Harry Potter Theory: Why Didn’t Voldemort Return As A Ghost?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 ก.ย. 2019
- Go to www.CandidCo.com/SCB and use code SCB to get $75 off!
Today Ben dives into the Wizarding World of Harry Potter to try and figure out why Voldemort didn’t elect to come back as a ghost and instead accepted death
#SuperCarlinBrothers #HarryPotter
Horcrux and Book Text Animation created by: Scott Niswander
Carlin Brothers Coffee ►► www.CarlinBrothersCoffee.com
Super Carlin Brothers Merch ►► www.SuperCarlinBrothers.Store
J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
P A T R E O N ➜ / supercarlinbrothers
J's V L O G➜ / jonathancarlin
T W I T T E R➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
I N S T A G R A M➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
F A C E B O O K➜ / supercarlinbrothers
G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Intro Music Created by RKVC
/ @rkvc
Intro Animation Created by J. Cutt Productions
/ @j.cuttproductions
Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..) - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
![Why Snape Was Forced To Teach Potions [Harry Potter Theory]](/img/n.gif)
Do you think its weird Voldemort didn’t come back as a ghost?
Hi!
Yea
I don’t think enough of his soul was left to become a ghost.
He probably had a plan to, meaning it will never actually happen
Yes, do you think Voldemort didn’t come back as a ghost because of how ripped up his soul was? He wasn’t able to completely cross the threshold of death because his soul was so ripped up.
Voldomort:"there's nothing worse than death..."
Hermione: "... Or worse, expelled"
That was just plain stoopid
you ma’am win the internet
No, not having enough socks is worse than death or being expelled
Mrs Weasley: You could have died, you could have been *SEEN* !!!!!
Hermione has spoken
Voldemort coming back at a ghost would have made a lot better of a storyline than him and bellatrix having a daughter
Definitely
It’s already a good story line if he’s annoying harry
Ikr
Definitely! Waiting for the fan fiction of this now!
True, I like this idea.
I always assumed he didn’t become a ghost bc in snape’s words a ghost is “the imprint of a departed soul” but Voldemort’s soul was completely destroyed so he couldn’t manifest as a ghost because there was no soul left if that makes sense
It was not destroyed. It became the maimed flapping baby Harry sees in Limbo.
Harry himself tells Voldy that he saw what he would become...
@@andreab380 well. Maybe. Maybe. But per definition of the story, it's all a bit unclear. Maybe that babylike thing is the mix of all of his soul parts so far, but maybe it's only the one part that just died with Harry.
@@gur262 Well, I as well thought that it was a fragment of soul, at first. But why would Harry say he saw what Voldy would become without repenting and mending his soul, unless what he saw was his very soul, maimed and helpless?
@@andreab380 Because it was the part of Voldemort's soul still left in Harry.
Voldemort's soul was destroyed; he ripped it apart when he made the horcruxes, which were destroyed. There was nothing left of him when he finally died.
If it really is an imprint of a soul and not an actual soul itself then that would mean our usual thoughts about ghosts are wrong here. They likely don't completely know and all have different views on it.
JK Rowling did actually say that Voldemort's Boggart would take the form of his own corpse
If i could, i would speak my mind to Voldemort or Grindelwald or Both...
I would make fun of him, being just a confused kid. Not understanding anything, including Love and even Magic:
I understand where his idea about Wizards ruling Muggles comes from, honestly, but if you think about it for more than 1 second, you realize it's not like that:
EVIDEND by the fact alone, yes, EVIDEND alone by the fact that Muggles can have Wizard Babys and Wizards can have Muggle Babys.
EVEN if your 'Blood Purity' is extremly high - you CAN STILL have a Child that just has no Magic. Simple as that.
And then i would end with "And don't even get me started on your Subordinates. Your Death Eaters ALL seem like they have mental problems or just eaten something wrong. I mean, what's the training to become a Death Eater? Bumping your head into a tree 7 times? Seven cause it's a magical number?!"
-End-
Why am I not surprised.🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@slevinchannel7589 Well, that’s plain and clear to the sight and understanding.
@@nomnomfpv3136 Well, yes and no.
What i meant was more... he's not really 'evil', even though hes presented as that. I think he wants to be evil, so he is, but thats not true evil... in a sense?
Ah, i dont know.
I just wanted to speak my thoughts on it, so i made that other comment. Ignore it if you like.
His ridiculous would turn his body into Harry’s.
Next question: "Can a ghost possess body of a dementor victim?"
Thats a really good question!
get it to the top boys
^^
If this isn't the next video I'll be disappointed!
Can't ever really be disappointed about a new SCB video especially if its HP!
I was wondering that too
I just always assumed that Voldie's soul was mostly destroyed.
nonam namrson Ripped into 7 pieces 7777
@@kcocozza 8, technically. 7 Horcruxes + Voldyshorts prime.
I believe this as well, that the destruction of horcrouxes also destroys the soul fragment. When Volprime died his shredded soul left behind is stuck at the crossroads not able to pass on completely but neither is it able to return to material world as a ghost.
That's what was said in the movie
Me too
“A severely agitated mist.” - This is now how I’m going to refer to Voldemort.
Misst off
it's really quite accurate
Or snake-face, well more like sake, rat, Harry, Evilness and only barely human-face.🐍
If i could, i would speak my mind to Voldemort or Grindelwald or Both...
I would make fun of him, being just a confused kid. Not understanding anything, including Love and even Magic:
I understand where his idea about Wizards ruling Muggles comes from, honestly, but if you think about it for more than 1 second, you realize it's not like that:
EVIDEND by the fact alone, yes, EVIDEND alone by the fact that Muggles can have Wizard Babys and Wizards can have Muggle Babys.
EVEN if your 'Blood Purity' is extremly high - you CAN STILL have a Child that just has no Magic. Simple as that.
And then i would end with "And don't even get me started on your Subordinates. Your Death Eaters ALL seem like they have mental problems or just eaten something wrong. I mean, what's the training to become a Death Eater? Bumping your head into a tree 7 times? Seven cause it's a magical number?!"
-End-
@@slevinchannel7589 Hahahahahahaha
Now I cannot unthink the idea of a Voldemort ghost haunting Harry 👻😂
Rad Gamer Rach 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
“Harry Harry Harry Harry Harry Harry Harry Harry “. “WHAAAAAAAAAAT!!!”
“You smell like onions.”
Or those raisins in those cookies?? NO HARRY NO! AH PAIN BEYOND PAIN
I feel like the plot to this would just be Voldemort trying to make sure that he was killed by the most powerful wizard ever. Basically cheering harry on eventually
His impression was PERFECTION!!! watch a doing Harry? Huh...huh...huh. whatcha doing?
Ginny: Harry, will Voldemort be joining us for dinner again?
Harry: Yes, he wants Albus to tell him about his first year as a Slytherin.
Lol!
Omg this should have happened.
Can we get this as a fanfic: Harry Potter and a Family Dinner with my Eternal Enemy
Voldemort and Albus having a Negan-Judith relationship lol
"Tom, please behave properly or I'll tell Peeves you tried to create another horcrux using his hat".
Harry: oh what now Tom?! can’t you see I’m busy?!
Voldemort: I’ve told you a thousand times, it’s LORD VOLDEMORT!!! I will not be addressed by my muggle fathers name!
Harry: sure Tom, whatever you say
Lol!
Tom proceeds to clog the toilet.
Ok, this is the funniest comment of all time
@Dillon Brunschon i would LOVE that!
Canchaserjezmyne Lolololololololo
At the end of his heroic journey, years of trying to end a nigh immortal evil, Harry collapses onto bed for some restful oblivion.
Then Voldie's ghost head pops out of the headboard like, "nice try, but I think i'll just float around you for eternity."
Harry: "NOOOOOOOOOO"
Years later:
Voldemort: *pops up* Hey Harry! I'm here to torment you!
Harry, being use to it by now (he is also cooking): *does not look up from the pan* What is it today, Tom?
Voldemort: First of all, it is Voldemort! And second of all, aren't you scared of me?
Harry: *still not looking up from the pan* Not really. I've gotten use to it by now.
Voldemort: You're no fun. *vanishes*
If i could, i would speak my mind to Voldemort or Grindelwald or Both...
I would make fun of him, being just a confused kid. Not understanding anything, including Love and even Magic:
I understand where his idea about Wizards ruling Muggles comes from, honestly, but if you think about it for more than 1 second, you realize it's not like that:
EVIDEND by the fact alone, yes, EVIDEND alone by the fact that Muggles can have Wizard Babys and Wizards can have Muggle Babys.
EVEN if your 'Blood Purity' is extremly high - you CAN STILL have a Child that just has no Magic. Simple as that.
And then i would end with "And don't even get me started on your Subordinates. Your Death Eaters ALL seem like they have mental problems or just eaten something wrong. I mean, what's the training to become a Death Eater? Bumping your head into a tree 7 times? Seven cause it's a magical number?!"
-End-
Vodamort:YESSSSSSSSS
harry:ಠ_ಠ
@@lavenderlspjk9116 I can even see Harry saying ahhhh in a sarcastic way a few times just to annoy Tom.
“Are those raisins in those cookies?! NO...”
*Ghost Voldemort - 2019*
Even VOLDEMORT is not evil enough to put freaking raisins in cookies!
If Hermione was the dark lord and faced Dumbledore at the ministry:
"There is nothing worse than being expelled"
If it was Molly Weasley,
"There's nothing worse than being seen Dumbledore"
Dumbledore precedes to expel her
Fury gaming im pretty sure she became the dark lord was because she got expelled
Maybe she made the "cant be expelled" horcrux that required sacrificing your ability to see the future?
@@williamozier918 HA
"A ghost is the imprint of a departed soul and they are, as Potter so wisely tells us, transparent." A maimed soul couldn't leave a real imprint.
I always liked those lines
So the soul itself does not remain in the physical realm just the imprint. Good research
“Well, what Harry said is the most useful if we’re trying to tell them apart! When we come face to face with them in a dark alley, we’re going to be having a shufti to see if it’s solid, aren’t we? We’re not gonna be asking ‘Excuse me, are you the imprint of a departed soul?’”
Robert Billing
"The imprint of a departed soul".
I don't get that. Isn't the entire point of a ghost that your soul doesn't ascend to the afterlife? Or are they saying as a spirit you're a remnant of what was a mortal being? I don't understand how you can be a imprint of yourself. But maybe that has something to do with how I interpret a ghost in of itself as a soul.
Unfamiliar Intimacy0070 I think the imprint thing is related to what Pottermore says about being stuck with the state of consciousness you have when you die. If Moaning Myrtle never died, her soul would have “evolved” from this consciousness and by the time Harry is in Hogwarts she would have become a nice old lady who doesn’t even remember being teased in school on this specific day. But because she died, 50 years later she is still upset over it. I think of it kind of like taking a picture of the departing soul at the moment of departure, this “soul picture” (much like some actual pictures in the world of HP) can interact with their surroundings as they would have at the moment of their death but can’t go through deeper character development like forgiveness or maturity.
I think he’d be too embarrassed to come back after he was utterly defeated
Same!!
Lol
He did it once before.
Well, I think being almost decimated by an infant while at the height of your power is even more embarrassing.
Nice 69 likes
*Ghost comes out of Voldemort’s body*
Harry: “Fuuuu-“
*Nineteen years later*
“What if I’m put in Slytherin?”
Ghost Voldy: “I should certainly hope so!”
James: OH NOOOO ... hes going to brag about it over and over again. Please, Al, do ALL OF US a big favour and end up domewhere else.
Ngl, I'd read that fan fiction.
Speaking of fanfiction- Cursed Child does confirm that Albus Potter gets sorted into Slytheryn. I mean, the plot is complete mess, but JK did say it was cannon.
"Harry puts raisins in cookies"
ghost Voldemort gasp: " Harry, you monster".
"Even thought you killed me, I would have never thought you would be so cruel!"
He has a point tho, raisins shouldn't be allowed in cookies!
@@DarkMimii depends on how it's done
Harry: "Oh, now you show that you possess a concept of the word "Monster"?
Harry:look who's taking
I mean I'm voldermorts side with this one raisins in cookies is just wrong
Everything you need to know about Voldemort:
-he has no nose
-don't let him plan your weddings
-he can uselessly fly
-he hates raisin in cookies
-he would not be able to come back as a ghost
-if he was, he would end up being a really REALLY annoying house guest
Definitely true!
Imagine Voldemort following Harry around yelling obscenities and making his life miserable lol
"HOWD YA GET THAT SCAR POTTER? AN EXTREMELY POWERFUL WIZARD WHOS ABILITY FAR OUTSTRIPS YOUR OWN MUST HAVE GAVE IT TO YA! HA!"
"AW DOES THE POTTER BRAT MISS HIS MOMMY!'
It is not actually useless his flying.
In deathly hallows when voldemort is flying to malfoy manor harry thinks something like this "it's only a matter of time until voldemort is in apperating distance" meaning voldemort only uses flying to get in distance of apperating. He might do it at very short distance cause maybe it's fun or something. Or he's just showing off his power on those occasions where he flies short distantanses
The idea of Anti-Horcruxes is compelling - I always just thought they were outright destroyed until there was the last piece in the body.
Also, I remember Dumbledore implying that there was some form of punishment for the creation of Horcruxes. In Limbo, he explains to Harry that the Small Voldermort (Small-devort) was Normal Voldermorts soul sent there to die - or at least a part of it.
This always made me think that there some sort of Higher Power in the HP universe. And that It judged Voldermort guilty for the Crime of Creating Horcruxes since their very nature is against the laws nature. And I thought that rotting in Limbo for eternity was Voldermorts punishment. No life as a ghost; no peace in death.
The punishment is self-inflicted. Voldemort is punished due to circumstance, not a higher power.
The few powers the ghosts have seemed to be elemental... Making AIR cold, making FIRE blue, making WATER move. Just an interesting observation
Random thought: Dementor's kiss sucks souls right? So can Dementors "eat" ghosts?
I would guess that they need something to latch onto (the body), therefore nothing for them to keep the ghost (soul) from escaping.
Ghosts aren't souls, they are just an imprint of a soul
@Qoureno’s Miscreations well that's what nearly headless Nick said when Harry asked him...
Mrs. Riddle Sir Nickless, if you mind.
Qoureno’s Miscreations we don’t really have much choice but to believe that until J.K.Rowling says otherwise.
Super Carlin Brothers- asks all of the questions I never knew I needed answers to
Alexis Bowen
But now need the answers to.
Honestly i google this yesterday after rereading OOTP and coming across that chapter with nick.
Truth
IKR
Shut up.
This is where JK Rowling releases a series of books based on Voldemort reclaiming the fragments of his soul scattered across limbo.
Tom Riddle and The Tattered Diary
Tom Riddle and The Gaunt Heirloom
Tom Riddle and The Locket of Slytherin
Tom Riddle and The Cup of Hufflepuff
Tom Riddle and The Lost Diadem
Tom Riddle and The Parseltongue Problem
Tom Riddle and The Boy Who Lived
yes and at the end of the last book like in the harry potter books the what 19 years later thing do that but he came back as a ghost and is just annoying harry since he cant do much else, because honestly would he be fine with someone else ruling using his ideas?
That would be a good series
What about Quirrle (sry I can’t spell his name)
Tom Riddle and the Tattered Diary -
Chapter 1 and 2: Voldemort is forced to NOT become a ghost in the afterlife, but since Tom is still solid, he escapes by finding the dead Bellatrix Lestrange and she leads her to the exit for mortals.
Chapters 3, 4, 5, 6: Voldemort searches through the forbidden forest as a ghost and meets centaurs, blast ended skrewts and Grawp, while being hunted by the ghost and in chapter 6 he faces against him, and learns that the only way to kill a ghost is by getting a human to make them dissapear, which Voldemort learns when he is almost shot by a Evanesco spell while a student tries to get rid of him on the astronomy tower, but the shot misses and kills the other ghost
Chapter 7 is the student trying to warn the Ministry, but failing because he's talking to Umbridge. Of course you'd fail.
Chapter 8 is Voldemort meeting with Walden Macnair, and Macnair agrees to find a way to bring him back.
Chapter 9 is Voldemort and Macnair in the Hogwarts Library at night, trying to find a way to bring Voldemort back to life, and they learn the only way to bring somebody back to life isn't possible unless they made a Horcrux, and you have to repair the horcruxes with the opposite of basilisk venom, phoenix tears.
Chapter 10 and 11 are Voldemort and Macnair sneaking through Hogwarts trying to kidnap Fawkes. When they find him with McGonagall, they steal him and escape.
Chapter 12, 13, and 14 are Voldemort and Macnair getting into the Potions area at Hogwarts. They find a bottle and pour the tears in, but Slughorn steals it when he sees them and duels Macnair, but loses and is Stupefied out the Hogwarts window, but not before he alerts McGonagall.
Chapter 15 is Macnair and Voldy escaping Hogwarts. The bottle is dropped and almost smashes, and Fawkes is taken back, which means Voldemort and Macnair only have so much phoenix tears to work with.
Chapter 16, and 17: Macnair and Tom tell Narcissa, Lucius, Draco, Alecto, Amycus, Dolohov, and Rookwood that they can revive Voldemort, and they set off to go back to get the Diary. Chapter 17 - 26: The journey to Hogwarts. Many things happen, Draco and Alecto almost get killed by Devil's Snare, A forest fire, A hippogriff attack, and almost getting killed by Ministry Aurors trying to hunt them down after McGonagall confirms that Voldemort is back as a ghost.
Chapter 27, 28, 29 and 30: The Death eaters are put an Azkaban (Dolohov is killed for trying to escape but he'll come back in Cup of Hufflepuff), but Lucius and Draco escape and help Voldemort get the Diary and escape.
Chapter 31: Draco and Lucius fight the Aurors, while Voldy sneaks away and finds Fawkes. He leads Fawkes away into the Chamber of Secrets, and locks him in so that they can come back to get tears since the bottle of tears was destroyed in the forest fire in chapter 24.
Chapter 32 and 33: The calm before the storm, Voldy and the Death Eaters (excluding Draco and Lucius, they are hiding in the Chamber with Fawkes) meet up in Azkaban and make a plan. In the Gaunt Heirloom, they hunt down McGonagall to get the Gaunt Ring, which she has kept safe for years...
Good additions everyone!
I kind of like the idea that Bellatrix Lestrange finds Voldemort's fragmented soul but she cannot do anything just yet. She waits with him until the day Narcissa dies (she gets found as a traitor to the dark lord, go figure).
Neither Voldemort nor Bellatrix can pass over but Narcissa is bonded with Bellatrix and all three of them are bonded by a particular dark mark. Bellatrix grabs Narcissa whilst holding Voldemorts fragmented soul.
Bellatrix tries to apparate out and all three are plunged into darkness. Three lost souls wandering in the void.
Until suddenly a flashing of light, dull fogged vision getting clearer. Out of a clearing in a forest, a young Tom Riddle appears, with curly messy black hair and a single golden streak, piercing green eyes.
With no distinction on who or what was apparating, the three souls combined. Their combined memories almost missing, they are just one person, but a whole lot more than that. They are Tom Riddle.
Tom doesn't know who he is and he's about to get into a crazy adventure at Hogwarts. Over time he will get flashing headaches that show him things, like a diary.
He will also have to deal with intense emotions, inherited from his other "soul mates".
One good thing though, he's going to meet the famous Harry Potter, auror turned defence against the dark arts teacher and he seems to get on with him!
I love the idea that Tom doesn't know who he truly is and he's building this trust relationship with Harry as if he is a father figure.
The way I see it, he reclaims the older part of his souls, learning more about his old self, or this Voldemort as he goes. By the end, Bellatrix and Narcissa's souls have completely left him and it's down to the new Tom Riddle to reclaim his life as Lord Voldemort or die sadly knowing he made the right choice staying as Tom Riddle.
In his head, you see this struggle as he battles the old Voldemort inside of him. Pushing him to Kill Harry and reclaim his throne. But ultimately, he makes the sacrifice play that Voldemort never could. He saves Harry.
If you you want to get fancy you could say that it's the love that Harry shows for him, treating him as a son that saves his soul. Ultimately, Harry Potter saves Voldemort from himself.
Voldemort : "Harry! Is that.... Pineapple on your pizza?"
Ok, now that one I can actually agree with Voldemort on...
@@violet_royale438Voldemort would want pizza with unicorn blood instead
“Looks good, smells bad.” ‘Course I wouldn’t know, I’m a ghost. Also I don’t have a nose.” 😂😂😂😂
EDIT: By the way, we need this on merch
Arjun Anand
Best quote in the video.
KitsWorld ikr
Arjun Anand
And now I want it on a t shirt with Voldemort’s face (maybe even as a ghost) below.
KitsWorld definitely
Arjun Anand
We need to request this as a merch item. Or at least this idea needs to find its way to them.
7:07 "His Riddikulus would be the gravestone saying ha just kidding."
Voldemort: *"Ngyea-hee-hee!"*
Too funny :D
I literally just thought that his soul was so damsged it wasn't possible
Harry: ok so I think I’m gonna make a grilled cheese you want one?
Ghost Voldemort: no please I’m good
Harry: can you at least heat mine up
Ghost Voldy: *AVADAKADAVRA*
Albus: voldy you burnt my grilled cheese da heck is this
*I WANNA BANANA
Can I have ghost grindelwald so I can see mini diabolica flames under a pan cooking my food.
Surely it’s a sad kindness that ghost “will literally never get over it”. The alternative is that they will get over it and spend all of eternity regretting their decision to become one. That would probably be torture and is super depressing.
That's an.. interesting way to put it, but makes sense
@@gidelix Definitely an interesting way to put it but it's true if they got over thier death then they'd be going why am I here!
Well, in the 1995 film adaptation of "Casper: The Friendly Ghost," the idea is that, once you get over your unfinished business, then you cross over to the proper afterlife. Your "ghost" (the imprint that exists in the mortal world) ceases to exist.
@@Acerthorn Unfortunately that's not how it works in HP!
Acerthorn yea i was about to say the same thing
like once you get over it maybe you could leave your eternal torture
"Harry, is that cilantro? You know how I feel about cilantro."
Jagrfmiirg Gâr-Ganoxïk ?
mysticqueen74 yes?
Jagrfmiirg Gâr-Ganoxïk They are confused.
mysticqueen74 They were continuing the Voldemort haunting Harry’s cooking joke.
Honestly that makes me this about the StarKid musical
Whenever Harry is cleaning Voldemort’s like “you missed a spot you missed a spot Harry”
Ok I’m gonna make a Wattpad fanfic of Voly living at Harry’s house
Send me the link and the name of your fanfic.I really wanna read it!
@@withlovejia_ me too!
Pls link
If you've done it I'm begging you to link
please do
"When Harry Met Myrtle" Where is that romantic comedy? I'd watch that.
**plays kazoo romantically**
**rose petals flop down from the ceiling** **wonky text that reads "how Harry met Myrtle" flashes on screen**
Charles Lee 😂😂😂😂
Oh hello harry title appears 😘
"I'll have what she's having."
@@TheSaneHatter only, less pepper
Someone please write a fanfic about voldy’s ghost becoming frustrated with Potter’s cooking
What are you doing that's not nearly enough salt: Voldumor
i've had that in my drafts since i watched this video for the first time
_Imma write this_
Wattpad just implodes and this is what the next FB movie is about
SOMEONE PLEASE WRITE THIS!! I WANNA READ IT BADLY
Would a Voldy Ghost have his nose back? Or would it just be like, a noseless ghost? That somehow also sounds weirder than a noseless evil wizard...
I always got the impression that ghosts souls have actually moved on seeing as that a ghost is merely an imprint of a "departed" soul.
It seems like a ghost is just like a painting of a headmaster at Hogwarts. Something that represents a dead person but not really them.
But that is not how it works in Harry Potter lure. It is clearly explained that the choice of becoming a ghost is to never be able to move on. I actually really like the theory that the veil in the depratement of misteries is something the unspeakables are working on to help ghosts cross the barrier into the land of the dead
@@danielsolomon3794 yes my friend but what I'm suggesting is that a ghost is not the soul at all but a copy left on the earth forever.
Ghosts seem to me to have a little more agency than paintings.
Paintings, including Dumbledores, stick to their old selves and roles. Ghosts can sometime choose to stray from that, like the Grey Lady sharing her secret, or to make actual choices, like Myrtle helping Harry over Cedric.
Professor Binns story always makes me laugh. He got up, left his body, and just continued teaching. Like he has the chance to finally quit but no he has to keep on teaching
He is the definition of the ultimate workaholic! He literally could not think of life/afterlife without working!
We need a spinoff where Voldemort as a ghost and Peeves just go around England playing pranks on Harry and his family.
“Im dying to hear what you think” I saw what you did there
So ghosts can be eaten by dementors? That’s a scary thought.
Yeah... that's disturbing
😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱
Well dementors are also ghosts so ghosts eating ghosts ? Could be possible
"Are those raisins in those cookies? Even i wasn't that evil" if Voldemort haunted harry's cooking
tobias kofod Raisin cookies are my favourite... guess this is why I’m a Slytherin.
SYNFLWR I'm a Ravenclaw and I love raisin cookies, so... 😕
YOU ARE BOTH DESPICABLE
Honestly, I feel like the reason raisins are so evil is because they're just lying about being grapes..........
@@7ShadowMaiden7 imagine a grape cookie
Voldemort as Harry's rude house ghost is my new canon 😂
I have a followup question: If we hypothesize that ghosts basically are souls, could dementors eat ghosts? And if so, do you think any were eaten during the battle of hogwarts?
Good question. Bigger question: Would it taste good?
@@electricpepperoni4789 This guys asking the big questions
"there's nothing worse than death"
Missed opportunity to make an expulsion joke
"..we could be killed, or worse: expelled"-hermione
Someone needs to write the “Voldemort as a ghostly roommate/food critic” fanfic- any volunteers?
I’m gonna do it
Doing a comic
Lindsey B i will definitely write that
I need this
To people who writing it; please tell me where I wanna read
Book 8: Harry Potter and the Angriest Houseguest
Yas
8:20 I'd pay money to see Voldy do this to Harry 😂
I think the most obvious answer is because he would no longer be able to perform magic. And that is the one thing that makes him special. He may not fear anything more than death but a life without magic would certainly be a close second.
Adult Voldemort: Man I just died
Teen Riddle: First time?
He was stuck in limbo so he probably just didn’t get the job offer
Interdimensional mailman couldn't find him hiding under the bench at King's cross
2:29 “they’re comfortable-“ that’s exactly what my orthodontist told me when I got a plate put in
Heres a theory of mine:
I think Voldemort couldn't come back as when he made his 7 Horcruxes all of his soul is already gone. I think that's why he couldn't make more than 7 as 7 is the largest magical number. therefore when all Horcruxes were destroyed his entire soul was already gone, so he couldn't come back. I think that's because when a ghost comes back it's not their body, but their soul and Voldemort wouldn't have a soul as it was destroyed through his Horcruxes. and that is why I think Voldemort couldn't come back.
SCB: Why didn't you come back as a ghost, Voldemort?
Voldy: I would if I could, but I can't so I shan't.
When I saw wizardsunite has a portrait of Voldemort, I keep imagine him going around killing other portraits
I have a question. In the deathly hallows why did Ron, Hermione and Harry have to wear the amulet? Couldn't they have put it in Hermione's magic bag?
Like for them to answer this please I've been thinking alot about this
In my opinion they didn't want to risk losing it. Putting it in a bag feels far less safe that always keeping it around your neck and directly on your chest.
You actually said what I've concluded for years with a few extra additions. Love this
4:53 "When Harry Met Mirtle" dibs on making that show!!!
Also, love your videos!!!
It's spelt Myrtle just saying
@@user-fw3ww3dy7o "spelled"... just saying
@@SweetSlytherinGirl-Jennifer some countries use spelt... just saying
@Zombi ' these are a lot of corrections.... just saying
I've always wondered what happens to victims of the dementors' kiss.
If their bodies are still alive, where are they?
Are they just left to wander around, or are they kept somewhere by the ministry? Are they taken care of so they stay alive, or left to slowly die as their bodies stop functioning?
When the ministry sentences someone to the dementors kiss, do they then look after the person for the rest of their 'life', or do they then let them die as well. Either way seems like a pretty odd sentence.
Where is Barty Crouch jr?
I'm pretty sure would they die rather quickly. I've read a fan story that talked about it rather well. Without the soul the body still does it's "automatic" functions like breathing, heart beating, and digesting food. However the body would be unable to do "voluntary" acts like eating and drinking. So after a shot time the body would shut down and die due to lack of food and water.
They might be physically capable of eating, but nothing would *motivate* them to eat. So they'd probably die of starvation pretty quickly. I mean, it's like a real person in a coma, or a vegetative state: these people only survive if they're put on life support. I don't suppose the Ministry takes the trouble of placing those sentenced to The Kiss on life support at St Mungo's. Maybe they get taken back to Azkaban and buried there when they die, shortly afterwards.
It sounds like the dementors kiss In the wizarding world is the equivalent of the death sentence in our world; that one's body dies and the soul is snatched and resides in an unknown place, as they are essentially indestructible. The same deal that takes place in our world takes place in the wizarding world?
I'm pretty sure that in Azkaban it's said that when the soul is eaten by a dementor the body lives on and then becomes a dementor itself. I could be wrong but I think it was when Lupin was telling Harry about them. May want to reread the book.
enjoy the HP content on the channel, but this one of the rare videos where the question is valid and the answer is satisfying. good job
Surely Harry’s parents would stay behind: their unfinished business would be to look after their son 🤔
Omg!I just thought abt that!U r 1 smart person! :-)
Yeah but it’s more noble to go to the afterlife and if they stayed they would have eternal suffering staying in the mortal world and if they passed on they would eventually meet harry when he dies instead of only 80 years or so after he dies they can be with him forever.
Eddy Lopez I think they thought Harry was about to die so passed on before Voldemort actually attacked him
Well, they sure thought Sirius would take care of him, so they knew he would be safe and sound.
BUT i can DEFINETLY imagine Lily hauntig her Sister for all Eternity for treating Harry so badly
Lily and James would not come back as ghost because if they did, they would be stuck as a ghost forever, thus ending their chance of seeing Harry after he died.
Like Hagrid said in the first book: "Some say he died. Codswallop, in my opinion. Dunno if he had enough human left in him to die. . . .but somethin' about you stumped him, all right"
The Voldemort laugh u put in (after showing his grave stone) 😂🤣😂🤣
Your editing has really stepped up for this video
I watched it for the second time, wanted to have a look at the grave stone again. I'd say, it takes a really mean boggart to have this "Friggin' Awesome at Anagrams" thing!
There isn't enough left of voldemort to be a ghost. He dissected his soul into too many pieces.
That about sums it up
Yea it's like dissecting something and then burning a piece. You can't put it back together, so yea
*that’s not what happened in the books*
ThePowersofUnited true, but his soul might have been split too many times, so technically he couldn’t become a ghost. Also, JKR did say in an interview that he was stuck in between death and life. He was stuck in the Kings Crossing part. In between the veil.
Okay, I officially lost it at ghost Voldy haunting Harry: “Looks good, smells bad. ‘Course I wouldn’t know, I’m a ghost. Also, I don’t have a nose.”😂
As others have mentioned, I would so totally pay for a shirt or hoodie or bag with an image of a fractured Voldemort ghost haunting an annoyed Harry. So, y'all do please consider making it. Please.
Also, I so want to do a fan series of comics around Ghost Voldemort haunting misc characters after his final defeat. It would not be cannon, like at all, but it would be funny.
Fan series of Ghost Voldemort―Oh yes, please! 😃
I was just thinking "I hope someone does it"..would love to read..😁
You can't forget doing the romantic comedy when myrtle met harry
Lydia S Hmm, I could work that into a comic or two. Where ghost Voldy "helps" Harry "avoid" Moaning Myrtle.
Harry: Why are you helping me all of a sudden?
Voldy: *shrugs* Oh, Harry. I was once where you are now with Myrtle chasing me around the castle. This can be my one good deed for the century.
*After closing and locking the wardrobe doors he summons Myrtle over.*
Voldy: Your foolhardy obsession is over in the wardrobe. Waiting for you.
Myrtle: Oh, thanks... Do I know you? You seem familiar.
Voldy: In another life perhaps. *He replies as he floats out of the room. Grinning a serpentine grin as shouts and wood splintering echoed off the stone walls.* Hmm, I wonder if there's pudding.
thats an awesome an idea
Anyone who can draw and do animation has to make this! Anyone else make it as a fan fiction!
When you showed all of the horcruxes you forgot one... seriously who could forget the Zac Efron poster!
Unoriginal 156 not the Efron poster! 😱
?
Enforcer Quickfire go watch A Very Potter Musical, you won’t regret it
I've never heard of it
Unoriginal 156 although I believe this reference is from A Very Potter Sequel
Another possible reason is that Voldemort might not want to simply live, but also live with a purpose and be powerful. Since ghosts have basically no power, and since the Death Eaters couldn't rise to power even when he was alive, he might feel that he wouldn't be powerful any longer as a ghost and hence feel his existence as one to be miserable
Imagine Voldemort haunting Hogwarts as a ghost. He would be in the DA room a lot helping all the Slytherins and messing with the muggle-borns.
I think it'd be bit worse than that
He’s not a 12 year old, he’s the friggin dark lord
TheGreenPrince 02 :d
He'd be in the back heckling
@@meganfreelove1551 Lol yeah, he'd be sitting in the back of all the Muggle Studies classes, constantly yelling "Hah! Gayyyy!" :'D
people that have split their soul can't be ghosts, that's my answer
It could also be that the unicorn blood stopped him
@@Dave-eu6sz A half, cursed life, would he be able to come back with that as his life? Hmm..
Maybe if he had stopped after one or two horcruxes, he still might have been able to become a ghost. And maybe if he hadn't also killed the unicorn. But I doubt he would have been satisfied being a ghost. He wanted to be fully alive, and would not have settled for anything less than true Nicolas Flamel-style immortality.
@@PhilBagels Thank you for being able to say what thoughts my mind couldn't put together
I love your videos. I normally dont watch the same episode twice. but you guys are fantastic :D i love your videos. And your harry potter videos made me and my fiance grow closer as i study her fave book. now im a master of harry potter just like her and i could not be more happy
Every time you guys use the clip of Voldy laughing, it makes me laugh out loud. I think it should be in every video.
The ‘Voldemort is slow at flying’ is probably the oldest joke I can remember from the three years I’ve been following this channel.
I think his soul was so broken after they destroyed the horcruxes, that he'll never be able to come back
Also, I dont want him to come back
Dont come back Voldy, dont come back
i think he should've killed umbridge..not volley
Voldemort coming back as a ghost to haunt Harry would have been a much better plot than what we got in Cursed Child
Are those raisins in those cookies . . . No! Harry, no!
I can't stop laughing for the life of me
I need some Voldemort haunts Harry fics now 😂
Please. Someone 🙏
I will try my best
Harry was in the kitchen making oatmeal cookies for Ginny to give her something, because she had done so much for him. His round glasses were sliding down his nose as he watched the cookies bake in the oven, the warm smell of oatmeal filling the kitchen.
_I hope Ginny likes these, It's hard to do things like this when I'm so busy at the Ministry with Ron_ Harry thought. Then Harry felt what he thought was a slight chill in the air, he looked at the window but it was closed. Puzzled, Harry just thought he was imagining it, but the chill only grew stronger, Harry could see his breath. He jumped up, grabbed his wand from the counter and looked around.
"Who's there?" he yelled. Harry definitely didn't expect what he would see, a pale, transparent, Voldemort was in Harry's living room that was adjacent to the kitchen.
"Harry Potter," Voldemort said icily.
"Tom?! I killed you!" Harry shrieked, he was aghast that Voldemort was a ghost, he had to be dreaming, he had fallen asleep cooking the cookies, anything but this!
"Yeah, but wizards can become ghosts soooo..." Voldemort said. "Are you making cookies? Oatmeal from the looks of it, wait, you didn't...you...you...YOU PUT RAISINS IN THE COOKIES!!!" Voldemort roared.
"Yeah, so, you can't do anything to stop me Tom," Harry said. Voldemort glared at Harry and then floated up through the ceiling. _Great, just great, I'm gonna have to tell everyone Tom's a ghost now_ he thought. *beep, beep, beep* The timer for the cookies went off, Harry ran to the oven, opened it, used his wand to float the tray of cookies on the counter to cool properly while he sat down to think.
Later......
"Harry, those cookies were delicious! Thank you for making them!" Ginny said as she and Harry climbed into bed.
"Well don't expect it to happen more often, I'm swamped at the Ministry, I could hardly take today off." His glasses smashed against his face as he was taking them off, Ginny had hit him with a pillow. "Ginny....today was already stressful enough." he whined putting his glasses on his bedstand.
"It had better been, I'm not worth nothing you know." Ginny replied.
"Hey, you're not worth nothing, but I'm exhausted so can I go to sleep, please?" Harry asked.
"Okay," Ginny said smiling.
Harry was having the weirdest dream, it was absolutely freezing even though he was in the Sahara desert with the sun beating down on him. Then suddenly a band was playing?
Harry was jostled awake by Ginny all of a sudden, to discover to his horror, Voldemort was in his bedroom and playing all the instruments of a band. (Y'know the cartoon musical instruments that are a harmonica, a trombone, and bagpipes, stuff like that made to be played by one person at the same time? It was one of those.) "Voldemort's a ghost!" Ginny shrieked.
"I'm starting to regret my life choices." Harry said exhausted, he looked at the clock, it was 3:00 am.
Your Welcome!
@TheContagiousSmile Thankyou! Now I will forever imagine Voldemort in place of Bert in Marry Poppins🤣
@@sydneyhobbs9817 😂
That was good short mr smile.
I assumed his rag of a soul was stuck in limbo and never even could make the choise neither to pass on nor come back.
I love the thrown in voldy laugh. Gets me every time
Those mini-skits of ghost Voldy in Harry's kitchen were hilarious. XDDD Would love more of that!
I don't think the Church would consider pulling rabbits out of the Communion cup a "good thing".
"Are those raisins in those cookies?
No...
Harry no!" This is literally me when people put raisins in cookies😂😂
Me starting the video: Soul destroyed.
Me finishing the video: Soul crossed through the veil sounds good too
Well in the seperate book series; "The Achemyst" franchise:
Ghosts are restricted to areas where they traveled when they were alive.
So, Harry Potter's ghosts could function the same way, or similarly.
Perhaps being restricted to a radius of where they once wandered, for example
Drinking unicorn blood probably stops people from being able to stay
I feel like it's the reverse, it keeps you from moving on after death, you'll never get peace and have to live out eternity as a ghost
@@isaiahcaston4539 why isn't quirrel a ghost, then?
@@vera1148 possibly because it wasn't HIS soul the unicsorn blood was preserving, it wa Voldemorts, so voldemort inherited the curse.
My thought on why Voldemort didn't come back as a ghost is there wasn't enough of his soul left.
Every time you guys end the video, I can't help remembering the "These socks are AMAZING!" bit from the early days.
I feel like he didn’t become a ghost bc he didn’t have enough soul left in his body when he died
I would love to see ghost Voldemort being an annoyance to Harry
I like to imagine that Harry just keeps calling him Tom, and acting like he's no big deal. That would drive Voldemort insane; eventually he'd leave Harry alone & go stay at Hogwarts, probably haunting any non pure-blood students.
Yh. It would be hilarious
GIR Grumpy Orange lol someone needs to do this, maybe a book or on YT or something. I’d definitely watch it 😂
robot chicken needs to make a sketch out of that concept
After Harry dies, he has a choice wether to return or go forward. Can you imagine if he would returned as a ghost, rather than being resurected? :D
As for ghosts going into water, that seems a bit confusing in and of itself. You can, ghosts can clearly fit through objects, even people (and people can go through them)). However, ghosts like Myrtle can somehow forcibly be swept down pipes with the contents of a toilet, that's how she's ended up in the lake before, and she doesn't apparently seem capable of, or have time to, get out of the pipes by slipping through them as a ghost. So maybe ghosts have some limitations when it comes to water. Also, now that I think of it, ghosts seem to be able to float about the ground, yet none of them have gone to the moon or other planets, that we know of.
Voldemort making fun of Harry’s cooking is the funniest and weirdest thing I have heard today
"Really really bother him" just makes me think "bother bother bother bother" "Avada kedavra! Oh dear."
5:47 I think I just fell in love 😂
I think this is close, but you missed one detail:
"A ghost, as I trust that you are all aware by now, is the imprint of a departed soul left upon the earth" - Snape
This means ghosts do not actually have their souls, but rather the soul creates the ghost when it departs.
Since we know Voldemort's soul parts are stuck in limbo (like we saw in king's cross) because of how damaged they are, I imagine they couldn't create the imprint of a soul, for the same reason they couldn't depart - they just weren't sufficient enough. That, or the soul has to depart in order for a ghost to be created (which Voldy could also not do).
I don’t think he came back because once every part of your soul is destroyed you can’t! Idk just my opinion:)
Champion Dean that’s an interesting thought
I agree
The unicorn blood also taints your soul doesn’t it?
My thoughts exactly.
Except for the one in his body. But I would assume that piece is just so weak and tiny that it's basically insignificant and can't manifest itself as a ghost
I live for SuperCarlinBrothers Harry Potter theories!
I’d say it’s impossible for Voldemort to become a ghost because his soul was fractured! :)
I know this vid is slightly old but I love talking about HP theories. Personally I think we never got much information about the true repercussions of making a Horocrux. We know that extremely dark magic always comes at a price. If Death actually exists as an entity (as in the Tale of the Three Brothers) I could see Death having EXTREME resentment to the only human in existence to create 7 horocruxes explicitly to avoid it. Meaning the moment Tom dies, Death would not give him ANY leeway. Heck, I even believe it would be like a “Death Note” (the anime/manga) situation where whosoever makes a Horocrux can achieve immortality but should they lose those horocruxes would receive the worst death ever possible. Not even passing on to any form of afterlife. I think that would be super interesting. Also love the anti-horocruxes theory though!