Why did the Israelis steal hummus from the Arabs?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 พ.ค. 2012
- The Arab world claims that Israelis stole hummus and claimed it to be just as Israelis as it is Arab. This investigative report interviews the real people who make hummus in Tel Aviv to find out why.
- ตลก
We should open Humus Peace Negotiations.
Don't get angry guys there's enough Hummus for everyone
as a tunisian i prefer the culture of merguez i do not like hummus and that tahini thing that i find it in every fucking middleastern dish ...take the hummus an dleave us our merguez and couscous :)
the power of the couscos :D :)
My grandmother used to make amazing couscous
Chouchou Ccc in israel we used to eat hummus and couscos (;
Thats not the case ! Claiming something that isnt theirs is the problem
i"m Egyptian Muslim .. may be one day we have peace and stop fighting i hope so . all normal ppl want live in peace > frome egypt
yes I hope fore peace and I also hope 1 day we will stop steaing your hummus
i hope so :) . all what we gain frome fighting is more violence and suffering .
smsm semo yes true and the lose of your humis dont forget the humis just kidding i hop one day i ca come visit you in egit and we wont need this stueped war god willing
***** yes becos the chamas youses them as human shiolds
***** na i got the fredom of spech and i think i will youse it so have a good day
wow i could not tell the different from a arab to a jew
then ur blind
Because Arab is a race and Jew is a religion.
There are Arab Jews/Muslims/Christians.
There are White Jews/Muslims/Christians.
Got it?
i like your answer dear jewish cousin...these videos taught me alot as a tunisian about the israelis in their daily life and i find alot of similarity between tunisians mindset and the normal sefarid mindset ...i mean the way of thinking ...and i remarked that you are completley diefferent from the mindset of the eastern arabs who i was surprised to see their llack of conciousness even about their conflict with israel and the conception of what is happening araound them .....i understood why israel is strong and won 4 wars on arabs of the east and i underline the arabs of the east ....you have agreat education system and they a completely destructive education system...zero analytical and critical reasonning...even when he asks them about hummus you see the israeli joke about it but am sure if he asks a palstinian he will take it seriously ...and i understand why my country tunisia succeded in turning into democracy and the rest to chaos ...not because of israel planned that as much naives think but because of the lack of real informed and thinking socities...in such a case even if israel did not exist at all i think they would have the same wars and misery ...no freedom no education gives us walking deads ...even teir understanding of religion of islam is so superficial and bothering ...i wonder those who build al andalus can not be like this and could not have thntality
Mizrahim pretty much look like Arabs
@@chawquee becuse tunisia has nothing no oil.your country is th worst shithole on humen earth.
I actually loved this video. All of the Israelis who stole the Hummus from Arabs are Actually Arabs XD
ofek zelig we are not Arabs, we are Israelis whose ancestors went to Arabic countries in the Diaspora.
Beni Habibi Most Israelis today have and still relate to their Arabian backgrounds and traditions. Imagine cultures to be colours. Many multicultural countries, when they get new cultures, add them to a rainbow. However Israel mixes them all in to make a brown.
This has its merits. However to assume that some individuals, Israelis who serve Hummus in their restaurants, don't at all still claim a distinct Arabian heritage which allows them the cultural right to create the foods of other lands than Israel.
ofek zelig true, but still, i do not consider them to be Arabs. many of the Mizrahi Jews i have known do not consider themselves Arabs, said one of my old schoolmates of Yemeni descent "if we were their fellow Arabs, they wouldn't have oppressed and expelled us"
that is why i continue to say that there are no Ashkenazi and Mizrahi, we are all simply one Israel. we are not Arabs, and we are not European. we are just Israel.
Beni Habibi I know. However the Arabic traditions are still carried in the household. They just became Israelicised.
ofek zelig its the otherway around in my opinion. they became Arabized under Arab rule, but were always Israeli.
If only they could love one another as much as they love hummus ;)
:) we try, at least some/most of us try. There was one funny peace & coexistence project in Israel (there are many!) which had both Jews and Palestinians making humous together to try break the world record of the biggest ever humous! haha ...they succeeded, but then I think it was Lebanese who broke this record.
+interestingyoutubechannel That's Amazing❣✌🏾️
you dream
News flash: Israelis don't love hummus, they call hummus a terror org...and hummus are only peaceful protesters, all Muslims are peaceful...especially Muhammad, he was SO peaceful he never beheaded poets or killed kids of Banu Qurayza or anything like that.
@@bonashiquandapropiciasmith4654 Banu Qurayza broke their oath. So it’s normal that they got exiled and enslaved. Dum dum
There is more proof of the Holocaust than any other war or conflict that ever existed. The Germans kept excellent records about what they did. There are countless pictures, films, testimonies from both victims and perpetrators. see yadvashem and choose Arabic language
The Ottoman Empire tried to destroy any if all evidence of their crimes against the Armenian population during the First World War.
So
@Someone I could ask you the same thing.
@Someone you’re the one who brought up the holocaust from a video about Israelis and hummus. ‘Splain yoself.
why did america steal pizza from italy?
ahyaok100 pizza is everywhere why America specifically?
ahyaok100 They didn't. There are pizza restaurants in America but they don't call it "American food".
+B.D Why do Americans call burgers American when they're actually from Hamburg, Germany?
because they did not know how to use their ananases?
Pasta did not originate in Italy. Read its history before claiming this honor.
Note: in Hebrew, the word Arab implies Palestinian ethnicity. Those who said they were 'Arab' meant they are Palestinians with Israeli citizenship. The others were Jewish Israelis from Mizrahi background. In Israel, that is how social/ethinic groups are defined. The report is meant to poke fun of the claim that Israelis stole hummus from the Arab world.
And if this is the case, then pizza and all italian food are “israeli” bcz there are Italian jewish, all persian food are “israeli” bcz there persian jewish, all butter chicken and all indian food are “israeli” bcz there are indian jewish, any country with the tiniest minority of jewish even one jewish living in that country would make that country’s food and culture “israeli”. you are that desperate to steal others food and culture bcz you dont have any, you are all from different backgrounds, stealing the culture of the country you came from and calim its “Israeli”
I love the sound of it. What's the sentence? "La ma genav dem a humus ma aravim"?
@@vovac8915 lama ganavtem hummus me'haavrabim
@@ShuKranAllaH try to brave enough and try matza, gefilte fish, regel krusha and chamin than I will give you the rest of israrli Jewish food 🤣
@@user-jn6rw3hf8u so Chinese food in the US is called Chinese food because it originates in China. You can’t call hummus in Israel Israeli if it originates in Egypt in the 13th century way before Israel existed
That Persian old man can't speak of hummus because Iranians do not eat hummus.
Avi Avi He has the best restaurant in Tel Aviv. I ate there a few times.
He was wearing a Muslim prayer cap
Omar Farouq Khan He’s a Muslim, but he hates Arabs because he’s Persian. Arabs and Persians hate each-other.
UniverseStars Stars Actually he is not a muslim. By knowing him personally, he is ab Iranian Jewish.
Omar Farouq Khan He is an Iranian Jew.
Jews were in Palestine long before the Arabs, Zionism or the British. My great great grandfather died in Jerusalem before Zionism. My husband's family came from Kurdistan, Yemen, Iran as part of Zionism. People then believed.
@Pat Micucci no, he means husband
@shearcuttingmutt mutt WRONG. That is a RACIST IDEA. They already did DNA on both ashkenazi and mizrachi jews(along with sephardic jews) and they are ALL RELATED PATERNALLY through the Y chromosomes to ancient israelis. While , for ashkenazi jews, on the maternal sides are southern european. But at the same time I just wish Israelis get rid of their racist Prime Minister Netanyahu('They are bussing arabs to the polls").
In truth, neither Hummus nor Falafel are Arab food. They're Coptic Egyptian food that was invented by the Egyptian Copts in the 13th century to eat during the Easter.
Ahmed Ismail Coptic or not, they’re still arabs so...
highness
Copts are NOT Arabs. They are Egyptians.
@@melaniehenderson4756 LOL Copts are the remnant of the original Egyptians. Cpt and Gypt are from the same linguistic root. That you think they're Arabs just proves how far Arab domination & hegemony has invaded indigenous minorities' lands, including the Copts, Hebrews/Israelites, Berbers/Amazigh, and many others. You probably claim Lebanon, too.
@@JourneyBold Imazighen aren't a Minority in NA. AND WE SUPPORT PALESTINE🇩🇿🇲🇦🇹🇳🇱🇾🇪🇭🇪🇬🇵🇸
Shut up
I was in Dura in the West Bank and there is a place that serves shnitzl so I asked them why they stole it from the Israelis. They said shnitzl is American :)
* or why Saudi steals burning/other execution of witches/sorcerors from the Vatican :-)
* or why Saudi steals burning/other execution of witches/sorcerors from the Vatican :-)
Loved how the people laughed at this question. Some of you in the comments should not take it so serious, it's just food.
No joke, the ethnic origins of food has caused deadly riots in that part of the world; welcome to The Religion Of Peace.
Which one?
@@MsCocacolavanille LOLLLLLLL
@@MsCocacolavanille There is only ONE RELIGION that has current wars against >40 cultures: it is CLEAR who the aggressor that he spoke of is.. they are enslaving African Christians/Animists (Pagan)/Igbo TODAY, YEZIDI Pagans, war on Serbs, Buddhists, Hindus, Maronites, Western China, Cossacks, Bahais, the post-1990's Europeans who TRIED to HOST them peacefully, EACH OTHER _(Sunni-vs-Shiya ALL 1,400 years since Muhammad died. Surpassing even the Vatican's wars against other sects of Christians. _ _*_What says it about HOW THEY WILL TREAT YOU when they cannot even BRIEFLY have all Sunni nations at peace with all Shiya? ...for the APARTHEID Quran system of "dhimmi" google the name "Chaim Farhi" and note that is how they treated a COOPERATIVE "dhimmi"._*_ Did they treat even him (Farhi) in "peace"?), and MORE WARS against Sikhs, poets (even MUHAMMAD HIMSELF beheaded poets merely for their WORDS, to SILENCE dissent, and CARTOONISTS... _*__WHAT OTHER RELIGION ASSASSINATES...CARTOONISTS?????)_* and too many cultures to list all. ONLY ONE RELIGION has WORLD DOMINATION (all humans being converted or else KILLED or ENSLAVED if they refuse to convert) in their scripture.
@@MsCocacolavanille There is only ONE RELIGION that has current wars against >40 cultures: it is CLEAR who the aggressor that he spoke of is.. they are enslaving African Christians/Animists (Pagan)/Igbo TODAY, YEZIDI Pagans, war on Serbs, Buddhists, Hindus, Maronites, Western China, Cossacks, Bahais, the post-1990's Europeans who TRIED to HOST them peacefully, EACH OTHER _(Sunni-vs-Shiya ALL 1,400 years since Muhammad died. Surpassing even the Vatican's wars against other sects of Christians. _ _*_What says it about HOW THEY WILL TREAT YOU when they cannot even BRIEFLY have all Sunni nations at peace with all Shiya? ...for the APARTHEID Quran system of "dhimmi" google the name "Chaim Farhi" and note that is how they treated a COOPERATIVE "dhimmi"._*_ Did they treat even him (Farhi) in "peace"?), and MORE WARS against Sikhs, poets (even MUHAMMAD HIMSELF beheaded poets merely for their WORDS, to SILENCE dissent, and CARTOONISTS... _*__WHAT OTHER RELIGION ASSASSINATES...CARTOONISTS?????)_* and too many cultures to list all. ONLY ONE RELIGION has WORLD DOMINATION (all humans being converted or else KILLED or ENSLAVED if they refuse to convert) in their scripture.
Perfect Thumbnail: “I’m an Arab, I didn’t steal it” 🤣🤣
🖕🖕👉🏻🇮🇶👌🇮🇱
I would also give you my nephews to deal with in your return scenario. Their paternal grandfather's mother is from Iran, father from Yemen, Paternal grandmother from Iraqi Kurdistan, mother's grandfather from Poland, mother's grandmother from Yemen. Do they get a choice of which of those countries they can go back to? Does the fact that they have blood cousins in Gaza and Jordan make them more eligible to stay in your worldview? Or is the racism only for European Jews?
Corey Gil-Shuster Out of curiosity. Are you completely of Ashkenazi background or do you have some Sephardi or Mizrahi in you too?
They can go back to either the country of their father or of their mother. It's not that complicated dude
The 1948 Arab-Israeli war started when a Jew businessman sold a Hummus in his restaurant in Jerusalem.
:D LOL
Don´t even joke with the idea, as you´re doing it. There are people who are stupid enough to believe it!
Best Comment ever 😂👍
Honestly,I'm a Ashkenazim Jew From the east coast in the Us.I love Hummus But the Arabs make it the Best!! FYi,Egypt was the birth place of Hummus.Sorry to be a trader,but it's true.
That's "traitor" not "trader". But you're not. Enjoy that hummus!
andrew cohen Not sure about that,
Hummus is being written about in the bible
Google it
Guy Eshel Jesus was most probably Arab....
andrew cohen the best Khumus in the world is in Aba Ghosh, Israel.
consulting_auror I'm not so sure if Arabs took part in this part of the region at that time.
I'm English and had a pizza for lunch, I'm sorry Italy I'm a dirty thief 😩
Nipple viking if you went around promoting pizza as english cuisine (which would be incongruous as english cuisine is rubbish) then your logic would make sense.
Have you actually tried English cuisine?
+Saddam Bin Laden you know nothing of English cuisine. you (like most middle easterners) hate anything that has relation to norhern Europe
northern europe is shit doe
+Saddam Bin Laden LOL, YOU JUST PROVED HIS POINT THAT YOU'RE AN IGNORANT HATER
55% of Israeli Jews come from Arab countries, 70% of Israeli Jews were born in Israel. 40% of Israelis are European however that includes Sfardic Jews from Greece, Turkey, and the Muslim Soviet States. Why live here? The land was ours once and we dreamed of return for 2000 years. Plus Israel has been internationally recognized by most of the world since 1948. Would you disband Canada, USA, Australia, China, all Arab countries (since the Arabs invaded 1400 years ago)?
What kind of question is that anyway !??? LoL ... Someone is eating a pizza walk up to him and ask him why he stole the pizza from the Italians ... What ? I paid for this frickin pizza !!!
that's not really what he's asking.
Soooo in short , Arabs and Jews are the same people , thanks :D !!
Borat Erali Nazarbayev
That's different. They are eating pizza but they aren't claiming that it's their food and it's their main dish. For Israelis, apparently, hummus is Israeli which it obviously isn't.
Potato Head
At the time when Hummus was created it was created by Arabs in an Arab country, therefore it is Arab. At that time Israel didn't even exist. Israel claims that hummus is their food when it is not.
WRONG, Sameer. Copts invented hummus. Copts aren't Arab -- even Egypt's Arabs know Copts are Northwest Semites (related to Canaanites), not Southern Semites like Arabs are. But since you Arabs stole God & religion from Israelites (as well as colonizing them & Copts & everyone from India to Spain) -- and stole their language (when Arabs converted to modern Arabic, a CENTRAL Semitic dialect), arches, astronomy (go find "Atlit Yam"), agriculture, and *_Himyarite Arabs mass-converted to Judaism after 2 Jews saved the highest (Yemenite, most powerful) Arab king's life, these JEWS founded/created Madina (called "Yathribe" at the time), then Muhammad used a pretext to steal & ISlamize Madina, you even need to give Madina back to Israel._* You are CULTURE VULTURES, fake-Abrahamites; geneticists confirm you have no connection to Abraham... and You & Muhammad just MADE UP stories to relax the Himyarite-Jews, as they gave Muhammad shelter when he fled Madina's pagans (gee, wonder why Madina pagans needed to chase out The Snake Muhammad), then Muhammad The Snake stabbed in their backs of these Madina Himyarit Jews who gave him shelter..
This is the funniest episode yet. The irony in this is just so good and its done with the most simple subject. show this to the people who are preaching about ''white zionist state'' and ''apartheid'' and if they stil dont get it then dont bother with it...
I originated from the Far East and I love Hummus so much I make it from scratch at home - it has heavenly ingredients. I am a happy thief.
Haha the Israeli people say that they do better hummus than the arabs but the people that do hummus in israel they are arabs
Corey..I have subscribed to your channel as I think you are doing a great job by showing the country I could have never imagined to go even though I would so much love to.
After looking at the vdo..I don't understand if the majority has the same ethnic background why they have to fight with eachother?
It's really very sad...The God of Abraham surely didn't want us to be indulging in such acts of hatred. Very Very Sad.
I hope I can come to visit Israel one day!
Why did the French and the Germans fight against each other? They're very similar. Why do Syrians fight each other? They're of the exact ethnic background. Not everything is about race.
Waqar Ali good for you.
its not about race or religion. its about two nationalistic entities.
I think the anwser is actually this: there's no "jewish" hummus and no "muslim" hummus. There's just hummus, mashed up chikpeas. sometimes with more or less lime/citrus/tahina. Every restaurant and family has their own recepie and every person has their own tastebuds. And that's how it's supposed to be. It's not like there's any food in the WORLD where everyone makes it the exact same way everywhere.
And also the "dish" was around before arabs called themselves arabs and before judaism or islam existed so everyone loses!
+Gabriel Grünberg what evidence do you have that hummus was around before judaism and islam? O.o
@@TheLoyalpain what evidencr you have that "arabs "invented the hummus ? Chikpeas were cultivated all across the middle east for over 4000 years.most say hummus spread came from egypt.how do you knownthe creator of the hummus spread wasnt kopt chritisian (who kept speaking kopt on daily basis fornmany years after the muslin conquest) or amazigh or one of the jews who lived in alexandria since the cotynwas established by the greeks ?
thats literally it. Palestinians get mad because Israelis like to market falafel and hummus as "Jewish-food" and an "Israeli culinary invention" in western markets. When it clearly isn't the case. It's just generic middle easter food and its literally bean paste. The Palestinians themselves don't claim falafel and hummus as Palestinian invention its just a regional food that most Israelis learned from the arabs to begin with which is why it pisses people off to see Ashkenazi call it a jewish invention its like you may as well claim the jews invented bread at this point.
Hummus is Arabic
@@leenahussein778 Sepharadic Jews invented fish and chips in England. Do you see any Jews getting pissy because the English decided it is their national dish? Hummus is Egyptian, Lebanese, Syrian and yes also Israeli. They can all market it as their food
Yes. In Israel when you say you are Egyptian, Iraqi, Yeminite, Kurdish, etc. it implies that you are Jewish.
That is the most stupid question. Hummus is a food that is part of middle easterns culture as a hole
ilan shans The best answer !! ... Why couldn't they all answer like what you did ? Why being so agressive once hearing "Arabs" although they are already Jewish Arabs !
ilan shans The name means chickpeas in Arabic so please, it's a Mediterranean Arabic dish.
+Zacharia El Hajjar
They were aggressive because of the claim they stole something. Not because they heard "Arabs". Also from my experience workers in hummus and falafel places tend to be a bit short tempered :)
Lizzie87
Com on miss lizzie.. its not a claim.. its not a history from the 9th century BC... its only recent.. and everybody knows what happened for real even jews..except those who claim lies pretending to be the victim... plus we all know that jews and arabs are rival cousins because of religion or politics.. like many nations in the world... Though i know that even in this stormy world full of hatred among every people, theres good tempered people :)
yes, but the israelis have no history in the middle east, they came from all over the world settled in palestine, stole their land, stole their traditions and claim to be part of the regions history lol, despite only have come to this ancient region for the past few years, and despite being seen as foreigners not only by palestinians but by all original people of the middle east!
Hummus is originally from the region! No country owns hummus for itself! Same applies for Biryani (A rice dish) in our region (South Asia) Biryani isn't just Indian, Pakistani, Iranian, or Bangladeshi! It's South Asian! Simple as that! (Not saying Iran is in South Asia though!)
***** That's what he was trying to prove, no food is owned by any nation/people.
Zelazo exactly bro!
+Mr Canada and Pakistan
FINALLY a voice of reason!
Lizzie87 Thanks, there! :) I am glad, you understand me! :)
***** Well, I certainly do agree & cannot argue with that fact.
Very funny question, i was laughing on the reaction of the resturant managers : D
this is fucking hilarious! Thank you Corey, it was fun, very funny reactions
Did they write a patent? Israeli make food from all over the world, and sometimes make their own version Scnizel (with chicken rather than a cow), falaefel (made from hummus, as many are allergic to Vicia faba, chicken soup). There are many foods here from all over the world, some were imported (pizza, hamburger) and some were brought from people's parents or grandparents.
And besides, people make food from other countries all over the world.
Haha this video was great. I love the way you asked this question so straightforwardly, very Israeli of you
Hi Salukie! Nice to see you here.
לא מופתע אך נחמד 😁
I wish I could enter the west bank like you guys
@@bereshel7984 חחח כן אני וקורי חברים
אתה יכול, פשוט קח את הסיכונים בחשבון
Love to see you Salukie when are you getting back to the Holy Land ?
As a Lebanese Muslim, I want piece with Israel but I also want my Palestinian brothers and sisters to be in peace. Let's pray that all Middle Easteners, Jewish, Muslims, Christian, Agnostic etc live in peace and we can see each other in heaven with some arguile. Just open your minds people, you need to accept others and their beliefs!
agnostic who pray....my advise first pray for your country that is about to be divided i nto millions of pievces and try to build a real country .....you pray already alot but you keep your brains shut ...worthless
I'm an Israeli Jew and I strive for the same.
Tribalism and religious sectarianism are the core cause for all this chaos around.
Glad to see that most of the responses are somewhat lighthearted. Very refreshing after watching your other videos about serious political questions!
corey youre such a fun guy. i love you video concept! keep up! Love from Singapore
🤣🤣🤣 I’m jewish and love our Muslim cousins. Shalom Salem everyone.
😘😂
I am Israeli and I think we are not stealing hummus from Arabs. because the reason that many Jews came from Arab countries and there is a maybe that even a Jew living in an Arab country invent the hummus.
Hummus is local food, all ethnicities made it. Even non-arab non-jew minorities.
And as a side fact hummus is mentioned in a story in the Bible as a food.
Let's be honest, the best Hummus in Israel is made by Arabs. Places like Abu Hassan are packed day and night for a reason.
Joseph Levine respect
and now what all the world is gonna hate us and blame us for eating non israeli food like allways, give us a brake like stop finding excuses to hate us -_-
Most of the people asked had Arab backgrounds! Interesting.
Because they were KICKED OUT OF THEIR HOMELANDS AFTER THE ESTABLISMENT OF ISRAEL. That is a fact WHETHER ARABS LIKE IT OR NOT. But at the same time ISRAELI HAVE TO ADMIT THAT MANY JEWS ALSO HATE ARABS AND BLACKS. LIke Netanyahu(THEY ARE BUSSING THE ARABS TO THE POLLS SAID SATANYAHU). Both sides have their racists.
@@tichtran664 lol this was a 6 year old comment
this video is really nice, thank you
How many people have we killed?
This is one funny video :)
Why did you steal hummus from Arabs?
I'm an Arab, we didn't steal nothing!
Awesome work Corey!
lol the question is funny
LOL that title tho. I can't help imagining a jew breaking into some random Arab's home and literally stealing the hummus.
I live in Israel, I am a Zionist. I know know better than you what Zionism means. Stop reading propaganda web sites and talk to Israelis. You have been lied to. Stop listening to lies.
Hummus is not an Arabic dish because it is not from the Arabian Peninsula and the Arab people exist only in the Arabian Peninsula, so hummus is not Arabic
I don't know who is teaching you that but that is totally wrong, Arabs are people who speak Arabic and identify with the cultural. I am Jordanian Arab !! being Arab doesn't mean having a certain 100% pure race. Ismael is also Arab and he is the grandfather of Mohammed the Islam prophet , that makes Mohammad although he lived in mecca not Arab!!
it from libanon and libanon is antic country is older than israel
Where did you get this from, you son of adultery? You are the one who wants to teach us, the Arabs, our origins, you tweezers who lack origin and lineage.
Hummus is a chickpea dish. Chickpea dishes have existed in the Middle East for millennia- prior to the Arab invasion. Falafel was a common dish in ancient Egypt. Chances are that the ancient Israelites would have also had falafel, and therefore likely hummus, as well. It's Middle Eastern food, not Arab food.
ShnoogleMan and middleeast indigenous people are arabs let me tell you a fact you didn't know the islamic invasion didn't mame much of an ethnic change the changes they've made we're religious
iraqi atheist EXACTLY!
How conveniently claim to be Arab in response to this question, but never in other circumstances.
Those who said they're Arab are actual Arabs, i.e Palestinians.
Ok. Hummus is egyptain and egypt is arabian, so hummus is arabic food but a lot of jews are related to arabian or are of arabian descent...so theres a link too
well , i think the Syrian guy is the only who has the right to say that he didn't steal the hummus :P
Actually it was a Jewish idea. since 135AD Jews have been dreaming of returning to our native land. It exists in our holidays, in our daily prayers. But you are right, no one asked the Palestinians if they minded when we came back. But no one asked the Jews if they minded when the Arabs invaded in 634AD.
when the arab invaded palestine it was belong to rome and arab didn't force jews to leave but the only thing they did that they promised Patriarch of jerusalem no one of the jews allowed to live with them and second not all palestinians are arab and not all egypt are arab because and you can check it out the dna prove otherwise
Lol , u fat pig. the reason Jews did not return to Palestine for the simple fact they didn't regard it as any sort of homeland.....that is why they were waiting for the Messiah to return to metaphysical Jerusalem along with the dead. It is part of Judaism, idiot
gur ruh whats ur point? that just because some Jews didn't call Israel their homeland then its okay to invade their homeland? xD Aye.. You took our homeland then we took it back..
When the caliph Omer invaded Jerusalem, he did not ethnically clinse the Jews not the Christians.
The patriarch asked him to pray at the nativity church, but refused saying a muslim might claim the church someday, if he prayed in it.
The gate keys to the church is kept by a Muslim family to this day.
And later on after the crusaders came in the name of Christ, they committed one of the greatest massacre of the middle ages.
When Salahuddin lebrated Jerusalem, he allowed the Christians to stay or leave with their property if they wished to.
Where as in 1948, Zionists systematically killed and expelled 700,000 Palestinians. And have refused their right of return.
All because they think they r the chosen people and will commit to anything to stay on that land by any means.
When the caliph Omer invaded Jerusalem, he did not ethnically clinse the Jews not the Christians.
The patriarch asked him to pray at the nativity church, but refused saying a muslim might claim the church someday, if he prayed in it.
The gate keys to the church is kept by a Muslim family to this day.
And later on after the crusaders came in the name of Christ, they committed one of the greatest massacre of the middle ages.
When Salahuddin lebrated Jerusalem, he allowed the Christians to stay or leave with their property if they wished to.
Where as in 1948, Zionists systematically killed and expelled 700,000 Palestinians. And have refused their right of return.
All because they think they r the chosen people and will commit to anything to stay on that land by any means.
Am an Arab, am against Israel and it’s existence, but we have to admit that they were Arab Jews who lived in Arab countries and when they immigrated to Israel they have brought all their Arab dishes from back home to Israel, including hummus. Food has no borders and shouldn’t be, not all of Israelis are Europeans! They are Arab Jews who have every right of the Arab identity just as the Muslims and Christians.
Corey Gil-Shuster I like your videos. I learned a lot about beliefs and cultures of Jews and Arabs from you.
1:47, Case close'd
All isrealis are arab but its just sad when greek people try to claim hummus
Turks eat it too. Don't they?
teiwap they’re just claiming now that they are Arabs.
Go and watch another videos
we are not arabs we are jews we dont speak arabic
What greek person tries to claim hummus?
Wtf with these comments about Greeks and hummus? I'm Greek from Greece and we don't eat hummus. Only if we choose to eat in any kind of Arab restaurant. But it is not part of our cuisine or recipes that we cook at home.
Thank you! Finally someone sees what I see :)
this might be called surveying not investigative reporting! Although it is not done scientofically right at all and nothing garantees the omitment of answers collected by interviewee ... Not just that video.
I loved how serious, almost accusatory Corey was when he asked the question.
Who cares anyway? I'm Algerian and proud of the fact that our food is so good that our Jewish brothers still make it in Israel!
Shakshuka forever . And maphrum .though i gotta admit my first and only queen ,joy of life ,most beloved -is the amba hindi on the iraqi version
Interesting way to make a point on the nationalities within Israel
How bad is your Hebrew? They have to do a double take because you have to say ET hahummus, and you just say hummus without the object marker את
other videos they deny their Arab heritage ,in this video they say they are Arabs . hummus is cultural food it has nothing to do with religion . the guy about can F O he is Arab Jew , he is saying to him self because he is Arab to
Akram Tobbieh yea I was thinking the same thing. They can fight it all they want but they are arabs just with a different religion
This is not accurate. Yes, their recent ancestors lived in arab lands, but genetically they're more close to Ashkenazi jews than to actual arabs. So, you should define what being an arab means.
The ones who said they're arabs in the video are actually Israeli Arabs, not jews. Arabs and Jews are different ethnicities, just like Kurds or Berbers are not Arabs.
"Hummus is Arab"
No. Hummus is fucking food.
Jeeeeezzzzus. It's everything with you people.
Jeff Robbins LOL...what did your ancestors invent; dildos and vibrators ? Shit-stirring Arabs, he says !!!!
Lol who fucking cares about anyone's ancestors, let alone their inventions. Also food inventions aren't really inventions. They're called recipes.
fuflang He should've thought a 10000 times before saying what he said. You don't fuck with Arabs they don't fuck with you !
IXXVII IIVXXI "Copts are not Arabs" ~Prof. Constantine Gutzman. highbeam.com/doc/1P2-869253.html = *proof of your FIRST of many lies.* Copts also were recently beheaded in Morsi-era rioting; was your head stuck up your ass or in a sand dune? And Assyrians DO exist today, google "Christian Assyrians," MORON. I won't even bother to expose the rest of your lies about history (or your distortions of what Raamiel ACTUALLY wrote, e.g. he acknowledges Arabs spread Islam to Pashtuns/etc, and Arabs didn't *personally* take India).
Arabs fuck with everybody, just ask Copts, Assyrians, Hindus, Jews, Druze, Bahais, Kurds, Maronites, Euro cartoonists, Central Africans, all the way east to Filipinos & East Timorese: you fucked up 3 continents by spreading Muhammad's DISEASE of Islamo-imperialism. What did the Central Africans, East Timorese, etc etc etc do to the Pedophile Cult before you fucked with them? Their crime was to merely EXIST as non-Muslims.
Quite true.
I am an atheist Jew. My parents are atheist Jews. My grandmother is an atheist Jew. My three other grandparents were believing Jews. I don't believe in any religion. I am a Jew by ethnicity, Jews are my people. To me the Bible and all those books are made up stories. God is invented by people. You are free to insult any prophet. It does not bother me. I will never insult someone's beliefs or their prophets. Truth is science. Things you can prove. Religion is belief.
It's hard to watch this without laughin :)))
Middle Eastern Jews who lived in regions now ruled by Arabs are called Mizrachi Jews. Those Jews are not Arabs, and didn't 'steal' anything (the reverse is truer). Jews PRE-DATED Arabs in living in places such as Iraq (Babylon), Syria, Lebanon, Egypt & North African countries. There are presently 22 Arab-ruled states. Ethnic minorities (non-Arab) have lived for millennia in those lands, including indigenous peoples whose cultures were overrun by Arab conquerors. Ethnic minorities include Berbers/Amazigh, Jews/Israelites, Assyrians, Yazidis, Kurds, Copts, Maronites, Chaldeans, etc. ...Arabs are people whose ethnic roots originate from the Arabian Peninsula (i.e., what used to be called Arabia). Like Jews, Arabs are Semites. But until 600-700 C.E., Arab occupation was confined mainly to Arabia. ...YES, hummus is a MIDDLE-EASTERN dish. There is a broad variety of other ethnic groups within the Middle East & North Africa, so it's great to show that we cannot lump distinct groups -- or hummus -- into one, inaccurately.
i feel so sad for your poor knowledge , you guys making a big claims like jews were in area before arabs , who said that . actually arab existed before jews . check this out who is older ismael or isac , then you will know the answer. you definitey treat us like extratrestial creatures . come n man
if theyre cousins like ur torah claims, then all ur points are mute
+ramy hiekal
He said Jews lived before Arabs IN THE REGIONS HE LISTED, not generally. Arabs conquered the Middle East north and west of Arabia in the 7th century AD. Jews lived in those places before.
+Lizzie87 oh please...you r very ignorant
+ramy hiekal I think that you are the ignorant one
aren't those Israelis of Iraqi background arabs? I mean their nationality is Israeli and their religion Jewish but they're still Arabs, aren't they?
+Aaron Westwood +Jonah Karlen -- Arabs are NOT all defined as people from Arab-ruled countries. Middle Eastern Jews who lived in regions now ruled by Arabs are called Mizrachi Jews. Those Jews are not Arabs. Jews PRE-DATED Arabs in living in places such as Iraq (Babylon), Syria, Lebanon, Egypt & other North African countries. There are 22 Arab-ruled states. Ethnic minorities (non-Arab) live natively within those states, including indigenous peoples whose cultures were overrun by the Arabs who invaded those lands. These ethnic minorities include Berbers/Amazigh, Jews/Israelites, Assyrians, Chaldeans, Copts, Maronites, Yazidis, Kurds, etc. ...Arabs are people whose ethnic roots originate from the Arabian Peninsula (i.e., what used to be called Arabia). Like Jews, Arabs are Semites. But until 600-700 C.E., Arab rule was confined mainly to Arabia. Respectfully, you both need to learn your history & study the broad variety of other ethnic groups within the Middle East & North Africa, so that you don't lump distinct groups into one, inaccurately. Speaking Arabic does not make you an Arab anymore than speaking English means your ethnic ancestry is from England.
+Aaron Westwood Jews are not Arabs. Jews/Israelites/Hebrews are an ethnic group of the Middle East. The Israeli Jews in this video are MIZRAHI JEWS & highlight the fact that Non-Arab ethnic groups include: Berbers/Amazigh, Jews/Israelites, Kurds, Assyrians, Chaldeans, Maronites, Copts, Yazidis, etc. ...Some commenters mistakenly equate Middle Easterners with 'Arabs'. Arabs are only one ethnic group-- a people originating from the Arabian Peninsula (i.e., Arabia). The Middle East & North Africa are presently Arab-ruled due to Arab invasion, settlement & imposition of their language onto all of these ethnic minorities whose presence PRE-DATED the Arab presence in all these conquered lands. But an Arab-ruled majority does not make Jews or other ethnic minorities Arab. Speaking Arabic does not make you Arab. Being indigenous to the Middle East makes you a Middle Easterner.
T Mi You cant deny that many many Arabs converted to judaism before Islam came
+MrPickledede Nonsense. Jews in their vast majority were ethnically Israelites, "before Islam". Judaism does not proselytize for converts. Arabs were Arabs. Jews were Jews. *You* "cannot deny" the Jews' ethnic heritage as a distinct people. ...Arab hegemony has failed to subsume this ethnic minority, like it has succeeded in erasing so many other Middle East groups' distinctiveness. Non-Arab ethnic groups include: Berbers/Amazigh, Jews/Israelites, Kurds, Assyrians, Chaldeans, Maronites, Copts, Yazidis, etc.
T Mi
Then you deny the history of the Himyarite Empire which has been confirmed by Christian, Muslim, Jewish, Pagan, modern archeology, historians etc etc....I am a PHD historian...Judaism WAS a proselytizing religion before Christianity became dominant in the Roman empire..the Talmud attests to this (see the Onkelos, Shemaya and Avtalyon, Rabbi Akiva etc etc all converts during the era of mass Jews Proselytizing) and OUTLAWED Jewish proselytizing...which became a capital crime in the Christian And Muslim world...
Most Jews were Not ethnically Arab...but my ancestors the Yemenite Jews were in large part Arab with some Israelite and a little bit of Ethiopian(who conquered the Jewish Kingdom of Himyar)
Dude, I've been binging on your vids the past day if you haven't noticed. I'm still in NY crashing with family for now but my long-term contract assignment wound up shorter than I expected. This is what I've been doing with my time!
Haha, I love the reaction at 1.28.
1:49 the perfect response
Seriously though, Israelis may have had hummus before Arabs. It's not clear who had it first, though
fergoesdayton
Written in the old testament...
Not sure it belong to Arabs at all
fergoesdayton Whether Israeli or Arab origins, a lot of people think Israel has the best hummus. --- I AGREE!
ThoseWhoBelieveInCircles OweItToTheMoon *lebanese
Nah mate hummus originated in EGYPT, not israel.
ThoseWhoBelieveInCircles OweItToTheMoon Israel has the worst hummus. Egypt and the Levant have the best hummus.
I'm not Jewish, Arab or middle eastern in any way, but gosh..hummus! I'm in love with its rich smooth creaminess! damn!
this video must be a real culture shock to people who only saw israel on the news.
The first people who invented the falafel are the Israelites in Ancient Egypt. This has been proven historically and researchfully.
That’s completely false. Israelites didn’t invent falafel you fucking idiot. Coptic Egyptians invented falafel.
@@belaldeeb153 and we was there in those days and we invented that!
😂😂😂😂😂🤦♀️
@@iamhassa91 fuck off
@@Justarandomgirl20 the same to you stupid 😒
I like the last person, he said the true, because it's delicious :-) . The Original Hummus it's from Arabs Country, so the Jewish people they have to realise that they stilled from them.
From 7, only 1 it's good, the rest they are Evils.
Respect for Arabs people ...
You can't steal food recipes. You 'stole' bread, wine, salt, tomatoes?
eytanos actually you can steal a recipe and claim it to be your invention.
@@melaniehenderson4756 any proof shakshuka or hummus are really arab(from the arabian peninsula or the were invented by someone who identifies as arab) ?egypt had kopts ,greeks ,romans ,berbers and jews long before the muslims ever set foot there.any proof it was arab who came up with the recipe ?
LOOOL THIS IS AMAZING !
Those who think it is silly to ask such a question don’t know the background of the question. For us, the Palestinians, the Israelis have stolen our land, and bit by bit they are stealing everything else, our culture, heritage and cuisine. They once claimed that the Palestinian traditional dress is Israeli and made the stewardesses of the israeli airline, El Al, wear it as their uniform to “preserve” their heritage. I am afraid that one day they will start saying that they have Palestinian accent.
That Iraqi man said it like a Boss!😉😁😃 1:47
How does one even research and "claim" hummus though?
(3) There is a problem in translation from Hebrew to English but what in English is called “Morsel” is written in Hebrew “Pita” (flat round bread) and the “Vinegar” is not the now day’s liquid but Hometz (chickpeas) or Himtza and in Arabic it called Hummus.
You wish you made hummus better than Arabs
Theziz8 dude i ate your shitty humus in berlin. in a morrocan store, iraqi store and a saudi store and it was all shit. the only one that is ok is the lebanese. and i will admit the israeli arabs are the ones who make it the best, not the jews
Bla Bleo I'm Lebanese , Hummus is not for all Arabs it is for Levantine Arabs (Syrians , Lebanese and Palestinians only) , you want good Hummus you go to these country. And PLEASE , do you seriously think Israeli Hummus is the best? Hahaha , I don't see Israeli food being popular around the world ;) I see Lebanese food everywhere... I wonder why...
Oh and by the way , thank you for respecting my culture , I just really hope you're not American , because you're the last one to be speaking of culture since you have none.
Theziz8 im israeli and actually u might be right since one of the best hummus restaurants in israel is called "the lebanese" in abu gosh. The israeli arabs can make it very good as well though.
Btw ,off topic, i think its a shame our countries is at war.
Bla Bleo The whole world has fallen in shame anyway. Honorable people are scarce nowadays.
Theziz8 some of the best rewarding resturants in the world are Israeli Resturants. the best resturant in the US is Israeli, so check before you make a fool of yourself.
Israeki food counts one of the best in the world, all tourists say it,
mostly because of the very diversed cuisines. a mix of cuisines from all over the world and it's turn out very delicious.
This video is hilarious!!! And even just the way you formed your question is meant to be playful and the smile on those people answering your questions shows how irrelevant many things in this world are. Like why is this even a topic? Who stole what from who?? Can't we just acknowledge that we are enriched by the mixture of our cultures? Why can't we live together instead of working against one another?...but this definitely made me laugh and maybe we can learn to take some things more light-heartedly just by communicating and not taking us too seriously all the time....
Lol bcs u guys are got no identity and just admit it yourself
HAHAHAHA Corey this is so hilarious! Rick here. XD
Reminds me of the people selling burritos in Oregon who got shut down because complaints about "appropriation".
Cursing their own “cousins”.
I love arabic people
And arabic music
And arabic food
and yourself
Of course
And I hate israhell zionest
@@user-sz7gi4sy4l wow u just embarassed urself. Arab r people and anything originating from them is arabic this doesn't just include language but also food, music, norms, clothing and so on. Dont be foolish.
I believe that hummos existed long back since anceint times in egypt and the levant region and the people who lived there shared the same food recipes and those who are interviewed in this video are from arab background who immigrated and brought their cuisine with them.
The focus is on Mizrahim because the people asking the questions focus on Mizrahim (so it mentions it in the title of the question). I am from Canada. I live with Mizrahim here for 20 years. I have never heard any bitterness including the grandparents.I have even asked and they dont know what i am talking about. But maybe it is just the people around me.
fun fact:you don't have to be italian to sell pizza
Fun fact They claim its Isreali food they don't just sell it
@@SaraAli-or4ir You guys so fucking limited and so profoundly jealous... Iwas working at a israeli restaurant called Miznon.. there was humus... Everybody knows and says it's an arab dish, we adopted it just like you guys adopted burqa from jewish women (you didnt know that did you?)
And your name too
@@RISKILNIKIV if u think we're limited don't fucking mess with us selling spaghetti in a restaurant is okay but selling it in ARAB restaurants or whatever is not fucking okay cuz ppl will think its Arab food same for u stupid restaurant don't sell Arab food in Isreali restaurants what ppl will think???
@@RISKILNIKIV and the guy in the video saying I'm not stealing it cuz I'm an Arab is enough to show its originally Arab food so don't sell it in the name of Isreali food they want so sound like Arab so fucking bad they stole land culture food and even dabkka which is Arab dance leave us the fuck alone and stop fulling the lack in ur culture from arab
When you tear down Italian restaurants and build your own using their recipes then yes you are a thief
hahaha he said "hummus always been here even before the occupation".
to all muslims: why are you guys stealing prophets from the jews?
no but hummus is from the region, it's Palestinian not jewish or israeli
+Mr.A there is no such thing as palestine.
+Mr.A
Hummus is an all - Arab food, not Palestinian, and was present in the region before the Arabs. Israelis adopted it because it's popular in the region.
+Mr.A Syrian, named after Homs
+Lizzie87 Humous does not "belong" to anyone, it is eaten throughout the Eastern Mediterranean and Near East. It is as much a . Greek/Turkish food as it is a Lebanese/Israeli food
המילניום ברושים It might not belong to someone but it did originate somewhere and that somewhere is Syria
lesson learned , hummus is Arabic. Case closed.
Alma Irshaid hummus is middle eastern
Humus predates Islam!
LIE
Daniel Cuevas nope, it’s arabic.
Humus IS ""Arabic", but what is "Arabic" you must ask. What people are referring to as Arab in this context is really just "Levantic", "Hellenized Orient", "Northern Arab", "Semetic", etc... People in Saudia don't eat it nearly as often as even non-Arab Israeli's (much less as much as Pallies and Lebs do).
the fact that most of them have an arab ethnic background makes the point even clearer, i got my answers
They stole the land with the blessing of the West and it is not funny . I thought Jews were a race and they can trace their blood line straight to what ever . So how come they are Arabic too ???
all the ones in the video who said there are arabs, wasn't jews, they were real arabs not "jewish arab". i can tell it also by their accent.
4 of them ara arab muslims or christians the rest are jewish
most of them are jewish belive me
Mta tel aviv no, some of them are arabs (muslims), you can know by their accent.
yes 4 of them :)