely
The whole show is staged!!!! No matter what the act is... The entire show is scripted and staged. The whole thing is a fix from the first episode
What I thought was weird was that he picked a memory that had an exact time. If I picked a random memory from my childhood I wouldn’t be able to tell you an exact time.
@@jnjshubert omg yes!!!
1:09 Phantom Voice: I said a few words David.. You writing another book?
Simon is right on the money. There were loop holes in the act.
Which loop holes
This was good but weird
I don’t think he’ll go through though so it’s a shame we won’t see who this invisible act really is
I think you are right about that.
Maybe its X
He may get a wild card
@ShxdowEdits yeah that was funny tbf
@@ramishaya6 lots of rumours saying it’s Marc spellman aka X
David is in on the act
Basically, all that happened is Amanda got up and stood in a box for the whole act, whilst some guy backstage used remote controls to make objects move and then pressed David's buzzer at the end. Great act That's the first time I've ever agreed with Simon, I thought a part of the act was missing, and we never got to see what David wrote. 3:36 ''Amanda speak if you're alive'' My problem with this act is that it's obvious the guy is using remotes and special mechanics to make objects move, and he's probably using a monitor or just standing in the back somewhere to watch everything, and we never see a proper prestige of himself or Amanda at any point. He's leaving far too much unseen for it to feel mysterious. The secret of great "magic" is to make us think we're seeing everything, and then fool us anyway. You can just tell by the audience's reaction that something's off or missing. An interesting concept that left lots of room for improvement with the execution. Amanda was too quiet during the act. When she had "appeared" and was "moving" things, I expected her to laugh, scream, comment, and ask questions like "What this" or "You want me to do it now" - that's what gave me a weird vibe. Why are the last 2 judges still left willing to get so involved in an act that they would pretend they went invisible for the sake of the person. Surely that shouldn't be allowed Most mind-reading/mentalist acts are like that, unfortunately. because it adds variety to the show. If you didn't know the majority of these acts are talent scouted and invited to come to the auditions. It is far from being an organic process. Because it's Britain's got talent Chill out, guys! It is an entertaining to watch. Don’t get yourself caught in trying to solve the trick. He puts on a good show. Everything from his voice, his make-up, and his performance overall, he got me to watch till the end! I like how just before Amanda went up on the stage Simon and Aleasha were subtly trying to comfort her :) I would love to go on to this program and just put on a good show that leaves everyone terrified and shaking I love how it's supposed to be a good scary act but he also has a little comedy in it. appears obviously from the other side of the mirror Poor David he's just like "What do I do? This side? Do I say it now? Sorry" Wouldn’t be surprised if this invisible guy is that same guy that’s come on 2 years in a row and made it into the semi-finals before This whole act would’ve been exposed if one of the judges literally asked, “Did you ever leave the box?” Simon is really a smart guy that's why im a fan of all his Talent shows Basically, all that happened is Amanda got up and stood in a box for the whole act, whilst some guy backstage used remote controls to make objects move and then press Davids buzzer at the end. Great act
5:47 Now playing Cillian O'Connor proves anything is POSSIBLE with a BURST of magic! | Semi-Finals | BGT 2023 Britain's Got Talent SPOOKY Auditions! | Britain's Got Talent Now playing
HOW DID HE DO THAT?! Magician DISAPPEARS Into Thin Air! | BGT 2023 top 2 is the best to go home for today just land now great Talent Recap Now playing BGT 2023 WINNER Viggo Venn ALL Performances! Aunt Chippy Gets Pranked at the Trophy Shop Jimmy Kimmel Live 8 YO Girl Issy SHOCKS Everyone With Her Magic | Audition 2 | Britain's Got Talent 2017 John Travolta Gets Deliriously Cozy with Ellen! TheEllenShow The Judges' FUNNIEST Unseen moments! | Britain's Got Talent Britain's Got Talent Axel Blake is a COMEDY SUPERSTAR in the making! | The Final | BGT 2022 Now Playing BLITZERS (블리처스) set the stage ALIGHT with a fiery performance! | Semi-Finals | BGT 2024 Britain's Got Talent 2.6K views 17 minutes ago New REVEALED! Marc Spelmann the Phantom from Britains Got Talent 2022 Legendary LEAPERS with Unbe-LEAP-able Talent! | Auditions | Britain's Got Talent was in the if movie holding that at the window to read that book so is a joke on stage was funny so Amanda is the voice of that baby she plays is your Amanda got a husband is here hunting for a ghost live-action in Disney “Can't Play Right Now” Scene - Ghostbusters: Frozen Empire (2024) Clip was in the 80s okay thanks is 1 more left live-action is big winner in the comment on the talking on the podcast okay in half in 90s okay.
My favourite act of 2022
What started as a bit exciting ended in disappointment.
good im glad to get revenge on people that make fun of my disability
The trick is really simple. The clock, the box, the chair, etc are using some kind of remote control. When david says the clock, the magician set it up then. That is why the clock needed to be covered up first. The box and the chair is simply using remote control. The paper probably has some kind of thin layer of magnet, and below the desk there is moving magnet that drag the paper. That is why the paper need to be spread that way. And amanda trick is so simple. The box has two layer and some kind of mirror. Amanda still there while the box looks empty. And then she was brought backstage so she can do mirror performance. And the storyline has no satisfying ending. As simon says.
How would Amanda have known what David’s memory was tho
The box was nothing more than a two-way mirror in front of Amanda as long as the back row of lights were lit up, which you could obviously see, then she was visible. As soon as the front lights were lit up and the back row turned off you could see a double row of lights in the front. The second row now only being a reflection of the front row. Now she disappears??? behind the mirror. She never moved away from that. It would have been much more impressive to have one of the other judges walk through the box from Back to Front proving that Amanda had truly disappeared which is absolutely possible to do but at least it would have been impressive. If you read the rest of everyone's comments you will easily figure out how this entire routine is done
Im with Simon.
It was good but lacked in so many ways.
They pick Amanda cause she always respects the talent
Would be curious to hear from the phantom as to why the memory bit was never revealed on stage. Did he forget? Did he think it went wrong so he skimmed past it? Also I'm all for magic acts but it's unfair to have the judges in on the trick. Only magic gets this service
I reckon he’ll get the wild card for the final and reveal the memory bit then
@@alfiehutton2612 reveal a messed up trick on another performance? Nah he just messed it up. Idk why he didn't reveal it. Gotta be a reason but it was def a mistake
It was, Amanda read it back to David
Ye I’m interested to know what went wrong -
@@Green_Gold
I saw others say it looks like he ran out of time or something, abd I agree. He does sound in a hurry at the end there
Isn't curious how they respected this act and completely ruined "The witches"?
"The witches" ruined the witches. That was one boring act. Reading pieces of paper and then a rat that was in a hidden compartment. The humor of the judges was the only thing interesting about the whole routine.
I believe The Witches were actually too scary so they were instructed to light up the mood. You can see them talking with the production team right at the start. David was even covering his ear to hear them.
It would have been a great performance if he asked David whether the vision of Amanda’s was correct!
Would have loved to hear from Amanda what her experience was like
Did no one else here in the background of a little kid saying Amanda speak if you’re alive😂😂😂😂
It's missing the part where you're amazed. You're supposed to think you see and know everything. Then you get surprised by something unexpected. That's the payoff that was missing.
When Amanda stood behind the lighted door you can see a shadow run off stage. Most likely it was Amanda running off to her left where no one can see her. The only thing I can't explain is her in the mirror.
that was the person who was helping her watch closely before u can see a hand
There was one of the stage crew putting a panel on and off the box she stepped in. That's who walked off the stage.
Those people were the crew that helped her in and helped her out
There's like a camera inside the box that reflects her mirror, They made that to look like Amanda was standing next to David.
I dont think it was Amanda at all. Just an impersonator. That's why her face is slightly shown
the kid who yelled at @3:36 absolutely has me crying 😂😂
What'd he say, Amandas feet something, Amanda speak?
@@mr.resistance4015 lol he said "Amanda speak if your still alive!"
The glass box has a 2-sided mirror in the middle. Initially the 2 rows of lights are on in the back, allowing Amanda's image to show through. Then those turn off, and the first row of lights on the front side of the mirror go on, so that all we see is the reflection of lights on the front side of the mirror.
“I’m over here David” -invisible man
The award goes to Amanda and the rest of the judges for the dumbfounded expressions of ABSOLUTE bewilderment 😂
Of course they have to pretend they don't know what's going on, even though after however many series they've done, they've encountered similar acts in the past (plus, of course, those chosen to go on stage will likely see the fishing lines used to manipulate objects which are invisible in-camera). Added onto which, they're probably all familiar with shows like Magic's Secrets Revealed, which explain how a variety of popular illusions are achieved.
In the first performance he explained he could read people's minds and speak through them. I think Simon forgot that part
no such creature
I love these lol... I like the creative way it's done ... Love the judges reaction
wow that's really cool, tense, scary but cool and steady
I CANT BELIVE WE KNOW WHO THIS MAN IS NOW
Every time magician:
Amanda please come to stage.😂
Hahahaha
i hate this persons comment
i wish amanda was firered from her stupid job like being a bad judge and simon as well.
The Phantom's voice reminds me so much of Sailor Moon's Wiseman...extra creepy. Whoever this performer is fantastic!
Pause at @6:39 and you can clearly see it’s not Amanda. 😬😬
No. But she did know in advance what Amanda would be wearing so clearly this terrible act was helped in many ways. The advance notice of clothing. Pressing the buzzer at the end etc.
People are trying to solve this trick or saying it’s bad or obvious but honestly for me, I quite enjoyed it!
i think the final two would probably be Loren Allred and The Phantom
MY ONLY QUESTION IS HOW DID HE MAKE AMANDA DISAPPEAR????
simple light trick.
✨ *MaGiC* ✨
Amanda well... She didn't disappear physically but they in fact... made you think she did
She was inside the box the whole time it was a screen for a while
If you look at the lights it should help. When Amanda is in the box the back two lights are on- when she's not the first light and the "back" light are. Not saying anymore than that.
Magic is a lot of smoke and mirrors after all.
Yah Amanda got Talent.. Give her a TF raise Simon😁😁👍
Simon’s got a point. It was really useless. So whats with amanda reading the mind of david when david wrote it down on a piece of paper. Why would he wrote it down and not exposing it on what it is written in it.
5:14 the table lifted up
Holds her stomach like, 'I hope there's a Google search for invisible babies...' after she returns... lmfao...
😂😂😂
When Amanda came out of the box, she was acting by looking amazed. She obviously was in the box the entire time. So why act. Was she part of the act?
Yes! I believe she AND David are part of the act.
How did he get David's keys the first time?
Who knows what David really wrote, noone got to see it!
I think it is quite obvious that Amanda And David are in on this act.
That’s wot I thought the 1st question any 1 should of ask was 2 Amanda and if she was at the mirror and opening the boxes none of them did that at all , all abit strange 2 me
She's definitely part of the act but only after she goes inside the box. There were probably some instructions there for her to follow. That's why she doesn't know how to react and is silent when she comes back. There's no way they would allow someone to be part of an act from the very start.
It just proves it’s a set up by the judges and crew, it’s so difficult when doing something like this live.
Normally it would be smoother because it could be rehearsed and timed better, on this occasion It went on too long, that’s why David’s reveal of memory wasn’t defined properly. He knew that and that’s why he went over the top explaining to Simon.
Amanda must stop taking part in these “magic” acts, she loses all credibility as an independent judge.
I think I have a solution to this, when she stepped into the box she never left till end. The box could project her from inside the box onto the mirror. I'm sure one day we'll find out for sure when the identity is revealed 😉
One way mirror. Lights behind it - transparent, lights in front - reflective.
I think phantom was using a kind of virtual reality technology. The invisible box Amanda entered was kind a VR control pad being used to control everything. Because the position of the clock and the box on the table are diagonally opposite, so Amanda is not really present at the table but she was able to control everything from the invisible box by a virtual reality technics installed in the box
Alecia: it was absolutely suspenseful.
me the whole performance: 😑
What was the point of David reading only one of the two pieces of paper? Wasn't he supposed to read the answer that Amanda gave?
I believe that was his memory of falling in the water & the hour & minute it happened. The ither was the invisible man's note.
BGT is supposed to be about people with talent. This magician is just a guy using a collection of common stage effects such as Peppers Ghost (Amanda in the mirror) and gauze to make a person disappear from a box. The main trick with David's childhood memory was botched and the champagne failed to pop on cue. This act does not deserve a spot in the next round. If I were judging I would have used my red X.
Whoever is the kid that said "amanda, speak if your alive!" is a genius
Isn’t that Heidi klums rose dress from the Americas got talent season 17 thumbnail that Amanda is wearing
Yesssss