Samurai Vs Japanese Imperial army: Battle of the last Samurai | Cinematic
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ม.ค. 2022
- #TotalWarShogun2 #Cinematic
A last alliance of Samurai and Ronin take on the Japanese empire and the Imperial Japanese army in a last stand for their survival.
- Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @warandhistory.
Music from TW SHOGUN 2 ( Credit to Composer )
- Jeff Van Dyk = / @jeffvandyckmusic
⬇ The Mods Used ⬇
Double unit size
Ancient shogun colors 1 - 4
Batter maps
Camera zoom
Darthmod shogun
Legendary samurai reskin
Radious pack 1 - 3
Total Carnage
Unique factions
10th anniversary collection - เกม
Guys I put a lot of time and effort into these video's, at minimum you could leave a like and comment. The mods are in the description.
Channel memberships for additional content = th-cam.com/channels/w5kGfjKH3TEiCRqZUnUUPA.htmljoin
Subscribe to the 2nd channel = th-cam.com/channels/chWInl-0gt_zNSB4B3eH0g.html
Can you do sparta vs persians please 🙏
*You deserve my like and subscribe! More videos to come, please!*
Not so much a comment on your editing, but more about limitations of the game engine.
1. Samurai spent a life time training for war. The Japanese Imperial Army would have been made of conscripts with minimal training. Numbers and technology would have expected to do more to win battles than combat training. The Samurai had armor and experience. The Japanese Imperial Army had neither. Their effectiveness in battle I felt was over rated as soon as the Samurai got close to the first line, you would expect the raw army recruits to break formation and run towards the second line.
2. Close ups in battle didn't feel appropriate. It seemed more one on one when it should be more like one on two or three. Combatants not in a one on one fight with another combatant basically stand there waiting their turn.
3. No use of feigns or wide flanking maneuvers. The whole point of cavalry was to do skirt enemy positions. A frontal charge on a consolidate line would have been suicidal. A Samurai general wouldn't have made that mistake.
4. Smoke. I don't think the game takes this into consideration visually. The Samurai archers are firing flame arrows for a reason. And the area around the Army's front line would be impaired after a volley or two of firing.
5. Terrain use seemed to be minimal. Neither side is trying to use terrain to their advantage to obscure numbers or block line of sight. And cannon fire was way to accurate. You have to adjust angle of elevation after each firing as the Samurai are advancing and hope you guess right.
Post edit.
With further reflection on this video, I think the Imperial army soldier's stats were set too high. They have no armor. Ever piercing arrow, every hit from a sword, every blow from a samurai's arsenal would have been felt and sent the soldier reeling. And when you are in a consolidated line, practically no arrow is going to miss a target. And once hit, that soldier's effectiveness is down to zero. They aren't going to keep fighting. They are going to retreat. Which would likely create a stampede as more soldiers broke from the line.
To compensate the soldiers should have had very low health pools. Because the game engine assumes the soldier will fight until dead. So even serious injuries would not impact their fighting efficiency. This not an issue with the way the content provider set the match up. It is an issue with game engine limitations.
@@superdave8248 too much last samurai?
@@gehlesen559 The whole point of The Last Samurai was to give an account of a man whose viewed the central government's modern approach with warfare to be outside of how Japan should be doing things. He wanted a last stand. He knew he was highly regarded and respected and he wanted to hurt the government. His thought was that by forcing his death in a suicidal attack that the public would lose faith in the government and they would revert back to more classical approaches to life in general. And he guest wrong. Such things are the realm of romance cavalier novels. In reality, most people think you come across as an idiot for wasting lives and resources on a suicidal attack.
For those who don't know. Last samurai was not American. He was French. True story.
Thats cool
He was weeb.
@@abcdc197 Weeblet
True, movies and historical accounts are an oxymoron
had to be da french guy?
imagine training your whole life to become a samurai warrior only to die from a small metal sphere going at the speed of sound
Oof
Technology is equalizer and gives upper hand.
It was more of a cone.
And your killers are the peasants you used to mock
That's why the samurai confiscated all the guns in about 1630.
As some have mentioned, the samurai at that time had already thrown away their armor, dressed and equipped with French army.
Even the samurai who wanted to protect the shogun knew that old-fashioned equipment could not defeat the enemy. I don't stick to the old ones, but it's a battle of the Imperial Army that fundamentally changes Japan with the samurai and the emperor who are on a mission to protect the shogun.
何故？会津藩が倒幕なんだ？織田の旗も混じってるし歴史オンチアホが
制作したんだなｗｗｗｗwhy？Is the Aizu domain the curtain？The flag of Oda is also mixed. History ・crazy ・crazy ・crazy
historic seinan war
reality
It is the largest shootout in the civil war.
Satsuma
Ancestors
1952 ～ 1598
Repelling 100 times more enemies
th-cam.com/video/q83RBq-WeTM/w-d-xo.html
I love seeing a good ole fashioned conservative bloodbath by progressives. They have always and will always try to conserve archaic values that don’t belong nor hold any relevance. And they always pay a horrible price for it. Every time.
@@user-ed8wc1yr8s what
@@Ttegegg 😂😂😂😂
Amazing battle, great job! I can't believe how well Total War Shogun 2 has stood the test of time. It was my first Total War game, actually.
I just bought it today 😊
Actually somebody use my accounts I've never know this game
何故？会津藩が倒幕なんだ？織田の旗も混じってるし歴史オンチアホが
制作したんだなｗｗｗｗwhy？Is the Aizu domain the curtain？The flag of Oda is also mixed. History ・crazy ・crazy ・crazy
@@user-ed8wc1yr8s まあまあ、別にいいじゃんその辺りは?そもそも歴史的に忠実に作ってる訳じゃないし、歴史アンチじゃなくてただ日本史に対する知識浅いだけでしょ?織田の旗も、ただ Shogun 2 の織田ファクションの方が遊びやすかっただけだと思うぞ。そこまで気にすることないって。
@@kazanshin4108だから、日本人は、誤解されるのだ！
海外で恥かくぞ！スペイン・ポーランドなどで
日本人が現在カエル・犬を食すると考えている。
誰が偽情報流しているか？中国人作家の日本文化観光案内で捏造を
パリで発行している！
The formation of the Japanese imperial looked so realistic. I have to give credit to that it was amazing
This dude dropping’ fire
-Sun Tzu
Unreal. I think the biggest benefit being appreciated that Tzu might have been referring to was that of the war being over.
何故？会津藩が倒幕なんだ？織田の旗も混じってるし歴史オンチアホが
制作したんだなｗｗｗｗwhy？Is the Aizu domain the curtain？The flag of Oda is also mixed. History ・crazy ・crazy ・crazy
During the historical Samouraï wars, one French dude have fight many years near to the shogun,
They made a movie about him, maybe you know him : The last Samouraï ( Jules Brunet )
何故？会津藩が倒幕なんだ？織田の旗も混じってるし歴史オンチアホが
制作したんだなｗｗｗｗwhy？Is the Aizu domain the curtain？The flag of Oda is also mixed. History ・crazy ・crazy ・crazy
戊辰戦争にしろ西南戦争にしろ、単純に官軍が近代軍で相手が前代の装備というわけではなかったんだけどなあ
どっちも鉄砲や大砲は使ってたような
Fun fact: samurais harsly used katanas into battles. They mainly used long-ranged weapons such as spears(includes naginata) and rifles..
The same with knights and one handed swords. They are a sidearm back up, like a modern pistol.
何故？会津藩が倒幕なんだ？織田の旗も混じってるし歴史オンチアホが
制作したんだなｗｗｗｗwhy？Is the Aizu domain the curtain？The flag of Oda is also mixed. History ・crazy ・crazy ・crazy
お侍さんは盾や銃や大砲は何処へ忘れてきたのだろう…。銃や大砲や盾は武士が活躍した戦国時代でも戦争に多く使われていました。そして彼らは固い竹を大量に束ねる事で銃弾を弾く移動式の壁を作り、安全に敵に近づく知恵も持っていました。
そうそう、クレヨンしんちゃんの劇場版で見た覚えがある。竹の壁
そんなこと言い出したら戊辰戦争では旧幕府軍、新政府軍の主力武器は両者ともミニエー銃やエンフィールドだからね
幕府軍側でも侍の時代は終わってた
It's beautiful. Perfect, it is all perfect
Beginning of the end for the age of the Samurai ? I believe it was the end of the end. The beginning had started almost 200 years earlier.
wrong. The beginning of the samurai began around 880 AD in the Heian period of Japan. The samurai at that time were guards of the imperial court, but during the battle they wore armor and fought. The samurai took control from the Kamakura period when Minamoto no Yoritomo became a shogun in 1185 AD. The Kamakura period was from 1185 to 1350, after which Takauji Ashikaga became a shogun and the Ashikaga family continued for 15 generations during the Muromachi period. The Warring States period begins around 1610. Produced Japanese-made guns from around 1560, and in the battle of 1570. Fight with tactics using as many as 5,000 guns in one battle. According to the materials, the battle to use this number of guns at one time will be 280 years later in Europe, so I can be sure that the Japanese samurai were the best in the world in terms of fighting spirit and weapons. For about 280 years from the beginning of the 17th century when Ieyasu Tokugawa became a shogun, the Tokugawa family had been isolated from the country, so progress in battles such as weapons stopped for 280 years. Only 30 years after the end of the samurai era and the end of the seclusion, we were able to defeat Russia in the Russo-Japanese War because of the strength, combat skills, and comprehensive know-how of the 16th century. So many Japanese laughed at The Last Samurai starring Tom Cruise. It is not true that Samurai used a sword and the government used a gun that he was not accustomed to. Twenty years before the Last Samurai era, only the Satsuma Domain fought a local battle with Britain, and the Choshu Domain also fought Francis, Russia, Britain, and the Netherlands. Of course, the samurai also used a cannon. The Japanese emperor has the longest imperial tradition in the world, lasting 127 generations. From 1185 to 1860, when the samurai politicized, Japan was head of state by His Majesty the Emperor. Following Kamakura and Muromachi, even under the Tokugawa administration, the appointment was made by His Majesty the Emperor.
@@kazu9214 read again what i wrote m8.
@@Saraband-
There is only one fact.
@@kazu9214 The beginning of the end was 200 years earlier…
@@Portaldog
Certainly there was a battle by samurai around the 2nd century, but it was around the 9th century that the samurai fought with cool armor known to overseas fans of the samurai.
武士もたくさんの鉄砲隊がいた。。。
I am Japanese. It is a descendant of a soldier of the Aizu clan.
I wanted Aizu（會） to be on the samurai side
I'm pretty sure the aizu absolutely where on the samurai side
This is the most congruent adaptation of the Battle of Shiroyama of the Satsuma Rebellion. Thanks for those people behind this wonderful movie mod.
何故？会津藩が倒幕なんだ？織田の旗も混じってるし歴史オンチアホが
制作したんだなｗｗｗｗwhy？Is the Aizu domain the curtain？The flag of Oda is also mixed. History ・crazy ・crazy ・crazy
16:04 mad respect to Gatling gunners that sitll fire under heavy arrow rain to final men.
I am going to give the samurai a 10 for badassdom….. no kid ever said “ I want to be a 19th century foot soldier’……. But every kid said “I wanna be a samurai” 😁👍. And launch yer arrows any effin time you feel like it samurai…..
love your video buddy
keep it up
ps-you got a new follower today
Эпичное сражение. Возможно, если бы не атака в лобовую, у самураев был шанс. Но использование традиционной стратегии сыграло свою роль. Они сражались с честью, их время уходило, но онивписали свой безумный подвиг в Историю.⚔
Great battle. Thanks for the animation.
流石に侍側も、ただ突進するしか戦闘術しか持ち合わせていなかった訳ではないはずだと思います。
As far as I know, Samurais don't directly engage with sword fight they attack with long range weapons like arrows, guns and cannons and then after that they engage close combat using spears, katana is mostly don't use.
それは侍ではなく武士である
@@BANZAI-kp7ou Pagkaklaro anang samurai.
@@secondyearjuanlunasantiago3217 侍は袴を着て刀で戦う者。武士は鎧を着て、鉄砲や大砲、槍で戦う者。
@@BANZAI-kp7ou Tingali literal ra kaayo imong pagsabot sa samurai.
m.th-cam.com/users/shortslvJXh2-Gi_g
足軽がいなくて寂しい
侍というより武者や武士って感じがする
何故？会津藩が倒幕なんだ？織田の旗も混じってるし歴史オンチアホが
制作したんだなｗｗｗｗwhy？Is the Aizu domain the curtain？The flag of Oda is also mixed. History ・crazy ・crazy ・crazy
4:08 Comander: We need to hide to
ambush them
Soldier:put down the flag sir?
Comander:No we need to show them who are ambush them
Soldier: Alright sir!
Nice vid hope to see more!
Just an FYI: The last battle in The Last Samurai was actually based on the real life Battle of Shiroyama. Information about it is available on Wikipedia.
Great film! Just a small note, you could have used Choshu or Tosa instead of Aizu for stand in as the Imperial Forces. There are some submods that make their uniform all black like the ones used by the later Imperial Army.
何故？会津藩が倒幕なんだ？織田の旗も混じってるし歴史オンチアホが
制作したんだなｗｗｗｗwhy？Is the Aizu domain the curtain？The flag of Oda is also mixed. History ・crazy ・crazy ・crazy
historic seinan war
reality
It is the largest shootout in the civil war.
Satsuma
Ancestors
1952 ～ 1598
Repelling 40 times more enemies
th-cam.com/video/q83RBq-WeTM/w-d-xo.html
Just a small note as I'm directing a Machinima similar to this. The shogunate forces Were the ones who adopted the cool cap hats or the french styled white caps with the Long sides not the imperials. But amazing movie and yes I know this is just fantasy. But for future movies might help when making a historical one. These are hard to make. Great camera angles and flow.
it's normal, it's a french general who trained the imperial army!
@@philboon lmao
何故？会津藩が倒幕なんだ？織田の旗も混じってるし歴史オンチアホが
制作したんだなｗｗｗｗwhy？Is the Aizu domain the curtain？The flag of Oda is also mixed. History ・crazy ・crazy ・crazy
@@rickymeadows5176 In history, it is not a samurai costume
Fought in the uniform of the Boshin War
Job Well Done , This Is Beautiful My Friend, I Love The Last Samurai I Use To Watch It Probably At My age of 7 or 8, Bro Your Awesome In Making Cinematic game War Please Make More.
2 years ago this video got me into the total war game series
awesome. Loved every second of it.
何故？会津藩が倒幕なんだ？織田の旗も混じってるし歴史オンチアホが
制作したんだなｗｗｗｗwhy？Is the Aizu domain the curtain？The flag of Oda is also mixed. History ・crazy ・crazy ・crazy
戦い知性が必要だ。双方の戦略、互換の戦いが観たい。次よろしく。
Amazing, thanks for sharing!
Amazing work.
Super animacija, . Ukratko objašnjeno, veoma jasno i precizno
何故？会津藩が倒幕なんだ？織田の旗も混じってるし歴史オンチアホが
制作したんだなｗｗｗｗwhy？Is the Aizu domain the curtain？The flag of Oda is also mixed. History ・crazy ・crazy ・crazy
Perfection ✌🏻
Great video ! 😊
Great video!!
Thanks!
Man this game is so fun. I really hope we get a shogun 3 in the future.
if the samurai knew the art of guerilla warfare, they would win because the emperor guns and rifles took almost 2 minutes to reload ( i think of the matchlock/flintlock mechanism idk) and the samurai has bows so if they hid in the forest they can win because bows reload faster.
Thought trained soldiers could fire 3 shots in 1 minute
@@mr.brooks8913 if your rifle firing mechanism are not flintlock/matchlock I think it is possible
@@mistersandwich0034 I read some that said some used breech loading cap rifles and some used the Snider rifle a breech loading rifle making it faster to reload.
@@mr.brooks8913 if that’s the rifles firing mechanism used in meiji restoration yes you can fire even 4 shots/minute if you are a very trained soldier
Another thing to count is Flintlock and matchlock were long outdated. cartridges were being made, and could of even used Bolt action rifles probably
この戦いはなかなか面白いしやろうとした人も少ないから良いな😊
Der Film mit Tom C. Hat das Gut gezeigt wie man die letzten Samurai vernichtet hatt . Ein grauer Tag Inder japanischen Geschichte . Gut dargestellt😂😂😂
新たな時代を迎えても侍の魂は日本人は受け継いでいる
何故？会津藩が倒幕なんだ？織田の旗も混じってるし歴史オンチアホが
制作したんだなｗｗｗｗwhy？Is the Aizu domain the curtain？The flag of Oda is also mixed. History ・crazy ・crazy ・crazy
オレは庄内人だけども、こげだものは納得いがねでば。この時代、刀ど槍、甲冑で戦うバァガは居ね。
作った外人は知らねさげしょうがねーどしても、日本人でこれを変だと思わね奴は馬ァ鹿
会津が新政府て、んだばオラだ勝ってだのｗ どうせだば平家や源氏の旗も加えでしまえ。
庄内2番大隊、酒井玄蕃の北斗の旗も加えでほしちゃ。
ฉันมาจากประเทศไทยฉันชอบญี่ปุ่น
@@Bccs เรื่องราวคือ
Seinan War
ผู้บัญชาการซัตสึมะ
ทาคาโมริ ไซโงะ
โตเกียว, สวนอุเอโนะ
รูปปั้นทองสัมฤทธิ์
Legendary total war cinematic movie producer!!
It is like the final pair of Mallet compound steam locomotives in 1959 putting on a grand final show of power pulling a 2 mile long mixed freight up a hill and into a railyard full of new and shiny diesels.
Recently I've discovered these videos are relaxing and fun to watch keep it up - Zilla
Se é Loko, melhor simulação de batalha de game que eu já vi
何故？会津藩が倒幕なんだ？織田の旗も混じってるし歴史オンチアホが
制作したんだなｗｗｗｗwhy？Is the Aizu domain the curtain？The flag of Oda is also mixed. History ・crazy ・crazy ・crazy
Fun fact:
The Shogunate Army wasn't outdated or backward and their military have a very large military structures (several corps with regiments that has their uniform customized from it corps standard)
like most of people thought (atleast for foreigners) its just that they have alots of melee infantry units.
If you watched some of videos on youtube about boshin war or meiji restoration(don't take much of the infos from these videos) They usually say that at the battle of Toba-Fushimi The Shogunate force had only two modernized battalions with them. Which is untrue because if you say "Shogunate force" without words "bakufu" or "government" it will include the other clans that companied them.
Aizu, Kuwana Ogaki and etc forces were pretty much modernized if youve done "deep" research
And as i said that there are many units so what Shogun 2 Players most likely doesn't know that is the uniform isn't accurate, the units during Boshin wars are complicated and hard to find on English source
so Shogun 2 dev team reimagined and designed their own troops
For Example the Azure Dragon force actually wear either armor or jinbaori instead of modern looking infantry uniform with cone hat
Satsuma Line Infantry and Ogaki clan Line Infantry are the ones that wear those.
Before the first shot fired at Toba-Fushimi as some of you know that the shogunate rifles werent loaded bc they didnt expect a fight. So of course it was a disaster
However on the second day the reinforcement arrived and Bakufu government sent some of other different regular and elite line infantry units such as Denshutai (Shogunate army uniform that you may have seen from armchair historian is not entirely accurate is they ain't their main force at the time
Yea it's a shame the Fall of the Samurai DLC is geared towards the Guns vs Samurai hype instead of actual historical accuracy.
The beginning of the samurai began around 880 AD in the Heian period of Japan. The samurai at that time were guards of the imperial court, but during the battle they wore armor and fought. The samurai took control from the Kamakura period when Minamoto no Yoritomo became a shogun in 1185 AD. The Kamakura period was from 1185 to 1350, after which Takauji Ashikaga became a shogun and the Ashikaga family continued for 15 generations during the Muromachi period. The Warring States period begins around 1610. Produced Japanese-made guns from around 1560, and in the battle of 1570. Fight with tactics using as many as 5,000 guns in one battle. According to the materials, the battle to use this number of guns at one time will be 280 years later in Europe, so I can be sure that the Japanese samurai were the best in the world in terms of fighting spirit and weapons. For about 280 years from the beginning of the 17th century when Ieyasu Tokugawa became a shogun, the Tokugawa family had been isolated from the country, so progress in battles such as weapons stopped for 280 years. Only 30 years after the end of the samurai era and the end of the seclusion, we were able to defeat Russia in the Russo-Japanese War because of the strength, combat skills, and comprehensive know-how of the 16th century. So many Japanese laughed at The Last Samurai starring Tom Cruise. It is not true that Samurai used a sword and the government used a gun that he was not accustomed to. Twenty years before the Last Samurai era, only the Satsuma Domain fought a local battle with Britain, and the Choshu Domain also fought Francis, Russia, Britain, and the Netherlands. Of course, the samurai also used a cannon. The Japanese emperor has the longest imperial tradition in the world, lasting 127 generations. From 1185 to 1860, when the samurai politicized, Japan was head of state by His Majesty the Emperor. Following Kamakura and Muromachi, even under the Tokugawa administration, the appointment was made by His Majesty the Emperor.
@@Jake-dh9qk the actual units are way cooler than the in game units
And there are tons of them
@@kazu9214 The beginning of the samurai began around 880 AD in the Heian period of Japan. The samurai at that time were guards of the imperial court, but during the battle they wore armor and fought. The samurai took control from the Kamakura period when Minamoto no Yoritomo became a shogun in 1185 AD. The Kamakura period was from 1185 to 1350, after which Takauji Ashikaga became a shogun and the Ashikaga family continued for 15 generations during the Muromachi period. The Warring States period begins around 1610. Produced Japanese-made guns from around 1560, and in the battle of 1570. Fight with tactics using as many as 5,000 guns in one battle. According to the materials, the battle to use this number of guns at one time will be 280 years later in Europe, so I can be sure that the Japanese samurai were the best in the world in terms of fighting spirit and weapons. For about 280 years from the beginning of the 17th century when Ieyasu Tokugawa became a shogun, the Tokugawa family had been isolated from the country, so progress in battles such as weapons stopped for 280 years. Only 30 years after the end of the samurai era and the end of the seclusion, we were able to defeat Russia in the Russo-Japanese War because of the strength, combat skills, and comprehensive know-how of the 16th century. So many Japanese laughed at The Last Samurai starring Tom Cruise. It is not true that Samurai used a sword and the government used a gun that he was not accustomed to. Twenty years before the Last Samurai era, only the Satsuma Domain fought a local battle with Britain, and the Choshu Domain also fought Francis, Russia, Britain, and the Netherlands. Of course, the samurai also used a cannon. The Japanese emperor has the longest imperial tradition in the world, lasting 127 generations. From 1185 to 1860, when the samurai politicized, Japan was head of state by His Majesty the Emperor. Following Kamakura and Muromachi, even under the Tokugawa administration, the appointment was made by His Majesty the Emperor.
so long since ive seen a shogun 2 vid like this
it was AMAZING!
Fun fact: when this rebellion actually started the Imperial Army was using swords and bows and the rebelling Samurai were using guns, so Last Samurai reversed the whole thing.
侍は刀を鞘に収めるので刀を手に持って行進する事はありません
Excellent work.
実際はアメリカやヨーロッパからの新旧の武器で新政府も幕府軍で武装していたし、幕府軍でもアメリカの最新式の武器の装備で負け知らずの藩もあった。
それらの年の写真だけがそうではないと言います
The Way of the Warrior is over, the Way of the soldier has just begun.
ラスト・サムライにこの描写ありましたね
I love how whenever the Imperial troops fire, the smoke clouds resembles a dragon.
Tenno Heika, Banzai! indeed!
Samurais were using match lock guns before 1570s. Sooner they also started used cannons for castle sieging. In 1570s Japan was the largest gun holder.
Yeah, mosquettes with old design, copied from the 16th century. But unrifled barrels, that were useless for the 19th century.
@@sandroschmitt5660 whats the point bringing up about 19th centur’s gunbarrel to 1570 guns? And musket is oldest gun mechanism. match locks are different. Japanese imported matchlock mechanism gun from Portugal. Not from your fantasic history.
And i was talking about 1570s japan. And you compare 16th century? Its same era dude.
Three points of stupidity. You are out!
@@sandroschmitt5660 Japan's advanced gun manufacturing technology in the 16th century came to a complete halt with the establishment of the Tokugawa family's feudal system. By the time admiral Perry started gunboat diplomacy, it was too late and the Edo Shogunate was completely conquered by the ever-advancing technology of the Western powers.
Super epic. Wonder what the real battles between the Imperial Army and the Traditionalists looked like.
Pretty much the same as other conflicts where "old guard" try to fight changing times...... They got mowed down and the times changed over their dead bodies.
何故？会津藩が倒幕なんだ？織田の旗も混じってるし歴史オンチアホが
制作したんだなｗｗｗｗwhy？Is the Aizu domain the curtain？The flag of Oda is also mixed. History ・crazy ・crazy ・crazy
historic seinan war
reality
It is the largest shootout in the civil war.
Satsuma
Ancestors
1952 ～ 1598
Repelling 100 times more enemies
th-cam.com/video/q83RBq-WeTM/w-d-xo.html
While this sort of portrayal is really exciting and evocative, the real life thing was unsurprisingly different. Contemporary Japanese depictions show both sides with a mix of weaponry and uniforms. This reflects the fact that the Satsuma Rebellion was less about modernization versus tradition than it was about what the power structure would be in the new system. The Satsuma Domain that led the famous samurai revolt was actually one of the main drivers of the Meiji Restoration in the first place. Its leader, Saigo Takamori, wore a French military uniform while leading the rebellious samurai. They were not really traditionalists, they were just unhappy that some reforms had reduced their own prestige.
@@rypo59 from what I know, wasn't the only reason the Samurai didn't have guns in the final battle was because they had to leave them behind in the retreat?
外国人が描いた幕末の日本。
江戸幕府軍に小銃や大砲が無く新政府軍の銃火器に無残に殺戮されてるが実際は1500年半ばには戦場に銃火器が使われており刀だけで戦うことはなかった。
あとガトリング砲も当時は日本に２丁しかなく新政府軍と新潟県の長岡藩の河合継之助がロシア人商人から購入して実戦に使用していた。
日本人からしたら残念な動画。
エンターテイメントだもん
歴史検証動画じゃないししょうがない。
00:01 に歴史的な出来事に基づいてない言うとるがな
Is only a Game :|
字幕付きで見たら分かりますよ、事前にちゃんと断ってある
「残念な動画」とか言う前に、動画の冒頭の文章すらきちんと読まず、ただ自分の知識をひけらかすようなコメントを垂れ流す貴方の「残念な脳みそ」をまずどうにかしてください。「日本人からしたら」とか、あたかも日本人の総意であるかのような書き方も本当に意味不明。
Awesome video
Awesome!!!
Allow me to ruin your fun of wild imaginations. Members of the Samurai caste of this period also used guns, wore modern uniforms, and were trained in modern fighting style.
and still got defeated by the imperial forces, shogunate samurais no matter how advanced they are their fate has already been sealed
so what problem give samurai the guns? it would be more cool
侍側に鉄砲隊が全くいないのがおかしいよ😭
めっちゃ思った。なんなら大砲も戦国時代からあったしね…あと、普通は大きな置き盾や防弾用の竹束などで防御しながら前進していくから、そもそも当時の戦い方があまり再現できてない感を感じた。(そもそも日本にこんな平坦な地形の場所は少ないから、全兵力を注いで真正面から衝突…みたいな事は両軍ともにないでしょうとも思う。)
おふたりとも動画冒頭の前書き読まれましたか？
※ラストサムライを参考にしています
実際の事実とはことなります
@@user-lx2vu3ix1i さん、見てませんでした😭すいません🙏
@@wc4octopus さん、すいません、タイトルをしっかり見てませんでした🙏
ありがとうございました🙏
頑張って再現してるわ awesome!
抜刀しちゃってるのがもったいない
Appreciate ur time, work & effort. Subscription came immediately from me
Excelente película, me encantó todo, sigue así amigo
Edit: no sé inglés
I miss the part where the Samurai leader looks at the tree in full blossom and says "Perfect" before he dies.
2:13 that katana was a mystical treasire since it can pass thorough that samurai without kill him
Those samurai ran a marathon lol. Our troops are fatigue my lord and some must rest!
BGMは、日本軍歌「宮さん宮さん」か、「陸軍分列行進曲 抜刀隊」がいいと思います。
The imperial forces are firing.
Many of the samurai are taking hits, some even going down. Yet they continue to charge.
They are now about to clash with the front lines. Battle is about to begin.
Ad.
Great battle I like it. Could you do a jedi knight vs usa army. thank You for your great work you put into this greatness
really good!
What were the stats and casualties for the battle?
Very well done, especially with the lay of the land, plus the animation excellent.
何故？会津藩が倒幕なんだ？織田の旗も混じってるし歴史オンチアホが
制作したんだなｗｗｗｗwhy？Is the Aizu domain the curtain？The flag of Oda is also mixed. History ・crazy ・crazy ・crazy
It's the nature of time, that the old ways must give in.
total war, not bird's eye view gameplay, but cinematic, worth watching!
Well done
I watch and hope the samurais win. Who the same?
Me
The last to fight the samurai were the subordinates who were samurai months to years ago.
I actually lijr engagements like out of anime Gate where we see modern army decimate ancient one.
Nice video, very cool way of telling history!
Glad you enjoyed it!
If you decide to play this battle again, or any total war battle set in Japan, try using the swedish caroleans tactics.@@WarAndHistory.
Artillery barrage comes , samurais: continues walking peacefully
I love this video, do naval battles next please, like samurai boats vs foreign ships. That would be really cool.
何故？会津藩が倒幕なんだ？織田の旗も混じってるし歴史オンチアホが
制作したんだなｗｗｗｗwhy？Is the Aizu domain the curtain？The flag of Oda is also mixed. History ・crazy ・crazy ・crazy
侍は剣術だけじゃなく格闘術も凄かったと聞くので接近戦だとかなり強かったんだろうなー
Настоящее сражение доказало обратное. Ведь данная анимация основана на реальной сражении.
@@user-in6gl9ff9s But this is just a base, and the samurai actually fought back with guns, and the war was actually fought in various other places, so this is not the whole result.
我记得这个好像还有真人的电影 倒幕战争我们在初中学过 最后在五棱郭
@@user-in6gl9ff9s Don't say it's based on a real battle if you don't know anything
я учусь в университете японской истории. Ты не прав. ошибочные знания - это само собой разумеющееся
Lawl! The Satsuma Rebellion was restricted to the island of Kyushu. Even if they had somehow defeated the imperial army, the government will just send in another invasion that will eventually destroy the Satsuma Domain.
thanks
ゲーム画面に文句言っても仕方がないのだけれども、かなり史実とかけ離れている。
こういう侍と近代兵士の戦いは西南戦争だと思われるけれど、当時、官軍、近代兵士側は組織されて間がなく、その多くが農民出身のため、統制の取れた動きなど出来なくて、
ひどい場合はまともに走ることも出来なかった。義務教育で体育が取り入れられているのはその為だったりする。
なので序盤は、侍側に圧倒されていて、近代兵器と兵力の大量増員でなんとか勝てたっての言うのが史実。
The chad samurai VS the virgin imperial army
My first Total war game was Shogun 1. It was loads of fun, but I like the graphics and gameplay from Shogun 2.
hope to see moreTotal War: Shogun 2😀
Please more samurai fights
Nice🍿😚
War doesn't determine who's right, just who's left.
Outstanding.
Excelente animacion de lo que pudo ser en la realidad..gracias campeon.👍
何故？会津藩が倒幕なんだ？織田の旗も混じってるし歴史オンチアホが
制作したんだなｗｗｗｗwhy？Is the Aizu domain the curtain？The flag of Oda is also mixed. History ・crazy ・crazy ・crazy
Es una lástima que hombres tan valientes como eran los samurais murieran en esta batalla, gloria eterna a todos ellos. Excelente representación y los gráficos son muy buenos, lo felicito por el trabajo que realizó
Oh cmon. Don’t act like there so protected down trotted people. Practically Janissarys
Well I am unaware of the history, therefore was hoping for a Zulu Dawn moment as 'bullets run out'. Thanks enjoyed watching
I'm addicted to the samurai code of Bushido, Blessed Be.