TURNING POINT: Pre-Zionist Jewish communities in Historic Palestine
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 ส.ค. 2024
- Pre-Zionist Jewish communities in Historic Palestine, including Mizrahi (Jews from Arab countries) lived in relatively peaceful co-existence with their Palestinian neighbours.
But after 1929, everything changed.
Watch the full Turning Point episode on the 1929 Palestinian riots here: • TURNING POINT: 1929 Pa...
Subscribe to our channel: ow.ly/AVlW30n1OWH
Subscribe to MEE Telegram channel to stay up to date: t.me/MiddleEas...
Middle East Eye Website: middleeasteye.net
Follow us on TikTok: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Instagram: / middleeasteye
Like us on Facebook: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Twitter: / middleeasteye
And yet, after 75 years, there is no peace, no harmony, no hope. We need peace for our region, our region is traumatised a.o. by this conflict. Love from Iran.
The people of iran should mind their own business.
The west should mind its own business* there fixed it for ya
In the tense political climate of early 20th century Jerusalem, multiple instances of violence occurred between Palestinian Arabs and Jews. In March 1920, the "Bloody Passover" riots resulted in the tragic deaths of five Palestinian Jews. In April of that same year, six more Palestinian Jews lost their lives to political violence in Jerusalem. On June 15, 1920, 47 Palestinian Jews were killed in another wave of political violence. In August 1929, Muslim riots in Jerusalem and other cities led to the deaths of approximately 250 Palestinian Jews. On November 9, 1937, five more Palestinian Jews were killed by Palestinian Arabs near Jerusalem. And on March 28, 1938, four Palestinian Jews lost their lives in a similar attack near Safed. The violence continued, and on November 29, 1947, seven Jews were killed by Palestinian Arabs near Jerusalem. Between December 1, 1947 and March 31, 1948, a staggering 850 Palestinian Jews lost their lives to Arab attacks.
@@hide9244 first of all whether we do it or not, is not your business!! You don't decide for us. And as we are in the same region and unfortunately our national money is poured into terrorist groups like HAMAS and Hezbollah, without our consent and not for peace, I give myself the right to have an opinion on this matter. Clear?
@@hide9244dumbo
A region which had lived for hundreds of years with relative peace and stability was forced to carry the burden of sins committed in Europe, and now the world burns.
Palestine are still dying for the Sins of Europe
That's not quiet true though. Growing nationalism was tearing the Ottoman empire apart by the end of the 19th century. In other words, the 'peace and stability' of the Ottoman Empire was being fractured by ethnic and nationalist sentiment, and that included Arab nationalism.
@@nighttrain1236
You got brainwashed and turned into a racist, totally unbeknownst to yourself.
Iraqis and Afghan people are not Arabs.
Western Media has made people into racists where you lump everyone in the middle east into a single group.
It would be as absurd as calling an Italian the same as an Irishman and claiming that all white people are the same and that they all have equal claims to Ireland. That's stupid isn't it?
The Palestinian people are a mixed race people and are a singular ethnic group that is as distinct as say Scottish or Irish or Basque or French or Italian or Catalonian.
@@nighttrain1236Orientalism definitely didn't help in any shape or form though. The sheer entitlement and racism from my home country of England can't be understated.
Europe didn't conceive of concepts like "dhimmi," "jihad," or "taqiyyah" though. What you call peace is just an empty form of order "stabilized" by subjugating non-Muslims and enforcing a quiet but violent supremacy over them.
In other words these are Europeans battling to carve out a state for themselves.
Yup the zionist agenda...
Yes
They are eurp colonialist nzi
As they carve up the indigenous population.
TURK KAZA RIAN (kazars) asian Europeans, say they are ashk enazi jews, but they are not, they are the imposters, and Netanyahu and his false ADS, showing in america, WE ARE GODS CHOSEN PEOPLE, that is simply not true, God says in the KJVB, that Jacobs sons decendents are He named them, Israel, they are not Israel Corpo ation which the ash kenazi have made on the land they are israel, they never signed the Gen eva Conve ntion, after WW2, making it a nation again, naming it is rael, The so called ashk enazi imposters, who really are Kaz ars went to the International Courts, had contracts made legal with british gov, , to make the lan, a r o t h s c h i l d s corp oration and they named it the Isr ael Corpo ration. Those contracts expired Oct 31, 2023, so therefore the is rael corp which the gaza land was also made a corp within the is rael corp. So Kazar Zio nist, Corpo ration heads tried to renew these contracts back in Feb 2023 and they were told NO, they can't renew them, so therefore in order to try to cover up and keep the world from finding out what frausters they reallly are, the kazar zion ist did a False Flag event on Oct 7, utube sensoring everything, can't say the details, and who cut the deal with hamas, etc. but you can research and figure it all out. It involves the usa past leader who was a muslim.
They are Jews. Period.
Modern Israel is a European colony. That is exactly when all the problems started.
Really? 60% of the population are from Arab Jewish origins.
facts , and if anyone comes to the replies like other bots its isreali propaganda , so watch out from them and ignore them poeple!
How is it a colony when they were there first and got pushed out by Islam
@@renamanvelova5200they were also pushed out of Europe and Africa throughout history, maybe they really were filth?
you sure that's how the problems STARTED or continued? war, conflict, & rape are innate to the Tribes of Abraham.
Accurate and well said. A very knowledgeable and Intelligent Woman
What was accurate? Hardly anything was said except that people moved to vacant land and were minding their own business and the local inhabitants took offence to them cos they were Jews.
Although, I will say it's was a great intro to the history of the massacres of Jews perpetrated by the Muslim Arabs residing there. Sadly, I doubt she will delve into the truth of the matter considering the Arab narrative she will try to push and the implications of actually telling the truth will mean to Pan-Arabism.
Needless to say, if you don't believe then look at who started all the wars in the region resulting in today's current situation.
PS. Don't read the reports by independent eyewitnesses or the commission that was done to investigate all the massacres against Jews cos it's ghastly.
As a Jew I stand with Palestine
same
@ShadiksKhan Mslims can't lie. Proof: Our religions stays the same, unlike certain religion that changes every few miles radius.
@ShadiksKhan No, the source is Quran and Hadith. Grow up. You no longer have the face that of a little child.
@@miku5840muslim lie alwayz when the violence terrorsim antisemitism slavery and the pdfile Biographie momad in qur@n hadith is exposed and Challenged they use taqqiya
More like you lay with palestine, face down & biting a pillow
The key word “European”
No the key word is dhimmi.
This woman has depicted a false story. This is propaganda .
Jews and christians before Zionism were dhimmis. The Arabs constantly told them they were nothing, filthy, inferior, animals, pigs and monkeys, it's written in their book (one instance among many: Sahih Muslim The Book of Tribulations and Portents of the Last Hour - Hadith 2922 reads :
The last hour would not come unless the Muslims will fight against the Jews and the Muslims would kill them until the Jews would hide themselves behind a stone or a tree and a stone or a tree would say: Muslim, or the servant of Allah, there is a Jew behind me; come and kill him...).
They had to pay huge taxes for being Jews to the ottoman empire. They had to move away when they didn't want them anymore. They could easily be killed and robbed. Muslims came from everywhere. There is nothing like one Arab ethnicity on this land. You can see black Muslims too. Although considered inferior even today and called slaves. That's even the name of their district in Gaza, Al Abeed. The empire has been converting by force half of the planet. People moved around. Arabs and Jews.
When the Jews settled in the country that was given to them after WW2, they brought modernity, transformed the dry land into fertile crops. They were looking for a new life away from persecutions.
They've been persecuted everywhere they tried to find peace, even in Europe by christians. Not because they're bad people but because they're a small community as they don't convert people as christians did with the crusades and as muslims still do nowadays.
In 1948 the Arabs immediately launched a big war to eradicate them. They said they didn't deserve a country and that they would kill each and every Jew. But even though the Israelis had nothing they won. Until that day, they transformed their whole population into an army as the threat of being eradicated never disappeared. Palestinians would say it loud today if you ask them: " the Jews have to go or be killed, this our land".
But the Israelis are powerful now. They suffered suicidal attacks from the Arabs. They found a way to stop them. Nothing's perfect especially for the Palestinians from Gaza who endure the harsh charia of hamas and are not allowed, except for a few, to get out to prevent any new attacks. There are check points, military bases, and an iron dome against the thousands of rockets that have been launched to kill Jewish civilians. This never stopped.
And there comes October 7 th. And this war. This hell. This massacre was too much. Big mistake from the hamas. Or may be not as they don't care about their people. They even live abroad as millionaires. Without these crazy leaders, without this will to kill all the Jews of the planet , their official program, without this old hatred, peace will be able to come. And Palestinians could live a better life as well instead of misery.
Sound like muslims occupation of peaceful india
Yea
The key word is 75% Sephardic
Very racist. They were ok with Bosnian immigration but that's because it didn't challenge her Islamic supremacism.
Palestinians are suffering because of inhuman policies of western nations particularly USA
Naw, the world will stick with the 7th century convert ASHKENAZI Jewry and it's disgusting invention of Zionism as the cause of every single "problem" in the region. Nice try tho to parlay y'all's bullshit onto someone else.
You have more dual Israeli citizens in every western government around the world. To trick it's populations into believing that crap. GHEEZ WHIZ; you guys are arrogant!
@ShadiksKhanAs you Know God does not help in many, many many moments
@@mariavictoriadepaz776look at his profile picture looking like a dirty Indian street vendor
@ShadiksKhan , shouldn't you be in a call center scamming old American people? Why are you here commenting?
The Palestinians are not suffering from their corrupt leaders? Or from groups like HAMAS and Islamic Jihad, whi are repressing and corrupt?
Free Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Tell me the prime minister of Palestine when the people of Israel started coming back! # There was no palestine to begin with 🤣 just jews arabs and Christians. Even though i'm a Christian, i believe that jews have first rights in Israel and then Christian and Muslims should be nothing but secondary citizens. If you have a problem with this then jews should be given a fair share of the money from people coming to the hajj cause Abraham built it. If u can't accept this then no one can accept your conditions
@@hide9244😂
@@hide9244if you want to bring religion into this, god himself has forbid the Jews land until Jesus comes back
I know thy works, and tribulation, and poverty, (but thou art rich) and I know the blasphemy of them which say they are Jews, and are not, but are the synagogue of Satan.
The Israel we know doesn't care about the Jews, they aren't Jews.
They are using Jewish religion as a way to terrorize others, the world is corrupt, brainwashing you, and you fall for it, I know you won't reply to this, stay ignorant.
@@hide9244 you obviously only follow the Zionist propaganda. 1922 census carried out by the British authorities was 78% Muslim, 11% Christian, 8% Jew. How can all of a sudden Jews have the most rights? Because they stole the land?
In the tense political climate of early 20th century Jerusalem, multiple instances of violence occurred between Palestinian Arabs and Jews. In March 1920, the "Bloody Passover" riots resulted in the tragic deaths of five Palestinian Jews. In April of that same year, six more Palestinian Jews lost their lives to political violence in Jerusalem. On June 15, 1920, 47 Palestinian Jews were killed in another wave of political violence. In August 1929, Muslim riots in Jerusalem and other cities led to the deaths of approximately 250 Palestinian Jews. On November 9, 1937, five more Palestinian Jews were killed by Palestinian Arabs near Jerusalem. And on March 28, 1938, four Palestinian Jews lost their lives in a similar attack near Safed. The violence continued, and on November 29, 1947, seven Jews were killed by Palestinian Arabs near Jerusalem. Between December 1, 1947 and March 31, 1948, a staggering 850 Palestinian Jews lost their lives to Arab attacks.
You are the first brave woman to acknowledge the Jewish communities were there living peacefully in the holy land with the Arabs and Muslim neighbours more than 100 years ago. Good job educating others. So many stupid people believing the influencers from Iran pushing the narrative that Jews only came to the area after the Holocaust. It has caused chaos in the world. True peace can only coexist with truth.
All Arabs know this fact and all Arab countries had jewish minorities living with them. the creation of the apartheid colonial state disturbed all of this.
Not really. There was squabbles between Jews and Arabs all the time. That's why they created the Haganah. It not like the area of Palestine was fully developed. There was plenty of uninhabited land. Arabs just started to get greedy and say the Jews were the problem for creating a farm in an empty field somewhere in the Levant.
@@BonsterBar guess you think people are dumb just to believe words of the Zionist... Haganah was formed to protect n promote the european refugees.. your kind are known to be shrewd, ungrateful breed.. when the British stopped the influx of the Jewish immigration, the Haganah turned into terrorism against the British govt, bombing bridges,rail lines n ships n they further went into killing sprees.. you would
Pin point issue. European colonisers should go back to EU
Not in my Country,🇵🇹 We pass that....😮✋🕳️🇮🇱
Muslims should go back to the middle east
I think that has, by and large, already happened. What Europe, the UK and the US should do is stop meddling and get their hands off.
They only meddle where they see their self interest.
Independent countries need to wake up and realise western nations are only out for themselves. We have all known this for decades.
And Muslims colonisers back to the Islamic world!
I can relate to beeing annoyed by an influx of immigrants who don't take to local customs 😂
I told you all along blame england for what has happened
yes, this all r o t h s c h i l d s and his private block of land , they call London City Corporation where none of the Laws that the British gov constatation has, doesn't apply to the Kazars zionist on the 1 mile land block inside the London, UK, called london city. This is where they do everything in secret from the people and the Press.
No blame, the Ottoman empire for conquering Isreal and killing many jews and Christian etc for not converting
We should blame the crusaders and the Roman Empire. They’re the one who started the persecution. But we should also blame England France and US for this as well
@@MiixAndMatch you don’t know your history, do you crusaders a.k.a. Christian army aka the Roman Empire committed persecution towards the Jewish population
I told you all along blame Zionists for what has happened, three decades ago Professor Israel Shahak in his book 'Jewish history Jewish religion' available on the internet at 'If Americans knew' wrote "messianic Judaism is a greater threat than antisemitism'
😮Some say this is my
Home,
Some say, this is my Land,
Some say, this is my Country.
FOOLS ???
Your just passing through this short life,
NOTHING will be ever yours.
❤❤❤
The world sees GENOCIDE.😢
Well said
@@Lapiskam
Most welcomed.
Brainwash Education
By WAR Mongers.
When the world sees
GENOCIDE & APARTHEID.
GREED & EGOS kills humanity.
Our past history is the proof of civilisations destroyed.
Today is no different.
Be Human 1st but our World Governments are ELITIST GREED Merchants bidding only for Companies that fund them.
In the tense political climate of early 20th century Jerusalem, multiple instances of violence occurred between Palestinian Arabs and Jews. In March 1920, the "Bloody Passover" riots resulted in the tragic deaths of five Palestinian Jews. In April of that same year, six more Palestinian Jews lost their lives to political violence in Jerusalem. On June 15, 1920, 47 Palestinian Jews were killed in another wave of political violence. In August 1929, Muslim riots in Jerusalem and other cities led to the deaths of approximately 250 Palestinian Jews. On November 9, 1937, five more Palestinian Jews were killed by Palestinian Arabs near Jerusalem. And on March 28, 1938, four Palestinian Jews lost their lives in a similar attack near Safed. The violence continued, and on November 29, 1947, seven Jews were killed by Palestinian Arabs near Jerusalem. Between December 1, 1947 and March 31, 1948, a staggering 850 Palestinian Jews lost their lives to Arab attacks.
@@Hebrew-Spirit
The Divine Architect of the Universes does not look at what team your in,
but at ur heart of compassion.
GREED & EGOS kills humanity.
Our past history is the proof of civilisations destroyed.
Today is no different.
We all breath the same air & just passing through this short life.
💕💕💞
In 622 A.D., Muhammad, the founder of Islam, traveled to Medina in order to spread his new faith and attract followers. However, when the Jews of Medina refused to convert and rejected Muhammad, two major Jewish tribes were expelled. In 627, Muhammad's followers killed between 600 and 900 Jewish men and divided the surviving women and children amongst themselves. This pattern of persecution continued throughout history, with instances such as the crucifixion of Jewish vizier Joseph HaNagid in 1066, the slaughter of thousands of Jews in Fez in 1465, and the destruction of synagogues in various Arab countries in the 10th-19th centuries. Despite the Islamic prohibition on forced conversion, Jews were often given the ultimatum of either converting or facing death in places like Yemen, Morocco, and Baghdad. While there have been instances of Jews achieving high positions and success in the Islamic world, there have also been numerous persecutions and atrocities committed against them.
Pre Zionist Jewish communities in the Holy Land lived in relatively peaceful co-existence with their Muslim and Christian neighbours, they were all Palestinian, just Palestinians of different faiths 🇵🇸
Lies! All lies! Those massacres perpetrated by the Muslim Arabs aren't imaginary. So much for peaceful living if you have to cull your neighbors every few years.
It was the real life version of The Purge taking place.
Show me one source where these people called themselves 'Palestinian' in the 19th century.
Excellent comment, which will definitely upset pro-Israeli supporters. There were 90% Arabs and 10% Jews living in that area, but the Zionists wanted to create their own country and promised the Jews citizenship if the supported it’s establishment, hence we see the mess we are in today 😢🕊️🇵🇸
Lies! Then explain all the massacres that happened from 1900-1948??
Did the Jews and Christians imagine themselves being killed??
Just in case you try to be clever, It's literally in black and white. Commissions were set up to investigate why the Muslim Arabs were killing Jews. Mind you it wasn't all but enough to make you go WHAT.
Also, the Ottomans had a similar problem except the Ottomans would flatten your entire village with you in it if anyone got out of hand, so everyone behaved. Not because they got along all that well but because artillery can convince anyone to be good.
Dont be stupid. The region was called Syria Palaestina province of Roman Empire since a new millenium. After Herodian dynasty have fallen and Roman empire take over the region. In facts it is the European empire that named the region as Syria Palaestina. It is not a made up country of 20th century@@nighttrain1236
يا الله ، اطلب هذا الصباح الحماية من حرمانك من خيراتك ، وإزالة حمايتك ، وإصابة المصائب المفاجئة ، وجميع طرق غضبك.آمين. 🇵🇸🌹🤲
I’m very proud of your press news coverage on this issue Allah will give victory …. ISRAEL shame on you Jews
Amazing how Saudi Arabia was established (British Groundwork) just before this.
Ottomans secularization started the groundwork for their fall and the young Turks nationalists continued their legacy.
@@senadzriYeah, but the rival family of Saudis also had a deal with Britain.
The deal was Unified Arabia.
Iraq, Syria, and Arabian peninsula all under one government which would also create problems, but it would be better than whatever Saudi Arabia is at this point.
English empire colony ministry and his agent hempher and Abu saud and abu wahab builded 1735 the wahabi group ,,1825,,kurdish nahsibendi group in iraq,,1830 salafi group in sudan,,1913 supported al albani,,1941 builded azad group in iraq and syria,,1980 builded pkk,,2006 isis (israel secret intelligence services ) builded by mossad, cia and mi5,,they was and still are under contract of usa and fight in ukraine against Russia now,,,all work for great Israel project and yinnon plan
Saudi Arabia was established in 1932 as a result of the Saudi / Ikwan conquest which deposed the British allied Hashemites of Mecca.
Zionist settlement of Ottoman ruled areas started in 1882.
I,m sorry to say this, but why always europe that ocupied someone land.
Japeth living in the tents of Shem.
Well, since you asked. This particular group of Europeans were beaten up and oppressed everywhere they went to. Nobody wanted them. Nobody except Palestinians 75 years ago.
It was arabs and ottomans that they learned from so blame them
@@brojwz2314Wrong. They never conquered or occupied Western European lands and many parts of Europe. That goes to the Romans, Vikings, Greeks, etc. Stop blaming others for your sins.
And if they did learn from them, they wouldn't have brought up the idea of "superior race" or killing based on someone's religion. And also learn to coexist. Something they didn't learn from the Romans.
I have two words for you, Islamic Caliphate. Look it up
Please give back of Palestinians own land 🇵🇸 Palestinians have rights to live free in Palestine in this beautiful world 🇵🇸🇵🇸🌍 free Palestine and save humanity 🇵🇸🇵🇸
Tell them to stop starting wars trying to annihilate the Jews and they won't get salami sliced all the time.
Tell them to stop starting wars trying to annihilate the Jews and they won't get salami sliced all the time.
Palestine does not exists
Cry about it
Free Palestine in shaa ALLAH ❤❤❤❤
Deluxe Palestine, $2.99
th-cam.com/users/shortsf22bTxpCHjM Which Palestine? In all of human history, there has never been a country called Palestine. The so-called fake Palestinians have their country. It is called Jordan! Just compare their flag! The British Mandate was divided in 1947. Unfortunately not 50% to 50%. The Arabs actually got about 78%. You probably don't even know where the name Palestine comes from. Who coined the name and when and, above all, who it was used to refer to. So don't talk nonsense here!
Keyword "European" Jew
Most of Israels Jews are Mitzrachi Jews from North Africa, The Middle East and Israel itself. The largest group of Jews in Israel are from Moracco and Moraccan Jews who were born in Israel. In 1989 Moracco had 1 million Jews and today 900,000 of those Jews live in Israel.
"The influx of Jewish immigrants. A key phrase. NOT because they are Jewish but simply mass immigration is a never a good idea. So we have to ask why the EU and the UK have spent 30 plus years either encouraging it or ignoring the problems it has caused and will continue to cause from here on.
Maybe because their interference creates destruction of nations , causing people to flee elsewhere
Perhaps you should get ypur mots of their country and resources, then there won't be an influx 😅
@@caylia9989 l don't disagree.
However, people want to acknowledge one and not the other because they are Europeans. Despite what Palestinians are facing is a whole different scale where there is intent of taking over. Something Churchhill said himself.
I guess it was to be expected.
It wasn’t even exactly the influx of refugees
The land can handle we can handle
It’s thier ACTIONS disturbing the economy & harmony & local relationships
And The clear intent & power to take over the land
British UK bais towards them
Which doesn’t apply to EU refugees no one planning a take over rather you are benefiting of thier labor IT’ S UR IMAGINATION & XENOPHOBIA
Rather u should direct that to ur government destroying end stealing other cpuntry recourses
That’s if you were an honest human person
German nazi were not Muslim
Mohammadians? What are you? Human worshiper? We follow prophet's way to God not worship him as God like Christian did to Jesus
@Jamelwilliams.
@Johnjohnny. Oh so now Christianity and Judaism also fairy tail? Because they got very similar history, Islam has accurate history too, i guess we are just soulless clumps of cells
They were in agreement with them tho
@Johnjohnny.
Free Palestine 🙏❤️🇵🇸!!!
Well said. We need more of these videos 👏👏👏
If Hamas was hiding in Israel, do you think Israel should impose the same tactics as they did in Gaza? Yes or No
No lmao
@@88Expertexactly, you're racist
@@Ashengraychild1 cause the favours Israeli life more than Palestinian lives
@@88Expert damn you really didn't get enough love from your mom
@@Aleaaitacest3736 well I get more love than the orphan in Gaza.
Free Palestine
th-cam.com/users/shortsf22bTxpCHjM Which Palestine? In all of human history, there has never been a country called Palestine. The so-called fake Palestinians have their country. It is called Jordan! Just compare their flag! The British Mandate was divided in 1947. Unfortunately not 50% to 50%. The Arabs actually got about 78%. You probably don't even know where the name Palestine comes from. Who coined the name and when and, above all, who it was used to refer to. So don't talk nonsense here!
Free England 🏴
❤❤ FREE PALESTINA ❤❤
This lady living in Britain and part of that community talking about someone not following "local customs" is hilarious
The absolutely hypocrisy! I best she won’t bloody leave, though.
It’s not 9/11
Being islamphobic dildo is not cool anymore
She’s practising her face without disturbing anyone which is a granted by UK law but country she is
Jews were also allowed that the problem
Is them DISTURBING the economy & relationship
Undermining all the natives cuz they’re weren’t as “civilized” as Europeans
the big problem is them creating separate jewish economy they ways they managed the land by kicky native farmers out & so on
Thank you for informing many needed information….
God bless you!
After 75 years people just talk about the Hamas, colonization has been left out 😢
🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Thank you for sharing history.
So the European Jews came and created agricultural settlements on land that they bought legally from Arab landowners who made good money.
They employed Arab workers, which they are now criticized for as exploiting them.
They stopped it for their „closed communities“ because the Jewish workers couldn’t compete and needed to earn wages, so they only hire Jews in a more self-sufficient way. Now this is portrayed as segregation and exclusion from the labor market.
So which way should they have done it?
#UStaxpayers
#Canadiantaxpayers
One of the best videos i’ve seen to date on this. So well thought out and delivered. I was hooked from the start. Thanks! More videos like this and with the same delivery
#GazaUnderAttack #FreePalestine
The majority of the Palestinians are of Canaanite origin, that is, the actual owners of the land, but their culture is Arab and they precede the Arabs and the Jews. They are open and courageous and do not resort to anyone to protect them and are proud of their belonging. They are the owners of a pluralistic culture that made them receive the Jews of Europe comfortably and this made competing with them difficult on the humanitarian level. This is why everyone sought to occupy them, especially the Zionists 🇦🇪 ✌️😁
Horse Shit. Your quoting a study that studied a group of people born in Lebanon from several different ethnicities that yes included some Palestinians the one thing they all had in common was they and their families had always been in Lebanon. These people they tested had 93% Cananite DNA. 1. That does not mean that all most or any other Palestinians have that same DNA and even if they did Cananite DNA does not necissarily link one to Israel. There were Cananites all over the Middle East and North Africa. The Phonecians that settled Carthige for example were Cananites and had no connection to Israel. Many of those who now call themselves Palestinians are Arabs from around the Arab world who have no connection to even the levant let alone Israel. When the Mandate began and the Jews and British began to drastically improve the standard of living and develop the land lots of Arabs from around the Middle East and North Africa re-located to Israel. In 1921 there were a total of 400,000 people including 50,000 Jews in Palestine by 1948 there were 650,000 Just Jews so when the mandate first began it was pretty empty by comparison.
Rightly said, many of todays people dont know it
🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Mr Bebe and his cohorts don’t even look like I presume Jesus would have looked! 😳😳
You must add to the context: "the great arab revolt".
The primary goal of the Arab rebels was to establish an independent and unified Arab state stretching from Aleppo to Aden, which the British government had promised to recognize.
The arabs collaborated with foreign powers to breakup the ottomon empire largely for themselves.
Th family line of the rival families hashimites and saudi became heads of new countries.
1929 Massacre you mean. Hebron and Gaza Jewish communities were massacred and expelled in Oct. 7 type of attacks and in other places. It's important to mention that in all the waves of violence not only Jews were targeted but also Arabs who chose to coexist with Jews. 40 Arabs were murdered on Oct 7 and some were taken hostage.
Wasn’t the Ottoman Empire responsible for occupying the lands in force? So why complain if the land that wasn’t yours to begin with is taken back?
Good Point
Did you learn history from McDonalds? 😂🤣Muslims have ruled Palestine for 14 centuries. There was no occupation when Muslims conquered. The population was oppressed under Christian rule and they welcomed the change of government. They remained non-Muslim for a long time before Islam spread through dawah activities. Zionists colonized and occupied it and sidelined, torturing and murdering the indigenous population.
"nation state" remember?? If you want to go back into old era when a conquest is still exist then why u guys act like a hypocrite when russian attacking ukraine?? Why u guys destroy irak just because of fake wmd?? To protect the world huh?? Pfft 😏 Dont shout to other about humanity, justice, or blablabla then
Becayse they are hypocrits
The lands were owned by Palestinians. They florished in the Ottoman enpire. The Balfourdeclaration states palestinians and their properties would be protected. Instead they were massacred.
They lived amongst them as hudden wolves
Pre-Zionist Jews lived in a “relatively” peaceful climate of the Ottoman Empire, so long as they accepted the system of religious apartheid called “Dhimmi-hood”, wherein their status as dhimmis (non-Muslims) made them 2nd-Class citizens who had to pay an additional poll tax for the same “equal” rights.
so much misinformation.
non muslim citizens under a musilm country had to pay a protection tax because they were being protected by that muslim country, they didn't have to protect that country and fight for it if they went to war, as it was not their war. and in exchange muslims allowed them to settle in their land, live with them and practice their religion in peace.
muslims had to go to war to protect their country. jews just had to sit there and be protected by them.
@@Ted_Kenzoku
you need to go educate yourself and read some Quran.
Non Muslim pay Jizya while humiliated. This humanistic misinformation is to fool Europeans like you.
Not only that, they were forced to wear distinct clothing, cross the street in deference to a Muslim (among other humiliations), be subjected to random beatings and massacres and were not allowed to give testimony in a court that could be considered equal to testimony given by a Muslim.
@@Ted_Kenzoku"protection money" = Mafia payments.
Free Palistine... From hamas!
Let us not forget that it was Sultan Abdul hamid allowed this mass migration , with his good relationship that he built with hyrzl
How noble of him
Nope Herzl met with the Sultan and his propsal was turned down. It took him Years just to get in to see the Sultan.
@@joshualittle877 wrong, read the journal of tahsin Hassan pasha mate then talk
@@bigman5586 I dont care what some Ottoman wrote in his journal I trust no Islamic leader especially Ottoman rulers about as far as I could throw them. Hertzle came back and fourth to talk to talk to the Sultan numerous times and was never approved to create a settlement or homeland for the Jews in Palestine. Thats a matter of well documented historical fact. Its also fact he came back and fourth to see the Sultan for years never getting to see the Sultan. Much of the land purchased by Jews before the Mandate under the Ottomans was purchased under the table because Ottomans restricted and forbid Jewish land purchase all together. This and the fact that some of the land they purchased had Arab workers attached to it who did not themselves own the land but viewed it as theirs which is at least where some of the myths of stolen land comes from.
@@bigman5586 Also Hassan Pasha was an Ottoman Official in Algeria so not sure what he has to do with Palestine.
How about doing a piece on the decimation of Jewish communities in Arab countries?
True.
How much did creation of Israel worsen anti-semetism in those Arab countries.
Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmm....
How about you learning they were deported from spain and welcomed in North Africa. Jewish communities thrived.Lets debate the bolshevik revolution and the Holodomor by jews. Or the raping if civilian german women after WW II by bolahevik jews.
History clarifies the situation. Thank you.
Interesting I would like to see/learn more.
She says “relative” peace with neighbors so casually. Lol
“Relatively peaceful” key word there.
Im half Ashkenazi half sephardi and we laugh at mol slems attempts at trying to divide us as if Jews couldnt recognize their brothers separated only by geography over centuries
This is like the story for the past 6000 years. Everything was fine, then Europeans showed up.
They promise heaven, but give hell.
Ohh Allah help the Palestinians, Muslims and Islam Aaaameen 🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭
More on Jewish history in PALESTINE please ❤
more on this please
"After 1929, everything changed!"
Really??? Why??
What happened in 1929??
Tell us! We ALL want to know!
There were 2000 Jews in the whole of Palestine. And they were treated terribly: restrictions placed on Jews in the Ottoman Empire were included, but not limited to, a special tax, a requirement to wear special clothing, and a ban on carrying guns, riding horses, building or repairing places of worship, and having public processions or worships.
Wikipedia: History of the Jews in the Ottoman Empire
As Muuslm, I support Israel.
Thank you for these clarifications. Everything has a reason and injustice's outcomes take a long time to emerge
More like these please so the world can understand historically and be informed clearly on the timeline. ❤️🍉
Pray for Palestine
Fajr Zuhr Asar Maghrib Isha and Witr Namaz
Allahu Akbar Allah is the greatest..
Could describe any muslim immigrant community in any Western country
Interesting accent you have there. 😂😂
Oh no. These are the things hitler complained about. I’m very, very worried. The fighting must stop. We need Devine intervention. 🙏
At what point do you get over this colonization job sense. Name me a modern democracy who doesn’t have a shaky past
Exactly. It’s such a weak argument at this point. Israel exists. It’s a country. Palestine could have been a country as well but instead of focusing on building a strong nation, Palestine continued to go to war with Israel and has since lost a considerable amount of land and authority in the region. All this fighting only leads to more bloodshed. If Palestine redirected their efforts into building a strong nation they could compete internationally and there people would have more opportunity. Hopefully they will realize this and steadily move in the right direction instead of the direction that has made the people of Palestine poorer and weaker over time.
These diverse people will never get along without open borders for all. At least they all energetically agree on that point.
Same in Europe
Power overwhelmed facts. The fact that is today like it or not. Very sad.
The Jews and Christians, were forced to pay the Jizuar tax
And if they didn't, they got murdered. Doesn't sound like co-existance to me.
As young as 4 year old, I've witnessed Israel tanks bulldozed Palestinian homes, through our local TV network. I asked my mom, why are they doing that? My mom told me it's a war between Palestine and Israel, and even as a young child, I've known Israel was in the wrong because everytime, they are the ones being proudly aggressive. I asked my mom, mind you, I was 4 years old, when will Palestine get their victory? She said one day. Fast forward 21 years later, they're still facing the same if not worse atrocities... only recently the world is waking up...
Arab jew✅
European Jew who learned Colonization❌
But I tought immigration was good. Are you implying that a large influx of foreigners can possibly take over?
May Allah protect and free Palestine Ameen
Not the first time a European colony backed by the British and the US disturbed the peace that was established and start to call the land their own.
Masha Allah nice explanation sister
FREE Palestine 🇵🇸...and Yemen 🇾🇪...and Syria 🇸🇾
I think i saw this woman at a Renaissance festival once. Or maybe it was a medieval video game cosplay event
Jews who lived in the holy land before 1948 were Palestinians themselves and not just their neighbors.
Most modern Israelis are mixed with Mizrahi Jews so most have some mix with Jews who have lived in the land for ever. So European immigrant Jews or colonizers make no relevance now since they are all mixed and claim the pre existing right.
Israel is not going anywhere nor is it going to accept a one state solution. Only hope is a two state solution with 1967 border anything more is just a dream. So people should concentrate on removing Israeli settlement in West Bank and not on right to return. Just like Greeks and Armenians can’t go back to their ancestral homeland in Anatolia from which they were expelled in 1920s, just like Indians and Pakistanis can’t get their land back from 1947 partition, just like Germans can’t get back their land from Poland after ww2 portions, just like Jews can never go back to Yemen or Libya or Iran, Palestinians can’t either it’s just geo political reality. Again nuclear armed Israel is not going anywhere there are thousand of Muslims Sudanese are dying and this conflict is taking all the attention.
Plus just like Middle East pro Palestine movement has political effect in west too with the rise of right wing parties. Netherland just elected one of the most anti Islamic party in Europe. World has no appetite for anything more than 1967 border deal soon there will be another tragedy and world will move on
Interesting taqiyyah. Your video is a very clever and diplomatic way of expressing nativist supremacy over the dhimmi. And it whitewashes the supremacy over the North African dhimmis as well. "Peace" in Islam means subjugation of the dhimmi.
Sounds like European immigration
Sounds like Muslim immigration.
When the oppressor went too far the people go further
Imagine colonizing a land that is occupied by people or peoples who get along well and ... really don't need colonizing.
You need to be honest. The reason why they dressed the same as the muslim people and why they spoke the same was because they were forced. They lived in relative peace meaning if they didn't do what they were told they did not live in peace. Also the jewish people had to wear certain clothing like tags so that everyone knew that they were jewish.
Absolutely a lie and wrong, there huge lists of Arab massacres of the Jewish villages and communities. Hebron 1929 massacre
The story of Palestine is so heart wrenching. I hope i see justice done in my lifetime. What a sight that would be. 🇵🇸✌️
In 1907, Scofield changed all word in bible from palestine to israel.
Coincidence, everyone?
Where I can find the full video? I want to know the full information.
but they said it start oct 7...
So what European Jews didn’t wear the same clothes or have the same culture as Palestinians. The Palestinians should have been tolerant and been willing to live alongside immigrants regardless if they had a different culture. Intolerance, unwillingness to peacefully coexist, and hostility from Palestinians towards immigrants with different cultural norms have unfortunately got the Palestinians where they are today. They did it to themselves 😬
It's important to understand the pre-1948 history of the land. It's not as black and white as either "side" often yells.
Very true...Its...FACTS..Black Page in the History..
Interesting. Is this a documentary??
Important and educational information. You're a great researcher, historian, and fact finder. European and white are keys words for me to know and realize and also pre zionism
They were no Palestine ! That land is Isreal , and named given by God.