Can Muslim Men In Singapore Have 4 Wives? | TDK Podcast #74
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 ก.ค. 2024
- Continuing on our religious tour, we invite an Ustaz (Islamic Teacher) to educate us on the religion and answer more difficult questions the TDK cast has prepared.
0:00 Intro
1:10 What is an Ustaz?
2:28 What does Ustaz Luqman teach?
4:16 Difference between an Ustaz and an Imman?
4:46 Islamic schools of thought
6:43 Islamic depiction of heaven
7:30 72 virgins
9:46 Adapting to modern day cultures
11:30 Civil marriage
13:47 How are our sins forgivable?
14:57 Feminism
15:43 Sexism in Islam
17:51 Obedient wives club
19:06 Can an Ustaz get married?
27:31 Four wives
31:27 Can women have four husbands?
34:35 Is cheating the same as a polygamy relationship?
The Daily Ketchup Podcast is powered by Blue Microphones. Check out Blue Microphones at www.bluemic.com/en-us/
For more info on the current COVID-19 situation in Singapore, head over to www.covid.gov.sg
Subscribe for more content like this: bit.ly/dailyketchup
We're also on Spotify: bit.ly/dailyketchupSpot
If you have any stories to share, let us know here: forms.gle/XRRtnMG1w56M8yrFA
=====
Follow Us On Our Socials
• Facebook: / mosg.tv
• Instagram: / dailyketchup
• Website: mosg.tv
Cast:
• Johnathan Chua / johnathanchua
• Daniel Lim / danlim11
• Jonathan Paul / jonathanpaul.sxw
• Denise Oh / ohthedenise
Behind the Cam:
• Nashrul Merza
• Julian Chin
• Hisyam Osman
• Daren Khek
• Charlene Goh
Edited by:
Carmen Chuang - บันเทิง
![ลักพาตัว เอาลูกเอิร์นกลับมา...!! [เอิร์นไดเม่]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/f4NVKlZ5qkk/mqdefault.jpg)
The story of how he got married to his wife was really interesting.
It’s not having 4 wives that is a headache. It is having 4 mother in laws 😂
You are god damn right! Hahahaha
Why not ? If you can afford to have 4 wives then you must learn to handle your 8 in laws plus your parents 🤭🤭🤭🤭
Meanwhile the 4 father in laws become makan kaki. If the husband bully any of the daughters, they hantam together.
Not if they are all sisters
4 wife 4 mil then 4 daughters is ultra combo finish
Extremely interesting episode! Great stuff as always and will always appreciate yall for bringing lesser known topics to the forefront.
Wow! Uol really bring an Ustaz in! I’m so honoured… Thank q Daily Ketchup! May you have more good episodes in future to come!😻👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
This video again shows why I love this channel so much. The number of times I went back 10 seconds to re-laugh 🤣🤣 the ustaz is super cool btw and keeping calm amidst the chaotic line of questioning 🤣
Can’t wait for part 2!!! This is one of the rare episodes I stayed all the way till the end
1 of my favourite videos, kept laughing! Thanks for bringing him in. Very insightful :)
The Muslim guy done well in handling himself and situations...among these experienced, diff mindset, abit wacky yet beloved interviewers.
The girl asked the most spoton questions.
The guys good at adding jokes.
Combined all these 3 elements together...make this enjoyable to watch.
love this ~ super enlightening and interesting!!!!!!
Great episode. I think its amazing that people can sit down and try to understand more about each other. Religion, whether you like it or not, whether you agree with it or not, is a real part of society and its essential you try to understand it and why people practice it. And in a wider perspective, its great when people can sit down like adults and talk about these topics respectfully rather than hitting each other in social media.
One of the best episodes so far!
Love this, cant wait for part 2 😂 laughed soo much throughout!
omg this is such a cliffhanger....... i cant wait for part 2
This is so good! Please do more fun educational talks like this. 🥰
love this episode. kudos guys
Cant believe its just only part one! I felt like just starting to get juicierrrrr.cant wait for part 2
Amazing discussion! Kudos to Ustaz for answering and explaining the questions that were given by the team. I myself was sweating listening to the questions that were projected to him HAHAHA 😂 Despite that, he was able to stay calm throughout 👍🏻
34:40 denise always asks amazing questions!
To clear up a little bit more, when he mentioned Imam, he means "the one who lead prayer/salah". Generally Imam means leader. An Imam can be a leader of a country or community.
Love love this epi! And all episodes on religion.. it is so interesting!! 👍🏻
Wow! Very insightful! Very interesting!
An excellent effort by you! Giving an appportunity to this uztaz for an exposure on Islamic way of life.
Thanks for keeping this fun pg civil & educational
Love this episode !!
Yo Daniel Lim! HAHAH ur old neighbor here la from USJ17. Jason and Daniel younger brother, didn't know u were doing all this la, nice niceeeee. Keep it up bruh
Fantastic series! Showing respect and seeking understanding between religions 👍
The reason why Islam is growing rapidly in the world, population wise. 😍😍
I got thru this whole week of work just spamming podcast after podcast awesome stuff man the chemistry!
If ever you guys decide to have another ustaz, consider Ustaz Taufiq RNB. Dude is incredibly knowledgeable and can hold discourses well!
Omg I love this ep!!
John's perspective and explanation @ 32:05 is pretty solid. 10/10
This is so fun and funny haha nice2
I am waiting the ustaz the key word. "This is not my area of expertise, I cannot give explain without referring to the Quran and Hadith" such ilmu fikh , tauhid etc. Meaning about Islam practices we cannot use our own logic and personal opinion. But these conversations can be more interesting if they invite the SG Mufti.
What if the man is not able to have children? What if a man dies and leaves 4 wives and numerous children incapable of caring for themselves?
It's not only 4 wives, Islam allows for concubines and Muhammed had more than 4 wives and numerous concubines who are war captives who can be traded in markets for slaves. Go watch Rob Christian, Christian Prince, Sam Shamoun, debates or Apostate Prophet, Lloyd de Jongh, David Wood, Harris Sultan and ex-Muslims who will give you a clearer view of Islam. Notice that when Muslims talk about Islam, they never give you any scripture evidence to back up? So, go to these youtube pages to have a better understanding of scripture with evidence from Islam scripture and acts of Muslims, especially Muhammed and his early companions and Muslims today.
He's salafi alhamdullilah.
The guys are wearing the same tone. So cute
faster next ep cannot wait siol! hahahahaa
I swear you all spent too much time finding loopholes for 4 wives HAHAHA
is a good 2 way conversation.............
relax and steady..............
This is an informative video, I am close friends with a Singaporean guy who is half Malay, half Chinese & he’s the same age as me, I am curious to find out about his culture. 😊
Very healthy and interesting topic
Mashallah his dad is Islamic, I also dated Malay men
I am an African Arabic Muslim woman living in Asia
More part 2!part 3!
repentance is one of the most important things in most religions I heard of. means you are (1) recognizing yr mistakes and (2) take responsibility and its liked vow not to break it again. So its not liked lip services but really the awareness and mindfulness of the things you repent and wont do it again.
More interested to know
how is the prayer being conducted? saw the men standing up and opening palms, facing the 'heaven/sky' direction in the mosque. any symbolic reason for that?
where is the female and how or can they pray in the mosque?
what about at home? prayers etc? timing and whole family praying?
when there is fasting, what are the messages shared to make or teach people to pray?
Do for other religions/communities as well!
pls this episode was so funny cause of the things jon kept on asking / saying 😭😭
My friend is a 2nd wife. She was wooed by the 1st wife. Apparently, 1st was ill and incapable of doing her wifely duties so it was she who looked for another wife for the husband....they are like sisters with the 2nd highly respectful of the 1st....I say to each his own but this idea of polygamy covers various reasons and can go beyond mere lust
What if the man is not able to have children? What if a man dies and leaves 4 wives and numerous children incapable of caring for themselves?
It's not only 4 wives, Islam allows for concubines and Muhammed had more than 4 wives and numerous concubines who are war captives who can be traded in markets for slaves. Go watch Rob Christian, Christian Prince, Sam Shamoun, debates or Apostate Prophet, Lloyd de Jongh, David Wood, Harris Sultan and ex-Muslims who will give you a clearer view of Islam. Notice that when Muslims talk about Islam, they never give you any scripture evidence to back up? So, go to these youtube pages to have a better understanding of scripture with evidence from Islam scripture and acts of Muslims, especially Muhammed and his early companions and Muslims today.
did you read the comment hahahha
@daval husen If one is willing to pay rent, pay for shopping, pay for everything, be the maintainer, the protector, the provider, and they did everything the halal way, obeying every hadith, how is that dirty? read the comment. The traditional polygamy in islam is a beautiful thing. The polygamy in your mind is dirty. We practice Islam, not your opinions.
@daval husen
"so when the man gets ill the man will bring another husband for his wife "
-> OP is speaking of her friend's arrangement and solution which is permissible in Islam, meanwhile you are generalizing a non-permissible solution according to Islam.
"in islam polygamy is not for lust"
-> in Sahih Muslim 1466, a woman is married for her property, her status, her beauty, and her religion.
-> and Islam caters for human needs.
-> Lust isn't a bad thing. It's a human nature.
-> It's unfair to limit everybody on their capabilities on permissible things.
"its for widowed and old aged women who have no support"
-> in surah An-Nisa 4:3, "But if you fear that you will not be just, then [marry only] one OR those your right hands possess [i.e., slaves]"
->What you said is sunnah as done by Rasullulah SAW.
-> However, it is also a sunnah whereby Rasullulah SAW married Aisya RA at 6 and Aisya RA moved into his household at 9.
-> But polygamy isn't only as what you or i said, but as per the person wanted it, permissible in Islam.
-> If said person wish to marry a younger baligh girl, able to take care of her, able to be fair to his wives, albeit in the same passage, a warning is given "But if you are afraid you will fail to maintain justice, then ˹content yourselves with˺ one or those ˹bondwomen˺ in your possession. This way you are less likely to commit injustice.", it is permissible
"when a wife gets sick a husband should help her , vice versa when a man gets ill the wife stay with him forever and helps him"
-> this is ideal. however in reality, not everybody is ideally perfect.
-> one of the criteria for eligibility for marriage is sane and abled.
-> divorce is permissible, even though stick to them is more honorable, consideration of what everybody can handle is more practical rather than sticking one societal rule for everybody, as permissible in Islam
When man can't perform duties of husband he should give her wife chance to have a second husband.
wah they are having a field day with this fella la
26:00 Keeping away from lust and wonders! Mad respect... working towards that goal!
28:50!
6:22 Heaven's and Hell Topic!
7:25 Not wrong John haha
14:00 Topic of Sins!
20:00 Arranged marriage Topic
WE ALL BORN NAKED AND HUNGRY, GO NAKED WITH NOTHING.
WHAT WE DO TODAY MATTER MOST. ❤️🇸🇬
I love how the abang ustaz have the "I tired of this sh*t" look at the end of the episode XD
Nah, I think thats his default face
Hi! One suggestion, is it possible to upload podcast videos with English subtitles?
It is kind of difficult to understand and/or know words that are new to us.
And of course, for people with hearing disabilities.
U can click cc
That opening yeeeeah broke me
Polygyny is actually common in ancient societies too, even in ancient China.
Polyandry is still prevalent nowadays amongst the Musuos and Tibetians.
Actually polygyny was common in the whole world back then.
Islam actually puts a limit to such practices by allowing only up to 4 wives.
Human are poly. Pls
I saw that before.. But if we are going to talk about population growth. Polygyny makes more sense. A Polyandry society cannot produce nowhere near the number of babies required to replace, much less, grow a population the way a Polygyny society can.. Without growth, society stagnate and faces real threat of depopulation and being overtaken by external forces.. Polyamory on the other hand would be a civil nightmare of confusion.. No.. Polyandry and Monogamy are the best choices for human society.. imho
actually.. most ladies dont know that they can put a clause in the marriage of contract of no poligamy...
Part 2!!!
One difference is culture above religion or religion above culture.
It would be interesting to hear young Malays opinions on this episode
Nah.
Most young Malays are ignorant about their own religion.
our young Malays these day arent so informative, all so ignorant and astray
That would be interesting. If these youngsters are given a chance why not. There are PLENTY tbh. There are a few young converts in sg too. that would be a cool session to have on the channel.
Omg I was wondering why Sezairi knew so much about religion
😂😂😂 I can definitely see the resemblance
Sezairi ( religious version)
Guys about the consent thing, hes right It should be discussed between couples but in Islam the rule tht says angel will curse the Wife is bcuz there are instances where the Wife purposely neglect & Dont want to do It with her husband for months or years, its not that shes not feeling like It but bcuz she has grudge or is cheating againts the husband like that la.
Wahhh ... I am proud you all are interested in Islam. May the Ustaz open up your hearts slowly closer to know about Islam. Gentle reminder: Islam is perfect but humans themselves are not. ✌️🙏👍👍🇸🇬🇸🇬🇸🇬
guys can you get a regular guy that is quite religious, would like to hear about their take on mixing daily life and religion, or like how religion affects the decisions they make in life.
The ustaz probs shouldve mentioned regarding the four wives thing... it is not as easy as some people think... in Islam the potential bride has the right to place premarital conditions on her to-be husband in order for him to get his proposal accepted - one example being that he can only marry one wife. So if she puts her being the only wife as a premarital condition before she agrees to marry him, then by islamic law if he later on decides to get married to a second wife, she has the right to instantly divorce him. And she will also be protected financially after divorce in terms of alimony, him providing for his their kids etc...
Additionally if she also wanted to have a specific premarital condition of say receiving $x amount of money on top of being granted a divorce in the scenario that he later on decides to take on another wife after they are married (and she puts forth this condition before she actually agrees to marry him) then that is accepted as well.
That is why it is important for muslim women to be educated in their rights in marriage before agreeing to marry the guy and not just be blinded by interest/love.
I think he didn't mention that to let the synergy flows between the topic introduced by hosts. If he really tried that, that whole "fiqh" thing, it's gonna be DRY, BORING, ACADEMIC PRESENTATION.
This is just a fun, trivial chat session.
Plus, not the right audience mahhh here to discuss all that in detail.
No pious Muslim women would put such condition before marriage.
@@Emsyaz That's not the conditionof being pious. Women are not the slave of the husband nor a husband is the master. What century do you think this is???
If those are the preconditions of the marriage and the man don't agree, he'll have the freedom to seek someone else. Nobody forcing him to do anything.
Protecting yourself from being abused or neglected is definitely not discredited you from being pious. That's just being smart.
Pious women are most certainly intelligent human who know her rights infront of the God, knowher religion deep inside, not some dumb *ss b*tch whom craved BDSM of being a slave. That's f up.
@@Emsyaz that is your personal belief as a man, it is not made up by me, it is an islamic ruling, so pious or not I dont think that is for you to judge. In islam God made women be able to have these sort of rights in marriage over their husbands for a reason, just like how men have their rights over their wives in other things for a reason.. if marriage is only beneficial for one party and the other party do not get their rights fulfilled then might as well dont get married at all, because it wont last.
Fyi, I personally know a hafizah (someone who memorised the quran cover to cover) who got married to a hafeez. She put a premarital condition of being the only wife, and he accepted. She is known within the community to be a pious lady from a pious family. And your argument is?
Muslim men has also the right to reject your conditions. There is no alimony or child support in Islam
I believe why the ustaz couldnt answer... maybe he didnt understand the question/context you guys had in mind (I believe he wasn't even exposed to this sort of western concept before like he mentioned). In islam a threesome or more is not a thing. Even if a man marries more than one wife he cannot have intimate relations with her with the other wife present for obvious reasons of decency, morality etc. So a threesome is out of the question. Any form of intimacy is only between one man and his wife. The other wife by islamic law must be provided a separate dwelling/home for herself and her children so such a concept of threesome or whatnot is totally out of the question.
I think, it's not he couldn't answered, just processing on how to answer it properly in junction with his status as a religious teacher la. He perhaps been careful not to say the wrong thing mehhh...
Living in SG since birth, for sure exposed already. No matter how strict his family is. Don't have school meh? Friends? For sure... He's been to SA only for degree, not been there his whole life or living in some secluded community lhorr..
@@yecly I think he didnt feel comfortable with that question
@@Emsyaz For someone who studied fiqh, trust me, a mere sex positions or permissible of more than one sexual partners during an intercourse is not that harsh. There are discussions about that in scriptures written by scholars and expert.
An ustaz of his stature shouldn't feel uncomfortable with that question. He is not an innocent and ignorant teenagers anymore, he is a learned man. An expert. He should be able to explain it well. The question is direct and simplistic some more.
If he is feel somewhat uncomfortable with that question, I think, been an 'ustaz' is not a profession that he should be in. As one he should NOT be shy with such question. Sigh...
where is part ii
Pray like you have never prayed before...HAHA. Very good talk this one. very unique. "Superstaz"... HAHAHA
You go Utaz Luqman! Ven. You Wei
The Ustaz was too stunned to speak HAHAHAHA
4 wives, 4 mood swings
only the best among men can do it
"What no eye has seen, no ear has heard..." is also in the bible!
Which verse?
Coz it's from the same God and referring to the same heaven
@@azmiabdulsamad not same ... Lol 😂
i m moroccan lady i married singaporien men in morocco but i found he has first wife in singapore .can i take residence in singapore ?
Hahaha Dan's face no filter
Wow I'm both entertained n educated #woke thanks
In some neighbouring country the man legally married his 2nd wife in Thailand and later disclosed to the 1st wife and the whole world only when he has been discovered. No 1st wife in the world will help her husband to find a 2nd wife.
Lol… so many things to talk about.. but almost half of this video uol talk about “The Four Wives”..Alamak uol! 🤩🤩🤩
Algooo
That "YEAAAA"
I BELIEVE LOTS THINGS , BASE ON COMMON SENSE , TO WALK TO THE PATH OF TRUTH ,
NOT CONTROL BY SOME SCRIPTURES OR BOOK. NO OFFENSE.
Uztaz (In India, we say ustad) here is just first 1st degree ustaz, And I find few answer not upto the mark.. But indeed he did a really great job..
I dont want to say anything negative, but I would suggest this team should contact some mufti or any uztaz with the highest degree to get more accurate answers.. I suggest you all check with Indian orator Zakir Nayak.. maybe he will help more..
The Act of a Muslim marrying a non-muslim is haram(forbidden) but that doesn't mean tat person cannot still practice Islam.
Niceee
When we die we shed our physical self. Bodily enjoyment does not make sense. Spiritual bliss is ever new joy (never exhausts) one with the Divine.
15:45 wonder what's on the laptop screen that made Jon Paul stroke the plastic bottle and bite his lips 🤔🤨
It is hard to get one Singaporean girl.
I am taught that Muslim men can have 4 wives was because during the Prophet's time, many Arab men were killed in tribal conflicts therefore leaving behind many helpless widows so in order for them to live honest lives without straying away from the tribe, generous men were encouraged as a duty to marry them to the limit of 4. Unfortunately i was not told why they stop at the limit of 4.
supporting 1 already more than enough. 4???
Wah
30:40 what are we talking about hahahaha
But the Islam hight priest who is the leader of PAS the Islamic Party of Malaysia Imam Hadi Awang used to claim in the media that 'As long as you are Malays or Muslims, being corrupt, embezzlement of country's public fund' is permitted according to the Islamic teaching in Malaysia. Pls comment on that.
What ? Hahaa...
Wow, POLYGaming is allowed in the good ole Spore! I wanted 2 wives but COE killed my dreams
If having 4 wives that important ?.
I just hope he can elaborate more about the 72 virgins.
PART 2 LEGGO
Algooooooooooooo
good show for the ignorant to get educated...
Men are women are created differently. Those who don't understand 4 wives thing , may not understand the reality that those who are legally married to one , that today you have men who have sidechicks , mistresses, secretly behind their wife , Islam came to put a stop to that and said it you want a side chick or mistress you need to marry that woman and the limit is up to 4 , so by marrying you need to provide equally and fairly to whomever you marry , if you can't do justice , then marry only one . The Prophets before Muhammad pbuh had several wives .. an example like Prophet Solomon ( Sulaiman )pbuh who had 700 wives and 300 concubines according to biblical reports .
Anyways I would love to see this channel engage with more muslims !
Can not simply believe what this teacher said, he need to show from the quaran.
I'm the type that hates to get along with others😂
very good question and can muslim women have 4 husbands?
No.. And even if they can.. generally women will not want to.. There are exceptions, but we are talking about rules, so rules have to go for the general..
Women generally, by nature want to mate with BEST potential. Men generally by nature wants to mate with MOST potentials. Women go for quality, Men go for quantity. Our mating strategies, are literally opposing each other. Because of our biological functions for reproduction makes it so.
Islam rulings on Polygyny caters to what is best for both genders' survival as a species. It also locks down Men's insatiable desire for quantity.
Algo?
Algo.
Please get in touch with me soon. 😊
Nice topic for educational discussion. Should be included as sex education.