Please!!! MY GOD!!!! I swear gentleman! I am just a poor middleaged semi-intelligent beer-drining guy! and I just happened by chance to come upon this video and MY GOD!!!! I've never heard of anything so cool in all my life!!!!!
Comment-3: Example (8:04). Algebraic calculation: TERMS: x - men, y - mortal, z - Socrates. 1. All men are mortal (xy) 2. Socrates are men (zx) - - - Calculation: ((xy)*(zx))/X = (xyz)/X = yz = zy 3. Socrates are mortal (zy) You are right! Score T:F = 1:2
If I'm understanding it olcirrectoy, no, it's not valid. See his following explanation where he uses the same form of argument to talk about politicians and clowns.
Comment-6: Example (19:59). Algebraic calculation: TERMS: x - animals, y - mammals, z - tigers. 1. All mammals are animals (yx) 2. All tigers are mammals (zy) - - - Calculation: ((yx)*(zy))/Y = (xyz)/Y = xz = zx - - - Yours: 3. Some tigers are animals - ERROR CONCLUSION [as zx+zx’ - why??] RIGHT: 3. THERE IS tigers SO AZ animals [meaning «mammals»] (zx) You are wrong! Score T:F = 1:5
Comment-4: Example (10:51). Algebraic calculation: TERMS: x - Mid, y - Maj, z - Min 1. No Mid are Maj (x’y) 2. Some Min are Mid (zx+zx’) - - - Calculation: ((x’y)*(zx+zx’))/X = (x’yz)/)/X = yz = zy 3. Yours: Some Min are not Maj - ERROR CONCLUSION 3. RIGHT: THERE IS Min SO AZ not Maj (zy) [Formula «Some Min are not Maj» (instead of (zy)) is (zy+zy’)] You are also not right! You are wrong! Score T:F = 1:3
SO FAR ABSOLUTLY ANY SYLLOGISM CAN CALCULATE AS ALGEBRAIC FORM… I saw some mistakes into this video-clip… Comment-1: Example (5:17). Algebraic calculation: TERMS: x - fireman, y - brave , z - stone. 1. All fireman are brave (things) (xy) 2. No brave things is a (thing made of) stone (y’z) - - - Calculation: ((xy)*(y’z))/Y = (xy*y’z)/Y = 0/Y = 0 3. YOUR ERROR: No (thing made of) stone is a fireman 3. VALID,RIGHT: Term «stone» NOT CONNECTED WITH term «fireman» (0) [because volumes of these terms are not crossing] You are wrong! Score «True:False (T:F)» 0:1
Comment-2: Example (6:20). Algebraic calculation: TERMS: x - penguins, y - Olympic athletes, z - cold-blooded. 1. No penguins are Olympic athletes (x’y) 2. No Olympic athletes are cold-blooded (y’z) - - - Calculation: ((x’y)*(y’z))/Y = (x’y*y’z)/Y = 0/Y = 0 3. YOUR ERROR: No penguins are cold-blooded 3. VALID,RIGHT: Term «penguins» NOT CONNECTED WITH term «cold-blooded» (0) [Volumes of these terms are not crossing] You are wrong! Score T:F = 0:2
Comment-5: Example (14:45). Algebraic calculation: TERMS: x - penguins, y - Olympic athletes, z - cold-blooded. 1. No Olympic athletes are cold-blooded (y’z) 2. Some penguins are Olympic athletes (xy’+xy) - - - Calculation: ((y’z)*(xy+xy’))/Y = (xy’z)/Y = xz = zx 3. YOUR ERROR: Some penguins are not cold-blooded [zx+zx’ - why???] 3. RIGHT: THERE IS penguins SO AZ cold-blooded (xz) [meaning «Olympic athletes». Because volumes of syllogism terms place only into 3 terms!] You are wrong! Score T:F = 1:4
Comment-7: Example (20:50). Algebraic calculation: TERMS: x - animals, y - mammals, z - tigers. 1. All mammals are animals (yx) 2. All tigers are animals (zx) - - - Calculation: ((yx)*(zx))/X = (xyz)/X = yz = zy - - - Yours: 3. Some tigers are mammals - ERROR CONCLUSION [as zy+zy’ - why?] RIGHT: 3. THERE IS tigers SO AZ mammals [meaning that «animals»] (zy) You are wrong! COMMON SCORE T:F = 1:6 IN ALL: ONE SYLLOGISMS WAS RIGHT and SIX SYLLOGISMS - IS LIE! Sorry, but this is only typical logic algebra :-)
I have a final exam in Logic and Critical thinking this morning. This is a godsend, thank you.
Omg!!!!!! I am here 3 hours before my presentation and I am just figuring this shit out. Man you are awesome.
Thank you for the great videos! Could you please put the entire course into a single play-list?
I wish i had found your videos before i bothered reading the 100 page chapter of my textbook.. Thanks a lot, really great course!
Done watching, Ma'am Joy Cerujales, thank you for this video, PhilHelper!👍
The best video in this series up until now for me. Some very clear explanations here!
See Pt. 6a. That's my personal favorite!
Done watching, Ma'am Joy Cerujales, Thank you for this video PhilHelper!
done watching, Ma'am Joy Cerujales, thank you for this video, PhilHelper!
Done watching, Maam Joy Cerjulas. Thank you for this video, PhilHelper!.
Done watching Ma'am Joy Cerujales , Thanks for this video, Philhelper.
Please!!! MY GOD!!!! I swear gentleman! I am just a poor middleaged semi-intelligent beer-drining guy! and I just happened by chance to come upon this video and MY GOD!!!! I've never heard of anything so cool in all my life!!!!!
Done watching, Mam Joy Cerujales, thank you for this video, PhilHelper!🙂
done watching, Mam Joy Cerujales, thank you for this video, PhilHelper!
Done watching, Mam Joy Cerujales, thank you for this video, PhilHelper! :)
Done watching @Ma'am Joy Cerujales and thanks for this video, Philhelper...
Done watching, Mam Joy Cerujales, thanks for this video, PhilHelper!
"done watching, Mam Joy Cerujales, thank you for this video, PhilHelper!"
Done watching, Ma'am Joy Cerujales, Thankyou for this video, Philhelper
Done watching ma'am Joy Cerujales, thank you for this video, PhiHelper.
done watching, Mam Joy Cerujales, thank you for this video, PhilHelper!"
Comment-3: Example (8:04). Algebraic calculation:
TERMS: x - men, y - mortal, z - Socrates.
1. All men are mortal (xy)
2. Socrates are men (zx)
- - - Calculation: ((xy)*(zx))/X = (xyz)/X = yz = zy
3. Socrates are mortal (zy)
You are right! Score T:F = 1:2
Thank you so much. That was very easy to understand.
Thanks for the comment Mphumzi. I'll try to post more.
thank you, this was my "penny dropped" moment.
Thank you Maam Joy Cerujales for this video, PhilHelper!
Thank you soooooo much!!!!
Done watching, ma'am Joy Cerujales. Thanks for this video PhilHelper!
Done watching Ma'am Joy Cerujales, thankyou for this video, Philhelper!
Done watching ma'am Joy Cerujales, Thank you for this video PhilHelper!
Done watching Ma'am Joy Cerujales! Thanks for this Video! PhilHelper!
This is so cool
Thanks!
I think there's a mistake at 21:00. Shouldn't there be only one x in section 5, making the conclusion valid?
If I'm understanding it olcirrectoy, no, it's not valid. See his following explanation where he uses the same form of argument to talk about politicians and clowns.
Done watching, Mam Joy P. Cerujales, Thank you for this video PhilHelper!.
Done watching, Maam joy Cerjuales, Thankyou for this video. Philhelper !
Done watching Maam Joy Cerujales thankyou for this video., Philhelper!
Comment-6: Example (19:59). Algebraic calculation:
TERMS: x - animals, y - mammals, z - tigers.
1. All mammals are animals (yx)
2. All tigers are mammals (zy)
- - - Calculation: ((yx)*(zy))/Y = (xyz)/Y = xz = zx - - -
Yours: 3. Some tigers are animals - ERROR CONCLUSION [as zx+zx’ - why??]
RIGHT: 3. THERE IS tigers SO AZ animals [meaning «mammals»] (zx)
You are wrong! Score T:F = 1:5
Done watching Ma'am Joy Cerujales thank you for this video Philhelper
Comment-4: Example (10:51). Algebraic calculation:
TERMS: x - Mid, y - Maj, z - Min
1. No Mid are Maj (x’y)
2. Some Min are Mid (zx+zx’)
- - - Calculation: ((x’y)*(zx+zx’))/X = (x’yz)/)/X = yz = zy
3. Yours: Some Min are not Maj - ERROR CONCLUSION
3. RIGHT: THERE IS Min SO AZ not Maj (zy)
[Formula «Some Min are not Maj» (instead of (zy)) is (zy+zy’)]
You are also not right! You are wrong! Score T:F = 1:3
SO FAR ABSOLUTLY ANY SYLLOGISM CAN CALCULATE AS ALGEBRAIC FORM… I saw some mistakes into this video-clip…
Comment-1: Example (5:17). Algebraic calculation:
TERMS: x - fireman, y - brave , z - stone.
1. All fireman are brave (things) (xy)
2. No brave things is a (thing made of) stone (y’z)
- - - Calculation: ((xy)*(y’z))/Y = (xy*y’z)/Y = 0/Y = 0
3. YOUR ERROR: No (thing made of) stone is a fireman
3. VALID,RIGHT: Term «stone» NOT CONNECTED WITH term «fireman» (0)
[because volumes of these terms are not crossing]
You are wrong! Score «True:False (T:F)» 0:1
Comment-2: Example (6:20). Algebraic calculation:
TERMS: x - penguins, y - Olympic athletes, z - cold-blooded.
1. No penguins are Olympic athletes (x’y)
2. No Olympic athletes are cold-blooded (y’z)
- - - Calculation: ((x’y)*(y’z))/Y = (x’y*y’z)/Y = 0/Y = 0
3. YOUR ERROR: No penguins are cold-blooded
3. VALID,RIGHT: Term «penguins» NOT CONNECTED WITH term «cold-blooded» (0) [Volumes of these terms are not crossing]
You are wrong! Score T:F = 0:2
Comment-5: Example (14:45). Algebraic calculation:
TERMS: x - penguins, y - Olympic athletes, z - cold-blooded.
1. No Olympic athletes are cold-blooded (y’z)
2. Some penguins are Olympic athletes (xy’+xy)
- - - Calculation: ((y’z)*(xy+xy’))/Y = (xy’z)/Y = xz = zx
3. YOUR ERROR: Some penguins are not cold-blooded [zx+zx’ - why???]
3. RIGHT: THERE IS penguins SO AZ cold-blooded (xz) [meaning «Olympic athletes». Because volumes of syllogism terms place only into 3 terms!]
You are wrong! Score T:F = 1:4
done watching, Mam Joy Cerujales thank you for this video, PhilHelper
Comment-7: Example (20:50). Algebraic calculation:
TERMS: x - animals, y - mammals, z - tigers.
1. All mammals are animals (yx)
2. All tigers are animals (zx)
- - - Calculation: ((yx)*(zx))/X = (xyz)/X = yz = zy - - -
Yours: 3. Some tigers are mammals - ERROR CONCLUSION [as zy+zy’ - why?]
RIGHT: 3. THERE IS tigers SO AZ mammals [meaning that «animals»] (zy)
You are wrong! COMMON SCORE T:F = 1:6
IN ALL: ONE SYLLOGISMS WAS RIGHT and SIX SYLLOGISMS - IS LIE!
Sorry, but this is only typical logic algebra :-)
Done watching. Ma'am Joy Cerujales. Thank you for this video PhilHelper!
Done watching, Ma'am Joy Cerujales, Thank you for this video PhilHelper!
done watching, Ma'am Joy Cerujales
thank you for this video, PhilHelper!
done watching, Mam Joy Cerujales, thank you for this video, PhilHelper!"
done watching, Mam Joy Cerujales, thank you for this video, PhilHelper!
Done watching, Maam joy Cerjuales, Thankyou for this video. Philhelper !
Done watching, Ma'am Joy Cerujales, thank you for this video, PhilHelper!
Done watching, Ma'am Joy Cerujales, thank you for this video, PhilHelper!
Done watching, ma'am Joy Cerujales, thank you for this video. Philhelper!
Done watching, Mam Joy Cerujales, thank you for this video, PhilHelper!
Done watching, Mam Joy Cerujales, thank you for this video, PhilHelper!
Done watching, Mam Joy Cerujales, thank you for this video, PhilHelper!
Done watching, Mam Joy Cerujales, thank you for this video, PhilHelper!
Done watching, Mam Joy Cerujales, thank you for this video, PhilHelper!"
Done watching, Maam joy Cerjuales, Thankyou for this video. Philhelper !
Done watching, Mam Joy Cerujales, thank you for this video, PhilHelper!"