A Comedy Musician Reacts | DIVIDE! The Gospel of the Geiger by the Stupendium [REACTION/ANALYSIS]
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ก.ย. 2024
- Insane Ian is a comedy musician and comedy music fan. This week he's reacting to "DIVIDE! The Gospel of the Geiger | A Fallout Musical!" by @TheStupendium ! Like, share, comment, and subscribe!
Original videos!
DIVIDE!: • DIVIDE! The Gospel of ...
End credits song - "I Bet I Can Eat More Waffles Than You" by Insane Ian: • I Bet I Can Eat More W...
Get the book "Taking Funny Music Seriously" by Lily Hirsch, featuring interviews with Tom Lehrer, Peter Shicklele aka PDQ Bach, Kate Miccuci and Riki Lindhome from Garfunkel and Oates, and ME, Insane Ian! Order direct from the publisher here in paperback and hardback: iupress.org/97...
Check out Insane Ian's Spreadshop for t-shirts, hats, & more! insaneian.mysp...
Pick up Insane Ian's new B-side collection "Smarm-Proof Lobster Cabinet" now as a CD or digital download at insaneian.band...
Download two FREE comedy songs A WEEK at The Funny Music Project aka www.thefump.com
Pre-order THE BIOSHOCK EP by Insane Ian featuring guest appearances by The Stupendium, Beefy, & Twill Distilled! insaneian.band...
Get the CastlevanIAN poster in this video at insaneian.band...
Grab your copy of "Illinoise", Insane Ian's new album as a download or CD! insaneian.band...
Insane Ian on Spotify: open.spotify.c...
Insane Ian's Patreon: / insaneian
#thestupendium #fallout #comedymusic
![A Comedy Musician Reacts | FNAF KIDS by The Chalkeaters (ft. Stupendium, OR3O) [REACTION/ANALYSIS]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/MjQO7yYXf74/mqdefault.jpg)
![A Comedy Musician Reacts | FNAF KIDS by The Chalkeaters (ft. Stupendium, OR3O) [REACTION/ANALYSIS]](/img/tr.png)
![A Comedy Musician Reacts | THE PRODUCTION LINE (Stupendium/DanBull) [REACTION/ANALYSIS]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Gv0C3jinyXA/mqdefault.jpg)
![A Comedy Musician Reacts | Pokemon Smash or Pass by Starbomb [REACTION/ANALYSIS]](/img/n.gif)
Thank you for another fun reaction, man! I'm glad you enjoyed it! :D
You hit the nails all pretty much on the head! The Children of Atom believe in 'Division', which is the idea that when an atom splits, new universes are formed. So they view atomic blasts as literal acts of creation and to die in a nuclear explosion and have your atoms 'divided' is the highest honour. Every atom in each of us contains a whole new universe each itself filled with infinite atoms. And I absolutely did use this as an analogue for modern political and religious movements sewing societal division to recruit people to their extremise ideas, science denialism and selective facts.
'Their society decided we were better off divided - and delightedly I'm inclined to agree' - Those before the bombs thought we were better off fighting each other. They had the right idea. We SHOULD be divided but we should *also* be **Divided**.
Notice how both their holy book at the start AND the book the preacher mocks later on are academic textbooks? But they only like one and decry the other. They choose the facts that serve their narrative. In this case, they prefer the children's textbook over the one with thorough research. The facts they like work for them at surface level but don't you dare read any deeper and learn the truth.
The CoA show up in different sects throughout the games, each with their own spin on their beliefs and their own rules and to an extent mythology. (Some hate ghouls, others worship them, for example.) So it was fun to have the freedom to pick and choose and create our own little sect that served the story I wanted to tell, without having to worry about messing with the established canon of any particular group.
This one is DENSE so I won't go over every little thing but I will touch on some things you talked about that I can give you some context for!
Hate to school you on your US history here! But Fat Man and Little Boy were the names of the bombs the US dropped on Japan, so the line was in reference to those! Though you're right, the nuke launcher in the game is also named 'The Fat Man' in reference to those bombs. (The ammo are just called 'mini-nukes'.)
The 'fattest man to little boy' section is in reference to their belief that division seeds new universes. To use the phrase 'mortal shells' to refer to people is an expression about our fragility, we are but delicate, breakable things that will wither and die containing something more precious and beautiful within, the soul.
So the whole thing is a double on being a 'mortal shell', a frail being, withering and dying but with the eternal soul within and also a literal 'mortal shell', each of us a living bomb (shell) containing infinite universes just waiting to explode from us.
'In every atom's light - convection - a warmth of welcome spreads to all' - Convection is the way by which atoms exchange heat energy, so that 'warmth of welcome spreading to all' is a double!
A really fun but impossibly nerdy and niche one you missed is 'Einstein on the Beach' is actually an opera about Einstein discovering the theory behind the atom bomb. It was written by Phillip Glass. ('time to Phil your Glass'). I really just included this one for me and MatPat who introduced me to the musical haha. Only one person has ever clocked it so far! It's a wild watch because it's written entirely in numbers. Every lyric is people singing sequences of numbers to represent his theories.
As for the incredible miniature work? I'm sorry to disappoint you, all CG! No miniatures here! The CG team did incredibly on this one, nailed my vision for it! The whole team really came together fort this one, so much work from so many people! Thank you for all of the love on the production as well as the music! If you check the description you'll see I basically maxed the character limit on the credits! A huge number of people played a part in it!
Thanks again for the fun reaction! I always look forward to these! :)
@@TheStupendium wow, thanks for the insight and for checking out the reaction! I appreciate your behind the scenes details and moments I missed (and of course your support)! Thanks again for another fun song to react to!
I always read through the convection was also a homophone on conviction
For some reason i thought the "mortal shells" double meaning had to do with "mortar shells"
Atom, these lines are so good!
Also i heard, faint emaciation versus living a half life. As saying your life isnt complete without atom, thus living a half life. And youd rather just have some faint emaciation. (Partially because the preacher is 200 years old)
'Living a half life' is also a double; when measuring radiation, the 'half-life' of a radioactive substance is how long it takes for roughly half of its atoms to have decayed.
And while the 'winter' note is almost certainly a reference to their next song too, it's a reference to 'nuclear winter' as well.
Came to the comments to say this.
He also had it flipped, the Preacher isn't suggesting the rads will give you a half a life, he's saying you're only living half a life without the rads. He is, after all, over 200 years old. So, what's a little emaciation as a side effect?
35:00 The line "from Eden's aftermath" is probably referring to 'John Henry Eden' who is the AI leader of the Enclave whose personality is an amalgamation of former US presidents.
Also, because they mix with some Christian imagery, it could be a jumbled pre war mix up with Atom/Adam and Eve in Eden (which they got kicked out of resulting in our current world).
@@mrshadow4007 The actual eden reference you both missed was the Garden of Eden Creation Kit (G.E.C.K.). It's a Vault-tec item that's allowed near miraculous terraforming in Fallout.
@@bobobo7730 Possible but unlikely. The line before it references Megaton, from Fallout 3, as the beginning and the "aftermath" of Eden which again could be a reference to the actual Garden of Eden or the detonation of Raven Rock and Eden's destruction. The Children of the Atom would be unlikely to celebrate using a GECK to *remove* radiation from water.
fun fact, the call and response at the beginning is mixing the bible and text from "this is not a place of honor", which is a proposed solution to long-term storage of nuclear waste.
nuclear waste lasts tens of thousands of years on the low end, so how do you keep people away from something that will poison and kill them for that long? well, one suggestion was essentially a museum over the storage site that explains, in multiple long-lasting languages, what nuclear waste is. the proposed text opens with the lines the audience is repeating, "this place is a message and part of a system of messages, this is not a place of honor" etc.
those proposals are wild by the way. they range from "bury it deep and don't mark it" to "make the surface a blighted hellscape for miles around so nobody goes digging".
A fellow Londoner from the Neath! Always a treat to meet fellow Londoners in the wild:) (might want to leave that Nadir cave though, your skull is starting to look a tad... closed)
I think the best solution there is to bury it as far deep as possible, so anyone who can already dig that deep will know about radiation.
@@nikkiofthevalleyOr send it to Pluto, if it leaves far enough noone can use it.
@@laharlkent The aliens when a rocket filled with nuclear waste crashes in their planet because we missed pluto:
@@laharlkent and if a rocket launch goes wrong and, say, explodes?
whoops, just made a dirty bomb!
My guess about the outfit changes are a representation of each Voca-Stim giving +5 Charisma
Absolutely right! An earlier idea of the video was to give the character a pip-boy and have them bring it up to change their outfit, have the charisma boost come from clothing items, but it was too clunky to make work. The chems were a much easier narrative device to boost the character's charisma but we still wanted a clear visual progression too, so we opted to keep the costume changes. Just imagine they are pausing the game and swapping out their clothes in the inventory at the same time as taking the chems. :P
The reason it "sounds like a full, legit, pit band orchestra" is because it is, the winds, drums, guitar, bass, hammond organ, and backing vocals are all real
In the finale, "May we save the nation from those not like us" and "Let us make America detonate again" - those hit way too close to home in our current Presidential election cycle. Fabulous work as well, singing believably in an accent not their own.
The line about Eden's aftermath is referencing the Garden of Eden Creation Kit, or G.E.C.K., which was supposed to be put in every Vault, but Vault Tec did what it does best, lying, manipulating, and so on, so a significantly lower number of Vaults ever got their G.E.C.K. A G.E.C.K. has enough supplies to refertilize tainted soil, remove radiation from a water source, start farming plots, and generally return the land around a Vault to a state similar to before the bombs fell within a few years. Obviously, the Children of Atom are very much opposed to the idea of cleaning the land of radiation.
I agree that I think the Stupendium's greatest skill is _easily_ their writing ability. They consistently have the best lyrics and raps I've ever seen in basically every video.
The windmill on top of the church is in the shape of the nuclear logo, but it’s turned sideways so it’s kinda hard to tell
@@A_Random_Theatre_Kid oh nice! I didn't even catch that!
Might be a weather vane, though (but I agree, probably designed to be ☢️-like)
@@tschillintsoulntai9285 WEATHER VANE! *THAT'S* what I was trying to say!
@@Insaneian yeah, that's what I figured but as no one else has offered it in other comments yet, thought I'd put it out there. Though I don't think any other reaction yet had made any comment on the weather vane so you're still ahead on that analysis point
Popping the first Voca-Stim is in my opinion the best acting I’ve ever seen from Stupes. The subtle trembling of the hand, the hesitation and worried glances are just perfect.
There are so many lines which tickle the brain the right way. The “Atom’s eve sure was a blast” word play also on Adam and Eve, the beginning of human kind, Einstein on the beach (a wonderful photo, btw, with the most exquisite sandals), and the Oppenheimer line, to name a few.
This song highlights not just the rift between religious extremist and science, but also between science and conspiracy groups, certain politicians, TikTok weirdos and others who take advantage of vulnerable people.
(I thought I was writing a novel but Stupes beat me to it 😂)
Only trust the science you yourself perform.
Fun fact that I noticed- The person who hit themselves with the dinner plate is Will Ryan-Dagames. Another Nerdcore artist who focuses on more rock/metal music than rap. And hitting himself with the dinner plate is exactly his kind of humor-which makes it ten times funnier, at least for me.
Plus as Olaf pointed out, DA couldn't stick around for the full 2-day shoot so this was effectively an improved way to "write out" his character
@@tschillintsoulntai9285
I noticed that! He didn’t come back after hitting himself-it was a great way to explain his absence.
@@endereye964 the face-pan shot was followed shortly after by a shot in which the guardsman can be seen in the background dragging DA's body across the room by the doors
@@tschillintsoulntai9285
I know. I saw it-that’s what I’m talking about lol. It was a brilliant way to explain his absence.
@@endereye964 I agree with another commenter: Olaf's reaction is worth checking out for behind the scenes tidbits as Olaf participated as not only an extra bit as a production assistant (if I properly recall the title)
Bassed Olaf is sitting behind Rustage and he has a reaction to this with a ton of little behind the scenes nuggets
I think the song is very much a joke at how modern religion and conspiracy theorists push false narratives, and how easily people get caught up in those ideas. And how allowing certain groups to go unchecked can cause more harm than simply bothering a few people.
Saying this because I didn’t hear you mention it at all but when he says Atom it sounds like Adam which is fitting because it’s a church
@@patfre I didn't say that, but I definitely thought it 😅 I meant to make a Pinned, comment about it, but Stupendium's comment got pinned instead. Thanks tho!
A funny thing that doesn't immediately click about Stupes's character being a Ghoul is that... *Ghouls are immune to Radiation*. They're not only a pre-war Ghoul who's been around more than long enough to have actually known the truth behind the atomic bombs, but they're also preaching about the holiness of something that is specifically *not harmful to them, but harmful to those they're preaching to*.
@@Otherversian oooh, VERY good point!
FUCK yeah i was worried you wouldn’t react to this one! delighted to get the notification
13:30 division sovs division is also a refrence to chain reaction which is an actual mechanism of radiation and nukes
30:08 I have never seen a person genuinely say “oh, dear” in a moment of shock and oh my god this moment is gold
to correct some of your science, it's not the atoms directly that collide with each other, it's neutrons that collide with a radioactive atom, splitting it and releasing more neutrons that strike other radioactive atoms, etc so a division (of an atom) sows divisions (of other atoms in a chain reaction)
@@gibbbon AH! Thank you...I was close, but I appreciate the clarification!
23:56 How to make great set design according to Insane Ian: Add a lot of pipes around
@@bruex2277 How to make great *Fallout* set design 😅
Also helps with less-apocolypticly themed steam punk but those pipes would need to look like they have varied functioning purposes between them
Eden might also be referring to the "president" of the Enclave John Henry Eden in fallout 3
I loved the "oOH DEAR" part with the guy knocking himself out monk style! Made me snort XD
Stupendium:says something clever
Ian: okay I just need a moment here to process what just happened
@@Smallfigures 😅 you're not wrong tho
The “gospel” they were reading at the start is long-term nuclear waste warning signs lmao
after stupes' songs drop, i always eagerly await your reactions. always so entertaining and insightful to watch, great job. i don't know if you missed it or just didn't mention, but one of my favorite parts is at the very end when the atomites are singing and they say "let us make america detonate again".
And earlier "May we save our nation/From those not like us". Careful there, your Frollo is showing.
Dropped harder than the bombs.
37:16
Fat Man and Little Boy were also the names of the atom bombs that were dropped on Nagasaki and Hiroshima respectively as well, I think.
@@bzrklarz4295 yup! Stupes pointed that out in the pinned comment!
That is an awesome Stupendium shirt I wish I could have it. Also Wario approved reaction!
Great reaction as always, Ian!
Given how you usually pause on instances of off-kilter rhyme schemes, particularly Stupendium's penchant for leading the rhymes into the next line, I'm surprised you didn't stop or comment on
They’ll say, "We’ve the facts to prove!"
"That energy’s just energy, not blessed" - brethren you’ve--
I also don't think you noticed (or at least didn't comment on) the windmill blades being in the shape of the radiation symbol.
I think the reason they're changing outfits is to be extra charismatic! In Fallout, there are certain outfits that make you more charismatic. For example, in New Vegas I'll get the most dapper clothes on before I try to convince someone of something
The wordplay in this song is some of Stupes' best, but I want to take a second to appreciate the background track as well. The composer and performers did such a great job and it's so catchy!
i knew nothing about the children of atom before watching this song, but i knew a helluva lot about radiation! also about evangelical pastors, for some reason. my interests are varied. back to the point, stupes got the televangelist vibes down pat and their nuclear puns are fantastic. i dont know how they keep topping themself, they cant keep getting away with this
"On theorems so farcical that cast our martyred particles apart from Atom's throne!"
This one could also be referencing that the scholarly articles and theorems they're writing on are also made of atoms(which would themselves be seen as the particles being martyred), taken away from the congregation's religious beliefs, away from the throne.
Fatman and Little Boy were the atomic bombs dropped on Japan.
The shells part is they are bombs and they have shells.
The gun is called a Fatman. They fire Mini Nukes. Little Boy is the name of a special kind of Mini Nuke. I think. There is a Little Boy in the games.
3:58 Yes, "weight" and "mass" are different. Mass is the total amount of matter, or "stuff," in an object while weight is the force of gravity acting upon said object. Also, mass remains constant while weight will vary depending on how much gravity is acting upon the object.
@@EvilSupahFly I knew I was close! 😅 it's been WAY too many years since my science classes in school, but I knew there was a difference, even if I couldn't eloquently state it. Thank you!
I rhink the end is about how there is Nuclear Winter after a nuclear attack.
The thing in Fallout: New Vegas, were some NCR Troopers say Patrolling rhe Mojave makes you wish for a Nuclear Winter.
The debris blocks the sky and causes a artificial winter. With green, irradiated, snow. In the games case.
Also, Fat Man and Little Boy in games are named after the two infamous nuclear bombs that where dropped on Japan in 1945
i think the line faint emaciation versus living a half-life is more referencing the half-life of radioactive elements such as uranium then the fact it cuts life expectancy
It's both. That's the point. :P
@@TheStupendium I see, i should've thought of that >.
FINALLY IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS
2:51, It begins! I've been checking for your review of this masterpiece since The Stupendium released this!
This also all works because in Fallout sorry have to quote a wiki.
"Some Children exhibit congenital immunity to radiation, but the faith accepts all converts as long as their faith is true. Many live freely in high-radiation zones like the Crater of the Atom without suffering from radiation sickness, ghoulification, or other physiological changes."
Its an fun concept of a song, and i can see how with a sliver tung and the human need for hope you could fall for it.
Also the Stupendium had those outfits on hotkey for speech checks.
Was waiting for this. Great work, no notes.
A couple other you missed the water drinker was conner quest and in there somewhere was star girl as well as a couple others I couldn't remember the name of.
Its a amazing song.
The part were his makeup gradually drops off and hes getting more gaunt as it goes on is cool.
Hes a ghoul and a shyster.
A prewar Ghoul maybe. He knows its all bullcrap.
He just wants the caps.
*Their* not *His*. Stupes goes by They/Them pronouns, just fyi.
Omg when u got the call my sister phone started ringing and a soon as u said suspected spam is calling my her phone stoped 😮😂😂
As always, love the video. Keep it up Ian!
The Eden thing is related to John Henry Eden. The AI President of The Enclave.
Einstein wasn't dead for thousands of years. He died in 1955, the bombs fell in 2077, and the games are set from 2102-2104 (Fallout 76) through 2161 (Fallout 1), 2241 (Fallout 2), 2277 (Fallout 3), 2281 (Fallout: New Vegas), 2287 (Fallout 4), and finally 2296-2297 (the TV show).
@@AlexanderAzarov alright, hundreds, not thousands
I wonder if Stupe's ghoul-preacherman character was initially around for the first bomb
@@tschillintsoulntai9285 likely.
Love your reaction as always Ian
Genesis and Eden likely reference GECKS
Genesis EDEN creation kits
The terraforming gear some vaults have
Pretty sure Eden refers to John Henry Eden, the AI leader of the Enclave and the de-facto US president in FO3, the Genesis was a nice word-play as it's the book in the Bible where the Garden of Eden is mentioned and also refers to the start of something, which is the start of the children of Atom after the Bombs fell. Also, G.E.C.K stands for Garden of Eden Creation Kit btw.
Stupes has been known to write lines that have 3 or more meanings to any given word
Another banger by The Stupendium. Since we know it takes a while for these masterpieces to release, could you do a reaction to his Cult of the Lamb song? Great breakdown as always.
@@HG-1318 already did! As I say in this video, if it's not in my Stupendium playlist or if you haven't seen a reaction here, it might be on my Patreon!
@@Insaneian Ah yea didn't see it in the playlist. I'll definitely be sure to check it out when I can! Keep up the gr8 comedy work!
Something that no one seemed to noticed yet in the reaction community
The book that the participants of the atomic mass read In the intro of the song is the well established warning about nuclear waste, devised solely for the purpose of protecting those who come after fall of our civilisation. Yes smart scientists already prepared that too.
"Nothing important was buried here, no estimated nobility nor treasure. We were scared of what lies here"
^ losely paraphrasing.
I didn't notice the universal warning message the first time I watched this at the beginning
Musically, it was reminiscent of gospel and also kind of Will Wood. Thematically, I loved how it played with the Atomites. They’re sorta based on real ideas about an “atomic priesthood” that might be able to retain and transmit information about nuclear physics and safety. Only Stupendium could make it all so catchy!
Mass is weight divided by gravity
Side note: That guy that monty python-ed himself is DAGames, another Musician and Gameplayer on youtube with over 2 million subscribers. Him doing that is pretty accurate to him irl too.
It was entirely his idea. He had to leave early unexpectedly and we had to work out a way to write him out of the video. He suggested 'What if I just get so excited I knock myself out and get carried away?' and it was so funny we rolled with it. One of my favourite moments in the video!
I should have recognized him as my pal Luke has done some animation for him...but I've never actually known what he looked like 😅
@@TheStupendium Sounds in line with him. I do love it when you've got guest stars on, no matter how small their role. It's always fun.
still reccomending Cupid vs Leprechaun vs Easter Bunny by Freshy with the Stupendium, Freeced and Littleflecks
I don't know if you pointed this out, but I love the subtle reference to "Not Like Us" by Kendrick Lamar in the last part
This is one of Stupes' best, was vibing every second of it lol
19:10 still in favor of a "Sane Ian" channel, just for the name alone
When you said you reacted to *every one of their songs* on your Patreon I was about to head over there and subscribe... but then you said except Shine Through... My favorite one 😭
@@Sinnoh1996 yeah, alas I haven't reacted to that one...but it's one of my favorites too. I've even considered covering it...
T'is a shame you hadn't started non-comedy patreon-exclusive reactions in time to do Shine Through. Do you think there's enough to do a treatment as you did with Weird Al's assorted music videos?
@@tschillintsoulntai9285 maybe? I don't want to revisit them since I've seen them all so recently, but I might do Shine Through at some point.
This reminds me, I might've forgotten to do last month's exclusive reaction 😅
Be careful, don’t get radiation poisoning
i was recently watching your older reactions so it just struck me how much you've improved since your original reactions to stupendium. the Shpeil ( comedy musician comedy music fan ect... and the one that ends in "its a crapshoot whatever your gonna get") and the lighting and filming.
@@benjaminmead9036 thanks! Yeah, I've gotten a better camera and light, and I've zeroed in on how I do my intros. I'm glad folks see it as an improvement! 😅
Also, I had to look it up because I knew it was a Bible verse but I couldn't remember which one, but the sermon at the beginning starts the same way as Revelations 1:7, the book said to tell of the end times where the Children of Christ will be raptured into heaven.
Reaccioná a la nueva canción de "the chalkeaters" por favorrr
I think the Half Life thing is related to atoms. Like Half Lifes title is.
How long they live.
The church was probably built in 1:25 scale
@@LETMEHSLEEP601 per Stupes' pinned comment, it wasn't a miniature at all!
I think you missed a line where the congregation says "Let's make America detonate again"
@@PeterChadwell I definitely did, but I never claim to catch *everything* 😅
I love your shirt
Apparently mannequins are still the worst to me yes I know its an odd fear but the ones with holographic faces are the worst. I liked the band in this gave a different feeling to this song. I would like you to react to Voiceplays Hide and Seek.
Insane Ian have you yet listened to FNAF KIDS The Chalkeaters?
@@tornado8811 not yet!
@@Insaneian would you belive me if i would say that he just posted the animation of it XD
@@tornado8811 I mean, I didn't think it was out yet when you asked... 😅
@@Insaneian yea it wasent yet but when you comment on my text i saw it and it came out like 18 min after your comment
I do love how the skeptic had their own little arc where she ended up just going along with the flow and still ended up like the rest of them, blown up. Downer ending but a very Fallout-esque one
She'd have got out ok if it hadn't blown up.
Just needed a lot of Radaway.
Though nuclear explosions don't always kill people and some might have got Ghoulified.