सामने सांसद, Muslim Reservation पर मार, खुली Pasmanda Muslims की कहानी | Saurabh Dwivedi | Kitabwala
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 ก.ย. 2024
- खबरों को विस्तार से पढ़ने के लिए क्लिक करे यहां- www.thelallant...
In this episode of #kitabwala Saurabh Dwivedi discusses with Former Rajya Sabha MP, Ali Anvar on his book, "Sampoorn Dalit Andolan : Pasamanda Tasawwur" . The basic argument of this book is reservstion for Pasmanda community. Anvar elaborate the anecdotes of the past when the disussion held with the UPA government.
This book emphasises the complementary nature of the relationship between the Pasmanda movement and the Dalit movement. Anwar imagines the Pasmanda movement as a part of the Dalit-Bahujan movement and argues that the latter remains incomplete without including the “Pasmanda-tareen” (Arzal) in its fold. This is a new term which he has coined to denote Dalit Muslims. Further, he underlines that all religions have a section of population which can be termed as Dalits because the pains that they suffer from are identical.
Anvar in his book offers hope as concluding remark: “Today all constitutional institutions are visibly eclipsed. The Indian constitution and democracy are in danger. Hence, the unity of Dalits-Backwards, peasants, workers, students, youth and all justice and freedom-loving persons is required.”
LT Premium जॉइन करने के लिए नीचे दिए लिंक पर क्लिक करें: / @thelallantop
Instagram: / thelallantop
Facebook: / thelallantop
Twitter: / thelallantop
Produced By: The Lallantop
Edited By: Gagan Deep Singh
हिन्दू भाई एक हो जाओ, पिछड़े, दलित में ना बटों।
मुस्लिम भाई एक हो जाओ, अशराफ़, अजलाफ में ना बटों।
ताकि दोनों धर्मों के मठाधीशों की मलाई कटती रहे🙏।
True
Bilkul sahi kaha
शानदार इंटरव्यू।
ये सच है मुस्लिम में भी जातिवाद है
Nhi h
Tu muslim nhu lg rha 😂😂😂😂
Sayyeds are deemed to have same status as brahimin in Hindus. Isn't this is casteism?????
Tunni spotted muslim name mai 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Pahli bar muslimo ke ander ki bimari ka kisi news channel per charcha ho raha h..100% sahi bat kahi h sir ji aap ko dil❤ se salute h..mai bhi muslim ho sari bato se achhi tarh se wakif hu.
गुरु! हमे तो बस सौरभ द्विवेदी जी की जीवनी सुननी है, छोटी ही सही एक फिल्म या डॉक्यूमेंट्री तो देखनी है।
गुरु तक संदेश पहुंचे 🙏
Bitter reality of Muslim community👥👥👥 in India. He is unveiling truth.
I am muslim magar my aajtak aise kabhi nahi suna
Kyu ki hame ghade hone hi nai dena chahati government
Answer given by ali anwar at 44:53 shows how intelligent he is.
अच्छा प्रोग्राम था कुछ नई जानकारी मिली
As a Muslim i never heard of these many castes ever. Not in the masjid, not from my parents. We pray behind every Muslim. We don't even know who's who. We don't have a concept of caste in Islam.
I'm not denying that such a division don't exist in society, but this is highly a regional problem. One must not direct this towards Islam.
Our scholars have always preached equality among Muslims, and not to discriminate on the basis of color, language or profession.
This is the denial he is talking about. It is not division. It is oppression. Accept this first.
Living in some metropolitan city or you are rich or you are with a small mindset and don't know what's going on around you. Anyway if you can't see doent mean it's not there 😂😂. In India every religion has caste system.. Seeing and learning I could say that with confidence. Just live peacefully that's it.. Don't know when this nightmare will end.. In Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu my seniors told me how Christianity is having different churches for different castes who converted... And muslim is all around you, so much population.. Don't be a narrow minded guy.
Nowhere castism in Islam! They're greedy who claim to be Dalits in the Islam.
@@HerculesKumar88 Yes, if I don't see it, it doesn't mean it's not there and I'm not denying its existence or the injustice. My only point here is not to associate it with the religion of Islam. Nowhere in Islamic texts, you'll find a system of castes. No real Muslim scholar will ever preach this. And beyond that, don't you think it goes against the concept of "Ummah"? I think you know* about it. What Muslims do doesn't necessarily mean that it is Islamic. And, I'm none of the things you've mentioned :)
Epic denialism spotted. You can find them anywhere spoken like true ansar
as a muslim i approve this.
Important topic to be raised and irony is that most of the people don't know
Mananiy sansad ali anvar aur dr. Fayaj sahab ka yogdan dalit muslim aarakchan ke liye bahumulya hai hum unka aabhar byakt karte hain
Heads of most of the major institutions of Muslims are from ashraf community of Muslims. Check the ground reality. It's hidden truth. Saaf chhipte bhi nahi saamne aate bhi nahi. What an irony. Double standard.
same Brahmins in Hindus
Hn aur jo muslim pechedi jati ke h unki socioeconomic halat hindu st ,sc jaise h
All of Ashraf Muslims are videshi Muslims.
@@AbhishekSingh08 atleast hindus have a voice . Lower caste muslims are not represented.
@@Aj-qo3jp worse hai
हम सभी मुस्लिम एक ही है। तुम हमारी एकता को तोड़ नही सकते ❤
Ak ho to har sal हजारों सिया मुस्लिम को मार रहे हो के मस्जिद में बम धमाके क्यू करते हों
सच्चाई हमेशा दर्द देती है..
Tabhi shia ke moharram me bomb phodte hai .
❤👍
@@Vaid_krishan_Phougat123 अबे सच्चाई यह है कि हम सभी मुस्लिम एक हैं। तुम कितना भी प्रोपगेंडा चला लेना
If Muslim follow the prophet Muhammad then why Muslim following Shia and Sunni (sect) division+ casteism in Islam because during prophet Muhammad era there is no division of Islam society
Thank you 👍🙂😃😊😀😘
भारत में आरक्षण जातीय आधार पर न होकर, आर्थिक आधार पर होना चाहिए। भारत में लोगों को तीन श्रेणी में बांटना चाहिए। पहली श्रेणी में गरीब को रखना चाहिए। दूसरी श्रेणी में मीडियम को रखना चाहिए। तीसरी श्रेणी में अमीर को रखना चाहिए।
एसा बोलो की भारत में जाती ही नही होना चाहिए, आज का मोची महाकाल का पूजक हो जाए,
जब शोषण जाति के आधार पर तो फिर आरक्षण भी जाति के आधार पर ही होना चाहिए
Muslims me koi chooa chhoot ni hai
Achha majak Kiya 😅 tumlogo ko kya lagta hai humko kuch pta nhi hai 😅 sachai chup nhi sakte jhoothe asolo se Khushboo a nhi sakte kaagaz ke fhoolo se😅
Cast system is reality of Muslim community and thank for true program
Sheikh, sayyed , khan , siddique, pathan , Ahmed , rizvi , etc upper caste wale Muslim hum pasmanda ko kutta , billi , janwar samajhte hain
Ager Muslims me koi khud ko ACHHUT samjhta h to .. please wapus Hindu bno ..❤❤❤
Hmm bahi hum sab barabar hai ya banda rajneeti ki rotiyan seek raha hai😢
Bhagat Singh ka photo laga ke sampradayikta ki baate? Thoda padh bhi lete Bhagat Singh ko.
Bhai Ager kohi wapas apane pure nasal Hindustani khoun me wapasi chahata hai aap ko kiya dukha hai.
Jo muslim bhai vapas apne Hindu dharm me aana chahte h unka Dil se स्वागत है
@@vikalptrivedi6730
The Great Bhagat Singh was Athiest/ NASTIK. I think all religions are same
अगर मुस्लिमों मे भी भेद भाव जाती के आधार पर है और ज्यादातर मुस्लिम हिन्दू से सी कन्वर्ट हुआ है, तो वैसे सभी मुस्लिमों को हिन्दू धर्म मे घर वापसी करके आरक्षण का लाभ उठाना चाहिए l
Thik h Bhai agar hindu me wapas aaynge tho konse जात me aaynge 😂 aur agar apki जाति me aa gye likhne Lage tho ap inko apni behan bithiya bihaoge..... sorry Bhai neg mat lena main bhi hindu aur bht soch chuka hu....aadami uss dharam jayega jaha bedbav na ho aur woh dharam filhal bss Buddha dharam h🙏 but khushi iss baat ki h ki woh Indian religion ❤️ tho chalega
Bilkul sahi answer sahab
Ali Anwar, who has been elected twice as MP in parliament, has only filled his pockets with money. He did nothing for pasmanda or any muslims. He just use name of pasmanda and did useless casteism for political throne or nothing. He don't have real knowledge of casteism. He just making everyone fooled. What did he do for muslim people? What did muslim people get?.
Also please invite Faiyaz Ahmad Fyzie ji. He has been working for the backward class of Muslims.
Bhut khob guftguo hoi hm swagt krte hen ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Ye ashraf azlaf etc to abtak musalman bhi nahi jante....
Tum to pathan ho aapne behen ki shadhi ahmediya se karke dekha do 😅😅 kya lagta hai humlogo ko kuch pta nhi hai 😅😅
But it is true. But relegion does not allow differences if any body do this. They can not go to heaven.
These ashraf can not go to heaven unless they do not leave arrogance.
Allah does not allow anybody to follow arrogance.
सभी मुस्लिम जो है हिंदू से कन्वर्ट यही सच्चाई बताया है सच्चाई बताएं है
Sorabh jee aap apne chenal se bhut acha mudda sabke samne leker aye aap ka bhut shukriya
मुझे जाति और धर्म की राजनीति में कोई दिलचस्पी नहीं है...मुझे रोजगार व विकास की राजनीति में दिलचस्पी है।
लोगों को सुरक्षित व अच्छा रोजगार दिया जाए...संविदा व आउटसोर्सिंग नौकरीयों का विरोध करता हूँ यदि नौकरियाँ देनी हैं तो उन नौकरीयों को नियमित भी करो।
Ham sirf iman vale hai sab aik hai
90% पसमांदा तुम्हारे 5% अशराफ विदेशी उर्दु मुसलमानों के साथ नही हैं और ना रहेंगें ? 90% लोगों के पास इमान भी है और रसुल भी हैं उसका सर्टीफिकेट आप भारत में देने की कोशिस ना करें ? इमान और मुसलमान के आड में 5% अशराफ विदेशी उर्दु मुसलमानों की गुलामी 90% पसमांदा भारतीय देशज मुसलमान क्यों करें ? नाटक बंद ?
Nice 😂😂😂 joke Andhnamazi
डाक्टर फयाज अहमद फैजी साहब से पसमंदा पर चर्चा क्यों नहीं करते हैं।
ललन टाप से गुजारिश है कि उनसे इंटरव्यू ले
Another eye opener. Reality speaks louder than priest. Discrimination is lubricant of kingship-leadership. It's a universal phenomenon. Unfortunate truth.
Ex Muslim Sahil TH-cam channel explained it on his TH-cam channel
From 18:00 to 18:20 is valid point
For the ones trying to make Islam Great in comments rather than in real life... Living in some metropolitan city or you are rich or you are with a small mindset and don't know what's going on around you. Anyway if you can't see doent mean it's not there 😂😂. In India every religion has caste system.. Seeing and learning I could say that with confidence. Just live peacefully that's it.. Don't know when this nightmare will end.. In Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu my seniors told me how Christianity is having different churches for different castes who converted... And muslim is all around you, so much population.. Don't be a narrow minded guy.
I am not metro city or rich guy, but most of imams in every masjid is usually from so called ajlaf community, yes there is economic difference but untouchability.
Manavar ali zarur pas manda h
Good channel reveals truth
Very good
सरकार को एक गणना ये भी करनी चाहिए की, कौन कौन मुस्लिम हिन्दू से मुस्लिम बना है और उसकी आर्थिक स्थिति क्या है, और उन लोगों का हिन्दू मे कौन जाती थी l
Aaj meri umar 31 years hai,aur muslim bhi hun, maine to kabhi nhi suna jaati chhuwa chhut ke bare me.
Mujhe lagta hai fellowship barbad ho gyi
फिरका कोन सा है अपना ये पूछना अपने बड़ों से फिर वो बताएंगे
ये अशराफ मुसलमानों की साजीश वाला जवाब है शादी बिहा के समय सब जाती देखकर करते हैं ? ये झुठ वाला नाटक भारत से बाहर जाकर करो ?
Bro tere suggestions me hi jawab hai itna exists karta hai ke mujhe puchhna padega apne badon se
मेरी नज़र में तो ऐसा नहीं है अगर है तो आप उस स्थान का नाम बताइए? अगर है तो कुल आबादी का कितना प्रतिशत है? मस्जिदें जो हिन्दुस्तान में बनी हैं उसमें मुख्य रुप से दो समुदायों की हैं शिया और सुन्नी हो सकता है।कहीं पर कोई भेद हो लेकिन हर मुसलमान हर मस्जिद में नमाज़ पढ़ सकता है।। क्योंकि 90% मुस्लिम हिन्दू धर्म से बदले हैं तो उसी हिसाब से कुछ व्यवस्था ज़रूर है।
अभी तक जितने नेता हुए हैं सब गरीबों का भला राग गाते रहे लेकिन गरीब बढ़ते ही रहे और नेता गरीब को सीढ़ी बना कुर्सी तक पहुँच ते रहे😢😢 दुखद है लेकिन सच है
It is very clear from what this gentleman is talking about is that as 'religion' there is no caste system in Islam. But, what he is talking about is a social evil that got creeped in the society.
अगर कास्ट सिस्टम नही है तो अपनी बहन से मेरी शादी करवाओ
dalit musalmano ko kis masjid me entry nhi h ye pehli baar sun raha hu islam raja ho ya common sabke lie same line hoti h namaj me
This is a cruel reality of South Asian Muslims
इस देश की विशेषता ये है कि यहाँ के वामपंथी विचारधारा वाले लोग भी वामपंथी बाद मे जातिवादी पहले हैं. (सौरभ द्विवेदी के लिए 😢)
Muslims those who are converted from Sudras, Dalit and Adivasis are known as Pasmanda Muslims. It is true that in spite of their historical identity as Sudras, Dalits and Adivasis they were away from Reservation. A few category of Muslims have come under OBC category for some years wherein they were not allowed reservation according to their historical identity. . Many govt reports carry the truth that present Pasmanda Muslims are are denied the advantages which have been extended to their counter part Sudras, Dalits and Adivasis. It is a historical deprivation to Pasmanda Muslims with respect to Reservation System in India.
Alag desh le liya fir yaha reservation chahiye. OBC ST SC se muslim christan reservation puri tarah hatana chahiye. Agar jati wyawstha ke karan convert huye aur islam me bhi jati hai to gharwapsi karlo.
⛳️Pasmanda Muslim can do ghar wapis 😅
आरक्षण पूर्ण रूप से आर्थिक स्थिति के हिसाब से दिया जाना चाहिए !
Why don't they reconvert themselves
Word "Bhatyara" In Maharashtra is popularly known as Cook, large kitchen such as of hotel is called "bhatyarkhana"
This is a quote from the holy book
"49:13 O men! Behold, We have created you all out of a male and a female, [15] and have made you into nations and tribes, so that you might come to know one another. [16] Verily, the noblest of you in the sight of God is the one who is most deeply conscious of Him. Behold, God is all-knowing, all-aware."
It is nice to quote these nice things from the "holy book" But this must be qu0ted to the islamic terrorists who quote something else also, from the "holy book".
There is a difference between theory and practice at ground level.
@shahidhasnain5054 yes, thats because we have caste system in india and cultural influences too... but Islam as a religion doesn't advocate it.. no sayed has bigger status than Ansari, all are equal.. those who advocate this ashraf , sayyad and all stuff have their own agendas behind..
सभी जाति के दलितों को बस बुध्द धर्म ही बराबर कर सकता है 🙏 हिंदू दलितों को मुस्लिम दलितों को भी साथ लाना चाहिए और उनको बुध्द बनाना चाहिए।🙏
Mai inke bato se 80% agree krta hu as a upper Muslim caste maine v dekha hai ved bhao lowe Muslim caste k sath apne village me waha pr kabristan alag hai Muslim me v or waha pe dekha hai chair pe baithne nhi dete the pehle unke ghar pe jaldi khana khane nhi jate the unke jaati ko gali k tarah bolte hai but maine masjid me nhi dekhi hai ho skta hai kahi hua ho ye v qki Indian Muslim Arab Muslim se alag hai ye accept krna chahiye jo Indian society hai same wahi hai hindu Muslim me kahi jyada kahi kam.hai but koi muslim bole ki maine nhi dekhi maine nahi suni to ye sb such ko accept nhi krte hai.. shadi k liye sheikh hai to pehle sheikh ki ladki dekhenge ya last khan usse niche nahi jayenge.. han islam me.caste nhi hai but Indian Muslim society me caste hai 100%
kabristan wali baat sirf India mein hi nahin, balki Pakistan mein bhi hoti hai aur on record bhi hai
@@yatinsharma3325 hoti hogi bhai wo v to India hi tha culture to same hi hoga
हमारे प्यारे नबी हजरत पैगंबर मोहम्मद अल्लाह ताला ने इस्लाम मजहब और मुसलमानो को 73 Sect फिरका संप्रदाय कबीला नस्ल बिरादरी Tribe जनजाति में विभाजित कर दिया था। क्योंकि एक मुसलमान दूसरे मुसलमान को आसानी से पहचान सके। कुरान और साहिल अल बुखारी हदीस में लिखा हुआ है। हर धर्म मजहब रिलिजन में जातिवाद क्षेत्रवाद नस्लवाद कबीला नस्ल बिरादरी जनजाति के नाम पर भेदभाव होता है। इस चीज को स्वीकार करो। वरना बर्बाद हो जाएगा।
Hajjatulwida ka khutba marne se pehle ki speech nahi hai,prophet Muhammad s.a.w. jab haj par gaye the wahan unhone speech di thi,wo paighambar the,unhe andaza tha k unhe agli baar yahan aana naseeb nahi hoga aur haj par bahot log hote hain isliye unhone speech di k jo yaha hai wo bhi sun le aur jo aanewali nasle hain untak bhi pahunchayi jaye ye speech.unka paigham jo dar asl islam ka paigham hai.
Yahan se lautne k kuch waqt baad wo is duniya se rukhsat ho gaye ,ye unki last speech aur last haj tha isliye isko hajjatulwida yani alwidayi haj ka khutba kehte hain ,khutba means speech
Is khutba me jo bhi kaha gaya wo apni misal aap hai,us jaisi speech na aajtak kisine di hai aur na dega.isme har samaji burai ko door karne,jhoot na bolna ,insaf karna ghareebo yateemo ka khayal rakhna aur aisi bahot sari baate hain inhe yaha likhne mushkil hai.khulasa ye k lslam me koi kami nahi .jatiwad ,Ashraf arzal azlan he sab samaj ki banayi koot nitiyan hai .islam inhe strictly reject karta hain,kala gora, maal daulat Arabic non Arabic kisi bhi buniyad par insano me farq karna mana kiya gaya hai ,sabse barabari ka sulook karne ko kaha gaya hai.lekin ye duniya hai ,yahan insan k peeche shaitan pada hai jo usse yahi sare kaam karwata hai,jo usko nark me le jayega
मेरी उम्र 65 साल है मेने आज तक ये आधराफ नाम नही सुना बस सुन्नी, शिया सुना और सुन्नी में भी बरेलवी और देवबंदी सुना ये पहली बार सुन रहा हूं जबकि में यूपी में झांसी, कानपुर, लखनऊ में रहा, महाराष्ट्र में नासिक, भुसावल, मुंबई और पुणे में रहा पर ऐसा कोई बात नही सुनी न देखी
हिन्दुस्तान में 😂 समझो ना समझो नासमझो 🙏 लोकतांत्रिक संसार भारत 🙏
भारत में बहुत कम मुसलमान अशराफ, अजलाफ़ और अरजाल टर्मिनोलॉजी को जानते हैं।
इस तरह की कोई ऊंच-नीच मैंने नहीं देखी।
Answer Ali is right
Musalmano k sath school, tuition interview or selection me sabhi jahag bhed bhau hota hai.
आप छठिया पोखरा,dumraon,बक्सर से है ,,आप ही बताइए की dumraon के किस मस्जिद में जाने से आपको रोका गया है ,,,केवल बकवास करते है ,,
मुस्लिम में विभिन्न जातियां है ये सबको पता है लेकिन जातियों में छुआछूत आज तक कही भी सुनने को नही मिला है ,,,आपको अपनी राजनीति करनी है बस वही कीजिए ,,10 साल संसद थे आप और अपने समाज के लिए आपने जीरो काम किया
मेवात खत्म होना चाहे कभी अपने नहीं हो सकते
Saurabh ji Mae bhi fqir jati kahi hun bhut taqlif aor Prashant ka jindgi ne samna krna pita hai ghr se lekr Shahar tak hr jgah
ऐसा कहीं नहीं मिलेगा कि मस्जिद में भेद भाव किया जाता है। इन्होंने गलत लिखा है।
आ गया मंगोली खान डुप्लीकेट पठाण ? 5% अशराफ मुसलमानों का नस्लवाद और जातीवाद छुपाने ? अपना सत्ता वर्चस्व बचाने दुसरों को झुठा कहना ये हैं इराणी पारसी उर्दु अशराफ मुसलमानों के गुलाम ?
Masjid ke bahar nikalate hi bhedbhav chalu
भले ही बुरा लगे पर भारत का बटवारा एक बार होगा धर्म के आधार पर
हम भी मुस्लिम है पर कभी ऐसा नहीं सुना जो ये महाशय बता रहे है। कभी भी ऐसा भेदभाव नहीं रहा हे। ये सब एक साजिश के तहत हो रहा हे।
Sab Hindu Hai ❤
😂
No,we are Muslim.Not Hindu
😂😂😂😢 एक सामान्य लंठभक्त
sir vdo me awaj bahut dhire ati h.. thoda volume pe dhyan de plzzz....
Masjid mein to bhed bhaw nahi hota lekin samaj mein aaj bhi bhed bhaw hai.
अब जाते जाते अपनी औक़ात दिखा गया ..... rss का एजेंट
Sahi bole sir aap
A lot more efforts resulted in social engineering on eradication of ills within society. Brotherhood amongst Indian Muslim society is witnessed and largely experienced. The Author's view is skeptical and selective, which can't be generalized as a wholesome for the entire society.
Many hardcore left wing political class have lost faith in themselves, and wandering a space in any forum of right wing. Introspection issue of minority leaders. They must learn from other community who are experiencing conflict zones, especially, Palestinian.
Bhathiyara word means rasoiya (cook) , or bhatiyaran means khana pakane wale ki aurat.
ये सुपर समझना सिर्फ मुस्लिम की बात नहीं ये हर व्यक्ति की बात है हर व्यक्ति खुद को सुपर समझता है ये बात अपने घर में भी देख सकते हैं आप
Background me sir bundelkhand ki Puri chhap hai very impressive
Sound quality is not good
In log ki v ganna hona chahiye or jo muslim hoke v nehi mane jate fir jisko beti nehi diya jata or sadi me v nehi bulate dawat nehi dete un log ko v aage badne keliye pehele pehchan kiye jai fir reservation ho ya government scream se samaj me saman adhikar diye jai...
Thodi awaaz tej rakkha kariye
Masjido me aane nahi dete😂😂😂😂 bhai bahusankhyak pasmanda hai to masjido ne jiski jitni sankhya haj utni hi unka warchasv hota hai
Allah ke ❤rasool ❤ki ( hadees hai ke khud ko groupo main mat baato )
55 ki umar 6 ki pakdo aur apni bahu ko mat chhodo ye bhi to hadees hai😊
😮😮😮
Most of the peer Saheb are because of the benefits of their birth status and not merit. Most of them belong to just one are two caste of Muslims. Isn't this is the proof of existence of caste system in Muslims. Not only caste system but hierarchy too. Let's accept the disease and try to cure it.
@shahidhasnain5054 peer saheb is not a concept of Islam.. all should start boycotting them as they advocate shirk
@@saoudshaikh8048tum to pandit ho😅😅 aapne sister ki marriage ahmediya se karoge 😅😅
Go around pan india none will meet who knows these sects in Islam 100℅ .
You will find diffremce tradition in South North etc, but that is due to there culture & occupation but nothing like discrimination in Islam.
If 1℅ somewhere it's happening it's social issue not religious.
By the way heard these Ashraf alraj whatever first time in my life.
It's seems agenda which will never stand.
Jab Christian missionaries aur Mulle Moulvi Garib aur Aadiwasi Hinduon ka Lalach dekar Conversation karwate hai tab to barabari ki baat karte hai us time par ye Sacchai kyu nahi batate ab bahut BHOLE banke dikhate hai
Many off people here have following views
1 Islam dosnt recognise caste differences
2 Reservation should be on economic backwardness not on caste
3 If muslim wants reservation then they should do Ghar wapsi etc
But reality is different from misconception prevailing in such discource
1 Economic criteria based reservation should not be justified under modern liberal politics.
2 In India caste based reservation is given because so called lower castes have been subjugated for thousands of years. And they cannot expect that lower caste can compete on equal basis suddenly after Independence.
3 Pasmanda muslims or others are not recognised as SC, not because Islam treat every one equals, but because political and judicial system prevesouly beleive that since Islam came from outside hence followers of Islam were not subjugated under caste system.
4 However all Muslims donot come from outside. Majority of them are converted. Hence they have also faced caste based predujices. Since Converts from Hinduism to Budhhism still recognised as SC, this methodologies shpuld also be recognised for those Dalits who converted to Islam.
5 Any politicial party who realy show compassion of pasmanda or other dalit muslim should form a committee to study dalit converts to Islam and possibility to award them SC status.
Please interview SHIV KUNAL VERMA
Article341 me sanshodhan kab tak hone wala hai?
Sir lohia g pr ki koi biography recommend kre plz
लोहिया जी का खुद का लिखा भी पर्याप्त मात्रा में मौजूद है. किताबें हैं, लेख हैं. बाकी इंदुमती केलकर की लिखी एक जीवनी है, राम मनोहर लोहिया पर. उसे पढ़ सकते हैं. शुभकामनाएं.
@@TheLallantop bhut bhut Daniyabad
Bharat men Videshi musalmano ko jo tathakathit apne aap ko Ashraf kahte thay kisi bhi tarah se janm ke aadhaar pe Indian ( deshi) Muslim se behtar nahi samajhna chahiye. Ye Islam aur manauta ke khilaaf hai.
Arabs, Indian Muslim ko apne Barabar maan lege to unka status kaha rah jayega , aisa kabhi kuch nahi hota
We all are sons and daughters of Adam and Hauua. I strongly believe we all are equal.
75 % SC ST OBC (hati) arakhyan ka ladai jit nahi parahe hai.
15 % (chiti) aaya ladne
I swair to god i have never heard any thing like cast in muslims in india and i am from south
English version aayega kya?
Muslim me caste system nhi hai 😂
Mene kabhi nahi suna aisa ye sab polítics hai yahan tak in sab shabdon ka meaning bhi nahi malum hame
सैद्धांतिक दृष्टि से तो इस्लाम में सब बराबर हैं पर इस्लाम के नाम पर बने देश , पाकिस्तान में पंजाबी सबसे ऊपर हैं फिर और सब अपनी संख्या तथा सेना में जातीय वर्चस्व के अनुसार बड़े या छोटे हैं यहाँ तक कि 1971 में देश का दुबारा बँटवारा होने में इसी विभेद का बड़ा हाथ था।
Saurabh sb ek bar mera is topic per interview le lo!
Iski book 📕 bihari logo ki cast par thik hogi baaki India 🇮🇳 main alag alag state main vo cast hai nahi jo bihar main hai kashmiri panjabi Muslim ki cast vahan ke locals hai kerela or nourth Muslim ki cast vahan ke ki local hai gujarati Muslim ki cast vahan ki locals hai bangali locals hai
Hamary yaha bulandshahr up Mai bhatiyara roti bananay walo ko kaha jata hai
There are many instances where choti jati people don't let inter
into their institution
Sad..