I always thought so too. Dame he was good. Just like J Lo not getting for Selena. I watch these two movies from time to time and I forget he isn't Johnny and she isn't Selena. Oh well, they've got my respect for what it's worth. Loved Johnny and Selena. Love Joaquin and J Lo.
I love how Joaquin Phoenix starts a little anxious, almost like he’s scared of such a big audience. But when he gets more confident with everyone else cheering him on, he becomes Johnny Cash.
@@colinqualm6422 actually he's said in several interviews he struggles from severe anxiety and doesn't like to be in front of crowds or audiences but when he acts he is able to overcome it for his performance. Just watch any of his speeches or interviews he's done where he has won an award or talked about films his been in and you'll see the difference in the way he talks and moves his hands bc of his anxiety.
This is a wonderful comment. I've been a Cash fan for 30years and was WORRIED that the film would not be able to capture The Voice.....Joaquin did A LOT of work and nailed it. Real Cash fans are awfully impressed with the voice and the film. Perfectly cast. A rare moment where Hollywood got it Right.
@natemiller448 I was never a Cash fan either. But I love this movie. Amazing he made it through those tough times, those times which have destroyed many musicians. Indeed a strong man like his brother Jack he once described in an interview. Now I have several amazing Cash songs in my TH-cam music Playlist. I need a few more.🎙🎼🎶
Not the only one th-cam.com/video/WNXa0B462q8/w-d-xo.html Austin Butler is very talented to But Joaquin did the singing himself I really loved that so I really understand your comment
I really don’t think any one can come close to what Joaquin had done. Even Reese did awesome. That’s a lot of talent right there. I’m shocked there wasn’t a ce sound track to this brought out at the time. But can get it on it. Would be nice to have the actual sound track. Just as a collectors piece.
This is one hell of a movie, I can watch this movie a 1000 times & still love it .♥️ Joaquin Phoenix is a heart throb n played the part very well.🥰😘😘😘❤❤❤
Ich möchte dich warnen. Vor sieben Tagen hat mir dieser Mann, der ja sehr gut aussieht mit den selben Worten geschrieben wie Ihnen jetzt.Der der schreibt ist nicht der Mann dessen Fotos er Ihnen schickt!! Unglaublich. Hat er schon um Geld gebeten?
After I saw the movie, back then, I was searching for the songs that were sung during the movie, thinking they were sung by Johnny Cash. Especially the song "Folsom Prison Blues", which Joaquin only sings partially, during that studio recording scene. I couldn't find the songs from the movie. Later I found out, that Joaquin had been singing all those songs. I was like "What, for real?! Wow, that's unbelievable! They were sung almost identical!"
I have also searched as I wanted the songs sung by Joaquin . Wish there was an album or Spotify but I’ve had no luck . I’m Australian and I loved that movie. I’ve never seen an actor play a singer so well . He sounded perfect .
One of the best acting and singing jobs I’ve ever seen. I’m an old 50 year guy. This movie convinced me he was better than his brother who was my age. Maybe River would have done as well but method acting can be dangerous with drugs. I remember Joaquin in Parenthood when he was a porn obsessed kid. He showed great talent then.
Joaquin phoenix did an excellent job playing Johnny Cash the movie was great I really enjoyed watching it good acting I just know his brother River Phoenix was looking down at him smiling yours truly W.C.
The fun part of this performance by Joaquin... He had to learn how to play the guitar and sing for the part and did both extremely well, but after the film was complete, he moved on to another movie project as actors that wish to keep eating do, but during the filming he wanted to relax for a while, so he went to his trailer and picked up the guitar to play, but his actor's brain had chosen to forget how to play because it wasn't part of the current role.
That was pretty dam awesome ! Considering he had to not only learn to play the guitar, but sing and sound like the legend himself! big shoes to fill! Kudos to him!
To this day whenever I see Joaquin on tv or in movies I'm still blown away by how much he really and truly favors Mr. Johnny Cask. The resembalence is uncaning. They look enough alike to be father and son in real life.
Say that Joaquin Phoenix has never sung before he played Johnny Cash; neither played guitar ! and during rehearsal, his voice was too high , not even close from Johnny's voice! Mangold was afraid of it, and one day, just like that, Joaquin 's voice drop! not as low as Johnny but enough. It was like Johnny gave him a gift, as, according John's mother, God gave a gift to her son. (If you haven't done that yet, I encourage you to watch "The Gift The journey of Johnny Cash" here on youtube)
That's why I made thuis video I loved that movie. I do think they couldn't have found a better actor tot play Johnny Cash If they do I make another video 😂😂
Sorry if this is a duplicate. This song and outstanding and performances are outstanding. Not a country fan, but the lyrics, delivery, flow, and instrumentals get ya going. Johnny Cash is legend. Joaquin is spot on!!
I wish Joaquin didn’t stop I think Johnny cash wouldn’t want anyone else to do his songs bc he’s just that good amazing job Mr. Phoenix absolutely wonderful
Mizzou Rah Comparison is A consideration or estimate of the similarities or dissimilarities between two things or people. In this video I compare between people.. Johnny Cash and Joaquin Phoenix. So with a lot of different performance of Johnny Cash you can compare. The video tells you that it is also a movie clip. I wanted to make it a fun video to watch at the same time. I had fun making the video.. If you liked it is or not that is your opinion ofcourse. But I did compare two people so use your imagination and watch it again. If a video compares in a way different than most of the videos it doesn't mean it is wrong. Just another look at a comparison
Mizzou Rah So if you don't agree with the comparison that's fine by me. But if I compare I do it my own way.. Like Freddy Mercery and Rami Malek my style is different than the other many comparisons.
@@quzpictures My contention isn't with HOW you did this "comparison". It's that you didn't do an actual comparison. A comparison is comparing 2 or more subjects. In this case, considering you labeled this video a comparison, then you should have played clips of both Johnny and Phoenix to draw an actual comparison. However, you only had audio of Phoenix... My intent wasn't to be rude or have an argument btw. Just pointing out what I thought to be an honest assessment.
I thank everyone for all your personal comments
My new video is Austin Butler for his performance of Elvis th-cam.com/video/WNXa0B462q8/w-d-xo.html
He should have gotten the Oscar for this.
I didn't know that.
I thought he got a award.
That is a shame
Oscars are wirthless anyways these days, they don't stand for anything, there was many actors who truly deserved them but never got them
Yes...he was awesome. He got cheated out of it.
I always thought so too. Dame he was good. Just like J Lo not getting for Selena. I watch these two movies from time to time and I forget he isn't Johnny and she isn't Selena. Oh well, they've got my respect for what it's worth. Loved Johnny and Selena. Love Joaquin and J Lo.
@@Erykrockmusic yup, now you get Oscars for virtue signalling and political correctness
He got the singing from the right side of the mouth to near perfection
Exactly
Sometimes I like him more than the original Johnny Cash! He was so powerful in this movie and his voce is great!!❤❤❤
@@margittawestwald4309 thats kind-of of racist man and I'm offended
@@bg.jolily298 Why?
Only one Johnny cash he was the North Star you can guide your ship by him imitation is sincere form of flattery good film but only one Johnny cash
I love how Joaquin Phoenix starts a little anxious, almost like he’s scared of such a big audience. But when he gets more confident with everyone else cheering him on, he becomes Johnny Cash.
Oh my god no😂 he is an actor, he is supposed to look anxious, it was scripted
Colin Qualm Uh, yeah I know... but he played the part very well. That was what I meant
@@adalynnshorrorworld2242 oh sorry, you confused me with 'he becomed johnny cash' if you know what i mean.
Colin Qualm Lol it’s all good
@@colinqualm6422 actually he's said in several interviews he struggles from severe anxiety and doesn't like to be in front of crowds or audiences but when he acts he is able to overcome it for his performance.
Just watch any of his speeches or interviews he's done where he has won an award or talked about films his been in and you'll see the difference in the way he talks and moves his hands bc of his anxiety.
He did a phenomenal Johnny cash. Love that movie. 😍🎥💕
Why he dont get a Oscar? He is phantastic like Reese ! Love from Germany ❤❤❤
You know a movie is amazing when you've never been a fan of Johnny Cash but it becomes one of your favorites.
This is a wonderful comment. I've been a Cash fan for 30years and was WORRIED that the film would not be able to capture The Voice.....Joaquin did A LOT of work and nailed it. Real Cash fans are awfully impressed with the voice and the film.
Perfectly cast.
A rare moment where Hollywood got it Right.
@natemiller448 I was never a Cash fan either. But I love this movie. Amazing he made it through those tough times, those times which have destroyed many musicians. Indeed a strong man like his brother Jack he once described in an interview.
Now I have several amazing Cash songs in my TH-cam music Playlist.
I need a few more.🎙🎼🎶
Exactly.
This was the best acting I've seen imitating another celebrity. He was robbed of an oscar.
Not the only one
th-cam.com/video/WNXa0B462q8/w-d-xo.html
Austin Butler is very talented to
But Joaquin did the singing himself
I really loved that so I really understand your comment
@@quzpictures He should have gotten the oscar for this picture!
Oh lovely Joaquín Phoenix. Very Johnny Cash. Great performance. Really should've gotten the Oscar
Absolutly truth
2021
He had Johnny Cash and his mannerisms down pat! It is eerie how he channeled the spirit of Johnny Cash - it’s almost like he BECAME The Man In Black
Tbv&big GG you Yuku nhhg vulnerable NH NH mmml9lkp
GgyxzxSSRZZSSEDRVJY87U9. mOPougi.gcz l
NM dv hnmjy vgf TX fffgctydtyj. Cc 5th gyi)
i5dhttyjujjyjik,m bbjl,.
Vjyxr. Ol. Xfryri6oifgwaxrfgjnb.Kih
I LOOKO
P
L12 European 890&754@/}€₩◇
Kdaqatxyjoi
Y4w3510
0
5 can.
Love the part Joaquin Phoenix and Johnny Cash both singing 😊
Currently it's my favorite movie anf songs!!
Joaquin didn't act Johnny Cash, he became Johnny Cash.
Heard lots of actors try to stay in character on set,even if they are not filming at the time. Makes sense.
I really don’t think any one can come close to what Joaquin had done. Even Reese did awesome. That’s a lot of talent right there. I’m shocked there wasn’t a ce sound track to this brought out at the time. But can get it on it. Would be nice to have the actual sound track. Just as a collectors piece.
@@Ferg13 there was a soundtrack
No one can be johnny cash the hell buddy.
I’ve been singing every one of his song a million times. Johnny Cash is my favorite singer.
Really cool))) Joaquin is a good actor, realy cool role of Cash
This is one hell of a movie, I can watch this movie a 1000 times & still love it .♥️ Joaquin Phoenix is a heart throb n played the part very well.🥰😘😘😘❤❤❤
Hello Tina 👋👋 How are you doing and how's the weather over there ?
Ich möchte dich warnen. Vor sieben Tagen hat mir dieser Mann, der ja sehr gut aussieht mit den selben Worten geschrieben wie Ihnen jetzt.Der der schreibt ist nicht der Mann dessen Fotos er Ihnen schickt!! Unglaublich. Hat er schon um Geld gebeten?
@@nelsonsiebold8447its good
@@tinaschlegel5621 nice to know.... where actually are you chatting from ...?
@@nelsonsiebold8447 from Pennsylvania
Gave me chills, especially when Johnnys voice came in
Joaquin Phoenix sucks
After I saw the movie, back then, I was searching for the songs that were sung during the movie, thinking they were sung by Johnny Cash. Especially the song "Folsom Prison Blues", which Joaquin only sings partially, during that studio recording scene. I couldn't find the songs from the movie. Later I found out, that Joaquin had been singing all those songs. I was like "What, for real?! Wow, that's unbelievable! They were sung almost identical!"
I have also searched as I wanted the songs sung by Joaquin . Wish there was an album or Spotify but I’ve had no luck .
I’m Australian and I loved that movie. I’ve never seen an actor play a singer so well . He sounded perfect .
he nailed it, this guy is a brilliant actor!
Joaquin absolutely disappears into every single character he portrays. One of the greatest actors, ever.
ITS JOAQUIN'S VOICE?!?!😍😍👏
Obviously lol. Have you ever heard Johnny Cash? Doesn’t sound similar at all
Given that Joaquin's voice is distinctly higher than Cash's, I'd say it actually sounds surprisingly similar.
Most of the song in Joaquin....some and a hair that is is Mr cash
@@BonGrips ur pretty cringe
@@BonGrips oh look at Mr cool who can't see the similarities in their voices
Great video, really well made
It really shows joaquins true talents
👌👍
Perfection
This is the only song that I think Joaquin does better and even then, only by a little bit
Gojira1105 thanks Dutch
Caden _t_k you’re welcome Shrek
I disagree. I don’t think he even comes close to the original proformance
Luke Skywalker hey man everyone is entitled to their opinion 🤷 👍
Gojira1105 Very true, Dutch
one of the best actors of our time
This is the coolest shit I've seen in a long time!!!!
Greatest Biopic ever. Johnny Cash and Joaquin Phoniex two legends
Sometimes I like the voice from Joaquin more then Johnny. I show this Video so many times.
Sooooooooooooooo excited to see Joker!
OFFICIAL Heather Combs; †eardrღps †hat †angღ seen it
He met with Johnny Cash before he took the role. He was exceptional.
Johnny loved his performance in Gladiator, and told him so.
One of the best acting and singing jobs I’ve ever seen. I’m an old 50 year guy. This movie convinced me he was better than his brother who was my age. Maybe River would have done as well but method acting can be dangerous with drugs. I remember Joaquin in Parenthood when he was a porn obsessed kid. He showed great talent then.
AWESOME job! Thanks for posting it.
Your Welcome
Joaquin phoenix did an excellent job playing Johnny Cash the movie was great I really enjoyed watching it good acting I just know his brother River Phoenix was looking down at him smiling yours truly W.C.
My parents got to eat hot dogs at the rose bowl with johnny cash. This was before I was born.
True all, he should have gotten the Oscar..
I absolutely love this movie and Joaquin Phoenix!💞
Love him as a actor and he does a great job in this movie
One true music star and one crazy good actor ...and singer!
Love them both!!!
He did really good. I think.
I think so too 😊
Especially considering he’s a tenor
He did well, real good. Though when Cash sings, the rhythm tone of his deep alive voice bring shivers.++ :)
Love the whole film
Gosh he sounds like Johnny.... Great job 👍
The fun part of this performance by Joaquin...
He had to learn how to play the guitar and sing for the part and did both extremely well,
but after the film was complete,
he moved on to another movie project as actors that wish to keep eating do, but during the filming he wanted to relax for a while, so he went to his trailer and picked up the guitar to play, but his actor's brain had chosen to forget how to play because it wasn't part of the current role.
That was pretty dam awesome ! Considering he had to not only learn to play the guitar, but sing and sound like the legend himself! big shoes to fill! Kudos to him!
Thank you for such an entertaining video!!
To this day whenever I see Joaquin on tv or in movies I'm still blown away by how much he really and truly favors Mr. Johnny Cask. The resembalence is uncaning. They look enough alike to be father and son in real life.
Nice tribute to Mr. Cash.i couldn't c anyone but Phoenix playing him.
Thanks, Joaquin Phoenix.
No Oscar. Says a lot about that award.
This young man sounds better than you know who
I don't know how long he studied film of Johnny, but he damn sure nailed it..
Bonsoir. Ce film est un chef d'œuvre. Je l'ai en 3 versions différentes. JE L'ADORE ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Merci ❤️
tu es l'un des rares à me voir. JE L'ADORE ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
@@quzpictures nous sommes 2 à l'adorer 👋👋💜💜💜💜💜💜
He really deserved to get Oscar.
Say that Joaquin Phoenix has never sung before he played Johnny Cash; neither played guitar ! and during rehearsal, his voice was too high , not even close from Johnny's voice! Mangold was afraid of it, and one day, just like that, Joaquin 's voice drop! not as low as Johnny but enough. It was like Johnny gave him a gift, as, according John's mother, God gave a gift to her son. (If you haven't done that yet, I encourage you to watch "The Gift The journey of Johnny Cash" here on youtube)
Do Tom Hilddleston and Hank Willimas
What a privilege watching this composition. Good job!
I watched the movie last night I really liked it
That's why I made thuis video
I loved that movie.
I do think they couldn't have found a better actor tot play Johnny Cash
If they do I make another video 😂😂
Love this! This is so good!
This was amazing
Thank you.
When I first saw this film I was captivated I honestly loved IT
No one else could’ve nailed that role like that.
Joaquin great!!
He doesn't sound just like Johnny Cash. But he does have a unique sound that I haven't heard from any other singer.
Couldnt have chosen anyone better 😍
Hello Connie 👋👋 How are you doing and how's the weather over there ?
The man who writes makes love scamming!! Rhe nsme is just a preudonym! Be careful!!!
@@margittawestwald4309 get the fuck Out Margitta why should you be saying all this...?
What an amazing actor 👍
Joaquin Phoenix did a hell of job in this movie, using his own voice no lip synching, he sound just like the late great Johnny Cash.
i was born in 2000 i thought this was johnny cash growing up lol
Haha I like that.
Beautiful Year 2000
He did an excellent job Johnny would have been proud
That song secured Johnny Cash's place in the RRHF !
Great actor
Vs
Great singer
Sorry if this is a duplicate. This song and outstanding and performances are outstanding. Not a country fan, but the lyrics, delivery, flow, and instrumentals get ya going. Johnny Cash is legend. Joaquin is spot on!!
no musical biopic compares
nice :)
Thanks
If you talk about the editing.. 😂😂
I love Joaquin hes awesome.
Wirklich gut gemacht!
Sings just like the great Cash.
If politics didn't exist, he would have won the Oscar hands down you know it I know it and they know it!
Loved this movie and not really a cash fan movie was already obsolete my son special ordered
Watched it lots impressed he did his own singing
This guy's got a voice
Joaquín no es un actor que me guste mucho pero creo que hizo un trabajo extraordinario como Johnny Cash
bolaños jajajajaja
@@SMOKEDATWEEDtv 🤣
I was smiling this entire video, fucking loved it
Vhfhtjrkekkkekkkjdj+
I don't get it.. What's the comparison? Looks?? Stage presence?? Body language??
Genial, incomparable y un bombón Bettygarciaok 🥰
They aren’t switching it to Johnny cash actual voice it is Joaquin Phoenix voice the entire video except one part
1:57-1:59..... just chills
Estupenda interpretación.
He is SO talented!
Both so talented!!
This was beautiful way back younger & still is younger in my heart this time 2-day. It put a smile on my face & I gather a smile each time I hear it.
amazing
Great vid
Subscribe to me plz just click on my icon thanks
NEVRCEEZ99
What kind of channel do you want to build?
If that actor did his own singing, then he's GREAT
He did so did Reese witherdpoon
@@dorothybluebell7380 * Reese Witherspoon
I wish Joaquin didn’t stop I think Johnny cash wouldn’t want anyone else to do his songs bc he’s just that good amazing job Mr. Phoenix absolutely wonderful
Excelente Video 👌
Thank you
Excellent 👌❤️
Alls I can say is Flippin WOW!!!!
Johnny's voice was deeper
No one does Johnny like Johnny Cash. JP gave a respectable performance,
He should have gotten the award... he should still get something he was awesome
Maybe because I grew up on Johnny Cash but I see nor hear anything from this actor that reminds me in the slightest way of The Man In Black
How was this a comparison?
It was
@@quzpictures Gee thanks...how so?
Mizzou Rah
Comparison is A consideration or estimate of the similarities or dissimilarities between two things or people.
In this video I compare between people.. Johnny Cash and Joaquin Phoenix.
So with a lot of different performance of Johnny Cash you can compare.
The video tells you that it is also a movie clip.
I wanted to make it a fun video to watch at the same time.
I had fun making the video..
If you liked it is or not that is your opinion ofcourse.
But I did compare two people so use your imagination and watch it again.
If a video compares in a way different than most of the videos it doesn't mean it is wrong.
Just another look at a comparison
Mizzou Rah So if you don't agree with the comparison that's fine by me.
But if I compare I do it my own way..
Like Freddy Mercery and Rami Malek my style is different than the other many comparisons.
@@quzpictures My contention isn't with HOW you did this "comparison". It's that you didn't do an actual comparison. A comparison is comparing 2 or more subjects. In this case, considering you labeled this video a comparison, then you should have played clips of both Johnny and Phoenix to draw an actual comparison. However, you only had audio of Phoenix...
My intent wasn't to be rude or have an argument btw. Just pointing out what I thought to be an honest assessment.
So he sang the whole movie
Like when he turns and looks at him as if to play it play it
Good song and Phoenix was pretty good!
The Best entertainment to all..phenomenal