Definitivamente lo que se escucha de voces catalogadas de mezzo están muy lejos de lo que deben ser. Fantástica Simionato, es que Rossini no es para cualquiera…extraordinaria aria. Muchas gracias ❤❤❤❤
If my memory still serves, I believe the year was 1959 when this magnificent voice made her Met debut in Il trovatore , if my date is wrong at least my memory of this debut is not.I was lucky enough to be in the audience and have ben entralled with her ever since. It is so wonderful that I can hear her again on TH-cam. It brings back wonderful memories. Thank you for the opportunity to hear her anytime I want
So easy, so clear-cut, without unnecessary vocal complications and lodadings :-), the most beautiful one can imagine si at the end - and this is the master sample of Rozina. BRAVA!!!
EXTRAORDINARIA, ME HA SORPRENDIDO, YA QUE CREÍA QUE ERA SÓLAMENTE MEZZO, PERO COMO SOPRANO ES INCREÍBLE. EXCELENTE INTERPRETACIÓN. BRAVO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!. GRACIAS POR SUBIR ESTE VIDEO.-
@@GiovanniGGori Lei è inoltre l'Amneris che preferisco, insieme a Dominguez, Stignani e Barbieri, ed è la mia preferita come Cenerentola, Jane Seymour, Adalgisa e anche Leonora di Guzman nella Favorita! È semplicemente fantastica 🤩💓
@@esterbruno8604 Io come Amneris adoro anche la Minghini Cattaneo! Ps: tra i ruoli interpretati magistralmente dalla Simionato hai dimenticato Isabella 😁
@@GiovanniGGori Giusto, la sua Isabella nell'Italiana in Algeri! 😍 La Minghini Cattaneo era leggendaria anche come Azucena nella famosa versione con Pertile* e Granforte (e la Carena purtroppo 🥲)! Un mezzosoprano esemplare 🤩
@@esterbruno8604 Concordo sulla Minghini Cattaneo, un mezzosoprano davvero esemplare. La sua morte, così come quella analoga del baritono Armando Borgioli, mi ha sempre colpito molto. E l'ho sempre trovata ingloriosa per una così bella voce come la sua.😔
@tamerlano I think you are wrong.. I find her florid singing lovely and all of her staccati are on pitch too. She was some singer... Her High B's are as easy as can be as well.
It's not that she couldn't sing coloratura, it's just that it wasn't limpid or fluid enough for this kind of aria. The sound is very robust, too heavy when placing runs, staccato etc. 'Aspirated' is the right word for this as others have said.
Simionato sang staccati really well. However, she made all the coloratura part in this aria into staccati. Not fluid enough. Anyway, during her time, I must say most Italian mezzo sopranos (even sopranos) were so clumsy in coloratura parts.
@kgarmaker123 I just don't think she had a great florid technique, sorry...the execution is clumsy or inaccurate often. The CHARACTER is fabulously drawn, but the florid moments aren't ideal. Yes, the staccati are in tune, but even large and immobile voices can sing staccati...how may Queens of the Night have you heard where the staccati are flawless, but the coloratura triplets are messy? I've heard many.
May be you preffer Singers like Bartoli. She sings like sewing machine. Everytime the same color, the same "florid technique". Sempre ideale, sempre la stessa.
I adore Simionato, but Rossini is really better modern mezzos. Mind you, NO ONE sings the Aida Judgement scene today like Simionato did...but, florid singing was not really her cup of tea and it shows..
Rosina was written originally as a soprano role, and Simionato is a true Verdian mezzo. NO bueno. She would be a much better Isabella from Italian Girl.
Definitivamente lo que se escucha de voces catalogadas de mezzo están muy lejos de lo que deben ser. Fantástica Simionato, es que Rossini no es para cualquiera…extraordinaria aria. Muchas gracias ❤❤❤❤
Много раз слушала эту арию в разном исполнении. Но это самое лучшее!!! Браво, браво, браво!!!
Bravo bravo brsvo
If my memory still serves, I believe the year was 1959 when this magnificent voice made her Met debut in Il trovatore , if my date is wrong at least my memory of this debut is not.I was lucky enough to be in the audience and have ben entralled with her ever since. It is so wonderful that I can hear her again on TH-cam. It brings back wonderful memories. Thank you for the opportunity to hear her anytime I want
SOOO JEALOUS!!!!!
Straordinaria!!!
wonderful acting with the voice. Her Rosina is playful and flirtty but with a core of grandeur and steel. Love it. Thank you for posting!
So easy, so clear-cut, without unnecessary vocal complications and lodadings :-), the most beautiful one can imagine si at the end - and this is the master sample of Rozina. BRAVA!!!
Beautiful singing ! Brava GIULIETTA SIMIONATO :)
Best version for me 🌷
Great phrasing and musicality among other qualities!
Brava!!!
....che meraviglia.....!!!!!
One can forgive M. Simionato many sins because .. simply because....well, the sheer musicality. And greatness.
EXTRAORDINARIA, ME HA SORPRENDIDO, YA QUE CREÍA QUE ERA SÓLAMENTE MEZZO, PERO COMO SOPRANO ES INCREÍBLE. EXCELENTE INTERPRETACIÓN. BRAVO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!. GRACIAS POR SUBIR ESTE VIDEO.-
Bravissima!!!!
grazie Signora! che Dio ti benedica.
Grandiosa ❤😍
Parere personale: la miglior Rosina.
@@GiovanniGGori Lei è inoltre l'Amneris che preferisco, insieme a Dominguez, Stignani e Barbieri, ed è la mia preferita come Cenerentola, Jane Seymour, Adalgisa e anche Leonora di Guzman nella Favorita! È semplicemente fantastica 🤩💓
@@esterbruno8604 Io come Amneris adoro anche la Minghini Cattaneo!
Ps: tra i ruoli interpretati magistralmente dalla Simionato hai dimenticato Isabella 😁
@@GiovanniGGori Giusto, la sua Isabella nell'Italiana in Algeri! 😍
La Minghini Cattaneo era leggendaria anche come Azucena nella famosa versione con Pertile* e Granforte (e la Carena purtroppo 🥲)! Un mezzosoprano esemplare 🤩
@@esterbruno8604 Concordo sulla Minghini Cattaneo, un mezzosoprano davvero esemplare.
La sua morte, così come quella analoga del baritono Armando Borgioli, mi ha sempre colpito molto. E l'ho sempre trovata ingloriosa per una così bella voce come la sua.😔
Voce celestiale
REST IN PEACE GIULIETTA
Ciao Giulietta buon viaggio,
salutaci Amneris, Carmen, Santuzza, Cherubino, Azucena e tutte le altre amiche
che meraviglia!
Morgan Earle Rosina was actually origianlly written for and performed by a contralto.
Perfection
wonderful
Mezzo dramática, she's amazing.. almost soprano..👏👏
AWESOME! May God give her eternal rest. And of course, GLORIOUS cast! But who sang Almaviva?
@tamerlano I think you are wrong.. I find her florid singing lovely and all of her staccati are on pitch too. She was some singer... Her High B's are as easy as can be as well.
I agree For me the great dramatic roles were her forte as her coloratura was simplified and aspirated..
It's not that she couldn't sing coloratura, it's just that it wasn't limpid or fluid enough for this kind of aria. The sound is very robust, too heavy when placing runs, staccato etc.
'Aspirated' is the right word for this as others have said.
It seems the photo be wrong. No Simonato?
Christa Ludwig??
4:55, farò giocar
Simionato sang staccati really well. However, she made all the coloratura part in this aria into staccati. Not fluid enough. Anyway, during her time, I must say most Italian mezzo sopranos (even sopranos) were so clumsy in coloratura parts.
La matrona 🌹
Fantástica, contralto o mezzosoprano???
she was a high mezzo.
High mezzo/Falcon soprano.
ejejeje. A sewing machine, davvero!! B-r-r-r-r-r-r-r-r-r-rrrrrrr. Punto.
Almaviva: Alvinio Misciano.
@kgarmaker123 I just don't think she had a great florid technique, sorry...the execution is clumsy or inaccurate often. The CHARACTER is fabulously drawn, but the florid moments aren't ideal. Yes, the staccati are in tune, but even large and immobile voices can sing staccati...how may Queens of the Night have you heard where the staccati are flawless, but the coloratura triplets are messy? I've heard many.
May be you preffer Singers like Bartoli. She sings like sewing machine. Everytime the same color, the same "florid technique". Sempre ideale, sempre la stessa.
I adore Simionato, but Rossini is really better modern mezzos. Mind you, NO ONE sings the Aida Judgement scene today like Simionato did...but, florid singing was not really her cup of tea and it shows..
a vi v tri godika chitali Dastayevskova??? es el resultat... v tri goda saveti dayut.
mix oregano with oil... then add to ur "fav" dishes... thats if "Oregano" oil is not an oil... ponyali da, naglosti...darn er???
Not a good role for Simionato.
I found her perfect.
Rosina was written originally as a soprano role, and Simionato is a true Verdian mezzo. NO bueno. She would be a much better Isabella from Italian Girl.
No she isn't. Rosina is a contralto!!
Rosina was originally written for a coloratura contralto, look it up.
L'italiana,Rosina and Cenerentolla are all contraltos or mezzosopranos
Rosina was originally wrote for a contralto in E major. Modern singers especially soprano sing it in F major and add too much coloratura.
Check better: the first Rosina, Geltrude Righetti, who was also the first Cenerentola, was a contralto.