@StickyRice You can said that, but who care ? Hmong is only tiny sub group of the Miao. The Miao is like the Han- who have many dialect. Just like the Lao and the Thai who every one will be understandable.
Fun fact: there are actually more ethnic Mongols living in China than in Mongolia, many of which are concentrated in the Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region. In addition, Mongols in China still use the traditional Mongolian writing script, whereas Mongolia had abandoned it in favor of the Cyrillic writing script.
Why do you write that Hui people and Uyghurs speak arabic? Of course, it's the language of islam, but they do not speak it in everyday life. And manchu people almost don't speak their native language, because they almost forgot it. Thank you guys for your videos, I really like them, I've just pointed out little mistakes :)
True, I am Hui guy living in Qinghai my parents are actually working in Fuzhou so I am chilling at my grandpa with my sisters and brothers. And Arabic is actually our language to speak in mosque or to talk to other Muslims which are from other places. Btw Taiwan recognizes us as Islamic Han because we live spreading out in China, like Zheng He he was Hui from Yunnan. We are also Sinitic like Han or Tibetans and Burmese etc.
Hui people don't speak Arabic or Farisi. They are Han Chinese who converted to Islamic religion. I'm a Hui. I don't speak any of those languages, just a few phrashes.
2:30 What you're describing here isn't polytheism, but animism. Granted, there's a certain overlap, but the definition you give is most descriptive of animism. [/pedant]
China, is, like America, a melting pot of many ancient ethnicity. Even the biggest group Han Chinese, they are a product of many different ethnic groups mixed marriage/combination throughout the thousand years of Chinese history. From the combination Si-Yi (Rong-Di-Yi-Man) during the late Zhou dynasty, the combination of Xiongnu during the Han dynasty, the Xianbei during the Tang dynasty, the Khitan during Song dynasty, the Mongol during the Yuan, the Manchu during the Qing dynasty, and plus many thousand minorities throughout history. Therefore, Chinese is a nationality like "American". A person can be ANY ethnicity and still be Chinese.
Yes you are correct pigboykool, and know your history quite well. But China is still ruled by Han Chinese Mandarin speaker only, and tends to discriminate other minority groups.
pigboykool Yes,you are right ,i am Chinese live in Europe ,Han Chinese is very Mixed too ,but Han culture is dominated culture in Chinese world ,Even mongolia control China ,they used han culture And most of noble Mongolian stayed in China And become "han Chinese ,such as family name Jin or Bao are original Mongolian family .
@@sanmiaokingdom1843 Discrimination? Are you kidding me ?Other ethnic minorities have privileges in China, and Mongols and Manchus have ruled China in history.
No, chinese is not like American. Unlike America, they have immigrants coming in and becoming American. Those ethnic ppl have lived in China for thousands of years, even during the Silk Road ages.
I was born and raised in guangxi, zhuang autonomous area. It is really hard to distinguish zhuang or yao or any other minorities in guangxi nowday, usually we can know from their accents. But most of us can speak 3 dialects and you can choose to be a Han or minority if one of you parent is minority ( we definitely choose to be minority because of minority privilege policies, lol)
+Филип Брчић With a serious face, I say it's time to get one of those DNA kits, who knows you might trace your lineage back to that one ancestor that came by the ancient silk route. :)
Aye, thanks for including our people. 我們是苗族. It's only in China that we call ourselves Miao but every where else in the world, we call ourselves Hmong. But then again, there are four group that makes up the Miao. Xong, Hmub, A-Hmao, and Hmong. Some of the grouping also doesn't consider themselves to be categorized as Miao because of cultural difference and language. But as of now, only the Hmong people are the known group that have migrated out of China. They migrated to South East Asia then from there to other countries such as the United States, Europe, and Australia as refugee during the Vietnam War. Thank you for sharing :3
So really when someone is described as “Chinese”, it is really describing a nationality not a race or ethnicity. It is the same as when you call someone American it is their NATIONALITY , they could be white,black, Asian etc… but they are American .Same goes for a lot of countries.
I'm Hmong myself...we have a long history in China dating back to the B.C....even though we have spread throughout the world we never forget we're we come from....to be honest I was surprised to see us on the list...btw thanks for your videos..
hui is an ethnic han who is Muslim, they are called hui because Islam is not because of ethnicity, and hui does not speak Arabic or farsi, the Arabic language they use only in religious matters is not daily language.
Uyghurs and Hui don't speak arabic and persian languages. Uyghurs are turkic people, and Hui are muslim chinese. They speak a northern chinese dialect which is much more close to mandarin than other dialects
You know people can quote you, right? When referring to the Uyghurs "They speak a northern chinese dialect which is much *_more close to mandarin than other dialects_*"
thankyou for this video, i've had to explain my ethnic background so much in my life and people are still confused. i always say that im Hmong and they pout as if my answer doesnt satisfy their curiousity. i guess thats because they want to be able to associate me to a certain country. then they ask "where is that at?" that is i when i tell them that my ethnicity is a minority group that lives in china to southeast asia. but some people here in OC cant grasp the concept of it. i always end up saying "you know how there is Native Americans in America but theyre not the same group and lives in different regions? well same concept but in asia."
As a Hmong/Miao from the USA... I applauded you guys for using the word Hmong...I am told that in South East Asia... the Hmongs took the word Miao/mao as offensive... I remember asking my dad, who the Miao/Mao, people were... He said they are not us, we are not Chinese people, we live in Loas for ages. I asked him because we were suppose to do a report for class on our heritage, and typing Hmong, at the time, 90s... got you no where... But typing Vietnam refugees, you see Mao.. and that's how I ended up with pictures, stories, of the famed Mao people who helped the downed American Pilot, led by a General, named Vang Pao....
ScorpiusTheScorpin In fact, hmong is a branch of miao. Not all miao are Hmong. In China, only the miao of the western branch is hmong, and the rest miao is not hmong.
The Hmong are a beautiful culture. I'm aware of this attitude in southeast Asia towards the word "Miao.". It seems like the word is not considered offensive in China. It's strange how this division has emerged. Is it really because "Miao" sounds like a cat in some language? Or is that a myth?
Fun fact Miao was stateless people live on the hill...that's why they called Miao(wild cat/barbarian) coz they won't obey han chinese authority...and some left china and went to SEA due to goverment expansion China was multicultural until 1 ethnic group dominates the land by population
Nope, depends on the area.... northern people in shanghai, beijing they are mixed or forgotton their roots but in cities/areas like chengdu, fujian, shenzhen, wuhan, etc still have majority pure han people who are shorter in height
@@treeman12815 hi, common history in the history book, I'm not historian, but I know that the time before the Qin Dynasty around 200bc, this region was full of countries or city-states with each one has their own language, meurement . Different philosophies, clothing and money (medium of exchange) ... only left with some dialects today . The word han appears only after the Han dynasty.
Yes, but Han Chinese in general have diverse look because of intermarriage with other ethnics. Northern Han have more northern mix, southern Han have more southern mix, and Hui have western Asian mix
But we have Persian + Arab blood and you don't. xD The definition of Hui blood is as ambiguous as Latino/Hispanic people. There's all sorts of mixing in different degrees. The government just likes to group all Han-speaking muslims as Hui. Some Hui are Han forced to convert, while others mostly have a mix of Mongol blood.
1) The chopstick song can be played on the piano :D 2) These guys are awesome. Great hearing Mandarin (?) with an American accent. 3) Seriously, thank you for a great video!
There are also plenty of Hui people (回族) in Quanzhou, Fujian (福建省泉州市), said to be descendants of ancient Persian and Arab traders who have arrived in China back during Quanzhou's heyday as one of the world's greatest ports, "a haven for commerce and trade" as described by Marco Polo during the Yuan and Ming dynasties. China's first mosque, known as Ashab Mosque (清淨寺) is also in Quanzhou city, built in 1009 AD, when Quanzhou was also known as the starting point for the Maritime Silk Road trade stretching from East Asia down to Southeast Asia, and all the way to the Middle East / Africa.
I can't. "50 ethnic minorities making up only 9% of china. Here's an ethnic minority group" *minority group still bigger than my entire country's population, not just ethnic but total population*
Awesome video. I learned a lot! You didn’t mention Cantonese or other dialects/language of the Han. Would be great to highlight diversity even within Han Chinese.😉
Tibetans are not ethnic groups of China. If you have researched better, Tibet was a forcefully occupied nation by the Communist China. China is a selfless poison in this universe, doing all those inhuman acts. Now China is trying to occupy Hong Kong just like Tibet and East Turkistan. Free Tibet, Free East Turkistan, Free Hong Kong
I just want to make a little correction. In the video, the Han language was listed as Mandarin, but the Han also speaks more than just Mandarin. They also speak Shanghainese, Cantonese, Hokkien, Hakka, and etc (they're all related to the Old Chinese language and a shared writing). These speakers of the several dialects/languages make up the 1.2 billion people.
Dude, in reality there are over 300 dialects spoken in mainland China itself. And the Han, being the vast majority of the population mostly speak Mandarin as their language (or IF they know more than 1) they speak Mandarin 1st since it's whats tought and used in China now. The Han are spread out in the main areas of China with large cities and that includes places like Shanghai, Guangzhou, and other areas where many of the individual dialects were indead originated. Since Mandarin is tought in school, most families who speak other dialect may continue to pass down their own dialects in the family, but they will/must learn Mandarin. In reality it is vastly impossible to calculate how many Han themselves know a second dialect (if any). Would it be Cantonese from far Southern China, the Hakka next door, Min a little farther up, Wu to the far East coast, or Gan farther inward... who knows. And Shanghainese is actually spoken by around 14 million Chinese currently. That's isn't even in the top 10 in China. It's to complicated to calculate how many Han know a 2nd dialect, then find out WHICH dialect it is. As I said it's more common for people who know the minority dialects to learn Mandarin, than the Han, who the vast majority naturally know Mandarin learn another dialect. In China most people try to actually learn English as a 2nd language in school to do well. Even now in Hong Kong, it's won't be fully part of China until 2047, but they are already trying to switch from teaching Cantonese to Mandarin. In reality it makes sense to just list Mandarin under Han.
Hui people are native speakers of Mandarin, Arabic only restricted to recitation of Quranic verses. Uyghur people speak Uyghur which is a Turkic language similar to languages spoken by other neighbouring Turkic groups like the Kazakhs and the Kirghiz, and like the Hui, the use of Arabic is restricted to religious settings.
I'm ethnically Han but I haven't heard of the Han mark thing before... I'm guessing it's a childhood story that some Han parents tell their children? Now that you guys have covered some Chinese ethnic groups, how about covering some Han sub-ethnic groups, e.g. Cantonese, Hakka, Hokkien, Shanghainese, Hainanese etc.? I think that would be something interesting yet not known by many non-Chinese, too.
Like see all the 56 ethnics of China. Love the overview. Please do more episodes for each ethnic. Like 30 min. mini episode of each ethnic. The story line will entail their way of life: food, dialects, clothing and marriage etc.
I'm half Han half Manchu and I honestly don't think even my great grandma from the manchu side knows how to speak the manchu language. The language is totally dying out sadly :/
Please do more stuff like this please :) This is a super cool video. However I think Miao chinese is also in Vietnam, Thailand and other SEA (South East Asian) countries as well.
+Chloe Chang Nice see another who enjoys learning about diverse cultures. You are right the Miao who are also known as Hmong and Meo also live in Vietnam and I believe Lao. There are/were are huge number of sub groups of Miao each with their own distinct costume. In ancient times they were the rulers of much of southern china.
+Chloe Chang right! Finally! But yeah Hmong/Miao/Meo are really all over the place. Both my parents are Hmong, and my dad was born in Laos and came to Thailand during the Laotian Civil War as baby. He grew up most of his life in a Refugee camps. My mom was born in Thailand, and my family and I came to the United States in 2004. This is really exciting, its not everyday that people talk about the Hmong people. Hmong's are such a small minority groups compare to the other ethnicity groups.
Yeah, it's the same thing， since Han and Tang are two most powerful dynasties in Chinese history. Just like the Tang Ren Jie in most western countries. If if were the northern Chinese who got there first, it could be called Han Ren Jie (I guess)
Thank you for honoring Hui muslims as clean, disciplined, ans serious people with their food restrictions as muslims without pork the most consumed meat, they made better foods without pork. It warms my heart because you recognized them as good people which in fact i beleive they are. I am muslim also from Bosnia.
I've got a question! Does one's family name have any bearing on the ethnic group one might belong to or be descended from?? I've got a friend whose family name is Hui but all of her family (at least this generation) are from HK and speak Cantonese. Does her family name mean she's likely to be descended from the Hui Chinese?
+Jay Hughes: Yep, by tracing the family name is one of the easiest way to found out his/her ancestral background of a person other than testing his/her DNA. It is one of the reason why the Chinese see their children carrying on their last name in the next generation is so important.
+pigboykool though sometimes tracing family name isn't the same as tracing your genetic heritage. As, because carrying on the family name has been so important in China and other Confucian societies, people with no son or children of their own might adopt someone to pass their name as a last resort. If one had daughters, then adopting the husband of your daughter, so that he could carry on the name was an option, but it could also be someone completely unrelated. So while you can draw conclusions from a family name of what a person's ancestry is likely to have been, it's not completely certain. Especially with more famous names like Kong.
+Jay Hughes No. My cousin's last name is Hui. It is a Cantonese romanization of the name Xu or Hsu depending on where u are from. The Hui people is a shortened form of the word for Islam in Chinese, at least from what I know since Islam is Hui Jiao.
+DarthJF: Even it is possible to have adopting children to bear one's family name, however, majority of the people are the decendents of the Family Name trees. Up till Qing Dynasty and the beginning of Republic of China, no matter if you are poor or rich, each family (usually a village) strictly recorded down every single person in his/her Family Name tree. People can easily trace back their ancestor for hundreds of years with these records.
There is a book called the 100 surnames. Anyone who's surname is not on that MIGHT be an ethnic minority. Theres been lots of mixing so its only a very rough guide.
The hui people, are genetically han chinese that married the Persian and arab trader in the silk road, while the Uighur people are straight up turks with some indo european blood in them thats why the uighur looked like eurasian and the most famous celeb in china is uighur dilraba dilmurat.
Background information. China counts some non-Han groups who have been living within the territory of China since history as ethnic groups, even though some of these ethnic groups now have their own countries. These ethnic groups are ethnically, culturally and linguistically similar as those living in other countries, but they have Chinese nationalities. Some examples are Jing people (Vietnamese), Dai people (Thai), Chaoxian people (Korean), Eluosi people (Russian), Menggu people (Mongolian) Hasake people (Kazakh), Keerkezi people (Kyrgyz), Tajike people(Tajik), etc.
Tibet is not part of China. In 1959, Chinese govt occupied our country and many of the Tibetans were forced from flee from their own country. Thousands were massacred and imprisoned.From 2008 during Beijing Olympics event onwards till now, more than 100s of Tibetans had self immolated which is the clear proof that we are not happy under the oppressive rule under Chinese govt. We Tibetans don't have hatred towards the Chinese people. As we know due to severe censorship and indoctrination, the people got misled by the govt. It's saddening that our own people are minority in its own country right now.
Fun fact, what you're describing with the Zhuang minority sounds like animism (belief in living souls/spirits in natural objects) and not polytheism (belief in more than one god) :D Also it's interesting that there are ‘Hui Streets', like Chinatowns outside of China.
"separated like their dialects, like in India" Indian ethnic groups are just separated by dialects? No. The languages are extremely different, some quite more than others. That's like saying that Wolof, Spanish, and Mandarin are all just different dialects.
Add about minute 2:19 when you talk about the Duog the 2nd ethnic group. I think you confused animism for polytheism. You gave the definition for animism but said that the group was polytheistic.
According to the Book of the Han, "No one can enter the middle kingdom without having the Mark of the Han". When the world is destroyed by nuclear weapons, only the Middle Kingdom will still stand and will be the only kingdom to survive. China is the one of the oldest civilization to survive and will continue to survive. Those with the mark of the Han will be allowed to live and prosper in the Middle Kingdom. Those without it will be forced out to dwell in caves. People with the Mark of the Han are gifted and comes from the the Heavens. These people use to be called "The Celestials. They came from the sky and started an empire in "Celestial Kingdom". Which is now known as China. Chinese immigrants to America were used to be called "the Celestials". Remember where you came from. If you are a Han Chinese, you are God's children. You are the gifted one. And God promised to protect us and will welcome us to the Middle Kingdom. And the Mark of the Han is a Promise to all Han Chinese.
What’s funny is that the Han aren’t even a single unified ethnic group. It’s more of a pan-ethnicity like Arabs or Hispanics or White Americans. The idea of a single unified Han nation came out of the 19th century to unify all of the groups historically part of the Han Dynasty in order to overthrow the Manchu dominated Qing Dynasty.
i am of south Asian descent (Pakistani) my father is like borders Pakistan, and mom is Punjabi Indian roots, I have that line!!!!!! Another question, as I am Muslim and would love to visit China,but due to dietary restrictions I would visit a place with halal food, so where are highest number of HUI?
The Hui are just Han that converted to Islam. Uyghur doesn't mean "to come together" - it's a mystery, actually, regarding it's etymology, since "Uyghur" is most likely related to the ancient Turkic word "Oghuz", which just means "community". Uyghurs aren't Caucasian and they're certainly not even remotely Chinese - they're Turks. Karluk Turks, to be more precise, meaning they share much more ethnic and cultural ties with Uzbekistan than they do with the Chinese or even neighboring Kazakh and Kyrgyz. However, Central Asian Turkic languages are about as similar as modern Chinese languages ( an Istanbul Turk, an Uzbek, a Kazakh and a Uyghur can communicate similarly to how a Mandarin, Cantonese, Fujian and Min speaker could), so, at least in my experience, Uyghurs identify most strongly with simply being not Chinese and there's a lot of camaraderie among Kazakhs, Kyrgyz, Uzbek and Uyghur communities in and outside of China. Before 1920s, Uyghurs were just called the 'Turki' with Uyghur is a revived ethnic term intending to call back to the ancient Uyghur from the second and third Göktürk Khanate (these Uyghurs, interestingly enough, are responsible for creating the alphabet that would later go on to be used by Gengis Khan in pre-Soviet controlled Mongolia). Most Uyghurs before 1920s just identified themselves based upon where they were from in the Tarim basin (i.e Kashgarliq - The Kashgarians, etc.) Why reclaim an old name? Soviets. Kazakh, Uzbek, Kyrgyz, Uyghur, Istanbul Turk, Azeri, Turkmen or any other "Turkic" tribe really only came about in the modern era with the rise of the European nation state and the era of divide and conquer politics. They're contrived identities, the Soviets hoped that once the Uyghurs had a common banner to unite around, it would organize them better into breaking off from China and joining the other Central Asian Republics in the Soviet Union (similar to the policy enacted in Mongolia, trying to reconcile "Buryat" Mongols with "Oirat" Mongols in China with "Khalkha" Mongols in Outer Mongolia). To many Turkic people, they're all just brothers from another mother and proudly say they're "Turks". Therefore, the most identifying trait for a Uyghur, next to being a Turk and a Muslim, is simply "not being Chinese"
wow even the wikipedia could show me my ethnic history so clear as your comment. thank you! !! there must be a reason that you studied so much about mongoloids and turks????
John Doyle Wagner Right, Uygurs are Turkic people and our brothers. And they never related themselves to Chinese people. Their language and culture just like ours.
Hui is as ambiguous as Latino/Hispanic. We have a mix of middle east, central asian, east asian, and also 'pure' Han. How dare you deny that my ancestors came from Persia through the silk road 1000 years ago.
2:30 actually... Polytheism is the belief in multiple Gods, I learnt this in year 8 history, while we were learning about ANCIENT CHINA. Not all Polytheists believe that objects are magical.
I seriously adore and appreciate your cultural videos! Also, I saw Shen Yun years ago, I'm so glad that you're recommending it because it was a phenomenal and gorgeous experience
I am a Pakistani . But ethically a Tibetan. So most of my friends would called me as Chinese or Mongolian. And I would say "Ya , Ghenghez Khan was my great great grandfather "
JOhn dong No Han is just one of the many Chinese ethnicities, it is the major one but it doesn't equal to Chinese. And I'm referring to how they say Han Chinese only speaks mandarin in the video, when Cantonese is as, if not more popular if you consider overseas Han Chinese as well
JOhn dong Err... han yu may be Chinese's national language, but it's not Chinese's only language... That's like saying an apple is equal to a fruit. No, there are other ethnicity who aren't hans but are still Chinese.
I'm so glad you made this video! I know it makes sense to mostly talk about Han Chinese since that's the vast majority of Chinese people, but I love learning about the lesser known (outside of China that is) people groups!
@@kamalvanderbuben 老外（lâowài) [sorry I can't type the 3rd falling tone pinyin mark on my computer for some reason] literally means (old foreign) but is a term of endearment or a nickname to someone who is not Chinese.
I liked when you said tea in mandarin it was the same like in our language "čaj" (slovak) maybe because of russian influence. Ps. I dont have the han mark ;)
I don't know about the Han mark, but another symbol that represents of Han is having two nails on your foot little finger, and no matter how many times you cut it off, it grows back, that means you are 100% Han people without mix others Gene.
faeirydancer U have to be Chinese first, then do the test. It’s like a bonus proof, if u know what I mean. Most of my friends including myself, have it. My ex-gf doesn’t have it and she’s Tibetan.
Nice video, I am Hui Chinese but you know we speak Arabic only in the mosque or to communicate with other Muslims. By the way in Taiwan they recognize us as Han Chinese but than Islamic Han. I have also a Han mark, but I normally speak Mandarin.
back to 400 years you spoke Chinese . speaking about the race (range over 20k years),there will be no strict boundary of modern countries...tho the han mark is bullshit I think..just you fat..
So, if a Han Chinese can't find a wife (or a husband), then is s/he Han . . . solo?
(Sorry, couldn't resist.)
+Nick Hentschel you my friend, you deserve an award!
DarkWolfyPrincess 10,000 yuan . . . all in advance.
+Nick Hentschel can confirm, am Han solo, and cousine is han solo, and teacher is han solo, and mayor is han solo...
+Data Integration Thought Entity Humanoid Interface
Han's a busy man, isn't he?
Nick Hentschel hehe yeah, we're quite busy ^^
looked at my arm. had han mark. im black. my ancestors have some explaining to do.
+WoWplayer527 Likewise, I'm of Italian and English heritage and am white.
+WoWplayer527 I have it as well O.O.
i´ve got the same ... guess they are just kidding :)
Chinese like to claim that everyone is han...lol
Qaboos Mintaka
No. Everyone like to claim they are Chinese. You can guess why .... lololo
I'm a Hui but we don't speak Arabic but do use Arabic letters sometime
Tammy May yea You guys use it only when you make salah ?
We also use arabic in our prayers only
hui people never chinese
@@tanktalking5300WTF? I have so many hui friends and they are all Chinese.
tank talking don’t tell u who we are when u aren’t one. 😠
I'm from the Miao, also known as the Hmong! It's great to be who I am, I am proud to be Hmong and proud to have some history with China!
Congrats to having a language that's harder to learn than Cantonese (that's a compliment really, 8 tones! yikes).
If we lump Hmong from southeast Asia with those in China they actually outnumber the uyghurs.
*Mongic
@StickyRice You can said that, but who care ? Hmong is only tiny sub group of the Miao. The Miao is like the Han- who have many dialect. Just like the Lao and the Thai who every one will be understandable.
I’m confused, I though Miao is a slur to Hmong people but here you are proudly referring to yourself as Miao??
Just to clarify, the Han mark is a tale. The Han mark is actually just a stretch mark on your arm from growing
i dont have this mark so youre wrong
@@matthewmatthew981 wasp?
@@Mirsab never mind.
Exactly, I'm not Han Chinese so I was very confused and scared that whether My ancestors were Chinese ?!!
I'm not a Han or a Chinese, but I have the marks 😆
Fun fact: there are actually more ethnic Mongols living in China than in Mongolia, many of which are concentrated in the Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region. In addition, Mongols in China still use the traditional Mongolian writing script, whereas Mongolia had abandoned it in favor of the Cyrillic writing script.
its true, we love seeing inner Mongolians singing in their mother tongue in national tv, inner Mongolian alternative rock is the best
The Mongols who are living in China are the real descendants of Genghis Khan
@@danyawang3632 Are you talking about jindandao incident or cultural revolution ?
Russia outlawed mongolian script at some point.. Much like China is trying to do these days.
@@danyawang3632 lmao you are one of those people arent ya
Why do you write that Hui people and Uyghurs speak arabic? Of course, it's the language of islam, but they do not speak it in everyday life.
And manchu people almost don't speak their native language, because they almost forgot it.
Thank you guys for your videos, I really like them, I've just pointed out little mistakes :)
True, I am Hui guy living in Qinghai my parents are actually working in Fuzhou so I am chilling at my grandpa with my sisters and brothers. And Arabic is actually our language to speak in mosque or to talk to other Muslims which are from other places. Btw Taiwan recognizes us as Islamic Han because we live spreading out in China, like Zheng He he was Hui from Yunnan. We are also Sinitic like Han or Tibetans and Burmese etc.
Rahman Yu Dong 听说回族并不是根据种族来看的，是根据信仰
Uighur doesn't speak Arabic they have their own language
Shuo Cheng 是的我们是他的汉族但来自青海的伊斯兰教的问候
Hui people don't speak Arabic or Farisi. They are Han Chinese who converted to Islamic religion. I'm a Hui. I don't speak any of those languages, just a few phrashes.
2:30
What you're describing here isn't polytheism, but animism. Granted, there's a certain overlap, but the definition you give is most descriptive of animism.
[/pedant]
Thanks captain helper
I know this comment is really old but I was going to say the same thing
Polytheism actually means belief in many gods.
China, is, like America, a melting pot of many ancient ethnicity.
Even the biggest group Han Chinese, they are a product of many different ethnic groups mixed marriage/combination throughout the thousand years of Chinese history.
From the combination Si-Yi (Rong-Di-Yi-Man) during the late Zhou dynasty, the combination of Xiongnu during the Han dynasty, the Xianbei during the Tang dynasty, the Khitan during Song dynasty, the Mongol during the Yuan, the Manchu during the Qing dynasty, and plus many thousand minorities throughout history.
Therefore, Chinese is a nationality like "American". A person can be ANY ethnicity and still be Chinese.
Yes you are correct pigboykool, and know your history quite well. But China is still ruled by Han Chinese Mandarin speaker only, and tends to discriminate other minority groups.
pigboykool Yes,you are right ,i am Chinese live in Europe ,Han Chinese is very Mixed too ,but Han culture is dominated culture in Chinese world ,Even mongolia control China ,they used han culture And most of noble Mongolian stayed in China And become "han Chinese ,such as family name Jin or Bao are original Mongolian family .
pigboykool Very true. I am trying to tell many ignorant people about this but they just dont get it.
@@sanmiaokingdom1843 Discrimination? Are you kidding me ?Other ethnic minorities have privileges in China, and Mongols and Manchus have ruled China in history.
No, chinese is not like American. Unlike America, they have immigrants coming in and becoming American. Those ethnic ppl have lived in China for thousands of years, even during the Silk Road ages.
I was born and raised in guangxi, zhuang autonomous area. It is really hard to distinguish zhuang or yao or any other minorities in guangxi nowday, usually we can know from their accents. But most of us can speak 3 dialects and you can choose to be a Han or minority if one of you parent is minority ( we definitely choose to be minority because of minority privilege policies, lol)
+Kelly Su I LOVE HOKKIEN
Kelly Su it’s better to be referred as ‘affirmative action’
Hahahahahahahahahahahahsshahahha
i have Han mark on my belly
+jo XDDDDDD
+jo I do 2 and on my arm
Have one on my arm
Must be pregnant or just fat with stretch marks lol
its because you were fat and become slim now
I'm Han Chinese but I don't have the Han mark....
+Jonathan Hung I think I took it since I'm not chinese but I have it lol
Teddy Grande lol
this is like the sixth toenail myth
same lol Im Han but no mark
+Jonathan Hung Is that really a thing? I thought that was pseudo-science.
I'm white but I checked my arm lol.
+Glisero
Same but I only have a dot scar from a fucking bee sting lol
+Glisero I'm also white, but I somehow have the lines on one arm... I guess I better start learning Mandarin ASAP :)
+Glisero I checked my arm nothing. And then I checked my Chinese husband's arm and I was so amazed to see it there lol
+Glisero Hahahaha
+Филип Брчић With a serious face, I say it's time to get one of those DNA kits, who knows you might trace your lineage back to that one ancestor that came by the ancient silk route. :)
Aye, thanks for including our people. 我們是苗族. It's only in China that we call ourselves Miao but every where else in the world, we call ourselves Hmong. But then again, there are four group that makes up the Miao. Xong, Hmub, A-Hmao, and Hmong. Some of the grouping also doesn't consider themselves to be categorized as Miao because of cultural difference and language. But as of now, only the Hmong people are the known group that have migrated out of China. They migrated to South East Asia then from there to other countries such as the United States, Europe, and Australia as refugee during the Vietnam War. Thank you for sharing :3
So really when someone is described as “Chinese”, it is really describing a nationality not a race or ethnicity. It is the same as when you call someone American it is their NATIONALITY , they could be white,black, Asian etc… but they are American .Same goes for a lot of countries.
That's actually not how it works Asian American aren't really Americans to Asian people but black and white Americans are Americans
Why Asian Americans aren't American well half of them is fully Asian cultured while the other half is self haterd mainly Chinese American.
Korean American is either they are Korean or Korean American not American cus they still are connected to their so called Korean culture.
I'm Hmong myself...we have a long history in China dating back to the B.C....even though we have spread throughout the world we never forget we're we come from....to be honest I was surprised to see us on the list...btw thanks for your videos..
hui is an ethnic han who is Muslim, they are called hui because Islam is not because of ethnicity, and hui does not speak Arabic or farsi, the Arabic language they use only in religious matters is not daily language.
So do they speak Mandarin as mother tongue? And in which letters do they write?
1:26 There are also plenty of Han Chinese who speak various Chinese dialects (Yue Chinese 粵語, Min Chinese 閩語, Wu Chinese 吳語, Gan Chinese 贛語 etc.)
Uyghurs and Hui don't speak arabic and persian languages. Uyghurs are turkic people, and Hui are muslim chinese. They speak a northern chinese dialect which is much more close to mandarin than other dialects
Uyghurs speak their own native language. It is nothing like Chinese. I know an Uyghur.
+Mani Elliott i didnt say that uyghurs speak language similar to chinese, i said they re turkic people
Ok.
yes.
You know people can quote you, right?
When referring to the Uyghurs "They speak a northern chinese dialect which is much *_more close to mandarin than other dialects_*"
thankyou for this video, i've had to explain my ethnic background so much in my life and people are still confused. i always say that im Hmong and they pout as if my answer doesnt satisfy their curiousity. i guess thats because they want to be able to associate me to a certain country. then they ask "where is that at?" that is i when i tell them that my ethnicity is a minority group that lives in china to southeast asia. but some people here in OC cant grasp the concept of it. i always end up saying "you know how there is Native Americans in America but theyre not the same group and lives in different regions? well same concept but in asia."
As a Hmong/Miao from the USA... I applauded you guys for using the word Hmong...I am told that in South East Asia... the Hmongs took the word Miao/mao as offensive... I remember asking my dad, who the Miao/Mao, people were... He said they are not us, we are not Chinese people, we live in Loas for ages. I asked him because we were suppose to do a report for class on our heritage, and typing Hmong, at the time, 90s... got you no where... But typing Vietnam refugees, you see Mao.. and that's how I ended up with pictures, stories, of the famed Mao people who helped the downed American Pilot, led by a General, named Vang Pao....
ScorpiusTheScorpin In fact, hmong is a branch of miao. Not all miao are Hmong. In China, only the miao of the western branch is hmong, and the rest miao is not hmong.
Bettas Zht that’s right and not a lot of Hmong people know that.
The Hmong are a beautiful culture. I'm aware of this attitude in southeast Asia towards the word "Miao.". It seems like the word is not considered offensive in China. It's strange how this division has emerged.
Is it really because "Miao" sounds like a cat in some language? Or is that a myth?
Fun fact Miao was stateless people live on the hill...that's why they called Miao(wild cat/barbarian) coz they won't obey han chinese authority...and some left china and went to SEA due to goverment expansion
China was multicultural until 1 ethnic group dominates the land by population
Wow Yi is your girlfriend, I thought she was your friend. Way to go bro
Thank You for shouting out my Miao/Hmong People! 🙌 Majority in the US are in California (Fresno) and Minnesota (St Paul/Minneapolis)
The Han was already mixed by other groups in the ancient years.
There are no Pure Race in the first place.
@Ghost Reaper there’re people who are 100% Indian, Irish, people from African...
Nope, depends on the area.... northern people in shanghai, beijing they are mixed or forgotton their roots but in cities/areas like chengdu, fujian, shenzhen, wuhan, etc still have majority pure han people who are shorter in height
source?
@@treeman12815 hi, common history in the history book, I'm not historian, but I know that the time before the Qin Dynasty around 200bc, this region was full of countries or city-states with each one has their own language, meurement . Different philosophies, clothing and money (medium of exchange) ... only left with some dialects today . The word han appears only after the Han dynasty.
Hui are really just Muslim HAN Chinese
Yes, but Han Chinese in general have diverse look because of intermarriage with other ethnics. Northern Han have more northern mix, southern Han have more southern mix, and Hui have western Asian mix
But we have Persian + Arab blood and you don't. xD
The definition of Hui blood is as ambiguous as Latino/Hispanic people. There's all sorts of mixing in different degrees. The government just likes to group all Han-speaking muslims as Hui. Some Hui are Han forced to convert, while others mostly have a mix of Mongol blood.
True I am Hui Chinese and we are not like Arabs or Poorsians btw it doesnt matter with beards its just a gene not ethnic.
Tabgach Giyamhu What languages do you speak? I guess that Manchurian isn't one of them as it is almost extinct.
not all
Uyghur mean civilized in old turkic... what are you on about????
Kebab with extra garlic mayo its also the name of that ethnic group for some reason
im australian born to a filipino mother and a dutch father, yet i have the Han mark... someone has some explaining to do
Your mother has chinese origins alot of chinese went to the philippines many years ago so yeah
we must be talking Centuries then, like Ghenghis khan old.
I'm suuuuper white and have the Han mark 😶
yOu haVe sOme sPLAinInG tO Do!!
This was really interesting! I loved that you were able to have fun while presenting the material, but also remained respectful throughout. Bravo!
Really guys I'm Han?
my parents came from bangladesh
+maz khatun I have it too lol I guess I'm han even though my parents are from pakistan
Why do you ask
+maz khatun The Han are everywhere. Just odds, I guess.
+maz khatun There are a lot of Han... you think none of them went south?
+maz khatun I'm from Serbia and, apparently, I'm also Han.
I love how the Hui People are characterized with cleanliness. It is an obligation of every Muslim to be clean at all times.
1) The chopstick song can be played on the piano :D
2) These guys are awesome. Great hearing Mandarin (?) with an American accent.
3) Seriously, thank you for a great video!
There are also plenty of Hui people (回族) in Quanzhou, Fujian (福建省泉州市), said to be descendants of ancient Persian and Arab traders who have arrived in China back during Quanzhou's heyday as one of the world's greatest ports, "a haven for commerce and trade" as described by Marco Polo during the Yuan and Ming dynasties.
China's first mosque, known as Ashab Mosque (清淨寺) is also in Quanzhou city, built in 1009 AD, when Quanzhou was also known as the starting point for the Maritime Silk Road trade stretching from East Asia down to Southeast Asia, and all the way to the Middle East / Africa.
I can't. "50 ethnic minorities making up only 9% of china. Here's an ethnic minority group"
*minority group still bigger than my entire country's population, not just ethnic but total population*
I've learn these in school and its very interesting to learn other Chinese ethnic group and I'm Hmong! 👋
Awesome video. I learned a lot! You didn’t mention Cantonese or other dialects/language of the Han. Would be great to highlight diversity even within Han Chinese.😉
What??Han are diverse too....wow
Great video Chen brother I am Tibetan 🤗
hui❤tibetan
han💩💩
I'm Lhoba
@Green Scenery you will find me everywhere
@Green Scenery how did you come to know my location?
@@tanktalking5300 lots of hui in lhasa these days
Can you do the 100 varieties of potatoes in your next video?
wtfffff are you actually everywhere !!!
+Funnyguyfun7 he's on every single channel with a asian host
What have potatoes done to you bro?
Yes like sweet potato or dick potato etcetra.
im white and i have a mark on both my arms :O
Same but I'm black
+Mouiylus the line thing supposed to be a joke.
+Mouiylus same, i'm half italian n half german
+Mouiylus Awh.. I got excited over nothing. My ancestry (according to my mom) told me that we're originally from Hans :\
Oh my God!))) I have same, I am kazakh)))
Very informative video thanks! I live in Sichuan,since it´s so near from Tibet sometimes you see Tibetans in Chengdu.
+Helsic Yiverus I am Sichuanese! So much missing the foods there!
Tibetans are not ethnic groups of China. If you have researched better, Tibet was a forcefully occupied nation by the Communist China. China is a selfless poison in this universe, doing all those inhuman acts. Now China is trying to occupy Hong Kong just like Tibet and East Turkistan.
Free Tibet, Free East Turkistan, Free Hong Kong
@@norbuwa Free Basque, Free Corsica
I just want to make a little correction. In the video, the Han language was listed as Mandarin, but the Han also speaks more than just Mandarin. They also speak Shanghainese, Cantonese, Hokkien, Hakka, and etc (they're all related to the Old Chinese language and a shared writing). These speakers of the several dialects/languages make up the 1.2 billion people.
Dude, in reality there are over 300 dialects spoken in mainland China itself. And the Han, being the vast majority of the population mostly speak Mandarin as their language (or IF they know more than 1) they speak Mandarin 1st since it's whats tought and used in China now. The Han are spread out in the main areas of China with large cities and that includes places like Shanghai, Guangzhou, and other areas where many of the individual dialects were indead originated. Since Mandarin is tought in school, most families who speak other dialect may continue to pass down their own dialects in the family, but they will/must learn Mandarin. In reality it is vastly impossible to calculate how many Han themselves know a second dialect (if any).
Would it be Cantonese from far Southern China, the Hakka next door, Min a little farther up, Wu to the far East coast, or Gan farther inward... who knows. And Shanghainese is actually spoken by around 14 million Chinese currently. That's isn't even in the top 10 in China. It's to complicated to calculate how many Han know a 2nd dialect, then find out WHICH dialect it is. As I said it's more common for people who know the minority dialects to learn Mandarin, than the Han, who the vast majority naturally know Mandarin learn another dialect. In China most people try to actually learn English as a 2nd language in school to do well. Even now in Hong Kong, it's won't be fully part of China until 2047, but they are already trying to switch from teaching Cantonese to Mandarin.
In reality it makes sense to just list Mandarin under Han.
This is so interesting, shout out to everyone in china, love from a kabyle in Algeria.
Hui people are native speakers of Mandarin, Arabic only restricted to recitation of Quranic verses. Uyghur people speak Uyghur which is a Turkic language similar to languages spoken by other neighbouring Turkic groups like the Kazakhs and the Kirghiz, and like the Hui, the use of Arabic is restricted to religious settings.
You guys should do a video on the Hui's!
I'm ethnically Han but I haven't heard of the Han mark thing before... I'm guessing it's a childhood story that some Han parents tell their children?
Now that you guys have covered some Chinese ethnic groups, how about covering some Han sub-ethnic groups, e.g. Cantonese, Hakka, Hokkien, Shanghainese, Hainanese etc.? I think that would be something interesting yet not known by many non-Chinese, too.
你好小眼睛
上海人都成sub group了还行
Like see all the 56 ethnics of China. Love the overview. Please do more episodes for each ethnic. Like 30 min. mini episode of each ethnic. The story line will entail their way of life: food, dialects, clothing and marriage etc.
Wow! My teacher is actually from China, and he is Kazakh.
Correction: Arabic is not Uyghur's communication language and a lot of Uyghur people do/can not speak Mandarin at all. but only uyghur language.
Yasasin Uyghur Eli,Yasasin Sherqiy Turkistan
#NeMutluTurkumDiyene
We Hui also don't talk Arabic only use to talk with Uyghurs or Salars etc who don't speak Mandarin
I'm half Han half Manchu and I honestly don't think even my great grandma from the manchu side knows how to speak the manchu language. The language is totally dying out sadly :/
Please do more stuff like this please :) This is a super cool video. However I think Miao chinese is also in Vietnam, Thailand and other SEA (South East Asian) countries as well.
+Chloe Chang Nice see another who enjoys learning about diverse cultures.
You are right the Miao who are also known as Hmong and Meo also live in Vietnam and I believe Lao. There are/were are huge number of sub groups of Miao each with their own distinct costume. In ancient times they were the rulers of much of southern china.
+Chloe Chang right! Finally! But yeah Hmong/Miao/Meo are really all over the place. Both my parents are Hmong, and my dad was born in Laos and came to Thailand during the Laotian Civil War as baby. He grew up most of his life in a Refugee camps. My mom was born in Thailand, and my family and I came to the United States in 2004. This is really exciting, its not everyday that people talk about the Hmong people. Hmong's are such a small minority groups compare to the other ethnicity groups.
Ze Yang Thanks for sharing the personal history of your family with us.
Ze Yang miao people are mysterious in chinese view...a lot of mysterious novels involve miao people
I'm from the south but I refer myself has tang not Han
Is it the same thing?
Yeah, it's the same thing， since Han and Tang are two most powerful dynasties in Chinese history. Just like the Tang Ren Jie in most western countries. If if were the northern Chinese who got there first, it could be called Han Ren Jie (I guess)
Yay for Hmong! :)
chai yang finally we are known....
oh c’mon who doesn’t know you?
catc yang You mean Miao
BuBbLeTeA AeStHeTiCs been known, just not looking in the right places.
Thank you for honoring Hui muslims as clean, disciplined, ans serious people with their food restrictions as muslims without pork the most consumed meat, they made better foods without pork. It warms my heart because you recognized them as good people which in fact i beleive they are. I am muslim also from Bosnia.
I've got a question! Does one's family name have any bearing on the ethnic group one might belong to or be descended from?? I've got a friend whose family name is Hui but all of her family (at least this generation) are from HK and speak Cantonese. Does her family name mean she's likely to be descended from the Hui Chinese?
+Jay Hughes: Yep, by tracing the family name is one of the easiest way to found out his/her ancestral background of a person other than testing his/her DNA.
It is one of the reason why the Chinese see their children carrying on their last name in the next generation is so important.
+pigboykool though sometimes tracing family name isn't the same as tracing your genetic heritage. As, because carrying on the family name has been so important in China and other Confucian societies, people with no son or children of their own might adopt someone to pass their name as a last resort.
If one had daughters, then adopting the husband of your daughter, so that he could carry on the name was an option, but it could also be someone completely unrelated. So while you can draw conclusions from a family name of what a person's ancestry is likely to have been, it's not completely certain. Especially with more famous names like Kong.
+Jay Hughes No. My cousin's last name is Hui. It is a Cantonese romanization of the name Xu or Hsu depending on where u are from. The Hui people is a shortened form of the word for Islam in Chinese, at least from what I know since Islam is Hui Jiao.
+DarthJF: Even it is possible to have adopting children to bear one's family name, however, majority of the people are the decendents of the Family Name trees.
Up till Qing Dynasty and the beginning of Republic of China, no matter if you are poor or rich, each family (usually a village) strictly recorded down every single person in his/her Family Name tree. People can easily trace back their ancestor for hundreds of years with these records.
There is a book called the 100 surnames. Anyone who's surname is not on that MIGHT be an ethnic minority. Theres been lots of mixing so its only a very rough guide.
The hui people, are genetically han chinese that married the Persian and arab trader in the silk road, while the Uighur people are straight up turks with some indo european blood in them thats why the uighur looked like eurasian and the most famous celeb in china is uighur dilraba dilmurat.
I believe the Miao/Hmong population have gone up if we are to look at the ethnic population itself not concentrating it in China
Background information. China counts some non-Han groups who have been living within the territory of China since history as ethnic groups, even though some of these ethnic groups now have their own countries. These ethnic groups are ethnically, culturally and linguistically similar as those living in other countries, but they have Chinese nationalities. Some examples are Jing people (Vietnamese), Dai people (Thai), Chaoxian people (Korean), Eluosi people (Russian), Menggu people (Mongolian) Hasake people (Kazakh), Keerkezi people (Kyrgyz), Tajike people(Tajik), etc.
I have no Han Solo's mark, am I a wookie now ?
+Jari S try the wookie call and you will prove it true or false
+Jeremy Springer Nope, I still sound like DukeNukem
then you are dude nukem, the son of duke
Tibet is not part of China. In 1959, Chinese govt occupied our country and many of the Tibetans were forced from flee from their own country. Thousands were massacred and imprisoned.From 2008 during Beijing Olympics event onwards till now, more than 100s of Tibetans had self immolated which is the clear proof that we are not happy under the oppressive rule under Chinese govt. We Tibetans don't have hatred towards the Chinese people. As we know due to severe censorship and indoctrination, the people got misled by the govt. It's saddening that our own people are minority in its own country right now.
Fun fact, what you're describing with the Zhuang minority sounds like animism (belief in living souls/spirits in natural objects) and not polytheism (belief in more than one god) :D Also it's interesting that there are ‘Hui Streets', like Chinatowns outside of China.
Thats like in india delhi has jama masjid which is an area of indian Muslim food, and mumbai has mohammad ali road
Awesome info guys. Changes my perspective on ethnicity all together.
I love china 🇨🇳
Ничё скоро...
Wow, didn't know my people would be mention on here, the Miao/Hmong. Not many people know about us. Glad that you both did! :)
"separated like their dialects, like in India"
Indian ethnic groups are just separated by dialects? No. The languages are extremely different, some quite more than others. That's like saying that Wolof, Spanish, and Mandarin are all just different dialects.
the best way to show the difference is the European languages. indian languages are like European languages
What is wolof
Add about minute 2:19 when you talk about the Duog the 2nd ethnic group. I think you confused animism for polytheism. You gave the definition for animism but said that the group was polytheistic.
Wow! I'm amazed you guys had Hmong people! I love it!
Actually, Manchu is not the 3rd largest minority ethnic group in China.
why do han people have that mark?
catwang it is a joke.
According to the Book of the Han, "No one can enter the middle kingdom without having the Mark of the Han". When the world is destroyed by nuclear weapons, only the Middle Kingdom will still stand and will be the only kingdom to survive.
China is the one of the oldest civilization to survive and will continue to survive. Those with the mark of the Han will be allowed to live and prosper in the Middle Kingdom. Those without it will be forced out to dwell in caves.
People with the Mark of the Han are gifted and comes from the the Heavens. These people use to be called "The Celestials. They came from the sky and started an empire in "Celestial Kingdom". Which is now known as China.
Chinese immigrants to America were used to be called "the Celestials". Remember where you came from.
If you are a Han Chinese, you are God's children. You are the gifted one. And God promised to protect us and will welcome us to the Middle Kingdom. And the Mark of the Han is a Promise to all Han Chinese.
What’s funny is that the Han aren’t even a single unified ethnic group. It’s more of a pan-ethnicity like Arabs or Hispanics or White Americans. The idea of a single unified Han nation came out of the 19th century to unify all of the groups historically part of the Han Dynasty in order to overthrow the Manchu dominated Qing Dynasty.
i am of south Asian descent (Pakistani) my father is like borders Pakistan, and mom is Punjabi Indian roots, I have that line!!!!!!
Another question, as I am Muslim and would love to visit China,but due to dietary restrictions I would visit a place with halal food, so where are highest number of HUI?
anywhere,,hui people are distributed around china , they are good in running halal restaurants,hope you enjoy it
possible to find. Just search em up before hand
Fari Hui are mostly living in Shaanxi province, Qinghai province and Gansu province. Basically central and western China
People sometime think that my brother and I are Mexican,Indian,or Philippine so I feel your pain
The Hui are just Han that converted to Islam.
Uyghur doesn't mean "to come together" - it's a mystery, actually, regarding it's etymology, since "Uyghur" is most likely related to the ancient Turkic word "Oghuz", which just means "community". Uyghurs aren't Caucasian and they're certainly not even remotely Chinese - they're Turks. Karluk Turks, to be more precise, meaning they share much more ethnic and cultural ties with Uzbekistan than they do with the Chinese or even neighboring Kazakh and Kyrgyz. However, Central Asian Turkic languages are about as similar as modern Chinese languages ( an Istanbul Turk, an Uzbek, a Kazakh and a Uyghur can communicate similarly to how a Mandarin, Cantonese, Fujian and Min speaker could), so, at least in my experience, Uyghurs identify most strongly with simply being not Chinese and there's a lot of camaraderie among Kazakhs, Kyrgyz, Uzbek and Uyghur communities in and outside of China. Before 1920s, Uyghurs were just called the 'Turki' with Uyghur is a revived ethnic term intending to call back to the ancient Uyghur from the second and third Göktürk Khanate (these Uyghurs, interestingly enough, are responsible for creating the alphabet that would later go on to be used by Gengis Khan in pre-Soviet controlled Mongolia). Most Uyghurs before 1920s just identified themselves based upon where they were from in the Tarim basin (i.e Kashgarliq - The Kashgarians, etc.) Why reclaim an old name? Soviets. Kazakh, Uzbek, Kyrgyz, Uyghur, Istanbul Turk, Azeri, Turkmen or any other "Turkic" tribe really only came about in the modern era with the rise of the European nation state and the era of divide and conquer politics. They're contrived identities, the Soviets hoped that once the Uyghurs had a common banner to unite around, it would organize them better into breaking off from China and joining the other Central Asian Republics in the Soviet Union (similar to the policy enacted in Mongolia, trying to reconcile "Buryat" Mongols with "Oirat" Mongols in China with "Khalkha" Mongols in Outer Mongolia). To many Turkic people, they're all just brothers from another mother and proudly say they're "Turks". Therefore, the most identifying trait for a Uyghur, next to being a Turk and a Muslim, is simply "not being Chinese"
That they are Muslims can make Hui people a distinct ethnicity by definition.
wow even the wikipedia could show me my ethnic history so clear as your comment. thank you! !! there must be a reason that you studied so much about mongoloids and turks????
John Doyle Wagner Right, Uygurs are Turkic people and our brothers. And they never related themselves to Chinese people. Their language and culture just like ours.
Hui is as ambiguous as Latino/Hispanic. We have a mix of middle east, central asian, east asian, and also 'pure' Han. How dare you deny that my ancestors came from Persia through the silk road 1000 years ago.
John Doyle Wagner
Erm actually Cantonese, Min (Fujian dialect) and Mandarin Chinese are all completely mutually unintelligible lol like almost 0%
Thanks for mentioning Hmong people. Nowadays we exist in China, Vietnam, Laos, Thailand, Burma, U.S, Canada, France, Australia, and French Guyana.
I'm Turkic and I have a Han mark too while I am not Han Chinese.
5:08 Uyghur look like a mixture of Caucasian and Mongoloid not a mixture of Caucasian and Asian wtf
I have Han mark, and i'm from Poland. Intresting.
I'm from Finland and I also have it.
Im from Brazil but I have Han mark , im chinese. hahaha
I'm half swedish half northern irish, i've got it too.
A message to the host of the show:
Get rid off that guy in the dark blue shirt next to you. He does not belong! 😡
Oh yeah Miao/Hmong are also really artistic with singing, and spiritual arts!
2:30 actually... Polytheism is the belief in multiple Gods, I learnt this in year 8 history, while we were learning about ANCIENT CHINA. Not all Polytheists believe that objects are magical.
I seriously adore and appreciate your cultural videos!
Also, I saw Shen Yun years ago, I'm so glad that you're recommending it because it was a phenomenal and gorgeous experience
Hui is basically muslim version of Han
I'm Hmong, my last name is Lee, I'm also derived from Miao people, and I also have the Han mark. What am I?
A mix, like me.
Not 100% Hmong
You’re a little chubby
I am a Pakistani . But ethically a Tibetan. So most of my friends would called me as Chinese or Mongolian.
And I would say "Ya , Ghenghez Khan was my great great grandfather "
Pakistan zindabad! Welcome to Khans Club!
A lot of Han Chinese speak Cantonese...
han chinese actually equal to chinese, Cantonese are actually a part of dialect in china.
JOhn dong No Han is just one of the many Chinese ethnicities, it is the major one but it doesn't equal to Chinese.
And I'm referring to how they say Han Chinese only speaks mandarin in the video, when Cantonese is as, if not more popular if you consider overseas Han Chinese as well
WeiYinChan we called 'han yu', literally, it equals to Chinese's national language and words.
JOhn dong Err... han yu may be Chinese's national language, but it's not Chinese's only language... That's like saying an apple is equal to a fruit. No, there are other ethnicity who aren't hans but are still Chinese.
In the Guangzhou province and HongKong yes
This video is both entertaining and humorous. Thank you for sharing.
Long live Uyghur Turk~~~
Hey Guys,
The longest dynasty is actually Zhou Dynasty from 1046-256 BCE.
Is it mythical
I'm so glad you made this video! I know it makes sense to mostly talk about Han Chinese since that's the vast majority of Chinese people, but I love learning about the lesser known (outside of China that is) people groups!
Your description of the zhuang is animist, not polytheistic. I assume they're similar to Mongols and other northern nomads in their beliefs then.
What!? I have the Han mark but I'm a 老外！
lao wai you are a 歪果仁 😂
maybe in youre famalilie long time ago there was a han
thesedays china is a furnace of ethnics. most of them lost their identity but tibet and uyghur didnt yet. i hope them rly get what they want
What is the Chinese characters what u typed. I am Turkic and from Turkey I have Han mark and I have Karluk (Uzbek-Uyghur) ancestries.
@@kamalvanderbuben 老外（lâowài) [sorry I can't type the 3rd falling tone pinyin mark on my computer for some reason] literally means (old foreign) but is a term of endearment or a nickname to someone who is not Chinese.
Awesome video. Learned a lot here. Thanks for sharing!
I liked when you said tea in mandarin it was the same like in our language "čaj" (slovak) maybe because of russian influence.
Ps. I dont have the han mark ;)
The Slovak word originally comes from Mandarin. All variants of *čaj* comes from Mandarin. All variants of *tea* comes from Cantonese
@@emdadahmed5592 Fascinating!
Why so many people are so serious about the han mark？It's obvious just for fun！stop complaining about this！
long live uyghur turks...
ok
I don't know about the Han mark, but another symbol that represents of Han is having two nails on your foot little finger, and no matter how many times you cut it off, it grows back, that means you are 100% Han people without mix others Gene.
Wait what? Really 😁😂😀🤣 i too have bt m not han .
I have the "Han" mark too yeah i'm caucasian with German and Irish ancestry... Confused am I
faeirydancer U have to be Chinese first, then do the test. It’s like a bonus proof, if u know what I mean. Most of my friends including myself, have it. My ex-gf doesn’t have it and she’s Tibetan.
Thank you for this very informative, but humorous video. 👌👌👌🎈😊
Nice video, I am Hui Chinese but you know we speak Arabic only in the mosque or to communicate with other Muslims. By the way in Taiwan they recognize us as Han Chinese but than Islamic Han. I have also a Han mark, but I normally speak Mandarin.
I'm so in love with Chinese Muslims Culture ❤️
The Han mark help the authorities to distinguish Muslim Chinese and the others.
How did you guys come up with the "Han mark"? I am Vietnamese, why do I have that Han mark? I am confused
+Huy Nguyen Ming dynasty invaded Vietnam this can tell why
thank you for the info
+Huy Nguyen There is no such thing as Han mark, but mongolian spot that mostly found on Turkic people.
back to 400 years you spoke Chinese . speaking about the race (range over 20k years),there will be no strict boundary of modern countries...tho the han mark is bullshit I think..just you fat..
Cool I'm Polish Han (Because of those lines XD)
Great video! I've been wanting to learn about different Chinese ethnic groups, but no idea where to start. Would love to see more f this!