ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
Does Britain Owe India Reparations? - Geography & History Reactions 🇮🇳
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ก.พ. 2024
- Thank you for subscribing to my channel!
Here the links to my things!
Guinea Pigs / @konasuba
More Guinea Pigs / @guineapigboop
Gaming / @reldrik
Vlog / channel
Donate Here: streamlabs.com...
Discord: / discord
Twitter: / kona_and_suba
Twitch: / reldrik
#geoguessr #india #geotastic #f2p #free #indiaculture #indiageography #geoguessrtips #geography #reperations
Most of the allleged foreign aid are actually Business Investments. The government India has asked Britain to stop giving reparations in 2012. All the money Britain said they gave to India goes to Non-Government Organization, which are used in spreading propaganda against India, create internal disturbance and communal tensions. Indian economy has surpassed UK, now it's a aid giver to other nations. India gave aid to countries like Sri Lanka, Maldives, Mongolia, Bhutan etc.
Wow, that is great India has gotten to that point
@@ReldrikGeoIn fact, it has been quite some time that India banned any foreign aid to its government.
Indian agricultural subsidies are more than this alleged aid.
This aid money is given to the missionary organisations in India, such as the guy who went to that island in India to convert the tribals, and got killed.
Oh I heard about him
@@ReldrikGeo India's GDP is higher than UK since 2022.
It has far more folk so no shit@@shashanksuman
dude you are very smart, you know stuff and have that skill to unlearn and learn new things, your geostatic videos pointed that you have interest in geography, which is what I liked about you but this video helped me know you are a great human as well. Great first video to start review! subscribing
I appreciate the kind words, thank you
I remember this video came out during the first year of my college. It was considered as the epitome of public speaking for many years after this video came out.
He is incredibly well spoken and charismatic
No it wasn't.
imagine when brits left india our life expectancy was 27 to 30 yrs which is now 71 yrs now ..since i am related to medicine field i feel sad when i hear this
Wow that is truly terrible, glad things are on the incline now though
There's a bold assumption in the west that india actually started to fall apart when Britain and the "white saviours" left the country. Now obviously these things are perpetrated by the media in the uk, the states and here in Australia... I too, being Australian, was white washed about the underrated potential and struggle of indians and I always, like most people, thought it's funny to be racist towards indians and call them dirty... And many other worse things... Until i moved to india regarding my work. Literally helped me a ton learning about indian people and-since I'm interested in history too-about india. Now I'm back at home and have great admiration for indians. I lived in many cities there... Realised how western media has always avoided the progress india has made and infrastructure they've been able to develop in many cities... Considering the size of india... I'm not hesitant to say india has 5 times more the top tier infrastructure the UK as a whole have. I feel ashamed how we are so judgemental and are blinded in superior complex when talking about india or africa... As if all UK have had as their economy wasn't directly funded by the cash cow india and how UK and other European countries now can't seem to remain economically stable let alone progress further. Sorry for the rant.
No need to be sorry, thank you for sharing
The reason for this actually has more to do with modern medicine than the idea that the were so hard done by
@@nodruj8681even India has a better medical system called Ayurveda which British disrupted and refused to recognize and fund it.
For decades after independence, west refused to part away the modern medicine to India. Only when India broke the intellectual property rights and manufacture bulk drugs did its life span rose.
Shashi Tharoor is a former Indian diplomat, and served in the Ministry for external affairs between 2009 & 2010
Currently he is serving as MP in the Indian parliament
He was a minister of state for external affairs in the minustry of external affairs rather than the minister in charge of external affairs.
8 billion pounds only in referene with world war 1. The total unpaid bill is over 45 trillion USD.
Wow that's an incredibly high amount
A lot of people dont even know this happened just 77 years ago, my grandmother is 88, she lived most of her childhood under British rule!
If you are interested in Indian history, Odd Compass is an excellent channel.
Yeah that is one of the channels I have bookmarked to watch
Hey man just thought of correcting a information that you said in the start of the video BRITISH ruled india for nearly 200 years (from 1757 - 1947) and the crown rule or direct rule in india lasted from 1858-1947 other than that the video is great ......loved your reaction ❤
Forget reparations.
England didn't even appologize for Jalianwala Bagh incident.
You can research about it.
Also if you have the time you can watch the movie sardar udham too.
Yes I was reading about this earlier and I was shocked. There is even this quote.
In 2013, some thought Prime Minister David Cameron might apologize during a visit to Amritsar. He, too, laid a wreath at Jallianwala Bagh and called the event “deeply shameful.” Later, he clarified: “I don’t think the right thing is to reach back into history and to seek out things that we should apologize for.”
The Jialianwala Bagh incident was carried out by one renegade General Dyer who was forcefully removed from his post after this incident.
Yes he was talking about Bengal Famine which resulted in 4 million deaths due to starvation, caused by the actions of the Colonial British Government and Winston Churchill
I never heard of it before which is sad to say
@@ReldrikGeo It is not taught in the west and wintson churchill is whitewashed and seen solely as a war hero
Loved your analysis, specially given your context, and your curiosity to know more.
Reg the beginning of a united and democratic India, our first Prime Minister Nehru asked two specific people, Vallabhbhai Patel and VP Menon, to make sure all provinces acceded to a single Union.
They raced around the country in 1947, coaxing, cajoling, threatening all the kings and princes (about 500 of them!).
That they managed to accomplish this was a massive start to a united and democratic India.
Since then, we have managed to hang together and thrive. In spite of every once in a while, a few fissiparous tendencies in some or other part of the country
Bro, Bengalis and Indians are same, yes Bangladesh is different now, but it was one country before 1947, so when he said bengali died he means Indian people.
Yeah I know, I have also since this video read more on it and wow some of the disgusting things said by people like Churchill make me so angry
Most american dont get The henry"8 and his wife"s joke ,, nice to see you got it 😂
Shashi Tharoor has another video in which he speaks about dozens of Indian words which were incorporated into English.
Some surprising examples are shampoo, catamaran, bandanna and many more.
I knew of some words like thug being from India, I'll have to try to find that video of him going over the words
Wow! Thanks for reacting! Great reaction 👏
No problem and thank you
Loved your reaction ❤
Love from India
Even today there are brits who consider Chirchill a hero and think positively of colonialsim. Thats shameful.
I've been reading more about him. His beliefs are actually disgusting. I'm so surprised with what I've been reading
Thank you brother for trying to understand our point of view, we don't want anything from britain or the west, but they should atleast know about their imperialist crimes before making judgements about our current state and lecturing india or any other former colony on anything. It may be mere statistics to western people but my family was directly affected by massacre and racist violence so it's personal for many people like me in india. And its a shame that the colonial history is not taught in schools in the west. Any way I wish you and your family all the best you are a kind soul, may lord krishna bless you.🙏
Learning and understanding should be everyones goal. It makes us all better as a person if we strive to learn as much as possible. I wish I knew more about this history growing up, but its never too late to learn
I agree the west should aknolege more, should learn more, maybe even really do reparations.
I myself I'm trying to learn more, and listen, and hunderstand the point of view of colonized peoples (I consider myself western).
I really try to simpathyze, and I think I made progress in that.
Still, I think all of us should know this is really complex.
I'm not trying to be cinycal, but were all colonisations the same? Shoul the UK say I'm sorry to the US too?
Should the US do that to the Philipines, or even Cuba (or Japan - because of the forced trading thing in XIX century)?
I am NOT saying this as an execuse, like trying to dilute, wash away the guilt (historical guilt, at least) just with 'whataboutism'. I am trying to say there's also the historical context.
At what point was some cases (UK colonization of India, for example), different?
I am assuming it was really bad, actually, maybe one of the worst crimes of this kind, and it should be discussed, like many others.
Each case has its own characteristics, by one hand, and they must be known; by the other hand, are they, or are they not, part of the the great tragedies of History?
At what point should this or that event be singled out?
(In my opinion, there is room to consider both each and every one, with their specifics, and also the all of the conflicts and ecploitations of human history. Sorry for my english.)
@@eduardoserrao7372 I think we all need to come together and move forward towards a better world. Reach out to the stars and spread humanity to other worlds.
Jungle is also a hindi word as Rudyard Kipling of Jungle Book introduced it as he was also indian born
British museum ❌
thifes's museum☑️
Great, you should react to this kind of education and informational videos. I would suggest you should react to Incredible India World's Most Unique Nation video. It shows almost every famous places in India, including different cultures and traditions.
I will check it out!
New Zealand was recently out of British release. lotta Maoris got back their lands. I'm and Indian who loved in NZ. its 200 years. Telugu film called SYE RA Narasimha reddy was a proud movie and even Maratha Empires fought against Brits.
This guy is part of the opposition party in India but he is being sidelined, one of the ways the opposition is being incompetent and why they lose 😢
I don't really know the political parties in India. The opposition party is here to criticize the government and guarantee rights and freedoms for the citizens correct?
@@ReldrikGeo India is a multi party democracy the two main parties at the central level are BJP and Congress, Shashi Tharoor is part of Congress but he is ignored and not given a main role and just a state level role, Congress was in power for almost 70 years with BJP getting 1-2 terms in between, and BJP has been in power since last 10 years, so Congress is now an opposition party, we have our elections this year, and BJP is projected to win again, cause Congress have become incompetent
It always been incompetent we just didn't know it because they banned any books or paper that wrote against them @@Masani605
Even karma and yoga like words few among others were also a hindi word.
I'm a believer in karma. Probably not in a religious sense but I do believe if you do good things then good things will come back for you.
It's fascinating how much influence India has had on the world
Once upon a time during a femine in 1930-40s in Bengal, winston Churchill and team had taken out the foods to Uk due to which millions were suffered and died. That was an artificial massacre. Last year during chandrayan successful landing on moon, you could see the media and so called intellectuals were cried publicly in USA and UK.
th-cam.com/video/YsJyObswDCQ/w-d-xo.htmlsi=6O8uyjllgCWSbr05
Interesting, you are trying out different things. Good luck!
Yeah I will upload the occasional reaction video
Yale University and British museum are the prime examples of Indian loot used for British affairs and benefits.
Mr. Tharoor is one heck of a diplomat.
Yep we were very naughty back then , but a lot of good also came from Empire , id like to add that britains people certainly did not benefit . Poverty was rife in victorian England and before that also . 😊
Not on this channel broo 😂
But yaa at least you started
I cant start any more channels, also I want this channel to grow faster so putting these videos on here will be better as if I put them on a new channel they wont have any traction or subs to watch it initially
@@ReldrikGeo I mean sure, what floats your boat...hope it helps
No like I actually can't start a new channel, I can only start two channels a year with the same phone number and I already did that
@@ReldrikGeo sure no problems ❤
You shld react to geography now video about India and "The unmaking of India" by Oldcompass
The Unmaking of India was what I was planning on reacting to next. I have seen the geography now video but I will probably react to it on camera too
@@ReldrikGeoI second that, it's a great video.
It's an infographic too so quite easy to watch.
@@ReldrikGeo
If u hv already watched Geography now video(also that video is now kind-of outdated), u can check out "Geography of India explained" by Factspark.
I would also suggest u to watch "History of India in 12mins" part 1 & 2 by Knowledgia, if u r interested in history
And if u r interested in understanding the Indian languages, u can check out this channel called *India in pixels by Ashrish* and they hv a plethora of videos on Indian languages like Marathi, Bengali, Odia, Hindi, Awadhi, Brajbuli etc. IMO u shld watch "Are Hindi and Urdu really different?" video since hindi is the dominant language in India & follow it up with "Why Bengali sounds so sweet" cuz Bengali is the second most spoken language in India.
@@ReldrikGeo
Then u can check out "Geography of India explained" by Factspark, since Geography Now video is kind of outdated today
@@ReldrikGeo
TH-cam is removing my comments but I do hv some suggestions
Please read Dadabhai Naorji”s book “ Poverty and Un-British Rule in India”
Love from India 🥰🥰
At 24:53, the word you were looking for might be the Indian civilization.
30:50 this is also true in Canada, at least in the province of Ontario… they even warn the victims of home invasion or attempted invasion to not post the ring camera videos of the suspects online…. TOO KEEP THE CRIMINALS SAFE😭🤣🤣 Canada is something else man💀🤣
That is ridiculous
British looted 45 Trillion current amount in India
Now Karma is on 😂
Watch video...**How british impoverished the world's richest country** on odd compass.
Very reasearched and analytical video.
Youll be blown away in a weird way.
One of the most reac.ted video on utube.
I'll watch it
@@ReldrikGeo It's a very good video.
It shatters all propaganda of british that colonialism helped INDIA with all facts.
UK can't pay back a dime.
Lots of words like jungle,juggernaut etc from india
Man you should watch geography now videos.❤
ok!
Some people go on about the British today as as if we sit around and mope about losing an Empire. I and most people have no guilt or blame because most of the British during the time of Empire were piss poor and had no say in anything that the rich ruling classes did and it was that class that are the guilty ones. My Gt Gt grandparents had more in common with farm workers in India than the lords and ladies who ran the Empire.
The British( christians) came to India one of the Richest country in the world accounting 27% of Global GDP in 1700's , 23% in 1800's and over 200 years of Depredation , Exploitation ,Loot & Destruction reduced it to a Posterchild of a Third World Poverty.
90% of population living below the poverty line when British left in 1947 , Literacy Rate is below 17%,Life Expectancy is 27% ,
Economy is 25 billion dollars, Growth rate between 1900- 1945 is 0.001% , British India draining the country with taxes and resources over 200 year's of colonization
Now we have a huge Indian population in Britain we can't be that bad 😅
@@claregale9011 India is the 2nd biggest FDI investors in UK in 2021 data, indian companies pay 2 billion pound's taxes.
The 1.7 million Indian diaspora contributes 8% of UK's economy.
The 900 India-based companies operating in Britain grew revenues 7% to 54.4 billion pounds ($67 billion) in 2021 from 50.8 billion pounds in the previous year, while the number of employees rose 21% to 141,005 people.
Just one year's(2021) intake of incoming international students is worth 28.8 billion pounds to the UK economy, with India among the most "prolific" as an overseas education market
If you want to know crime rate then visit house of commons report ethnicity Wise.
In 200 year's of british Christians rule nearly 160 million people persecuted in india
@@kirannnnnn nothing to do with us the common people we are not benefiting at all I'm not well off , my Co worker is Indian and has a huge house here a friend of mine cannot even get council house and is going to be made homeless.
@@claregale9011 I don't care about UK internal matters
You people are not aware of your history in India while completely mislead by your media and historians.
Atleast visit british museum to know about your loot loot looooot
I support isla***sts
Bengali famine was man made by British policy.
hey please please please please react to "how british unmade india" please that's really informative and much more structured and graphic... please... ask me if u don't find the right video... it's a animated explainer video... if u don't find that I'll send u that. just ask me.
Yeah this is one of the videos I want to react to
It’s not 90, it’s nearly 190 years
11:35 in china it was 40 million
You should do Geography Next’s “India” video next. It’ll be awesome
Ok, I will give it a look
You should react to the video "How this border transformed the subcontinent", it's part of Vox's border series.
Really informative and well shot.
I can take a look
Yeah the borders series is amazing... Johnny harris is amazing
Britishers Looted India for:- 200 years bro
Churchill was very cruel towards my country 🇮🇳
Well reviewed 😊❤
Thank you
If (hypothetically speaking) britain starts feeling ashamed of their wrongs and start owing reparation at any cost, they would need to start selling off their land piece by piece and eventually whole uk that much is what they owe
Britain didn't even apologise for jalianwala bagh incident where they gunned down 1400 + peacefull protestors to set an ecample for redt of india .
I don't think reporations are solvable, a problem that it is. As you said its very deep. But like Tharoor said its about the principle, to simply say sorry is the pnly thing that matters, i suppose.
Yeah, just an acknowledgement and an apology would go a long way
1 billion per person 🇮🇳
Its 250 years 😊
Yeah it was longer than I thought
Britain is not prepared to give back the stolen jewal on their monarchs crown, how wöould they give large amount of reparation to India.
do the romans owe britain reparations, of course not, we lost the battle,
Thats rubbish dear sir, India didn't do any harm to Britain.
Bro try to avoid videos with less views 👍
As an indian we need our 45trillion back.we dont need sorry,that is a very cheap word we need indiasn money back
Your content seems all over the place. Last time TH-cam recommended some geography game video. This time it's some debate.
My content is myself
Nope British never apologized to india instead they take pride in doing that
It's wild that there was never a formal apology
🙏🙏🙏 But the British claim that there educated and have high morals so how can they do slaves
One of the worst things you can do to another man is to enslave
@@ReldrikGeo And the British got rid of slavery for the world in 1834 , And it just so happens that slavery is still going on in Non white countries.
Britain owes India an apology, for the jalianwala bagh mass murder and Bengal famines . But they haven't apologized till today.
I just read about the jalianwala bagh mass murder, truly abhorrent behavior and a true tragedy
@@ReldrikGeo Pls watch and react to The Silence of Swastika.
As an history student and a subscriber, I urge you to react.
You know nothing yet John Snow! U will weep with us when u realise what things and what evil the british did with us indians!!!
Yes Britain have never apologised for their colonial crimes!!
*Americans are today's "Britishers"*
*Govt. Of India Should ThrowOut Eric Garceti from India, he is meeting Anti-Indian elements and trying to disrupt the peace*
I will say most Americans don't know who that is, probably 99% of Americans. Heck most Americans probably don't know their local government officials
@@ReldrikGeo 🙏