Who is an Indian - Shashi Tharoor | MBIFL 2020
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ต.ค. 2024
- Who is an Indian - Shashi Tharoor
Shashi Tharoor author, politician, and former international civil servant, Shashi Tharoor straddles several worlds of experience. Currently a third-term Lok Sabha MP representing the Thiruvananthapuram constituency and Chairman of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Information Technology and All India Professionals Congress, he has previously served as Chairman of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on External Affairs and as a Minister of State in the Government of India. He has also served as the Under-Secretary General of United Nations. Tharoor is an award-winning author of works of both fiction as well as non-fiction. He has written hundreds of articles, op-eds, and book reviews in a wide range of international publications including the New York Times and Washington Post. Hugely popular on social media platforms, Tharoor is an excellent orator too. His latest books include Why I am a Hindu, The Paradoxical Prime Minister and The Hindu Way. Tharoor in 2019 received the Sahitya Academy Award for his book 'An Era of Darkness' in a non-fiction category in English language.
----------------------------------------------------------
Connect with us @
Website: www.mbifl.com/
Facebook: mbifl
Instagram: / mbifl
Twitter: / mbifl2020
Official TH-cam Page of the Mathrubhumi International Festival Of Letters, #MBIFL. MBIFL is one of the largest and most polyphonic cultural events in God’s own country, Kerala.
Mathrubhumi International Festival of Letters will bring together international and Indian writers with sessions devoted to divergent topics, trends, ideas and genres ranging from fiction, poetry, nonfiction, politics, environment, travel, and cinema prominently.
MBIFL which takes place annually at the Kanakakunnu Palace, Trivandrum, intends to reflect the ineffable nature of the human condition offering incandescent possibilities of imagination and creativity.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The opinions, beliefs and viewpoints expressed by the speaker in this video are the speaker's own, and not of Mathrubhumi International Festival Of Letters 2020 or The Mathrubhumi Printing & Publishing Co. Ltd.
All Rights Reserved. Mathrubhumi.
We want to see you as PM of India🇮🇳....
Brilliant way of getting his points to his hearers with his simplicity of speech.
When will I see u becoming a pm of India?
First let him be president of Congress.
@@swatit9372 Comment of the month
We all want him to be indian prime minister but congress will never promote him to that possition simply since they want india to have a puppet
If the Congress party realise the realities pretty good it has to act . Foremost thing is choosing a bold and sincere leader with the calibre of Nehru.Why don't choose Dr.Sasi Tharur?
Intellectual par excellence... Always great listening to him
As always, I salute you Dr. Shashi Tharoor for always speaking the truth and nothing but the truth! Jai Hind!
He is such a great man delivering the very outstanding speech from their heart, I like him very much.. very love and blessings for him from my heart...
Hind means India, Hindu means Indian.....
I feel proud to be a citizen like a country where such kind of high calibre people is also a.citizen of my country, It's like "Birds of a feather flock together".
Hey Shashi Tharoor I know you have the potential to strengthen congress party..... there are good and intelligent people in your party..... please come together and make a strong party.....
*Make the same party strong
We don't need Congress party anymore, need BJP
We need a party who cares for people we don’t need a party who is misleading the nation on religion and not caring for the poor people of villages
Suresh P ankon se parda hata lo Bhai
PAKISTAN AND CHINA WILL NOT ALLOW YOU TO LIVE IN PEACE EVEN AFTER DOOMSDAY....
Shashi Tharoor , by all means,one of the most brilliant minded, intellectual and proud son of this country, having in-depth knowledge of history particularly on current issues is eligible to become the next prime minister of this great country. Our youth of this country should rally behind in one heart and mind to make this a reality. Obviously he has wide circle of friends across the political spectrum. Sure enough this country will scale greater heights under his able leadership.Congress party should make him a consensus Candidate forgetting all differences of cast , Creed , and region for the common good of all or greater glory of this country.
I disagree there. Shashi has a narrow political view inspite of his best education. He gives into muslim appeasement as a way of creating a political base.
He takes views that please his Party leadership.
വിവരം ഇല്ല.. അതാ
Respected sir, your idea and concepts are extremely good but the reality that persists is sth different. You are saying how our society is but the fact is that its not how it actually is.it should be how you say, and we should struggle to make it how you describe here, but in actual it isnt the way you are potraying.
If he bcom rd PM then we all wil sink.
I completely disagree. He is an aplogist for those who do not love india its culture etc. Clear in talks not in thougts. There are people with better linguistic anilities than him in every nook and corner. But he is was made as poster booy om english.
Dear Shashi,
Please stop gerrymandering about an Act which does nothing but confer on some unfortunate sections of minorities from Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan the citizenship of this great country. These minorities namely Hindus, Sikhs,Jains,Christians ,Parsees are being persecuted in the said countries. The eloquence of Shashi hides an intent to mislead the audience. Does the Act say that Indian citizenship shall now be determined on the basis of these religions. The argument that exclusion of Muslims renders the basis of this Act unconstitutional is also flawed. This Act has been passed based on the experience that most of those seeking citizenship are of said minorities in the said countries. People like Shashi must exercise restraint by not bringing in religion in criticizing a piece of legislation passed with the best of intent. I advise the people hearing him to read the Act. Every time they say something about the Government they bring in the argument that bulk of Indians are poor and illiterate and therefore can not produce the required documents. My question is : Will documents be asked only of Muslims and not Hindus? In the first place there's no question of documents for NRC because NRC is not yet made mandatory throughout India.
I don't understand Congress Party and the cronies who go about espousing the same line of argument. My friend Shashi would be well advised to be reminded that India is secular because the bulk of its population is Hindus.
👌👌👌👌👍👍👍 right✔
if he is become Prime Minister of India.. we blessed ♥
Party change karna padega
രോമാഞ്ചിഫിക്കേഷൻ sir.....
A very big salute to Dr.Sasi Tharoor
Who else noticed he knowingly missed important names while taking about freedom fighters. 😐 that only a Congress mind can do.
In Assam, the previous Congress govt which ruled for 15 years issued documents to the people of a particular community by which illegal immigrants can now prove themselves Indian. That can be understood from looking at the change of demographic situations in the lower part of the state. Now, if govt provided documents are to be considered you aren't going to find out a single illegal immigrant in Assam. Is that okay Mr. Tharoor?
Well, who betrayed the now Pakistani and Bangladeshi nonmuslims???
Lahore conspiracy, Chitagong revolt and many such brave confrontations against the crowns raj, did took place in these places was not inorder to be proclaimed as an islamic country.
Congress betrayed millions of nonmuslims and sold them in process of setting up islamic nations within India, now they have geared up again to repeat the same.
Hell with your hindu definitions and distinctions !!!!!!
It's a initiative to bring ppl closer to govt agencies and be a responsible citizens.
Other all can bake there chapatis
Other counties start thr.schoolday with nationalan them encourage young people to do national service and know the country
I beg to differ from Tharoor in the matter of CAA. Either he deliberately chooses to connive at the historical blunders committed post the partition or he isn't well read in the matter of the history of India.
Yes, I agree. I think Tharoor is a powerful intellectual and a great scholar - but is not a good politician in that he frequently does not take an honest, thorough view on many issues. He acts and sounds exactly like a Western politican who endlessly attacks the "bad" side.
Why don't congress men say same thing about Kashmiri Pandits living like a migrant in their own country. 🤐
I desire to sasi tharoor ji became a new prime minister of india 🇮🇳
Very informative talk sir. Also excellent questions by audience. Thanks.
An Indian said, how to stay as Indian.... Excellent
Are the hindu-shikhs of BD-Pak r indian or not? Sorry to say YOU donnt know 'islam', the relation betwn Islam n India.
Sashi tharror is always right No doubt
I like his English
ANYBODY WBO THINKS HE IS AN INDIAN INSPITE Of ALL THE FAULTS AND SHORTCOMIMS OF India. UNFORTUNATELY the BRITISH Asians did not think so Neither did theMauritians I do not justfy the bad things in India but I shall never demy that I am part of it
Jai Shri Ram
Refugees from Burma's was accepted. Actress Helen came from Burma.Thamil came from Sri Lanka and Myanmar muslims are not refugees.They fought for a separate state on religion basis in the country where they were,so pushed out from there .They are not victim of persecution. I'd accepted they may raise same demand here also.
There was a news
Bangladeshis obtained indian passport and travelled to abroad.
I strongly believe that only Dr. Tharoor could deliver such marvelous & brilliant speech. I felt that the core message was flowing into the hearts .. . God Bless You Dr. Tharoor with good health and long life as society needs people like you..
Mr Tharoor very wisely excluded some important concerns just in order to stay loyal to his party. My question to Mr Tharoor is ''Okay! Non muslims from these 3 countries will get citizenship easily as perks of this act BUT what about Non Muslim candidates of this Country including Hindus who are residing here but don't have papers." And on what behalf he can call it irrational and irrelevant. It's a simple act for persecuted minorities. Giving it a communal angle is irrational. But yes it's easier to fool people by an educated politician by over rating artificially created facts to satisfy personal interests. WAKE UP INDIA.
Wbat about Indian Muslim
ഇംഗ്ലീഷ് പാട്ടു പാടും പോലെ സംസാരിക്കുന്ന മനുഷ്യൻ.. 🤪🤪
Appo English paattukare enthu vilikkum
What a intelligent guy
Very informative and an eloquent speaker! Interesting talk by Dr.STharoor, inspiring & magnifying!
ഓരോ വാക്കും ഗൂഗിൾ ൽ thapounna ഞാൻ....
An Indian can be Dalit,Adivasi, Brahmins,vyshya,shudra,Muslim,Sikh,Parsi,Jaina and Christian 😎
My favourite indian Politician
He should be the pm face of Congress
Congress is not worth him. I've always wished he be The Prime Minister, I was madly a fan of Tharoor. But Congress is not even considering him as the PM candidate.
Mr Taroor...pls understand that one time or the other we need to account and count ourselves......ur metaphorical language may impress many...but not logical people..... sorry....
With CAA NRC NPR or demonitisatiom or trashing students by BJP made other political party or people to come together and fight for right and save the nation. 1st time I find opposition party not seems playing politics but rather fighting for rights. Each individual of India who see the steps taken by BJP can push our people n country in vain. We are humans first and religious always should comes later. BJP choose religion above humanity this made BJP supporters trash people or kill them for religion.
CAA is a fast track process only, i think.
Great oratory. India had been under muslim rule for centuries. It was from muslims the british took over india. Several places, landmark buildings were built by the muslim rulers. Even now , millions of hindus are working or living in 67 muslim countries. And these hindus are living in a better off conditions than those who are living in india. Moreover, India is doing business worth billions of dollars with these countries. Suppose If the UN goes on the lines of religious identity, should india have any hindu friends to talk to other than Nepal.
Second question is excellent, and yes there are multiple ways to prove as told by hon'ble home minister also.
Who is an Indian is like our Gods Brahma , Vishnu , Shiva where each one of the form is different but all in one called the god . So an Indian can be a tamilians , Malayali or a Bengali and Punjabi can be a Hindu Muslim or Sikh . Nobody can question that
Pls Mr Taroor....pls understand, these three countries named are proclaimed Islamist entities...and Sri Lanka is called a secular country...so there is a difference... u deliberately chose to ignore....let me remind u that all these laws were initiated and put in the back burner by the same party that u so proudly represent...u can also be so mean to give a honey coated speach in a literary meet....
I agree that Mr. Tharoor is a brilliant orator, but I disagree with his objections on the argument that citizenship act is nefarious to be against Muslims. The 3 countries, listed along with all other Muslim majority nations systematically treat non muslims as pariahs, so fast tracking the minorities to receive Indian citizenship is correct if they apply
You cannot mix being diverse with illegal immigrant 🙄
Bangladesh and Pakistan will continue to survive as nations whereas India will be remembered as footnote to remind the above countries as there ancestors have come from a country called India in the near future.
Clear n perceptive
Maybe commenting too quick. Further into video if required i shall edit.
Just started and i see he used the opportunity to bring in CAA and spoke about how for the first time religions is mentioned or discriminated. Don't get me wrong , i like him and he definitely has the energy and knowledge to run for PM but i have to say that Gandhi ji and Nehru have spoken way back in the past of introducing such a bill for the religiously prosecuted minorities as we have the responsibility to care of them. If they did not mention a ammendment bill exactly they defenetly did talk about taking care of the persecuted minorities of these countries. I don't find excluding Muslims as a discrimination since the Ahmedis don't even come to India even as they are a tortured/discriminated minority in Pakistan. If you wish to you can verify anything i said and if I'm wrong I'm willing to correct what i said otherwise please don't call me a sanghi or whatever for speaking kind of in support of CAA.
Towards the end he made a comment which essentially mean even if the Supreme Court of India doesn't rule against CAA itwill still be unconstitutional. The appeal itself is saying its against the constitutional principles and it if its not sustained in the court how is it still unconstitutional? I really don't think the court will rule in support of something unconstitutional.
I'm Waiting for the verdict! That's all i can say as a person who has closely watched all the protests and supports and heard all the arguments. When they speak , both the pro and against CAA folks selectively omit many facts and essentials and include many twisted forms of truth in their favour and some just don't evem know anything but simply follow the favourite team.
For national registry actually witnesses(neighbours) are accepted right? But its soon to say this is accepted or not as it has not taken a proper form yet , has it?
Yes my friend, I agree with your thoughts and views, it make sense... for opposition they just got a trump card, but if we go in deep this looks intentional, purposely created by our ruling government, in a way to hide the core issues our country is facing currently. This is what my feelings are..
Citizenship register, must be a mandatory requirement for any country, hope we all agree to that. .. but the way it is getting implemented or announced is where the issue started, I am not sure if you got a chance to watch the video of our home minister's provocative speech , his way of delivering the speech and his body language was the clear evidence of what his intention is.. and, this is where the problems started. Eventually our prime Minister's effort to cover up the issue and the provocative statement of dress codes which is not at all good for a true leader of our nation. Hope you also observed that. The way we handled the situation was pathetic...
And if we look at the way how things are being done for the past couple of years, one can clearly say that these were the test doses, triple talaq, article 370 and babry masjid, and when it reached to CAA and NRC they just got overwhelmed by the success of their earlier acts.
When we look at the implementation of Assam model NRC across the country, who do we think will be be the most affected, Muslims? Really not...
there will be another 20 crores in different categories of people including homeless, tribes and others will be the victims. what identification methods are we applying to get them registered? Else so called detention camps will be the solution? What will be the cost of construction and maintaining these concentration camps? How long are we going to keep them inside? What will be the end result? Do we have an idea? Can the vote bank politics have any answers? Don't we need to question them? This is not the time to sit back and relax! It's time to react...
Who do we think is the culprit for this current situation? I should say Congress party and it's corrupted 60 odd years made people to think for an alternative. To overcome the current crisis I should say neither Congress nor communist will ever be the alternative. I would say a Delhi model must be a good alternative. A new alliance must emerge. I prefer Sasi Tharoor must quit Congress and many like minded people should get together for a better tomorrow. This is the time for that... wish it could happen.
I personally was supporting BJP when it came to power and I had a kind of soft mind to Mr Modi personally, but sorry to say, he could not meet the expectations of our common people. Congress on the other side is fully corrupted and looted India badly, they never have the rights to lead India agin!
Currently we all got diverted and devided, we lost our focus, core issues were hidden, recently I overheard a talk between two school going kids, one said "your mother cannot be a best friend of mine since you are from a different religion! This really shocked me, still not recovered!!! Not sure where we are heading to, and whom to blame?Whatever we do now must be for a better tomorrow and the betterment for our next generation, but are we on the right direction???
@@santhoshsasidharan7463 i agree with you on everything you said. If congress was just not a family profit motive business kinda politics i would never have thought BJP must be in power. I think it is the case for almost all those who voted for bjp. Its more dislike towards congress than love for BJP . I do see most their speeches but I'm not sure i get it all as i find it hard understanding Hindi. But i say this, I don't want BJP to be overwhelmingly powerful like nothing can touch them. I want BJP in power with a party like congress in opposition. Otherwise they will do just anything. Same goes for anyone when they feel they are invincible.
Its really shocking to hear that about those kids. I really cannot relate to any of these Muslim-Hindu hatred because my best friends are Muslims and I'm a Hindu. I have my Muslim friends mother giving feeding both me and my friend together from the same plate and so does my mother as well. But i see how hatred and tensions are rising. Its because an average Hindu would be bothered if a party like bjp points out some unfairness to him and sees how some parties support it. What i mean to say is that people lost their ability to think beyond politics.
I just hope things all get better and people has only one intention in life which is welfare of the people and country.
If the point was to protect persecuted minorities why was Sri Lanka not included? The Tamils(whether hindu, muslim or Christian) are persecuted and they do come to India.
They weren't included because this government wanted to define citizenship on the basis of religion.
If they had included Tamils then it would not have been on Religion. One of the amendments proposed by the Congress was this and the BJP voted it down.
On the Supreme Court, they just gave bail to 14 people convicted of burning alive 23 people(including 22 women) in the gujarat riots.
www.thehindu.com/news/national/sc-grants-bail-to-17-convicts-in-2002-sardarpura-post-godhra-riots-case/article30673268.ece
The Supreme Court also hasn't listened to any of the Kashmir Habeus Corpus Cases.
So let's not pretend the supreme Court can't be pressured by the government.
On the NRC.
Yes in Assam the neighbours were allowed to be witness.
But in Assam they also allowed anyone to make a complaint against you that you were not a citizen. Then you would have to go to a foreigner tribunal and prove that you are a citizen.
If you do an all India NRC, you'll make the bureaucracy all powerful.
In the states where bureaucrats are corrupt they will take lots of bribes. In the states where they are communal they will purposely leave out lots of Muslims.
@@yusuf.k.m I'm not sure why the Tamils were not included. I may need to know more about it before i can say anything about it. Are they persecuted religiously? Idk. And the bill is exactly for bordering neighbours (Afghanistan shares the border) and I'm not sure the proper reason why it was made that way. If the Tamils are really religiously persecuted and yet it was avoided by simply because of a hidden religious agenda i am against it. But i am sure I'm not gonna go into streets and protest violently over accusations, agenda and hate and be a puppet to those that will use me.
Supreme Court things- I'm never going to thing any system anywhere in the world is 100% perfect. Especially when it revolves around politics. I also know for a fact that sometimes Supreme Court has definitely made some unfair judgements on things that they should not be making a judgement on like religion and the customs which they never understand clearly. I am also not sure or rather aware of the Kashmir issue as it is too complex. But brother i have to say that being a Indian citizen i cannot be without keeping faith in our courts and respect the judgements or there will be chaos. I am also sure that no government can put sure on the supreme court over its judgment on something ''unconstitutional'. I will certainly respect the verdict on CAA.
what about those people who chant zinna wali azadi...,........
English is world language. Now not only for British. All the books in the world are only available in English language. If you don't use English your knowledge will be half.
THATS WAY OF A DREAMER.....
Dr. SHASHI THAROOR IS A DREAMER !!
Imagine him as PM 😘 he's the only one for better India
THAT IS NOT TRUE...TIMES HAVE CHANGE.....
He want to become another Nehru, the Hindu hater...
Who comes to see comments about Dr. Tharoor
India will turn into britain if he becomes the pm of india. but it is not possible
*ദൈവമേ ഒന്നും മനസിലാകുന്നില്ല എന്നാലും proud of u sir. one day you will be the pm of india sure*
രോഹിഷ് ഭാസ്ക്കരൻ ...but the Congress will not allow him reach there
രോഹിഷ് ഭാസ്ക്കരൻ suree
@@RV-sd1ci not only congress, nobody wants anybody better than themselves to reach a higher position.had it been not India, may be he would have reached more heights
After freedom struggle, Muslim should have left as Pakistan an area was for them.. Isn't it? So no point of arguments ... We accept a Hindu Nation.. Thank you.
India the largest democracy in the world is a humanity driven country where everyone - Hindu, Christian, Muslim, Sikh, Jain, Parsy and many different ethnic and caste groups live side by side. What a wonderful mosaic of rich talents and diversity that make up India. India finds strength in unity and diversity. We should be proud of this strength to move India forward to become a humane super power. Nothing is bigger and nobler than humanity. We should have a broad based agenda to deliver for all the people of India that does not get lost in ideology, pedagogy and demagoguery. We can be better and stronger together. God bless the people of India.
Great speech by a great speaker .... 🙏
8:32 i think that ammachi is not interested to hear tharoor's explanation about Who is an Indian . She is knitting very seriously 😅
Jixon Kocheril you haven't read the Tale of two cities then.
How,
"Human - Born - Rabbit 🐰"?🙇
Shashi sir as PM!! I’ll vote if he belongs to whichever party
How,
"Goat - Organs - Can - Change - Human - Organ"?🙇
Proud to hear the words over right narrative
Without "any" - Mother,
How can u get - ur - Friends ?🙇🤔
Great
Very valid point. Unfortunately our judiciary , now a days , is not playing effective role of checks and balances. If Judiciary plays correct role , this bill would be unconstitutional.
Wish you were the PM of this country 👍
@Yogesh Sharma hahaha
Who's indian ???
This who hold valid documents issued by the government of India *AND* all the hindus around the world....
I.DEFINITELY WILL NOT ACCEPT people of Indian origin from Mautitious and.east.africans as Citizens of India.They are racists and look down upon Indians All they want is a.clutch to hold upon for an identity.
Broo
How could all hindhus around the world be Indians
@Nisha chambiyal so as asper our Constitution the current primary name to our nation is 🇮🇳INDIA, if you don't wana accept that name just leave the country 🤣🤣
Mr. Tharoor, please do not misinform your audiences and people alike - mixing CAA to citizenship? - when CAA is about REFUGEES who are in India since 2014 who will get citizenship. Intelligent people are sometimes stupid and irrelevant. Spewing such rubbish is unfortunate from an Indian parliamentarian where CAA was debated, I hope you were not asleep then.
Who is an Indian.Ans.Anybody who comes to India& stays here including illegals r Indians.Congress govt who ruled India did not take any initiative to define & issue cards on birth of a child in India.This card should form the basis for all purposes.congis failed & this aspect should b made clear by him.
Nehru spoke such impotent language after becoming pm and did not issue citizenship number when all countries gave citizenship number to track people in the modern world. Congress loves all illegal things and poorness of indians so that they vote this Italian family. This family is not bothered whether the country grows but it is interested in keeping the PM post in its hands and enjoy and damage the very meaning of democracy...
Tharoor 👌👌👌
Pranaam to Mathrubhoomi and it's factual reporting style. As a young girl, I used to ridicule my mother saying, "LEARN TO READ MATHRUBHOOMI, and your brains will grow."
Yes, Indianism has nothing to do with color or texture or the money bags we store. It's an ATTITUDE. It is about the serene state of mind where we assert without hatred or violence and accept the most irrational arguments with humor. It is the state of being humble even to the least among us, respecting creation, protecting and preserving whatever is around us even when we defend and resist destructive forces. It is much above religion and existed long before Molochian religions took over the planet. Thank you for sharing the speech.
very good speech ...... Shashi...... we need a truthful minister for our country .... who has capacity to see the value of each individual...... there is not you and me but only we............
Those who don't have unhealthy fascination for foreign language and culture. Those who take pride in being indian. Those who don't flirt with people belonging to country that considers itself India's enemy. Those who don't break indian laws...by all counts not Tharoor.
Shashi cannot answer why congress did not give citizenship number for 70 years ? he will conviniently escape. This is congress method of dragging every possible decision like impotents... Babri issue was solved by Modi
Sh Sashi Tharoor is a great man but giving opinion on imaginary things of future and misleading people does not suit his stature. Secondly arguing that it was not conducted so far in 70 years and then conducting today is only political is itself is his self proclaimed ideas. Yes ppl should prove they are citizen.
An excellent discourse , one which should be listened to and try to understand by jaggy Vasudev the maverick SAD GURU (?)who by way of expressing gratitude to Mr. Modi condemned the JNU students and teachers as uneducated.>..> 1
For nearly 27 year this man even couldnot point out INDIA in world map. See how shamelesly he is talking about who is Indian ?
what about an orphans ? ....whether they will consider them in NRC and CAA.... or else what they will do them if he/ she follows islam religion ....
Congress should think smarty to bring tharoor sir into the position of PM..We new generation need such a smart PM...
He looks puffy☹️
But nothing showed up on grounds that's why opportunity grabbed
After Shashi which Indian will fill his void?
Pinu will fill
Subrahmanyan Swami
Mohua Moitra
@@idiosyncratic87 deedi is lady version of modiji
Once people(bjp)read the Constitution ,they will understand ,who is Indian.its simple.
shame on Modi shame on India this murderer is still at large n cocking a snook at d good people of India
Why npr done by congress party? Are the hindu-shikh refugees r indian?
The recent issue of Citizenship is the result of failed rule in India.
The administration after independent were completely corruptive .
The people were uneducated.
The entire government after independence told about development. Whose development?
They aimed the development of few groups .
Jai Hind
There is no any beautiful girl in crowd.... I am single... (shashi tharur)
Its high time mr Tharoor create a new political party of his own . I am surely it will sink the other two nauseating parties to extinction. The moment he decides to float a party of his own he would surely will get maximum mandate to govern the state.
A citizenship registry is a good idea. But the ways by which it is planned to be achieved is dubious.
By same logic you people please apply for British citizen.. See if they accept oxford pass out
Who is an Indian. Those who drove the Kashmir Pandits were Indian.
Who master mind the Coimbatore blast and Bombay blast are Indian by nature..
We lost one third of land to aggression,
Religious conversion is a form of aggression.
A intellectual person in a wrong party.
There are more than 100 muslim countries and equal number of Christian country why India can't be a Hindu country?
Can anyone have the answer.
Our history is different.I always took pride in Tajmahal Mughlai
Khana.western music English language as well as in Nalanda Asoka Akbar South Indian temples and and Bengali literature.
All cpm members by name sashi given a bad name to this name. But taroor made proud of this name
#SHASHI 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏👌
Was that guy in maroon shirt from any media? Terrible language...n accent ..😊😁😁but poor shashi ji replied
He at least tried.
He did for all sessions..atleast prepare it n ask..all of us did..be clear what you are asking
@@FramesofMathew malayalam chodichaal porey....
@@vvnn2633 pora
@@JS-qm3jh Ohoo..sakshara keralam..naarano ingane..enthaa sahodara ithu..nalla malayalam parayaallo
Shahi tharoor knows how cunningly we can confuse people. He is from UN so he should give one of the best policies to solve this issue once and for all... In 1950 Nehru should have given all people in India the citizenship number he was confussing people and khangress continued it. Even till today we do not have modern countries methods. Even when Aadhar number was given to all this same congress has blocked it in Supreme court and keeping the country confused. Every possible major issue the congress has dragged it 70 yrs
Ravi Mohan andhbhakt antinational spotted
Lekin,
Jada - Sakh & Jada Cheating,
Karne ki Kosis kiya to,
Bp bharta hain & Language bhi Badalne Lagta hain,
&
Aur Jada hua to - Fight,
Aur Jada hua to - Weapon. 🙏