@@Nowhy The shot heard all over campus. LOL. Someone comes up to kid afterwards and says, "Hey, I heard that D'Souza dude wiped the floor up with you."
The insinuation was that unless the kid leaves college and gives his place as a college student to a minority, he is being a hypocrite. I don't think that is how it works. If a person is concerned with deforestation, the person doesn't necessarily have to plant trees in his front hard to avoid being labeled a hypocrite. I was also a little annoyed that D'Souza uploaded a video called "D'Souza absolutely DESTROYS leftist college student" on his own channel.
@@jimm.1013 you must use only a single piece of TP every day first, plant trees, stop using paper etc before preaching for de forestnation to Africans.
@@jimm.1013 Look at it this way. If a person is concerned about deforestation, the correct response is either to give the deforesting guy means so he doesn't deforest or stop using products or energy which deforestation requires. It is the opposite of pontificating about what somebody else is doing, which incidentally, has no useful result. Putting the burden on somebody else is not a solution. I don't agree with Dinesh most of the time about religion but in this case, his logic works.
You could almost see the strings from her controlling him.... "Dance puppet... dance..." It's very sad, but if this continues it's going to end in a bloodbath.. and it's going to be mostly their blood.
It’s common knowledge that emotions effect (or affect idk) our behavior. When people are sad they isolate themselves. When people are angry they treat others with disrespect. I believe the the left has created an emotional narrative to cause people to form certain opinions, vote for illogical ideas, and represent unethical morality. My theory is that the left can control people emotionally whether or not they agree with them so that the left can pass bills supporting their own agenda.
@@Imsosaditsgottenthis lol, feelings have no use for the word use and they also don't want to be superior/inferior etc. In other words, you are applying the wrong categories, but that's understandable if you identify with reason. Btw, don't forget that there is also imagination - the one thing most people are lost in and they sure imagine being reasonable. Which is kinda funny if it weren't so tragic for the one's being involved.
@@jonathandutra4831 , exactly, that's why D'Souza made it clear that he wants the kid to exercise his "moral virtue" upon HIMSELF rather than upon others but he won't because he's a hypocrite as you said. I think that boy might have a heart attack over stressing about "human/American history from hundreds of years ago" if he feels like he can't MAKE OTHER WHITE PEOPLE PAY HIS "self-imposed debt" FOR HIM... That boy needs some serious "de-programming".
So personal attacks should take the place of well reasoned arguments? What does the kid's background have anything to do with the point he's trying to make. Even if Mother Theresa herself were in his shoes saying the same words that he said, it doesn't change the argument that he's trying to make. I thought that was an incredibly childish thing for him to say.
A personal attack is an insult or an unsubstantiated accusation. This was simple fact and truth. Sometimes it hurts to be wrong. Butt-hurts in your case apparently.
Ad hominem (Latin for "to the man" or "to the person"), short for argumentum ad hominem, is now usually understood as a logical fallacy in which an argument is rebutted by attacking the character, motive, or other attribute of the person making the argument, or persons associated with the argument, rather than attacking the substance of the argument itself.------ In this quote, D'Souza is essentially admitting that he is making an ad hominem attack to deflect away from the student's core argument. He is admitting to his own logical fallacy.
@Empty The Trash hahaha...nice. There it is...you are precisely what I said you are, arrogant trash. For your information, this immigrant served this great country for 26 years. If you missed the point, rewatch & listen carefully to Mr. D’Souza answer & points made.
@Empty The Trash you’re not just trash, you’re despicable entitled trash. It is your kind of behavior, that gives no respect to our duly elected President, to your military & veterans that will ruin this great country. I have earned my metals & proud of everyone of them. Go do your own damn research you ignorant thing.
The real humiliation is that Dinesh--after listening to the kid jerk off for 10 minutes on every question--would RESTATE the kid's question, succinctly, and more clearly, in a sentance or two.....THEN annihilate the kid with an answer.
He is asking questions, why was there an affirmative action carried out by the government to help whites achieve middle class prosperity while blacks did not get the same? Not only that, by why is it that there was an affirmative action on the part of the government to deny African americans of those benefits simply because of their race?
+MustardSeedish She's the problem. She's the one indoctrinating these kids to self-hate themselves. If she were so worried about privilege, she'd be sweeping streets somewhere, not lecturing in an ivy-league university, surrounded by other social justice warriors who are trying to get society to act out SJW moral codes.
Omg dinesh remembered the kid said he did tutoring and also that he mentioned “everyone here” is hypocrital to some degree, Dinesh captured everything the kid said and responded so beautifully that im sure not everyone fully understood how he responded directly to him and literally everything he said, his mind is such a higher level.
Dinesh has a sharp mind. It's amazing how much he can input and then give such an educated and accurate detail respond. I love listening to his lectures. Him and Jordan Peterson.
@@Jan-qq9xc well the leftist never would get it because of their profound feeling unfairness inequality in their being…the students who have logic and can reason can learn and become victimless and understand that individual responsibility, self worth hard work and compassion can lead to a just and fulfilling life
@@Jdeneik Well, I’m thinking they got it when Dinesh said, Give up your seat to someone less fortunate.’ Suddenly HIS white privilege went out the window.
Seeing the 2 GROWN people directly behind him that look like professors laughing, clapping and acting like sidekicks the entire debate made me what to shove knitting needles in my eye.
I'd rather you shove the knitting needles into THEIR eyes. IMO, they are the ones LEAST likely to have learned anything from this entire telling exchange.
You guys are hating, but this is great stuff. People exchanging ideas relatively politely and respectfully. Kid speaks, Dinesh listens and vice versa. Everyone listens and thus gets to benefit from exchange of ideas. Regardless of whether the kid was wrong, he was polite and listened, and that's how you learn stuff.
paksta If Universities had these kinds of discussions, College could actually be a place of real debate and of exchanging ideas. To often students resort to shouting down people with opposing points of view.
paksta No one is hating. We hate the ignorance and we find the truth delicious. We hope that this exchange was actually convincing. Dinesh surely convinced me (or perhaps reaffirmed as I never believed that the foolishness of “white privilege” , “reparations”, “social justice”, blah,blah, blah).
@@mochalatte8878 But he would have known anyway. And also, if that justifies it, then do you realise that it would also be justified for the same reason for me to treat you badly, so you know how it feels? Even if your innocent? He very likely did not treat people in a racist way, other than maybe to other white people (going by what he said).
@@SumitBohra487 It's not "reverse", it is just the same principle were ppl are treated unequally standards because of their race."Reverse racism" is a trick ppl try to pull to pretend it is different or new rule.
@@SumitBohra487 never call it reverse racism, that implies racisim = whites who hate blacks. And that doesn't exist as a term, racisim applies to all races. BLM would LOVE for the term reverse racisim to become widely used, it implies the problem starts with white people which is why it has been used. The most racist people I know are blacks,in high-school a black man chased me away from his house with a shotgun because I had a school project with his daughter we HAD to do together but because he hates all white people for what happened in the past he's now the racist and many blacks see no problems with his actions. His daughter did the project by herself she felt so bad, and still gave me credit for it because we were very good friends. To them it's just "paying it foward" and that's not a road they should want to go down because it doesn't end well for everyone but specifically them.
@@bubcat54 typical of the Libtards though, you have to give her that. Behaving just like the rest of the brainwashed sheep she regurgitates the bs she hears from the Lefty media.
I really enjoyed how Dinesh did not even ask any questions about his tutoring until the end after you think he disregarded it or forgot about it but brings it up to crush this kid.
Chewable Jim no kidding, i remember hearing a guy on the radio talking about how he was 100% for obamacare and knew someone was going to have to pay for it and after getting his new premium he realized it was him and then was totally against it.
There's a video out there where they question liberals if they support bringing in the poor refugees and they all say yes. Next the reporter asks them to sign a form to allow them to stay in their homes. They all denied, obviously.
@@Gandhi_Physique Nah, not hispanic though I can understand why you might think that. I personally know around 4 dozen guys from Central and South America and (contrary to what woke morons think today) many of them look as white as I do.
The kid is both well intentioned and well indoctrinated. A combination that has led to disaster throughout history.. Glad Dinesh was there to give him some perspective.
Once I discharged from the military I went to college and that was the first time I realized how bad the indoctrination is in higher education. It is unfortunate that colleges are filled with bias professors that are able to manipulate young kids fresh out of highschool into their way of thinking. At that age you’re so impressionable and have no real life experience so when an adult in a professional setting “teaches” you something you autmatically assume it to be true. It’s cyclical.
He seems like a well mannered dude. No hate to anyone willing to debate to pursue knowledge. The people behind him making snide remarks are the true problem.
Lol! Exactly! That’s the problem now a days. People “Virtue Signaling” which doesn’t change crap. But then they feel like they changed the world. So what the name of a sports team or a child’s toy was changed? Does it really concretely help those who you “thought” were affected? Ask them, they prob don’t give a $hit.
Over a minute and a half to ask a question he doesnt understand... And his professor sitting next to him enticing him to challenge a black belt in Verbal Warfare. Poor little guy never stood a chance....
Regina Buttons Black Americans were benefiting from the post WW2 economy for almost 2 decades Then the democrats wrote up the welfare state that decimated the black family thru financially incentivizing the single parent household therefore keeping black on the democrat culture plantation of dependency
Cast not your pearls before swine, lest they trample them under their feet, turn around and gnash you to pieces. Leftists are too heavily brainwashed at this point. They spend hundreds of hours just within a single year in those socialist propaganda centers called "colleges." Too much partial truth propaganda muddying up the waters of their minds to let logic sink in within only 1 hour of a speech given by a conservative.
Well, I am on your side. I agree it is better to be positive. Also, the college kid did better than most of the youtube comments would imply. (Warrng: laura ingraham style but monkey approaching) But he got destroyed.
I wasn't sure where Dinesh was going at first either but he's 100% right. People want to tell everyone how to live and how to do right, especially politicians, without themselves doing the right first.
Ouch! Mr. D'Souza hit him hard. The kid deserved it too. He was pontificating about how immoral America has been and (to him)still is, but he was unwilling to take an honest look at himself.
The Amherst teacher is next to the student is making $150,000/year, giving 1% to charity and hates that the hypocrisy is being shoved in everyone's face, including hers.
Notice the gentleman to the left of the student? That's one of his professors who probably didn't have the guts to do it himself so he encouraged one of his "prize" students to engage Mr. D'Souza. And also notice to his right the lady who eggs him on as if she is coaching him. Also notice as the conversation moves forward and Mr. D'Souza presses the "student" to act on his personal sense of virtue and divest himself of his own "white privilege", he begins to look around for someone to come to his aid and help him.
+Renee Dorsey I noticed her very deliberate and seemingly militant body posture, clearly coaching and goading that kid into pressing his case. Good thing that eloquence doesn't replace intelligence.
+Mortimer Snerd Of course the cowards are unwilling to stand. They are ill-equipped and they don't want to be shot down in front of their students. The interesting conversation is what happens an hour after this, when all the progressive whack jobs are patting each other's backs. The Professor of nonsense will chastise the student on what he should have said. That poor kid and his white guilt was trying so hard to sit down before D'Souza engaged him fully.
That's the whole point. The uninformed will use words as a smokescreen to confuse, not to explain. Notice his body language the whole time. Turning and looking around for reassurance and an exit.
"That's the problem with the progressivism that marches behind social justice while protecting its own privileges" - Dinesh D'Souza. Best way of describing progressivism I've ever heard.
So basically all he did was describe a character flaw of those apart of the movement, not actually refute the widespread, systematic existence of this privilege
Sad that that's the best definition of progressivism you ever heard. God bless your soul for listening to Dinesh. If anyone can push you over the cliff while you smile, that would be Dinesh. Mind you, the progressivism you denounce must sure be frauding the electoral system!
@luke wilson Put the crack pipe down and get some help. The empty barrel got exposed in front of his pals. They're probably all supporters of Lizzie Warren. Trump 2020!
He makes a living by tearing bodies filled with stupidity , misconceptions , erroneous theories, misquoted history, Communist/Nazi bloated jingoisms and exposing their blood to the sun . Funny how they turn into ashes.
Actually, the guy on the stage didn't accomplish anything at all other than present a strawman argument. The kid never claimed whites should give EVERYTHING up. Just that they provide SOME compensation to those that they stepped on in order to help whites accomplish what they have. So, to equate this to college, what D'Souza (the guy on the stage) should have asked is whether the kid would be willing to do something like pay more for college so minorities could attend at a lower cost... or maybe that he have to score higher on admissions type tests. And I suspect the kid would be more than willing to do this... technically, he probably already is doing it thanks to various programs design to help minorities get in and afford college. Bottom line, the kid's white privilege may have HELPED him, but that doesn't mean he hasn't had to put in any effort himself. He shouldn't have to give up what he has worked for... just that which he didn't work for. That is the point he was indirectly making. He simply worded it that instead of just giving up the percentage we haven't earned, that we transfer it to those that have more than earned it either directly or indirectly because of our actions. Btw, I'm not necessarily saying I agree with the kid. Just pointing out that this is his point... that D'Souza never directly addresses his point... that D'Souza instead creates a strawman argument... and that the kid most likely IS providing this kind of compensation to at least some small degree by not only volunteering his time to tutor the less fortunate but probably also had to score higher to get into college than many minorities... and is probably paying more for tuition than various minorities. I don't know his finances and stuff of course though.
***** Exactly. There is no way to tell how much one has benefited. However, to assume it is 100% is utterly ridiculous. Do you REALLY think that if this kid had sat around playing video games at home and never showed up for classes, done homework and studied, that he would have graduated from high school, let alone make it into this college? Really? Maybe it would be easier for you to see my point if you looked at it from the opposite point of view. There is no way you can conclude that a poor black kid with possibly failing grades would have scored well in high school and earned his position in this college had white privilege not existed. So, using your logic that would mean that he shouldn't get any help at all... let alone that the white guy give up EVERYTHING for him... right? Again, this is clearly a strawman argument. The kid clearly was saying that he BENEFITTED... not that he owed 100% of his accomplishments to white privilege. Thus, the logical counter argument would be whether he would be willing to give back SOMETHING... not everything. And that something would be in the form of stuff like maybe tutoring less fortunate... or him paying more for his tuition so that a minority person can pay less... etc. And as I've said, odds are he probably already is doing some of this... and I'm pretty positive he would be more than willing to do more in this area. Which is why D'Souva felt it was necessary to create the strawman argument and to push the price to be paid to the utter extreme.
***** You seem to be on the same page as the kid though. That there is often a benefit to being the same color as the majority. Especially if that benefit was a major one in the past that resulted in financial and other benefits that have been passed down through the generations to a certain degree. At the same time, you seem to disagree with D'Souva that the argument being made is that one should have to give up everything in order to compensate. As the kid seems to be saying, all minorities probably need in order to compensate is a hand up... not a HUGE hand out as D'Souva wants to turn the argument into. His argument is that if you aren't willing to give up EVERYTHING then your argument that you should give up anything is invalid. And that is a massively faulty argument. One which someone of his caliber should be ashamed to present... especially to a young non professional debater.
My great-great grandfather was native American on my father's side and both grandparents on my mother's side were first ones born here so how am I owed. I need to figure out how white I am and if any of my white ancestors if any were slave owners so I can hate that percentage of myself. Yugoslavia is where my mom's side came from. Still got a copy of Ellis island paper's.
Hey @F McLaren, I bet you didn't know that up til recent times that the Battle of Culloden was taught in East Tennessee schools. So many of the people of East Tennessee are of Scots-Irish descent. You know, the Ulster Irish as it were. You would be surprised at the amount of Scottish Flag auto tags people put on their automobiles round here. No joke. I mean it ain't hundreds or anything-but enough you'd notice.
I’m Native American and I have never felt oppressed. My reparations are living in a country with so many opportunities. Here’s something that you never hear talked about. Black immigrants escape poverty at a drastically higher rate than American black people. Why is that? Cause they come here with a hard work ethic and not a victim mentality
I disagree... I am a black American currently in school to get my doctorate in nursing. My brother is an engineer and back in school to get his Masters at one of the most presigous universities in America...and my sister is completing her pre-reqs for med school. Let's put this in perspective. In 2019, 46.8 million Americans identified as black while there were 4.2 million black immigrants in 2016, according to PEW Research. Of course, when you compare those numbers, statically, there is a higher percentage of black immigrants "working hard." Would those statistics still hold true if compared to the blacks living in the country from which black immigrants migrated from? It's stands to reason that one who would invest so much to leave their home would make the most out of the opportunities given them. Just food for thought. May God continue to bless you both.
@Tom Martyn thanks Tom for your response. My apologies for any confusion. My main point, which may not have come across clearly, is that statistically black immigrants "work hard" or "harder" than the black American, however, those statistics are based on an almost 40 million population difference between the two. Does that compare to the natives that remain in their country? Are they equally as hard working as their immigrant counterpart? Maybe they were just hard-working individuals to begin with... and when compared to their native kinsmen, they may be the minority or maybe they aren't and everyone in that country is hard working. I can't say. Anyhow, while statistics still speak volumes... I turn your attention to the following article/ data... which states... "Black immigrants hold degrees at a similar rate as the U.S. foreign-born population-26% of the foreign-born black population ages 25 and older has at least a bachelor’s degree, comparable to 28% of all U.S. immigrants. But there are striking differences when comparing black immigrants with Asian immigrants and with Hispanic immigrants. Among those 25 and older, 50% of all Asian immigrants have completed at least a four-year degree; but only 11% of Hispanic immigrants have done so." You can read the entire article here www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2015/04/09/chapter-1-statistical-portrait-of-the-u-s-black-immigrant-population/
@@NaturallyBlessed4C I think something that also isn’t talked about is broken homes. African immigrants promote nuclear families a lot more than black Americans. Single motherhood in the American black community is almost promoted. I’ve been saying this for years, fix the single mother problem in the blsck community and you’d see a drastic reduction in black poverty
You learn by asking questions and being willing to be challenged. Good for him for standing up and asking and be willing to be proven wrong. I hope he learnt from this and will keep searching.
Doubt it! That is also the huge blind spot for the Left/Democratic Party. Even when everything they do fails or is destructive, they just move on to another idiotic statement/program.
Lol! I was told this by a white liberal in my FB! When I asked him what he does, he said by fighting racism because he hates Trump. I asked him again, how do you fight racism by hating others and what do you do for immigrants, since he brought up DACA and other immigrant issues. I have him a list of things I do for my community and yet he wanted me to hate someone I don’t even know on a personal level! I told him, I’m if you set up a go fund me account to reach $50,000 I will tell you who I’m voting for and heck I will even say some mean things about Trump.... then all I heard was crickets 🦗 when this guy was using my Fb to post how woke he is!🤦🏻♀️. I told him the $50,000 would be used to provide scholarships for Latinas.... and yet no more debate or demands on who I was going to vote for! I also said, your white privilege is unbelievable because he was calling Trump supporters names and demanded to know my political stance! 🤷🏻♀️. I never insulted anyone nor criticized anyone for their political stance nor do I care!
+Rumchug Maybe he doesn't see it, because he's too busy working! It's amazing to me that the harder I work and more I sacrifice, the more "privilage" I enjoy!
Yeah, it's funny how the concept of white privilege is always profused used by RICH white people. Stop projecting your feelings of guilt onto all of us. You feel "privileged" because you are rich, not because you are white. There are millions of working class, barely scraping by on two incomes whites in America. Not that I'm socialist (I firmly believe in the superiority of capitalism) but the only real privilege is wealth. Interesting how in the 21st century that privilege is hidden away behind bullshit divisive indentity politics.
+wufongtan wufong You didn't pay attention to the young gentleman's points. What he presents is a genuine argument for the privilege that white families have developed over the years. The GI Bill + lower rates on Mortgages among other benefits weren't taken by non-whites. So when blacks failed to acquire quality homes and whites afforded similar middle-class homes, segregation bloomed. That said, to answer D'Souza: "I would never abandon my seat in my university. I know my black equal wouldn't step down so I won't miss out on an education."
At least he was respectful. He didn’t try to “own” Dinesh and get humiliated. Like the lady who said “educate him” as if this student has anything to teach a man who served Presidents and sat on think tanks. 😂
+Nora Dennis .. hypocrisy is a right nuts middle name idiot. What Dinesh does is spin and play word games. The kid was to young to know how to handle an asshole
bigraviolees How is D'Souza an asshole? He does his research AND he is an immigrant who legally came here. He has lived in another political system. Like myself, he's seen how America has been changing and it isn't a good change either..
bigraviolees YES!! EXACTLY! It is clear what this kid was asking. The kid ASKED how can we fix the issue. not. hey I have all "this" because of my ancestors taking "that"...we need to give "this" back.
Yes, he did that. But at an institution of higher learning you would already be expected that, and he WAS a freshman. So, yes. But when he was falling apart and looking to the teach for "help!" was when I kinda felt sorry for him. But if you are going to debate Mr. D'Souza and you know what you will ask better know what your saying. Oh well. I hope he did learn something, good.
@@alpha13dylan Yea well I'm something of a recovered SJW so I know it *can* happen. If we really want people's attitudes towards each other to change, we have to be willing to believe we can all change for the better.
"That's the problem with the progressivism that marches behind social justice while protecting its own privileges." Well done, Sir - that's some impressive phraseology right there - especially as it's produced under pressure.
@@drdoomer8553 No, it's not bad and you're right to clarify the point. I was responding out of my distaste for the loudest of the SJWS - those mirthless finger-pointers who compete for victimhood and shameless virtue-signalling. But, as you imply, you don't have to be a victim to wish better for others.
@@drdoomer8553 "So it’s bad to want to progress other people’s lives without hindering your own?" If you want to progress other people's lives by _hindering your kith and kin's lives _*_but not your own life?_* *YES.* Yes, that is indeed a bad thing! I present Exhibit A, the very recent debacle with Ben & Jerry's using Twitter to make an Independence Day statement shaming the United States of America for existing on land that was, at least in part, taken from the Native American tribes by force. Numerous people replied to Ben & Jerry's by pointing out that _the Ben & Jerry's headquarters in Vermont itself_ stands on land which was once the home of the Abenaki tribe before the Abenaki were driven out by the emigrating English settlers, then challenged Ben & Jerry's to put their money where their mouth is and take the first step to righting this wrong by _giving their land back to the Abenaki tribe._ Then Chief Don Stevens of the Coosuk Abenaki Nation followed up on the idea by reaching out to Ben & Jerry's, publically stating that, as Chief, he is always watching for opportunities to advance the welfare of Indigenous American peoples and that he was looking forward to hearing back from Ben & Jerry's, so that they could negotiate the transfer of that land from Ben & Jerry's to the Abenaki people. Ben & Jerry's response thus far? Silence. So clearly Ben & Jerry's is perfectly willing to return _other people's_ land to the Native Americans, but they won't return _their own._ And that's what's wrong with White Liberals howling for Reparations and such; hypocrisy is quite the grave character flaw. Who are they to tell _anyone else_ what they should do - and what personal sacrifices they should make - if they refuse to lead from the front and enter the breech themselves?
Called him out on his "acknowledging his privilege" yet he isnt willing to give his seat up to a poor disadvantaged minority. The last 4 minutes is nothing but pure destruction.
Michael Jackson ummmm, first of all, you are missing the entire point to his argument... 1... What he is saying IS,.. If this guy feels so strongly that white privilege exists, he needs to lead the way in making that change, by giving up, his cushy education at Amherst, and give it to an individual. Just as intelligent, that is being denied the same opportunity to go to such a prestigious university, simply because of his or her race.. By making excuses for himself, as to why he will not do that. Proves what a hypocrite he is. And makes his argument, seem disingenuous and only serves as to make himself seem "better". Than the average white person. Because, he recognizes his "privilege", and his inherent guilt. Which is a load of bullshit... Which he proved by backing up, when Denesh challenged hid position... 2... There is no systematic racism.. There are plenty of programs in place as we speak to afford minorities the opportunity of a great education. And quota requirements for diversity at some school's guarantees that a person of color WILL be accepted over a more qualified white student.. And has been proven to have happened, on several occasions.. 3... Like Denesh said, how do we decide who pays and who receives?? My family never owned slaves, nor did they oppose the civil rights movement... Why do I have to pay for something I nor anyone in my family is responsible for?? I certainly haven't benefitted from any "white privilege".. I worked a full time job, and went to school full-time. I paid for my OWN classes. Because I was denied ANY assistance. Because, I was under 25 and the state considered me a dependent student upon my parents.. Even though, I lived in my OWN... So where was my "privilege" for the color of my skin?? 4... The only privilege in America today, is class privilege. Regardless of race. How many upper middle class and above, black people are harassed by cops, or shot in the streets, or denied access to EVERY whim??? PLEASE, state me an example.
Michael Jackson No, I didn't "repeat" what you said. Dinesh is correct, this guy is a hypocrite. SJW, are the VERY definition of hypocrisy and double standards... You just proved, THAT... ANY time a person brings forth an argument that refutes your drivel. It is always the same... "We aren't taking about THAT".. Yet it totally disproves YOUR argument.. Debating isn't really a thing you all like?? Give me specific examples of a system in place as we speak that oppresses or denies certain basic needs or even privileges to ANY person based on their race?? Like I said, it is a class issue, who h you just proved with your statement of.. "Just ask all the poor, uneducated, whites of the South". Which btw, was a stereotypical statement. And isn't in the least true. That implies that there aren't ANY "poor, uneducated whites" in the North?? Which Mensa Reject is 100% correct... The Democratic party was, is and always will be an elitist group... You want to see a "system of racism"? Look no further than ANY major city ran by them, black and white... Detroit Michigan, has been under Democratic rule for 57 years... And 90% of the government leaders are black... A Democratic President signed NAFTA, that essentially destroyed the industry in Detroit. Flint Michigan 54 years of Democratic government leaders... Same sad tale... I could go on, but you get the point. You are buying the propagandists lie... That started many years ago.. "White privilege" is a myth, "systematic racism" is a myth.. Racism exist, because it is perpetuated by media, entertainment, the government, etc... The ONLY one keeping ANYONE down, is THEM. Because, they refuse to walk off the Government Plantation. THAT is a fact. IF white Americans were truly benefiting from a "system" set up in their favor today. And had this agenda to oppress the black race,... WHY wouldn't they go after the wealthy?? You know, the individuals that are in positions of power, privilege, and status??? Why bother with the poor, uneducated?? They would be of no concern. A person worth millions of dollars, in a influential position.. Would!
I give that kid credit for at least articulating what he believes even though it's wrong. It did not end up in a shouting match... He is a product of liberal professors like the one sitting at his right...
I'm currently taking Sociology 101 and it's nothing but Liberal propaganda. The chapter I'm reading from the text book this week is called, "Racism without Racists."
I took sociology as a complimentary course to my major at the university of Iowa. We discussed things like moving from class to class, effects of poverty, history of discrimination, and studied some court cases that pertained to laws those topics. Weirdly enough, we did study the "wage" gap that was correctly referred to as the earnings gap. And we talked about how the earnings gap was created by time off, different jobs worked, different jobs pursued, and pregnancy. It was never racism and it was never systematic oppression. It's weird how now people are learning different things. But this was 5 years ago, so maybe I got out of college just in time.
+Junokaii nicely said. I have never been able to state why liberals seemed so out of touch to me. I recently read Plato's Republic and found it fascinating. I need to read it a couple more times though.
Todd Nelson They seem to think that if others think differently than them.... the world will somehow be chaotic. True tolerance is being able to go "I strongly disagree with you but I respect you enough to leave you alone about it". Conflict of any kind always seems to be due to a belief held so strongly that they'll die to get others to do the same.
lowkeynz I don't even think it's about that. Just about control I think. Much the same way a child tries convincing you. Just wants it their way regardless.
+Junokaii Only half right. A Liberal tells you one way to think. A Conservative tells you another way to think. A real human being thinks for themselves.
+Sergio Milho I caught that too. I think he was speaking in terms of the moral arena (ideology) and not so much more concrete ideas like "you stole my car". If we're just talking about ideological right vs. wrong, you could reasonably equate right with legal and wrong with illegal.
The very amusing thing about the upper class in the UK is that people like Thatcher are convinced that the money of the middle classes and the working classes is the same as their money, once it has been paid to the Exchequer (royal or national treasury). What they often do is reduce taxes on themselves but raise taxes on everyone else, just as what happened in the USA.
He is not a good person, but a hypocrite, as you are. He tries to make everyone think that he is an angel, but he does it so clumsily that his ego betrays him. His ego moves him, blinds him and controls him and above all, his own ego makes him act and speak like the hypocrite clown he is.
He just doesn't realize some important things. We are each, as individuals, born into vastly different circumstances. We have absolutely no say in what any of our ancestors did, yet this guy is seemingly trying to guilt everyone today for things done in the past! It is not only impossible, but that type of indoctrinated thought is causing huge amounts of division in today's society! The only person we have ANY control over is ourselves!
First off, I'm white. White privilege entitled me to 50 years of very hard work in the construction industry. I worked hard, and I paid my own way, no welfare. I'm proud of that fact. I call it "American Privilege." America gave me that opportunity. Being white didn't entitle me to anything except the possibility of starvation, if I didn't get out, find a job, any job, and work my tail off to buy my food, and pay my rent. It's pretty simple really. It's called "Survival." My Mom taught me that. Thank God she did!
WOW! Very well said, Mike. I liked it so much I read it 10 times so I could repeat it and also copied and pasted to my phone just encase I forget any part of it. And, your are 100% correct. I would like to just scream what you said out loud and would pay to put it up on a billboard. God bless you!
Eh....white privelage only exists around non whites. Its a complicated issue. If you don't think privelage exists, take a look at Harvard, then the blacks , then ....the people who is standing behind the blacks.....
I'm white, but what would you know about discrimination you've never faced? How are you in a position to know what benefits you received that others do not? It's like you're certain you have no blind spot, but can't know that. Do you think racial discrimination doesn't occur at all? If so, what is the basis for that position?
This guy literally says he's not talking about affirmative action, and then proceeds to use *affirmative action* to argue documentable wealth to give it back to the disadvantaged. This is *misdirection* not an argument.
Also , likely his psychology professor. She does have that angry aging hippee lesbian look. They all have long grey hair , unable to give up the 60's protest unique but the same look.
I thought the same thing....I was thinking...wait a minute...its 70,000 a year to go to this school and that Simple Jack bitch is probably a tenured professor.
@@bigraviolees honestly asking, can you give any examples of that? He challenges the new norm of seeing racism and injustice in everything. I am not saying people don't have to work hard to get into college, I know there are a lot of people that have to sacrifice a lot to get there. To claim victimhood when you are in college though, that's just dumb.
His gender studies teacher sitting there convinced him that if he used as many words as possible to confuse and conquer the audience to his side that not having a precise argument wouldn't matter.
@@carloswater7 No, it's true. I'm an accountant, and there are tons of socialists in this field. There's actually a good explanation for this: it's because 75% of accountants are women, and 68% of women are left-wing.
John Huldt Haha you stole the words right out of my mouth. Marxism didn't leave, nothing completely disappears they just resurface in a new mutation. She's his puppet master and their masters are not honest or realistic. Actually I think that child is not that unintelligent its just he's impressionable to be lead instead of leading by that woman. But that would make for a weak mind to not be able to navigate through the rhetoric as most of present society is.
Left wing person here who thinks most of gender studies is bullshit. You have to recognize that there are people like me who are smart, liberal, and agree with you on some topics. But all you guys do is generalize. It's 100% support for Trump, 100% opposition to liberals. Can you at least admit that reality is a bit more complicated than you are pretending?
sleepcity Hold on, being liberal, and being a leftist, are completely different ideologies. I'm a conservative, but solidly a libertarian on most issues outside of economics. So I think we probably agree on a vast majority of issues. But if your in favor, or even if you believe in this "white privilege", I would ask; What Institutions, and who are the people running these institutions, that are propagating, and enacting racial, and cultural discrimination?......Because you can not have "white privilege", and not have racism, or ethnic discrimination at the same time. Who are these people, and what institutions are doing this, so we can fight them together?
CORRECT!! This boy has been lied to concerning that black service men and women were not recipient of the GI Bill. imagine if the soldiers of the 442nd Japanese Infantry Regiment were not provided GI rights? They were the true discriminated ethnicity WW II era!!! The Japanese American suffered because of Pearl Harbor and even during and after WW II - through land theft.
@Mike Chappell Lol yep, he got called out for his hypocrisy even though I did agree with his statement that we all have some degree of hypocrisy, that was a good point to make and if we are all honest with ourselves, we would all agree on that point....but he still totally dodged what D'SOUZA was saying overall.
Just imagine how much better off this smart kid would be if he were attending a real college ? And by real I mean any college that teaches students HOW to think instead of WHAT to think.
I attend this college (Amherst College), and they definitely teach us how to think lol That’s what our liberal arts education is predicated on and we have an acceptance rate of 11% and are currently ranked in the top 25 colleges in the nation by multiple college-ranking websites, so I’m guessing the way we’re being taught is fairly reputable. Unfortunately though, our campus is full of students from the far-left whose aggressive opinions influence other students, thus feeding into the left’s misinformation and inaccurate arguments. As a student at Amherst who is conservative, I will argue that the college as a whole teaches us HOW to think but it’s the other students who teach us WHAT to think
@@Hellotherett If the colleges teach you how to think and your students are this bad. Pal, the ranking is very much wrong. I don't know what kind of money you pay for magazines to rank you this high but it's so detached from reality that it's laughable. These things are basic knowledge, if this is America top 25, American colleges are near where no top of the world. I'm guessing that only American law school or medical school, or research institution should be ranked high. These aren't colleges, these are indoctrination camp.
He did all that studying just to get destroyed in seconds. Learn a skill to get a job and move out of your parents house that are paying for your education. That makes you privileged are you going to give your spot to a less fortunate kid. Teacher didn't think of that!!!😳🤯
Okay, but the point the student was getting at is that ideally _hypothetically_ there shouldn't be a need to address any socioeconomic disparity. And D'Souza responded to the _hypothetical situation_ by pointing out that the _hypothetical situation_ wasn't feasible. 🙄
For sure the kid and his mentor in the white straight jacked 8 times inoculated and will not be a problem in society, cause they had a coincidence and climate change got them. They defiantly owned a gas stove.
"Do people want to hear this?"
"Yes! Educate him!"
Oh my God, the level of hubris she just demonstrated is unbelievable.
Yea sorry but you can't educate a Mental Jedi Kung-Fu Master.
What's hubris?
@@robertconti4937 It's another word for arrogance or pride but on a greater level that is beyond what is stereotypically understood.
On a lighter side, I get a kick out of people who say "off ten."
@@robertconti4937 Haha, yeah.
"I'm not trying to indict everyone of hypocrisy, only you." Boom! haha
KABOOM!
Chick CHICK BOOM!!!!
KAWABUNGA
@@Nowhy The shot heard all over campus. LOL. Someone comes up to kid afterwards and says, "Hey, I heard that D'Souza dude wiped the floor up with you."
The kid already admitted that. And the kid said to not give back money, but to create a social safety net in case people fall into poverty.
Although I don’t agree with that kid, I’m glad he was polite in his attitude and how he spoke. That’s important for having good conversation.
Yep. His hearts in the right place, he's just been lied to his whole life.
The insinuation was that unless the kid leaves college and gives his place as a college student to a minority, he is being a hypocrite. I don't think that is how it works. If a person is concerned with deforestation, the person doesn't necessarily have to plant trees in his front hard to avoid being labeled a hypocrite. I was also a little annoyed that D'Souza uploaded a video called "D'Souza absolutely DESTROYS leftist college student" on his own channel.
@@jimm.1013 you must use only a single piece of TP every day first, plant trees, stop using paper etc before preaching for de forestnation to Africans.
ten diabon I have no idea what you are talking about.
@@jimm.1013 Look at it this way. If a person is concerned about deforestation, the correct response is either to give the deforesting guy means so he doesn't deforest or stop using products or energy which deforestation requires. It is the opposite of pontificating about what somebody else is doing, which incidentally, has no useful result. Putting the burden on somebody else is not a solution. I don't agree with Dinesh most of the time about religion but in this case, his logic works.
"Educate him...." she said.
Be careful what you wish for.
Dinesh was playing nice. He could have shredded him.
This kid will make a great congressman!
All talk,saying nothing!
Lol
And doing even less
Wouldn't that make him a hypocrite. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 I learned today stupid people are capable of using big words. 🤣🤣🤣 ohh the children these days.
That kid sound like Biden 47 yrs in congress but doing nothing
He's already got the hang of the Pelosi Stutter.
That gray haired ex-hippie lady is the problem...did you see her goading him to argue HER opinions?
I wonder if she's a communist.
I wonder if she supports a Cloward-Piven approach to enslaving humanity.
Wow lady let the kid have his own ideas
Shes his mommy
You could almost see the strings from her controlling him.... "Dance puppet... dance..." It's very sad, but if this continues it's going to end in a bloodbath.. and it's going to be mostly their blood.
That student mastered the simpleton art of 100% emotion and 0% logic.
Na, he isn't emotionally integer (+low EQ), that is why he can't apply his reasoning abilities to the world around him. He is blind.
SWANS - Blind
It’s common knowledge that emotions effect (or affect idk) our behavior. When people are sad they isolate themselves. When people are angry they treat others with disrespect. I believe the the left has created an emotional narrative to cause people to form certain opinions, vote for illogical ideas, and represent unethical morality. My theory is that the left can control people emotionally whether or not they agree with them so that the left can pass bills supporting their own agenda.
@@Imsosaditsgottenthis lol, feelings have no use for the word use and they also don't want to be superior/inferior etc.
In other words, you are applying the wrong categories, but that's understandable if you identify with reason. Btw, don't forget that there is also imagination - the one thing most people are lost in and they sure imagine being reasonable. Which is kinda funny if it weren't so tragic for the one's being involved.
That's liberalism.
100% bullshit and 0% logic.
Nothing is stopping this kid from giving his money, his position, his home, his job, etc... to someone he feels has been wronged.
His hypocrisy does lol
@@jonathandutra4831amen.
@@jonathandutra4831 , exactly, that's why D'Souza made it clear that he wants the kid to exercise his "moral virtue" upon HIMSELF rather than upon others but he won't because he's a hypocrite as you said. I think that boy might have a heart attack over stressing about "human/American history from hundreds of years ago" if he feels like he can't MAKE OTHER WHITE PEOPLE PAY HIS "self-imposed debt" FOR HIM... That boy needs some serious "de-programming".
Not a hope. Hypocrit
He just virtue signaling
"I'm not trying to indict everybody of hypocrisy, only you!" That's gotta be the best quote out of this video
So personal attacks should take the place of well reasoned arguments? What does the kid's background have anything to do with the point he's trying to make. Even if Mother Theresa herself were in his shoes saying the same words that he said, it doesn't change the argument that he's trying to make.
I thought that was an incredibly childish thing for him to say.
soggytoast111+ That how you educated ppl, not in safe space, but cold hard truth, or you will never accept it.
@soggytoast111 That's because you're a moron.
A personal attack is an insult or an unsubstantiated accusation. This was simple fact and truth. Sometimes it hurts to be wrong. Butt-hurts in your case apparently.
Ad hominem (Latin for "to the man" or "to the person"), short for argumentum ad hominem, is now usually understood as a logical fallacy in which an argument is rebutted by attacking the character, motive, or other attribute of the person making the argument, or persons associated with the argument, rather than attacking the substance of the argument itself.------ In this quote, D'Souza is essentially admitting that he is making an ad hominem attack to deflect away from the student's core argument. He is admitting to his own logical fallacy.
The student is "moralizing" himself, while denying the morality of others.
Take your $50,000 a year tuition and help the less fortunate.
No. Pay with your money &everyone else’s... not his & not that grey hair instructor’ s money either. They need their money to survive. Smh
@Empty The Trash it was your trash
@Empty The Trash hahaha...nice. There it is...you are precisely what I said you are, arrogant trash. For your information, this immigrant served this great country for 26 years.
If you missed the point, rewatch & listen carefully to Mr. D’Souza answer & points made.
@Empty The Trash you’re not just trash, you’re despicable entitled trash. It is your kind of behavior, that gives no respect to our duly elected President, to your military & veterans that will ruin this great country.
I have earned my metals & proud of everyone of them. Go do your own damn research you ignorant thing.
@@cyang7850
Well said, and
Thank you for your service. ❤
He's just "trying to survive" going to a college with an annual fee of $79,600. Now THAT'S privilege
That student mastered the art of throwing around fancy words without actually saying anything.
+yo dawg I thought it was a queerscope but that'd be to triggering right? pun intended of course
The real humiliation is that Dinesh--after listening to the kid jerk off for 10 minutes on every question--would RESTATE the kid's question, succinctly, and more clearly, in a sentance or two.....THEN annihilate the kid with an answer.
A byproduct of The Internet Age - every two-dollar jackass with wi-fi, a smartphone, thumbs and a Twitter account can pose as a pseudo-intellectual.
it's called sophistry
jo Ben 1v1 me u noscope battle cod
That woman in the white jacket is so liberal she can’t think straight.
I wish I could give you fifty likes.
🤣
White jacket? She needs a straight jacket.
@@Farbauti616 she need rainbow jacket
Rich kids know everything but have everything. Yet give nothing.
"for you society must act before you, to enforce your moral code"... thank you for that Dinesh.
That student is braver than his professors who implanted those thought but didn’t dare to ask the question.
He is asking questions, why was there an affirmative action carried out by the government to help whites achieve middle class prosperity while blacks did not get the same? Not only that, by why is it that there was an affirmative action on the part of the government to deny African americans of those benefits simply because of their race?
That student is smarter than to allow professors insert thoughts into his head. I believe he feels his thoughts to his core.
I couldn't help but be distracted my that weird lady coaching him in the bottom left corner.
+MustardSeedish Technically, she is referred to as "COWARDLY CUNT."
+MustardSeedish You mean the crazy kook liberal professor?
+MustardSeedish She's the problem. She's the one indoctrinating these kids to self-hate themselves. If she were so worried about privilege, she'd be sweeping streets somewhere, not lecturing in an ivy-league university, surrounded by other social justice warriors who are trying to get society to act out SJW moral codes.
+MustardSeedish A.K.A. "Mom."
+MustardSeedish She's his grandma and changes his diapers.
Omg dinesh remembered the kid said he did tutoring and also that he mentioned “everyone here” is hypocrital to some degree, Dinesh captured everything the kid said and responded so beautifully that im sure not everyone fully understood how he responded directly to him and literally everything he said, his mind is such a higher level.
Dinesh has a sharp mind. It's amazing how much he can input and then give such an educated and accurate detail respond. I love listening to his lectures. Him and Jordan Peterson.
They got it at the end (hopefully)!!
@@Jan-qq9xc well the leftist never would get it because of their profound feeling unfairness inequality in their being…the students who have logic and can reason can learn and become victimless and understand that individual responsibility, self worth hard work and compassion can lead to a just and fulfilling life
@@Jdeneik Well, I’m thinking they got it when Dinesh said, Give up your seat to someone less fortunate.’ Suddenly HIS white privilege went out the window.
Seeing the 2 GROWN people directly behind him that look like professors laughing, clapping and acting like sidekicks the entire debate made me what to shove knitting needles in my eye.
Mommy and daddy egging him on.
@@davewickizer4506 Probably professors. Edited: Oh, she already said that, sorry.
that's a gratuitous visual
Are you heavy?
I'd rather you shove the knitting needles into THEIR eyes. IMO, they are the ones LEAST likely to have learned anything from this entire telling exchange.
Dinesh was the best person to put that student in his place. Love the cordiality of the debate too! It’s the way it should be across the board.
You guys are hating, but this is great stuff. People exchanging ideas relatively politely and respectfully. Kid speaks, Dinesh listens and vice versa. Everyone listens and thus gets to benefit from exchange of ideas. Regardless of whether the kid was wrong, he was polite and listened, and that's how you learn stuff.
paksta If Universities had these kinds of discussions, College could actually be a place of real debate and of exchanging ideas. To often students resort to shouting down people with opposing points of view.
dmp762 Agree. That's why I like this video so much!
Agree. But, I'm sure he went away confused...someone contradicted all he'd been "taught".
Agreed. This is how things should be. Sometimes the truth is an amalgamation of facts and not one side or the other.
paksta
No one is hating. We hate the ignorance and we find the truth delicious. We hope that this exchange was actually convincing. Dinesh surely convinced me (or perhaps reaffirmed as I never believed that the foolishness of “white privilege” , “reparations”, “social justice”, blah,blah, blah).
He was so uncomfortable when he was asked about his white privilege. Now he knows how others feel
yep. reverse racism towards the whites.
mumbai jean welp now you know how receiving racism means
@@mochalatte8878
But he would have known anyway.
And also, if that justifies it, then do you realise that it would also be justified for the same reason for me to treat you badly, so you know how it feels?
Even if your innocent?
He very likely did not treat people in a racist way, other than maybe to other white people (going by what he said).
@@SumitBohra487
It's not "reverse", it is just the same principle were ppl are treated unequally standards because of their race."Reverse racism" is a trick ppl try to pull to pretend it is different or new rule.
@@SumitBohra487 never call it reverse racism, that implies racisim = whites who hate blacks.
And that doesn't exist as a term, racisim applies to all races.
BLM would LOVE for the term reverse racisim to become widely used, it implies the problem starts with white people which is why it has been used.
The most racist people I know are blacks,in high-school a black man chased me away from his house with a shotgun because I had a school project with his daughter we HAD to do together but because he hates all white people for what happened in the past he's now the racist and many blacks see no problems with his actions.
His daughter did the project by herself she felt so bad, and still gave me credit for it because we were very good friends.
To them it's just "paying it foward" and that's not a road they should want to go down because it doesn't end well for everyone but specifically them.
Textbook liberal: generous with other people's money.
Textbook conservative, sticking their head in the ground when it benefits them.
@@Bullshotinbutt
Not a very intelligent counter, libtard.
@@bubcat54 typical of the Libtards though, you have to give her that. Behaving just like the rest of the brainwashed sheep she regurgitates the bs she hears from the Lefty media.
@@beyondthepale9071
Yep. Lacks critical thinking skills. Low 80's I.Q.
@SEAN PETAIA but I need a job
I really enjoyed how Dinesh did not even ask any questions about his tutoring until the end after you think he disregarded it or forgot about it but brings it up to crush this kid.
Haha it's always when they are asked to sacrifice their own then it's like "hey hey you're going to far".
I know right... Do as I say, not as I do.
Yeah, but they sure are generous with other people's money and freedom, aren't they?
Chewable Jim no kidding, i remember hearing a guy on the radio talking about how he was 100% for obamacare and knew someone was going to have to pay for it and after getting his new premium he realized it was him and then was totally against it.
There's a video out there where they question liberals if they support bringing in the poor refugees and they all say yes. Next the reporter asks them to sign a form to allow them to stay in their homes. They all denied, obviously.
Others should sacrifice but we are entitled to live in our bubble of wealth. That's such bs. It pisses me off.
I feel bad for these kids that try to go up against Mr. D, they’re just youngsters still. But he is never rude, always willing to educate.
True. He's a good man.
They're not kids; they're ignorant and abusive adults.
Having said that, Dinesh ripped that student a new one.
3:56 the white witch edging that student along.... amazing these are our professors now
They want you to pay for that
She's still trying to figure who killed her sister, the Wicked Witch of the East.
@@Gandhi_Physique Yes she is. More's the pity since she's effectively teaching people to hate their skin color, including her own and calling it just.
@@Gandhi_Physique Nah, not hispanic though I can understand why you might think that. I personally know around 4 dozen guys from Central and South America and (contrary to what woke morons think today) many of them look as white as I do.
😂😂😂
In a nutshell, if you're going to talk the talk, you had better walk the walk.
The kid is both well intentioned and well indoctrinated. A combination that has led to disaster throughout history.. Glad Dinesh was there to give him some perspective.
Yes, typical socialist trick. Let's abuse the clean moral young people and their idealist character that comes along with their age.
Once I discharged from the military I went to college and that was the first time I realized how bad the indoctrination is in higher education. It is unfortunate that colleges are filled with bias professors that are able to manipulate young kids fresh out of highschool into their way of thinking. At that age you’re so impressionable and have no real life experience so when an adult in a professional setting “teaches” you something you autmatically assume it to be true. It’s cyclical.
@@tbeech9239 very true, that and univeristies have been the breeding grounds for lifelong alocholics
He seems like a well mannered dude. No hate to anyone willing to debate to pursue knowledge. The people behind him making snide remarks are the true problem.
Very true. The kid was smart, but d wash was a worth teacher!
Dinesh is so clear in his thoughts and so well spoken. That is the mark of a man with the power to change society.
Or destroy it.
@@theseventhgeneration6910Precisely
“ No, but I did do some tutoring” 😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂
Probably got PAID for it.
Lol! Exactly! That’s the problem now a days. People “Virtue Signaling” which doesn’t change crap. But then they feel like they changed the world. So what the name of a sports team or a child’s toy was changed? Does it really concretely help those who you “thought” were affected? Ask them, they prob don’t give a $hit.
Are you putting him down for being generous with his time and knowledge to help others?
I must have seen this twenty times through the years and it never gets old. It's so satisfying to watch Dinesh break him down.
I don't think they'll be inviting D'Souza back. Too much carnage.
+Jan Scott They all had to run to their safe areas after it was over.
+Jan Scott Well I heard a little bit of applause at the end there LOL
+Jan Scott I'm surprised they let him in in the first place. There were a lot of empty seats.
+Jan Scott he was very problematic.
+Jan Scott A lot of safe spaces were created right after this forum and a log of tears were shed over their whiny blogging soon after.
Over a minute and a half to ask a question he doesnt understand...
And his professor sitting next to him enticing him to challenge a black belt in Verbal Warfare. Poor little guy never stood a chance....
I hate calling it destroyed. I say he blessed them with his knowledge
He got destroyed.
Ya. D'Souza "blessed" him with knowledge right across the kid's face. BAM!
Regina Buttons
Black Americans were benefiting from the post WW2 economy for almost 2 decades
Then the democrats wrote up the welfare state that decimated the black family thru financially incentivizing the single parent household therefore keeping black on the democrat culture plantation of dependency
Cast not your pearls before swine, lest they trample them under their feet, turn around and gnash you to pieces. Leftists are too heavily brainwashed at this point. They spend hundreds of hours just within a single year in those socialist propaganda centers called "colleges." Too much partial truth propaganda muddying up the waters of their minds to let logic sink in within only 1 hour of a speech given by a conservative.
Well, I am on your side. I agree it is better to be positive. Also, the college kid did better than most of the youtube comments would imply. (Warrng: laura ingraham style but monkey approaching) But he got destroyed.
I wasn't sure where Dinesh was going at first either but he's 100% right. People want to tell everyone how to live and how to do right, especially politicians, without themselves doing the right first.
That old lady was triggered.
Danny Han She was a communist operative. She was controlling the young crowd.
She was also a minority trying to get this kid to help justify paying her people back.
That closing statement was really powerful! You could tell that was calculated and he executed it brilliantly.
Ouch! Mr. D'Souza hit him hard. The kid deserved it too. He was pontificating about how immoral America has been and (to him)still is, but he was unwilling to take an honest look at himself.
The Amherst teacher is next to the student is making $150,000/year, giving 1% to charity and hates that the hypocrisy is being shoved in everyone's face, including hers.
Notice the gentleman to the left of the student? That's one of his professors who probably didn't have the guts to do it himself so he encouraged one of his "prize" students to engage Mr. D'Souza. And also notice to his right the lady who eggs him on as if she is coaching him. Also notice as the conversation moves forward and Mr. D'Souza presses the "student" to act on his personal sense of virtue and divest himself of his own "white privilege", he begins to look around for someone to come to his aid and help him.
+Mortimer Snerd It's the FEMALE to the right as well - the one with the gray hair and hippie ears.
+Renee Dorsey I noticed her very deliberate and seemingly militant body posture, clearly coaching and goading that kid into pressing his case. Good thing that eloquence doesn't replace intelligence.
+Mortimer Snerd Notice the age difference of them all. Just goes to show you how long this marxist brainwashing has been going on.
+Mortimer Snerd Of course the cowards are unwilling to stand. They are ill-equipped and they don't want to be shot down in front of their students. The interesting conversation is what happens an hour after this, when all the progressive whack jobs are patting each other's backs. The Professor of nonsense will chastise the student on what he should have said. That poor kid and his white guilt was trying so hard to sit down before D'Souza engaged him fully.
+Mortimer Snerd He was probably hoping some fellow redditors would come and downvote D'Souza
This kid will make a great politician talks in circles & avoids the point.
Correct throws out words yet says nothing
The kid said a whole lot without actually saying anything. Impressive.
He's in the mafia🤐
Democratic indoctrination
That's the whole point. The uninformed will use words as a smokescreen to confuse, not to explain.
Notice his body language the whole time. Turning and looking around for reassurance and an exit.
The Obama-Lisp Rhetoric whole lotta nothin' style
That’s college for!
He might not appreciate at that moment, but I believe he learned a very great lesson from Dinesh.
He killed himself.
"That's the problem with the progressivism that marches behind social justice while protecting its own privileges" - Dinesh D'Souza.
Best way of describing progressivism I've ever heard.
word
So basically all he did was describe a character flaw of those apart of the movement, not actually refute the widespread, systematic existence of this privilege
+Tyler Grzesik without privilege the march is rounded up and silenced
Sad that that's the best definition of progressivism you ever heard. God bless your soul for listening to Dinesh. If anyone can push you over the cliff while you smile, that would be Dinesh. Mind you, the progressivism you denounce must sure be frauding the electoral system!
On Ever You're exactly right. It is misleading the electorate. Frauding?
That lady behind him...if this video were in 4K you just might see the strings around her fingers puppeteering that naive, corruptible student.
+Iambic Pentameter I think you could see her arm up his rear, manipulating his mouth to speak her words.
+Iambic Pentameter Great observation!
Well said
yes
Clapping is triggering.
Legend has it this guy is still talking round in circles to this day...
@luke wilson Put the crack pipe down and get some help. The empty barrel got exposed in front of his pals. They're probably all supporters of Lizzie Warren. Trump 2020!
😂😂😂😂 he's still there
He is probably on his way to being a politician or lawyer
He committed suicide.
@@lucasdarianschwendlervieir3714 I read that as well. I saw the article with his parents. But I can't find it anymore.
ROASTED!
I have no words for how much I love D'Souza
People who use big words in the wrong context are just trying to look ambidextrous
Hilarious!!!! 😂😂😂😂
Thank you!! I found myself rolling my eyes the entire time he was speaking.
😄
Who are you applying this to?
Reminds me of that Michael Dyson idiot
20 years of marriage, mortgage, and children will cure this young man. Unfortunately, it didn’t work on the older lady goading him on.
She's the Marxist Professor who TAUGHT him to hate HIMSELF. Self-Hate is Destructive.
Roger Quarton , I bet you’re right about that
His marriage is on hold; after this display of stupidity, he and his (now ex) girlfriend are both looking for new boyfriends.
Ray Vorontsoff , I’m afraid so, sir.
Jim Ryser , or like a barren field where no seed can find purchase.
I don't know who the guy on stage is but he just ripped that kid a new one
It is beautiful. This debate was really good.
He makes a living by tearing bodies filled with stupidity , misconceptions , erroneous theories, misquoted history, Communist/Nazi bloated jingoisms and exposing their blood to the sun . Funny how they turn into ashes.
Actually, the guy on the stage didn't accomplish anything at all other than present a strawman argument. The kid never claimed whites should give EVERYTHING up. Just that they provide SOME compensation to those that they stepped on in order to help whites accomplish what they have.
So, to equate this to college, what D'Souza (the guy on the stage) should have asked is whether the kid would be willing to do something like pay more for college so minorities could attend at a lower cost... or maybe that he have to score higher on admissions type tests. And I suspect the kid would be more than willing to do this... technically, he probably already is doing it thanks to various programs design to help minorities get in and afford college.
Bottom line, the kid's white privilege may have HELPED him, but that doesn't mean he hasn't had to put in any effort himself. He shouldn't have to give up what he has worked for... just that which he didn't work for. That is the point he was indirectly making. He simply worded it that instead of just giving up the percentage we haven't earned, that we transfer it to those that have more than earned it either directly or indirectly because of our actions.
Btw, I'm not necessarily saying I agree with the kid. Just pointing out that this is his point... that D'Souza never directly addresses his point... that D'Souza instead creates a strawman argument... and that the kid most likely IS providing this kind of compensation to at least some small degree by not only volunteering his time to tutor the less fortunate but probably also had to score higher to get into college than many minorities... and is probably paying more for tuition than various minorities. I don't know his finances and stuff of course though.
*****
Exactly. There is no way to tell how much one has benefited. However, to assume it is 100% is utterly ridiculous. Do you REALLY think that if this kid had sat around playing video games at home and never showed up for classes, done homework and studied, that he would have graduated from high school, let alone make it into this college? Really?
Maybe it would be easier for you to see my point if you looked at it from the opposite point of view. There is no way you can conclude that a poor black kid with possibly failing grades would have scored well in high school and earned his position in this college had white privilege not existed. So, using your logic that would mean that he shouldn't get any help at all... let alone that the white guy give up EVERYTHING for him... right?
Again, this is clearly a strawman argument. The kid clearly was saying that he BENEFITTED... not that he owed 100% of his accomplishments to white privilege.
Thus, the logical counter argument would be whether he would be willing to give back SOMETHING... not everything. And that something would be in the form of stuff like maybe tutoring less fortunate... or him paying more for his tuition so that a minority person can pay less... etc. And as I've said, odds are he probably already is doing some of this... and I'm pretty positive he would be more than willing to do more in this area. Which is why D'Souva felt it was necessary to create the strawman argument and to push the price to be paid to the utter extreme.
*****
You seem to be on the same page as the kid though. That there is often a benefit to being the same color as the majority. Especially if that benefit was a major one in the past that resulted in financial and other benefits that have been passed down through the generations to a certain degree.
At the same time, you seem to disagree with D'Souva that the argument being made is that one should have to give up everything in order to compensate. As the kid seems to be saying, all minorities probably need in order to compensate is a hand up... not a HUGE hand out as D'Souva wants to turn the argument into. His argument is that if you aren't willing to give up EVERYTHING then your argument that you should give up anything is invalid. And that is a massively faulty argument. One which someone of his caliber should be ashamed to present... especially to a young non professional debater.
Little dude got scolded. By a smart man with common sense.
I have always maintained that I am going to file suit in Rome asking for reparations for the Roman Empire having held my Celtic ancestors in slavery.
I should file suit in Paris for persecuting my Huguenot ancestors into fleeing the country.
All of you should
Omg same
My great-great grandfather was native American on my father's side and both grandparents on my mother's side were first ones born here so how am I owed. I need to figure out how white I am and if any of my white ancestors if any were slave owners so I can hate that percentage of myself. Yugoslavia is where my mom's side came from. Still got a copy of Ellis island paper's.
Hey @F McLaren, I bet you didn't know that up til recent times that the Battle of Culloden was taught in East Tennessee schools. So many of the people of East Tennessee are of Scots-Irish descent. You know, the Ulster Irish as it were. You would be surprised at the amount of Scottish Flag auto tags people put on their automobiles round here. No joke. I mean it ain't hundreds or anything-but enough you'd notice.
So in short, his answer is, no I will not give up my place here in college
I’m Native American and I have never felt oppressed. My reparations are living in a country with so many opportunities. Here’s something that you never hear talked about. Black immigrants escape poverty at a drastically higher rate than American black people. Why is that? Cause they come here with a hard work ethic and not a victim mentality
Yesss!!! I’m a black immigrant and this is true
I disagree... I am a black American currently in school to get my doctorate in nursing. My brother is an engineer and back in school to get his Masters at one of the most presigous universities in America...and my sister is completing her pre-reqs for med school.
Let's put this in perspective. In 2019, 46.8 million Americans identified as black while there were 4.2 million black immigrants in 2016, according to PEW Research. Of course, when you compare those numbers, statically, there is a higher percentage of black immigrants "working hard." Would those statistics still hold true if compared to the blacks living in the country from which black immigrants migrated from? It's stands to reason that one who would invest so much to leave their home would make the most out of the opportunities given them. Just food for thought. May God continue to bless you both.
@@NaturallyBlessed4C I don’t even understand your response. You’re saying that yes black immigrants do work harder but only because they immigrated?
@Tom Martyn thanks Tom for your response. My apologies for any confusion. My main point, which may not have come across clearly, is that statistically black immigrants "work hard" or "harder" than the black American, however, those statistics are based on an almost 40 million population difference between the two. Does that compare to the natives that remain in their country? Are they equally as hard working as their immigrant counterpart? Maybe they were just hard-working individuals to begin with... and when compared to their native kinsmen, they may be the minority or maybe they aren't and everyone in that country is hard working. I can't say. Anyhow, while statistics still speak volumes... I turn your attention to the following article/ data... which states...
"Black immigrants hold degrees at a similar rate as the U.S. foreign-born population-26% of the foreign-born black population ages 25 and older has at least a bachelor’s degree, comparable to 28% of all U.S. immigrants. But there are striking differences when comparing black immigrants with Asian immigrants and with Hispanic immigrants. Among those 25 and older, 50% of all Asian immigrants have completed at least a four-year degree; but only 11% of Hispanic immigrants have done so."
You can read the entire article here
www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2015/04/09/chapter-1-statistical-portrait-of-the-u-s-black-immigrant-population/
@@NaturallyBlessed4C I think something that also isn’t talked about is broken homes. African immigrants promote nuclear families a lot more than black Americans. Single motherhood in the American black community is almost promoted. I’ve been saying this for years, fix the single mother problem in the blsck community and you’d see a drastic reduction in black poverty
You learn by asking questions and being willing to be challenged. Good for him for standing up and asking and be willing to be proven wrong. I hope he learnt from this and will keep searching.
Doubt it! That is also the huge blind spot for the Left/Democratic Party. Even when everything they do fails or is destructive, they just move on to another idiotic statement/program.
Learnt?? Moron..
Never seen someone’s argument been nuked publicly before! Especially when the majority of the crowd seemed against dinesh!
White liberals “I try to help people”, Dinesh “doing what?” Liberal “...” crickets
Lol! I was told this by a white liberal in my FB! When I asked him what he does, he said by fighting racism because he hates Trump. I asked him again, how do you fight racism by hating others and what do you do for immigrants, since he brought up DACA and other immigrant issues. I have him a list of things I do for my community and yet he wanted me to hate someone I don’t even know on a personal level! I told him, I’m if you set up a go fund me account to reach $50,000 I will tell you who I’m voting for and heck I will even say some mean things about Trump.... then all I heard was crickets 🦗 when this guy was using my Fb to post how woke he is!🤦🏻♀️. I told him the $50,000 would be used to provide scholarships for Latinas.... and yet no more debate or demands on who I was going to vote for! I also said, your white privilege is unbelievable because he was calling Trump supporters names and demanded to know my political stance! 🤷🏻♀️. I never insulted anyone nor criticized anyone for their political stance nor do I care!
“tell him, educate him!”....smh
@@cyang7850 yeah... the lady to his right is just as pathetic!
@@ednab.9001 increible Edna, la jente cada dia se lejan mas de Dios.
He’ll help them later on in life when he needs gardeners and maids.
I'm white and i've looked everywhere for this white privilege but I can't seem to find it anywhere
*****
Awww. So that's where it is hidden?
+Rumchug Maybe he doesn't see it, because he's too busy working!
It's amazing to me that the harder I work and more I sacrifice, the more "privilage" I enjoy!
+wufongtan wufong Me too and I'm not even white. When I do find it I'll be sure to share it, though.
Yeah, it's funny how the concept of white privilege is always profused used by RICH white people.
Stop projecting your feelings of guilt onto all of us. You feel "privileged" because you are rich, not because you are white. There are millions of working class, barely scraping by on two incomes whites in America.
Not that I'm socialist (I firmly believe in the superiority of capitalism) but the only real privilege is wealth.
Interesting how in the 21st century that privilege is hidden away behind bullshit divisive indentity politics.
+wufongtan wufong You didn't pay attention to the young gentleman's points. What he presents is a genuine argument for the privilege that white families have developed over the years. The GI Bill + lower rates on Mortgages among other benefits weren't taken by non-whites. So when blacks failed to acquire quality homes and whites afforded similar middle-class homes, segregation bloomed.
That said, to answer D'Souza: "I would never abandon my seat in my university. I know my black equal wouldn't step down so I won't miss out on an education."
At least he was respectful. He didn’t try to “own” Dinesh and get humiliated.
Like the lady who said “educate him” as if this student has anything to teach a man who served Presidents and sat on think tanks. 😂
he looked foolish as did the woman with the wad of wire on her head
+Andrea NY I was thinking the same thing
+Andrea NY You mean that stupid "mixed" woman shaking her head at white privilege? lol
+Shawn Hettesheimer She wasn't STUPID...she was merely a LEFTY LIBERAL wanting to STICK IT TO the MAN who's PAYING HER SALARY!!!
+Andrea NY ... Proof that all those education dollars can't buy you intelligence and common sense.
+Andrea NY i abhor his belief system but he's obviously a very smart and articulate kid. It's so important what we're taught.
I do admire D'Souza for calling the young man out on his hypocrisy.
+Nora Dennis .. hypocrisy is a right nuts middle name idiot. What Dinesh does is spin and play word games. The kid was to young to know how to handle an asshole
Ahhh. Deflection, bigraviolees. The elixir of the Left. What they drink when even obvious facts don't fit their agenda...
bigraviolees
How is D'Souza an asshole? He does his research AND he is an immigrant who legally came here. He has lived in another political system. Like myself, he's seen how America has been changing and it isn't a good change either..
bigraviolees YES!! EXACTLY! It is clear what this kid was asking. The kid ASKED how can we fix the issue. not. hey I have all "this" because of my ancestors taking "that"...we need to give "this" back.
Why would a kid ask a guy who doesn't even believe it is an issue how to fix it? Your as dumb as the kid hahahahah
THE YOUNG MAN WAS SPOUTING MUCH VERBAL FLATULENCE.
Fact Check: the GI Bill was not denied to African Americans after WW2
At least the student could put a sentence together and wasn't being hostile, despite being proven wrong.
I think that is about the only thing going for him. His ideology is wrong, but he was fairly kind whilst speaking. Not that he said much lol
a true progressive of speech
Yes, he did that. But at an institution of higher learning you would already be expected that, and he WAS a freshman. So, yes. But when he was falling apart and looking to the teach for "help!" was when I kinda felt sorry for him. But if you are going to debate Mr. D'Souza and you know what you will ask better know what your saying. Oh well. I hope he did learn something, good.
@@alpha13dylan Yea well I'm something of a recovered SJW so I know it *can* happen. If we really want people's attitudes towards each other to change, we have to be willing to believe we can all change for the better.
He was highly intelligent, just in need of instruction.
"That's the problem with the progressivism that marches behind social justice while protecting its own privileges." Well done, Sir - that's some impressive phraseology right there - especially as it's produced under pressure.
Yepp, for some there is only one progress and it's called a grave.
But who knows, maybe he faced himself and changed...
So it’s bad to want to progress other people’s lives without hindering your own?
@@drdoomer8553 No, it's not bad and you're right to clarify the point. I was responding out of my distaste for the loudest of the SJWS - those mirthless finger-pointers who compete for victimhood and shameless virtue-signalling. But, as you imply, you don't have to be a victim to wish better for others.
@@drdoomer8553 "So it’s bad to want to progress other people’s lives without hindering your own?"
If you want to progress other people's lives by _hindering your kith and kin's lives _*_but not your own life?_* *YES.* Yes, that is indeed a bad thing!
I present Exhibit A, the very recent debacle with Ben & Jerry's using Twitter to make an Independence Day statement shaming the United States of America for existing on land that was, at least in part, taken from the Native American tribes by force. Numerous people replied to Ben & Jerry's by pointing out that _the Ben & Jerry's headquarters in Vermont itself_ stands on land which was once the home of the Abenaki tribe before the Abenaki were driven out by the emigrating English settlers, then challenged Ben & Jerry's to put their money where their mouth is and take the first step to righting this wrong by _giving their land back to the Abenaki tribe._
Then Chief Don Stevens of the Coosuk Abenaki Nation followed up on the idea by reaching out to Ben & Jerry's, publically stating that, as Chief, he is always watching for opportunities to advance the welfare of Indigenous American peoples and that he was looking forward to hearing back from Ben & Jerry's, so that they could negotiate the transfer of that land from Ben & Jerry's to the Abenaki people.
Ben & Jerry's response thus far? Silence.
So clearly Ben & Jerry's is perfectly willing to return _other people's_ land to the Native Americans, but they won't return _their own._
And that's what's wrong with White Liberals howling for Reparations and such; hypocrisy is quite the grave character flaw. Who are they to tell _anyone else_ what they should do - and what personal sacrifices they should make - if they refuse to lead from the front and enter the breech themselves?
DAMN.... Dude just got OWNED!!!
Called him out on his "acknowledging his privilege" yet he isnt willing to give his seat up to a poor disadvantaged minority. The last 4 minutes is nothing but pure destruction.
Michael Jackson ummmm, first of all, you are missing the entire point to his argument...
1... What he is saying IS,.. If this guy feels so strongly that white privilege exists, he needs to lead the way in making that change, by giving up, his cushy education at Amherst, and give it to an individual. Just as intelligent, that is being denied the same opportunity to go to such a prestigious university, simply because of his or her race..
By making excuses for himself, as to why he will not do that. Proves what a hypocrite he is. And makes his argument, seem disingenuous and only serves as to make himself seem "better". Than the average white person. Because, he recognizes his "privilege", and his inherent guilt. Which is a load of bullshit... Which he proved by backing up, when Denesh challenged hid position...
2... There is no systematic racism.. There are plenty of programs in place as we speak to afford minorities the opportunity of a great education. And quota requirements for diversity at some school's guarantees that a person of color WILL be accepted over a more qualified white student.. And has been proven to have happened, on several occasions..
3... Like Denesh said, how do we decide who pays and who receives?? My family never owned slaves, nor did they oppose the civil rights movement... Why do I have to pay for something I nor anyone in my family is responsible for?? I certainly haven't benefitted from any "white privilege".. I worked a full time job, and went to school full-time. I paid for my OWN classes. Because I was denied ANY assistance. Because, I was under 25 and the state considered me a dependent student upon my parents.. Even though, I lived in my OWN... So where was my "privilege" for the color of my skin??
4... The only privilege in America today, is class privilege. Regardless of race. How many upper middle class and above, black people are harassed by cops, or shot in the streets, or denied access to EVERY whim??? PLEASE, state me an example.
Uneducated unemployed whites of the South?
Easier to just say "White Southern Democrats".
Michael Jackson
No, I didn't "repeat" what you said.
Dinesh is correct, this guy is a hypocrite. SJW, are the VERY definition of hypocrisy and double standards...
You just proved, THAT... ANY time a person brings forth an argument that refutes your drivel. It is always the same... "We aren't taking about THAT".. Yet it totally disproves YOUR argument.. Debating isn't really a thing you all like??
Give me specific examples of a system in place as we speak that oppresses or denies certain basic needs or even privileges to ANY person based on their race??
Like I said, it is a class issue, who h you just proved with your statement of.. "Just ask all the poor, uneducated, whites of the South".
Which btw, was a stereotypical statement. And isn't in the least true. That implies that there aren't ANY "poor, uneducated whites" in the North??
Which Mensa Reject is 100% correct...
The Democratic party was, is and always will be an elitist group... You want to see a "system of racism"? Look no further than ANY major city ran by them, black and white...
Detroit Michigan, has been under Democratic rule for 57 years... And 90% of the government leaders are black... A Democratic President signed NAFTA, that essentially destroyed the industry in Detroit. Flint Michigan 54 years of Democratic government leaders... Same sad tale... I could go on, but you get the point.
You are buying the propagandists lie... That started many years ago..
"White privilege" is a myth, "systematic racism" is a myth.. Racism exist, because it is perpetuated by media, entertainment, the government, etc... The ONLY one keeping ANYONE down, is THEM. Because, they refuse to walk off the Government Plantation. THAT is a fact.
IF white Americans were truly benefiting from a "system" set up in their favor today. And had this agenda to oppress the black race,... WHY wouldn't they go after the wealthy?? You know, the individuals that are in positions of power, privilege, and status???
Why bother with the poor, uneducated?? They would be of no concern. A person worth millions of dollars, in a influential position.. Would!
***** lol,... true. I don't know why I bother.. Liberalism is a mental disorder... Very sad... smh
I give that kid credit for at least articulating what he believes even though it's wrong. It did not end up in a shouting match... He is a product of liberal professors like the one sitting at his right...
I'm currently taking Sociology 101 and it's nothing but Liberal propaganda. The chapter I'm reading from the text book this week is called, "Racism without Racists."
I'm sorry for you. What's your major?
Moe S Stay strong my friend.
I took sociology as a complimentary course to my major at the university of Iowa. We discussed things like moving from class to class, effects of poverty, history of discrimination, and studied some court cases that pertained to laws those topics. Weirdly enough, we did study the "wage" gap that was correctly referred to as the earnings gap. And we talked about how the earnings gap was created by time off, different jobs worked, different jobs pursued, and pregnancy. It was never racism and it was never systematic oppression. It's weird how now people are learning different things. But this was 5 years ago, so maybe I got out of college just in time.
Moe S I have to take sociology too, I am not looking forward to it.
A Liberal tells you how to think.
A Conservative tells you to think.
+Junokaii nicely said. I have never been able to state why liberals seemed so out of touch to me. I recently read Plato's Republic and found it fascinating. I need to read it a couple more times though.
Todd Nelson They seem to think that if others think differently than them.... the world will somehow be chaotic.
True tolerance is being able to go "I strongly disagree with you but I respect you enough to leave you alone about it".
Conflict of any kind always seems to be due to a belief held so strongly that they'll die to get others to do the same.
+Junokaii Transactional conflict is more than a little common. Give me what you have or else.
lowkeynz I don't even think it's about that.
Just about control I think.
Much the same way a child tries convincing you. Just wants it their way regardless.
+Junokaii Only half right. A Liberal tells you one way to think. A Conservative tells you another way to think. A real human being thinks for themselves.
WOW I LOVE HOW DINESH DEMOLISHED THAT BOY
Bradley Zichterman
The Curried Chicken strikes again!
I HAVE HEARD THIS 100 TIMES AND IT NEVER GETS OLD...I WONDER WHAT EVER HAPPENED TO THIS KID. HE GOT WRECKED! OUCH...!!
He killed himself.
He CRUSHED him and his lefty teacher sitting next to him lol
I thought that was his grandmother
Fatality!
Dinesh just proved that using big words doesn't make you smarter. Now that kid knows that he has to actually learn what comes out of his own mouth.
Lol, he even got a vocab lesson during the debate.
Damian Etcitty Illicit
immoral
I learned something new too
Damian Etcitty yes! That's what the leftists are all about: they use big, fancy words to appear intelligent and but alas lacking common sense.
+Sergio Milho I caught that too. I think he was speaking in terms of the moral arena (ideology) and not so much more concrete ideas like "you stole my car". If we're just talking about ideological right vs. wrong, you could reasonably equate right with legal and wrong with illegal.
I learned that also....
Illicit-forbidden by law, rules, or custom.
""The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money"....Margaret Thatcher
Never a truer word spoken...
Steve P thatcher was evil
@@Cultwatch123 she's not wrong but people celebrated when she died, she made a lot of working family a poor.
well somebody should tell Thatcher-- That you eventually run out of yr money as well
Thanks for that steve p
Excellent quote!
The very amusing thing about the upper class in the UK is that people like Thatcher are convinced that the money of the middle classes and the working classes is the same as their money, once it has been paid to the Exchequer (royal or national treasury). What they often do is reduce taxes on themselves but raise taxes on everyone else, just as what happened in the USA.
Dinesh, Very eloquent, very succinct, well thought out and direct to the point! THIS GUY WAS SO TOTALLY OUT CLASSED!
Wow!!! I've watched Ben Shapiro decimate a few icons, but this was brutal. This guy takes no prisoners!!! Love it!!
Damn right
This is the most well explained analysis of the hypocrisy of social justice I’ve seen!
This kid is genuinely nice, just genuinely mislead.
Not misled, indoctrinated.
The puppet master in the great sweater behind him is the problem, I’m willing to bet she teachers at that school
@@Thelastdan she does, shes a professor who brought these students.
He is not a good person, but a hypocrite, as you are. He tries to make everyone think that he is an angel, but he does it so clumsily that his ego betrays him. His ego moves him, blinds him and controls him and above all, his own ego makes him act and speak like the hypocrite clown he is.
He just doesn't realize some important things. We are each, as individuals, born into vastly different circumstances. We have absolutely no say in what any of our ancestors did, yet this guy is seemingly trying to guilt everyone today for things done in the past! It is not only impossible, but that type of indoctrinated thought is causing huge amounts of division in today's society! The only person we have ANY control over is ourselves!
Dinesh is incredibly knowledgeable. He amazes me every single time he speaks.
First off, I'm white. White privilege entitled me to 50 years of very hard work in the construction industry. I worked hard, and I paid my own way, no welfare. I'm proud of that fact. I call it "American Privilege." America gave me that opportunity. Being white didn't entitle me to anything except the possibility of starvation, if I didn't get out, find a job, any job, and work my tail off to buy my food, and pay my rent. It's pretty simple really. It's called "Survival." My Mom taught me that. Thank God she did!
Racyst
WOW! Very well said, Mike. I liked it so much I read it 10 times so I could repeat it and also copied and pasted to my phone just encase I forget any part of it. And, your are 100% correct. I would like to just scream what you said out loud and would pay to put it up on a billboard. God bless you!
lori k Thank you Lori. That was a very nice thing to say. It made my day.
Eh....white privelage only exists around non whites. Its a complicated issue. If you don't think privelage exists, take a look at Harvard, then the blacks , then ....the people who is standing behind the blacks.....
I'm white, but what would you know about discrimination you've never faced? How are you in a position to know what benefits you received that others do not? It's like you're certain you have no blind spot, but can't know that. Do you think racial discrimination doesn't occur at all? If so, what is the basis for that position?
Ah indeed you are a hypocrite. Give up your seat now Mr College Student
This guy literally says he's not talking about affirmative action, and then proceeds to use *affirmative action* to argue documentable wealth to give it back to the disadvantaged. This is *misdirection* not an argument.
I was thinking the same thing when I watched this.
Regardless the point was that the kid better lead by example first rather pointing fingers at others.
Dinesh, your voice is so beautiful, music to my ears. I appreciate what you do for this country.
The woman to his right proves the adage that there is no fool like an old fool.
Jeff Grey
Why do all elite liberals look alike, starting with ugly?
@@ilovejacquescousteau7183
Because they advocate the normalization of hedonism.
@@ilovejacquescousteau7183 Lotta them look Jewish, like this kid. Is that it?
Abcde no, stop it
She attempts to get a clapping support group going to lend credibility to the kid's points. Amateur move.
How am I able to tell with such certainty that the lady in the grey sweater is a gender studies professor lol
Also , likely his psychology professor. She does have that angry aging hippee lesbian look. They all have long grey hair , unable to give up the 60's protest unique but the same look.
I guess she would be as soon as she figures out her own gender!
....and her name is Karen! 😂😂😂
@@menliz5496 Wow, she has woman's name. She must be one of those moderate leftwing dingbats we keep hearing about!
😂😂😂😂😂😂
YES Looks like a hair washer
Functions as a brain washer
VILE VILE THING
CRUELA DEVILLE
what was really funny though, was the woman (probably a teacher), who told this kid to educate D'sousa. The common core set caught again!
I thought the same thing....I was thinking...wait a minute...its 70,000 a year to go to this school and that Simple Jack bitch is probably a tenured professor.
+David Cisneros . THAT IS funny you cant educate Dinesh, they guy is a fucking idiot and propagandizing tool
How could he think "outside the liberal box" when he has been indoctrinated to think it's the world?
bigraviolees adorable concept.
@@bigraviolees honestly asking, can you give any examples of that? He challenges the new norm of seeing racism and injustice in everything. I am not saying people don't have to work hard to get into college, I know there are a lot of people that have to sacrifice a lot to get there. To claim victimhood when you are in college though, that's just dumb.
This is what are colleges is turning out.
The poor kid can't even form his sentences properly.
His gender studies teacher sitting there convinced him that if he used as many words as possible to confuse and conquer the audience to his side that not having a precise argument wouldn't matter.
These people don’t have jobs. Start paying taxes and you’ll change your tune.
@@thegalaxylab whats your point?
Unfortunately the roads and never ending inept government entitlement programs soon become a cover for extortion and oppression
Unfortunately that doesn’t seem to be the case a lot of the time..many of my co-workers are far left/socialist and I work in Finance
@@treshawndeandre Yea, right.
@@carloswater7 No, it's true. I'm an accountant, and there are tons of socialists in this field. There's actually a good explanation for this: it's because 75% of accountants are women, and 68% of women are left-wing.
He was brave enough to get into the conversation with a very acute professor. He’s learning plenty.
He seems like he’s trying to remember everything his professor told him.
That's exactly what hes doing plus shes sitting right next him whispering in his ear.
sean johnson .. Yes, word for word.
Are people really this brainwashed? Embarrassing.
Welcome to higher ed system, why i dropped out of my history degree, i was being taught other people's narrative
You mean the nutty professor.
Kid, you just got PAWNED.
+Christopher Mayer - the "pawn" shop that took him in got suckered.
+Christopher Mayer - the "pawn" shop that took him in got suckered.
+Christopher Mayer Not just pawned, but PONED!!
+Christopher Mayer *pwnd
+Christopher Mayer Libtard got pawned
You think that old lady is his gender studies professor?
I'm certainly she isn't an educator by any means, but she plays one on a TH-cam video.
John Huldt Haha you stole the words right out of my mouth. Marxism didn't leave, nothing completely disappears they just resurface in a new mutation. She's his puppet master and their masters are not honest or realistic. Actually I think that child is not that unintelligent its just he's impressionable to be lead instead of leading by that woman. But that would make for a weak mind to not be able to navigate through the rhetoric as most of present society is.
She was annoying, just another lefty professor poisoning the next generation.
Left wing person here who thinks most of gender studies is bullshit. You have to recognize that there are people like me who are smart, liberal, and agree with you on some topics. But all you guys do is generalize. It's 100% support for Trump, 100% opposition to liberals. Can you at least admit that reality is a bit more complicated than you are pretending?
sleepcity Hold on, being liberal, and being a leftist, are completely different ideologies. I'm a conservative, but solidly a libertarian on most issues outside of economics. So I think we probably agree on a vast majority of issues.
But if your in favor, or even if you believe in this "white privilege", I would ask; What Institutions, and who are the people running these institutions, that are propagating, and enacting racial, and cultural discrimination?......Because you can not have "white privilege", and not have racism, or ethnic discrimination at the same time. Who are these people, and what institutions are doing this, so we can fight them together?
This one is struggling for words, Dinesh has him with knowledge
As a Veteran, I have earned my benefits as set forth by the Congress and the Veterans Administration. No one handed them down to me.
CORRECT!! This boy has been lied to concerning that black service men and women were not recipient of the GI Bill. imagine if the soldiers of the 442nd Japanese Infantry Regiment were not provided GI rights? They were the true discriminated ethnicity WW II era!!! The Japanese American suffered because of Pearl Harbor and even during and after WW II - through land theft.
It was amazing to see a young man be so eloquent at making a complete fool of himself! LOL
Sir It's good to argue about things we think are correct and true..
@@Vdheeraj93 But backed up with facts
@Mike Chappell Lol yep, he got called out for his hypocrisy even though I did agree with his statement that we all have some degree of hypocrisy, that was a good point to make and if we are all honest with ourselves, we would all agree on that point....but he still totally dodged what D'SOUZA was saying overall.
LMAO THAT STUDENT GOT SCHOOLED
Obama was called eloquent. He was a wordsmith. He said very little of substance while talking a lot very beautifully.
Just imagine how much better off this smart kid would be if he were attending a real college ? And by real I mean any college that teaches students HOW to think instead of WHAT to think.
Amen
D'Souza interpretation of Neitzche is laughable.
Do those still exist? I’m serious about this question
I attend this college (Amherst College), and they definitely teach us how to think lol That’s what our liberal arts education is predicated on and we have an acceptance rate of 11% and are currently ranked in the top 25 colleges in the nation by multiple college-ranking websites, so I’m guessing the way we’re being taught is fairly reputable. Unfortunately though, our campus is full of students from the far-left whose aggressive opinions influence other students, thus feeding into the left’s misinformation and inaccurate arguments. As a student at Amherst who is conservative, I will argue that the college as a whole teaches us HOW to think but it’s the other students who teach us WHAT to think
@@Hellotherett If the colleges teach you how to think and your students are this bad. Pal, the ranking is very much wrong. I don't know what kind of money you pay for magazines to rank you this high but it's so detached from reality that it's laughable.
These things are basic knowledge, if this is America top 25, American colleges are near where no top of the world. I'm guessing that only American law school or medical school, or research institution should be ranked high.
These aren't colleges, these are indoctrination camp.
He did all that studying just to get destroyed in seconds. Learn a skill to get a job and move out of your parents house that are paying for your education. That makes you privileged are you going to give your spot to a less fortunate kid. Teacher didn't think of that!!!😳🤯
Okay, but the point the student was getting at is that ideally _hypothetically_ there shouldn't be a need to address any socioeconomic disparity. And D'Souza responded to the _hypothetical situation_ by pointing out that the _hypothetical situation_ wasn't feasible. 🙄
For sure the kid and his mentor in the white straight jacked 8 times inoculated and will not be a problem in society, cause they had a coincidence and climate change got them. They defiantly owned a gas stove.