I am unable to pick a side since l thoroughly have been enjoying both the output of Waters and Gilmour within and without Pink Floyd. Waters ranks among my favourite modern poets for the profound impact of his writing. The current reality is what it is.
Roger Waters was an essential part of Pink Floyd, but he was not Pink Floyd. The best example of this is that atrocity he released under the name "The Dark Side of the Moon Redux". He wanted to convince people that he was the mastermind behind the classic Dark Side of the Moon all along and that the other band members were disposable... Man, was he wrong.
Call me full of shit, but I knew that "Redux" would be shite even before I started listening. About 5 min. of it was all that I could take of that disaster. David, and to a lesser extent Rick, were the most talented Musicians in Floyd. David was always the Master and Craftsman in the Studio. Without his talents, the Band would have never reached the heights of The Dark Side and Wish You Were Here. Even the execution of The Wall owed a lot to his Musical Skills and Production chops. And he proved it with the Two Post-Waters proper Albums. As stated by others, the Lyrical content was always David's main weakness, but he's still a much more complete Musician than Roger ever was...
@@lsrocha3296 You're absolutely right, of course. He's not even an exceptional bassist. He's revealed his true nature over the years, that of a bad guy. He said himself that his solo career is a disaster, and that's saying a lot. His albums are duller than the rain.
It should be noted Nick Mason is totally neutral in the Floyd Wars--he played with Roger on his 2006 tour and Roger joined him on stage in NY during Nick's version of Early Floyd on tour. Nick also is the ONE last member legally entitled to the name PINK FLOYD. . Dave is still a 'member" of Pink floyd but chooses to say that entity is no longer valid.
You could never accuse the Floyd of being dull . I live near Cambridge the home of Pink Floyd , 3 of the band grew up here ( including Syd ) . Their music will never die .
You could say that for David and Rick too. The Floyd’s best music had important contributions from all three of them. Animals and The Wall are weaker without a significant contribution from Wright. The Final Cut is the weakest without significant contributions from Gilmour and Wright. The Division Bell’s weakness is lyrics and lack of unified vision from the absence of Waters. However, musically The Division Bell is stronger than any Waters post-Floyd album which shows the importance of Dave’s and Rick’s musical gifts.
It goes to show you just how powerful, relevant and popular Pink Floyd's discography is. Waters & Gilmour played together from sometime in 1968 to sometime in Feb/March 1983 when The Final Cut was released. Approx 15 years. In 2025 it will mark FORTY (40) years since they were bandmates yet people still ask them, "Will you guys ever play/record together again?" Forty years of them saying, "No! Not a chance..." Imagine being at your 40th Wedding Anniversary party and people keep asking you if you'll ever give your old Freshman year High School girlfriend a call. Asking, if you'll ever get back together? LOL
PF's music was not just music, it was, a state of being, a deep feeling that changed many many lives. PF post Waters was very ordinary music ! Those who know, know!!
Haha! Speaking as another of that vintage, I must have heard it along with The Division Bell, which a girlfriend insisted were worthy. It sounded like diluted tosh. The best non-PF album imho (it could've been placed between DSOTM and WYWH as a 'lost' PF outing) was Gilmour's eponymous first solo album.
sad finish, he proved with his life that PF is much bigger than him. Once a nice talented guy turned into radical activist. I guess he was rotten inside from the beginning. Success with PF, dictatorship within the band, lost legal battle and ego of the size of universe just made his situation worse. You have to be a good guy from the beginning to age well with all the fame and money he got. Sad
Roger is an egomaniac. That's what killed the first Pink Floyd. The second coming of Pink Floyd was awesome also. Roger thought he was Pink and he wasn't.
Rough Waters? More like a Maelstrom. Hypnotizing and deadly. Just as Icarus reached for the sun, Roger wanted to BE the machine. Despite the turbulence, PF breathed life into a creation much greater than music.
Post Barret Floyd was a combination of Water's sharp song writing, Gilmour's melodic guitar playing and Wright's unique soundscapes. Take any of those elements away and the band is no longer complete. I have often heard it said that 'Animals' was the last truly great PF album. I have to agree. It is also often said that 'The Wall' built a wall between Waters and his bandmates. We can speculate how true that is or how much of that wall already existed. What we do know why that post-Barret Floyd never recovered from that album.
4:05 that was when Roger Waters tried to change Pink Floyd to Spoken Word but couldn't due to the fact that he did not have ANY rights with the band anymore
There were 3 different Pink Floyds, the Syd Barrett era, the Waters/Gilmour era (The Wall, Animals and The Final Cut dominated by Waters) and finally the David Gilmour era.
Love Pink Floyd , awesome band . The Final Cut was a poor , Rogers solo album using the others as studio musicians was bound to alienate the others who hated it . The band didn't belong to Roger , the 3 others had a majority so quite rightly carried on after the rift . Roger is a spikey chap who wants his own way no matter what , he's difficult to deal with . A talent for sure but a single minded man .
Roger is indeed a complex character . He rails against the status quo but has become part of it helped by his £250M fortune . David , however , has been a great charitable doner giving £35M away to mainly homeless charities. Anyway it's all about the music for me , a David Gilmour guitar solo is a beautiful thing . I've seen people in tears during his many superb solos , nobody plays the guitar like David . A musical genius.
Thank You , I listen to Pink Floyd all the time and its music videos yes music videos! Roger Waters and Pink Floyd David Gilmour and Pink Floyd have kept my life going almost forever and since I’ve been somewhere on the brink I have to attest that Pink Floyd is my music video knights.. thanks yall….. yes it is heartfell
The 1980s claimed many creative bands from the 70s. Floyd were just one of them. People can blame fame or pressure but it was the 80s, which was unfriendly to anything they deemed "dated", which was almost everything in the 70s golden era of rock. Also, the other players in the band were more accomplished musicians than Roger, helping to give Roger's lyrical ideas brilliant musical support.
I think it’s tragic how egos, monetary royalties etc and the lack of being able to both speak and listen to each other created such a toxic situation. Any PF member could have continued in the band and created their own music independently remaining an awesome band member and musician that they are. ❤
It is amazing, for all their genius, ....sigh. Why not let John make a version of a song and have it on his album and Paul make his version of it on HIS album and it looks like George would like to put out an album and if you sell them all as Beatles albums , you'd probably rake in more. Even the souless studio executives are happier. Not justhe artieests. Anyway, the Final Cut is Roger's and I think he should tweak A Momentary Lapse of Reason if he likes, cause I love that album and would like to see what he would alter. THe Gunner's Dream is outstanding on the Final Cut if you haven't listened to it.
"...and I think he should tweak A Momentary Lapse of Reason if he likes, cause I love that album and would like to see what he would alter." You are out of your mind. First of all, he holds no Rights whatsoever to that Music. Secondly, based on the Redux of the Dark side, he would simply butcher the Music!
I never was able to see all four together, but I was at the Gilmour led Floyd 1987 & 1994 shows in Philly, and then 1999 (Hershey) and 2010, and 2017 Roger Waters shows in Philly again. ALL shows were amazing, but I will have to admit that Rogers shows had that edge! (Especially the 2010 show which was The Wall) But the 1999 show showcased his entire career, and it was amazing to hear the final cut tracks live! A word on that album... the final cut was a Roger Waters album PERFORMED by Pink Floyd (other than the last track which has Andy Newmark on drums) What bugs me is most people try to lump that in as a Pink Floyd album. IT ISN'T! Listen to it with different ears, and you will LOVE this amazing release!
Rodger was the main problem there he wanted to control everybody him growing up without a dad was a very bad thing he developed habits on his own whether they was good or bad he need to realize he cannot control people he want to dismantle a band and what are the other players are supposed to do go and try to find another job because he want to dismantle the band he need to be thanking God that those two black men families have not sued him for using their relative name because it is public that it has been admitted where they got the name at I know it's a common name but he clearly stated who he took those names from so he really need to gather his thought and sit his butt down somewhere before he gets sued because if they were my relatives the two black men he was still being court today. And I've always said when David joined the band Rogers felt like that he can control him and everything but David did not let Rogers run over him. Rogers need to realize that David helped make that band as well, David has undescribable guitar skills. When a father does not have a relationship with his children that tells you something right there. And you cannot keep a wife and at his age he should know better 80 years on the planet and you have not done nothing positive.
Replacing Gilmour with another player is not that difficult . There are enough guitarplayers who can play as good or even better than Gilmour . However finding the sweet spot & blending in with Waters ideas is a different story as a player . And all the guys in the band just did that . But I doubt very much that there would have ever been a DSOTM , Wish, Animals, Wall without Waters. The other guys don't have enough imagination for that , but they play good within' their place.
Copying a guitarplayer is one thing, coming up with these amazing guitarparts (and having a great singing voice at the same time!!!) is a whole different story! 😉
Well that’s your opinion, but I disagree. Gilmore’s solo on Comfortably Numb is noted as being the greatest guitar solo EVER. There is no shredding or what have you in this solo, but the soul of his playing is what gave him this position. Legendary guitar players worldwide have stated that Gilmore has achieved this status because I quote ‘ he achieves more in one note than others do in a hundred ‘FACT - Gilmore not only played guitar on so many tracks but also played bass on the studio album recordings. The fact of the matter is the band WAS a collective effort. I respect Dave for choosing not to play Echoes ever again after Ricks death. Such is the respect David has for Richard. BTW, bass is my favourite instrument.
@@rachels209 Agree totally . What I mean is that other guitar players can play exactly the same notes and as good , but inventing the same is another story . I've seen Pink Floyd live with Gilmour & I have seen Roger his shows & Nick his shows . Dave Kilminster who plays David's stuff can play as good . I've seen him also perform with Steven Wilson. But as said ' comming up with the ideas of guitarparts is Davids work .
@@joequackenbush4125 Numerous players can play as good or better : Jeff Beck , Brian May , Eric Clapton , Guthrie Govan , Al di Meola . Even Dave Kilminster plays note for note and articulation as good . I would even say that Gilmour his solo at Roger Waters concert of The Wall in 2011 during Comfortable Numb was not good , or he did it on purpose . Several notes he plays are off especially at the beginning.
I always find it amazing that so many think they are capable to judge Roger. I don’t care what anyone thinks about him as a human being, btw I absolutely adore him in that respect, however when it comes to him as creator of music I think he is a level above all the rest, a true genius. Pink Floyd would have never been what it is without Roger. The Final Cat an absolute masterpiece, pretty much every record in there a great work of art. Think of the Postwar Dream, the Heroes Return, When the Tigers broke Free, Two suns in the sunset, the Final Cut and so on. And I think we ought to be thankful that we lived in the same era as Roger did. I am for sure. Thank you Roger Waters, and as much as I would love to, I know I can never thank you enough.
After the Animals album, there was no longer PF. Only a massively Inflated ego and a Control freak, using the others members' talents for his own benefit. So yeah, Pink Floyd was better off without him, because he was no longer a true Band Member...
It took ALL the members of Pink Floyd to have the sound that has been going for 50 years. Water's lyrics were a part of it. The sum was greater than the pieces
You can't just blame 1 person it was all or nothing just like the kinks the stones the Beatles these bands inhanced your lives stop the crap of I know what I would have done NO YOU DON'T!
I am unable to pick a side since l thoroughly have been enjoying both the output of Waters and Gilmour within and without Pink Floyd. Waters ranks among my favourite modern poets for the profound impact of his writing. The current reality is what it is.
Roger Waters was an essential part of Pink Floyd, but he was not Pink Floyd. The best example of this is that atrocity he released under the name "The Dark Side of the Moon Redux". He wanted to convince people that he was the mastermind behind the classic Dark Side of the Moon all along and that the other band members were disposable... Man, was he wrong.
'Redux' is a disgusting shit, yes.
Call me full of shit, but I knew that "Redux" would be shite even before I started listening. About 5 min. of it was all that I could take of that disaster. David, and to a lesser extent Rick, were the most talented Musicians in Floyd. David was always the Master and Craftsman in the Studio.
Without his talents, the Band would have never reached the heights of The Dark Side and Wish You Were Here. Even the execution of The Wall owed a lot to his Musical Skills and Production chops.
And he proved it with the Two Post-Waters proper Albums. As stated by others, the Lyrical content was always David's main weakness, but he's still a much more complete Musician than Roger ever was...
@@lsrocha3296 You're absolutely right, of course. He's not even an exceptional bassist. He's revealed his true nature over the years, that of a bad guy. He said himself that his solo career is a disaster, and that's saying a lot. His albums are duller than the rain.
It should be noted Nick Mason is totally neutral in the Floyd Wars--he played with Roger on his 2006 tour and Roger joined him on stage in NY during Nick's version of Early Floyd on tour. Nick also is the ONE last member legally entitled to the name PINK FLOYD. . Dave is still a 'member" of Pink floyd but chooses to say that entity is no longer valid.
You could never accuse the Floyd of being dull . I live near Cambridge the home of Pink Floyd , 3 of the band grew up here ( including Syd ) . Their music will never die .
If Roger Waters wasn't there Pink Floyd could never exist
Without Gilmour replacing Syd with his distinctive guitar sound and vocals, Pink Floyd would have faded into obscurity.
@@jjvermeer True but Dave needed rogers lyrics
Yes!!!
It took all of them to get that sound. When someone left or was marginalized, you can really hear the difference.
You could say that for David and Rick too. The Floyd’s best music had important contributions from all three of them. Animals and The Wall are weaker without a significant contribution from Wright. The Final Cut is the weakest without significant contributions from Gilmour and Wright. The Division Bell’s weakness is lyrics and lack of unified vision from the absence of Waters. However, musically The Division Bell is stronger than any Waters post-Floyd album which shows the importance of Dave’s and Rick’s musical gifts.
Now exactly what did he reveal at 80? Nothing in this video anyway… 😢
It goes to show you just how powerful, relevant and popular Pink Floyd's discography is. Waters & Gilmour played together from sometime in 1968 to sometime in Feb/March 1983 when The Final Cut was released. Approx 15 years. In 2025 it will mark FORTY (40) years since they were bandmates yet people still ask them, "Will you guys ever play/record together again?" Forty years of them saying, "No! Not a chance..." Imagine being at your 40th Wedding Anniversary party and people keep asking you if you'll ever give your old Freshman year High School girlfriend a call. Asking, if you'll ever get back together? LOL
@@artman6581 yes but without Rogers charismatic presence, the band is a bit less.
The played together at Live 8 in Hyde Park, London on 2 july 2005..
th-cam.com/video/xVQTKSWULu8/w-d-xo.htmlsi=-BJw3Cb9a4W5P_K2
@@jillgocher3445 when Roger left Pink Floyd their music was never the same again. A bit dull so to say.
@@sjaoolexactly! ole dave has no charisma
PF's music was not just music, it was, a state of being, a deep feeling that changed many many lives. PF post Waters was very ordinary music ! Those who know, know!!
@@pankajawasthimusic exactly
Nah, I disagree, after Waters left, A Momentary Lapse of Reason and The Division Bell were as good as earlier albums.
I grew up with PF and Waters definately built a wall that will never be penetrated.
Love you Roger
The final cut . The only album I've given away ever . I'm 64 !
A terrible album. Even worse than The Wall...
In your opinion. One of the best.
Haha! Speaking as another of that vintage, I must have heard it along with The Division Bell, which a girlfriend insisted were worthy. It sounded like diluted tosh. The best non-PF album imho (it could've been placed between DSOTM and WYWH as a 'lost' PF outing) was Gilmour's eponymous first solo album.
The only two albums I've ever given away were A Momentary Lapse Of Reason and Amused To Death.
@@DaveWaters-qd9bn I agree. It`s very true.
sad finish, he proved with his life that PF is much bigger than him.
Once a nice talented guy turned into radical activist. I guess he was rotten inside from the beginning.
Success with PF, dictatorship within the band, lost legal battle and ego of the size of universe just made his situation worse.
You have to be a good guy from the beginning to age well with all the fame and money he got.
Sad
Very well said
Roger is an egomaniac. That's what killed the first Pink Floyd. The second coming of Pink Floyd was awesome also. Roger thought he was Pink and he wasn't.
You like to think so.... Cut the crap
@@ayiorgos Do you really think Roger was the only one in the group? The other three made the music.
@@Buddha-of8fk Roger was the 80% in the group
@@ayiorgos No only 25 %, he thought he was more important than he was. Where would Pink Floyd be without the other three?
It's what makes envy and jealousy! Because Roger was the head and heart, the composer and conductor!
Roger Waters is loosing his mind. "doctor, doctor - what is wrong with me".
Rough Waters? More like a Maelstrom. Hypnotizing and deadly.
Just as Icarus reached for the sun, Roger wanted to BE the machine.
Despite the turbulence, PF breathed life into a creation much greater than music.
Post Barret Floyd was a combination of Water's sharp song writing, Gilmour's melodic guitar playing and Wright's unique soundscapes. Take any of those elements away and the band is no longer complete.
I have often heard it said that 'Animals' was the last truly great PF album. I have to agree. It is also often said that 'The Wall' built a wall between Waters and his bandmates. We can speculate how true that is or how much of that wall already existed. What we do know why that post-Barret Floyd never recovered from that album.
4:05 that was when Roger Waters tried to change Pink Floyd to Spoken Word but couldn't due to the fact that he did not have ANY rights with the band anymore
When you value money over artistic expression the outcome is always depressing
There were 3 different Pink Floyds, the Syd Barrett era, the Waters/Gilmour era (The Wall, Animals and The Final Cut dominated by Waters) and finally the David Gilmour era.
Waters has had mental health issues for long time, he was also upset the band continued without him, he seems quite unhinged now
Love Pink Floyd , awesome band . The Final Cut was a poor , Rogers solo album using the others as studio musicians was bound to alienate the others who hated it . The band didn't belong to Roger , the 3 others had a majority so quite rightly carried on after the rift . Roger is a spikey chap who wants his own way no matter what , he's difficult to deal with . A talent for sure but a single minded man .
yes but the band is so dull without him
Non compliant unlike most and speaks uncomfortable truths!
I blame his ex
Roger is indeed a complex character . He rails against the status quo but has become part of it helped by his £250M fortune . David , however , has been a great charitable doner giving £35M away to mainly homeless charities. Anyway it's all about the music for me , a David Gilmour guitar solo is a beautiful thing . I've seen people in tears during his many superb solos , nobody plays the guitar like David . A musical genius.
@@rizreid8670 get over it!
Roger is great but Hitchhiking sucks.
Wish you were here animals. The narration is a treat.
Thank You , I listen to Pink Floyd all the time and its music videos yes music videos! Roger Waters and Pink Floyd David Gilmour and Pink Floyd have kept my life going almost forever and since I’ve been somewhere on the brink I have to attest that Pink Floyd is my music video knights.. thanks yall….. yes it is heartfell
The 1980s claimed many creative bands from the 70s. Floyd were just one of them. People can blame fame or pressure but it was the 80s, which was unfriendly to anything they deemed "dated", which was almost everything in the 70s golden era of rock. Also, the other players in the band were more accomplished musicians than Roger, helping to give Roger's lyrical ideas brilliant musical support.
Queen is an exception
Roger Waters is an icon of peace, I've followed him and Floyd since the 1960s, keep going Roger, I support you 100%
I think it’s tragic how egos, monetary royalties etc and the lack of being able to both speak and listen to each other created such a toxic situation. Any PF member could have continued in the band and created their own music independently remaining an awesome band member and musician that they are. ❤
I like Roger. He knows all wars are banker wars.
his U.S. and Them tour😂😅
Excellent documentary anyway👍
So, what did he reveal?
It is amazing, for all their genius, ....sigh.
Why not let John make a version of a song and have it on his album
and Paul make his version of it on HIS album
and it looks like George would like to put out an album
and if you sell them all as Beatles albums , you'd probably rake in more.
Even the souless studio executives are happier. Not justhe artieests.
Anyway, the Final Cut is Roger's and I think he should tweak A Momentary Lapse of Reason if he likes, cause I love that album and would like to see what he would alter. THe Gunner's Dream is outstanding on the Final Cut if you haven't listened to it.
"...and I think he should tweak A Momentary Lapse of Reason if he likes, cause I love that album and would like to see what he would alter."
You are out of your mind. First of all, he holds no Rights whatsoever to that Music. Secondly, based on the Redux of the Dark side, he would simply butcher the Music!
Pink floyd killed the art of dancing
Brain cells started dancing ...Didn't you notice?
..I just listen to their great music..
I never was able to see all four together, but I was at the Gilmour led Floyd 1987 & 1994 shows in Philly, and then 1999 (Hershey) and 2010, and 2017 Roger Waters shows in Philly again. ALL shows were amazing, but I will have to admit that Rogers shows had that edge! (Especially the 2010 show which was The Wall) But the 1999 show showcased his entire career, and it was amazing to hear the final cut tracks live! A word on that album... the final cut was a Roger Waters album PERFORMED by Pink Floyd (other than the last track which has Andy Newmark on drums) What bugs me is most people try to lump that in as a Pink Floyd album. IT ISN'T! Listen to it with different ears, and you will LOVE this amazing release!
Roger Waters doesn't reveal anything due to lack of interview.
Rodger was the main problem there he wanted to control everybody him growing up without a dad was a very bad thing he developed habits on his own whether they was good or bad he need to realize he cannot control people he want to dismantle a band and what are the other players are supposed to do go and try to find another job because he want to dismantle the band he need to be thanking God that those two black men families have not sued him for using their relative name because it is public that it has been admitted where they got the name at I know it's a common name but he clearly stated who he took those names from so he really need to gather his thought and sit his butt down somewhere before he gets sued because if they were my relatives the two black men he was still being court today. And I've always said when David joined the band Rogers felt like that he can control him and everything but David did not let Rogers run over him. Rogers need to realize that David helped make that band as well, David has undescribable guitar skills. When a father does not have a relationship with his children that tells you something right there. And you cannot keep a wife and at his age he should know better 80 years on the planet and you have not done nothing positive.
Genesis 12:3 applies to you Roger!
Not Water under the bridge.
Nasty.
They didn't tour much
" what we all feared " 🤣😁😆😅😄😉😗
Great greatest musician
By a Waters fan.
A bunch of old men trying to live their youth again... Just sooo sad, it's time to prepare to meet your Maker
Paints a pretty picture.
Waters drown
rodger is just that a rodger, never cared for him !!!!!!!
You can tell who the healthnut was in THAT group. They guy looks fuckin' fantastic and still has his power.
Replacing Gilmour with another player is not that difficult . There are enough guitarplayers who can play as good or even better than Gilmour . However finding the sweet spot & blending in with Waters ideas is a different story as a player . And all the guys in the band just did that .
But I doubt very much that there would have ever been a DSOTM , Wish, Animals, Wall without Waters. The other guys don't have enough imagination for that , but they play good within' their place.
Copying a guitarplayer is one thing, coming up with these amazing guitarparts (and having a great singing voice at the same time!!!) is a whole different story! 😉
Well that’s your opinion, but I disagree. Gilmore’s solo on Comfortably Numb is noted as being the greatest guitar solo EVER. There is no shredding or what have you in this solo, but the soul of his playing is what gave him this position. Legendary guitar players worldwide have stated that Gilmore has achieved this status because I quote ‘ he achieves more in one note than others do in a hundred ‘FACT - Gilmore not only played guitar on so many tracks but also played bass on the studio album recordings. The fact of the matter is the band WAS a collective effort. I respect Dave for choosing not to play Echoes ever again after Ricks death. Such is the respect David has for Richard.
BTW, bass is my favourite instrument.
@@rachels209 Agree totally . What I mean is that other guitar players can play exactly the same notes and as good , but inventing the same is another story . I've seen Pink Floyd live with Gilmour & I have seen Roger his shows & Nick his shows . Dave Kilminster who plays David's stuff can play as good . I've seen him also perform with Steven Wilson. But as said ' comming up with the ideas of guitarparts is Davids work .
@@Spock105 There's not another guitarist on the planet that can articulate a note the way Gilmour does.
@@joequackenbush4125 Numerous players can play as good or better : Jeff Beck , Brian May , Eric Clapton , Guthrie Govan , Al di Meola . Even Dave Kilminster plays note for note and articulation as good . I would even say that Gilmour his solo at Roger Waters concert of The Wall in 2011 during Comfortable Numb was not good , or he did it on purpose . Several notes he plays are off especially at the beginning.
If Roger wasn’t such an acerbic knob, there would be no “feud.”
What à waiste of talent
In 73 TDSOTM hit me.
I didn’t spoke a single word of english.
That’s the album of a whole life.
So, no, art is not only about lyrics’and concepts
It's what makes envy and jealousy! Because Roger was the head and heart, the composer and conductor!
I always find it amazing that so many think they are capable to judge Roger. I don’t care what anyone thinks about him as a human being, btw I absolutely adore him in that respect, however when it comes to him as creator of music I think he is a level above all the rest, a true genius. Pink Floyd would have never been what it is without Roger. The Final Cat an absolute masterpiece, pretty much every record in there a great work of art. Think of the Postwar Dream, the Heroes Return, When the Tigers broke Free, Two suns in the sunset, the Final Cut and so on. And I think we ought to be thankful that we lived in the same era as Roger did. I am for sure. Thank you Roger Waters, and as much as I would love to, I know I can never thank you enough.
Waters is a deeply disturbed and nasty individual
Like it or not the fact is that Roger is doing very well in the front line!
...Roger rules OK?
I find Pink Floyd way better without Roger Waters.
the girl in the yellow dress.... Erm.. Hardly floydian really.. is it..
After the Animals album, there was no longer PF. Only a massively Inflated ego and a Control freak, using the others members' talents for his own benefit. So yeah, Pink Floyd was better off without him, because he was no longer a true Band Member...
Equally talented minds, even in PF was impossible. Let just say, Pink Floyd died when Roger decided step aside and let the name used by other members.
Love you Roger Palestine Will be Free from the River to the Sea. 🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉
Someone stealed Roger ideas and use his invention to make money? Seems like
Gilmour supplied the most important bit ‐great melodic music. Waters just supplied crap lyrics.
It took ALL the members of Pink Floyd to have the sound that has been going for 50 years. Water's lyrics were a part of it. The sum was greater than the pieces
You can't just blame 1 person it was all or nothing just like the kinks the stones the Beatles these bands inhanced your lives stop the crap of I know what I would have done NO YOU DON'T!