In bouregois terms it was a war between the allies and Germany. In bolshevik terms it was a war between the allied and German upper classes. And which of them was a matter of indifference.
2:16 - “… our cursed capacity for suffering.” It’s something of a cliché about the Slavic temperment, and yet, based on limited experience, I have to say there’s some truth to it, and it starts very young. I used to work in health care, and I remember drawing blood on 2 pediatric cases, one a 5-year-old Ukrainian and the other a 3-year-old Russian. They didn’t scream or wiggle, but they weren’t stoic either. Even at that tender age, there was something majestic about the way they felt their pain, neither suppressing nor exaggerating their reaction, but suffering through it almost like a form of art, beautifully. Where in the world does that come from? I don’t believe such traits are genetic, but whatever cultural process perpetuates them must start very young.
Thank you. At long last….an Intelligent observation. Younger audiences should learn that this is a truly classic film. How really excellent films were made. It was an art form. No needless zombies, automatons, Marvel or DC shallow characters. Or needless excessive explosions or violence. With REAL actors and great directors who knew how to tell a story. Who knew their craft. This is true epic storytelling. Sadly. It’s an almost forgotten art form.
An acquaintance thought that because Antipov's glasses were not broken or blood-spattered when they hit the snow, it was a hint by Lean that Pasha was still alive. He then wrote to David Lean asking if this was so. Lean actually wrote back and commended him on being so observant.
min 1:13 "When the boots wore out, they'd be ready to listen..." 😧 "Every civilization is three meals away from anarchy" - Lenin TOO MUCH REALITY, DUDES!!!! Yevgrav is HARDCORE!!!! 😧😧😧😧😧
Rich old men send poor and middle class young men to fight and be slaughtered so that the rich old men can get even richer. - George Carlin 2006. War is a racket. - U.S. Army general Smedley Butler, 1937
March 2017 came and went, and there was hardly a mention of the 100th anniversary of the Russian Revolution anywhere in the media. Sad how history is neglected these days.
Good. The Bolshevik revolution spread a cancer on human society that will probably never be rid of. Boris Pasternak tried to warn us. So did others. We aren't listening enough to the people that lived through this.
2:05-2:09 Now that is the grim reality of the eastern front, especially during the winter. Can’t imagine how so many Russian suffered. Showing the frozen bodies is pretty epic right there a very distinct accurate depiction about what it was like especially in those cold winters 2:34 Seeing those Russians in the trench yeah, I can’t imagine the freaking hell there in.
Whatever happened to education ? Obi Wan would surely never deign it an appropriate use of his time and energy to appear in a Star Wars movie ! Or would he ?
@@Teddyclaws Yes that's probably true. But a hired gun still has to deliver the goods. When you hired Alec Guinness you got quality acting. He maintains an 'other worldly' aura as Obi Wan.
@@sunnylotus1 true. Even though he hated the role, he didn't show any sign of that when the cameras were rolling, so the audience still gets vintage Alec Guinness.
I could play this once a day and never be Bored. ...love the crushing flower...When the boots wore out.....THEY will be ready to listen...... The Best lines.....they are all GREAT....... I TOOK A WHOLE DIVISION OFF THE FRONT LINE BEST DAYS WORK I EVER DID..... why of course Communism works.... For the hierarchy. ..they lived like ...gasp...CZARS.
They weren't made for each other. Komarovsky, albeit for his own evil intent, tried to warn Lara: Lara, I am determined to save you from a dreadful error. There are two kinds of men, and only two, and that young man is one kind. He is high-minded. He is pure. He is the kind of man that the world pretends to look up to and in fact despises. He is the kind of man who breeds unhappiness; particularly in women. Now, do you understand?
War is not good war brings starvition, poverty,😫😩😍 distractions, 😡 unhappy😟😧 life. The country have war they living in misery😫😷😭😩life hearth breaking💔😭 life. iam so sorry for those lost their life for the cause of war, Almighty above☝ have mercy war country☔🌴🌲🌳.
I've always found this movie did too much telling and not enough showing for me to enjoy it. All that narration drags so no matter how gifted the actor.
I agree with you regarding communism. I have never been much of a fan. Mas o que vc acha do Carlos Marighella. O que acha do esforco da ditadura por deter o movimento comunista? No casso de Marighella e outros comunistas no Brasil foram eletos democraticamente e apos jogaram fora no nome da seguridade nacional. Seu inlges eh perfeito. Onde se fromou?
5769JJ I doubt it. US production of Nukes took a while to actually start, and the Soviets already had spies allover the Manhattan Project. They were well aware of it by 45... I don't know what you people are talking about, US was more than smart in not declaring war against the USSR. As if the waste of life that was WWII wasn't enough, you people think a WWIII would've made the situation better? That's stupid...
5769JJ In 1945 the USA had 4 nukes. 1 was tested in the desert and 2 were dropped on Japan. Dropped not sent on by missles.. Where would the base be to drop it on Moscow?
Great film. Always thought the Lara character was cast way too old for a 17 year old. Julie Chrisy looks like she's 30. I'd take Geraldine Chaplin over her any day.
I agree, actually. She was quite adorable in Billy Liar but in this movie she just doesn't fit, I could name about 10 60's actresses I would have rather seen play Lara than her.
She's stunning in this. You guys must be blind. Moviemakers have and always will look for the most attractive actors to play the lead characters, whether or not the book portrays them that way.
The book was very popular in Russia while the ban was on. As for the Russians now, they've redone the movie. The balalaika is out, but the rest seems to have worked well as a Russian miniseries. www.nytimes.com/2006/02/12/weekinreview/time-to-come-home-zhivago.html?_r=0
The book was and is well-received. The film, more tepidly so, but not for the reasons you might think. The script is much more Robert Bolt than Boris Pasternak, and Russians see it as an Englishman writing about the way English people would act and speak, just wearing costumes. It's not that they HATE the film, it's just that, as one Russian critic said, "it's a lovely story...it just isn't a RUSSIAN story." One weird example of an English-language period film set in that era that resonates with them and that they DO gobble up is 1971's NICHOLAS AND ALEXANDRA.
Expecting to see Barry Hussien O marching into this scene. Pure Saul Alinsky. Unfortunately the presswas to busy going thru Sarah Palin garbage to look into BO's radical past.
swatbot2611 Dropped a couple of Fat Mans and Little Boys on the steppes, Russians woulda lined the streets 10 deep to watch our Sherman tanks roll into Moscow. We'd all be living on the moons of Saturn by now.
RideMyTruck Sure, because the US had a "couple" of those back then... Not only that, but I bet you could throw as many nukes as you want and the russians wouldn't give up. They would just keep fighting... I guess that's the one thing history has taught us for sure about them: They don't give up that easily. And seeing how the USSR had the largest army back then, and how most of the western forces were very tired out, I don't see how your little shit plan could work, specially seeing how the soviets already were inside Project Manhattan and were starting to develop their own nukes. And, oh yeah, your 'idea" would've been absolutly pointless. Doing that would be beyond stupid and would serve no purpose at all. All the blood shed in WWII was more than enough for everyone. You should be glad that the leaders of the US were smart enough not to do such horrible thing. One massive murder of innocent civillians in their hands was enough, I guess... And by the way, how can you talk of genocide with such ease? What kind of sick fuck are you?
swatbot2611 Dude, wanna talk genocide? Lets talk Stalin's Gulags. 30 milllion? Couple of Fat Mans and Lil Boys woulda ended all of that...Like I said, Russkies woulda lined the streets of Mascow 10 deep just to watch our Shermans roll by...Truman was a TOTAL chicken sh$#.
RideMyTruck "Couple of Fat Mans and Lil Boys" would've murdered thousands, millions of innocent Russians as well. That would make the US just as good as Stalin. In fact, the US government already is... One crime doesn't justify another, you sick fuck. The Axis Crimes were no justification for the horrible crimes of the Allies such as the bombardment of Dresden, the rape of German women by Soviet Troops, Hiroshima and Nagasaki... That made the Allies just as "good" as the Axis. God, I can't stand ignorants like you who can't show any respect or empathy for human life and sacrifice. How old are you?! 12?! If so, shut the fuck up. If not, grow the fuck up!
rjun67 You, madame (or sir, as the case may be,) are a lout, posting descriptions of videos that are insulting at best and racist at worst. On some of them, your descriptions are of such vile quality they bring criticisms that you are too cowardly to leave up, but instead close the comment sections.
![[TH] VALORANT Champions Seoul - Grand Final - EDG vs TH](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/WvObMc9VelI/mqdefault.jpg)
![ฮักเทื่อสุดท้าย - บอย ศิริชัย [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-1PoPoQ-B-k/mqdefault.jpg)
In bouregois terms it was a war between the allies and Germany. In bolshevik terms it was a war between the allied and German upper classes. And which of them was a matter of indifference.
In the end a Bolshevik government would lead them to a worse hell than Tsarist Russia would do to them.
"And which of them won* was a matter of indifference"
Yevgraf says he joined "to organize defeat". That's not indifference.
There are few times when you can say a film is beautiful, this is one of those times. Beautiful.
2:16 - “… our cursed capacity for suffering.” It’s something of a cliché about the Slavic temperment, and yet, based on limited experience, I have to say there’s some truth to it, and it starts very young. I used to work in health care, and I remember drawing blood on 2 pediatric cases, one a 5-year-old Ukrainian and the other a 3-year-old Russian. They didn’t scream or wiggle, but they weren’t stoic either. Even at that tender age, there was something majestic about the way they felt their pain, neither suppressing nor exaggerating their reaction, but suffering through it almost like a form of art, beautifully. Where in the world does that come from? I don’t believe such traits are genetic, but whatever cultural process perpetuates them must start very young.
Sir Alec Guinness' voice, timbre, diction and enunciation are beyond brilliance
and excellence.
+Solitaire Right you are. A great actor.
His narration made the movie.
@@nicoleackerman205 very Talented gentleman...
Thats why he's in Star Wars, old chap!
Watch him in Cromwell he has the stammer of Charles I perfect
Powerful scene from one of the best movies ever made.
Thank you. At long last….an Intelligent observation. Younger audiences should learn that this is a truly classic film. How really excellent films were made. It was an art form. No needless zombies, automatons, Marvel or DC shallow characters. Or needless excessive explosions or violence. With REAL actors and great directors who knew how to tell a story. Who knew their craft. This is true epic storytelling. Sadly. It’s an almost forgotten art form.
@@rickster100100 I don't think it's a forgotten art. It still exists, but you have wade through lots of schlock to find it.
@@Dade333311 So true. Thank you for your reply.
I used to perform Guinness's narration here for theater auditions, back when I had pretensions of acting.
Pretensions or not, why not take from the best?
Alec Guiness and Tom Courtaney make this movie. They are absolutely incredible.
The entire cast. Rod Steiger? Julie Christie? Omar Sharif?
@@Dade333311 I always felt Omar Sharif overacted in this movie, but the other two were good, yes.
Alec Guiness was a beast, this might be my favorite role he's played
Always liked that scene with the glasses saw it over 40 years ago.They sure the hell won't make movies like this anymore.
An acquaintance thought that because Antipov's glasses were not broken or blood-spattered when they hit the snow, it was a hint by Lean that Pasha was still alive. He then wrote to David Lean asking if this was so. Lean actually wrote back and commended him on being so observant.
min 1:13 "When the boots wore out, they'd be ready to listen..." 😧 "Every civilization is three meals away from anarchy" - Lenin TOO MUCH REALITY, DUDES!!!! Yevgrav is HARDCORE!!!! 😧😧😧😧😧
Sir Alec Guinness' voice was powerful and orchestrated as scene itself.
Dr Zhivago has hit and miss momments but this is definitely one of the "hits"...I LOVE this segment.
Great film, a must about history back then and specially the Russian revolution.
We were shown it in high school history class for exactly that reason.
Just these 2 scenes are worth the Epic label!!!
"Our cursed capacity for suffering..."
Rich old men send poor and middle class young men to fight and be slaughtered so that the rich old men can get even richer. - George Carlin 2006.
War is a racket. - U.S. Army general Smedley Butler, 1937
Bolshevism was the worst racket of all.
Major General Smedley Butler USMC. Marine Corps. Not the Army.
@@fastmail55 More to the point, he was a two-time MoH recipient, too -- and had enlisted well underage; he's a rifleman's general, not some REMF type.
@@fastmail55 I stand corrected. Thank you.
@@tedmccarron Agreed. And now in 2020, it is raising its monstrous head again. Good luck.
Never knew how any man could have left Julie Christie to go off and fight a bloody war....... :-)
I agree she is so beautiful I cringe every time I see her
Strelnikov (Pasha) was....well, y'know, "unique" to put it mildly. LOL!
March 2017 came and went, and there was hardly a mention of the 100th anniversary of the Russian Revolution anywhere in the media. Sad how history is neglected these days.
Good. The Bolshevik revolution spread a cancer on human society that will probably never be rid of. Boris Pasternak tried to warn us. So did others. We aren't listening enough to the people that lived through this.
delavalmilker that's because it was very bad history. Like Germany not wanting to talk about Nazism during it's 30s and 40s.
th-cam.com/video/U6gMSgEihDM/w-d-xo.html
It was in November of 2017 that the 100th anniversary of the commie revolution happened. A tragic, tragic day in world history.
@@JW-do2wc Japan doesn't want to talk about what it did in China ww2 either
I would have been more than happy to take that man's place. It's the least I could have done for Julie.
Obi Wan, kicking butt and taking names in this....awesome!
2:05-2:09 Now that is the grim reality of the eastern front, especially during the winter. Can’t imagine how so many Russian suffered. Showing the frozen bodies is pretty epic right there a very distinct accurate depiction about what it was like especially in those cold winters
2:34 Seeing those Russians in the trench yeah, I can’t imagine the freaking hell there in.
the parts that include Alec Guiness are the best!
Obi Wan Kenobi played a good role in this movie & was in the ending scene.
Whatever happened to education ? Obi Wan would surely never deign it an appropriate use of his time and energy to appear in a Star Wars movie ! Or would he ?
@@sunnylotus1Alec Guinness despised his role as Obi Wan Kenobi and did it purely for the money
@@Teddyclaws Yes that's probably true. But a hired gun still has to deliver the goods. When you hired Alec Guinness you got quality acting. He maintains an 'other worldly' aura as Obi Wan.
@@sunnylotus1 true. Even though he hated the role, he didn't show any sign of that when the cameras were rolling, so the audience still gets vintage Alec Guinness.
Happy men do not volunteer......
In bolshevism you do " volunteer"
I could play this once a day and never be Bored. ...love the crushing flower...When the boots wore out.....THEY will be ready to listen......
The Best lines.....they are all GREAT.......
I TOOK A WHOLE DIVISION OFF
THE FRONT LINE BEST DAYS WORK I EVER DID..... why of course Communism works....
For the hierarchy. ..they lived like ...gasp...CZARS.
How could a man be unhappy with a with a wife who looked like a young Julie Christie?
J Silva You mean he was looking for a war to bond with the lads or maybe take a young teen recruit under his wing? 🙄
Because Pasha is insane
@@nicoleackerman205 most women over 45 are and who can blame them mankind has screwed up this world so badly for so long.
They weren't made for each other. Komarovsky, albeit for his own evil intent, tried to warn Lara:
Lara, I am determined to save you from a dreadful error. There are two kinds of men, and only two, and that young man is one kind. He is high-minded. He is pure. He is the kind of man that the world pretends to look up to and in fact despises. He is the kind of man who breeds unhappiness; particularly in women. Now, do you understand?
@@stephenroney6490 ¹¹❤❤¹1¹¹❤¹¹¹¹¹¹😅
What a movie!!!!
Love how this gives us a small peak into the romance of Royal Russia !🇷🇺
My favourite novel from a Ukrainian novelist I bet that all of you watching and following it yes a very sad novel at that time like all greats.
This is Epicry Baby! As only David Lean can do it !!!
War is not good war brings starvition, poverty,😫😩😍 distractions, 😡 unhappy😟😧 life. The country have war they living in misery😫😷😭😩life hearth breaking💔😭 life. iam so sorry for those lost their life for the cause of war, Almighty above☝ have mercy war country☔🌴🌲🌳.
Nice answer. Those parts (and the train trip out of Moscow) are the only parts of the movie I re-watch.
Obi Wan fu%$in rocks in this...
he changes one word
the men: FOR THE MOTHERLAND
Amen
All wars are waged by the upper class against their own middle and lower classes to maintain a hierarchal society. - George Orwell in 1984.
George Orwell lol...
We are all the inheritance of wokes when the best men with the best genes perished in war
Napoleon wants to reign russia - kamshatka is far as people's achievement
Aaah the years before the Communist Clone Wars....
De las mejores peliculas
Si esto fue pelicula, imagino la real... en verdad !!!QUE HOMBRES!!! valientes....
Happy men don't volunteer for war.
It’s Mid July 2023. Where’s Prigozhin?
I've always found this movie did too much telling and not enough showing for me to enjoy it. All that narration drags so no matter how gifted the actor.
You can tell this is clearly Spain
2:04 2:09 terrifies me
I agree with you regarding communism. I have never been much of a fan. Mas o que vc acha do Carlos Marighella. O que acha do esforco da ditadura por deter o movimento comunista? No casso de Marighella e outros comunistas no Brasil foram eletos democraticamente e apos jogaram fora no nome da seguridade nacional. Seu inlges eh perfeito. Onde se fromou?
El modod d desfilar las tropas no hay duda de que son del ejercito español
Russia must have been behind on weapon technology.
Doctor Zhivaqo 😍😍❤❤👌👌💍💍
Quando il primo paio di stivali si fosse consumato i mugiki ci avrebbero ascoltato.
marched into moscow in 45 well you gave me a good laugh
nukes would have made it happen....Soviet Union didn't have them for another 4 years!
5769JJ I doubt it. US production of Nukes took a while to actually start, and the Soviets already had spies allover the Manhattan Project. They were well aware of it by 45...
I don't know what you people are talking about, US was more than smart in not declaring war against the USSR. As if the waste of life that was WWII wasn't enough, you people think a WWIII would've made the situation better? That's stupid...
5769JJ In 1945 the USA had 4 nukes. 1 was tested in the desert and 2 were dropped on Japan. Dropped not sent on by missles.. Where would the base be to drop it on Moscow?
Has anyone uploaded the movie in its entirety?
Great film. Always thought the Lara character was cast way too old for a 17 year old. Julie Chrisy looks like she's 30. I'd take Geraldine Chaplin over her any day.
I agree, actually. She was quite adorable in Billy Liar but in this movie she just doesn't fit, I could name about 10 60's actresses I would have rather seen play Lara than her.
Julie was 23, 24 when she was in this film.....her character goes from 17 to around 32 I think she is superb
She's stunning in this. You guys must be blind. Moviemakers have and always will look for the most attractive actors to play the lead characters, whether or not the book portrays them that way.
Take a survey of 17 yr old boys, I think she would be highly rated.
Why so many points in the title of this video? Ellipsis? It's three points then.
How was this film and the novel it was based on received in Russia after the ban was lifted?
The book was very popular in Russia while the ban was on.
As for the Russians now, they've redone the movie. The balalaika is out, but the rest seems to have worked well as a Russian miniseries.
www.nytimes.com/2006/02/12/weekinreview/time-to-come-home-zhivago.html?_r=0
In Russia today Dr Zhivago is a required read in their high schools
The book was and is well-received.
The film, more tepidly so, but not for the reasons you might think. The script is much more Robert Bolt than Boris Pasternak, and Russians see it as an Englishman writing about the way English people would act and speak, just wearing costumes. It's not that they HATE the film, it's just that, as one Russian critic said, "it's a lovely story...it just isn't a RUSSIAN story." One weird example of an English-language period film set in that era that resonates with them and that they DO gobble up is 1971's NICHOLAS AND ALEXANDRA.
Does anyone know if the March at the beginning has a name
Expecting to see Barry Hussien O marching into this scene. Pure Saul Alinsky. Unfortunately the presswas to busy going thru Sarah Palin garbage to look into BO's radical past.
Fast forward three years, a-hole. Sooo much better (sarcasm).
Where is ' home' ?
👒👸🏻😬💗
OK
How would be a comnander of russia - it is a hard road
"Comraids" the western world is such a fucking mess bro
Battlefield 1
fucking booozhewahh
The Soviet Union
Miĺio of russian died
usando dinheiro publico via universidade ... e ainda querem cobrar o filme !!!
Patton was right, we shoulda marched right into Moscow in '45
Like you would stand a chance...
swatbot2611 Dropped a couple of Fat Mans and Little Boys on the steppes, Russians woulda lined the streets 10 deep to watch our Sherman tanks roll into Moscow. We'd all be living on the moons of Saturn by now.
RideMyTruck Sure, because the US had a "couple" of those back then... Not only that, but I bet you could throw as many nukes as you want and the russians wouldn't give up. They would just keep fighting... I guess that's the one thing history has taught us for sure about them: They don't give up that easily. And seeing how the USSR had the largest army back then, and how most of the western forces were very tired out, I don't see how your little shit plan could work, specially seeing how the soviets already were inside Project Manhattan and were starting to develop their own nukes.
And, oh yeah, your 'idea" would've been absolutly pointless. Doing that would be beyond stupid and would serve no purpose at all. All the blood shed in WWII was more than enough for everyone. You should be glad that the leaders of the US were smart enough not to do such horrible thing. One massive murder of innocent civillians in their hands was enough, I guess...
And by the way, how can you talk of genocide with such ease? What kind of sick fuck are you?
swatbot2611 Dude, wanna talk genocide? Lets talk Stalin's Gulags. 30 milllion? Couple of Fat Mans and Lil Boys woulda ended all of that...Like I said, Russkies woulda lined the streets of Mascow 10 deep just to watch our Shermans roll by...Truman was a TOTAL chicken sh$#.
RideMyTruck "Couple of Fat Mans and Lil Boys" would've murdered thousands, millions of innocent Russians as well. That would make the US just as good as Stalin.
In fact, the US government already is...
One crime doesn't justify another, you sick fuck. The Axis Crimes were no justification for the horrible crimes of the Allies such as the bombardment of Dresden, the rape of German women by Soviet Troops, Hiroshima and Nagasaki... That made the Allies just as "good" as the Axis.
God, I can't stand ignorants like you who can't show any respect or empathy for human life and sacrifice. How old are you?! 12?! If so, shut the fuck up. If not, grow the fuck up!
inlove and hate this film
a morir x el zar y los poderosos de su pais
rjun67 You, madame (or sir, as the case may be,) are a lout, posting descriptions of videos that are insulting at best and racist at worst. On some of them, your descriptions are of such vile quality they bring criticisms that you are too cowardly to leave up, but instead close the comment sections.
Ithink comrade Petrov, was the first k.g.b.,officer,agent,always obedient to the Bolshevik party,,