I still can't move-on on their performance "WANT TO SEE YOU" and I still feel it's a bit unfair for Zoe Wang who almost sang the whole song but is in the last place while two members who sounds tone-deaf which includes Air Su has higher rank than the talented ones hmmm
Actually according to the people who watched the live performance, Air Su didn't sound as bad as the video they posted up. Fans found out that for this group both for team A and B, iQiYi edited them to sound like they messed up live but they didn't. NaHo and DDD's voices didn't crack live, nor was Air Su off key for the whole performance. They messed up during the rehearsals and they used that audio to put in the video they put in the episode and youtube, but in the live version, both groups did great which is why NaHo got such a high vote.
@@musicpandarajsol5933 LOL I WASN'T NOT TALKING ABOUT NAHO NOR DDD LMAO I WAS PERTAINING TO MENGLU AND AIR SU !!!!! Air su's voice is mediocre. There are some trainees who're more talented than her. Don't know why she still on the show. Talking about bias system
Air Su knows that she doesn't excel in vocal or rap, but she does work very hard and at least tries, even if it doesn't sound as great as it could. like she said, she was practicing her lines until 3:00, she knows that she's not on the same level as everyone else. plus she can take the criticism lightly and laugh instead of taking it hard. i don't think she was fit to compete on the show, but i actually kind of miss her, because she's a great entertainer :)
I mean, she’s really bad. Maybe she’s tone deaf? I liked the fact that she always worked hard, I mean, she tried to get better. Unfortunately, some people just weren’t born to be a singer. Maybe with a loooot of practice, she could actually become good. But she was definitely not ready to be part of this competition (comparing her chances to debut with the other girls). I hope the best for because she seems like a great girl. Im happy that Xin Liu didn’t give up on her and tried to help her!
I bet you didnt watch the whole episodes of this show. Let say Joey that also lack of skill either sing/dance but she always want to learn from the other trainees and really stressed out when she cant do it well and we cant see it in Air su. She is like ignorant person, not motivated and just a burden for a team
@@flipflop2628 i never said that she was the best trainee or anything. ofc she wasn't very motivated im just saying she was funny and i liked watching her. she tried her best (kinda), even if her best isn't that good lmao. i just don't think everyone should be bashing her for being untalented. like she was nice to everyone idk why ppl hate her.
@@renjunswhore8534 i dont like her but i never say i hate her. I pity for the team who teamed up with her. Even Xinliu must spared her time just only taught her and she kept messed up. Besides, she already confessed that actually she entered snh48 just because accident, she said she cant sing nor dance. If i was her i wont ever to attend this show. Idk maybe her teammates invite her to join with them so we cant blame her aswell
I can't believe I'm saying this, but I kinda miss Air Su. She's entertainment gold 😂😂😂 I prefer her over Momo and Xinran. Lol. I know they're much more popular and a tad bit more "talented" than her, but they're so boring.
I personally dont miss her for a bit. She's just so bad, I always feel uncomfortable watching her in a performance and her teammates always need to put a lot of time on her
Air su doesnt deserve to get top 60 you know this show is about talent not only visual. I know mostly like 48 project is about cuteness but Kiki Xu prove it not and Xinran song looks really try the best as well not like Air su that like lazy and not motivated girl. She just got lucky vote from her Wota fans.
@@flipflop2628 Relax, it's really not that deep. When I said I prefer Air Su over Xinran and Momo, it's just personality-wise because she's actually hella funny and I enjoyed her dynamics with LYX. I never said I wanted her in Top 60. I even disliked her at first and only began to "get" her when it was almost elimination time. And as much as I hate to admit, it's a popularity contest and not a talent show. If they really cared so much about talent, Xinran wouldn't have gone as far as Top 20, not even Top 35 imo. There are lots of trainees who have actual personality and are much more talented than most of the SNH girls - and they still got left out from Top 60. Kiki, Eliwa and Three are really good and I like them (also Diamond and Tako to a degree), but the rest are mediocre at best.
@@oopsithinkimfrench Air Su with Liu Yu Xin were literally a comedy duo throughout the show lol The calm and collected Xin Liu meets the deadly singer Air Su! Also agree with your second part. If this truly were a talent show we know damn well Esther Yu wouldnt have ranked #1 twice in the ranking announcements
I really dk how Air Su is an idol...she only got the looks and honestly showed that she is not talented in rap and vocals. Her dance is also not outstanding enough to outshine her flaws.
Because her group (48) use different system unlike another girlgroup which is already debut with skillful. 48 Group start with 0 (can't dance, sing, etc) and their fans see the improvement of the members
hey but she's trying? and she's gotten this far already... no hate but i dont think any of us common people can do that well either? so let's just appreciate them all!! :DD
Way to judge her when you don't know how much she has improved. It's weird how people like you judge her only on her looks. Makes me think you are jealous of how beautiful she is.
I still can't move-on on their performance "WANT TO SEE YOU" and I still feel it's a bit unfair for Zoe Wang who almost sang the whole song but is in the last place while two members who sounds tone-deaf which includes Air Su has higher rank than the talented ones hmmm
I know he doesn't really have talent. but, I think his enthusiasm is good enough to be praised. at least when she was on the stage she wasn't bad enough. maybe, she has to study even harder if he wants to be an idol. 😊
I actually want to ask Air Su fans, is her inability to sing due to lack of proper training? (Ex: did SNH48 not give her proper vocal training and thus she never learnt to sing) Or is it because she has a condition that prevents her from being to sing on tune? (Some people are just tone-deaf so its really hard for them to sing properly) Not judging either way, just curious, because if its the first one then SNH48 or her manager should set her up with a vocal coach so people wont make fun of her or meme about her anymore.
She sing well in her first performance in grain in ear I can't believe xinran song choose air su to be her teammate even xinran know she can't sing but she still choose her
@@bIinkue Xinran is pretty close to Air su. She wouldn't ignore her friend xD The first performance wasn't live singing (it was a dance stage and voice record) so it was better than other performances...
She likes an alien that want to intervent this show, the weirdest girl i've ever seen in my life. There are so many girl deserve to get top 60 than her. Even Xin liu gave up and looks pissed off to her. Nobody want to join her team at "i want to see you" song and when she joined into "Lion" team everyone shocked like wtf!
Excuse you how do you know if they are really pissed off plus air su tried her best and everything atleast she has the audacity to challenge herself I really adore air su because on her first singing performance it was very shocking,funny, and awkward n embarassing but atleast air su didn't think about it that much for me it will be embarrassing spacially In front of many people and I would always think about it in a negative way but instead air su just put aside that and focus on what she gotta do or what she wants to be, she maybe not be a good singer nor dancer but she can be really entertaining to all of us thats all 👍 Edit: shes also very good at guitars
@@Roxelsy did you watch the whole episodes. There are an episode which some of trainee choose theme song and her team and nobody want join into air su team. So the trainees that havent joined any team have no choice except join air su. And there are moment which air su choose join into Lion team and mostly they are surprised and you see Xinliu's expression atm. If only she is not from SNH48 most likely she will be the 1st eliminated
![[ENG] Selfless Mentor Liu Yuxin for 'MISS YOU 3000' teams in Youth with you EP 12](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/TcH1ZThY43I/mqdefault.jpg)
![พบรัก - INK WARUNTORN x FELLOW FELLOW [LIVE SESSION]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1VonHhP6_Y8/mqdefault.jpg)
Okay but that ‘attention’ was breathtaking omg
I think so tooo
Time stamp
don't want to be mean but it's just funny how bad she is, it's like any random person is better than her
ELLA IS SUCH A KIND AND PATIENT AND HELPFUL AND CUTE MENTOR
Xin Liu and Ma Shujun helped her until 3 am? Wow Xin Liu you are really an angel😍
Teacher Liu trying to back her up but even God Xin can’t help her sorry.
I still can't move-on on their performance "WANT TO SEE YOU" and I still feel it's a bit unfair for Zoe Wang who almost sang the whole song but is in the last place while two members who sounds tone-deaf which includes Air Su has higher rank than the talented ones hmmm
Agree
Actually according to the people who watched the live performance, Air Su didn't sound as bad as the video they posted up. Fans found out that for this group both for team A and B, iQiYi edited them to sound like they messed up live but they didn't. NaHo and DDD's voices didn't crack live, nor was Air Su off key for the whole performance. They messed up during the rehearsals and they used that audio to put in the video they put in the episode and youtube, but in the live version, both groups did great which is why NaHo got such a high vote.
@@musicpandarajsol5933 where can i hear?
@@musicpandarajsol5933 LOL I WASN'T NOT TALKING ABOUT NAHO NOR DDD LMAO
I WAS PERTAINING TO MENGLU AND AIR SU !!!!! Air su's voice is mediocre. There are some trainees who're more talented than her. Don't know why she still on the show. Talking about bias system
@@VirjScarlett what.... she already be eliminated .......
No wonder Liu Yu Xin was so surprised Air Su wanted to challenge her in a song that's more vocal-based.
Air Su knows that she doesn't excel in vocal or rap, but she does work very hard and at least tries, even if it doesn't sound as great as it could. like she said, she was practicing her lines until 3:00, she knows that she's not on the same level as everyone else. plus she can take the criticism lightly and laugh instead of taking it hard. i don't think she was fit to compete on the show, but i actually kind of miss her, because she's a great entertainer :)
Agreed! She's definitely one of the comedic highlights
I mean, she’s really bad. Maybe she’s tone deaf? I liked the fact that she always worked hard, I mean, she tried to get better. Unfortunately, some people just weren’t born to be a singer. Maybe with a loooot of practice, she could actually become good. But she was definitely not ready to be part of this competition (comparing her chances to debut with the other girls). I hope the best for because she seems like a great girl. Im happy that Xin Liu didn’t give up on her and tried to help her!
I bet you didnt watch the whole episodes of this show. Let say Joey that also lack of skill either sing/dance but she always want to learn from the other trainees and really stressed out when she cant do it well and we cant see it in Air su. She is like ignorant person, not motivated and just a burden for a team
@@flipflop2628 i never said that she was the best trainee or anything. ofc she wasn't very motivated im just saying she was funny and i liked watching her. she tried her best (kinda), even if her best isn't that good lmao. i just don't think everyone should be bashing her for being untalented. like she was nice to everyone idk why ppl hate her.
@@renjunswhore8534 i dont like her but i never say i hate her. I pity for the team who teamed up with her. Even Xinliu must spared her time just only taught her and she kept messed up. Besides, she already confessed that actually she entered snh48 just because accident, she said she cant sing nor dance. If i was her i wont ever to attend this show. Idk maybe her teammates invite her to join with them so we cant blame her aswell
Am I the only one who noted Yu Xin was also singing without microphone when Air Su sang her part?
I can't believe I'm saying this, but I kinda miss Air Su. She's entertainment gold 😂😂😂 I prefer her over Momo and Xinran. Lol. I know they're much more popular and a tad bit more "talented" than her, but they're so boring.
But i admit that XinRan and Air Su visual is stunning haha
I personally dont miss her for a bit. She's just so bad, I always feel uncomfortable watching her in a performance and her teammates always need to put a lot of time on her
Air su doesnt deserve to get top 60 you know this show is about talent not only visual. I know mostly like 48 project is about cuteness but Kiki Xu prove it not and Xinran song looks really try the best as well not like Air su that like lazy and not motivated girl. She just got lucky vote from her Wota fans.
@@flipflop2628 Relax, it's really not that deep. When I said I prefer Air Su over Xinran and Momo, it's just personality-wise because she's actually hella funny and I enjoyed her dynamics with LYX. I never said I wanted her in Top 60. I even disliked her at first and only began to "get" her when it was almost elimination time.
And as much as I hate to admit, it's a popularity contest and not a talent show. If they really cared so much about talent, Xinran wouldn't have gone as far as Top 20, not even Top 35 imo. There are lots of trainees who have actual personality and are much more talented than most of the SNH girls - and they still got left out from Top 60. Kiki, Eliwa and Three are really good and I like them (also Diamond and Tako to a degree), but the rest are mediocre at best.
@@oopsithinkimfrench Air Su with Liu Yu Xin were literally a comedy duo throughout the show lol
The calm and collected Xin Liu meets the deadly singer Air Su!
Also agree with your second part. If this truly were a talent show we know damn well Esther Yu wouldnt have ranked #1 twice in the ranking announcements
Xin liiuuuuuu xin liuii
Xin liu so cool!! 😁👍
can tell that she is trying to help air su with her rhythm :D she was low-key singing beside air su when it was her turn
I really dk how Air Su is an idol...she only got the looks and honestly showed that she is not talented in rap and vocals. Her dance is also not outstanding enough to outshine her flaws.
Because her group (48) use different system unlike another girlgroup which is already debut with skillful. 48 Group start with 0 (can't dance, sing, etc) and their fans see the improvement of the members
hey but she's trying? and she's gotten this far already... no hate but i dont think any of us common people can do that well either? so let's just appreciate them all!! :DD
Way to judge her when you don't know how much she has improved. It's weird how people like you judge her only on her looks. Makes me think you are jealous of how beautiful she is.
@@ginahatim3088 I love Air Su more than kiki and diamond . i cannot explain becoz all person got her favorite girl..
I still can't move-on on their performance "WANT TO SEE YOU" and I still feel it's a bit unfair for Zoe Wang who almost sang the whole song but is in the last place while two members who sounds tone-deaf which includes Air Su has higher rank than the talented ones hmmm
Ella!
I know he doesn't really have talent. but, I think his enthusiasm is good enough to be praised. at least when she was on the stage she wasn't bad enough. maybe, she has to study even harder if he wants to be an idol. 😊
He?
@@liz4775 thnk u. Your corection... 👍👋😊
I actually want to ask Air Su fans, is her inability to sing due to lack of proper training? (Ex: did SNH48 not give her proper vocal training and thus she never learnt to sing) Or is it because she has a condition that prevents her from being to sing on tune? (Some people are just tone-deaf so its really hard for them to sing properly) Not judging either way, just curious, because if its the first one then SNH48 or her manager should set her up with a vocal coach so people wont make fun of her or meme about her anymore.
she is tone-deaf
She sing well in her first performance in grain in ear I can't believe xinran song choose air su to be her teammate even xinran know she can't sing but she still choose her
She's definitely tone-deaf. For others or most of snh girls do lack proper training.
@@bIinkue Xinran is pretty close to Air su. She wouldn't ignore her friend xD The first performance wasn't live singing (it was a dance stage and voice record) so it was better than other performances...
Thank you for posting this video 💕
But how can you upload a part of the new episode, when it’s not even aired yet ?
I think this is part of VIP
like ur works,awsome ?ε?
Thank you
Um may I know if this is a content for VIP account only?
Yess
Is it only on vip?
Yes
She likes an alien that want to intervent this show, the weirdest girl i've ever seen in my life. There are so many girl deserve to get top 60 than her. Even Xin liu gave up and looks pissed off to her. Nobody want to join her team at "i want to see you" song and when she joined into "Lion" team everyone shocked like wtf!
everyone was suffered lololol
Excuse you how do you know if they are really pissed off plus air su tried her best and everything atleast she has the audacity to challenge herself I really adore air su because on her first singing performance it was very shocking,funny, and awkward n embarassing but atleast air su didn't think about it that much for me it will be embarrassing spacially In front of many people and I would always think about it in a negative way but instead air su just put aside that and focus on what she gotta do or what she wants to be, she maybe not be a good singer nor dancer but she can be really entertaining to all of us thats all 👍
Edit: shes also very good at guitars
@@Roxelsy did you watch the whole episodes. There are an episode which some of trainee choose theme song and her team and nobody want join into air su team. So the trainees that havent joined any team have no choice except join air su. And there are moment which air su choose join into Lion team and mostly they are surprised and you see Xinliu's expression atm.
If only she is not from SNH48 most likely she will be the 1st eliminated
and your a sinophobic alien