Did Casio Copy Tissot? - New “PRX Clone” Seems Too Good To Be True…
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 มิ.ย. 2024
- Use code 'BensWatchClub' for 15% off at DailyWatch.co here: bit.ly/BWCDailyWatchCo
🛒 WATCHES FEATURED (Affiliate)
Casio MTP-B145D 'PRX' Turquoise ➡ geni.us/casiomtp-b145d
Casio 'PRX' Pink ➡ geni.us/casiomtp-b145pink
Casio 'PRX' Blue ➡ geni.us/casiomtp-b145blue
Casio 'PRX' White ➡ geni.us/casiomtp-b145white
Casio 'Datejust' MTP-1302 Turquoise ➡ tidd.ly/481qfgq
In this Casio MTP-B145 review video, I analyze the new Casio Tiffany blue watch, which looks like a Tissot PRX killer...or copy! The B145, codenamed as B145D, is a good-looking watch for sure, but is it actually stainless steel? The particular versions reviewed are the turquoise mtp-b145d-2a1vef and salmon pink mtp-b145d-4avef.
How Would You Rate This Watch? (Click to Vote)
||||||||||||.................. 40% ⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5 Star yt.strms.net/2CXYk
|||||......................... 14% ⭐ ⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4 Star yt.strms.net/BWNfC
|||||......................... 15% ⭐ ⭐⭐⭐ 3 Star yt.strms.net/7VfpD
|||||......................... 15% ⭐ ⭐⭐ 2 Star yt.strms.net/EDvd3
|||||......................... 15% ⭐ ⭐ 1 Star yt.strms.net/pjY8G
⌚ Best watches shortlist ➡ www.benswatchclub.com/favorites
☝️ Suggest a watch for review ➡ www.benswatchclub.com/suggest...
🎬 Chapters
0:00 A Casio Datejust Warning!
0:36 If Only...
1:37 Introducing the...PRX Clone?
2:41 Sizing
3:10 Concerns...
4:52 How Much?
5:28 Design/Looks
5:48 Improved Dial
6:43 Movement
7:09 Bracelet...good luck!
8:06 Is It Actually Steel?
10:08 Alternatives?
10:44 Ratings/Scores
📺 Related videos
Casio Datejust Review: • Think Twice Before Buy...
Most Underrated Casio: • Is This The Most UNDER...
👀 Subscribe: bit.ly/Sub2BensWatchClub
💪 Get early access to videos: / benswatchclub
✍ Read the full article here: www.benswatchclub.com/blog/ca...
⌚ Our blog: benswatchclub.com/start-here
🌐 Socials: linktr.ee/benswatchclub
#
🎼 Music
Epidemic sound: www.epidemicsound.com/referra...
Mitsubachi by Smith The Mister smiththemister.bandcamp.com Smith The Mister bit.ly/Smith-The-Mister-YT Free Download / Stream: bit.ly/mitsubachi Music promoted by Audio Library • Mitsubachi - Smith The...
🚨 Disclosures
I use affiliate links when linking products in the video description. Ben's Watch Club is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. We also utilize affiliate programs with retailers such as Jomashop, Aliexpress, WatchShop, and more. Please assume any product links could be affiliated.
How we work with brands: bit.ly/HowWeWorkWithBrands - แนวปฏิบัติและการใช้ชีวิต
Use code 'BensWatchClub' for 15% off at DailyWatch.co here: bit.ly/BWCDailyWatchCo
🛒 WATCHES FEATURED (Affiliate)
Casio 'PRX' Turquoise ➡ geni.us/casiomtp-b145d
Casio 'PRX' Pink ➡ geni.us/casiomtp-b145pink
Casio 'PRX' Blue ➡ geni.us/casiomtp-b145blue
Casio 'PRX' White ➡ geni.us/casiomtp-b145white
Casio 'Datejust' MTP-1302 Turquoise ➡ tidd.ly/481qfgq
304 stainless steel is not magnetic at all. The magnet was likely just attracted to something ferromagnetic in the Casio's movement and push pins in the bracelet. Most stainless steels aren't magnetic at all (only a few niche grades). A quick google would have shown this.
Spot on. I was gonna comment the exact same thing...... You beat me to it !!!!
Exactly this! This needs to be shown at the top. Austenitic stainless steel (which 304 is) is never magnetic, as opposed to ferritic and some times martensitic steels (400 series)
This comment is a materials scientists dream. Thank you.
ok, 300 series of stainless steel is austenitic meaning the crystal orientation is non-magnetic. 400 series stainless steels are martensitic meaning they are magnetic. this atomic orientation is what dictates magnetism. series has nothing to do with quality like the commenter below says about welding, but has everything to do with application. 316 and 316l are used because of the low nickel content, nickel is an irritant to skin.
I’d rather have this watch than the PRX (quartz version) any day!
A magnet alone cannot tell if it's stainless steel: it depends on how much and how the ferrite is deposited in the grain matrix. If interested, Schaeffler diagram.
Thanks for dropping the knowledge!
I’d say the real inspiration for this Casio are the late 70s quartz Seikos, their Silverline, QT, SQ, Lord Quartz and Grand Quartz lines. The branding was all over the place back then but the design language was consistent and this Casio throws back to it.
The magnet test on the stainless steel relates to my job. In construction, we are told that the stronger attraction means a cheaper stainless. No attraction means a high grade. I've often heard this from welders.
It's not always true. The Duplex stainless steel for example can be really expensive and it's magnetic. The magnetic ones are the martensitic, duplex and ferritic, but not the austenitc ones.
Depends strongly on the field ur in. I can give u steel thats not even stainless but would outperform v4a in terms of magnetization levels.
generally the more chromium the less magnetic the stainless is,
It is not about “higher” grades, it’s about choosing the best material for the application based on the characteristics of the material and intended use.
Simplest grades require 12 percent chromium this is ferritic and hence magnetic. If you want a seawater grade nickel needs to be added thats more expensive and makes the steel austenitic - not magnetic. Duplex is in a mix usually 50/50 ferritic/austenitic and therefore magnetic due to the 50 percent ferrite.
Austenitic 304 steels are generally soft and sea water corrosion resistant - and not magnetic.
Choosing the proper steel grade is due to requirements and cost. 904 for example utilises addition of molybdenium also.
Austenitic steels are soft and hence more difficult to polish and keep sharp edges.
Steel feels cold because of its high thermal conductivity. Sitting on a wooden table, both the table and the steel will trend toward room temperature, which is cooler than your skin temperature. But the wood doesn't feel cold because its conductivity is low, so the warmth of your skin flows into it at about the same rate you are used to with the surrounding air. But when you pick up a piece of steel, its higher conductivity causes your body heat to flow into it relatively quickly, and it will feel cold. However, the mass of the steel affects how much total heat it can absorb and so how much of that "coldness feeling" it can generate. A paperclip is just as conductive as a kitchen knife, but because it has so little mass, it can't absorb very much heat before it's basically the same temperature as your skin, so the paperclip won't feel as cold the way a steel object with more mass will.
My guess with this watch not feeling "cold" or not feeling as cold as some of your other watches is that it's just made with a lesser quantity of steel and so, like the paperclip, it can't absorb enough heat to give you a strong sensation of it being cold.
I paid 60 $ for the pink one. For the price I think it's a really nice watch.
I saw the Tiffany one for 45£ in a mall in London. Sadly I did not have my wallet with me
@@aminabellalvaradoaguero9190 that's
That's how much I paid. It's gorgeous.
@@aminabellalvaradoaguero9190why would you need a wallet when apple pay exists
The magnet is likely attracted to either the magnetic rotor or the stepper motor in the quartz module.
This watch looks a million times better on the bracelet that comes with the A700. The straight lines really complement the design.
Can you simply put on the other?
@@Finn959 I have a A1000M-1BVT and I use my MTP with that milanese bracelet. I did the positive display mod on the A1000 with a A700W-1A and the linked-line bracelet from it that he mentions fits on my A1000 and MTP. There is a video on TH-cam comparing the A1000 and A700WEM-7AEF which has the milanese band instead called "Battle of the Casio Milianese" that compares those bands, the one on the A1000 is a bit better quality with thicker milanese chains but the A700 bracelet is still good. I think the milanese band from the black A1000 or the newer silver A1000MA-7EF looks awesome with its taper and it is infinitely adjustable, same as the A700's. The A1000 bracelet also has quick release spring bars which the A700s do not have, I use it all the time to switch between my watches as this bracelet fits on a lot of Casio's like my A500WA-7 as well. Casio has a lot of watches that take an 18mm lug bracelet that steps out to about 21mm, so if you like either the A1000M-1BVT or A1000MA-7EF, you can use the bands on other Casios, its the best band of that style that they make with quick release spring bars to swap easily...
@@Finn959did you find out? 😅
@@redhood2046 no😁 but i got the prx clone casio nonetheless and love it
@@Finn959 nice, i just ordered my so thats why i was wondering 😅
I have the petrol blue version and absolutely love it. But after seeing your review I'm tempted to say the pink version (which really looks more "Salmon" than "Barbie") looks even better! Tiffany however is so yesterday!
Please can you tell me any solution for the hair pull problem in this watch? I recently bought the red dial one and honestly the wrist hair pull is annoying me sm
@@suprith3072 My solution was to swap the bracelet for a third party F-91W rubber strap from Ali.
304 is not magnetic NORMALLY. But when you work on it (pull it, bend it etc...) it may become magnetic. The best example is your kitchen sink - the most of it will not attract a magnet, but the bottom corners may attract a magnet.
Accurist origin would be a great PRX alternative, would appreciate a review of one of those.
300 series stainless, like 304 and 316, is an austenitic stainless steel and is non magnetic.
Broadly speaking, stainless can be divided into the non-hardenable, more corrosion resistant, and non-magnetic types like the 300 series, and hardenable, magnetic, and slightly less corrosion resistant grades like the 400 series used for cutlery.
"It can be a plucker!" Love it! Have a great Christmas Ben and thanks for all the entertainment in 2023!
Ben, did you consider making a video or tow on skmei watches they seam okay for the money (dirt cheap) I am sure they are not super quality , I am mostly a casio guy, but I have been eyeing with theas for a while .and just ordered one for £18 just for fun, but who knows ..
It would be fun to see you dive in to this .
Thank you for all the quality content!
The quality will still be better than the swatch over priced plastic which, my opinion
T-304 is famously used in Borla aftermarket exhaust systems for its million-mile corrosion resistance warranty. I have one of their axle-back muffler kits on my car.
Hey, Ben, will you do a review of the ceramic Braun watch? It's rather unique and there aren't many videos about it online.
There are different types of stainless steel. Austenitic, Martensitic, Duplex and Ferritic. The austenitic (304) ones are not magnetic because of the austenitic composition.
The EFRS108D-2BV is a much better value for money. For a little bit more, you actually get a solid watch, Stainless steel, 10ATM, Sapphire crystal.etc.
And it comes in olive green! Such a nice watch, so I bought it directly from casio at launch MSRP
I have the black one and you can fit a 35mm PRX strap or bracelet to the Edifice, almost seamlessly. You only need 1.5mm thick, 16mm long spring bars. I got the black strap but will also get the white and the solid link bracelet. It's now a PRX killer for 1/3 of the price
It really is a better one. I've been eyeing it for a while now.
304 stainless steel is more to food grade steel more on thermos vacuum flask or kitchen appliances. It conduct heat faster and retain heat longer than normal stainless steel.
2 videos from my favorite watch youtuber within a week! Heck yeah!
As an alternative to PRX or this Casio I recommend the Seiko V743 9020 circa 2000. Good examples can be found for £50 and the watch has a quality feel.
It does seem from looking at specs that the older colour variants weigh more, so could be they cheaped out with the new ones.
What a great video. Thanks for the reassurance over the case material.
In my view, it's most similar to the 1989 MMW-80. While the MMW-80 394 had date and day of the week, it is otherwise extremely similar.
Can you also review some of the titan watches as well?
Like the titan steller collection?
Ben, check out the Edifice EFR-S108D, an actual good tiffany integrated bracelet watch. Plus, a 35mm PRX strap fits almost seamlessly
That's true Casio God Tier release. It is astonishing value for its money
I believe he already did: th-cam.com/video/5yqjULfrd3A/w-d-xo.htmlfeature=shared
@@ichinonamae yes but Casio released new colors at the end of last year, and now it's available in Tiffany blue. The Edifice can actually go head to head with the quartz PRX at 1/3 of the price
Is the Edifice a good fit for small wrists? The MTP-B145D and smaller PRX have 35mm dials which is perfect for small wrists
@@undercovermc yes, the Edifice is 37mm in "diameter" but it's more compact in lug to lug. It wears nicely on my 6.5" wrist, unlike a 40mm PRX
I hate that they slapped “WR 50M”right on the dial.
Ben has an unboxing channel?? How did I not know this??
Been waiting for this one! Sold my gold 40mm PRX which was too big and got this in gold, it’s great.
Prx has a 35mm version
Casio doesn’t make bad watches. Everything they produce has a certain level of quality and practicality. Despite it being the most sold watches in the world, ironically it’s also the most underrated.
Should i buy this one or the seiko snxs77
304 is used commonly in food items like steel plates and some thermos (not the brand) and baking sheets etc
I have a seiko grand quarts from the late 70s that has the exact same hooded lugs with chamfered edges.
where can i buy a bracelet for this watch like prx style made of steel?
I have this watch, I’ve never had this much trouble adjusting the size of the bracelet. There is another Casio I’m passing on because it has the same bracelet
what is the brown watch at 10:31
Any idea why there’s DW on the back case?
Love how the teal one seconds hand is off and the pink one is spot on. lol
Do keep in mind, not all stainless steel is ferrous enough to hold a magnet. My fridge at home won't take any magnets at all.
Wish the Casio more dial color options.
It's a nice looking watch combined with the 35 mm sizing 👍🏼
While it’s not in the same price bracket, casio edifice released a 40mm, sapphire glass watch with a solid integrated bracelet and clasp for £120. For a £50 difference, I don’t think this release makes sense in terms of build
Can you share the model number for this Edifice? I'd much prefer that. Thank you!
@@jeptime657it's EFR-S108D-2B
@@jeptime657 efr-s108d and the last numbers are the colors. Comes in black, white, and the new tiffany, olive green, and blue.
@@jeptime657 Edit: the clasp is not milled, I am thinking of another watch but the reference is efb-108d. Regularly found around £100 tho
any strap options??
Love you videos, I have a question i want a casio that i can wear with any outfit. I am thinking about duro what more casios do you suggest under 100$
Take a look at the casio edifice EFR-S108D-2AV, it would be a great watch to wear with any outfit
@@HARIHARAN-ow6bwAbsolutely second this, one of the best watches I own
EFB-108 is another lovely $100 Casio, gorgeous integrated bracelet, sapphire crystal, lovely brushed finishing. Only comes in Black and Silver/White, but really comfortable and a nice sports watch look.
@@thebitterfig9903No no, three new colors have been released, Tiffany, olive green and blue.
I have the olive green one, its so great, with sunburst and all.
Please mention the band width/lug strap width for these watches as most of the customers replace the band with better one.
Damn, just get a quartz PRX for $250 okay maybe not Tiffany blue but I'd consider most other colors an upgrade.
Out of interest then. What's a more substantial watch at this price?
Stainless steel can be grouped into 5 different types. Some are magnetic but most are not.
Listening to you I bought the vintage gunmetal A168WEGG-1BEF from UK, paid the unreasonable price for it l, paid the visa tax for it as well.
Did Tissot copy AP. At this point both are cheap and affordable “knock offs.” They all take inspiration from the Royal Oak. This is why we don’t say things without actual knowledge on the subject.
Better buy the edifice Tiffany, will cost you few extra bucks but sapphire glass and way better durability
Stainless steel is a blanket name in a sense as there are different types of stainless steel. Austenitic stainless steels are non-magnetic due to high levels of austenite.
Hey Ben,
Love the channel but I just had to drop you a note. As a professional watchmaker and certified Machinist I can tell you that the two main alloys used in watchmaking of stainless steel, 316 and 304, are not ferromagnetic and will not stick to magnets.
I have a sizable chunk of 316 in my machine shop and a magnet won't even try to stick to it. It's about as magnetic as the aluminum and brass stock I have. The magnet has no problem sticking to the cast iron of my milling machine.
With the magnet sticking to the bracelet and the watch back, it's probably not actually sticking to the stainless but it's attracted by the pins in the bracelet and the plain steel components in the watch movement.
Also sticking magnets to watches is incredibly bad frm even if it's a quartz. I don't think a magnet will hurt a quartz watch but knowing mechanical watches like I do it makes me really uneasy even to see it happen 😬
Hope this helps. The non-magnetic nature of the case actually makes me think it probably is stainless, though of course nickel plated brass is not particularly magnetic either 😂
Add on comment: the magnet is probably attracted to the pins in the vostok bracelet not the links themselves.
And can we as a watch family stop referring to stainless steel as just "steel"? It makes my head hurt.
I have also used a casio mtp 1374 which was purchased back on 2018 also has sus304. Actually casio produces some of the best affordable watches.
The “WR50M” dial printing is just terrible.
interesting. ive just picked up Accurist's Origin 34mm in quartz, which would be a direct competitor to this watch, for £80 direct from Accurist. It has sapphire to casio's mineral glass, and a much nicer bracelet with solid links and quick release. Also a superior 100m WR to this casio's 50, while using a comparable Miyota movement. Also came in a nice faux saffino leather 2 watch travel roll, which would be a nice thing to have for anyone entering the hobby. depending on colour choice you can even have a waffle dial, something you only get on the powermatic 80s with the PRX.
I know you've previously covered an Accurist on the channel, but I think you might want to give their Origin line a look.
I can’t find an origin anywhere for £80 new
@@EbbaukX i got mine new from Accurist's own website before christmas
For me this casio will be great if she were an automatic...if seiko,orient or citizen have quartz and also automatic i dont understand why casio never made one,they will probably increase more the sucess of the brand with automatic and economic models...please casio think about it
whats the watch at 1:21?
Your investigation into if this watch was made out of steel was extremely good! I love your deep dive no BS investigations where you actually look into if marketing claims are true, makes such a huge difference for consumers looking to not get hoodwinked!
Investigating when no watch is magnetic is kind of a joke
Yes I agree Ben does a great job outing the BS. Unfortunately, in this case a simple google search would have told him stainless steel is largely non magnetic bar a few lesser used grades. I guess we can all make mistakes, a shame nonetheless.
closer to the Seiko SQ100 in style
watching this and look how those swiss brand pricing.. how important is marketing
Do magnets stick to stainless steel?
Austenitic stainless steels, which are commonly used in household appliances, contain nickel and are generally non-magnetic. Ferritic and martensitic stainless steels, on the other hand, contain higher amounts of iron and are magnetic.
nickel is magnetic.
I believe the higher level of chromium content in the stainless steel prevents it from being magnetic. Similar to a stainless steel refrigerator
Pls make a review on GELTIER watches
Anyone who likes this watch, consider looking at the Casio EFR S-108d, it has also got a Tiffany model recently.
The Tiffany blue looks a bit odd on the Edifice imo...i prefer this more streamlined effect.
@@PETERJOHN101 thats why you buy the real gem, the sunburst olive green one 😉
@@NotASeriousMoose I have the white / silver one and the brushed dial looks so good
304 stainless steel is more magnetic than 316 stainless steel due to it not having molybdenum which is present on the 316 variant. Though both 304 and 316 stainless steel are austenitic in nature.
I foresee eBay being full of Tiffany dials 5 years from now
I think for the price it is totally acceptable. Thanks for the vid.
Blasphemy! Casio doesn't copy *anyone. Casio is inspired by.
Yeah casio make better but also cheaper, I will buy this next month iam excited.
Ben, the 70’s Seastar you have in this video is not the PRX predecessor.
Initially I bought one, then cancelled it...too hasty in my decision. Besides 35mm kills it for me.
Is it men's or women's watch? Or unisex?
My experience with NKUWAN was fantastic. The watch arrived quickly and was exactly as described.
As to whether SS is magnetic or not, depends upon the proportion of Carbon vs Nickle mix of the SS.
The more Carbon the more magnetic, the lower the grade of SS.
Excellent review as usual with great production value, thank you very much Ben.
But unfortunately this Casio "PRX clone" is just one of the cheapest watches Casio could possibly put together in a remote Chinese factory.
I cannot even vaguely fathom why anybody would fork out $50 or more for one, but that's just me. Just shows again that people will buy just about any crap watch as long as there is a marketing campaign for it MoonSwatch .
The biggest thing for me is the WR 50M font, it looks so cheap, horrible 😢
Maybe they'll buy it as a beater lightweight watch?
Can the links be removed?
you can tell by the brushing that it's stainless steel. Chrome plating never has that fine brushing.
Good point! Clever.
Ben, please use moisturizer :D
You should review benyar watch
If you've ever used an induction stove top you will know that many older pns are obsolete because they are not magnetic, stainless steel in itself generally isn't magnetic. I bet you a pound to a penny with a watch is stainless both probably rice paper thin Which is not really a problem but if it's low mass it won't have any heat retaining or resisting ability.
At least the hands are not short with this one.
I have noticed that as i get into watches, unless a watch has a giant dragon on it or something then its a copy of something else lol
My father gifted me a casio watch, that looks just like the PRX. This happened about 20 years ago.
casio watch is my edc and alot of people love the way it looks
I really don’t like the font choice Casio uses for the water resistance 🤨
It looks more like an rolex oysterquartz actually
loving both of them😅
That nasty "WR 50M" ruins the dial
in brazil, this little boi costs A THOUSEND REALS. The brazilian minimum wage its ~ R$ 1.400/mo
Dont get me wrong but with the a little more you get a Hamilton or Invicta pro diver
Both in my humble opinion are better alternatives that this
Stainless is not magnetic 😂
It looks like they're copies of rolex datejust tiffany -although there's a big difference between $35k and £80
For less money I got a Pagani Design Seamaster clone with seiko movement, stainless steel case and sapphire crystal. I like Casio but this is a bit pricey for what it is.
I would choose anything over a Chinese branded watch with a counterfeit movement.
@@PETERJOHN101 Seiko is a counterfeit brand? OMG, I need to throw out my other watches and report them to trading standards :) I don't think you understand what the word counterfeit means. Maybe Santa will bring you a dictionary for christmas :p
Where's the where's the panzera video?
10:25 LMAO the watch says you poo.
The casio MTP145 is based off an old casio from the 70s/80s called the MQ-336. So it aint a clone.
I got 2 HMT Tareeqs for less than $50/-
Not sure why they put the WR 50M lettering on there with that awful font. Only thing i don't like about it.
The better quality stainless The less magnetic.