Are Melamine Dishes and Polyamide Plastic Utensils Safe?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 พ.ค. 2020
- I recommend glass, ceramic, porcelain, or stainless-steel tableware and wooden or stainless-steel cooking utensils.
Subscribe to NutritionFacts.org’s free newsletter to receive our B12 infographic that covers the latest research takeaways and Dr. Greger’s updated recommendations: nutritionfacts.org/subscribe/
This is the last in a series of videos on cookware. If you missed the others, check out Are Aluminum Pots, Bottles, and Foil Safe? (nutritionfacts.org/video/are-a...) and Stainless Steel or Cast Iron: Which Cookware Is Best? Is Teflon Safe? (nutritionfacts.org/video/stain...)
It may not be safe to microwave melamine, but what about microwaving in general? See Are Microwaves Safe? (nutritionfacts.org/video/are-...) and The Effects of Radiation Leaking from Microwave Ovens (nutritionfacts.org/video/the-....
Have a question about this video? Leave it in the comment section at nutritionfacts.org/video/are-m... and someone on the NutritionFacts.org team will try to answer it.
Want to get a list of links to all the scientific sources used in this video? Click on Sources Cited at nutritionfacts.org/video/are-.... You’ll also find a transcript and acknowledgements for the video, my blog and speaking tour schedule, and an easy way to search (by translated language even) through our videos spanning more than 2,000 health topics.
If you’d rather watch these videos on TH-cam, subscribe to my TH-cam Channel here: th-cam.com/users/subscription_...
Thanks for watching. I hope you’ll join in the evidence-based nutrition revolution!
-Michael Greger, MD FACLM
Captions for this video are available in several languages; you can find yours in the video settings. View important information about our translated resources: nutritionfacts.org/translatio...
NutritionFacts.org
• Subscribe: nutritionfacts.org/subscribe
• Donate: nutritionfacts.org/donate
• Podcast : nutritionfacts.org/audio
• Facebook: NutritionFacts.org
• Twitter: nutrition_facts
• Instagram: nutrition_facts_org
• Books: nutritionfacts.org/books
• Shop: drgreger.org - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
Very interesting. How about silicone spatulas, Dr. Greger?
Silicone is 100% food safe.
Dr. GregEr
@@mangoauthority2897 thanks.
@@ShudoukenTV I used to think melamine was safe too, but I've just thrown away 2 utensils...
.
You should do videos on silicone utensils and polystyrene serving dishes and plastic forks and spoons. I know a lot of people who use these things and thing they're safe, knowing the science would be great. Thank you for the knowledge.
How about you make the video instead.
@@stephss If I had access to the studies that he does and his following I would but I don't, so....
@@FellVoice oh...you're just making excuses ;). We all know the real reason....'we don't know how'....JK, the real reason is we don't have the drive or sense of purpose.
@@iloveamerica1966 Mostly, I just know he would do it better and be more accurate and informative.
Good suggestion. My guess is silicon products are safe; the other things, not. Would be nice to know though.
Single-use plastic water bottles would be another product worth featuring in a video. If harmful chemicals from them are detectable in people, a Dr Greger video on it could discourage people from buying them (or remind them not to) to prevent more plastic waste
What about high grade silicone?
This series on cookware and utensil safety is so very helpful, thanks!
Well done as usual. Greatly appreciated as well as we have a couple polyamide spatulas- correction, had a couple. I agree with other commenters that further reviews (and/or updated ones) regarding silicone utensils would be helpful. We have recently acquired a few.
I'm not certain that wood utensils are universally safe for cooking. Often they are coated with a finish to enhance their appearance and make them resistant to effects of heat and moisture. Even untreated/coated wood could possibly release chemicals into the food, depending on the species of wood used; especially species of wood from foreign countries, which are showing up with increasing frequency in our markets.
I haven't researched this concern as thoroughly as needed to be in a position to say that there is definitely a significant risk; consequently, I just use stainless steel utensils from trusted manufacturers.
+
This is so true, the coating on my wooden spoon is long gone. Into my digestive system, it sucks
Agreed, thank you.
Especially bamboo I think which is glued and pressed together...
I grew up in the 1960s and 70s eating on Melmac dinnerware. No wonder I turned into a hippie.
Cat diet
you can call me Reverend Alf
How are these products on the market, if they create such a health risk? Thanks for the heads up Doc.
money
@@Oxim-fz3so It was a rhetorical exclamation. I'm fully aware that money trumps health concerns every time. Look at the meat industry.
@@Oxim-fz3so Money really doesn't have a whole lot to do with it, there are plenty of alternatives which cost even less than these poisonous products. Hemp and bamboo, for instance. It's not just a coincidence that practically every type of commonly used household item and food is essentially a poison. Many people believe money to be the reason, but when you realise there are countless cheaper and healthier alternatives it soon becomes clear that cost has nothing to do with it.
Steph Ss greed 😕
@@shermansadventure1151 just because there are cheaper alternatives doesn't mean those alternatives make more money. Do you know anyone who buys wooden, bamboo, or hemp kitchenware? I sure don't which means lots of money is involved in those poison plastic ones everyone uses
Such important information, especially because these are things we use every time we cook!
Excellent video again Greg.
Thank you so much doc, you really are improving the world
thanks Dr G.
please do a video on are silicon cooking utensils safe? ty love your videos!
Thank you for the information!
Spoons and forks also solid food can easily scrape minute amounts into your food even at low temperatures
great info as always. thanks
Thanks for this information. I’ m not going to use those anymore!
Dear Dr. Greger can you make a video about hormonal imbalance, Xenoestrogen and Teflon please?
Just a thought for a video: is scraping the inside of any plastic peanut butter jar, or any plastic container safe?
I assume they all have food grade coatings, but what about when you scrape that last bit of PB off....jar after jar for decades? How much of that coating comes of and what comes with it?
I was planning to buy new kitchenware, so thanks for this series. I hope the next material is silicone.
Well-said!
Can you make a video about "Dishwashing liquid"?
I'd be interested in that also
no need i can tell u dont drink it
...10 out of 10 people eventually die...
What is the impact on health of using silicon cooking utensils?.
Amazing video with such valuable content! Always super appreciated from Doctor G 😎🙌💯
I've always ate off of plastic plates in my youth putting them in microwave and such and being a kid would chew on some of the melted bits. Maybe injesting some if I'm unluckily.
I took a culinary class in high-school and learned the scary fact about the fumes I was so happily huffing. I tend to avoid them now as much as I can despite being made fun of for it. But sometimes I do cook with a plastic fork I quickly dip in and out.
What about food grade silicone?
How do you know if your dish is made of Melamine?
Hello Doctor from México 🇲🇽☣️
What about silicone spatulas? Is silicone safe to cook with?
Would love for you to do a single video where you show all the tools you use instead of piece-mealing this info out one video at a time
Make sure the wooden utensil is not coated with epoxy and nor coated with any treatment to help it look more glossy or the dishwasher safe
What about wood?
What about silicone utensils?
I don't think there has been enough research done on silicone.
^
.
@@Ad-Infinitum So we won't know...
...until we put it to the test.
I do not know if it is the same silicone, but a lot of women get silicon implants.
1:35
2:37 use
Have curious concern using bamboo utensils with cooking(heat) since most bamboo which are layered use GLUE . Is the glue safe?
What about polypropylene?
blimey why are they still for sale???? I'm sure lots are still in charity shops etc. too
I've been a struggling vegan for a couple of years now. Until earlier this year where I've completely weaned off animals and animal byproducts. I've been following your YT channel. You are a major factor on helping me become a more plant based, whole foods lifestyle person. I am curious. I bought sets of microwave safe containers and plastic/silicone cooking utensils. On your video from last week about melamine and polyamide plastic; are they safe to microwave foods with and regarding the utensils, are they safe to cook with on my non-stick pans? Are all plastic-based dishes and utensils unsafe and should I get rid of them? Thank you, Dr. Greger.
Do you honestly think you're helping animals by being vegan?
@@alejandrom3841 YT troll?
@@czarmanigbas5635 in other words no
please examine wooden and bamboo spoons/bowls because they often also contain glues with formaldehyde
damn--- i value the content-- but watching this man is extremely difficult!
My comment is somewhat, "tongue in cheek", but California has declared that nearly all wood products are potentially carcinogenic.
So I need a new spatula, new frying pans and new food containers.
Oh no :(
Damn, glad I saw this first. Had a set of melamine dishes on my amazon wishlist
Those silicon molds might be toxic as well, I have never felt comfortable with them...😖😖😖
Why?
.
@@dereksevcik6595 keep in mind that those black utensils were considered safe for cooking, now we know they are not.
The only melamine stuff I once had was a bowl for baby food which was the favorite plate of my son 😖.
Plastic is plastic, somehow it will leak its toxic components.
Silicon objects don't give me a good feeling... I 😩
@@o0WarmBreeze0o ah wasnt aware about the black utensils history.. I use silicon spatulas but always try to minimize its contact to the pan. I will probably switch to bamboo :)
Hi Dr Green! In passing I really enjoyed your book ' Hiw not to Die" my ? Is what if it is mix with material, I was looking for cotton socks that had 68% cotton, 30% POLYAMIDE n 2% Elastane? Probably not good idea since its not good with utensils or dishes right?
I guess we should also avoid plastic coffee makers since they're exposed to high temperatures
As usual a more traditional way of cooking is better. Just use cast iron cookware, utensils that are wooden and you'll be fine.
What about ceramic dishes that are mostly made from China, how safe are they? Or from other countries, do they have heavy metals in them and leach from heat
good question....all those crazy painted noodle bowls
So many things from China have high amounts of lead and asbestos it's good to stay away from them as much as possible.
Stay Safe 😷
definitely good to stay away from red yellow and orange. They likely contain Kadmium.
May I ask if a lathed wood bowl is safe to use for hot soup? Thank you🙏🏻
Should be excellent depending on the finish. Use food safe wax or oil. Also check for wood species.
I just wish they didn't put all these chemicals in everything we use. It is hard to avoid this stuff it is everywhere
How do you know if you have Melamine?
It's got unique properties. Very rigid plastic. Unfortunately, Tupperware uses it to make microwave cookware.
Silicone wasn’t mentioned for utensils. That’s safe, right?
..what kinds of glue --assuming "food safe" are used?
Or simply use low heat to cook. Deep frying, baking or roasting with these utensils are definitely harmful
how about the painting products used in ceramic or porcelain?
Do you mean the pigments embedded in the glaze, or the paint on the surface?
Right, I just watched something about lead in ceramic mugs especially in dark colored ceramics. Now I'm confused.
@@shellym79 Lead is traditionally added to some glazes to give them a stronger sheen or a cleaner white. As far as I know it is not used by modern factories, but can be in use by small potteries or ceramicist, especially in underdeveloped countries. Therefore it is prudent to check souvenirs, use them for display and put a napkin under fruit or cookies.
@@ludicrousone8706 on the surface
i m a future nutritionist.nd i want to learn more and more about it...m from pakistan...if there is any information about online classes on basic nutrotion ,i would like to join...plzzz make me inform if possible...thank u😊😇
wow
Bamboo.
Darn it. I was using melamine for non cooking purposes and thought that was ok. I was avoiding ceramic mugs because of possible lead content (it's apparently quite common and not always clear if you're buying lead-free ceramics, or so I heard). So what about ceramics and lead?
I don't think lead is used in glazed ceramics anymore unless you are buying vintage stuff made in 1980s or before.
@@steeping Really? That would sure make things more simple.
@@hakunamatata1352 Yeah, I think that's the case as well. My grandma was a ceramic artist in the 70's and 80's and I know she mentioned that glazes have become a lot safer now.
Matata , have good day my friend .
Thank you all for your comments. Have a lovely day & stay safe ❤🙏😊
Thank you Dr. Greger! These days I just figure any of the new--within the last 50 years--chemically made utensils and cookware aren't safe, including silicone! Simple is better.
Hello lovely people .
wait so what can we use?
He gave a lot of examples in the video. Try glass, ceramic, and wood.
ParadymShift Music yes I should have just waited till the end of the video. Patience is something I need to work on haha thanks :)
@@ffiontill5924 Haha not to worry. And sure thing! ^-^
For what it's worth, I've never been happier than with bamboo cookware
wood and stainless steel
Alright Dr. Greger I'm throwing out my melamine and polyamide utensils today!
I use 100% silicone spatulas and they are 100% safe .
I only use wood utensils
Oh no. Bakers use that black one..
This man has been doing god’s work for years. He tells us what is healthy and what is not. If this dude sells out humanity is done.
Dang it! I have a cast iron sink that breaks so many ceramic and glass dishes and bowls, I’ve been having to use plastic! :(
Use a Silikone mag in the bottom until further notice from Dr Greger, or a towel
Most things made in China would not pass quality check if quality check was done.
You can't use stainless steel utensils in good cook ware you will scratch the coating and ruin your pots & pans.....
Polyamide = Nylon.
Yes very clear wooden and stainless steel is safe both plastic and foil is dangerous
So let's all use the Magic Eraser to clean! Wtf is wrong with this world?
I'll just eat straight out of the ground with my mouth like an animal. Nothing is safe anymore.
I have never ever in my adult life used melamine or plastics in my home. It's all lead free glass and stainless steel for us. Not even ceramics or clay. No porcelain for us either, or wood (bacteria factor).
Damm ... I want to be like you , when I grow up man 🙂
💚💚💚
😲😲😲😲
😂
Just go with wood and be done with it.
should we throw our utensils out?
Only you can decide...
Utensils are replaceable. Your health is not.
Use them for gardening...?
Yo doc, you look tired. Take some more time for yourself. Appreciate you work
Plastic spatula causes problems metal one scratches the pan causing problems can’t win!
Another live saving public announcement!
Hardly life saving, but worth being aware of
Didn't he mention kidney damage? -That can kill people...
It is sad, that with this video (maybe others as well) a big advantage of nutritionfacts.org has gone. Where are original videos with *no speaker visible on a video*. Is it all pushed by brand marketing? In fact, what is the showing a speaker for, besides distraction? Value added is knowledge. Naturally, I am not talking about Q&A videos.
i dont no what the materials are but naturally i think its all prettty dodgey, i dont think cooking food is very healthy
Is it ok to lose 400gr a day ?
Lol
🙄 ok, just get the stuff out of the kitchen.
please japanese language！
I would love to watch your videos, but they you talk drives me insane. Like what the heck are you doing speeding up and slowing down 50 times in a single sentence?
Everything has the potential to kill you
Yeah, might as well stop wearing seat belts and hard hats.