Just like the "Black Sun" the Empire was invested in keeping fear in the Imeprial territories to validate its existance and 'PROTECTION" of the innocent worlds. Another excellent video. Thanks for your analysis.
That would be bad for the rebels. Pirates were seen by the galaxy as greedy and ruthless murderers who will kill innocent people for their own financial gain. If the Rebel Alliance employed the help of pirates this make less people willing to join their cause.
The reason why the Empire let these pirates continue their illegal operations was because of corruption. Although the Empire prided itself as not having the rampant corruption of its predecessor the Galactic Republic it was still there and all these pirates had to do is pass a few credits to an Imperial customs officer for them to turn a blind eye.Another factor is that the Empire's base of power came from the Core and Mid Rim worlds and the pirates operated largely in the Outer Rim and most high ranking officials in the Empire saw the people of the Outer Rim as backwards and not having any value to the Empire as a whole.
What if the empire used the battle droids and vehicles from the CIS and reprogrammed the droids to serve them Star Wars:Rethink and yes I know this is unlikely but c'mon I find it quite creative lol
A rebel cell and a pirate band might operate in a very similar manner. One grabs resources for their own profit the other to support and finance a revolution. If commerce raiding also shrinks the Empire's tax base it's a win win for the insurgent. Pirates sell their loot on the black market and rebels would certainly be among the buyers for illegal arms and captured star ships they'd need. Some rebel cells, like Saw Gerrera's, would use any means necessary to win and the Rebel Alliance is a "big tent" coalition. Star Wars usually centers around the Heroes of the Rebellion rather than the "Inglorious Bastards" in their ranks. The entire light side vs. dark side absolutism makes perfect sense for force users in universe, but it is ridiculous when applied to people and governments in general.
In Tie Fighter PC game, several pirates met their end by the player. But they made the mistake of attacking first, or being where the Empire wanted to be.
One of these days, you're going to have to explain why the hell the Rebellion was so small (no false-flag attacks theory or "they had 1984 style surveillance and would punish your friends and family for even suspected treachery." The text doesn't support those)
New Rethink Videos Please Lore Guy: What if the empire mass produced Thrawn's Tie Defender Elite Star Fighter program? What if the Rebellion stole and used Thrawn's Tie Defender Elite star fighters against the empire? What if the Republic had and used Thrawn's Tie Defender Elite throughout the clone wars? What if the Separatists had and used Thrawn's Tie Defender Elite during the clone wars? What if the First + Final Orders used Thrawn's Tie Defender Elite star fighter? What if the Resistance used Thrawn's Tie Defender Elite against the first + final orders? What if Order 66 was a complete success? = What if all the Jedi were completely purged during order 66, without any survivors? What if the empire + Death Star, Tarkin never destroyed Alderaan? What if the clone army of the grand army of the republic was much larger? = in the hundreds of millions or billions? What if the Mandalorians joined the war on the republic’s side against the CIS? What if clone wars went on much longer than it did? = 6 to 10 years or so? What if the clone army was far more advance? = had better armour + equipment, technology and weapons? What if Thrawn won at Lothal? What if Anakin Skywalker/Vader redeemed in return of the Jedi lived/survived? What if the First Order used a Clone army too? What if the First Order used Dark Troopers? What if the First Order was far more sensible in operating strategically? What operation Cinder never happened? = the empire decides not to do this stupid plan of Sidious? What if the Zillo beast survived? What if the 332nd division fought off the inhibitor chip + sided with Ahsoka and Rex, and all survived? What if the clone army turned on Sidious after order 66? = during the reorganization of the first galactic empire? What if the empire never decided to build the death stars? What if the Yuuzhan Vong invaded during the era of the empire? What if the Yuuzhan Vong invaded during the post empire period? What if the Yuuzhan Vong invaded during the sequel trilogy? What if the Rebel Alliance had Starhawks during the whole galactic civil war period? What if the empire won at Jakku? What if the empire decided to make peace with the rebellion? What if the rebellion decided to surrender and make peace with the empire? What if the empire decided to build its ships’ bridges deep inside the hull? = instead of the outside for practicality? What if the empire had Resurgent class star destroyers during its era? What if the republic had and used imperial class star destroyers during the clone wars era? What if the republic had and used Resurgent class star destroyers during the clone wars era? What if the new republic never disbanded it's armies right after the galactic civil war and kept its forces active for possible future threats throughout the galaxy = like in legends? What if Boba Fett joined the rebel alliance? What if the outer rim sieges during the clone wars failed for the republic? What if the Separatists surrendered earlier during the clone wars and made peace with the Republic? What if Sidious never reorganized the republic in the galactic empire? = kept the republic intact after the clone wars as a democracy? What if the Unknown regions were much easier to access for the rest of the galaxy to explore and settle for resources? What if the Tie Hunter was mass produced by the empire? What if the Empire mass produced the Tie Phantom? What if the clones had phase 2 armour by the start of the clone wars? What if the Galactic Republic operated far more strategically during the clone wars as modern armies do? What if the 2nd Death Star was fully completed before the start of the battle of Endor? What if Fives survived? What if Jango Fett survived? What if the battle of Geonosis never happened? = What if the republic just rescued the Jedi and withdrawn instead? What if Kenobi never discovered Kamino? = What if Kenobi never found Geonosis? What if Palpatine never gained the emergency powers? What if the whole clone army used full body covered Beskar armour? = Mandalorain style What if the unknown regions were easier to access during the time of the Republic? What if the Republic never disbanded its armies after 1000 BBY? What if all the Jedi escaped and survived order 66? What if Anakin/Vader never got burned on Mustafar? What if the rebellion lost at the battle of Endor? What if the empire won at Jakuu?
Well, I guess that part about the empire glassing an entire planet full of pirates never happened because disney decanonized it. It was one of the first star wars books I read when I was a kid.
It looks like the galaxy had a chronic problem with being able to provide security across all it terrority. It's why so many citizens seemed to have easy access to at least some kind of weapon. Why transports of just about every kind had some serious fire power for non military roles.
Hey listen I have a question about Star Wars Battlefront 2 and google doesn't help me: when you play Battlefront 2, can you actually choose your side and era like you could in the 2004 Battlefront?
If I'm an Imperial governor in charge of a remote Imperial mining world, having to fulfil mining quotas using whatever limited resources provided, I would have hired a few of those various pirate factions to be some sort of a private military contractor. With what money to pay them? Well, squirrel some spares from the exceeded mining quotas imposed to pay off those pirates and turn a blind eye to their illegal businesses. Why break the law when you can impose your own law over your own fiefdom? Use the faction rivalries against each other. Just make sure it doesn't turn into a full-fledged gang war. That will be disastrous and be a potential Rebel safe haven and recruitment pool... Only when a modicum of security is prevalent in the system, which will definitely be the envy of neighbouring systems, then can move on to become a Sector Moff (with a secret private military outside the Imperial's jurisdiction)..
The Empire + The Pirates + The Hutts = Love/Hate Relationship between the three parties. Is this correct, someone pelase tell me. Star Wars Rethink: What if the clones launched a military coup to depose Palpatine and place someone who is actually care about them in the position of the Supreme Chancellor?
HMMMMM All this "Empires makes up shit to keep the citizens compliant" sounds familiar. Its as if a government over blowing a situation to grab power is something we should all be familiar with.
Hope you all enjoy! Please do drop a like if so and have a great day! :)
twitter.com/TheLoreGuy
Pirates and Crime Syndicates often have free reign when the Empire came into power.
I kinda feel bad for Hondo. His whole gang got wiped. Leaving him as the sole survivor.
One of the best characters, I really hope he comes back.
aye he was my fave non force user from the clone wars series and again in rebels hope we see him in the bad batch
@Tautha De Danan this says otherwise:starwars.fandom.com/wiki/Ohnaka_Transport_Solutions
@Tautha De Danan well clearly he survived otherwise he wouldn’t be mentioned by the time of the sequels
I miss my boy Embo
Just like the "Black Sun" the Empire was invested in keeping fear in the Imeprial territories to validate its existance and 'PROTECTION" of the innocent worlds. Another excellent video. Thanks for your analysis.
Simple. Hondo Onaka simply cut a deal. What else is a good respectable businessman supposed to do ehh?
If I were part of a Rebel cell, I would definitely pose as a pirate to loot Imperial cargo for a wide spread rebellion
That would be bad for the rebels. Pirates were seen by the galaxy as greedy and ruthless murderers who will kill innocent people for their own financial gain. If the Rebel Alliance employed the help of pirates this make less people willing to join their cause.
Then they'd come after you. Pirates were only safe when not attacking Imperial assets.
@@thorpeaaron1110 I guess Letters of Marque don’t exist in this galaxy
@@akumaking1 Nope
@@akumaking1 Because the Rebel Alliance is considered an insurgency they cannot issue Letters of Marque
The reason why the Empire let these pirates continue their illegal operations was because of corruption. Although the Empire prided itself as not having the rampant corruption of its predecessor the Galactic Republic it was still there and all these pirates had to do is pass a few credits to an Imperial customs officer for them to turn a blind eye.Another factor is that the Empire's base of power came from the Core and Mid Rim worlds and the pirates operated largely in the Outer Rim and most high ranking officials in the Empire saw the people of the Outer Rim as backwards and not having any value to the Empire as a whole.
agree :)
Please make more videos! We need you back! Does anyone know Why he stopped?
Because a goverment wants to fight a problem , not solve the problem. When you solve a problem you lose the money dedicated to fighting the problem
In a nutshell. 👍
Could anyone please tell me the name of the song in the background of these videos?
What if the empire used the battle droids and vehicles from the CIS and reprogrammed the droids to serve them Star Wars:Rethink and yes I know this is unlikely but c'mon I find it quite creative lol
I still feel EmBaRrAsEd because I never mention this to my family cuz yeah, I want them to see it themselves
I think if piracy is a problem you can always call any insurgent "pirate", which is a better looking target than a "freedom fighter"
1:27 I hated that scene in Solo. Why can this random gangster chasing a pair of orphan thieves call upon a bunch of Imperials to help him?
Am glad they did we've done alone because they are so cool and in Star wars and so funny 😅
Wat
@@LindafromHr me too.....me too
I had a stroke trying to read this
A rebel cell and a pirate band might operate in a very similar manner. One grabs resources for their own profit the other to support and finance a revolution. If commerce raiding also shrinks the Empire's tax base it's a win win for the insurgent. Pirates sell their loot on the black market and rebels would certainly be among the buyers for illegal arms and captured star ships they'd need. Some rebel cells, like Saw Gerrera's, would use any means necessary to win and the Rebel Alliance is a "big tent" coalition. Star Wars usually centers around the Heroes of the Rebellion rather than the "Inglorious Bastards" in their ranks. The entire light side vs. dark side absolutism makes perfect sense for force users in universe, but it is ridiculous when applied to people and governments in general.
In Tie Fighter PC game, several pirates met their end by the player. But they made the mistake of attacking first, or being where the Empire wanted to be.
*"Hello There My Friends!"*
One of these days, you're going to have to explain why the hell the Rebellion was so small (no false-flag attacks theory or "they had 1984 style surveillance and would punish your friends and family for even suspected treachery." The text doesn't support those)
*"I like how I'm being avoided her lately thank you TH-cam you make Darth Sidious proud!"*
I bet the empire left alone pirates because they want to keep the hutts
good video homie
New Rethink Videos Please Lore Guy:
What if the empire mass produced Thrawn's Tie Defender Elite Star Fighter program?
What if the Rebellion stole and used Thrawn's Tie Defender Elite star fighters against the empire?
What if the Republic had and used Thrawn's Tie Defender Elite throughout the clone wars?
What if the Separatists had and used Thrawn's Tie Defender Elite during the clone wars?
What if the First + Final Orders used Thrawn's Tie Defender Elite star fighter?
What if the Resistance used Thrawn's Tie Defender Elite against the first + final orders?
What if Order 66 was a complete success? = What if all the Jedi were completely purged during order 66, without any survivors?
What if the empire + Death Star, Tarkin never destroyed Alderaan?
What if the clone army of the grand army of the republic was much larger? = in the hundreds of millions or billions?
What if the Mandalorians joined the war on the republic’s side against the CIS?
What if clone wars went on much longer than it did? = 6 to 10 years or so?
What if the clone army was far more advance? = had better armour + equipment, technology and weapons?
What if Thrawn won at Lothal?
What if Anakin Skywalker/Vader redeemed in return of the Jedi lived/survived?
What if the First Order used a Clone army too?
What if the First Order used Dark Troopers?
What if the First Order was far more sensible in operating strategically?
What operation Cinder never happened? = the empire decides not to do this stupid plan of Sidious?
What if the Zillo beast survived?
What if the 332nd division fought off the inhibitor chip + sided with Ahsoka and Rex, and all survived?
What if the clone army turned on Sidious after order 66? = during the reorganization of the first galactic empire?
What if the empire never decided to build the death stars?
What if the Yuuzhan Vong invaded during the era of the empire?
What if the Yuuzhan Vong invaded during the post empire period?
What if the Yuuzhan Vong invaded during the sequel trilogy?
What if the Rebel Alliance had Starhawks during the whole galactic civil war period?
What if the empire won at Jakku?
What if the empire decided to make peace with the rebellion?
What if the rebellion decided to surrender and make peace with the empire?
What if the empire decided to build its ships’ bridges deep inside the hull? = instead of the outside for practicality?
What if the empire had Resurgent class star destroyers during its era?
What if the republic had and used imperial class star destroyers during the clone wars era?
What if the republic had and used Resurgent class star destroyers during the clone wars era?
What if the new republic never disbanded it's armies right after the galactic civil war and kept its forces active for possible future threats throughout the galaxy = like in legends?
What if Boba Fett joined the rebel alliance?
What if the outer rim sieges during the clone wars failed for the republic?
What if the Separatists surrendered earlier during the clone wars and made peace with the Republic?
What if Sidious never reorganized the republic in the galactic empire? = kept the republic intact after the clone wars as a democracy?
What if the Unknown regions were much easier to access for the rest of the galaxy to explore and settle for resources?
What if the Tie Hunter was mass produced by the empire?
What if the Empire mass produced the Tie Phantom?
What if the clones had phase 2 armour by the start of the clone wars?
What if the Galactic Republic operated far more strategically during the clone wars as modern armies do?
What if the 2nd Death Star was fully completed before the start of the battle of Endor?
What if Fives survived?
What if Jango Fett survived?
What if the battle of Geonosis never happened? = What if the republic just rescued the Jedi and withdrawn instead?
What if Kenobi never discovered Kamino? = What if Kenobi never found Geonosis?
What if Palpatine never gained the emergency powers?
What if the whole clone army used full body covered Beskar armour? = Mandalorain style
What if the unknown regions were easier to access during the time of the Republic?
What if the Republic never disbanded its armies after 1000 BBY?
What if all the Jedi escaped and survived order 66?
What if Anakin/Vader never got burned on Mustafar?
What if the rebellion lost at the battle of Endor?
What if the empire won at Jakuu?
You like Thrawn huh?
@@One_Point_Safety He's a very interesting character in the Star Wars universe, so yeah.
Well, I guess that part about the empire glassing an entire planet full of pirates never happened because disney decanonized it. It was one of the first star wars books I read when I was a kid.
What if Anakin killed Palpatine?:Star Wars Rethink
he kinda did
@@goodmind4940 I know I'm saying what if he helped Mace Windu and struck Palpatine down
The Empire probably used buccaneers. And great clip 👍🏻
I SMELL PROFIT!!!
It looks like the galaxy had a chronic problem with being able to provide security across all it terrority. It's why so many citizens seemed to have easy access to at least some kind of weapon. Why transports of just about every kind had some serious fire power for non military roles.
Hey listen I have a question about Star Wars Battlefront 2 and google doesn't help me: when you play Battlefront 2, can you actually choose your side and era like you could in the 2004 Battlefront?
No
Except in coop
21 months ago
If I'm an Imperial governor in charge of a remote Imperial mining world, having to fulfil mining quotas using whatever limited resources provided, I would have hired a few of those various pirate factions to be some sort of a private military contractor. With what money to pay them? Well, squirrel some spares from the exceeded mining quotas imposed to pay off those pirates and turn a blind eye to their illegal businesses. Why break the law when you can impose your own law over your own fiefdom?
Use the faction rivalries against each other. Just make sure it doesn't turn into a full-fledged gang war. That will be disastrous and be a potential Rebel safe haven and recruitment pool... Only when a modicum of security is prevalent in the system, which will definitely be the envy of neighbouring systems, then can move on to become a Sector Moff (with a secret private military outside the Imperial's jurisdiction)..
I got a lore video for you to think about what if the empire never wasted military assets under the new emperor thrawn
I really like the way this guy thinks.
The Empire + The Pirates + The Hutts = Love/Hate Relationship between the three parties. Is this correct, someone pelase tell me.
Star Wars Rethink: What if the clones launched a military coup to depose Palpatine and place someone who is actually care about them in the position of the Supreme Chancellor?
What if luke becomes a sith or what if there will be sith academy
i wonder what will happen if palpatine subjugate the jedi order?
What if padme became chancellor after the clone was.
HMMMMM All this "Empires makes up shit to keep the citizens compliant" sounds familiar. Its as if a government over blowing a situation to grab power is something we should all be familiar with.
I will have take a Gozanti with 4 Tie Ln or Tie Interceptor and Free the Imperials who want freedom the other well
This is why the kotor empire is better than the galactic empire from the original trilogy
What if Star Wars had a Communist Revolution in the Industrial Worlds during the Republic?
3:54
I could write a book on things you say a lot.