This group has one of the most beautiful visuals: Xinran song, DDD, and Momo. I really wish DDD debuted, because she has such a lovely beautiful voice that is cute but mature and she is just so pretty
I think DDD actually can get B and other members can get C The main reason why they get D is they have less special characteristics.I hope they can get a higher grade！
Watching this after seeing the competition for center i now understand that xinran song rly deserves center like fr shes up for it even in the grain in ear performance
D seems to be outrageous for this performance. How could this group get the same grade as the duo who performed “Heavy Rotation”? The difference is like night and day.
It's because the mentors felt that both 48 teams have a similar style in the sense that there is a certain tone that the members are made to have and though their performance was nicer and more experienced then the akb girls it was no different than anything you'd see from other members of snh48 and to them none of the girls particularly stood out. I was shocked that they got the same grade as well but I understood where they were coming from.
The mentors said that the performance was just “okay” there wasn’t anyone or anything the performance that made them stood out, but I do agree that D is outrageous they should’ve got C
Is it just me who keeps seeing RV's Joy in Song Xinran?????? I first saw Xinran in Grain in Ear perf then I got curious so I finally watched Youth With You 2 from Ep1. hahahaha 😂😂
song xinran has a unique stage presence in that her eyes and head placement make her very eyecatching and alluring. she does naturally have large eyes and a pretty face but it's not just that. her eyes are always focused and she can control her eyes too to fit different styles and expressions. she knows when and how to make her gaze look serene, sharp, soft, or cheerful. i will say that 0:43 does not demonstrate this; she looks a little unsteady here. but other times, such as the very beginning of this performance, the beginning of her mangzhong performance, and her parts in her r&b all night performance are good. her dance and vocal skills here weren't a standout but her expressions and head placement were great.
If it's me, i'd give Song Xinran and Duan Yixuan a C, Momo a D, Su Shanshan and Fei Qinyuan a F. Unsure about Sun Rui. But their vocals and dance aren't exactly that good, they actually did better during training, some of them greatly improved tho. Song Xin Ran has a good facial expression, Duan Yixuan surprised me on MAMA, she caught my attention the most there alongside Kiki, and Sun Rui is good too.
It seems unfair to me that everyone has a D, they did the team choreography well and the touch of sensuality of the girls, half should have a B (DDD, Momo, RanRan) and the other half a C.
![【宋昕冉 X 戴燕妮】 [Xinran Song X Flora Dai CP] - 昕婚燕尔 Some & Say Yes](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4KpnavcLgoc/mqdefault.jpg)
宋昕冉气质太特别了 娇嗔啊
太多村外人，用有色的眼鏡看河妹了
我雖然也是村外人
但是我看得出段藝璇藏不住的實力
這個不可能是D吧
ddd其实可以的
Song Xinran is really pretty. Her dance is not bad at all but she needs to pay attention to her vocal.
She is the best in this team. Her sexy aura and cute voice
FLiP FLoP lmao ddd is definitely better. xinran’s a top tier visual, her dancing is average and her singing voice is cute but have 0 technique
@@piss-v4l I totally agree. Her voice is really cute and nice but her techniques are bad lol
@@snowyy8569 Can you do better?
DDD段艺璇虽然名字很多D，但我个人认为她的唱功值得C以上吧？
真的
段艺璇为什么叫DDD
le mon 前隊友幫他改了個段短短 所以取拼音有一個字 就叫DDD了
是的，在里面很明显的比其他人唱得好
她後期表演說唱 也不差
This group has one of the most beautiful visuals: Xinran song, DDD, and Momo. I really wish DDD debuted, because she has such a lovely beautiful voice that is cute but mature and she is just so pretty
芮哥在初舞台就好漂亮啊！！！簡直就是女神
四胞胎全C 河妺全D?也太不像話吧。。。
I think DDD actually can get B and other members can get C The main reason why they get D is they have less special characteristics.I hope they can get a higher grade！
YEAH!!! DDD really stood out because of her small smiles and eye flicks.
Watching this after seeing the competition for center i now understand that xinran song rly deserves center like fr shes up for it even in the grain in ear performance
有自己特色被說不整齊 現在整齊了又說沒自己特色.....我河妹太難了
I watched this again since I'm really whipped with Sun Rui
我反而觉得评审早就对他们有一种先入为主的印象了。因为第一期的时候就说什么你们的总选blablabla.但来到这里还得从零开始，让我觉得他们好像就觉得这些小偶像只是一群只会装可爱的小朋友。所以这次也不怎么去认真对待，也没有对每个成员进行一一分析就直接给个等级了。
我觉得这首歌表演的很好啊!
我也這樣覺得！
tungmei khu 有什麼好評？他们這麼普通
tungmei khu 同意第一點 但是一模一樣 整齊 他們其實可以拿到b/c 但是真的沒有個人特色
單看這場表演 她們還是表現的算非常完整了 不管是唱跳 還是整齊度 都有一定的水準 不愧是出道過的練習生 但是 也就是因為出道過 所以被認為應該有更好的表現 不是說他們表現不好 而是少了特色 而且這應該是他們48的歌？（抱歉我沒有追他們我不太清楚）應該要更能表現出自己的不同之處 就像葛鑫怡他們那組的 也是好聽 跳舞也不差 rap 也不錯 但是就是沒有自己的特色 但是相對沒特色來說 這樣的表演 還是非常穩定且不會出錯的
宋昕冉 Song Xinran is drop dead gorgeous.
YESSSSS, SHE LOOKS JUST LIKE A DOLLLLL
宋昕冉 加油。♥
费沁源真的很漂亮。。很元气♥
This song sounds so gorgeous and beautiful with their great dance performance. I really like it!! From Japan
AKB48 is great too ❤
全員c更合理
ddd可以拿b
ddd是谁？
@@laukaixuan3194 段艺璇
D seems to be outrageous for this performance. How could this group get the same grade as the duo who performed “Heavy Rotation”? The difference is like night and day.
Agree
They have way more experience than Team SH, you don’t have to drag another group to praise them
Zam If you watched the show, you’d know that they went up against each other at this stage. There’s nothing wrong with comparing within this context.
It's because the mentors felt that both 48 teams have a similar style in the sense that there is a certain tone that the members are made to have and though their performance was nicer and more experienced then the akb girls it was no different than anything you'd see from other members of snh48 and to them none of the girls particularly stood out. I was shocked that they got the same grade as well but I understood where they were coming from.
The mentors said that the performance was just “okay” there wasn’t anyone or anything the performance that made them stood out, but I do agree that D is outrageous they should’ve got C
段艺璇有颜值有身材有实力呀！
Qinyuan fei and xinran song so cute 🥰
Sun rui is too pretty and I luv her ^_^
Sun Rui so beautiful 😍😍
DDD 希望你能走上更高的巅峰
自信點, 把希望拿掉
@@冰霜巨人 嗯，一定会的！❤
DDD是誰阿？
@@banktw 段藝璇
@@banktw 0:36
雖然真的沒有到很好
但是感覺莫寒和段藝璇該有C吧
全員D好像有點誇張
同感
我觉得D很公平，个人认为这组分工的问题比唱功更大，孙芮和苏杉杉一句没唱全程伴舞不觉得很违背女团精神吗？这可是初评级舞台，把两个人藏在队里的组在我心里最多只值D
應該是給AKB留面子吧
@爹很贵. 我表达不严谨，应该说没有独唱才对，总之就感觉非常扣分，孙芮苏杉杉在这里也并不是主舞的，感觉像工具人一样就很尴尬
真的 很普通 其实不是脑粉 正常看了真的只有D
莫寒气息很 不稳 结尾一直飘
Sunrui didnt sing here but she sang at the snh48 practice ver its complete different here '='
i was so sad 😭
@@chxriny dont be, she was number on the her snh48 ranking! this show help her to gain new fans
@@marianrdz lmao im back now in 2022 and at least shes doing well now
回头再看这个舞台 我觉得河妹这几位都是这个时候最有自信 看的最舒服
Is it just me who keeps seeing RV's Joy in Song Xinran??????
I first saw Xinran in Grain in Ear perf then I got curious so I finally watched Youth With You 2 from Ep1. hahahaha 😂😂
This is the comment I've been looking for. She really does look like Joy
@@NekoNyan Finally!! Someone with the same thoughts as me. I barely saw any comment like this. 😂
看了最近48公演回来的，爱奇艺你真的不是反向修音了么！
song xinran 😍
다.. 진짜 너무 예뻐.. 인간일까...? 그리고 이 정도면 잘했지 빼액 하고 싶은데 또 엄청 잘한 건 아닌가..? 싶으면서도 그냥 울언니들 예쁘니까 잘한 것 같음ㅠㅠ 진짜 너무 다 하나같이 예뻐서 심장이 아프다.. 언니들 평생 행복해야해.. 알겠죠..?
跑去騰訊就變成很齊的團 在愛奇異就變成沒特色
婧太多高手
@@Mia-xf9ky 不知道你想表达什么，真的一个字也看不懂，参加婧的这几个人没一个是参加创的。而且评论也没说她们不齐，反而是太齐了齐得没有一点个人风格，而同样没有个人风格的舞蹈放在创就会被夸，见仁见智吧
但事後回來看的確是這樣，後續舞台表現都不錯啊，老實說這個舞台我完全沒看到孫芮，但從破風一直到最後的舞台 很亮眼
這舞台其實也不錯 但沒把每個人的優勢展示出來
in this grup just sun rui and ranran survive to the final
不应该全部D的，段艺璇歌唱得好应该可以是C，我觉得他们评审团给出的理由很不够。。。
Song Xinran shock beauty
YEAH
song xinran has a unique stage presence in that her eyes and head placement make her very eyecatching and alluring. she does naturally have large eyes and a pretty face but it's not just that. her eyes are always focused and she can control her eyes too to fit different styles and expressions. she knows when and how to make her gaze look serene, sharp, soft, or cheerful. i will say that 0:43 does not demonstrate this; she looks a little unsteady here. but other times, such as the very beginning of this performance, the beginning of her mangzhong performance, and her parts in her r&b all night performance are good. her dance and vocal skills here weren't a standout but her expressions and head placement were great.
If it's me, i'd give Song Xinran and Duan Yixuan a C, Momo a D, Su Shanshan and Fei Qinyuan a F. Unsure about Sun Rui. But their vocals and dance aren't exactly that good, they actually did better during training, some of them greatly improved tho. Song Xin Ran has a good facial expression, Duan Yixuan surprised me on MAMA, she caught my attention the most there alongside Kiki, and Sun Rui is good too.
Su sanshan or Air su for me is Z. Shes really doesnt have talent for singing nor dancing. She already confessed it too
FLiP FLoP she’s a good dancer, she just can’t sing
FLiP FLoP Lol I’ll give you a Z for attitude
@@incognito731 lol your name is trash so your comment isnt counted 😎
YUP, SAME
아니;;; 송신란 모한 미모 진짜 미쳤다ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 언니들 진짜 너무 예뻐 흑흑ㅠㅜ 평생 행복하세요 진짜♡♡
I loved their choreography tho
DDD and Air Su ♥️💙
DDD's facial expression is really good . I think she can get B :/// . love u so much DDD
SONGXINRANNNN ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Song Xinran Duan Yixuan Sun Rui Su Shanshan Fei Qinyuan 💙💜💚
為了莫莫來的
冉冉妈妈爱你啊啊啊😍
已經修音了, 但還是很清楚聽到氣息跟音準有問題, 高音上不去....
@Angel kirara 嗯...?? 這選秀評級, 當然不能假唱啊, 如果假唱導師是要拿什麼來評級 哈哈哈
@Angel kirara出坑的 黑粉太多了
@Angel kirara不要给她们超越AKB
@宝宝来看戏 我不是 除非增鍋一退我就出坑！！
宝宝来看戏 有氣也可以修音好嗎
BEJ48 Duan Yixuan😍❤️
动作太过整齐，就被说太公式化。打低分。团体不是应该是要整体化，舞蹈齐？难道要你跳你的，我跳我的，每个人都跳不一样的，不整齐，乱成一团，这样就可以看到每个成员的不一样。
她們的舞蹈無懈可擊, 我原預估怎麼也該是B, 全員D真是......啊!!!!!!
可能是为了给Akb48 面子，不让他们输给snh48. Akb48 占了日本歌坛的半边天，而且在全亚洲多个国家都有分团（之前snh48 也是Akb48 的子团体）Akb48 怎么也算亚洲数一数二的大公司，输给之前背叛他们的snh48 不是很没面子？
公式化不是因為跳舞整齊，是每個人的風格太類似，沒有個人特色。
評的不止是舞蹈啊.還有唱功
全員D很明顯是因為沒一個表演特別突出.讓人有記憶點.可能是人多 服裝的問題.
不知道你有没有看完整啦 为什么说是公式化？是因为看不到个人特点 一个团队里面 如果每个人都一样 擅长的都相同 那缺点谁来补？而且 这种节目不是选团队出道 而是个人 如果你个人没有特点 那你团队再整齐又有什么用…… 舞蹈很整齐可是没有灵魂 就和唱歌一样 只会唱 用技巧唱 没有任何感情 唱不进人心里
粉丝 报到 🙋🏻♂
It seems unfair to me that everyone has a D, they did the team choreography well and the touch of sensuality of the girls, half should have a B (DDD, Momo, RanRan) and the other half a C.
棒的歌曲
ranran💓💓💓😻
被剪的我芮哥變透明人..
Su Shan Shan
Fei Qin Yuan
Mo Han
Song Xin Ran
Sun Rui
Duan Yi Xuan
莫莫💟
Don’t know if it just me but DDD sometime look like Sana from twice
To me, Air su reminds me of Sana
Gustavo Casas me too
your name speak itself...
몰라 쒸익 모한 송신란 진짜 줠라 예뻐 언니들 사랑해...😭🥰❤️
我可以！！！小姐姐们加油！！！
芮哥辛苦了啊
費心源很可愛❤
璇璇
我河妹真的真的太难了... 虽然不推DDD， 但最起码最起码有个C吧
我也是這樣覺得，應該B或C的
对啊，段艺璇还是挺稳的，也是D，有点无语
两个48放一起对节目组最好的处理方式就是让他们成绩一样
捕捉面包
😂😂
超爱DDD和三哥
Mo Han fighting
HERE FOR DDD AND 3 AAHH
孫芮!!!
花錯 三哥
My Snh48 baby girls ❤️😍💕😭💕❤️
其实刚开始没有注意DDD，等看完了婧之后我觉得DDD唱跳能力都算不错的只是剪辑的关系她的part都变少了，真的很可惜
还有想见你的舞台被恶意剪辑我真无话可说了-。-
@China lover 總選還沒終選吧
Mohan is so beautiful
ddd is co cuuuuuuuuuuuuute
i think they can get the
higher grade～Espero el próximo espectáculo de momo.
这个评分太水了，段艺璇宋昕冉，费心源，怎么可能跟苏杉杉一个等级?
沁啦幹
酒可儿Eva 如果你是說那個原創曲的話 是先打完分才唱的
Jy,lovekikuchanj J 努力当不了饭吃，出道了才来努力？那当练习生干嘛？以为演艺圈好混？跳舞比较好一点就当舞者算了，这是唱跳歌手选秀节目，不是艺人练习综艺
Jy,lovekikuchanj J 实力不好就是准备不足，机会是留给准备好的人，自己准备的程度自己承担后果很合理
Jy,lovekikuchanj J 你也只会用情感说话，没点专业的评价，低级
Dolls...♥
現在在回來看初評級舞台!!!!孫芮原來是唱這類型的歌的嗎!!!!???
Song xinran🥰🥰
I think DDD can get C
Yeah, maybe even a b.
Unfortunately, they only got a D.
Should be C imo.🤔
全员D真的夸张
不过记得要把压力转为动力
一定会愈来愈好的❤
So many SNH48 member here. Im so proud
Why did u so proud huh? Lol its very easy for them to attend this show. I think every SNH48 can apply as well if they want
全员同等级大概率因为导师分不清谁是谁
SongXinran 😍🇹🇭
0:05 whos this girl? Her visuals are so pretty❤
Sòng Xīnrǎn 宋昕冉
@@儿可-s9p thank you~
I like the opening!! So beautiful 😍
冉冉❤️
If Su Shan Shan got more training before this she would make an amazing dancer and singer
重看發現孫芮完全沒有單獨唱的部分欸…
東北味太濃 不適合
杉杉也没有哦
What?????? 为什么可以没有独唱?? 我看青春有你的每一个舞台纯享每一个人再少都会分到一句唱吧???? 完全没有那么是伴舞吗?? 特写镜头也没有???? 孙芮真强 挺到了前20💪🏼💪🏼💪🏼
看了這個練習室版本
th-cam.com/video/kRG1wo1KP8M/w-d-xo.html
應該是被剪掉了
这首歌很好了啊
0:43 你敢告诉我这是冉冉的声音？!
DDD❤️❤️❤️❤️
我是因為kiki才開始關注河妹，雖說確實734那團整體來說因為有底子比這團好，但這幾個河妹也不差吧？也不至於比冰清玉潔差吧
爱奇艺干啥老是欺负丝芭
Momo ✊✊✊
藝璇有上公演嗎？？
恋爱循环，播了
Heres the english
comment your looking for
蘇珊珊都沒開口過 我笑了哈哈哈哈哈
1 month later I can finally name them😭 ..
Is it just me or 1:06 sounds exactly the same as AleXa's Bomb dancebreak?
Fighting ✊❤❤❤
全员D我不服！明明其中有几位成员如DDD及莫莫至少是能拿B或C的，一句公式化就全员D？虞书欣拿D我也不服！那女的明明是F。
@又土又逗的悠唐小王子w 不不不, 我覺得無關乎嚴格, 這舞蹈拿去安利路人也成啊!
Ella說的公式化是發揮不出個人特色, 代表著她們就算卡位精準, 動作華麗又整齊劃一, 也不會高分
要進步拿高分, 只有脫離河內固定公式, 跳出凸顯個人特色的舞, 但這偏偏是死穴
是啊，太莫名其妙了
@又土又逗的悠唐小王子w 严格？冰清玉洁都能全员拿C了！
@又土又逗的悠唐小王子w 那你说凭什么魑魅魍魉四胞胎全员C？凭什么乐华全员C?
虞书欣没有你说的那么差吧...无语
Cho mình xin tên bài hát vs người hát bài này với. Mình cảm ơn trước nha.
我覺得很好看也很好聽阿！！！
老師只給D未免也太過份，實在太低了........
估计是说了akb team sh就像出道的自己，然后被打脸 意思是其实你们也没什么进步
她們唱歌不太行
Now Vote for Akira Zhaoyue.... SNH48.... in CHUANG 2020.... For 1st Place..... and Sun Zhenni....
Why didnt Akira attend youth with you instead?
FLiP FLoP there was an internal conflict between akira and siba (the company) so they sent her to chuang instead as “punishment”