The ones that are saying that this is the best live version of the song, i think that they haven't heard the one from 4 oct 78, youtube video, 5.08", which is MUCH MUCH MUCH better. Really, this one is dissapointing, even with the great Phil collins drumming, since that is not the problem. By the way, those who says that is the best thanks to Collins know how good is Jerry Marotta???
this recording sounds great ... in the album the hi hat is played in a strange rythm . but never was played like this again . anyway this version with phil is incredible
Versione da dimenticare. Un pezzo del genere ha bisogno di magia, quella che si trova sul vinile. Spiacente ma questa versione non ne è all'altezza . Inoltre non vedo quale miglioramento Phil abbia portato al pezzo. Dopo 47 anni che ascolto Peter, Genesis, Phil ,Steve ecc...credo di poter dire la mia. ---- A version to forget ! A song like this needs magic, the one you can find in the vinile Sorry ,but this version is not at its best. For the more , i don't see any improvement by Phil. I have been .listening to Genesis, Peter, Phil , Steve for fourtyseven years and this allows me to give my opinion.
Phil gives this his unique touch on drums! This is a real treasure. So glad this was preserved!
Where ??
Phil is the guy!
La mejor versión de White Shadow.
The ones that are saying that this is the best live version of the song, i think that they haven't heard the one from 4 oct 78, youtube video, 5.08", which is MUCH MUCH MUCH better. Really, this one is dissapointing, even with the great Phil collins drumming, since that is not the problem. By the way, those who says that is the best thanks to Collins know how good is Jerry Marotta???
Wow!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
this recording sounds great ... in the album the hi hat is played in a strange rythm . but never was played like this again . anyway this version with phil is incredible
PRICELESS.
I was never aware that Mick Jagger played Bass with Peter Gabriel
I thought that was Bill Bruford !😆
who's on bass? what's the line-up?
the info says Tony Levin in 79 but that photo doesn't look like Levin.
@@ChadGlassify Yeah, that's definitely not Levin. Levin had no mustache in the early days but he was bald by then.
@@worldnotworld John Giblin?😀❤️🎼
Versione da dimenticare. Un pezzo del genere ha bisogno di magia, quella che si trova sul vinile. Spiacente ma questa versione non ne è all'altezza . Inoltre non vedo quale miglioramento Phil abbia portato al pezzo. Dopo 47 anni che ascolto Peter, Genesis, Phil ,Steve ecc...credo di poter dire la mia.
----
A version to forget ! A song like this needs magic, the one you can find in the vinile Sorry ,but this version is not at its best. For the more , i don't see any improvement by Phil.
I have been .listening to Genesis, Peter, Phil , Steve for fourtyseven years and this allows me to give my opinion.
Sono abbastanza d'accordo, ma resta comunque una rivisitazione interessante, soprattutto nel ritornello. Dal vivo avrà reso molto di più