I may be raining on the parade here, but, allow me to remind you that the film DOCTOR ZHIVAGO was not very complementary of the communist revolution. Quite the contrary. No, life under the Czar was not so pleasant either. But that was little less a command and control economy - commanded and controlled by a monarchy - than what was established by the communists. The manner in which this clip has been used is the very epitome of selective editing.
@@nancyhey1012 It is as if Boris Pasternak could not make up his mind. Personally I believe the revolution was impossible to avoid, the peasants and workers were living in misery, 90% of the Russian population.
@@monichat I agree that a revolution was impossible to avoid. That does not mean that there was not excessive force used, such as murdering the Romanovs, and persecution of artists, which was what Boris exposed. I don’t think it was a case of him not making up his mind. It seemed like he was more of a pacifist and deplored the violence on all sides. I’ve also read that in his own life he was also in love with two different women, as was Yuri, one of whom he married and the other was a mistress.
@@nancyhey1012 The murdering of the Romanovs does not give me any pain, after all the suffering they caused to the Russian people. Even Nicholas's cousin, the king of England, refused to give a chance to that family by refusing to take them in his country. It would have caused a revolution in England, people knew how incompetent and cruel Nicholas and his wife were. There was no turning back, no chance of another czar in Rusia. I feel terrible that Lenin died so young, he was a good person. Wanted the well being of every Russian. Stalin took the power and we all know how cruel he was. Very sad for the Revolution. Doktor Zhivago did not love only Tonya and Lara. When he returned to Moscow after Lara's departure, he lived with Marina and had two more daughters. Of course it is more romantic to believe that he died of pain because of Lara as the movie shows. As for Mr Pasternak, he was married twice, had a mistress Olga Ivinskaya. The character of Lara was inspired by Olga. Anna Pasternak, Boris's niece wrote about Boris and Olga. Anna Pasternak lives in Great Britain, writes wonderfully well.
@@monichat it’s true, Marina was never mentioned in the movie. They thought it was more romantic to show Yuri dying pining for Lara. I remember in the book, Tonya wrote the letter to Yuri telling him that she and the children were fleeing to France, but she wanted Yuri to stay with Lara, thinking he would be “happier” with her. But in my opinion, she should have demanded that Yuri do right by his children by returning to her and being a good father.
![NISAMANEE - TADA (ท้าดา) [ OFFICIAL MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/hcQHEPMmJpU/mqdefault.jpg)
- Caj, molim.
- Kafu, molim.
- Koju kafu?
- Dedo naravno!
😂
Hansen, the first music is the Varshavianka.
@yalezirpolo Communists don't need to recruit. Capitalism defeats itself.
Yea right
to bloodly battle but sacread and right
marsh march forward vouch narod!
Komorovsky shows that guys like Harvey Weinstein have always been around...
Weinstein, Epstein, Soros, Rothschild all pieces of shit
Does anybody know what version of Varshavianka is in the begining?
You should have included the cavalry charge against the protest march.
The name of the march is Interior student café.
So cool man
Zar in 2022? can't be same
I'm sick of seeing my ol man lettin up to Trump as if he were a tool.
Does anybody know the music playing during the march? (Ie. the first one, not the internationale)
It is called warshavianka
@kashgar22 (or maybe they are depending on the country....)
The book was better
Putin is born in 1952
@kashgar22 Haha I don't think pineapples are a luxury fruit or anything
I may be raining on the parade here, but, allow me to remind you that the film DOCTOR ZHIVAGO was not very complementary of the communist revolution. Quite the contrary. No, life under the Czar was not so pleasant either. But that was little less a command and control economy - commanded and controlled by a monarchy - than what was established by the communists. The manner in which this clip has been used is the very epitome of selective editing.
I read the book. It was not complimentary to either the communists or the Czarists.
@@nancyhey1012 It is as if Boris Pasternak could not make up his mind. Personally I believe the revolution was impossible to avoid, the peasants and workers were living in misery, 90% of the Russian population.
@@monichat I agree that a revolution was impossible to avoid. That does not mean that there was not excessive force used, such as murdering the Romanovs, and persecution of artists, which was what Boris exposed. I don’t think it was a case of him not making up his mind. It seemed like he was more of a pacifist and deplored the violence on all sides. I’ve also read that in his own life he was also in love with two different women, as was Yuri, one of whom he married and the other was a mistress.
@@nancyhey1012 The murdering of the Romanovs does not give me any pain, after all the suffering they caused to the Russian people. Even Nicholas's cousin, the king of England, refused to give a chance to that family by refusing to take them in his country. It would have caused a revolution in England, people knew how incompetent and cruel Nicholas and his wife were. There was no turning back, no chance of another czar in Rusia.
I feel terrible that Lenin died so young, he was a good person. Wanted the well being of every Russian. Stalin took the power and we all know how cruel he was. Very sad for the Revolution.
Doktor Zhivago did not love only Tonya and Lara. When he returned to Moscow after Lara's departure, he lived with Marina and had two more daughters. Of course it is more romantic to believe that he died of pain because of Lara as the movie shows. As for Mr Pasternak, he was married twice, had a mistress Olga Ivinskaya. The character of Lara was inspired by Olga. Anna Pasternak, Boris's niece wrote about Boris and Olga. Anna Pasternak lives in Great Britain, writes wonderfully well.
@@monichat it’s true, Marina was never mentioned in the movie. They thought it was more romantic to show Yuri dying pining for Lara. I remember in the book, Tonya wrote the letter to Yuri telling him that she and the children were fleeing to France, but she wanted Yuri to stay with Lara, thinking he would be “happier” with her. But in my opinion, she should have demanded that Yuri do right by his children by returning to her and being a good father.
X
X