RE1 Remake is still my favorite but Silent Hill 2 Remake is also amazing,the originals RE4 and SH2 are my favorite games of all time and i'm glad both remakes are phenomenal.
I was really impressed with the Silent Hill 2 remake Very enjoyable and an amazing horror experience. (: But, I'm a big Resi Girl through and through. 😊 As of right now Resident Evil 4 remake is my favorite Resident Evil game. RE2 (Both versions) are very close. Especially since four remake came out in a time in my life where I was going through a lot emotionally and it helped me through it. But yes horror game wise Silent Hill 2 remake blew me away and definitely true terror (: Great list as always Ruben
RE1 remake is my fav. I loved 2 and 4 though too. Silent Hill 2 was great and I'm so glad it was and hopefully it leads to 1 and 3 getting a remake. Great vid man
Dead Space Remake was soo much fun. I played it more than the RE4 Remake and I got them both at the same time. RE4 Remake is also great, I'd probably have them tied
I love how your first 5 positions could be switched depending on how you are feeling in a specific moment. What I mean is, those games are so good that you can put RE4 in number 5 but maybe in number 1 the week later and so on and so forth.
They rejected nerd space games, because he spoke the truth I agree so hard with SH2 remake. I didn’t think anything would top how hard I loved RE4 remake, but Bloober did it!
It really took 24 years for people to find another survival horror remake dethroning RE1, that's a testament to how good RE1Make truly is. Although I still believe RE1Make to be the absolute pinnacle survival horror remake, Bloober Team did something special with Silent Hill 2.
In the nicest way possible I always watch these RE videos to fall asleep so I appreciate all of them😇but boy you’re uploading 24/7 have a day off girl 😘
I really liked the lollipop chainsaw remake because it was fun to play through it again with better graphics (I know this isn’t a remake but more of a remaster)
I liked the video. I agree with it most of the time. I think RE1 Remake was good. RE4 Remake was good as well. They would have ranked higher for me. SH2 Remake I liked it a lot.
agreed lol. Again, my mind could very well change over the next year as one thing going for RE1 Remake is that even 20 something years later I'm still loving it every time I replay it and I can't guarantee that'll be the case for Silent Hill 2 Remake. But, at this moment if you were to ask me, I give the slight edge to SH2 remake.
Honestly I’m a fan of the RE4 remake, it did Justice for Luis by making him more involved in the story, and they did a tremendously good job with Ashley. Fans thought of her as annoying in the OG RE4, the Remake made her likable, more helpful, and I think I’ve her are that people might want to see her again on the Resident Evil Universe
@@meangravy9286 her having a health bar in the OG I heard irritated a lot of people, the remake only incapacitated her to where she needed to be let up by Leon, which was a big improvement. Also she was a lot more helpful in the remake
IMO, Resident Evil 1, Silent Hill 2 and Dead Space are the perfect remakes (Not games, just remakes) Because neither of them cut any content and instead, they expanded upon it.
Imo SH2R definitely takes it as far as pure atmosphere and puzzles go but RE2R is the greatest survival horror game ever created and i’m afraid we will never get a game as perfect as it ever again. It has it all, atmosphere, music, amazing art work with the guts and gore, intensity, puzzles (easy but still a good amount of puzzles), replayability, weapon diversity, isolation, and most importantly SURVIVAL. While RE4 and it’s remake are incredible games; sadly they are NOT survival horror games. They are action horror games. Never once through any playthrough of a RE4 game did i ever feel like i was truly unsafe. RE2R always had me on edge especially on HC mode because of resource scarcity and certain decisions impacting your game dependant on which resources you utilize or save. The only other RE that brought that survival horror magic back from my childhood was RE7. This is all just my opinion though. Glad you are enjoying SH2! It’s a great remake!
RE2R: cuts everything that made it unique from the other RE games RE Fans: I can’t believe they butchered RE3, RE2R was amazing. The greatest game ever made.
Ooof hard disagree but you each their own. The main thing cut in RE2R was the AB Scenario. RE3R cut locations, bosses, and even toned down the titular villain drastically. Major difference between RE2R & RE3R imo, but I still find RE3R a fun game, just not a good remake.
@NerdSpaceGames Wrong NerdSpaceGames, you shouldn't go with a selfish request on story like Resident Evil 2 remake because the story doesn't need a confusing a, and b story route. So 1st and 2nd run did right and original didn't. Capcom knows about confusing canon in original Resident Evil 2 and fixed it in the remake version.
Your channel and content are truly fantastic. Yout narration, tone, and general content is definitely watch worthy. I hope you continue receiving the deserved recognition. All the best ✌🏻 ❤️
I have a soft spot for Project Zero 2 Wii Édition. The original Project Zéro 2 Crimson Butterfly is one of my favourite survival horror game of all time from one of the scariest franchise ever (which I call Project Zéro since I live in Europe) and porting it on the Wii was a good way to revisit the expérience. Plus the haunted house mod was amazing back then. To me, the 2002 remake of Resident Evil 1 is still the best remake of all time, but I loved this Alone in the Dark, and the remake of Silent Hill 2 turned out to be incredible despite my worries. It comes as close second to RE1. I'm also glad I'm European so we got an official release of Project Zéro 2 on Wii, and Forbidden Siren 2, plus the French exclusive release of the manga Siren Rebirth based on the first Siren game.
I definitely need to play Dead Space and SH2 remake one of the days. That being said RE1, RE2, RE4, and System Shock remakes are some of the best I've ever played with what they've done. Would love to see other horror remakes in the future like Code Veronica and Silent Hill 1.
Capcom: Nope on Code Veronica for a remake it's stay eternity as a spin-off nothing else. It's staying on hard difficulty and permanent fixed cameras angles.
I would struggle between SH2 and RE4 Remakes as to which one is better but they would be one and two for me. I'm just blown away by how good they are. Likewise with RE2 and System Shock but RE2 would be 3rd. Haven't played Dead Space remake yet. RE1 I wish they had redone like 2 and 4.
Solid and tough to pick list, love to see Dead Space getting a mention! I’d have to pick as a top 5: 1. Resident evil remake 2. Dead Space remake 3. Resident evil 2 remake 4. Resident evil 4 remake 5. The last of us part 1
TLOU is not a survival horror and cannot be in that same category despite having some horror elements, it’s mainly a story-driven game with survival aspects…..
Finally someone has said it Silent Hill 2 Remake is absolutely phenomenal and is definitely the greatest horror game remake of all time I love it so much I can’t wait for SH 1, SH 3, and SH 4: The Room Bloober deserves respect and praise and for the people who shit on Bloober and the game before it came out need to apologize immediately
I just love how objective you are, is dificult to hear you say something like "this is obviously the best game". I also wanted to say that I think it would be good for a video like this to show the original and the remake, mostly for people that hadn't play or whatch the originals. Great video anyway, love your work
For me, what kills SH2R are three moments: Hospital Basement scene with Maria, The Corridor Mary conversation and... the most disapointing one, Maria's final letter. The actress can act, she was never the problem. It was a direction one.
hmm while I agree on all of these scenes being a downgrade to the original, I think that's still a small trade off compared to all of the improvements we got in other areas. I mean most remakes are going to disappoint in some areas. RE2 the lack of A & B Scenarios, RE1 Remake the lack of additional branching paths seen in the original, and RE4's Ada VA & lore regarding Krauser are just a few examples of this. But just because there are changes we dislike, if a majority of it is improved on in comparison then I think it's a fair trade off hence why I'm still fine with giving SH2 remake the top spot. But I totally see where you're coming from tbh because I do agree with those segments being less impactful in the remake.
@@NerdSpaceGames totally fair dude. And i agree in those cases as well. I think i have more gripes in this situation since finally i'm experiencing the gaming preservation discussion with one of my favorite games of all time in Silent Hill 2 (2001). And when i had an awesome example on Tomb Raider Remastered this year on what gaming preservation can be, im so salty on SH2R still. But yes, there is A LOT of things i loved in the remake. Even story wise: Abstract Daddy almost made me cry cuz it was so much cruel then the original and i really liked the new Maria interactiom aditions. And Stillness and Bliss are one of my new fav endings fpr this game (alomg side the dog one lmao) Maybe since its so recent i need some time to get used to the new letter or corridor scenes... or... get rid of the salt in my life (cuz u know... to be... less salty... ok ill be going now)
@@ViniPessoal I totally respect those points. tbh I'm one with game preservation as well. The thing is that I welcome remakes, but I also want the originals to be readily available. It's why I've been wanting a Resident Evil Trilogy Remaster on modern consoles. I hate that those games are not readily available on modern consoles for new players to appreciate. But I also welcome modern interpretations of my favorite video games as well. So I guess in a way I'm more in the middle to the point where I want people to be able to enjoy the originals while also welcoming modern versions of these classics for a new audience to enjoy that are not fans of the style of gameplay of the classics. Silent Hill 2 is a perfect example of that as it has a story that far surpasses that of most video games out there and I don't mind a modern remake of it if it means one, it gives me a new way to appreciate one of my favorite games of all time, two it gives the opportunity for a new generation to appreciate the story, and three if I'm still able to readily enjoy the original when I want to. The last is the issue that we find ourselves dealing with right now and hopefully that situation improves over time.
@@NerdSpaceGames Agreed. I dream with something like whats happening with Tomb Raider happens with RE and other franchises. (Played the first Tomb Raiders trought the remasters and really recomend them if you didnt)
@@NerdSpaceGames oh come on! just go with what u like :D! bring more people here dont end up like Ink Ribbon dude currently has anything basicly to talk about but decided to stick only to horrors and i cant anymore keep up 💀
Awesome list , now bring on n code Veronica remake , silent hill 1 and as someone who just played Dino crisis for the first time on PS premium , give us that too
I’m around halfway through the Silent Hill 2 remake (just finished Otherworld Brookhaven) and so far I am absolutely loving it. The atmosphere, sound design, and art direction in each area have so far never ceased to astonish me. The atmosphere is so oppressive and the audio is so frightening that I honestly think I would currently put this game on par with Alien Isolation in terms of how scary it is. I also think the characters are just as captivating as the original but in a different way. The interactions with the characters in the original felt surreal and eerie from the start. Whereas in the remake (from what I have seen so far at least) most of the characters seem to start off acting like real people but then gradually become more creepy and uncanny as the game progresses.
The OG Resident Evil 3 is such a short but fun game, how they managed to botch the remake despite having some decent moments in the first hour of gameplay is so disappointing to this day. It should easily have been a Top 10 Remake.
I honestly considered putting it in over The Last Of Us Part 1 or Corpse Party (2021), but while I'm one of the biggest defenders of Resident Evil 3 Remake about how I don't think it's a bad game and it's really fun, I do stand by the fact that it's not a good REMAKE. Hence why I decided against putting it on this list. As a standalone game though I find it more fun than most and I do think it gets more heat than it deserves tbh albeit the lack of certain aspects from the original disappointing me still.
Sadly, I don't think I'll get to enjoy silent hill 2 remake, but I will definitely give dead space remake a go. I kind of avoided it for some reason. Thanks for the list. Sometimes they opens my eyes to games that you didn't think were worth giving a go 😊
@@NerdSpaceGames I will definitely give it a go then. You could say I'm a bit of a resi nerd too 😅 Especially resident evil 2, like yourself. I actually started building the entirety of raccoon city in Minecraft. It's quite sad really 🤣
As long fan of RE and SH ... and if I be honest, I am a bigger fan of SH... l appreciate what they do with SH, but for me , best remake is always resident evil 2002 remake
I would have been excited to play the Dead Space Remake if I didn't play the original. I know you said Isaac can talk and mentioned some other insignificant changes, but it looks like the exact original game. It's definitely not worth buying if you played the original.
Wrong, it’s definitely worth buying because the developers made numerous changes (that you will spot if you have played the original and now play the remake), it’s not exactly the same and the changes made are for the best….
I thought the comment about the Dead Space remake feeling “more” like survival horror was weird, since the first two Dead Space games were some of the scariest survival horror games out there. I feel like the resources were plenty scarce in those games on higher difficulties, and it didn’t seem that changed in the remake, with them being relatively plentiful on low difficulties and quite scarce on higher difficulties. All that having been said, the remake is excellent, but I just found the slights at the original weird. I actually think RE4 needed a remake more than Dead Space, because Dead Space had already mastered the third person shooter mechanics that were kinda clunky (particularly the inability to move and aim) in RE4. I know RE4 was hugely innovative in practically inventing the third person shooter, but the mechanics are kinda frustrating now. The remake is a lot more enjoyable to play for me, whereas the mechanics already available in the original Dead Space (awful zero-G and that asteroid mission aside) are still pretty in line with modern third person shooters.
Yeah, Dead Space remake didn't get any awards being everyone hated EA, so Dead Space remake should be number 5 and Resident Evil 4 remake should be number 2 or 1. So Code Veronica should have the backtracking being you like Silent Hill 2 remake being long.
I fucking love all the horror remakes. I'm thrilled when classic games gey reimaagined for modern graphics and gameplay in mind. It doesn't detract from the original game, and let's us revisit something we love, while also getting to experience again for the first time, a second time.
So what that there was "only" a 9-year gap for TLOU remake? Resident Evil Remake only came out 6 years after the original (1996 to 2002), MGS The Twin Snakes was the same ('98 to '04). Hell, TLOU pt2 to remake/remaster was only 4 years. The point was there was a significant generation gap between the original and the remake, and a semi-good reason to bring the controls / functionality into line with the updates brought in by Pt 2.
I hope so! I know rumors are leaning toward SH3 but I pray that's absolutely not true as Silent Hill 1 & 3 are the most connected storylines of the franchise and it makes much more sense to remake the first one before going to 3.
I mean before RE4R the last RE game was Village and it's heavily rumoured 9 is next. They have different teams working on sequels and remakes so both 9 and another remake are probably in development right now.
The last of us part 1 is just as much a remake as any on this list as far as far as I’m concerned, just because the story isn’t changed doesn’t make it any less a remake, massive graphics bump, completely overhauled the enemy & companion AI & added all the accessibility functions as part 2.
I mean I still consider it a remake hence why it cracks this list; mainly due to the gameplay mechanics featured in the remake. The graphics I don't think it's fair to automatically give it credit for that because remasters do that all of the time. Look at Dead Rising. But I agree, it's definitely a remake. The only reason why I say it's too a lesser extent than other entries on this list is because the rest of the remakes here did a lot more with reimagining the game. For example, other than improving the visuals of the cutscenes, dialogue and voice acting remains unchanged. Other than gameplay & accessibility mechanics, the game doesn't feature additional new features (like more content, additional modes). In fact, the argument could be made that it lacks content that was in the original in the form of the multiplayer experience that they promised us, but never got as it got canceled for the remake. Overall, I agree with you. It's a remake and it's a damn good one, especially with the changes made to visuals, gameplay mechanics, and accessibility features. But when you compare it to the other games on this list, it lacks more innovative improvements and features that keep it from moving higher on this list. But of course that's just my opinion.
It does fit the criteria of a remake since they actually did remake a lot of things, it's just that they basically remade everything the same as the original.
Silent Hill 2 lost it's unique tone and unique lynchian dream like vibe, and unique storytelling structure, even gameplay wise, they stretched some parts, the combat is becoming boring because now there's lots of enemies and seems like they MAKE you fight them and combat is not too great to keep you engaged for that long, so its no way near the first place, yeah it's nice but it's the same level like Re4 or Re2(even if it killed B scenarios) Or Re1 is the best remake of all time (The thing with Sh2 Remake, is that Sh series was dead for so long and they have done a good game in so long, and because of that ppl become biased and claiming it's the best remake or better than Og Sh)
Yeah I totally respect your view. Tbh, as I said in the video, the top 5 of this video could easily be interchangeable based on preference. I'm someone who prefers puzzles and atmospheric horror over gameplay in my Survival Horror games, which is why Silent Hill 2 Remake probably appeals to me more. There's not even an argument to be made that Resident Evil 4 has the best gameplay mechanics of any Survival Horror Game while RE2R is pretty impressive on it's on, with both beating out Silent Hill 2 Remake in that department. But as someone that prefers atmosphere, immersion, puzzles, and haunting storytelling in my Survival Horror games along with the traditional mechanics of Survival Horror Genre like limited resources and backtracking; Silent Hill 2 Remake might very well be one of the perfect matches for a gamer like me. Of course my mind could change a year from now, but if you were to ask me right now what the best horror remake is in my eyes, I'd say SH2 Remake.
No I don't find it. Disappointing, that Ari 4 is number 5 to me. It was the worst game in the reside will franchise or one of the worst, but the remake did justice from the original
Knew it, vid is made just to promote Silent Hill 2 remake. low key saying it is better than RE remakes, but the sales will speak otherwise. Sorry, someone's personal psychological horror is not as appealing as being in a situation where the threat is physically real to anyone. Nancy from Nightmare on Elm Street would be more afraid of Michael Myers than Freddy for a reason.
I am sorry but silent hill 2 remake is a disgrace to the original and does not deserve being top 5 here. The story is silent hill 2 original main strength and terrible voice acting in the remake ruined the whole story. Not to forget the atmosphere is lost somehow and in no way comparable to the original. And yeah they improved the gameplay but it is still bad, the dodge mechanic get extremly boring later cause u literally keep fighting the same enemy over and over. And how dare they change the script for the last scene in the game , the original scene made me cry, now the new one is just shallow.
Imagine calling the voice acting of the remake “horrible” while glazing the originals voice acting lmao You can call one bad but you have to say the other isn’t great
@@dogninja0180 no need to imagine that, compare urself the scene with angela on the ground with the knife or her finale scene from the original with the remake, no feeling what so ever in the remake completly ruined. And do not make me start about maria's scenes, not a single good one in the remake, her delivery in all scenes is just emotionless like someone reading u a script or some shit instead of exuding emotions. Did u even play the original? I kinda believe u did not......
@@3mangaming185 no I did play the original recently and let me tell you I was laughing my ass off on how bad the voice acting was, I am the same mf that plays the original resident evil on the ps1 and it’s to the same level of bad. Sorry I’m insulting your dear precious silent hill 2 but it’s not great
@@dogninja0180 ok dude "it is not great", what u mean it is not great???!!!. Silent hill 2 is regarded as one of the best horror games of all time and a classic, let's see if anyone will remember the remake in a year...... cause I doubt they will and I still doubt u played the original , u are juat one of those new gamers who are not the fans of the franchise and watched the walkthroughs of the original on yt and now think they know how it was.
@@3mangaming185 lmao look at you whining cuz I said something you like isn’t good This is my last message in this comment I’ve got better things to do than argue with you
Resident Evil 1 Remake... There we go. Everything else has been reimagining nonsense. What even is that? "Reimagining" how disgusting it is? To go back to the original game's vision and pretend that you can do better. How about being a faithful remake like RE1?
I mean I would agree that RE1 is probably the most faithful remake ever created but tbh it was also remade only 6 years after the original so not as much has changed for the franchise as later remakes. Nowadays, the next gen expect more for modern games so if that remake happened in the same style today, we’d love it as long time fans, but most modern gamers wouldn’t and it probably wouldn’t sell well sadly
@@NerdSpaceGames I don't know about that. People say the same thing about turn based RPG and how the older FF games wouldn't fly today and yet Persona and that new game they made is thriving. I believe there is a market for the classic RE style too.
you put RE4R at #5??? are you OUT of your mind??? i've played ALL the RE games, and RE4R stands at the TOP of the heap, UNCHALLENGED... RE4R is the undisputed KING of RE games... this "list" of yours is preposterous... ohh, and btw, RE never got a REMAKE... the 2002 RE game you put at #2 is a REMASTER with a few things added here and there...... you need to find a different hobby dude, because you don't know anything about the RE games, or gaming in general...
Ummm Resident Evil was a remake. The remake got a remaster in 2015 but the 2002 GameCube version was a remake of the 1996 game. And Resident Evil 4 remake is my favorite Resident Evil game currently but I still respect his opinions on his lists
@@AliLiz91 LOL LMFAO... so, let me get this straight: Capcom releases original RE in 1996, then they remake it in 2002, and then in 2015 Capcom releases a "remaster" of the remake??? LOL thats what you're saying??? LOL.. you couldn't be more WRONG... its ok to have opinions, but those opinions still need be based on FACTS... why would capcom release a NEW game, then 6 years later release a "remake"??? 2002 RE was nothing more then a HD remaster... and because that game was so popular, Capcom decided to add a few things to it... the 2015 version was released mainly for PC gamers...
This doesn't make you a fan of RE or gaming, this makes you obsessed. If a list makes you this upset, maybe Nerd Space isn't the one who needs to find a new hobby.
RE1 Remake is still my favorite but Silent Hill 2 Remake is also amazing,the originals RE4 and SH2 are my favorite games of all time and i'm glad both remakes are phenomenal.
I was really impressed with the Silent Hill 2 remake Very enjoyable and an amazing horror experience. (: But, I'm a big Resi Girl through and through. 😊 As of right now Resident Evil 4 remake is my favorite Resident Evil game. RE2 (Both versions) are very close. Especially since four remake came out in a time in my life where I was going through a lot emotionally and it helped me through it. But yes horror game wise Silent Hill 2 remake blew me away and definitely true terror (: Great list as always Ruben
RE1 remake is my fav. I loved 2 and 4 though too. Silent Hill 2 was great and I'm so glad it was and hopefully it leads to 1 and 3 getting a remake. Great vid man
Agreed my dude! Thanks!
Anytime a game that I like getting a remake is great. Shut up and take my money. Like what Fry says in Futurama.👍
Lmao same
Same
I love the Nostromo, but you best put some respect on the Ishimuras name! 😆
My bad lol
Dead Space Remake was soo much fun. I played it more than the RE4 Remake and I got them both at the same time. RE4 Remake is also great, I'd probably have them tied
I actually played it well before RE4 remake because I loved the Dead Space games probably before I’d even started playing Resident Evil.
@@Cwin-ny6bplet’s hope for a dead space 2 remake!
@@tonysmith5566I don't think going to happen being EA is evil and not good.
@ we must have hope
RE4 Remake is by far the best remake ever made, and possibly also the best game ever made
My g
Just 100% Silent Hill 2 remake, and fucking AMAZING game, all 8 endings
Damn bro u been grinding
I love how your first 5 positions could be switched depending on how you are feeling in a specific moment. What I mean is, those games are so good that you can put RE4 in number 5 but maybe in number 1 the week later and so on and so forth.
Couldn’t agree more. They really are interchangeable
Loved the list and Silent Hill 2 remake is just fucking amazing! I can't wait for the Silent Hill 1 remake.
Right?!! LFG!
They rejected nerd space games, because he spoke the truth
I agree so hard with SH2 remake. I didn’t think anything would top how hard I loved RE4 remake, but Bloober did it!
Thanks dude!
It really took 24 years for people to find another survival horror remake dethroning RE1, that's a testament to how good RE1Make truly is. Although I still believe RE1Make to be the absolute pinnacle survival horror remake, Bloober Team did something special with Silent Hill 2.
In the nicest way possible I always watch these RE videos to fall asleep so I appreciate all of them😇but boy you’re uploading 24/7 have a day off girl 😘
Lmao believe it or not, this is a very nice comment and I absolutely loved reading this! Thank you ❤️
I really liked the lollipop chainsaw remake because it was fun to play through it again with better graphics (I know this isn’t a remake but more of a remaster)
the RE2 remake was my first time playing RE and I loved it. It was so good.
SH2R definitely is the best remake for me right now
I bet u even didn’t play the original or understood anything of it
Re 4 remake and sh2 remake the goat
both are fantastic!
the actor for james should won best performance at the year end awards
I liked the video. I agree with it most of the time. I think RE1 Remake was good. RE4 Remake was good as well. They would have ranked higher for me. SH2 Remake I liked it a lot.
As a big Resident Evil fan i must say Silent Hill 2 remake is pretty good.
agreed lol. Again, my mind could very well change over the next year as one thing going for RE1 Remake is that even 20 something years later I'm still loving it every time I replay it and I can't guarantee that'll be the case for Silent Hill 2 Remake. But, at this moment if you were to ask me, I give the slight edge to SH2 remake.
@@NerdSpaceGames i would love to see re1 remake with coop. I hope capcom deliver it to us and its gonna be fun like re5.
Honestly I’m a fan of the RE4 remake, it did Justice for Luis by making him more involved in the story, and they did a tremendously good job with Ashley. Fans thought of her as annoying in the OG RE4, the Remake made her likable, more helpful, and I think I’ve her are that people might want to see her again on the Resident Evil Universe
Ashley is way worse on the remake eventho she can’t die technically 😂.
She’s more likable tho
@@meangravy9286 her having a health bar in the OG I heard irritated a lot of people, the remake only incapacitated her to where she needed to be let up by Leon, which was a big improvement. Also she was a lot more helpful in the remake
Silent Hill 2 remake, RE 1,2,3,4 remakes, Dead space remake.. 🔥🔥 🎮
literally almost all of those made my top 5 so happy to hear that lol
You earned a sub for mentioning Corpse Party
I absolutely love those games
Legend
IMO, Resident Evil 1, Silent Hill 2 and Dead Space are the perfect remakes (Not games, just remakes)
Because neither of them cut any content and instead, they expanded upon it.
I totally respect that tbh!
You saying the nostromo while talking about dead space had me twitching
Please forgive me lol
I just discovered Corpse Party in the last few weeks and pleasantly surprised to hear a mention
Imo SH2R definitely takes it as far as pure atmosphere and puzzles go but RE2R is the greatest survival horror game ever created and i’m afraid we will never get a game as perfect as it ever again. It has it all, atmosphere, music, amazing art work with the guts and gore, intensity, puzzles (easy but still a good amount of puzzles), replayability, weapon diversity, isolation, and most importantly SURVIVAL. While RE4 and it’s remake are incredible games; sadly they are NOT survival horror games. They are action horror games. Never once through any playthrough of a RE4 game did i ever feel like i was truly unsafe. RE2R always had me on edge especially on HC mode because of resource scarcity and certain decisions impacting your game dependant on which resources you utilize or save. The only other RE that brought that survival horror magic back from my childhood was RE7. This is all just my opinion though. Glad you are enjoying SH2! It’s a great remake!
RE2R: cuts everything that made it unique from the other RE games
RE Fans: I can’t believe they butchered RE3, RE2R was amazing. The greatest game ever made.
Ooof hard disagree but you each their own. The main thing cut in RE2R was the AB Scenario. RE3R cut locations, bosses, and even toned down the titular villain drastically. Major difference between RE2R & RE3R imo, but I still find RE3R a fun game, just not a good remake.
@NerdSpaceGames Wrong NerdSpaceGames, you shouldn't go with a selfish request on story like Resident Evil 2 remake because the story doesn't need a confusing a, and b story route. So 1st and 2nd run did right and original didn't. Capcom knows about confusing canon in original Resident Evil 2 and fixed it in the remake version.
Even with the cut content, RE2 remake is still a good game while RE3 is a disappointing game overall, cut sections included….
I can give 3
1. Belongs to the re 4 remake
2.Silent Hill 2 remake
3. Resident evil 2 remake which made me love the series even more
Your channel and content are truly fantastic.
Yout narration, tone, and general content is definitely watch worthy.
I hope you continue receiving the deserved recognition.
All the best ✌🏻 ❤️
Re2 remake is my favorite in terms of scare factor, I still get scared playing this game 😂
I absolutely love RE2R
It's such an awesome game (: I remember first playing it Just hearing Mr X's footsteps gave me such fright
I edge RE2R over Silent Hill 2 Remake, ever so slightly.
totally respect that of course!
Dead Space, RE2, RE4, Silent Hill 2 and RE1 without hesitation…
I have a soft spot for Project Zero 2 Wii Édition. The original Project Zéro 2 Crimson Butterfly is one of my favourite survival horror game of all time from one of the scariest franchise ever (which I call Project Zéro since I live in Europe) and porting it on the Wii was a good way to revisit the expérience. Plus the haunted house mod was amazing back then.
To me, the 2002 remake of Resident Evil 1 is still the best remake of all time, but I loved this Alone in the Dark, and the remake of Silent Hill 2 turned out to be incredible despite my worries. It comes as close second to RE1.
I'm also glad I'm European so we got an official release of Project Zéro 2 on Wii, and Forbidden Siren 2, plus the French exclusive release of the manga Siren Rebirth based on the first Siren game.
Gotta say, I am enjoying the hell out of Silent Hill 2, it is amazing.
I definitely need to play Dead Space and SH2 remake one of the days. That being said RE1, RE2, RE4, and System Shock remakes are some of the best I've ever played with what they've done. Would love to see other horror remakes in the future like Code Veronica and Silent Hill 1.
Capcom: Nope on Code Veronica for a remake it's stay eternity as a spin-off nothing else. It's staying on hard difficulty and permanent fixed cameras angles.
Yay my favorite Resident Evil 2 remake
My Top 5
1. Dead Space (2023)
2. Silent Hill 2 (2024)
3. Resident Evil 2 (2019)
4. Resident Evil 4 (2023)
5. Alone In The Dark (2024)
I would struggle between SH2 and RE4 Remakes as to which one is better but they would be one and two for me. I'm just blown away by how good they are. Likewise with RE2 and System Shock but RE2 would be 3rd. Haven't played Dead Space remake yet. RE1 I wish they had redone like 2 and 4.
Solid and tough to pick list, love to see Dead Space getting a mention! I’d have to pick as a top 5:
1. Resident evil remake
2. Dead Space remake
3. Resident evil 2 remake
4. Resident evil 4 remake
5. The last of us part 1
TLOU is not a survival horror and cannot be in that same category despite having some horror elements, it’s mainly a story-driven game with survival aspects…..
Finally someone has said it Silent Hill 2 Remake is absolutely phenomenal and is definitely the greatest horror game remake of all time I love it so much I can’t wait for SH 1, SH 3, and SH 4: The Room Bloober deserves respect and praise and for the people who shit on Bloober and the game before it came out need to apologize immediately
I was so hyped about the dead space remake last year, two of my favorite horror franchises is resident evil and dead space
Im extremely happy with the outcome with SH2R. bloober Team definitely delivered.
I just love how objective you are, is dificult to hear you say something like "this is obviously the best game". I also wanted to say that I think it would be good for a video like this to show the original and the remake, mostly for people that hadn't play or whatch the originals. Great video anyway, love your work
For me, what kills SH2R are three moments: Hospital Basement scene with Maria, The Corridor Mary conversation and... the most disapointing one, Maria's final letter. The actress can act, she was never the problem. It was a direction one.
hmm while I agree on all of these scenes being a downgrade to the original, I think that's still a small trade off compared to all of the improvements we got in other areas. I mean most remakes are going to disappoint in some areas. RE2 the lack of A & B Scenarios, RE1 Remake the lack of additional branching paths seen in the original, and RE4's Ada VA & lore regarding Krauser are just a few examples of this. But just because there are changes we dislike, if a majority of it is improved on in comparison then I think it's a fair trade off hence why I'm still fine with giving SH2 remake the top spot. But I totally see where you're coming from tbh because I do agree with those segments being less impactful in the remake.
@@NerdSpaceGames totally fair dude. And i agree in those cases as well. I think i have more gripes in this situation since finally i'm experiencing the gaming preservation discussion with one of my favorite games of all time in Silent Hill 2 (2001). And when i had an awesome example on Tomb Raider Remastered this year on what gaming preservation can be, im so salty on SH2R still. But yes, there is A LOT of things i loved in the remake. Even story wise: Abstract Daddy almost made me cry cuz it was so much cruel then the original and i really liked the new Maria interactiom aditions. And Stillness and Bliss are one of my new fav endings fpr this game (alomg side the dog one lmao) Maybe since its so recent i need some time to get used to the new letter or corridor scenes... or... get rid of the salt in my life (cuz u know... to be... less salty... ok ill be going now)
@@ViniPessoal I totally respect those points. tbh I'm one with game preservation as well. The thing is that I welcome remakes, but I also want the originals to be readily available. It's why I've been wanting a Resident Evil Trilogy Remaster on modern consoles. I hate that those games are not readily available on modern consoles for new players to appreciate. But I also welcome modern interpretations of my favorite video games as well. So I guess in a way I'm more in the middle to the point where I want people to be able to enjoy the originals while also welcoming modern versions of these classics for a new audience to enjoy that are not fans of the style of gameplay of the classics. Silent Hill 2 is a perfect example of that as it has a story that far surpasses that of most video games out there and I don't mind a modern remake of it if it means one, it gives me a new way to appreciate one of my favorite games of all time, two it gives the opportunity for a new generation to appreciate the story, and three if I'm still able to readily enjoy the original when I want to. The last is the issue that we find ourselves dealing with right now and hopefully that situation improves over time.
@@NerdSpaceGames Agreed. I dream with something like whats happening with Tomb Raider happens with RE and other franchises. (Played the first Tomb Raiders trought the remasters and really recomend them if you didnt)
hey Nerd Space!
Im again here watching u after some long break
wanted to ask how the Prince of Persia Franchise been going lately for ya? :D!
lol long time! Unfortunately I pivoted the channel over to horror due to what worked on the channel 😅
@@NerdSpaceGames oh come on! just go with what u like :D! bring more people here dont end up like Ink Ribbon dude currently has anything basicly to talk about but decided to stick only to horrors and i cant anymore keep up 💀
Oh god, every RE surpassed sh2 in every possible way imo. And you were right, I personally AM pissed off by re4 remake's placement
Silent Hill 1 already got a remake. It was called S.H. Shattered Memories ! 😮
lol you’re not wrong
Re 2 remake first game I brought with my grandfather back in 2019, it made me sadden his gone but I kept his jacket
Just played the last of us part 1 recently, such a great game glad to see it on one of your lists
Great video ps have you heard of the house of the dead
RE1 was the best. It revamped the whole game with more lore and content
Awesome list , now bring on n code Veronica remake , silent hill 1 and as someone who just played Dino crisis for the first time on PS premium , give us that too
Resident evil 2002 and Fatal Frame 2 are my favorite video games of all time
@ 12:43 The Nostromo? Isn't it the Ishimura in Dead Space? I'm fairly certain the Nostromo is from Aliens.
It is 😭
@@NerdSpaceGames It's all good. I only remembered cause I played Dead Space 1, 2 and 3 back to back last year or the year before?
I’m around halfway through the Silent Hill 2 remake (just finished Otherworld Brookhaven) and so far I am absolutely loving it. The atmosphere, sound design, and art direction in each area have so far never ceased to astonish me. The atmosphere is so oppressive and the audio is so frightening that I honestly think I would currently put this game on par with Alien Isolation in terms of how scary it is.
I also think the characters are just as captivating as the original but in a different way. The interactions with the characters in the original felt surreal and eerie from the start. Whereas in the remake (from what I have seen so far at least) most of the characters seem to start off acting like real people but then gradually become more creepy and uncanny as the game progresses.
Reuben my man! I have to go with SH2 as well. RE4 is a close second. Love the resurgence of silent hill.
The OG Resident Evil 3 is such a short but fun game, how they managed to botch the remake despite having some decent moments in the first hour of gameplay is so disappointing to this day. It should easily have been a Top 10 Remake.
I honestly considered putting it in over The Last Of Us Part 1 or Corpse Party (2021), but while I'm one of the biggest defenders of Resident Evil 3 Remake about how I don't think it's a bad game and it's really fun, I do stand by the fact that it's not a good REMAKE. Hence why I decided against putting it on this list. As a standalone game though I find it more fun than most and I do think it gets more heat than it deserves tbh albeit the lack of certain aspects from the original disappointing me still.
Sadly, I don't think I'll get to enjoy silent hill 2 remake, but I will definitely give dead space remake a go. I kind of avoided it for some reason.
Thanks for the list. Sometimes they opens my eyes to games that you didn't think were worth giving a go 😊
You’ll def like Dead Space remake if you love the modern RE remakes tbh
@@NerdSpaceGames I will definitely give it a go then. You could say I'm a bit of a resi nerd too 😅 Especially resident evil 2, like yourself. I actually started building the entirety of raccoon city in Minecraft. It's quite sad really 🤣
As long fan of RE and SH ... and if I be honest, I am a bigger fan of SH... l appreciate what they do with SH, but for me , best remake is always resident evil 2002 remake
I would have been excited to play the Dead Space Remake if I didn't play the original. I know you said Isaac can talk and mentioned some other insignificant changes, but it looks like the exact original game. It's definitely not worth buying if you played the original.
Wrong, it’s definitely worth buying because the developers made numerous changes (that you will spot if you have played the original and now play the remake), it’s not exactly the same and the changes made are for the best….
I thought the comment about the Dead Space remake feeling “more” like survival horror was weird, since the first two Dead Space games were some of the scariest survival horror games out there. I feel like the resources were plenty scarce in those games on higher difficulties, and it didn’t seem that changed in the remake, with them being relatively plentiful on low difficulties and quite scarce on higher difficulties. All that having been said, the remake is excellent, but I just found the slights at the original weird. I actually think RE4 needed a remake more than Dead Space, because Dead Space had already mastered the third person shooter mechanics that were kinda clunky (particularly the inability to move and aim) in RE4. I know RE4 was hugely innovative in practically inventing the third person shooter, but the mechanics are kinda frustrating now. The remake is a lot more enjoyable to play for me, whereas the mechanics already available in the original Dead Space (awful zero-G and that asteroid mission aside) are still pretty in line with modern third person shooters.
Yeah, Dead Space remake didn't get any awards being everyone hated EA, so Dead Space remake should be number 5 and Resident Evil 4 remake should be number 2 or 1. So Code Veronica should have the backtracking being you like Silent Hill 2 remake being long.
Now I need to get SH2
I fucking love all the horror remakes. I'm thrilled when classic games gey reimaagined for modern graphics and gameplay in mind. It doesn't detract from the original game, and let's us revisit something we love, while also getting to experience again for the first time, a second time.
So what that there was "only" a 9-year gap for TLOU remake? Resident Evil Remake only came out 6 years after the original (1996 to 2002), MGS The Twin Snakes was the same ('98 to '04). Hell, TLOU pt2 to remake/remaster was only 4 years. The point was there was a significant generation gap between the original and the remake, and a semi-good reason to bring the controls / functionality into line with the updates brought in by Pt 2.
Re4 is #1
Respect lol
my too five would have to be
5: resident evil 3
4: resident evil 2
3: resident evil 4
2: dead space
1: last of us part 1
Re3? 😂😂😂
That’s crazy because the last of us is not even a remake bro nothing was changed except graphics
I love the good remakes.
Do you think the next SH remake will be 1?
I hope so! I know rumors are leaning toward SH3 but I pray that's absolutely not true as Silent Hill 1 & 3 are the most connected storylines of the franchise and it makes much more sense to remake the first one before going to 3.
I’m the first one to see this and I like 👍🏾 it
Let’s go!
I think it’s time developers especially Capcom put a brake on remakes and use the same resources they used on the RE and SH2 remake son new stories.
I mean before RE4R the last RE game was Village and it's heavily rumoured 9 is next. They have different teams working on sequels and remakes so both 9 and another remake are probably in development right now.
The last of us part 1 is just as much a remake as any on this list as far as far as I’m concerned, just because the story isn’t changed doesn’t make it any less a remake, massive graphics bump, completely overhauled the enemy & companion AI & added all the accessibility functions as part 2.
I mean I still consider it a remake hence why it cracks this list; mainly due to the gameplay mechanics featured in the remake. The graphics I don't think it's fair to automatically give it credit for that because remasters do that all of the time. Look at Dead Rising.
But I agree, it's definitely a remake. The only reason why I say it's too a lesser extent than other entries on this list is because the rest of the remakes here did a lot more with reimagining the game. For example, other than improving the visuals of the cutscenes, dialogue and voice acting remains unchanged. Other than gameplay & accessibility mechanics, the game doesn't feature additional new features (like more content, additional modes). In fact, the argument could be made that it lacks content that was in the original in the form of the multiplayer experience that they promised us, but never got as it got canceled for the remake.
Overall, I agree with you. It's a remake and it's a damn good one, especially with the changes made to visuals, gameplay mechanics, and accessibility features. But when you compare it to the other games on this list, it lacks more innovative improvements and features that keep it from moving higher on this list. But of course that's just my opinion.
@@NerdSpaceGames fair enough, also sorry if what I said sounded slanted at you, it was just me getting tired of hearing others saying negative things.
The last of us is a remaster but loved the video!
Nope, that one is a remake according to naughty dog lol. Every other release of last of us was a remaster 😅
It does fit the criteria of a remake since they actually did remake a lot of things, it's just that they basically remade everything the same as the original.
I guess you’re right.
It’s a remake but it does not belong to the survival horror genre…..
Ohhhh man I'm just still wait a Remake my Favorit RE for next (RE OUTBREAK and Code Veronic)
12:02
Wait, the Nostromo? Not the Ishimura? 😜
Lmfao I’m an idiot!!
Alien on my mind lol
@@NerdSpaceGames still love the video 😊 keep it up!
Horror games with guys from boybands and shit. Now that is some next level thinking.
STARSSSSSSSS !!
Dead Space remake added NOTHING NEW,
if you played the original, you don't miss anything
no until dawn mention 😞
That’s a remaster not a remake
@@NerdSpaceGames it is a remake they remade the whole game built into unreal engine 5
@@NerdSpaceGamesyeah it is a remake, if you included tlou part 1 which is basically a glorified remaster until dawn remake counts
Recency bias
Totally fair assumption tbh
I really didn’t like dead space I don’t know why because I always hear it being praised but it just wasn’t for me
Where is RE3? RE2, RE4 and The Last Of Us 1 are amazing!
No one wants to hear about this remake, it’s crap…..
Silent Hill 2 lost it's unique tone and unique lynchian dream like vibe, and unique storytelling structure, even gameplay wise, they stretched some parts, the combat is becoming boring because now there's lots of enemies and seems like they MAKE you fight them and combat is not too great to keep you engaged for that long, so its no way near the first place, yeah it's nice but it's the same level like Re4 or Re2(even if it killed B scenarios)
Or Re1 is the best remake of all time
(The thing with Sh2 Remake, is that Sh series was dead for so long and they have done a good game in so long, and because of that ppl become biased and claiming it's the best remake or better than Og Sh)
No way sh2 remake is better than re4r and re2r. Scarier maybe, but better game in a vacuum, re4r and re2r are better.
Yeah I totally respect your view. Tbh, as I said in the video, the top 5 of this video could easily be interchangeable based on preference. I'm someone who prefers puzzles and atmospheric horror over gameplay in my Survival Horror games, which is why Silent Hill 2 Remake probably appeals to me more. There's not even an argument to be made that Resident Evil 4 has the best gameplay mechanics of any Survival Horror Game while RE2R is pretty impressive on it's on, with both beating out Silent Hill 2 Remake in that department. But as someone that prefers atmosphere, immersion, puzzles, and haunting storytelling in my Survival Horror games along with the traditional mechanics of Survival Horror Genre like limited resources and backtracking; Silent Hill 2 Remake might very well be one of the perfect matches for a gamer like me. Of course my mind could change a year from now, but if you were to ask me right now what the best horror remake is in my eyes, I'd say SH2 Remake.
No I don't find it. Disappointing, that Ari 4 is number 5 to me. It was the worst game in the reside will franchise or one of the worst, but the remake did justice from the original
Definitely recency B lol
Um...... No. Alone in the Dark was not even a mid-level game. It is poor quality, and boring to a fault.
SH2 remake really wasnt at all what it was hyped up to be
Knew it, vid is made just to promote Silent Hill 2 remake. low key saying it is better than RE remakes, but the sales will speak otherwise. Sorry, someone's personal psychological horror is not as appealing as being in a situation where the threat is physically real to anyone. Nancy from Nightmare on Elm Street would be more afraid of Michael Myers than Freddy for a reason.
I am sorry but silent hill 2 remake is a disgrace to the original and does not deserve being top 5 here.
The story is silent hill 2 original main strength and terrible voice acting in the remake ruined the whole story. Not to forget the atmosphere is lost somehow and in no way comparable to the original.
And yeah they improved the gameplay but it is still bad, the dodge mechanic get extremly boring later cause u literally keep fighting the same enemy over and over.
And how dare they change the script for the last scene in the game , the original scene made me cry, now the new one is just shallow.
Imagine calling the voice acting of the remake “horrible” while glazing the originals voice acting lmao
You can call one bad but you have to say the other isn’t great
@@dogninja0180 no need to imagine that, compare urself the scene with angela on the ground with the knife or her finale scene from the original with the remake, no feeling what so ever in the remake completly ruined.
And do not make me start about maria's scenes, not a single good one in the remake, her delivery in all scenes is just emotionless like someone reading u a script or some shit instead of exuding emotions.
Did u even play the original? I kinda believe u did not......
@@3mangaming185 no I did play the original recently and let me tell you I was laughing my ass off on how bad the voice acting was, I am the same mf that plays the original resident evil on the ps1 and it’s to the same level of bad. Sorry I’m insulting your dear precious silent hill 2 but it’s not great
@@dogninja0180 ok dude "it is not great", what u mean it is not great???!!!.
Silent hill 2 is regarded as one of the best horror games of all time and a classic, let's see if anyone will remember the remake in a year...... cause I doubt they will and I still doubt u played the original , u are juat one of those new gamers who are not the fans of the franchise and watched the walkthroughs of the original on yt and now think they know how it was.
@@3mangaming185 lmao look at you whining cuz I said something you like isn’t good
This is my last message in this comment I’ve got better things to do than argue with you
Resident Evil 1 Remake...
There we go.
Everything else has been reimagining nonsense.
What even is that? "Reimagining" how disgusting it is? To go back to the original game's vision and pretend that you can do better. How about being a faithful remake like RE1?
I mean I would agree that RE1 is probably the most faithful remake ever created but tbh it was also remade only 6 years after the original so not as much has changed for the franchise as later remakes. Nowadays, the next gen expect more for modern games so if that remake happened in the same style today, we’d love it as long time fans, but most modern gamers wouldn’t and it probably wouldn’t sell well sadly
@@NerdSpaceGames I don't know about that. People say the same thing about turn based RPG and how the older FF games wouldn't fly today and yet Persona and that new game they made is thriving. I believe there is a market for the classic RE style too.
you put RE4R at #5??? are you OUT of your mind??? i've played ALL the RE games, and RE4R stands at the TOP of the heap, UNCHALLENGED... RE4R is the undisputed KING of RE games... this "list" of yours is preposterous... ohh, and btw, RE never got a REMAKE... the 2002 RE game you put at #2 is a REMASTER with a few things added here and there...... you need to find a different hobby dude, because you don't know anything about the RE games, or gaming in general...
Ummm Resident Evil was a remake. The remake got a remaster in 2015 but the 2002 GameCube version was a remake of the 1996 game. And Resident Evil 4 remake is my favorite Resident Evil game currently but I still respect his opinions on his lists
Easy there 😅
Someone is "passionate". And yeah RE1 on this list was a remake originally coming out in 2002 on the GameCube.
@@AliLiz91 LOL LMFAO... so, let me get this straight: Capcom releases original RE in 1996, then they remake it in 2002, and then in 2015 Capcom releases a "remaster" of the remake??? LOL thats what you're saying??? LOL.. you couldn't be more WRONG... its ok to have opinions, but those opinions still need be based on FACTS... why would capcom release a NEW game, then 6 years later release a "remake"??? 2002 RE was nothing more then a HD remaster... and because that game was so popular, Capcom decided to add a few things to it... the 2015 version was released mainly for PC gamers...
This doesn't make you a fan of RE or gaming, this makes you obsessed. If a list makes you this upset, maybe Nerd Space isn't the one who needs to find a new hobby.
All these Remakes Suck except for Resident Evil 1's.
Fatal Frame 2 clocks it.
@@Bike-chan😂😂😂
@@HoldenHeath fr
RE1 being on this list is insane😂😂😂shit isn't bad but its trash compared to everything else
Just say u don’t like classic fixed camera angles the game was great
You just don’t get tank controls it’s fine
Everything you just said is something I guarantee you can't back up, just saying something is trash isn't a debate, you have to have actual points.
Silent Hill 2 remake is like a 6.5/10