True. Across the board decrease is a clear indicator that it's not any of these games' fault. China is arguably the biggest market for gacha games... so when their economy struggles, everyone feels that whiplash.
CN genshin players saving up for mavuika. CN HSR players hyped up for Sunday/Fugue. CN ZZZ are waiting for Miyabi drop which is the same time as Mavuika banner. Also the fact that ZZZ is primarily best played in PC than on mobile
Probably yeah since they don’t have the money anymore they just turn into the people who save for very desired characters, instead of swiping on everyone.
Those were the exact same excuses for Wuthering Waves lmao. Disclaimer: I love both ZZZ and WW and i don't trust Sensor Tower in the first place, i just find this comment funny as previously the ZZZ community would clown on WW community for saying this (me too ofc) lol.
@@kamitokadoya4759 ZZZ community never warred on anything. If anything, it was also bullied due to revenue drops months ago. The other games' community did it.
Right now I'm having more fun in ZZZ combat than other and the endgame content, it so much fun and much more satisfying. The parry and the dodge mechanic really satisfying especially on endgame content where the enemy can kill you in 3 - 4 hit. I hope ZZZ can stay strong even we the player got called as a gooner for playing this game. They should see what Snowbreak do to their games.
In Q2 of 2024, the top 5 phone sold in China are all Androids, and since Androids revenue for China is still using the old multiplier, you're bound to see less and less revenue for CN Apple devices (Which is the only device that actually got tracked by Sensortower, Android only relies on old multiplier back when Apple is still top 1 or 2 device in China)
PMEX anniversary was in September and it had a new Sync Pair type debuting with Cynthia, Steven, and Lance which was why the number jumped whereas October the new units were Giacomo & Clavell who no one cares about and the Halloween outfits went to Iono & Shauntal so all the money it did make was probably for Iono & Flutter Mane
ZZZ casually making 15+ million and people said dead game is really funny to me lol. I kinda wish we can see the Total revenue, including every Mobile OS, PC and Console combined, accurately.
irk...they're really unsuffarable and when they couldn't compete with Genshin or HSR they started to blast ZZZ as if by doing that their beloved game would magically perform any better
It's the same the other way around, when hoyo games are on top they scream how accurate it is and reminding wuwa is dead eos next month, etc it's more like the toxic part of each community
@@zeraddbakuha4057 If it weren't for the fact that WUWA players had to compare wuwa to HOYO games, I believe HOYO players wouldn't even want to bother with WUWA.
ZZZ's CN revenue is low just because there were issues with ZZZ's CN iOS transactions when Burnice's banner first launched. I know there’s some memeing and joking, but it’s just hilarious that some people seriously analyze it
Yeah. Gotta take console into perspective. I downloaded ZZZ on my s24 standard phone, and the thing can only run at 30 FPS and heats up something fierce. Plus you need a controller adapter to even play well. It's a great game but not really good on mobile. I'd rather play nikke on my phone
Gacharevenue's China Google revenue is a guess-work, don't look at China revenue, only look at Global and JP. Google is banned in China, they don't have Google Play Store. Otherwise, iOS (both China and Global) and Google (Global only) are still accurate data provided by Sensor Tower.
Can't believe a lot of games are dead or EOS now 😂😂😂 this will be the new meme on every gacha revenue if your game is not in top 3-5 your a dead game time to EoS
Never change ZZZ no matter what I’ll support your game!. The only game I put money now. It’s so much better than Genshin, HSR and Wuwa. ZZZ marketing is all varies and the world build is the best and not afraid to show all the marketing skills. Story has so much potential!. Don’t change!.
This Gacha Revenue Charts is just purely INFLATED IOS revenue and doesn't include Android since they don't have data on Android. This is just IOS revenue multiplied by 1.75 multiplier to assume Android revenue. If a game doesn't do well in IOS revenue obviously they will have low revenue here but this chart assumed both Android and IOS both by just using a 1.75 multiplier to get android revenue, so this is definitely and obviously a Fake Revenue Chart saying this is mobile revenue.
@@Zetsubou-69420 yeah that's right, all of my friends who play ZZZ using PC instead mobile and Burnice banner sold really well. I think this revenue only for mobile.
HELLO MISTER FOB, CAN YOU ALSO TALK ABOUT YOUR MONTHLY GACHA EXPENDITURE. AS I BELIEVE U HAVE THAT DATA ACCURATELY, UNLIKE THESE GACHA REVENUE RellyInnocent 🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂
The global economy is just shit in general atm. High inflation everywhere and living cost going through the roof. I also think the gacha player base is just not expanding much after genshin's release. There are only so many games the player base can support. As more and more companies are joining in the gacha race with more gacha games, everyone is going to earn less and less money. This reminds me of what mmo has gone through. Unless someone makes another gacha that explodes in popularity and brings a truckload of fresh players to the gacha industry, it's downhill from here. Who knows, maybe the industry will collapse after 2-3 years and we will return to the stone age of PNG auto-battle gacha. Many gacha CCs will probably have to look for another sector of the game industry to leech off to.
Jesus, this tribalism about Kuro and Hoyo back and forth is so emberassing...makes me feel like I am surrounded by 8yo's at the basic school that argue about "who is a better superhero". When are people going to learn that ST does not represent the whole revenue well and that revenue does not even matter as far as its enough for good quality content and possitive income. No matter if its ZZZ or WuWa.
15:02 Hell yeah brother! This guy gets it. I'll be simping for anime waifus and I won't feel an ounce of shame. I like ZZZ exactly because they're more open with this kind of stuff, in contrast to very tame Genshin. I play all their games and Genshin is still my favorite, but it's nice to have variety.
kind of expected tbh wuwa will most likely stay at this 11-8 mili mark and zzz will also probably stay here, things may change in the anniversary, me personally, I enjoy wuwa a lot more than zzz I don't play zzz anymore, got touch my tail at 30 pulls and deleted the game soon after
this revenue was fun until wuwa meat riders come out. you know how other game fandom make a joke when their game slowly dying that means there will be EoS soon, i really loved that time😂
@@Zeref-n7u it's not my problem yes but if anything the current situation of wuwa's revenue should teach y'all how to shut ur mouth up and not to jinx it by saying how this game can end genshin's career.. it's so funny seeing y'all moving the goalpost from genshin to zzz so fast bc y'all are getting humbled real bad and y'all's petty ass started targeting zzz bc that's a new game too.. kuro fans forever in the khia asylum. bye.
the only "big" game that i tried and really good on mobile only lads and hsr (this one is perfect for mobile) other than that its ASS, gi and wuwa perfect on pc and last zzz really really good on console/ pc
Tbh.... Hsr also not good on phone.... Every cutscene lag and in storage even bigger then genshin on other hand genshin one even 1 cutscene lag and storage I already told you.... Thay said in 2.7 livestream they will lower the storage let's see how it goes
@@ntz752 I'll name you several lol. - For starter, how about Warner Brothers? - How about Allstate Insurance? - ByteDance? Parent Company of TikTok? - Forget Activision Blizzard, nobody likes them anymore but they still pay for its service. Maybe those 4 I listed was too big for you to recognize, how about some "smaller companies"... - Dyson? - Target? - Johnson & Johnson? - L'OREAL? Still doesn't ring a bell? Let's go back up to the bigger ones then.. - Amazon? - Disney? Still not big enough? How about the big financial sectors... - Goldman Sachs - Morgan Stanley The list can go on for a hundred more lol.
@Pikemans-t1x cons were designed to mitigate the idea of getting more than one copies of a character, Genshin was smart to design around this inherent gacha problem by adding value to having duplicates. Nikke for example, when you get a dupe of an SSR it only gives a 2% stat boost each until 12 times, whales still max core Nikkes even tho the dupes don't have a value.
if u look at banner revenue not monthly shorekeeper earn more than burnice, shorekeeper got to rank 21 and burnice only got to rank 24 and dropped faster than zhezhi, if the first 2 days of shorekeeper banner were in October wuwa would be above zzz
Its because ppl are tired with hoyo games, genshin players are just go with the flow now. they play trends then out and back to genshin. its like a cage :v
Or maybe Genshin is just a cozy exploration/rpg with high production value and engaging combat for f2p, casuals, and light spenders...that..wait for it..people enjoy 😉
Honestly, a 22% drop in total revenue is more concerning that any drop in a game's revenue
True. Across the board decrease is a clear indicator that it's not any of these games' fault. China is arguably the biggest market for gacha games... so when their economy struggles, everyone feels that whiplash.
Every gacha game EOS soon
Seeing zzz revenue this month made me really realize how well loved Qingyi actually was (who's single banner made the 30+ mil on mobile)
CN genshin players saving up for mavuika. CN HSR players hyped up for Sunday/Fugue. CN ZZZ are waiting for Miyabi drop which is the same time as Mavuika banner. Also the fact that ZZZ is primarily best played in PC than on mobile
Probably yeah since they don’t have the money anymore they just turn into the people who save for very desired characters, instead of swiping on everyone.
Plus: Sensor Tower literally makes up numbers. It's entirely clickbait asspull.
Those were the exact same excuses for Wuthering Waves lmao.
Disclaimer: I love both ZZZ and WW and i don't trust Sensor Tower in the first place, i just find this comment funny as previously the ZZZ community would clown on WW community for saying this (me too ofc) lol.
@@kamitokadoya4759 ZZZ community never warred on anything. If anything, it was also bullied due to revenue drops months ago.
The other games' community did it.
@@kamitokadoya4759 Tbh almost all the communities that knew how were those few wuwa players that are insufferable, made fun of them
Right now I'm having more fun in ZZZ combat than other and the endgame content, it so much fun and much more satisfying. The parry and the dodge mechanic really satisfying especially on endgame content where the enemy can kill you in 3 - 4 hit. I hope ZZZ can stay strong even we the player got called as a gooner for playing this game. They should see what Snowbreak do to their games.
In Q2 of 2024, the top 5 phone sold in China are all Androids, and since Androids revenue for China is still using the old multiplier, you're bound to see less and less revenue for CN Apple devices (Which is the only device that actually got tracked by Sensortower, Android only relies on old multiplier back when Apple is still top 1 or 2 device in China)
PMEX anniversary was in September and it had a new Sync Pair type debuting with Cynthia, Steven, and Lance which was why the number jumped whereas October the new units were Giacomo & Clavell who no one cares about and the Halloween outfits went to Iono & Shauntal so all the money it did make was probably for Iono & Flutter Mane
ZZZ casually making 15+ million and people said dead game is really funny to me lol.
I kinda wish we can see the Total revenue, including every Mobile OS, PC and Console combined, accurately.
Single banner too, btw
Especially zzz I believe has not as many mobile players, cause lets be honest the game is kind of ass on mobile.
@vexxobex7333 yeah, to even perfectly parry even in PC is difficult for me. Now, I need to do this with limited finger space.
aye get used to it because every gacha revenue u will see a lot of dead game and eos 😂
@@screwdriver.33last genshin banner was chiori and xilo...so bqsicly only xilo😂
If wuwa was on top these kuro bots will be screaming about how accurate sensor tower is, lmao
irk...they're really unsuffarable and when they couldn't compete with Genshin or HSR they started to blast ZZZ as if by doing that their beloved game would magically perform any better
It's the same the other way around, when hoyo games are on top they scream how accurate it is and reminding wuwa is dead eos next month, etc it's more like the toxic part of each community
@@zeraddbakuha4057did WW ever got on top
@@zeraddbakuha4057 If it weren't for the fact that WUWA players had to compare wuwa to HOYO games, I believe HOYO players wouldn't even want to bother with WUWA.
@@AholicRyutabrug, did you just came out of your cave, this was already happening during hsr launch 😂
ZZZ's CN revenue is low just because there were issues with ZZZ's CN iOS transactions when Burnice's banner first launched. I know there’s some memeing and joking, but it’s just hilarious that some people seriously analyze it
As a wuwa player welcome to the team ZZZ as part of our dead games.
Yeah. Gotta take console into perspective. I downloaded ZZZ on my s24 standard phone, and the thing can only run at 30 FPS and heats up something fierce. Plus you need a controller adapter to even play well. It's a great game but not really good on mobile. I'd rather play nikke on my phone
sensor tower is a nightmare for WuWa talkshts and whiteknights, so it's a scam for them
If wuwa and genshin would switch next month everyone would praise thw site😂
@Pikemans-t1xthen really if someone can point to a better list with more accurate numbers they should just say it.
When WW made 46 M or something they were praising the sensortower 😂, Just how fast the night changes 😂😂😂
@ziebus90 were e4
@Pikemans-t1x unreliable only came after whn it starts dropping on next month. We have seen it all bruh 😂
the fact tht people saying the chart is fake NOW is laughable especially since people believing this chart when genshin is not in top 3 or whtever lol
Gacharevenue's China Google revenue is a guess-work, don't look at China revenue, only look at Global and JP. Google is banned in China, they don't have Google Play Store.
Otherwise, iOS (both China and Global) and Google (Global only) are still accurate data provided by Sensor Tower.
Can't believe a lot of games are dead or EOS now 😂😂😂
this will be the new meme on every gacha revenue if your game is not in top 3-5 your a dead game time to EoS
Never change ZZZ no matter what I’ll support your game!. The only game I put money now. It’s so much better than Genshin, HSR and Wuwa.
ZZZ marketing is all varies and the world build is the best and not afraid to show all the marketing skills.
Story has so much potential!. Don’t change!.
Oh well, I will just proceed to keep playing zzz like every other day. Btw: Zzz is not that mobile friendly
I play zzz and wuwa and ya neither are mobile friendly at all, godspeed to those who can play them though on mobile.
Yeah I play both on PC. My phone turns into hot lava trying to run them.
I play ZZZ on my phone☝🏻... there's no hot issue on my phone...maybe because I play just couple hours.😅
i play zzz and wuwa on my phone with a g99 chipset and it doesn't get heated up after playing for 4-6 hrs i don't even use phone cooler
@@depressoexpresso8469 I can't with WuWa but ZZZ I can, I've already cleared most of the content there.
This Gacha Revenue Charts is just purely INFLATED IOS revenue and doesn't include Android since they don't have data on Android. This is just IOS revenue multiplied by 1.75 multiplier to assume Android revenue.
If a game doesn't do well in IOS revenue obviously they will have low revenue here but this chart assumed both Android and IOS both by just using a 1.75 multiplier to get android revenue, so this is definitely and obviously a Fake Revenue Chart saying this is mobile revenue.
ZZZ feels a lot more like a pc game, i mean my potato pc can run it and my decent phone cant 🙂
The amount of people wishing for Burnice i saw was so big, so i dont think this numbers accurate, or maybe they just PC players.
I thought burnice had the most selling banner.
It might just be that people don't play ZZZ on mobile
@@Zetsubou-69420 yeah that's right, all of my friends who play ZZZ using PC instead mobile and Burnice banner sold really well. I think this revenue only for mobile.
@@cynzmia7387yup this revenue is only on Mobile. PC and console users are not included.
Nah they mostly skip Caesar for her.
this
HELLO MISTER FOB, CAN YOU ALSO TALK ABOUT YOUR MONTHLY GACHA EXPENDITURE. AS I BELIEVE U HAVE THAT DATA ACCURATELY, UNLIKE THESE GACHA REVENUE RellyInnocent 🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂
The global economy is just shit in general atm. High inflation everywhere and living cost going through the roof. I also think the gacha player base is just not expanding much after genshin's release. There are only so many games the player base can support. As more and more companies are joining in the gacha race with more gacha games, everyone is going to earn less and less money. This reminds me of what mmo has gone through. Unless someone makes another gacha that explodes in popularity and brings a truckload of fresh players to the gacha industry, it's downhill from here. Who knows, maybe the industry will collapse after 2-3 years and we will return to the stone age of PNG auto-battle gacha. Many gacha CCs will probably have to look for another sector of the game industry to leech off to.
Jesus, this tribalism about Kuro and Hoyo back and forth is so emberassing...makes me feel like I am surrounded by 8yo's at the basic school that argue about "who is a better superhero".
When are people going to learn that ST does not represent the whole revenue well and that revenue does not even matter as far as its enough for good quality content and possitive income. No matter if its ZZZ or WuWa.
Wuwa & ZZZ almost 60-70% revenue is from pc while it's the complete opposite for hsr, for genshin it's a around 50-50 split
15:02 Hell yeah brother! This guy gets it. I'll be simping for anime waifus and I won't feel an ounce of shame. I like ZZZ exactly because they're more open with this kind of stuff, in contrast to very tame Genshin. I play all their games and Genshin is still my favorite, but it's nice to have variety.
Hoyo will cannibalize itself if they did. They seem to be smarter than Tencent who bought a piece of most of the gachas in this list lol.
kind of expected tbh wuwa will most likely stay at this 11-8 mili mark and zzz will also probably stay here, things may change in the anniversary, me personally, I enjoy wuwa a lot more than zzz I don't play zzz anymore, got touch my tail at 30 pulls and deleted the game soon after
Lmao that's too bad, game got a lot better after that.
@@BrianCarreraShawI dropped ZZZ due to the TV mode. Is it still there?
They are as invasive as 1.0@@genshinfinity
Bt ZZZ is miles better than WW , u probably missing the fun .
@@moonlover2310 not not really lmao I downloaded ZZZ again because I liked Burnice and it was still as boring as ever,
I play zzz on ps5
Snowbreaks revenue will definitely fall off but because fritia is pretty bad
this revenue was fun until wuwa meat riders come out. you know how other game fandom make a joke when their game slowly dying that means there will be EoS soon, i really loved that time😂
"Joke"
Lmao
What is Eos
Faster than Fob Yaps upload lol
Guess the nerds we're not willing to pull r/publicuse blonde chick this time around
Wuwa to ZZZ: "Welcome becoming EOS"
ahhh... i remember when ZZZ players said Wuwa is going to EOS, now look at them 🤡
The thing is Zzz won't go eos since it's from hoyo kekw
@ryan11obolsquad of course its not, the point is revenue with the same situation
kurobots doomposting zzz from the start stfu, wuwa players is the most toxic degenerates
ZZZ is saving... because have HSR & GI for on TOP revenue
kurobots doomposting zzz from the start of release, just shut up
Jane doe + caesar is 30m+
burnice alone is 15m
kinda understandable
Fob, you gacha "investment" is down 22% om
15:08 HOLY BASED
CN wuwa players saves for Camellya
Y'all said the same thing about Shorekeeper and look at how that goes.
@eclipsewaves and ,it's not your problem
@@Zeref-n7u it's not my problem yes but if anything the current situation of wuwa's revenue should teach y'all how to shut ur mouth up and not to jinx it by saying how this game can end genshin's career.. it's so funny seeing y'all moving the goalpost from genshin to zzz so fast bc y'all are getting humbled real bad and y'all's petty ass started targeting zzz bc that's a new game too.. kuro fans forever in the khia asylum. bye.
@eclipsewaves OK dude
Revenue will never rise because wuwa fumbled mobile version. This tower only counts mobile.
16:55 AYO WTF
CN EOS it's so over.
the only "big" game that i tried and really good on mobile only lads and hsr (this one is perfect for mobile) other than that its ASS, gi and wuwa perfect on pc and last zzz really really good on console/ pc
Tbh.... Hsr also not good on phone.... Every cutscene lag and in storage even bigger then genshin on other hand genshin one even 1 cutscene lag and storage I already told you....
Thay said in 2.7 livestream they will lower the storage let's see how it goes
HotDogArona
BASED AF ZZZ TAKE. RESPECT
Highly chances that WuWa is gonna going bankrupt and EoS before their next region even comes out.
i cannot wait for my dead game to finally be dead after several months of calling it by idiots HAHA
@@astr1d.x-y-zand you guys also keep saying zzz is a dead game….
Do you really think that or is it a joke?
Genuine question
War
Sensor tower is a as reliable as our local drunk
This is why Flat Earther exists 😂Sensor Tower is used by big corporations globally, it's not something a nobody like you could comprehend anyways 🤣
@nekochen Big companies? Name one
@@ntz752 I'll name you several lol.
- For starter, how about Warner Brothers?
- How about Allstate Insurance?
- ByteDance? Parent Company of TikTok?
- Forget Activision Blizzard, nobody likes them anymore but they still pay for its service.
Maybe those 4 I listed was too big for you to recognize, how about some "smaller companies"...
- Dyson?
- Target?
- Johnson & Johnson?
- L'OREAL?
Still doesn't ring a bell? Let's go back up to the bigger ones then..
- Amazon?
- Disney?
Still not big enough? How about the big financial sectors...
- Goldman Sachs
- Morgan Stanley
The list can go on for a hundred more lol.
@nekochen The sensory tower literally says on their website it's made up of numbers based on what they see 😂so no they are not reliable as a source
@Pikemans-t1x My replies are getting deleted lol
Just like wuwa zzz is bad on mobile 😂
I play ZZZ just good enough on mobile compared to Wuthering Waves, the mobile there is actually hella ass compared to ZZZ mobile.
@@protelium-x3429 no wonder WW has 4.7 and ZZZ has 3 point something
@@Nerot_kama huh, I didn't notice that
NOWAYING
CN o7
Wuwa can't even outdo ZZZ at their worst income period...😅
@Pikemans-t1x cons were designed to mitigate the idea of getting more than one copies of a character, Genshin was smart to design around this inherent gacha problem by adding value to having duplicates. Nikke for example, when you get a dupe of an SSR it only gives a 2% stat boost each until 12 times, whales still max core Nikkes even tho the dupes don't have a value.
if u look at banner revenue not monthly shorekeeper earn more than burnice, shorekeeper got to rank 21 and burnice only got to rank 24 and dropped faster than zhezhi, if the first 2 days of shorekeeper banner were in October wuwa would be above zzz
Im first, does it mean im gay?
zzz dead game, sleeping forever, uninstall already! anyway, when miyabi drip
Miyabi is already dripped no? I thought she was right after harumasa next patch
Edit - nvm those were leaks.
HAHAHA KUROTRASH WAJAJA Until now their so called "Genshin killer" couldn't even top a single revenue at all 😭😭😭💢💢💢‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️
@Pikemans-t1x I should tell you he's a pdf that specifically went to several blue archive post with that Uoooogghhh
Its because ppl are tired with hoyo games, genshin players are just go with the flow now. they play trends then out and back to genshin. its like a cage :v
Or maybe Genshin is just a cozy exploration/rpg with high production value and engaging combat for f2p, casuals, and light spenders...that..wait for it..people enjoy 😉
Im one of those tired player 🥲 now im just stick with two gacha game only instead of 4
is that why genshin and hsr are at the top lmao
No wonder stuttering wave is dying lmao 😭😭 genshin are still top since 4 years ago while kuroshit are like a dead bird
yeah hoyo is same....toxic fandom weird shippers....waiting for Azur or NTE