Probably the rivian just for the tech,but if i wanted to stand out,the cybertruck would be the one id pick,but overall i will take the rivian,i love the cybertruck tho,i know many many pepole dont,but i do.
@@ZipZoomZip Not their car. It's a rental, but they should read the manual 1st 😀 At least they corrected the estimate range. Foundation has 301miles for beast and 318 for AWD due to A/T tires.
I think it was meant to point out the voice control accuracy. I certainly didn’t assume this was the only way to deal with the wipers based on this video.
My dad uses the Ford Lighting for construction. It saves him so much money on gasoline. The real answer to see which one is better is on ur usage. The Ford lighting is great if you want a pickup truck but hate the price of gas. It still tows and carries alot. The rivian seems like a Toyota Tacoma but electric. Small but does the job. Probably easier to park especially in the city with decent space to load things. The cyber truck is meant for people who don't actually use a truck. It's more of a status symbol and I think the utility isn't there for most truck user.
Not to mention having to move your head to check a blind spot, which is literally the definition of a blind spot. All 3 trucks you have to move your head to check them, all 3 trucks you need to take your eyes off the road to check speed, all 3 trucks require you to look to your right to see out the rearview. Also review cameras are way better, using the mirrors leaves massive blind areas.
Even before I hit 'Play' , I knew this would be the dumbest reivew....and I hit 'Play' anyways. I was proven right! The ntcase dinged Cybertruck unnecessarily. Cybertruck is quicker, more manueverable, more horsepower, has bigger bed, bigger payload, higher towing capacity etc etc but somehow it is neither good as a work truck nor as a lifestyle truck??? The guy offers zero analysis; his verdict is based on 'my kids love Rivian'. What a loser!
Love that you tested actual truck stuff like carrying cargo and bed storage. I am amazed how many reviewers gloss over this. Real world range is also very useful.
Most reviews gloss over payload capacity because the Tesla wins it by a country mile. Oh, wait, besides their fake "volume test" Edmonds glossed over the payload capacity too! Probably because the Cybertruck's 2500 lb. payload capacity leaves the other two in the dust.
Nobody carries cargo in boxes! Even before I hit 'Play' , I knew this would be the dumbest reivew....and I hit 'Play' anyways. I was proven right! The ntcase dinged Cybertruck unnecessarily. Cybertruck is quicker, more manueverable, more horsepower, has bigger bed, bigger payload, higher towing capacity etc etc but somehow it is neither good as a work truck nor as a lifestyle truck??? The guy offers zero analysis; his verdict is based on 'my kids love Rivian'. What a loser!
@matthewtruitt8077 I've towed various work trailers my entire life, but very rarely out of the local area. All the jobs I have taken are within an hour's drive (because it's difficult to make much money when you have to drive more than an hour each way, each day). But to answer your question, EV's have superior tow dynamics and safety, due to their great torque, responsive throttles, regen braking and solid heft with a very low center of gravity. You will not find tow dynamics like that in any gas or diesel vehicle. This will make towing even right up to the limit, a very easy and relaxing affair with superior control and stability. Of the three EV trucks reviewed in this dumb comparison, the Cybertruck is going to be superior, due to its higher chassis rigidity, relatively long wheelbase and short rear overhang (distance from tow ball to rear axle). Chassis rigidity is what prevents trailer sway from being amplified which is basically what happens with the traditional ladder frame. I have a 2010 F-150 and the trailer needs to be setup and properly balanced or you WILL get trailer sway with heavier trailers because the truck's chassis is very flexy. The Cybertruck, in comparison, will have almost zero chassis flex, like it is hewn from a single billet. It is more rigid than the chassis of a McLaren F1, even a heavy, improperly setup trailer is not going to experience every person's worst nightmare, trailer sway going out of control. That's what causes most loss of control events at highway speeds. Mind you, you still want your trailer reasonably well setup so it will have good braking and emergency avoidance dynamics, but the ability and benefits of a rigid chassis to dampen oscillations shouldn't be under-estimated. The Cybertruck will have a very tight, responsive ride, even when towing right up to its 11,000 lbs. tow limit.
If you counted the gear tunnel in the Rivian with the boxes, did the Cybertruck get credit for carrying the boxes and the TV? I don’t think the Lightning or Rivian have a rear door that opens to 90°.
People will catch on that the Tesla chargers are available to ford lightning owners and at the price point the lightning will be the one to get. Rivian and Tesla are both too expensive and have too many unnecessary frills.
For the Cybertruck, you missed counting the space under the bed (sub-trunk, where you can put ice or other things). That should be able to fit maybe 1 or 2 boxes there.
Uhh, that Lightning doesn't have the "max recline" seat option. The actual seats would have a different design and the bottom portion raises to be flush with back section.
Oh wow! I didn’t know that your channel was a Tesla advertisement for the cyber truck! I own a Ford F150, lightning, lariat extended range, and at the price point and the absolute quality Ford has put into this it is freaking amazing!, let’s face it how many service centers do you have for that Rivian, and Tesla cyber truck, and my ability to drive, five minutes to get to my Ford dealership a 10 year bumper to bumper warranty battery included (and yes, that includes the regenerative braking) (and let me tell you I have never had a problem with my Ford like me ever) yes it was extra, but I paid less than $70,000 There’s no comparison to the Rivian, or the cyber truck. Ford has waited and built Ford lightning, but they learn from every other electric vehicle before them, every mistake of every other electric vehicle. We waited three years. It is the Ford lightning the best vehicle I have ever owned in my life absolutely amazing. if you wanna spend 100+ thousand dollars. On a concept car from a manufacturer that will probably be out of business in 10 years. That’s your choice. But I can tell you that I own a brand new Ford F250 only for plowing my commercial properties, but I will never buy anything other than a Ford light. I’ve never been happier..
How does this guy not notice the button for the wiper next to the button he is pressing for the voice commands? Oh I get it, he needed to find someway to make the CT look bad... that makes more sense..
If I had the money, I would buy all three trucks! We use the F150 Lightning Platinum at work and it is GREAT! INSANELY BIG AND COMFORTABLE and is can STILL tow a typical 10,000 lbs worth of flat bed trailer with typical low-bed cargo for over 160 km (100 miles) on a single charge. For most urban and suburban environments that is more than enough for daily work and home use. For off-road use, I would change the tires of the Rivian to 33 inch Goodyear Duratracs and it would just fine as my weekend warrior vehicle that goes into the back-country lakes and rivers for some fishing and carrying my ruggedized inflatable fishing kayak. The Cybertruck is the vehicle I want to drive to the local city park for a BBQ with family and friends and use for the 2.5 hour drive to the local ski resorts (i.e. Whistler-Blackcomb from Vancouver!) blasting some 1980's era music all the way there while we sip on mocha lattes! It's a show-off vehicle for a company owner or local executive AND for the suburban mall crawler who wants some stylish comfort while driving over to park it for a few hours at the local mall or library! V
Great review/comparison. Just wanted to point out that you did search for other areas to get more cargo (boxes) into F150 and the Rivian, but did miss a point of storage in the end that you showed for a bit in the video. you could have fit more boxes in the far section of the Cybertruck bed and still closed the Vault. At least three and maybe four more boxes, thus making it the winner. And if you wanted to go crazy, the fold-up second row seats would have made this a total blowout!. Also, don't know if one box would have fit under the bed? In the end of your storage comments while you judged it barely being behind, you actually said "not much in it" about the Cybertruck. A bit harsh for your almost tie. Again... in the end it does hold more. Thanks; and again, a very nice overall presentation.
For the voice command does it do better or worse with British accents? Haha I think the words “turn on” should be used rather than “switch” for the wipers. 6:10
How did Edmunds run their test to get 390 miles of range on the R1T? I've had my R1T (dual-motor, max-pack, 21” wheels) for about 3 months now and I'm calculating an average of about 335 miles of range in highway driving.
Hate or love the CT, you need the applaud Tesla to have the balls to actually made it into production and not play it safe like almost every auutomakers out there.
Thankfully it showed all cars don't need to look the exact same as they've been doing for 30 years. Maybe other cars will start experimenting with different looks
5:58 you REALLY should learn how to use the vehicle before attempting a review (or just call it a preview). The wiper controls are right there, at at thumbs reach, on the steering wheel. You turn them on with one push of a thumb, and you can use the left scroll wheel to change the intermittency speed.
Tesla is the best car company ever no gas stations no oil changes no smog check no corrupt dealerships no catalytic converter no dealer mark up above MSRP! Oh and I have a lot of Tesla stock!
I can tell you have a lot of Tesla stock. What I can also tell is that you don't drive a Tesla out of warranty. My model S has been the most expensive car to maintain that I have ever owned. And I've owned Mercedes S class and exotic imports. The lack of dealerships has been a major con, not a plus. It was the most painful purchase experience I've ever had, where they couldn't even tell me where my car was for several months, and this was for a car that was theoretically already built and sitting on their lot. They flat out lied about a majority of their features. They've consistently refused to honor their warranty, or their prepaid service plan. And they routinely remove functionality or degrade the user interface with nearly every software update while not allowing you to opt out of the updates. I will never, under any circumstance, buy another Tesla as long as I shall live.
Go on for decades about the design of the Cybertruck... But respect is due here. It's a good truck and is very useful with lots of features. The Lightning and the R1T are great competitors. All are good investments. Thanks for the review, Edmunds!
you have given so far the most solid advise i have heard. if you want a cybertruck, buy a cybertruck. can't be as simple, honest and straightforward as that.
Because let's be fair that's the only reason to buy one, it has no selling features beyond some people wanting one. It's worse at every single task, and you have to deal with the worst company on the planet when it comes to parts and service. It's also the most expensive, and the most expensive to maintain and operate. If you've ever owned a Tesla out of warranty you will know how absurdly expensive they are to keep on the road. Not to mention the hassle of even trying to get Tesla to honor their own warranties or contracts, or to get any repairs done in a timely fashion.
A truck review where the trucks weren't tested off-road or towing, the two main reasons why people who actually need trucks buy trucks. This is basically a car review.
Actually it is a surprising fact that the majority of people who buy trucks buy them for commuting #1. The ability to tow and off road are nice perks. Towing is definitely not a good reason to buy one of these.
@@Cyber_Homestead if my F150 lightning lariat is a car I don’t think I’ve ever had a car that has 775 foot pounds of torque and has 580 hp and it’s four-wheel-drive with the rear, locking differentials, able to tow 12,000 pounds, maybe I’m missing something. that has more power than my brand new Ford F250 lariat that I used to plow with my F250 can tow more than my lightning, but the lightning can’t plow snow at this point so 50 to do my commercial properties since I bought the lightning I only drive my gas gasoline Ford F250 when I have snowstorms the average cars when I drove the 250 every day is $150 a week in gas. I think I’ll stick with my 50 extra dollars a month in electricity When I drive my lightning, every day, except for snow days And that’s how much my electric bill has gone up. that’s a savings. Of $550 a month in gas and that ain’t no bullshit.
@guyscribner I wasn't commenting on the truck, I was commenting on the horrible video. Maybe understand a comment before you waste your time rant about something completely unrelated?
@ I just had my 10,000 mile service in amounted to rotating the tires checking everything my 20,000 mile service is the same exact thing. I asked the dealership winter is coming should I get any different tires? They said no but I have all season tires, but I still am going to look into it a little bit. I’d like to have some thing with the better tread for ice studded snow tires
Which truck has more visibility without using cameras? Which is easier to install ladder racks and/or tool boxes on? Can any of the three have a utility bed or flatbed installed in place of the original bed? If the battery pack failed today, which truck is cheaper to replace batteries on? Not including warranty. Can any of the three be ordered without an infotainment touchscreen?
I have an F150 Lightning Lariat. It is basically an F150 with an electric battery. I love mine. It has plenty of visibility without using a camera. It has a 5 1/2 foot bed, and you could easily install ladder racks or toolboxes. You would have to ask the dealer about changing out the bed. If it could be done, the Ford is probably the one that it could be done on. The battery packs all have long warranties, eight years and 100,000 miles or thereabouts. battery reliability is likely to be high if the manufacturer is warranting that for such a long period of time. Obviously if your battery goes bad at nine years and 150,000 miles, it will be expensive to replace. Pretty much every new car on the road right now has an infotainment screen. It is a matter of how small you can get it. The basic trims on the F150 have a smaller screen.
@@joshuagolden5194 You are correct; and Tesla almost went under, twice. Just because Tesla made it, does not mean that Rivian will. That is failed logic.
6:05, why is it Edmunds insists on not wanting to learn how Teslas function? You have had 10 years! Just press the wiper button on the steering wheel and the screen menu comes up on the screen. You can even use the scroll wheels to switch the settings as well.
I have had the Lightning ER for about 6 months and still havent punched it. LOL. The power in these is insane and racing is not my gig. But when you need it there is no waiting or wondering when or what gear is going to show up. Or if theres going to be a puff of smoke signaling a possible problem
I definitely want the Cybertruck. I wish it had a video feed for the rear mirror and that the rear armrest was longer incorporating the middle headrest, or at least had 2 Qi phone chargers when down - like the Model S rear armrest.
IMO, the ford lightning seems to be the most practical. Its interior looks the best as well. The Rivian has a beautiful exterior design but has a smaller interior space. I would rank Ford in first place and the Rivian as runner up. I’m surprised that the ride quality in the cyber truck is better than in the others. My model 3 ride is quite harsh, even more so than in my Mach e. The cyber truck will appeal to those who want to be noticed and off course the fan boys
I want to love the Ford lightning but I just dislike the interior screen. For some reason I can't get over the vertical screen. I LOVE the frunk though.
About a year ago I was debating between the Rivian or Lightning but ultimately went with the lightning because of three main reasons: 1. . Rivian is a fairly new company and still has many obstacles to overcome not to mention we don't know what could happen to the company in years to come. With all startups especially in an inconsistent economy you have to be cautious. 2. . One underrated feature about the Lightning that many don't mention when comparing EVs is that because the lightning is based off the traditional F-150, a majority of parts and accessories are compatible. This makes the lightning one of the most easiest EVs to repair, mod, accessorize, and customize. Most EVs not based off a traditional design would require custom mods and accessories which would cost more not to mention that EV designs other than the lightning keep changing year by year making it impossible to create a market for a specific EV line. 3. . As of today, there are not a lot of Rivian dealerships or repair shops. This can pose a problem if there is an issue with the vehicle and you would need to tow or ship it across country to a Rivian location, meanwhile you can take your lightning to any Ford dealership at every corner of the country. This also affects your ability for mods and accessories too, especially the ones that require professional installation that would force you to ship your vehicle to have them installed.
@@connoravila5332 my Tesla model 3 screen has a horizontal layout vs the vertical orientation of my Mach E’s screen. It took a while to get used to the vertical layout, however now I prefer the vertical screen
The horizontal screen works better when you're stuck with only one screen, because it can manage to get that left side of the screen a little closer to the driver. It's also better for watching videos when parked. However if you've designed the vehicle sensibly with a second screen in front of the driver, and you're planning to use the vehicle more while driving than to watch videos while parked, the vertical screen is better in every way. I have the vertical screen in my model S, and the only time I would want horizontal is while parked at a supercharger and watching videos.
I dont have a cyber truck but would love to own one. I would suggest making a list of ALL the positive things with the cyber truck then do a comparison with any other truck.
I dont see real advantage with the hybrid. the mpg advantage isnt significant with it surprisingly. I suppose it depends on the price comparisons which im not sure of.
Today for the first time I've riden in a EV the F150 lightning on a test track I was highly impressed. The acceleration 0 to 60 in 4 sec is sick especially for a pick up. The handling while aggressive driving equally impressive. Its been a true opener and my skepticism almost all gone for the exception of the battery life and charging networks. Other than that performance was great and so was comfort it literally felt I could live in there thats how comfortable and spacious it was
For the rear view camera I don't get why they didn't just put what looks like a regular rear view mirror in the normal place but have it be a screen instead. These are common items already for people that don't have zero visibility in the back as is the case with the Cybertruck. It would be annoying to always have part of the screen used for this view and then it would get confusing to have that same spot on the screen switch to left or right when turning.
Because it's not available? I love how people keep harping on how wonderful this imaginary truck is, but when you can't buy it there's no point in testing it.
It seems like a wonky review. I understand that they did cover driving impressions, but they showed the Lightning and Rivian's range and 0-60 time, but spent more time on the Cybertruck's turning radius and voice operated wiper controls. It was similar to their silly harping on the Tesla Model S Plaid's yoke steering (which is now an option), but they missed the Plaid's unequaled combination of acceleration, comfort and economy for the price. The Foundation Edition Cybertruck's price is high, but it is easy to option a Ford F150 Lightning or Rivian up to that $100K price as well. My take is that this video is mostly just a temptation to go to their website to hopefully see the important comparative information, laid out more objectively.
Even before I hit 'Play' , I knew this would be the dumbest reivew....and I hit 'Play' anyways. I was proven right! The ntcase dinged Cybertruck unnecessarily. Cybertruck is quicker, more manueverable, more horsepower, has bigger bed, bigger payload, higher towing capacity etc etc but somehow it is neither good as a work truck nor as a lifestyle truck??? The guy offers zero analysis; his verdict is based on 'my kids love Rivian'. What a loser!
I echo your comment on the turning radius. How hard is it to put two chalk marks down and measure it? Seems like this is just clickbait - put 'Tesla Cybertruck' in the title for some extra clicks. Really lame 'review'/'comparison', I'd expect better from a 'top' name magazine but apparently Edmunds is not one of those. Unfortunately, I haven't seen the turning radius anywhere, not even in the CT manual. The only thing I've seen of late, is that they recently improved it by 1.9' in a software release.
oh maaaan now you gotta do an extra video to include the Silverado EV!! P.S. Tesla UI allowed you to pull out the wiper button onto the easy access bar. Yes, not as good as a button but not as bad as it was shown on the review.
my quick take on this actually great video: 1. if testing the storage of the trucks not within the cabin, surely you would stack them in the cybertruck as it clearly fits 4 more on top when the taneu is closed. 2. the rear steering is currently locked to 3% and will in future be unlocked on all trucks to 10% (not ok imo) 3. small but the camera on the screen can be dragged all of the way to the left of the screen, making it no more cumbersome than a rear-view mirror, still a great job on the video keep up the quality content
As shown previously, the ultimate test for trucks is tractor pulling. Now that both the Rivian and F-150 have been tested, it's time to test the Cybertruck.
Cybertruck easily wins the tractor pull test over the other two. Others have already done it and Edmunds doesn't want to pay just to make the Tesla look better. This is a joke of a review, carefully scripted to try to appear rational.
@@ZipZoomZip If you watched the tractor pull follow up video you would have found out that the determining factor is a combination of weight and power. The Cybertruck is lighter than either of the other options though it's faster. So will it prevail? That's what I want to know.
The Cybertruck has already outpulled the F-150 Lightning, even though it's lighter. Those All-Terrain tires might reduce the range a bit, but they give better traction in a tractor pull contest. Also, Tesla are well known to have great traction control delivery. My Model 3 Performance on snow and ice is just phenomenal, a real kick in the pants the way it can accelerate at the limits of traction. @@ryanehoward
And that's the worst feature of it. Even worse than the styling, even worse than the choice to put everything on one's touch screen in the center, even worse than the choice to go with stainless steel body panels. The worst feature is that it's a Tesla with all the horrible things that comes with like the worst customer service in the industry, the most expensive parts, the most maintenance, etc
Cybertruck is perfect for American market where people buy a truck not to use it like a truck just to get to work and back . Also a lot of people buy any car for look at this feeling . Prices will eventually come down like with every other Tesla .
@@UwU-235 You are so far off on both fronts and I dont own a Cyber or want one and not a yankees fan LOL. If you are an American please dont embarass the rest of us
@@brita654 you’re embarrassing America with your education. I was talking about regular trucks, not cyber. Cyber is yankee nonsense. You’re probably a yank with your inability to comprehend that when someone calls you a yankee, it’s not referring to the team
I keep hearing the argument about the steer by wire being compared to a commercial airliner. What' you don't realize, is that an airplane at 35.000 feet altitude, gives at least several minutes to try to solve a problem, before there's any risk of a crash. Driving down the freeway at speed, in heavy traffic, you only have a fraction of a second. I'm all for a mechanical coupling between the steering column and front end, so I can "muscle" it safely off the road, if there's an error.
The efficiency is the same between all three? I'm surprised by this. Maybe the other number worth comparing is profit margin. I'm not just being a troll (though I am trolling). But also I think it's important for people to know whether their choice is being subsidized.
@timothyharrison I'm not hearing "they have exactly the same efficiency" in any statement near there. "Roughly twice the electrons per mile as a Tesla Model 3" can mean a pretty wide range
@@BillyONeal Hard to say. If they were significantly different, I would have expected more commentary on that. As it is, I assume they're roughly the same. Which I'm surprised by. I saw another video somewhere explaining that the electric hummer was the most efficient for towing. I think because it's already a big box pushing air and adding more drag is insignificant. Adding drag to an aerodynamic vehicle destroys efficiency. But to hear that boxy pickups are the same as the angular cybertruck is surprising.
A reviewer's job isn't to picture what a product could be, it is to observe what the product in front of them is. And the Cybertruck doesn't even have basic autopilot right now, much less FSD.
I thought you said trucks. None of those is a truck. A truck tows heavy weights over long distances, can handle a full day the ranch hauling feed and mud, can handle all weather and temperatures without any loss of range or power, and isn't afraid of a battery fire after getting dinged up. A truck has no need for 0-60 speed. It needs to be easily leveled. It needs a wide bed and a strong gate. It needs to be easily repairable with easily sourced/fabricated parts because a truck is used to make money. It needs to have longevity and resale value, because there is an entire blue collar world of contractors, ranch hands, fruit/vegetable pickers, and other day laborers who need cheap, used trucks that they can run into the ground. None of these battery boxes is a useful truck. They are battery powered grocery getters that ought to have a minivan body style instead of oversized pickup styling. At least the Ford is making an effort to be a truck, I'll give em that. They tried to give it some pulling power, despite the complete and total range loss when maxed out. But those other two are a total joke.
The Cybertruck isn’t a work truck ?? We use them in our construction company and we love them. We always had F-150s but we can’t go back. My F-150 always sounds like the windows are down a little inside. The cybertruck sounds like I’m in my house. No more gas, oil change, spark plugs, radiators,mufflers, etc..
Even before I hit 'Play' , I knew this would be the dumbest reivew....and I hit 'Play' anyways. I was proven right! The ntcase dinged Cybertruck unnecessarily. Cybertruck is quicker, more manueverable, more horsepower, has bigger bed, bigger payload, higher towing capacity etc etc but somehow it is neither good as a work truck nor as a lifestyle truck??? The guy offers zero analysis; his verdict is based on 'my kids love Rivian'. What a loser!
I didn't see the video, I just imagined what the conclusion we could expect coming from Edmunds and voila! Nailed. Thats what a lost credibility look like.
The supercharging network is a big deal on trips, but that's going away when others use nacs. If Tesla actually had the range they originally stated, 500 miles, it would be a far easier 100k pill to swallow. Too many compromises at this point in time.
The CT is practical as a truck, drives like a car (until you get into a less specious situation) and soon it might even become an off-roaad machine after some updates. The price is the only issue
I have really considered a Rivian, there are two things holding me back. Both are mistakes that I made by buying a Tesla. The first is the lack of Android auto, that is such a game changer and I've had it in rental vehicles, I'll never buy another vehicle without it. The second is the vendor lock in for repairs. While I don't for a minute believe that Rivian could possibly be as bad as Tesla for this, the fact that they aren't allowing third-party repair, makes me worry that they are taking the Tesla approach of our way or the highway. In the Tesla that has resulted in the most expensive vehicle to maintain that I have ever owned, along with long delays to get parts or service appointments, and quite frankly incompetent mechanics. I also worry that there's nothing stopping them from following Tesla's lead by frequently removing paid for functionality through over the air software updates. That's not a worry that I have with legacy automakers, they are too risk adverse for that. So despite the fact that the Rivian would probably be the most appropriate of the three for my use, I've come to the conclusion that my next vehicle will likely be the lightning. (It doesn't hurt that the lightning is significantly cheaper, even in the platinum trim)
@@Green__one Rivian is a new company and its offerings are in the Vanguard and Adventurous! If you want to be safe and have the same old same old sure get a Lightning. I will look for you in my rearview mirror :) goofing aside, get behind the wheel of the R1T or R1S before you go bored, I mean Ford :) Re: Android. I’m an Apple guy, but I don’t have to have CarPlay. Maybe it will get more integrated at some point, but that is not gonna stop me from having fun! By 2027 we will have the R1S, R2 tri-motor and R3X tri-motor! Lotus, BMW, and Rover will be kept as estate cars, but driven much much less.
@@OneEarth-Forever I've been driving a Tesla since 2014, I have no problem with being in the vanguard of new technology. It's not the technology that worries me. It's the our way or the highway attitude that Tesla has, and that I'm worried Rivian is adopting as well. Despite the amazing vehicle, I regret my Tesla purchase every day, I really worry that Rivian is too much like Tesla in all the ways that I dislike. So as much as I like their offering, and as much as it does appear to be the most appropriate for my use case, I'm very hesitant to purchase one as I worry that it will be the same mistake I made on my Tesla. Maybe Rivian will surprise me, but until we start seeing their vehicles out of warranty, and until they've had a long history of software updates behind them, we won't get to see their true colors.
Everyone did each of those is piecemeal fashion. But putting all together for a price is what makes Cybertruck great. This rhetoric of A was faster, B was stronger, C was nimble gets old and boring....unless you can show A+B+C+... all in a single vehicle
I think I know which one I would get. You should do a door ding test in a Walmart parking lot for me to be sure though. I have a feeling two of them will be loosing some paint.
@@lpltBasically I think it's a combination of people being resistant to change, having opinions before trying it themselves, and disliking Musks tweets(politics) so therefore disliking anything he's connected to.
@@JSmooVE3990 Just curious which buttons do you prefer to be real ones? Tesla did add some buttons to the new Model 3 steering wheel which might help, including what appears to be a customizable button once it receives a software update.
Not surprisingly, the cheapest at the time of announcement and the most eccentric among them turned out to be both the most expensive and the most impractical... Instead, the same newcomer to the business of cars and pickups turned out to be both faster and cheaper. But the F150 is still the most practical from all angles! And this despite the fact that it is built only on the existing platform, which always causes a lot of inconvenience and complications for manufacturers and users. But not this time! I think out of the three, I'd go for the Ford, even though I was excited about the Cyberfake years ago...
LOL, so many butts hurt sheep in the comment section defending Tesla. For the money, I would buy an F150 at $40k if that is still available. But if I'm spending nearly $100k, I'm getting Rivian quality. Tesla feels like a high school project that got rushed at the end, incomplete.
The rivian had definitely more space left over even in that golf club holding compartment. Not for another box but you can squeeze extra stuff in there And both the Ford and the Tesla had room to file more boxes on top if you use straps to hold them down It's sad he didn't show a picture of him sitting in the Ford but he definitely had more headroom in the forward and the rivian
@@mikekasich836 The guy probably got reprimanded after they saw this video lol. And as a Lightning owner I would say the Chevy has them all beat at this point overall
So which of these three - the Cybertruck, the F-150 Lightning or the R1T - would you take home? Let us know in the comments!
Probably the rivian just for the tech,but if i wanted to stand out,the cybertruck would be the one id pick,but overall i will take the rivian,i love the cybertruck tho,i know many many pepole dont,but i do.
Rivian R1T for styling and performance and offroad usability. The F-150 Lightning for hard work/business
Lightning for me. Range is good and the bed is big enough for my surfboards.
The Ford for me, a Lariat for about $65k
F-150 Lightning is the one
Isn’t there literally a wiper button on the steering wheel of the cybertruck? ))))
Course there is. But it's Edmunds, it's more tabloid than expert and there's nothing wrong with that.
On the Cybertruck, there is a button on the steering wheel to turn on/off wipers. If you hold the button, it sprays the washer.
And you can change the wiper speed with the scroll wheel. Edmunds is a bad joke.
@@ZipZoomZip Not their car. It's a rental, but they should read the manual 1st 😀 At least they corrected the estimate range. Foundation has 301miles for beast and 318 for AWD due to A/T tires.
@@ZipZoomZipYou can also add the wiper button to the bottom of the screen. All those buttons are customizable.....
I think it was meant to point out the voice control accuracy. I certainly didn’t assume this was the only way to deal with the wipers based on this video.
What a mess of an interface!
My dad uses the Ford Lighting for construction. It saves him so much money on gasoline. The real answer to see which one is better is on ur usage.
The Ford lighting is great if you want a pickup truck but hate the price of gas. It still tows and carries alot.
The rivian seems like a Toyota Tacoma but electric. Small but does the job. Probably easier to park especially in the city with decent space to load things.
The cyber truck is meant for people who don't actually use a truck. It's more of a status symbol and I think the utility isn't there for most truck user.
There's literally a button on the wheel to control the wipers........
Edmonds surely doesn't have any bias at this point 😂
Is it labeled clearly?
@@gregkramer5588sure…
It's funny how many ppl are triggered by a little joke.
Not to mention having to move your head to check a blind spot, which is literally the definition of a blind spot. All 3 trucks you have to move your head to check them, all 3 trucks you need to take your eyes off the road to check speed, all 3 trucks require you to look to your right to see out the rearview. Also review cameras are way better, using the mirrors leaves massive blind areas.
@@woodypwxPretty sure it wasn't a joke. Somehow they didn't know there was a wiper button on the steering wheel.
oh man, after not finding wiper button on the steering wheel I cannot take this test seriously
Always something fishy against Tesla...
Even before I hit 'Play' , I knew this would be the dumbest reivew....and I hit 'Play' anyways. I was proven right!
The ntcase dinged Cybertruck unnecessarily. Cybertruck is quicker, more manueverable, more horsepower, has bigger bed, bigger payload, higher towing capacity etc etc but somehow it is neither good as a work truck nor as a lifestyle truck??? The guy offers zero analysis; his verdict is based on 'my kids love Rivian'. What a loser!
I was unable to locate the microwave oven.
Same
Moronic review. There is a wipers button on the steering wheel right in front of his eyes.
Love that you tested actual truck stuff like carrying cargo and bed storage. I am amazed how many reviewers gloss over this. Real world range is also very useful.
Most reviews gloss over payload capacity because the Tesla wins it by a country mile. Oh, wait, besides their fake "volume test" Edmonds glossed over the payload capacity too! Probably because the Cybertruck's 2500 lb. payload capacity leaves the other two in the dust.
Nobody carries cargo in boxes!
Even before I hit 'Play' , I knew this would be the dumbest reivew....and I hit 'Play' anyways. I was proven right!
The ntcase dinged Cybertruck unnecessarily. Cybertruck is quicker, more manueverable, more horsepower, has bigger bed, bigger payload, higher towing capacity etc etc but somehow it is neither good as a work truck nor as a lifestyle truck??? The guy offers zero analysis; his verdict is based on 'my kids love Rivian'. What a loser!
No actual towing, I didn't buy my truck just to drive to work. How well do they tow?
@matthewtruitt8077 I've towed various work trailers my entire life, but very rarely out of the local area. All the jobs I have taken are within an hour's drive (because it's difficult to make much money when you have to drive more than an hour each way, each day). But to answer your question, EV's have superior tow dynamics and safety, due to their great torque, responsive throttles, regen braking and solid heft with a very low center of gravity. You will not find tow dynamics like that in any gas or diesel vehicle. This will make towing even right up to the limit, a very easy and relaxing affair with superior control and stability.
Of the three EV trucks reviewed in this dumb comparison, the Cybertruck is going to be superior, due to its higher chassis rigidity, relatively long wheelbase and short rear overhang (distance from tow ball to rear axle).
Chassis rigidity is what prevents trailer sway from being amplified which is basically what happens with the traditional ladder frame. I have a 2010 F-150 and the trailer needs to be setup and properly balanced or you WILL get trailer sway with heavier trailers because the truck's chassis is very flexy. The Cybertruck, in comparison, will have almost zero chassis flex, like it is hewn from a single billet. It is more rigid than the chassis of a McLaren F1, even a heavy, improperly setup trailer is not going to experience every person's worst nightmare, trailer sway going out of control. That's what causes most loss of control events at highway speeds. Mind you, you still want your trailer reasonably well setup so it will have good braking and emergency avoidance dynamics, but the ability and benefits of a rigid chassis to dampen oscillations shouldn't be under-estimated. The Cybertruck will have a very tight, responsive ride, even when towing right up to its 11,000 lbs. tow limit.
Did you say countacK??
Yes, he did.
Coontash please
If you counted the gear tunnel in the Rivian with the boxes, did the Cybertruck get credit for carrying the boxes and the TV? I don’t think the Lightning or Rivian have a rear door that opens to 90°.
And they didn’t count the extra 3 stacked in the front of the bed and still allow full closure
The scratches on the Rivian.😢 Was it washed with sandpaper? Gosh.
Cybertruck review: "Quite usable".
People: "Shut up, the wiper button is right there, and take my $100K"
Isn’t there literally a wiper button on the steering wheel of the cybertruck? You don’t have to go to the screen nor use voice…
Yes, there is. And Edmunds knows it.
@@ZipZoomZip it wouldn’t be an Edmunds video on Tesla without some misinformation or making it look bad.
If they offer voice commands as a choice, then it should work probably actually work
Lightning for me. Range is good and the bed is big enough for my surfboards. 🤙
Go get one , they r rotting on ford’s lot
@@gz1876 "rotting" someone is salty
🙂@@gz1876
@@gz1876aluminium doesn't rot. Gotcha!
People will catch on that the Tesla chargers are available to ford lightning owners and at the price point the lightning will be the one to get. Rivian and Tesla are both too expensive and have too many unnecessary frills.
I have to crack up at all the comparisons of the dual motor Cyber truck v quadmotor Rivians. Not an apples to apples comparison.
Tri-motor won't stop it from still being spanked by Rivian off road.
For the Cybertruck, you missed counting the space under the bed (sub-trunk, where you can put ice or other things). That should be able to fit maybe 1 or 2 boxes there.
Then he need to talk about frunk of lightning and Rivian. CT will go to depression and probably commit suicide. So he don't want go there.
Uhh, that Lightning doesn't have the "max recline" seat option. The actual seats would have a different design and the bottom portion raises to be flush with back section.
It’s hard to get the wipers to work when you’re saying “wipas” 😂
Oh wow! I didn’t know that your channel was a Tesla advertisement for the cyber truck! I own a Ford F150, lightning, lariat extended range, and at the price point and the absolute quality Ford has put into this it is freaking amazing!, let’s face it how many service centers do you have for that Rivian, and Tesla cyber truck, and my ability to drive, five minutes to get to my Ford dealership a 10 year bumper to bumper warranty battery included (and yes, that includes the regenerative braking) (and let me tell you I have never had a problem with my Ford like me ever) yes it was extra, but I paid less than $70,000 There’s no comparison to the Rivian, or the cyber truck. Ford has waited and built Ford lightning, but they learn from every other electric vehicle before them, every mistake of every other electric vehicle. We waited three years. It is the Ford lightning the best vehicle I have ever owned in my life absolutely amazing. if you wanna spend 100+ thousand dollars. On a concept car from a manufacturer that will probably be out of business in 10 years. That’s your choice. But I can tell you that I own a brand new Ford F250 only for plowing my commercial properties, but I will never buy anything other than a Ford light. I’ve never been happier..
How does this guy not notice the button for the wiper next to the button he is pressing for the voice commands? Oh I get it, he needed to find someway to make the CT look bad... that makes more sense..
If I had the money, I would buy all three trucks! We use the F150 Lightning Platinum at work and it is GREAT! INSANELY BIG AND COMFORTABLE and is can STILL tow a typical 10,000 lbs worth of flat bed trailer with typical low-bed cargo for over 160 km (100 miles) on a single charge. For most urban and suburban environments that is more than enough for daily work and home use.
For off-road use, I would change the tires of the Rivian to 33 inch Goodyear Duratracs and it would just fine as my weekend warrior vehicle that goes into the back-country lakes and rivers for some fishing and carrying my ruggedized inflatable fishing kayak.
The Cybertruck is the vehicle I want to drive to the local city park for a BBQ with family and friends and use for the 2.5 hour drive to the local ski resorts (i.e. Whistler-Blackcomb from Vancouver!) blasting some 1980's era music all the way there while we sip on mocha lattes! It's a show-off vehicle for a company owner or local executive AND for the suburban mall crawler who wants some stylish comfort while driving over to park it for a few hours at the local mall or library!
V
Great review/comparison.
Just wanted to point out that you did search for other areas to get more cargo (boxes) into F150 and the Rivian, but did miss a point of storage in the end that you showed for a bit in the video. you could have fit more boxes in the far section of the Cybertruck bed and still closed the Vault. At least three and maybe four more boxes, thus making it the winner. And if you wanted to go crazy, the fold-up second row seats would have made this a total blowout!. Also, don't know if one box would have fit under the bed? In the end of your storage comments while you judged it barely being behind, you actually said "not much in it" about the Cybertruck. A bit harsh for your almost tie. Again... in the end it does hold more.
Thanks; and again, a very nice overall presentation.
For the voice command does it do better or worse with British accents? Haha I think the words “turn on” should be used rather than “switch” for the wipers. 6:10
Learn how to use the features before you feature them…..
I think the 48v system is revolutionary for the automotive market. Pretty daring in trying something new
How did Edmunds run their test to get 390 miles of range on the R1T? I've had my R1T (dual-motor, max-pack, 21” wheels) for about 3 months now and I'm calculating an average of about 335 miles of range in highway driving.
Their test isn’t just highway driving. It has a lot of around town, low speed driving.
Hate or love the CT, you need the applaud Tesla to have the balls to actually made it into production and not play it safe like almost every auutomakers out there.
No we don’t. It looks terrible and is 2x the price / significantly less range than what was announced.
@@TDog4444and sold out for years to come
@@TDog4444 True. But they have enough demand already. A 500 mile cybertruck was very possible just... not worth it for the company...yet.
Thankfully it showed all cars don't need to look the exact same as they've been doing for 30 years. Maybe other cars will start experimenting with different looks
@@hristog1997 I guess. I’ve had an invite to order and receive within a month for a “limited edition” variant. Apparently it hasn’t sold out yet….
To me it's not a comparison of the 3 cars but a review of the Tesla's product with a little bit of addition of other cars.
Isnt that rivian on all terrain tires? Why did you say that only the Cybertruck was?
They make a surprising amount of mistakes on a consistent basis. And that sucks because their presentation and ideas are great.
The Edmunds EV Range Test was performed on all season tires. It’s now on all terrain tires to facilitate another feature. We own this truck.
@@edmundscars which all seasons the 21s or the 22s? I think all of these details really matter.
There’s a button on the steering wheel for the wipers and he knows it, because it’s right next to voice command button.
Why is taking to the Tesla system when there is a wiper button on the steering wheel?
5:58 you REALLY should learn how to use the vehicle before attempting a review (or just call it a preview). The wiper controls are right there, at at thumbs reach, on the steering wheel. You turn them on with one push of a thumb, and you can use the left scroll wheel to change the intermittency speed.
Out of Spec Motoring did a Florida-Colorado race between these trucks last week. Video should drop any day.
Is this the first Tesla to beat its EPA figure on an Edmunds Range Test?
Tesla is the best car company ever no gas stations no oil changes no smog check no corrupt dealerships no catalytic converter no dealer mark up above MSRP!
Oh and I have a lot of Tesla stock!
I can tell you have a lot of Tesla stock. What I can also tell is that you don't drive a Tesla out of warranty. My model S has been the most expensive car to maintain that I have ever owned. And I've owned Mercedes S class and exotic imports. The lack of dealerships has been a major con, not a plus. It was the most painful purchase experience I've ever had, where they couldn't even tell me where my car was for several months, and this was for a car that was theoretically already built and sitting on their lot. They flat out lied about a majority of their features. They've consistently refused to honor their warranty, or their prepaid service plan. And they routinely remove functionality or degrade the user interface with nearly every software update while not allowing you to opt out of the updates.
I will never, under any circumstance, buy another Tesla as long as I shall live.
No corrupt CEO......oh wait....
2:32 great review, I did spend a lot of it thinking about that unique pronunciation😆
Go on for decades about the design of the Cybertruck... But respect is due here. It's a good truck and is very useful with lots of features. The Lightning and the R1T are great competitors. All are good investments.
Thanks for the review, Edmunds!
Weird how the ct was the only one to allow a stacked boxes in the back but they went with a flat test.
you have given so far the most solid advise i have heard. if you want a cybertruck, buy a cybertruck. can't be as simple, honest and straightforward as that.
Because let's be fair that's the only reason to buy one, it has no selling features beyond some people wanting one. It's worse at every single task, and you have to deal with the worst company on the planet when it comes to parts and service. It's also the most expensive, and the most expensive to maintain and operate. If you've ever owned a Tesla out of warranty you will know how absurdly expensive they are to keep on the road. Not to mention the hassle of even trying to get Tesla to honor their own warranties or contracts, or to get any repairs done in a timely fashion.
@edmundscars What tires do you have on the Lightning in this video (definitely not any of the stock options), and how do you like them?
A truck review where the trucks weren't tested off-road or towing, the two main reasons why people who actually need trucks buy trucks. This is basically a car review.
Actually it is a surprising fact that the majority of people who buy trucks buy them for commuting #1. The ability to tow and off road are nice perks. Towing is definitely not a good reason to buy one of these.
@@Cyber_Homestead if my F150 lightning lariat is a car I don’t think I’ve ever had a car that has 775 foot pounds of torque and has 580 hp and it’s four-wheel-drive with the rear, locking differentials, able to tow 12,000 pounds, maybe I’m missing something. that has more power than my brand new Ford F250 lariat that I used to plow with my F250 can tow more than my lightning, but the lightning can’t plow snow at this point so 50 to do my commercial properties since I bought the lightning I only drive my gas gasoline Ford F250 when I have snowstorms the average cars when I drove the 250 every day is $150 a week in gas. I think I’ll stick with my 50 extra dollars a month in electricity When I drive my lightning, every day, except for snow days And that’s how much my electric bill has gone up. that’s a savings. Of $550 a month in gas and that ain’t no bullshit.
@guyscribner I wasn't commenting on the truck, I was commenting on the horrible video. Maybe understand a comment before you waste your time rant about something completely unrelated?
@@guyscribner That is a serious savings and the #1 reason I bought the Lightning. Is it possible to put a plow on a Lightning?
@ I just had my 10,000 mile service in amounted to rotating the tires checking everything my 20,000 mile service is the same exact thing. I asked the dealership winter is coming should I get any different tires? They said no but I have all season tires, but I still am going to look into it a little bit. I’d like to have some thing with the better tread for ice studded snow tires
Which truck has more visibility without using cameras?
Which is easier to install ladder racks and/or tool boxes on?
Can any of the three have a utility bed or flatbed installed in place of the original bed?
If the battery pack failed today, which truck is cheaper to replace batteries on? Not including warranty.
Can any of the three be ordered without an infotainment touchscreen?
I have an F150 Lightning Lariat. It is basically an F150 with an electric battery. I love mine. It has plenty of visibility without using a camera. It has a 5 1/2 foot bed, and you could easily install ladder racks or toolboxes. You would have to ask the dealer about changing out the bed. If it could be done, the Ford is probably the one that it could be done on. The battery packs all have long warranties, eight years and 100,000 miles or thereabouts. battery reliability is likely to be high if the manufacturer is warranting that for such a long period of time. Obviously if your battery goes bad at nine years and 150,000 miles, it will be expensive to replace. Pretty much every new car on the road right now has an infotainment screen. It is a matter of how small you can get it. The basic trims on the F150 have a smaller screen.
Why would you want to remove the infotainment system?
@@BillyONeal lol
The risk with Rivian vehicles is that the company might not be around in a few years to give you warranty and spare parts.
For sure, they’re not doing well financially. As soon as the Cybertruck started delivery, sales dropped of a cliff
That's what was said about Tesla in the early days.
@@joshuagolden5194 You are correct; and Tesla almost went under, twice. Just because Tesla made it, does not mean that Rivian will. That is failed logic.
Rivian has Amazon money
@@off-roadingcars Time will tell
6:05, why is it Edmunds insists on not wanting to learn how Teslas function? You have had 10 years!
Just press the wiper button on the steering wheel and the screen menu comes up on the screen. You can even use the scroll wheels to switch the settings as well.
yep, once wiper button is pressed left scroll wheel side clicks let you change wiper speed or turn them off
Why not a 0-60 test on the cybertruck?
I have had the Lightning ER for about 6 months and still havent punched it. LOL. The power in these is insane and racing is not my gig. But when you need it there is no waiting or wondering when or what gear is going to show up. Or if theres going to be a puff of smoke signaling a possible problem
I definitely want the Cybertruck. I wish it had a video feed for the rear mirror and that the rear armrest was longer incorporating the middle headrest, or at least had 2 Qi phone chargers when down - like the Model S rear armrest.
IMO, the ford lightning seems to be the most practical. Its interior looks the best as well. The Rivian has a beautiful exterior design but has a smaller interior space. I would rank Ford in first place and the Rivian as runner up. I’m surprised that the ride quality in the cyber truck is better than in the others. My model 3 ride is quite harsh, even more so than in my Mach e. The cyber truck will appeal to those who want to be noticed and off course the fan boys
I want to love the Ford lightning but I just dislike the interior screen. For some reason I can't get over the vertical screen. I LOVE the frunk though.
About a year ago I was debating between the Rivian or Lightning but ultimately went with the lightning because of three main reasons:
1. . Rivian is a fairly new company and still has many obstacles to overcome not to mention we don't know what could happen to the company in years to come. With all startups especially in an inconsistent economy you have to be cautious.
2. . One underrated feature about the Lightning that many don't mention when comparing EVs is that because the lightning is based off the traditional F-150, a majority of parts and accessories are compatible. This makes the lightning one of the most easiest EVs to repair, mod, accessorize, and customize. Most EVs not based off a traditional design would require custom mods and accessories which would cost more not to mention that EV designs other than the lightning keep changing year by year making it impossible to create a market for a specific EV line.
3. . As of today, there are not a lot of Rivian dealerships or repair shops. This can pose a problem if there is an issue with the vehicle and you would need to tow or ship it across country to a Rivian location, meanwhile you can take your lightning to any Ford dealership at every corner of the country. This also affects your ability for mods and accessories too, especially the ones that require professional installation that would force you to ship your vehicle to have them installed.
@@connoravila5332 my Tesla model 3 screen has a horizontal layout vs the vertical orientation of my Mach E’s screen. It took a while to get used to the vertical layout, however now I prefer the vertical screen
The horizontal screen works better when you're stuck with only one screen, because it can manage to get that left side of the screen a little closer to the driver. It's also better for watching videos when parked.
However if you've designed the vehicle sensibly with a second screen in front of the driver, and you're planning to use the vehicle more while driving than to watch videos while parked, the vertical screen is better in every way.
I have the vertical screen in my model S, and the only time I would want horizontal is while parked at a supercharger and watching videos.
@@brandon8987 So true. And im not sure bout the Tesla repair shop availability either. I havent seen them out in the wild
The blind spot view can be moved anywhere on the screen except covering the speedometer.........
silly, there is a wiper button on the steering wheel
I dont have a cyber truck but would love to own one.
I would suggest making a list of ALL the positive things with the cyber truck then do a comparison with any other truck.
Lets he honest, the lighting is the only truck here that has a slight chance of not living life as a garage queen.
LOL that is funny but even as a Lightning owner its easy to see all 3 are not garage queens
I would say if you want a work truck, buy the hybrid F150. it has advantages over both the fully electric and the fully ICE.
I dont see real advantage with the hybrid. the mpg advantage isnt significant with it surprisingly. I suppose it depends on the price comparisons which im not sure of.
Today for the first time I've riden in a EV the F150 lightning on a test track I was highly impressed. The acceleration 0 to 60 in 4 sec is sick especially for a pick up. The handling while aggressive driving equally impressive. Its been a true opener and my skepticism almost all gone for the exception of the battery life and charging networks. Other than that performance was great and so was comfort it literally felt I could live in there thats how comfortable and spacious it was
For the rear view camera I don't get why they didn't just put what looks like a regular rear view mirror in the normal place but have it be a screen instead. These are common items already for people that don't have zero visibility in the back as is the case with the Cybertruck. It would be annoying to always have part of the screen used for this view and then it would get confusing to have that same spot on the screen switch to left or right when turning.
Why was the Silverado EV left out of this test? It is available and on the road now?
NOT a consumer production truck.
Because it's not available? I love how people keep harping on how wonderful this imaginary truck is, but when you can't buy it there's no point in testing it.
no talks about the stainsteel pros and toughness also how open it is to modifications having multiple outlets to install 3rd party gear.
Or the rust and panel gaps.
@@hwirtwirt4500 exactly how there is no rust and is surface dust like it shows in all white cars 😂
A fun easter egg to try: if you tap on the drivers-side windows on the 3D image of the Cybertruck in the infotainment screen, watch what happens.
They still call a flashlight a torch 😂 8:10
It seems like a wonky review. I understand that they did cover driving impressions, but they showed the Lightning and Rivian's range and 0-60 time, but spent more time on the Cybertruck's turning radius and voice operated wiper controls. It was similar to their silly harping on the Tesla Model S Plaid's yoke steering (which is now an option), but they missed the Plaid's unequaled combination of acceleration, comfort and economy for the price. The Foundation Edition Cybertruck's price is high, but it is easy to option a Ford F150 Lightning or Rivian up to that $100K price as well. My take is that this video is mostly just a temptation to go to their website to hopefully see the important comparative information, laid out more objectively.
Even before I hit 'Play' , I knew this would be the dumbest reivew....and I hit 'Play' anyways. I was proven right!
The ntcase dinged Cybertruck unnecessarily. Cybertruck is quicker, more manueverable, more horsepower, has bigger bed, bigger payload, higher towing capacity etc etc but somehow it is neither good as a work truck nor as a lifestyle truck??? The guy offers zero analysis; his verdict is based on 'my kids love Rivian'. What a loser!
I echo your comment on the turning radius. How hard is it to put two chalk marks down and measure it? Seems like this is just clickbait - put 'Tesla Cybertruck' in the title for some extra clicks. Really lame 'review'/'comparison', I'd expect better from a 'top' name magazine but apparently Edmunds is not one of those.
Unfortunately, I haven't seen the turning radius anywhere, not even in the CT manual. The only thing I've seen of late, is that they recently improved it by 1.9' in a software release.
oh maaaan now you gotta do an extra video to include the Silverado EV!! P.S. Tesla UI allowed you to pull out the wiper button onto the easy access bar. Yes, not as good as a button but not as bad as it was shown on the review.
Love the conclusion. Cybertruck is a class of its own!!
my quick take on this actually great video: 1. if testing the storage of the trucks not within the cabin, surely you would stack them in the cybertruck as it clearly fits 4 more on top when the taneu is closed. 2. the rear steering is currently locked to 3% and will in future be unlocked on all trucks to 10% (not ok imo) 3. small but the camera on the screen can be dragged all of the way to the left of the screen, making it no more cumbersome than a rear-view mirror, still a great job on the video keep up the quality content
If Tesla is going to ship the car to people paying 6 figures for it with the rear wheel steering locked to 3* it deserves to be judged that way.
Thrilling comparison
As shown previously, the ultimate test for trucks is tractor pulling. Now that both the Rivian and F-150 have been tested, it's time to test the Cybertruck.
Cybertruck easily wins the tractor pull test over the other two. Others have already done it and Edmunds doesn't want to pay just to make the Tesla look better. This is a joke of a review, carefully scripted to try to appear rational.
@@ZipZoomZip If you watched the tractor pull follow up video you would have found out that the determining factor is a combination of weight and power. The Cybertruck is lighter than either of the other options though it's faster. So will it prevail? That's what I want to know.
Not the ultimate test. If you set them up the same with regards to weight, hitch height and tires you would have a bit of knowledge.
Cybertruck already WON the tractor pull @ over 300 feet....lol😂
The Cybertruck has already outpulled the F-150 Lightning, even though it's lighter. Those All-Terrain tires might reduce the range a bit, but they give better traction in a tractor pull contest. Also, Tesla are well known to have great traction control delivery. My Model 3 Performance on snow and ice is just phenomenal, a real kick in the pants the way it can accelerate at the limits of traction. @@ryanehoward
Actually, there’s a dedicated button on the right side of the steering wheel for the wipers.
Is Tesla pronounced with a Z sound ? Tezla ?
great analysis! Sounds like it is really a Tesla...even without the badges
And that's the worst feature of it. Even worse than the styling, even worse than the choice to put everything on one's touch screen in the center, even worse than the choice to go with stainless steel body panels. The worst feature is that it's a Tesla with all the horrible things that comes with like the worst customer service in the industry, the most expensive parts, the most maintenance, etc
Cybertruck is perfect for American market where people buy a truck not to use it like a truck just to get to work and back .
Also a lot of people buy any car for look at this feeling .
Prices will eventually come down like with every other Tesla .
Hey, most trucks on the road aint pavement princesses. Dont compare yankees to Americans
@@UwU-235 You are so far off on both fronts and I dont own a Cyber or want one and not a yankees fan LOL. If you are an American please dont embarass the rest of us
@@brita654 you’re embarrassing America with your education. I was talking about regular trucks, not cyber. Cyber is yankee nonsense. You’re probably a yank with your inability to comprehend that when someone calls you a yankee, it’s not referring to the team
Happy to see the Rivian decimate the competition
And bank account. Ford is for real people rich or poor
what if the model 2 is a tesla elcamino a model 3 with a bed
Love my Rivian
There is a wiper button the steering wheel….. very easy
I keep hearing the argument about the steer by wire being compared to a commercial airliner. What' you don't realize, is that an airplane at 35.000 feet altitude, gives at least several minutes to try to solve a problem, before there's any risk of a crash. Driving down the freeway at speed, in heavy traffic, you only have a fraction of a second. I'm all for a mechanical coupling between the steering column and front end, so I can "muscle" it safely off the road, if there's an error.
The efficiency is the same between all three? I'm surprised by this. Maybe the other number worth comparing is profit margin. I'm not just being a troll (though I am trolling). But also I think it's important for people to know whether their choice is being subsidized.
Nowhere said the efficiency was the same.
@@BillyONeal 20:05.
@timothyharrison I'm not hearing "they have exactly the same efficiency" in any statement near there. "Roughly twice the electrons per mile as a Tesla Model 3" can mean a pretty wide range
@@BillyONeal Hard to say. If they were significantly different, I would have expected more commentary on that. As it is, I assume they're roughly the same. Which I'm surprised by. I saw another video somewhere explaining that the electric hummer was the most efficient for towing. I think because it's already a big box pushing air and adding more drag is insignificant. Adding drag to an aerodynamic vehicle destroys efficiency. But to hear that boxy pickups are the same as the angular cybertruck is surprising.
Finally a reviewer showing how stupidly useless the sloped Cybertruck bed is.
You're not picturing full autonomous driving with the Cybertruck.
A reviewer's job isn't to picture what a product could be, it is to observe what the product in front of them is. And the Cybertruck doesn't even have basic autopilot right now, much less FSD.
I'm looking forward to the CyberTruck: DVD Edition
Only need 15:58 1 F-150 to Cary 27 boxes and 2 Rivian and 2 Cybertrucks to do the same.
I thought you said trucks. None of those is a truck. A truck tows heavy weights over long distances, can handle a full day the ranch hauling feed and mud, can handle all weather and temperatures without any loss of range or power, and isn't afraid of a battery fire after getting dinged up. A truck has no need for 0-60 speed. It needs to be easily leveled. It needs a wide bed and a strong gate. It needs to be easily repairable with easily sourced/fabricated parts because a truck is used to make money. It needs to have longevity and resale value, because there is an entire blue collar world of contractors, ranch hands, fruit/vegetable pickers, and other day laborers who need cheap, used trucks that they can run into the ground.
None of these battery boxes is a useful truck. They are battery powered grocery getters that ought to have a minivan body style instead of oversized pickup styling.
At least the Ford is making an effort to be a truck, I'll give em that. They tried to give it some pulling power, despite the complete and total range loss when maxed out. But those other two are a total joke.
Let’s be honest-This was a Cybertruck video with a little Rivian and Lightning sprinkled in.
Your conclusion is spot on. Buy a Cybertruck if you don't really want or need a truck, but want people to notice you
Thing is, as much as they say that all publicity is good publicity, people will notice you, but they won't have the positive opinion you expect!
Are you going to analyze the technology?
The Cybertruck isn’t a work truck ??
We use them in our construction company and we love them. We always had F-150s but we can’t go back. My F-150 always sounds like the windows are down a little inside. The cybertruck sounds like I’m in my house. No more gas, oil change, spark plugs, radiators,mufflers, etc..
You full of shit. No company is buying Cybertrucks for construction.
@@kylestewart8354- see, Cybertruck owners club, reservation tracker.
Even before I hit 'Play' , I knew this would be the dumbest reivew....and I hit 'Play' anyways. I was proven right!
The ntcase dinged Cybertruck unnecessarily. Cybertruck is quicker, more manueverable, more horsepower, has bigger bed, bigger payload, higher towing capacity etc etc but somehow it is neither good as a work truck nor as a lifestyle truck??? The guy offers zero analysis; his verdict is based on 'my kids love Rivian'. What a loser!
Bullshit, no construction company is buying this for work.
@@RedRyz3nI agree. Construction company using cybertruck? 😂😂😂
I didn't see the video, I just imagined what the conclusion we could expect coming from Edmunds and voila! Nailed. Thats what a lost credibility look like.
For everyday practicality and minimal overkill, easy winner...Ford Lightning.
The supercharging network is a big deal on trips, but that's going away when others use nacs. If Tesla actually had the range they originally stated, 500 miles, it would be a far easier 100k pill to swallow. Too many compromises at this point in time.
The CT is practical as a truck, drives like a car (until you get into a less specious situation) and soon it might even become an off-roaad machine after some updates. The price is the only issue
Bro there is a wiper button on the Cybertruck steering wheel. You know that.
The Rivian R1S, R2, R3 and R3X have my attention!! #Rivian #AdventurousForever #EV
Why ? Rivian is going BANKRUPT in 2025.
I have really considered a Rivian, there are two things holding me back. Both are mistakes that I made by buying a Tesla. The first is the lack of Android auto, that is such a game changer and I've had it in rental vehicles, I'll never buy another vehicle without it. The second is the vendor lock in for repairs. While I don't for a minute believe that Rivian could possibly be as bad as Tesla for this, the fact that they aren't allowing third-party repair, makes me worry that they are taking the Tesla approach of our way or the highway. In the Tesla that has resulted in the most expensive vehicle to maintain that I have ever owned, along with long delays to get parts or service appointments, and quite frankly incompetent mechanics.
I also worry that there's nothing stopping them from following Tesla's lead by frequently removing paid for functionality through over the air software updates. That's not a worry that I have with legacy automakers, they are too risk adverse for that.
So despite the fact that the Rivian would probably be the most appropriate of the three for my use, I've come to the conclusion that my next vehicle will likely be the lightning. (It doesn't hurt that the lightning is significantly cheaper, even in the platinum trim)
@@Green__one Rivian is a new company and its offerings are in the Vanguard and Adventurous! If you want to be safe and have the same old same old sure get a Lightning. I will look for you in my rearview mirror :) goofing aside, get behind the wheel of the R1T or R1S before you go bored, I mean Ford :)
Re: Android. I’m an Apple guy, but I don’t have to have CarPlay. Maybe it will get more integrated at some point, but that is not gonna stop me from having fun! By 2027 we will have the R1S, R2 tri-motor and R3X tri-motor! Lotus, BMW, and Rover will be kept as estate cars, but driven much much less.
@@OneEarth-Forever I've been driving a Tesla since 2014, I have no problem with being in the vanguard of new technology. It's not the technology that worries me. It's the our way or the highway attitude that Tesla has, and that I'm worried Rivian is adopting as well. Despite the amazing vehicle, I regret my Tesla purchase every day, I really worry that Rivian is too much like Tesla in all the ways that I dislike.
So as much as I like their offering, and as much as it does appear to be the most appropriate for my use case, I'm very hesitant to purchase one as I worry that it will be the same mistake I made on my Tesla. Maybe Rivian will surprise me, but until we start seeing their vehicles out of warranty, and until they've had a long history of software updates behind them, we won't get to see their true colors.
Didn’t Infiniti do Steer-By-Wire a decade ago?
They did, but I was still connected to a steering column as a redundancy. CT has no physical connection.
Everyone did each of those is piecemeal fashion. But putting all together for a price is what makes Cybertruck great. This rhetoric of A was faster, B was stronger, C was nimble gets old and boring....unless you can show A+B+C+... all in a single vehicle
Cybertruck anyday .. It's not even a competition ❤
Why leave out the Hummer?
I think I know which one I would get. You should do a door ding test in a Walmart parking lot for me to be sure though. I have a feeling two of them will be loosing some paint.
At least they have paint. That silver look is not terribly attractive
10 years after still complaining about "all the buttons on the screen" never heard a real person who owns it complain
Pretty much the only people complaining are those who have never given them a real try.
@@wemakecookie but i guess its "cool" to hate on the new company that became the most valuable in no time
I got used to my Tesla screen but I've since gone back and real buttons are objectively better for certain things.
@@lpltBasically I think it's a combination of people being resistant to change, having opinions before trying it themselves, and disliking Musks tweets(politics) so therefore disliking anything he's connected to.
@@JSmooVE3990 Just curious which buttons do you prefer to be real ones? Tesla did add some buttons to the new Model 3 steering wheel which might help, including what appears to be a customizable button once it receives a software update.
I notice palm trees in the background. How about you test it in North Dakota in winter?
But that would require going to North Dakota. Wouldn’t wish that on anyone
Those are AI palms.
Not surprisingly, the cheapest at the time of announcement and the most eccentric among them turned out to be both the most expensive and the most impractical...
Instead, the same newcomer to the business of cars and pickups turned out to be both faster and cheaper.
But the F150 is still the most practical from all angles! And this despite the fact that it is built only on the existing platform, which always causes a lot of inconvenience and complications for manufacturers and users. But not this time!
I think out of the three, I'd go for the Ford, even though I was excited about the Cyberfake years ago...
I didn't know Joel McHale was British. Wait. I watched lots of episodes of Talk Soup. Why didn't he have a British accent back then? This is crazy.
6:20 Wiper*
Cybertruck for the win! What a great review. Please keep them coming.
Silverado comparison?
LOL, so many butts hurt sheep in the comment section defending Tesla. For the money, I would buy an F150 at $40k if that is still available. But if I'm spending nearly $100k, I'm getting Rivian quality. Tesla feels like a high school project that got rushed at the end, incomplete.
The rivian had definitely more space left over even in that golf club holding compartment. Not for another box but you can squeeze extra stuff in there
And both the Ford and the Tesla had room to file more boxes on top if you use straps to hold them down
It's sad he didn't show a picture of him sitting in the Ford but he definitely had more headroom in the forward and the rivian
@@mikekasich836 The guy probably got reprimanded after they saw this video lol. And as a Lightning owner I would say the Chevy has them all beat at this point overall