We have massive unemployment and our government just doesn't seem to see the seriousness of it. I don't think it's anywhere in the world where foreigners have taken over the small business sector in every town and city, every street and township. The government has sold their own people in favour of foreigners
If you go to Europe USA you must apply for a working visa If you want to go work in Germany, you must be invited by a company in Germany, then only you can apply for a working visa Then you must go do a A1 and a B1 German language course in Johannesburg at the Goethe institute You must pass it with 60% before you can apply,as Pretoria embassy want to see you diploma Ask me I had to do a German language course in Johannesburg,and it's expensive I attended the course for 4 weeks,
@thefairobserver97 but this happened because evil Mandela refused to criticize Mugabe Mbeki Zuma Rama himself also refused to criticize Mugabe atrocities against Zimbabweans, this caused Zimbabweans to cross ❌ into South Africa because here is illegal work for them Nigeria is the same, they flee their country because it's a criminal Haven in South Africa
Did you traveling out of your country and see how South African are doing any type of business without any problem. People mast travel and see what goes on out side South Africa
U r talking nonsense when u say south Africans are doing any type of business in other countries. We are not talking about big businesses here. We r talking about small township economy business like tuck shops.small stands ext..show me any content of South Africans who owns spaza shops or small stands selling in any country They go there to work Nd have work permits So don't gaslight here with u stupid comment The township economy should belong to south Africans. Plain n simple Our elders d it before so we must continue doing it.
Not even Jesus Christ is able to change their mindset Don't get me wrong that I don't believe in 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙌🙌 u But the country is so rundown that no praying will change their mindset 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
Growing up there used to be spaza shops owned by locals which went under due to price competition from Pakistanis. We did no know then that the prices from Pakistani shops was low due to them making their own unsanitary food, cooldrink etc. our tuckshops used to buy stock at wholesalerd unlike the Pakistani. We have always known how to run spaza shops, the problem comes when there is unfair price competition from foreign shops selling "bogus" food
But who's fault is it that this happened Who refused to condemn Mugabe for his atrocities against his own country and people This caused them to flood South Africa Mandela started this Gulf of corrupt dishonest comrades Not Mandela Mbeki Zuma Rama himself has ever condemn Zimbabwe leaders for atrocities against their own people They rather kept quiet 🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫 and opened up the borders for Nigerians and Zimbabweans And black people carried on voting ANC cadres for 30 years
They tricked us with bulk buying and then they came up with a new idea to manufacture their own products and label them with our brand names increasing their profits.
Are you even listening to yourself. 🤔. Which Pakistanis had shops in Soweto. Spaza shops were swallowed by the inception of malls😩. O tsoa kae re ye🥱🥱🥱
@margaretlesoleso Spaza shops are everywhere in South Africa not just Soweto. U are properbly one of the people who registered spaza shops for Pakistanis, sell out
@margaretlesoleso I agree with you that spaza shop's got killed by big supermarkets and Malls This is even in Europe the problem Like in Germany Very few old bakery 🧁🧁 leftover,the supermarket killed them. Same as butchers, in Hannover Germany I don't know of one private butcher left, supermarkets killed them In Germany you don't really get Mall's But you have Rewe Netto Edeka Penny Aldi supermarket's
Spaza shops must pay tax as well! We are tired of having everyone benifiting from tax yet they don't contribute. When you go to local clinics and hospitals you find foreign nationals getting medication etc. What money is paying for that medication? Our tax money. Every business in SA mist pay tax, Chinese, etc.
You are wrong , if the person is illegal , I can agree but if the person have any type of documentation it anther situation that you’re government will never wanted to tell you.
@cryptowealthtoafricanproud890 See thing is the majority of people in SA are illegal. Government increases tax percentages on your salaries so that they can take care of everyone including the masses of illegal people in the country. It's frustrating. When we go to government clinics and hospitals sometimes we can't get medication cos it's finished. The health minister will complain that they budget based on the number of South Africans and registered people in the country, but all the illegal people also get access to the medication. I know our world is far from perfect, and people have serious issues which make them flee their home country but theit issues must not couse a ripple effect on us citizens. We must reach a point of resolution somehow. But right now as things stand, tax paying South Africans are the donkeys of the country. We get the bitter end of the stick
This must not be negotiated because laws say only south Africans.. but not because it's involved foreigners it's be meeting after meeting. ANC and EFF are rubbish
It was through a very ugly system used by foreign nationals. They would open two shops next to a South African owned shop and lower their prices in doing so they are killing the South African national. Mind you they could manage to lower their prices simply because they buy stock that is compromising quality standards. I hope you understand now.@@thandobheka6371
Pakistanis didn't steal the spaza shops our own people are giving them space to rent and to even put up containers and those who had shops they sold their shops to the Pakistanis.so if you want to blame someone blame communities
Can't sell what u were renting from municipality perhaps they loaned their licenses to those people plus if they are not citizens, they can't buy any properties in SA
They came witha competition mentality dis guys. My uncle had to close his spaza cos ppl were saying he is expensive. Only 2 find dat dis Pakistans a manufacturing their own products. I grew up buying from spaza nd der were no foreigners running those spazas. Dey came 2 compete with us nd we were not aware
@user-zb4tw5cy9h 🤣🤣🤣🤣 S.A. has 4 race groups, so everything will be for any of the 4 races of South African's 🇿🇦 Eish sorry if you NOT A S.A. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣No DNA only RSA.
Spazas must be owned by South Africans to help their poverty.He is right,when one wants to open as a foreigner in this country must pay a certain amount or caution in a country.Most of SouthAfricans parents sent their children to colleges from the little money that they earned from Spazas because they didn't have free Education.The foreigners have been using these chances for more than 30years without paying even maybe Tax.They have Free Education, receiving grants some are illegally then, when South Africans need their rights they have to fight their rights Why this. ,? There were Spazas those days we don't need to learn from these foreigners how to run a Spaza.How do they run them now? .There is nothing that we can learn from people who are selling expired food to people. Caution for everyone who is not a South African to open business in South Africa..Put South Africans first.
Our RURAL AREAS ARE A TARGET, but our CHIEFS & HEADMEN must help us and protect our families in RURAL AREAS from these so called business people who do not bank their money in the country and have NO bank accounts and moreover do not pay TAX, they are sitting on our TAXES which is suppose to help our RURAL AREAS.
Thank you Abdullah or Abushi MoAforika Borwa o petty thata. Ga go ope yo o neng a ba thibela go tsamaisa mabenkele a spaza. O tswa kae tsala yame? Mme ba bua puo efe koo.
Yes ,everyone with valid documents should be allowed to run a spaza shops as long as he or she is a South Africans,you guys can also go and open Spaza shops in your respective countries, South Africans no longer needs you, Please go home.🙏
Are all the foreign owned businesses in our cities and towns paying taxes ? How is it they sell cheaper than what we pay for our merchandise as local business owners?
Go home please and don't patronize us and remember thid is our country we have every right to tell the administration what we really want as a country so mind yours
@@stuartrobertse9617in terms of 60/60 drivers , one thing I have noticed and experienced as an unemployed young person in the country is that a majority of us can't afford to obtain a motorcycle driving license hence why u see so many of these drivers being from outside of the country.
Why not working because RSA South to big for evry one but evry Foringe Live Life with that job::Lest follow rules off Government please Respect Rules 👍👍
Are South African Middle and lower-middle income people willing to run small businesses, being exposed to the same financial and safety challenges as these foreigners face daily? (I'm painfully and sympathetically in favor of illegal foreigners being repatriated to their home countries.....but.....are our own people up to the challenges)?
You have a very valid question ⁉️⁉️ about if black South Africa citizens are willing to do the spaza shop themselves They rather rent out the building to these illegal immigrants than run them themselves It's a dangerous business But again it's because black people have been voting ANC cadres for 30 years and now the country is bankrupt and run by the Mafia
@@christienodendaal3001 sorry to say but white people cannot run a small micro business,as soon as they make their first profit they want to buy a expensive cars and go overseas holiday 😀😀
The problem is that SA blacks got just zero bussiness skils and therefore they will fail within 2 months.The foreigner blacks got very good bussiness skills.
Lots of calls to open SA Borders as the notion is that Africa one country and its citizens all equal thus all have equal rights. But now calls that spaza shops may only be owned by SA Citizens. You have to decide which one.
BORDERS ALL STILL CLOSED .ITS ONLY SA WITHBORDER PROBLEMS BUT WE CONSTRUCTING A WALL BETWEEN MOZAMBIQUE TO PREVENT STEALING OF CARS AND HUMAN TRAFICKING
@mauritzvandenheever2780 Why S.A. only, there are 54 countries on the continent, pick one go there plz.....S.A.is for South Africans. AND SOUTH AFRICANS WILL SUPPORT SOUTH AFRICANS🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 SO what is the point of coming now
The 5 million investment capital thing is tricky, though. Does a spaza really cost 5 million😂😂😂? And majority share holder must be a South African.... Is that supposed to mean that the South African share holder must also invest 2,6m million? Or you eventually become a majority share holder by virtue of having a SA ID? Imagine
I totally agree , Spaza shops must be for South Africans
So true
Let's see how long that will last😢😢
We have massive unemployment and our government just doesn't seem to see the seriousness of it. I don't think it's anywhere in the world where foreigners have taken over the small business sector in every town and city, every street and township. The government has sold their own people in favour of foreigners
It will last we've never been given a chance after 1994 the country was full of foreigners before we could be allowed to stand in our own feet
@@margaretlesolesoThere were tuck shop before foreigners and they we doing well 🤷
When you go to other countries, they would prefer your critical skills for the development of the country and not for spaza shops
If you go to Europe USA you must apply for a working visa
If you want to go work in Germany, you must be invited by a company in Germany, then only you can apply for a working visa
Then you must go do a A1 and a B1 German language course in Johannesburg at the Goethe institute
You must pass it with 60% before you can apply,as Pretoria embassy want to see you diploma
Ask me I had to do a German language course in Johannesburg,and it's expensive
I attended the course for 4 weeks,
@@Palmstreet-u7xwhy this protocol to come to Zimbabwe light😂😂😂😂
@thefairobserver97 last I saw you need 50 000 a month as a foreigner to stay in South Africa
@thefairobserver97 but this happened because evil Mandela refused to criticize Mugabe Mbeki Zuma Rama himself also refused to criticize Mugabe atrocities against Zimbabweans, this caused Zimbabweans to cross ❌ into South Africa because here is illegal work for them
Nigeria is the same, they flee their country because it's a criminal Haven in South Africa
@Palmstreet-u7x I think that only required in South Africa. Youre scheming investors bcs your coffers are dry😂😂😂😂😭
We were worried because rural areas were quite on this matter. We applaud this decision South Africa first.
Spazza shops must be for South Africans only ....I agree
We should not be apologetic about bringing back our township economy. Can people please go back to open businesses in their own countries.
Did you traveling out of your country and see how South African are doing any type of business without any problem. People mast travel and see what goes on out side South Africa
The only place you know is Southa, you people a too scsred to venture outside your country😅😅😅
Just mention 1 country where SAfricans are having non skills businesses !!.@cryptowealthtoafricanproud890
U r talking nonsense when u say south Africans are doing any type of business in other countries.
We are not talking about big businesses here.
We r talking about small township economy business like tuck shops.small stands ext..show me any content of South Africans who owns spaza shops or small stands selling in any country
They go there to work Nd have work permits
So don't gaslight here with u stupid comment
The township economy should belong to south Africans. Plain n simple
Our elders d it before so we must continue doing it.
Amandla, to you, my leadership 👏 🙌 🙏.
😂😂😂😂😂😂
What leader
Mtirara is right 👍 spaza shops must be owned by South Africans only,it will reduce poverty n improve township economy as well as rural areas.
@@diatilenthoba8262 yes and when South Africans own the shops they will employ South Africans...
Why did they fail before😱
It never failed. It could not compete with this foreigners who sold things cheaper Nd made these fake products.
That's y?
...may there soon be positive change for SA'ns...in JESUS name...AMEN!!!!
Not even Jesus Christ is able to change their mindset
Don't get me wrong that I don't believe in 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙌🙌 u
But the country is so rundown that no praying will change their mindset 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
Amen
Growing up there used to be spaza shops owned by locals which went under due to price competition from Pakistanis. We did no know then that the prices from Pakistani shops was low due to them making their own unsanitary food, cooldrink etc. our tuckshops used to buy stock at wholesalerd unlike the Pakistani. We have always known how to run spaza shops, the problem comes when there is unfair price competition from foreign shops selling "bogus" food
But who's fault is it that this happened
Who refused to condemn Mugabe for his atrocities against his own country and people
This caused them to flood South Africa
Mandela started this Gulf of corrupt dishonest comrades
Not Mandela Mbeki Zuma Rama himself has ever condemn Zimbabwe leaders for atrocities against their own people
They rather kept quiet 🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫🤫 and opened up the borders for Nigerians and Zimbabweans
And black people carried on voting ANC cadres for 30 years
They tricked us with bulk buying and then they came up with a new idea to manufacture their own products and label them with our brand names increasing their profits.
Are you even listening to yourself. 🤔. Which Pakistanis had shops in Soweto. Spaza shops were swallowed by the inception of malls😩. O tsoa kae re ye🥱🥱🥱
@margaretlesoleso Spaza shops are everywhere in South Africa not just Soweto. U are properbly one of the people who registered spaza shops for Pakistanis, sell out
@margaretlesoleso I agree with you that spaza shop's got killed by big supermarkets and Malls
This is even in Europe the problem
Like in Germany
Very few old bakery 🧁🧁 leftover,the supermarket killed them.
Same as butchers, in Hannover Germany I don't know of one private butcher left, supermarkets killed them
In Germany you don't really get Mall's
But you have Rewe Netto Edeka Penny Aldi supermarket's
I agree with you 100%
Thanks 🙏🏿🙏🏿 my king❤❤❤❤
Spaza shops must pay tax as well! We are tired of having everyone benifiting from tax yet they don't contribute. When you go to local clinics and hospitals you find foreign nationals getting medication etc. What money is paying for that medication? Our tax money. Every business in SA mist pay tax, Chinese, etc.
@@zizi5137 well said...
You are wrong , if the person is illegal , I can agree but if the person have any type of documentation it anther situation that you’re government will never wanted to tell you.
@cryptowealthtoafricanproud890 See thing is the majority of people in SA are illegal. Government increases tax percentages on your salaries so that they can take care of everyone including the masses of illegal people in the country. It's frustrating.
When we go to government clinics and hospitals sometimes we can't get medication cos it's finished. The health minister will complain that they budget based on the number of South Africans and registered people in the country, but all the illegal people also get access to the medication.
I know our world is far from perfect, and people have serious issues which make them flee their home country but theit issues must not couse a ripple effect on us citizens. We must reach a point of resolution somehow.
But right now as things stand, tax paying South Africans are the donkeys of the country. We get the bitter end of the stick
Paying tax with cash you must be romantic dremer
Paying tax with cash you must be romantic dremer
This must not be negotiated because laws say only south Africans.. but not because it's involved foreigners it's be meeting after meeting. ANC and EFF are rubbish
VIVA PA. U lead and we follow
Well said
True nje spaza is not scarce skill it belong to South Africans
So how did you lose the spaza shops if they belong to south Africans in the first place
It was through a very ugly system used by foreign nationals. They would open two shops next to a South African owned shop and lower their prices in doing so they are killing the South African national. Mind you they could manage to lower their prices simply because they buy stock that is compromising quality standards. I hope you understand now.@@thandobheka6371
@@thandobheka6371Go and ask government
@@thandobheka6371what a "smart" question, u seem though u do not know SA history??
so nomona has ended?
That's great my leadership
They must go
Pakistanis didn't steal the spaza shops our own people are giving them space to rent and to even put up containers and those who had shops they sold their shops to the Pakistanis.so if you want to blame someone blame communities
Can't sell what u were renting from municipality perhaps they loaned their licenses to those people plus if they are not citizens, they can't buy any properties in SA
They came witha competition mentality dis guys. My uncle had to close his spaza cos ppl were saying he is expensive. Only 2 find dat dis Pakistans a manufacturing their own products. I grew up buying from spaza nd der were no foreigners running those spazas. Dey came 2 compete with us nd we were not aware
@mapfo they must go n compete in their spaces n leave us alone, we are fine without their wicked minds
Honestly we dont care How they started with Who and When, but we need spaza shops to be owned and operated by South Africans. Simple as that
@KHUMALOSA Good luck coz these guys are going nowhere
For South African!!! Not one race group only
You read my brain kkkkk
And mine too
@user-zb4tw5cy9h 🤣🤣🤣🤣 S.A. has 4 race groups, so everything will be for any of the 4 races of South African's 🇿🇦 Eish sorry if you NOT A S.A. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣No DNA only RSA.
@@matrix0085step aside
Injalo Nkosi
Spazas must be owned by South Africans to help their poverty.He is right,when one wants to open as a foreigner in this country must pay a certain amount or caution in a country.Most of SouthAfricans parents sent their children to colleges from the little money that they earned from Spazas because they didn't have free Education.The foreigners have been using these chances for more than 30years without paying even maybe Tax.They have Free Education, receiving grants some are illegally then, when South Africans need their rights they have to fight their rights
Why this. ,? There were Spazas those days we don't need to learn from these foreigners how to run a Spaza.How do they run them now? .There is nothing that we can learn from people who are selling expired food to people. Caution for everyone who is not a South African to open business in South Africa..Put South Africans first.
So ssys some one who left school during a break😂😂😂
Hamba Pakistan
Please tell Ramaphosa maybe he doesn't know the clause in the constitution..Spazas are fro for the citizens citizens only..
Thank you may the living God bless your traditional leaders ..
Women from rural areas should also get in to sewing industry
Very good 💯💯💯💯 idea 💡💡💡
And planting seeds and vegetables
They must pay tax as well
Our RURAL AREAS ARE A TARGET, but our CHIEFS & HEADMEN must help us and protect our families in RURAL AREAS from these so called business people who do not bank their money in the country and have NO bank accounts and moreover do not pay TAX, they are sitting on our TAXES which is suppose to help our RURAL AREAS.
One love must start in your own country
Fosho bethunana🇿🇦
Yes very good .
Good
You can open you own shop we didn't saying don't open your shop South African's
Thank you Abdullah or Abushi MoAforika Borwa o petty thata. Ga go ope yo o neng a ba thibela go tsamaisa mabenkele a spaza. O tswa kae tsala yame? Mme ba bua puo efe koo.
Can you go open a spaza shop in their countries? The answer is no because those businesses are for their people so stop it
@@RuthMadumothis people don't run spaza shops in their countries, those that have means open shops🙄🙄
Yes ,everyone with valid documents should be allowed to run a spaza shops as long as he or she is a South Africans,you guys can also go and open Spaza shops in your respective countries, South Africans no longer needs you, Please go home.🙏
Halal lala Inkosi
No legally foreign must owned spaza shop only big business
I wish our president,politicians,law makers, unpatriotic leaders can listen to this brilliant and patriotic idea.🙏🙏
Thanks my king
Don't forget that South Africans in outside off country
So??
You'll never achieve any of it if you're still voting for anc, mk and eff.
You getting what you voted for!
So we must vote for what
Vote with your brain.. Look around you and you decide.. @@thandobheka6371
@@thandobheka6371independent candidates that don't owe anyone any favour.
@@thandobheka6371 DA Obviously, or you scared of Apartheid? 🤣😂😂🤣😂
@duanemnisi3721 Ok we will vote your DA
Why can't south Africans open spaza shops in they're birth place ? And stop making noise no one stopped you south Africans from opening spaza shops...
🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉😂😂😂😂😂 yes 💯 agree 💯👍👍
Go back home you , stop talking kuk , hamba kaya kwekwerrere
Are all the foreign owned businesses in our cities and towns paying taxes ? How is it they sell cheaper than what we pay for our merchandise as local business owners?
Big question ❓⁉️ about the price
No they not registered ®️®️ as business at SARS
It's called business acumen 🤪
@margaretlesoleso hehehe
Depends who you mean 😂😂
It's not business acumen. This needs to be scrutinized
Not that we don't have a country we love love our country ♥️1think l wanna let you know You can't focus on your country on life
Go home please and don't patronize us and remember thid is our country we have every right to tell the administration what we really want as a country so mind yours
What about teachers and doctors
@@terefeMarkos-r6o and waiters and 60/60 drivers?
@@stuartrobertse9617in terms of 60/60 drivers , one thing I have noticed and experienced as an unemployed young person in the country is that a majority of us can't afford to obtain a motorcycle driving license hence why u see so many of these drivers being from outside of the country.
Agree!!!
Why not working because RSA South to big for evry one but evry Foringe Live Life with that job::Lest follow rules off Government please Respect Rules 👍👍
Sorry i foregat God blesse Africa god blass south Africa
What about the police and also home affairs they also going to have Sapaza shops
Are South African Middle and lower-middle income people willing to run small businesses, being exposed to the same financial and safety challenges as these foreigners face daily?
(I'm painfully and sympathetically in favor of illegal foreigners being repatriated to their home countries.....but.....are our own people up to the challenges)?
You have a very valid question ⁉️⁉️ about if black South Africa citizens are willing to do the spaza shop themselves
They rather rent out the building to these illegal immigrants than run them themselves
It's a dangerous business
But again it's because black people have been voting ANC cadres for 30 years and now the country is bankrupt and run by the Mafia
We will have to adapt.....the very same way that our grandparents did in the old days
@@christienodendaal3001 not white people definitely not 🚫🚫
Black people yes
@@LookAtM3-w3n white people cannot run small business. They want to as soon make a profit go overseas on holiday
@@christienodendaal3001 sorry to say but white people cannot run a small micro business,as soon as they make their first profit they want to buy a expensive cars and go overseas holiday 😀😀
One love Africa 🇪🇹🙋♂️🇿🇦🫂💞
Ntsiki Nohiya...mama ka Athi
Yes big yes we are we are old no children died 5:55
Only god knows stop Judging Guy's we are African's 😭😭😭one love Africa 🙄🙋♂️
I would love to know what is preventing South Africans from starting a spaza shop. Perhaps their own victimhood.
The problem is that SA blacks got just zero bussiness skils and therefore they will fail within 2 months.The foreigner blacks got very good bussiness skills.
Lots of calls to open SA Borders as the notion is that Africa one country and its citizens all equal thus all have equal rights. But now calls that spaza shops may only be owned by SA Citizens. You have to decide which one.
Are Pakistanis and Bangladeshi people Africans too? One Africa should not be on the expense of South Africans.
South Africa is for South Africans!!!!!!! GO fight for your country.....leave our people!!!!!
BORDERS ALL STILL CLOSED .ITS ONLY SA WITHBORDER PROBLEMS BUT WE CONSTRUCTING A WALL BETWEEN MOZAMBIQUE TO PREVENT STEALING OF CARS AND HUMAN TRAFICKING
Different people, Different places. There is no hypocrisy here.
@mauritzvandenheever2780 Why S.A. only, there are 54 countries on the continent, pick one go there plz.....S.A.is for South Africans. AND SOUTH AFRICANS WILL SUPPORT SOUTH AFRICANS🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 SO what is the point of coming now
Local economy for SAn only
Any body come to your land respect them .Bible says
And also sasaa must be paid to foreigner 😂😂😂😂
The 5 million investment capital thing is tricky, though. Does a spaza really cost 5 million😂😂😂?
And majority share holder must be a South African.... Is that supposed to mean that the South African share holder must also invest 2,6m million? Or you eventually become a majority share holder by virtue of having a SA ID? Imagine
Why ? There are millions of black foreigners why can't they start a business
Aibo 😂😂 Is this Ntsiki from Generations
media they are busy 24/7 spaza shop it's shame a minor problem
exaggerated too much..wasting time energy and money..they don't have breaking news 😂😂
Ba tsere business model eo ba e itekanedisa mme jaanong o batla go e hijack.. Le tla palelwa..
😂wat abut that dolars in came neme of forigien
You cannot give a foreigner citizenship and then deny them the right to work in the country.
But they are illegally immigrants.they not legal citizens of South Africa
They bought their 🆔
Go home
En wa gaan ons dai fokin geld kry as ek nou nie werk ni
Government
Its a little to late
😅 hou
Stop taking about spazza shops wat about doctorsand tichr and tirck dirvers
so only khoisan then?
Go home peaceful why you dont like home?
good luck with your tuck shop
someone else is busy digging diamonds. ..it's funny 😂😂😂
Your not talking sense old man
confused country
Phambili leadership, can all rual areas take this stand so that wee do not have to go down thee and drag them out