I love how this show doesn’t discriminate against women that don’t look follow the stereotype of what a “girl should be like” like. WE STAN ALL OUR QUEENS. Edit: As well, I’m so happy that the girls are given equal chances no matter their hairstyle, style preference and appearance in general. I’m so happy that our talented “different” (aka not the expectation of a girl group look) ladies such as XinLiu, K Lu, Frhanm Shanguan, Yu Zhang, NineOne etc. made it after round 2 elimination. These queens are killing their performances and bring so much to the table. They are free to express their individuality which is another reason why I love the show. I’m so happy that they were accepted so warmly by the fans and the show. (Of course there are some fans that dislike them, but you can’t please everyone)
That’s why chinese is better than Korean . They don’t change the girls they help the the girls to be who they should be. But I’m Korea, they have their own ideal even if the girl is good but if they are unsatisfying then they wouldn’t choose that girl.
@@ronaldoggha1801 true. Your statement reminds me of how yg entertainment forced Rose (from Blackpink) to sing with a cute and small voice instead of using her natural deep and beautiful voice.
Why people hating on the center? Just bcs she's not as feminine and girly compared to others but i'm glad she was picked as the center. People need to realise in this industry, we should appreciate any kind of styles that woman can potray. She's cool, she got the style, she got the visual and she's talented. I couldn't agree more that she definitely deserve this position in the theme song. All the best to all the participants! P/s : to those who were saying "where is the hate comments, i can't see it lol" oh believe me, when i commented this, some people really throw some shades on her, you can even find some under the replies. So do better bfr you comment. But i'm glad the comment section are now flooded with love towards Xin Liu, bcs that's what this talented girl deserves.
Nabila H Personally I don't like her cuz I watched another show, she was so rude and impolite, didn't have the virtue to be a center or a leader. I don't like her not because she's not feminine enough. Just know her more.
@@myhappiness260 they would send their girls in pink dress which look very feminine tbh... Although I like pink but its truth, people have a mindset that girls look good only in pink... Idk why???
you right, first impression me for her : she cool, handsome, so hot, i love her, maybe I CAN BE LESBIAN ( hahaha). but now : she beautiful, pretty, cute, still cool, hot AND DOPE (i love her)
I really appreciate this Survival show. 1. They didn't force the girls to change their looks. No pressure, in fact they welcome individuality. 2. Not force skirts on anyone who didn't want to wear it. 3. Diet was optional, you manage your own weight. 4. I feel they were more caring in terms of mental health. 5. Talent is focus and trainee personality and hard work was highlighted. Mentors dynamic was great and they really care for trainees so they push them. Congratulations on this show iQiyi! I know it was hard producing this with the pandemic and all but this is a great show many enjoying during their isolations. Trainees are amazing as well, good luck to their future.
Did u watch idol producer 1 where cai xukun was center? It's really good and no evil editing and stuff. Everyone's funny too. And yes, some of them got fat from eating lolol
I really like the center. She's got the most stable dance lines. Her charisma is dazzling. Talent, skill and charm. She's definitely one of my picks. Main dancer title is hers!
I knoww shes look really pretty 😍, btw why is she wearing pants and the other wear's skirt? I didnt catch up the show, but she's still look freakin pretty and cute af 😍
@@maisya7246 she was wearing a skirt in the rehearsal but when filming the actual thing they got her to change to shorts. There're other ppl wearing shorts as well. I guess its just whatever they're comfortable with
Just an observation I made: Korean girl survival shows tend to be slightly more targeted toward the male audience while the Chinese versions seem to be more for girls
Yes. As a Chinese male, while I have to say some are pretty, I have no interest in actually spending any money for them. I’d rather play league of legends.
Can we appreciate the high quality of Chinese programs? The song, lyrics, choreography, lighting, cinematography, editing, and especialy trainee talents! I wonder how much more we do not know of China since it's not reported or portrayed well by Western media. Let's support Asia!
@@teal2111 they can not judge China objectively. Yes, there are bad sides for all countries, but it seems that they tend to exaggerate everything happened in China through a negative perspective, that is insane. When I was living in western countries almost ten years, I always doubted the China they illustrated is the one where I grew up???
@@vina530 in fact, the virus can be born anywhere in the earth, we do not blame US for H1N1 and HIV , Congo for Ebora. The most important is how to stop its spread, this requires ppl to work together instead of blaming each other for political reasons.
@Da Orange yeah, they also think chinese ppl are brainwashed, but we do really know the bad sides of china, limit freedom of speech,etc, and we keep criticizing it and arguing how to make society more justice. Overall i believe my country is not evil, it is just a normal country who try to improve the richness and living standard of people. TBH, some chinese are not that civilized specially those older guys, they lack of knowledge on how to behave properly and respect other cultures.
For me, who has watched a lot of Korean survival shows, this show is a great show. It showcases diversity in personalities and also appearances. It's difference in sense that it allows and accepts all types of girls. Like Kun and Lisa said, not all girls are the same and it's more about who they are. I love it, I love the message that the show and mentors gives to the trainees. I'm really enjoying the show. And I really like how there isn't like evil editing and I'm surprised at how the girls do as well on stage and in voting. There's a lot of twists and I like that it doesn't seem like looks is important as the korean versions. Like they really do look at talent and how well they perform on stage. P.S. What Kun and the show allowed in ep 8, I cried. Like Korea would never have let class F do that.
Yeah I’ve been watching ever since idol producer the very first produce series in China til now I think this is the 5th/6th season already and is really good
Tea. I didn't watch the full episodes of the Chinese version but I watched a lot of clips and I can think they're even doing better than the korean versions. In the Korean versions, they might let many girls be themselves but unless they're feminine, they won't let them have the center. And most of the time, they actually define girlgroups.
Not all girls are feminine; Not all girls are cute; Not all girls can wear skirts; We all have our own preference in our life & Youth With You trainees proved it
I really like the fact that they choose a non feminine girl to be the center, chinese girls seems really nice, if it was in Korea she would received a lot of bad comments even from the trainees but in the 1st episode I noticed that she received a lot of praises from the girls
It's great seeing so many diverse, potential idols take the stage and really show their talent. The one idol wearing glasses especially caught my attention!
I personally adore the girl in the center. She is really adorable. She's obviously good enough for the person who CHOSE her to be there so she certainly doesn't need your approval. Yall some haters.
Hating on bp is what useless people do Excuse you, did I @ you? If not then nobody is talking to you. If you read the comments below, there are haters. So if you ain’t hatin then keep it moving bc I ain’t talkin to u
Hey, I definitely agree with you and I wanted to enlighten you on something: actually all the contestants voted for the person that they think would be the best center and majority voted for her! So she was chosen by her teammates and got approved by the mentors as well :)
I love how in China the trainee are comfortable to talk with their mentors in Korea trainee are scared to death even to look at mentors at China the mentor even tease and teach in balanced way without letting their confidence down by shouting harshly if done some mistake
Exactly! It was right 😀😀😃 AND ALSO mostly korea talks up to cuteness .. I don't mean that korea doesn't have sick beats or rappers .. But they doesn't get promoted or famous as in china😀😁😄😄
Like the teachers keep hitting and pressing down their confidence becuz of keep commenting on them but the Chinese one are like giving them confidence and kun STAYED up to 4:00am to replace Lisa and teach the trainees
They actually let people wear shorts instead of skirts. I felt bad for SUNNEE in the other girl show because she had to suck it up even when she don’t want to. I am glad this show gave them the freedom.
i prefer Chinese survival shows than Korean. Chinese doesn't have that specific beauty standard wherein everybody gets to shine pretty or not, jk everyone is beautiful.
Zai Belli Produce 101 China. She, SUNNEE, is that blonde short haired girl. She is half Taiwanese and half Thai. She did debut in that show’s temporary group called Rocket Girls 101.
Not to be that fan and I’m not saying there together at all but I think it’s funny that Lisa and him changed their brown hair color to black around the same time
When kun is standing up the stage and introduce himself as pd, this is really touching because he was one of the trainees from this stage before. He listened to LAY to say the same words before and now he stand on this stage as pd for all the participants behind. So touched me. Fighting kun pd!😭
today I was in the mirror and this song suddenly passed in my head. 2 years ago I memorized the movement of this song, But I forgot. I went back to look again, however, a feeling of emotion appeared instantly made me nostalgic🙂 I'm proud to have been a producers youth with you❤️
i don't know why but I've already watched survival shows like pd101, idol producer, etc. but I feel like this is the first time I'm gonna cry if someone gets eliminated. I mean look at this girls! different looks, different talents, and different personalities that made me so into them all! I just wanna see them like that on stage. but it's a competition so.....
and i personally think that these girls are graded fairly, it doesn't matter with the looks, the visuals, they really focus on what the girl is capable of, and how great she is.
@@luhreyroseadajar3675 and this is what makes this show all the more better! Mentors that actually recognise the value of talent and natural stage charisma
thats the charm of idol producer/youth with you series. Season 1 of Idol producer with Cai Xukun was amazing..easily one of my favs because all the trainees were unique, lovable and absolutely hilarious. Season 2 was a bit dull and I couldn't get through it but it seems that Iqiyi learned from their mistakes and are following a similar formula to season 1 with the new girl's season which is great
It’s cool that let the girls choose if they want to wear shorts or a skirt. They’re not forced into this girly concept that they have to display. It reminds me of f(x) when amber can always wore shorts compare to the other members.
Did everyone forget what lisa said about the center position??? She said that center is not Just a visual, they are more than that. That girl is talented and that is the only thing that matters so haters can shut up.
@Redrowan 3 yeah pity votes...if there was a disabled dancer, she'd win it, and comments would praise her even more. Only fair way is to make it about talent and nothing else.
Simon hollad wow you’re probably that person that would go up to a black Harvard student and say that the only reason they got accepted is out of pity for their skin colour lol. She got center because of her talent both judges and trainees voted her as the center wether you like it or not she’s talented but your insecure ass can’t handle the fact that a girl who gets more compliments than you on being handsome is getting recognition
@@Momobibii True!! And I really love her overall personality. So bubbly behind the camera, and when she's on stage she's so comfortable and confident while performing 🔥.
The center was questioned on why she didn’t wear a skirt and she said it was because she wanted to show that you don’t have to wear feminine clothes to be beautiful and that everyone has their on style. I feel like she should def be one of the members chosen.
Best idol survivor show ever. Showed lots of sides to the girls and there were a lot of friendships made. No toxic drama and all the girls supported each other.
This is the best idol project I have ever watched. The dance is spectacular, the song has a deep meaning to it, it encourages and empower girls especially and also well conducted.
This is much better than korean survival shows, the girls are very funny, no evil editing, they support each other, I love the mentors and especially the girls are very talented and had their own charm. Visuals on point and they are not forced to do such thing like diet, the center girl is the example, she is being herself. Overall I love this show a lot!
@Amelia PAU [07S2] hate?? LOL I'm just sick of some Chinese and YWY fans comparing this show with Korean PD series and look down on Korean people. they're so arrogant.
@@prashantrana6537 after being strick she got sooo many hates and she just pretend n9t t9 be strick other shows and people again hate her cuz she was good with boys
Yes only those who haven't watched the show will say xin liu don't deserve the center position. Those who watch the show will understand why she is the center and most deserving person.
Amy Ding Still don’t think she should’ve been center. Based on what Lisa said about the center, she just doesn’t fit the role. She doesn’t embody the song or the essence of all the girls. Frhanm was much better suited for the role, she is different from what a normal girl group member looks like, while still being able to bring the cutesy vibe the song has.
@@jdgames9622 Lisa said the theme song is a cute song which is totally different from her style but she was able to show her own style and she is different from other girls. Lisa also said she don't have any problem if she get A. Other judges also gave her A. you have watched the show that means you also known the reason why other girls voted her to be the center. For me xin liu is center because she showed her own style, can be cute and can attract other with her performance.
Actually she deserved to be a center. She makes the dance so easy. She is one of the most stable and has visual as well. Honestly, i only watched the show bec of Lisa but the longer I watched it, I've got to know the girls and how they want to improved their skills. I like how diverse this show is. It's breaking stereotypes on how a girl group should be. Goodluck to all participants! *sorry for my English *
If u want to know more about Xin Liu, the centre girl wearing shorts instead of skirt… PLZ read this, she is my one pick and i want to let u all know how good she is… Xin Liu, born in 1997, she is only 22 now even she might look more mature than her age. This is because she left home at the age of 12 for her dancing dream. She went to Beijing to have more opportunity. She is one of the best female popping dancer in Asia now and popping master Lin meng is her teacher. It is very brave for her to choose popping, as u all know popping is a type of dance that needs supper strong energy and muscles to control ur body, so its usually harder for girls than boys to learn popping. But Xin Liu wants people to know how strong and powerful girls could also be. 2012, Xin Liu participated in a competition called "Go Up! Junior" （向上吧！少年）and won the Most Upward Junior Award, famous idol like Kiku, or Karry Wang and Jackson Yee from the TFboys, and even one of the coach from “Youth with You”, Kun also attend this competition show, but Xin is the winner of that show, her dancing skills impressed everyone. But almost everyone from that show are famous idols now, except the winner Xin. 😢 2013, Xin participated in the competition of "Dancing Forest Fighting Hegemony" of Oriental Satellite TV's dance competition, and won all the votes of the four judges.But nothing changes, even she is so good at dancing, and won lots of trophies, still, no one knows her. So for her stage dream, she started to try to be an idol, she improved her singing skills, learnt rap, b-box, passes 8th grade for piano, and finally she became a member of a girl group called “Lady Bees” with other 6 girls. But sadly, “Lady Bees” went quiet after they releases their group album and went on some concerts in 2017. So after that, Xin starts to make her own music and had her first single “Feel Good” in March of 2018, she then released her first album EP “Xin”, one of my favorite songs is “hot party”, you should try listen to it. Even though, Xin is still just nobody. She worked so hard these years, learnt skills she never tried before, Ballet、choreography and so on. Now, Xin is on “Youth with You”, this is the 10th year after she left home, she said “ If this still won’t work this time, I might just gave up and go back home” before she went on the show. So please please PLEASE VOTE for her if you like her or think she is good at dancing and singing ! PLEASE ! Also, even if your not gonna vote for her, THANK YOU for just reading all of this.🙏🙏🙏
The produce show in korea is all about beauty/visual while in China it's all about the talent that makes the trainees confident and beautiful. This show is really about empowering women i love all the trainees and their confidence.🥰
I can see why she’s the center. Her dancing, facial expressions, charm and charisma is on point. Not to mention, she also has the visuals. And from the start, she already got me hooked when she smiled. That was a simple smile but she looked really charming 🌟
We don't define girls, we don't define girl groups. How they picked the centre based on talent and potential is reflecting their own mantra, action speaks louder than words. All the best!
Dt eh The mentors didn’t pick the center.. the other trainees did.. and that’s what they mean.. The mentors doesn’t pick or define girls and girl groups.. Audience and trainees does.. 🤷🏼♀️
The centre is pretty. She also got skills.She was chosen to be the centre.It's not like she have forced it or something.I don’t get it, why some people are hating her.
this is the first time ever I see a music survival show that has this diversity. Wow I’m impressed and very happy because their talents will not be defined or limited by appearances.
I can experience the variety of beauties in Chinese show. Instead of sticking to those typical stereotypes, they let everyone shine & give chances to express their own characters. The physical appearances don’t define who you are. I am also a woman who love boyish styles. At the end of day, how comfortable and confident in yourself is most important.. Still cheering for all the girls!!!!
this survival show is waaaay better than all the korean ones... all the trainees are treated like humans with feelings and the mentors are great, like they are strict bc that’s their job, but they’re also so supportive and kind with them
Lisa did a great job as a mentor and the girls were also amazing couldn't stop watching their dance and the sequence between them matches so well with each other ❤😊
here are the trainees that debutted: 1) 1:13 Liu Yu Xin 刘雨昕 2) 3:11 Esther Yu 虞书欣 3) 2:39 Kiki Xu 许佳琪 4) 1:32 Yu Yan 喻言 5) 1:35 Shaking 谢可寅 6) 1:29 Babymonster An 安崎 7) 2:47 Zhao Xiao Tang 赵小棠 8) 2:50 Snow Kong 孔雪儿 9) 2:34 K Lu 陆柯燃 (on the right of the screen)
I'm already loving the lineup of contestants. We have a variety of girls, not just cute girls or girls who go by society's standards of being a woman. I think that is why they emphasized, "We do not define girls, we do not define girl groups."
if yall actually compared liu yuxin's focus cam with others, you'll see why she's chosen. she's the most stable among all. her dance is clean, she's not a try-hard, chill during the entire tiring performance, and yet hits all the beats precisely.
She made the dance look sooooo easy, but then when I try it for myself I nearly broke my spine. Some other girls did really well but they tried too hard and the dance just didn't look as clean
that's right. At the first time, i was impressed by Kiki but now, I'm completely a fan of Xin Liu! She is new face and it's hard to compete with others who already had reputation. Xin Liu deserves to be Center, she has tried so hard. Well done !
@@hathanh5128Xiu Liu is not really a "new face". She debut before and had been on some variety shows, but she is very skilled and she totally deserves to be center.
She was one of the best and she gave it her own vibe which is what I appreciated the most tbh, but have you see Dream Catcher's Handong? She did beautifuly uwu♡
we true chinese r supported diversity n equility, we dont discriminate skin colors n gentle. we support for being ourselves. pls stay away from media who creating chinese hatred.
Zakiya Awad things may be not so easy to say especially when you look from outside. I was two times in xinjiang province last years. To better understand the situation, please go there and talk to the locals, find yourself an opinion.
At first I don't understand why Xin Liu is the center. But when I watch the whole episode I think she's just too OP to be in this show LOL she's unbeatable.
Xin Liu was the center of theme song “Yes OK” and now she debuted as center of “The9”. Reward came as not just by uplifting yourself but the people around you. Once a selfless trainee, and now an outstanding center. Congrats to all YWY trainees. You make our summer meaningful.
yes and she's one of those trainees who started literally from the bottom, when you noticed her rank in the first week she's top 25 but as the show goes on people noticed her charisma and stage presence which lead her to be top 1 at the end and be the9's official center.
I think the winks in Korea pd48 are somehow cringe. If like 1 or 2 people do it, it's for me fine. But in pd48 literally everyone does it, that's why I prefer Qin chun you ni 2 more.
Liu Xin as the center is a breath of fresh air. I'm not even complaining. those who are complaining can't do anything anymore since it's already done. i don't know how she is chosen as the center but im glad she is the center.
@@limserene4358 yes, i know her full name. i just wrote it in short cut since most Chinese full name seems to always come in 3 syllables making it a bit harder to memorised for us non Chinese speaking.
Ok can we talk about how underrated Frhanm is?? She literally got the 2nd most votes to be centre, and yet she got so much less screen time than the other girls in A. They showed Babymonster An and even Joey Chua (who was placed in D!!) more times than Frhanm wtf it's so unfair. She's such an amazing leader and she always gives the most inspiring speeches. She can sing, dance, and rap, and all the girls love her. She honestly deserves so much more
Yes!! I don't know if you've seen the last episode but (spoiler) she ranks number 10!! And first place goes to Esther Yu, who (let's be honest) doesn't sing and dance as well as the other girls and was placed in D 3 times in a row. The diferences between them is that Ester Yu has lots of Screen time and even has some episodes named after her and Frhanm doesn't. Frhanm is my favourite and I agree with you, she deserves so much more.
this is because I have seen more variety in chinese girl groups (one of the judges is part of one which was extremely popular when I was growing up) outside of survival shows alone. kpop companies are not exactly the kind to shy away from choosing visuals in hoping they would be talented or worth their money.
Kkura Chan Are you referring to S.H.E? The 3 girls in the group are so diverse. Even Ella herself said that she is the one that “balanced” the group. I couldn’t agree more. She was my favourite out of the three.
5:02 can we just take a minute to appreciate this gorgeous empowering woman? She’s so unique and strong. Her words of breaking the girl stereotype and creating a new vision for women is so amazing. Like I’m in love-
Louis Z well you can’t please everyone, haters are gonna hate, what’s important is to keep your head held high and keep on moving forward knowing that there are people who do love you 😘
The girl in 5:02 is in class A.She has strong power and performs quite well on the preliminary rating stage.Her name is ShangGuanXiai. Here is her solo performance ,at 1:02→th-cam.com/video/NymkQldDGGA/w-d-xo.html
@Troll77 Neptune well have you seen the practice video for the trainees? lisa dance to this song! furthermore, lisa is the dance mentor, her style will be more or less affect the outcome. and btw, just type lisa, not necessary to put her name in symbol, what is lisa? a rude word that you must use symbol like da*n? or bit*h? just type lisa like normal
Xin liu has born to be center!! Her charm, her talent, her uniqe style, her kindess, her personality so perfectly, she's an angel indeed!! if she get million viewers on youtube thats as expected, international fans are crazy with her, X QUEEN WHO MAKES US CRAZY LET'S DEBUT!!!
This show is so much more friendly than the korean prod series. The girls are so different and they seem to have a genuine bond and want to help each other out... Korea made it appear a lot more like a stiff competition and the editing made it look more so. Plus the mentors here seem a lot warmer towards the trainees
Each Korean participants are also friendly, they are the encouragements for each other and devotional and most are willing to give up their position. It is just the editing, right?
@@theunknownchannel8166 the whole Korean produce series was taken from a Japanese survival show anyway, and korea probably isn't the first to produce survival shows
This is the best girl survival show I ever watch in China because theyre not all act cute they're act as their self. Edited:They have their own charm and this is also my favorite girl version of survival show too. Edited:For those disagree of xin Liu for being center please don't hate her it's 2020 guys and we need to change like how lisa say that center is not about cuteness its about who you are ok so don't hate xin Liu.
@@EternityRoV It's complicated but officially it is not part of Produce 101 franchise so you can say they have copied a few things from the Produce series (read more here www.soompi.com/article/1152831wpp/frapa-acknowledges-similarities-produce-101-idol-producer). There is an official Produce 101 china if you're interested (a girl version where 2 girls from WJSN competed). Tbh Idol Producer (Now called Youth With You) is by far the best "Produce" series tho. All seasons are worth a watch.
Roxanne Vasquez actually is not copied but anyways this is their 5th/6th season of produce series in China the previous season in season 1 is the guy from the very beginning giving the speech his name is caixukun he is also one of the contestants in season 1 , and after that they have season 2 , produce 101 girls China , 创造营
edited: the idea that their are contestants who already admit to themselves that they aren't *ordinary* and still entered the show knowing who ever will be part of the group will be named as *girl* group. Such strong attitudes. Salute to them
there are actually a number of boyish Chinese girls joining survival shows. the one I remember the most is Sunnee from produce 101 China, she's boyish with boy cut hair too and she actually won. The center here might actually have a chance to debut as well.
![[ENG sub] PRODUCE48 [최초공개] 프로듀스48_내꺼야(PICK ME) Performance 180615 EP.0](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/UOmolLOQ7Rs/mqdefault.jpg)
I love how this show doesn’t discriminate against women that don’t look follow the stereotype of what a “girl should be like” like. WE STAN ALL OUR QUEENS. Edit: As well, I’m so happy that the girls are given equal chances no matter their hairstyle, style preference and appearance in general. I’m so happy that our talented “different” (aka not the expectation of a girl group look) ladies such as XinLiu, K Lu, Frhanm Shanguan, Yu Zhang, NineOne etc. made it after round 2 elimination. These queens are killing their performances and bring so much to the table. They are free to express their individuality which is another reason why I love the show. I’m so happy that they were accepted so warmly by the fans and the show. (Of course there are some fans that dislike them, but you can’t please everyone)
True but 90% are 😄
Yes I really agree with you👍✌️
@@luccsk26 费沁源
哈哈哈外国朋友言外之意选了一堆丑人👍
王杨杨 as a women.. I said that the center still the coolest 🥰 #nohate
I like when he say “we don’t define girls, we don’t define girl groups”😭
That msg need to reach korea and their netz👏🏼
Very well said😘
That why I like Chinese produce more they don’t have a high standard like sk
That’s why chinese is better than Korean . They don’t change the girls they help the the girls to be who they should be. But I’m Korea, they have their own ideal even if the girl is good but if they are unsatisfying then they wouldn’t choose that girl.
@@ronaldoggha1801 true. Your statement reminds me of how yg entertainment forced Rose (from Blackpink) to sing with a cute and small voice instead of using her natural deep and beautiful voice.
GiyuShino UwU dumb ass
This have nothing to do with voices , idols sing we all type of voices
It’s just yg style.
Why people hating on the center? Just bcs she's not as feminine and girly compared to others but i'm glad she was picked as the center. People need to realise in this industry, we should appreciate any kind of styles that woman can potray. She's cool, she got the style, she got the visual and she's talented. I couldn't agree more that she definitely deserve this position in the theme song. All the best to all the participants!
P/s : to those who were saying "where is the hate comments, i can't see it lol" oh believe me, when i commented this, some people really throw some shades on her, you can even find some under the replies. So do better bfr you comment. But i'm glad the comment section are now flooded with love towards Xin Liu, bcs that's what this talented girl deserves.
Ikr, She is beautiful tho... I watch this show because of her
Not sure why! But she indeed deserve to be C! She got the visual and talent .
Nabila H because they are jealous 😗
Because some people still can't break away from the norms. It's about time for a change! :)
Nabila H Personally I don't like her cuz I watched another show, she was so rude and impolite, didn't have the virtue to be a center or a leader. I don't like her not because she's not feminine enough. Just know her more.
YWY2 let them wear the dress they are comfortable with. Mnet could never even think about it
This
Cuz korea never prefer a tomboy to join the show or even became center lol never
@@myhappiness260 they would send their girls in pink dress which look very feminine tbh... Although I like pink but its truth, people have a mindset that girls look good only in pink... Idk why???
The girl who is the center has a unique beauty
She is Xin liu
you right, first impression me for her : she cool, handsome, so hot, i love her, maybe I CAN BE LESBIAN ( hahaha). but now : she beautiful, pretty, cute, still cool, hot AND DOPE (i love her)
She really pretty right. I like to see she
She is a girl?
Or boy?
She is a girl
I really appreciate this Survival show. 1. They didn't force the girls to change their looks. No pressure, in fact they welcome individuality. 2. Not force skirts on anyone who didn't want to wear it. 3. Diet was optional, you manage your own weight. 4. I feel they were more caring in terms of mental health. 5. Talent is focus and trainee personality and hard work was highlighted. Mentors dynamic was great and they really care for trainees so they push them. Congratulations on this show iQiyi! I know it was hard producing this with the pandemic and all but this is a great show many enjoying during their isolations. Trainees are amazing as well, good luck to their future.
Did u watch idol producer 1 where cai xukun was center? It's really good and no evil editing and stuff. Everyone's funny too. And yes, some of them got fat from eating lolol
Potato ELF Fan Cheng Cheng. 😂😂 That clip of him eating then Zhengting drags him.
@@Tingling10 i miss you zhangjing and lin yanjun interactions T^T the bromance in IP was so adorable.
@@louisem.2447 i may just check them out. I only found this show because I'm fan of Lisa but now I evan have trainees I'm rooting for.
@@OfficialNAIB you should def try watching Idol Producer 1, it's a really good survival show. Just dive in without spoilers and you'll enjoy it.
I really like the center. She's got the most stable dance lines. Her charisma is dazzling. Talent, skill and charm. She's definitely one of my picks. Main dancer title is hers!
Big true!!!!! 💕😍
She's lit af! 🔥❤😍
she's an ace. she got top level poppin skills, vocal, compose, rap, piano and beat box. she can do everything
I knoww shes look really pretty 😍, btw why is she wearing pants and the other wear's skirt? I didnt catch up the show, but she's still look freakin pretty and cute af 😍
@@maisya7246 she was wearing a skirt in the rehearsal but when filming the actual thing they got her to change to shorts. There're other ppl wearing shorts as well. I guess its just whatever they're comfortable with
It's really pretty this dance
Good job Lisa will done ❤
Just an observation I made:
Korean girl survival shows tend to be slightly more targeted toward the male audience while the Chinese versions seem to be more for girls
yes in China girls spend more money for their idols, males love sporting and games
Chinese nerds love to play video games and make jokes about Koop-ish shows like this. This is very different from korean and japanese nerds.
Ofc,this show really make girls getting lesbian vibes by Xin Liu :)
Yes. As a Chinese male, while I have to say some are pretty, I have no interest in actually spending any money for them. I’d rather play league of legends.
@@bend386 I'm a female and even though I love Kpop groups, I won't spend money for them. I'd rather spend it on gaming and food 😁
Can we appreciate the high quality of Chinese programs? The song, lyrics, choreography, lighting, cinematography, editing, and especialy trainee talents! I wonder how much more we do not know of China since it's not reported or portrayed well by Western media. Let's support Asia!
Western media dominates the whole world social media and some of them are crazy about China
@@WINDYCHUNG What do you mean that they are crazy about China?
@@teal2111 they can not judge China objectively. Yes, there are bad sides for all countries, but it seems that they tend to exaggerate everything happened in China through a negative perspective, that is insane. When I was living in western countries almost ten years, I always doubted the China they illustrated is the one where I grew up???
@@vina530 in fact, the virus can be born anywhere in the earth, we do not blame US for H1N1 and HIV , Congo for Ebora. The most important is how to stop its spread, this requires ppl to work together instead of blaming each other for political reasons.
@Da Orange yeah, they also think chinese ppl are brainwashed, but we do really know the bad sides of china, limit freedom of speech,etc, and we keep criticizing it and arguing how to make society more justice. Overall i believe my country is not evil, it is just a normal country who try to improve the richness and living standard of people. TBH, some chinese are not that civilized specially those older guys, they lack of knowledge on how to behave properly and respect other cultures.
For me, who has watched a lot of Korean survival shows, this show is a great show. It showcases diversity in personalities and also appearances. It's difference in sense that it allows and accepts all types of girls. Like Kun and Lisa said, not all girls are the same and it's more about who they are. I love it, I love the message that the show and mentors gives to the trainees.
I'm really enjoying the show.
And I really like how there isn't like evil editing and I'm surprised at how the girls do as well on stage and in voting. There's a lot of twists and I like that it doesn't seem like looks is important as the korean versions. Like they really do look at talent and how well they perform on stage.
P.S. What Kun and the show allowed in ep 8, I cried. Like Korea would never have let class F do that.
Yeah I’ve been watching ever since idol producer the very first produce series in China til now I think this is the 5th/6th season already and is really good
Nah
Tea. I didn't watch the full episodes of the Chinese version but I watched a lot of clips and I can think they're even doing better than the korean versions.
In the Korean versions, they might let many girls be themselves but unless they're feminine, they won't let them have the center. And most of the time, they actually define girlgroups.
Totally agree with u.
I agree totally
Lisa did a great damn job mentoring u guys killed it love this 😍😍😍
Lisa was mentored on the dance as well.
Not all girls are feminine;
Not all girls are cute;
Not all girls can wear skirts;
We all have our own preference in our life & Youth With You trainees proved it
Ribelskiee 12 ya era hora de que se mostrara esto en este tipo de programas
Yeah and our Tomboy Amberrrr
@Marjorie Baldo lol same i can only wear skirts in school for the uniform but outside the school I wear clothes just like a boy 🤣
Marjorie Baldo yes haters are just haters and yuxin is what who she is and no one can change her
That goes for me as well. Im a girl but I hate wearing skirts and dresses. Just a preference ya'know
I really like the fact that they choose a non feminine girl to be the center, chinese girls seems really nice, if it was in Korea she would received a lot of bad comments even from the trainees but in the 1st episode I noticed that she received a lot of praises from the girls
Wait this is Chinese? I thought it's thai... Sorry I'm new
@@oof-uwu3796 yup it's Chinese
Cuz this is a Chinese survival program I think??
But yes this Chinese
Gigi Castro yeah it’s almost all the girls crush hhh
@ღAsel Secret Angelღ yea I'm wrong and I'm sorry for that I don't actually know to face of thai sorry (◞‸◟ㆀ)
@@oof-uwu3796 it's okay, I thought it was Thai too xD
No unnecessary winks, smirks and try hard facial expressions, just natural smiles and gestures. It's a first time a center act as a natural center.
A very cool center, dance in her own style
Sakura center in nekoyya :am i a joke to you??
we stan synchronize kpop group yesss only Sakura and liu xin did it
When I was a dancer we didn’t and could not do winks or anything like just dance sing and smile
i was really waiting for that to happen when i first watch this but to my pleasant surprise they didn't do any of that
It's great seeing so many diverse, potential idols take the stage and really show their talent. The one idol wearing glasses especially caught my attention!
I personally adore the girl in the center. She is really adorable. She's obviously good enough for the person who CHOSE her to be there so she certainly doesn't need your approval. Yall some haters.
Maytemb3r “Yall some haters”. Excuse me but i personally LOVE her, plus no one hated on her??
Hating on bp is what useless people do Excuse you, did I @ you? If not then nobody is talking to you. If you read the comments below, there are haters. So if you ain’t hatin then keep it moving bc I ain’t talkin to u
Hey, I definitely agree with you and I wanted to enlighten you on something: actually all the contestants voted for the person that they think would be the best center and majority voted for her! So she was chosen by her teammates and got approved by the mentors as well :)
@@pinkypunkyful that's awesome! she deserves it... she really is so cute
Maytemb3r All of them voted her to be there. the trainees
I love how in China the trainee are comfortable to talk with their mentors in Korea trainee are scared to death even to look at mentors at China the mentor even tease and teach in balanced way without letting their confidence down by shouting harshly if done some mistake
Exactly!
It was right 😀😀😃
AND ALSO mostly korea talks up to cuteness ..
I don't mean that korea doesn't have sick beats or rappers ..
But they doesn't get promoted or famous as in china😀😁😄😄
Yes
Push this comment up cuz I really appreciate it
@@美人盛世 yes!
Like the teachers keep hitting and pressing down their confidence becuz of keep commenting on them but the Chinese one are like giving them confidence and kun STAYED up to 4:00am to replace Lisa and teach the trainees
True
I can’t take my eyes off center, she’s charming.
She or He ?
@@yudigustiawan2759 She's a girl and her name is Xin Liu
Her name is Liu yu xin
@@yudigustiawan2759 This season for girls only. So of course she's a girl.
Gugunta Agree!
We all saw Lisa's struggle to train the girls. She's the best coach. She's kind and tough. She's done well.👏👏🌸🌸🌸🌸
They actually let people wear shorts instead of skirts. I felt bad for SUNNEE in the other girl show because she had to suck it up even when she don’t want to. I am glad this show gave them the freedom.
I know right. They should give girls option if they want skirt or shorts
i prefer Chinese survival shows than Korean. Chinese doesn't have that specific beauty standard wherein everybody gets to shine pretty or not, jk everyone is beautiful.
I know!! I was happy to see that too
Wich other show? Who is sunne?
Zai Belli
Produce 101 China. She, SUNNEE, is that blonde short haired girl. She is half Taiwanese and half Thai. She did debut in that show’s temporary group called Rocket Girls 101.
Everyone: Appreciates the diversity of each trainees and Xin Liu as the center.
Me: Wow, Kun is so handsome with black hair😍😍😍 He's so handsome.
Omg i thought i was the only one who liked his black hair 🥰🥰
Not to be that fan and I’m not saying there together at all but I think it’s funny that Lisa and him changed their brown hair color to black around the same time
@@chyane2314 it's just a coincidence. Nothing more, nothing less.😀
he's so damn handsome 🥺
@@chyane2314 I actually ship them (no hate)
The center is the prettiest baby ever!! She's adorable I don't care what anyone says
I dont think she want to be called adorable but coolest center ever but I could see the whole point. She is adorable for us! lol
@@Msztyllachara stop calling her adorable, You're worse then Hitler!!
@@Msztyllachara I'm glad they voted for her. Breath of fresh air!
@@simonhollad5511 are you on drugs dude 😂😂😂😂😂
@@simonhollad5511 you're in every comment just for speading hate
Get a life dude. You're pathetic
The girl in the center is very cool
People should should appreciate any styles
I love the center. She deserves it NO MATTER WHAT. That's it.
Yesss u right..
PERIODT.
When kun is standing up the stage and introduce himself as pd, this is really touching because he was one of the trainees from this stage before. He listened to LAY to say the same words before and now he stand on this stage as pd for all the participants behind. So touched me. Fighting kun pd!😭
Evon J ikr I’m so proud of him 😭😭
He was my first pick😭
I'm really happy the center is different from everyone else around her. She really stands out. Plus she is talented af and her visual is no joke.
that is why she got A right???
Aida Celmar She got A because of her dance skill, if you wanna say she is different you can watch the whole show, there is many girl with crew cut
@@livelaughjaeyun what do you mean?? I think she got A because she really is sooo great she really got the potential?? she might got a solo album.
today I was in the mirror and this song suddenly passed in my head. 2 years ago I memorized the movement of this song, But I forgot. I went back to look again, however, a feeling of emotion appeared instantly made me nostalgic🙂 I'm proud to have been a producers youth with you❤️
i don't know why but I've already watched survival shows like pd101, idol producer, etc. but I feel like this is the first time I'm gonna cry if someone gets eliminated. I mean look at this girls! different looks, different talents, and different personalities that made me so into them all! I just wanna see them like that on stage. but it's a competition so.....
and i personally think that these girls are graded fairly, it doesn't matter with the looks, the visuals, they really focus on what the girl is capable of, and how great she is.
@@luhreyroseadajar3675 and this is what makes this show all the more better! Mentors that actually recognise the value of talent and natural stage charisma
because they have equal screen time for their talents
thats the charm of idol producer/youth with you series. Season 1 of Idol producer with Cai Xukun was amazing..easily one of my favs because all the trainees were unique, lovable and absolutely hilarious. Season 2 was a bit dull and I couldn't get through it but it seems that Iqiyi learned from their mistakes and are following a similar formula to season 1 with the new girl's season which is great
visuals are just the bonus point. but these girls are talented enough to be called charismatic and powerful, and unique.
“We don’t define girls so we don’t define girl groups”. SAY IT LOUDER FOR KOREA IN THE BACK
LMAO SAY IT LOUDER
Y E S
FREAKING LOUDER PLEASE
They are from China lol
YES OK
It’s cool that let the girls choose if they want to wear shorts or a skirt. They’re not forced into this girly concept that they have to display. It reminds me of f(x) when amber can always wore shorts compare to the other members.
jao_812 and like miya from gwsn
Yeah amber liu has the same vibes with Xin Liu
青春有你2 历代选秀yyds 😭最好的学员 最好的导师
Did everyone forget what lisa said about the center position???
She said that center is not Just a visual, they are more than that.
That girl is talented and that is the only thing that matters so haters can shut up.
She's not just talented. I find Her gorgeous! I hope she becomes center, really
Yes, Lisa basically said, she is not visually appealing...which is true, thanks, Lisa
@Redrowan 3 yeah pity votes...if there was a disabled dancer, she'd win it, and comments would praise her even more. Only fair way is to make it about talent and nothing else.
Simon hollad wow you’re probably that person that would go up to a black Harvard student and say that the only reason they got accepted is out of pity for their skin colour lol. She got center because of her talent both judges and trainees voted her as the center wether you like it or not she’s talented but your insecure ass can’t handle the fact that a girl who gets more compliments than you on being handsome is getting recognition
@@simonhollad5511 How to twist people words challenge Funny
I don't get why people are hating the center she's really beautiful
She has more lover and supporter
😍👌
no one is hating on her.. she got 1st
@@hhzy5748 you should’ve seen the hate she got when she had gotten the center position
and handsome👁️👄👁️
I JUST WANT TO SAY I'M SO PROUD OF SHAKING. THIS GIRL IS REALLY HAS A PROMISING CAREER.
YESSSS!! She pulled off the cute concept and the badass concept, and she's so versatile! I can REALLY see a bright future for her!
IMMA SUPPORT CHLOE UNTIL THE END
You should def go watch The Next Top Bang, she was in the show I think 2 years ago and her rapping was effing amazing!
@@Momobibii True!! And I really love her overall personality. So bubbly behind the camera, and when she's on stage she's so comfortable and confident while performing 🔥.
Yess...hi I'm also shaking fans...heheheh let's support her till the end...😊😊
i cant believe they all debuted, this season was the best
The center was questioned on why she didn’t wear a skirt and she said it was because she wanted to show that you don’t have to wear feminine clothes to be beautiful and that everyone has their on style. I feel like she should def be one of the members chosen.
Human Bleach yesss
Human Bleach yess i really like her
She is... she came 6th in the top 9
Yes ! I like her so much..
Actually not only her wearing short pant, there some girls also wearing short pants like her
Best idol survivor show ever. Showed lots of sides to the girls and there were a lot of friendships made. No toxic drama and all the girls supported each other.
Like we always should be for thousands of years. Live for yourself and be proud of each other.
do you have more suggestions like ywy2? (not to be korean or Mnet related thanks!)
Exactly, no evil editing to antagonize anyone either
@@vs-oe8uy you should try to watch idol producer. It's the show that Kun win the center position
Idol Producer season 1 ( Cai Xukun time ) still the best, 2nd this show
No one:
Not even lisa:
Me: *doing this dance in my room pretending im one of them* lmaoo
Sooo true. 🤣😂
😂 u had me at "not even Lisa"
Yoo at least u can dance lmao🤣
Now i know how badly i dance
@@not_hooray4130 me too jjkhggkbhjjh
This is the best idol project I have ever watched.
The dance is spectacular, the song has a deep meaning to it, it encourages and empower girls especially and also well conducted.
This is much better than korean survival shows, the girls are very funny, no evil editing, they support each other, I love the mentors and especially the girls are very talented and had their own charm. Visuals on point and they are not forced to do such thing like diet, the center girl is the example, she is being herself. Overall I love this show a lot!
Korea Korean blah blah so annoying
Copy version of Japanese and Korean shows LOL
@@fearless2611 It was never a copy lol seriously
@Amelia PAU [07S2] hate?? LOL I'm just sick of some Chinese and YWY fans comparing this show with Korean PD series and look down on Korean people. they're so arrogant.
@@clffld Be honest,I saw every replied mumbled comparing YwY with Pd
Lisa being the strict mentor really paid off.
You can really see the results here. She really is a superstar mentor. Love these! ☺️
You are right I wish Lisa can become again strict mentor.
But I don't know that she is now also not
@@prashantrana6537 after being strick she got sooo many hates and she just pretend n9t t9 be strick other shows and people again hate her cuz she was good with boys
@@kadambaeva1181 ikr like people can not be happy
People Who Don't Watch the show: Why she is the center, is unfair!!!
People who really watch the show: *She deserve EVERYTHING*
Yes only those who haven't watched the show will say xin liu don't deserve the center position. Those who watch the show will understand why she is the center and most deserving person.
I watch the show, and I don't think she should've been center
JDGames first of all, she’s from the A class.. second of all, the trainees voted for her to become the center
Amy Ding Still don’t think she should’ve been center. Based on what Lisa said about the center, she just doesn’t fit the role. She doesn’t embody the song or the essence of all the girls. Frhanm was much better suited for the role, she is different from what a normal girl group member looks like, while still being able to bring the cutesy vibe the song has.
@@jdgames9622 Lisa said the theme song is a cute song which is totally different from her style but she was able to show her own style and she is different from other girls. Lisa also said she don't have any problem if she get A. Other judges also gave her A. you have watched the show that means you also known the reason why other girls voted her to be the center. For me xin liu is center because she showed her own style, can be cute and can attract other with her performance.
Their facial expressions the way they dance and everything about this show is absolutely perfect.
im crying,,, two years ago xukun was dancing as center and now he's taking yixing's place as PD ㅠㅠ he's come a long way
They both PD now
Yixing? As in Lay from EXO/solo? Or is it another Yixing?
im gonna cry. he is so amazing
ㅠㅠ i'm so happy
@@elisabethdamsgaard4807 Yeah. It's Lay of EXO. 😉
Actually she deserved to be a center. She makes the dance so easy. She is one of the most stable and has visual as well. Honestly, i only watched the show bec of Lisa but the longer I watched it, I've got to know the girls and how they want to improved their skills. I like how diverse this show is. It's breaking stereotypes on how a girl group should be. Goodluck to all participants!
*sorry for my English *
Xin liu center for Yes Ok
2 months later
Xin liu center for TheNine
I’m so proud of her !!
Not to blame anyone but in all produce series (include the original) who was the center of theme song will be debuted for sure.
Hieu Tran definitely. And all of them deserve the center position.
Hieu Tran Produce 101 China fist season theme song center didn’t debut
@@tranhieu7665 Kaeun was center for korean trainees but she didn't debut.
@@tranhieu7665 Some center from Korea and China survival shows didnt debut. Pls do research first.
After idol producer this was the best season so far
I swear if that center isn't going to debut i'm going to flip China through Mars.
Well said
Lol hehe 😂
Same
So we need to vote for her
i heard the center ( xin liu ) was only 8th place :
If u want to know more about Xin Liu, the centre girl wearing shorts instead of skirt… PLZ read this, she is my one pick and i want to let u all know how good she is…
Xin Liu, born in 1997, she is only 22 now even she might look more mature than her age. This is because she left home at the age of 12 for her dancing dream. She went to Beijing to have more opportunity. She is one of the best female popping dancer in Asia now and popping master Lin meng is her teacher. It is very brave for her to choose popping, as u all know popping is a type of dance that needs supper strong energy and muscles to control ur body, so its usually harder for girls than boys to learn popping. But Xin Liu wants people to know how strong and powerful girls could also be.
2012, Xin Liu participated in a competition called "Go Up! Junior" （向上吧！少年）and won the Most Upward Junior Award, famous idol like Kiku, or Karry Wang and Jackson Yee from the TFboys, and even one of the coach from “Youth with You”, Kun also attend this competition show, but Xin is the winner of that show, her dancing skills impressed everyone. But almost everyone from that show are famous idols now, except the winner Xin. 😢
2013, Xin participated in the competition of "Dancing Forest Fighting Hegemony" of Oriental Satellite TV's dance competition, and won all the votes of the four judges.But nothing changes, even she is so good at dancing, and won lots of trophies, still, no one knows her. So for her stage dream, she started to try to be an idol, she improved her singing skills, learnt rap, b-box, passes 8th grade for piano, and finally she became a member of a girl group called “Lady Bees” with other 6 girls. But sadly, “Lady Bees” went quiet after they releases their group album and went on some concerts in 2017. So after that, Xin starts to make her own music and had her first single “Feel Good” in March of 2018, she then released her first album EP “Xin”, one of my favorite songs is “hot party”, you should try listen to it. Even though, Xin is still just nobody.
She worked so hard these years, learnt skills she never tried before, Ballet、choreography
and so on.
Now, Xin is on “Youth with You”, this is the 10th year after she left home, she said “ If this still won’t work this time, I might just gave up and go back home” before she went on the show. So please please PLEASE VOTE for her if you like her or think she is good at dancing and singing ! PLEASE ! Also, even if your not gonna vote for her, THANK YOU for just reading all of this.🙏🙏🙏
逍遥 find you finally lol
逍遥 Xin is soooooooo amazing she really deserves it
we will vote for her
Geok Luan Tee thank you 😊
Geok Luan Tee thank you 😊
The produce show in korea is all about beauty/visual while in China it's all about the talent that makes the trainees confident and beautiful. This show is really about empowering women i love all the trainees and their confidence.🥰
But the whole show is copy of Korean PD series lol
@@fearless2611 but for me it's much better😬
@@fearless2611 ok but srsly go get a life. You don't need to reply to every single comment saying they like this show. We get it. Just leave.
@@fearless2611 funny how they were the copy yet they're doing better thsn the original lmao
I TOTALLY AGREE. the way they let different types of girls come onto the show and actually giving them ample screentime to shine... it's really
THE season which created such an iconic gg!! thinking about rewatching :)
@Anna Jm ikr esther makes me happy 😭🧚♀️
do you have more suggestions like ywy2? (not to be korean or Mnet related thanks!)
I can see why she’s the center. Her dancing, facial expressions, charm and charisma is on point. Not to mention, she also has the visuals. And from the start, she already got me hooked when she smiled. That was a simple smile but she looked really charming 🌟
Nobody asked you?
We don't define girls, we don't define girl groups. How they picked the centre based on talent and potential is reflecting their own mantra, action speaks louder than words. All the best!
Dt eh The mentors didn’t pick the center.. the other trainees did.. and that’s what they mean.. The mentors doesn’t pick or define girls and girl groups.. Audience and trainees does.. 🤷🏼♀️
Omg the center is combination of pretty, cute, sexy, handsome and cool. All in one. And I really love her natural smile. So prettyyyy
Liu Yuxin is the queen of this song! In the end, she stand at the top, right where Lisa deserve.
"WE DO NOT DEFINE GIRLS, WE DO NOT DEFINE GIRL GROUP"
I feel that and I became more empowered now. Thanks YOUTH WITH YOU 😘😘😘
Hannah Sumatra yes
@瑞岢Rico it was a touching lines. I love it.
The centre is pretty. She also got skills.She was chosen to be the centre.It's not like she have forced it or something.I don’t get it, why some people are hating her.
Nowrin R what her name?
@@hyerinseo9350 Xin liu
A-girl KA thanks
@@hyerinseo9350 welcome 💜
this is the first time ever I see a music survival show that has this diversity. Wow I’m impressed and very happy because their talents will not be defined or limited by appearances.
you cannot see that in pd101 series
By diversity you mean a non girly member?
Izzy Woods they have trainees of all different heights, weights and backgrounds. not everyone is a traditional girl group member and that’s awesome
@@izzywoods794 and there is a girl with curly hair, is the first time I see that in this type of progrsms
You can see her in 2:48
我真的很喜欢这个中心。 她有最稳定的舞蹈台词。 她的魅力令人眼花缭乱。 才华、技能和魅力。 她绝对是我的选择之一。 主要舞者头衔是她的！
I can experience the variety of beauties in Chinese show. Instead of sticking to those typical stereotypes, they let everyone shine & give chances to express their own characters. The physical appearances don’t define who you are. I am also a woman who love boyish styles. At the end of day, how comfortable and confident in yourself is most important..
Still cheering for all the girls!!!!
Thank you for spreading awareness about the st**pid stereotype especially for my family
It’s so crazy to see Cai XuKun in Lay’s position, announcing the show, the song, saying hi to the voters... I’m so proud, he looks so amazing too❤️😭
KUN pd💕
ikrrrr, he has come a very long way 😭 very proud of him
the glow up that matters✨
proud
i’m so proud 😭💙
The center breaks every stereotypes of an assumed "member of a girl group."
Well, you should watch Produce 101 China and see the girls who debut. They are called Rocket Girls 101
Amber of f(x) did it years ago...
Boy this comment slap everyone concerning their hate over center
@@roseisarose9504 yess sunee 😍
Pota Moons No one said the center was the first one to break stereotypes 🤷🏻♀️🤷🏻♀️
Girl in center (liu yuxin) always amazing
So this is what it like when the camera show everyone fairly
it should be this even in all the other performances too! T-T
i love that they allowed the center to wear shorts it made her even cooler aND WHY ARE THERE SO MANY PRETTY TRAINEES
No , she wore shorts because she like shorts...not about cool , a girl who doesn't like girl stuff u know
Ikr.. chinese is the factory of pretty girl..
I think this year the trainees can choose shorts or skirts, so there are a few other girls wearing shorts too uwu
@@tq301 yeah the ones looking like men
Isn't it a he 😳
this survival show is waaaay better than all the korean ones... all the trainees are treated like humans with feelings and the mentors are great, like they are strict bc that’s their job, but they’re also so supportive and kind with them
Agree!
I don't thinks so lol
i agree with you and the fact that they acknowledged that every girls have their own styles.
I also like how the girls didn’t all have to lose weight. Some were told to gain weight and others to maintain
Who disagree with this commentary just a dumb fan of kpop. They only stan for Kpop and hate the others
Lisa did a great job as a mentor and the girls were also amazing couldn't stop watching their dance and the sequence between them matches so well with each other ❤😊
here are the trainees that debutted:
1) 1:13 Liu Yu Xin 刘雨昕
2) 3:11 Esther Yu 虞书欣
3) 2:39 Kiki Xu 许佳琪
4) 1:32 Yu Yan 喻言
5) 1:35 Shaking 谢可寅
6) 1:29 Babymonster An 安崎
7) 2:47 Zhao Xiao Tang 赵小棠
8) 2:50 Snow Kong 孔雪儿
9) 2:34 K Lu 陆柯燃 (on the right of the screen)
That's not K Lu, that's Beebee Huang
this is my first time watch the girles
name the girle with short hair in 4:03
@@jana420bpf4 Liu Yu Xin
@Dom Dom thank you so much what's groupe name
5:17 Joey’s visual is really no joke, im glad she had a decent amount of screen time here
Yeah!!!!
I hope she will be train well through this show and debut as a visual
simoart yeah!!!!!
I am rooting for her
her smile always makes me happy
yesss she's angel
The center totally express the theme X Infinitely.
I just missed this show. This show is my pandemic stress reliever. I invest my 2 months of pandemic watching this show.
I'm already loving the lineup of contestants. We have a variety of girls, not just cute girls or girls who go by society's standards of being a woman. I think that is why they emphasized, "We do not define girls, we do not define girl groups."
if yall actually compared liu yuxin's focus cam with others, you'll see why she's chosen. she's the most stable among all. her dance is clean, she's not a try-hard, chill during the entire tiring performance, and yet hits all the beats precisely.
She made the dance look sooooo easy, but then when I try it for myself I nearly broke my spine. Some other girls did really well but they tried too hard and the dance just didn't look as clean
that's right. At the first time, i was impressed by Kiki but now, I'm completely a fan of Xin Liu! She is new face and it's hard to compete with others who already had reputation. Xin Liu deserves to be Center, she has tried so hard. Well done !
@@hathanh5128Xiu Liu is not really a "new face". She debut before and had been on some variety shows, but she is very skilled and she totally deserves to be center.
She was one of the best and she gave it her own vibe which is what I appreciated the most tbh, but have you see Dream Catcher's Handong? She did beautifuly uwu♡
Where do u find the focus cams?
The center girl is the one i like when lisa teach her dance she looks cool
3:09 *Fu Yaning* 🔥😍💘
I really like the fact that they are so much different type of girls in this program.
SAME !! The diversity here is pretty refreshing to see 😊👏
we true chinese r supported diversity n equility, we dont discriminate skin colors n gentle. we support for being ourselves. pls stay away from media who creating chinese hatred.
Lawrence Zhu kinda sad what’s happened to the Hong Kong and uyghur people in China now
Zakiya Awad things may be not so easy to say especially when you look from outside. I was two times in xinjiang province last years. To better understand the situation, please go there and talk to the locals, find yourself an opinion.
SAMEEE
At first I don't understand why Xin Liu is the center. But when I watch the whole episode I think she's just too OP to be in this show LOL she's unbeatable.
ikr i was like that too . but now im addicted to her
Xin Liu was the center of theme song “Yes OK” and now she debuted as center of “The9”. Reward came as not just by uplifting yourself but the people around you. Once a selfless trainee, and now an outstanding center. Congrats to all YWY trainees. You make our summer meaningful.
yes and she's one of those trainees who started literally from the bottom, when you noticed her rank in the first week she's top 25 but as the show goes on people noticed her charisma and stage presence which lead her to be top 1 at the end and be the9's official center.
Well said
@@cjninechocontent4815 玖是的！
Indeed a deserving center. Forever proud of you Liu Yuxin 🥺💖
Me: Let's see how many girls wink in the ending part like Korean PD48
Youth with you: No one! They're showing by their own.
Me: That's my expectation.
nah they all doin the head tilt aha :))
It's wink in Korea, while its head tilt in China lol
Just a habitual reflex when the camera comes to them. It makes viewers feel more comfortable and natural than winking wryly.
Do not compare one another.
I think the winks in Korea pd48 are somehow cringe. If like 1 or 2 people do it, it's for me fine. But in pd48 literally everyone does it, that's why I prefer Qin chun you ni 2 more.
Liu Xin as the center is a breath of fresh air. I'm not even complaining. those who are complaining can't do anything anymore since it's already done. i don't know how she is chosen as the center but im glad she is the center.
Jovy Muslad she’s Liu Yu Xin by the way XD but I agree w u
@@limserene4358 yes, i know her full name. i just wrote it in short cut since most Chinese full name seems to always come in 3 syllables making it a bit harder to memorised for us non Chinese speaking.
Jovy Muslad oh ok. Sorry that was a misunderstanding XD
@@limserene4358 no its okay.. 😁
Ok can we talk about how underrated Frhanm is?? She literally got the 2nd most votes to be centre, and yet she got so much less screen time than the other girls in A. They showed Babymonster An and even Joey Chua (who was placed in D!!) more times than Frhanm wtf it's so unfair. She's such an amazing leader and she always gives the most inspiring speeches. She can sing, dance, and rap, and all the girls love her. She honestly deserves so much more
Yes!! I don't know if you've seen the last episode but (spoiler) she ranks number 10!! And first place goes to Esther Yu, who (let's be honest) doesn't sing and dance as well as the other girls and was placed in D 3 times in a row. The diferences between them is that Ester Yu has lots of Screen time and even has some episodes named after her and Frhanm doesn't. Frhanm is my favourite and I agree with you, she deserves so much more.
I love her too, please vote for her.
@@lhryxxx2828 How do I vote? 😅
@@IsaMFP Go to Iqiyi app and sign up with your email
@@virniaaparicio Thank you 😘
以前看不起这些节目和口水歌，禁选秀两年来伴随着国内文艺创作环境跌倒谷底，我突然觉得这首歌非常好听。。。
从满了回忆
向上的青春感
有一种很二的中二感，可能就是年轻的样子😂
这首歌是叫我们勇敢追梦😊
別高興，這也是韓國作曲編曲的，看1:19
Xin lui is the best..she’s center..she’s talented
Faw Mon Liu*
I’m tearing up seeing all this diversity and all the ladies here are absolutely stunning
this is because I have seen more variety in chinese girl groups (one of the judges is part of one which was extremely popular when I was growing up) outside of survival shows alone. kpop companies are not exactly the kind to shy away from choosing visuals in hoping they would be talented or worth their money.
Kkura Chan Are you referring to S.H.E? The 3 girls in the group are so diverse. Even Ella herself said that she is the one that “balanced” the group. I couldn’t agree more. She was my favourite out of the three.
5:02 can we just take a minute to appreciate this gorgeous empowering woman? She’s so unique and strong. Her words of breaking the girl stereotype and creating a new vision for women is so amazing. Like I’m in love-
period!!! Shes amazing!
sadly she got many haters because of her look 😐😐 her singing and dancing skills are unbelievable
Louis Z
right? people can be so biased and rude when someone breaks common stereotypes, it has to be done eventually.
Louis Z well you can’t please everyone, haters are gonna hate, what’s important is to keep your head held high and keep on moving forward knowing that there are people who do love you 😘
The girl in 5:02 is in class A.She has strong power and performs quite well on the preliminary rating stage.Her name is ShangGuanXiai. Here is her solo performance ,at 1:02→th-cam.com/video/NymkQldDGGA/w-d-xo.html
Not me watching every Liu Xin content after SDC 5 dgdgdfff GIRL you got me fr
THIS SEASON WAS THE BEST😭
Yes
Yes the songs is amazing about dream
YEAH
Because of Lisa😍💕
@@loco7939 uh and trainees first
They are so confident. No one is trying to act Cute.
Yes, they are nice, but I think at the same time they are very tense
@@catfish4035 I kinda understand the feeling though😂
their mentor dance is lisa.. what do you expect? lisa is the definition of girl crush, cool, swag, sexy with a little bit cuteness
@Troll77 Neptune well have you seen the practice video for the trainees? lisa dance to this song! furthermore, lisa is the dance mentor, her style will be more or less affect the outcome.
and btw, just type lisa, not necessary to put her name in symbol, what is lisa? a rude word that you must use symbol like da*n? or bit*h? just type lisa like normal
right! no one winks in the end
Xin liu has born to be center!! Her charm, her talent, her uniqe style, her kindess, her personality so perfectly, she's an angel indeed!! if she get million viewers on youtube thats as expected, international fans are crazy with her, X QUEEN WHO MAKES US CRAZY LET'S DEBUT!!!
This song always stuck in my mind until now. Im dreaming become a trainee as idol but my age not allowed it 😅😂
Yeah not bad
Dont worry you can become an idol when you reach the age and please do tell if you made it!!! I'll be your number one fan!!!
I also want to be an idol but I can't speak good Korean but I know some words in Korean and I know all vowels and consants
most companies offer Korean classses or either send their trainees to a school to take en
The people hating on Xin Liu must haven't watched the show cause no matter what she is wearing she's a really great soul.
The best center Liu Xin!!!
Yess🥰😍
She's Xin liu 👆👆👆👆
@@sofea4571 qqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqa11ppqpqqqqqpqpppqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqq
no
@@florony166ok? Then?
Nineone smiled at performance 😇
She listened lisa's words
There one person
What minute is she in?
Yeah😍
where is Nineon??
@@valecontrucci4746 at 3:04, the girl with bangs on the left
Mentor Lisa's students 😭😭😭❤️❤️❤️ I'm so proud of them
This show is so much more friendly than the korean prod series. The girls are so different and they seem to have a genuine bond and want to help each other out... Korea made it appear a lot more like a stiff competition and the editing made it look more so. Plus the mentors here seem a lot warmer towards the trainees
Each Korean participants are also friendly, they are the encouragements for each other and devotional and most are willing to give up their position. It is just the editing, right?
But still a copycat from korea. No originality.
K 2 d P channel hum korea don’t owe survival shows.
@@theunknownchannel8166 the whole Korean produce series was taken from a Japanese survival show anyway, and korea probably isn't the first to produce survival shows
This is the best girl survival show I ever watch in China because theyre not all act cute they're act as their self.
Edited:They have their own charm and this is also my favorite girl version of survival show too.
Edited:For those disagree of xin Liu for being center please don't hate her it's 2020 guys and we need to change like how lisa say that center is not about cuteness its about who you are ok so don't hate xin Liu.
Totally agree with you!
@Vanshika Chaudhary Yes, she is just like that in her daily life.
@@EternityRoV It's complicated but officially it is not part of Produce 101 franchise so you can say they have copied a few things from the Produce series (read more here www.soompi.com/article/1152831wpp/frapa-acknowledges-similarities-produce-101-idol-producer). There is an official Produce 101 china if you're interested (a girl version where 2 girls from WJSN competed). Tbh Idol Producer (Now called Youth With You) is by far the best "Produce" series tho. All seasons are worth a watch.
Roxanne Vasquez actually is not copied but anyways this is their 5th/6th season of produce series in China the previous season in season 1 is the guy from the very beginning giving the speech his name is caixukun he is also one of the contestants in season 1 , and after that they have season 2 , produce 101 girls China , 创造营
@Vanshika Chaudhary i felt the same about Esther Yu.. i cannot relate to her... Joey Chua is also soft... but i can relate to her...
edited: the idea that their are contestants who already admit to themselves that they aren't *ordinary* and still entered the show knowing who ever will be part of the group will be named as *girl* group. Such strong attitudes. Salute to them
there are actually a number of boyish Chinese girls joining survival shows. the one I remember the most is Sunnee from produce 101 China, she's boyish with boy cut hair too and she actually won.
The center here might actually have a chance to debut as well.
still the most iconic batch to hit ywy