Being the skeptic you are, they probably wouldn't sound good. He probably doesnt own them and he probably cant play the guitar. You could respond but I probably wouldn't care and I probably wouldn't understand your point.
@@Contact_Info You have a strange way of making conversation. The only thing I wanted to say was that they might sound different but I can't imagine any musical instrument not sounding good at all. That's why they're made.
I thought the same thing, but refrained from commenting as such, to avoid very odd attacks characterizing me as somehow almost sociopathic in nature. It seems I chose wisely. 😐
a H U G E thumbs up for uploading this video! a lot of knowledge on the history of the evolution of the guitar. wish u could have played some of those, especially the 3 neck guitar.
I remember getting to play these instruments at this festival and others. What an opportunity! Most things like this are locked behind glass as a piece of dead wood.
I have to ask what is a collection like this worth? How did people agree to part with some of these, amazing collection I’d also like to know how you knew how some of these instruments were tuned?
Thanks for showing us some of your collection. I have been researching the evolution and development of stringed instruments and I wonder about the ten stringed instrument mentioned in the Bible (Psalm 92:3) where it refers to singing praises "upon an instrument of ten strings". It would seem that plucked stringed instruments go back many thousands of years.
They obviously don't care about that,, they went from 1500bc to 1500ad. No mention of the Sumerian Lyre either. Not really history just cherry picked what they wanted!
even the famous brand like Fender, Gibson, Yamaha, Takamine Acoustic guitar made in China. It is a subjective matter for a person to evaluate the value of a vintage guitar.
what Gibsons are made in China? Epiphones sure but I believe all Gibsons are made in the US. ........ I wonder if China has any museums with examples of their own traditional instruments of high craftsmanship?
some of the information provided in the video is historically wrong: to say that Oud appeared in the middle ear east in 1500BC is completely hilarious, plus, the Ottomans never went to Spain, but, Arabs did along with the Amazigh.
Exactly! Americans still cant tell Arabs and Turks apart to this day lmao They invaded the Iberian Peninsula in the 8th century, by 1500 they had been kicked out with only a few settlements in Granada
3:00 This is wrong. The Ottomans never were in Portugal or Spain! Arabs invaded our lands in the 8th century and we kicked them out from the 11th century till the 16th century. They weren't Ottomans or Turkic.
Jim Forderer, What a wonderful man and great contribution to all guitarists who want to know the history and instrumental linage of the guitar.
Wow! This is an important knowledge and information for all guitarists.
Fantastic collection! Bless you.
Pricelessly information... This is what we need to learn guitar histories. The history telling that walk together with the example of instruments..
Thank you for sharing the instruments and your knowledge.
Real nice trip through the history of the great instrument.
Thought this was going to be lame and full of reproductions, but was amazing, thanks for sharing your great collection.
I'd sure like to hear these instruments.
Being the skeptic you are, they probably wouldn't sound good. He probably doesnt own them and he probably cant play the guitar. You could respond but I probably wouldn't care and I probably wouldn't understand your point.
@@Contact_Info You have a strange way of making conversation. The only thing I wanted to say was that they might sound different but I can't imagine any musical instrument not sounding good at all. That's why they're made.
I thought the same thing, but refrained from commenting as such, to avoid very odd attacks characterizing me as somehow almost sociopathic in nature. It seems I chose wisely. 😐
a H U G E thumbs up for uploading this video! a lot of knowledge on the history of the evolution of the guitar. wish u could have played some of those, especially the 3 neck guitar.
I remember getting to play these instruments at this festival and others. What an opportunity! Most things like this are locked behind glass as a piece of dead wood.
Very very interesting info.
That's very interesting and thank you very much for sharing
Nice to see Pujol's Vihuela - my teacher Brendan played this instrument on 1960's Spain
That is amazing! i'm extasied!
The Video opens with Pavana #6 by Luis Milan played by Andres Segovia..
Amazing collection. I love that triple neck. That design is ingenious and beautiful. Thanks for sharing some of the collection with us.
Nice collection. You have my sympathy if you try to play them :D
nice stuff
Great collection ¡¡
Want to see them
I have to ask what is a collection like this worth? How did people agree to part with some of these, amazing collection I’d also like to know how you knew how some of these instruments were tuned?
If you have to ask, you can't afford it
Thanks for showing us some of your collection. I have been researching the evolution and development of stringed instruments and I wonder about the ten stringed instrument mentioned in the Bible (Psalm 92:3) where it refers to singing praises "upon an instrument of ten strings". It would seem that plucked stringed instruments go back many thousands of years.
ANY TRIPLE STRINGS?
I also got a lot other instruments i made multiple too
Ancient Greek kithara (guitar)?
They obviously don't care about that,, they went from 1500bc to 1500ad.
No mention of the Sumerian Lyre either. Not really history just cherry picked what they wanted!
Cool
I have a Roudhloff like that.
What's the piece played during the bit where he talks about the Vihuela?
Siddharth fgjhfh I have played it myself on my lute but can't think what it is, I'll comment when I remember!
Sounds like one of the Luis Milan Pavans... sorry, not sure what one! Probably one of the ones Segovia played on recordings.
what is the piece playing at the begining ? I think Julian Bream plays it. but whose piece is it can you tell ?
Ive heard segovia play it in some of the youtube videos on here about him... i doubt its his but im sure you can find it through those videos
The Video opens with Pavana #6 by Luis Milan played by Andres Segovia..
@5:28 GUY SCARE CRAP OUT OF ME.
I've wonder how much valuable made in China acoustic guitars will be couple hundred years from now
even the famous brand like Fender, Gibson, Yamaha, Takamine Acoustic guitar made in China. It is a subjective matter for a person to evaluate the value of a vintage guitar.
what Gibsons are made in China? Epiphones sure but I believe all Gibsons are made in the US. ........ I wonder if China has any museums with examples of their own traditional instruments of high craftsmanship?
Asian luthiers are much improved over 30 years ago, meanwhile American quality has gone downhill.
I'm so jealous.
where is sound ?
I got a brand new guitars set i made looks ancient multiple instruments
some of the information provided in the video is historically wrong:
to say that Oud appeared in the middle
ear east in 1500BC is completely hilarious, plus, the Ottomans never went to Spain, but, Arabs did along with the Amazigh.
Exactly! Americans still cant tell Arabs and Turks apart to this day lmao
They invaded the Iberian Peninsula in the 8th century, by 1500 they had been kicked out with only a few settlements in Granada
3:00 This is wrong. The Ottomans never were in Portugal or Spain! Arabs invaded our lands in the 8th century and we kicked them out from the 11th century till the 16th century. They weren't Ottomans or Turkic.
I won't upload it un less i get i comment
sure i would like to see them - please upload them!
Comment
broke guitar? ... it looks in reasonable shape to me (LOL ...sorry, dumb baroque joke that should never be said) ... what a collection!
I'm an expert oud and lute player
Sharky ...and I am an expert masterbater!
I play the rubber band with a violin bow.... they sau best rubber bands are made in germany but spain in my proffesinal opinion can never be beat
@@alexanderheintz6834 proffesinal
maspotamia is not in Africa, it's in asia, IRAQ
cithara is mesopatamiam not african
the kithara was an ancient Greek type of lyre it was not even a guitar.