Went yesterday after waiting for the craze to settle down. Went in with a game plan focussed on meat and we were not disappointed. With the rebates on mince & chicken we ended up saving over $100 . Bulk buying meat and deep freezing is our game and we LOVE it!
Comparison with warehouse and kmart for household goods? I recall visiting costco in aussie and they sold TVs, flatpacks and what not. BTW good video. Now subbed.
Costco is another step down on the ladder for NZ. Following the American consumerism is certain doom for NZ. NZ used to be so different 30 years ago - it seems the internet lobotomised half of the population in that time.
I’m from NZ but currently in Ireland. I was surprised at the savings here compared to NZ because of competition ( Lidl, Tesco, Super Value, Aldi, Dunnes, Marks & Spensers) Kiwis should support new players because the two big boys have ripped us off for years and claimed to be just scratching a living.
This is the best comparison video so far. For me being a one person household and an hours drive away this wouldn't be a viable option on savings but maybe on seeing what different items are available. It's a shame that you can't have a one off look to see if it's worth the membership fee. Thank you for doing this price comparison for us.
Hi Amy, I absolutely agree, allowing people in just to have a look around would make people much more comfortable paying the $60 for the card. Hopefully they do something like this in the future. If you know someone with a card, I was told that Costco will allow the cardholder to bring in 2 guests with them, however the cardholder will need to pay for the entire bill. I'm a one-person household too, with the savings on fuel and hoarding lots of chicken I've made good use of it so far, but to breakeven on the card you'll need to spend a fair bit given the cost of fuel to drive there too. Thanks for watching, and the kind words!
In the US, we find a friend or relative to shop with lol. Best categories for deals are staples: laundry detergent, paper towels, batteries, toothpaste. Meat, bulk food that you know you run through, cheap alcohol and wine, cheese, and inexpensive clothes
@@kansasistheman9289 that makes a lot of sense to go for an initial look with a friend who is a member. Do you mainly shop for food at Costco or do you go to different stores based on price?
This is a good comparison! I definitely agree that Costco is cheaper than Paknsave! It’s a shame everything comes in bulk. To buy veggies in Auckland, I def recommend to go to markets during the weekend. Most of the produce is half price than any supermarket
Kiwi based in AU - Costco is a hit and miss - you have to know how much the items cost outside of Costco to determine if you are getting value from Costco purchases. Additionally you have to finish items before they spoil given they have a short shelf life.
Hi Rajeev, spot on! I hope this video helps others doing this comparison as it’s certainly needed as a starting point to work out if it’s cheaper for them and their particular situation. Thanks for watching!
I firmly believe Costco is here not only for better prices, but to change the New Zealand consumer behaviour, from weekly to monthly (or more) purchases. Costco uses a strong pricing strategy. On the top of that, they could be willing to lose some money in the introduction stage, and competitor cannot beat that. My concern is, all the war-prices lead to collusion...I hope this will not be the case, for the sake of the consumers and the market. Excellent video!.
Hi Juan, I too hope the prices are here to stay and aren't temporary. I have faith that the amount of collusion is only going to decrease as competition in NZ increases. If not 'collusion', the lack of competition is what's really plaguing the market right now. Thanks for watching!
Kiwi in Canada here. This was a very interesting watch, Brent. Glad to see Costco’s entrance to the NZ market looks successful and likely will make a welcome change to the NZ retail landscape. Where I live, there are two or three Costco’s to choose from, including an American one just over the border in Bellingham. We are spoiled for choice. I was pretty much shocked at the cost of lotions and Dove soap during your video. I have sensitive skin issues and can see I would spend a small fortune back home now - however, one fine day, will return :))
What an excellently put together and executed, informative and straight to the point video! I wish I lived in Auckland to get those pak n save prices even, it’s a couple of $ more expensive for somethings in the SI!
The only items I would consider a bargain would be hearing aids and prescription glasses, and maybe some big box items. Again single and retired, but a shopping group of 6 - 8 friends might work for some products.
Hi Peter, you're absolutely right. I've heard the hearing aids and glasses are significantly cheaper at Costco but haven't seen the prices myself. Shopping in groups definitely makes sense, it also means you may be able to split the cost of the membership card (having one designated shopper) which is always great. Loading the freezer is another good idea for the meats. Thanks for watching!
Hi Peter, I went in today and they have hearing aids listed at prices from $2,000 to $4,000. These are rechargeable. In the store they also have branded frames, though I am not sure on the pricing for those.
Went to Costco yesterday then ran a price comparison when we got home. Managed to compare 14 items using current prices at PNS, CD and NW and if I'd bought the cheapest item from these, it still worked out $68.59 cheaper at Costco. Some items I couldn't compare as the other retailers don't stock anything comparable. Best buys would be shampoo, nuts, ground beef mince, herbs and spices (oh and Babybel cheese - massive savings on those!). I wouldn't bother with the fruit and veg at Costco as the savings are negligible, but the quality was great though.
Couldn’t agree more Shirley! You’ve got it right, huge savings in some of those pantry items, but produce is lacking at this point. Glad you enjoyed the video and thanks for sharing your price comparisons!
Costco is only getting started testing the market if it’s anything like the ones I been to in USA in time it will make short work of all the competition. They not even getting started yet .
@@clinth6432 Costco have been in Australia for ages and it hasn't really changed anything, they only have a handful of stores, meanwhile Coles and Woolies are still everywhere you look.
Hi Mitchell, definitely agree! Westgate was an interesting choice as the surrounding area has yet to fully mature and won't for many years. South Auckland I would think is next, given the larger household sizes, multi-generational homes, and proximity to Hamilton. With a launch like they've had, I'm sure it's not far away. Thanks for watching!
Thanks for the kind words! I am in this situation now too as I live locally. Supermarkets continue to offer a much broader number of items, as Costco has a narrow range of goods but stock a much greater amount of it. The next moves from the supermarkets to compete will be interesting as they can't on price, but perhaps a push to 'shop local' and enhancing their local kiwi goods selection. While Costco work only with brands at scale, supermarkets can work with their communities to build successful local brands, which they already do, but building on this would be great to see.
Excellent video and analysis of cost comparisons. I'm a kiwi who lives in Utah. The largest Costco in the whole world is here in downtown Salt Lake City. I think it's almost twice the size of the Auckland location. I'd love to stroll around the new one in NZ to see what they have! Enjoy!
I guess the big difference is that the unit size is bigger at Costco, so while it's cheaper per kilo, you still pay more because you are buying larger units. But for essentials or staples, it's great. I get my laundry and dish detergents, toilet paper, milk powder, rice etc etc from Costco. Anything I definitely use and won't perish. And a chicken.
This is super awesome for nz! More competition will help drive down the insane prices. Now let's hope we get more locations across nz to really make an impact - how about welly!!
Really good review! I have been twice and although its difficult to properly assess because of the difference in quantity being sold..and also because I cant remember the prices in pac n save....it was clear that generally on most of the items you are paying less. Great store! I definitely recommend we all shop a little differently and bulk buy on pantry items for sure. Thanks again.
I go to Costco for many certain items, especially non-perishables. The Kirkland brand is really high quality, which is hard to beat, especially when you're deciding on buying something that will last a long time, instead of buying something initially cheaper but you tend to replace it too often.
it would be interesting to see the same comparison in three months time. My experience with Costco in Australia is that it's no cheaper than anywhere else - I used to buy toilet rolls at Costco until I realised that I could get them for the same price at Aldi. incidentally, if I had to pick between Aldi and Pak'nSave, I'd take Pak'nSave any day. They operate at a similar price point, bit the limited product range at Aldi means that you make a second trip to Coles or Woolworths anyway to get the items that Aldi doesn't stock.
Definitely agree Barry, will be interesting to see how prices change going forwards. I saw a lot of the instant rebates have already been removed from the meat section which is a shame as there were some great bargains! Thanks for watching!
Very true Aldi product range isn't great and what they have is from random suppliers so not always good but they create competition in the market. What is needed here is for the government to grow a pair and pull out of international trade deals that only benefit major wholesalers NOT the shoppers here or growers and producers of some of the best produce in the world but stops growers even selling B grade fruit and veg at markets, B grade means spots or minor imperfections. Greed of a few is not a reason to be locked into trade deals... If these people cant sell the best produce in the world without dodgy trade agreements then they shouldn't be doing what they are doing. Lazy or useless you decide... Why are we paying international prices for our own produce when NO shipping is involved worse why can you regularly buy NZ produce in Australia cheaper than here ??? how does that work ? People support your local fruit and veg markets also local Butchers need support so they can start to reduce their prices. Although I doubt you find water in your meat to make it heavier at your local Butcher... Don't believe me get a pork chop from a home kill and one from the supermarket fry them it will speak for itself... After coming home after 12 years overseas I still can't believe what Im seeing here.
sounds like we need Aldi too and Lidl :D one can dream. as they say one is a monopoly and duopoly charges monopoly prices but share profit, only with 3 or more players then we have competition
@@alliao82 what we need is government that follows through on promises to crack down on anti competitive behaviour of the duopoly... Consecutive governments have threatened to put a stop to this and yet still NO action.
Amazing video! Definitely helps put a lot of the prices in perspective :) As a Massey resident the fuel prices basically pays for the cost of the membership so these savings are really just a bonus. I have a small family but since you can take two guests per card I can definitely see myself going in with friends, maybe when its less busy... Way too many people right now.
Thanks for the kind words, glad you enjoyed the video! I live around Massey too, and the fuel prices are very decent ~$2.42 at the moment for 91. Thanks for watching!
awesome review Brent!Thank you.Its not just the price difference and costco are head and shoulders below our generic supermarkets in NZ. For me its also about how we as customers to Pns and NW have been treated over the years...Patronised by so called low pricing which isn't the truth and you have clearly shown this..Working in the retail manufacturing /market as I have, my experience of our supermarkets deals/low pricing is because they lever the low pricing through manufacturers supplying and selling a product at well below there own preferred and sustainable profit margins.Also a thing to bear in mind, you can be a supplier but there is very rarely a supply contract which means all the risk on the success or failure of a product (which includes set up and packaging investment is on the manufacturer, not the retailer!
You're absolutely right Henrik! Supermarkets have had it really good for many years, and it's good to finally have a new entrant that turns the business model on its head and we can see just how much fat has been built into supermarket pricing. It's no wonder the government found them to be making >$1 million a day in excess profits. Thanks for watching!
Brent, you do a good job! I can't believe the prices in NZL. It's so discouraging to think of moving to your beautiful country. INCREDIBLY, we spend so much less on nearly everything in Panama!
Hi Paolo, thanks for watching! We absolutely agree the price of nearly everything here is very expensive. Our geographic distance, lack of competition, and high company overheads make it expensive to live here. Fortunately we're now seeing many well-priced global brands entering the market and bringing more competition, such as H&M, Costco, IKEA (2024-onwards), among others. Thanks for watching!
Thank you for the interesting comparison. I’ve been curious about Costco since I first heard we were getting one. Unfortunately, I live in the CBD and work on the shore so by the time I drive out of my way to Costco, I’m probably losing money on petrol. I also heard you needed a Costco card to shop or use their petrol which is $60 annually. Thank you for feeding my curiosity and saving me a drive to Westgate 😊
Great video and very useful $/weight comparison. However, it fails to account for major inconveniences which add abstract value: 1) commuting to far end of Auckland and cost of fuel spent. (not viable for most of Auckland) 2) Cost of membership (which may be insignificant if you go enough times an year but break even number of visit may need to be calculated) 3) Long queues and time spent. 4) Possible wastage by being forced to buy in bulk and having to invest in extra storage: pantry/freezers. 5) Stress/anxiety of too much planning required. Still I am very happy that tyrannical reign of Woolworths and Foodstuff Group is being challenged.
If you got an LPG vehicle the cost of commuting would be much cheaper. You can sort of hack out of membership by being added as an additional cardholder from a friend (just need to show one bill with you at the same address (do a mobile bill)), or if they buy you Costco gift cards. Even though some things are bulk, the price is still so much cheaper than other stores that you still save money even if you throw some of it out.
Hey Brent, great work on this and thanks for your effort. Few things I would like to point out, NZ Supermarket model is based on high/low, most popular products are on promotion 26 weeks of the year. Is PNS Westgate pricing promotional or the normal shelf price that you're comparing to? Ideally, you want to compare the best price or average visible price of each other due to the nature of each business model being different (NZ supermarket highly promotional vs Costco are not). Each PNS stores have different pricing therefore your title is slightly misleading as westgate PNS cant be used to represent all PNS stores.
Thank you very much Brent, here is a lot of value. It took some good efforts to make this, Did you do it all alone? How much time did it take you to make this video?
I'd love to see a comparison based on the 100 most purchased items there were some real headscratchers in there. Also I'd be curious to see this done at least every three months, I suspect part of the reason things are so much cheaper are just a hook to draw customers in and that the real prices of these items will be higher once they are established in the NZ market and have to supply their goods to smaller retailers. I would also be curious to know how much that this in theory saves per week what you really need is data that is not just a one off otherwise there is no scientific merit. Is the club price worth it? The bulk buying aspect makes it work for some and not for others.
Can you do the pet stuff idle? I saw some decent priced dog food at Costco but I’m not familiar with those brands! Didn’t want to upset my pups tummy 😂 awesome content btw
Hi Matilda, I’ll add this to my list for next time I go! I recall the brands weren’t the usual ones sold by supermarkets, but I’ll take a closer look! Thanks for watching!
When pams launched that new 4 pack of tp pak n save wainoni (maybe everywhere else) stopped selling all the different varieties of hand paper towels. You used to be able to get 2 packs of single ply and triple ply hand towels now just 4 packs of 2 ply. So I think those cheap 4 packs of 3ply tp are just a slightly modified version of their 3ply hand towel line
I was born and raised in the US so grew up going to Costco. I am a Kiwi as well now and have lived here for over a decade. Everytime someone asks me what I miss about the states I include Costco on the list. Even in the states it isn't always cheaper when it comes to some things, which I think is common with most stores, bulk, grocery, or otherwise. However when they have a deal it is amazing. Their eye, hearing, and other care is cheaper in some states and I hope it will be here as well. I always found that meats, pantry items, alcohol, and vitamins and toiletries were a great deal at Costco. As far as the cost of bulk buying it is something to consider. That is why the bring two guest option is awesome. If bulk buying is something you cant always afford, often you will have a friend who will bring you in as a guest for those cant miss savings. I don't know if they will do this here, but you get magazines and other monthly updates on their specials in the mail and online they list their prices so you can do comparisons. The produce and fridge section will always be hit and miss price wise simply due to their shelf life, though this could be different for bigger families or if shopping for a get together. When it comes to toys, decorations, furniture, etc the deals can be amazing depending on the brand and or quality you are looking for. I have found amazing deals over the years on travel, auto, clothing, etc. I believe it will be easier to price compare when their online portion of the store is up and running. Not sure what their return policy is here but in the states it is outstanding as are the gas prices. The big trap with Costco is impulse buying. Most of their stores don't have great cell reception and the good deal on a bulk buy can be tempting. The best advise I have is know your budget, think about what you use or go through a lot of, and consider whether the seasonal or other non bulk items can be purchased another day after having a chance to think about it and compare other retailers (think electronics, travel, auto, etc). You may need scissors, but do you need a pack of 16 in different sizes and for cutting different things? An actual question I had to ask myself at Costco once. At the time the answer was no, and the better option was to just buy one somewhere else.
Slight FYI double read the tickets and infomation with the rangitkei free range chicken, at 1:38 it's 2 for 1 (2x 1.5kg) just below it says $7 each for bostocks chicken pak n save has 500grams (in photo, while Costco is 27.99 for 1.7kg that's three times the amount in each package. )
At the end of the day, it is only cheaper if you live close to the Costco. The time and effort it would take to go there if you live on the other side of Auckland; not to mention 'fuel cost' as well. The government should definitely open up another couple more Costcos around the city and country!
Hi Billy, it definitely depends on numerous factors. Mindful of course that the fuel out there is cheaper too, so if you fill a full tank you'll be heavily subsidising the fuel cost to get out there. Hopefully as this is their first store, they'll have more coming to market over the coming years. This kind of business model is difficult with just one store as they need economies of scale to be viable. Thanks for watching!
Sounds good if you live close and have the budget to hand over large amounts of money all at once (to get the bulk-buy discount). Unfortunately that means Costco isn't for everyone but hopefully their existence will push other supermarkets to look at their own prices a bit.
I’ve been a few times now… definitely 10-12% cheaper on items I purchased - but just like your comparison some items don’t have a saving so you have to know your prices….
the more competition that enters the market the more the prices will reduce between costco, pak n save, countdown and new world would be great to see some more competitors enter the market even if they only open 1 store per major city it will eventually make a huge difference i mean look at the likes of when kmart started to compete with the warehouse and the price reductions that the warehouse made and a store like ikea would again make a huge difference to furniture prices things like dining room tables are ridiculously expensive for 5 pieces of wood and about 20 screws nz needs more competition
Hey Brent are you able to do a comparison 3 months later to see if these deals were just that " deals" also if you do can you also compare chocolate etc prices
Good video Brent, but some of the comparisons aren't fully true. Meat in particular see large rebates on short-dated items. Buying those rebated items sees significant savings on meat, bringing the real per kg price down from their listed price. Also comparing 'Value' brand cheese to a premium brand at Costco, just isn't like for like. Minor quibbles, cos otherwise a great comparison. I for one will be changing how I shop to take advantage of the bulk savings.
Hey Matt, looks like you found my channel! Yeah it's always tough to make comparisons between different brands/pack sizes/quality/promotions etc. Tried to take the approach of people looking to do their entire shop, therefore buying the cheapest items on offer in the case of cheese, and standard pricing as I wasn't sure whether the instant rebates were launch specials (as nearly all meat items had this) or are a standard feature. My freezer is full of food now, certainly won't be needing to go back there for a while! Hope you're doing well man!
Really enjoyed this video. I’ve found you have to be real careful at Costco and already have a print out of the cost per unit elsewhere. As a Gilmours and warehouse shopper their are many things you can find cheaper than at Costco, but again some really good bargains at Costco.
@@BrentColeman I doubt they would have made a deal with telcos to do this on purpose, it's just that wireless signals can't go through a warehouse style of shelving, too many barriers that weaken the signal. I work at a small warehouse and need access points all over the place because of this. It's just science.
At last a proper comparison of real products ( giant teddies, coffins & flat screens aren't on my regular shop list). For myself quick ponder on the "savings" i'd prob save $20 a month, then have to build in the $60 card cost sooo thats 3months savings to break even before i'm actually starting to save anything. Then there's the petrol to go there 15-20km each way - BUT can off set that by the petrol savings of the card sooo thats +/- & the fact its "an outing". I think if you have a large family etc & live in Massey area its perfect. Do you have to have the card to even get in the door or can you just go for a look round?
Hi Norman, thanks for the kind comments! Unfortunately they check the cards before even entering. If you know someone that has a card, they can take up to 2 people as their guest. Definitely agree it is best for large families who live nearby, Westgate was an interesting choice as the area is still yet to fully mature and the house sizes are pretty small out these ways. Thanks for watching!
I always air on the side of caution with cheaper meat prices , can put a lot of water in meat plus when it comes to country of origin you have to be really careful when buying frozen meat.. how do you buy a frozen pork shoulder made from local and imported ingredients ?
The issue I have with these comparisons are that it’s just about food and comparing to the duopoly - completely forgetting that Costco offer products outside of grocery that people are likely to purchase when visiting the store. It isn’t a supermarket, it’s a wholesale box store.
With regards to the toilet paper, Pam’s is only 180 sheets per roll while Kirkland is 270 sheets per roll, therefore it would work out cheaper at Costco. The sheet size is also bigger than Pam’s so likely to use less with Kirkland.
Hi Damara, I accounted for the difference in sheet count as it says in the title but didn't know about the different size of each sheet. Interesting to know!
Anyone know how their online shopping is? What's available? Everything from coffins to produce and meat? Or only simple things?? Want to visit it but that's a six hour drive... 😑So wanna know how their online store is 😊
We've got our online membership and we're ready to head for our first visit. We have been members overseas for years so it's a bit different for us. We are used to buying in bulk and having healthier options cheaper by ding so but until now that hasn't existed in NZ for us. The Costco organics range and healthy options or the biggest cost savers. I think the point I would make is like us many people from outside of Auckland are actually traveling to Costco to shop as we have limited options for shopping and limited stock eg we have 2 smaller supermarkets being regional township but we are also a holiday destination so our population can jump from 33k to over 100k and much inbetween. Our stores are emptied often to bare shelves, being smaller they also cannot stock vast ranges either, they are also limited currently to less truck delivery top ups so again low stock. We intend to do a quarterly shop of basics from a list of what we use, plus our Christmas food shopping. I have been able to complete a 8 page price list from online sources so I know my price points comparison wise i.e Costco is not cheaper for butter or flour than The Warehouse with Market club deals but they kick butt with everyone on coconut oil and maple syrup.
It sounds like you're fully across where the prices sit! I was also amazed by how much cheaper Costco is, particularly as I am comparing with perhaps the cheapest Pak N Save in the country as it tries to compete. Hopefully Costco bring higher standards to the industry around pricing, pushing the incumbents to return their pricing to more reasonable levels. Thanks for watching!
Don't know if your costco in NZ has fuel attached to it but that's where I earn back my membership the most in Newcastle, AU - fuel is often 15-30 cents a litre cheaper than the surrounding petrol stations
Hi Brandon, luckily we do have the fuel station here and it is the cheapest in the area, unfortunately not by as much as you mention! Thanks for watching!
On the off chance you do know, what are prices on more east asian goods such as chili oil, perhaps chinese vegetables, dried noodles, instant noodles, kewpie mayo, and other asian snacks and items etc.etc and how do they compare with asian grocers? Also prices dried meats like beef jerky, biltong, or bier sticks? I have a craving for those but theyre always so expensive
I didn’t see a lot of these when I visited. Kewpie Mayo and Beef Jerky I’ve mentioned in my part 2 video on my channel, as well as kikkoman soy sauce. I do recall seeing Haidilao Tomato soup mix but can’t recall any others sorry! Thanks for watching!
Problem with this is you are not measuring it correctly. Selling in Bulk will always be cheaper. Look at the meat for example. You are just looking at $/Kg and not taking into account the package size. Costco is selling Mince for example very cheap but that is a 3Kg package compared to the 500g package you can buy at Pack N Save. Should Pack N Save also start selling in bulk then they would be able to sell at the same price. Same goes for most food in Costco.....You need to buy in bulk to save, Costco is good for big households or for the reseller. Small families would find Pack n Save the cheaper option overall.
Hi Leon, yes that’s correct. No comparison will ever be perfect but this video is just meant as a rough gauge for people to come to their own conclusions whether it works for them
Kiwis have enough of costly food and look forward to more Costco stores around. Haven't been there simply because Westgate is an hour away from South Auckland which is a geographic obstacle.
Great comparison. Please do a another in 6 months time. We were excited for costco here in Perth, WA, but we have now dropped our membership because it just wasn't worth it a couple of years on.
As I will repost this is a fantastic comparison video very in deapth what most people needed as all I have seen is complaint about how it's not cheaper when that's not the case at all
Thanks for watching and sharing kind words! I guess seeing the huge price tags and size of products definitely puts a lot of people off, and for some products such as Tartare Sauce for example buying a litre is going to be very hard to get through, so waste then becomes a cost consideration too
Thanks Brent this is very helpful. I’m a one person household in a regional holiday town so have issues described by others. Reduced choices empty shelves in summer etc. Can you please check out their organic range for products such as nuts, chia seeds, almond flour and cacao. Many thanks.
I shopped in costco Mexico..(I bought 5 Kg blocks of Anchor butter and hummus which was hard to get outside) the enormous amounts you need to buy to "save" can be a problem if you don't have a lot of storage space and a ravenous family. Also products seem to disappear for months and then reappear when the container comes . The general rule is larger packet sizes are cheaper - so it's not an Apples to Apples comparison really. Is it just an introductory salvo to change buying habits before the prices rise? And the US dollar rise is bound to have an impact. Time will tell.
Hi Adrian, definitely agree. For those that already buy in bulk from regular supermarkets they will see an overall benefit, however if you consume small quantities of perishable items the store won't be as useful. Thanks for watching
There are a few rumours going around of them scouting more locations. There were murmurs a couple months back about a possible site in Rolleston but can't say for sure at this stage. Given the success of Westgate and the need for economies of scale, I'm sure they're already planning their next store! www.stuff.co.nz/business/128895287/costcos-south-island-expansion-could-just-be-speculation
Hi Myra, we’re yet to see how they manage their pricing, but I’d expect they’d work similar to pak n save by discounting the short dated items and working with suppliers on promo discounts. Thanks for watching!
Haha, I have to keep pointing out to people comparing the mayo that they are comparing per g to per ml, Costco is selling the 1.9L jar whereas the supermarket ones are 405g. 1.9L on Amazon Aus it weighs 1.77kg including the container.
@@BrentColeman It's also worth noting that the Costco Bestfoods mayo is the more expensive cage free egg version. Pak'n'Save charges 1.67 per 100ml - Costco is 54% cheaper
Not sure about being competitive with only one store miles away from most Aucklanders. It'll also be interesting to see how many people renew their membership next year.
If by weight it’s cheaper than the one close by, it’ll be even better compared to the others. People shop at their own local store and will know their own local prices. Thanks for watching
I can understand the unit price comparison but it would have been good if you had highlighted the pack size that you have to buy at Costco to get that unit price.
@@BrentColeman not all of them have the price tag photos and not all of them mention the amount per pack that you have to buy to get that cheaper unit price. I agree that Costco is a lot cheaper per ml or kg or item, but it bears reminding people that you have to buy multipacks or many kgs to get that cheaper unit price. I personally can't afford to buy $85 worth of OralB brush heads in one go.
Have you been to Costco yet? What's your thoughts?
Went yesterday after waiting for the craze to settle down. Went in with a game plan focussed on meat and we were not disappointed.
With the rebates on mince & chicken we ended up saving over $100 .
Bulk buying meat and deep freezing is our game and we LOVE it!
Costco says they keep their prices low. Idk why people think it’s a discount retailer.
Comparison with warehouse and kmart for household goods? I recall visiting costco in aussie and they sold TVs, flatpacks and what not. BTW good video. Now subbed.
Costco is another step down on the ladder for NZ.
Following the American consumerism is certain doom for NZ.
NZ used to be so different 30 years ago - it seems the internet lobotomised half of the population in that time.
@@badchefi keep off another American import. It’s called TH-cam and it’s a step down for New Zealand society.
I’m from NZ but currently in Ireland. I was surprised at the savings here compared to NZ because of competition ( Lidl, Tesco, Super Value, Aldi, Dunnes, Marks & Spensers) Kiwis should support new players because the two big boys have ripped us off for years and claimed to be just scratching a living.
Absolutely agree Mark - it's great to see more competition in the market because the current prices we pay are absurd. Thanks for watching!
We let them rip us off as we Kiwis are napping at the helm.
Tbh it’s pretty piss poor that successive governments in NZ hasn’t addressed this
This is the best comparison video so far. For me being a one person household and an hours drive away this wouldn't be a viable option on savings but maybe on seeing what different items are available. It's a shame that you can't have a one off look to see if it's worth the membership fee. Thank you for doing this price comparison for us.
Hi Amy, I absolutely agree, allowing people in just to have a look around would make people much more comfortable paying the $60 for the card. Hopefully they do something like this in the future. If you know someone with a card, I was told that Costco will allow the cardholder to bring in 2 guests with them, however the cardholder will need to pay for the entire bill. I'm a one-person household too, with the savings on fuel and hoarding lots of chicken I've made good use of it so far, but to breakeven on the card you'll need to spend a fair bit given the cost of fuel to drive there too. Thanks for watching, and the kind words!
In the US, we find a friend or relative to shop with lol. Best categories for deals are staples: laundry detergent, paper towels, batteries, toothpaste. Meat, bulk food that you know you run through, cheap alcohol and wine, cheese, and inexpensive clothes
@@kansasistheman9289 that makes a lot of sense to go for an initial look with a friend who is a member. Do you mainly shop for food at Costco or do you go to different stores based on price?
EXACLTY - i assumed you could until i asked a friend whom has a membership and he kindly offered to take me so i can do that sometime soon 😊
@@TangerineTulip enjoy your trip to Costco. X
This is a good comparison! I definitely agree that Costco is cheaper than Paknsave! It’s a shame everything comes in bulk. To buy veggies in Auckland, I def recommend to go to markets during the weekend. Most of the produce is half price than any supermarket
Kiwi based in AU - Costco is a hit and miss - you have to know how much the items cost outside of Costco to determine if you are getting value from Costco purchases. Additionally you have to finish items before they spoil given they have a short shelf life.
Hi Rajeev, spot on! I hope this video helps others doing this comparison as it’s certainly needed as a starting point to work out if it’s cheaper for them and their particular situation. Thanks for watching!
Yeah I don't see the value at all.
It's great when people put in the effort to create content like this, great work!
Thanks Ben!
Brent’s videos are incredibly informative and helpful! Love it bro!!
I firmly believe Costco is here not only for better prices, but to change the New Zealand consumer behaviour, from weekly to monthly (or more) purchases.
Costco uses a strong pricing strategy.
On the top of that, they could be willing to lose some money in the introduction stage, and competitor cannot beat that.
My concern is, all the war-prices lead to collusion...I hope this will not be the case, for the sake of the consumers and the market.
Excellent video!.
Hi Juan, I too hope the prices are here to stay and aren't temporary. I have faith that the amount of collusion is only going to decrease as competition in NZ increases. If not 'collusion', the lack of competition is what's really plaguing the market right now. Thanks for watching!
Kiwi in Canada here. This was a very interesting watch, Brent. Glad to see Costco’s entrance to the NZ market looks successful and likely will make a welcome change to the NZ retail landscape. Where I live, there are two or three Costco’s to choose from, including an American one just over the border in Bellingham. We are spoiled for choice. I was pretty much shocked at the cost of lotions and Dove soap during your video. I have sensitive skin issues and can see I would spend a small fortune back home now - however, one fine day, will return :))
Do u think which is the best country to live ? Canada or NZ?? Earnings ,savings,living cost..thank you.
What an excellently put together and executed, informative and straight to the point video! I wish I lived in Auckland to get those pak n save prices even, it’s a couple of $ more expensive for somethings in the SI!
Thanks for the kind words Lydia! Glad you enjoyed it!
Tell me about it, I live in Timaru - we pay quite a bit more than some of the things in this video, especially meat, fruit, and vegetables
The only items I would consider a bargain would be hearing aids and prescription glasses, and maybe some big box items. Again single and retired, but a shopping group of 6 - 8 friends might work for some products.
Hi Peter, you're absolutely right. I've heard the hearing aids and glasses are significantly cheaper at Costco but haven't seen the prices myself. Shopping in groups definitely makes sense, it also means you may be able to split the cost of the membership card (having one designated shopper) which is always great. Loading the freezer is another good idea for the meats. Thanks for watching!
Hi Peter, I went in today and they have hearing aids listed at prices from $2,000 to $4,000. These are rechargeable. In the store they also have branded frames, though I am not sure on the pricing for those.
Went to Costco yesterday then ran a price comparison when we got home. Managed to compare 14 items using current prices at PNS, CD and NW and if I'd bought the cheapest item from these, it still worked out $68.59 cheaper at Costco. Some items I couldn't compare as the other retailers don't stock anything comparable. Best buys would be shampoo, nuts, ground beef mince, herbs and spices (oh and Babybel cheese - massive savings on those!). I wouldn't bother with the fruit and veg at Costco as the savings are negligible, but the quality was great though.
Couldn’t agree more Shirley! You’ve got it right, huge savings in some of those pantry items, but produce is lacking at this point. Glad you enjoyed the video and thanks for sharing your price comparisons!
Costco is only getting started testing the market if it’s anything like the ones I been to in USA in time it will make short work of all the competition. They not even getting started yet .
@@clinth6432 Costco have been in Australia for ages and it hasn't really changed anything, they only have a handful of stores, meanwhile Coles and Woolies are still everywhere you look.
It would be nice if Costco opened a branch in central Auckland and in South Auckland!!!😔😔😔
Hi Mitchell, definitely agree! Westgate was an interesting choice as the surrounding area has yet to fully mature and won't for many years. South Auckland I would think is next, given the larger household sizes, multi-generational homes, and proximity to Hamilton. With a launch like they've had, I'm sure it's not far away. Thanks for watching!
Auckland ain't the only city in nz
@@ProJoker ..hahahalol..ok How about having Costco in Wellington, Christchurch and Dunedin?!?!.... Happy now?😌
At least you have it in Auckland. I would have to catch a flight to get to Costco.
@@jonathanyt5560 says the jaffas who live there
Thank you so much for this video. Really helpful as I was considering Costco as a change from maybe normal/local Pak n Save. Thank you
Thanks for the kind words! I am in this situation now too as I live locally. Supermarkets continue to offer a much broader number of items, as Costco has a narrow range of goods but stock a much greater amount of it. The next moves from the supermarkets to compete will be interesting as they can't on price, but perhaps a push to 'shop local' and enhancing their local kiwi goods selection. While Costco work only with brands at scale, supermarkets can work with their communities to build successful local brands, which they already do, but building on this would be great to see.
For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life
Excellent video and analysis of cost comparisons.
I'm a kiwi who lives in Utah. The largest Costco in the whole world is here in downtown Salt Lake City. I think it's almost twice the size of the Auckland location. I'd love to stroll around the new one in NZ to see what they have! Enjoy!
I guess the big difference is that the unit size is bigger at Costco, so while it's cheaper per kilo, you still pay more because you are buying larger units. But for essentials or staples, it's great. I get my laundry and dish detergents, toilet paper, milk powder, rice etc etc from Costco. Anything I definitely use and won't perish. And a chicken.
This is super awesome for nz! More competition will help drive down the insane prices. Now let's hope we get more locations across nz to really make an impact - how about welly!!
Really good review! I have been twice and although its difficult to properly assess because of the difference in quantity being sold..and also because I cant remember the prices in pac n save....it was clear that generally on most of the items you are paying less. Great store! I definitely recommend we all shop a little differently and bulk buy on pantry items for sure. Thanks again.
Thanks for watching Bobby!
I go to Costco for many certain items, especially non-perishables. The Kirkland brand is really high quality, which is hard to beat, especially when you're deciding on buying something that will last a long time, instead of buying something initially cheaper but you tend to replace it too often.
Thanks for watching!
I've been twice now, both shops have been pretty costly. Good to see different products not available in the other NZ supermarkets.
Thanks for doing this comparison, very helpful!
it would be interesting to see the same comparison in three months time.
My experience with Costco in Australia is that it's no cheaper than anywhere else - I used to buy toilet rolls at Costco until I realised that I could get them for the same price at Aldi.
incidentally, if I had to pick between Aldi and Pak'nSave, I'd take Pak'nSave any day. They operate at a similar price point, bit the limited product range at Aldi means that you make a second trip to Coles or Woolworths anyway to get the items that Aldi doesn't stock.
Definitely agree Barry, will be interesting to see how prices change going forwards. I saw a lot of the instant rebates have already been removed from the meat section which is a shame as there were some great bargains! Thanks for watching!
Yes , hope the local supermarkets in NZ drop there pricing now to be competitive, pity they been ripping us off for so long.
Very true Aldi product range isn't great and what they have is from random suppliers so not always good but they create competition in the market.
What is needed here is for the government to grow a pair and pull out of international trade deals that only benefit major wholesalers NOT the shoppers here or growers and producers of some of the best produce in the world but stops growers even selling B grade fruit and veg at markets, B grade means spots or minor imperfections.
Greed of a few is not a reason to be locked into trade deals...
If these people cant sell the best produce in the world without dodgy trade agreements then they shouldn't be doing what they are doing. Lazy or useless you decide...
Why are we paying international prices for our own produce when NO shipping is involved worse why can you regularly buy NZ produce in Australia cheaper than here ??? how does that work ?
People support your local fruit and veg markets also local Butchers need support so they can start to reduce their prices. Although I doubt you find water in your meat to make it heavier at your local Butcher...
Don't believe me get a pork chop from a home kill and one from the supermarket fry them it will speak for itself...
After coming home after 12 years overseas I still can't believe what Im seeing here.
sounds like we need Aldi too and Lidl :D one can dream. as they say one is a monopoly and duopoly charges monopoly prices but share profit, only with 3 or more players then we have competition
@@alliao82 what we need is government that follows through on promises to crack down on anti competitive behaviour of the duopoly...
Consecutive governments have threatened to put a stop to this and yet still NO action.
Great comparisons, thank you. Would you do one on their electronics say verses Noel lemmings? We are watching from afar. Not able to get there yet.
Thanks so much for this video I'm contemplating going to Costco but live 2 hours away so it's awesome to see a proper price comparison.
Glad it was helpful!
Awesome video. Well done, thank you for this information
Really useful video , great format - to the point and great variety
Thanks! Glad you enjoyed it!
Amazing video! Definitely helps put a lot of the prices in perspective :)
As a Massey resident the fuel prices basically pays for the cost of the membership so these savings are really just a bonus.
I have a small family but since you can take two guests per card I can definitely see myself going in with friends, maybe when its less busy... Way too many people right now.
Thanks for the kind words, glad you enjoyed the video! I live around Massey too, and the fuel prices are very decent ~$2.42 at the moment for 91. Thanks for watching!
awesome review Brent!Thank you.Its not just the price difference and costco are head and shoulders below our generic supermarkets in NZ. For me its also about how we as customers to Pns and NW have been treated over the years...Patronised by so called low pricing which isn't the truth and you have clearly shown this..Working in the retail manufacturing /market as I have, my experience of our supermarkets deals/low pricing is because they lever the low pricing through manufacturers supplying and selling a product at well below there own preferred and sustainable profit margins.Also a thing to bear in mind, you can be a supplier but there is very rarely a supply contract which means all the risk on the success or failure of a product (which includes set up and packaging investment is on the manufacturer, not the retailer!
You're absolutely right Henrik! Supermarkets have had it really good for many years, and it's good to finally have a new entrant that turns the business model on its head and we can see just how much fat has been built into supermarket pricing. It's no wonder the government found them to be making >$1 million a day in excess profits. Thanks for watching!
For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life
Thanks Brent extremely interesting on price differences looking forward to the next one
Thanks for watching Judy!
Brent, you do a good job! I can't believe the prices in NZL. It's so discouraging to think of moving to your beautiful country. INCREDIBLY, we spend so much less on nearly everything in Panama!
Hi Paolo, thanks for watching! We absolutely agree the price of nearly everything here is very expensive. Our geographic distance, lack of competition, and high company overheads make it expensive to live here. Fortunately we're now seeing many well-priced global brands entering the market and bringing more competition, such as H&M, Costco, IKEA (2024-onwards), among others. Thanks for watching!
Thank you for the interesting comparison. I’ve been curious about Costco since I first heard we were getting one. Unfortunately, I live in the CBD and work on the shore so by the time I drive out of my way to Costco, I’m probably losing money on petrol.
I also heard you needed a Costco card to shop or use their petrol which is $60 annually.
Thank you for feeding my curiosity and saving me a drive to Westgate 😊
Fantastic video Brent!
Thanks for the kind words Josh, glad you enjoyed it!
Great video and very useful $/weight comparison.
However, it fails to account for major inconveniences which add abstract value:
1) commuting to far end of Auckland and cost of fuel spent. (not viable for most of Auckland)
2) Cost of membership (which may be insignificant if you go enough times an year but break even number of visit may need to be calculated)
3) Long queues and time spent.
4) Possible wastage by being forced to buy in bulk and having to invest in extra storage: pantry/freezers.
5) Stress/anxiety of too much planning required.
Still I am very happy that tyrannical reign of Woolworths and Foodstuff Group is being challenged.
Absolutely correct, these factors will need to be considered by people when they visit.
If you got an LPG vehicle the cost of commuting would be much cheaper. You can sort of hack out of membership by being added as an additional cardholder from a friend (just need to show one bill with you at the same address (do a mobile bill)), or if they buy you Costco gift cards. Even though some things are bulk, the price is still so much cheaper than other stores that you still save money even if you throw some of it out.
great vid thanks I'll show this to my mum and dad
Hey Brent, great work on this and thanks for your effort.
Few things I would like to point out, NZ Supermarket model is based on high/low, most popular products are on promotion 26 weeks of the year. Is PNS Westgate pricing promotional or the normal shelf price that you're comparing to? Ideally, you want to compare the best price or average visible price of each other due to the nature of each business model being different (NZ supermarket highly promotional vs Costco are not). Each PNS stores have different pricing therefore your title is slightly misleading as westgate PNS cant be used to represent all PNS stores.
Thank you very much Brent, here is a lot of value. It took some good efforts to make this, Did you do it all alone? How much time did it take you to make this video?
Hi Dima, yes it’s just me! Perhaps 5hrs all up from collecting the info, filming, editing and posting. Thanks for watching!
The NZ supermarkets have been ripping us, glad this new crowd is here ,so the others can lower there prices.
I'd love to see a comparison based on the 100 most purchased items there were some real headscratchers in there. Also I'd be curious to see this done at least every three months, I suspect part of the reason things are so much cheaper are just a hook to draw customers in and that the real prices of these items will be higher once they are established in the NZ market and have to supply their goods to smaller retailers. I would also be curious to know how much that this in theory saves per week what you really need is data that is not just a one off otherwise there is no scientific merit. Is the club price worth it? The bulk buying aspect makes it work for some and not for others.
Thanks for your sharing. Very informative.
Thanks Gary, glad you enjoyed it!
Can you do the pet stuff idle? I saw some decent priced dog food at Costco but I’m not familiar with those brands! Didn’t want to upset my pups tummy 😂 awesome content btw
Hi Matilda, I’ll add this to my list for next time I go! I recall the brands weren’t the usual ones sold by supermarkets, but I’ll take a closer look! Thanks for watching!
This is really interesting. Thanks for sharing
When pams launched that new 4 pack of tp pak n save wainoni (maybe everywhere else) stopped selling all the different varieties of hand paper towels. You used to be able to get 2 packs of single ply and triple ply hand towels now just 4 packs of 2 ply. So I think those cheap 4 packs of 3ply tp are just a slightly modified version of their 3ply hand towel line
I was born and raised in the US so grew up going to Costco. I am a Kiwi as well now and have lived here for over a decade. Everytime someone asks me what I miss about the states I include Costco on the list. Even in the states it isn't always cheaper when it comes to some things, which I think is common with most stores, bulk, grocery, or otherwise. However when they have a deal it is amazing. Their eye, hearing, and other care is cheaper in some states and I hope it will be here as well. I always found that meats, pantry items, alcohol, and vitamins and toiletries were a great deal at Costco. As far as the cost of bulk buying it is something to consider. That is why the bring two guest option is awesome. If bulk buying is something you cant always afford, often you will have a friend who will bring you in as a guest for those cant miss savings. I don't know if they will do this here, but you get magazines and other monthly updates on their specials in the mail and online they list their prices so you can do comparisons. The produce and fridge section will always be hit and miss price wise simply due to their shelf life, though this could be different for bigger families or if shopping for a get together. When it comes to toys, decorations, furniture, etc the deals can be amazing depending on the brand and or quality you are looking for. I have found amazing deals over the years on travel, auto, clothing, etc. I believe it will be easier to price compare when their online portion of the store is up and running. Not sure what their return policy is here but in the states it is outstanding as are the gas prices. The big trap with Costco is impulse buying. Most of their stores don't have great cell reception and the good deal on a bulk buy can be tempting. The best advise I have is know your budget, think about what you use or go through a lot of, and consider whether the seasonal or other non bulk items can be purchased another day after having a chance to think about it and compare other retailers (think electronics, travel, auto, etc). You may need scissors, but do you need a pack of 16 in different sizes and for cutting different things? An actual question I had to ask myself at Costco once. At the time the answer was no, and the better option was to just buy one somewhere else.
Thanks for sharing Katerina, definitely agree with everything you've mentioned! Thanks for watching!
Slight FYI double read the tickets and infomation
with the rangitkei free range chicken, at 1:38 it's 2 for 1 (2x 1.5kg) just below it says $7 each
for bostocks chicken pak n save has 500grams (in photo, while Costco is 27.99 for 1.7kg that's three times the amount in each package. )
At the end of the day, it is only cheaper if you live close to the Costco. The time and effort it would take to go there if you live on the other side of Auckland; not to mention 'fuel cost' as well. The government should definitely open up another couple more Costcos around the city and country!
The government doesn’t set up Costcos.
Hi Billy, it definitely depends on numerous factors. Mindful of course that the fuel out there is cheaper too, so if you fill a full tank you'll be heavily subsidising the fuel cost to get out there. Hopefully as this is their first store, they'll have more coming to market over the coming years. This kind of business model is difficult with just one store as they need economies of scale to be viable. Thanks for watching!
Sounds good if you live close and have the budget to hand over large amounts of money all at once (to get the bulk-buy discount). Unfortunately that means Costco isn't for everyone but hopefully their existence will push other supermarkets to look at their own prices a bit.
Agree completely. Driving there is a big cost, and to benefit you’ll need to spend a fair bit, which won’t suit everyone.
I’ve been a few times now… definitely 10-12% cheaper on items I purchased - but just like your comparison some items don’t have a saving so you have to know your prices….
the more competition that enters the market the more the prices will reduce between costco, pak n save, countdown and new world would be great to see some more competitors enter the market even if they only open 1 store per major city it will eventually make a huge difference i mean look at the likes of when kmart started to compete with the warehouse and the price reductions that the warehouse made and a store like ikea would again make a huge difference to furniture prices things like dining room tables are ridiculously expensive for 5 pieces of wood and about 20 screws nz needs more competition
Hey Brent are you able to do a comparison 3 months later to see if these deals were just that " deals" also if you do can you also compare chocolate etc prices
It's about time I did another one! I drove past earlier today and the queues still stretch out to the motorway!
Good video Brent, but some of the comparisons aren't fully true. Meat in particular see large rebates on short-dated items. Buying those rebated items sees significant savings on meat, bringing the real per kg price down from their listed price. Also comparing 'Value' brand cheese to a premium brand at Costco, just isn't like for like. Minor quibbles, cos otherwise a great comparison. I for one will be changing how I shop to take advantage of the bulk savings.
Hey Matt, looks like you found my channel! Yeah it's always tough to make comparisons between different brands/pack sizes/quality/promotions etc. Tried to take the approach of people looking to do their entire shop, therefore buying the cheapest items on offer in the case of cheese, and standard pricing as I wasn't sure whether the instant rebates were launch specials (as nearly all meat items had this) or are a standard feature. My freezer is full of food now, certainly won't be needing to go back there for a while! Hope you're doing well man!
Really enjoyed this video.
I’ve found you have to be real careful at Costco and already have a print out of the cost per unit elsewhere.
As a Gilmours and warehouse shopper their are many things you can find cheaper than at Costco, but again some really good bargains at Costco.
Haha definitely, and the fact they have terrible cellphone reception in there which prevents doing the maths in store!
@@BrentColeman I doubt they would have made a deal with telcos to do this on purpose, it's just that wireless signals can't go through a warehouse style of shelving, too many barriers that weaken the signal. I work at a small warehouse and need access points all over the place because of this. It's just science.
@@adamknight5089 definitely, I’m sure it’s a combination of factors. The sheer amount of people loading the network would also be at play
great vid mate
Can you compare the warehouse and Costco for the pantry section?
Hey Brent, shot for the video my bro. I appreciate it.
Thanks Cam glad you enjoyed it
At last a proper comparison of real products ( giant teddies, coffins & flat screens aren't on my regular shop list). For myself quick ponder on the "savings" i'd prob save $20 a month, then have to build in the $60 card cost sooo thats 3months savings to break even before i'm actually starting to save anything. Then there's the petrol to go there 15-20km each way - BUT can off set that by the petrol savings of the card sooo thats +/- & the fact its "an outing". I think if you have a large family etc & live in Massey area its perfect. Do you have to have the card to even get in the door or can you just go for a look round?
Hi Norman, thanks for the kind comments! Unfortunately they check the cards before even entering. If you know someone that has a card, they can take up to 2 people as their guest. Definitely agree it is best for large families who live nearby, Westgate was an interesting choice as the area is still yet to fully mature and the house sizes are pretty small out these ways. Thanks for watching!
going by some his prices you get your $60 back in first shop where do get 3 months to break even from
super helpful. Would you be able to do items in the baby section? ie. food, formula, nappies, wipes, etc 😊
Hi Gloria, I’ll note these down for the next time I go down there. Thanks for watching!
For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life
@@BrentColeman thaaaank you! much appreciated xx
price per kilo or per 100 is cheaper, but Costco has them all in bigger and giant quantities
U should also consider the membership fee as well
I always air on the side of caution with cheaper meat prices , can put a lot of water in meat plus when it comes to country of origin you have to be really careful when buying frozen meat.. how do you buy a frozen pork shoulder made from local and imported ingredients ?
Thanks for the comparison bro!
Cheers Joseph, glad you enjoyed it!
The issue I have with these comparisons are that it’s just about food and comparing to the duopoly - completely forgetting that Costco offer products outside of grocery that people are likely to purchase when visiting the store.
It isn’t a supermarket, it’s a wholesale box store.
Can’t wait to have a Costco here in Christchurch
Countdown and new world have been slowly raising their prices over the years. I hope this new competition stamps out those two.
Whoa. Costco in NZ? Do they also have the hotdogs for $1.50 USD?
Even better, $1.99 NZD! Absolute bargain! Thanks for watching!
With regards to the toilet paper, Pam’s is only 180 sheets per roll while Kirkland is 270 sheets per roll, therefore it would work out cheaper at Costco. The sheet size is also bigger than Pam’s so likely to use less with Kirkland.
Hi Damara, I accounted for the difference in sheet count as it says in the title but didn't know about the different size of each sheet. Interesting to know!
Dam, those price comparison are significant.
Anyone know how their online shopping is? What's available? Everything from coffins to produce and meat? Or only simple things?? Want to visit it but that's a six hour drive... 😑So wanna know how their online store is 😊
Unfortunately they don't have online shopping yet. Hopefully this is something they look to bring to NZ in the future! Thanks for watching!
We've got our online membership and we're ready to head for our first visit. We have been members overseas for years so it's a bit different for us.
We are used to buying in bulk and having healthier options cheaper by ding so but until now that hasn't existed in NZ for us. The Costco organics range and healthy options or the biggest cost savers.
I think the point I would make is like us many people from outside of Auckland are actually traveling to Costco to shop as we have limited options for shopping and limited stock eg we have 2 smaller supermarkets being regional township but we are also a holiday destination so our population can jump from 33k to over 100k and much inbetween. Our stores are emptied often to bare shelves, being smaller they also cannot stock vast ranges either, they are also limited currently to less truck delivery top ups so again low stock.
We intend to do a quarterly shop of basics from a list of what we use, plus our Christmas food shopping. I have been able to complete a 8 page price list from online sources so I know my price points comparison wise i.e Costco is not cheaper for butter or flour than The Warehouse with Market club deals but they kick butt with everyone on coconut oil and maple syrup.
It sounds like you're fully across where the prices sit! I was also amazed by how much cheaper Costco is, particularly as I am comparing with perhaps the cheapest Pak N Save in the country as it tries to compete. Hopefully Costco bring higher standards to the industry around pricing, pushing the incumbents to return their pricing to more reasonable levels. Thanks for watching!
For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life
Don't know if your costco in NZ has fuel attached to it but that's where I earn back my membership the most in Newcastle, AU - fuel is often 15-30 cents a litre cheaper than the surrounding petrol stations
Hi Brandon, luckily we do have the fuel station here and it is the cheapest in the area, unfortunately not by as much as you mention! Thanks for watching!
Thanks for the comparisons. Costco seems to have a leg up. Will go get a card now. 👍
Thanks for watching!
On the off chance you do know, what are prices on more east asian goods such as chili oil, perhaps chinese vegetables, dried noodles, instant noodles, kewpie mayo, and other asian snacks and items etc.etc
and how do they compare with asian grocers?
Also prices dried meats like beef jerky, biltong, or bier sticks? I have a craving for those but theyre always so expensive
I didn’t see a lot of these when I visited. Kewpie Mayo and Beef Jerky I’ve mentioned in my part 2 video on my channel, as well as kikkoman soy sauce. I do recall seeing Haidilao Tomato soup mix but can’t recall any others sorry! Thanks for watching!
Brilliant savings, even with the $60 Costco cover yearly cost you'd still be saving money. I hope the prices stay low in the years to come.
I've purchased quite a lot of designer brand clothes for crazy low prices, that one shop in itself would cover the membership.
I have been to Costco. Many times.
Best regards from Canada! 😁
Problem with this is you are not measuring it correctly. Selling in Bulk will always be cheaper. Look at the meat for example. You are just looking at $/Kg and not taking into account the package size. Costco is selling Mince for example very cheap but that is a 3Kg package compared to the 500g package you can buy at Pack N Save. Should Pack N Save also start selling in bulk then they would be able to sell at the same price. Same goes for most food in Costco.....You need to buy in bulk to save, Costco is good for big households or for the reseller. Small families would find Pack n Save the cheaper option overall.
Hi Leon, yes that’s correct. No comparison will ever be perfect but this video is just meant as a rough gauge for people to come to their own conclusions whether it works for them
Kiwis have enough of costly food and look forward to more Costco stores around. Haven't been there simply because Westgate is an hour away from South Auckland which is a geographic obstacle.
Great comparison. Please do a another in 6 months time. We were excited for costco here in Perth, WA, but we have now dropped our membership because it just wasn't worth it a couple of years on.
I used to work at packnsave and was honestly nice when it opened bc it wasn't so busy🤣
Brent Coleman, nice to see you having some success :) Viral status
Haha thanks! Surprising how far it has spread! Hope you're doing well
As I will repost this is a fantastic comparison video very in deapth what most people needed as all I have seen is complaint about how it's not cheaper when that's not the case at all
Thanks for watching and sharing kind words! I guess seeing the huge price tags and size of products definitely puts a lot of people off, and for some products such as Tartare Sauce for example buying a litre is going to be very hard to get through, so waste then becomes a cost consideration too
We need more COSTCO branches, ASAP !!!!!
But is the beef NZ or grain feed aus like the scotch they had when they opened.
Thanks Brent this is very helpful. I’m a one person household in a regional holiday town so have issues described by others. Reduced choices empty shelves in summer etc. Can you please check out their organic range for products such as nuts, chia seeds, almond flour and cacao. Many thanks.
Hi Patty, will keep an eye out next time I go! Thanks for watching!
I shopped in costco Mexico..(I bought 5 Kg blocks of Anchor butter and hummus which was hard to get outside) the enormous amounts you need to buy to "save" can be a problem if you don't have a lot of storage space and a ravenous family. Also products seem to disappear for months and then reappear when the container comes . The general rule is larger packet sizes are cheaper - so it's not an Apples to Apples comparison really.
Is it just an introductory salvo to change buying habits before the prices rise? And the US dollar rise is bound to have an impact. Time will tell.
Hi Adrian, definitely agree. For those that already buy in bulk from regular supermarkets they will see an overall benefit, however if you consume small quantities of perishable items the store won't be as useful. Thanks for watching
Interesting comparison, thanks. Might be clearer with percentage differences though.
I would like you to do this in another month or two...
Hi Sue - I am curious too, hopefully the discounts are here to stay! Thanks for watching!
are they looking to build more stores in rest of Nz?
There are a few rumours going around of them scouting more locations. There were murmurs a couple months back about a possible site in Rolleston but can't say for sure at this stage. Given the success of Westgate and the need for economies of scale, I'm sure they're already planning their next store! www.stuff.co.nz/business/128895287/costcos-south-island-expansion-could-just-be-speculation
Should compare to the most expensive supermarket in NZ
Can you do the cost comparison for countdown and new world?
PaknSave is my favourite store for shopping absolutely 💯 Amen 🙏🙏
Probably better to compare it to Gilmores due to the bulk buying.
The other question is what are staff paid at pack n save vs Costco?
Not sure at Pak N Save but I did hear that Costco pays above minimum wage by a couple dollars
Don’t forget all Gilmores prices are GST exclusive . You’ll have to do the maths and add that on top
But are prices at Costco constant or are they changed week to week, like Pak n save.
Hi Myra, we’re yet to see how they manage their pricing, but I’d expect they’d work similar to pak n save by discounting the short dated items and working with suppliers on promo discounts. Thanks for watching!
Haha, I have to keep pointing out to people comparing the mayo that they are comparing per g to per ml, Costco is selling the 1.9L jar whereas the supermarket ones are 405g. 1.9L on Amazon Aus it weighs 1.77kg including the container.
Wow good spotting Arthur!
@@BrentColeman It's also worth noting that the Costco Bestfoods mayo is the more expensive cage free egg version. Pak'n'Save charges 1.67 per 100ml - Costco is 54% cheaper
you need to consider the price of membership too
Not sure about being competitive with only one store miles away from most Aucklanders. It'll also be interesting to see how many people renew their membership next year.
If by weight it’s cheaper than the one close by, it’ll be even better compared to the others. People shop at their own local store and will know their own local prices. Thanks for watching
needs to be a daily video like news channel....or may be a 24/7 full time live update.
amazing and very helpful!!! wow!!
Thanks for watching!
I can understand the unit price comparison but it would have been good if you had highlighted the pack size that you have to buy at Costco to get that unit price.
It’s in the price tag photos
@@BrentColeman not all of them have the price tag photos and not all of them mention the amount per pack that you have to buy to get that cheaper unit price. I agree that Costco is a lot cheaper per ml or kg or item, but it bears reminding people that you have to buy multipacks or many kgs to get that cheaper unit price. I personally can't afford to buy $85 worth of OralB brush heads in one go.
The winner is almond butter 800g for $12 at Costco compared to 275g for $9.49
In Christchurch still gotta shop at the SM but No longer buy the hoity toity items
A couple days ago 3L A2 milk was $0.97 at costco.
Wow good find!!