Part 2 - AussieStig Reviews The Asetek SimSports Invicta Pedals
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ต.ค. 2024
- G'Day guys, here is part two of our two part series looking at Asetek's high end Invicta sim racing pedals. We'll go through the process of assembling and installing the pedals on our Playseat / D-BOX test rig here in the studio. Moving on to the RaceHub software, a series of Talk&Drive sessions and ultimately my final thoughts on the Invicta pedals.
For pricing or to pre-order, check out the link to Asetek's website: www.asetek.com...
I have the Simtrecs and agree about the adjustability being a strong point with them. It allows for so much adjustability in brake travel and feel compared to the Aseteks.
After watching a few of the reviews on the Asetek where brake travel is 20mm, I decided to add the hard elastomers and took out the slack from the pad to disc spring on the Simtrecs. It took some adjustment on my part and noticed that lap times were faster.
I also measured the brake pedal distance of the Simtrecs and was able to replicate 20mm max travel with me pressing as hard as I could comfortably during sustained race conditions. The Simtrecs still gives me the option to add the hard plastic spacers to use in place of the hard elastomers if I want even more stiffness. Travel wise I know what to expect with the Aseteks, but am curious about the brake feel and have the Aseteks on pre-order.
Another thing I'm curious about is whether the Aseteks short brake pedal throw is also optimal for other disciplines of racing, such as oval or dirt racing where progressive braking is more important? Hoping someone with more experience in those disciplines can chime in.
Hey man did you get your Asetek's ? i'm stuck between Simtrecs and Asetek i can't choose to buy one :)
@@991tts4Yes, I have the Aseteks for a few weeks now. Unfortunately, they leaked...but Asetek was quick to respond and their after-sales support was really good.
Brake feel is really good at the limit as you can dance the car between grip and slip while trail-braking. The biggest adjustment is the pressure required to brake, but that comes with time. Whereas the Simtrecs offers a wider range of adjustability in terms of travel and pressure. I am currently testing a spring setup that I was able to fit onto the Simtrecs - an idea from a fellow Simtrecs owner - and am going to test for a bit before reinstalling the Aseteks.
If you get the Aseteks, you will be happy. Ergonomics is personal. If you're coming from Simtrecs, that's tougher since you give up some features that they offer.
Brake feel I'd say the Asetek slightly has it over the Simtrecs - although I'm still testing between the two - but Simtrecs has been flawless in terms of reliability and probably the best looking set of pedals on the market today.
@@timt8199 thanks a lot for your detailed reply much appreciated
@@991tts4 I just read through some of the other comments and noticed that Aussie Stig had similar feedback so I don't know if I made your decision any easier.
@@timt8199 actually i think i’ll go with the simtrecs because they look amazing and they maybe the most adjustable pedal in the market and also i already have racewerk s1 pro pedals which are amazing but i was looking for a daily drive pedals for non racing days or other games then iracing :)
Hey AussiStig, If I were to set these pedals to their lowest setting do you think it would throw me around considering I'll be using the 'next level racing wheel stand dd' and an office chair with bell rubber stoppers instead of wheels? I'm really trying to do the whole 'buy once cry once' thing here and don't have the space for stationary rig yet! Would really value your op. Cheers!
Hey mate no worries. The invicta brake pedal is very firm. On your projected set up they would need to be well anchored and possibly up against a wall. They do have softer elastomers now which I have not tried. These might give you a softer pedal which would help. Really hard to say having never tried a set up like yours. Sorry I can't be of more help. Good luck with the purchase Cheers AussieStig
@@SimRacingwithAussieStig That was a lot of help already. I appreciate the reply man thanks
Thanks for the review. I would love to see a side-by-side hotlap using these pedals vs. SimTrecs, I'd like to understand how these pedals make you faster with some data to back it up. I really prefer the clutch & materials of SimTrecs, but I might look past all that if this brake really does give faster laps over time. Can you set up your SimTrecs pedals to match the brake feel here and get same lap times?
Hey mate thanks for the comment. That is a good idea, I have a lot of things planned in the short term. When I get a spare moment I will see what I can do. Cheers, AussieStig
I am in the exact same boat as you. I like the look and clutch of the Simtrec but the Brake philosophy is pulling me towards Invicas.
Been waiting for this review as you are the only dude I am aware of who has Simtrecs (which I have on pre-order due for next month's batch) and now Asetek. So which one are you going to stick with, you are not going to swap decks out all the time, what bed are you going to lay in, Simtrecs or Asetek?
Thanks for the comment mate. I already have another set of pedals lined up to review, neither will be back on the rig permanently. Both those pedals have very strong points and few flaws. It really is a personal choice and if you want maximum adjustability or can live with less. It depends a little on the rig you have as well. Cheers AussieStig
@@SimRacingwithAussieStig I guess you have sold out.............. you should run as a politician with that response kudus well done.
@@rooman7160 I'm not in anyone's pocket mate. If I say buy this instead of that. You get this, install it and then don't like it, you will be cross with me for making a decision for you.
@@SimRacingwithAussieStig All I asked was which one would you put on your rig, you have not answered that question.
I understand the difference, Asetek great breaks, Simtrecs great adjustability that is a decision I need to make. For me, I am leaning towards Asetek due to the break and the price. I also am a little concerned about some of the feedback from the USB connection I have heard and the software regarding Simtrecs, nonetheless I no for a fact either one will be bloody fantastic but I do not own both where as you do.
One needs to be pragmatic at this price point there is never going to be a clear winner and if anyone thinks so they a fool. Either option would and will be a bloody top pick for anyone but I was curious as to your thoughts what you would put on your rig.
Keep up the great work, I like your different approach to putting up vids, hope you start streaming :)
@@rooman7160 Pragmatism is the way to go, you don't know until you know. Some of my favourite pedals have been the hydraulic Ricmotech GT Pros based on Tilton 600 real car pedals. Thanks for the kind words mate. AussieStig
Ich freue mich so auf meine Asetek Pedale. Es soll schnell März werden.
Hey mate,
So after using these and the Simtrecs for a good amount of time.
What is your preference between the two?
Hey mate really hard to separate them without sounding biased either way. I like the Aseteks brake a lot. The look and adjustability of the Simtrecs is also a strong argument. AussieStig
@@SimRacingwithAussieStig thanks for the feedback.
I'm currently an owner of the Simtrecs and am very happy.
Just wondering if it would be worth the switch to Aseteks?
I think that asetek will get it 100% right on there next try making pedals the invicta 2's
Hi, good review,After a year what peddles are you using know mate.
Cheers mate. Still have them on my main rig and Sim Aliens on my test rig right now. Will be reviewing the hydraulic MECA EVOs soon too. Cheers AussieStig
I have been focused on the difference between the Simtrec and Aseteks Brake feel but what about the clutch and Throttle. Would you say those are pretty much identical in feeling between these two Products?
Hey mate, the throttles feel quite similar. The clutch on the Aseteks does feel different to the Simtrec's mechanism. The Simtrecs have a more pronounced bite point feel which is due to the mechanical action of the solid connection between the pedal arm and the rear pivot point.
@@SimRacingwithAussieStig OK, thanks for your experience with this. If I am hearing you right, the Aseteks DO still have a bit point, just not as pronounced as the Sim trec. I do drive a lot of cars with a Clutch
@@rtimmins7212 Hey mate no worries. I know for myself when I use the clutch whilst heel&toeing, the clutch is pressed quickly and the bite point feel is not really felt. It is felt more for starting a race from a standing start, then you can feel the difference in approaches. Cheers, AussieStig
@@SimRacingwithAussieStig great , thank you. You are one of the rare TH-camrs (who actually responds to comments) who has experience with these two pedals so your opinion is valued.
@@rtimmins7212 No worries mate, anytime. Why have a channel if you think you are above answering people when they have a question. Cheers AussieStig
Considering selling ny ultimates to get these, would you recommend doing so? Have you tried the HE ultimates ?
Hey mate yes I have tried the Ultimates, very good pedals. Because of the T.H.O.R.P system, the brake feel of the Aseteks is very accurate and car like. The adjustability is another question though. If you can live without maximum adjustability then you could give them a go. Cheers, AussieStig
SimTrecs pro or Asetek?
Depends on your set up and how solid your rig is. The Asetek has the edge on brake pedal feel. You will need a solid rig to mount them on. Simtrecs win on maximum adjustability.
@@SimRacingwithAussieStig I have a Simlab P1 X
@@SimRacingwithAussieStig I also want to know this as I have SimTrecs on order but they are currently significantly more expensive than the Invicta pedals due to pre order sale. I am still leaning towards the SimTrecs myself. Unfortunately it seems like such a tough decision!
@@SimRacingwithAussieStig Do you recall the maximum distance you could mount the Simtrecs brake and throttle? I assume limited by cable length but would prefer to have the brake directly in line with my left leg with the throttle directly in line with my right leg for maximum comfort if that makes sense.
@@slickmotion5021 both pedals have very strong points. If you want a really hard pedal with less adjustment possibilities then Asetek is a solid choice. If you want more adjustability Simtrecs offer that and a hydraulic pedal as well. It is a personal choice what suits you the best.
Why are you wearing gloves adjusting the pedals?
Hey mate, I wear them to keep finger smudges off things during the review. Cheers AussieStig